Land Purchase (Guarantee Fund) Bill, 1935—Committee.
Contributions 339–494 of 494. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 39 of 1935 ›
This would-be humorist amongst humorists! Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney this evening referred to poetasters amongst poetasters.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin told us during the discussion that he himself, under the full impression that the law was as the law is now stated to be in this Bill, attempted to have it amended. There cannot be any better testimony than that the Deputy himself tried to amend it out of the position in which this Dáil is now going to declare it was, is, and always has been.
Comment on this
Membership of this House has many privileges and pleasures and it has an occasional torture. I have often suffered torture, and often when the Deputy who has just sat down has dared to speak of men like Kevin O'Higgins, I have wondered if my feelings when he spoke of Kevin O'Higgins could have been realised, as I think they must have been realised, by members of the Party opposite, who must have experienced the same torture when he spoke of Roderic O'Connor. It is no wonder that the Deputy should open his speech with a reference to slaves and heroes, because he has had the experience of, in fact, being the one and has, in theory, been the other. It is no wonder that he, like others, as Deputy Brennan has pointed out, has had to delve into the background to try and get a precedent in order to justify what they know cannot be justified. Even a man so full of revolutionary ardour, so steeped in the French revolution, such a delightfully sansculottist person as Deputy Flinn, cannot get a precedent although he has turned the barricades over and over again. He should not be afraid of a breach of the internal law. It is through breaches of the internal law that individuals like the Parliamentary Secretary arise and get into Assemblies like this. Why is there the necessity for all this precedent? Because it is clear to everybody that wrong is being done. Supposing there was a true conscience about this matter, is it not a simple thing to say: "There are such and such arrears; we intend to have them paid. By certain councils they have been paid. We have failed in the law by which we tried to make them pay but we shall let them go and take it out of them by a new Bill"?
Why not come in with a new Bill? Why not make the drafts on the county councils so much less, or even carry it over two years, if there is not sufficient to draw upon? Why not start anew? The Deputy knows that he dare not ask that lot, no matter how tied they are, to have such a Christmas-box sent to the local councils. So it has to be done under the shadow of a previous Act, and that this is merely a carry forward of what was always intended. You have people tied by what was previously done. If there was any manliness or a decent feeling about this or a consciousness that it was right, and that people when faced with it could vote honestly, openly and smilingly for it, and people were faced with a debt to pay believing it was just, we could deal with this and get rid of the taint of retrospection by having a Bill brought in simply to pay the money as a debt accruing as from the date upon which the Bill was brought in. The reason that that is not being done is because, hard as Party discipline is, and sharp as is the crack of the Party Whip, men would break through rather than vote for that as a new measure. They must have some little bit of clouding of the atmosphere, some little bit of secrecy as to what they are to vote upon.
Again, we have the further excuse given that it is not breaking or amending the law. We were told by the Deputy who has just spoken that some of the speeches made might have been relevant if it were meant to change the law, but the law is not being changed. The bringing forward of an argument like that shows the scarcity of good argument and definitely shows the straits to which certain people are reduced. We are not changing the law. Why? Because the Attorney-General has advised that the present two actions taken by the Cork and the Louth County Councils must succeed. If we are not changing the law, we are doing this—we are forestalling because we know what the decision of the court is going to be.
The Attorney-General has often been paraded in the courts of this country in a very dishonoured and, I should say, dishonourable way. He certainly appeared as a man of no substance, of no weight. He has, I might say, been cuffed around the courts of this country in certain actions in which he had the temerity to appear. In these two actions he claimed that the proceedings instituted by these councils were a nuisance, and he was, in so many words, told that he himself was a nuisance, and that the vexatiousness was not on the part of the county councils but on his part. He hides all that ignominy and shame in the phrase he used the other night, that he could not advise the Government that they could succeed. He knows well that he must have advised them that they were going to lose, and the loss is before this House at this moment as clearly written down as if the court had decided that what the Government have been doing is wrong and illegal. Therefore, we have this patching up and haste to get the matter right before the court will have taken a decision on these actions.
The Parliamentary Secretary told us that Deputy O'Higgins had derided a majority of this House. I was here for his speech, and it is warping his phrase to say that was his speech. What he derided, and properly derided, was a majority of this House uncontrolled by a second House or the courts. That is where the trouble and scandal in this matter arises. We get back to a very disordered, very barbarous and savage state of society if people do not know the rules they have to obey, if the rules can be changed by those who have strength at a certain moment, and changed to operate backwards. That was the old-time system when people were ruled in certain communities and certain areas by the strong hand, and what the strong man said at any time was the law; he could change the law at any time for his subjects. But when we come to decent times and to ordered society one of the things inherent in ordered society is that the rules of the game are known before you start to play, and that the rules cannot be changed while the game is in progress. People who have established rights, either definitely or in a prima facie way, or people who are on the road to establish rights, should be allowed to proceed with whatever they have instituted until the rights are declared. Then, if the Government do not like it, they can change it as from that moment on. I do not mind if there is a change as long as it does not hurt people, as long as it does not work against people who have been assured of rights. It is because it is known that this action has thrown us back into the most disordered state that we have all this delving and seeking for precedents.
Deputy O'Higgins was on the right note when he said that it is not a good mark for the society that we want to have established here that you should have one House ruling by a majority of one, say, with no second House to control, advise or supervise, even to delay, and certainly without any judicial power independent of this House to interpret what has proceeded from this House, always subject to the fact that this House at any moment can from a given date change. Men in communities all over the world have built up this system of checks and balances —the two-house system and the system of a judiciary quite independent, put on a pedestal, free from interference with salaries or conditions of employment or dismissal. These people should be left to interpret the laws made here. What Deputy O'Higgins reviled was the system sought now to be introduced, by which a majority of one individual in this House is going in future to rule the whole community and to overawe and overpower the judges with regard to something the judges might have said five, 10 or 15 years ago. That is not ordered society. That is not what men have progressed to. That is the bad old system, that is retrogression, that is reaction, if ever the terms could be applied.
Why not be naked and clear? Why not get to the point that Deputy Cosgrave spoke of the other night, that men ought to have given to them as a warning, when they seek to introduce any action in the courts, that they should first of all ring up some Minister, some head of a Department, and ask him: "If I succeed in this, is it so contrary to Government policy that a retrospective piece of legislation will be introduced and that the fruits of my victory will be snatched from me"? Nobody could stand for that, plainly and openly stated, but can people vote for it when stated in a mess, because that is the principle that juts out from what is before us now? That is definitely going back from an ordered state of society to the more savage position where the strong hand rules; and the strong hand is now pretending to rule in accordance with democratic forms, when its strength is merely being used not to support democracy but to break down democracy. We have on the Government Benches a delving into the past for precedents and a sorry lot of precedents have been brought forward. I want to make this statement very distinct—that as a member of the Executive Council for a certain number of years, and a member of this House for a longer number of years, I know of no Act which reverses the judgment of the Supreme Court of this country. I know of several Acts which re-establish the judgments of the Supreme Court in this country.
Comment on this
I know of no attempts. I intend to go through these measures; I will quote them. I know of several Acts that were passed to validate and strengthen, if that were necessary, the judgments of the Supreme Court in this country and to prevent any judgment being got from anybody else outside this country against the judgments of the Supreme Court. I stand for that. That was upholding the judgments of the Supreme Court that we always regarded as the supreme judicial authority in this country. What happened? The main example brought forward here has been the Copyright Act. Phrases have been repeated here as if they formed precedents for this Bill.
Comment on this
I will, and read the comments on it also. The best comment on it was passed by the best legal mind that the Senate had and he wound up by saying that this Act was upholding the Supreme Court judgment. I accept it as such. I argued for that Act as upholding the Supreme Court judgment. The Minister does not know the reactions of the Copyright Act. The Minister has not stopped to think. I intended a small reference to the Supreme Court judgment. I referred to four cumbrous sections in that Act. There had been copyright in this country under laws passed—not in this country—up to the Treaty. It was thought that the 1911 Copyright Act had been carried forward by Article 73 of the Constitution. There was an Act passed in 1927 to continue such copyright as there was. Now the Bray Urban Council got a band to play a tune called "Lilac Time." The Performing Rights Association did allege that they had copyright in that tune and they sought for those rights in our courts. The High Court decided that there was an infringement of the copyright of the Performing Rights Society. The Bray Urban Council went to the Supreme Court and the Supreme Court held, contrary to the view—that was the view of everybody who thought about the matter—that there had been no copyright. In a certain limited way, the decision, as far as it affected two sets of litigants, was this, that the Bray Urban Council who had done what was supposed to be against the law, had in reality done only what was within their right and they had not to pay the costs. The Performing Rights Association who had all along thought they had copyright were mulcted in costs. They had to pay the costs of this action.
We brought in a measure here to validate that judgment of the Supreme Court. Now there had to be a view beyond that. We were a member of an international union. We had attended a Copyright Convention, the Berne Convention as it was called. Under the provisions of that convention we were bound to continue copyright in this country and we did so. We gave to people whom we supposed to have copyright before that judgment of the Supreme Court, this much right, that their copyright would not be broken in the interim. These were based on the paragraph that the Parliamentary Secretary quotes as showing a breach of the Supreme Court judgment. Think of the situation. The Supreme Court said they had no copyright. We said we would tie up the breach of copyright again. Here was the situation that people like the Bray Urban Council might be discovered to have been breaking copyright which never existed. And so we said: "We will tie up the years but in between we will hold to the judgment of the Supreme Court; if anybody has broken the law there will be no breach and no penalties for the infringement." We validated the judgment of the Supreme Court and having validated it we said: "We will not allow anybody to get damages for infringement." Because we did that I am told here now that the section which did it is breaking the Supreme Court judgment. The fact is that not merely was that section in support of the Supreme Court judgment but it implemented it in the fullest possible way. It implemented what the court had found.
If there had been a little more thought this matter of the Copyright Act would certainly never have been thrown in as an example. Copyright is a monopoly right. It gives a position adverse to the whole world in favour of one person. We had another alternative to the Copyright Act. I could have said that "copyright was to be deemed to have existed from this on." I had to enlarge the terms of the Act by adding a number of years in which it was supposed to be dead and I enlarged it by the intermediate term. What we did was to say: "We thought that you had carried forward copyright in 1922, and in 1927 we found that was not the position. You had no property in the meantime in any copyright and anyone who has broken it will not suffer for it." I am told this evening that that is the precedent for what is happening here now. I stand on that Act as validating, upholding and implementing in the fullest possible way the Supreme Court view. Whatever else we did, I did because as a member of the International Union we were bound to remake the Constitution and we remade it because no person had a right to have it broken. And even though we thought it was theoretically right, or that there had been an infringement of the Copyright Act, we carried out everything because the Supreme Court said that in that period there was no copyright in this country. And that is the example that has been given here this evening of retrospective legislation. This at any rate is clear, that as between the Bray Urban Council and The Performing Rights Society we made no change. I thought that the Bray Urban Council had gained a victory that it should not have gained. I thought that the Performing Rights Society had been mulcted in costs for doing what I thought they had a right to do. Did I change the burden? I left it as it was.
Are the Government prepared to leave the actions by the Louth and Cork County Councils to take their course and not disturb the findings of the court? That would approach what I did in the case of the Copyright Act. But it is the last thing the Government will think of. The other example quoted here is based on a speech and criticism by the Parliamentary Secretary of some part of the Finance Act of 1931. I do not say it for the purpose of evading criticism or examination of that or what he was referring to. He read out a speech that would appear to refer to what was retrospective legislation. That does not bring confidence to me. We would have a better case if he had quoted to us the provisions which he said were retrospective under that Act. It was possible for him to found an argument to prove to him that it was retrospective but to do so it had to be on his speech and not on the provisions of the Act.
Comment on this
The Indemnity Act was retrospective. That Act started by saying that there were conditions prevailing in this country that were not governed by law at all. If they were governed by law Deputy Donnelly would not be here.
Comment on this
Possibly, and it may be a pleasure now that we did not succeed, but we might not have thought so then.
Comment on this
There was only one decision of the courts, and that decision of the courts ran and was upheld. We changed the law from that moment on.
Comment on this
Possibly. I do not care about this Government saying with regard to these annuities: "You will pay from this moment on." That is not retrospective. What we are at, the evil we are against, is the changing of these rules with backward effect. If we are going to be in a state of ordered society, people ought to know the conditions under which they are to live, and those conditions ought to be made clear to them. They ought to be capable of ascertainment by the independent judicial authority set up for that purpose. It ought not to be possible for a Government to say: "That is not what we meant," and it ought not to be possible for the House here to tell the courts what they are to find. It is a wrong thing to let people live in certain circumstances under the belief that their rights can be ascertained by an independent authority, and then the Government can come along and say: "That is not what we meant," and the Government then sets about altering things. The present proposal is that a certain condition of things will rule backwards to the extent of two years.
Comment on this
There is many a man who signed a contract in the belief that it meant a certain thing, and when it was discovered to mean something else he had to pay for it. Would Deputy Moore like business in the commercial world to be run on the basis that any man can declare what he meant a particular contract to be?
Comment on this
It is simply the law imposed by a superior force, the majority in this House, on the community. The proposal is that the superior force of the majority can impose its will after a certain date. It has always been regarded as contrary to the dictates of order in any community to do that with any backward effect.
Comment on this
There has not been a single assertion by any Deputy that he understood the Guarantee Fund arrangement was not to apply.
Comment on this
I do not care if the House were unanimous, if there was one man who took an action to test it and got a declaration against the unanimous view of the House, the judge's decision ought to hold against the unanimous view of the House.
Comment on this
If the Deputy was the one man he would not consider it formalism. Any one man has a right to be indemnified against the blunder of even a unanimous House if the courts find the unanimous view was not properly expressed.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance knows that the Attorney-General was chased out of court as a nuisance.
Comment on this
I know the Minister for Finance sent the Attorney-General with a motion looking to have a particular action dismissed on the ground that it was a nuisance and vexatious, and the result of the court's judgment was that he was a nuisance himself. That is not a parody. That is the fact, and if it was not the fact there would not be this Bill. All that is being asked is that the Minister will do what has been done in another Act. The Minister for Industry and Commerce introduced a Bill this year to amend an Act and give it retrospective effect and to preserve all proceedings instituted before the introduction of the measure. Will the Minister for Finance take that easy way out of the situation? Why should not people who start proceedings, looking for a decision, be allowed to have the independent minds of the people who were established to rule as judges in an independent position?
Comment on this
On an entirely technical point? Will the Deputy not move his group? If this is so technical, if it is clear it is technical, then there should be no hesitation about the Deputy's group voting for a new Bill which will not have retrospective effect but will have the same result; which will simply deem a debt of a certain amount to exist on the county councils arising, say, as from to-morrow, and that will be collected from them in certain payments. If there is only the difference between these two things, and that it is due to a technical defect, the Deputy surely could justify himself in his constituency. Why not go on that foot? The Deputy knows well he could not go to any constituency and say, without knowing what the law was going to be, not caring what the law was going to be, that Deputies on his side of the House with their majority were simply going to mulct the county councils in certain moneys. That will not be done, and the Deputy knows it.
The Deputy suggests that the difference between the Government's proposal and what I suggest is only formalism. I submit there is no case against what I propose. We have all this groping for precedent; we have all this talk about the Finance Act of 1931, the Copyright Act, which was not understood, and the question of the Indemnity Act, which is ludicrous in the circumstances. After we have done with these so-called precedents we get to the reality. The non-payers, according to the Parliamentary Secretary, should not have the debts extracted from them—that is the view of the persons who vote against this measure. He asked Deputy Davin if he had not suggested a more intensive enforcement of measures in order to have compliance with the law, and the Minister told us what that meant—bailiffs and battering rams. We are supposed to be voting against the application of more battering rams and the impact of further bailiffs and their batons on the people. Supposing we say we are not in favour of more bailiffs and battering rams, is there anything shameful in that? Will Deputy Moore, the man who feels the farmers would suffer anything for the mere exaltation of upholding a Party standard, be prepared to advocate more bailiffs and more battering rams?
Comment on this
If we are we would like to have it better explained to us, and it might bring a little enlightenment as to what members of the Minister's Party are voting for. We are asked, do we want non-payers to get off? What we want is that, just as in ordinary commercial dealings, the people should get the law declared for them by the judges, and the law can be changed if it is decided it is not a good law to have running. But it should only be changed with forward effect. I am against bailiffs and battering rams for retrospectively declared debts—I am definitely against that. We are supposed to be in the dilemma that if we are not for more bailiffs and battering rams we are for more taxes. I am not in favour of that either. Until I get a clear confession that the members of the Government, who hold their positions through a certain plan that they promulgated to the country some years ago, now realise that that plan was nonsense, I will not rest satisfied. I am still going to stand on this, that there were economies to the extent of £2,000,000 promised as feasible in this country. If we are £2,000,000 short in any regard, let us get the economies. There were economies to be got without cutting salaries or imposing hardships on anybody.
Comment on this
There was a plan to that effect, and there was a Government that should have given effect to that plan. I am not in the dilemma that I must fight for the sheriff or the battering-ram or the new taxes, unless there is a definite confession that the £2,000,000 plan cannot be produced. To protest against that does not mean that we are driven back to these unfortunate alternatives. The non-payers who, we are told, have been dishonest and defaulting, require some consideration by having their appeals heard rather than being subjected to the bailiffs and the battering-ram. Should not there be some consideration, in this year 1935, as to why there is so much deficiency in the payment of the annuities. Remember we are supposed to have an almost new heaven in this country. There are signs of prosperity all round, we are told. New schemes are being embarked upon. Government money is being lavished about. There is help and subsidies and the declaration of new markets here at home as well as the waning ones abroad. The whole country, we are told, is very well off. Why then so much non-payment? It must be that there is a great deal of vice in the community if people are to hold that view.
Will Deputies in this House go to their constituents and tell them that that is so? Will they go to their constituents and say that is the position, though in their heart of hearts they know that this measure should really be passed. Will they tell their constituents that only the honest people will be mulcted? How many Deputies will go to their constituents and tell them these things and get away with their lives? Are there any men in this House prepared to say that, other than Ministers? Has any man representing a constituency courage enough to stand up and say that in the main this Bill will hit dishonest people and should be voted for? Does anybody believe in that? There is much truth in what Deputy Davin said, that the people are so beaten down and depressed that they cannot pay. It is a secondary consideration, but it also has its effect, that you may be doing this wrong in retrospective legislation in securing this result.
What is the good, at a time when nearly £760,000 is outstanding, in regard to those annuities alone, in trying to get that from people who are more in arrears now than at any other stage in history, with their ordinary rates? If a man cannot pay a pound one year, there is no use asking him to pay £5 the next year if he has got deeper into arrears in the meantime. That is what is proposed here. The ordinary rates brought forward this year show greater arrears than any for several years past. There is nearly £760,000 outstanding in regard to this matter. Less than £160,000 of that has been carried forward into the new rate, so far. There is nearly £560,000 extra money to be found, and that has to be found from people who cannot pay their ordinary rates. If it was nothing else than a matter of expediency, then expediency would suggest to the Minister to pause in view of the facts disclosed showing the terrible state to which the ratepayers have been brought. It is not very much good setting up precedents and rules for ordered society if we find ourselves in the position that no matter what the wrong, or what section of the community are attacked, the majority of the House can do nothing to protect them. It is not much good for the Government to do what they are doing from the angle of expediency if, when it is done, it is not going to bring any advantage or any result. In such circumstances the Ministry will have failed doubly, because they will have deprived the institution of the judiciary of any respect or power they have, and they will not get their money at all now unless through this dishonest way of pilfering it from the community.
The Government are doing two things here. They are establishing a precedent, as Deputy O'Higgins said, blatant and clear for everybody to see, and that nobody in any predicament can fail to see. The only hope is that the results may be so bad that although it is seen clear as a precedent, still, folk in a predicament may not be inclined to follow it, because the result is as damaging as the precedent is bad.
Comment on this
In speaking against this amendment the Minister for Finance referred to the dishonesty of the farmers of this country. I, as a farmer, and as one representing farmers, think I am in duty bound to offer my protest against that insinuation in this House. He referred to an organisation in Cork against the payment of annuities, but I would point out to the Minister that there is no organisation in Cork against the payment of annuities. There was an organisation against having to pay them over and over again. Deputy Flinn said: "Hear, hear!" when it was stated there was an organisation in Cork against the payment of annuities. Will the Deputy say "hear, hear" now to what I have said?
Comment on this
And he is getting it too damn soft. The Minister for Finance rebuked Deputy Davin because he said there were 25 per cent. of the people in Laoighis who could not pay these taxes.
I would like to point out what Deputy Corkery, speaking at the Ard-Fheis last week, said: "This thing has come to the breaking-point with the people living in the poorer districts. They are barely existing at the present, and it is the duty of the Government to see that some means be devised by which they will be able to live at least in some kind of comfort." I am sure Deputy Corkery will stand over that statement. He is a business man and has been amongst the farmers, not like the Minister who never stood in a farmer's house in his blooming life. I am sure, when the Minister for Finance was knocking around he looked for better quarters than he could get in a farmer's house in this country. He was always a keen gentleman and looked for a good time. The Minister for Finance referred to the manner in which the people of Mayo are paying their annuities. I wonder what the Minister has to say about the commission that Deputy Corkery was demanding to have set up to find out the real position of the farmers. He might then find out they paid them at the loss to themselves or their families of something which they very much needed, or perhaps, leaving the shopkepers to wait for their debts. These are points we would like to have investigated in connection with this matter. Deputy Flinn refers to the deliberate misrepresentation of Deputies who drafted this. It is very easy for Deputy Flinn to talk like that, but will he vote for such a commission if it is brought forward in this House? Is he prepared to vote for the setting up of a commission similar to the one demanded by Deputy Corkery at his own Ard-Fheis last week, so that we can find out the real position of the farmers in this country? I am not demanding it on political grounds. I am demanding it because I worked with the farmers during my life and always tried to improve their position; but, God knows, when I look back at the sacrifices the people of this country made for the last 30 years and see the whole thing being destroyed by people like the Minister for Finance and Deputy Flinn, I say: May God help the people of this country.
Deputy Flinn has let the cat out of the bag and says to us: "If we do not find this money from the farmers, how are we going to find it?" He, therefore, admits that this is not a land annuity; that it is a tax. I agree with him, because the President himself has stated in this House, on more than one occasion, that the farmers of this country had paid their annuities to the British Government and that they had been extracted from them in a more painful way than they had ever been paid before. How has the Minister for Finance the audacity to stand up here in this House and speak as he has spoken to the people of this country, particularly the people in the cities who do not understand the position of the farmers of the country? How would some of the supporters of the Minister for Finance, who are not farmers, like to be compelled to pay their debts twice, and three times, and four times over, and even ten times over, as a great many small farmers have had to pay them? Deputy Flinn says that the farmers want to hand their obligations to somebody else. On several occasions, Deputy Cosgrave gave the figures for the ten years previous to the coming into office of the present Government, and pointed out that the farmers had met their responsibilities during that period. The Minister for Finance, last week, asked me how it was that I never protested against paying my annuities to the British Government. I paid them because I had to pay them, and I pay them now, and there is no use in the Minister trying to get away from the question at issue. My annuity was fairly large, but I can tell the Minister that it was far easier to pay it during that time than I find it to pay my annuity now. There was no such thing as slaying calves at that time. My calves were worth £3 10s. apiece at that time, but to-day it is very hard to get £1 apiece, and if I were to wait for Dr. Ryan I would probably get only a shilling or two.
Deputy Flinn referred to Deputy Davin. He wants to know where is this money going to be taken from if not from the farmers, and what article are we going to put a tax on. Deputy McGilligan has pointed out that, before they came into office, the Government promised the people of this country that they would reduce taxation by £2,000,000 without interfering with any of the public services. They should go back and try to fulfil their promises to the people of this country in that way. The President himself has been boasting about the fulfilment of their promises. In any case, I am supporting this amendment and I do so, and I am proud to say it, along with the people in Cork, the representatives of the different political Parties on the county council, who have been unanimous in demanding that this Bill be withdrawn. I have great pleasure in supporting them in doing so.
Comment on this
It would be very difficult to conceive of a more audacious attempt by any Government to filch from the people the rights that are theirs by law. It is an attempt for which there is no precedent, and the Government, by its action in unlawfully withholding money from the county councils, has created chaos in the whole local government of the country. In a time of depression caused by Government policy, the Government have illegally withheld grants from the county councils to which they are entitled. That is one of the chief causes of all the wrong that has happened the county councils of the country and is the main cause of the embarrassment which exists in so many counties. In my own County of Westmeath it has resulted in the County Council being abolished and the whole administration handed over to a paid nominee of the Government. The difference in the amount of grants paid to the Council of Westmeath in the first year of the present Government's term of office and the last accounting year—not the present financial year— is over £30,000, an amount which the Council has to make good by an increase to that extent of the rates. There is nothing about arrears of annuities in those years, and the amount this year would be hard to count, it is so large. The Westmeath County Council had struck a rate this year, and they were ordered by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health to strike a fresh rate to meet the arrears of annuities. We sent a deputation to the Minister to try to point out to him that the people would not be able to bear the increased rate. Nothing was done, however, and we were told to go back and strike this increased rate. At the next meeting of the Council that was called, nobody turned up except the Fine Gael County Councillors. Westmeath has a majority of Fianna Fáil County Councillors, but they would not come in. They wanted the Fine Gael Councillors to do the dirty work for them, and then they could come in afterwards and pose as great fellows. I came in to the meeting and I told the councillors that I was not elected by the people of Westmeath to strike a rate for the Government. I told them I was not elected by the people of Westmeath in order to be a tax-gatherer for the Government.
We are told that the arrears of annuities is the chief cause of the stoppage in grants, and that there would not be any stoppage if the land annuities were paid. The farmers have two very excellent reasons to account for their position in regard to land annuities. The first is that they maintain that they paid them in full, if they did not pay more, through the tarrifs which were imposed by the British Government for the purpose of meeting the liability to the bondholders. The second reason is that they are unable to pay because the Government, through its policy, has pauperised the agricultural industry of the country.
The Government now seek to penalise the farmers by transferring the liability for the annuities to the ratepayers who, in the main, are the farmers, and the way they are punishing the farmers and ratepayers of Westmeath ought to make every member on the Government side hang down his head in shame. In September, 1934, they sent down four squads of Broy Harriers and, in eight months, they took from the people of Westmeath three half-years' arrears of annuities and frightened them into paying two current half-years as well. The people were so frightened that they tried to pay the two current half years also. Never in the worst days of landlordism, or of British tyranny in this country, was a thing like that done to a body of farmers and ratepayers in this country; but now we have a native Government sending down its agents to terrorise the people and, after taking seven half years of annuities in nine months from the people of Westmeath, they dissolved the council. They dragged three half years of arrears from the people and the people were so frightened that they were compelled to pay the two current half years also. The people tried to pay their rates, and then the Government sent down a commissioner and compelled them to raise the rates up to 2/- in the £ on top of all that, while the neighbouring County of Meath, which had as large an amount of arrears, got off scot free without a raising of the rates.
We have been presented with this dastardly Bill because it has been brought home to the Government and its officials that it is illegal to stop the grants. Now they are trying to transfer the liability arising in connection with the annuities to the ratepayers. Their object in bringing in this Bill is to make legal what has been declared to be illegal, and to take from the ratepayers the freedom that is theirs by law. This Bill is a piece of barefaced political dishonesty, and if introduced by anybody, except the Government, would be scouted out of any properly constituted Assembly. It would be treated with the scorn and contempt that it deserves. If there was a spark of honesty in the members who sit on the Government benches they would vote against this measure. It gives one a true indication of what is going to happen to the people when all power to make laws in this country is vested in the Dáil, and the Dáil only. What, in fact, will such an Assembly be? It will be composed of a small body of members forming an Executive Council. I trust the Dáil on this occasion will show it has sufficient independence to refuse to take this step towards absolute dictatorship.
Comment on this
As an ordinary farmer I would like to say a few words on this Bill. In my opinion the Bill seems to be framed for the purpose of destroying the agricultural community. It is a rapacious piece of legislation and, so far as the farmers of the country are concerned, may be said to be the last straw. It shows absolute contempt for the honesty, impartiality, and sound judgement of the courts of this State. During the last election Fianna Fáil promised the people a reduction of £2,000,000 in taxation, and said that out of that they would completely derate agricultural land. But the position to-day is that we find ourselves called upon to pay rates which are much higher than we can afford. Agriculture produces 80 per cent. of the wealth of this State, but to-day the farmers find that, as compared with two or three years ago, they are 80 per cent. worse off. In the county which I have the honour to represent, and which had, perhaps, the honour to elect the President, the sum of £25,000 is being withheld from the Agricultural Grant this year, and £2,700 of the Road Grant has been withheld as compared with what we received last year.
A few days ago the Clare County Council, of which I am a member, passed a resolution asking the Government to give 50-50 towards the relief of the unemployed at Christmas. The Council proposed to give £3,000 of the ratepayers' money if the Government would give a similar amount. We now find that the Government are giving us the very generous sum of £1,000 out of the Exchequer as against the £3,000 put up by the unfortunate farmers of Clare. The net result of that will be an increase of 2/- in the £ on the rates in the County Clare during the coming year.
We, as the representatives of the people of this State, have a duty to perform, and that is to establish peace and order in this country with reasonable prosperity. I hope every Deputy realises that. I wonder if any of us would be ashamed to go outside the door of this House and have to admit that we had brought the country to a state of lawlessness, destruction, despair and bankruptcy. I should like to say that the time is fast approaching when the farmers will again have to band themselves together, as they did during the land agitation under the leadership of Dillon and Davitt, and let the Government see that no Acts of Parliament will deprive them of their homes and of their land. It would be well for the Government to realise that the farmers of this country can organise themselves just as the Fianna Fáil Party or any other body in the country can, and I think it is time they did so. I admit that there are decent farmers and decent members of the community representing other branches of life sitting on the Fianna Fáil Benches. We had an example of that here some evenings ago when one responsible Fianna Fáil Deputy spoke on this Bill and did not vote for it. I hope his example will be followed by many other Deputies here to-night: by those who realise their duty to the country and remember that the people are greater than any little Act of Parliament.
Comment on this
I desire to stress my opposition to this section of the Bill and to support the amendment moved by Deputy Brennan. The county that I have the honour to represent was, to use the phrase of the Minister for Finance, one of those responsible for the institution of the legal proceedings that have been referred to. I would like to say that the members of that council, to which I have the honour to belong, did not take that action with the express intention of being, to use a familiar phrase, "again the Government." The people of Louth have always been remarkable for their observance of the law as it exists to-day, as it existed yesterday, and they will continue to observe it. The members of that council have as their Chairman one of the best citizens to be found in this State. He is a man who, I believe, commands the confidence not alone of the present Ministry but of the past Ministry. On behalf of the members of that council, I resent most emphatically the suggestion made by the Minister for Finance this evening as well as on the Second Reading of the Bill, that the people of Louth were animated with no other idea than that of starting an action that was supposed to be, in the words of the Minister, a vexatious action. The members of that council—the elected representatives of the people and the custodians of the people's rights—considered this matter at an ordinary finance committee meeting. They went into the question in great detail. Having done so, they did as every other council would do under the same circumstances. They referred the matter to their solicitor. He took counsel's opinion. That opinion was to the effect that, as the law stands at the moment, the council had a good chance of winning their case on the question of the reduction of the agricultural grants due to the deficiencies in the Land Purchase Annuities Fund. The council, having received that opinion, institued legal proceedings in order to defend the rights and the interests of the people whom they represent. I am a member of that council, and one who, possibly, may not have the same knowledge as the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance—I believe he has been styled by the members of the Fianna Fáil Party as the greatest orator since the days of O'Connell——
Comment on this
——I always held the opinion that law, after all, was nothing more than ordinary commonsense. The man in the street takes the view that as the Guarantee Fund is not functioning as it was intended, there could not, by any stretch of the imagination, be any deficiency in that Fund, since the Government is not paying any moneys. The ordinary members of Louth County Council—simple men no doubt —not having the brains of Deputy Donnelly, or possibly the brains of Deputy Corry or Deputy T. Kelly——
Comment on this
——thought that our people were duly entitled to these moneys and, consequently, entered upon this action, as they were entitled. The sums involved for the years 1933-34 are £5,157 5s. 1d.; for 1934-35, £3,034 19s. 4d., making a total of £8,192. In connection with the Estate Duty Grant, the amount involved from 1932 to 1935 was £10,000, the combined sum making a total of £18,000. That is a sum worth fighting for, but even at the risk of losing the case, we were prepared to spend anything from £400 to £500. Let me say at the outset that as a member of the council I was not at all happy about entering upon these legal proceedings, because I thought it was possibly a question of luck, we might lose or we might win. The introduction of this Bill is, I am glad to say, confirmation of our action, because it means that we are going to win. From that viewpoint alone I am deeply grateful to the Attorney-General, who, I suppose, advised the Government to introduce the Bill. On the other hand, I think it is nothing short of dishonourable on the part of a Government to introduce a Bill, having for its object the anticipation of a judgment of the Supreme Court of this State. We have always more or less prided ourselves on the fact that we are a just people, an honest people, and that we like to see fair play. There is absolutely no fair play in this matter. We are prepared to abide by the decision of the courts. If we lose the case we have to pay, but, if we win we are entitled to have the benefit of whatever decision is given by the courts duly constituted in this State. The judges are men who by their position are free from every influence when interpreting the law. In introducing this Bill the Government has thought otherwise.
A great deal has been said about the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, and that individual members of the Party possibly are against this Bill. I suppose there are individual members against it, but I am conscious of the fact that one of the things President de Valera is fortunate in having is unanimity amongst the members of the Party. The reason he has such unanimity amongst the members of his Party is that, if any member dared to put up his own mind against that of President de Valera he would be put out of the Party. Not one member of that Party could on his own get ten or 20 votes in any constituency in this country. That is the explanation of the unanimity that prevails amongst the members of that Party. I advise my friends on the opposite benches to have a little of that very necessary quality known as moral courage. I never accused members of that Party of having that.
Comment on this
That is the Party that masqueraded outside this House for six or seven years as republicans, created damage amounting to £30,000,000 or £40,000,000, then swallowed their principles, came in here and took the oath and their seats and £360 a year. The men who would do that would do anything. I was never surprised when people said what a wonderful thing it was that President de Valera had such unanimity amongst his Party. That is the explanation. Not one Deputy could leave the Party and hope to get ten votes.
Comment on this
Would the President do the same and make the same fight that I did at five elections on my own between two big machines? That is a good record, and to-morrow I could do it again standing on my head. In support of the Bill it was stated here by the Minister for Finance that the people who have paid their annuities will have to make up deficiencies in the Guarantee Fund. The Minister went on to draw a comparison between the amounts outstanding in counties like Tipperary, Monaghan and Donegal. The Minister waxed eloquent on that and taunted Deputy Davin and members of the Labour Party on their attitude to the Bill. The Minister should be a little more fair in his comparisons. I put it to the Minister that there are farmers in County Tipperary who have 40 or 50 fat cattle to sell and who have to sell them on an average of from £9 to £10 apiece, which in ordinary circumstances would realise £15 to £16 apiece. There would be a loss of £6 a head in the case of 50 cattle which would represent about £300 on one item alone. Put that against the position of the average farmer in Donegal. It is well known that there is good land in Donegal. There may be some big farmers there, but not to the same extent as in Tipperary. A Tipperary farmer on one deal would lose as much money as would pay the annuities of hundreds of farmers in Donegal and Monaghan. The analogy is the same as what happened in connection with the British Post Office. When the Post Office included Great Britain, Scotland, Wales and Ireland there was an annual profit of from eight to ten million pounds. On the Irish end nearly two millions was lost every year, yet we enjoyed the same privileges as Great Britain because there was a profit on the service as a whole. It is not a fair, a just, or an honest comparison to compare the differences in the amounts outstanding in Tipperary and Cork and in Donegal and Monaghan. I could quote examples to prove that that is not a fair basis to go on. Amongst other things, it was stated by the Minister for Finance that there was a campaign against the payment of land annuities.
There again, let me tell the Minister for Finance and President de Valera that it does not require a law to make the people of Louth or any man who has been brought up in the real Christian spirit law-abiding. We in Louth always paid our debts and I resent the suggestion of the Minister for Finance, because I myself had the courage to tell the people of Louth to pay their annuities and their rates so long as they were in a position to do so. If there is any Party responsible for the position in which the annuities fund is to-day, it is the Fianna Fáil Party, for, previous to their entry into this Dáil, they told the people to pay no rates and no annuities. On behalf of the people of Louth I throw that insinuation back in the teeth of the Minister for Finance. We in Louth have always done our best to pay our way, and, as a county having a 100 per cent. majority against the Government— two members out of three—there is not a county in the Free State that has done as much to put into operation the policy of the Government in the interests of the people of the country in general. They have sunk their differences and they have cooperated with the Government in putting into effect any measures which they thought would react to the benefit, not alone of the people of the county, but of the people of the Twenty-six Counties.
It is about time that the members of the Executive Council and of Fianna Fáil dropped all these old shibboleths about compaigns against the payment of annuities and rates. We have taken on this action in County Louth and we are prepared to abide by the decision of the courts duly constituted in this country, and, as a people, we resent the action of the Government in introducing this Bill to anticipate the verdict of the courts. If the Government had any decency left they would easily achieve the same object, if and when the decision of the courts was given, but they have thought fit to introduce this Bill in order to spike, as it were, the decision which the judges are about to give in this action.
It is another instance of the insolence, if I may so call it, of the members of the Party opposite. It is another instance of tyranny. It is an old saying that the greater the slave, the greater the tyrant, and members of the opposite benches who were always prating about the tyranny of the British Government, and of the tyranny and dishonesty of the late Government, and who owe their position to propaganda of that nature, are to-day the worst tyrants themselves. They have introduced this Bill with the idea that no matter what verdict the judges give, they are going to make that verdict null and void in so far as the Counties of Louth and Cork are concerned. As people representing a very important county in this State, we think that is not playing the game. It is not justice and it is not honesty, and I hope and trust that, even though this Bill goes through, there will be found time to decide this action and that the result will be a vindication of the views held at present by the members of the Louth and Cork County Councils.
Comment on this
I had no intention at all of taking part in this debate, but after the thunderous pronouncement by Deputy Coburn I cannot resist the temptation to say one or two words in reply. It is a great thing to hear in this House so many Opposition Deputies—and I see Deputy Coburn has joined the group—vying with one another about the steps they took in their constituencies and the advice they gave, the number of people they told "By all means pay your annuities," and how active they have been as propagandists in carrying out the policy of the Government in the collection of land annuities. That is a satisfactory thing coming even at this hour of the day. I am delighted to see that Deputy Coburn has joined that group, but I noticed that he avoided one very important matter with which the Minister for Finance dealt here to-day, in reading out the payments in the various constituencies and counties. Louth is one of the best counties; Louth is one of the places where there are very little arrears. County Louth is only 16 per cent. behind. What is the explanation of that? Is it due entirely to Deputy Coburn going around amongst the people of County Louth and telling them to pay, or is it due to the fact that they are able to pay? Will Deputy Coburn deny this, that of all the constituencies in Ireland —and County Louth is the one constituency in which the representation is 2 to 1 against the Government— there is no county or constituency in Ireland that had done better as a result of Government policy than the County Louth. Take it from whatever angle you like, I defy anybody to deny that, and that, to my mind, is one of the main reasons why there are no arrears and why the people are able to pay.
Comment on this
I will put them up. The proofs are in the fact that the cash has been paid, and there is no better proof than a patent fact. There are no arrears there.
Comment on this
Certainly, plenty of them; and many of them who used to go in for grazing have changed over to the intensive tillage policy. I believe that one of the most successful is the gentleman referred to—the Chairman of the Louth County Council.
Comment on this
I do; I know that much about it. I am glad to see that Deputy Davin is back in the House. After all, I think our constituency has contributed a little to this debate.
Comment on this
I want to say one or two things in reply to the remarks made by the Deputy. He seems to stress, and very unnecessarily, I thought, the fact that the Minister for Finance and the rest of us were not in this House since 1922.
Comment on this
Yes, the Deputy did. The Deputy was here from 1922, he said, and the Minister for Finance was not.
Comment on this
That is quite correct; it is accepted. I want Deputy Davin to know that this Dáil is not the first Dáil set up in the country. There was one which functioned in 1919 and from 1919 to 1922. It was no bed of roses to be a member of that Dáil. The Minister for Finance and many men on these Government Benches attended there and it was no bed of roses, I can assure the Deputy. At no period during the activities of that Dáil did I see Deputy Davin there as a member, and I never even heard that he stood as a candidate. I think he would be well advised, when talking in future about attendances in this Dáil, to keep it at the back of his head that this Dáil is supposed to be the successor to one existing some time previously.
Comment on this
Am I not entitled to reply to remarks made by Deputy Davin? Deputy O'Higgins referred to the poverty of the country and the bad state of affairs in the rural districts. Other Deputies did the same. Either Deputy MacEoin or Deputy Morrissey said that the policy of the Government had so ruined the country that it was necessary to come along with legislation of this sort, whip the people into submission and make them pay. Deputy O'Higgins subscribed to that statement a short time afterwards. I happened to be reading through a few old papers the other evening and I saw where Deputy O'Higgins was making speeches about the poverty of the country. Whoever is managing the organisation of which the Deputy is so prominent a leader ought to select their dates with greater care. Deputy O'Higgins was selected to make a speech in Fethard down in Deputy Morrissey's constituency. He referred to the poverty and the plight of the people. On the same Sunday at which he made the speech in Fethard, 47,000 people were paying £4,000 for admission to a football match at Croke Park.
Comment on this
No. On that day fortnight, the managers of this organisation arranged another meeting in County Tipperary at which the people were told that the country was broken and destroyed. On the same day 40,000 people were attending a hurling match. Yet, Deputy Belton and other Deputies go through the country saying there is not a penny left, that the country is destroyed and that everybody is broken and ruined.
Comment on this
Some Opposition Deputies say that this is an attack on the privileges of the courts, that it is unprecedented, and that the people will have no respect for the courts after this Bill goes through. There is not much in that argument. Notwithstanding the statement of Deputy McGilligan that this is unprecedented, I think I could quote precedents.
Comment on this
I could refer to an attempt which was made, and made successfully, to torpedo a decision of the courts. A special meeting was called, and in five hours a Bill was put through the Oireachtas, got the final assent and was paraded in court the next morning to torpedo a decision given the morning before.
Comment on this
The Minister would not come in to vote against that when I wanted him to come in. When it was through, he came in—a fortnight afterwards—and took the oath.
Comment on this
No. Deputy O'Higgins introduced his speech this afternoon by saying that, for the first time in this House, 100 per cent. of the units opposed to the Government were aligned against a Bill and that, by our majority of one, we were going to bludgeon that Bill through. That position did obtain in this House before the last general election. So much did it obtain—this alignment of the odd Parties as against the Government of that time—that a general election was forced. The issue fought at that election was to give the Government a clear majority over all the possible combinations in this House.
Comment on this
The business before the Committee is amendment No. 1. Deputy Donnelly purposes to be replying to statements made by Deputies in the course of this discussion. It would be possible for any Deputy to pick out all the "asides" or obiter dicta of previous speeches without once referring to the amendment. The Deputy must deal with the amendment in the main.
Comment on this
I am supporting this Bill and voting against the amendment. As I said on the occasion of the Budget, the collective sense, ability and brains of the Executive Council should be able to foresee events as well as any interested Deputy on the opposite side.
Comment on this
When business before the House has to be talked out, we see the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance come in smilingly. When some makeshift arrangement has to be made, Deputy Donnelly is always found to be there. In the course of his few remarks Deputy Donnelly said that County Louth was one of the counties that were prosperous because that county, even though two to one against the present Government, has carried out the Government's policy. There is nothing like having a good opinion of one's self. Before a member of the Fianna Fáil Party knew what tillage was, County Louth farmers were the first farmers behind the plough in Ireland. Amongst them, no man led better than the Chairman of the Louth County Council—James T. McGee. At the present time, he is the only man in Ireland who has an all-in harvester.
Comment on this
Mr. McGee is a personal friend of mine and will have no objection to my stating that he is making money out of wheat. But he has grown it in the same land four years in succession. Is that farming?
Comment on this
The whole necessity for the action in the courts and for this Bill has arisen out of an attempt by the Government, in 1933, to conceal its real intentions. There has been talk about honesty and about people in arrears with their annuities. I have never told anybody to pay their land annuities, for the simple reason that they had to pay them and are paying them—whether they like it or not—to the British Government. That case was made in the 1933 Land Bill. That case holds good to-day. What is this half land annuity which is supposed to be in arrear? It is no land purchase annuity at all. It is a land tax, and it is on that, I understand, that the lawyers advising the County Councils of Cork and Louth have based their case—that the Guarantee Fund was a fund which could and should be raided if there was a deficiency in the money to pay dividends on land purchase stock. What deficiencies have arisen in land purchase stock? None. All money coming in to this Government in the shape of land annuities goes into the revenue. The fact that this Bill is introduced is proof in itself that this alleged half land annuity is really a land tax. The position in which local authorities find themselves at the present time is a desperate one, and the deliberate misconstruing and exploiting by the supporters of the Government of the situation which confronts the local authorities is something which could not be done by anybody with a sense of responsibility.
If Deputy Donnelly can make a sweeping statement, and say why Louth is able to pay its annuities, I think the Minister for Finance should interest himself nearer home. I think he should interest himself in his own constituency, a constituency in which, from one end to the other, there never was more unemployment than there is at present. Never was unemployment so bad in County Dublin as it is at this moment. And what is the position of the Dublin County Council? The position of the Dublin County Council is that last year it had arrears of about £22,000 in rates and £13,000 in land annuities. That £13,000 was stopped from our grants, and it would come to us if this action were allowed to take its course. We had those arrears to throw into the estimates. We had to add £17,000 to the ordinary current expenditure, and strike a rate on that. We are collecting that rate now, and we have instructions from the Ministry of Local Government to take farmers to the courts and get judgment mortgages, when we cannot get any goods to sell in order to realise the rates. Only last night I signed a requisition to the Law Agent to have that done in the case of six or seven farmers. So well is the Fianna Fáil Party whipped up, that a motion to suspend Standing Orders, to give expression from the Dublin County Council to instructions—instructions which the county council in any county has a perfect right to give—to Deputies representing County Dublin, including the Minister for Finance——
Comment on this
Are you above the people of County Dublin? If you are, I will meet you on the platform next time.
Comment on this
The electors of County Dublin, and I as Chairman of the Dublin County Council, have responsibility to see that local government is carried out, and that the county does not go into bankruptcy.
Comment on this
How? I hope the Minister will answer that when he is replying to these criticisms, or that he will answer it anywhere in Dublin, at any cross-roads, and I will meet him at the cross-roads.
Comment on this
If this amendment is not carried, we—I am speaking for the county I know best, and the administration of which I know best—will be up against a desperate situation. We have about £40,000 collected out of £280,000, and land annuity arrears are increased this year. We are proceeding in the courts to register judgment mortgages against farmers who are unable to pay, and who have no realisable assets. Unemployment was never greater in the county than now. Licences are being handed out for fat stock in the county, worth from £1 to £2, to be bought and passed from hand to hand; and there is a tax of £6 per head on those cattle when they are exported, all coming out of our only source of productive revenue in the county—out of agriculture. And those people who support the Government on that council calmly put down a motion that we should put up £3,000 for unemployment at Christmas. On last Monday fortnight a motion was carried there that we should put up £3,000 to relieve unemployment at Christmas, on condition that the Government would put up £8,000, and we have not yet got a reply from the Government. The right horse will be saddled this time.
Comment on this
If the county will have to bear the loss of that £13,000 deducted last year, and in all probability a much larger amount this year, unemployment will increase, and local government in the county will be impossible. Of course, a Chinn Comhairle, I realise that this is the Committee Stage, and that this is only an amendment to a section. While, in the ordinary way, if we were to claim privilege to answer all the points raised, we could go a long way, I think that perhaps, through no design, the debate has been a bit confined, but I appreciate that it is all the better that the debate should be kept within narrow limits. I feel that every Deputy in this House understands the position quite well, and if they were a free vote—if there were no Whips on—I am sure that Deputy Corry would be the first man into the Lobby to vote for this amendment, because he has the request of his county council to vote against the Bill altogether. There would be no pairing.
If the wishes of the constituents were carried out on this measure, as well as on this amendment, there would be an overwhelming majority for the amendment and against the Bill altogether. After all, I think that my old friend, General O'Duffy, has justified himself. The Party system and the Whips of Parties are permitting legislation to go through and compacts to be entered into by our Government and other Governments that the country does not want, that the country turned down and that Deputies in this House would turn down if they were only free to do it and if they were not tied to the tails of the Party machine.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance and the Attorney-General, when they were defending this section of the Bill, made two claims, the first being that they were not interfering in any way with the courts. The Minister for Finance said that he does not admit that he is interfering in any way with the courts. He argued, in other words, that the courts have not given any decision in the matter, and that, not having given any decision, it is fair for him to step in and anticipate what they might possibly do. That reminds me rather forcibly of the story of a lunatic who escaped and struck an innocent man on the head. On being asked, "Why did you strike an innocent person who has not done you any harm?" he replied: "I am striking him before he can do any harm." The Minister is in fear and trembling lest the judges' decision might be adverse to what he considers would be good for himself and his Party. The Minister has in many ways tried to terrorise various sections of the community and to override the decision of bodies such as the Seanad. Deputy Cosgrave said that the proceedings in this House had been reduced to a farce—he did not use the word "farce"; I am supplying that myself—inasmuch as a minority of the House can control legislation. He went so far as to say that a majority of the Fianna Fáil Party, 39 Deputies, can control legislation in this House. I believe that Deputy Cosgrave was exaggerating, because I honestly believe that if there were a free vote the Minister would not get 39 Deputies to stand behind him in support of this amendment or the measure as a whole.
The second argument which the Minister advanced for this Bill is that it was introduced to clarify the intentions of the House, and particularly of his Party, as expressed by the Minister for Defence when he was in charge of the Land Purchase Bill of 1933. I see that that argument is repeated in a letter from the Minister for Finance in the Irish Times in which he gives, in defence of this Bill, a quotation from Deputy Aiken. If statements of the Minister in charge of the Land Bill, which were not translated into sections of the Bill, are to be taken as an excuse for the Minister in bringing forward this legislation, then certainly the Minister has got a very poor foundation for the introduction of the Bill. We find that on other matters referred to by the Minister for Defence, on that Bill, on questions on which there was extreme controversy in this House—and there was no particular controversy at the time the Minister made the statement quoted by the Minister for Finance—on sections of the Bill on which there was immense opposition, we had definite statements from the Minister that certain things would happen. He actually got the support of the House on the understanding that certain things would or would not happen. We have had an illustration, during the last two or three weeks, of the fallacy of putting any faith in that Minister's assurances, given during the passage of the Bill, in a case raised in this House. It is on a declaration made by that Minister during the passage of the Bill through this House, when he made other statements which it was afterwards proved could not be relied upon, that the Minister bases his claim to express the intentions of this House.
The Minister to-day said that they were not responsible to local authorities if they did not budget properly. I might inform the Minister that the local authorities are responsible to the people who elected them, whether they do or do not budget properly. The amount for which local authorities budget is determined by what they believe the people who elected them can pay, an amount which in some cases can only be dragged out of them. There is a story told of a man who went to borrow a fiver from a particular friend and the friend said to him: "I cannot give it to you for three reasons. The first reason is that I have not got it." The would-be borrower said to him: "Well, you can destroy the other two reasons." I would recommend that to the Minister, that there is a limit to the extraction of money from the taxpayers of this State. The limit is expressed in the first reason that that particular would-be lender gave, that he had not got it. That is the position of nine-tenths of the farmers at present.
The Minister made a foul accusation of dishonesty against the farmers and the ratepayers of this State in reply to Deputy Davin. I cannot even say that he did not intend to do it because he went on to qualify it in his comparison of Leix and Offaly when he said that there were 20 per cent. of the people of Leix dishonest and 25 per cent. of the people of Offaly dishonest or vice versa, and so on, with other counties. I hope the Deputies behind the Minister are not in agreement with him in this vile accusation against the hardest working section of the community. There are excellent reasons why this amendment should be accepted. The Minister, through his legal advisers, has at last come to recognise that some of the proposals which the Government anticipated would be met by little resistance when they set out to take a certain course two years ago, have not proved so easy of fulfilment as they expected they would be. When he was advised by seven lawyers of his Party that a certain action was proper and right, it is a pity that these seven lawyers did not at that time advise him that the consequences of his action would be that he would have to come to this House repeatedly to rectify the steps he was taking.
The Minister, when he withheld the land annuities and relieved himself of the responsibility of paying them to another party and turned the moneys received in payment of a particular debt into revenue, also believed that he still left himself authority to use a particular fund in a way in which it had been used when the necessity for the payment of certain sums to another party existed. He believed that he still had power to extract from the farmers, through the agricultural grants, the money that used to be paid over to another party for interest and sinking fund on borrowed money. That money is now used by the Government mainly as revenue and, as has been admitted in debate here by the Parliamentary Secretary, is purely and solely a land tax dragged unwillingly from the landowners of this State. When the Minister now finds himself in the position that he is not legally entitled to do that, he asks the House to support him in his efforts to anticipate an almost certain verdict of the courts that he was not justified in taking that action.
During the last couple of weeks we have had an expression of opinion from three or four county councils— most of them had not up to this got an opportunity of expressing their opinion — as to what they believed should be done with this Bill. We had the resolution of the Cork County Council which, it might be argued, is controlled politically by members of this Party. But we had the Limerick County Council, which has a strong Fianna Fáil majority, unanimously passing a resolution condemning this Bill, and we had the Wexford County Council, on which there is a majority of members of the Government Party, also passing a resolution condemning the Bill. I daresay that if we could wait for another week or so we would have similar resolutions from other counties and that, eventually, the Minister would find himself in this position, that there was not a county council in this State, whatever its political complexion, that did not protest against this imposition.
Apart from the legal side of this particular matter, there is the economic point of view. Even if certain circumstances had never arisen which raised a doubt in the minds of the people and the county councils as to the right of the Government to collect this money through the Guarantee Fund by reductions in the agricultural grants, there are other reasons why that particular procedure should not be adopted. The responsibilities of county councils are infinitely greater now than they were when the agricultural grant was instituted. The sum given as a grant in aid is totally insufficient at present, even though it has been increased threefold in the last ten years. When some years ago Deputy Cosgrave was President and proposed as an addition to a double agricultural grant a further sum of £750,000, the members of the Government Party, who then formed the Opposition, claimed that it was totally insufficient and that much more would be needed to put the county councils and the ratepayers in anything like a fair position. Will anybody say that the position of the county councils and ratepayers has improved since then? Will anybody deny that the position of the county councils and the ratepayers has not got much worse since then, and that the man who could pay £1 then would find it very difficult to pay 10/- now?
This Bill, especially in its retrospective aspect, is a further attempt to destroy the liberties of this House and the liberties, I might say, of the judges of this State, because it is an attempt to say to the judges: "You may do your damnedest, but we will do what we like in spite of judges or courts." Any effective opposition to Government measures is not now likely by any appeal to any other House, or any amendment by any other House, and a minority on the Government Benches, if so directed by the President, the Minister for Finance, or the Party bosses, can outvote what in reality expresses the opinion of a majority of this House, because, just as Deputy Corry ran away from the vote the other night there are numerous other Fianna Fáil Deputies who, if they had his guts, would do the same. Remember, there are some things beyond political expediency, that men have rights outside their political policy, and that some of us will come to be judged some day, by our political supporters if you like, without going to any higher sphere, by our actions in this House and outside it. It will not be an excuse for some of us to say that it was because of political expediency we voted for such-and-such a measure. After all, there is something in the words: "Loved I not honour more." I would appeal to the honour of the Fianna Fáil Deputies, if I cannot appeal to them in any other way; they were elected to this House as Deputies on some higher plane than as mere cats' paws for the Minister for Finance or any other Minister who brought in legislation which these Deputies in their hearts believed was doing a wrong to their constituents—to the people who elected them.
Mr. Corry rose.
Comment on this
Deputy Bennett has talked about the position that has brought about this Bill. I wonder was he in the House on the last day when Deputy Brennan told us that the reason that so large an amount of annuities was unpaid was because the people expected, in plain language, that they would get out of paying them.
Comment on this
No, Sir. I said that the county councils did not strike the rates. That is a different matter.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that the reason why the annuities were not paid was because the people thought that they would get out of them.
Comment on this
No; I expect Deputy Corry will accept my correction. I said the county councils did not strike the rates on the assumption that these grants would be deducted.
Comment on this
Well I expect that better means will be found to collect the annuities other than this method. Still we cannot close our eyes to the fact that this position of affairs has been very definitely brought about by those who preached the gospel about the country: "Do not pay them and you will never have to pay them; get away with the annuities now and you will never have to pay them." That gospel was preached throughout my county.
I have been accused of running away from voting here on the last day. I did not run away from any vote. Why I did not vote is because I am quite prepared to facilitate any Deputy because I expect to be facilitated myself at times. We all have to be facilitated some time or another. But there are Deputies over there who have different fads. One of them has an idea that he must kiss every baby born in Dublin as soon as the baby is born. I met that unfortunate Deputy out in the Lobby the other evening. Apparently several babies had been born in Dublin that evening and he wanted to kiss them all. It was in order to facilitate Deputy Byrne, the Lord Mayor of Dublin, in kissing babies that I did not vote that evening, but I do not think that this arises in any way.
Comment on this
Well this statement was made about my not voting on the last sitting on three separate occasions to-day.
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney made several statements to-day; he had the impertinence to say that he was present during certain speeches at the last sitting. He was present here, but I respectfully suggest to you that though he may have been present in spirit he was absolutely slumbering peacefully on the Opposition Benches.
Comment on this
The Deputy was sound asleep and could not account for anything that was said. I got up to speak because three Deputies opposite made statements about my absence from the division. When Deputies in future look for facilities from me I hope they will not come in afterwards and say, when a division is taken, that I deliberately absented myself. I would like to facilitate every Deputy as I would wish to be facilitated myself. If any Deputies over there want to kiss babies, young or old, in the future, I hope they will always be facilitated.
Comment on this
I do not want to go into the legal aspect of the Bill. That has been dealt with by people more able than I am to deal with it. I want to draw the attention of the House to what the situation will be in connection with local authorities when this Bill is passed, and when the considerable addition will have to be put on the rates. Deputy Corry understands that aspect of it just as well as I do. He understands what the situation will be in the various counties of the Saorstát.
Comment on this
There has been too much of that sort of talk made use of here. Deputy Corry says better means will be found. By that I presume he means that the sheriff will be busier than ever.
Comment on this
There is one thing at all events that I never thought would come to pass in this country—that the bailiffs and sheriffs would be so active as they are at the present time. It has remained for the Fianna Fáil Party to bring about that situation. While I have heard people talking here about making farming pay, I will content myself with giving just one brief instance to the House before I sit down. I know a farm that was sold for £2,400 odd in 1929. All that farm would make on last Saturday was £900 odd. Is not that in itself a sufficient proof of the situation which is being operated up and down the country?
We have heard a good deal of talk as to the reduction in the land annuities. But is it not a fact that the land annuities have been already collected from the farmers by penal duties on live stock and live-stock products? Did not the President state that these annuities have been collected with perhaps more hardship than if they had been paid over at the beginning? Is not that the truth? Is it fair then to the farming community, who are hardworking and honest, that they should be compelled to pay them again after having paid them several times over? I am really surprised at Deputies on the Government Benches, who know the situation as well as anybody, as far as the land annuities are concerned, to be supporting a measure like this. Apart altogether from the precedent which this Bill creates, I am simply objecting to it from the point of view of the hardships that would be imposed on the local authorities and on the ratepaying section of the community. I venture to think that when the Minister for Local Government and Public Health will come up against it next year or the following year, he will find the situation in the country much more serious than it is now. Everybody knows the difficulty about collecting the rates already and the difficulty of collecting the land annuities. The position is that nobody can look with equanimity to the future if this Bill passes.
Comment on this
I am going to vote for this amendment. But the arguments that weigh with me are much more the arguments that have just been stated by Deputy Curran than those to which I have listened during the greater part of this debate. I will vote for this amendment because it is one avenue of attack on the Bill, and I am strongly opposed to the Bill as a whole. I regard the Bill as an attempt by the Minister for Finance to thrust on the local authorities, who have no responsibility for his policy, the financial results of that policy; I regard it as an attempt to make the local authorities face the difficulties that the Minister ought to be facing himself.
I would really give a silent vote for this amendment but for the fact that I do want to dissociate myself from some of the things that have been said in its favour. It is true, of course, that the retrospective character of this Bill is an additional objection to it. It is true we are, I gather, on all sides of the House opposed in principle to retrospective legislation when it can be avoided. But I do not think that the retrospective character of this measure is in any way the main objection to it, and, in fact, I think the case with regard to its retrospective character has been grossly exaggerated by several of the Opposition speakers. I think it desirable to say that, for I think it is an injury to the cause of democracy and liberty to be shouting "Wolf" at the wrong moment, because when the moment arises when there is really need to shout it, the shout does not carry the conviction it ought to. I listened with amazement to the speech of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, for instance. I thought it was astonishing that a responsible front bench Opposition Deputy should reintroduce those expressions "traitor" and "treason" which, I think, have been absent from our proceedings for 12 months or more. I even regret that a word such as "embezzling" should be used in connection with the action the House is invited to take if it passes the Bill. I am strongly against the Bill, but I do not think it makes any sense to use such a word as "embezzling." This House has a right to pass legislation imposing burdens, even unjust burdens, and if it does do something unjust it is still not embezzlement, and it only confuses our minds to use expressions of that kind.
Retrospective legislation is not making its appearance for the first time. I see that many examples have been quoted. I quite agree none of them is exactly on all fours with this Bill, but they are near enough to make it impossible that the man in the street, who does not draw very fine distinctions, will see something extraordinarily novel in principle in what we are doing. Apart from precedents in this State, there have certainly been far more glaring examples outside this State. Take, for example, the action of the American Legislature in making it impossible for the holders of bonds with the gold clause in them to sue before the courts for their rights in that respect. That was certainly a piece of legislation very much harder to defend than anything that the Legislature of this State has been called upon to consider so far.
I do not believe there is justification for all this talk about tyranny and dictatorship that we are constantly being treated to, and it is a great mistake that such talk should arise before the proper time has come for it. After all, the situation about which Deputy Bennett has been complaining, the possibility of a small majority in this House passing some very drastic sort of legislation, is not a new situation. That existed under the Cosgrave Government. It existed when, under a previous Government, there was a Second House that could be practically relied upon to pass anything it was asked to pass by that Government. And, if you are looking for authoritarian language, I have not seen any in the reports of the proceedings of either House to compare with the language used by President Cosgrave, as he then was, when he was suggesting to the Seanad—I would rather say demanding from the Seanad—that they should pass a measure abolishing the right of referendum that had been guaranteed by the Constitution.
I am quite wholehearted in my opposition to the Bill. I do think that it is unjust, and that the whole principle of putting this liability on the ratepayers is wrong, even apart from the special difficulties created by the Government policy. But I do put it to my late colleagues and present friends of the Opposition that it is a mistake from the patriotic point of view to be shouting too loudly about tyranny and dictatorship before the need to do so really arises.
Comment on this
It is rather difficult to understand the attitude of Deputy MacDermot on this amendment. The object of the amendment is to remove the retrospective character of the Bill. If Deputy MacDermot does not agree with the members of this Party in denouncing the retrospective character of the Bill, in other words, if he is opposed to the amendment in its essential feature, then it seems clear to me that he should vote with the Government against this amendment.
Comment on this
The Deputy may not have listened to what I said. I stated that the retrospective character of the Bill was an additional objection to it, but I added that the case on that subject had been overstated, that it was not so flagrant or so novel as represented.
Comment on this
As I understood the Deputy's speech, which was very short, it dealt solely and entirely with the retrospective character of the Bill and this amendment deals only with the Bill in so far as it has a retrospective character. The Deputy went out of his way to talk about the Cumann na nGaedheal Government — that it had been guilty of introducing retrospective legislation. I do not care a hang what Cumann na nGaedheal did, but retrospective legislation in itself is a bad thing. Every one knows that and appreciates the fact that if people have rights to-day, these rights should exist to-morrow. If this sort of thing is to go on, if retrospective legislation is to be recognised as a good thing in itself, something to which objection cannot be taken, then all I can say is this, that we will not know until the year 1940 what rights we have to-day, and possibly in 1940 the rights which we have to-day may be deemed not to be rights. Retrospective legislation seems to me to be essentially a bad thing.
Now, let me come to the facts of the case before the House. Almost every speech on this amendment and on the Second Stage of the Bill, which came from the Government Benches, was devoted to an examination of what Cumann na nGaedheal had done and what had been done in other countries and there was very little effort made to face up to the facts. At present there are two actions before the courts. The Louth County Council and the Cork County Council brought actions for the purpose of securing their rights as they exist. If, as the Minister says, the object of this Bill is merely to clear up doubts and not, in the words of the Parliamentary Secretary, to alter the present state of the law, then let the proceedings take their ordinary course and let us find out in the courts what the law is. Let men who are qualified to interpret the law tell us what it is. A motion was brought in the courts on behalf of the Minister for the purpose of having these two actions dismissed as vexatious and frivolous. That motion was lost in the High Court.
Comment on this
The Deputy is simply following Deputy McGilligan in a misrepresentation of what occurred in the High Court and the Supreme Court. So far from the High Court taking up the attitude which Deputy McGilligan stated it had taken up, the judge went out of his way to say that this preliminary point which was tested in the High Court was one which the defendant quite properly brought before the trial of the main issue.
Comment on this
Of course the Minister would be quite justified if he thought that the actions were frivolous and vexatious in bringing in this Bill. But I am concerned with the Supreme Court.
Comment on this
The case made in the High Court was that the action did not properly lie against the Attorney-General and should be brought against the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
We have this position: Two actions were pending before the courts, and legislation was brought into this House to defeat the purpose of those two actions so far as we can judge by the introduction of this Bill. It is brought in for the express and sole purpose of depriving these two parties from having their right adjudicated upon in the courts. Apart from the retrospective character, there is another thing that seems to me important in this discussion, and that is the nature of the Guarantee Fund itself. When we come to consider the Guarantee Fund, it seems to me there is no justification whatever for attaching the Guarantee Fund. That Guarantee Fund explains itself by its very name. It was put there to guarantee interest and sinking fund under the Act of 1891 to the people who subscribed the money to enable the farmers to buy their land. That purpose has ceased to exist. Money is no longer paid to the people who subscribed it. It is held by this State and paid into the Exchequer. It is now nothing more or less than a tax. In my opinion, the responsibility for collecting taxation should be thrown upon the shoulders of the Government, and for that reason, and because of the vicious principle of introducing such legislation, I intend to vote for the amendment.
Comment on this
I am in entire agreement with what Deputy McGuire said. I cannot understand the attitude Deputy MacDermot has taken up, because he devoted most of his time to making a case, not against the amendment, but making a case against somebody else. In my opinion, there is an unanswerable case against this declaratory Bill. It is a Bill which, if enacted, sanctions a very vicious principle, because, in the words of Shakespeare, it will be regarded as a precedent and many errors will creep into the State.
My words on this matter will be few. I ask Deputies to take note of what has occurred. The county councils of Cork and Louth made certain claims— that they were deprived of money for local government. The county councils brought legal proceedings to enforce what they believed, and what they were advised, were rightful claims. The proceedings were challenged at every step by the Attorney-General, on behalf of the Government, and now, when the case had reached almost its termination, the Government bring in a Bill to nullify any possible decision that may be given against them by the duly constituted courts of this country. I think, without using any talk about tyranny or despotism or dishonesty, this measure ought not to commend itself to any Legislature in this country or in any other. I do not care what the previous Government did, or what the United States Government did. But I challenge the Minister or his legal advisers to cite any declaratory Act which did not save through its provisions pending litigation which had not been decided.
I challenge the Attorney-General or the Minister or anybody in this House to produce any precedent of retrospective legislation which covered a case pending before the courts. Really it seems to me that at present, in the confused and confusing legislation of the present Government, the ordinary citizen does not know where he stands, and does not know whether his position to-day may not be altered by something to-morrow.
It reminds me of a British Bill called "the Colchester Prison Bill." Section 1 provided that a new prison should be erected in the town of Colchester. Section 2 provided that the new prison should be built out of the stones of the old prison, and Section 3 provided that the old prison should continue to be the prison until the new prison was built. That is a sample of the legislation we are getting here from a responsible Government. It has been stated here—it was part of the case made for the passing of this Bill—that it was the intention of the Act of 1933 to do what is now proposed by the present Bill. In other words, that the language used by the gentlemen who drafted the Act of 1933 was not sufficient to effectuate their intention. That is all right for the future, but I think, in all sincerity and solemnity, that the case now before the courts should be determined on the law that existed before the introduction of this measure. I take this opportunity of suggesting to the Minister that the county councils of Cork and Louth should at all events be indemnified against any costs they have incurred up to the present time. That would be only pure justice.
Comment on this
The arguments used in favour of the amendment appear to me to be not only lacking in force, but if applied, dangerous to the interests of the State. If the point made that retrospective legislation proposed in this Bill was going to injure the interests and safety of individual citizens in the State it would, in the ordinary way, justify arguments such as were put forward by the Opposition. But nobody can seriously contend that any vested interest is being interfered with in this proposed legislation. If the county councils of the Free State felt, since the passing of the 1933 Act, that they were ultimately entitled to have their grants paid, irrespective of the payment of the land annuities, there can be no serious doubt in anybody's mind that the county councils would have taken action in the last two years, and that they would not have waited until this point to take it. Even yet the case is an undecided one. It is merely a matter of second thought that originated this legal action which has given rise to this question at the moment. Therefore, since no decision has been made on it, nobody can definitely say that the established and recognised rights of any citizen or of anybody in the State, local or otherwise, have been interfered with. On the other hand, if the Government were to concede the point made by a number of speakers on the opposite side, with regard to the case of the two county councils which have already made claim to the refund of the moneys withheld for the last few years, and if the moneys due to all the county councils, which have run into arrears and which have had moneys withheld during those two years, were paid back to these bodies, what would be the position and what would be the actual happening at the moment? We would have the county councils, such as Cork, Tipperary, and a few others of those counties where very strong agitation during the last few years was brought to bear on the people not to pay their annuities, and where considerable arrears have accrued, receiving very bounteous gifts from the State as a whole, and we would have counties such as my own County Leitrim, a poor county, where the arrears were the smallest of any in the Saorstát, receiving the very smallest amount of benefit. You would have a proportion of the better-to-do counties receiving a very bountiful return. In other words, you would have the Government of the country giving benefits to people who deliberately opposed the administration of the law of the country. That would be a very serious aspect of the matter, and if there were no other argument in favour of making this legislation retrospective, then that would be a substantial argument, and, to my mind, it is an argument that all people in this House, who do stand for established law and good government, should be very slow to oppose. It is really the one thing upon which all Deputies in this House, at any rate, should give a lead, so as to demonstrate that opposition to established government should not be tolerated.
Certainly, it comes very badly from Deputies in this House, who claim that they are taking part in making laws and seeing that those laws should be applied and adopted generally by the citizens of the State, that they should ask the Government to pay a bounty to the people who are opposed to law and government and who are endeavouring in every way they can to destroy that Government. It comes badly from Deputies in this House to suggest that such a bounty should be paid to the people who have been successfully pursuing such a course. I think the amendment is a dangerous one, and I hope that the Deputies on the opposite side, in fairness to their constituents, will take the line of action I have indicated by withdrawing the amendment.
Comment on this
Before proceeding further, there is one aspect that I should like Deputies to consider, and that is with regard to the conclusion of this discussion. If there are several divisions to be taken, as it is quite possible there may be, it would be necessary to bring the discussion to a conclusion now in order to allow the divisions to be taken, if we are to have a decision to-night on this amendment. We have had 25 speakers already and, while the Chair does not wish to curtail discussion, the Chair thinks that there has been a good deal of discussion of most of the matter concerned. The Chair has no desire to interfere with the number of Deputies who may wish to speak, but if we are to have a division or divisions to-night, the Chair thinks that Deputies ought to consider the desirability of curtailing the discussion now and allowing divisions to be taken.
Comment on this
As far as we are concerned, we would be prepared generally to finish the discussion on this amendment now and go as far towards concluding the Committee Stage of this Bill to-night as the time will allow. We agree that there has been a lot of discussion directed to this amendment already, and we think that anything that might be required to be said later on could be said with as good effect on the Fifth Stage of the Bill.
Comment on this
Is there general agreement that I should put the amendment now?
Agreed that the amendment should now be put.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
Question proposed: "That Section 1 stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
Question put: "That Section 2 stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
Question put: "That the Bill be received for final consideration."
Do you agree with this result?