Supplementary Estimates. - Vote 52—Agriculture.
Contributions 183–372 of 372. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Exactly. What is our policy? If the Minister would only endeavour to get some policy other than trying to solve agricultural depression by having a loss of from £5 in one class to £2 10s. 0d. in another class of our stock, we would get somewhere.
Comment on this
You have not got any policy, so there is no use in listening to you.
Comment on this
Of course not. Deputy Moore does not believe that at all. Deputy Moore also thinks that a scheme of general subsidisation is quite all right. I agree with Deputy Moore as far as auxiliary industries are concerned, or any kind of side show. But if Deputy Moore is in business himself, and if the main lines which he is pursuing, and upon which rests his entire income, are not paying, is he going to continue? Let him ask himself that question. First and foremost I think there is one thing upon which we all agree, and that is that agriculture is the main industry of the country. Is it or is it not? If Deputy Moore agrees with that, we know where we are. If Deputy Moore thinks that the building of motor bodies is the main industry I do not agree. If he thinks that the manufacture of some other articles in this country is the main industry of this country I do not agree at all. I maintain that agriculture is the main industry, and it must pay or get out. There is no use in Deputy Moore thinking that the industry of building motor bodies or anything else can afford to pay a subsidy to the main industry. It cannot be done. What I want to know is: What is really the responsibility of the Department of Agriculture in this country? Has it a responsibility? If it has a responsibility is it acting up to that responsibility? And what is the Minister's responsibility? Is he responsible to the Department, and is the Department responsible to the country? Let us then have an examination of the whole policy which is being pursued at the present time in the country and see where it is leading to.
I do not want to find fault with the tillage policy. I have always been an advocate of tillage. My advocacy always went this far and no further, that there ought to be a tillage policy in this country; that there ought to be cereal production in this country for the feeding of live stock, which is the only thing we can sell with profit and advantage. Let Deputy Moore take his wheat policy, his beet policy, or his tobacco policy. Let him compare them with his own business, whatever it is. Here are the main lines of business which the present Government propose to follow. Those three or four lines have got to be subsidised. They have got to be paid for in some way. What is it being paid out of? If agriculture is the main industry, then all that is happening is that we are creating a mortgage on the future of agriculture. We are paying out of resources; it does not matter what they are at the present time, or where they are coming from. Those are the resources of the main industry. It cannot be done. You may do it for a year. You may do it for two years. If we are as progressive, and if we are as successful as Deputy Moore in his innocence thinks we are, was it not an extraordinary Budget we had this year? Was it not an extraordinary thing that we had to put on all that taxation? Is it not an extraordinary thing that with all the money which is being invested in the new industries in this country there does not seem to be any hope of getting more money by way of income tax out of the new investments. Is not that an extraordinary thing? We had to fall back upon the absolute necessaries of life in order to get the money which is required.
There is another matter which I think Fianna Fáil has never really considered at all. If they have, I am afraid they have been guilty of gross neglect in not taking it into account. Does the Government think any kind of policy which is pursued in this country, as far as agriculture is concerned, is good enough for the country; that the land can bear any strain that is put upon it, and that there is in the land an inexhaustible supply of plant food, either for tillage, live stock, or anything else? Do they think that? Apparently, they do. We had the Minister for Industry and Commerce advising us to study his statistics. Of course he runs away from them himself. He ran away from them very badly here the other day in regard to pig production. I have the figures here now, and I am sorry that the Minister is not here so that I could read them for him. He should turn to those statistics which he himself has published, and see the amount of artificial manure which is used at the present time in this country, as against what was used three years ago before Fianna Fáil came into power. He is not, of course, as good a man at stacking wheat as the Minister for Agriculture, but if he read those things and settles down to think of them—or if the Minister for Agriculture thought of them—he will see where we are drifting.
Coupled with that there is the destruction of live stock, and we have the Minister for Industry and Commerce boasting that we have now no surplus cattle. The first thing that will tell upon is the land. I do not know if there are any farmers opposite to me at the present time, but if there are any farmers on the Fianna Fáil Benches who are accustomed to mixed farming as I have been, or if they have been accustomed to the reclamation of land, they will know what I am talking about. They will know that the land of this country has not an inexhaustible supply of plant food by any means. It has got to be supplemented both by artificial manure and particularly by animal manure. We can get land into perfectly good heart for tillage by manuring it. Once we get it into that, we can continue it in pasture, if we keep enough live stock on it. If we till that year after year and have not animal manure for it then the land is finished. As a friend of mine said quite recently, before Fianna Fáil came into power they burned practically everything that was in the country, and now they are killing the very soil of the country. That is what is happening; they are killing the very soil of the country.
Of course it is very hard to know where one is when dealing with the Minister for Agriculture. His views are constantly shifting; he has constantly shifted values even for his own policy. Two years ago he drew attention to a statement I made in the House and said: "Deputy Brennan appears to think that I do not know that an increase of tillage means an increase of live stock." Some time afterwards he said that he did not see any reason why there should be an increase of live stock with an increase of tillage. Now, apparently, the latest we have from the Minister, of course we had it from some of the backbenchers before with regard to pig production, is that we must produce less if we are going to get a price for it. So that our new policy is going to be: the less you produce, the better off you will be. Of course that is entirely compatible with statements made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who told us that the less surplus cattle we have the better off we are.
If we are going to be richer people by growing wheat, we have to be very careful about the soil and how we are going to manure it if we are going to continue growing it. But it is an extraordinary thing that in 1929 the present Minister for Agriculture, the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, President de Valera and others, put up certain proposals with regard to wheat-growing in this country. One of the things the proposals contained was, that no man in this country should be asked to grow wheat at a lower price than 31/6 per barrel. That is published in the report of the Economic Committee which is to be found in the Library. There was no economic war at that time; there was not £6 per head or £5 or £4 being collected by Great Britain on our live stock. We had a good price for everything we were selling, although Deputy O'Reilly tells us that the rates were paid at that time out of overdrafts. They are not paid at all now, which is worse. Apparently the overdraft accommodation is not available now. Was it not a peculiar thing that in 1929, when we were comparatively rich as compared with the present time, President de Valera, or the Minister for Agriculture, would not ask us to grow wheat at a lower price than 31/6 per barrel? Now we can become rich on growing wheat at 23/6.
What is really the responsibility of the Minister for Agriculture? I am very often at a loss to know what his responsibility is, because he does not appear to take any responsibility for anything that happens in this country. After all, we are an agricultural community and the Minister ought to be the watchdog of agriculture. He ought to be the man on the Executive Council to watch the interests of the farmers. That ought to be his job. Is he doing that? Have we any evidence that he has done it; or have we evidence that he is neglecting to do it? I maintain that we have ample evidence that he has neglected to do it. It is quite possible that the Minister is well-meaning; but I do not believe that he is as innocent about agricultural conditions in this country as he pretends to be. I do not believe that any man reared on a farm here, as he was, is as innocent or as ignorant of the conditions obtaining in this country at present as he pretends to be.
We had recently a coal-cattle pact in which, to my mind, the Minister for Agriculture ought to have been very interested. I do not know to what extent he interested himself at the time. I do say that the interests of the agricultural community were very badly looked after as far as that coal-cattle pact was concerned. Quite recently somebody said in this House by way of interruption: "But you voted for it." We did vote for it; we had no option but to vote for it. You might as well have asked a starving man would he or would he not take half a loaf rather than none. Of course, he would take half a loaf; he had to take it. Deputy Moore and Deputy O'Reilly said that it was manifestly unfair to the farmers for members of the Opposition to be trotting out that if the present Government were out of the way we could get in any quantity of produce we liked into Great Britain at any price we liked. The Opposition will admit one thing, that we would get whatever price was going in any case.
Let us see exactly how far the Minister for Agriculture has been watching our interests in this matter. A statement was made in April, 1935, by Mr. Thomas on the coal-cattle pact. That statement does not tally with the expressions we heard from the Government Benches at one time or another. Mr. Thomas, as reported in the Irish Independent of April 3rd, 1935, said: “The restriction with regard to the Irish Free State is a restriction due to political reasons, and if, happily, as I hope some day, a settlement is arrived at, there will be an entirely different figure.” That was something at least for the Minister for Agriculture to hang his hat upon, and something that other Fianna Fáil members ought to remember when speaking in this House. If there were an agreement on a better basis than the coal-cattle agreement, and if the penal tariffs were removed, there is evidence that it is quite possible that we would have a very different figure with regard to our cattle.
Quite recently Commonwealth countries like Australia, New Zealand, Canada and South Africa have been endeavouring to make better bargains for their agricultural produce in the British market, which is at our back door. What have we been doing? What has the Minister been doing? Every slice of that market taken by somebody else means a loss to us. Has the Minister been looking after our interests? All that time we have been listening to the President telling us that he was going to alter the Constitution. That is what we are getting out of it. Of course, it is a great solace to us to know that the Governor-General, even though he is at present a kind of figurehead, is also to go. That is the extent to which agriculture is being looked after.
We are fighting this economic war and boasting that we fired the first shot. Let us see how we are getting on with it and what the reactions are on the conditions in our own country. From figures given in this House by the Minister for Finance we find that up to 31st March last £14,576,435 was withheld by us from Great Britain. At the same time, figures were given in the British House of Commons which showed that the British Government collected during the same period £11,757,000. We withheld £14,000,000 and they collected £11,000,000. It may be said that we gained £3,000,000 by the transaction; but we did not. During that period we paid £6,323,000 to get our cattle into the British market, and over £2,000,000 to get our butter into that market. That is £8,000,000 it costs us to get into the British market, all of which is paid by the taxpayers. In addition £11,000,000 have been paid by the farmers off their stock, giving us a total of £19,000,000 to save £14,000,000. Is that good business? Is that the type of business that Deputy O'Reilly would like to engage in on his own? Yet he thinks it is good enough for the nation and for the farmers of the country.
What is the reaction of that? We have in this country at present a very deplorable state of affairs, and if the Government think they can boast out of it or if they think they can make Party capital out of it, I wish them luck of it. The state of affairs existing in the South of Ireland with regard to the non-payment of annuities makes very sad reading for anybody who takes up the daily papers. Mind you, when these people take up the daily papers and when they read that the British have collected £11,750,000 off the farmers of this country in respect of annuities which the present Government have not transmitted to Britain—when they read that and when they find their stocks depleted, find that they are not able to support their families or sell the live stock that they have, is it any wonder at all that they would regard a demand for another annuity as exorbitant?
Comment on this
I agree, Sir, but we are waging an economic war to which I maintain the Minister for Agriculture ought to have put an end. That is his job. If he is not the watch-dog for agriculture, if he is not there in the interests of the farmers of this country, he should not be there at all. That is his job. We have at the present time the most law-abiding and the most conservative people in the world driven to violence in this country. I do not condone it, but I understand it. We have a tradition in this country that demands of that kind have been met with physical violence before, demands for payments that are not due. If people do rise out against it, the Government ought to inquire what the real reason for that is. There is no use in saying that the people on the Opposition Benches have put them up to it. That kind of thing will not wash. He may get away with it to-day or to-morrow, for a month or for a year, but history will record it in black and white, and the blame will be laid at the proper doors.
There is another matter regarding which I should like to ask whether the Minister for Agriculture has interested himself or not. If he is the watch-dog of agriculture, as he ought to be, he should be able to tell us in this House why he permitted the farmers of this country to be denied of what was their right in the Agricultural Grant last year and this year. It was not enough to withhold £750,000 from the local authorities or from the farmers of this country last year, until, as evidence of the prosperity in which they are wallowing, agricultural land was docked of another £100,000 this year. Yet we have the Minister for Agriculture getting up and saying that everything is all right, and Deputy O'Reilly feels that the country is flourishing. There is even worse than that. There is still the worst feature of the whole Government policy. You may pauperise people; you may bring even decent people to violence, people who have always paid their way and who have always wanted to pay their way. But you have also demoralised them. You have demoralised the people of this country so that we have small farmers, some of them not so very small, put in the position that they must go and look for doles and free meat— for anything but an honest day's work, because they cannot get it. Once you did that, you destroyed the biggest asset we had in this country.
I do not know whether the Government realise what they have been doing in that respect. If the Government think that by this patching up of the situation, by giving free beef and giving doles, by endeavouring to patch up what cannot be patched up, they are improving matters, they are making the biggest mistake they ever could make. If agriculture is going to be our main industry it must pay. If it does not, it is going to die out and it is no use endeavouring to build up other industries on the ruins of the main industry. It cannot be done. Agriculture is going to provide the purchasing power of the people if it is the main industry. Will it be helped by such a thing as the slaughter of 250,000 calves, such as was carried out last year? According to the figures given by the Minister for Finance, a sum of over £135,000, at 12s. 6d. per skin, was paid out by way of bounty on the skins of slaughtered calves. That means there are 250,000 cattle less in the country this year, and we are better off and richer for it, according to Fianna Fáil. Again, we are told that we have 100,000 cows this year more than previously, and that is given as evidence of prosperity. How did they become cows? By bringing calves. Why have the people got into cows? They have gone into them because the dairying industry is being subsidised at the present time. Butter is being sold at an artificial price. Everything at the moment is at an artificial price. It does not matter whether you are buying or selling, the value of everything in this country at present is hidden.
These are the conditions that apply in the whole country at the present time, irrespective of what the Minister for Agriculture may endeavour to make the House think he feels but which he cannot feel. He must pay some attention, even to his own constituency, where they demanded quite recently free beef for the agricultural workers as they were paid such a bad wage. The appalling conditions into which agriculture has been driven in this country have got to be put right very soon. There are only two things that would justify the present Government policy as far as agriculture is concerned. One would be increased employment, and the other would be increased prosperity. Nobody has claimed increased prosperity for agriculture, and according to the figures given in the Agricultural Statistics from 1927 to 1933, agricultural employment has decreased from 1931 to 1933. We had the Minister for Industry and Commerce endeavouring to tell the House here the other day that there was prosperity in the pig industry since the present Government came into office. He told us in the same speech before to read the productions from his office and to study them. As a matter of fact he warned Deputy Dr. O'Higgins that he was taking the wrong meaning out of these productions, that he was not reading the right figures. Now with regard to pigs, we find on page 22 of the Agricultural Statistics publication for 1933 that the total number of pigs was 1,177,000 in 1927 and 1,227,000 in 1931— the highest number recorded from 1871. Then followed the decline to 930,934 in 1933, and that is the progress of the pig industry.
In addition to what Deputy Moore said, that the farmers in this country are not able to save anything and put it by, we have the fact that their credit is broken down. If there are some members of the Fianna Fáil Party who do not believe that the credit of the farmer is broken down, let them go into a bank or let them go to the Agricultural Credit Corporation, and try to obtain money, and they will find out the facts. Not only are the farmers in this country mulcted, so that up to £11,000,000 was collected from them in March last, but I find that their credit is completely gone at home. They have suffered by the de-valuation of every head of their stock in this country in the same manner as if these were exported to Britain.
We are being asked for a new policy. We do not propose to give you any new policy. The old one was very much better than the Fianna Fáil policy. People who started raising live stock in this country did not do it by accident. It was not an accident, nor was it designed by Britain for John Bull. We have the best live stock in the world, and Britain knows that. Since the Fianna Fáil Party sent their Ministers to say that they would kill the cattle trade, they took the fatal step. They have got to get back from that, and to remember that this country is principally a live stock country. Let them advocate more tillage and greater tillage; let them divide farms into smaller farms, compatible with economic conditions, and let them say there is live stock on the land and we want to feed them and make them pay.
Talk about wheat? What is the labour content of wheat? I am a grower of wheat, and if I could produce men in connection with that scheme as wonderful as the Minister for Agriculture, and if they could stack three acres of wheat in a single day, as the Minister said he could, the labour content of wheat would, indeed, be very little. But even allowing that there are very few supermen like the Minister for Agriculture, what is the labour content of wheat? Suppose a man was to sow ten acres of wheat, reap it, stack it, thresh it, and send it to the market, that is all he could do. But suppose he had ten acres of oats, which he fed to his live stock, and got rid of his oats in that way, and got rid of his live stock, in which of these operations would there be greater labour content? Fianna Fáil Deputies who have been engaged in farming should get after the Minister for Agriculture and not let him be pulled by the nose by anyone else. They should impress upon him what his job is, and get him to do his job.
Comment on this
There are certain factors in regard to agricultural policy which have not been mentioned so far. There were facts which we have all forgotten. We ought to get back to the years 1904 or 1905 and see what was happening. Take any rural district such, for example, as Bandon or Clonakilty. What was the position then? I remember at that time when 12 splendid yearlings were sold for £3 15s. apiece. I remember my father taking five tons of hay to Cork and getting £8 for first crop hay. I remember when 60 or 70 horses were engaged for the carting of hay to the market in Bandon. That is one of the facts not mentioned. It was the big change brought about by the use of oil as machine fuel, and the use of motor cars that finished agriculture in this country. That is the position beyond the control of this Government or any other Government. It is the position beyond the control or solution of any Government. Even if we had a Republic for the whole of Ireland, these facts would have to be faced. Deputy Brennan told us that the cattle trade did not develop in Ireland by accident, and he mentioned that the British had not designed it for us. I challenge him to go back to 1883.
Comment on this
The historical records show that the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland in opening the Horse Show in Cork that year repeated the self-same words that were used by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney in opening this debate. There is no doubt that John Bull has got us at the weakest point of our armour, because they were able to control the market to which our cattle were exported. Admitting that, and if the Opposition had admitted it, and if as men they put their heads together, and stood with us, the financial victory would have been achieved. That would have enabled the country to win through. I admit there is suffering. I know that the farmer is the one man in this country who has never been properly recompensed for the work he has done. But apart from that fact, if independent, he has a life equal to anyone in this country. Personally if I were independent, I would not exchange my life as a farmer for that of any other. The farmer may not have thousands of pounds in the bank but he has the great blessing of leading an open air life in the country.
The Minister wants practical suggestions. We ought to realise not merely for ourselves, but for the whole country, there are great issues at stake. Deputy Brennan may say that our trials were brought about by this Government. They may have made mistakes. Were it not for mistakes that were made by the first people who were put into this world we would all be able to fly up to heaven at will. If we are suffering to-day we are suffering for the mistakes and for the sins of the past. The question is how to get out of it with the least possible suffering. The atmosphere during this debate to-day has been improved and has been very friendly, and there have been suggestions made from many angles. If that continues we will be at least attracted to one point where the issue at stake would be more exposed and men could reason and finally come to the point at issue, namely, that all our troubles, difficulties and confusions are not created within this country but without.
Deputy Bennett spoke about the war period and I remember during the war period getting a cheque for £42 for three Shropshire sheep. But what happened? I can prove that there are more old debts hanging over since the war period than will ever be cleared off. It is an extraordinary thing that it was in those times which were considered prosperous and glorious that the farmers went into debt. How did that happen? The position was that each farmer's son—I and the rest of us—sold our stock and invested in land. The great financier said "You are getting £40 to-day for your sow; to-morrow she will be worth only £7 or £8 but you have to pay me back pound for pound." That is a very important factor which I would put to the Minister as a member of the Executive Council. One of the big things we should insist upon is that the claims of these banks and these debt contractors should be based on the values of the present day. Another factor which controls us now is that in those days, and up to, and beyond, 1928, there was accommodation given in the shape of overdrafts by banks. To-day that has ceased completely. There was no earthly difficulty then in getting money, even by farmers who were pretty well stuck beforehand, but, at present, if you take half the country with you, you have no earthly hope of getting money unless you have some money on deposit. That is another serious factor which the Minister should consider.
My suggestion is that, where humanly possible, we should go back again to horse transport in this country. Men will tell me that you cannot put back the clock, that it is a human impossibility. The self same thing was said, I expect, before the Dark Ages, until the Great Man above said: "Thus far shalt thou go and no further," and at present, from the way the world is going, man is going to invent something again that will destroy himself, and he will have to go back to the old order of things and to the horse transport that will be there for all time. There are various other things affecting agriculture, and we farmers are a bit selfish in our own way. I will give an instance from West Cork. We have co-operative societies all over West Cork, and, at the rate they are going, they will have the grass growing around the doors of every little shopkeeper in the towns and villages in West Cork. I maintain that that is wrong and morally wrong. Not alone are they selling manures and stuffs of that character, which I agree they are entitled to do in a reasonable way, but they are selling boot-laces, pennyworths of mustard, snuff, tobacco and everything else, even to the Southern Star on a Sunday. I honestly think it would be the duty of the Minister for Agriculture to bring in legislation to stop that, because those shopkeepers are there anyhow for generations, and at the rate things are going they are going to be wiped out. I realise that the Minister does not appreciate the gravity of the situation, and I ask other Deputies from West Cork to give their views on the subject. I think it is only fair to these poor shopkeepers in the small towns and villages that they should be helped.
There are other factors, too, which I am sure Deputy Belton will reveal to the House and with which I would be very much in agreement. Before the Truce, England might have said: "This is all a mistake; I am wasting men and wasting ammunition; I will try different tactics altogether; I will withdraw every one of them and I will beat you with finance and the curtailment of finance." Of course, I will be told that there are not five or ten people in the world who understand finance. I agree that there are not five or ten people who understand the ingenuity, the brains or the devices that brought about the present position of finance and created a position in which it is scarce, for the good of the classes at the expense of the masses. That is one thing we do know. In Emerson's essays, which I read as a young fellow, it is stated that man is only man for the thought within, and that man is only man while he expresses that thing that ticks within the soul of man. If, as he said, artificial learning and everything else departs from the original thing, he is man no longer. He will often find that the thoughts he first put forth, and which he rejected in scorn, afterwards assert themselves. In that regard, you have to-day the Agricultural Credit Corporation. I believe it is not worth three rows of pins so far as the farmers are concerned, and if, to-morrow, I had power, as a Minister or a dictator, I would do away with it, because it is useless, for the reasons that they are giving money at six per cent. and they will give it only to special persons. There are times when a £10 or a £20 note would be a wonderful advantage to a small farmer, but so far as that place over in 2 Merrion Square is concerned, it is simply there, in my opinion, to help bankers to recover some other debts from the farmers.
So far as the great national issue is concerned, I would personally lose the last cow I had and the last roof over my head before I would surrender one principle to an outside power, because I believe that she has staked her cards on the will of one people against the will and endurance of another. If we have the patience and power to endure, we are going to win, and, in my opinion, win very shortly and decisively. If we can once get united on the main issue, we can each of us put up constructive ideas and healthy criticism, but the unfortunate thing in this House is that there is a barrier which one or the other side cannot cross. I might attack the Minister by putting forward healthy criticism, but I will not do it, because I am, as it were, giving way to the Opposition, and if a member of the Opposition like Deputy McGovern puts forward a helpful suggestion, he is hauled over the coals and he will not do it. There was one thing which Deputy McGovern said to-day which I appreciate and about which I believe he was honest. I think that in his own heart he believes that if there is one man can bring this country over its difficulties to ultimate success it is Eamon de Valera.
Deputy Brennan referred to wheat and the manuring of wheat. Here is one fact worthy of consideration which was given in Professor Baldwin's little school book—a little book worth reading but which cannot be got now. From 1841 to 1847 you had double the population in Ireland that you have now, and you had only half the amount of cattle to make the manure. How did they manure the land?
Comment on this
I admit the burning was done all right on part of it. The old art of manure making is also gone out of this country. Take, for instance, the sandhills. In reply to Deputy Belton, I would like to point out that there is a place called Inishannon, 12 miles in from Kinsale Harbour. There was sand brought there from Kinsale Harbour; 100 men were employed to draw sand from it. I got it analysed, and it was found to contain nitrogenous matter and 50 per cent. pure lime.
Comment on this
I was merely explaining how the land was manured. Deputy Brennan used the argument that we cannot grow the wheat if we cannot manure the land; in other words, we will not have the cattle and, therefore, we will not have the manure. The extraordinary thing is that in the period to which I have referred they did it. I do not intend to delay the House very much longer. I only wish to be helpful in this debate. I, at any rate, am definitely convinced that there is no other policy than that advocated by the Government. So far as withdrawing our line in the national struggle is concerned, as long as I live I will oppose that to the end. If we could get together as a whole House and try to do what we can for agriculture we might agree on one fundamental issue, the fundamental issue that things come to an end. And so will this come to an end. The question is whether you are going to come to a triumphant end or meet with defeat. On the policy of agriculture hangs the whole position, because our line has been attacked in its weakest point, and if we do not rally and barricade and strengthen that, we must suffer. If we leave the line open we are bound to end in defeat, with the evil consequences that follow.
Comment on this
The last speaker is a brave man. He made the suggestion here to cross certain barriers, but I was surprised that a man of his bravery funked a certain fence when he came to it. He suggests accommodation between Parties here on one fundamental issue and that is, in effect, no surrender on the economic war. I would like to ask the Deputy if he would not support a condition precedent to that stand. Is it not time that the Government should concede what they have been requested to concede and what, I think, the Deputy would agree with? That is, that the time has come for a survey as to the proper distribution of the burden of the economic war. I am sure the Deputy agrees with that. Recently I heard the Minister for Agriculture flinging a query at the Opposition that if they put down a motion concerning agriculture there would be time given to debate it. I suggest to Deputy Hales that the motion in my name and in the name of Deputy Kent on the Order Paper should have been taken months ago; not now but many months ago the Government should have given time for a discussion of that motion. If after a proper, fair and impartial inquiry it is found that agriculture in this country is only bearing its fair share of the burden of the economic war, I would be one of the first to say that no farmer has any cause for grumbling. The Government have consistently refused to set up this tribunal to investigate as to the distribution of the economic war burden, and I take it they are afraid to face the issue. I would be glad if Deputy Hales would add his name to this motion.
Comment on this
I agree to make you one of the tribunal. All we farmers want is to get out the stuff, get it there for investigation and that is the very thing the Government do not want because they are anxious to camouflage the issue. I must say the Minister for Agriculture, when introducing this Vote, was helpful and seemed to be anxious to help. He introduced it in a very good spirit and I hope it will be met in that spirit. I hope that criticisms of his statement will not be taken as carping criticisms but criticisms honestly given in the belief that they are true. The Minister gave figures of cattle production for 1926. I do not know why he picked on 1926. In dealing with the butter situation at the present time, he said that milk in the creameries for the manufacture of butter was fetching 5½d a gallon. I challenge that. I say that no creamery in Ireland is paying 5½d and no creamery has paid it for a considerable time. The Minister followed that up by saying that 30,000 cwts. of cheese would be made this year. There is where a little extra was paid. The Minister also mentioned that we were going to can meat. I suppose we will can all we can and we will can all we cannot. I think we will have to "can" the lot— throw it away. What is the sense of canning meat in this country? What is it going to be used for? Where is a market going to be found for canned meat? Canned meats originated in out-of-the-way places where there was a surplus of cattle in order economically to take it to big centres of population. I think it is a terrific joke.
The Minister has awakened up now to the pitfalls that were in the Pigs and Bacon Act. He finds that the curers have the ball at their foot and they have been manipulating the position preparatory to a good send-off when they get the machinery provided by the Pigs and Bacon Act in working operation. The Minister talked of the fact as he said that in 1935 we will have a market for £3,000,000 worth of wheat and beet that we did not have in 1926 and 1927. We could have a market for three times that amount if we taxed the people to put up the money to pay the subsidies. But fundamentally is there a profit out of that? Of course there is not. I am sorry Deputy Hales has gone.
Comment on this
There is no doubt that since the repeal of the corn laws the trend of farming in this country was dictated by the development of new countries. Corn was a thing that could be handled for shipment from new lands and that crushed out corn growing in this country. We have been taught to believe that it was the British that drove our lands into grass. If the Minister will look up the statistics published by his own Department he will see that the trend of prices from the 'forties down to a few years ago was all in favour of animal products, grass products, as against cereals. That tendency has not been so much noticeable perhaps of late, because there are new devices for the transport of meat, butter and cheese in a comparatively fresh condiiton. The refrigerating plants have been invented and these are bringing those distant lands into closer competition with the lands in the old countries—more and more every day. That was the position here before the Government, when they came into office. The economic trend with its results and consequences was there before them. New developments in refrigerating plant were also there before them and they set about deliberately to change that economic trend.
If the Minister will look at the price of store cattle he will find that no other commodity increased in the last 60 or 70 years to a greater extent than store cattle, and that nothing diminished more than wheat. He set about the cultivation of wheat here, and concurrently with setting about the cultivation of wheat he or his Government embroiled themselves in the economic war. As Deputy Brennan has pointed out, the Minister for Agriculture should be the watchdog for agriculture, but he has not proved a useful watchdog, because, as has been stated here and admitted by the President a short time ago, when the fight started over the economic war the British collected all they claimed. They collected it off the agricultural produce exported by this country, including, of course, the live stock. I noticed that the Minister, when giving a list of the prices here to-day, ignored entirely what the British were taking off our goods by way of the penal tariffs. The President anyway admitted some time ago that the loss to agriculture here could be measured by the British tariffs less the bounty. That, he agreed, worked out at about £3,000,000. He also agreed that a similar amount was lost on the home market—that is, about £6,000,000 in all. There was agreement up to that point. But then the President, like the Minister for Agriculture, like the other members of the Executive Council, and like the Fianna Fáil Party, says: "Look at what we are giving for wheat." What is being given for wheat would have to be given if there never had been an economic war. The subsidy for wheat, whether by way of protection or whether by revenue tax, means the lifting from the people of a certain amount of money and paying it back in bounty. That is something that has to be done in order to offer an inducement for the production of wheat against the production of other crops that have been grown in this country. The subsidy for wheat has nothing whatever to do with the loss sustained by the farmers on account of the economic war. The Minister and the Government generally should see whither they are travelling. They should see that the necessity that has arisen to tax all the necessities of life and to impose new taxation for hundreds of thousands of pounds more for the increased revenue that is required this year as against last year is not producing the revenue. Something must be wrong somewhere when the yield from taxation is not what it should be. The Minister and other speakers on the Fianna Fáil side dealt with the question of the price of butter. The position with regard to butter is that we are getting 85/- a cwt. for our butter now. I think I would be right in saying that the British deduct from that about 34/- a cwt. for the tariff. That leaves 51/- a cwt., and that is all that this country is getting from Britain for the butter exported to them. The policy which the Minister has adopted is this: he accepted the position that anything under 102/- would not pay for the production of butter, and this should be of great interest to people who, like Deputy Bennett, are prepared to subsidise butter but will not subsidise anything else. Personally I would not subsidise either of them. I would get at it in another way, and I will tell the Minister what I think is the way to get at it. If your only means of livelihood is a certain thing, you cannot subsidise that, because you must get something out of that thing before you can pay a subsidy, and I can see nothing else productive in this country but agriculture. Of course money can be shown in other things, but that money which can be shown in other things represents old savings out of agriculture. If you are to start from scratch in this country, agriculture must pay or nothing else can.
The Minister wants 102/- for the producer of butter. How does he go about that? He taxes the home consumer 39/- per cwt. He guarantees 102/-. That 39/- per cwt. for butter consumed here is thrown into the Exchequer, and the Exchequer then pays the difference. If we had no economic war it would pay at the present time the difference between 85/- and 102/-, but with the economic war on it has to meet the difference between 51/- and 102/-. 102/- is guaranteed, but I challenge the Minister to say what creamery has got it in the last year. We have been told in this House that it is paid to creameries. There is what is known as the best seller, that is the creamery which gets the best price for its butter. If that price is 102/-, say somebody got 87/-, that would be 15/- that would be allowed to fill up the gap there. If others got 85/- or 84/-, the gap there would not be filled up. They would only get the difference between the best seller's price and 102/-. I am aware that an inquiry was made from 80 creameries, and the highest price that any of those 80 creameries got was 100/-. I should like the Minister to name a half-dozen creameries who got 102/- for their butter last year. In any case the people at home have to pay a retail price of about 1/5 per lb. for their butter. The Minister is aware that in Australia they were confronted with the same problem, but they did not tax the people for it. The Minister is aware that Australian butter is fetching at the present time in the British market 87/-, 89/- and 90/- per cwt. The Minister, I suppose, like his colleague the Minister for Finance, is a Republican. At one time the Minister and his colleagues believed not only in political, but in financial independence. Now, as full-blown Republicans here they ought to be at least as anxious for financial independence as some imperialist Dominions. I do not know whether or not it is news to the Minister that in this country we have not financial independence. In Australia they have; in Canada they have; in South Africa and New Zealand they have. How did Australia face up to the butter situation? The Commonwealth Bank of Australia depreciated Australian currency by 25 per cent. Can the Minister do that? Can the Republican Government of the Free State do that?
Comment on this
Not without the leave of the Dáil. They must get the permission of the Dáil first.
Comment on this
But you have appointed a Banking Commission to "examine and report on the system in Saorstát Eireann of currency, banking, credit, public borrowing and lending, and the pledging of State credit on behalf of agriculture, industry and the social services, and to consider and report what changes, if any, are necessary or desirable to promote the social and economic welfare of the community and the interests of agriculture and industry." That is all you have done. That is the declaration of a republic you have made.
Comment on this
You have appointed a Committee and you have asked that Committee "Will you examine and report as to whether we shall be financially free or not."
Comment on this
The Deputy recently produced that document on another Estimate. International banking, currency and credit, cannot be relevant to every Estimate. It was not the Minister for Agriculture who set up the Banking Commission. The matter before the House is an Estimate for agriculture, and debate is confined to the Department of Agriculture. On Estimates, as the Deputy is aware, legislation may not be advocated. To attain the objects he now proposes, legislation would be necessary. He has, in fact, questioned the Minister as to whether he will introduce legislation. That is not in order on Estimates. He must deal with the matter before the House, namely conflicting policies on agriculture.
Comment on this
If the Deputy suggests a matter which requires new legislation, then he is indirectly suggesting legislation.
Comment on this
The Minister said that in order to be as big a child in the Empire as Australia or New Zealand they would want legislation. Those Republicans who are kicking against the Empire are not as fully developed —and there is nothing to stop them— as the Dominions of New Zealand and Australia. Where is the Republicanism?
Comment on this
But the Estimate and the speeches on it have a very close relation to agricultural prices.
Comment on this
I was comparing, and I think when I give a little explanation you will agree that I may go on——
Comment on this
The Deputy was quite in order in advancing reasons for certain results in Australian agricultural prices——
Comment on this
Of course, any normalminded person who would visit this country, and hear so much of a row about Republicanism and Imperialism —anybody who does not shout for a Republic is an Imperialist—would at once take it that those who were shouting for a Republic had got to the last fence; that they were chained down and could not do anything until they got over that fence——
Comment on this
I am just crossing it, A Chinn Comhairle. If there were any sincerity in the republican talk we hear, there should be no need for legislation to bring us up to the standards I am referring to. Here is what Australia did. Australia depreciated its currency by 25 per cent. and New Zealand did the same. So that the Australian merchant sending butter to Great Britain gets 87/- per cwt. for it, and when that 87/- is taken back to Australia it is worth 109/-; 7/- more than we are taxed for in this country to give John Bull cheap butter. The producers in Australia get 7/- more than we do without paying any 4d. per lb. What is more, the Australian consumer has his butter, without any loss to the producer, at a wholesale price of 109/-. The Australian people, producers included, were adamant against any such thing as an artificial raising of the price of butter in Australia. They wanted the consumers in Australia to get butter at the lowest possible price so that they would not be switched off butter on to margarine.
I suggest to the Minister that we should be at least as big a Dominion or nation in the Commonwealth as Australia or New Zealand. If we were, we could have depreciated our currency without any trouble by 25 per cent., and we would be getting at present 106/- per cwt. for our butter without any levy on the creameries. Why is it not done? How does the Minister think that agriculture is going to survive here? I will take it first as if the economic war was settled and we were waving the flags that we would wave. I will take it that way in one case and I will also take it in the other way, that the economic war was on and we were winning or losing, if you like. There is no use in talking about winning or losing because we have lost it long ago. We will take it first that there is no economic war. We send our butter to the British market and get 85/- per cwt. That 85/-, without any British tariff, is only worth 85/- when we bring it back here. The Australian sends his butter to the British market and gets 87/-, which is worth 109/- when he takes it to Australia. The New Zealander gets from 90/- to 92/-, and that is worth 112/- when he takes it home. Immediately Great Britain went off the gold standard, Denmark also depreciated her currency by 25 per cent. The Dane gets from 100/- to 105/- for his butter in the British market, and that is worth 125/- to him when he takes it to Denmark. I would ask the Minister when replying to tell the House and the country how we can compete in the British market with Denmark, New Zealand, and Australia in butter when they have an exchange advantage over us of 25 per cent.
Let us take another item—meat, which the Minister told us something about to-day. The price of Argentine meat in Smithfield market is about 3/6 per 8 lbs. or 5¼d. per lb. I think that is a bit higher than the minimum price fixed by the Minister of 25/- per cwt. live weight. I am not quite sure of the ratio of live to dead weight, but I think it would be 1½d. per lb. better than we are getting for our meat—the minimum price fixed by Act of Parliament here which the Minister blames the farmers for not securing and which they did not secure. I should like the Minister to consider that the Argentine producer and exporter of meat to the British market has nearly 70 per cent. of a currency advantage over us owing to the working of the depreciated currency. I am afraid that all this talk about currency is bewildering to the Republicans.
Comment on this
Not a bit of wonder. They have been shouting for a republic for 10 or 15 years, but they did not know what they were talking about. I should like the Minister to explain how, without any economic war on, our farmers could compete in the British or any market against countries working on a currency depreciated relatively to ours. We were sending cattle to Belgium, and the Minister told us we were getting a satisfactory price. The reason was obvious. At that time Belgium was in the gold block. We were off it, and we had an exchange advantage. Although we got a small price, we won on the exchange. But the moment Belgium went off the gold standard, we lost that market. If Germany went off the gold standard to-morrow, we would lose the German market. It only holds while Germany is on the gold standard. The Minister referred to the new market which he discovered in Spain. I had some samples of Spanish oranges which I meant to bring in, and I am sorry I did not.
Comment on this
That is the trouble. You could not suck them; not even Deputy Kelly could suck them, because there was not a suck left in them; they are like old timber. The quota given to Spain for these old timber oranges is two-thirds. If the Minister wants to get information on that I will take him round to-morrow morning to the fruit merchants in Dublin, who will import them and who are making their living by them. Then, if he is not afraid, we will get a few addresses from them and we shall go, not to Grafton Street, but to the back streets of Dublin, in which live the old women who have to make a living selling these oranges. God help the Minister if they knew that he was the Minister responsible for bringing in Spanish oranges here. He would get a warm reception around Gloucester Diamond.
I said before the Minister came in, and I repeat it now, that I appreciated the way in which he introduced this Vote. The Minister knows that I am not an antagonistic critic of his wheat policy. But the Minister must decide, and I, as one who believes in the development of wheat growing in this country, would like to see him consider it, not to proceed too quickly in developing this wheat policy because he may over-reach himself. At the present time it is very easy for him to do that. There is a surplus of 200,000,000 bushels of Canadian wheat on hands, and it is estimated that from the prairies alone there are 400,000,000 bushels of wheat of a new crop. There is every indication that will be sold at about 12/- or 13/- a barrel. It is very important to bear in mind the world price of a commodity that you are trying to develop and which you are developing at a loss. Such rapid development may sour people against producing it. Though in favour of wheat growing, I quite see the danger of the arguments that have been used against it to-day. I quite see that when normal conditions, if we ever have normal conditions, are restored in this country, the greatest problem the Minister for Agriculture will have will be to get beet provided for the beet factories. Wheat, too, will have to be much dearer than it is now. The only thing that popularises these crops at the present time is that there is no other agricultural crop that can be grown, I will not say at a profit, but without a loss.
The Minister knows that beet cannot be grown at 37/6, the flat rate which is paid now. He knows that that is a very bad business arrangement. What was visualised in the Sugar Act was 35/- for beet, with 17 per cent. sugar content. Now the growers do not know very well what they are growing. Another fault which I have to find with the Minister is that I do not think that any grower of beet in this country knows what breed or strain of beet he is growing. I should like if I could be corrected on that, if what I am saying is not a fact. From any sources which I have been able to tap, I have been informed that the seed is provided by foreigners and that we do not know what strain of seed is being put into the ground. Certainly no attempt is being made to breed a strain of seed here.
It was said in the discussion here to-day that wheat is only increasing at the expense of oats. My opinion is that in this discussion extreme views on agriculture were developed too much. On one side the position was taken up of extensive tillage and on the other of grass products. No matter to what side any member of this House may be inclined, there is one thing, if he has any practical knowledge of the matter, he must know, and that is that there cannot be such a thing as all tillage and no stock. Of course we could have all stock and no tillage. If an intermediate course were developed, it would probably meet the case much better. It is the only course that in the long run could survive. The Minister for Agriculture has shifted his ground on many occasions here. As Deputy Brennan said he did admit some time ago that more tillage meant more live stock. He contradicted that afterwards but he kind of agreed to it again.
The growing of wheat at the present time is an entirely uneconomic proposition. I think the Minister for Agriculture ought not be responsible for a policy that will destroy the fertility of the soil. He knows that most of the increased wheat production in this country is carried out by a method of farming that would not be called good husbandry. He knows that in many parts of the country a third crop of wheat has been taken from lea. That is not farming. To keep land, as it is described, "in heart," you must have six or seven years in which you will not sow wheat in it. There is quite a lot of wheat land in this country, sufficient to meet our requirements by growing wheat on that land only every six or seven years. I put it to the Minister that if he asks his technical advisers in the grain world they will tell him that the intensive growing of wheat, especially soft wheat—the only wheat that is being grown here—there is great danger that the soil will become impregnated with disease. The Minister will not contradict that. He cannot contradict it because I am only repeating what I got years ago from the very experts the Minister has to consult to get expert knowledge here. But unless these experts have changed their minds, with the change of Government they must give him that view. They cannot have changed their minds with the change of Government because I have got these expert views also from other sources. There is the danger that good wheat lands that are being cropped with wheat too frequently now, without any help in the way of farmyard manure, will become impregnated with disease. As regards farmyard manure, I do not see where it can come from.
The Minister said that fault was found with the Department of Agriculture for the manner in which they distributed fat cattle licences; but now he said they were giving them to committees of agriculture to see what they could do. The Minister has been distributing licences from the 1st January last. Surely, his Department must have acquired some knowledge as to some method of distributing these licences. But it is strange to relate that the Department of Agriculture, with over one and a half year's experience of distributing these licences, have now sent down a circular to the committees of agriculture, without any prior notice, saying that as from the 1st July the committees of agriculture would distribute those licences. After a few days, another circular followed, to say as the committees of agriculture had not called meetings the Minister would not be in a position to allocate the licences until the middle of July. Why did not the Department of Agriculture send to these committees in order to get the value of their experience over a year and a half? The Department has been groping in the dark for over a year and a half and they failed and could not advise us or the committees of agriculture as to what should be done. It is most extraordinary to find that we have here a public Department for the upkeep of which almost a £1,000,000 has to be paid by the tax-payer, and that after distributing cattle licences for over a year and a half they have shown that they have failed, and that the distribution of licences is to be done by committees of agriculture composed of old farmers, and that these people are to do the distribution in their own time. The Department of Agriculture which requires nearly £1,000,000 for its upkeep could not do that work.
Let us examine this a little further. In the beginning we were told that the producers could not get the licences at all and that they were to be given to the dealers. Fortunes have been made, and I defy contradiction of this, by dealers in connection with this matter. It has been said in this House that in this economic war of ours there are people making enormous fortunes. Fortunes have been made quicker out of cattle licences than in any other way. The Department of Agriculture, whose duty it was to protect Irish farmers, have ensured that the Irish farmer, as well as having to pay £6 per head export duty on his beast, has also to pay £2 or £3 for a licence, because the Department of Agriculture was not able to devise a system that would convey the licences direct to the persons to whom they rightly belong and that would enable those persons to get the full value of their beasts.
I heard of a person who got an order for 150 head of cattle. I will not say in what county. It was not in Dublin. But a man in Dublin got into a motor car and drove to a place 80 miles from Dublin where he knew there was a merchant who traded in licences. This Department of highly-paid officials was not able to protect the farmers. Let me now come to the practical side, the utility side of this question. Dublin County is one of the first fattening counties in Ireland. Dublin, Meath, to a less extent Kildare, and to a small extent Louth, are the grass beef-producing counties. The Minister will admit that the counties I have named produce 80 per cent. of the grass-fed beef, and they should at least be entitled to 80 per cent. of the licences. County Dublin is the earliest grass county in Ireland, and although it does not turn out as much grass-fed beef as Meath and, perhaps, Kildare in the year, yet probably it turns out more in July than any of the others, with the possible exception of Meath. Our census for July for fat cattle in Dublin was a little over 5,000 and we got 411 licences. Who will get up here and say that with 5,000 fat cattle in the County Dublin for the month of July, and with many more to follow in August and September, we should get a permit to shift out of the country only 411? And we did not get that until near the middle of the month of July—about the 12th. Even these 411 will have to pay £6 per head tariff. What is going to happen to the others? I am not going to swear that although we have a return of 5,000 fat cattle that that figure is absolutely reliable. I want to be quite fair in this matter. But even if it was only half true, what good are licences for 411 beasts? That would leave over 2,000 cattle in hands. How is that county to meet its commitments in rates and annuities? The real trouble is the impossibility of cashing the other cattle at all. Let the Minister apply his mind to that. I would like him to approach it in the way he approached the introduction of this Estimate. I do not mind telling the Minister that my opinion to the Committee—we met yesterday or the day before—was that we should not go on with the issuing of these licences. Taking Dublin, Meath, Kildare, and Louth and Westmeath as one county for fat cattle purposes, for the month of July, we are left with four counties. I understand that the export of fat cattle to Britain is about 10,000 a month. How does it come that we, perhaps the largest producers of grass-fed beef, for the month of July get only 411 licences out of 10,000 —about four per cent.? Is it that the 10,000 was divided by 26? I know a little more about it. I know that a county which applied for licences got very nearly one licence for every two applications. They got nearly 200 licences. We looked for 5,000 and we got 411. I hope that the recent by-election has nothing to do with that.
I heard the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and, I think, the Minister for Agriculture, though he was not so emphatic as the Minister for Industry and Commerce—he does not hit the bench, but his colleague does; he hit the bench until his knuckles ought to be sore—saying that we cannot afford to lose the economic war. The farmers are paying for it, and is the old farmer to be like every broken soldier, the victim of politicians and flag-waving, starting the fighting, and ending in the workhouse when the fight is over, whether it is won, lost or drawn? I think that is what it is coming to. The Minister for Industry and Commerce supported this economic war. The Minister for Agriculture did, too. It is only some time ago that I read where he said that we had it won already, but I shall not be too hard on him for that. There is talk of a war now between Italy and Abyssinia. Suppose Abyssinia challenged Italy to a fight when she had no arms, no ammunition and no equipment, except what she could get from Italy, I I should like to ask the Minister who would win.
Comment on this
You answered me and said that we could not deflate our currency and deal with the butter problem here, as Australia did, without passing an Act of Parliament.
Comment on this
Keep your eye on that. In order to get control, financial and economic, in the country, you would have to pass an Act of Parliament.
Comment on this
I hope, for the sake of this country, the Minister is not so foolish as he wants us to believe. Does the Minister not know that the central bank of every State controls the whole economic life—money, credit, borrowing and everything else—of that State, and does he not know that the Bank of England is our central bank, controlling the whole economic life of this country? And a Republican Cabinet, with entire control of this State, economically and financially, vested in the Bank of England, declared war on England and thought they would win.
Comment on this
If you do—and I say it without any personal application—it is in Grangegorman the lot of you should be. When England could not sell her goods abroad, what did she do? She handled her currency; America did the same; Japan the same and Belgium did the same. But these highfalutin Republicans we have here did not understand what was the key to economic activity.
Comment on this
I thought the Minister was going to say that it might be all for luck, and perhaps it is, because we know the saying about children and edged tools. It might be dangerous to have that instrument in the hands of the Executive Council. We have the Minister for Agriculture admitting that they have no control over the banking, currency or credit of this State.
Comment on this
The Minister said it without knowing it. The Minister said that to handle the butter position here as Australia handled it, we would require new legislation.
Comment on this
And what would the new legislation be for?—to establish a central bank here. That is the only possible thing the legislation could be for, because you could not touch your currency without the central bank and you had to establish that. That is admitting that we have not got it here, and, therefore, the central bank of our banking system must be somewhere else, and, of course, it is in the Bank of England. The Bank of England is controlled by its Governor and the British Chancellor of the Exchequer, in consultation with the British Prime Minister. When we declared war on these Britishers and were going to squeeze them into starvation, imagine how Montagu Norman and the British Prime Minister and Chancellor must have smiled at the big brains over here. The Minister for Industry and Commerce then comes in here and, thumping the table, says "We must win," with the British holding all our arms, all our ammunition and all our food. How can we fire a shot? The President was right when he denied that he fired the first shot. Of course, he did not fire the first shot, because he had not got a shot left to fire. The British had all the shots, and they have been pumping lead into us for the last three years.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce says we cannot afford to lose. I agree that it will be a terrible humiliation and loss to lose, but the blame for losing can rest only on certain shoulders. It can rest only on the shoulders of those who challenged England to an economic conflict before we in this country had full control of the economic and financial resources of this country.
The Minister has brought Bills in here, no doubt with the best intention in the world, fixing prices for cereals. In addition to the monetary advantages that our competitors have in the British markets, they have other advantages. Let us take the Argentine. Its maize crop this year shows 8,000,000 tons of an exportable surplus. That will be sold at scrap prices. That is going to produce beef somewhere, eggs, poultry, pork for sale in the British market, and there it is going to compete with our produce. Whether or not we use any of that maize does not matter. From the Danube States it is estimated 11,000,000 tons of maize will be dumped on the European markets this year, also at scrap prices. The Minister fixes the price of oats and barley. By the way, I am afraid a Deputy to-day fell into a trap when he said barley was grown in this country only for malting. It is principally grown here for feeding. How can the Minister fix an economic price for barley or oats when they have not reached their ultimate destination, their ultimate destination being the finished article in pork, beef, etc., as the case may be?
Our grain will have to compete with scrap price maize producing similar finished agricultural produce. That is really the price that will count and, if it is not counted during the development of the finished article, it will be counted finally in smaller returns to the feeder of stock in this country. Perhaps his stock may show a loss while his competitor feeding on cheap maize can show a big profit. It is an utter impossibility, absolute foolishness, to try to fix a price for cereals when those cereals have to be fed to animals which will find a market outside this country, where they have to compete with animals fed on maize and other cereals from other countries. The little conditions which exist here will not govern the market; the world conditions will establish the real price.
The Minister said here to-day that he will have to bring in a Bill soon to compel the butcher to give the minimum price of 25/- a cwt. fixed by an Act last year. There is no use in the Minister trying to shift on that matter. I told him when he was introducing the Bill that it was futile to try to get a minimum price for beef when we were not able to consume all the beef we had. Take the 411 licences for fat stock that he gave to us to distribute to the farmers of Dublin who claim to have 5,000 fat beasts for sale. Those 411 licences will ship 411 beasts at the minimum price of 22/- or 25/-, whatever it is. What are the people to do with the others? Supposing a butcher says "I will give you £1 a cwt. for ten cattle that are finished and are only wasted by being left any longer." Supposing I had those ten cattle, would the Minister say I was wrong in accepting £1 per cwt. when I could not get an offer from anybody else? Was I to be obliged to keep them there wasting and pining? Of course not. I would take £1 and then how will I evade the law? I told the Minister how, and that is the way it has been evaded every day since. Nobody can stop it until there is a sufficient demand for all we produce.
If the butcher asks me to give him a receipt for 22/- or 25/- a cwt., do you think I would not give it to him? Of course I would, and it is done every day in the market. It is futile and absurd for the Minister to try to fix a minimum price for an article when you have twice as much of that article on your hands as you have consumption for. I will be interested to see what sort of Bill the Minister will bring in to catch people who, through necessity, must evade the Act. I think we should hear something from the Minister about the position with regard to the economic war. Not only is the economic war responsible for £6 per head on the older cattle, but I am convinced, and everybody who speaks his mind here or outside is convinced, that the economic war is responsible for the quotas as well.
If there is to be any chance of industrial revival here you must have agriculture flourishing. The famous dictum of Arthur Griffith to make this a two-armed nation cannot be achieved by cutting off the one arm that the nation has; so far from making this a two-armed nation the present Government has only succeeded in partially severing the arm it already had. I would like to know from the Minister what is the position of the economic war? Is there anything being done towards a settlement or is the thing to go on indefinitely with one side sitting by the other and the agricultural population here having to pay?
Comment on this
Yes, keep on enduring with the arms and the ammunition and everything else in charge of the British and we are going to fight on. Before we can take control of our own house, the Minister says we must pass an Act of Parliament. Surely it is a humiliating position for this country to be in. Surely it is a humiliating position for any Irishman outside this country who reflects on the situation that the Government of this country that claims to be Republican, that claims to stand for Irish independence and Irish separation from the British Commonwealth of Nations, has been so stupid, has been so negligent of national dignity or independence as not to do what every small State has done. All the small States, the product of the Great War, all the secession States of the Austria-Hungarian Empire, all the secession States of the Russian Empire, and even the Free State of Dantzig, have set up their own independent financial position. And our Republican Government did not do it and yet they declared war on the British Empire, that Empire that is actually in control of our money. Surely outside Bedlam you would not meet such madness. There is no parallel for it in history. They are continuing to fight, filling up gaps here and there with taxes and more taxes.
Surely the Minister for Agriculture ought to redeem the promise he made here last week that if any member of the Opposition put up a motion for discussion on agriculture that it would be accepted and time given. Will the Minister give Government time for the motion already on the Order Paper, the motion to ascertain who is bearing the burden of the economic war? That is the whole crux of the situation. Personally I admit that the Government has got a mandate for it. Of course they did a good deal of cajolery and misrepresentation, but nevertheless the people should have sense enough to see through that if they did not believe in the economic war. Now it is up to the Government to reassure the country that the burden of the economic war is equally distributed. And if the burden of the economic war were equally distributed, Deputies like Deputy Kelly here, who are paying nothing for it but making money out of it, would not smile. With these few remarks I leave the matter to the Minister's consideration.
Comment on this
It is an extraordinary thing in the year 1935 to be discussing truisms of this sort. I have been told to-night that you cannot have live stock without tillage, and you cannot have tillage without live stock— a lot of things that I heard from my grandmother about fifty years ago. The real trouble about the present situation is that this policy that we have been hearing about, this agricultural policy, is not Fianna Fáil policy at all. The Minister asked what is our agricultural policy. The trouble about the Minister's and the Government's policy is this, that it is not their own policy really. They came into office, and as a result of their past they were forced to do two things: one was to make trouble with England. That had to be done right or wrong, but some excuse had to be found for it; the other was to do something different in the matter of agriculture from that which we did. That is all that the Fianna Fáil agricultural policy comes to—there is really no use dignifying it with the name of a policy at all. It is simply the case of certain people who do not know much about agriculture, people who are not very competent, having to do, rightly or wrongly, something different from what we did. We encouraged the production of live stock and live-stock products while in office. The Government Party, when in opposition, talked about tillage and grain crops, wheat and beet and the sort of thing I used to hear from my grandmother. They talked a lot about these things. They had to do something different from us afterwards. There was no possible agricultural policy in this country but the policy we pursued, and I venture to say there is hardly an agriculturist, a practical farmer on the Government Benches who does not realise that. It is positively humiliating to be pointing out what everybody in the country knows—that a two-year-old beast which the farmer raises and which fetches £16 in a couple of years would pay just as well as an acre of beet or an acre of wheat with all this subsidising. Every farmer knows that. Nobody can deny that a well-bred Hereford heifer one-and-a-half years old will pay three times as much as an acre of beet; five or six ewes with their lambs at the price they were fetching three years ago in the open market would pay three or four times as much as an acre of wheat. Everybody knows that; if they could only get down to the finances of it, nobody on the opposite benches would deny it. But here we are seriously discussing as an alternative to the policy of the production of live stock and live-stock products, the production of beet and wheat. I ask the Minister himself to say is that a serious alternative? Is there a single person on the benches opposite who believes it is a serious alternative? I do not want to go into figures too much, but let us take this figure for a moment. Between 1931 and 1934 there was a fall of £8,000,411 in the value of cattle exports. I repeat it—£8,000,411.
Comment on this
Does it convey anything to Deputy Kelly? I am rather glad Deputy Kelly made that interruption. The Deputy professes to be an old standing Sinn Feiner who wants to find work for everybody in the country, who wants to keep money in the country. He talks of all that and he uses all these phrases and all these shibboleths without understanding them. That is his run of country. Now look at this figure again—there is £8,000,411 gone out of the country. Does that convey anything to Deputy Kelly? There is £8,000,411 worth of employment gone out of the country. There are opportunities there for increasing taxation; there are opportunities for an increase in population and there are opportunities for increasing employment to the extent of £8,000,411. As against that, in the Dáil, after 12 years of self-government, someone will talk of other things. I am only dealing with one item. Someone will talk of sugar beet. Are we really serious? Or are we only playacting, or is it all humbug? Go down along the figures. On sheep £732,000 was lost. This is all in one year, remember. On pigs there is a loss of £1,814,927. They are only the exports. Tot them all up and you will get a total of £11,000,000. And you talk of keeping the money in the country; you talk of not sending out for foreign goods; you talk of more employment and progress and a bigger population, but there is the loss on three items in one year on exports alone.
Does the Minister for Agriculture seriously tell us that the alternative to those is sugar beet and wheat? If I had the time and if I thought I was talking to children I would explain that, of course, you cannot possibly till for wheat more than a very small proportion of your land, and only a very small proportion of the land is fit for wheat growing. Everybody knows that, but no one seems to advert to it or realise it. Equally, if I had time, I should like to ask the Minister for Agriculture what is the real profit out of an acre of sugar beet, and what is the subsidy that is being paid? I do not know. But I do know that when we were setting up the Carlow factory and when we were paying about 48/- per ton for beet, the subsidy was close on £70 an acre. What is it now? It must be at least £35 to £40. I make an allowance for the fact that there is no 5 per cent. dividend to be paid, and that the price of the beet is a lot lower, but it certainly must be £35 to £40 per acre. This is what the whole Fianna Fáil agricultural policy has come to—the growing of wheat and of sugar beet, and the killing of the live-stock industry and the live-stock products industry of the country.
Comment on this
How can there be progress? If Deputy T. Kelly is serious, if it is not merely politics with him, if he wants to see an increase in the population of the country, if he wants to see increased production and increased labour, I would ask him seriously to take the trouble to analyse those figures, and then ask himself is he doing what he professes to have near his heart in allowing this to go on? Is not bankruptcy clearly written on those figures, and is not that all about it? Can anybody deny it? Do you think you are going to stave off bankruptcy by producing, we will say, perhaps, 50,000 acres of sugar beet and feeding it with a subsidy of £40 to £50 per acre? Do you think you are going to stave off bankruptcy in that way? Is not that what we are coming to? Is not that the policy? You have killed the live stock industry; you have killed the live-stock products industry; you have substituted two small items of production kept alive by the most extravagant subsidies, and while all that is happening what have you done? You have increased taxation—I am speaking of direct taxation—from about £22,000,000 to, I suppose, close on £30,000,000. At a time when practically no branch of non-subsidised farming is paying, when bankruptcy is staring every hard-working farmer in the face, you have increased taxation by close on £8,000,000 or £9,000,000. Where is it going to lead to? What is the use of talking of currency? What is the use in debating small points about the price of butter, the price of eggs, or interesting little academic discussions such as Deputy O'Reilly treated us to, when he told us all about what happened in 1888, with a little bit of anti-Imperialism thrown in? Why not get down to the real problem? Is not this country going bankrupt agriculturally?
I hear a lot of propaganda at the expense of the unfortunate farmers in Cork at the present moment. The President is very fond of making use of them as an example of our supporters who really do not believe in democracy, and who are quite willing to resort to force if it pays them. He uses that particular example to show that we are as bad as they are. He thinks it proves that. The economic system in this country was very powerful, and very well laid. It could stand a lot of shocks, but you have strained it almost to breaking point. The democratic sense, I think, was also fairly deeply rooted in this country, but you have strained it almost to breaking point. Consider those farmers, and the strain you have put upon them. If we were the most highly civilised people in the world, if we had the most highly developed sense of law and order, it would be very hard for them to stand what is going on at the present moment. Look at their position. The people in the district where you have the most of the trouble are amongst the very best farmers in Ireland. They were the people who always got the prizes in the Show. They produced more wealth per acre out of their land than the Meath men, with far better land. Wherever there was improvement, they were in the van. Wherever sound new methods had to be adopted, they adopted them first. It was a pride with them to pay their way, to put a bit aside, and to have a fairly decent standard of life. In other words they were the cream of the country as a class. Now look at their position. I heard Deputy Belton say there was a mandate for the economic war. I think they got a mandate to settle it. It is a small point, and I will not go into it, but I think they got a mandate to settle it. This is the point: where did you get your mandate? Where would your mandate be only for the doles? Some of them are necessary. Where would the mandate be only for the free this, the free that, and the free the other thing; only for the bribery of one kind or another? I do not use the word "bribery" in any objectionable sense. Where would the mandate be for the economic war or Republicanism or anything else you like?
Those people whom I speak of get no old age pensions. Their valuations are too high. They get no dole of any kind. They get none of the benefits, good, bad or indifferent, of the £8,000,000 that is being raised. Do they get one penny out of it in any way, direct or indirect? They get none of the social services, because they worked hard in the past. I am not saying that many persons who worked hard in the past do not need social services, and are not entitled to social services. Of course they are. Taking those people as a class, they get none of that £8,000,000. They have to suffer all the disadvantages of the economic war. They have to face all the losses. They have to pay their way. They have not even the temporary and transitory advantages that other people have in the way of doles, subsidies and other grants coming out of that increased taxation. Was there ever any tyranny like that? Here are people producing cattle. They all have cows. They have to rear calves. They are worth £1 at six months old; at two years old they are worth £3 10s. Here are people producing pigs. The best they can expect for them is 40/- per cwt. live weight. Remember they have to employ labour. The man who feeds one or two pigs around the house can make a bit of profit on 40/- per cwt., but for the man who has 20, 30 or 40 pigs and has to employ labour, there is no profit; it is a dead loss. Look at the price of their eggs and the price of everything else they sell.
On the other hand, they buy Indian meal—another part of the Fianna Fáil policy—at £8 10s. per ton, at a time when the world price was never lower. Their raw materials are taxed; at every hand's turn the position is made absolutely impossible for them. Then they must pay their way. They must pay their rates, they must pay their annuities, they must pay the shopkeepers; and if they do not, the full rigour of the law is used against them. You talk of landlordism. There was no landlordism in the history of this country as great a tyranny as what is going on to-day with regard to the farmers. It was the pride of these people to pay their way. They were a class of people who put up the money, if you like, for Sinn Féin, for the Nationalist Party, for every forward movement. It was their pride to pay their way and they always had a bit over for any good cause.
Look at the position they are in now —these decent people who are entitled to a fair standard of living. It is all very fine for us here to say "You have to cut your cloth according to your measure; someone must make the sacrifice." But, remember that people who worked hard to put a bit aside and were able to afford a decent standard of life are entitled to it; and it is the last thing in tyranny for the Government to take it from them. It is not good enough to expect these people to remain strictly within the law. I would not encourage lawlessness under any circumstances. But do you not think that you are putting too great a strain upon them? Do you not think it is unfair to make the strain so heavy that they are bound to break, and then to penalise them when it happens and take full advantage of it? I remember the Minister for Agriculture saying on one occasion "Of course, if you do not make your land pay we have a lot of young fellows who will." Just imagine these farmers listening to that sort of thing, with all their money gone, all their stock gone, all their means gone, and no hope for them after all their work. That is what you have reduced the best farmers in the country to.
Where is your policy leading to, apart from the fact that it is leading to a financial crash? I will tell you. You can go on as you are going on, and you will have to go back to the 1848 conditions. There is going to be an increased population in this country but not because of the little employment you give in half a dozen, a dozen, or 30 highly subsidised factories. It is not worth a snap of the fingers. The slightest increase in the prosperity of agriculture would mean three times as much. There is going to be an increase of population because emigration is stopped. How are these people going to exist? Surely it is an elementary economic truism that cannot be denied that people must live out of production. But is not production going down? How are those people going to be employed? You lost that £8,000,000 worth of production on cattle alone. Where are you going to make it up?
What is the future for the young men that you think so much about, and who are going to make something of this country? There is no future for the great bulk of the young men of this country except to reduce the holdings in this country from £10 holdings to £5 holdings and put them on them. That is where you are going. That will not deal with half of them, but it will bring you back to 1848 conditions; back to a country where you will have a very large number of peasants with a very low standard of life. That may not be your idea of progress, but that is where your policy is leading. There is no doubt about that. That is where this policy is leading, if it lasts long enough.
I really do not believe that the present Government had any choice in the matter. Having regard to all they said and did, they had to make a quarrel with the British. If it was not on the annuities, there would have to be some quarrel with the British. What is more, it seems to me that that quarrel was made for quite irrelevant reasons, for political reasons. It must be kept on for the same reasons. That is what is happening. It seems to me that the Government and Fianna Fáil Deputies believe that if the economic war was finished they would lose a very valuable political advantage over the Opposition. If that is the position, is it not a shocking state of affairs? Is it not a terrible state of affairs that the main industry in the country, the agricultural industry, should be allowed to drift into the paths into which it has drifted merely because of certain political considerations which a certain political Party regard as important for themselves?
There is no doubt that the economic war could be settled. It could be settled on terms. You may ask: "What are the terms?" That is a big question. There is no doubt that no genuine or real attempt has been made to settle that economic war. Unless it is settled, where is all this going to end? What agricultural policy can you successfully carry out unless it is settled? Surely even the Minister for Industry and Commerce does not think that by producing all the wheat you require and all the sugar you require—I will leave out tobacco—you are finding some approximate substitute for a prosperous live-stock industry? How can you have a prosperous live-stock industry unless the economic war is settled? It must be settled at once if the country is to progress. I believe firmly that it could be settled without any loss of national dignity, and that it would be settled if the Government only took their courage in their hands and forgot politics.
If anything further were necessary to make the position of the farmers impossible, anything added to high taxation and low prices, there is the extraordinary policy that the Minister has adopted of taxing one by one their raw materials. That is a thing he need not have done. We would have been thankful for small mercies. But just imagine that at present there is a tax on Indian meal, a tax on fertilisers, a tax on everything the farmer buys to produce, at a time when the bottom has gone out of all prices. How does the Minister justify that? Can it be justified? There is no use going into the matter in detail, because these figures speak for themselves. The condition of the country at present, the condition of the producers, the people who expect to live by their produce, speaks for itself. These conditions must be changed at once, and this Rakes' Progress must be stopped or this country goes bankrupt.
Comment on this
The Deputy has just five minutes, as I will call on the Minister to reply at 9.45 p.m.
Comment on this
I can scarcely answer the last Deputy in five minutes. It could not be done. He has arrived as the star-turn from Galway, after having been absent for two years, I think. He is the star-turn to-night.
Comment on this
I would not mind having a try if I had the time. The greatest economist who ever lived in this country wrote these words: "The real riches of a nation are its people, not its bulls or its cows or its pigs." The greatest economist who ever wrote regarding Ireland wrote these words.
Comment on this
Every man and woman born into this world are producers, and if they cannot produce in one way, they will get opportunities of producing in another. These are two economic axioms you did not expect to hear. It is needless for me to say that I am not a farmer, but I have been listening here to debates about farmers' grievances every day that this Dáil sat, session after session—no one but the farmers. Are there not any other people following any other callings living in this country? Have not thousands of people to earn their bread at other work? Yet nothing is ever said about anybody but the farmers. It is time that was stopped.
Comment on this
I cannot choke them off. I am speaking as a man who, although not engaged in farming, has a great respect for farmers because I believe they are a hard-working community and I would very much wish to see the grievances under which they are labouring removed. I say that quite sincerely, but the question is how are we to do it with honour and decency? That question has been put here several times and there should be an answer to it from somebody on the opposite benches who can speak with authority. President de Valera has declared over and over again that he is willing to submit the quarrel between England and Ireland to a fair arbitration. What is the fair arbitration suggested? That there should be a neutral chairman to preside over it. I remember that I referred in this House previously to the grave fact that once, and not so long ago, an arbitration was set up in connection with the boundary question presided over by a man named Feetham. We know what was the result of that. Do you want a reproduction of that result? Is it fair to ask President de Valera or the Executive Council to submit to the arbitration of a chairman who would follow on the same lines as Mr. Feetham?
Comment on this
He is prepared to submit it to a fair arbitration. That is an honest offer, and you know it. You have never submitted any alternative to it. You talk here about the economic war but you have never submitted any alternative to this proposal that could be accepted. Can you do it? You have asked for a great debate on agriculture and you have got it. I heard the Minister say in his opening statement that he hoped some useful suggestions would be put forward that he could act on. I hope he has got them. We heard Deputy Belton speaking for an hour. He made the one old speech, the same old dog, and the same old piece of twine all the time. I have heard it over and over again. All these speeches on agriculture have been the same constant repetition. If this is the deliberative assembly of the Irish Free State you want something better than that.
Let us look at this farming business from the city man's standpoint. Do we not support the farmers? Do we not buy their butter, their milk, their eggs, their ducks, their onions, their beef and their mutton? I do not eat beef because I was told it was bad for my complexion. I was told that when I would become an old man I would be a very ugly man if I continued to eat beef, so I turned to mutton. If it spreads abroad that beef is bad for the complexion, there will not be an old cow sold at all. I am sure that the Centre Party is composed of very intelligent farmers. Do you not recognise that the farming business all over the world is suffering? I read accounts of it in many newspapers. I read it not alone in the Irish but in the English newspapers. The farmers in foreign countries have the same complaints and are suffering from the same disabilities as the farmers here. Scientific production is going ahead at such a rapid rate that this may be one result of it. There is already a Convention sitting in England to deal with the question of canned food. We are told that that may be very wholesome food but if the canned-food age continues, what will succeed that? I am not able to tell you what the scientists hope to do, but it is possible that some day people may be able to do without food at all.
Comment on this
Exactly. We are told that the electrons in the air contain life-sustaining substances and that all you need to do in future when you are hungry is to open your mouth——
Comment on this
By simply opening your mouth, you will swallow some substance that will sustain life. When that comes to pass how many grievances will the farmers have?
Comment on this
I should like to put a few questions to the Minister before he concludes with regard to some important matters relating to his Department, so that he may be able to deal with them in his reply. I want him, first of all, to deal with the question of redundant creameries, which is a very important matter for my constituency. He has promised time and time again to do something in regard to this matter, but nothing has been done. I trust that he will do something to get the co-operative creameries taken over. Pending that, if he would grant them a temporary licence, it would be a step in the right direction. Another matter which I would wish to bring to his notice, has reference to Clydesdale stallions. The Cork County Committee of Agriculture and Deputies from Cork County have repeatedly asked for two registered Clydesdale stallions, particularly for the West Cork area, but that has been ignored. One has been left in this year, but he is only a licensed stallion, not a registered stallion. I think the wishes of the representatives of Cork County should be considered in cases like that, that the people should get what they want, and that it is not the wishes of Department officials or the wishes of whoever the people are who look into the matter, will prevail. I should also like to know what is the situation at the moment with regard to pig production. The price of pigs at the present time is so low that they will not pay for the cost of production. Further, I should like to know from the Minister what arrangement he has made for the absorption of the surplus supply of oats in the country at the moment. I should like to have that information from the Minister.
Comment on this
I shall first deal with the items mentioned by Deputy O'Donovan. The matter of the redundant creameries is being dealt with. I think, as a matter of fact, agreements have been made with at least some of the co-operative creameries in some of the cases referred to in West Cork. It is hoped to have them fixed up as soon as the necessary agreements can be made. With regard to the Clydesdale stallions, I think it has been already announced, unofficially at least, that a commission is being set up to deal with the horse-breeding industry. The matter raised by the Deputy is one that can be dealt with by that commission. I dealt fairly fully with pig production in my opening statement. I did say that nothing could be done until the boards become operative under the Act.
Comment on this
It might be something like the advice the Deputy has been giving to some of his followers. With regard to the Deputy's question about surplus oats, it is hoped that the new percentage of maize meal mixture will absorb all the oats in the country. I must say that I have not been disappointed with the debate, because I did say at the beginning that I did not expect to get any useful suggestion from it. I did expect that the full day would be taken up with the usual speeches on the economic war. We got no suggestion that would in any way seem to benefit agriculture in this country. There was no suggestion, as a matter of fact, that anything could be done, except from Deputy Belton, to improve agriculture provided the economic war goes on and that the quotas go on.
I have to take the position as it is. There is an economic war and there are quotas. Therefore, I have dealt with the position as I find it and as the Government has dealt with it. There has not been the slightest suggestion, in a full day's debate, from the Opposition as to how they would deal with that position. Are we to take it that we are dealing with it in the best possible way and that no one could deal with it better in the position that we find ourselves in? Am I to take it that the Opposition preferred to base themselves on the economic war, rather than get down to the things that matter in existing circumstances? They did not do it anyway. I do not know whether they were not able to do it or whether they did not want to do it. It is absolutely ridiculous for any Deputy to say that we could get unrestricted imports into Britain whether there is an economic war or not. It is held, because we appear to be on unfriendly terms with the British, that on that account we are not getting unrestricted imports. That is absolutely untrue. Anyone who reads the newspapers will see that New Zealand and Australia for the last two quarters of the year were permitted only to import a certain amount of beef into Great Britain. There is no case of their being on unfriendly terms with the British Government. But, nevertheless, they are restricted in their beef imports. In the same way Canada and New Zealand are restricted in other products and Canada is also limited in her imports of bacon.
Comment on this
They are restricted now under the quota system, but never until the quota system came. If Deputies opposite had any sense or decency they would admit that whatever Government is here will have to put up with a certain amount of restriction on their imports into the British market. On that basis we had a number of speeches from the Opposition, but no criticism was levelled against the Department of Agriculture, or made to meet the set of circumstances that are existing, except indeed the criticism of Deputy Belton. No one else offered any criticism as to how we were dealing with that position.
We heard the usual talk of the country going into bankruptcy. We heard all that three years ago. This time three years ago we were told that we would be in bankruptcy before Christmas. Then we were told we might last until the following spring, when, Deputy Belton said, the bad harvest would kill us. Deputy Hogan said we were walking straight into bankruptcy for the last three years.
Comment on this
The people. The country we were told was to go into bankruptcy within three months. Well, then, let the Opposition give us credit for keeping the country floating for three years, although the Opposition told us that bankruptcy would happen in three months. That is an achievement! And I am quite optimistic that we will keep afloat for a little longer despite the predictions of the Opposition. We were told we must develop live stock and live-stock products. What did the Opposition say in regard to the Coal-Cattle Pact? What did we make that pact for except for the development of the live stock industry? Let us look at their criticisms. If we were to take the Opposition seriously we should not have entered into the Coal-Cattle Pact at all. We should have allowed our cattle to be destroyed or got rid of them in some other way. We have tried on every occasion to get markets for our live stock at home and in Great Britain and everywhere that we could possibly get a market.
Deputy Bennett said before the economic war started that we had embarked on a system of cereal production versus live stock. I referred to Deputy Bennett before and said that he made some of the meanest suggestions that are made in this House. But when it comes to voting he votes all right, because it would not suit him to do otherwise before the eyes of the dairy farmers in Limerick. He tries to support his Party by making criticisms and suggestions in the meanest possible way, but when it comes to voting he puts himself right. Deputy Bennett knows that the very first Bill we brought in was a Bill to save the butter industry. Certainly we have been endeavouring to develop the cereal industry, but we never showed that we were against the live stock industry or the live-stock products industry. We have sought markets in every possible place for our live stock and live-stock products. We have the biggest possible quota for bacon from Great Britain. We have got an increased quota for our cattle in Great Britain, and, also, in Belgium and Germany. The Opposition have criticised us for sending our cattle to Belgium or Germany at all, and for having increased our export of cattle to Great Britain under the coal-cattle pact. We are not destroying the live-stock industry, but we are doing everything in our power to develop it. If the Opposition are sincere they should put a stop to all this criticism of these markets that we are trying to get for our live stock and already have secured.
Comment on this
Senator Connolly is well able to mind his own business. We have secured, as I said, quotas for our produce in Belgium, Germany and in Spain, and are getting good prices. Deputy Belton went on to talk about Spanish oranges and the quantities that are coming in. There are no more Spanish oranges coming in this year than last year. The quota permits the same number of Spanish oranges this year as last year, but Deputy Belton is prepared to listen to, and to use, the propaganda which is being put forward against the Government. Because there was a good treaty made with Spain for the purpose of exporting to them some of our goods, we are taking in return from Spain quantities of oranges. We are getting the same oranges from Spain under that arrangement as previously.
Comment on this
Now, as to the slaughter of calves, I explained that before. Why then should Deputies continue to slander the Government? I explained that if we were to supply our own needs entirely in milk products without exporting any, that would require between 800,000 and 900,000 cows. But if we reared our calves and let them mature as cattle we could not possibly consume them as beef.
Comment on this
I did not say we should consume them. I only mention that in any country if all the cattle are allowed to grow to maturity, you will have greater difficulty in disposing of them than you would have of milk products. It would take a larger population to consume that beef than it would to consume the milk products. Other countries have dealt with that problem by consuming veal to a large extent, and, in order to get rid of a certain surplus of cattle which we would have to meet the British and other quotas we have, we considered it good policy to try to get the people to develop a taste for veal in this country. We thought the best way to do that was to say: "We will make it worth your while to sell the calf as veal by giving you more than the value for the skin." That, perhaps, has not worked; the people have not consumed veal. It may be necessary to adopt other methods, if other methods can be adopted, to encourage the consumption of veal in order to get over that beef surplus. Deputy Belton has referred to the beef surplus, and we all know that there is a beef surplus. We have tried to deal with it as best we can.
Comment on this
Probably not at present. Deputy Belton is the only Deputy who made suggestions for dealing with the present position, assuming that there is an economic war and British quotas, otherwise than in the way in which we are trying to deal with it. The big suggestion he made referred to currency. I do not follow Deputy Belton exactly, because I am not as well up in finance as he is, but he says that 87 English shillings are worth 109 Australian shillings. If we get back 87 English shillings, is it not as good as 109 Australian shillings? I may be wrong in that, but I am not going to argue about it.
Comment on this
We have set up a Banking Commission, and I think the members, most of them at least, are fairly open-minded. If they understand the problem as clearly as Deputy Belton, there is no doubt about their report. If they are as clear on this problem as Deputy Belton is, there is no doubt that they are going to report in favour of a separate currency. Deputy Belton might try to influence them if possible.
Comment on this
On page 10 of the Banking Commission's Report of 1926 the Minister will see that the case is put much better than I put it here to-day by a then official of the Department of Industry and Commerce. I would advise the Minister for Industry and Commerce to study that.
Comment on this
We will leave it to the Banking Commission to decide.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton also spoke about the county committees and the distribution of cattle licences. He complained that the Department would not give these county committees the benefit of their experience.
Comment on this
That is not so, I think, because the Department did give to the county committees a general indication of the line the Department thought they ought to take, but, on the other hand, they told the county committees that they were not binding them to any particular method, because we wanted to give the county committees full freedom of movement in the distribution of these licences. The only condition laid down was that they should be distributed on some basis. I thought that Deputy Belton, and Deputies like him, were entirely dissatisfied with the way in which the Department was distributing licences.
Comment on this
I thought that if we were to give them to the county committees that they would have some better way of distributing them. Now, Deputy Belton complains that they got only 411 licences for 5,000 cattle. He appears to think, like many Deputies on the other side, that the only market possible for cattle in this country is the export market. That Anglo-mania will have to stop because we cannot get on in this country if we ignore the better and bigger market—the home market. The City of Dublin takes many more cattle per month than Deputy Belton has on hands in County Dublin.
Comment on this
I know it is not, but it is a much bigger market than the English market for County Dublin.
Comment on this
I know all about this talk of closing the ports. These are the wise men——
Comment on this
I say to Deputies: Close the home market for three months and see what happens. We are selling three cattle on the home market for every two we export at present. Deputies ought to get over this inferiority complex of thinking nothing about their own country as a home market or anything else.
Comment on this
The Deputy intervened at some length, I understand, in this debate and had the opportunity of putting his points. He should allow the Minister to make his speech now.
Comment on this
That is true. The licences were given out to the county committees on the basis of the number of cattle over two years old in each county. Dublin got its proportion the same as every other county and will have to put up with it. That is the sort of thing we had to put up with when we were being blamed in regard to the distribution of licences.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton says that he advised his Committee not to go on with the issue of licences. I suspected that Deputy Belton and people like him would do that, and I am glad that we gave them to the county committees because now we have called their bluff. They know very well that they cannot do any better than we, and they are going to throw it up.
Comment on this
Nine thousand odd. I will give the Deputy the exact number if he asks for it.
Comment on this
Deputy Moore raised the question of the Wicklow milk suppliers to the Dublin market. That is a question engaging the attention of at least two Departments. I do not know yet what can be done, but if anything can be done, it will be done. The figure I quoted as to the price paid by creameries, whatever Deputy Belton may say, was taken from the Irish Trade Journal. I said that for the first quarter of this year creameries paid 5.3 pence per gallon as against 5.2 pence per gallon for the first quarter last year.
Comment on this
Yes. That is the average price paid by the creameries, and I would point out to Deputy Bennett that the statement made on this side over and over again is true, that if there was no economic war, no tariffs, no subsidies and no bounties but the free market Deputies talk so much about, the Limerick farmers would get 2d. a gallon for their milk.
Comment on this
We will never agree on it because it suits the Deputy, but the Deputy knows very well that if he gets 66/- a cwt., which was the price during all the big supply last year——
Comment on this
No, not for the year, but it was the price when about 80 per cent. of our butter was exported. Take off 20/- for working the creamery and you have 46/-, which represents exactly 2d. a gallon. That is what the Limerick farmers would have got, and the Deputy ought at least to have the decency to agree with that. Reference has been made to this reduction in the export figures for live stock and live-stock products. In the first place, it must be remembered that there was a big decline in the value of our exports from 1929 to 1931, and if it had continued—I do not know whether it would or not—it would have gone down fairly low in 1933. The total value of our exports of live stock and live-stock products in 1929 was £34,169,000; in 1931, it was £27,186,000—a drop of £7,000,000; and in 1933, it was £12,370,000—an enormous drop of £15,000,000. But I will tell you a thing which Deputies have not quoted at all. It is that, during those two years, our imports of the same things went down from £14,000,000 to £8,000,000. It was because we closed the market here to bacon, butter, cheese, eggs and several other things——
Comment on this
The closing of the imports of agricultural products would not represent more than £2,000,000 or £3,000,000 at the outside—eggs £70,000 worth, and "large," about £100,000 worth.
Comment on this
I will give the Deputy the exact figures. Foodstuffs of animal origin went down from £1,845,000 to £429,000; cereals and foodstuffs for animals went down from £8,352,000 to £4,798,000 and other articles of food show very little change.
Comment on this
Is not that exactly what I said, that the imports of live-stock and livestock products were only about £1,000,000 odd? What did go down was the raw material for producing.
Comment on this
Wheat and maize and these things. Wheat showed the biggest reduction, as a matter of fact, and that £6,000,000 of a reduction was largely produced by the farmer here. Deputy Bennett, when he was quoting his statistics, talked about the population in Limerick and Wexford. He must have heard about the fallacy of that argument, because it has been stated over and over again, even by the Statistics Department, what the fallacy is. It is this. You have, as Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney said, the best land in the world in County Limerick. Generally speaking, you have bad land in Wexford. It is through tillage in Wexford that they have almost as many people maintained on the land as in County Limerick. I think it was mentioned that there is one for every 28 acres in Wexford and one for every 27 acres in Limerick. Turning to the figures in 1851, we find that from 1851 to 1926 there was a much bigger reduction in the population in Limerick than in the population in Wexford. We can claim that because Wexford tilled its land it maintained its population better than Limerick.
Comment on this
On the best land in the world, according to Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, you employ as many as in Wexford. You should really employ twice as many.
Comment on this
The argument was advanced here that if we went in for tillage we would employ God knows how many more people.
Comment on this
So you would. In Wexford, a poor county, we are able to employ as many as are employed in the best land in the world, according to Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, and we do it because we till the land and work hard. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney told us we had increased tillage by only 72,000 acres, an increase that should, he said, take place in the normal way. The acreage under tillage was going down under the last Government; it was steadily going down until 1932 and then it began to increase. There was no increase taking place in the normal way; it was quite the reverse. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, and other Deputies, made the usual accusation. The only person who did not stand by it was Deputy Belton. They said that the Executive Council here fired the first shot in the economic war. That is a nice patriotic thing for the Opposition to say—that the Executive Council here was responsible for the trouble and that the English people were not responsible in any way, that they are the decent people who did nothing against this country. They declared that it was this Government created all the trouble. Surely, no Deputy on the opposite benches will claim that such statements are going to do this country good. They may claim that it will do their Party good, but they cannot claim that it will do the country good. Deputy Bennett's great trouble is that we may produce more wheat in this country than we can consume and he wonders where we are going to find an export market. That is an extraordinary argument and perhaps Deputy Hogan would best be able to answer it. Deputy Bennett should read the majority report of the Economic Committee that sat in 1929 and he will find his answer there.
Comment on this
Did the Minister not say a few weeks ago that we will shortly be able to meet all our wheat requirements? Will you not be at the surplus point then?
Comment on this
Unless we exceed what will be necessary to meet our own requirements we will not be at the surplus point. I think we should keep our policy to ourselves in the future, like the Opposition. Deputy Hogan mentioned that taxation had gone up from £22,000,000 to £28,000,000. That is correct, but the Deputy should realise that we are taking £2,000,000 a year into our receipts for land annuities and, to make a true comparison, the £4,000,000 that farmers were paying under his Government should be added to the £22,000,000.
Comment on this
If you want to make a true comparison you would have to add all the increased prices as a result of your tariffs.
Comment on this
The whole thing is becoming a bit involved now. Deputy Hogan talked about the Cork farmers and he made a statement characteristic of the leaders of the Opposition. It is the sort of statement that is immediately qualified by saying, "We do not want disobedience of the law." The Deputy said it is not good enough to ask these people to remain silently within the law, and then he qualified that by saying that they did not want any trouble and they did not want any of these people to disobey the law. That is going as closely as a clever man could go to telling them that they ought not to remain within the law.
Comment on this
What does it mean? If any farmer down the country reads that it is not good enough to ask them to remain silently within the law, what meaning do you expect him to take from it? Take the farmer who has confidence in Deputy Hogan and might be inclined to take his advice, and what meaning would he be expected to take from that?
Comment on this
I am perfectly entitled to state that you are putting a strain on that class of farmer, that you should not in all justice put on him. I make no excuse for saying that. It is no incitement to anybody.
Comment on this
The Deputy asks us where our policy is leading. Where is their policy leading them? They send the wives and daughters of farmers to kick up a row and then they come along and buy back their stock and pay the costs. Why should they be encouraged to carry on a resistance to the payment of land annuities? Recently, on the motion for the adjournment, Deputy Dillon said that £1,000 worth of stock were seized from a man to meet a debt of £70.
Comment on this
It was quoted here as a typical case. That man allowed his stock to be seized and sold because at that time they had not adopted the policy of buying back. They are buying back now and paying expenses.
Comment on this
The man did not get a chance of buying back his stock. He got the short knock.
Comment on this
If he has any legal grievance he is all right. I think it is rather a pity that we should have the Opposition not only countenancing, but encouraging these tactics so far as they can. There are very few sales at which some of the Deputies opposite do not attend and address protest meetings. It is rather a pity that sort of thing is countenanced and encouraged all for the sake of having a political meeting.
Comment on this
No Government but yourselves would be responsible for such a terrible condition of things as exists throughout the country.
Comment on this
In Fermoy, a few days ago, there was a protest by the women and the children first, and then the owners went in and bought back the cattle. They could just as easily have paid that money to the sheriff when he called.
Comment on this
In Mullingar the people had to join together to buy the cattle back. The men whose cattle were seized had not the money. They were in a condition of desperation. They had to go around and beg the money in order to buy back their cattle. Go down to Westmeath and you will see the women and children almost starving there because of the conditions your Government have brought about, and the bailiffs are there taking away all their property.
Comment on this
That is quite true. That is the position in almost every town in the Free State.
Comment on this
All I want to say is this —Deputy Hogan gave great praise to the County Cork farmers. I do not know these men personally. What Deputy Hogan says may be quite true —they may be good farmers. He says they are good farmers and they have been successful. But what I want to know is why is it that this particular agitation or conspiracy is confined to the County Cork if what Deputy Hogan says is the case?
Comment on this
I think I explained that; they are the class of farmers with just the size of farms who get nothing out of the social services. They are simply men who pay out.
Comment on this
Are there not farmers of that type in Galway and Mayo, too— men with £40 to £50 valuation?
Comment on this
No; most of the farmers in Galway and Mayo are from £10 to £12 or £15 valuation. These Cork farmers are valued up to £40 and all these people get no benefit out of the social services.
Comment on this
There are good-sized farmers in Galway and they pay their annuities, and there is none of this conspiracy going on there at all.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister this—are there not a very great number of the farmers on whom seizures have been made in Westmeath and Longford supporters of the present Government? Surely, they are not in the conspiracy; these men are not really able to pay their annuities. Is not the Minister aware of that?
Comment on this
The seizures are not made in the case of farmers who are unable to pay.
Comment on this
I have a list here of Fianna Fáil supporters, decent, hard-working people who voted Fianna Fáil in the last two elections and who, I am satisfied, would vote Fianna Fáil again to-morrow, and these people are quite unable to pay their land annuities.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?