We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Land Purchase (Guarantee Fund) Bill, 1935—Committee.

Contributions 168–338 of 494. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Land Purchase (Guarantee Fund) Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 39 of 1935 ›

We will come to that question of a majority and how a majority is reached. Is it reached by spokesmen who break their necks to get downstairs to find a "pair" to escape the shame of voting for this Bill? For the first time in the history of the Dáil you have all the Parties and elements other than the Government Party lined up. You have lined up at the outset the political Opposition, the whole weight of the Labour Party and, if it were not for the Party Whip, we could claim to have the Attorney-General lined up with us also. I think it is only fair, and it is due to the Attorney-General, that at least we pay our tribute of respect for the honesty he displayed in condemning that measure and for the shame he displayed in having to support it. We have this particular Bill, as its long title states, to remove any doubts that may arise as to the interpretation of the law, and we have had it introduced by a Minister who blatantly tells this House that the supreme authority is the authority of the Minister speaking on behalf of the majority. Now I think that was a statement in keeping with the whole tone of the Bill. It was the statement of a petty tyrant, a would-be dictator who writhes under the law of the equality of the humble and the great——

Comment on this

Will the Deputy quote the words he attributes to me?

Comment on this

The Minister knows that the Official Report will not be out until to-morrow. If I am misinterpreting the Minister I apologise. I can only, in the circumstances, give him my own recollection of his remarks. My recollection runs definitely along these lines—that not once but many times in the course of the Minister's opening statement he referred to the fact that a Minister speaking with a majority behind him——

Comment on this

Is competent to speak for the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

——that a Minister speaking with a majority behind him was the authority to decide.

Comment on this

Oh, no—was competent to speak for the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

Why, that statement is exactly on a par with the one I am quoting—that the only one competent to speak for the Oireachtas is a Minister with a majority behind him. The Oireachtas has not become a Single Chamber as yet. The Oireachtas at the present moment consists of the two Houses——

Comment on this

And the King.

Comment on this

Yes, two Houses and the King, who is served by the Ministers opposite. I think it was a thoroughly outrageous statement on the part of the Minister to make. It was a statement in keeping with the whole principle running through this Bill. The gravity of that statement is not, in my opinion, the financial injustice it will inflict on every county in the Saorstát. Its gravity is not in the heavy load that it is going to impose on the shoulders of the ratepayers, who are only a minority of the people. There may be something in the principle that if one section of the people goes bad and fails to pay that the people as a whole will have to make good. If that argument were advanced in favour of the principle that the taxpayer should make good the deficiency, there would be something in it. If it were the case of an extremely wealthy individual who occupies a room, say, in an hotel and can slip from one place to another, there would be something in making him pay. But under this Bill it is the people who are the poorest and the most hard hit at the moment who are the people specially selected to make up the deficiency.

The financial penalties imposed by this Bill are not its most serious aspect. The really serious aspect of the Bill is the precedent it creates and establishes. It is a fact that this Bill is a blatant defiance of the Irish courts. It is a brushing aside of the Irish courts. It is trampling on the Irish courts. The Attorney-General advances arguments here which, to my mind, would more properly be put in court. We can all surmise that the reason why they are advanced here rather than in court is that he knows the arguments are not in themselves sound. Remember the principle we are establishing here. What follows is that at any time a citizen or group of citizens think they find a loophole to escape from some Ministerial ultimatum and appeal to the Irish courts in order to settle the point beyond yea or nay, the Minister speaking on behalf of the majority will walk in here, click his fingers at the courts and tell us, in fact: "I do not care a fig what the law is on that point. We will settle the law and the doubts as to the law without the Irish courts."

Comment on this

Has it been done before?

Comment on this

The Deputy or any member of that Party is the last man who should attempt to do this and compare it with what was done in the case of the Privy Council. Whatever was done in that case of the Privy Council was done in defence of the findings of the Irish courts.

Comment on this

Was that the only case?

Comment on this

We have got in this country to train our people up in reliance on rather than in defiance of the courts. The precedents we are establishing here will live long after you and I are gone. Governments will come and go, Parties will disappear and be forgotten. The present Deputies will be gone and forgotten when this particular precedent will be used and abused by people hereafter. We have got to remember that. Young as this country is in its independence, young as this House is, we should lose money from both pockets before we take a hand or play a part in establishing dangerous precedents in this State. We have got to remember that we are living in a country whose history is interwoven with lawlessness, sometimes glorious and sometimes glorified, where the popular thing, the popular cause was the cause that was most lawless. Every one of us who sits in this House has that type of blood running all through his veins. We have got to legislate and mould our behaviour here along such a road as will drag the people back from the old hereditary tendencies. If the Government should get an awkward dot in the nose during a case in court and get that through a flaw in legislation or through an omission in the Act which provides the loophole for the annuitants to escape, even in such a case we should be very slow to rob that man or any man of the right of seeking guidance and a ruling from the courts.

What is done in the case of the county councils in this Bill can be done against any individual to-morrow, next month, or next year. Remember the real principle that is sticking out of this Bill is this: that when any individual challenges the Government in the Irish courts and is likely to win, a Minister, speaking on behalf of the majority, will come in here and lay down the law. What is the good in bleating about democracy and bleating about the equality of the people within the law if certain individuals are put over the law and if there is to be no fair hunt within the law. A régime sooner or later has got to be established in this country where the humblest person and the mightiest person in the land will be equal by the fact that they are both within the law, and that both will get the same race. How does that apply to this case? With a law made properly or improperly, carefully or carelessly, with the whole weight of hundreds of highly-paid officials behind you, you go down the country to collect your annuities from the hard-pressed people, not with the decree of the courts but with the Minister's writ in one hand and a machine-gun in the other. Between the two, the hard-pressed ratepayer sees a possible channel of escape by seeking the protection of the Irish courts, by asking that an Act if illegal will be defined as illegal and that a practice if unlawful will be defined by the courts as being unlawful. The response of the Government to that is to walk into the courts and say: "This is a frivolous action, it is factious, it is vexatious," and the answer of the courts is that it is neither frivolous, factious nor vexatious and the case at that stage goes against the Government. And the defiance and contempt of court is not just in the Bill itself; it is in the repetition by the Minister for Finance, in spite of the ruling of the courts, that the case is factious and vexatious. The Attorney-General remembers putting up that himself in the Irish courts, and he recollects the answer he got and now, apparently, the most expeditious and economical manner of setting and deciding legal doubts is by coming in here and listening to the Minister for Finance, speaking on behalf of the majority. What are the courts for, what is the law for, what are the judges for, if we have only to listen to the voice of the Minister speaking on behalf of the majority?

Comment on this

What is the Dáil for?

Comment on this

It is the duty of the Parliament to legislate, and it is the duty of the courts afterwards to interpret that legislation. It is never the function of the Parliament to interpret its own legislation. That is what the courts are for. The taxpayers are paying heavily for those courts. The people of the country are looking with hope and confidence to those courts. The courts were always a big, respected institution in this State. The very minute we have this kind of legislation pushed through the House by a Minister, speaking on behalf of a majority, who can respect them? Why should anybody respect an institution that has only the life of a mushroom from day to day? How can anybody with any intelligence——

Comment on this

The Deputy might prefer a dictatorship.

Comment on this

That is where we are driving, drifting to rapidly. The Second House is to go by Resolution; the courts are to go by the Minister, talking on behalf of a majority. The people in here and outside are not blind and the various elements other than those who are whipped behind at the crack of the whip can see where this legislation is pointing. Why should any business men or anybody else ever again risk money in a big legal case when a political ward heeler may pull a string and we will have a Minister talking on behalf of a majority telling the courts what the law is. No wonder the Attorney-General is ashamed. Any democrat, not to speak of a democratic lawyer, should be properly ashamed to have any hand, act or part in that type of legislation. Look at what the aim of the whole thing is. If certain people are unable to pay certain contributions into Government revenue—because that is what it amounts to now —by retrospective legislation a selected group of people will be called on to make good the amount, not all the people. If, as is suggested opposite, the deficiencies are due to dishonesty, to national crime and national sin, even assuming that they were correct, surely a nation must pay for its own crimes, for its own sins, and not a selected group of individuals.

Assuming, on the other hand, that the real truth of the situation is that some people are so bent or broken that they are no longer able to pay their contributions, then, if there is any legal way out—as every member of the Cork County Council unanimously conceded—they are entitled to get whatever benefit or whatever relief from pressure the laws of this State permit. But when they seek that relief, when they contribute their money in an attempt to make an escape through that door, they have the answer that the case does not matter, the verdict does not matter, and all that matters is the voice of the Minister speaking with the majority behind him.

I ask every Deputy in the House to remember this, that what is done to-day can be repeated next month, and what is done to-day in order to get the Government out of a difficult situation will most certainly be repeated every time a Government is in a difficult situation, and any time a body of men, a trades union, any group of taxpayers, any section of the community, find themselves armed with the law against the Government, as you had in this case, the Government will brush aside the courts, make a new law defining what the law is and give it retrospective application. I think even at this stage of the Bill the Ministry should pause. This Bill is bad and it will be evil in its results; but the real gravity of it is the weapon that it puts into the hands of further Governments in this country.

You saw in connection with this Bill the delving that was indulged in for a precedent, for anything that could be claimed to be parallel to what they are attempting to do. You can see the value in the hands of legislators of a precedent for what they are doing. Should this Bill go through, successive Governments will not have to dig or delve to find a precedent for any evil act they want to commit in order to deprive the public of the benefit of having courts to protect it. The precedent will be there and it will be created by the votes of people who call themselves Irish democrats. That is the problem inside, but the problem outside will be how any of us can go outside after the Bill becomes law and preach to anybody respect for the law or reliance on the courts. A happy country is a country where, next to God, the greatest power is the power of the law and the greatest evil, next to godlessness, that could inflict any country is lawlessness; and the way to bring about lawlessness is to undermine respect for the law or the authority of the law or the extent to which people rely on the law. Once this Bill becomes law, once that precedent becomes the established practice, once that weapon is placed in the hands of any group who happen to sit over there, what is the use of anybody preaching reliance on the law?

What is the use of anybody talking, or attempting to glorify the authority of the law? What is the use of anybody preaching respect for the law? Humbugs we would be to preach respect for the law if we have no respect for it ourselves. Humbugs we would be to tell people to rely upon the law, if we were to snatch the protection of the law from them when they attempted to rely upon it. The first law officer—the Attorney-General—was merely apologetic when he spoke on this matter; he was merely ashamed. He should have spoken right out for the case of those who are attacking the attackers of the law. He should be their champion in opposition to those who advocate this particular type of administration. Better than any of us he knows the dangers, and he knows the manner in which a Bill of this kind can be used afterwards. Better than any of us he knows how dangerous it is to establish the kind of precedent now proposed to be established by the Government in this country. It is an insensate effort to have a political crow over two county councils.

The authority of the law is to go. The supremacy of the courts is to go, so as to have a political crow over a couple of Irish county councils. Have we nothing better to do than that? Have we nothing better to do in this place than to use the Parliament of this country in order to snatch the protection of the law from the county councils of this country? Is it not really a thing, when you think it out, that we would be thoroughly ashamed of being associated with? We are told that when the Minister speaks he has a majority behind him. Has he a majority behind him in this case? Is the majority of this House so devoid of conscience and a sense of fair play that when a humble body appears to get the best of the Government in the Irish courts, they should be deprived of the benefit of their test case? How many people opposite who voted for this Bill would vote for it if it was left to a free vote of the House? The real test, of whether there is a majority behind this Bill, would be by allowing Deputies to give a free vote in this House. It is being made a test of Party discipline. I respect Party discipline, but I do not think it is fair when doing injustice to the people of this country, and when you are doing harm to the future, that you should brag about a majority that can only be secured by the rigid use of the Party Whips. If the Minister is so sure of his Party majority behind him, would he not risk a free vote of the House upon this amendment? The Bill can alter the law for the future, but this amendment merely deals with the past. Would the Minister submit to that test whether he has a majority or not?

After all, none of us can divide himself into two. There are people on the Government side of the House, when no Party Whips were cracking, who honestly did justice by their county men, and the body they belonged to, when they gave their assent to the case being tested in law. There their consciences spoke; the individual spoke; men with free minds spoke and acted. Those same individuals come up here, and tramp the stairs to the Division Lobbies against the action they took in their own areas. Is that fair to those individuals? Would it not be more reasonable, if the Government are so sure of their majority, to leave this amendment to the free vote of the House? I tell the Minister that if he left it to the free vote of the House, and got a majority, then he would be in a position really to claim that the majority of the House, as individuals, acting according to their consciences, were in favour of this Bill. The Minister knows that is not so. The Attorney-General knows it is not so.

This type of legislation is bad in itself. It will be evil in its results. It will provide an excuse for anybody who follows the path of lawlessness, in this country, if this Bill is passed. It will be a justification for anybody who says: "You need not go to the courts because the courts cannot be relied upon; because there is a political junta that will overrule them." The evil that will be done if this Bill is passed is of a type that will grow each year. This House should aim at building up rather than destroying. But the whole trend of Government policy, latterly, is to destroy and replace by nothing. So in the long run we shall see come to pass what the Minister talked of in his opening speech, namely, that the only authority worth relying upon, or taking account of, is that he has a majority behind him.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance, with all the pomp and authority he carries with him, got up in this House on Thursday last and deliberately accused me of having made a dishonest speech in opposition to this Bill, and he proceeded—I shall quote his words —to try to justify that allegation. He said: "The Deputy stood up with the decision of his Party in his pocket and he knew in speaking that no matter what he (the Minister) said it would not change his mind on the matter." Are we to understand by that kind of argument that the Minister has come to the conclusion that the majority of Deputies sitting on those benches, and who have sat here since 1922, are incapable of realising, or understanding, the implications of a measure of this kind? I sat here with the majority of those here now, during the discussions on the Indemnity Act, or Bill, as it was at that time. Those who put forward that measure put it forward for the purpose of giving legal sanction to things already done, with, or without, the authority of the Government of the day during the civil war period. Does the Minister contend that there is any comparison of any kind between the Indemnity Act of 1923 and the measure now before the House? Has the leader-writer of the Irish Times, who apparently is the new-found friend of the Minister for Finance persuaded him that the members of this Party would vote for anything or everything put forward by the Minister regardless of the consequences of such measures? I have been reading the articles in the Irish Times, and I would like to hear from the Minister for Finance the reason for the conversion of the gentleman who writes these articles. I know many of his articles slander the members of this Party, but I would like to know what is the Minister's standard of honesty in politics?

The Minister is entitled, more than I am or more than any ordinary member in this House, to a Christmas holiday. I hope he will enjoy it, and that during the Christmas holidays, if he thinks of politics, if he has any spare time to refresh his memory on things that happened when he was not here and on things that happened when he was in opposition, he will read his own speeches in connection with the Landlords and Tenants Bill of 1931 and the reasons given for supporting 87 amendments to that Bill at that time. I hope that he will compare them with the dishonest excuse which he gave last week to the Ard Fheis for refusing to bring forward a Town Tenants Bill now when he has the power to do so. Is that the standard of honesty the Minister stands for?

I am glad that the Minister has read out in this House figures in connection with the arrears due by the various counties, and I am glad to have the privilege of speaking here as a native of the County Laoighis. I am glad to accept his figures and claim that that county stands one of the highest counties on the list of those which have proved their honesty to this Government since it came into office. The proof of their honesty is that, at a particular period, the 31st July this year, they only owed 25 per cent. of the amount due. That is due by people who, in my opinion, are honestly unable to pay. I speak here in this House, not as one who gave any encouragement to the non-payment of land annuities. I speak here —and the Minister knows it perfectly well, and if he does not know it he can find it out from the Minister for Agriculture and from the Minister for Lands and Forestry, or from others of his colleagues—as one who did my best to give every encouragement, both verbal encouragement and encouragement other than verbal, to my friends and relatives and other supporters of mine to pay their way even if they found it difficult to do so. On the records of the Land Commission there is proof that I gave more than verbal encouragement to my friends to do that, and I know that the records will show that there are other Deputies in this House who did the same—gave more than verbal encouragement to their friends to pay their way, and I hope the Minister understands what I mean by that. One would think, from the Minister's attitude and from his speeches during recent times, that it is an injury to public credit to criticise constructively the Minister himself. I never saw such a jack-in-the-box exhibition as was given here the other evening by the Minister in moving the Second Reading of this Bill. The Minister gave such an exhibition that he drove every one of the members of his own Party, except five, out of the House. He even drove Deputy Corry—he was so ashamed of the Bill—into the lobby to look for someone to pair with him rather than have to vote for this Bill. Is that honest or dishonest, or is it a fact or is it a lie?

Those of us who were members of this Party since 1922 are quite capable of summing up the meaning of a measure of this kind, and quite incapable of being misled by the Minister's dishonest argument that he compares this Bill with the 1923 Indemnity Act. There is no precedent since this House was set up for this particular measure. Give me the name of a Bill that was brought into this House since this House was set up which purported to set aside the decision of a court after a case is brought to court and while the case is still at hearing and before a decision is given by the judges. The Indemnity Act is certainly not one of those that would bear comparison with this particular measure.

Comment on this

Does this Bill do that?

Comment on this

This Bill has been introduced into this House since a certain case was brought before the courts of this country; and after a certain opinion had been expressed on the measure by a certain judge, who is paid by this Government to do his duty impartially. The Minister knows perfectly well that the hearing has not concluded, but before the judge can hear the case the Minister brings in this Bill as a sort of blackthorn stick to bully the judge or judges that may be called upon to give an impartial hearing on the case at hearing. Is that a fact or is it not a fact? The Minister, of course, says that we should have waited for his Second Reading speech in order to hear the real case in support of this measure. Now, I admitted the other day, and I say it again to-day, that we had come to a Party decision on the matter. I give my colleagues credit for having some common sense, and I hold that with our experience—an experience longer than that of the Minister—we are capable of understanding the meaning of a measure of this kind; and, having understood the meaning and implication of the measure, after careful consideration we did come—I present the fact to the Minister—to a decision. We did come to a decision, but I think that if we had waited for the Minister's Second Reading speech, as he suggests we should have done, it would have only meant this: that it would have enabled us, at any rate, to come to a decision sooner than we did.

Comment on this

Of course, they all came in with their minds free!

Comment on this

Whether they came in with their minds free or not, the whole lot of them became so alarmed that they all cleared out, with the exception of five.

Comment on this

Five good men and true.

Comment on this

I am afraid I shall have to take the Deputy's word for that, but I shall pay this compliment to Deputy Tom Kelly: that he sits here all the time listening to everything, and i know that he was one of the five—the Big Five.

Comment on this

The mention of that was too much for him.

Comment on this

We oppose this Bill because it is without precedent, because it is an attempt to interfere with the impartial judgment of our judges upon a matter of prime importance to the people of the country as a whole. What did the Minister say to-day when speaking against this particular amendment? He said that it was brought in for the purpose of preventing the ratepayers from wasting their money and preventing the judges, if you please, from wasting their time. Is the Minister a good judge of whether the judges are wasting their time or earning their money, and what right, so far, has the Minister to express opinions on these matters? If you have no confidence in the judges who are there to administer the laws we make, then sack them. The Minister for Justice came in the other day to this House and said that he had no power over judges who would not do their duty. I suggest that judges who acted in that manner should have been brought before the Military Tribunal, and probably they would have been dealt with much quicker than have been the cases which have come before them recently. The Minister for Finance himself is not a good judge of the ability or inability, of the willingness or unwillingness, of the people of this country to pay the land annuities. I claim to be a better judge of the position in my constituency than the Minister is, in matters of that kind. There has been no organised agitation in my constituency against the payment of annuities. There was an attempt in the earlier stages by some of the people in my area to lie quiet and to lie low and go slow in the matter of paying the annuities. Again, the Minister can find out from some of his colleagues what my attitude was on these matters at the time.

Comment on this

And then a commissioner was sent down.

Comment on this

Deputy Donnelly says that a commissioner was sent down, but Deputy Donnelly knows quite well that he has nothing whatever to do with the collection of land annuities. That is one of my reasons—one of my two reasons—for opposing this Bill. I understand that, when the Agricultural Grant is being allocated for the relief of rates, the relief only goes to the relief of rates on agricultural land. I also understand—and I want to be corrected on this if I am wrong—that when the county authority, who is the Commissioner for Laoighis, to whom Deputy Donnelly refers, in this case, is compelled by order of the Government to make up the amount of the deficiency, he then is compelled, as all local bodies are, to increase the rates on all the people in that county regardless of those who occupy land or otherwise.

Does the Minister for Finance know that, and, if he does, why did he make the ridiculous statement that he made in support of the Second Reading of the measure by asking whether we want him, as an alternative, to penalise the poor for the sake of the rich? Is it not a fact that every cottage tenant in this country and every small farmer —I speak for the small farmers of my constituency 75 per cent. of whom have paid their annuities this year—will have to make up next year the amount of the deficiency in that county? If the Minister for Finance does not know that, then I suggest to him that he should send for the Minister for Local Government and ask him to educate him with regard to the operation of this Guarantee Fund and of the unfairness of this measure towards the small-holders in Donegal and in every other part of the Free State who pay their way.

The Minister talks about the small-holders in Donegal and Timbuctoo paying for the bad debts of the people in the County Cork. I had nothing to do with the organisation of that campaign in the County Cork. I know that there was an organisation there at one time for the purpose of preventing people or, at least, of encouraging them not to pay their annuities. The Minister for Finance also said—I suggest it was bluff on his part—that the only alternative to this measure was to increase direct taxation upon the poorest of the poor. But, before he sat down, he said that they had smashed this organisation that had been started against the payment of the land annuities, and that the payment of them was now going on in the normal way. If that is so, how is this increase in taxation going to be justified and why is this Bill brought in? I suggest that it is all bunkum. It is bluff, double bluff and treble bluff. We get a good deal of bluff from the Minister on occasions here, but he is not going to get away with it this time. I want to say at once that I prefer this Government in office to the Party that now sits in opposition.

Comment on this

We settled that at the last election.

Comment on this

I hope I am charitable to Deputy Donnelly when I say that before the next election he will have carried out all his promises. Look up the records of the divisions that have taken place in this House, and there you will get proof of who put the Minister sitting where he is to-day. It was not Deputy Donnelly, but the seven of us who sit here. I had the duty cast upon me in my constituency of defending the policy of this Government and of all its works and pomps when some of those who sit in the Government Party were silent, or, at any rate, would not do so.

Comment on this

That was a terrible responsibility.

Comment on this

It was a tough job.

Comment on this

The Deputy will not do it again.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy now making his recantation?

Comment on this

No, but I claim the freedom, and have the freedom, to vote on all measures in this House on their merits. I challenge contradiction on this: that I raised the question of the operation of the Guarantee Fund on the relevant section of the Land Bill of 1933 when it was being discussed on Committee in the House. I protested against it then and I protest now, seeing that the Land Commission annuities are now part and parcel of the revenue of this country. I protested against a continuance of the existing procedure which attempts to penalise the honest people of the country, and, which, in my opinion, is one of the things that have helped to increase the number of people who have not paid and do not want to pay. Take the case of the hard-working honest people in my constituency who are paying. Could there be anything more demoralising than for these people to see their neighbours, who are not paying, getting away with it? These honest, hardworking people have paid this year, and, next year, they will have to pay an increased rate to make good the default of those who could pay and would not pay.

If the land annuities are not being collected, why does not the Minister use the machinery of the central government for the collection of them, the machinery that he employs where income tax and excise duty, or any other direct tax, is not being paid? It is his duty to find some better way than the way that he proposes in this Bill to make good the deficiency. It is certainly a wrong thing to make the local authorities responsible for the collection of the annuities. It is not fair to make the honest ratepayers pay, in the following year, for those who, perhaps, could pay and would not pay in the previous year.

That is my attitude on this Bill and I stand or fall on that. I raised this matter before on the Second Reading of the Finance Bill for this year. When the President came into the House he dealt with it, and said it was a matter for serious consideration. I wondered, when I heard the Minister for Finance speak on the Second Reading of this Bill, what amount of consideration has been given to this unfair procedure since the President made that statement in the Dáil. Has there been any consideration given to it except the consideration which prompted the Minister to take the hasty action that he has taken to prevent the ratepayers of this country from getting the benefit of the law. The only place that they can get the benefit of the law is in the courts, set up by the Oireachtas, from the impartial judges appointed to administer the law. Would the Minister explain to me what is the difference between the land annuities and income tax or excise duty? I say that the threat made by the Minister is all bluff: the threat to increase direct taxation if he is not able to recover the full amount of the land annuities. When income tax payers in Leix or Offaly fail to pay their income tax who makes good the deficiency? The land annuities are now part and parcel of the revenue of this country, and, again, I ask would the Minister explain what is the difference between the land annuities and income tax, excise duty or any other form of direct taxation that has to be collected from any and every section of the community?

The threat of economies in salaries and of an increase in the price of food is, I suggest, all so much dishonest political window-dressing employed to mislead the people and intended to carry them away from the real meaning of this measure. We had a lesson in the meaning of this kind of legislation long before the Minister ever dreamt of coming into this House: at a time when the Minister was afraid to come into the House or would not come in. The experience that we had then makes us realise the serious consequences of a measure of this kind. It is much more serious in its import than any of those which were mentioned by the Minister. Personally, I do not mind in the least what the Minister said about my speech on the Second Reading of this measure, as to whether it was honest or dishonest. What the Minister said about me will not matter a thraneen to the people of my constituency, and it is to them that I am responsible. As long as I am honoured by being elected here as their representative, I will vote against legislation, and especially legislation coming from a Government that I had some responsibility for putting into office, that would put a premium on dishonesty. I will never vote for a Bill of this kind or for that type of legislation.

Comment on this

I have heard this Bill discussed a good deal through the country, and I find that it is one of the most unpopular measures that have ever been introduced. I was pleased to hear the references that were made to it by the members of the Fine Gael Party. I gathered from their speeches that their object is to try and extricate the farmers of the country from the quagmire of economic ruin in which they now find themselves, but I suggest to the members of the Opposition that they have just as much responsibility for the position in which the farmers now find themselves as the Government in office. During the whole of the period that the Opposition formed the Government of this country they took very little interest in the farming community. They allowed the farmers gradually to sink deeper and deeper into the state of bankruptcy in which they now find themselves.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is this relevant to the amendment before the House?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has not gone very far yet.

Comment on this

If the Deputy would allow me to develop my argument perhaps he might be of a different opinion by the time I have concluded. In withholding the agricultural grant, amounting to £716,000, for which the present Government now seeks legislation, I consider that to be the last straw on the ratepayers and farmers. It has been stated on all sides that farmers have been going through a terrible hard time during the last two or three years. They have borne the burden of the economic war without assistance from any class in the community. Where is the responsibility going to be placed if this Bill becomes an Act? On whose shoulders will the burden be placed? Will it not be placed on the county councils who are responsible for the collection of the rates? In my opinion if that happens every honest person will be made a defaulter. If they become defaulters how in the name of heavens is the Government going to collect the annuities and the rates? Do they expect people who pay the annuities and the rates to turn around and to bring the bailiffs on their neighbours and to seize their cattle because of default in the payment of annuities and rates? One of the greatest mistakes made since the Government became a Government was to place this burden of taxation on a people who, at the present time, are groaning under the weight of taxation. In my opinion it would be well for the Government to withdraw this Bill. By doing so, the farming community will be given an opportunity of carrying on, and of honouring their obligations and trying to pay rates and annuities. It should be remembered that no class works so hard, from morning to night, under adverse conditions, as the farming community. In fact, they are slaves from the time they are born until they go to the grave. To suggest that the farming community is dishonest is to create a false impression, because there is no more honest or hardworking people in the community. They are in difficulties, but they are trying to pay their way. No one would like to see the sheriff's officers or the cattle waggons going into farmers' yards if it could be avoided How are they going to continue to be honest? If this Bill becomes law it will make everybody dishonest in the eyes of the Government and it will mean the breaking up of the farming community, because it will reduce them to poverty and misery from which it will take them generations to recover.

Comment on this
Hugh Victor Flinn Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Flinn) Fianna Fáil

The whole atmosphere of this debate can be summed up by the single phrase used by Deputy Kent, when he said that the farmers of Ireland were slaves from the cradle to the grave. In other words, Deputy Kent summed up the whole spirit of grave and deliberate exaggeration which was evident in every speech against the Bill. Deputy Kent does not believe that every farmer in Ireland from the cradle to the grave is a slave. No man who examines the economic agricultural position in Ireland would dare to say anything of that kind, if he desired to have any reputation amongst his fellow-men as a reasonable man. Take the line from Monaghan to Limerick, and from Limerick south to the Old Head of Kinsale. There is no low valuation land east of that line. There is no man practically, and certainly no electoral area in any county, and no recognisable geographical unit which could be selected in that area of which that could be said with truth. There is not any truth whatever in the suggestion that the Deputy has made. If you take the other area west of that line you will find places in which farming is a heroism and the continuance of human life a miracle. These are not the people who are kicking up this row; and they are not the people who are in arrears with their annuities. These are not the people who are trying to hand on their obligations to someone else. I am deliberately raising that point of exaggeration because I think it is time we got back to something like a perspective in the matter of this Bill. In my opinion there was one good speech delivered on the Second Reading, and that was by the Chairman of the Cork County Council, Deputy Broderick. There was not another speech which had any matter of any sort which was worthy of any respect. But Deputy Broderick's speech had nothing to do with the Bill. It was a speech which, in my opinion, could very properly and very valuably be delivered if the question before the House was that the law should be altered. That is not the question before the House.

The second line of country that we had here is fairly well represented by Deputy O'Higgins, who had no use for a majority, and who poured contempt on majority in every possible form so long as it was expressed through this House. Unfortunately we are the heirs of our predecessors. We live within their precedent and, to some extent, are bound by their bad custom. A precedent which is made is made, and nothing that happens afterwards will remove it. The first time a thing is done it is done. You may strengthen it by a second or a third performance of the same act, but it is the first doing of the act that makes a precedent from which there is no escape. For anyone with any respect for his own reputation to say that there is no precedent in this House for the interpretation of the law by this House; that there is no precedent in this House for overruling a decision given by a court and declaring it to be wrong from the beginning, is absolute nonsense. To say that there has been no interference with the court during the actual time it was trying a case is also not a fact. Deputy Davin put up to me the problem of finding one single Act which covered all the possible indignities, if you like to use the term, which a legislative assembly can put upon a court, one single Act that would contain the whole of them. There is not such an Act, but there is no indignity as far as I know in relation to the authority of a court which this Dáil has not already accomplished. I believe as a rule in painting on small canvases. I believe that small incidents which do not contain the elements of passion and prejudice can illustrate a principle as well as, or better than, those which do regiment passions in that manner. There was the case of a man who, on interlocutory motion, went to a court in Ireland in relation to the patent on a lamp—not a very important thing. The judge on that motion, an entirely preliminary motion, declared the law to be of a certain character and hot-foot the then Minister for Justice, without waiting to reduce the Act even to a title, came down and told the House that if the black flag of piracy—that was his phrase—which had been raised in that preliminary decision was not pulled down by a further court, it would be pulled down by this House.

Comment on this

I suppose you have a quotation for that?

Comment on this

I will get it later.

Comment on this

It is wrong.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

Obiter.

Comment on this

Quite definitely, you have not got the quotation. There is a rule in this House that when a member purports to quote, he shall give the quotation, the ipsissima verba of it. I want to get that quotation.

Comment on this

We will find the ipsissima verba later. You are not going to get it now.

Comment on this

Are we to understand that the Parliamentary Secretary is withdrawing that phrase?

Comment on this

I am withdrawing nothing.

Comment on this

It is the practice of this House that when a phrase is given purporting to be a quotation, the phrase ought to be given accurately. Can we have the quotation?

Comment on this

When did the Deputy become Ceann Comhairle?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

He is entitled to make a point of order.

Comment on this

Can we have the date? I suggest that that is entirely the practice of the House, as is well known over there. Can we have the quotation, the date and the record?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not quite sure—perhaps the Deputy would remind me—as to when that rule was made. I know there is a practice that when a Deputy purports to quote, he gives the reference to what he is quoting from so that it can be examined and verified.

Comment on this

If we are to take it that this is not a quotation, I pass on, but it was given as such.

Comment on this

It is a perfectly honest and full summary of the spirit in which it was done.

Comment on this

I suggest the Parliamentary Secretary has now brought himself within the rule. Can we get the reference to the quotation?

Comment on this

This is not the end of it——

Comment on this

Again, on a point of order. May we get the reference to the quotation in order that we can have the matter discussed properly?

Comment on this

That is so, as far as my recollection goes.

Comment on this

It is wrong.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Parliamentary Secretary purporting to quote the exact words?

Comment on this

No, Sir.

Comment on this

Let him go on now. We have nailed him on that.

Comment on this

It is very good of the Deputy to allow me to proceed.

Comment on this

But not to proceed with dishonesty. Proceed with honesty.

Comment on this

The Deputy is a judge.

Comment on this

I am not in the Criminal Court, so I am not over you.

Comment on this

We had another case which did not regiment dangerous public feeling, and that was the case of the Local Authorities (Mutual Assurance) Bill. The Oireachtas passed an Act for a specific purpose— the specific purpose of enabling a particular company to be registered and to function without putting up £20,000. That was the declared purpose and intention of that Act. After this Act had been in operation for some considerable time, certain other insurance interests in this country that did not see why this particular company should be privileged in that matter, went to the courts and the courts decided that the Act did not in fact do what it set out to do, and the Oireachtas passed a law stating that the law is, and always has been, what the court said it was not.

Comment on this

That again is not a quotation?

Comment on this

Let us take another case. You have the Finance Act of 1929. Why I have tried to put things in a quieter and more moderate tone is because I think that a case can be made for something entirely different from what is being contended here to-day, and that those two things are being confused. If, for instance, someone were to get up here and speak to a resolution that retrospective legislation should not ever be part of the machinery of this Dáil, a good many of the speeches, which in my opinion have been irrelevant in that matter, would then be relevant and there would be a great deal to be said for it. What I am going to say to the House now is what we have already said. When these precedents were being made, we were not silent. We tried to prevent these precedents being made, and after they had been made, when one after another these recurrent precedents were put before the House, appeals were made to those who were then responsible for the Government——

Comment on this

Does this apply to the Indemnity Bill?

Comment on this

I could not tell the Deputy, but I will go into that later.

Comment on this

He was in the hills then.

Comment on this

We will take the Finance Act of 1931, which used these same words "to remove doubts" and, speaking on this matter, I said:

"This is not to remove doubts; it is to alter the law and to alter it retrospectively.... Why I am taking this point is this: we have had those particular phrases included in other Bills. If they had not been included in other Bills I would ask the House to fight them word by word and line by line. Once you have included in any Act those words every contract which has been made by this State of every sort and kind, big and small, with individuals or with larger bodies, is at the disposal of the majority of this House. A precedent has been made, unfortunately, and you cannot get away from precedents. Retrospective legislation means that every pension which is paid in this country can be abolished under exactly the same power. The security of tenure of every civil servant can be abolished under that power. Every contract of every sort and kind which the State has made with an individual or which individuals have been enabled under the law of this State to make with each other can be declared to have been null and void from the beginning."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What is the Parliamentary Secretary quoting from?

Comment on this

I am quoting from the debate on the Finance Act, 1931, Volume 30, column 1638. In the face of that, for anyone to say that the position in which we are to-day, dealing with retrospective legislation, is unprecedented is to talk nonsense and to know that he is talking nonsense. It was suggested by Deputy O'Higgins that no retrospective legislation had been passed, or should be passed, which would affect existing rights. He used very elaborate phrases. Here is the last clause of the Copyright (Preservation) Act, 1929, and its caption is "Prohibition of remedies for past infringements." That could not be any clearer.

Comment on this

Read the clause.

Comment on this

Here it is:

Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, no remedy or relief, whether by way of damages, injunction, costs, expenses or otherwise, shall be recoverable or granted in respect or by reason of an infringement in Saorstát Eireann before the passing of this Act of a copyright by this Act declared to subsist or deemed to have subsisted in Saorstát Eireann.

Comment on this

I think there is more than that.

Comment on this

That is the whole of it. In case the Deputy may have any doubts, I was wrong in saying that that was the last clause. There is another clause, Clause 5, which states: "This Act may be cited as the Copyright (Preservation) Act, 1929."

Comment on this

Do you know the meaning of the clause you are after reading?

Comment on this

You will have an opportunity of interpreting it.

Comment on this

I should like to have your view of it.

Comment on this

My view is that it is a prohibition of remedies for past infringements.

Comment on this

Of what?

Comment on this

Of this Act, if you like.

Comment on this

Not at all—of a right deemed to subsist by that Act but which the court found not to exist.

Comment on this

Perfectly right—a prohibition of remedies for past infringements. I take up a point raised by Deputy Davin, not for the sake of the heat of the matter but for its significance and importance. He referred to the Indemnity Act of 1923.

Comment on this

The Minister did.

Comment on this

You asked what we had to say about it. If you do not want me to say anything about it, I shall not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If we had less of the second person, the proceedings would be more orderly.

Comment on this

I was trying to be nice, kind and gentle to the Deputy.

Comment on this

Thanks very much.

Comment on this

I am not asking you to walk up any by-way with me, as in the case of Deputy Curran. One of the things that the Indemnity Act claimed to legalise was the execution, as it was called, of Rory O'Connor and Liam Mellowes. The day after that had been done, there was read out in this House a statement of the reasons why it had been done. That written statement is an indictment for murder of those who executed.

Comment on this

At a time when there was respect for the courts.

Comment on this

There is no question whatever in my mind that the mere production of that document in court would have rendered the people who so executed liable to a charge of, and, in my opinion, to conviction for, murder. Is that small matter not to be regarded as a precedent?

Comment on this

What is the comparison with this Bill?

Comment on this

This Bill is much more dreadful than that. I want to understand Deputy Davin's position, because he, with five or six others—I forget how many—went into the Division Lobby to help to make the total of 63. I am inclined to think that there is a difference of attitude of mind between Deputy Davin and some of those with whom he went into the Lobby—not of his own Party. I want to get that clear, if I can. The position of Deputies opposite is that the people who have not paid annuities should not have those annuities extracted from them. I think the position of Deputy Davin is different.

Comment on this

He said they could not pay in Laoighis-Offaly.

Comment on this

If there is one person in the world who could not help me, it is Deputy MacDermot. What has happened? A minority of 63 in the Division Lobby is made up of two sets of people who go into it for diametrically opposite reasons. I understand that Deputy Davin thinks that some intensive enforcement measures should have been used by somebody to get in the annuities.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy quote me correctly?

Comment on this

I am merely trying to understand the Deputy.

Comment on this

I did not say any such thing.

Comment on this

I am very anxious to find out what the Deputy does mean. What was his reason for going into the Division Lobby? I shall give way to him while he tells me.

Comment on this

The explanation was given last day and to-day.

Comment on this

What I understand is that the Deputy thinks there was other machinery by which these payments could have been enforced. Do I misunderstand the Deputy?

Comment on this

You can understand or misunderstand me as you please. You will find what I said in the Official Debates. I said that I never supported a no-rent campaign and that I never will. I also said that I would not vote for a Bill which puts a premium on dishonesty.

Comment on this

This Bill does not put a premium on dishonesty.

Comment on this

It certainly does.

Comment on this

The Deputy will allow me to discuss the question as to whether it does or does not. Let us take the statement which Deputy MacDermot has hurried out of its place. Deputy MacDermot would have been much wiser to leave that alone for a few minutes. Deputy Davin says that the people in Laoighis who have not paid cannot pay. Does he require any further activity, from the point of view of the Government, in relation to those who cannot pay? He does not. Therefore, there is going to be a deficit. That is what I wanted to get. There is going to be a deficit.

Comment on this

It would be less than Cork, anyway.

Comment on this

Now we are getting off the point.

Comment on this

We are getting back to the real point.

Comment on this

I am prepared to go to Cork quite willingly. There is going to be a deficit. How is that deficit going to be made up?

Comment on this

In the Budget.

Comment on this

In the Budget?

Comment on this

Right. And every Deputy on the other side is going into the Lobby to vote for the increase of taxation? Is Deputy Davin going to do it?

Comment on this

There is no necessity.

Comment on this

When Deputy Davin is asked about taxes he says "Oh, no; no food taxes; no tax on coal; no tax on anything of that kind, but a tax on income-tax and a tax on ground rent." But those are already earmarked by Deputy Davin. It was for that reason —because those taxes, in his opinion, were available in the last Budget—that he refused to vote for coal and sugar, and other taxes of that kind, which, in the absence of a tax upon income-tax and ground rents, would have been absolutely necessary for the purposes of the public services and the social services which Deputy Davin demanded.

Comment on this

You are forgetting the plan. What about the £2,000,000?

Comment on this

I will agree even with Deputy McGilligan——

Comment on this

What about the £2,000,000?

Comment on this

Let us assume, for the moment, that there is no £2,000,000——

Comment on this

I cannot do it.

Comment on this

You cannot? Then you did not listen to your colleagues. Your colleagues can assume anything. One of them got up here to-day and told us that we had exhausted all the resources of tyranny, that there was embezzlement from the people of this country by the Executive Council.

Comment on this

So there is.

Comment on this

But surely, if they say nice gentle things of that kind about us, the mere suggestion that we might conceivably have made a mistake in regard to such a little matter as £2,000,000 is not too much for Deputy McGilligan to swallow.

Comment on this

If you admit both the embezzlement and the £2,000,000 I will be glad.

Comment on this

At the moment I want to know why the supporters of Deputy Davin went into that Lobby; they are perfectly entitled to go in—I am not blaming them—but they ought to tell us some logical ground. Are they going into it to say that taxation has to be put on in the Budget for the purpose of finding this deficit?

Comment on this

I do not think they are.

Comment on this

They need not say it.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan has now been briefed as counsel for Deputy Davin.

Comment on this

It is the worst brief I ever had.

Comment on this

I quite agree.

Comment on this

But we had a statement about that £2,000,000.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin wants this money not to be collected——

Comment on this

So says Deputy Flinn.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin has said that there is no money in Laoighis which is outstanding and which can be paid.

Comment on this

It would be equally true for me to say that Deputy Flinn wants no income-tax.

Comment on this

All right, I will say that.

Comment on this

You have often said it.

Comment on this

That is too far back.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin wants this money taken from some other source than his constituents in Laoighis.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

He would not provide money during the last Budget by a tax upon anything new except income-tax and ground rents.

Comment on this

Go on with the other ones.

Comment on this

Give me another one.

Comment on this

You should not pretend to quote me if you have lost your memory.

Comment on this

He voted for a tax on tobacco.

Comment on this

And super-tax and excess profits.

Comment on this

Super-tax and excess profits tax are very different from income-tax.

Comment on this

It would probably hurt the Deputy if that were put into operation.

Comment on this

We will assume, then, that the Deputy did not, in the last Budget, consent to any increase of taxation except income-tax, super-tax, excess profits and ground rents.

Comment on this

Oh, he did.

Comment on this

Yes, I did.

Comment on this

Those are the sources from which Deputy Davin thinks that all the future revenue which is required can be got.

Comment on this

And he already wants it for the social services.

Comment on this

Is it fair that the Deputy, whose memory is supposed to be good, should go on saying that those are the only taxes I voted for when he knows quite well that I voted for many other taxes?

Comment on this

Those are the new taxes which the Deputy wanted.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I admit that Deputy Hugo Flinn is not the first offender, but I think he is going further than anybody else has gone in straying from the terms of this amendment. I submit that we are really getting altogether too far afield from the amendment to be dealt with.

Comment on this

He is being constantly interrupted.

Comment on this

How long is the Deputy the judge of relevancy?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am afraid that nearly every Deputy who has spoken has wandered very far afield from the terms of the amendment. I think that if the Parliamentary Secretary were allowed to make his speech in his own way he would not wander so far.

Comment on this

If he addressed the Chair it would be a good thing.

Comment on this

I am very pleased that the Chair should feel as I do that it is my natural instinct always to keep rigidly to order, and that any digressions have been due to weakness in the face of misleading by interrupters. I am glad to feel, Sir, that you do appreciate my position, because sometimes it is painful to me that anyone should think I would wander from the razor-edge of order.

Retrospective legislation has not been limited to this; there is retrospective crime. Just imagine that! This House, which is horrified at the idea of this Bill, has actually introduced and passed through it an Act creating retrospective crime. Under the Public Safety Act a court could decide that a thing which was not a crime at the time at which it was committed became a crime afterwards, and such a crime was punishable at the discretion of the court by any sentence up to death. And we have no precedent in this House for retrospective legislation! I think it was Deputy O'Higgins who—due to the fact that Deputy Morrissey had got up before him, was robbed of his usual speech; in his usual speech Deputy O'Higgins said that the speech just before his was the most despicable, the most abominable and the most complete bit of buffoonery he had ever heard in his life—had to get a new line, and told us about the horrible doctrine which had been enunciated in this House by the Minister for Finance. This is how he quoted it: "The highest authority is the authority of the Minister talking for a majority." Now, the mere fact that the Minister did not say that does not mean that it has not been said; does not mean that it has not been acted on, and does not mean that this House is not controlled by the precedent that it has been used and has been acted on. There was a Minister for Agriculture, who once did sit on this side of the House—apparently he will not condescend to sit on that side —and who said that a majority could do anything it damn well pleased, but that may be regarded as one of the hectic and loose expressions of the Minister in a moment of irresponsibility. But there was a precedent; there was a President who, when his attention was called to the fact that not an ordinary Bill but a Bill altering the structure of the machinery of this State—the Constitution Amendment Bill—had been passed by a majority of one, said: "That is democracy." That President was the then President, President Cosgrave. No wonder Deputy O'Higgins talks about bleating about democracy. He says that this is blatant defiance of the Irish courts. What was the Public Safety Act but the complete abolition, in criminal cases, as far as they could do it, of the whole jurisdiction of the courts in Ireland? And behold, we have no precedent for actions of this kind!

If someone would put down in this House for consideration on another day, a motion which would raise the question of under what limiting condition retrospective legislation could or could not be introduced in this House, I would be very glad. I think it would be a debate which would be extremely valuable and on which the lines of demarcation would certainly not be the lines of demarcation of Party Whips. I think it is a subject which would, undoubtedly, develop very great differences and in which Deputies who, like myself, are absolutely against retrospective legislation and the interpretation of the law by a legislative Assembly, if it could be avoided, would find themselves up against very real difficulties such as the real difficulties that have arisen in relation to Acts which have been already passed by the House. But in relation to an Act of this kind, in which the whole thing has been already done, I think the position is entirely different. Deputy Brennan, who got up here, first told us that these accumulated arrears were due to the fact that the people did not think they would ever have to pay them, and did not think that these Acts might ever be enforced. I think there is a lot of truth in that. They were led away by the wagons and the banners and the salvation armies that wandered round the country. They had come to believe that by some means or other this agitation would be strong enough to prevent the necessity for payment eventually and the result was, not merely in relation to annuities, but in relation to rates, in relation to rents of cottages, in relation to ordinary debts, people began to think that if you could get an agitation of that kind strong enough, you could get out of your liabilities. These debts would then continue to accumulate unless and until it was made perfectly clear to all those concerned that these debts are debts, that they will be collected by the machinery available and that no one is going to get away from his obligations by means of agitations of that kind.

Deputy Morrissey asked why all the thousands were due. They are largely due for that reason, because a good many honest people very foolishly were led away into the idea that if their next neighbour were refusing to pay while he could pay, there was no reason why they should pay. This is a sanitary measure. It is in order to clear up this whole position and to see that these debts are not going to accumulate until they are a milestone too heavy to carry, that this Dáil is called upon to reassert the law in this Bill. If I might quote the devil in my defence, I would call Deputy Davin into the witness-box. The Attorney-General told us that when the Act of 1923 went to the "House of Lords" they attempted there to amend it and that they did amend it in the direction in which Deputies opposite now want it amended, and when it came back to this House, this House took out that amendment, and Deputy Davin is the witness——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary is referring to the Seanad, I take it?

Comment on this