Committee on Finance. - Conditions of Employment Bill, 1935—Recommittal.
Contributions 167–335 of 335. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 13 of 1935 ›
The principle of the amendment is, I think, important if we are going to have, as, unfortunately, we have to-day, a large number of industries employing a considerable number of juveniles. It would be most unfair if they were to introduce one or two adult workers and say that it was necessary to have all these young persons in order to feed with work the couple of adult workers. Instead of working for 40 hours, the employers may say that they will make application to have these juveniles deemed adult workers and work them up to 48 hours. The excuse will be that the juveniles are necessary to the work of the adults and the employment of a couple of adults will bring the employer within the scope of this section. I think that that would be most unfair. The Minister may say that he objects to the proportion of one to five, but he should fix some proportion. Otherwise, this section may be used as an excuse by firms employing a few adults and a large number of juveniles for extending the hours of work of the juveniles.
Comment on this
Another question arises on this amendment. There is increasing difficulty in finding employment for young persons in the City of Dublin. I happen to be connected with the juvenile department of the labour exchange, and we have some 6,000 applications every year from juveniles. We have an increasing difficulty in finding employment for them. In fact, we cannot find employment for half the number who apply. If we are to have a large number of young persons out of employment, we shall have difficulties in other connections. Tradesmen have told me, over and over again, that one of the reasons why Dublin is so expensive for men with large families is that they cannot get employment for the members of their families, as they can in industrial centres. If employment cannot be obtained for the young people, naturally it is more expensive for the head of the family to support them. That aspect of the question does not, I am afraid, get the consideration in the Dáil that it deserves. On all sides, at present, we find young persons unemployed. We have difficulties of all sorts arising out of that unemployment. That is a question which will become very serious in the near future. I ask the Minister to be very careful as to what he does in the way of restricting employment for young persons for the reasons I have given.
Comment on this
I should like to know from the Minister what the unit is for which the regulations are to be made. Is the unit to be a particular industry or a particular firm engaged in an industry? If it is to be an industry, it seems to me that it would be very difficult to decide the number of persons—juveniles or others—to be engaged in that industry. One firm engaged in the industry might have a certain proportion of juveniles and another might have a different proportion. I should like the Minister to make plain what the unit will be.
Comment on this
The unit will be forms of industrial work. For practical purposes, that means industries. It will not apply to individual concerns. We may exempt, say, iron foundries, flour mills, or some other class of industry but, once the regulation is made, it will apply to everybody engaged in the industry.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 69:—
In page 15, before Section 35, to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) Subject to the provisions of this section and subject also to the restrictions imposed by this Act on the employment of women and young persons at night but notwithstanding any other provision of this Act, an employer may employ a worker to do industrial work in an industrial undertaking for a longer period on any particular day than the period permitted in that behalf by this Act (other than this section), but subject to the limitation that the length of time by which such longer period exceeds the said period so permitted as aforesaid shall not exceed:—
(a) in respect of any adult worker, two hours on any day, or 12 hours in any week, or 240 hours in any year, or
(b) in respect of any young person, two hours on any ordinary day or one hour on any short day, or 10 hours in any week, or 200 hours in any year.
(2) The Minister may at any time if he thinks fit by order, made after consultation with representatives of employers interested in the relevant form of industrial work and with representatives of workers so interested, make regulations for either or both of the following purposes, that is to say:—
(a) prohibiting the employment, under the next preceding sub-section of this section, of workers or any specified class or classes of workers to do any particular form of industrial work in an industrial undertaking for a longer period than the period permitted by this Act (other than this section);
(b) reducing the length of time during which workers or any specified class or classes of workers, may, by virtue of the next preceding sub-section of this section, be employed to do any particular form of industrial work in an industrial undertaking in excess of the period permitted by this Act (other than this section).
(3) Whenever and so long as regulations made under the next preceding sub-section of this section are in force, sub-section (1) of this section shall have effect subject to such regulations.
This matter has been discussed on No. 62.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 70:—
In page 15, to delete Section 35, lines 1 to 41 inclusive.
This is a consequential amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 73:—
In page 15, before Section 36, to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) The Minister may, if and whenever he so thinks fit on the application in accordance with this section of an employer who employs workers to do industrial work in an industrial undertaking, grant to such employer a permit in writing to employ, during a specified period beginning not less than seven days after the date of such application, workers or any specified class or classes of workers to do industrial work in the said industrial undertaking for a specified longer period on each day than the period permitted in that behalf by this Act.
(2) The Minister may attach to the permission granted by a permit under this section such conditions as he shall think proper and shall specify in such permit.
(3) The Minister may at any time revoke a permit granted by him under this section.
(4) Whenever a permit has been granted under this section to an employer it shall be lawful for such employer, subject to any revocation of such permit, to employ workers in accordance with such permit notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Act.
This is governed by a previous decision.
Comment on this
The power there is really power to deal with what I might describe as emergency circumstances. The circumstances of each particular case would have to be considered on their merits before a permit is given.
Comment on this
I take it that it is intended only for an emergency, and is not intended to regularise the employment of persons on overtime for three or six months?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 74:—
In page 16, before Section 37, to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) It shall not be lawful for an employer to employ a worker to do any form of industrial work on any day on which such worker has done any form of industrial work for another employer, except where the aggregate of the periods for which such worker does industrial work for each of such employers respectively on that day does not exceed the period (exclusive of overtime) for which such worker could lawfully be employed to do industrial work for one employer on that day.
(2) Whenever an employer employs a worker in contravention of this section, such employer shall be guilty of an offence under this section, and such worker shall also be guilty of an offence under this section.
On the Committee Stage, I think it was fairly generally suggested from all parts of the House that it should not be lawful for an employer to employ a worker to do any form of industrial work on a day on which that worker had done industrial work for another employer in circumstances which would bring the total amount of the work done in excess of the total amount permitted by the Bill, and that it should be made an offence on the part of the worker or the employer thus to exceed that limit.
Comment on this
There is just one point which I would like to raise, just merely in regard to the drafting of sub-section (2). It says here:
Whenever an employer employs a worker in contravention of this section
Should not that be:
Where an employer knowingly employs a worker....?
Comment on this
It is very difficult for an employer always to know whether the man he is employing has been working for somebody else earlier on that same day. Suppose the employer is told "I have not worked for anybody else to-day" and on that undertaking the employer gives him employment. As the section stands the employer will be liable. It is entirely against the general principle of the law that a man should be deemed to commit an offence unless he has had an opportunity of really knowing it. I suggest to the Minister that he would meet that point by putting in the word "knowingly".
Comment on this
The putting in of that word "knowingly" would place upon the Minister, or his officers concerned, the obligation of proving that it was done knowingly. The plea that it was done unknowingly would undoubtedly be the grounds for the defence. It would be a very difficult matter to prove that it was done knowingly, as distinct from proving that it was done.
Comment on this
Could not the Minister meet it to some extent by saying something to the effect "Unless the employer shows that he did not know," thus putting the onus on the employer? It does not appear to be equitable to make the employer absolutely responsible in a case like this where he himself might have been deceived. I am sure the intention is that a man shall not be deemed to have committed an offence unless he has in fact broken the law knowingly?
Comment on this
It is really a matter of dealing with the evidence. If the Minister will tell the House that he will consider what suitable alteration might be made in the wording in order to meet that point I shall be perfectly satisfied. I do not like the idea that a man who acted in perfect innocence should discover that he has committed an offence.
Comment on this
In those days it is impossible for an employer legally to employ a man for portion of a day unless he provides for insurance and all those things. I take it that what the Minister wants to ensure is that a tradesman who has been working for a legitimate employer during the day-time should be prevented from doing work for other people at night?
Comment on this
The clause is intended to prevent him being employed by persons who are not in any way entitled to employ him; who do not cover him for unemployment insurance, or do not fully cover him for national health insurance. They merely call him in as a handy man.
Comment on this
That is undoubtedly the case. As Deputies who were present at the discussion on the Committee Stage are aware, I am not very enthusiastic about this provision, because I see considerable difficulties in its enforcement. There is apparently a general opinion that the power should be there to prevent this type of employment, which interferes with the normal working of certain businesses. Probably the building trade, the motor-repairing trade, and one or two others, are particularly affected. The intention is to prevent a worker who has been employed during the day from doing for a private employer at night work which would ordinarily be done by his day-time employer in the ordinary commercial way. There is a point, undoubtedly, in what Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney has said. I do not know how we can meet that point, but I will consider the matter.
Comment on this
Take Deputy Beckett's case. Suppose a man comes to the employer and says: "I am unemployed. Will you give me this job?" and he is given the job. Now, if he is in fact out of work, the man who employs him has committed no offence; if in fact he has been working that day the man who employs him will, under this section have committed an offence. If he has genuinely deceived the person who gives him work it seems to me to be rather hard that the person whom he has deceived should be convicted. However, if the Minister will think the matter over I will be satisfied.
Comment on this
I should be glad if the Minister would think it over in such a way as not to let outside the scope of the Act the person who takes employment after his ordinary day's work.
Comment on this
So far as the worker is concerned there is no difficulty. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's point is that the employer may not know he is breaking the law.
Comment on this
There is a very easy test for anybody who knows anything about the conditions under which employment may be given. He has simply to ask: "Where is your card?" If the man has not got his card, it is obvious that he is in employment; the man who is put off gets his stamped card.
Comment on this
There is another test which is equally efficacious, and which I think would apply in 90 per cent. of those cases. The worker should be asked: "Are you prepared to come back and finish the job to-morrow during the normal working hours?" To my mind that is the acid test.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 75:—
In page 16, Section 37 (2), line 14, after the word "section" to add the words "and such young person shall also be guilty of an offence under this section."
This is similar to a number of amendments which we have inserted in the Bill. It puts on the worker as well as on the employer the obligation of observing those provisions.
Comment on this
As regards prohibition, would there be an offence on the part of the employee? Is that provided for in all similar sections?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 76:—
In page 16, Section 38 (1), line 15, to delete the word "other" and after the word "Act" to insert the words "other than the provision empowering the Minister to make exclusion regulations."
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 77:—
In page 16, Section 39 (1), line 25, to delete the word "other" and after the word "Act" to insert the words "other than the provision empowering the Minister to make exclusion regulations."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 78:—
In page 17, Section 40 (1), line 4, to delete the word "one" and substitute the words "half an."
I indicated on the Committee Stage that I intended to move this amendment. As the Bill stands it provides for a luncheon interval of one hour. It was pointed out that that might be a hardship on workers in certain places, working some distance from their homes, where it would not be convenient for them to go home, where they took luncheon on or convenient to the job, and that they would prefer to have a shorter luncheon interval. Consequently it is desirable, while there should be a statutory obligation to give time for luncheon, to insert the words in the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 79:—
In page 17, Section 40 (2), line 7, after the word "overtime" to insert the words "for more than one and one-half hours."
This is somewhat similar. The section provides for an interval before working overtime. It was pointed out that if the amount of overtime to be worked was only one hour, or half an hour, the worker might prefer to go right through and then go home in comfort for a meal. The provision is that the section will not operate unless one and a half hours' overtime has to be worked.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 80:—
In page 17, before Section 40 (5), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
(5) Every worker employed on industrial work who is present on the premises of his employer while industrial work is being done on such premises shall, unless he is so present on such premises in contravention of the orders of such employer, be deemed for the purposes of this section to be present on such premises for the purposes of doing the industrial work on which he is so employed.
This amendment was suggested by Deputy Norton, and I think it is desirable. It provides, where a worker is found present on the premises of an employer while industrial work is being done, that he shall be deemed to be there for the purpose of doing that industrial work. It will facilitate the working of the Act and also the Workshops and Factories Acts.
Comment on this
How is it possible to assume that if a man goes into the workshop? We have all sorts and conditions of men coming in who are not employed on the premises.
Comment on this
If they are not employed there the question does not arise. It is possible that if an inspector went into factory premises after the working hours and found workers present while they might not be actually working, the employer could say that they were not working and thus evade the obligation to cease work at a particular hour. The purpose of the amendment is to give the inspector the right to assume that if workers employed to do a particular form of industrial work are found on the premises at any time, they are deemed to be there for the purpose of doing work, unless the employer says they are there in contravention of his instructions.
Comment on this
No, I am putting it on the employer to see that they leave the premises at the end of the maximum working day.
Comment on this
What does happen is that workers are employed over the regular hours in certain factories, and when the inspector goes in they are told they can go and they put on their hats and coats. The employer says they are not working; that they have been talking about social affairs on the factory premises. That is a common method of evasion. This amendment will prevent that happening.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Minister will want to look into this matter. An employee might remain on the premises for a considerable time after work was over, waiting out of a shower of rain or to see someone. It would be very unfortunate if anything happened to that person, say half an hour after the works were closed, and all the other men had left, and if employers would be held liable for an accident. There will have to be some limitation.
Comment on this
That is a very wide application. Work might not be done on the premises at that moment.
Comment on this
The amendment only deems the worker to be present doing work for the purpose of this section. It would not deem him to be doing work for the purposes of the Workmen's Compensation Acts. These Acts are not affected by this amendment.
Comment on this
The words of the amendment are "employed on industrial work". I am afraid they will have wider application.
Comment on this
Take the example given by the Minister, of an inspector coming along and finding the workers on the premises with their hats and coats on. An employer could not possibly be caught under this section, for the reason that it says the work must actually be going on when he arrives. The Minister did not contemplate that work was going on in the example he gave.
Comment on this
It might not be illegal to employ certain classes of workers at the time of the inspector's visit, but it might be illegal to employ others. The usual case is that where juveniles are kept working until an hour which is quite legitimate for adult workers but illegal for the others. That would be the usual type of case, employing juveniles beyond the legal hour. It is in such cases these circumstances might arise. The section is not of practical effect except as a means of enforcing the obligations of this and other statutes of the factories and workshops code.
Comment on this
Will the Minister have the matter looked into, with regard to the liability that falls on employers?
Comment on this
I think there is no doubt about that. They are only deemed to be at such work for the purposes of the section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 81:—
In page 17, Section 41 (1), before pragraph (b) to insert a new paragraph as follows:—
(b) licensed shift work.
This is really a drafting amendment. It is clear that if shift work is licensed in a particular industry it may be necessary to continue the work continuously over Sunday and Sunday work might be permitted. Therefore it is desirable to have licensed shift work mentioned in the section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 82:—
In page 17, Section 41 (1), to add at the end of the sub-section a new paragraph as follows:—
(d) industrial work excepted from this sub-section by regulations made by the Minister after consultation with representatives of employers interested in such industrial work and with representatives of workers so interested.
I think it is desirable to have this provision. As the section stands, workers are permitted to work on Sundays and holidays when engaged in continuous process shift work, such as printing newspapers or working in creameries. There may be other industries of which we have no cognisance at present, or there may be industries established, in respect of which work on Sundays and public holidays may be as necessary as in the case of the industries mentioned. Consequently, there should be some section which would enable an order to be made extending the scope of these industries after consulting with the workers and the employers concerned. Otherwise we would have to promote amending legislation and that is, I think, not desirable when the possibility can be provided against by an amendment of this kind. I cannot at the moment mention any such industry. If I could mention the industry that might be brought under this amendment, I would insert an amendment in the Bill to cover it. I do not know that there are any such in respect of which this power will have to be used at present, but there is always the possibility of some new industrial development taking place of a kind which would justify the making of an order under the proposed amendment to unable work on Sundays and public holidays to be done, subject, of course, to the usual provision in respect of another day off, etc.
Comment on this
I can give the Minister one of the cases he is thinking of. Apart from continuous process and licensed shift work, there is work that has to be done on Sundays and holidays in relaying the line. That is done on Sunday for a period of eight or nine hours, and it is additional to the working week of the operatives, who in their agreement have a guaranteed week of six days. Occasionally they have to do this relaying, or work in connection with bridges, and they are paid at the rate of time and a quarter. That is not in conflict with their agreement for the 48-hour week. I want to know if the concluding portion of the section will be applicable to these men, that they will have to be laid off for 24 hours before the Sunday, in case they could not do this work of relaying on any other day, and that the result will be that they will work on Sunday for time and a quarter and be laid off on some other day of the week, so that they will have to work on the Sunday for just the extra quarter time. That will mean a hardship on the workers and dislocation of the company's organisation. These staffs are not drawn from the particular area where the operation is taking place, and having to make arrangements for the laying off of these men for a day is going to cause considerable dislocation. The point arises whether the Minister contemplates that they should be paid for the day they are laid off. If the effect is to be as I have stated, it is going to cause hardship to the men concerned and great dislocation to the organisation of the company's work, because these are regular employees who cannot be replaced from outside as they are semiskilled men trained for this work. I should like to know from the Minister if my interpretation is correct.
Comment on this
In fact that particular class of work was brought to my notice by representatives of the railway companies. I indicated here before, I think, when some reference was made to it that it would have to be met by an exclusion order under Section 22. It would mean that that class of work would be excluded from the operation of this section. But there may be classes of work which we would permit to be done on Sundays, but in respect of which we would like to attach the obligation to give a day off in lieu of Sunday. If we did not make this amendment, the only thing we could do in relation to such classes of work would be the same thing which we contemplate doing for the class to which Deputy Keyes refers—to exclude them from the section, in which case the obligation to give a day off would not arise. It might be preferable in these cases, instead of excluding them from the section, to include them in sub-section (1) by an order under the amendment, in which case the obligation of sub-section (2) would be attached and the day off would have to be given.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 83:—
In page 17, before Section 41 (2), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in the next preceding sub-section of this section, an employer may employ an adult male worker to do, on any Sunday, for a period not exceeding three hours or for two or more periods not exceeding in the aggregate three hours, any industrial work to which the prohibition effected by the said next preceding sub-section applies.
I mentioned that it was represented that in certain trades it is necessary for a worker or two to attend at the factory premises on the Sunday for a short period, perhaps an hour or two hours, to do certain necessary work where chemical processes, etc., are in progress, and that in such a case it was not in the interests of the worker that that attendance upon Sunday for an hour or two should operate to require that he should get a complete day off during the week. Consequently, I am proposing to insert a section to make this prohibition apply only in respect of work exceeding three hours in duration. That will permit of these casual supervision jobs, which it is necessary to do upon Sundays, being executed without dislocation in respect of the organisation of the work, or without hardship to the worker in the matter of reducing his weekly earnings.
Comment on this
Is the Minister putting in three hours advisedly to meet the circumstances of the case?
Comment on this
What has the Minister in mind in respect of the reduction of the earnings of the workers?
Comment on this
At the present time the worker does six days in the week, plus two hours on Sunday, and he is paid for that. If we did not make the amendment, he would only do five days in the week, plus two hours on Sundays, and if he is paid at piece work or day rate his earnings would be less.
Comment on this
Deputy Keyes is, I think, dealing with an entirely different matter. That is where workers are brought together from a number of areas to do a particular job and they prefer to be left at that job until finished, rather than have their time broken. We would meet that case by taking it outside the section. The only class of work dealt with in the section is a regular normal practice.
Comment on this
Deputy Keyes is interested in the case of men who work on six week-days and also on Sunday for which they get time and a quarter. They must, unless they are excluded under Section 22, get a day off. Deputy Keyes' problem is this: What is the financial position of the men after working six week-days and one Sunday? Are they going to be paid for five week-days and one Sunday or six week-days and one Sunday?
Comment on this
If the working of seven days in the week is a regular practice. I think it should be stopped.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 85:—
In page 17, before Section 41 (3), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
(3) Where an employer is prohibited by this section from permitting workers in his employment to do industrial work for him on a public holiday, such employer shall pay in respect of every public holiday one day's pay (calculated at the rate which would be applicable if such public holiday were a day of annual leave) to every worker who—
(a) is a worker to whom such prohibition applies, and
(b) is in the employment of such employer on the working day next before such public holiday, and
(c) has been continuously in such employment during the whole of the period of four weeks ending on the said working day, and
(d) has worked in such employment not less than one hundred and fifty hours during the said period of four weeks, and
(e) has worked in such employment not less than twenty hours during the six working days next preceding such public holiday.
Comment on this
I do not think that this amendment is quite clear for one section of the workers. The amendment does not bring you any further in one respect because when you come to amendment No. 86 it deals with the case of a worker "whose ordinary remuneration is calculated by reference to time, at such rate per day as shall be the average earnings of such worker for the last six working days immediately preceding such public holiday."
And then it proceeds to deal with piece-work. Now, there is another class of workers who are paid nominally by the hour, and who work 44 or 48 hours per week at an agreed rate. The practice, in most of these trades, is to work five days at a longer period and, on the Saturday, at a shorter period. Now, if the bank holiday falls on a Saturday, at what rate is the pay to be calculated? I would say that it was to be calculated at the number of hours that would be normally worked on a Saturday, but the employee might contend that he should receive payment on the basis of the longer day's pay, namely, at the rate of the ordinary working day of the week. I would like the Minister to clear that point up. I take it that, in the case of that class of employee, no difficulty will arise about what his pay for the week will be, because he will get 44 hours; but, in the case of the bank holiday falling on a Saturday, is it to be calculated as if he were working on a Saturday or as if he were working on an ordinary day of the week?
Comment on this
I am not quite clear whether the Deputy is dealing with amendment No. 85 or amendment No. 86.
Comment on this
Would the Minister elaborate that a little further and tell us whether, when a bank holiday falls on a Saturday, and a worker who is paid at the rate of 44 hours per week for a full working week, the worker should receive five hours' pay for that bank holiday which fell on the Saturday, or eight hours' pay? I contend that he should only receive five hours' pay.
Comment on this
But that is just the point. What is the average day's pay in this connection? Perhaps Deputy Norton will tell us what he calls an average day.
Comment on this
It will not help us. I am referring to the case where a worker works five days at eight hours and for four hours on Saturday.
Comment on this
My only point is that there will be confusion. My contention is that four hours' pay should be substituted for what appears in the amendment. It does not say "per hour" in the amendment.
Comment on this
It says that the day's pay shall be calculated at the rate which would be applicable if the public holiday concerned were a day of annual leave, and the method of calculating the days for annual leave is set out precisely and it is averaged over the last six working days immediately preceding the public holiday concerned.
Comment on this
It seems to me that Deputy Dockrell's point is that if a public holiday falls on a Friday it would be calculated in the ordinary way, but that, if the public holiday falls on a Saturday it should be calculated in the same way. His contention is, as it appears to me, that that is not just to the employer, because, if it were not a public holiday, the worker would be kept on. It is not specified in the Act what should be done in the case of a public holiday falling on a Saturday instead of an ordinary week-day. Is that your point, Deputy Dockrell?
Comment on this
It is complicated by the worker working on an occasional rating. If the Minister's contention is to stand, and if it is a question of an average rate, it will then be a case of what is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander, and, instead of getting eight hours' pay for a full bank holiday, the worker will only get a somewhat lower fraction. I think that it would be better if the Minister would clear that point up.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 49, which was passed earlier, provides for the calculation of annual leave, and the calculation there provided for is the annual leave in respect of each day. The same rate has to be paid in respect of public holidays.
Comment on this
That is no help, because we can shorten the period and say there is no contention or dispute as to what the weekly rate is—it is 44 hours—but when it comes down to daily pay, that is where the difficulty will arise, in the case of a worker who works five long days and one short day. I should like the Minister to elucidate that point.
Comment on this
For every public holiday, no matter whether it be Saturday or Friday he gets one day's pay, calculated at the rate, and in the manner, set out in three paragraphs of amendment No. 49. That is the average daily rate of his earnings in the period in which he is allowed annual leave.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say is this an, amendment that compels the employer to pay for public holidays?
Comment on this
The Minister introduced a Bill to give holidays of six days with pay. Now in this amendment you are providing for at least 12 days pay for non-work. In a very large number of employments in this country at present bank holidays are at the workers' expense. In very few cases are these holidays at the employers' expense. This amendment provides for the payment of the workers for every bank holiday. I think that is a mistake. To introduce this section now for the payment of public holidays is, I think, unwise. It may happen in this country that at various times the Government may decide to proclaim other public holidays, and then the question will always arise whether they are to be paid for or not. That sort of thing creates friction, and friction is not a matter that should be allowed to enter into this thing at all. When the Bill was introduced it was amongst other things a Bill providing for a definite number of holidays. But now this amendment alters that.
Comment on this
When the Bill was before us in Committee this question as to whether public holidays should be paid for or not was discussed at considerable length. The Bill, as introduced, does not provide for the payment of public holidays, and it was urged here from all sides of the House that it was a doubtful benefit to give the workers additional public holidays throughout the year unless provision was made for payment. I found myself in the position of having no argument that I considered really effective against the argument advanced, and after due deliberation I decided to introduce this amendment. It provides that the workers covered by the Bill should have their holidays paid for. That, I admit, is imposing an extra charge upon the industries in which they are employed. It is not a very heavy charge.
Comment on this
It may be more heavy in some cases than in others, but it is difficult to suggest reasons against it, otherwise than the one argument that it effects an increase in industrial cost. This obviously is a matter upon which differences of opinion will exist according to the outlook of the individual. But it is justified. It does not put any individual employer at a disadvantage as against his competitor. That is because of its general application. It might put the nation as a whole at a disadvantage against competitors in external markets, but the percentage of increase in cost in relation to any industry is not of sufficient importance to create really an adverse effect upon the national trade. The proposal was one which would have come forward at some stage. I contemplated originally the development in the industrial holiday idea would come in two stages. The first was to be provided for in the Bill as introduced in which the obligation to provide a statutory weekly holiday in the year would be imposed for the first time, and the second one in which the obligation to pay for public holidays would be imposed. However, having regard to the representations that were made, and apparently having regard to the general opinion which existed throughout the House and which was expressed by spokesmen of all Parties, this obligation to pay in respect of public holidays was imposed. My own feeling was that it was a reasonable thing to do and a difficult thing to oppose and I brought forward this amendment. I think it is one which has been fairly generally welcomed, and it is likely to commend itself to the House. I did not myself intend that this provision should operate when framing the Bill originally. The introduction of the amendment is, I think, an improvement in the Bill. It is an improvement which it is easier to effect in so far as it appears to be one which is generally desirable.
Comment on this
The operation of this will come in in a rather difficult way. Suppose there is a question of special employment during the holiday season. The Minister may take it that a firm is going to put on extra men for a week. The question will at once arise as to whether there is a holiday in that week. Difficulties unfavourable to the workers will be created. I think this should be done in some other way. If a firm wants to put on an additional staff of men to do a certain amount of work, say, on the Thursday before Good Friday, until the following Tuesday, they will have to pay a certain additional amount of money. An extra day will have to be paid for the four days. It would be far better, I think, to make provision otherwise. The Government may proclaim a day a public holiday at any time. It is not that I grudge the men payment for the day, but I can foresee how it is going to work to their disadvantage. It is going to create very large difficulties. Public holidays have for long been established. In some parts of Ireland public holidays are bank holidays, while in other parts they are Church holy days. I take it that this amendment, as the Bill stands at the moment, will not provide for Church holy days to be paid for in country districts unless the employer elects beforehand that these will be public holidays. Even I question then that they will be paid for. The workers in the country are on a different basis from those in the city. I take it that Church holy days will not come under this Bill.
Comment on this
There are only six holidays at any rate. There cannot be more than six in respect of which this obligation to pay will exist.
Comment on this
In the country you will have to elect for one or the other— elect for the Church holy days or the bank holidays.
Comment on this
That is already provided for. If it is a public holiday in substitution of the existing holiday, it is provided for by amendment No. 18.
Comment on this
All the workers do not get the same bank holidays, and there will be considerable overlapping.
Comment on this
In any event the total number of public holidays in respect of which the obligation to pay exists is six, and there cannot be more than six.
Comment on this
I would like the Minister to justify this section a little more than he has done. First of all, it seems that if there is no holiday on a Saturday a man will get paid for four hours. Why, if there is a public holiday on the same day, should he get paid for seven and one-third hours? In other words, why should he get more if he is not working than if he were working? I do not begrudge the man what he will get, but I would like the Minister to justify the section more than he has done.
Comment on this
What the Deputy has stated would be the case if Saturday were a normal short day for a particular worker. It is for the majority of workers, but it may not be for all.
Comment on this
Yes. We have to make a general provision. There are six public holidays which may occur on any day of the week. We say, in relation to these days, that payment has to be made on the same basis as payment is calculated for the purpose of the annual leave. That may work out to the advantage of the worker when the holiday falls on a Saturday, and it may not. The worker may be employed in an industry in which the short day is on some other day of the week, in which case he gets the advantage if the holiday is on that other day of the week and not on Saturday. Taking the average for seven years, there will be no great advantage to anyone.
Comment on this
You must assume that the worker always, has a slight advantage because he is not working at all on a public holiday.
Comment on this
Is the Minister's ruling that, in the case of a worker who is paid by the hour, his average day's pay is to be the number of hours that he worked in the week divided by six?
Comment on this
The day's pay is calculated for the purposes of the annual leave. That is his average daily earnings over the period concerned.
Comment on this
Then he is going to receive less than the day's pay if the holiday falls on an ordinary day and more if the bank holiday falls on a Saturday. According to the Minister's argument, apparently the day's pay in calculating his leave would be not eight hours but seven and one-third hours. I think that many workers will begin to scratch their heads and wonder why they receive less than a day's pay for a day's pay. I think it would be well if the Minister made the position a little bit more clear in the Bill because I fear this is going to lead to a good deal of friction.
Comment on this
It may, but he is going to get less than what he considers his day's pay for eight hours, and he is going to get that every time this question of leave arises. Perhaps the Minister's way of dealing with this is the better way, but I fear it will lead to a great deal of friction. According to the inexorable arithmetic laid down by this section it does not deal with the worker who is paid by the hour. At least, it does not mention him specifically. It is going to be seven one-third hours or the number of hours worked divided by six.
Comment on this
In this Bill we are introducing a new principle, and I am anxious that the discussion on Deputy Dockrell's point should not obscure the main purpose of the section which is to introduce, for the first time, the principle of payment for public holidays.
Comment on this
You propose in this amendment to pay for public holidays. I think we should vote on that.
Comment on this
The Minister says that he is introducing a new principle in this Bill. He is also introducing a new principle in the case of many large industries. There are agreements at present existing in those industries relating to public holidays and in connection with which the men are not paid. They have never been paid for those public holidays in some of those industries. In the case of those industries what is to be the position in the future? Are the agreements or the provisions of this Bill to be followed?
Comment on this
So far as that is concerned, this is a legal obligation to pay for the holiday and it cannot be evaded.
Comment on this
The wage agreements in those industries have been made on the basis that the worker was to have holidays at his own expense.
Comment on this
I understood that the position was to be that if agreements were in force in certain trades, then those agreements were to be registered and that the conditions embodied in them were to be observed. According to the Minister, the provisions in this Bill are now to take precedence of those agreements.
Comment on this
The Agreements Register relates only to rates of wages. The Bill does not propose to register anything else, and the object of that is to ensure uniformity of payment in the rates of wages in industry. It is not proposed to enforce agreements relating to conditions of employment.
Comment on this
If those registered agreements are only to be made applicable so far as wages are concerned, how are we to get the special clauses, that specialised trades require, agreed upon?
Comment on this
There is nothing to prevent that. The purpose of the Agreements Register is to ensure that where agreements are made between a majority of employers and representatives of the workers the minority of employers will have to conform to them. That is the purpose of the register. It relates only to rates of wages and not to conditions of employment, which would be a more difficult thing to enforce.
Comment on this
But where in the Bill does it limit the registration of agreements to the particular items that the Minister mentions?
Comment on this
My objection to this was not on the grounds put forward by Deputy Beckett that a man should not be paid for a public holiday at all. I concerned myself chiefly with the position with regard to Saturday, because it does occur to me as rather strange that if a man were at work on a Saturday he would only get paid for a four-hour day, whereas if he is not at work he will get paid at the rate of seven and one-third hours.
Comment on this
It is not correct to say that the man is not at work. To qualify for this he must be in employment. He is not unemployed.
Comment on this
He is employed all right but he is not actually at work. He is drawing more wages than if he were at work.
Comment on this
If the holiday is a Saturday holiday then over seven years he is going to get seven ordinary days' pay. It will average out.
Comment on this
I asked the Minister with regard to Section 42, what was to be done with existing agreements in future?
Comment on this
Whatever agreements have been made between organisations of employers and employees can be made in future. We are not preventing the making of agreements dealing with conditions of employment. We provide machinery by which these agreements, in so far as they relate to rates of wages, can be made statutorily enforceable and if both parties desire the agreement can be registered.
Comment on this
Where is there permission in this Bill to make such agreements, if you tell me that Section 42 only refers to wages?
Comment on this
What are they to be governed by? Authority must exist somewhere to govern the trade. What is it to be governed by?
Comment on this
So far as the Bill is concerned there is no reference to them. They are agreements which will be made voluntarily or made at any rate by mutual consent between the parties and they will be enforceable in so far as the parties agree mutually to enforce them on themselves.
Comment on this
You get into a difficulty under Section 42. These agreements are referred to in Section 42——
Comment on this
Yes. You say that the legislation only governs the rate of wages. There is only legislation governing that clause of the agreements, otherwise they go by the board.
Comment on this
No agreement comes under the scope of Section 42 until there is a joint application by both parties to it for the registration of it and until the Minister has agreed to accept it as suitable for registration. In the event of a certain situation arising, as the Bill stands, that does not impose any obligations on the Department of Industry and Commerce, but it gives the workers who are concerned in the industry to which the agreement relates certain rights against the employers if the employers should not observe the agreement.
Comment on this
I should like to get clear on this. The point has been raised that there are at present operating certain agreements with regard to wages under which public holidays were not paid for. Now that provision has been made that there will be a statutory obligation to pay workers in respect to public holidays, do I understand that some of these agreements in regard to wages will have to be reopened because the principle of payment for public holidays has been established?
Comment on this
This establishes a minimum which must be applied in regard to these agreements. In other words, if there is no agreement providing for holidays, this Bill gives holidays.
Comment on this
The suggestion is made that the acceptance of this particular principle is going to upset certain wages agreements.
Comment on this
The whole Bill may have that effect in so far as it reduces hours of work or in some other way affects conditions of employment. We hope that we shall get all these problems in relation to industry considered as a whole and agreements recorded which will be implemented through the various sections of the Bill, by the different regulations or by the registration of agreements. The Bill does not come automatically into operation. It can be applied part by part, or it can be brought into operation in relation to particular classes of work. Generally speaking, it does not effect any substantial change in the prevailing conditions except in certain cases. The changes will really come when the regulations under the Bill are made. One of the changes that will come automatically into operation is this one relating to payment for public holidays or the provision for annual holidays. They are automatic in their operation and will apply to all workers operating in activities within the scope of the Bill. They will be enforceable irrespective of what is embodied in existing agreements.
Comment on this
Is the Minister prepared to say that if public holidays are to be paid for, that does not invite the reopening of agreements with regard to wages?
Comment on this
I see no reason why it should involve any, alteration in existing agreements with regard to wages.
Comment on this
A number of Dublin men may have to go to various parts of the country. Supposing they are in a part of the country where the public holidays are altogether different to those observed in Dublin. Is the Dublin practice to be followed or is the country practice to be followed in the case of these men?
Comment on this
That is entirely at the discretion of the men's employers. So far as the Bill is concerned, these statutory holidays operate unless the employers decide to substitute the public holidays for four of them.