Committee on Finance. - Conditions of Employment Bill, 1935—Recommittal.
Contributions 1–166 of 335. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 13 of 1935 ›
Is the Minister prepared to stand fast to the position he took up, and is he not prepared to depart from the terms of the amendment proposed by himself? Does he consider that there is no substance in the arguments advanced by members of the Labour Party in this matter?
Comment on this
I never asked that. I know the Minister finds considerable difficulty in understanding and appreciating my arguments. What was suggested would make no material difference to the arrangements he has in mind, and would, in fact, only give satisfactory recognition to what he himself said. Will he consider the matter between this and Report Stage?
Comment on this
The class of industry affected here is a very small class and is a continuous process industry. It must be run, not for eight hours, but all the time. Where there is interruption of the working of the shift, for the purpose of providing a rest interval, I think it is reasonable to require that the worker should not leave the premises without the permission of the employer. There are certain classes of process industries in respect to which the permission of the employer would be readily given, but in quite a number the permission of the employer would not be given. In such cases either of two things can happen: Considerable risk would be run by leaving machinery, parts, tools and things of that kind about, or it would be necessary to employ another shift for the purpose of replacing the one at work. In this process industry it is necessary that rest should be taken on the premises. The actual work done is not heavy work; it is important work but rarely heavy work. There is little hardship imposed upon the workers by the restriction that they should remain on the premises. That is the practice at the present time, and it is in no way intended to depart from that practice, except after an examination of all the circumstances in conjunction with employers and employed. If, after such consultation, it is considered desirable that the existing practice should be altered and the conditions of employment improved. there is power to do that. If it is felt, on the other hand, that the provisions of the Bill are too onerous then, after consideration, there is power to exempt an industry from that observance. Having regard to these two provisions—the power to alter one way or another the actual proposal in the Bill—I think it is necessary to meet the obvious difficulty by this amendment to the Bill.
Comment on this
The Minister will agree with me that these continuous process industries represent about 5 per cent. of the total industry of the country. They are the exception rather than the rule?
Comment on this
Therefore, it would be fair to say that the necessity for this continuous supervision applies to approximately 5 per cent. of the total industrial workers' population?
Comment on this
Yes, but of course the section to which the amendment has been moved relates to that class of industry only.
Comment on this
No. It applies only to continuous process work. It is an amendment to Section 26, which relates only to continuous process industries.
Comment on this
I put it to the Minister that, in dealing with those people, it would be more expedient to say that where he is satisfied it is essential that they should remain in constant attendance they should not be subject to this part of the Bill at all; they should be taken out. Otherwise you are going to have continuous dissatisfaction arising. If he constitutes himself the judge of the special circumstances in which persons can legitimately be asked to remain constantly on duty, no reasonable complaint will be left to anybody. It is not going to be a very onerous business, because as he himself knows, very few of those people are to be seen. It will remove a considerable sense of grievance from a number of other people, and will make the whole thing work easily. I would urge on the Minister that he is mistaken in standing pat in regard to this particular amendment. He always has the remedy, if he proves to be right in face of the whole rest of the House—the whole rest of the House is against him—of bringing in further amending legislation, and steam-rolling it through.
Comment on this
Oh, no. That is the remedy—but a remedy which I do not want. If that amendment is not in then the only power we would have of dealing with the circumstances in this particular case would be to exempt those industries from the whole of the section, which would be obviously against the interests of the workers concerned.
Comment on this
I do not think that is the only remedy. However, I do not propose to weary the House. I have put my case, and Deputy Norton has stated his view. I can only say that I think the Minister is imprudent in not undertaking to review the matter between this and the Report Stage, if he is not prepared to come the whole way and accept a compromise solution such as I have proposed.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
Can we hear from the Minister why he is not prepared to agree to an amendment, the object of which will be to require that he should be satisfied that it is necessary for workers to remain on the premises? If he is satisfied that it is necessary the Minister could make a regulation requiring that workers should remain on the premises. In the vast majority of cases I think it will not be possible to satisfy the Minister that it is necessary to keep workers in a factory, but some captious employers may refuse their workers a few moments' recreation during the licensed shift period.
Comment on this
It is no different from the present position. What I want to make clear is that in any event there is no change and no worsening of the position of the workers. In so far as an employer gives permission to leave the premises he can do so. Presumably he will continue to do so. There is no reason why he should not. What we are aiming to do is to leave the present practice undisturbed unless it should become necessary to make an exclusion order in reference to that section following consultation with the parties. The reason I think these words should be in is because their absence would make it practically necessary, in the case of a number of responsible industries, to make an exclusion order under section which would be very undesirable.
Comment on this
I do not think it is necessary to go to that extreme at all. Under the Bill as it stands, the worker is entitled to a certain rest interval. Apparently the Minister thought he should have that rest interval when the Bill was circulated, and passed through Committee, because he did not propose to amend it then. He proposes to amend it now in such a way that although the worker is given the rest interval, he cannot leave the premises unless with the permission of the employer. I think that is an unfair amendment. It ties the worker down to the premises, while the employer is not required to show to anyone's satisfaction that it is necessary to keep the worker on the premises. If an employer can say that he can refuse the worker permission to leave, then that employer automatically vitiates whatever value there was in the Bill as it passed through Committee.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy not appreciate the fact that there are industries in respect of which it is not possible to let workers leave the premises?
Comment on this
Taking the gas gauge and the sugar gauge for argument, supposing it can be shown that it is necessary to prevent workers leaving premises where they are engaged watching these gauges, can the Minister not deal with that problem in respect of these or any other industries, where their presence is constantly necessary, by making an order in the terms that they cannot leave without permission?
Comment on this
No. The only order I could make would be one excluding that class or work from Section 26, but not from the operation of the section which relates to the rest of the work.
Comment on this
The Minister is not serious in that. What is to prevent him from leaving Section 27 (1) (e) as it stands and saying that on application from the employer, or after consultation with both sides, he may make a regulation providing that it is an offence on the part of the workers to leave or that they shall not be given permission to leave during the rest interval? What is to prevent the Minister saying, if certain representations are made to him that it is necessary to keep workers on the premises, that he has power to make a regulation? That regulation would be just as effective as any phraseology in this Bill. Is not that the simple way out? Would it not enable the Minister to get constant attention, where it is shown that constant attention is necessary, without at the same time giving the employer the wide and promiscuous authority that is given in the amendment, to refuse the worker permission to leave the premises during the rest interval?
Comment on this
It would be practically impossible for a Minister in such a matter to act contrary to the advice of an employer. If any employer came and said that in his opinion it was necessary that an employee should be on the premises, there would be a great risk if the Minister made an order contrary to that advice. He would be in a very curious position if he was wrong, or there was an accident involving loss of life or destruction of property, in consequence of that order. No Minister could take the responsibility of acting in that matter except he either had, on the one hand, first-class technical advice or, on the other hand, was prepared to accept the opinion of those interested in the matter as employers.
Comment on this
That is not a case for taking this excessive precaution. Surely the Minister can get the advice which he needs. The Minister has people on his staff qualified presumably, to judge of the merits of a claim of that kind made by an employer. If there was the remotest danger of anything going wrong on account of a worker leaving a machine, most sensible people would say that the machine must be watched at all cost, because of the possibility of some catastrophe occurring. But it is the patent case, where there is no justification for keeping a worker on the premises, that I want to safeguard against. I would not mind if the Minister used his discretion.
Comment on this
Why do you assume that an employer is going to keep a worker there when there is no reason for it?
Comment on this
Because he can do it and there is nothing to prevent his doing it unreasonably under the amendment.
Comment on this
Can you not take the power which we suggest you want to decide these difficult cases? The whole principle of this amendment is wrong. The language of it belongs to the Constitution (Amendment) Act and not to a Conditions of Employment Bill. The whole principle underlying it is vicious. The Minister is asked to decide the issues in a dispute. He can decide in favour of the employer where he is satisfied and, if he is not so satisfied, he can decide in favour of the worker. But he is legislatively too lazy to do that. He will not put a provision in the Bill saying he will examine the merits of the dispute. He says: "No, let the employer do it and do not trouble me with these administrative details."
Comment on this
In a matter of that kind the employer, whether the employer is a private individual or a company or the State, must be the person to determine what is required in the interests of the industry. The employer in this case need not necessarily be the bloated capitalist the Deputy is always attacking. The employer may be a Department of State.
Comment on this
The Deputy is talking about an employer who is so utterly unreasonable that, out of sheer vindictiveness, he is going to keep his workers there when there is no need.
Comment on this
I saw a case recently where an inspector of the Minister's Department had to prosecute an employer for failing to pay Trade Board rates.
Comment on this
You see that in the papers frequently. In that particular case, it was obviously to the advantage of the employer if he succeeded in getting away with it. What possible advantage is there to an employer to keep his workers on the premises doing nothing when there is no reason for it?
Comment on this
I think it is often advantageous to an employer to be on good terms with the trade union which represents his staff.
Comment on this
Very much to the advantage of the employer. That is why none of the dangers which the Deputy anticipates will arise.
Comment on this
We had recently to bring to the notice of the Minister cases of employers who tried to prevent workers belonging to a particular trade union and who spent their whole time creating friction between themselves and the union, instead of harmony. The Minister then comes along and says: "You can trust the employers implicitly; they would not do a thing like that."
Comment on this
The Minister should undertake to look into this matter and see whether it is possible to meet the proposal in the way suggested. It has been suggested from all sides of the House, except the Minister's own side, where there has been silence.
Comment on this
That benediction to the Minister will be quite good. This is clearly an employer's amendment put in unreasonably and the Minister falls for it. Anything the employers ask for is reasonable and you can trust them all.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton has been supported by Deputy Dillon and he says that is support from all sides of the House.
Comment on this
And my opinion is right. I make a final appeal to the Minister not to be unreasonable. His Bill has been fairly discussed and he ought to try to make it a good and reasonable Bill. Instead of that, he simply digs his heels in the ground and gets stubborn and infuriated. He says: "I have decided this and I have done so at the request of the employers; I think it is all right." He should try to meet this thing in a reasonable way.
Comment on this
I dislike very much the mentality behind the amendment, because there is no doubt that the language of the amendment and the mentality disclosed by the Minister in the discussion shows that it is a purely militaristic mentality, the mentality of the sergeant-major when dealing with a body of soldiers on parade. The Minister admitted—he was frank enough on that, but he has not been frank on other questions—that he had been approached by a body of employers and that it was as a result of his leg being pulled, either by the Saorstát Federation of Industries or the Chamber of Commerce, represented by Deputy Good, that he seeks to insert this amendment. The meaning of the amendment, and I am not attempting to exaggerate, is that he does not trust a certain type of workmen engaged at a certain type of machinery to carry out the spirit of an understanding as to when they should leave work and whether they will go out a minute before or remain out a minute after they are due to attend to certain machines.
Will the Minister tell the House frankly what kind of case has been put to him by the body of employers which convinced him that this amendment was necessary? Will he give the House the case made to him? It is the House he has to convince. The absent Deputies do not want to be convinced. They will stroll in and register their votes like putting a penny in the slot. Will the Minister give a case where any cantankerous or careless workman left a machine and allowed the machinery to be upset or any damage to be done to the factory? If he cannot give a case of that kind, he should at least trust the workmen who are going to come under the terms of the Bill that they will do in the future what they have done in the past. If there is a cantankerous or careless workman who is going to evade the spirit of a measure of this kind as between himself and his employer, surely the Minister knows well that there are disciplinary measures which can be taken by employers rather than by bringing in an amendment of this type.
Comment on this
The Minister thinks that any man who leaves his work a minute before or remains out a minute after the 15 minutes' rest must be compelled by the wording of this section and that as a result of that he is going to be a better workman than he otherwise would be. Legislation of this Public Safety Act type is not going to make better workers in the future than in the past. In any case, the Minister should give the House any cases put forward by Deputy Good or some unnamed body which persuaded the Minister to put in a section of this kind. I do not believe any sensible argument of any kind was put up to the Minister but that he was merely approached or written to by the Secretary of the Dublin Chamber of Commerce, or by some of those people who speak for these new industrial concerns set up in this country, and led to believe that the workmen who attend to machinery are a reckless and careless body of men and cannot be trusted, and that the only way to make them do work in an efficient and conscientious way is to bulldose them with a section which should be contained in a Public Safety Act.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin's speech convinces me that he does not know what we are talking about. There is nothing in this section which compels a worker to do anything. For the first time we are giving him a statutory right——
Comment on this
A statutory right to this rest, and we are limiting that right in a manner which is necessary in his own interest as a worker as well as in the interests of his associates. Why say we are compelling workers to do one thing or another? We are doing nothing of the kind. We are saying that these workers are being given from the date upon which this Bill becomes law this right to a rest on a statutory basis. Deputy Davin says that if a worker walks away from a machine he can be punished by an employer in some other way. He can at present, but after this Bill goes through, unless the amendment is adopted, the employer will commit an offence punishable by a fine if he attempts to interfere with a worker leaving his machine, no matter what may happen.
Comment on this
There is one way out, and that is to put the responsibility of deciding whether or not it is possible to leave the machine unattended for the rest interval upon those running the concern. That is being done at the present time, and it is being done when the workers have no statutory right to protect them. The fact is that the whole of that section is conferring, as of right and by law, upon workers certain limitations upon the conditions of their employment which a number of workers enjoy at the present time because of voluntary agreement between their employers and the representatives of the employees. In future that will be a matter of law, and it is necessary, in future, that one should have these statutory provisions ringed round with the necessary safeguards to ensure that the machinery of industrial production will work and that, in relation to machines which must run continuously and must run under proper supervision, it is not possible to allow these workers to leave the premises. It is not done at the present time and it has never been done.
Comment on this
This section has a marked difference from sections of a similar nature in another Bill. We were then dealing with continuous processes in industries and it seems that we are now dealing with industrial workers. There are types of workers engaged in continuous processes, such as railwaymen, who have to deal with the safety of the line. The men I am referring to might be, perhaps, 40 miles away at the time they are supposed to get this 15 minutes' rest. If a man of the type I am referring to is to get his 15 minutes' rest, is it intended that he must sit down under the eye of his employer or his foreman? What would be meant by "the premises" in a case of that kind? Should there not be some discretion with regard to this question of the 15 minutes? I hold that there ought to be some elasticity if you are going to give the worker 15 minutes. If you are going to give the man 15 minutes' rest, it should not be done under a rigorous code.
Comment on this
That is what is set down here, but my point is that he has to be under supervision in order to have that relaxation, and, if he is so many miles away, that would not be possible.
Comment on this
So far as Section 27 is concerned, no work shall be taken into account unless a licence is issued in regard to it.
Comment on this
I do not see the relevance of that point. You cannot grant a licence until it is shown that the employer has not contravened any condition contained in the licence authorising the licensed shift work concerned, under certain conditions.
Comment on this
The section we are discussing—Section 27—relates to licensing shift work which need not necessarily be carried on by shift work; but the issue of that licence cannot take place until the representatives of the workers have been taken into consultation.
Comment on this
I agree; but take the case of a railway company which wants to build a bridge which can only be built by a continuous shift process. My impression was that such work must be done and that, where the workers concerned are away some distance they would not be entitled to this 15 minutes' period of rest, unless they are under the eye of the foreman. I hold that the measure is not going to confer a benefit on such workers, if that is the case. The man wants a period of relaxation and rest and, according to this, it would appear that he has to walk a distance from his place of occupation. Who can construe what are the premises?
Comment on this
There is one question that has emerged from the discussion on this amendment and on the previous amendment on the same section, and that is that the amendment, apparently, is designed to meet certain exigencies in certain industries. The cases of sugar cookers and the watchers of gauges in gas companies have been mentioned. When I saw the Minister and Deputy Norton billing and cooing on this matter, I thought there was some agreement, but it seems to me that, in order to avoid further divisions, I should like to point out that there are relatively very few things to decide. Would it not be better, in view of that fact, to legislate for the few occupations to which this amendment would apply— which are, relatively, very few, in relation to other occupations for which the Minister caters. I suggest that the Minister should agree to add, at the end of the section, some such words as "save and except these occupations and trades"—and then to name the cases to which the section should or should not apply. I suggest that this is a way out of the difficulty. The Minister has been good enough, on many occasions, to consider the views put forward by members of all Parties and I hope that, in the same spirit, in this case he will give this suggestion the same consideration. I think that very good suggestions were put forward by Deputy Norton and other members of the Labour Party. While there is so much good in the Bill I do not want to see a whole lot of controversy over some sections, and I think some via media might be arrived at whereby these difficulties might be got over. I know that the Minister has become rattled by the rather schoolmasterly style in which Deputy Norton proceeded to lecture him and I am sure it is because of that that we cannot now proceed in the peaceful and helpful attitude under which we were previously discussing the Bill. I put it to the Minister that he should accept this qualification to his amendment—“save and except the following occupations or industries”—which could be set out.
Comment on this
I do not think that is a practical suggestion. The determination must be left to the employer. The whole thing we are dealing with here is a statutory obligation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 58:—
In page 12, Section 29, line 45, before the word "grant" to insert the words "after consultation with representatives of employers interested in the relevant form of industrial work and with representatives of workers so interested."
This merely provides for a consultation with the representatives of the employers and the representatives of the workers.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 59:—
In page 12, at the end of Section 30, to add a new sub-section as follows:—
Nothing contained in a shift-work licence granted in accordance with the provisions of this Act shall operate so as to disturb any agreement either expressed or implied relating to the hours of work, rates of pay or conditions of employment subsisting between the person to whom such licence is granted and the workers employed by such person.
This amendment was discussed on the first Committee Stage. I think it is an eminently reasonable amendment. It does not prevent the person obtaining a shift-work licence and it will not prevent the working under a shift-work licence. All it does is to endeavour to ensure that shift work licences cannot be issued in such a way as to constitute an infraction of agreements relating to hours of work, rates of pay or conditions of employment. On the first Committee Stage the Minister undertook to look into this amendment.
Comment on this
This amendment cannot be accepted. The granting of a shift-work licence will not or need not affect the rates of pay. There is nothing in the Bill which suggests that these should be affected. But it will almost certainly affect the hours of work and the conditions of employment. If the industry is one that for any purpose is to be transformed into a shift-work industry then there are going to be alterations in the hours of work, and so on. These are matters that will have to be considered before the licence is issued and it is to provide that the representatives of the workers shall have ample opportunities of putting forward their case that I moved a previous amendment. A shift-work licence will alter the hours of work. It will actually increase the hours. Workers under the Bill as it stands may be worked for longer hours than in the case of an industry which can only be divided into a certain number of shifts. There may be variation of the working hours if a man is given a shift-work licence. We cannot provide automatically that there will be no alteration of the hours. There may be alterations upwards or downwards but all these matters will be taken into consideration before the licence is issued.
Comment on this
It will not do so. The shift-work licence may upset existing agreements where it results in improvements in the conditions of work. But so far as this particular question of a licence for shift work is concerned, there is no doubt that if an industry which has been working on the day system is transformed into a shift-work industry, there is going to be variation in the existing agreements whether that is done voluntarily or under licence. What we are providing for is that a change-over cannot be effected unless the licence is issued and the licence will be issued only after all the parties are consulted. If such a change takes place whatever alterations are involved in the conditions of employment will be known beforehand. It is after that knowledge that conditions in the issuing of the licence will be laid down.
Comment on this
Somebody comes along to make application for a licence for shift work, and if shift work is to be done the workers' representative will have to admit that that work must be done and the licence must be issued by the Minister. If he has regard to reason and commonsense, the conditions laid down in this Bill will have to apply——
Comment on this
No. Any conditions at all can be laid down. The Bill says "subject to such conditions as the Minister may think fit to impose and to insert in such licence."
Comment on this
In amendment No. 82 the Minister is cutting across this by the proposed sub-section (1) (d) which gives power to except industrial work. The workers' representatives will not have power to vary that unless they appear unreasonable.
Comment on this
The Minister can lay down whatever conditions are considered necessary. These can be imposed on the licence.
Comment on this
If there is an agreement in existence between the workers and employers should not that subsist after the granting of the licence?
Comment on this
I am not so sure that if this section stands as it is that the Minister will not change the conditions after hearing the employers.
Comment on this
If an agreement is made between them and they have not waived the conditions already arrived at, what will prevail?
Comment on this
My answer is that this Government has brought in this Bill and the Bill is designed to improve conditions of employment. The Deputy seems to think that the object of the Government is to make the conditions worse.
Comment on this
True, the Bill is being brought in by this Government. But this Government, no more than the last, has no title deeds to these benches.
Comment on this
I think it would be very much better if the Minister would be reasonable about this and make sure that, in granting a licence, there is no loophole left for tearing up an existing agreement between employers and the representatives of the workers.
Comment on this
The existing agreement may be a bad agreement, and perhaps the best thing that could be done with it would be to tear it up.
Comment on this
I would like to hear the workers on that. Let the workers, if necessary, make representations to have an agreement varied. But surely the Minister does not want to grant a shift work licence merely for the purpose of tearing up a bad agreement. A shift work licence can be granted for other reasons, but I hope he is not going to grant one so that he can tear up a bad agreement.
Comment on this
Of course not. I think the Minister should give some assurance that it is not intended to interfere with existing agreements merely because he gets an application for a licence.
Comment on this
If the Deputy says that no such licence must alter the conditions of employment or hours of work, then it is not possible to do that because the licence may alter the conditions of employment and hours of work.
Comment on this
It may result in longer hours of work for the period during which the licence operates.
Comment on this
Under Section 27, if workers who are at present working a 48-hour week have, for any reason, to work on shift work and that a three-shift system is operated, a 56-hour week may have to be worked for a period.
Comment on this
No. Under paragraph (d) the average numbers of hours worked may not exceed 48. That may be in the existing agreement that the Deputy has talked about. This is to permit of a longer week than a 48-hour week to deal with the changes that may have to be made in existing agreements in order to meet the change-over. I cannot see what danger the Deputy apprehends in view of the fact that, presumably, both sides will have to agree to the change before it can be effected.
Comment on this
There is no compulsion on an employer to keep a factory open or on a worker to work.
Comment on this
There is the obvious illustration for this that a four-shift arrangement has been put into operation in certain cases. Obviously, if a four-shift system is going to be worked, then of course old-fashioned conditions will have to be readjusted.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 60:—
In page 13, Section 31 (1), in line 4, to delete the word "to" and in line 5, before the word "commence" to insert the words "if a woman, to".
The effect of this amendment is to keep in this limitation upon the commencing hour of work only in so far as it concerns women workers. I do not think there is any necessity to have the limitation in respect of male workers. I think women should not commence work before 8 a.m. If we had such a limitation there would have to be a large number of exemptions from it because, in respect of a certain class of work those engaged on it must commence before that hour, and they may prefer to maintain the practice of starting earlier and finishing earlier. So far as women are concerned, however, the International Convention concerning the employment of women at night does put this limitation on their commencing hour, and it is necessary to preserve that in order to conform to the Convention. It is not necessary to maintain that restriction in so far as it affects men.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 61:—
In page 13, Section 31 (1), line 7, before the word "to" to insert the words "whether a man or a woman."
This is consequential.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say what is the effect of clause 3 of paragraph (b) of sub-section (3) of Section 31, which reads:
The time on any ordinary working day when such adult worker has completed nine hours' work on that day.
Would travelling time be regarded as time worked for the purpose of computing what time a worker had worked? I take it that this section is intended to cover in future all ordinary employment that has not been specially exempted, and while 48 hours is quite long enough, at the same time I think that these working hours for any one day are not sufficiently flexible. On the Committee Stage of the Bill instanced the case of a worker who had to catch the mail train in the morning. I agree that under paragraph (a) a male worker can now catch the mail train in the morning, but at the same time there are instances in which, on a particular day, there would be a very long period of travelling to and from, and, possibly, a very short period of work. For the sake of argument, let us say that there might be six hours spent travelling to and six hours travelling back again, with two hours of work. Would the Minister say how that is to be accomplished in a single day? I do not suppose the Minister wants to legislate for every case of an employer who has a very small and highly skilled job in which case the work has to be done a very long way from his base. Would the Minister say what is to happen at 8 p.m. if the workman has not returned home? Has he to stop a motor car or a train to get out?
Comment on this
I am willing to answer any reasonable questions the Deputy puts, but in case his speech should be regarded as a precedent, I suggest to the Chair that it is out of order.
Comment on this
Work, where mentioned in the section, is industrial work as defined in Section 3. Travelling in a train is not industrial work.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 62:—
In pages 13 and 14, to delete Section 32, lines 21 to 58 inclusive, page 13, and lines 1 to 5 inclusive, page 14.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 62, 63, 69, 70, 72 and 73 are interrelated. These are proposals dealing with the uncontrolled or additional permitted overtime in certain cases. These new proposals involve the deletion of two sections to which sections amendments have been moved. Obviously, if the sections are deleted the amendments may not be moved. I suggest that the question of overtime be discussed on amendment No. 62, and if that section is deleted the other consequences follow.
Comment on this
In connection with this amendment, during the discussion on the Committee Stage I indicated that it was my intention to propose a general recasting of the provisions of the Bill relating to overtime. Arising out of that statement, I think there was practically no discussion of this section in Committee. The original proposals, as set out in Section 32, were framed for the purpose of keeping our legislation in conformity with the international convention. The international convention provided for the control of overtime working by regulation. We were anxious to keep as close as we could to the convention but we found, when we went into the matter in great detail, that it was undesirable to do so in so far as the making of regulations was going to create considerable difficulty and, therefore, we decided to depart from the terms of the convention and bring forward our own proposals for dealing with overtime. These proposals are set out in amendments Nos. 69 and 73.
The proposals are practically these. We propose to fix a certain percentage of normal working which can be worked by way of overtime without seeking specific sanction for the doing of it. That is called for the purpose of identification in these amendments "uncontrolled overtime." It is proposed to set out how many hours in the day or how many hours in the week may be worked at overtime, automatically, at the discretion of the employer, subject to the payment of overtime wages and also to provide for the granting of permission in special cases, after due application has been made and due consideration has been given to the matter, to work in excess of the uncontrolled overtime while at the same time taking power by regulation to abolish uncontrolled overtime or to limit uncontrolled overtime in any particular trade. The position, therefore is, that when the Bill becomes law there will be power to work overtime as set out in amendment No. 69—a power, however, which may be limited by regulations made subsequently, after consultation with the representatives of employers and employees in any particular trade, or which may be abolished in relation to that particular trade. On the other hand, there will be power in exceptional cases to extend the amount of overtime work. That is in my opinion the most satisfactory way of meeting this particular problem.
There may be some question as to the amount of uncontrolled overtime that may be worked. The proposal in the Bill is, roughly, 10 per cent. of the normal working time, that is with certain outside limits with respect to each day, each week or the whole year, but having regard to the fact that that section is going to have general application to all industries, irrespective of circumstances, and that in some industries the working of overtime, and even a considerable amount of overtime is almost inevitable at certain times of the year, I think it is advisable to leave that general percentage there, seeing that we have power, if the concession should be abused, to limit it by regulation after these consultations and also having advertence to the fact that if it is necessary in particular cases of an exceptional kind, to work longer than the overtime permitted in the uncontrolled overtime section, we can issue a permit for that purpose also. It is the system which will create least administrative difficulties and impose least hardship on either workers or employers in the matter of overtime.
So far as we are concerned, we wish to discourage the working of overtime as a regular policy and if the proposals here regarding uncontrolled time in relation to any industry, result in overtime being worked regularly, when an increase in normal staffs should be effected, then I would propose to use the powers which we are taking to limit the uncontrolled overtime in such cases, or even if necessary to abolish it altogether, permanently or temporarily. It is desirable that it should be known that I intend these powers to be used for the purpose of discouraging and preventing the working of overtime except in exceptional circumstances or in relation to such industries where, because of the seasonal nature of the business to be done, overtime working cannot be avoided.
Comment on this
I should like to understand further the Minister's proposals on the question of overtime, both uncontrolled overtime and the overtime which might be worked after the period of uncontrolled overtime had been exceeded. I think most people would desire that a pretty ruthless measure should be adopted to eliminate the evil of some persons working overtime while others are unable to find any employment whatsoever. Any powers which the Minister takes in the second portion of amendment No. 69 to intervene in the case of industries which are working overtime regularly, or which are abusing the uncontrolled overtime provisions of the amendment, will, I think, have the hearty support of everybody who desires to eliminate the evil of overtime in any shape or form so long as or in cases where it is possible to grapple effectively with that evil. I think, however, that in amendment No. 69 the amount of uncontrolled overtime which the Minister will permit to be worked without any licence or any control is somewhat excessive. Two hours a day may not be very much in an emergency. Conceivably 240 hours in a year, which is about 10 per cent. of the normal year's working, may not be excessive, but 12 hours in a week is excessive. It is another day and a half in the week. Twelve hours in the week is too long to permit as uncontrolled overtime because in that trade while you are giving an average of 10 per cent. in respect of the whole year, you are running up 20 per cent. in respect of the week. I think 20 per cent. is too high in respect to a particular week. If that is true, as I believe it is, in respect to sub-section (a) of the amendment, it is increasingly true in respect to young persons who are to be permitted ten hours' overtime in any week—that is 25 per cent. of the normal working week.
Comment on this
I agree, but it could go on unchecked under the first portion of this amendment until 200 hours in the year had been reached, and unless the case were then brought to the notice of the Minister and he put in operation the machinery provided in the second portion of the amendment. I would suggest to the Minister that he ought to reduce the 12 hours in the week. I am not complaining about the general 10 per cent. If he must have overtime it is not an unreasonable percentage, though we would like to eliminate the evil as far as possible. Two hours in a day are not, in an emergency, a great evil either, although one would like to be able to eliminate that completely. But running overtime for a young person for ten hours a week, which represents 25 per cent. of a normal day, is, in my opinion, excessive and it infringes the overriding average of 10 per cent. for the whole year. You might conceivably, under this amendment, and in perfect conformity with the amendment, have the case where an adult worker might work the normal 48 hours and another 12 hours, making a total of 60 hours a week, and he might do that until such time as the 240 hours had been reached for the year, and then they might be passed on to some other worker in the same employment. This overtime may not apply to all workers at the same time. By a series of relays, employing different workers on overtime, considerable abuse might be possible, although there might be no infraction of the amendment. I think the Minister should consider this matter with the object of reducing the amount of uncontrolled weekly overtime. In the case of the adult worker and the young person it is 25 per cent., whereas the Minister is aiming at a national average of 10 per cent. A good case can be made for the reduction of overtime in a week, but a specially strong case can be made in the case of young persons.
Comment on this
I do not know that there is much objection to having 12 hours in the week. If you permit two hours in the day it is conceivable that overtime might be worked for the whole week, making a total of 12 hours. One of the difficulties in this matter is, of course, that it is very frequently the case that the worker as well as the employer wishes the overtime to be worked. That is the evil of it and that is why it is necessary to have limitations imposed, otherwise the workers would probably never complain about being asked to work overtime, particularly when they are secured by law in future in regard to the overtime rate. The question is what is the wisest allowance to make that will apply to all industrial concerns. We must have some general provision and that is what is set out in amendment No. 69. If that general provision is too great, having regard to the circumstances of particular industries, we can reduce it. If it is not sufficient to deal with the circumstances of other industries, it can be extended under the proposed new section, amendment No. 73. I do not think there will be many cases where it will be necessary to extend it, except to deal with entirely abnormal circumstances which might necessitate an abnormal amount of work in some trade for a limited period, perhaps a period that might never recur.
For ordinary overtime work so as to allow employers that liberty of action which is essential to enable work to be completed and occasional rush orders to be met and contracts to be completed on time, the 10 per cent. margin is, I think, reasonable enough, provided the yearly 10 per cent. can be made a larger percentage for particular periods where extra work has to be done. Ten per cent. of a 48 hour week, 4½ hours, would be of very little advantage if that was all the overtime that could be worked. It is necessary to allow a much higher percentage in the week, knowing, however, that as regards each week in which the full permitted overtime is worked, each such week brings earlier the period in which no overtime can be worked. Employers will, on the whole, I think, endeavour to economise on uncontrolled overtime. It is only rarely that there is an inducement to an employer to arrange overtime. In the majority of trades in which overtime is worked occasionally there is no advantage to the employer except in so far as he completes a contract or avoids penalties by getting the work done in the time arranged. It is only rarely the economy of capital equipment which the working of overtime permits is of sufficient advantage to the employer to offset the higher rate of wages. In these circumstances, I do not think the power of uncontrolled overtime will be used unreasonably. If it should be, we have adequate powers under sub-section 2 of the proposed new section to limit it.
Comment on this
I would not think so. It is not unusual in certain industries to do two hours each day.
Comment on this
There is also a point in connection with the Christmas trade, for instance. At that period of the year traders have to deal with perishable goods. There is a rush coming up to Christmas time and people place orders at the last moment. Following the Christmas period there is a lull, in which time the workers get a rest.
Comment on this
It ought not to be more than six. Ten hours would be altogether too high for young persons.
Comment on this
It is enough for them, and the remuneration they get is almost negligible. It would be better for them if they get recreation.
Comment on this
Deputy Beckett referred to the Christmas season. I know that last year and the previous year certain people engaged in the confectionery trade were working overtime in order to deal with the particular rush of business at that time, and they worked that overtime even though they were being prosecuted for it and they paid the fines that were imposed upon them on prosecution. They could not avoid working overtime if their contracts were to be completed. That circumstance will arise in such industries from time to time almost inevitably. We should try to prevent it and make these employers plan their activities and operations in a way which will prevent unusual overtime having to be worked. But when the circumstances do arise, there must be power for the particular week or two in which the abnormal circumstances arise to deal with them. I do not think ten or 12 hours in a week, uncontrolled overtime, is unduly high. If it should prove to be, we have power to reduce it. For a general overriding limit applying to all industries, I think it is safe enough.
Comment on this
The Minister has power to reduce the weekly overtime in that case, and he has other powers under amendment No. 73.
Comment on this
If we make a reduction in sub-section (2) of amendment No. 69, that alters the uncontrolled overtime generally. In so far as amendment No. 73 is concerned, we are giving a permit limiting the time to an individual concerned to work permitted overtime for the period of the permit. But the permit has not general application; it has application only to the firm that gets the permit.
Comment on this
My point is that if the Minister does reduce the weekly period of overtime provided in amendment No. 69, he can, if any firm represents special difficulties to him, grant that firm a permit under amendment No. 73. True, it has only application to a particular firm, but if a particular firm feels that there is an emergency in the matter of staff which requires to be met by permitted overtime, there is not very much difficulty in making an application for a permit, and still the Minister would be maintaining the reasonable maximum overtime in amendment No. 69. The Minister has power in amendment No. 73 on a good case being shown to allow the maximum to go up to ten or 12 hours. Under amendment No. 69, the difficult case could then be provided for.
Comment on this
But by the time the employer makes the application to the Minister, the occasion for overtime may have passed.
Comment on this
It appears to me that there might be a compromise as between Deputy Norton and the Minister. Deputy Norton's main point, I take it, is that if ten hours a week overtime is worked by a young person and a further ten hours period in the next week, it puts an undue strain on the constitution of a young person. If the Minister put in the ten hours period in the first week and then said that for the second week, while working consecutively, not more than six hours overtime or something of the kind were to be worked, it might bring Deputy Norton and himself together.
Comment on this
There could be full overtime for ten weeks and it would then stop for the rest of the year.
Comment on this
I do not think the circumstances are likely to arise in which these powers will be considerably abused. I said earlier that employers will be influenced by self interest in the majority of cases and it is very rarely in the interests of an employer to work overtime. It is in the interests of the worker. In these matters, it is the worker who wants to work because of the additional earnings he gets; the employer usually only does it when he has to, and he does it knowing that his costs of production arc going to be increased merely to enable him to fulfil a contract.
Comment on this
Of course, the employer docs not want overtime because he is then paying higher rates, but what struck me about Deputy Norton's argument is that a young person may be anxious, and probably always very anxious, to get overtime and possibly a young person working for two consecutive weeks at overtime may be impairing his health. For that reason, I thought a compromise might be reached between the Minister and Deputy Norton, in the shape of a provision that he or she should not be allowed to work the maximum overtime for two consecutive weeks.
Comment on this
I think the Minister should look into the matter. The maximum in the week is too high. I am not complaining about the annual or the daily average.
Comment on this
I do not know that the case is so serious in view of the fact that the maximum working week of the juvenile has been decreased to 40 hours, and at the very most it is a 50-hour week, even with full overtime being worked.
Comment on this
I think that it is necessary to allow an exceptional amount of work to be done at exceptional periods.
Comment on this
Only where it is possible to foresee well in advance that the circumstances are going to arise.
Comment on this
It is not possible to apply in advance. That is my objection. We get an order suddenly; some circumstance has arisen which entails working overtime. If you have to apply to the Minister, as the Deputy knows, it will take some considerable time for the Minister to have the matter inquired into and get his assent.
Comment on this
I think that the case in respect to seasonal trades would probably be met if you inserted a clause setting out that the maximum overtime for a juvenile was not to be worked for longer than three consecutive weeks.
Comment on this
It would have to be more than two weeks, I think. If you take the seasonal trades, like the confectionery trades, one week would not be much use.
Comment on this
One week would not be any use and I doubt if two weeks would be sufficient but three weeks would probably meet all the cases.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Norton is right in saying that there ought not to be maximum overtime over a number of weeks indefinitely, one after another, but I think you could meet the case by saying that it should not be worked for more than three consecutive weeks.
Comment on this
I will look into that but I am not so sure that it is necessary to provide it in the Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 64:—
In page 14, Section 33 (1), line 12, to delete the word "to".
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:—
In page 14, Section 34 (1), line 32, after the word "persons" to insert the words "or young persons who have attained a specified age."
This is, I think, an improved revision in relation to Section 34. Section 34 gives the Minister power to authorise young persons, who are employed as assistants to adult workers, and without whose assistance those adult workers could not carry on their work, to be regarded as adult workers for the purpose of the maximum working week. It is proposed to amend the section so that the powers of the Minister can be exercised, not merely in relation to young persons as a class, but in relation to young persons who have attained a specific age. Thus, the Minister could limit a permit to young persons between the ages of 17 and 18 or the ages of 16 and 18 years instead of merely to young persons generally.
Comment on this
I move amendments Nos. 66 and 67:—
In page 14, Section 34 (2), line 36, to delete the words "persons who in his opinion are representative", and substitute the word "representatives".
In page 14, Section 34 (2), line 38, to delete the words "persons who in his opinion are representative", and substitute the word "representatives".
These are consequential.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 68:—
In page 14, to add at the end of Section 34 (2) the following words "and in any event no such regulation shall have effect in respect of any industrial undertaking if the number of young persons employed to do industrial work in such undertaking bears to the number of other workers so employed in such undertaking a proportion greater than 20 per cent."
The object of this amendment is to deal with the position which is created where the Minister, on being satisfied that young persons are necessary as assistants to adult workers and that the work could not proceed without their being employed, may by Order make regulations, in accordance with the section, directing that young persons while employed on such form of industrial work shall be deemed to be adult workers for the purposes of the Act. There may be cases where it is necessary to say that a certain kind of operation which is being done by adult workers and on which a young person is assisting cannot effectively be done if the young person ceased employment through the operation of the provisions of Section 33.
One of the objects of this Bill is to endeavour to restrict the number of young persons in industry and to get a better balance as between men and women and youths and adults and, while I think some case can be made for examining a case where the fact that a young person left off work earlier than the adult might cause inconvenience and dislocation, I think that firms who are given facilities to retain young workers in such circumstances ought to be able to show that they are not employing a predominantly large number of young workers. In order to qualify for whatever benefits they will get under Section 34, they ought to be able to convince the Minister that all their workers, or a substantial number of them, are not. in the category of young workers.
An amendment, therefore, which limited the benefits of Section 34 to such firms as employed a substantial proportion of adult workers would, I think, encourage the employment of adult workers and, at the same time, eliminate the difficulties which will inevitably be caused where applications under this section are received from firms who employ a very substantial number of young workers. In order to qualify for benefits under Section 34, the firm should be able to show that it has no greater proportion of young workers than one to five. If it has one to ten, it should be treated very differently from a firm which has only one to five. Under the section as it stands, it is possible for a firm employing a very large number of young workers to make this application and present the Minister with difficulty in refusing it, whereas the amendment, if accepted, would recognise the special difficulties in the case of a firm which had young workers in no greater proportion than one to five. I think the Minister should examine that point.
Comment on this
I do not think that this amendment should be accepted. I dislike Very much inserting limiting provisions of this kind when nobody knows precisely what the effect of them will be. I could not say straight off what the effect of the amendment would be in relation to particular industries. I can imagine circumstances in which it might be desirable to grant the concession contemplated by Section 34 in a case in which the percentage of young workers to adult workers was higher than 20—say 25 per cent. That might be the case where, for every three adults there was a young worker employed, the employment of that young worker being necessary to enable the work of the adults to proceed. What we provide is that each individual case be examined by the Minister on its merits. Before he makes any decision he must consult the interested parties—representatives of the employers in the industry concerned and representatives of the workers—and obtain their views. It is only after hearing their views and considering the application on its merits that he will make his decision. I think that it is much better to leave the matter like that than to impose in the statute an overriding limitation on the Minister's powers when you cannot say exactly how the imposition of that overriding limitation will work out in practice.