We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Constitution (Amendment No. 24) Bill, 1934. - Motion Under Article 38A of the Constitution.

Contributions 1–98 of 203. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Constitution (Amendment No. 24) Bill, 1934
Enacted

No. 20 of 1934 ›

I move: It is hereby resolved, under Article 38A of the Constitution, that the Constitution (Amendment No. 24) Bill, 1934, be again sent to Seanad Eireann. This is simply to give effect to the decision of the Dáil taken here on 25th May, 1934. On that occasion the question of a Second Chamber was exhaustively discussed and I think it would be unreasonable to embark again on the same discussion and travel unnecessarily over the same ground. There is, perhaps, only one matter that would merit attention at this stage, and that is that certain work which was performed in the Seanad in regard to trimming up Bills gave an opportunity, as all Deputies know, to the Minister after the Report Stage had been passed to examine the Bill as a whole and to consult with the draftsman as regards the full effect of any amendments that might have been introduced. When the Seanad goes I think some provision must be made for a stage here in the Dáil which would enable that general review of a Bill as a whole to be undertaken and give to the Minister in charge of the Bill an opportunity, such as was afforded him in the past in the Seanad, to make any small amendments which might be necessary to make the Bill a completely consistent whole and an artistic whole, if you like, from the draftsman's point of view.

Accordingly we are going to ask the Committee on Procedure and Privileges to go into the question and see whether it would not be possible to have, in addition to the present stages of a Bill, a further stage after the Report Stage, during which, at the request of the Minister, the Bill could be reviewed as a whole. I think that that will enable the Dáil to do practically everything that was done in the same manner as the Seanad. I do not think, as I have said, that there is any point in my repeating the arguments which I advanced here in the past in favour of the removal of the present Seanad and I, accordingly, confine myself to moving the motion.

Comment on this

It is quite obvious that the President is never going to justify motions, at least in his opening statement. He has a great predilection for waiting until the end, when he cannot be answered, especially in matters of this kind. His statement to-day was very short, but it was very revealing. I think that will be conceded. His conception of the functions of a Second Chamber is to trim up the mistakes of the Minister and make them artistic looking. The Dáil has good reason to believe that it is also his conception and that of his Party and of his Government of the functions of a First Chamber. Any little mistakes that might have been made in the office, come in here and they will be trimmed up and made more artistic for us—that is the business of a Parliament. We said that was whither they were trending. We were always very much of the opinion that that is where the whole policy and conduct of the Ministry, not merely in reference to the Seanad, but to this House as well, was trending. The purpose was not to give an opportunity to the Legislature to discuss the value of Bills, but to trim up Bills. What applies to the Seanad applies, as we all know, to this House as well. The main purpose, in future, is that an opportunity will be given to a Minister of trimming up his legislation, making good any mistakes. There is to be no Second House; an amendment of the Standing Orders is to be sufficient so far as the functions of the Second House are concerned.

As usual, there is no justification for the motion. There is a reference back on the part of the President to the extraordinary medley of misrepresentations and bad arguments he produced on several occasions when the Bill was before us. I always like to pay him a tribute. He has sufficient contempt for the country and for this House not to try to justify what he does—to think that any argument is good enough for the country, or for the House. I will say this for him, that he knows perfectly well it is good enough for his Party, therefore it has to be good enough for the country. He has consistently maintained that attitude and I think he should get every credit for it. It would be unfair to him to deny him that particular credit.

What is the line he has taken up? The Second Chamber of the Legislature is unnecessary; it is bad even, and against the canons of democratic legislative control. I think I am summing up fairly accurately the line taken by the President on the last occasion. It is unnecessary, even bad, and against democratic principle.

We are not very much wiser now as to the ultimate intentions of the President than we were before. Having listened to that elaborate statement to which he treated the House, I do not know if that is a transitory measure or a final measure. Perhaps the President can answer that. What does he mean it to be? He has, I think, a very useful habit of saying things of which the public is not quite sure of the precise significance.

He attempted to clarify that by further statements which instead of introducing two alternatives introduced three or four. What is his attitude towards the Seanad? Is it that he objects to the Seanad, as at present constituted? Is that his line, or does he object to the Second House altogether? Is that his line? Not merely has he the habit himself of this want of clarification, but he is also corrupting the Press. We read reports of the Ard-Fheis that was held the other day and in one report we read "the Seanad must go." In another report we read that the Seanad must go, "as at present constituted." Which did the President really say?

Comment on this

Ask the reporters.

Comment on this

Will the President say which is right? He has not done so up to the present, but at all events he has clarified that as much as he has clarified anything else. One thing certain is that his silence does not introduce further confusion into the matter. In any case we were not relying on that report of the Ard-Fheis for the President's views on this matter. He made an election statement in which he referred to the Seanad "as at present constituted." But do these words mean anything? Are they meant merely as a kind of sop? It may be that he may have some amongst his followers who believe in the necessity of a Second House of legislation. Is the President's declaration merely meant as a sop to opinion of that kind or is it meant as a serious contribution that he has under consideration the necessity of a Second House and its desirability? His statement this evening, as I read it, does not solve that question at all. If we were to regard it as the final constitution of this Legislature, then we are in for a unicameral system. That is perfectly true. But I defy anybody to know whether that is merely a transitional stage or whether is is something of a stop-gap while the President is thinking. Deputy Donnelly laughs. There is no use in laughing at that. The President does think. Deputy Donnelly does not think so. The President has given this matter thought. He referred to it before the general election. He referred to it again last year. Therefore, I assume that the President has given the matter thought. A few moments ago a Deputy complained that the House had laboured and had brought forth——

Comment on this

A mouse.

Comment on this

No, he complained that the Minister for Local Government had laboured and had brought forth a mouse. Well, the President is now labouring, and what has he brought forth? He is labouring to amend the Standing Orders. He has not brought forth even a mouse. What was the President's contention? That the present Second House is bad. How does he prove that? By relying on the calumnies indulged in by himself and the members of his Party. By relying on calumnies refuted in the Seanad itself he seeks to prove that. I was glad that the Seanad was able to refute the President's attack on that occasion.

When I referred to the Press a short time ago and asked the President to clarify that particular matter of the report of his speech at the Ard-Fheis, the result was the usual thing. In one paper he was reported as saying "as at present constituted" and in the other papers there was no qualification. Which paper was right? He tells us he is often misrepresented by the Press. I do not like relying on Press reports, but I gather that recently the President was in Geneva. My authority for that was the Press, and a certain knowledge of what occurs there. On that occasion the President met the representatives of at least 50 States. Now the President cannot pretend that they were all monarchically or dictatorially or monopolistically governed States. Did he seek any enlightenment from the representatives of those States? Did he ask them how many of them believed in a unicameral system? Did he ask why it is that not only in every democratically governed country in the world but especially in the most democratically governed countries you have a Second House? Did it strike him to inquire when he met the representatives of those States why it was that they were in favour of the bicameral system of legislature? If he takes the biggest State of all, the United States of America—that was not represented at Geneva—he would have in that alone plenty of examples in favour of the bicameral system. Surely the President will not take up the attitude that the United States is not a democratically governed country. At the time he introduced this Bill it was, and at the present time it is the most democratically governed country in the world. The President will not get out of the controversy by saying there is a Federation there. Because you have it not merely in the Constitution of the United States, but in all the different States that make up the United States. How many of these 48 States has a unicameral system of government? These States have always been governed by popular democracy, they have been governed popularly since their inception, every one of them. Some of them even before their existence as independent States had a bicameral system of government. How many of these States have only one House of legislature?

Is the world wrong? Is all democracy elsewhere on the wrong road? Is it here alone that we have democratic wisdom? Every other country—and some by bitter experience—has recognised that a Second House is almost a sine qua non for the continued existence of democratic government. Surely the practical wisdom of the world is worth all the misleading arguments that were put up here on the last occasion. Let the President bring forward his examples for a unicameral system. Let him tell us whether where you have only a unicameral system, that the condition of these States is the ideal that he has before him for this country?

The President in a statement on the last occasion and in his speeches outside referred to this matter. What did his speeches consist of? Perversions of history, perversions of fact as regards the existing calumnies. Beyond that, there was precious very little in his speeches. The House by this motion is asked to take further steps towards the abolition of the Second House. Apparently, so far as one can judge, the Government has not yet made up its mind as to the final form of the Constitution so far as the Second House is concerned. We have nothing more than a suggestion of transitional arrangements to make good the forgetfulness of Ministers. That is the President's and the Government's contribution to this, one of the most serious constitutional questions that can be raised.

Were the President not in the position in which he is, and were the Fianna Fáil Party not so easily led as they are—and Deputy Donnelly tells us they are proud of that—it would be impossible for anybody to take a statement of that kind seriously. But we must remember the position in which the President is. He is the head of the Executive Council of this State. He is rushing through a Bill of this kind for the destruction of the Second House of the Oireachtas and he is doing that without any serious effort to replace that Second House. We must take it for granted—and I see nothing to the contrary, despite the remarks that he was excogitating a Second House— that, like other remarks, these are meant not as a principle but to tide over certain difficulties with his followers. We may take it for granted that he is still in favour of the unicameral system. He is not convinced of the wisdom of having a two-House system. In that he refuses to follow what has been the practical experience of every democratic country in the world. And he has given no reason for doing that.

We have had a few theoretical arguments and an epigram or two from the Abbé Seyès. I suggest to the President that you cannot base the constitution of this country on theoretical opinions of that kind, whether from the Abbé Seyès, from the Quai D'Orsai or Gambetta. I do not think you can do it. Recollect the particular man you choose as an example. He is well known. He could turn out a series of constitutions that might satisfy the President, but the only thing about them is that they do not work. I used a metaphor about them on the last occasion, a metaphor constantly applied to the Abbé, and that is that they are like his French clocks, kept under his glass case and so beautiful to look at, but they will never tell you the time. That is a description that has been applied to the Constitutions that his constitution machine turns out in the countries that have tried, and some countries did try, the unicameral system, with disaster to themselves. I wonder when the President chose that particular example, that particular epigram, to try to convince this House of the wisdom of abolishing the Second House, whether he had really considered what had been the effect in the Abbé's own time of trying the single chamber system? Was it democracy? Nothing of the kind. It was, as the President knows perfectly well, one of the most degraded forms of tyranny, because it was degrading not merely to the people tyrannised over but, it possible, it was still more degrading to the people who exercised the tyranny.

Relying on a one-House Government of that kind does tend to tyranny of that type. Theoretically you may argue against that—I have not heard a theoretical argument against it — but in practice the other thing has too often worked out for this or any other House to accept lightly the obiter dictum of the President in favour of single chamber government. He should have utilised the opportunity afforded to him in moving this motion of saying what are the future intentions of the Government. They are asking the Oireachtas to wipe out one House of the Oireachtas, and they have not made the slightest effort to indicate what they are going to put there instead. The President must have a clean slate. He would remind one of the person always cleaning a blackboard, wiping off everything on it. That is not government. The House would like to know what he is going to write on it afterwards. Many people inside and outside the House would need to have a little more confidence in the political foresight of the President before they could be satisfied with this wiping off process. To my mind all this is purely destructive. There was every opportunity between the time this Bill left the House and the moving of this Resolution for the President to have thought out what really were to be his ideas in reference to the legislative assembly of this country. Apparently he has not advanced a single step from the position that we found him in 18 months ago.

We have heard the cordial and glowing tribute from his colleague sitting there to the left of him on the work that has been done for majority rule. Majority rule means that the minority will accept the legislative decisions, properly carried through, of a majority in Parliament. But apparently the view is that the minority, whether they are great or small, whether they are ten or 10,000 or 500,000, must accept the views and cannot criticise the views of the Party that is for the moment in the majority. That is the interpretation that is so often given to majority rule now. If a law is passed in this Parliament, as long as it is a law properly passed, the minority must respect it. That does not mean that the minority is deprived of any right of criticism. It must not be assumed that everything the majority does is full of wisdom. If you hand over the legislative power of this State to one House, do you think you are always going to get wisdom? What check is there on any Minister? Does anybody think that this House is a check on any Minister? The President is quite right, the business of this House is to trim up the ideas of the Minister, get rid of any ragged and loose ends lying about, make the thing nice and tidy.

Comment on this

Give it a permanent wave.

Comment on this

That is just about the conception the President has of the functions of this House—not a bit higher than that. I must say that the Deputy for once has made a very valuable interruption. He has summed up the attitude of the President and his Party towards the business of this House. All we do here is to smooth it out nicely and make it artistic. Barbers are artists, I admit, so the Deputy was perhaps quite right. But what we want on this occasion is something more than the mere dipping into a student's book on political theories. The President was at Geneva. I gather he was there and that he spoke there. He had an opportunity there of meeting people who have experience of legislative bodies. I wonder did he inquire of the representatives of any of the countries represented there that are democratically governed whether they believe in a Second House? Did he find out whether the countries that started with one House have kept up that particular practice? His references to the French Revolution by implication show that he is fully familiar with that. He could have found an excellent example there of the working of a single House, how destructive it was of every single right of the ordinary citizens.

Remember that you can have Party dictatorship, and that has been proved again and again. Some of the worst tyrannies have come out of the single House system, where you had a Party in the majority. That does not save you from dictatorship; that does not give you a democratic Government; it does not ensure it in any way. Some people would ask us to wait until the disaster of dictatorship is upon us before we say a word about it. We can only judge the actions of the President, we can only judge what the President is aiming at, not by what he says—who would undertake to do that?—but by what he is doing. He is now aiming at abolishing the Second House, abolishing any kind of check on himself and his Ministers, because the majority here is not a check on the Ministry. I do not think even Deputy Donnelly would hold it was. In fact, I will say this for the Ministers, that the Ministry are a check on the majority of this House and even, possibly, the majority in the Ard Fheis. Even possibly a majority in the Ard Fheis would not be an effective check at the moment, if you wipe out the Second House at the will of the President and at the will of the Executive Council. That is the practical proposal at present. Speaking on April 18, 1934, as reported in volume 51 of the Official Reports, columns 1830-31, he said:—

"Historically the idea of having a Second House in the Legislature has been the result, to a very large extent, of accident."

That is not so. A second Chamber is the result of deliberate design on the part of the people in a great many countries. I know this, and everybody who follows the words of the Fianna Fáil Party knows, that in this matter they have one example constantly before their minds. They are obsessed, and they cannot get rid of it, either positively or negatively, with the system in one country and that is Great Britain. There the Second House means the House of Lords, which must always be a bulwark of privilege and aristocracy. The syllogism is so simple that the President accepts it. There you have an example of one particular kind of House, but what about all the other assemblies in the world? They are not the result of accident, but the result of deliberate action. Political experience convinced people of the necessity of setting up a Second House. The President went on to say:—

"It is not at all essential to the idea of representative government. In fact, it is, I might say, obnoxious to the idea of truly representative government."

Is that seriously the view of the President? Is he to be an example against the whole world? Is the idea to be Athanasius contra mundum? I know the President fancies himself in that role, but does he expect the House and the country to adopt that rôle? He says:—

"It seems to me that there is only one way of avoiding the dangers which the advocates of a Second House have in mind, and that is to educate our people politically, to make them understand the consequences of their acts at election times."

I admit the Government are doing this pretty thoroughly.

"To let them know that when they are electing their representatives they are performing an act from which will result the good or ill government of the country for the period of years fixed by the Constitution."

The Government should by their methods educate the people into a proper sense of responsibility for their actions.

"A sense of responsibility on the part of the elected representatives, when they are elected, is the only real safeguard, and I think that we are wise, in these times, in depending upon that rather than upon some artificial arrangement such as has been suggested by the supposed check of a Second House."

I am quite willing to have the people educated in the matter of constitutional machinery. You cannot have effective political machinery unless people are politically educated. That is common ground, but is the President, when dealing with this measure, educating people in the right way? I do not think so. I think the calumnies circulated about the Seanad, and the propaganda indulged in, is not the best political education for the people. But I say, no matter how you protect your institutions, unless you have goodwill and sound political tradition and practice behind them, you cannot make any institution work well. The arguments that the President puts up against the Seanad would apply equally against the Dáil. Let the country elect a President for five years; let him appoint his Ministers, and in effect let the country depend on the goodwill of such people. What is the good, then, of this House? That argument is equally fatal to this House as it is to the Seanad. Whatever the President says about the necessity for political education and political customs on the part of the people towards the working of such institutions, it is equally true that these things cannot work properly without good institutions. The President's argument in that connection cuts at the very root of constitutional legislation. There should be no constitution, according to his argument. The goodwill of the people appointed to rule the country is enough. That is what his argument amounts to. Why then all this expense in connection with the Dáil? What good can it do? I have heard the argument that institutions do not count and that everything must depend upon the goodwill and wisdom of the administration. How often have we heard that? It is an argument that cuts at the root of all institutions, and it is quite as fatal to the Dáil as it is to the Seanad.

What was the argument? It is extraordinary at the present day, with the example of every other country before us, that we should have to labour this point of unicameral versus the bicameral system. Are we not to learn from every other country? Take the case of the Seanad. What was the cause of its offence? Is there any truth in the statement of the President that they had tried unduly to obstruct the Government? If there was one thing that was completely refuted in the Seanad it was that particular charge which was made and was never withdrawn. I think the record of the Seanad, as pointed out by the Chairman and by Senator Douglas, is a record to be proud of. They did not unduly interfere with legislation. What have they done? What were the charges made against them? That with undue haste they passed through all its stages what we may roughly call the Public Safety Bill when it came before them, and which had been opposed by the then Opposition in this House. They did so in extreme circumstances, when jurymen were intimidated, when trial by jury had broken down, when an attempt was made to terrorise members of the Oireachtas and to prevent them passing legislation. That was the situation they had to face. They had either to stick to form, or else they had to pass that law immediately; otherwise, the country was in the throes of disaster. But it is extraordinarily strange that that should be made a charge against the Seanad. I have a vague idea that the President, having made his gaol delivery, thought he had better open them again and close them behind prisoners. I have an idea he has enforced that Act. He need not have done so. That is one of the principal offences of the Seanad, and yet that Government, supported by that Party, stands pat behind that Act, in circumstances not at all comparable to the circumstances under which the Seanad passed that Act. It held up that Bill. Why? Because there are in this country a certain number of people who have reverence for an oath; who do not regard it as a mere empty formula; who have some attachment to principle. Because they have some attachment to principle, and because they saw the Government making a deliberate attempt to victimise their political opponents, they held up the Blueshirt Bill. They opposed that effort to tyrannise the political opponents of the Government. Are they to have no sense of duty? Is it wrong for them to have principles to which they can be true, and to which they were true? I am not defending the present members of the Seanad or the present body. They do not need defence. There is many a man in that Second House who deserves well of this country; who gave it great service, and who risked his life by giving it that great service when the majority rule was attempted to be imposed in this country—the majority rule which now appeals so strongly to the Minister for Finance.

People say, "We do not wish to talk about dictatorships." See the powers already in the hands of the Executive in this country. Take two Acts alone operated by the Government. The Public Safety Act is one. The other is the Emergency Imposition of Duties Act. Those give complete power—power which I am sorry to say they are using in some cases— over the lives and property of the people of this country into the hands of the Executive. If I blame the Seanad at all I may blame it for not trying to hold up that Imposition of Duties Bill longer. Remember the Government were generously met by the Seanad on the question of having no loss of time on that measure, because it was represented to them, I understand, that speed was necessary. Was it necessary really for the winning of the economic war? Has it been mainly used for that purpose? We have this House tamely passing a Bill for the Government to give complete control over every penny in this country to the Ministry, without coming before this House. That was passed by this House. They have that power, and they have used it. I understand there has been a case in which they levied a duty and then allowed the Order to lapse, and it has never come before this House. The dangers in that Act were pointed out at the time. The House still voted for that Act on the understanding that it would be used only as long as it was necessary for the economic war. It is no longer being used in connection with the economic war. It is used as a piece of daily machinery of government, and it is being so used that there is no longer any real security for property. They may say it is justified in this case. It is easy to find cases in which it is much more justifiable than the case in point, but the precedent has been set of imposing a duty, then letting the Order lapse, collecting the duty, and never having to come before the House for that levy of money. That can refer to an individual. Look at the lives and property of individuals, and see the tremendous power in the hands of the Executive. Then we are told that you have only to rely on the goodwill of the majority—the goodwill of the Government. The majority does not act as a check on the Government. The majority acts as a stimulus to the Government, and eggs them on. I firmly believe that the Party is much more to the Left than the Ministry is; I believe that the Ard-Fheis is still more to the Left. Are those the checks you have? Is that the public opinion that is to act as a check on unwise measures on the part of this Government? Does anybody believe it—anybody who tries to envisage the future so far as this country is concerned? I see no evidence of any check. You had there a body which did useful work. You are scrapping it because it did not immediately bow the knee to the Executive when it felt it was violating a principle. That is the sole reason why it is being scrapped. The President came in here in a fit of pique, and that is the ground for this legislation. The Seanad gave consideration to Bills—consideration which, from my experience when I was Minister, I can say was quite as good and quite as valuable as the consideration given them in this House. I think most of the other members can say the same thing. It was a different consideration; new ideas were brought out which were not brought out in this House. That is one of the great values not merely of a Second House but of a Second House which is different in its constitution from the First House. I think it is a pity that Party lines have become as marked in the Seanad as they are here. I think it would be much better if the Bills got the same consideration which they used to get in the first years of the Seanad, when they were examined from a new point of view, and when the Minister had to look at the legislation from a point of view which was not put before him in his Department or in this House. All that is being swept away. Leaving aside the immediate issue, I think it is exceedingly unwise that we should be asked to abolish the Seanad without being given the slightest intimation that anything is to take its place, or if so, what is to take its place. I do not believe the course of honour or safety for the democracy of this country lies along the lines marked out by the President.

Comment on this

This motion really raises two distinct questions: one, whether it is desirable to have a Second Chamber; and, two, whether our Second Chamber as at present constituted is worth preserving. I have consistently held throughout this controversy that it was desirable to have a Second Chamber, and I have held as consistently that the present Second Chamber is unsatisfactory, especially since the introduction of the system of election which now prevails. I expressed those views in the old days of the Centre Party, and I also expressed them when I was a member of the official Opposition. It so happened that when the Government introduced the Constitution (Amendment) Bill, No. 24, I was acting temporarily as leader of the Opposition in the absence of Deputy Cosgrave. In view of the rather outspoken statements that I had made about the present Seanad, my position might have been embarrassing but for the fact that the President introduced this Bill in very special circumstances. He admitted in so many words that he had introduced it in order to show his indignation at the action of the Seanad in throwing out the Bill for preventing the wearing of what were called political uniforms. Throughout all the debates which took place on the Second and later Readings of this Bill that motive was uppermost in the speeches from the Fianna Fáil Benches. This was a naked piece of revenge upon the Seanad because they had done something which vexed the Government. That something which they had done was something of which I thoroughly approved at the time, of which I approve still, and of which I rather imagine that the Front Bench of the Government Party now approves. I very much question whether that anti-Blueshirt Bill will ever in fact be put into operation after the Seanad has disappeared, assuming that it does disappear. In the earlier debates on the subject we were hardly dealing with the merits of the present Second Chamber as an abstract question. It was all mixed up with this matter of the Blueshirt Bill and Party resentment over what was going on.

I want now to say something briefly about the general question of a Second Chamber and its desirability. The President has very disappointingly said nothing at all to-day either against Second Chambers or against our own Second Chamber, but I also find that Deputy O'Sullivan's remarks have been somewhat disappointing. I find he has not put forward anything that appears to me to be a persuasive case for Second Chambers in general, or for our own Second Chamber in particular. He has almost altogether confined himself to answering a number of remarks made by the President at earlier stages. In the various utterances and writings that one comes across advocating a Second Chamber there is a great deal of contradictory argument. Deputy O'Sullivan remarked that the Party opposite were suffering from a sort of obsession that Second Chambers must be bulwarks of privilege because of the English House of Lords. But it is not only the opponents of Second Chambers but very often the supporters of Second Chambers who suffer from that obsession. Much of the argument I have seen in favour of a Second Chamber in this country has assumed that such a Second Chamber would be a bulwark of privilege. I think we really need to get clear in our minds what we want a Second Chamber to be before saying we want a Second Chamber at all.

Deputy O'Sullivan has made some rather vague and sweeping statements about the experience of mankind on the subject. He has referred loosely to a number of States which were alleged to have tried Single Chamber Government and who found it so disastrous that they gave it up and went back to Second Chamber Government. I wish he had mentioned these States and given a description of the events that took place. He referred to the French Revolution, and he suggested that the events following the French Revolution were such as showed up Single Chamber Government. The events of that time may have produced unsatisfactory Single Chamber Government, but they also produced unsatisfactory Double and Treble Chamber Government. It is rather audacious for me to argue with a professional historian, but I think the truth of the matter is that at the time of the revolution, the French were so politically uneducated and so violent in all their doings and passions, that no form of democracy could then succeed. That is why Napoleon came forward and that is why an absolute Government was established, not because of some technical defect in the arrangements of the Legislature in France. Deputy O'Sullivan also referred to the United States of America and suggested that we should take them as an example. I do not agree with him. I think politics and democracy in America are extremely unsatisfactory. I do not think that there is any reason why we should go out of our way to copy the American Federal Constitution or the Constitution of any of the American States.

Democracy is exposed to great dangers at this particular time. We have seen democracies swept away and tyrannies of one sort or another put in their place. Take the three countries where Fascism exists—Italy, Germany and Portugal. Not a single one of them had Single Chamber Government. Each of these countries had government by two Chambers. I think that what is going on in the world to-day is of much more importance to us than anything that went on in the world 50, 100 or 150 years ago, because the political dangers that are present in one part of the world at a particular time, are likely to be present in another part of the world as well.

Deputy O'Sullivan suggested that we have set our feet on the downward slope, that the Dáil is being degraded, and that we are becoming mere tools of the Ministry. For my part, I am not conscious of that degradation. I am honestly not conscious of it. He referred to the immense financial powers the Ministry are able to exercise, but these powers are not in any way affected by the existence of the Second Chamber because the Second Chamber is precluded from asserting itself on questions of finance. I personally regret it is but that is so. Although I listened to Deputy O'Sullivan's remarks very attentively I really found very little in them to support the notion that a Second Chamber was essential and still less in them to support the notion that our existing Second Chamber is entirely satisfactory. He used, of course, the word "tyranny," a word which is now in fashion. I am going to quote on that subject from some important authorities, from none other than the ex-President of the Executive Council, Deputy Cosgrave, and the ex-Vice-President, Senator Blythe.

Comment on this

How are you going to vote?

Comment on this

Do not hurry him.

Comment on this

When the Constitution (Amendment) Bill, No. 10, was introduced, a Constitution Amendment Bill which abolished the Referendum, there was a suggestion in the Seanad that it was an attack on democracy. Here is the statement then made by Deputy Cosgrave—I am quoting from column 814, volume 10, of the Official Report of the proceedings of the Seanad:—

"There is no danger either now or at any other time that any Government here will be autocratic, will abuse its power, will infringe the rights of the people, will interfere in any way with the liberties of the people and this is, to my mind, one of the last expiring sparks of the slave mind which stands out and says to the people: ‘Beware of your Government. Government is a thing which you have never had before, a thing of which you have no experience, something to be afraid of and something to be watched.' That is not a true expression of sound Irish citizenship, and I hope that the Seanad will take that view of it."

At a later stage of the Bill Deputy Cosgrave got extremely angry with Sir John Keane, because Sir John Keane joined with the Labour Party in resisting the removal of the Referendum.

He says in column 1046 of the same volume:

"It is a nice thing to say people can easily decide on one thing. That is political nonsense, democracy gone mad .... You are not presenting them with a fair and honest question when you say there are some important matters of legislation which you could put to the people and which they could decide. Equally, the Senator will find on the programme of every political Party in the State something with which he agrees or disagrees. That is the usual position of a crank."

That is one in the eye for me.

"You will never find a person in that position doing any good for himself or anybody else."

Comment on this

Another in the eye for you.

Comment on this

"The Government carried out on democratic principles is mainly government by Parties. In modern times with proportional representation a greater diversity of views can be expressed than under the old system. The main consideration is, you must get a Government. I would like to see a Government in which Senators Linehan, O'Farrell and Sir John Keane would be the moving spirits."

The whole purport of these quotations is that it is an improper attitude of mind for a Senator to pick and choose, that he should throw in his lot with one Party or the other; hit upon some people who are worthy to form a Government, and stick to them. If that is what a Second Chamber is to be for, I personally can see no use in having one. I am definitely not in favour of a Second Chamber if that is all that is to be aimed at.

Now I am going to quote from Senator Blythe in column 1425, Volume 24, of the Dáil Reports:—

"My opinion is that while Constitutional checks will prevent hasty and ill-considered legislation, that legislation being passed in good faith by a particular House of the Parliament, I do not think that any checks can be devised which will frustrate the policy of an unscrupulous Executive supported by an unscrupulous majority in the House."

Then, lower down, he says:—

"The safeguard lies really in public opinion, and some sort of moral standard being held by any majority that may be in power. We must look at these proposals not as safeguards against the tyrannical majority, but simply as ordinary legislative checks designed to prevent hasty or wrong-headed action."

In other words, this argument about a Second Chamber being for the purpose of frustrating tyranny is a bad argument. That is not what it is for. There is only one way of preventing tyranny, and that is by educating the people to dislike tyranny. In the last resort, the country will have the Government it deserves to have. If the people of this country do not want tyranny, they will not have tyranny. You may have two Chambers, three Chambers or four Chambers, and if the people of this country did not mind having tyranny, tyranny they would get. No Second Chamber is capable of preventing it, as was clearly pointed out on these earlier occasions by Deputy Cosgrave and Senator Blythe.

What is it that does justify the existence of a Second Chamber? I think Deputy O'Sullivan put his finger on the real point when he said that what he wanted was to get in another House a different kind of approach to each subject that presents itself from the way of approach there is in this House. That is in definite contradiction, to my mind, with what Deputy Cosgrave said in the quotation I have read. Notwithstanding that, I believe that it is sound. There would be no need for such a change of approach if this House were perfect. It is absurd to expect any House to be perfect. The President sometimes speaks as if there ought to be no Second Chamber, because he cannot think of an absolutely perfect Second Chamber. But it would follow from that that there ought to be no sort of Legislature at all, because it is impossible to find a perfect one.

This House is necessarily very far from perfect. Anybody who reflects on what general elections are must realise that that is so. A large number of people are practically debarred from presenting themselves at general elections, because they are too busy, or they are not the sort of people who are able to get up and make a speech that is a popular hit. They may be people who, if they did get up, would have opinions that were so unusual that they would not be understood.

We are apt to get in this House men like all of us who are able to get up and say more or less the sort of things that people expect to hear, perhaps not an awful lot more than what the people expect to hear. There is no way, depending on democratic election, that I can think of by which you can hope to get into the service of the Legislature people who have not got the qualities of popular appeal.

It is suggested sometimes that proportional representation enables every kind of person to get into this House. That is not true, because a great many of those who would be valuable to this House have not got the time for an election campaign, or are not prepared to spend money on an election campaign. Of course, where a Party puts up the money for a candidate, all is easy, or where even, say, a vocational group may be found to put up the money, it is easy. But how few people there are in this country who are in a position to go out as individuals and spend the time and money necessary to secure their election to the Dáil, even if they had the requisite popular qualities of mind to give them a chance of election.

I have suggested before, and I repeat the suggestion, that on the whole, the best hope of getting a thoroughly satisfactory Second House is by nomination by the Government of the day, always provided that the necessary precautions are taken to secure that the people going into that House take no part in purely Party politics, that they are in some way divorced from Party politics, that if they have been members of a Party they should cease that membership, and that they do not subscribe for Party or organisation purposes——

Comment on this

You are nearly qualified.

Comment on this

——and that they will approach each subject that crops up for them to deal with without Party prepossession, so far as that is humanly possible to secure. The main point is that this House, is not, as the President of the Executive Council once alleged, a good microcosm of the country. It is not a good microcosm of the country, because there are large classes of people who could not by any possibility, make their way here. Moreover, it is not a true microcosm of the country because once we get in here the bonds of Party discipline and the intensity of Party feeling count for enormously more with us than they do with people outside in the country. So that in a sense we are always living here in an artificial Party atmosphere. It is for that reason I suggest that it would be of immense value to supplement the democratically elected House by a non-Party House. I consider that is necessary in order to make democracy work well. I believe in democracy. I believe in democracy intensely, and I want to see it saved in every country where it exists, and I want to see it working well. I do not think its chances are good if you confine yourself to a purely elected House without any sort of supplement such as would be provided by a Second House constructed on another basis.

It is easy to think of a whole lot of different types of people who might be put into a Second House. You might put in businessmen, who have not the time for Party politics. You might put in intellectuals taken from universities. Personally, if I were the President nominating a Second House I should deliberately include representatives of opinions that have any sort of important following in the country, even though they were minority opinions, or even though they were extremely unpopular opinions. I should for instance, put in one or two representatives of the social credit movement—not that I agree with that movement. I should put in one or two Communists.

Comment on this

A kind of national zoo.

Comment on this

And a few cranks.

Comment on this

They would be cranks on the Deputy's definition of what cranks are.

Comment on this

Is it the Deputy's intention to establish a national Madame Tussaud establishment?

Comment on this

I do not see any reason why cranks should be compared to Madame Tussaud figures. Cranks are more alive and kicking than others. The general objection to cranks is that they do not behave like the figures of Madame Tussaud. If you behave as a good Party man you are a Madame Tussaud figure.

Comment on this

If you have a bee in your bonnet about licences you are qualified for the Seanad.

Comment on this

As regards the general question of having a Second Chamber, I do hope that the President has not closed his mind to the possibility of establishing one. He has been very cautious of late, at any rate, in saying nothing at all about that. But I hope he will not allow this debate to close without giving us an indication that he will devote serious attention to the problem of devising a Second Chamber. I have always had sympathy with the argument that the sort of Second Chamber we have been accustomed to must be either useless or mischievous; that it is useless when its friends are in power, and that it is mischievous when its opponents are in power, because then it blocks the will of the people. I think there is a great deal in that. But I suggest that it would be possible to get away from the Party system in creating your Second Chamber provided you have such conditions as to make the Second Chamber unattractive to anybody as a career. It has not got to be regarded as a career. After all, it meets 30 or 35 times a year for only a few hours in the afternoon. It would be perfectly possible for people to go there and perform their duty without expecting to be paid for it—more than their out-of-pocket expenses—and not to regard it as a career to which they should devote their whole time. If you once make membership of the Seanad attractive as a livelihood, as a career, I am afraid there is nothing in the world can prevent it from being caught up in the Party machine and made part of the system.

The present Seanad contains men of great distinction. I am far from desiring to speak disrespectfully or offensively of them. But the fact remains that the system of election to it is one that must make it more and more a mere Party machine. Take what happened here after the General Election of 1933. There was a Senatorial vacancy shortly after that election. We of the Centre Party had 124,000 votes, or I think it was 127,000 votes—first preference votes—in the General Election. The Labour Party had 80,000 odd first preference votes in the General Election. They had six or seven representatives in the Seanad already. We had one, just one— Senator Dillon. The Cumann na nGaedheal Party, needless to say, were more than adequately represented in the Seanad in proportion to its numbers in the Dáil, apart from the fact that the Independents could be pretty well relied upon to act as the Cumann na nGaedheal indicated to them. We sought to have that vacancy filled by somebody representative of our Party, and if there were any sincerity in the pretence that it was the desire to have all Parties in the House proportionately represented in the Seanad, obviously we ought to have had no difficulty in getting the seat. But we could not get it. There was no use in our putting forward a candidate. The official Opposition, though the Party was already well represented, insisted on putting forward a candidate, and he was elected. In other words——

Comment on this

And Deputy MacDermot came into that Party afterwards, did he not?

Comment on this

What has that to do with it? The Deputy will have an opportunity of explaining what bearing that has on the argument. The Party system applies under the new method of election just as fully to the Seanad as to this House. It must go on doing so more and more, and the nominated members will gradually disappear. Nobody will be elected to that Seanad who has not got the approval of——

Comment on this

Those Parties representing public opinion.

Comment on this

Those Parties representing public opinion. But I thought we were all against tyranny in this House. Yet I presume the Deputy will concede that at the moment the Government Party represents public opinion more than does the Opposition, and that Party is capable of doing tyrannical things. That is one of the things that might be called tyrannical—to elect people to the Upper House who are sent there for purely Party purposes.

When I was a member of the official Opposition and sitting on those benches over there, I said that the present Seanad was unduly prompt to perform everything that it was ordered to perform during Deputy Cosgrave's administration. From the point of view of the Government the present Seanad is an unfair Seanad, unfair to them while they are in power, but even the majority against the present Government is going rapidly. If they are in power a few more years they will have a majority in that Seanad. Then judging by the quick changes that have been made in the past I would not be at all surprised if in five or ten years time, assuming that Deputy Cosgrave comes back here again to this House with a majority and finds a hostile majority in that Seanad, he would be as strong for doing away with it as is the President to-day.

Comment on this

He will bring in another Constitution (Amendment No. 10) Bill.

Comment on this

It will then be possible to turn up the quotations and to show that there should not be this distrust of the Government of the day which he regarded as proof of the slave mind characteristic of our people.

Comment on this

It will be all right when we have a few Communists in the Seanad.

Comment on this

This Bill has an unfortunate history. I think the President of the Executive Council was very ill-advised in bringing it in at the time that he brought it in or stating the grounds on which he did it. I personally am not prepared to vote now in favour of doing away with the present Seanad unless the President gives us some indication that he is constructing an alternative. At the same time I believe the Seanad to be of very little use at the moment and I believe it will be of less and less use as time goes on, and I find myself unable to cast a vote in its favour.

The Fianna Fáil Party has so far been remarkably lucky. It has had almost uncanny luck since it came into office, but I am inclined to think that its luck is turning. For the last few days it has had a very rough passage indeed for one of the most unpopular Bills ever brought into this House. And now it looks as if there was quite a sporting chance that the Seanad, which has, on the whole, been an unpopular body throughout its career, would end up that career in a blaze of glory as the result of throwing out the Land Purchase (Guarantee Fund) Bill. Possibly they will seek to purchase a prolongation of their existence by passing the Bill—one never knows what may happen.

What I have said boils down to this. A Second Chamber is desirable, not for the purpose of saving the country from tyranny, because it cannot save the country from tyranny and anyone who thinks it can is hugging an illusion. It is better to have no safeguard at all than a sham safeguard and, considered as a bulwark against tyranny, a Second Chamber is a sham safeguard and above all the present Chamber is a sham safeguard. What is desirable is that in view of all the manifold drawbacks of an elected Chamber, in view of the amount of Party discipline that is necessary in an elected Chamber, in view of the fact that so few actively engaged, practical business men have the time to come into an elected Chamber or have the sort of character that makes them feel able to expose themselves to the vicissitudes of an election—in view of these things, we should have a Chamber of another kind where questions are approached from another angle, where Party discipline does not prevail, where Party ties and Party shibboleths are forgotten. I beg the President to consider the problem thoroughly from that point of view and I appeal, on the other hand, to members of the Opposition who do believe in a Second Chamber not to destroy their case by continuing with a blind defence of the present one as if it was perfect, when it is, in fact, so very, very far from being satisfactory.

Comment on this

Anybody who has been in this House for the last half-hour would have wondered very much what was the proposal before the House. I must confess that the speech we have just heard left me completely in doubt as to what Deputy MacDermot's intentions were or what his view on any single subject was. I think most Deputies in the House must be in the same position as that in which I now am. I prefer not to follow any of the ramblings of Deputy MacDermot, but to come to the concrete facts which are before the House. The one question before us is this: Is there to be in this State a system of government of one or of two Chambers? No alternative scheme has been put forward. The question is not whether there is going to be a different type of Seanad. What is before us is this: Is the Seanad going to be abolished within a very short period of time and is this country going to be left without a Second Chamber? What are the arguments put forward in support of the Government's revolutionary doctrine? We have here a Constitution which has been established and worked, and proposals are brought forward for an alteration of that Constitution.

What are the reasons given? Is it suggested that the Seanad has failed? There is no such suggestion made. We have the statement that the Committee on Procedure and Privileges may have to do something to alter the internal arrangements of legislation in this House. Not a single argument has been advanced to discharge the very heavy burden of proof which the President has upon his shoulders. We on this side of the House may not have a very high opinion of the abilities of the President, but there is one thing we do recognise and that is his very great astuteness. We realise that the President, recognising his own mediocrity, sees courses which other people would adopt but which are thoroughly unsafe for him to adopt. He knows if he puts forward any argument for the abolition of the Second Chamber that that argument would be riddled, as his previous arguments were riddled, and therefore he seeks a cowardly refuge. He states nothing when he asks the House to make this change. He shirks the duty of discharging the burden upon his shoulders and he merely asks the House to make this revolutionary change in our Constitution.

Why does he shirk his responsibilities? There is only one answer and that is that just as his arguments were refuted before any arguments he could now put forward would be similarly refuted. He hates to sit in his place over there and hear his arguments riddled, just as he hated in another place listening to his arguments being riddled as they were riddled. What are the faults of the existing Second Chamber? What has the Seanad done? We have heard a whole lot of vague declamations against the members of the Seanad from time to time and we heard another vague declamation from Deputy MacDermot to-night. We are told they were completely subservient to the Administration when Deputy Cosgrave was President of the Executive Council. That statement was false. I myself conducted Bills through the Seanad on behalf of the then Executive, and so did other Ministers. To state that the Seanad was subservient to Ministers is to make a statement which is absolutely at variance with the facts. Bill after Bill was amended and Minister after Minister accepted amendments in the Seanad which were proposed there and which the Minister never saw until he saw them on the Seanad Order Paper.

What are the Bills in connection with which we are told the Seanad misconducted itself? Take Constitution Amendment Bill No. 17. I heard Deputy Norton put a question to the President the other day about that Act and I heard the President's answer. His answer was that that Act was an absolute necessity for the Government, at the present time, if they were to maintain order in the State. It is put forward in argument in this House that the Seanad was wrong because it passed a Bill which the President now says is an absolute necessity for the Government of the country. Was that a crime on the part of the Seanad? We were told they did it quickly. Everyone knows they put it through quickly. Everyone knows that at that time members of the Oireachtas were under police protection, and everybody knew that the Bill had to be put through the Oireachtas quickly. The position was far more serious then than now. Guards had been murdered; witnesses had been murdered; the unfortunate boy Ryan had been murdered; Deputies had been threatened. Further legislation was necessary at the time and that further legislation was rushed through the Seanad. Is that House to be abolished because it rushed that Bill through, when the Executive Council said to that House that the Bill was necessary, and must have it passed through the House. They rushed the Bill through. Members of the Executive Council told the Seanad that in order to maintain law and order in the State they must have that Bill and have it at once, and the Seanad passed the Bill and they did so because they said the Executive told them that it was necessary for the maintenance of order and for the preservation of the State. Was that a fault of the Seanad? Will the President or any responsible member of his Party say that the Seanad was then wrong?

On another occasion, when the same argument was put forward by members of the Executive on a matter of urgency, upon which Deputy O'Sullivan has spoken, exactly the same attitude was taken up by the Seanad. They were right. If the Executive says "This is a matter of supreme urgency, we have all the facts at our disposal and we, who are members of the Executive Council, tell you that the law should be enacted quickly in what are abnormal circumstances," then the Seanad is perfectly right in those abnormal circumstances to give the Executive the power it wishes for in such circumstances. The attitude of the Seanad on that occasion was a right and proper one for them to take. I would be surprised if President de Valera would suggest when he comes to reply that that attitude was not a proper one. If he felt himself compelled to ask for powers further than those contained in Constitution Act No. 17, and said, "I want those powers and must have them at once, to prevent murders being perpetrated," would not the President be horrified if the Seanad refused him such powers as he asked?

What else did the Seanad do? We were told about their rejection of the Blueshirts Bill. Were they not right? Looking back upon the matter now would not that Bill have produced chaos if passed and put into force? Were the Seanad not right in dealing with that Bill as they did in the exercise of that right? Yet I will assume, for the purpose of argument, if you like, that they were wrong. But is the whole Constitution to be blown up and abolished because one House on one occasion made a mistake? That is the whole case, as far as we know, that can be put forward against the present Seanad. There is a tremendous amount to be said about what is the real issue, but whether this Seanad is good or bad, or whether its work was well or badly done, is not before the House. This is not a question of amending the Seanad or improving its constitution, or of providing some other method by which it should be elected. None of these questions arises here. It is a question of Seanad or no Seanad. What are the advantages of that, or rather, what are the disadvantages? In the first place, we have a Seanad; we have a Constitution and we have people living under that Constitution. People have a right to know for what reason that Constitution is to be changed. It is there. We know what the Seanad is like. We know we have a sea that has been charted with two Chambers. We are asked to leave the sea and to go into the uncharted sea of Single Chamber Government What are the advantages? We are being told one. We are to take a leap in the dark not because any good reason can be put forward that we are dissatisfied, but we are to take a leap in the dark at some mere whim. What else can it be? Nothing else can be put forward but a whim.

If I had to argue an affirmative case, between the existence of a Seanad and no Seanad, I could do it with the atmost ease. Experience has shown that in our present system of Party government a Second Chamber is a necessity. Personally, I do not believe that representative government, any where in the world, can be a success, or will be a success unless connected with the Party system. You find places where the Party system is not in effect such as France; and there you discover the chief Minister, in a grave crisis such as exists now, with the threat of international war breaking out, has to spend most of his time trying to get a Party majority. That is very unsatisfactory. I believe unless France manages to evolve two political Parties, representative government will not live long there. In England for a short period there were three Parties but they have since worked down to two. I believe if you are to have successful government you must have Party government. I need not defend Party government. We have it in this State. The only man who once defended Party government did so in one of the most famous passages ever recorded in political literature. He will be remembered as the most brilliant intellect that ever entered English politics, and possibly the finest master of English prose. It is unnecessary to quote it. It is not for me to deal with the advantages of Party government, and it is unnecessary for me to express my adherence to Party government. I do recognise that Party government has its advantages. But Party government is a human institution, and while it has its advantages, it also has its dangers, and it must have its checks to counteract, as far as ever we can, those dangers. Party government means that the legislation will be controlled by a certain small number of persons—the Leaders of the Party. Their followers follow. Very often their followers have to follow against their best wishes. In regard to that very Bill to which Deputy MacDermot made allusion, that Bill which we discussed so fully in this House yesterday, and the day before and last week. I believe that if there had been a free vote of the House, and the Party Whips were off, the Minister for Finance and the other members of the Executive Council would not have had a handful of supporters behind them in the Division Lobby. But the Party Whips were on. Were the members who voted entirely wrong? I do not think so. I think the members of a Party must obey the Party Whip. I think that if they are not willing to do so they should not remain in the Party, because Party government is essential in my opinion, and, if Party government is essential, then on matters which are not essential the individual must fall in with the judgment of the majority of those who are co-operating with him in the Party. But then you have a tremendous danger, and that is that you have an Executive Council who are suddenly rushed away by some emotional feeling, and come to some hasty decision. They come into the House here; they put forward their views, and their Party has to support them. Their Party is not free. The matter goes to a Second Chamber. What is the function of the Second Chamber? The function of a Second Chamber, and the only function it can exercise under our Constitution, is the function of delay. It has got no power of complete destruction; it can only delay. It can only give to the Executive Council leisure to think out fully their own thoughts, and—if they are an Executive Council which is composed of men big enough in outlook and big enough in their conception of their duty —to admit, where they have made a mistake, that they have made a mistake; all men make mistakes.

A delaying Chamber like the Seanad is necessary to prevent any democratic Chamber being rushed away against its own better judgment, and rushed away against the better judgment of its own leaders, the better judgment being subordinated to the hasty decisions formed in a moment of emotional impulse. That is the safeguard—and the main safeguard—which the Second Chamber brings and must bring. But there are other things. Not merely is it a safeguard, but it is an improving body. There is nobody who looks through the records of the Seanad, and nobody who reads the magnificent apology for the conduct of the Seanad which was made by its Chairman, Senator Westropp Bennett, but must admit that he set himself out to prove certain things and prove them to demonstration; and proved to demonstration that the action of the Seanad in this State had been to improve, and improve very considerably, the legislation which left this House. The very fact that the Speaker of this House need not stand for election was a suggestion which was made not in this House but in the Seanad. We have this body. I will leave the realm of theory altogether; I will leave what is the real question before this House, and I will just consider on its own merit how this Seanad stands. The case that it is not discharging a useful function in this State is simply nil, and the case that it is discharging a very useful function is overwhelmingly established by anybody who takes the trouble to examine the facts. But there is another reason. There are many persons who, led by considerations in troubled times, just when the Treaty had been signed, had to decide as to whether they would still continue to make this country their home, or whether they would go abroad. There were many of those people who, when they made up their minds that they would remain in this country, were actuated largely by the fact that there would be a Double Chamber Government, and that there would be no hasty legislation detrimental to them. They may not be a very large body. They may not be able to sway a great number of votes in any election, but they are a body who have trusted the people of this country, and trusted the legislation of this country. They ought not to be told that they put their trust in the legislation of this country and in the Constitution of this country in vain. This House, no doubt under pressure from the President and under the pressure of the Executive Council, will pass this resolution and, no doubt, we will have a Single Chamber Government, without any check. Any kind of hasty legislation can and will be run through this House. I recognise that it will be done, but I believe that when historians come to look back upon what has been done they will conclude that no worse blow was ever struck against the personal liberties of the people of this State than was struck by this House when, by abolishing the Seanad, they put absolute and unfettered control into the hands of the Executive Council.

Comment on this

I have no intention of entering into an academic discussion as to the merits or demerits of unicameral legislatures and bicameral legislatures. I can conceive no more futile waste of time than to enter into a discussion of such a matter in this House, however important and vital it is to the interests of the people of this country. During the course of the remarks made by Deputy MacDermot, Deputy Donnelly interrupted him, and his remark was repeated by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. Deputy Donnelly, interrupting Deputy MacDermot said:—

"How are you going to vote?"

The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance subsequently said:—

"You have not told us yet how you are going to vote."

These two remarks demonstrate clearly the attitude of mind of the Fianna Fáil Party in this House towards parliamentary procedure and practice, and parliamentary institutions. They have no other conception of the duties of people in this House except to know how they are going to vote. To enter into an academic discussion, however important and useful it may be to the vital interests of the people of this country would, as I said at the outset, be futile. We on this side of the House have made it clear that it stands for a bicameral legislature, and that that is one of the fundamental planks in the policy of this Party. We propose to make that policy known throughout the country, through other sources, rather than to continue to debate it in the atmosphere of a House informed by the sort of opinion that gave rise to the expressions to which I have already referred.

Academic discussion will not settle this point. Neither the President nor any member of the Fianna Fáil Party has any interest in the academic side of the discussion as to whether, in the interests of the people, we ought to have a bicameral Legislature or a unicameral Legislature. That does not enter into this discussion to-day, nor it did not enter into the discussion on the first occasion when the Bill to abolish the Seanad was introduced by the President. The President or any member of his Party has no interest whatever in the abstract principles governing the consideration of unicameral or bicameral Legislatures. The Bill, as has already been stated by previous speakers, was introduced, not after mature consideration as to whether a two-Chamber or a one-Chamber Legislature was the better system having regard to the circumstances existing here, or whether one or other of these systems was the better system having regard to our peculiar features as a nation. It was introduced, perfectly obviously, without any consideration having been given to that abstract question. It was introduced, as Deputy O'Sullivan stated, merely in a fit of pique, not as a result of thought, not as a demonstration of statemanship. It was introduced immediately after the Seanad had rejected the Uniforms Bill, as a punishment for the Seanad. It was introduced because the Government's will had been thwarted at that time.

They went to the Seanad and said, as they said here subsequently, that the Seanad had sinned because it had not followed the advice given by the Government. They said that the Uniforms Bill was essential if good order and government were to be maintained in the country. Subsequent events since the Seanad refused to pass the Bill have justified in no small measure the action of the Seanad in rejecting the Bill. The state of the country for the last 18 months since the Seanad threw out the Bill has justified the action of the Seanad. The fact that the Government have not brought that Bill into operation at the time that they would have been enabled under the Constitution to do so is a clear justification of the action of the Seanad.

The President, when he was attempting to justify the measure to abolish the Seanad, wandered at some stage— certainly not when he was introducing the Bill—into a quasi-academic discussion. Every single reference he gave in justification of his so-called arguments—they could hardly be dignified with the name of arguments; I would prefer to call them unfounded contentions — in every single detail these unfounded contentions have been laid bare in their naked falsehood by the Chairman of the Seanad, by the late Vice-Chairman, Senator O'Hanlon, and by Senator Douglas. His arguments have been torn to shreds and tatters, and every supposed fact which he gave has been demonstrated to have been unfounded. His whole argument, so far as it was founded upon political theory and upon the writings of political theorists and thinkers, has been demonstrated to have been utterly untrue. His quotations were unfounded, and his arguments founded on the writings of political thinkers were demonstrated by these three gentlemen who spoke in the Seanad to be without foundation. I repeat, and it cannot be controverted, the statement of Deputy Professor O'Sullivan here to-day that the experience of the world from the time of the ancient Greeks, through the Roman Senate and down to modern times, has demonstrated the necessity for the existence, in the interests of the people of the country, of some sort of Second Chamber as a check on the hot-headed actions of Governments.

Every single writer of eminence has been in favour of a Second Chamber. But the President, not having thought out at that time, as I said, and not having since thought out the matter, not coming to this House with reasoned arguments as to why we, in the interests of the people of this country, and having regard to our own peculiar circumstances, should adopt a unicameral system of Legislature, but coming merely because of hurt pride and merely because of his intolerance of criticism, endeavours to take away one of the fundamental institutions set up by the Constitution in 1922 with the approval of all Parties in the House at that time. We are not, as I say, discussing the question here academically. It does not enter into the matter. The President has no academic reasons to support his Bill, and so far as he tried belatedly on the last occasion to use any such arguments, they have been demonstrated to have been without foundation.

We are here—and we had better face it—and the country had better face it —getting rid of an institution which was built up by the last Government, by Deputy Cosgrave. In the words of Kevin O'Higgins the last Government were building with one hand and they were trying to stave off with the other hand the attacks of the people who now form the Government of this country. There should be some justification for such a revolutionary measure as is proposed by this Bill. There has been no justification given. The President and his Ministers on various occasions —extracts from their speeches in the Dáil and in the country can be found in the speeches of the Chairman of the Seanad, of Senator O'Hanlon and of Senator Douglas—have gone around traducing the members of the Seanad. They have gone around telling the country that Government measures have been in every respect hampered by the Seanad. That contention, untrue as it was, was exposed in all its falseness by the Seanad. It was exposed by the production of facts and figures which have merely not been controverted since, but which cannot be controverted. The record of the Seanad as exhibited by these figures which can be found in the speeches to which I referred shows that the Seanad, as constituted for the last ten or 12 years has done very good and useful work for the successive Governments that ruled in this country. I do not intend to go through all the facts and figures that are on record in the proceedings of the Oireachtas, and in the Seanad Debates particularly.

The House will remember this and take note of its significance: that during the course of this Government's administration in 1932, 1933 and for the five months ending in 1934, there were 17 recommendations made by the Seanad in reference to Money Bills, all of which were accepted by the Government. Supposing the Seanad had not been there to tell the Government where they were wrong in their Money Bills on 17 separate occasions, there would have been 17 separate holes in these Money Bills that could not have been discovered, except probably by a process of actions in the courts, and then, while these actions were pending and about to be exposed, we probably would have the performance initiated in this House a few days ago, of a Bill being brought in to prevent the judges giving a decision against the Government. At all events, there would have been 17 holes in 17 Money Bills if it had not been for the Seanad. In reference to other Bills which are not Money Bills, there were 434 Seanad amendments in these two and a half years agreed to by the Government. There would have been 434 errors in Government Bills in those two and a half years if the Seanad had not been there.

It is folly and waste of time, as I said at the start, to discuss this matter here. We are not discussing it in a serious vein, not discussing it with a view to seeing whether from the joint intelligence of all Parties in this House we ought to come to a decision as to whether a unicameral or a bicameral Legislature was better in the interests of the country. We are doing either one of two things: either endeavouring to heal the President's pride, or, perhaps, a better explanation would be the explanation he gave to the Fianna Fáil Convention last week: "I made a promise and I am going to fulfil it." It is about the only promise of all the promises of the President and the members of his Party that they are fulfilling. That is what we are doing to-day—endeavouring to make it apparent to Fianna Fáil supporters in the country that the President is fulfilling his promise to get rid of people, many of whom, at least, if not all of whom, come within the definition in the Constitution of people who, by reason of useful public service had done honour to the nation.

I offer no apology, and I speak in no sense in the terms of which Deputy MacDermot spoke in reference to the existing Seanad or any past Seanad. We have nothing to apologise for or excuse to offer on their behalf. They have done good work for the country. Many of them who belong to the old ascendancy party in this State gave more useful service and have put more patriotic endeavour and work into the service of this country than many of the members who to-day occupy the Front Bench of the Government Party in this House.

Comment on this

The House was rather disappointed with the manner in which the President introduced this motion. We have not seen very much of the President in this House for the last 12 months. Many people were wondering what exactly he was doing. We were told that the President was preparing an alternative scheme. That was said and it was denied; it was said again, and denied again in the Irish Press last week. As I say, the President has not given very much of his time to this House. He has not shown very much respect for this House, not to speak of the Seanad. The President has contented himself for the last 12 months with simply coming in to register his vote without having heard a single argument. When the President treats this House, of which he has been elected President, in that manner, it is hard for anybody, either inside or outside the House, to expect that he would have respect for the other House.

The Seanad has got to go, not because it is necessary for the good of the country, not because it is doing any harm; the Seanad has to go whether it is useful or not, because it had the temerity to stand in the President's way. What the House and the people ought to realise is that this is not a question of the good of the country, or having proper laws made, but a question as to whether the President's word or his whim shall have absolute and free play. That is the real issue. In that, at least, if in nothing else, the President is quite consistent. The President could never brook any opposition. He has destroyed the Seanad. He is quite consistent in that. If there is one thing consistent in the President's public career, it is his successful destruction of anything that he ever put his hand to in this country. We have all this talk about democracy. The President had shown before he came into this House, and particularly since he came into the House, that while he might prate freedom and blather about democracy he is at heart an autocrat. He is removing every obstacle that stands in his way towards an absolute dictatorship. He is very very near it at present.

I suggest to the President that he should consider changing his own title, the title of President. I suggest that he might take for himself as head of this State the title which he took for himself as head of the Irish Press, that is, “Controlling-Director.” It would be much more fitting than the title which he enjoys at present. There is talk about the Seanad and the powers of the Seanad. It seems to me a great pity that during the last four years the Seanad had not powers much greater than they had. If they had powers great enough perhaps they would have saved this country many millions of pounds and saved many people who are to-day brought to the verge of destitution and many of them almost bankrupt through the measures introduced by the Government.

As Deputy Costello said, there is hardly much use in trying to discuss seriously a matter of this importance when it is dealt with so lightly by the President. If the President wants anything in the nature of a check he wants a very harmless one. Deputy MacDermot made some suggestions to him. I suggest that he should consider them seriously and, if he really wants a harmless Seanad, which must necessarily be very few in numbers, he might consider Deputy MacDermot and a few such types, if there are any such in the country, to form a Second Chamber. We had from Deputy MacDermot what we have been accustomed to from him in this House—lectures from the superior person to the ordinary man in the street.

Comment on this

How is it Deputy Morrissey put up with him for 18 months?

Comment on this

I confess I found it very difficult.

Comment on this

These late confessions.

Comment on this

The Deputy might ask how I put up with other people for a longer time. Deputy MacDermot told us that there were a few distinguished men in the Seanad. The Deputy, of course, has no regard for the ordinary man drawn from the ordinary people of this country and elected by the votes of the people— even though only indirectly elected by those votes. I think that the men in the Seanad, taking them as a whole, irrespective of the Party to which they are giving their allegiance, are representative of what is generally considered the best in this country. I think they have done their work well, and they do not want any lecture of the type we listened to from Deputy MacDermot. I suggest to the Deputy that he might refrain from inflicting himself in that way on the House.

I feel with Deputy Costello that this is merely a waste of time. I think the House will find that it has made a very big mistake. The President himself may perhaps find that he has made a very big mistake; he may find out that before he is very much older. The House is asked to take action for which this country will yet be sorry. We have heard a lot of talk here, but it is hard to believe that a good deal of the talk from the Government side of the House is sincere.

Comment on this

Judging by the speeches which have been made by the Opposition, one must come to the conclusion that they seem determined to preserve the Seanad and that they are equally determined to annihilate Deputy MacDermot. Their enthusiasm for the annihilation of Deputy MacDermot seems to be greater than their enthusiasm for the preservation of the Seanad. Deputy Morrissey just now let us into the Party secrets by saying that he did not know how he tolerated Deputy MacDermot in the Party for 18 months, and then, as if to justify that toleration, he said he wondered how he put up with other people for a longer time——

Comment on this

Yes, in response to an interjection by the Deputy.

Comment on this

In response to an interjection by the Deputy. But Deputy Morrissey did not inform the House that he was still willing to put up with the Labour Party. He has now the audacity to say what he said, notwith-standing the fact that he was expelled from the Labour Party. Deputies will remember that the Seanad passed in a few short hours the Public Safety Bill——

Comment on this

Which the Labour Party have now swallowed, Jock, stock and barrel.

Comment on this

Any more interjections? I will deal with that in a few moments. Deputy Costello said that it was hardly worth while making a case against the abolition of the Seanad. Probably that was the truest thing said here to-day, because it is almost impossible to make a case for the retention of the present Seanad. Deputy Costello, in the short time in which he addressed the House, might have taken care to have checked up on the statement he made. He said that all Parties agreed to the Seanad being established in 1922. Is not that an obvious mistake for the Deputy to have made? Deputy Morrissey could have told him that in 1922 the Labour Party opposed the establishment of the Seanad, and its attitude to-day is the same as it was then and has been since.

Comment on this

Did they vote against it?

Comment on this

Nobody more than the Deputy ought to know that they voted against it.

Comment on this

Refer me to the date.

Comment on this

If the Deputy looks at the first volume of the Official Debates he will see where at an early date they voted.

Comment on this

The reason I ask the question is because I have looked up the Official Debates and I have not seen it.

Comment on this

An attempt was made by some Deputies here to invest the Seanad with a certain authority and a certain degree of holiness which I cannot discover enshrouds that body at all. When considering the Second Chamber we ought to ask ourselves in what way and for what purpose Second Chambers are being created. If we look at the history of Europe and the history of the world, where can we see that Second Chambers have made their appearance side by side with the expansion of the franchise and with the growth of democracy in democratically governed countries? With the growth of democracy and with the expansion of the franchise and the development of modern democratic methods in the various countries in the world there has been a desire on the part of reactionaries to constitute Second Chambers as a check against the popularly elected Governments. The creation of Second Chambers has been for the purpose solely of having a check and a curb on the progress of the plain people, to exercise a curb on democracy and prevent the people from deciding public questions in their own way.

If we take as an example our next-door neighbour we will find that their Second Chamber, very little different from the Seanad in its composition, has acted in the same way as the Seanad has acted here. It has acted as the ally of the Tory Party in power for the time being and the bitter opponent of any legislation promoted by Governments consisting of persons opposed to the political point of view of the Second Chamber there. In short, Second Chambers, both in Great Britain and elsewhere, have been tyrannically established for the defence of vested interests. The attempts by the Party opposite to try to prove that the Second Chamber here has been the guardian of the people's liberties has been so much silly nonsense.

At all events, we can get some views held in other days by the Party opposite as to the Seanad. In endeavouring to defend it in 1922 the late Kevin O'Higgins had little to say in favour of the present Seanad. He admitted that the case might be made that it might be a useless and valueless chamber, and if anybody cares to read his speech defending the Second Chamber one will discover little substance in his argument. Clearly, Kevin O'Higgins of that period had little use for the Seanad as then constituted. If he could be asked to-day free from Party bias to express his opinion of the Second Chamber constituted in 1922 he would have much less to say in its defence than he had in 1922.

Deputies Costello, O'Sullivan and Fitzgerald-Kenney told us that the Seanad has been doing good work for the last ten years. In the words of Deputy Costello we are told that it did good work in that period. Let us ask ourselves in what particular respect has the Seanad done good work for the people of this country during the past ten years. Let us ask ourselves in what way has the Seanad been the guardian of the people's liberties during that period. Let us ask ourselves in what way has the Seanad from 1922 to 1932 acted as a curb on reaction. Let us ascertain in what way they have acted as the guardians of the people's liberties and the defenders of the people's rights. Though a statement to that effect has been made by the Party opposite not a single instance has been produced where the Seanad challenged any reactionary measure passed by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government in all those years. As everybody not blinded by political association knows, the Seanad from 1922 to 1932 was just a rubber stamp and a recording machine for the Cumann na nGaedheal Party of the day. We are told that the Seanad is the bulwark between the people and reaction, that the Seanad is the defender of the people's liberties and the people's rights. We are told these things by the Party which in a few short hours was able to induce this Seanad to pass the Public Safety Act of 1931.

Comment on this

Which you subsequently voted for.

Comment on this

We will have that in a minute. We will have it in a truthful perspective and not as misrepresented by the Deputy. The guardian of the people's liberties—we were told that was the rôle the Seanad played in our national life. It seems to me to be a rather extraordinary attitude for the guardian of the people's liberties to adopt when in a few hours it passed the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act, the Act which tore up the Constitution and trampled upon the rights of the people. The Party opposite were able to induce the Seanad, the so-called guardian of the people's liberty, to pass that Act in a few hours. Is there any evidence in that action by the Seanad that they acted as the guardian of the people's liberties or the defender of the people's rights? Everybody knows that apart from that one test as to whether it was the guardian of the people's liberties, the Seanad showed itself to be—and everybody knows it has been from 1922 to 1932—a rubber stamp for the Party then in power. Deputy Dillon now pretends to look disturbed.

Comment on this

The Deputy is in a permanent state of amazement. Most members of the House would like to meet him when he is not in that permanent state of amazement in order to see if they could get anything sensible out of him in those subnormal moments of his. Does the Deputy deny that the Act to which I have referred contains all these vicious attacks on the liberties and democratic rights of the people? That is admitted by the Party opposite even though they steam-rolled it through this House and through the Seanad. How can you pretend that anybody that willingly acquiesced in the passage of that Act was in any way a guardian of the people's liberties and rights?

Comment on this

Were you listening to the Minister for Finance last night? Were you listening to his declaration as to the rights of democracy in this country?

Comment on this

This is much more interesting and more truthful than anything the Minister said last night.

Comment on this

Go ahead, until we hear you develop it.

Comment on this

An attempt is being made by the Party opposite to place the Seanad in the position of being the custodian of the people's liberties and rights, but nobody there can deny that it was a rather strange rôle for a defender of the people's liberties and rights to pass in a few hours, and on the only Saturday on which they ever met, the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act—and that from a body that claims to be the guardian of the people's liberties and the defender of their rights. Deputy Dillon wants to pretend that he believes we voted for the passage of that Act.

Comment on this

No, but your ailies were glad to use it.

Comment on this

They never used it in our name. On every occasion in this House the Labour Party voted against the Bill. One thing we did refuse to do and that was to be trapped into voting for the sham motion which the Party opposite submitted to the House protesting against the provisions of an Act which they themselves passed with the aid of the body they now claim as the defender of the people's liberties.

Comment on this

The wise man from the East.

Comment on this

The Deputy is a very unwise man from the South and of the two I would prefer the appellation he has put upon me. An effort is being made to suggest that the Seanad is a thoroughly democratic Assembly. We had Deputy O'Higgins a few months ago going around the country as one of the people who wanted to establish and maintain a League of Youth. He wanted to give youth an opportunity of participating in the government of the country. One of the Party opposite worked himself into a state of hysteria defending the right of youth to take their place in the government and the national life of the country. One would imagine Deputy O'Higgins and the other active members of the Party who believed in what they claimed in respect of the right of youth to have a say in national and local polities, would be only too pleased to ensure that any legislation designed to give youth that voice was supported in this House and carried through. Although we have the Party opposite pretending it wants to give youth a chance, to give an outlet for the talents of youth, to give them an opportunity to take an active interest in local and national affairs, we find the Seanad, the body which they now seek to put on such a high pedestal, actually throwing out a Bill designed to give to people, 21 years and over, the right simply to record their votes in local elections. The Party opposite, claiming to give youth its rightful say in local and national affairs, not only opposes a measure of that kind here, but gets its allies in the Seanad to do the same. This is the body we are told is a thoroughly democratic body which ought to be retained as the guardian of the people's liberty.

Let us have a look at what the Seanad is. From 1922 to 1932 it was simply a replica, on a small scale, of the Government then in power. Not even Deputy Dillon will deny that during the years 1922 to 1932 the Seanad was simply a miniature edition of the Party in control here. The Cumann na nGaedheal Party were in office here and their friends were in office in the Seanad. To imagine that a Party in the majority in the Dáil which had a majority also in the Seanad could possibly be put in an inconvenient position by its friends in the Seanad is asking people to give credence to the most utter nonsense. From 1922 to 1932 there was no such thing as an effective Second Chamber because the Second Chamber of the period was controlled by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. To that extent there was never a likelihood that a body so constituted during that period would ever have interfered with any legislation which the Cumann na nGaedheal Government desired to have passed. While there was a Seanad in existence from 1922 to 1932 it never acted as a curb against reactionary legislation; it never exercised its right to delay legislation; in fact, the whole purpose of the Seanad during that period was to facilitate in every possible way the passage of any kind of legislation which they were asked to pass by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. In what circumstances did the Seanad ever act as a check upon reactionary legislation during the ten years? Is there a single instance in which the Seanad impeded the passage of legislation in any way in that period? Is there a single instance in which the Seanad acted as a guardian of the people's liberties when reactionary legislation was passed by the Party opposite? Coercion Acts and Public Safety Acts were passed time and again in these ten years and never once did the Seanad exercise its right to delay legislation of the Party opposite.

Any one who cares to study the records of the Seanad will fail to find any instance where the Seanad intervened to impede reactionary legislation from 1922 to 1932. But they will find that the Seanad, constituted by the then Government acted as the counterpart of that Government and not as the guardian of the people's liberties. Is it likely to be any better in the future? Is it likely to effect such a transformation if maintained? Let us assume that it maintains its normal life, and that in three years hence there was another election to that body and no general election in the meantime. Then the present Government could secure a majority in the Seanad if that body was allowed to remain; they would then have an absolute majority. Does anybody believe that if the present Government had a majority in the Seanad that a Seanad so composed would hold up any legislation passed by this Government? I for one am honest enough, and realist enough, to believe that the Seanad would not in any way impede the Fianna Fáil Government if they had a majority in the Seanad. When that body was composed of Cumann na nGaedheal Senators did they decline to impede the Cumann na nGaedheal Government in their period of office?

Let us bring some sense to bear on what the Seanad is. It is an out-of-date replica of this House. And we get this state of things where we have a Seanad maintained for no other purpose than to enable the Party in power to stuff it with their own supporters, and, then, to get that body to pass any legislation the Government of the day thinks it ought to support. A vote for the continuance of the Seanad, as at present constituted, is a vote for a useless piece of machinery at best, and which is no longer an institution of which the people approve. But it never has been, and never will be, an institution that will prove a bulwark between the people and a tyrannical executive Government. So long as the Seanad is elected on its present basis, and constituted in the main by the majority of the supporters of the Government in power, that Seanad never can be an effective guardian of the people's liberties and rights. Yet it is to maintain that kind of institution that this flood of eloquence has been released in the benches opposite.

If the people who constitute the Party opposite were to retire into private life, and if, in one, two or three years after their retirement, they were asked for their views on the Seanad, I doubt that one of them would say a word for it. There is no use for the Seanad or for continuing the Seanad as at present constituted. Let us, therefore, understand what the position is. It is not a popularly elected Chamber. It is elected in the main by a majority of this House, and so long as the Executive of the day can secure a majority for their political Party by the exercise of their votes in this House, then the Seanad at its best is only a second edition of the Party in power in this House.

But suppose the Seanad was constituted so that it was ever likely to interfere with the Government, or try to cause any difficulty or inconvenience to the Government of the day, still to regard it as representative of the people or as the guardian of their rights would be a piece of arrant nonsense. Yet, in order to make a case for this institution, Deputies opposite want to shroud it as an assembly of dignity, honesty and a sense of democracy. If there was any ground for attributing these qualities to the Seanad they never exercised them in the whole of the ten years from 1922 to 1932. I concede to the Party opposite that there is one reason why they should try to make a case for the Seanad—one ground upon which they could justify it. There is one reason why they should make a fight to save its life, and that is because from 1922 to 1932 it was the friend of the Party opposite. It was simply a recording machine for the Party opposite. During that period it acted as a steam-roller to steam-roll through that House legislation of any and every description passed by the Party opposite.

Whatever debt of gratitude the Party opposite owes the Seanad from 1922 to 1932, they also owe them a debt of gratitude for what they did for them from 1932 to 1933. During those years the Seanad, constituted as it was of a majority of persons who gave allegiance to the Party opposite, certainly did not forget its friends. From 1932 to 1933 the Seanad has been the willing tool of the Party opposite. Every time in that period that they asked for legislation to be thrown out, be it good or bad legislation, it was thrown out. When the Party opposite asked the Seanad in those three years to obstruct and impede the Government in every way, the Seanad, loyal to its obligations to the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, did its duty in the manner expected of them by the Party opposite. In the last three years the Seanad has played the part of wrecker in thwarting the will of the people.

Comment on this

How many Bills sent up by the Government in that period did the Seanad reject?

Comment on this

Every Bill the Party opposite asked them to reject, and they passed only those to which the Party opposite did not object.

Comment on this

That is not an answer to my question. How many Bills did the Seanad reject in the last three years?

Comment on this

Am I permitted to bring in a blackboard and chalk and explain all these things to the Deputy?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not obliged to take notice of interruptions.

Comment on this

I hope Deputy Minch has heard that remark. In the last three years the Seanad has played the part of wrecker. Every piece of legislation that it was possible for the Party opposite to suggest to the Seanad should be rejected was rejected by the Seanad. Every piece of legislation designed to strengthen the nation's national position was rejected by the Seanad. During the past three years, when the Party opposite were wailing in the face of the British attack upon our national and our economic life, the Seanad was used as a platform to cheer the hearts of those who were responsible for waging that economic attack upon our people. The Party opposite may regret to lose its friends by the abolition of the Seanad. The Party opposite may be sorry that its friends have fallen from high places, but no person in this country who has any pretensions to being a democrat, no person in this country who has any pretensions to desiring that the country shall stretch itself to the full height of its national manhood will have any regret that the Seanad is passing.

Whatever case might be made for a Second Chamber, whatever case might be made for a revisionary Chamber, there can certainly be no case made for the Seanad as at present constituted. There can be no case made for the continuance of the Seanad on the basis on which the present Seanad is elected. Having regard to the record of the Seanad since 1922, one is tempted to ask whether it is worth the while of this Legislature to try to put in its place something which, in the course of time, may follow in the same reactionary footsteps. A case can, however, be made for creating and giving into the hands of the people a machine which will be a real safeguard for the people. A case can be made for enabling the people to assert their own viewpoints on tremendously important national, economic and financial issues. Under our present electoral system the people are consulted approximately once every four years. It may happen that a Party which is elected to form a government may ask the people for a mandate on certain issues, and may receive that mandate from the people, but before it next consults the people it may find it desirable from its own point of view to enact legislation on a particular issue. The merits of that legislation, the wisdom or otherwise of that legislation, may be questioned by the people from very good motives. There may be keen feeling and bitter controversy throughout the country as to the wisdom of passing that legislation, and, in my opinion, there ought to be some machine created in order that the views of the people can be expressed on a matter of that kind. We know from our experience of the Seanad that even if the contemplated legislation were of a reactionary character that body could not be depended upon to reject it.

We must, therefore, endeavour to create instead some kind of a machine by which the views of the people on important national questions can be determined in a manner which will enable the views of the people to be heard in no uncertain way without, perhaps, recourse to a general election. One of the very valuable provisions of the original Constitution was that which provided for a referendum by the people on matters upon which there was keen feeling throughout the country. In 1922 that valuable piece of machinery was lauded by the Party opposite, and, in my opinion, rightly and properly lauded by the Party opposite, but in 1927, when presented with a petition for a referendum, and when it realised that the Referendum which they thought so much of in 1922 had become very inconvenient in 1927, the Party opposite abolished the Referendum so as to get rid of the inconvenience which was then threatening. Yet this is the very same Party which wants some check against reactionary legislation. If they had retained the Referendum in the Constitution instead of abolishing it in 1927 they could have had a permanent check against any reactionary legislation. A petition signed by 50,000 people could have got a referendum on any national question, and if the people to-day are not given an opportunity of expressing their viewpoints on legislation through the medium of the Referendum it is because the Party opposite, when confronted with a difficulty in 1927 abolished the Referendum, which was the real check upon reactionary legislation in this country. They come along to-day and say: "There is now no means of consulting the people; they have got no remedy and no redress if this Government desires to introduce and pass reactionary legislation." Why have we not redress? Why have we not a remedy? If there is legislation of a reactionary character or, as Deputy Dillon will surely say before this debate concludes, of a dictatorial character——

Comment on this

Or of a Socialist character.

Comment on this

——and there is no remedy against legislation of that kind, is not the simple explanation that the Party opposite, in the years, of course, before Deputy Dillon became a member of it, abolished the Referendum which gave the people real and effective control over any legislation proposed in this House? If, therefore, the people have no effective control over the actions of the Executive Council the explanation is clear. The explanation is that the Party opposite, when it was the Government, deliberately abolished the Referendum in order to deny the people the check which they now pretend they want to give to the people. It is very difficult to understand the actions of a Party which, although now pretending that it wants to provide the people with a check, removed the only effective check which the people had over the Executive Council. Deputy Dillon might endeavour to ascertain from the Party opposite how he is going to make a case for giving the people control over the Executive Council when the Party of which he is a member deprived the people of that very valuable power. I would regard the reinstitution of the Referendum in the Constitution as worth 1,000,000 Seanads such as we have to-day.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I believe the Referendum would give the people a real and effective check over the Executive Council, and even over the Parliament. So far as I am concerned, I should prefer to see the Referendum in operation for one year than the present Seanad in operation for 1,000 years, because the people would have much more control in that one year than they can ever expect the Seanad to exercise on their behalf during 1,000 years. I want to address a word or two to the Government in connection with the Referendum. In 1927, the President was in favour of a Referendum. He thought that it was a very valuable piece of democratic machinery. He thought it was a very useful institution in order to give the people control, and as a matter of fact he believed in it so much that he actually called it into play on that occasion, thinking that he would exercise control over the Legislature, but, of course, not counting on the wiliness of his opponents opposite. If the Referendum was good in 1927, it is good in 1935. If we are going to have any really effective check over this House and over the Executive Council, then we ought to put back into the Constitution the Referendum which gives the people real control, and makes the people masters in their own country. The President believed in the Referendum in 1927, and I should like to know the reasons which have converted him from his belief in its utility in 1935. I would certainly urge the Executive Council, and in particular, I would urge the members of the Fianna Fáil Party to exercise their opinions within the Party to ensure that the Referendum will again be incorporated in the Constitution, because that is the one really democratic safeguard which the people of this country have

A small country on the Continent like Switzerland has been able for many years to utilise the referendum as an integral part of its legislative and electoral machinery. In Switzerland the referendum, which works excellently and smoothly and which is accepted by all parties, is utilised to decide the most difficult problems, to liquidate the keenest of bitternesses. In Switzerland all parties vie with one another in paying tribute to the value of the referendum, as enabling the plain people to decide matters of national importance. If it is possible in Switzerland, a country which in many respects is similar to our own, it should be possible for us here to re-embody in the Constitution the referendum which has proved of such immense value to the people of Switzerland and which has been responsible, probably more than anything else, for the growth and the strengthening of democratic thought in that essentially democratic country. I hope, therefore, the Executive Council will give serious consideration to the question of re-establishing the Referendum. I believe it to be a very valuable piece of legislation. I believe it to be a piece of legislation which will make a very valuable contribution to democratic progress and the strenthening of healthy democratic opinion in this country. If the Executive Council would reinstitute the Referendum and make it part of the Constitution, I believe that, as part of our legislative machinery, it would be much more valuable than the maintenance of the present Seanad.

But, in any case, whether the Referendum is to be reinstituted or not, nobody can make a case in which he seriously believes, for the retention of the Seanad as at presently constituted. Far from being a bulwark of defence for the people's liberties, the Seanad has simply been a Chamber of reaction, if one is to test it by the votes which it recorded. Every reactionary piece of legislation introduced by the Party opposite was passed without question.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy ought not to repeat himself.

Comment on this

I am not repeating myself.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is the third time the Deputy has used that argument since I came to the Chair.

Comment on this

Unless it is that the truth becomes monotonous to the Party opposite I cannot understand——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not the Party opposite; it is the Chair that is objecting to repetition.

Comment on this

Is it not permissible for me to point out to the Party opposite, even if I have to reinforce it by slight repetition, that the Seanad which they are endeavouring to defend——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has ruled that that is repetition and, even in the guise of a submission to the Chair, it should not be again repeated.

Comment on this

I do not need to repeat it in order to make a case for this motion and against the maintenance of the present Seanad. The Party opposite have sought to justify the continuance of the Seanad on the ground that it acts as a check against a reactionary Executive Council, but the Seanad has never acted as such. The Seanad could never be relied upon to act as such and during the past 12 years those who thought that at some time the Seanad might believe it had a separate existence and ought to exercise independent judgment were profoundly disappointed when every piece of legislation sent to them was passed without question. What is the case for maintaining a piece of machinery of that kind? What is the case for maintaining an institution which is only a sham and a delusion so far as the people's rights are concerned? What is the purpose of keeping in existence a Seanad which far from being an aid to national or economic progress is a barrier to such progress?

Comment on this

Has the Deputy not considered the possibility that he might have a majority there in a few years?

Comment on this

I hope I never will have a majority there. Even if any Party in this House, even a Party formed by Deputy MacDermot, had a majority in that Assembly, that Assembly so constituted will never act as a brake on Deputy MacDermot if he were passing legislation through the Oireachtas. That is because the Seanad has never been constituted in such a way as to act as a brake. It is because it has never acted as a brake on reactionary legislation that I am opposed to its continuance. A case might be made for the creation of a Second Chamber, in a revisionary sense, as complementary to this House, but nobody has yet been able to submit any proposals designed to create a body of that kind. I frankly admit that I have no proposals to make which would be likely to result in the creation of an institution of that kind—we are not deciding to-day whether we are in favour of a bicameral or a unicameral Legislature. What we are deciding to-day is whether the Bill which passed through this House in 1934 abolishing the Seanad as at present constituted should be made effective. Having regard to its uselessness from a democratic point of view, I am of the firm conviction that it could never be regarded as an institution which would defend the rights and the liberties of the plain people and I am certainly opposed to the continuance of the present Seanad. During its 12 years it has done little to enhance the national status or enhance democratic though in this country. All efforts which have been made to justify the Seanad as a useful body have failed lamentably. Not a single instance has been quoted in this House where the Seanad has proved its usefulness unless it can be said that its function was to dot the i's and cross the t's of legislation passed in this House. We do not need the Seanad to dot the i's and cross the t's of legislation passed here, a Seanad which is at the same time given power to prevent the passage of useful legislation through the Oireachtas. Whatever case might be made for a revisionary Chamber, complementary to this House, there can be no case made for giving to a body not elected by the people and not responsible to the people the enormous powers which the Seanad had in this country, powers which during the past 12 years have been used, not to advance the people, not to strengthen democratic thought, but to weaken in many respects our democratic institutions and to allow the people's liberties to be walked upon as when, for instance, they passed, in a few short hours, the notorious Constitution Amendment Act. It is because the Seanad will not act as a bulwark for the people's liberties that I see no case for its continuance.

Comment on this

To restrict oneself to moderate language, the least one can say of Deputy Norton's speech is that it is one which does not seem to reflect any credit on the Party of which he is leader. He began his speech to-night with an attempt to indict Seanad Eireann for that they perpetrated two unpardonable crimes. One was that they passed the Public Safety Act. When he got that far he detected on the faces of his colleagues on all sides of this House a look of amazement that any Deputy could be guilty of such audacity as is represented by Deputy Norton condemning Seanad Eireann for passing an Act, admittedly of the most rigorous and extreme character, when a Minister for Justice of this State had been foully murdered in the public streets, and he, Deputy Norton, had voted in this House for the reintroduction of that Act by the Fianna Fáil Government when no danger to the State of any kind, good, bad or indifferent, threatened——

Comment on this

There was no vote in this House on it.

Comment on this

——when the only peril that manifested itself was a peril to the continued tyranny of the Fianna Fáil Party that was running amok. Everyone knows that the Public Safety Act was reintroduced in the confident anticipation that it would be eventually used for the purpose of harassing and imprisoning members of the League of Youth. It was handy to introduce it upon that occasion in order to do what the Government was subsequently obliged to do, and that was to put back in Arbour Hill the gentlemen they made such a fuss about letting out 12 months earlier. I remember the jubiliation which was shared by Deputy Norton when the Christian Government went out and threw open the jail gates and let out the innocent boys. This Deputy voted in this House for the maintenance of that Act which put the patriotic boys back behind the jail gates.

Comment on this

On a point of order. There was no vote in this House in connection with the Constitution (Amendment) Act.

Comment on this

I submit that is not a point of order, but an attempt to interrupt me. Let him go to Kildare and explain to his constituents, or let him go round to the leaders of the Republican Congress in Suffolk Street, or wherever they are, and explain to them that though they have got these into Arbour Hill it was not Deputy Norton's fault——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On the point of order raised by Deputy Norton, if it is stated in this House that a Deputy voted in a certain way the Deputy is surely entitled to say "I did not so vote."

Comment on this

It all depends on how it is said. He was trying to say that there was no vote reimplementing the Act. There was not, but there was a vote on a resolution whether that Act should be continued.

Comment on this

A Cumann na nGaedheal motion.

Comment on this

The Labour Party voted that it should continue, but it should not be reintroduced. Deputy Norton proceeds to explain that he never voted for the Public Safety Act. I will not waste time in exposing the indecent in consistencies of Deputy Norton. I sympathise with Deputies Keyes and Pattison. It must be a humiliation to them to sit under a leader who made the kind of speech we have listened to.

Comment on this

We do not want your sympathy.

Comment on this

When the Deputy began to realise that the indeceny of that pretence was patent to the simplest and dullest member of the Fianna Fáil Party he then proceeded to a long, repetitious, and, as far as I could make out, meaningless tirade, which was finally capped by a plea for the reinstitution of the Referendum. I pass over that, because we all know what that was for. It was to present an appearance of offering some constructive alternative to cover the discreditable patches in the earlier stages of his speech. His second indictment of the Seanad was one which should engage the most careful consideration of the House. His second indictment was that they rejected what has been commonly known as the Blueshirt Bill.

Comment on this

On a point of order. To my recollection, I did not make mention of that Bill at all in my speech.

Comment on this

The history of that Bill is this. A perfectly legitimate organisation was established. Repeated endeavours were made by the Executive to prostitute the Constitution and to prostitute the law with a view to destroying the law. We brought the Attorney-General into court and upset him again and again.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy relate that to the motion before the House?

Comment on this

We upset the Attorney-General and made a public fool of him by demonstrating that he did not know the law, and that he was quite incompetent in regard to these matters to advise the Executive Council. It is something of which he might well be proud.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy relate that argument to the motion before the House?

Comment on this