We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Conditions of Employment Bill, 1935—Recommittal (Resumed).

Contributions 1–152 of 308. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Conditions of Employment Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 13 of 1935 ›

Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

I explained yesterday evening why it was desired to make this change in the Bill, and the improvement that it would effect in the definition of continuous employment. The only point that arose from the discussion was the advisability of having power to vary the number of hours in the year which would constitute continuous employment; the necessity for that variation arising possibly from the fact that the normal working week of particular classes of workers is now below 48 hours, or may in the future become below 48 hours. I agree that there should be power to vary the number of hours set out in the amendment, and I am considering the form of an amendment to that end which it would be necessary to introduce on the Report Stage, if we decide to do so. It is undesirable that the number of hours should be fixed in the Bill and be unchangeable, except by amending legislation, because the aim of the Bill is to effect generally a reduction in the working hours. That reduction could not be effected if it meant that the workers concerned could not qualify to receive the annual holidays. Therefore, while I think this method of determining continuous employment is the best, and that this amendment should be inserted, I will have consideration given to the advisability of producing on the Report Stage an amendment conferring power in some form to vary the number of hours in the year that will constitute continuous employment.

Comment on this

Am I to take it that while the Minister will take power in the Bill to vary the number of hours to qualify for holidays, nevertheless that he will keep the datum line at 1,800 hours?

Comment on this

I think so.

Comment on this

I put it that the datum line of 1,800 hours is something more than 75 per cent. of the full year's work on the basis of a 48-hour week. I suggest that the Minister should fix a datum line on 75 per cent. of the normal working period only on the basis of a 44-hour week, and not on the basis of a 48-hour week. The Minister knows that in a very large number of occupations the working week is in the vicinity of 44 hours, and that the tendency of this Bill will be probably to reduce the working week to 44 hours. If the Minister will take 44 hours as the figure upon which he ought to base the datum line, I think he will produce a figure based on 75 per cent. of the normal number of working hours in a year, which would meet the point Deputy Keyes has in mind and, at the same time, represent a greater approximation to fairness than 1,800 hours does in these circumstances. The Minister is not giving very much away, but he certainly will meet the point raised by Deputy Keyes, and which deserves to be met. At the same time, he will have the power which he seeks to make the variations, and probably any variations made by the Minister at an early date will bring the Bill into line with the 1,700 hour average over a period of one year.

Comment on this

Whatever number appears in the Bill must be related to the 48 hours, which is the working week prescribed as the maximum in the Bill, and I do not think that 1,800 hours in a year is an unreasonable proportion in relation to a 48-hour week. But if in any particular trade it is now the practice, or if in future it should become the law that a shorter working week would operate, then this has to be revised, not necessarily revised proportionately, but downwards to some extent, because otherwise you might have a position in which a large number of workers, because of the reduction in the working week, would be unable to qualify for the annual holidays; in fact, it would in certain circumstances become illegal to qualify for the annual holidays. In these circumstances, I agree that this number should be varied, but in so far as the maximum working week prescribed in the Bill is 48 hours, I think 1,800 hours in the year is a reasonable figure to put in the Bill. I do not think it is unduly high in relation to a 48-hour week, but I agree that it should be capable of being reduced when the working week is shorter.

Comment on this

Taking the particular case I cited last evening, where men work three-quarters or 75 per cent. of the available time in the way of days —they work four days out of six, and they are cut off for two days; and as they have been working like that for a period of over five years it has come to be recognised as a fairly established practice—would it not be equitable to fix the number of hours at 75 per cent. of the available work provided? In this case it is a 47-hour week over six days, and they work four days, making 34 hours in all. That gives them a total of 1,768 hours, which would bring them under the 1,800 hours, which would be definitely putting them outside the intention of the Bill. Would it not be feasible to prescribe for three-quarters of the days of the week or 75 per cent. of the days available, or alternatively 1,800 hours or 1,700 hours or 1,600 hours, which will be 75 per cent. of the working week? In that way you will meet the cases where half-time or three-quarter time has been put into operation in various industries. It will definitely cover the point which I raised which deals with a very hard case.

Comment on this

Does the Minister's amendment cover the type of work to which Deputy Keyes refers? Deputy Keyes speaks of a man who works four days in the week and is laid off for two days; then works four days in the next week and is laid off for two days. The terms of the amendment are "during which he has been continuously in the employment of such employer." Surely a workman who is only working four days in the week and is laid off for two days cannot be held to be in continuous employment? I remember at an early stage we discussed that at some length, and I know that in connection with the Galway Harbour Bill that question arose, and it was held that a man so employed would not come within the terms of the Bill, which described a workman as being continuously employed.

Comment on this

I would be amazed if the Minister took that reading of it. I spoke of servants of the railway company who in some instances have worked for 40 years. They are at the disposal of the railway company on Friday and Saturday just as they are on the other days of the week. If that is not continuous employment, just because the company sees fit only to give them four days' work in the week, I do not know what it is.

Comment on this

I am not arguing one way or the other. I am directing the attention of the Minister to something that might pass by unobserved. I am giving the House the benefit of the experience I had when on the Committee of the Galway Harbour Bill when that question arose, and the best legal opinion before us informed us that a person working in that way would not be deemed to be in continuous employment. I am drawing the attention of the Minister and interested Deputies to the fact, so that if it has to be altered it may be altered now and not pass into the Bill and require another Bill to set it right.

Comment on this

I think there is no doubt that the workers to whom Deputy Keyes refers are continuously employed by the same employer even though they may be doing a 37- or 38-hour week at present. I agree with Deputy Keyes that there should be power to prescribe a lower number of hours in the year to deal with the difficulties of certain cases. I object to taking the particular type of case which he has in mind as typical, as it is rather an abnormal type of case. A typical case is where the worker does a full working week which is nevertheless less than 40 hours.

Comment on this

It is not unique.

Comment on this

I am not saying it is unique, but it is not the type of case on which I should like to build legislation. Legislation should be built up against normal conditions. There should be power to prescribe variations in the number of hours per year in order to deal with cases where the working week of a person continuously employed is less than the maximum prescribed by the Bill. I am considering what amendment would be necessary in order to have power so to prescribe. I do not think we should alter the maximum in the Bill, but merely take power to reduce the maximum wherever the circumstances seem to justify a reduction of it.

Comment on this

Will the Minister endeavour in his amendment to consider the case submitted by Deputy Keyes, not because of the particular circumstances advanced in this case, but because of the desirability of meeting a general problem such as that which may be presented in the future?

Comment on this

I might be prepared to meet the particular case, but the Deputy will appreciate that there will be many cases of all kinds similar to that mentioned by Deputy Keyes, where, however, it may be that there was not continuous employment. We have to walk warily and make sure that we are not defeating the purpose of other sections of the Bill, which prescribe that in lieu of holidays certain payments are to be made where the continuity of the employment is broken. A worker who does four or four-and-a-half days every week is undoubtedly continuously employed, but workers in industries similarly situated might do one month out of two months, or two months out of three, and they would be in a somewhat different position and should be dealt with in a different way. In so far as there is no doubt that the workers are continuously employed in the same occupation by the same employer, I think they should be met in the way I suggest by a reduction of this maximum.

Comment on this

The point as to what is continuous employment is a very important one. It is possible, as Deputy Dillon has mentioned, that it may be held that, if a normal working week is spread over six days, and a person works four days this week and does not work on the two following normal working days, he is not in continuous employment.

Comment on this

It is because that interpretation might be put upon the Bill that we are introducing the amendment.

Comment on this

The Minister in his amendment No. 44 moves "to delete all words from and including the word `employment' in line 37 to the end of the sub-section and substitute the words `complete employment year of such worker during which he has been continuously in the employment of such employer and has worked in such employment not less than 1,800 hours." It might be held that a person who in fact worked 1,800 hours would be required to prove two things. That he was in continuous employment and in the continuous employment of the one employer.

Comment on this

"Continuously employed" is not in the amendment.

Comment on this

I want assistance in this matter, Sir, with regard to the word "continuously."

Comment on this

Continuously in the employment of the same employer is an entirely different thing from being continuously employed.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not a function of the Chair to interpret Bills. The Deputy must be guided by the Minister.

Comment on this

The words of the Minister's amendment are as follows: "complete employment year of such worker during which he has been continuously in the employment of such employer."

Comment on this

Yes, "of such employer."

Comment on this

"Of such employer," yes, but that does not matter very much. What does matter is that the worker will be required to prove that he has been continuously in employment, and, as Deputy Dillon says, it may be subsequently decided that a person who works four days a week for and then does two days a week for another employer is not in continuous employment.

Comment on this

Is there any need for the word "continuous" at all?

Comment on this

In view of the fact that 1,800 hours are provided for, the word "continuous" is necessary.

Comment on this

Yes, I understand. The worker must be continuously employed by the same employer. His work must not be interrupted by working for another employer. Supposing a man had been working for four days a week for one employer, and that he did a day's work for another employer in the same week, would that be included?

Comment on this

It might be. Deputy Norton is continuously misreading the amendment. The words "continuous employment" are not there, and the meaning is that the worker remains in the one employment without interruption.

Comment on this

If the Minister says that he is legally advised to that effect, I am prepared to agree.

Comment on this

My view is the commonsense view.

Comment on this

The Minister's common sense is often astray. I think that the Minister should not give himself these certificates of common sense at all.

Comment on this

I do not need to.

Comment on this

Yes, because it is not appropriate. Deputy Dillon comes into the House and says that the same point arose on a previous occasion before a Committee of the House, and that that viewpoint was put to counsel.

Comment on this

I do not think Deputy Dillon said that. If he did, he is wrong.

Comment on this

I should like to say that there is a fine distinction between the words used here and the words used in the other case. These are not the same words that were used in connection with the Galway Harbour Bill. In addition, there is the point raised by Deputy MacDermot that a man working four days of the week might take a day's work from a friend and by so doing might destroy his right to holidays.

Comment on this

But, in order to show that, he would want to prove that he was in continuous employment.

Comment on this

During the employment year.

Comment on this

But the worker has to satisfy two conditions: (1) that he has been continuously in the employment of the employer, and (2) that he has worked in such employment for not less than 1,800 hours. The employer might argue, however, that, by reason of the fact that the worker only worked four days in the week for him, he should not be liable for those other two days. Is not that a real danger that ought to be met?

Comment on this

I hold that there is a very real danger there which ought to be met by the Minister, by defining what continuous employment means. I think that constant employment would be better, because there can be regularity in employment even if it is only one day or a half a day per week. A person might only work one day of the week, but would be constantly employed for that one day or two days, or even a half a day per week; but the word "continuously" has a much more serious significance than "constantly" or "regularly" employed. I suggest to the Minister that there is a very real difficulty there which ought to be met. I suggest that it ought to be met by eliminating the word "continuously," and substituting the word "regularly," or that it should be made clear that the 1,800 hours' work must be with the same employer.

Comment on this

That is already there.

Comment on this

It is something different from what the Deputy requires. The Deputy wants something different from what the worker wants even when the employer is agreeable.

Comment on this

But I want to ensure that the employer otherwise fulfils his obligation.

Comment on this

That is what the amendment does, and it is what it is designed to do, and what, in fact, it does.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell us whether or not there is some legal opinion to back up what is meant by "continuous employment"? Is there any legal opinion behind this amendment?

Comment on this

Obviously.

Comment on this

I think the Minister is optimistic. It is conceivable that there might be a difference of opinion between what is meant by being continuously in the employment of one person and being continuously employed.

Comment on this

Would the Minister look into this?

Comment on this

It seems to me that the meaning is quite obvious. We propose that a worker becomes entitled to, and must receive, six consecutive days' leave in every employment year; that is, provided he has been continuously in the employment of the particular employer and has worked 1,800 hours, which is substantially less than one year; that is because of the employment having been interrupted—as employment is frequently interrupted —and which interruption did not terminate the contract between the employer and the employee, which would terminate his employment.

Comment on this

But ten words would clarify what is meant there, and I hold that it ought to be clearly shown what is meant by "continuous employment."

Comment on this

I put this case to the Minister, and I believe that, if he makes inquiries, he will find that there is some ground for finding out that it happens in his own constituency.

I know that the Minister can get information from people working in the Inchicore Works. At present there is a limited number of people in Dublin employed at work who only get four days a week. These people are free on the other two days, and they are quite entitled to do carpentering or any other work on these two days for other employers, and since house-building started here in Dublin they do it. Are they going to be prejudiced by the insertion of this word "continuously" in the amendment?

Comment on this

If they are not continuously employed by one employer they are not entitled to six days' annual leave. Under another section they are entitled to something in lieu of it.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister if he would consider qualifying the word "continuously" in some way; if he would say "continuously in the employment or available" to the employer. I say that because the men I speak of are available to the employer but he does not require their services. You could obviate whatever dangerous meaning might be attached to the word "continuously" by saying "or available."

Comment on this

So long as the contract of service is not broken, the workman continues to be employed by that employer. One can visualise the position of an engineer who works Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday, week in and week out, and the case of a man to whom the employer says "I will want you next Monday," and at the end of the week says "I will want you again next Monday." That is not continuous employment. That man may do spells of work, but that does not mean that he is continuously in the employment of the employer. A man doing a 40 hours' week may work six days or five days a week. So far as he is concerned it may be a five-day or a six-day week. The mere fact that he does not work a six-day week does not mean that he is not continuously employed. The men that Deputy Keyes has in mind are in that position.

Comment on this

Would the Minister substitute "regularly" for "continuously"?

Comment on this

I do not think it would be an improvement, and the section would not be as clear as it is.

Comment on this

If a man had a regular contract of employment four days a week and spent the remaining two days of the week in the employment of another employer, would he be disqualified under this amendment for his claim for six days' holidays?

Comment on this

It is clearly the Minister's intention not to provide for the case of the man who refuses to sit at home idly on the two days on which he is not employed.

Comment on this

If he is a casual worker, working casually in the manner the Deputy suggests, he does not come under this section.

Comment on this

We appear to be unanimous on one point, but we differ as to how this is to be got over. The question before us is to find words to fit this case. I understand from what the Minister has said that if John Smith contracts with an employer to work on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday, and is offered or accepts work from another employer on the other days, he is entitled to six days' holidays every year if he works 1,800 hours in the course of the year?

Comment on this

I would not say so.

Comment on this

But the man is in constant employment, and the Minister has spent half an hour proving to us that if the man works for the employer regularly and spends 1,800 hours working for him he is entitled to the holiday.

Comment on this

Very well. Surely it should not be the intention of the Minister to put a premium on idleness. Surely the Minister would like to see the man who gets four days work per week looking for two days additional from someone else. Our objection to the Minister's amendment is that it will prohibit the man who gets four days employment per week from looking for two days work from another employer, because if he does he will lose the benefit of the six days holidays. Perhaps if another word were used it might be possible that the purpose we all have in mind will be served. I appreciate that it is impossible for the Minister to strike out one word and stick in another without consultation. If the Minister says he will look into it, and that he will take such steps as are necessary, perhaps that would be satisfactory.

Comment on this

The worker who is not continuously in the same employment is not entitled to come under the section. The Deputy talks about a man working four days with one employer and two days with another. That man is precisely in the same position as the man who works two months with one employer and one month with another. He comes under another section.

Comment on this

The Minister's position is that if the man remains idle for the two other days——

Comment on this

It may be illegal for him to work for another employer.

Comment on this

That does not arise for the moment but suppose he does remain idle he will get these six holidays. If the man looks for two days' employment additional to complete the week he is to be penalised. That is manifestly unjust and no Deputy could stand for such an arrangement. I urge the Minister very strongly to consider that and to say that the man who seeks work for the other two days will not be put in a worse position.

Comment on this

What I said was that the case made by Deputy Keyes was one for which legislation could not be framed. A worker might have the normal working week reduced from 48 hours to a lower number of hours and working more than that number might be an offence.

Comment on this

The Minister knows that is quite irrelevant.

Comment on this

The Minister is ignoring the point that was raised earlier, namely, what is continuous employment. What is the definition of "have been continuously in the employment of such employer"? I say there is a danger that that may mean that the person must be able to show that he has been working regularly for the normal working week for that employer and that if he cannot show that it may be held that he is not continuously in the employment of such employer even where he is working a 46-hour week for that employer and has rendered him 1,800 hours work during the year. We think that in such case the man ought to get his annual leave.

The Minister also says, I think, that he ought to get his annual leave. The difference between us is that the Minister sees no seriousness in the words "continuously in the employment of such employer", but it may well be held by the courts that "continuously in the employment of such employer" means that the man is working regularly for a fixed number of days or a fixed number of hours each week. The courts may hold that it did not matter how many hours he worked so long as he put in a normal working week. But the courts may also hold that if he was out of employment for one day or two days a week that did not constitute being "continuously employed for such employer." I suggest to the Minister that he ought to define what the word "continuously" means. If he does it will avoid a good deal of hardship and confusion later, and I suggest to the Minister that he ought not to be so stubborn about the matter.

Comment on this

The word "continuously" is defined in the section, and it is because continuously had to be defined that the amendment is produced. If the word "continuously" could be defined as simply as the Deputy suggests, then the amendment would not be required at all. "Continuously in the employment of such employer" means that a man has been employed for not less than 1,800 hours.

Comment on this

Why does not the amendment say that?

Comment on this

It does.

Comment on this

That a person has been "continuously in the employment of such employer and has worked in such employment for not less than eighteen hundred hours" does not clearly say that "continuously in the employment of such employer" means a person who has worked for such employer for 1,800 hours.

Comment on this

It obviously means that a year's work need only be 1,800 hours.

Comment on this

Where is the difficulty then in saying what you mean?

Comment on this

We have said it.

Comment on this

The amendment says the very reverse and emphasises the fact that it does not mean that, because it provides two conditions which must be fulfilled by the worker. The first is that he has been "continuously in the employment of such employer", and the second is that he has worked in such employment "for not less than eighteen hundred hours." The courts must hold that, whatever be the several meanings of these two conditions, one thing is certain, and that is that their meanings cannot be identical and that one cannot be a definition of the other because the Bill provides that both must be present. Therefore, the position will be that a man must have not only the one qualification but the other as well. It means that there is a difference between the two.

Comment on this

Has it struck the Deputy at all that the meaning must obviously be different to that, and that continuous employment for 48 hours must obviously be higher than 1,800 hours over a year?

Comment on this

Does the Minister conceive it possible that a person could fulfil one of these conditions and not fulfil the other?

Comment on this

Of course it is possible. A person could be employed for 1,800 hours and not be "continuously in the employment of such employer."

Comment on this

If a person works 1,800 hours and is employed by a particular employer for four days a week, should he not get the six days' holidays?

Comment on this

What is in the amendment to say that he will not?

Comment on this

The danger created by this word "continuously." He may be deemed not to be continuously in the employment of such employer, because he does not work on the two remaining days in the week.

Comment on this

I suggest that we will get nowhere by wrangling about this in the House. It seems to me to be a question on which the Minister should undertake to get legal opinion.

Comment on this

I have got more legal opinions on that particular point than are available in the House at the moment.

Comment on this

I think this question has been debated altogether from a false angle. The Minister is making provision for workers to be paid for a six days' holiday. In order that broken time, illness and so on, will not interfere with the giving of that holiday, he has introduced this reduction of hours. That is done in order to ensure that a reasonable interpretation may be given to the employment period. There is the other side of the picture that has not been touched upon. I am one of those who give a certain amount of casual employment, and I would like to see that casual employment protected in this connection. Deputy Norton spoke of the employer who employs a man for three days a week. The man gets employment from other people for the remaining three days. Surely, the employer who gives employment to the man for the first three days should not be asked to shoulder the full burden of the holiday payment. If an employer employs a man to the extent of 1,800 hours a year, the Minister holds that it is reasonable that he should be responsible for the holiday payment. But, supposing the man worked a total of 2,400 hours in the year, I submit that it is reasonable to expect that the person employing him for the 600 hours —the balance over the 1,800 hours— should bear a share of the holiday payment. I think that, in order to do justice to all parties, something should be done to meet that particular situation; that in a case such as I have mentioned, there should be a sharing of the cost.

Comment on this

I have already suggested to the Minister that if a man is continuously employed and is available, or at the disposal of his employer for a full week, then that employer ought to have responsibility placed upon him of providing the worker with a holiday. The last speaker dealt with the case of a man who worked a certain period with one employer and another period with a second employer. I am dealing with the case of men who, because of the action of their employers, are only allowed to work four days a week. That is their regular week, and in their case that has been the practice for ten years. The Minister should take notice of that. As a result of that practice, their minimum working hours will fall short of the minimum set down in the Bill. It would certainly be a hardship on them to be deprived of the benefit of the holiday, while it would be no hardship on their employers to be obliged to give them the holiday. Since this question of the meaning of "continuously employed" has been raised, I suggest to the Minister that he should do something to meet the case of those men who are available to their employer. I am not suggesting that they ought to have liberty to go out and undertake work for other people on the two days of the week that they are not required by their present employers, because I am not in favour of putting men on three-quarter time in competition with those who can find no work at all. These men are available to, and are at the disposal of, their employers if they are required by them on the two days a week that they are not engaged at present, and therefore, I think, the full responsibility for their holiday payment should be put on their employers.

Comment on this

Might I call the Minister's attention to the fact that in amendment No. 45 which he has submitted there is no question of a person being continuously in employment for a period of two months? "Continuously" is omitted from amendment No. 45, and the amendment has as much sense as amendment No. 44 and seems to operate more equitably. What is the necessity for "continuously" in amendment No. 44 when it is not in amendment No. 45? If he can drop it in amendment No. 45 he can drop it in amendment No. 44.

Comment on this

There is one other aspect of amendment No. 44 upon which I should like some information from the Minister. Under amendment No. 45 the employer pays the worker a day's pay on his employment ceasing with him for more than a day's pay according to the scale. Under amendment No. 44 the much-debated year is under discussion and I am wondering if there will not be a tendency, where the holiday may have been overlooked or interfered with, to pay a worker a week's pay in lieu of the annual six days' leave. Is it illegal for the employer to do that or for the worker to accept it?

Comment on this

It is illegal.

Comment on this

Under what section is it illegal?

Comment on this

Under this particular Section 19, which we are discussing.

Comment on this

The amendment has had a very fair discussion, and perhaps the Minister will look into it.

Comment on this

I shall look into any matter the Deputy raises, but the Deputy is setting himself up to interpret words in a manner in which, obviously, they are not capable of being interpreted.

Comment on this

More than I have done that.

Comment on this

We discussed this particular point in Committee. The question was raised in Committee of what was "continuous employment," and in order to meet the point I brought forward this amendment.

Comment on this

Would it not satisfy Deputies if the Minister promised to meet this on the Report Stage?

Comment on this

That meets the whole case.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is amendment No. 44 agreed to?

Comment on this

Before we agree, can the Minister amend his own amendment on the next Stage?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Although we have adopted this, he can amend further on the Report Stage what we have adopted?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the House consents.

Comment on this

I did not know that the Minister could move to reverse a decision of the House in that way.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister may.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 45:—

45. In page 9, before Section 19 (2), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(2) Where a worker employed by an employer in an industrial undertaking ceases, at any time other than the end of an employment year of such worker, to be in the employment of such employer, such employer shall either:—

(a) allow such worker, before such cesser, six days annual leave in respect of the portion of such employment year during which he was so employed, or

(b) pay such worker, at such cesser—

(i) one day's pay (calculated at the rate which would be applicable if such day were a day of annual leave allowed immediately before such cesser) in respect of every complete period of two months in the said portion of such employment year during which he has worked not less than three hundred hours, and

(ii) one day's pay (calculated as aforesaid) in respect of the period (if any) in the said portion of such employment year which is less than two months but not less than one month and during which he has worked for not less than one hundred and fifty hours."

Amendment No. 45 brings the same principles into the calculation of the shorter period in respect to which pay in lieu of holidays is allowed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 46:—

In page 9, to delete Section 19 (3), and substitute four new sub-sections as follows:—

"(3) Where a worker who is a member of the Reserve Force of the Defence Forces of Saorstát Eireann is absent from his employment for the purpose of attending and performing his duty as such member at any initial training, annual training, or test mobilisation, such worker shall, for the purpose of reckoning any period of employment or of continuous employment within the meaning of this section, be deemed to have been in his said employment during his said absence, and accordingly the period of his said absence shall for the purposes of this section be reckoned in the said period of employment or continuous employment.

(4) Where the ownership of an industrial undertaking is transferred by act of the parties or operation of law, a worker who is employed in such undertaking immediately before and immediately after such transfer shall be entitled to reckon, for the purposes of this section, the period of his continuous employment in such undertaking beginning before and ending at such transfer and the period of such continuous employment beginning at and continuing after such transfer as one uninterrupted period of continuous employment in such undertaking notwithstanding such transfer.

(5) This section shall apply to the employment year current at the commencement of this Act of every worker who, at such passing, is in the employment of an employer in an industrial undertaking, and this section shall have effect in respect of such employment year and such worker as if this section had been in force at the beginning of such employment year, but subject to the modification that, if such employment year expires within one month after the commencement of this Act, such employer shall be deemed to have complied with this section if he allows to such worker, not later than three months after the expiration of such employment year, such annual leave as such worker may be entitled to under this section in respect of such employment year.

(6) In this section and the two next following sections of this Act the expression `employment year' in relation to any worker means a period of one year beginning on the day on which such worker last entered the employment in relation to which the expression is used or on an anniversary of that day."

Amendment No. 46 does a number of things. In the first place it deletes sub-section 3 of section 19. That is consequential on the adoption of amendment No. 45. In the second place it provides that where a worker is a member of the Reserve Force of the Defence Forces of Saorstát Eireann and is called up for any period of initial training, annual training or a test mobilisation, and is consequently absent from his employment during such period of initial training, annual training or test mobilisation, he shall, nevertheless, be deemed to have been continuously employed for the purposes of this section, that is, for the purpose of qualifying for the annual leave. We think it is undesirable that workers who are members of the Reserve Force should be penalised on that account, or put in a less advantageous position than their fellows in the matter of qualifying for the annual holidays.

In the next sub-section the amendment provides that the continuity of a worker's employment will not be interrupted merely because the ownership of the business in which he is employed is transferred by act of the parties or the operation of law from one person to another, provided the worker has been employed in the concern both before and after the transfer. The next sub-section provides for the transition stage, the period that will immediately follow the coming into operation of this section and is designed to prevent any serious dislocation arising in industry, if a large number of workers should become qualified and entitled to receive their annual leave in the same week. The necessity for having some such provision, that is, a provision for the spreading of the holiday season over a particular period by employers so as to prevent dislocation will, I think, be obvious. Sub-section (6) is merely a re-insertion of the definition of the "employment year" which we deleted from an earlier part of the Bill.

Comment on this

I do not know how the Minister deletes sub-section (3) in the Bill and substitutes this amendment, because it seems to me that the sub-section dealt with another question entirely.

Comment on this

Sub-section (3) is being deleted because a new sub-section has been inserted by a previous amendment.

Comment on this

And amendment No. 45, which did effect in other circumstances what amendment No. 44 did in its particular place, has taken the place of paragraphs (a) and (b) of the old Bill?

Comment on this

This is completely new stuff that is going in?

Comment on this

I have no objection to Clause 3 of this amendment except in regard to its uncertainty. In all this question of holidays so far provided for in the Bill, it is possible to calculate what will be the expense beforehand and to make provision therefor, but this sub-section (3), which provides for time spent on service in defence forces such as a test mobilisation or initial training, gives no indication as to what period will be taken up, and therefore does not afford the contractor or the firm concerned an opportunity of calculating what expense will be incurred. I think some limit should be put on this, so that a definite calculation can be made. Conceivably to the layman it might mean a week, a month, or two months. Could the Minister give us any indication of the period which it is intended to cover by this clause? It is quite a new feature in the Bill.

Comment on this

The period of initial training or annual training is very short, and the period of a test mobilisation will be only a matter of two or three days. I am not sure what the exact period is, but it will not go beyond two or three weeks. It is never longer than that. A member of the Reserve Forces might be called to service in circumstances which would require a longer absence from his work than is mentioned here, but that absence would not count for the purposes of this Bill. I think the Deputy will obviously see the desirability of having this provision here, because otherwise there would be a very strong reason why workers should not become members of the Reserve Forces.

Comment on this

I stated I had no objection to it except its uncertainty.

Comment on this

The element of uncertainty is very slight. If any contractor were calculating the cost of certain work that might take a long time to execute, the amount he would have to allow against this item would obviously be very small, because such worker would qualify for the annual leave in any event if he were continuously employed on the job for a long period; he would succeed in securing the 1,800 hours' qualification without the necessity of availing of this provision. It is only in certain cases that it might happen that the worker's absence with the Reserve Forces might disqualify him from annual leave, and that is a hardship I am anxious to avoid. The total amount which a member of the Reserve Forces does is one month's training annually.

Comment on this

The Minister has made a new calculation. The original calculation has been revised by the amendment. Now the calculation will be varied again by the period of one month, if I have heard the Minister correctly. I am not sure if he said a month.

Comment on this

Yes, a month.

Comment on this

That is at least four weeks at 48 hours. It reduces it again to the region of 1,600 hours.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 47:—

In page 10, before Section 19 (5), to insert the following new sub-section:—

"(5) A worker while on his annual leave shall not perform work for remuneration in the service of the employer of such worker or in any other employment whatever. Every person who acts contrary to the provisions of this sub-section shall be guilty of an offence under this section."

This is an amendment which we discussed on the Committee Stage and the Minister then undertook to look into the matter with a view of accepting the amendment either in the form submitted or in some other form. When the matter was discussed on the Committee Stage there was a general opinion expressed that, so far as the Act could ensure, every effort should be made to prevent workers taking up other employment during the period of their annual holidays.

Comment on this

The Deputy should read the speeches of his colleagues. This proposal is put forward, in the first place, in order that the workers would have an opportunity of recuperating on their holidays and enjoying them and, secondly, to create, if possible, a source of employment for those normally unemployed. On the 28th June (Parliamentary Debates, col. 1325) the Minister said: "I think we shall have to make some provision to ensure that workers on a week's holidays, during which they are paid. will not be free to take employment in the manner described by Deputy Dockrell." The Minister's statement is a clear indication that he is favourable to the idea of preventing workers working during the period of their holidays. I hope he will accept this amendment, or at least the principle of it.

Comment on this

The matter was, as the Deputy said, discussed at length on the Committee Stage, and I think we had a division on a somewhat similar amendment. There are many objections to this. While it is desirable that workers who get annual leave under this measure should not work during that period of leave, it is very difficult to impose that as a statutory obligation on them. A worker cannot work during that period in the service of his employer, but he might decide to do harvesting work or some other class of work which would mean a change of occupation and would be as good as a rest for him. It would be practically impossible to enforce any such provision and I do not think we should have in the Bill provisions of this kind unless we can see our way to make them effective. I cannot see how we could effectively enforce a provision which debars workers on annual leave from taking employment which might be taken by them in different parts of the country far away from the district in which they were ordinarily employed.

Comment on this

I strenuously object to the principle enshrined in Deputy Norton's amendment. I think it is typical of the Socialist mind that loves to dragoon everybody. It may be necessary to have certain regulations in industry to preserve the rights of people and to keep an even keel between employer and employed, but the less we have of them the better. I strenuously object to pursuing a man outside his employment because he happens to work for wages; I protest against any attempt to dragoon him in his free time.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy did not hear Deputy Dockrell's speech.

Comment on this

Deputy Dockrell is entitled to hold his own views. It does not follow that he should subscribe to my views or that I should subscribe to his. Workmen are entitled to as much liberty as their employers. I have no doubt if an attempt were made by the Government to prevent an employer pursuing any hobby he chose to pursue there would be a general outcry. If that is so of employers I strenuously object to this House attempting to restrict the liberty of employees. It is typical of the Socialist mind of Deputy Norton that he should want, not only to provide against abuses in industry, but to dragoon and discipline every citizen of the State in his working hours, out of his working hours, and every time he can get his claw on him.

Comment on this

How about the Corporate State?

Comment on this

It is perhaps useful that the followers of Deputy Norton should get some inkling of what Socialism means, and what the principles he espouses would be likely to involve us in.

Comment on this

Deputy Dockrell is a Socialist after this.

Comment on this

The amendment is directed to preventing a worker, while on annual leave, performing work for remuneration in the service of his employer. I understood the Minister to say that the Bill provides that he cannot, if he is entitled to a week's holiday from an employer who has employed him during the whole working year, work during that holiday for that employer. In so far as the amendment is directed to that purpose, it is superfluous, mere tautology, because that is already in the Bill. But, surely, he can take harvest work or casual work with some other employer if he so desires.

Comment on this

It is desirable to prevent them doing so, but my trouble is to enforce such a provision.

Comment on this

That is quite a different thing. It is one thing to advise workers not to do it; it is quite another thing to put the Socialist claw on the backs of their necks and forbid them to do it. I feel sure the Chair would not desire us to enter into a discussion at this stage as to the Fascist or Hitlerite tendencies of President de Valera, or his colleagues—we shall reserve that for another day—but in the meantime let us rejoice that the Socialist tendencies of Deputy Norton negative the Hitlerite tendencies of President de Valera and, in the middle, liberty is preserved for the workman, who can enjoy his holidays.

Comment on this

I rise to support Deputy Norton's amendment.

Comment on this

Another Socialist.

Comment on this

There seems to be some idea in Deputy Dillon's mind that this is a Socialistic idea and that the State, or somebody else, is fastening its claws on a man's neck during his free time. That is where we join issue, because the man is having a free holiday at the expense of his employer and he is supposed to be having it for the benefit of his health. I quite agree that there may be a wide range of ideas as to how a person should take a holiday, and I agree that there should be considerable latitude. I should find it difficult to say that a man who is employed in Dublin and who goes down to the West of Ireland and engages in harvesting operations is undermining his health. I see by the Minister's attitude that he is sympathetic towards the idea, if he could get some words to express what is in the mind of Deputy Norton and others. My definition of it would be "analogous employment," because I think it would be a most flagrant injustice if, during a very busy period in the building industry, let us say, an employer has to give a worker a week's holidays and see that worker working for a rival employer.

We had a good deal of talk in a previous debate as to whether a man could mend a clock in his leisure time, but I believe the Minister, if he put his mind to it, could find some way of expressing what I believe would be best expressed by the term "analogous employment." I do not at all agree with the Minister that, because he cannot catch somebody who is doing something he ought not to do, it should not be prohibited. I would far rather maintain our high ideals, even though it were not possible to detect very much of the abuse which we knew was going on.

Comment on this

There are many sections in this Bill that will be extremely difficult to administer, and there are many offences created in the Bill that will be extremely difficult to detect. For instance, one portion of the Bill says that if a worker, after having worked for one employer, accepts employment with another during his holiday period, it is an offence, and if the other employer employs him, it is also an offence. One can easily see the enormous difficulty of detecting offences of this kind, but the House has decided that it is an offence and that, as far as the Bill is concerned, every effort should be made to detect the offence.

There is no difference at all between the principle in that case and the principle in this. I agree that there are difficulties in this case, but I think we should endeavour, so far as legislation is concerned, to get as much grip over the offence as possible; otherwise, we are calmly contemplating a worker who has been given holidays for the benefit of his own health entering into undesirable competition, either with his unemployed colleagues or with some other persons in some other industry. Bear in mind that the worker is not unemployed during that week. He actually has a week's wages for that week, and ought to be content with that. If they are not enough, there is another method of getting more wages, but he ought not to be allowed to say "I am getting a week's wages for my holidays this week, and I am going to try to get some work either at my own industry or at some other craft," to the possible detriment of another worker normally following that craft or engaged in that industry.

I think this is a very simple proposition. I agree that you cannot make the offences punishable in all cases, but even 10 per cent. efficiency is better than no efficiency at all, and there might be respect for this amendment from the point of view of preventing the offences occurring if there was a section such as this in the Bill. Deputy Dillon, with his typical bogeyman mind, sees red ruin and revolution in this amendment. It is a Socialist amendment, he says; it is reeking with Socialism and reeking with regimentation. And all that from a Deputy who is a member of a Party that wanted to regiment everybody, to make them join trade unions, whether they liked it or not, to make them pay contributions to trade unions, whether they liked it or not, and to prohibit their normal right to withdraw their labour if they liked. This is the Deputy who now objects to regimentation—the Deputy who a short time ago was giving his benediction to a policy which not alone made the ordinary employee at, say, the Bank of Ireland come into a trade union, but made the Governor of the Bank of Ireland come into the same union with the employees.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What about the amendment, Deputy?

Comment on this

I am coming to the amendment. As a matter of fact, I am discussing the amendment now by pointing out to Deputy Dillon that there is no real regimentation in this amendment at all. It is quite a sensible amendment, and if that is Deputy Dillon's conception of Socialism, the Deputy has still a lot to learn. Even Deputy Dockrell embraces this amendment. He says it is a sensible amendment, and I suppose Deputy Dockrell talks for the Party in this matter. Probably he is longer in it than Deputy Dillon and knows more about the policy of the Party. Deputy Dockrell does not see any Socialism in this. He says it is a sensible amendment, and it is an amendment which Deputy Dillon, I should imagine, if he had any pretence to being logical or equitable, ought to have gladly accepted.

This amendment has been supported by other Deputies of the Fine Gael Party in addition to Deputy Dockrell. It is an eminently reasonable amendment. It may not be 100 per cent. efficient, but a substantial measure of efficiency can be got under it, and I think that if even only 10 per cent. efficiency can be got, it is very much better than leaving this matter unprovided for and in such a way as to allow workers, who are being paid a week's wages for a week's holidays, to enter into competition with other workers who are unemployed or find it difficult enough to get employment in their industry or at their craft. Even if the Minister cannot make the thing wholly effective, I suggest that he ought, as a deterrent or even as something that will get a certain measure of efficiency in detection, agree to accept the principle of the amendment.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy be satisfied with an amendment to prevent a worker working in the same form of industrial work? The phrase "or in any other employment whatever" is much too wide.

Comment on this

If the Minister will agree to accept an amendment as wide as it would be reasonably practicable to administer it, I will agreeable.

Comment on this

I will agree with Deputy Dockrell that there is a case for preventing certain classes of workers in particular from using their forced annual leave to do work. Take the case of the aristocrats of the trade at the moment—the plasterers, who are in demand, I understand, by all contractors. A plasterer who got annual leave might well be induced by another contractor to do work for him during that period, and it would be unfair to the first employer who has to pay him for his period of leave. I should not like to prevent a plasterer from taking on a job at fruit picking or harvesting or, even in certain circumstances, working in various occupations associated with or similar to his ordinary work.

Comment on this

Assuming that there is not somebody else to do the job.

Comment on this

We cannot prevent that altogether. We have no means test in respect of employment and I do not think it would be possible to get that without regimentation of a ruthless kind. There are people doing jobs who are in receipt of pensions which bring them in much more than this worker might be getting during his leave. There is nothing to prevent them getting a job, even though there may be other people more in need of the work. That is not the principle on which we ought to go. The principle is that a worker, having been in employment for a year doing a certain form of industrial work and being given by law six days annual holiday from that work, should take that holiday, because otherwise the whole purpose of the scheme might be defeated. I think that the great majority of workers will take the holiday but there may develop a practice in relation to the different trades which it may be desirable to check. My difficulty has been the practical one of devising a workable scheme, not objection to the principle. Now that I have heard Deputy Dillon on the principle, I am very anxious to find a workable scheme, and I should like to have another opportunity of considering the matter.

Comment on this

Surely we should be told by Deputy Norton, since he attaches so much importance to this amendment, what he considers will be the percentage of workers who will seek alternative work during the six days holiday they will be allowed. How many workers does he think will walk out of an engineering job and seek another engineering job elsewhere? Surely, he agrees that the overwhelming majority of workers will make straight for the hills and bogs and harvest fields rather than that they will start and search for another establishment similar to that in which they were employed so that they may work for the six free days. It is obvious that Deputy Norton attaches great importance to this amendment. But is it worth while, if he is satisfied that the efficiency will be only 10 per cent. and that it will cover only 1 per cent., 2 per cent. or 3 per cent. of workers, to insist upon the amendment? Would it be worth while passing a law merely to secure that? In many cases, even the analogous-occupation proposal will be impossible to administer. If a painter goes down the country and some of his friends want a painting job done, he may take it rather than be idle, particularly if it be wet weather. You will then have his neighbours reporting him for what could not be considered a very serious offence. The amount of unemployment that will arise from workers availing of their holidays to engage in other work cannot be considerable. I rather think the matter is too petty to legislate upon, especially in view of the suggestion that there is not likely to be anything like substantial compliance with the law, no matter what amendment is passed.

Comment on this

I take it that Deputy Moore is aware that there is a pretty serious evil already, with which Deputy Dockrell and Deputy Beckett are, no doubt, familiar, in respect of certain workers in the building trade and electrical trade working for an employer during the day and taking on other jobs at night.

Comment on this

I am entirely against that.

Comment on this

The Deputy admits that there are workers in employment during the day who take on private contracts at night while the industry in which they are engaged is carrying a substantial percentage of unemployed. Deputy Moore knows that there is a substantial amount of unemployment in the building industry at the moment and the tendency in existing circumstances in the city will be, I think, for that unemployment to increase. If you can get workers to work a normal day for an employer and do some other work at night, is there not a great danger that, during the holiday period, they will take contracts which should go to others and compete with their unemployed brethren? That problem has to be met.

Comment on this