We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Land Purchase (Guarantee Fund) Bill, 1935—Committee.

Contributions 1–167 of 494. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Land Purchase (Guarantee Fund) Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 39 of 1935 ›

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The purpose of amendment No. 1 appears to be to remove the retrospective provisions of the Bill. A decision on that point may be arrived at on amendment No. 1 on the question that the words proposed to be deleted stand. If that is answered in the affirmative the subsequent amendments, Nos. 2 to 6, fall. If, however, Deputies have special points outside that aspect of the case to raise on amendments Nos. 2 and 5 they may do so. The Chair does not see that those two amendments have any other purpose than to remove the retrospective provision of the Bill.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 6 is an amendment to Section 2.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Having the same object, it stands or falls consequentially on amendment No. 1.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1:—

In sub-section 1 (a) to delete the words "whether before or" in line 18.

In the first place, retrospective legislation is dangerous and in this case it is more than dangerous. We are endeavouring, while not accepting the principle of the Bill, and while not accepting that either justice or equity can be met by the operation of the Bill, to come as far as we possibly can to the assistance of local authorities who are at present in very sore straits. Particularly is that so because of the moneys which the Government withheld without apparently any legal right to withhold them, as this Bill has proved. The majority of local authorities in framing their estimates last year were confronted with a very serious situation, but they did not dream at the time that the threats of what professed to be a poor man's Government would be carried out to the extent to which they were carried out, and local authorities did not make provision for the serious deficits occurring in their estimates owing to the withholding of grants on the head of the annuities. Firstly, Sir, the best case I think that can be made for this amendment is that generally county councils are not notified in time with regard to the amount of grants withheld from them. This year particularly when the withheld amounts were of such enormous size the position was most unsatisfactory. To tie local authorities definitely down to the losses which must ensue as a result of the operation of this Bill by having it retrospective would be, to my mind, a gross and serious injustice and entirely outside the laws of equity and justice. Further, I maintain that local authorities in this respect have been victimised to a very great extent, not only by the Minister for Finance, who withheld the grants, but by the Minister for Local Government. Ordinarily, local authorities are supposed to budget for the full expenditure. Last year I do not think any county council did. They were relying to a large extent—at least many of them were relying—upon the fact that these grants would not be withheld to the extent threatened; that some effort would be made by the Government to meet the situation.

The position that confronts local authorities if the Bill is to be retrospective is that they have to make good a sum of over £567,000, which at the moment is unprovided for, in addition to the provision which they made last year of £159,000 to meet the withheld grants. It is a very serious state of affairs, more particularly when we look at the situation which confronts local authorities generally even outside this matter altogether. I am sure the Minister and the Government must realise when a situation exists in the country which demands on their part the withholding of £716,000 from local authorities that that situation must be very serious and that the condition of the people who failed to pay their annuities to that extent must be very sad indeed. Coupled with that we have the position of the local authorities in connection with the uncollected arrears of rates. We have enormous sums carried forward last year as uncollectable and enormous sums written off. We have the unpaid annuities, then the withholding of the grants, and we have the unpaid rates—the uncollectable rates, and the written-off, irrecoverable rates.

We have even further figures supplied in reply to a question by Deputy Doyle on 13th June, which show that the arrears of cottage rents have been increasing since 1932. According to the figures supplied by the Minister for Local Government, in 1932, on a particular day, there was outstanding in arrears of rents of labourers' cottages in each county health district a sum of £34,519, or 21.5 per cent. In 1933 that had increased to 27.5 per cent.; in 1934 to 33.5 per cent., and this year it is practically the same. Taking all these figures together, they reveal a very sad state of affairs in the life of the community. Together with all that we have the sum of £716,000 withheld from local authorities last year and, I maintain, withheld entirely outside the law, as this Bill proves. Although there was a threat to withhold the moneys, local authorities generally felt that it really would not be carried out, that the grants would be forthcoming in some other way. The cost of living is going up, and the credit of the people is going down. Taking it all in all, I wonder does the Minister realise the difficulties which confront the people and which confront local authorities at present if they are ever to get out of the rut in which they are? Does the Minister think that by making this contemptible little Bill retrospective, so that he can hold on to his £716,000 which he withheld last year, he will put local authorities on their feet?

It is high time that the Minister and his colleagues took stock of the situation and considered what is happening in the country. Taking into consideration the huge sums which the Minister felt compelled to withhold for the purposes of his Exchequer in order to meet his outgoings, and that he is endeavouring to pass this type of Bill to ensure that in future the grants ordinarily accruing to local authorities will be withheld to the extent of the unpaid annuities in each county, he should at least allow local authorities to get on their feet; he should at least have the decency to say, "I was outside the law last year in what I did; I am admitting that and I will give the local authorities what they were entitled to last year inside the law, and will give them the opportunity to get on their feet in that way." Instead of that we have this Bill put before the House to-day. Not alone is it ensuring the future of the Exchequer so far as the grants to local authorities are concerned, but it wants to ensure that the huge deficiencies in the estimates of all local authorities will be real, and that the financial embarrassment which confronts local authorities will not be an imaginary but a real one.

I am sure that if the Minister considered for a moment the situation he would feel that the local authorities are entitled to some consideration and that a retrospective clause such as this ought not to be inserted in the Bill. The rates last year all over the country were enormously increased. The increase over those of a few years ago was something like £500,000—that is the normal increase. Then there was an enormous increase of arrears carried forward and, in addition, we have £716,000 withheld, which the Minister now endeavours to validate by this Bill. The local authorities will be obliged, if this particular section is passed in its present form, to provide for huge sums for which they have little or no resources at present. It is outside all justice and equity that a Bill of this type should be brought in at all. I have always maintained, and still maintain, that local authorities ought not to be responsible for unpaid annuities, because they have absolutely no control over them. Legislation which not alone makes that secure for the future, but makes it retrospective when local authorities were not prepared for it, and when they are passing through very hard times, is, to my mind, a type of legislation that ought not to be accepted by the House. Consequently, I move the amendment.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

We have not heard the purpose of this amendment explained to us.

Comment on this

What does the Minister say?

Comment on this

We have not had the purpose of this amendment explained to us.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would make it as clear as he did in the Irish Times to-day.

Comment on this

That is clear enough.

Comment on this

He has converted the Irish Times anyway.

Comment on this

Let us hear the Minister.

Comment on this

We might have a vote on it.

Comment on this

There are just a couple of things which we ought to make clear at the earliest opportunity on the Committee Stage of this Bill. The Deputy said that the Minister has gone outside the law. I should like to say that I do not admit that we have gone outside the law, but whether we have or not——

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

——we have been carrying out the intentions of the Legislature which passed the Act of 1933. I do not think that can be challenged. It has never been challenged here in relation to the vote for the Land Commission or in relation to the vote for the Minister for Finance in 1933, 1934 or 1935.

Comment on this

It was never put in the Act.

Comment on this

It was never challenged here.

Comment on this

It was not there to be challenged.

Comment on this

It was made clear to the Oireachtas when we were debating the Act of 1933 that we were charging against the Guarantee Fund any deficiency which would arise in the collection of the Land Commission annuities. That was never challenged in the Dáil, and in passing this Bill we are not acting contrary to the intentions which the Oireachtas had when it passed the 1933 Act.

The Deputy has made the point that the local authorities did not budget for the £550,000 in respect of the draws upon the Guarantee Fund. Why did they not budget? Are we responsible if the local authorities did not budget when the Government policy and the policy of the Oireachtas in relation to this matter was stated plainly and unmistakably? Are we responsible that they did not budget? Are we responsible if they choose to disregard those warnings and to adopt some other course? I think there is another reason why the local authorities did not budget to the extent of £556,000 for the Guarantee Fund deficiency. The reason is this: that against that £556,000 for which they did not budget there was advanced to the Guarantee Fund a sum of £550,000, which left the uncovered deficiency then at £6,000. That is why they did not budget. That is why they were not compelled to budget for it. We realised that there was a transition stage. We realised the incitements that were uttered in the country in order to paralyse the local finances, and we advanced out of the expected £550,000 to the Guarantee Fund to allow a corresponding amount to be released to the local authorities. That is why the local authorities did not have to budget.

What is at stake here? A sum of £716,000. We heard in speeches from Deputies that they proposed to oppose this Bill because they did not believe that honest people should be called on to discharge the debts of dishonest people. That is the argument that has been advanced. If we do not get £716,000 from the Guarantee Fund where is it to come from? It is going to come from the general taxpayer, as I pointed out on the Second Reading. It is going to come from men and women who do not own a perch or a rood of land——

Comment on this

Bluff.

Comment on this

The Deputy says "bluff."

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Well he can only say "bluff" on one assumption—that the Deputy's method of dealing with this question is that we would reduce the grant which is made in relief of rates on agricultural land by £716,000.

Comment on this

Double bluff.

Comment on this

Very well. The Deputy says "double bluff." Then the Deputy is not going to reduce the Agricultural Grant. Will he tell the House where he is to get it? Is he going to get it out of the unemployment assistance?

Comment on this

Treble bluff.

Comment on this

Can I have a reply?

Comment on this

More bluff.

Comment on this

Is he going to get it out of the Widows' and Orphans' Fund?

Comment on this

He will get it out of the £2,000,000 which the Minister was going to save on national expenditure.

Comment on this

Get it out of the bounties.

Comment on this

I would like to hear Deputy Davin say "yes" or "no" as to where the money is to be got. Is the Deputy going to get it next year or the year after from any Government services?

Comment on this

Is the Minister admitting his inability to collect the money? He is responsible for that collection.

Comment on this

I assume from that reply that the Deputy is not going to get the money out of any Government services. Is he going to get it out of increased taxation? When the last Budget was going through the Dáil the Deputy opposed the Government in endeavouring to make provision for social and other essential services by increased taxation. If he is not going to get this £716,000 out of economies, is he going to get it out of increased taxation?

Comment on this

What about the ground rents?

Comment on this

Is that sextuple bluff? While the Deputy is not going to get the money out of economies, and while he is not going to get it out of increased taxation, he says there are other methods, and the other matters are bailiffs and the battering ram.

Comment on this

Yes; they were indicated in the Minister's speech.

Comment on this

We cannot get the money out of taxation, nor out of economies, and the only thing then to do is to employ the bailiff and the battering ram.

Comment on this

How about the guns in Marsh's Yard—the guns of the gentlemen who shoot the farmers?

Comment on this

I wish the Deputy would keep his head in this matter.

Comment on this

I wish the Minister had a head to keep.

Comment on this

Other methods which have not been employed were suggested to collect this money. I have described what the methods of Deputy Davin were. The Deputy, having first of all alleged that we had not recourse to these methods, comes along now and says we are using them. I think the series of answers which the Deputy has given to the queries I put showed the confusion of mind which exists in the Labour Party. But let us consider this matter further. One of the grounds upon which this Bill has been opposed is that Deputies object to making honest men pay for the liabilities of dishonest individuals. I was pointing out that the alternative which has been offered to us by the Opposition is that instead of having a limited number of people belonging to one section of the community becoming responsible for the debts of the persons in that section who have defaulted in their commitments to the State—to make responsible the general body of the taxpayers, including, as I have said, men and women who do not own an acre or rood of land. That is the alternative which is offered to us by the people who say they do not want to compel honest men to pay the debts of dishonest people. But what is going to be the position now? Let us consider how the situation with which we are dealing has arisen. There are some very wealthy areas in this country.

Comment on this

Not now.

Comment on this

There are some wealthy agricultural areas in this country. There is the County of Cork, for example. The total amount of annuities collectible in that county from 1st November, 1933, to 31st June, 1935, was £505,000. The actual amount in arrear on the 31st July in respect of this was £227,000, or 43 per cent. of the total annuities collectible. In County Donegal, the county in which Deputy McMenamin is interested, and in which Deputy Dillon has a passing interest, the total amount of annuities collectible to the 31st June, 1935, was £136,000 and the amount of the arrears was £10,018. The position in regard to these two counties is that whereas Cork failed or refused or conspired in the matter of the payment of 43 per cent. of the annuities collectible, Donegal, a very much poorer county, with very much less opportunity to pay, failed to pay only 8 per cent., and yet Deputy McMenamin's attitude in this House is to make the honest, poverty-stricken people of Donegal discharge the obligations of the very much more prosperous and the wealthier community of County Cork.

Comment on this

What about Limerick, Clare and Kerry?

Comment on this

All in due course. I shall possibly be in a position to analyse the figures in Deputy Davin's constituency.

Comment on this

I shall be glad if you do so; it would help me.

Comment on this

It is obvious the Deputy requires some help in the position in which he has found himself. Now, with regard to Tipperary, in Tipperary South the total amount of annuities collectible for the same period was £202,000 and the amount in arrear on the 31st July was £103,000 or, 51 per cent. of the total collection.

Comment on this

Does the sum of £202,000 cover the two Ridings of Tipperary?

Comment on this

No, Tipperary South.

Comment on this

What are the figures in regard to Tipperary North?

Comment on this

The total amount collectible is £140,000 and the arrears represent £49,000, not very creditable, but somewhat better than Tipperary South. Let me now deal with County Monaghan. I was pointing out that in Tipperary South 51 per cent. of the annuities collectible were in arrear, but in Monaghan, where the total annuities collectible amounted to £114,000, the amount in arrear was only £7,906.

Comment on this

The good old Border!

Comment on this

In Monaghan they were only 7 per cent. in arrears.

Comment on this

That shows you how smuggling pays.

Comment on this

As an Ulsterman I am proud to say that the Ulster counties, which are suffering hardest in the economic war, are setting a headline to the rest of the country in this matter, and they are to be admired.

Comment on this

They are setting a headline for very successful smuggling and we admire them.

Comment on this

The good old Border!

Comment on this

It is quite obvious Deputies opposite do not want the facts to be put before the House.

Comment on this

It looks like it.

Comment on this

In Monaghan, which is not a wealthy county, because they have no beet and they find it difficult, I believe, to grow wheat and they have been very badly hit in relation to their pig-rearing industry, they are, nevertheless, only 7 per cent. in arrears in regard to their land annuities. The proposal made by Deputy Morrissey is that the honest people of County Monaghan are going to be penalised; they have got to discharge not merely their guarantee in relation to the 7 per cent. of their county annuities which are in arrear, but also to take a part, and a very onerous part, of the 51 per cent. and the 43 per cent. of the annuity arrears in South Tipperary and County Cork.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give us the figures in relation to West Cork?

Comment on this

The Minister will tell you a lot before he is finished.

Comment on this

Give us the figures for Belfast.

Comment on this

I assume that Deputy Burke put his question because he thought I should have figures here which would show that West Cork had been discharging its obligations in regard to these annuities. May I assume that?

Comment on this

You may assume it.

Comment on this

I regret I have not the figure which would carry conviction in that regard, but if the Deputy does believe that West Cork has discharged its obligations in regard to these annuities, why should he ask the honest people of West Cork not merely to assume liability for the obligations of their brethren in the less honest portions of the county, but also obligations in regard to counties like South Tipperary and the others to which I have referred? We shall now come to Offaly and Laoighis. One is not quite so bad as the other and neither of them is quite so bad as Cork or South Tipperary, but I regret they are not so good as other parts of the country. In Offaly the total amount of the annuities collectible between 1st November, 1933, and 31st July, 1935, was £134,000, and the arrears in respect of Offaly for the same period amounted to £41,577, or 31 per cent. Now we come to Laoighis, in which Deputy Davin has a very great interest. In Laoighis the total amount collectible was almost the same as in Offaly; it was £136,000. The amount in arrear was only £33,273, so that whereas in Offaly 31 per cent. of the annuities were in arrear, in Laoighis only 25 per cent. was in arrear. That is a nice point for the Deputy.

Comment on this

It is very good when compared with a place like Cork.

Comment on this

Obviously there are 6 per cent. more honest people in Laoighis than there are in Offaly, and the Deputy opposing this Bill because he does not want the honest people to pay for the debts of the dishonest people, is now asking the 6 per cent. more honest people of Laoighis to discharge the debts of the less honest County of Offaly.

Comment on this

Is it in order for the Minister to laugh at his own speech?

Comment on this

He can well afford it.

Comment on this

Apparently the Deputy does not enjoy the flippancy of this speech in the same way that he enjoyed the flippancy of the speech on the Second Reading. There is just one other county I might mention. There is Mayo where the total amount was £204,000. The amount of that in arrears on the 31st July was £22,800, only 11 per cent.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney will be interested in that.

Comment on this

1/9 in the £ on the rates is what it means.

Comment on this

The Deputy is interested in that. He is going to ask the Dáil to ask the honest people of Mayo who paid 89 per cent. of the annuities collectible, not only this year, but the total annuities collectible since the 1st November, 1933, to discharge some part of the obligations of the less honest people of Roscommon who, out of a total of annuities collectible of £179,000, have failed to pay £43,600.

Comment on this

Not bad at all.

Comment on this

So that a much poorer county like Mayo, where the people on a total collection of £204,000 are in arrears for only something like £22,000, are not merely to make good their own £22,000, but a considerable part of the £44,000 owed by the people of Roscommon.

Comment on this

Are there no taxpayers who are ratepayers also?

Comment on this

Deputy Brennan is a very forceful person in the councils of his Party, but I did not think he could put it over Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney to that extent.

Comment on this

The Minister does not understand. He cannot make a proper comparison.

Comment on this

I could go down through this whole list——

Comment on this

What about Limerick, Clare and Cavan?

Comment on this

They are not as good as they ought to be, but is that any reason why they should pay for counties which are better than they are?

Comment on this

Give us the figures.

Comment on this

In Limerick the total amount collectible was £278,800; the amount in arrear was £87,000 or 31 per cent. of the total. In Clare the total amount collectible was £176,000 and the arrears amounted to 23 per cent.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give us the figures for Louth?

Comment on this

Yes. In Louth the total amount collectible was £96,800 and the amount in arrear was £15,181. That is to say that Louth, which was only 16 per cent. in arrear in collection on 31st July, 1935, has to make good the deficiencies of Limerick, Kerry, and Clare. I am sure that will bring joy to the heart of Deputy Coburn. I am sure the taxpayers of these counties, which have made honest attempts to discharge their obligations, will realise what a delight it is to not merely have to pay for the deficiencies of their neighbours, but to have also to assume responsibility for people in other counties who are much wealthier than they themselves are——

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister a question? How much was collected by the British Government during that period?

Comment on this

Before I sit down——

Comment on this

Tá bodhar Uí Laoghaire air anois.

Comment on this

——I would like to make clear——

Comment on this

You should not accuse the Irish farmer of being dishonest.

Comment on this

——that the figures I have given show the state of the collection up to the 31st July this year. But there is no reason to anticipate that this £716,000 which, up to the present, has been withheld from the local authorities is going to be permanently withheld from them. It is clear, from the figures I have given, that the arrears in a number of those counties are withheld deliberately and do not arise from an inability on the part of the general body of the annuitants to pay but to an unwillingness to pay.

Comment on this

They paid them over and over again.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

And my reason for saying that is that whereas on the 1st February this year the total amount of the annuities in arrears was £1,185,000, by dealing with this non-payment campaign the amount in arrears has been considerably reduced and I have no doubt that, now that people have been convinced that the annuities have to be paid, all the arrears outstanding will be reduced. And each county council, and particularly that of Cork, where this campaign has been rampant, will find their position speedily improved, and that by the normal operation of the Guarantee Fund we will be able to release, in due time, a considerable part of this £716,000 now impounded. Therefore, I think there has been a great to-do about nothing.

Comment on this

Why the Bill?

Comment on this

Why the Bill? To save those unfortunate ratepayers——

Comment on this

From themselves?

Comment on this

——from engaging in futile and useless litigation. As I said from the beginning, the purpose of this Bill is to make clear what the law is and what the Oireachtas thought the law was when it brought in the 1933 Act—nothing else. I have not any doubt that, if our predecessors were in the same position, they would do the same thing.

In introducing his amendment, the Deputy said that he was opposed to this because it was retrospective legislation. On that question, and as to the need for that, I think I might refer to a speech that was made here on the Copyright (Preservation) Bill, 1929. On the Second Stage of that Bill, the then Minister for Industry and Commerce, Mr. McGilligan, said:

"I move the Second Reading of the Bill.... The Act is a short one and is simple. The necessity for it has been brought about by a decision given by the Supreme Court in a case litigated over a year ago, and by virtue of the decision of the Supreme Court which, of course, is recognised as the highest authority on what the state of the law is at any time in this country, it has been discovered that the intention of the legislature, as expressed here, during the course of debate, with regard to the Industrial and Commercial Property (Protection) Act, 1927, has not in fact been carried out."

Comment on this

As a result of the position after the judgment.

Comment on this

The Deputy wants to wait until the court has committed itself before taking action. Mr. McGilligan went on to say that The Performing Rights Society, to which he was referring in his speech, took their case to all the courts in this country before whom they could bring it and that their case had been turned down. He then went on to say:—

"We want to amend the law and to amend it retrospectively."

Comment on this

Not to interpret it.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy dissociate for me the process of making the law from the process of interpreting it and construing it?

Comment on this

I am not here to educate the Minister.

Comment on this

When a Bill is going through here, do we not try, so far as we can, to write into it the interpretation which the Legislature wishes to be put upon it? There is no doubt that the speeches of the acting Minister for Lands, in introducing the Land Bill of 1933, and the decision which the Oireachtas took in relation to amendments to abolish the Guarantee Fund, make it quite clear that it was the intention of the Oireachtas that the Guarantee Fund procedure should apply to the reduced annuities under the 1933 Act. Are we going to wait until people have wasted their money, until judges have wasted their time, until we have a decision which may or may not be in accordance with our interpretation of the law; which may or not be inconsistent with the intention of the Legislature; and if it is inconsistent, are we to follow this regrettable precedent and bring in a Bill to reverse the decision of our own Supreme Court? No. Before people waste their time; before people waste their money, and before the public services are disorganised, we come in here and say that if, as some people allege, the Statute, as it was enacted by the Oireachtas, is ambiguous, we will clear up the ambiguity before the matter goes to the judges. We would have been entitled to do that at any time during the past two years. If Deputies, who now profess that there was a doubt in the matter and that we have not acted in accordance with the intention of the Oireachtas in charging these deficiencies in the purchase annuities against the Guarantee Fund, had raised the matter here in the House at any time during the past two years, as I said already to-day, the position would have been clarified. However, better late than never. It is never too late to mend, and, if there be indeed a doubt on the matter, we are asking the Oireachtas now to make its intention clear.

Comment on this

If I might be permitted to intervene for a moment, I should like to point out that the case mentioned by the Minister has absolutely no bearing whatever on this one now before us.

Comment on this
Hugh Victor Flinn Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Flinn) Fianna Fáil

Obiter dicta!

Comment on this

This is no obiter dictum. It is the truth, and the Parliamentary Secretary knows it is the truth, if he knows anything about the case.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary will tell us what he knows?

Comment on this

No, let the Parliamentary Secretary proceed with the obiter dicta.

Comment on this

The particular case mentioned by the Minister is one in which the Oireachtas passed laws in connection with copyright, believing that they were putting the position beyond doubt. The case went to the Supreme Court and the Supreme Court found that the Oireachtas had not done so. The decision of the Supreme Court was not interfered with in the least iota by that particular Bill. They said that, in so far as a person has gone to the court and got a decision, his case is settled, but for every other case the Oireachtas laid down the law. If the Minister thinks that that is a parallel of the present case, I make him a present of his case.

Comment on this

There is only one other member of this House who could exceed the performance we have just witnessed from the Minister for Finance, and that is his chief lieutenant, the Parliamentary Secretary. I have no doubt that the Deputy will succeed in doing so, although the Minister has set him a fairly hard task, even for Deputy Flinn. This is, perhaps, the most important matter that has come before this House this year, with the exception of the Budget; and the gentleman who is responsible for the finance of this country treats it in the manner in which he has just treated it. We had an exhibition of buffoonery, flippancy, and of dealing with everything except the matter before the House—an absolute refusal to recognise the condition to which he and his Government have reduced the public authorities in this country. If the Minister did one thing, it was this: in the course of his speech, to demonstrate very clearly what effect his so-called economic war has had upon the ratepayers of this country. Why are all the thousands due? The Minister says that there are rich agricultural counties in the Free State. There were! There are very few of them to-day, and if the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary do not know it, there are members sitting there, farmers and members of public authorities, who know it, and know it quite well.

Comment on this

Deputy Corkery knows it.

Comment on this

They know the fight that the local authorities have had to make for the last few years, and they know that there is hardly a county council in the Free State that is to-day in a sound financial position. They know that there are county councils that have been unable to pay their road men. They know that there are county councils that have been compelled to reduce their services to the barest minimum. They know that one of the reasons we have so many extra thousands of unemployed to-day is that county councils and other authorities are not able to give the same employment as they were giving some years ago. The Minister talked about honesty and dishonesty. He blathered in every sentence about the honest farmers of this county and the dishonest farmers of the other county. If there is any dishonesty and demoralisation in this country it is the people on the opposite side who are responsible for it. Perhaps the greatest crime they are guilty of in this country is the fact that they have gone a long way towards demoralising certain sections of the people and have done their damndest to make certain people dishonest. Then we have this sort of tripe trotted out by the Minister. I notice that the Minister laughs at that. Probably he never heard of it. They do not keep that at the other side of the Border. The Minister must have learned something about it, particularly in the days when he was learning how to get up here and treat us to the exhibition we listened to a while ago. Honest and dishonest! Would the Minister give us the other side of the picture? Will he tell us how many millions of pounds have been lost to the farmers of this country? Has he any figures to show what the economic war has cost the farmers of Tipperary, Cork, and the other counties he mentioned? The Minister talked about the annuities and about the £1,185,000 that had been outstanding. He said that they had taken action and that that amount had been reduced. Yes, with the battering ram, the bailiff and the revolver.

Comment on this

They were not used.

Comment on this

That is the kind of action that was taken by the Government until they found that it was not succeeding. Then they resorted to the old system of dealing with them through the State solicitors. They did that when they found that they could not browbeat the people into meeting unjust demands. They found that when the people were treated in a proper way and given time, they did their best to meet their obligations, as they always did. Has the Minister any idea of what the position is? There are Deputies sitting on the other side of the House who are members of county councils, and they will tell the Minister how hard put these county councils have been to meet their demands.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy expect the poor farmers in Mayo, Leitrim and Donegal to pay for the well-to-do farmers in Tipperary, Cork and Limerick? Is he aware that in 1925 or 1926, when there was no economic war, the Roscommon County Council, of which Deputy Brennan was chairman, had to strike a special rate to meet deficits arising out of default in the payment of land annuities?

Comment on this

If the Deputy will listen to me for a moment I will explain the position. The present Government has succeeded in making the farmers pay their annuities twice over.

Comment on this

Ten times over.

Comment on this

Now, the Minister is bringing in a Bill to make the ratepayers pay their rates twice over. Is the Deputy aware that, so far as certain counties are concerned, the passage of this Bill, with the retrospective clause in it, will mean an extra 2/- or 2/6 in the £ on the rates?

Comment on this

Bunkum.

Comment on this

It means nothing of the sort.

Comment on this

Deputy Donnelly says "bunkum." In the case of North Tipperary it will mean an extra 2/1 in the £ on the rates. I wonder would the Deputy tell us what will be the amount of the increase in his constituency? Is there any Fianna Fáil Deputy, who is a member of a county council, who will get up and say that the ratepayers in his county are in a position to-day to meet an increase in the rates? Are we to be told that there are county councils that can afford to meet, not only their ordinary demands, but as well the increased demands that this Bill will mean? A burglar comes in and robs your house. He takes everything in it and beats you because you do not give him more out of nothing. That is the position that we have reached, as far as this Bill is concerned. The Minister, if he were not so brazen, would be heartily ashamed to stand up and defend a Bill like this in the House.

I am quite satisfied, as I have said, that an attempt will be made to excel this piece of tomfoolery. The Minister talked about the intentions of the legislature. It is not the intentions of an Act that count once it has been passed by the Oireachtas, but rather what is in the Act and the interpretation put upon it by the judges. In future, is the position to be that we are to change the law every time a case is brought before the courts? The Minister has told us that the Act of 1933 is all right: that it is watertight, and that he is safeguarded. The Minister has stated that it expresses the intentions of the Government, and of Government policy, plainly and unmistakably. If so, why this Bill? I would like to have the real facts at issue here met, not by the Minister or by Deputy Hugo Flinn, but by some person who has practical knowledge of the country and of the people, of the work of the county councils and the difficulties they are faced with in getting in the rates. I have not the slightest doubt that Deputy Hugo Flinn would be able to get up and make as good a case against the Bill as for it. In fact, I think he would be able to make a better case against it. I grant that the Deputy has that kind of facility. I do not want to follow the Minister's example of wasting the time of the House in this discussion. The Minister succeeded in wasting about threequarters of an hour.

Comment on this

He was interrupted a lot.

Comment on this

Only for that he would not be able to say anything at all about the Bill. I think that any little knowledge he has of the Bill was given to him by way of interruption. Were it not for those interruptions the Minister's speech would have been about as clear as his letter to the Irish Times to-day. I confess that letter was not very clear to me. It was not any more clear than the Minister's speech. So far as I could understand the Minister's speech, it was an attempt to suggest that the reason why this Bill had to be introduced was: (1) because of the dishonesty of the ratepayers of this country, and (2) because of the campaign against the payment of rates. Of course, it was necessary to resurrect that again as one of the reasons for introducing this Bill. Are we to take it that Fine Gael, which is supposed to be at the back of this alleged campaign, is so strong in every county of the Free State that their supporters are able to paralyse the collection of the rates?

It has been suggested in the course of the debate that there are Fianna Fáil supporters in the country who have paid their rates or annuities. I think that on one occasion I was able to give a certain amount of information on that. I refer to the time when the Department of Local Government issued a circular to local authorities suggesting that the names of members of councils who had not paid their rates should be published. The names were published in one particular county in which I am interested. There were five members of the council there who had not paid their rates, and it turned out that they were five strong, loud-voiced supporters of the Party opposite.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would suggest to the Deputy who has sat down that the introduction into Parliamentary debate of the word "buffoonery" is inadvisable.

Comment on this

I said that the Minister gave an exhibition of buffoonery, and if the Chair thinks that is an unparliamentary expression, I certainly withdraw it.

Comment on this

If that is the case, I would like to remind the Minister for Finance that he used that expression towards me some considerable time ago.

Comment on this

When?

Comment on this

It does not matter now, but it is on the records of the House as being a Parliamentary word. The Minister referred to certain action on my part as "buffoonery." I think he said it twice, but it does not matter. It slipped off me.

Comment on this

I have no recollection of it. If I had, I would withdraw it.

Comment on this

If the Minister did not say anything worse than that, it would be all right.

Comment on this

I rise to support the amendment. The Minister, in the course of his speech, quoted a lot of figures which, in my opinion, hardly have any bearing on the matter before the House, when one considers that the farmers, whether rich or poor, in Donegal and Mayo, have not only paid the amount claimed from them, but also the amount that the British Government collected from them. What has happened is that they have paid their land annuities at least twice over. Coming as I do from a county for which figures were not given, I am aware that in Longford this Bill if it is passed will increase the rates next year by 3/6 in the £. If a rate is not struck to meet that amount it means that there will be a deficit. I am assuming that the amount for which the rates were struck this year will be paid. A rate for £5,000 was struck, leaving a debit of £10,000, and, adding approximately a similar amount next year, the total will be equivalent to a rate of 3/4 in the £. That will be the result in a county of small farmers, where they have always done their best and made every effort to meet their liabilities. I think that would be an outrage.

The Minister says that the Legislature has a right to interpret the law and to say what was the intention of the Oireachtas. I admit that would be right, provided it carried out that principle, but we find that if there is an increased imposition and that it will be a hardship upon the citizens, the Legislature will take no steps to remove that hardship. On the other hand, if it is found that the Legislature, by passing an Act, gives some advantage to the citizens or to the community, in steps the Government to take it away. It is only what benefits the community is to be amended. In that way the principle is not carried to a logical conclusion. Seeing that it has been the custom to leave what is a hardship upon the citizens, even where that was not the intention of the Legislature, if citizens get some advantage it should be left to them. The Minister stated that the citizens have got an advantage and that what he is trying to do is to save himself from spending money in the courts. In that case, people who want to avail of the courts to ascertain their rights should be able to do so. This legislation reminds me of something that was discussed in the debates on the Courts of Justice Bill. I told the Attorney-General that I knew of a case that went to the Court of Appeal where the person who was appealing said: "We will mend our hands and make a new case the next time." That is what this legislation is doing. The Minister tried his case with the Act that was supposed to re-establish the Guarantee Fund. He found that it did not do so, and he now comes here with an appeal by mending his hand and trying a new line. That is what he is doing, and it is something that the House should not approve of.

A county like Longford that is meeting its obligations as far as it can, and meeting them well as far as the rates are concerned, is now to be called upon to increase the rates by a substantial amount. If the council strikes the full amount that will be required it will represent approximately 3/6 in the £, plus other increased expenditure that will arise, and with the present rate of 11/3 in the £, Columcille's prophecy, to which Deputy McGovern referred recently in this House, will be nearly fulfilled, "the rates will be higher than the rents" and the farmers will not be able to pay them. That is the position we have under a Government whose representatives went to Ballinamuck in 1931 and told the people to support their families, to live reasonably well, and to let the sheriff and the rate collectors go to a hot place.

Comment on this

Deputy Victory went there.

Comment on this

Deputy Victory could not go to the county because he was in it. One of these people was an eminent lawyer and a member of this House. The two Deputies came to Ballinamuck and expressed these views. Therefore, I suggest that if we had a non-payment campaign, because a hardship is to be imposed on the county council, it was generated and developed by the Party that now forms the Government. There are people who will pay this imposition, but it will entail very great hardship that they will not easily overcome. I am satisfied that the House should not pass any retrospective legislation against its own citizens where admittedly they have got an advantage. It might be argued, of course, as the Minister stated, that it is better to mend your hand late than never. It is an extraordinary admission, that a Government has to mend its hand. Of course it has been proved that that is so for three or four years past in the case of several Acts. It is admitted by the bringing in of this Bill that citizens and the community got an advantage, but this House is now asked to take away that advantage, and it is going to increase the rates on honest as well as dishonest ratepayers, if such exist, in every county. Whether a county council was honest or not, this Bill will increase the rates definitely. A number of county councils, I submit, did not strike the necessary rate, as they believed that some county which was not controlled by Fianna Fáil would take the bit in its teeth against the Government. I admit that the Government was wise when the county council elections were being held, when they said they wanted to get control of the county councils and local bodies, because they would then have "yes, yes men" on them, who would do everything they were told.

Comment on this

Where did the voters come in?

Comment on this

What about the Cork promises?

Comment on this

Where did the voters come in at the local elections?

Comment on this

They were told that the economic war would be ended if they elected Fianna Fáil councils, and the Fianna Fáil Party developed and made full play of that in order to get control. What is the result? Have the county councils and the local authorities got the advantage? How far are they meeting your wishes? What you have got is a number of "yes, yes men" who are prepared to impose taxation on the ratepayers at the behest of the Minister for Finance who, by retrospective legislation, is to see to it that if they have not the courage to contest this within the next month they cannot do so. I say to the House and to Deputies on the opposite benches that this amendment should be supported and that they should show the courage of their convictions, because, in his heart of hearts, every one of them, including the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Finance, believes that this is not a Bill that should pass this House.

Comment on this

Might I ask how the Deputy knows what is in my heart of hearts?

Comment on this

The very same way as the President knows what the people of Ireland have in theirs—by looking into his own.

Comment on this

Then we both know.

Comment on this

There is a very simple question before the House: Do you or do you not believe in embezzlement? If this Bill is made retrospective, it is an act of embezzlement by the Executive Council. It is that and nothing else. County councils and, through them, the ratepayers, have by law the right to recover certain sums of money. Sums of money are payable to them under statutes passed by this Oireachtas. They have a vested right in these sums of money and the Executive Council, by this measure before the House and by this principle which is being debated on this amendment, ask from the House leave to embezzle sums of money which it is their duty to pay to the county councils. That is the plain, simple issue before the House, in this amendment—do you or do you not believe in the right of the Executive Council to embezzle money? It is upon that issue, like it or do not like it, because that is the real issue here, every Deputy in this House who votes must cast his vote.

It is an extraordinary principle, and I say, having listened to the Minister for Finance with great care, it is an unprecedented principle which this Bill embodies and which we wish to drive out from its confines by this amendment. It stands absolutely unprecedented. The Minister talked about the decision in the Performing Rights case; he talked about the decision in the Bray Urban Council case. The object of the legislation was to set up the decision of our courts. When there was anxiety to amend the legislation, it left the decision of the court untouched and did not take away any rights from any individual but it set up a right by legislation. The Minister, if you please, talked here, and, taking the extraordinary course, in order that he might gain publicity, of writing a letter to the Irish Times, quotes the fact that there was an Indemnity Act passed after the civil war had been dealt with. Of all the impertinences that could be given utterance to, the Minister and his colleagues talking of the Act of Indemnity after the civil war are guilty of the greatest possible impertinence.

What did the Act of Indemnity do? What did the whole course of action taken by the then Executive Council do? The present Executive Council— most of them, at any rate—and their friends had taken up arms against the Government of this country. They had endeavoured by force of arms to upset majority rule. They had become traitors to the State and to the Government which they now represent and traitors to the people of this country. Their lives even were then forfeited, and now, if you please, it is to be flung in the teeth of the men who were then members of the Executive Council that they did not put into force the laws of treason against those who had been guilty of treasonable offences against the State and with whose connivance and approval members of this House and other persons had been murdered. It is now to be put against the members of the Executive Council of that time that instead of enforcing the law in its full severity, they showed a magnanimity shown by very few Governments in the history of this world, and instead of putting into force the laws against the people who had broken the laws and who had endeavoured by force to disturb the foundations of this State, they preferred to walk the ways of clemency and to tread the paths of mercy.

That is supposed to be the precedent for the passing of this Bill which takes away from certain citizens of this State the moneys justly due to those citizens. I do not suppose anybody pays much attention to the Minister for Finance. I listened to him here to-day and it struck me that mentally he is something like an early 19th century young lady who has walked straight out of the pages of Jane Austen indulging in a fit of the vapours. That seems to me to be about the best description that could be given of the exhibition we saw by the Minister for Finance to-day. What he says on a question of law, however, is not a matter of very much importance, but I deal with the same matters when they are expressed by another person who is Attorney-General for the Irish Free State and whose views on law and on the interpretation of statutes must be treated, because of his high office, and, I will say, because of himself personally, with respect. But I must say that anything more astonishing than the views which were put forward by the Attorney-General I could not well imagine. If there is one thing which is clear, if there is one thing which is definite, it is that in the interpretation of our law, it is the expressed intention of the Legislature that can be looked to and nothing else. Where did the Attorney-General get his new canon of interpretation? What authority has the Attorney-General, or what authority can he quote to this House, for the view that in the interpretation of statutes in the future, you are not to look to the expressed opinion of the Oireachtas, within the four corners of a statute, but to interpret statutes by the speeches made by Ministers when introducing the Bills?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I will ask the Deputy to quote me because I think he is completely misquoting me. I think I said quite the opposite to what he suggests.

Comment on this

What the Minister said when introducing a Bill is not to be taken into consideration at all in interpreting statutes. There I am with the Attorney-General entirely, because the Oireachtas can speak with one voice only, and it does not matter one button what any Minister said when introducing a Bill. That is not the voice of the Oireachtas, because it can speak with only one voice. That voice is the statute, and in interpreting the statute, what the Minister or the Leader of the Opposition or any back bencher of the Fianna Fáil Party said is entitled to the same weight.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Would the Deputy quote me as saying anything different?

Comment on this

That is what I am saying.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Would the Deputy quote me?

Comment on this

The Attorney-General knows that we have not received the parliamentary reports. I listened to the Attorney-General's speech and that is what I understood him to say, unless my memory is terribly at fault. I heard him quote speeches made in the Seanad. For what purpose were they quoted?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

For this House.

Comment on this

They have absolutely nothing to do with the expressed opinion of this House. The Minister comes along with a pathetic complaint: "Why, when this Bill was introduced, was not its real meaning pointed out to me; why was I not told what was meant; why is it that I am left to find out its meaning when an action has been brought against me?" What duty of ours is it to instruct the Minister for Finance? What power have we to put brains into the head of the Minister for Finance? Yet, the Minister pathetically complains to-day of his deficiency of brains.

Comment on this

I should not ask the Deputy to share his poverty.

Comment on this

Will the Attorney-General or the Minister for Finance contradict me when I say that they stated that they had an intention in their minds which they were not able to express and that now they want to do by retrospective legislation what they intended to do in 1933 and make the position the same as if they had expressed what they wished to express in 1933? A general principle flows from their action on this Bill—that it is within their competence and it is even their duty, when they find that a statute has been interpreted by the courts in a manner different from that which they intended, to introduce retrospective legislation and render the position the same as if they had expressed themselves clearly and properly in the first instance. That is the general proposition over which the advocates of this Bill, which is retrospective, must stand. Let me give a concrete example to show how that principle will work. In introducing a similar Bill—the Land Act of 1933— the Minister in charge of the measure —the Minister for Defence—said:—

"We definitely state that, notwithstanding anything in this Bill or in any other Act, a man shall not be disturbed for any purpose other than the relief of congestion in the same locality in which the farm is situate or for the provision of sports fields,"

provided, as he says in another place,

"adequate employment is being given and the land, taking the situation of the whole country into consideration, is producing a sufficient amount of food supplies."

That is a clear statement of intention.

The Land Commission have interpreted that section in a different way. I myself was in a case in which a man from the neighbourhood of Tuam —near the beet factory—who was growing a large quantity of beet and wheat, had his land taken up, not because there was congestion in the immediate vicinity but because the sub-commission held—and there was no appeal from their finding—that it was quite sufficient if there was congestion in any other part of the country. There, the law is being interpreted in a manner different from that which was intended by the Minister and that interpretation has been acted upon in scores—I might say hundreds—of cases by the subcommission. If the Attorney-General is right, it is the duty of the Minister for Lands to introduce retrospective legislation now to give effect to his intention and to bring about the same position as if that intention had been embodied in the Act of 1933. If the Attorney-General is right, every acre of land which has been taken over through misinterpretation of this section should be restored to the owners. Every single person to whom this land has been distributed should, if the Attorney-General's contention is right, be dispossessed and a position should be created the same as if the Act had been worded as the Minister for Defence thought it was worded. That is an example. Men have obtained vested rights. If the Attorney-General is correct in his view, all these rights should be divested. If the Attorney-General is correct in his view, the title of every tenant who has had title vested in him through a misinterpretation of this statute should be divested. I put that example before the House to show the meaning of this principle—that it is right and proper when a mistake has been made—I assume for the purpose of argument that a mistake has been made—to set that mistake right, not from the date of the discovery, not as to future occurrences but so as to divest persons of rights acquired as a result of the mistake.

The county councils, in this instance, have acquired rights under statute to sums of money. These sums of money are being withheld from them. We have had some extraordinary arguments from the Minister for Finance. A strange argument seemed to have caught the attention of a Deputy whose name I do not know. He seldom intervenes in debates in this House but I presume he represents Leitrim. Why, he asked, should Leitrim be made to pay when it has paid its way? This charge would fall on the general taxpayer. Are there no persons who pay taxes except ratepayers? I should like to know if the Minister for Finance is a ratepayer in respect of agricultural land. Is the Attorney-General a ratepayer in respect of agricultural land? Is the Deputy who is so fond of interrupting—Deputy Kelly—a ratepayer in respect of agricultural land? Is even Deputy Donnelly a ratepayer in respect of agricultural land? I should like to know how many of the Fianna Fáil Front Bench pay rates on agricultural land. Yet, the extraordinary argument is put forward by the Minister for Finance that if the ratepayers of one county do not bear the burden, then the ratepayers of another county will have to bear it— and they alone. There is no sense in his argument otherwise.

Our contention is that those principles are wrong—those entirely new principles which this Bill introduces: one making it retrospective and the other making a selected number of taxpayers responsible for the non-payment of taxes by another. Those so-called annuities are not annuities in the proper sense. Those moneys do not go to pay off any sums which were borrowed for the purchase of land. They are taxes, and nothing else but ordinary taxes, and the principle that is sought to be set up here is the principle that the poor rates of the country are to be made liable for a deficiency in taxes payable to the State. That is an entirely unsound principle.

Then we have the argument of the Minister for Finance—and we had the same from the Minister for Education the other night—that the Irish farmers are a wretched, dishonest set of fellows; they will not pay. "Let us put it on the rates," said the Minister for Education the other night, "because the farmers are so cowardly and dishonest that they will not pay." The honest counties are to pay for the dishonest counties. Running through the speech of the Minister for Finance, there is the suggestion that those wretched, dishonest farmers do not want to pay their way. I remember some years ago there used to be a number of speakers sent over from this country to England, who were paid at the rate of 30/- a day to run down the people of this country, to attack the people of this country, and to abuse this country in every way in their power. Those men were nicknamed "the carrion crows." I had hoped that the breed was extinct, but I find it is not extinct. I found a couple of very finely developed carrion crows in the Executive Council. I found the Minister for Finance and I found the Minister for Education attacking and abusing and accusing of dishonesty the most honest section and the best section of the Irish people—the farming community. The Minister may keep running down the agricultural community of this country; he may call the agricultural community of this country people who will not meet their debts, but any person who knows this country knows that the agricultural community endeavours to pay its way, and knows that there would be no arrears of land annuities were it not for this Executive Council, which has exhausted the last resources of tyranny in collecting or endeavouring to collect from the agricultural community money which they have not got to pay.

The Executive Council should know, and this House should know, what the truth of the matter is, and that is that the Irish tenant farmer is as honest a man as there is in this world, and that those statements that the Irish tenant farmer is dishonest and unwilling to pay his debts are false. There was one course, and one course only, open to the Ministry here if they wished to act in accordance with precedent, and that course was to amend the law as from the present time. I would oppose them in amending the law, because the principle is wrong. The principle of making the poor rate liable for the non-payment of other classes of taxation is wrong, but the principle here is worse still, because it is coupled with the embezzlement from the people of this country by the Executive Government of sums of money which are payable by the Executive Government in relief of the rates, under laws which have been passed by this Oireachtas. We are asked to do all that to save the face of the Minister for Agriculture and to save the face of the Minister for Finance, this great Minister for Finance, who is so proud of his language, this petit amongst orators, this wretched poetaster among poets, who cannot understand the plain meaning of the words in which he wishes this House to embody the legislation that he asks this House to pass. This Bill, Sir, is a dishonest Bill. It is a Bill which is establishing two completely new, unsound and vicious principles, and if this Bill in its present form, or indeed in any form, passes this House, it will show that this House has no sense of right, no sense of justice, no respect for law, no respect for our courts, and no respect for its own dignity.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I think that the artificial heat which the Deputy has generated has somewhat clouded his reason. I think in the first place his memory is at fault as to what I said on the Second Reading. I do not know whether or not he was present in the House——

Comment on this

I was present during the whole of your speech.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I certainly did not intend to convey what the Deputy has now stated I did convey. I think, furthermore, that he has misunderstood the Minister. Apparently he has so much contempt for the Minister, his oratory, and his various failings that he becomes riled every time the Minister speaks. Anybody who has listened to the discussion on the Second Stage of this Bill, and to this discussion so far, I think, will agree with me when I say that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney has exaggerated beyond all reason the failings and faults of the House, and the possible sins of the Government in connection with this measure. I do not at all deny that the introduction of retrospective legislation is not a good practice, and I agree that it is one to be commended. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney has stated that the position is that if a Bill is introduced here and it turns out that, when it is interpreted in the courts, it does not exactly express the intention of the Legislature, a new principle is now being adopted whereby the Government will come back here and seek to have the legislation amended, and amended retrospectively, so as to deprive the successful litigant of any right which he may have succeeded in having vindicated in the courts. I suggest that that is a gross and deliberate exaggeration. Retrospective legislation, or legislation to clear up a doubt in past legislation, is, however, a step to be taken on the rarest of rare occasions. It is only justified in exceptional circumstances.

I do not at all say that this House is not justified in examining in the most critical way a measure which is designed to clear up ambiguity or to make clear something which an earlier piece of legislation had failed to make clear—at least to make it so clear that the courts would correctly interpret the intentions of the Legislature. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney seemed to suggest that I had advanced for the acceptance of this House a principle of interpretation binding the courts, namely, that they could look at the speeches delivered in this House in order to gather what were the intentions of the Legislature. I never intended to convey any such thing. Possibly my words may not have made my point clear. The very fact that we are bringing in such a measure shows that I could never have thought of such a thing. I merely read the speeches delivered in the Seanad by the Minister then in charge of the Bill—I think the Minister for Defence —and referred to the fact that the Seanad apparently interpreted the Bill as we have been interpreting it since its passage, as continuing the Guarantee Fund as a support to the Exchequer right to take over the annuities. It was so interpreted by the lawyers in the Seanad. So much was this the case that they actually framed an amendment designed to abolish the Guarantee Fund. They introduced that amendment designed to do something which Deputies say now was not necessary. That amendment was discussed in the Seanad and brought back to the House here, and after discussion in this House it was rejected by this House deliberately.

On the Second Reading I merely said that I thought, in this particular case and in exceptional cases such as this, the Government is entitled to come back to the Legislature and ask the Legislature to make clear what were its intentions when the original Bill was before the House. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney rants and raves here and we had several other speakers also working themselves into a frenzy about this being retrospective legislation. One would imagine that such legislation was being introduced for the first time. No reference is made to earlier pieces of retrospective legislation. There have been several. Some of them were defended on the grounds that nobody would question the propriety of a Government, after a period of difficulty and disturbance when it would find itself constrained to act quickly, to take certain measures in defence of itself, coming to the House subsequently and seeking ex post facto ratification by way, say of an Indemnity Act for what it had done.

I do not want to enter into a discussion of what did happen and about the parallel which can be drawn between the Indemnity Act and the present measure, but I would say to Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney that he forgets the fact that a good many of the sections in the Indemnity Act refer to steps which were taken under a resolution of this House. The resolution was passed in this House on the 22nd October, 1922, I think. When I say this House, I should say perhaps the Provisional Parliament. That resolution was passed although at that time it was open to the House to pass an Act. It deliberately refrained from passing an Act. It merely passed a resolution and it came back years afterwards to ratify its action by an Act in the Dáil—a step that could have been taken on the first occasion. However, I am not stressing that as a parallel. There have been several instances of legislation dealing with very minor matters. There have been in several finance measures sections introduced having retrospective effect, sections validating what had been the practice, sections introduced while cases were pending in the courts, dealing with the precise points at issue in the courts. That has been a feature of legislation here.

I accept whole-heartedly the principle that if by any chance individuals discover that they have certain rights under legislation and seek to have these rights vindicated in the courts, the Legislature should hesitate very much before it should interfere with these particular rights. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney must have been in this House on an occasion in 1930 when the then Minister for Finance, now Senator Blythe, said, on the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill, as reported in Vol. 39, column 1376-77:—

"We act really before there is a final determination as to what the law is on the matter.... As a matter of fact, both here and in England legislation has had to be introduced with retrospective effect.

"In the present year's Finance Bill in Great Britain, pending a decision of the final court, a section was introduced because they feared that a decision might be given which would have upset the practice as it had existed for 40 or 50 years. Before the court had announced its decision at all, a section was introduced to continue the existing practice if it proved to be necessary. You can get the most extraordinary results if the whole meaning of legislation is going to be revealed, by some court decision, to be entirely contrary to what was intended and to what it was always believed to be. In those cases, no injustice is done if what everybody has been doing is confirmed as right. In many cases a grave injustice would be done if the practice were entirely upset. Though certainly no injustice might be done in a high degree to individuals, a grave injustice might be done to the community as a whole."

I suggest to the House that this is an exceptional case, in which a certain practice has been followed by the Minister for Finance dealing with considerable sums of the taxpayers' money. A practice has been followed by him which was in line with the practice observed since the first time the Guarantee Fund was set up under the Land Act. I suggest that when the Act of 1933 was before the House, as a Bill, it was made clear by this House that it intended, notwithstanding the fact that there was a change in the destination of certain annuities, that the Guarantee Fund provisions should apply, that that practice has been followed by the Minister and that if that practice is now to be upset —by reason of the court's discovery that the House did not clearly express itself in the Bill, now the Act —a situation will arise which will make it necessary for the Minister to go to the general taxpayer to make good the deficiency which he is now making good by draws upon the Guarantee Fund. It is only in exceptional circumstances such as those that a Government would, I think, come to the House and ask for retrospective effect to be given to clear up the position while a case was pending in the courts, to have retrospective effect given to the interpretation upon which it has been acting and which everybody must admit who looks at the debates, was intended by this House should be contained in the legislation. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney worked himself up into a frenzy—in fact it was a regular crescendo while he was speaking—about the abuse of the honest farmer by the Minister and the Minister for Agriculture. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney can hardly have such a short memory if he was in the House, and I think he was, during the whole of the Second Reading discussion. If my recollection serves me right, the use of the words "honest" and "dishonest," particularly the word "dishonest," which roused the Deputy's wrath so much, came from opponents of this measure. It was trotted out as an argument against the Bill.

Comment on this

It came from the defender of the measure.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin was the first person who used it.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I may be wrong about the first person who used it, but my recollection is that it came first from the opponents of the measure who said it was unfair that the honest ratepayer should have to pay for his dishonest annuity-paying neighbour. That is how the use of the contrast between the dishonest and honest farmer ratepayer or annuity payer came to be used in the House. I think it is quite unnecessary and quite improper, but, of course, in this kind of a debate almost anything is fair.

Comment on this

Does the Attorney-General agree with the principle?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I believe that you must enable the Minister for Finance in some way to secure the payment of these moneys. If you are to abolish the Guarantee Fund provision, then the Minister must only have recourse to some other means of obtaining this money or depriving the county councils of it. There are other ways which the Minister could have availed of to prevent the county councils getting this money. If I am right, he need not have introduced some of the Votes unless he felt he had this Guarantee Fund to fall back upon. The last state would be as bad as the first. The machinery of the Guarantee Fund is, in a sense, I suppose, a sanction—whether a good one or not is a matter of opinion—to bring home to persons who are liable for annuities and to the ratepayers in a particular area that, if default is made in the payment in their particular county, the ratepayers in that county will suffer for it. The other alternative is to say that if the annuity payers are allowed to escape, or are able to evade payment, the general taxpayer should suffer. It is a choice between the two things. I cannot see how Deputies get out of that.

No Deputy who has spoken has yet said what is to be done to meet this deficiency. Some Deputies suggested that the Minister had in his hands machinery for the collection of these annuities and that he was not making full use of it—that the deficiency was due to the fact that the machinery was not being availed of. That sounds to me a most startling suggestion from any Deputy, considering the withering fire directed against the Government on several occasions about the use of the new powers which they took in that same Land Act, in Section 28, and the suggestion that they were behaving with the utmost cruelty in their attempts to collect the annuities. Deputies cannot have it both ways.

Another Deputy suggested that it was unfair to county councils that they should be made suffer for the non-payment of these annuities if they are not to be in the position of being assignees of the debt and allowed to collect it. No Deputy has come forward yet to make the practical suggestion that when they are called upon to suffer the loss in the amount which would be otherwise payable owing to default in payment of annuities the Land Commission should then assign to them these annuities and allow them to collect them. Apparently, that does not appeal to any county council. They are not prepared to undertake collection of the annuities, although that complaint was made.

Comment on this

They have no power.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I do not know that there is any other point that occurs to me in Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's speech that demands an answer. I suggest that a great deal of it was mere artificial froth, attempting to make political capital out of the situation by suggesting that something is being done contrary to all precedent, unjustified by any examples which could be quoted as a parallel to this, and that the Government was adopting some wholly new procedure and going about it in a wholly new way.

Comment on this

I admire and respect the Attorney-General more at the moment than I did heretofore. I must say that my respect for him has increased by the very apparent shame he displayed in having to stand over a Bill of this type; for his apologetic tone and confession that really, in fact, the principle contained in this Bill is definitely bad practice and the type of practice that should only be availed of in the rarest of rare circumstances. That is a very important admission from the principal law officer of this State. It is a very important confession from the Government Front Bench that the principle contained in this Bill is not one to be commended, that it is not good practice, and that it is the type of expedient that should only be utilised on the very rarest of occasions. Is it any wonder that for the first time in the history of this Dail you find lined up against this measure 100 per cent. of all the units and elements constituting this Dáil except one Party.

Comment on this

Except the majority.

Comment on this