We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Conditions of Employment Bill, 1935—Recommittal (Resumed).

Contributions 153–308 of 308. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Conditions of Employment Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 13 of 1935 ›

If the Deputy is willing to hold over the amendment, I shall look into it again. I am not definitely promising to produce an amendment but I shall consider the matter.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 48:—

In page 10, at the end of Section 19 (5) to add the words "and shall be liable to pay to such worker in respect of the period of the annual leave a sum equal to double the amount of the salary, wages or other reward earned by such worker in respect of the period aforesaid."

The Bill provides that a worker shall be entitled to obtain a week's annual leave. If the employer is unwilling to give it to him, then he is empowered to proceed at law for the recovery of the wages. That may involve him in a considerable amount of trouble and he may be a long time waiting for his week's pay for the holidays to which he is entitled. The object of this amendment is to provide that if an employer puts a worker to the trouble and expense of suing for his pay at law, not only will the employer be guilty of an offence under the section but he shall be liable to pay the worker double the amount of the wages earned by the worker in respect of the holiday period. This matter was discussed on the Committee Stage. The Minister then said that he thought there was something to be said for the amendment and that he would look into it. He added that he had every sympathy with the amendment.

Comment on this

The worker can recover the pay due.

Comment on this

That is so. He could do that under the Bill as it was being discussed when the Minister said he had sympathy with this amendment.

Comment on this

Is the amendment necessary? If the worker works, he gets paid.

Comment on this

He may not get paid. He may have worked 1,800 hours and the employer may make no move to grant him his week's holidays. If he asks for holidays, the employer may say that he cannot afford to give them and that if he goes off he will do so at his own expense. There may be no wages forthcoming at the end of the week. The worker will then have to obtain the services of a solicitor, show the solicitor that the employer has contravened the Act, issue a summons against the employer and claim a week's wages. The case will be heard in the courts and, in the end, the worker will get only a week's wages with, perhaps, costs, although he has been subjected to very considerable inconvenience.

Comment on this

If you put in the amendment which you propose, are you not giving the worker a temptation not to take the week's holidays but to arrange with the employer instead?

Comment on this

I do not think so. I am merely seeking to add at the end of Section 19 (5) the words set out in the amendment. Section 19 (5) says: "If any employer fails to allow annual leave to any worker in contravention of this section he shall be guilty of an offence under this section." I want to add to that that he will be liable for double wages. If the Minister accepts this we will know that the employer is liable to pay for two weeks' holidays if he causes all that difficulty to the worker. A judge may hold the circumstances only entitled the worker to a week's wages. But there should be some deterrent placed upon the employer, so that he should not captiously refuse the worker his holidays. He might well agree to pay a week's wages rather than give the holiday. It is to deal with the obstreperous employer who will not act in accordance with the Bill that some penalty should be laid down if he does not comply with its provisions.

Comment on this

The penalty of £10 is provided.

Comment on this

Whom does that go to?

Comment on this

We do not want to give the worker any inducement not to take his holidays. If we say to the worker: "If you do not take your holidays you may recover two weeks' pay," there is an inducement to the worker not to take them.

Comment on this

No, it is if the employer fails to allow leave to the worker to take his holidays. The employer must fail to allow the worker to take his holidays.

Comment on this

Yes, the source of information is the dissatisfied worker. If he does not get his leave, he will report to the Inspector, who makes an investigation, and if it is found that the employer fails to allow the worker to take his leave, he will be prosecuted. But if the worker knows that unless he claims his holidays he will not get them at all, he may be tempted to put things off; he may not claim his holidays, and allow the employer to commit an offence. There will be a temptation to do that if the worker knows that by reporting the matter he will recover two additional weeks' wages. I do not like to put that temptation in the way of the worker, or to induce him to do anything but claim his holidays. I think it would be undesirable to have the position otherwise than it is. If the worker wants the benefit there is only one way of getting it, and that is by taking his holidays. The Deputy's amendment would provide an alternative to recover three weeks' wages.

Comment on this

The Minister says he gives the worker the right to get his holidays, but if he goes on his holidays and exercises his right he may not get his pay.

Comment on this

We give him the right to recover through the courts.

Comment on this

Yes, but that does not give him the right to get his wages when going on his holidays. Take the case of a man who has done his 1,800 hours of work and wants to go on his holidays next week. The employer says: "I cannot pay next week; if you go you will get no wages from me." The worker exercises his right under the Bill, and on the following Monday does not present himself for work. Then later he asks the employer, what about the week's wages for the holidays I had last week? The employer says: "I told you last week I could not pay you," so that the employee-does not get his wages. The Minister says that he can see a solicitor, issue a summons against the employer and bring the case into the courts.

Comment on this

As a simple contract debt there is no necessity for all that machinery.

Comment on this

Of course there is. The employee must go to a solicitor and have the case decided before a judge in court. That is the right the Minister gives the worker. I think if the worker is compelled to go to court he ought to be entitled to get something more than he would be entitled to if the employer respected his duties under the Act. It is no innovation. It is already a well-known policy in respect to employment insurance where an employee may recover against an employer who refuses to stamp his card. The employer who refuses to stamp the card of his employee will be compelled to stamp it and will not get any assistance to meet his liability. The same thing applies under the Unemployment Insurance Act. If the Minister is not prepared to accept the amendment in its present form I would be quite satisfied if he looks into it and meets the principle involved.

Comment on this

I do not want to give the employee any inducement not to take his holidays. The Bill, as we propose to amend it by a new Section 49, is quite satisfactory. We give the worker the right to take his holidays whether the employer gives them or not. He can take his holidays and he becomes entitled to be paid and by simple legal machinery he can enforce his claim to be paid.

Comment on this

What is the simple legal machinery?

Comment on this

He can recover on a simple complaint to the inspector. There is no difficulty.

Comment on this

There is difficulty. Here we are up against the impact of new legislation, while we know that employers will not comply with existing legislation, such for instance, as the Factories Act, and the Minister bemoaned that fact himself.

Comment on this

I did not bemoan it. I bemoaned the attitude of the District Justices in enforcing these Acts. We say to the employer he must do this, and if he does not he is going to be penalised by the imposition of a penalty for every day during which the employer continues his offence. In these circumstances there is no reason to think that employers will take such a risk. Take the other position. If in addition to the employer suffering this penalty he will have to pay two weeks' wages to the worker, the worker might be induced to allow the offence to be committed and let the week pass in order that his employer might have that penalty inflicted upon him. It would become a source of gain to the worker if the employer failed to do his duty.

Comment on this

I do not say that he should be paid two weeks but that the employer should be liable to pay two weeks. Let the judge decide the matter. If the employer was clearly wrong let the matter be decided by the judge.

Comment on this

I do not think that is an effective way of securing what we both want, that is that the worker should get his holidays. I think the provision in the Bill is sound.

Comment on this

In regard to Deputy Norton's observation I am not assuming the Minister accepts his interpretation of the conditions under this Bill. Deputy Norton drew a picture of an employee, having served 1,800 hours, going up to his employer and saying, "I am going on my holidays whether you like it or not."

Comment on this

It is not after 1,800 hours; it is after 51 weeks.

Comment on this

In fact, what would happen is that the employee must take his holidays when it is convenient to take them, unless the employer allows the year to pass without giving any week.

Comment on this

If there are only six days left the worker can take those six days.

Comment on this

Or sue the employer for default in not having allowed the holiday, but he is not at liberty to go up to his employer and say: "Having served 1,800 hours I am going to take a week's holidays."

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

He is entitled to go up to his employer and say: "My employment year is just over. There are only six days left in which you can fulfil your statutory obligation. I propose, therefore, to take those six days." In such an eventuality the employer is bound to pay him.

Comment on this

Would the Minister examine my point?

Comment on this

It is not so much a matter of examining the Deputy's point as examining the whole machine for ensuring that the statutory holiday period is going to be enforced.

Comment on this

I think this is a reasonable way of meeting it.

Comment on this

I think it is a dangerous way.

Comment on this

It is not a dangerous way unless you cannot trust the judge.

Comment on this

You might not be able to trust the worker to take his holiday instead of his pay.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

If the Deputy is pressing the amendment I shall have it looked into.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 49:—

In page 10, before Section 20, to insert a new section as follows:—

Whenever a worker for salary or wages is allowed by his employer any annual leave to which he is entitled by virtue of this Act, such employer shall pay to such worker, in respect of each day of such leave, salary or wages at whichever of the following rates is applicable, that is to say:—

(a) in the case of a worker whose ordinary remuneration is wholly calculated by reference to time, at the rate at which such remuneration was payable immediately before the commencement of such anunal leave, and

(b) in the case of a worker whose ordinary remuneration is wholly piece-work wages, at the average daily rate of his earnings (exclusive of pay for overtime) in the period in respect of which he is allowed such annual leave, and

(c) in the case of a worker whose ordinary remuneration is partly calculated by reference to time and is partly piece-work wages, at the average daily rate of his earnings (exclusive of pay for overtime) in the period in respect of which he is allowed such annual leave.

This is an improved provision of a kind which is already in the Bill. It does not effect any substantial change. It deals with the calculations of the payments to be given to the workers during the annual holiday period.

Comment on this

And is in substitution for sub-section (20), paragraph 4?

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 50:—

In page 10, to delete Section 20 (4).

This is a consequential amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 51:—

In page 10, before Section 21, but in Part II, to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) Every employer who is required by this Act to allow annual leave to a worker shall give to every worker to whom he is so required to allow such annual leave notice in writing of the day on which such annual leave will begin, and shall so give such notice not less than one week before such day.

(2) A notice given in pursuance of this section to a worker may be given either by handing such notice to such worker or by exhibiting such notice in a prominent position to which such worker has access in the place in which he is employed.

(3) Every employer, required by this section to give to any worker such notice as is mentioned in the preceding sub-sections of this section, who fails or neglects to give in accordance with this section such notice to any worker on any occasion on which he is so required so to do shall be guilty of an offence under this section.

It was suggested by Deputy Norton that it would be undesirable if the position were left in such a way that the employer could notify the worker at mid-day on the Saturday, when paying him his week's wages, that he must take his holidays in the following week. Consequently, we are proposing to provide here that at least one week's notice must be given to the worker as to the period during which he must take his holidays. That notice can be given either in writing or by publication of a notice in an accessible place in the factory, which, I take it, will be the ordinary practice. I should imagine that in an ordinary factory the practice will be to publish a notice early in the year indicating the period at which each employee will get his leave. The third sub-section here merely provides for penalties in the event of default.

Comment on this

I think that in fixing one week the Minister has drawn this amendment rather tightly.

Comment on this

A minimum of one week.

Comment on this

That enables the employer to sail down closely to the week. Visualise the position of a worker who may be told on, say, Monday morning: "You are to take your week's holidays from next Monday." The worker might want to arrange to take his family away for the week. He might want to arrange some other details as to where his family would go, and at what price they would get there. He might want to arrange with some other member of the family to go with him. All that will have to be done in a week, during which the worker will be employed. I think a week's notice of the time at which they must take their holidays is very inadequate. I had hoped that the workers would get much longer notice, and, in fact, there is no real difficulty for the employer in giving it.

Comment on this

There might well be difficulty. I agree that, ordinarily, longer notice should be given, but I do not think that the statutory obligation should be for more than one week.

Comment on this

Under an amendment passed by the Minister the employer was required to give a month's notice of his desire to substitute a Church holiday for a bank holiday.

Comment on this

But that is a different thing.

Comment on this

He is required to give a month's notice of changing one holiday, but he need give the worker only a week's notice in respect of his whole six days.

Comment on this

That is the individual worker.

Comment on this

But this may not be the individual worker?

Comment on this

The worker who is in employment, and has had continuous employment for 12 months, and becomes entitled to a holiday, is one of the fortunate people, while I think he is entitled to get—and probably will get in the great majority of cases— longer notice than a week, if the exigencies of the business, the volume of orders coming in, and the nature of the contracts that have to be fulfilled by the employer allow it. If he can get longer than a week's notice that is good enough. I do not think he has much grievance, if, as an effect of giving that week's notice, he is secured continued employment in the future.

Comment on this

It is a curious consolation to the worker that he must be satisfied if there are not some weeks in the year during which his family are hungry. That is a curious effect of the system under which we live.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that a contractor or manufacturer might have several workers engaged in the execution of a particular order. He knows that other orders are coming in. He says: "Between those two orders I can give my men their annual holidays. It suits my business. It means that their convenience and my convenience will be served."

Comment on this

Do the workers agree that their convenience is served?

Comment on this

I think that the workers have every reason to be satisfied if, because of that arrangement, they are secured continued employment under the new order.

Comment on this

I cannot at all agree with the Minister when he says that a worker ought to be quite satisfied to put up with the inconvenience of getting a week's notice of his employer's intention to grant him his six days' holidays. Six days is a miserable period of holidays. That is all the worker is going to get under this Bill. In other countries he gets much more, notwithstanding the statement to the contrary by the Minister on the Committee Stage of the Bill. He is going to get six days' holidays under this Bill.

Comment on this

A minimum of six days' holidays enforceable by statute. Why does the Deputy think it necessary to misrepresent the Bill in order to meet his point?

Comment on this

That statement is untrue. I am not seeking to misrepresent the Bill.

Comment on this

There is a minimum of six days, enforceable by statute.

Comment on this

Does not the Minister know that a lot of people do not get any holidays at the moment?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

They are going to get six days under this Bill. That is the only enforceable holiday they can get. The Minister knows perfectly well that employers will not give anything more than the enforceable minimum. Surely the Minister knows that?

Comment on this

Some employers are giving holidays at the present time when there is no enforcement.

Comment on this

I know that, just as some countries are giving more than six days, and going much further than the Minister is going.

Comment on this

Very few.

Comment on this

If the Minister wants me to read them I will read them. The Minister's previous statements on the Committee Stage were very inaccurate in that respect. Here is a case where a worker is only to get six days' holidays per annum. That is all he can enforce under this Bill, and he ought to get as long a notice as possible of those holidays.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

He is going to get a month's notice if the employer proposes to substitute a Church holiday for one of the six Bank holidays, but he is going to get only one week's notice when his employer is going to give him all his holidays at a particular time which will suit the employer. I think a week's notice is inadequate. I think if the Minister were to provide for a month's notice the employers would find very little difficulty in adjusting themselves to that. It is done at present in many cases where workers get holidays; they generally know a considerable period in advance. If that can be done by good employers, with good organisation, there should not be any difficulty in others finding it possible to accept the same standard. A good employer will give reasonable notice. An employer who has been accustomed to giving holidays to his staff will give adequate notice, but the inefficient employer, who has no conception of his social responsibility, who has got an inefficient outlook, and who dislikes a Bill of this kind, will squeeze the last right that he can get out of this Bill. The tendency will be to give the minimum notice rather than the maximum. I think the Minister should substantially increase the week's notice.

Comment on this

In looking at this section I think that Deputy Norton approaches it from an entirely different angle to that of the average employer. I should like him to consider just where this point is leading. There is no doubt that in most employments holidays are arranged as far ahead as possible, and in many cases employees—and I consider very properly—get two or three months' notice when their holidays will come on. But all sorts of unforeseen circumstances turn up. For instance, the lining of a furnace may fall down and leave a factory idle. I suggest to Deputy Norton that if he is too hard on employers in emergencies, he may force them to shut down, instead of giving notice of holidays. If Deputy Norton wants longer notice, it should be stated that cases of emergency were excepted, because these are really the cases where employees will be cut down to the minimum of a week. I am sure Deputy Norton would be the last to contend that in industry at the present time all sorts of unforeseen circumstances do not turn up. The lining of a furnace might fall down, there might be a serious fire on a ship during the night or a ship might founder in some other part of the world. As all sorts of circumstances crop up, I suggest to Deputy Norton that he should either leave this matter alone, or put in a saving clause dealing with cases of emergency.

Comment on this

Emergencies will not occur during the period of the notice. I want it so that an employee can be told in May that he is going on holidays during the first week in July. What happens between May and July does not matter, as the worker will be still at work.

Comment on this

But if an emergency occurs during that period the employer will want to advance the holidays.

Comment on this

That may be true. If it is a case for providing for emergency of that kind, I am willing to accept any provision for dealing with that position.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 52:—

In page 10, section 22 (1), line 53, before the word "declaring" to insert in brackets the words "(in this Act referred to as exclusion regulations)".

This is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendments Nos. 53 and 54:—

In page 11, section 22 (2), lines 6 and 7, to delete the words "persons who are in his opinion representative" and substitute the word "representatives"

In page 11, section 22 (2), lines 8 and 9, to delete the words "persons who are in his opinion representative" and substitute the word "representatives"

These are consequential on amendments Nos. 2 and 3.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 55:—

In page 12, section 25 (2), line 4, after the word "section" where it secondly occurs, to add the words "and such worker shall also be guilty of an offence under this section".

This is similar to other amendments that we had on other sections, which put the obligation on the worker, as well as the employer, to observe the principles of the Bill.

Comment on this

I move amendments Nos. 56 and 57:—

In page 12, section 26 (1), paragraph (e), line 19, after the word "shift" to add the words "but shall not be entitled to leave the premises of the employer during such period of rest without the permission of the employer".

In page 12, section 27 (1), paragraph (e), line 39, after the word "shift" to add the words "but shall not be entitled to leave the premises of the employer during such period of rest without the permission of the employer".

These are necessary provisions in relation to the rest period for shift workers. Quite a number of employers have made representation that the only thing in the Bill that is perturbing them is the provision that workers on shifts in certain industries may be allowed to leave the machines during the rest period. In certain cases risk would be involved if the machines for any period were left otherwise than under observation by the skilled workers concerned. We propose, therefore, to preserve the rest period, but to make it clear that a worker will not be entitled to leave the premises during that rest period or that he will be available in the event of anything going wrong that would require skilled attention.

Comment on this

This is a most extraordinary kind of amendment and is clearly put in by the Minister at the request of employers. Is there any danger of anything happening a machine? Is not a worker fully conscious of the danger to which he exposes himself and his colleagues? There may be cases where there is a particular boiler or machine in some factory where a worker stays in for a long period and then says: "I am now entitled to fifteen minutes' rest, and I am going outside for a few minutes' recreation." Surely he should be entitled to do so during the rest period. Under this amendment he cannot even go out for a breath of air.

Comment on this

At present these workers get no rest at all. They take their meals and attend to the machines at the same time.

Comment on this

What is the Minister talking about?

Comment on this

Of the class of workers I have in mind.

Comment on this

That is a most audacious statement. Does the Minister contend that people working under those conditions do not get out of the premises for a short interval?

Comment on this

Some of them do.

Comment on this

Under this Bill none of them may go out. This is an amendment to cage the workers.

Comment on this

Nothing of the kind. The Deputy is deliberately misrepresenting me.

Comment on this

That statement is deliberately untrue, and was made by the Minister knowing it to be untrue.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must withdraw that remark.

Comment on this

I will, if the Minister withdraws his statement, that I deliberately misrepresented the position.

Comment on this

The Deputy's amendment is not what is on the Order Paper.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I am solicitous for the Chair in this matter. Deputy Norton stated that what the Minister said was untrue, and deliberately untrue.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not proceed until he withdraws the unparliamentary words.

Comment on this

I said so in reply to a remark made by the Minister to the effect that I was deliberately misrepresenting the purpose of the amendment. I was not deliberately misrepresenting the purpose of the amendment, and the Minister's statement, therefore, was of the character I described. If the Minister is prepared to withdraw his statement I am perfectly willing to withdraw mine.

Comment on this

The amendment is that workers shall not be entitled to leave the premises without the permission of the employer. That is quite contrary to what Deputy Norton said.

Comment on this

What about the point of order?

Comment on this

I withdraw the word "deliberately."

Comment on this

And I withdraw the other remark.

Comment on this

Birds in their little nests agree.

Comment on this

A nice pair of birds.

Comment on this

To get back to the amendment, at present a worker can get out during the rest interval. He may be engaged in circumstances that make his work very fatiguing and very strenuous, and if he gets out for 15 minutes during the shift the worker is getting nothing very extraordinary from the Minister or from the employer. If there is any danger of anything happening a machine, that might injure the worker or his colleagues in the industry, the worker may be relied to be fully alive to that danger. Of course any sensible worker in these circumstances would remain on the premises. Ordinary common sense would suggest that he should take steps to avoid any possibility of such a catastrophe occurring.

I think the section is quite all right as it stands. It allows a worker 15 minutes' rest in each shift. It reads: "Every worker shall be allowed at least 15 minutes' rest in each shift not less than three nor more than four hours after the commencement of such shift." That is as much as anybody could reasonably require. But the Minister is not satisfied with that. A person may be working at a boiler or at an open fire; he may be working in a fetid atmosphere or in a place which few of us would care to choose as a place for industry. But he is not to be entitled to go out for the 15 minutes' rest. The Minister says in his amendment: "but shall not be entitled to leave the premises of the employer during such period of rest without the permission of the employer." If Deputy Dillon had any justification for talking about Hitler methods he has it in this amendment with a vengeance. One would think the worker had no rights at all. At present he can go out.

Comment on this

With the permission of the employer.

Comment on this

Where is the permission of the employer required?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Under what Act is it required?

Comment on this

There is no obligation to give a rest.

Comment on this

In fact they do go out at present, but the Minister is going to cage them.

Comment on this

In some industries they go out, but in others they do not.

Comment on this

You are going to cage them under this amendment.

Comment on this

I am not going to cage anybody.

Comment on this

They are not to go out during the rest period. Those who go out at present will be kept in.

Comment on this

That is not in the amendment we are discussing. The Deputy is not capable of understanding it.

Comment on this

I would not come to the Minister for advice on understanding anything, because he seems to have an insurance policy against understanding anything.

Comment on this

He is a sergeant-major.

Comment on this

He is even worse. You would expect common sense and equity in what a sergeant-major would do. This is an amendment to keep the workers in during the 15 minutes' rest. I think it is an outrageous proposal. I do not believe the employers thought the Minister would accept this when they submitted it. They said they found the Minister most pliable in the matter. He was prepared to agree to introducing the amendment to keep these people in during the period of the rest interval. The amendment is a most unfair one. No employer could reasonably expect more than is in the section.

The Minister might make a case for the amendment if he stated that some terrible catastrophe had occurred while the workers were out, but no such case has been made. All we are told by the Minister is that the employers wanted it done, and therefore he agreed to do it. He is not prepared to let the present position alone. What is the difficulty in leaving it alone? If some of them stay in, they may stay in for a good reason, and if others go out, they may go out for a good reason. Why not leave the present position alone instead of compelling the worker to remain in even during the 15 minutes which he is going to get out of a nine-hour day? That is the prospect the Minister is offering them. He is not satisfied with the present position but would worsen it.

Comment on this

I submit that the amendment is bad in principle. It does not effect the purpose the Minister has in mind. What the Minister has in mind is that in very exceptional cases, where constant supervision of dangerous machinery is necessary, employers can depend upon an employee to stand by. These can be the only circumstances under which it would be justifiable to restrict the freedom of the employee in his free time. As Deputy Dockrell said to me a moment ago when speaking to him, the fact is that these matters only give rise to difficulty where you meet a curmudgeon employer or a curmudgeon employee, and in 99 out of every 100 cases it will be just as much the solicitude of the employee to keep his machine in order as it is of the employer.

I suggest to the Minister that, instead of a general provision purporting to keep the employees within the premises, unless the employer permits them to leave, he should introduce some provision whereby individual employees, on the application of the employer or themselves, might have a certificate permitting the employer not to grant this 15 minutes as a statutory right, and then whatever compensating relaxation there should be would become a matter of personal arrangement between the employer and the employees. It would mean that, in general, factory employees are entitled to 15 minutes' rest, but in special cases, where employees are engaged with dangerous machinery, the employer could get a certificate in respect of them relieving him of the statutory right to give them any rest, and they would be left in the same position they were in before this legislation was passed, which, as we all know, means that, in fact, they do get some free time during a shift which is taken in a way which conforms to the convenience both of employer and employees. That is a practical proposal to get out of the difficulty.

Deputy Norton, in spite of all his Socialist indignation, knows well that there is a difficulty here, because if you have a cantankerous workman who insists upon his statutory rights at every turn, he may walk out and leave an important machine unsupervised, and serious damage may be done. He would be able to defend himself by saying that he had a right to leave the factory during the 15 minutes' rest. If this is inserted it will inconvenience thousands of men, whereas all we want to do is to provide for perhaps half-a-dozen exceptional cases. The practical way to get out of that is to leave everybody free and to make provision that a certain man can opt out of the 15 minutes part of the Bill where the Minister is satisfied that a reasonable case is made for allowing him so to opt out. If the Minister will adopt that course he will save himself from the fury of Deputy Norton, who will feel constrained to make several violent speeches describing the Minister as what I really believe him to be—an Irish Hitler.

Comment on this

The Minister led the House to believe by what he said when moving the amendment that the parties responsible for the suggestion looked upon this as a most important matter concerning them.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

At any rate he has clearly led the House to believe that cases had been put to him that men and women who were not under some kind of statutory discipline of this nature would recklessly go away from their machines and leave these machines probably to be smashed up or something like that. I am sure the Minister has no definite evidence in his possession from any big industrialist that that kind of recklessness has been going on. Therefore I do not see that there is any case for the insertion of a provision of this kind in this Bill. I think the Minister might leave it to the ordinary disciplinary rules of industrial firms to deal with a cantankerous workman, as Deputy Dillon said, who would be so reckless as to leave a machine and ignore the fact that by doing so he was going to upset the working of the concern.

Comment on this

How would an employer deal with that workman unless the amendment is inserted when the freedom is a statutory right? It would be an offence for an employer to deal with him.

Comment on this

Let us have the case put to the Minister in connection with the insertion of this amendment. Let us know what body of responsible people put this suggestion up to the Minister. Were they representatives of the Saorstát Federation of Industries or representatives of the Dublin Chamber of Commerce? Let us have the arguments put up to the Minister in support of the insertion of the amendment in a Bill which, as far as I can see, otherwise provides for decent working conditions for people and the continuance of harmonious working conditions between employers and employees. There are men in charge of the firms which will have the obligation of administering an Act of this kind and it should be left to the heads of the firms and the foremen and others to co-operate to such an extent as not to require the insertion of a mandatory disciplinary provision of this kind.

Comment on this

This mock indignation of Deputy Norton and Deputy Davin does not deceive me. They know quite well that the industries covered by this section—continuous process industries—are in a special category. These industries are concerns that must be kept going.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any case to show?

Comment on this

Has the Minister any case to show where such concerns must be kept going, by statute—where the workers must do their work?

Comment on this

No, I have not, but they have certain rights.

Comment on this

They have, virtually, the same rights as always.

Comment on this

Not by statute.

Comment on this

What is the difference?

Comment on this

The difference is that there would be no right to keep them from leaving their work.

Comment on this

The suggestion is that they might do it in a reckless way.

Comment on this

Well, I will give you the case of a sugar cooker in a sugar factory. His business is to watch the sugar boiler and to read the index. There is no labour, so to speak, involved; his sole labour is the adjusting of a tap or two to keep the boiler right. He can take his meals, and he can even read the paper while he is doing so.

Comment on this

He can read the paper?

Comment on this

Yes—providing that he does not leave the place, and that he can always see the gauges on the boiler.

Comment on this

Reading the paper?

Comment on this

He can perform his duty. The employer says:"If we give the man the right to leave the boiler, then an entirely new shift must come on to take his place, because the boiler cannot be left neglected or unattended; if it is left unattended there may be an explosion and other places may be affected." The same would apply to such places as gas works. There would be a definite danger, not alone to the people engaged in the particular industry but to other people engaged in other industries. Then, take industries governed by this particular section. The practice has been that the workers take their meals and their rest periods adjacent to the machines they are watching. It is proposed to continue that. It is not proposed to confine the workers in the factory. The provision is that they cannot leave the premises without getting the consent of the persons in charge, and I think that it is such a reasonable provision that it is ridiculous to describe it as a proposal to cage the workers. It is an obviously sensible proposal and I am quite certain that, in the regulations governing sugar factories, and other such factories, in Russia, or in any other country, similar provisions apply. This is not a question of restricting the opportunities of workers, but it is a question of securing reasonable working conditions for the workers, subject to the conditions of the industries in which they are engaged, because, if these industries are not carried on, the workers concerned will not have any work. This section is designed for the protection of the employees, and if the employees want it to be deleted, we will delete the section altogether. If the Deputy wants this attempt to regulate the employment of these workers stopped, I will stop it. I am not prepared to force these improved conditions on the workers if they do not want them. Personally, I think they do want these improved conditions. But, if they do not want these improved conditions to be enforced as a statutory right, I am prepared to agree to that.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister condemns himself out of his own mouth. I thought we were going to give these people 15 minutes' rest; or is it that we have determined that it is impracticable to give them that period of rest?

Comment on this

There are certain cases where it might not be practicable, and other cases where it might be necessary to deal with the problem in a different way.

Comment on this

I recognise that, in certain cases, it may not be practicable, but there is no use in telling me that you are not going to give a sugar-cooker 15 minutes' rest.

Comment on this

Do not forget the 15 minutes in the gas works.

Comment on this

Yes, let us take the gas works. Well, if so, it is no use to tell me that they are enjoying 15 minutes' rest if they are still watching the gauge in the sugar factory or the gas works, as the case may be. If this provision is made, that the man in the gas works, or the sugar-cooker, will stop watching the gauge for 15 minutes a day, the result is that the employer can say to these workers: "Well, if we have to give that 15 minutes' rest, you must spend that 15 minutes' rest watching the gas gauges."

Comment on this

Where is that?

Comment on this

I understood the Minister to give us the case of the sugar-cooker and the watcher of a gauge in a gas company, and that he pointed out that if the sugar-cooker elected to read his newspaper away from the gauge no harm would be done.

Comment on this

I suggest that no harm would be done if Deputy Dillon would spend 15 minutes reading the amendment and not in making a speech about it. This Assembly is not a gas works.

Comment on this

The Minister says that great damage might be done by a man leaving his work in such a case, and that, if the Minister was not prepared to make a concession with regard to this amendment, it would mean the employment of a completely new shift of sugar cookers for that period of 15 minutes' rest. If that is the purpose the Minister has in mind, this amendment is calculated to do away with the whole 15 minutes' rest in practice, and means that an employer can take away the privilege. I think that there may be cases in which men ought not to have a statutory right to 15 minutes' rest-cases where it might not be practicable —but where such cases do exist, I suggest that representations can be made to the Minister, and that he can certify that certain people, doing such work, would be entitled to a certificate and would be in the same position as they would have been before this legislation was passed. I would like to pass over the 15 minutes' rest for the vast majority of cases, but the inevitable fact remains that, in certain cases, as the Minister must confess, it is not practicable to deal with all these cases. If the Minister would give us the particular cases he has in mind, then we would know where we are; but, under this system nobody is going to be satisfied. The employer is going to be inconvenienced and Deputy Norton is going to address himself in Ringsend to the people there about the Hitler proposal in this present Bill. I make that practical suggestion, and the Minister must agree that it is a practical suggestion, and one that will get over the difficulty he has in view, and at the same time deprive everybody of any sense of grievance.

Comment on this

After all that has been said on this amendment there are one or two points that I want to clear up. Is it only necessary to get the permission of the party in charge of the worker if effect is to be given to the terms of the amendment? As it is the amendment is perfectly meaningless for the employee should go and seek his employer and get permission from him. If the Minister wants it to mean the representative of the employer he should say so in the amendment. As it is the employee on each separate occasion should seek the permission of his employer in advance; or is he to get agreement in advance as to the particular hours he would be entitled to leave the premises during each period of rest?

Comment on this

"Employer" there would cover the representatives of the employer. He would not have to go to the Board of Directors.

Comment on this

Then it would be necessary to have the word "representative" inserted there and it would also be necessary to know if he could have this permission for every day of the week. Otherwise, he would be brought back to the position of his schooldays. The amendment seems to envisage a lack of confidence or trust in the workers for it suggests that they would recklessly go away and leave the machinery unprotected and uncared for. It must mean that they are so reckless and irresponsible in regard to the care of the machines at their disposal that they would go out and seek the fifteen minutes' period of rest without the permission of those in charge of the undertaking. Those who suggested the amendment apparently looked at the workers from a suspicious angle. In the past the men had to take their meals and the meals period was much more important than this fifteen minutes' rest period. And in the past there has been no case where the worker has done anything to show that he did not feel full responsibility for the machines of which he was in charge. The Minister told us that the men had to take their meals while at work.

Comment on this

In certain cases. Men who had charge of the gauges will have little actual work to do.

Comment on this

I think the amendment is a reflection on the workers and it shows a lack of confidence in their sense of responsibility. If the amendment is going to be persisted in I do hope it will be made clear that the worker is not going to go out looking for the Board of Directors before he gets his fifteen minutes of rest.

Comment on this

If this amendment is carried the worker will not be allowed to go and seek for permission. This Bill passed through the Committee Stage of the House leaving Section 27 untouched. That section apparently then expressed the Minister's view in connection with shift work. The Minister's advisers told him that in shift work there were adequate safeguards, and the Minister, on being satisfied that there were, allowed the section to go through the House. He now comes here on the second Committee Stage and tells us quite calmly that the employers asked him to put in this amendment, and he has put it in for them. The artificial fury of the Minister about watching the gauges betrays the whole weakness of his case. Section 27(1) (e) as it stands is a perfectly sensible section. But the employers got at the Minister and, according to his own statement, said: "You must amend this." Then we have the Minister coming back and saying to the House: "Will you accept this amendment, which provides that the worker `shall not be entitled to leave the premises of the employer during such period of rest without the permission of the employer'?" which, in effect, is saying that if the employer agrees, the workers may have a 15 minutes' rest in each shift, but if the employer does not agree he will not get the 15 minutes. That is the effect of the Minister's amendment, which vitiates whatever value was in Section 27 (1) (e).

Comment on this

Only in special industries such as those to which I have referred.

Comment on this

If there is any danger of lives being lost or machinery being blown up I am prepared to meet the Minister in a situation of that kind.

Comment on this

That is what the amendment is designed to do.

Comment on this

The amendment gives the right to the employer to say to the worker: "I will not give you permission to go outside," and Section 27 (1) (e) is rendered ineffective once the Minister adopts that attitude and refuses to allow an appeal to himself. I am willing to allow the matter to be decided by the Minister. Let the employer make an application to the Minister that it would be undesirable that the worker should leave the machines for this 15 minutes' period. If this amendment is passed we have no guarantee that it will not be used in cases where legitimately the permission could be granted. The most the Minister should ask the House is to give him authority to decide these cases, and I think the employers would be satisfied with that. He told us he is inserting this amendment at the request of one set of employers. Is the Minister sure that the employers would not agree to allow the matter to be decided by the Minister himself? I am sure the employers have sufficient confidence in the Minister to allow him to decide border-line cases. The Minister should go back to the people who asked him to make this amendment, tell them the difficulties in the way and the vicious principle underlying this amendment, and ask them if they will be satisfied with his decision. That is a reasonable request. The sub-section is quite useless if the employer is allowed to refuse permission indiscriminately. Is there to be any appeal from the refusal of the employers? If this amendment is carried there will be no such thing as this interval except with the permission of the employer.

Comment on this