Constitution (Amendment No. 24) Bill, 1934. - Motion Under Article 38A of the Constitution.
Contributions 99–203 of 203. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 20 of 1934 ›
Yes. In order to overcome that, they sought to prostitute the law by legislation and the Seanad interposed and, in so doing, did something praiseworthy for which they ought to be thanked. The Attorney-General showed no aptitude for prostituting the law or twisting the Constitution to do something that it was never intended to do.
Comment on this
I will deal with that. Having been forced to make a public fool of himself in the courts four or five times, he went in despair to the Government and said: "This is a perfectly legitimate organisation and, if you want to ban it, you will have to pass legislation to do so." Accordingly the legislation was introduced and though the Bill was described as a Prohibition of the Wearing of Political Uniforms Bill, the Minister for Justice freely admitted that it was a Bill to ban the Blueshirts. The Opposition met that Bill on the Second Stage by saying: "We certify that the members of the League of Youth have no illegal intention; they have no desire to resort to force of arms; they are resolved not only to obey the law themselves, but to uphold it in the country, and they have no conspiratorial intentions."
Comment on this
I implore Deputies not to draw me on the subject of burning houses and to esehew the subject of shooting cattle, lest I deal with the subject of shooting men. Let us not allow heat to be engendered into what should be an academic discussion. We made the case that there was no reason to apprehend violence or danger to the State, and we gave our certificate, for what it was worth, as the leaders of the official Opposition, that knowing the members of that organisation, knowing its nature, we were satisfied that it constituted no menace to the legitimate interests of this State. That is a guarantee I gladly repeat now. In face of that, the Bill was carried through this House, and went to the Seanad. The Seanad took our view and rejected it. I ask Deputy Norton who was right?
Comment on this
Has there ever been an occasion since the time the Government introduced that Bill down to to-day that they would have been justified in using it to outlaw the Opposition in this State? Has there been a single occasion in which the Executive Council or the legitimate Government was imperilled or threatened by that organisation? Has there been a single occasion on which the leaders did not show themselves ready to protect the legitimate interests of the Executive of the State or of this House, whenever any such interests were in danger? Have not the members of that organisation shown themselves——
Comment on this
No, but I think it is legitimate for me to make the case that it was nothing for the Seanad to be ashamed of that they rejected that Bill. I am entitled to make the case that they have been vindicated by the event. They were told then that if the Bill was not passed chaos and anarchy would break out in the lands. The Bill did not pass, and the Government did not get the powers they sought and which they intended to use. I ask now, in the light of what has happened, who has been vindicated? The Seanad was asked to give powers to the Government of a certain kind. They said: "The powers are unnecessary; there is no menace to the State in this organisation." The President got up and said that red ruin and chaos would spread through the land if he did not get it. I ask him now who was right? Did red ruin, chaos and anarchy spread through the country?
Comment on this
The Deputy and the Attorney-General can make smart remarks. These people are there still. They are a force in this country still, and they preserve the essential liberties of the individual in this country. But let us not get into a protracted discussion upon the merits or demerits of that. The simple question is this: that the Executive said to the Seanad: "unless you give us that Bill, chaos and anarchy will break forth in the land." The Seanad said: "we will not give you the Bill." and that is the charge on which the Seanad is indicted now. Who was right, the Seanad or the Executive? The vast majority of the people of this country, passing judgment on that issue, will say that the Seanad was right. The Bill was an unnecessary trespass upon the rights of individual citizens of this State, and the Seanad protected the citizens of this State from that trespass. That will be to their eternal credit and, whether they are destroyed or not, that vindication of individual liberty in this country will stand to their credit when the history of this country comes to be written.
Comment on this
They will not be mentioned in any book that the Deputy is likely to read, but that does not mean that they will not be mentioned. The President, in introducing his motion to-day, adopted his now well established practice of bringing this House into public disrepute by refusing to offer any reasons at all for it. I have no doubt that his well established feminine characteristic will manifest itself later on, and that he will jump up and have the last word. But, I am not surprised that the President was reluctant to embark upon a discourse in this House on this subject again. One of the main grounds on which he rested his argument for the abolition of the Seanad, when he first started on this pious purpose, was expressed by him on the 19th April, 1934, in this House when he said:—
"Adams was no mean political thinker. He stood for the single Chamber."
Now, Adams wrote a book which I commend to the attention of Deputy Jordan, and in that book the following words occur:—
"I cannot think that a people can be long free nor ever happy whose Government is in one Assembly."
President de Valera paraphrases that sentence in this way:—
"Adams was no mean political thinker. He stood for the single Chamber."
Is it any wonder that President de Valera is reluctant to break another lance with the constitutional issues that present themselves in connection with this matter. However, though the President does not care to join in the thrust and parry of debate that takes place in the House, he has a kept newspaper, and it is fortunate that we have an opportunity of discovering what is passing in the Presidential mind through the columns of this kept newspaper. He says, in the leading article of the Irish Press, in its issue of 12th December——
Comment on this
No, but he says this through the leading article of the Irish Press—I have not the slightest doubt that he wrote the article—I can read his hand in every line of it— though I am not in a position to say that officially.
Comment on this
I asked the Deputy if he was quoting the President's words so that the reference might be given. The other aspect of the question does not interest the Chair.
Comment on this
Quite. He says:
"No one can question that it (the Seanad) brought its fate upon itself. It constituted itself a barrier to the progress of measures to which the electorate had given the stamp of their approval, or which the Government believed to be necessary for the maintenance of public order and the safeguarding of existing institutions."
Observe the indictment: that the Seanad constituted itself a barrier to the passage of measures which the Government believed to be necessary for the maintenance of public order and the safeguarding of existing institutions. We have listened for an hour to Deputy Norton explaining that the Seanad has to go because they passed too rapidly an Act which the then Government thought necessary for the maintenance of order and the safeguarding of existing institutions.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that the Public Safety Act was passed too quickly in the days of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. President de Valera, or his agent, the Irish Press, says that one of the reasons why the Seanad should be abolished now is because they were too slow in passing similar Acts. It must be remembered, in that connection, that the Minister for Finance put himself on record yesterday as saying that he now knew that Deputy Cosgrave and Party were defending the institution of majority rule in this country, that they had succeeded in defending it, and that he was now concerned to maintain it. I congratulate the Minister for Finance on that statement, and it is interesting to bear it in mind when we are considering what Deputy Norton said. The article goes on:
"When Mr. Cosgrave's Government was in power it (the Seanad) proved itself to be his obedient instrument. It passed without delay or compunction every Bill sent up to it——"
I ask Deputies to note the words "every Bill sent up to it."
"——even though some of these measures were grave invasions of the liberty of the citizen and infractions of the safeguards provided for in the Constitution."
There is a categorical statement. What are the facts? The clear implication of that passage in the leading article of the Irish Press is that the Seanad did not desire to, or did not, in fact, alter any of the legislation of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. With the usual astute avoidance of a positive statement, that is the impression conveyed to the public in words typical of President de Valera which can subsequently be explained to have an entirely different meaning. But the facts are, that during the period of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government the Seanad amended, altered and blocked more Bills, or, at least, as many as they amended or stayed in their progress during the Fianna Fáil Administration. No one knows that better than the President himself. It has been pointed out by Senator Douglas, by the Chairman of the Seanad and by the Vice-Chairman of the Seanad in the House above. Nevertheless, we find in to-day's Irish Press a categorical statement of the very reverse of those facts. He then says:
"The Public Safety Bill, for instance, was rushed through notwithstanding the extraordinary powers which it contained."
Surely he does not expect the people of this country to be so completely blind as not to realise that it was that Public Safety Act which was rushed through the Seanad which he is at present operating, and under which he has dozens of people in jail at the present moment. How can he indict, or hold up to public odium, the Seanad for passing an Act which he himself at present is using and which he has announced his intention of using indefinitely. When asked by the Leader of the Labour Party a couple of weeks ago in a question, whether he intended to abandon that Act, the President himself said "No. I do not intend to abandon it." And on an earlier occasion he said:
"In the event of my ever drafting a new Constitution, I shall have to incorporate in that Constitution a provision similar to that contained in the Public Safety Act which the Seanad passed."
His second charge is that the Seanad rejected the Oath Bill. Some people may agree with it for doing that and others may disagree, but it seems to me that it is no reflection on their integrity or honour that they should have done so if they believed it right to do so. On the contrary, they would have been selling their consciences if they did not do it. That there was not agreement upon that measure is not surprising, and that it should be made a bone of contention which would justify the introduction of this Bill is not convincing, to say the very least of it. "It adopted," said the article, "the same course towards the extension of the franchise to the growing manhood and womanhood of the country." That statement is grossly dishonest, because the impression that it meant to convey to people is that the Seanad was opposed to universal franchise in Parliamentary elections. It does not actually say that, but it is meant to say that, and to create that impression on young people, that the Seanad wanted to exclude them from the vote; the fact being that the Seanad shared our view, that in the matter of local government elections it did not seem reasonable to extend the principle of universal franchise, seeing that the only defence that could be advanced for universal franchise in the case of Parliamentary elections was as a pis aller.
It was the best method that could be thought of, and admittedly was highly unsatisfactory. There is universal franchise for parliamentary elections. We recognise its weaknesses— and they are many—but there is no better method of electing a democratic government. Lastly, they repeat the allegation made, I think, by Deputy Norton about the passage of the Blue-shirt Bill. I say the Seanad has been amply vindicated and that posterity will set it down as having averted bitter civil strife, which Fianna Fáil apparently designed, wanted and were hoping to provoke. Propaganda is a potent thing. There is a saying of some of the most evil supporters of propaganda : "Give a good lie a good start and no man will ever catch up with it." That leading article of the Irish Press is plastered with falsehood. It is not good, straight falsehood that you can drive a nail in once and for all, but it is that detestable prevarication which is designed to deceive. If it poisons the minds of a good many readers of that paper it would be extremely difficult to clarify the minds of the people who read it as the first introduction to the problem we have now to consider. In my opinion, it is a very deplorable thing that any newspaper, even the Irish Press, would stoop to deception of its own readers by half-truths, suppression of the truth, and prevarication of the kind disclosed in the article.
The fact is that all Parties in this House who favour the retention of the Seanad want a perfect Seanad. That is a very laudable ambition. I wonder if Deputies when waxing so eloquent about the shortcomings of the Seanad ever heard what the Seanad thought about this House. There is an old saying—it is as old as the Scripture—that one should remove the mote from one's own eye before one undertakes to remove the beam from the eye of one's neighbour. The Seanad has many shortcomings. I think it is capable of reform. What about Dáil Eireann? Is it a perfect institution? Is it competent to undertake the claim of the Seanad and to remodel itself into a perfect object 1 If it finds itself incompetent to do so should it not rather reflect on itself than shatter the Seanad we have got? I freely agree that it is a very difficult problem to get an ideal Seanad, but I note with interest and with material encouragement that the Seanad shares that view. The Seanad does not take up the position which Dáil Eireann—or a certain section of it—seemed to adopt to-day; that it is a perfect institution, quite capable of lecturing its neighbours on what they ought to be. The Seanad in all humility sets down the following motion which appears on the Order Paper:—
That it is expedient that a Joint Committee, consisting of five members of the Seanad and five members of the Dáil, with the Chairman of each House ex offlcio, be set up to consider and report on the changes, if any, necessary in the Constitution and powers of the Seanad.
I think that is a good suggestion. It speaks well for the Seanad that they recognise their own shortcomings. I have heard no suggestion from Dáil Eireann that a committee should be set up, consiting of five members of Seanad Eireann and five members of Dáil Eireann to consider what improvement could be made in this Assembly. If we are not prepared to make a similar gesture I think we should walk warily when pointing to others' shortcomings. I think the Seanad could be a more useful body. So does the Seanad. The Seanad very rationally says: "Come and sit down and let us talk it over, and if we can improve our procedure or our personnel we will be glad to co-operate in doing so." That is the sensible thing to do. That is the difference between reform and revolution. Reform is never popular to the kind of persons to whom certain Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party turn for support. It is not popular because the intellect of the supporters of Fianna Fáil is not capable of understanding it. Revolution is a nice, simple thesis. If you do not like the colour of something, smash it up; if you do not believe in the religious tenets of a particular body of citizens, burn their churches. That is a nice simple doctrine. If you do not agree with senatorial institutions, burst up the Seanad. If you do not agree with the political philosophy of a certain group of citizens, wipe them out. These are nice simple proposals to lay before the electors, but they are not sound. Simplicity and soundness comparatively rarely go together. It is much more difficult to say to the electors: "Here are evils that require reform." Let us be on our guard lest in attempting to abate existing evils we do not create far graver evils.
The President will be in clover at the end of the debate, because he will be discussing an abstract theory which is capable of discussion ad infimituin. He will walk round it, over it, under it, to the right of it, and to the left of it and, in the end, no one in this State will know what he thinks about it. If I may say so with great respect to Deputy MacDermot, he and the President will be able to exchange compliments across the floor. Their language and perplexity certainly will endear neither of them one whit the less to me nor will it serve to clarify my mind or the mind of anyone else. Does that cause dismay to President de Valera? Not a bit. He is most anxious that the mind of no one in this country should be clarified. He wants them to remain in profound confusion as he does about most important questions of the kind. I do not think that this question of a bicameral system or a unicameral system is capable of final settlement by abstract argument, and I think you are obliged to turn deliberately away from abstraction, away from theory, and even from logic, and try to find some empirical solution of the problem of whether you should have unicameral or bicameral government in the country. When you do that, you find, as has been pointed out, that the whole of the civilised world which accepts democratic institutions has opted in favour of bicameral systems with these exceptions, Turkey, Esthonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Bulgaria and Spain.
Comment on this
I am not so sure about Czecho-Slovakia, but I am prepared to throw in Finland, though it is not a genuine case.
Comment on this
I am not quoting, but if the Deputy wishes to know what the source of most of my information is, it is contained in two things which I would not advise him to try to peruse. One is the speech of the Chairman of the Seanad made on the Third Stage, of the existence of which he knows just as well as I do; and the other is the speech made by Senator Douglas on the Second Stage of this Bill in the Seanad, of the I existence of which he knows as well as I do, because, although a helpful announcer from Radio Ath Luain announced that the President, after everybody had spoken, responded and tore their arguments to tatters, the President has bitter reason to remember both the speeches to which I now refer. If he would like to know at any time in the future where any effective arguments come from, on this question of whether we should have a Seanad or not, I suggest he drop down to President de Valera and say : "Have you heard that one before, and where did you hear it? Would you give me the sentences in which you tore them to tatters?" And the President will blush even a little more deeply than he is blushing at the present time.
Comment on this
Does the President seriously suggest to us that, approaching it from an empirical standpoint, he thinks that the experiences of Turkey, Esthonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Bulgaria, Finland and Spain are more acceptable than the experiences of other great democratic countries which did have the bicameral system? I do not think the President will attempt to sustain the argument that there is any analogy between an elective body of the character of the Seanad, no matter how it is elected, and a hereditary body such as the House of Lords. There is not, and nobody knows that better than the President himself. So you are driven outside Great Britain to find comparisons, and in the perplexity of trying to envisage a scheme whereby I could get the perfect legislative assembly, I looked to the other democratic countries of the world and, finding that having tried one system and another, they have adopted the bicameral system, I lean in that direction until a strong argument is adduced against it.
The President did advance arguments, the first of which was that of the Abbé Seyés. I know where he got the Abbé Seyés, and he hoped to God that nobody else would, and then it was revealed by Professor John Marcus O'Sullivan that the only comment the world had to give on the Abbé Seyés was that he was like a clock in a glass case that was prepared to do everything but tell the time. Does the President not think that when he is driven back to defend his proposal to quoting to this House the Abbé Seyés, whom posterity has written down as the crazy clock of constitutional procedure, his case must be weak?
Comment on this
The President will not drive me into drawing an analogy between the Abbé Seyés and Deputy MacDermot. Surely the President agrees with me that when he finds himself driven back to relying on that kind of testimony, his case must be weak. Surely he will agree with me, when he is driven back into stating unconsciously, of course, what is not so, in defence of his argument, on the authority of Adams, that his argument must be very weak? My submission is that we are in the position of saying that the vast majority of mankind find that in practice the bicameral system works best. We accept that in default of convincing proof that it is not the best system. The President sets himself to prove that it is not the best system and he relies on a crazy clock and a misquotation from Adams. Does he not feel his position a little weak? Does he not realise that there devolves upon him some heavier obligation if he wants to carry the consensus of opinion in this House with him?
I agree with Senator Blythe, who was quoted by Deputy Norton as saying that no matter how perfect a Seanad you had or how effective an Oireachtas as a whole you had, an unscrupulous Executive could circumvent it. I quite agree with that. It is inevitable. But let not that argument be used for the purpose, as it seemed to me it was being used in certain quarters to deride Parliamentary institutions as a whole, because even though an unscrupulous Executive can override this House, or the Opposition in this House, and can, day after day and week after week, defeat them in divisions in this House, Parliament still is serving a useful purpose. One of the purposes of this House, and by no means its least important purpose, is to provide a forum from which public men can do the work of moulding public opinion in the shape they think it ought to take. I feel that an additional argument to that which I have already adduced for the bicameral system is that that function of moulding public opinion can be more effectively done under the comparatively leisurely system of bicameral legislation than it can be done if legislation shoots through, as it inevitably will, a unicameral system.
I sometimes hear Senators waxing very eloquent on the superiority of the debates in Seanad Eircann. Of course, in the Committe Stage, the Seanad is very frequently better than Dáil Eireann, the reason being that Dáil Eireann has provided them with their brief. This House gets a green paper and this House tears that green paper to pieces in Committee and advances innumerable views from both sides. The reports are perused by Senators who have seen both sides of the question by the time the Bill reaches them, and, in the knowledge of the arguments the Government will put up in defence of their proposals, the Senators may mend the hand of the Opposition, or state their case in a way which will more effectively anticipate the Government defence. When that is used for the purpose of proving that the Seanad is a more efficient body than Dáil Eireann, it makes me smile, but when it is used for proving that the Seanad serves a useful purpose in consolidating the argument of —for want of a better term—the more turbulent House below, and in marshalling and arranging the arguments and interplay of minds, in order that the public may more fully appreciate them, I say that the Seanad is doing useful work—and it is doing useful work, not only in improving legislation, but in moulding more effectively public opinion upon which the proceedings of this House ought to play. I have given two reasons, which seem to me to be cogent reasons, why we should have a bicameral system rather than a unicameral system. I freely admit that the Seanad is not perfect nor is this House perfect. If this House has a bee in its bonnet and is determined to hammer out a new scheme, the Seanad is quite prepared, and has been prepared, to sit down with it and examine anything and everything in regard to its constitution and procedure, with a view to making it a more effective instrument than it is at present. I should be glad, and I believe the whole Opposition would be glad, to co-operate with the Government if they put that work in hands.
The President has advanced no reason why the Seanad should be abolished. I feel that we are really betraying the truth in trying to discuss this motion on its merits at all, because I believe that the real reason the President decided to abolish the Seanad was because he was in a bad temper. I remember the night he came in to do it and my mind went back to my childhood days, when one would be playing a game of ball, or any other game, and one member of the group would first try to make the rules for the game. So long as the rest of the group agreed with his rules, everything in the garden was lovely. Then some independent-minded individual, possibly myself, would say: "I do not think that that is a fair rule; it is a new rule which you are just after making and it was not in when the game began. I do not think that it is a goods rule." The rule-maker would first try to break my jaw and, when he found he could not do that, he would go for his cap and say, "I won't play." The President will not feel it unjust if I say that he began by saying: "If the Seanad does what I think right, everything in the garden will be lovely." Then he heard that they were not going to do everything he thought right and he went to them and said: "If you do not do what I think right, everything in the garden will not be lovely as I will soon show your." To his horror and dismay, he discovered that he could not show them; they could not be intimidated; so he got his cap, came in here and said: "I won't play." That is the genesis of this Bill. The president wanted to demonstrate to any man who was not prepared to play the game according to his rules that he would smash him or take such other steps as were necessary to ensure that he would not block him any longer. That is what is behind this Bill and, so sure as we are in this House now, the President will trot out some lucubration hereafter about a Fifth Stage or a Sixth Stage in the consideration of Bills in this House—something as ludicrous, as futile and as absurd as his suggestion on the Committee Stage of this Bill for the protection of the independence of the judiciary.
Deputies will remember the ingenious and brilliant suggestion the President introduced for the protection of the judiciary when this Bill was passing through — the passing of an Act of this House to the effect that a judge could not be dismissed without a three-fifths majority. We all remember how he was figuring and balancing his fractions, quite oblivious of the fact that a simple majority of the House could repeal the Act and sack the judges without further ado. However, many "goms" were taken in by that suggestion. They said: "He was accused of being prepared to sack the judges, but now he has suggested a plan by which they are perfectly safe." They swallowed the suggestion. The Irish Press made them swallow it. I have no doubt that a equally ludicrous and imbecile suggestion will be made in respect of a substitute for the Seanad. It is because I apprehand that, that I wonder if we are not betraying the truth in trying to deal with this question seriously. Whether we are or not, I conceive it to be our duty by this House and its procedure to discuss to the best of our ability any measure the Government, or any other authorised persons, bring before us.
This is not a measure to abolish the Seanad as at present constituted. It is a measure to abolish the bicameral system of government in this country. It is no use for Deputy Norton to prepare the ground now for the day he will be lamenting the disaster he has brought upon the country by the act of folly he intends to perpetrate in connection with this legislation. There will be no use in his saying then: "It never occured to me that the President did not intend to establish some substitute for the Seanad; I meant only to get rid of the Senators, not the Seanad." He is getting rid of the Seanad. Let the Labour Party do that with their eyes open. Let the Labour Party make no plea that they were blinded by prejudice or bitterness in this matter. In the position they occupy, they have no right to make such an excuse. They should not allow themselves to be blinded by personal prejudice. You are ending bicameral government in this country for a certain time. Heaven knows what abuses will result therefrom. You are doing it without any cogent reason advanced by the President of the Execute Council or any of his Ministers. You are doing it in face of the fact that almost every civilised democracy in the world has found the bicameral system the most effective. You are doing it in face of the fact that one of the President's authorities for the view he now holds is a notoriously unreliable authority on constitutional affairs, and that the other authority he quoted did not say what the President thought he said and, in fact, instead of being an argument for President de Valera's unicameral theories, it stands out par excellence as the most eloquent and effective assertion of the urgent necessity of a bicameral system in any democratic country. I think it was another distinguished American democrat—and a radical democrat at that —who said he could conceive of only one dictatorship more detestable than that of an individual; that was the dictatorship of the mob. Be very careful you are not setting up a dictatorship of the mob. The President is, and always has been, a close and scrupulous student of Niccolo Machiavelli. He will remember that Machiavelli recommended to him the stirring up of disturbance until he got into office and to stir it up with all the exterior appearance of benignity, magnanimity, justice, truth and religion. He will remember that Niccolo Machiavelli further advised him, having got into the saddle, to take mighty good care he stayed there. At the moment the mob will probably keep him there. But the mob is an unreliable element in this or in any other country. And extreme as the President may hold himself to be, there will be some lunatic in this country who will rise on his left hand, and the President will strain and struggle to move further to the left, but he will meet his match in that matter some time, and he will find to his astonishment and amazement that the mob on whom he depends so confidently now for support, will start to move off to the new light on the horizon.
Comment on this
Deputy MacDermot is so naïve, so innocent and so anxious to understand that it rather discourages one to be asked at the conclusion of one's oration what it all meant. I would be willing to go through it all again——
Comment on this
Possibly Deputy MacDermot descends to an et tu quoque which appears to be a bit low. I have made the case that a bicameral system of legislation helps to mould public opinion and helps to restrict the dominance of the unreasonable mob. I am pointing out that the President is departing on lines which may lead into a position which neither he nor his followers can now see. Deputy MacDermot has his own opinion and he has expressed it. I have my opinion and I have expressed it.
Comment on this
Might I point out that the Deputy has forgotten completely that the Seanad must become and is becoming a mere echo of this House?
Comment on this
I would have thought that our long association would have led Deputy MacDermot to accept the logic of my speech as flowing from sound arguments. If the Deputy failed to follow what I have been saying I advise him to peruse the Official Report of my speech and he will there find closely reasoned arguments. I invite the attention of the President when his keener perspicacity has mastered the thread of my argument to realise that we are prepared to co-operate with him in making the Seanad more nearly perfect than it is. We are satisfied that the Seanad is prepared to co-operate with the President and with the Dáil and to do what it can to make both Houses more perfect. If the President would appreciate that it would be a good thing for the country. Let us in the Dáil resent the inclination to abolish the Seanad just as we would resent the inclination of the Seanad to abolish this House. Let both Houses realise that both are necessary for the liberties of the country and let us join together to improve the efficiency of both Houses rather than joining in a trial of strength between the two Houses, aimed at the destruction of one.
Comment on this
One would have thought, on an occassion such as this when we were called upon to abolish one House of the Oireachtas, that fairness to the Dáil, if not courtesy to the Seanad, would compel the introducer of such a motion as this to attempt to make at least some case for that motion. I consider that it was an act of discourtesy to the Dáil, an act uncharitable in itself and unkind to a body that has worked well for the past 12 years that something has not been said by the leader of the majority in Dáil Eireann than merely to throw a resolution such as this before the House and to say to the docile people behind him, "Vote for that." From a political leader or statesman, at all events, from the President of the Executive Council, one would imagine that before this type of reckless legislation was indulged in that he would at least be man enough to give some reason and make a case for his motion—that he would first present something to Dáil Eireann for criticism, or alternatively, for discussion.
There have been unmanly acts done in this House from time to time. Thank the Lord they are rare, but perhaps the unkindest and the most unmanly thing that was ever done is the way and the method in which it is proposed to abolish the Seanad. Does it matter one bit whether the Seanad contains a minority or majority of Fianna Fáil representatives? Should it not at least be recognised that these men and these ladies gave 12 years' long service to this State and they did their work well, fearlessly and conscientiously? Whether we as politicians agree with their findings in the Seanad in every case or not at least a case should be made against it before that House is sentenced to death. It may be said that the case was made before. But nobody knows better than the President that the case he made previously is like Johnson's description of a net—a bundle of holes tied together. When the inaccuracies, the falsehoods, the misstatements and the misquotations were picked out of that particular statement of the President's there was nothing left but a bundle of holes. Is it that the President was unable to replace those tattered fragments of a case by any other case? Or is it that the new Republican way of leading Parliament is to act as a quitter, to funk the responsibility of making a case before the Opposition, leaving them an opportunity of replying? Are we to have the shirker's method of only making a case when the debate is over and when no remarks, observations or replies can be made? This habit of dealing with grave constitutional issues in this insulting manner is unfair to the Dáil and is an evading of the responsibility which the country imposes on the shoulders of the President.
Here we have had a Bill for four hours before Dáil Eireann, to abolish entirely one of the Houses of the Oireachtas. We have a Front Bench of Government mutes. We have a majority Party, a Party of mutes. In that four hours not one of them has been found to stand up even out of courtesy to the Dáil and attempt to state to the House why this act should be committed. There has been no one to stand up and say why we should by a majority vote abolish one of the two Houses of the Oireachtas. The only spokesman who had the courage to get up in an endeavour to make a case for the resolution is the leader of the Labour Party. It would be better for him, for the resolution, and for the Labour Party that he had followed the President's example and sat dumb. The case he made, in so far as it could be considered a case, was a case chock full of misstatements and inaccuracies. It was a case that showed he did not even consider the subject sufficiently worth while to look up figures, to ascertain facts. It was good enough just to stroll into the Dáil as one of a majority Party and make any kind of slipshod, inaccurate case, and that was a good enough fate for his own loyal colleagues in the Seanad. We had all the old clap-trap, the old Hyde Park type of oratory. We had a reference to the Ascendancy gang and the Seanad labelled as so many creatures under the control of one political Party; a group of creatures who passed without comment, without question any and every type of legislation introduced by us; a group of creatures who resisted and obstructed, altered and held up every type of legislation introduced by the present Government.
It is said that fair play is bonny play, and it is grossly unfair to the Seanad whether it lives or dies, grossly unfair to the Seanad as a whole, to have that type of statement made from any bench in Dáil Eireann. It is particularly unfair to the Seanad to have those statements made by a man who is too lazy to look up the facts and who refuses to give the figures. It is very well known, and cannot be disputed either by the Government or by the Labour Party, that during the Cumann na nGaedheal régime very many Bills were held up, amended, altered and referred back by the Seanad. It is equally true that the same occurred during the Fianna Fáil régime. I put it to the President or to Deputy Norton that that was the Seanad's job, that is what the money was voted for. If the Seanad did not amend Bills, did not delay Bills, then you would have a fair and honest and just case for the abolition of the Seanad. The Seanad was established and maintained and paid for in this country to examine, to alter, to amend and to delay Bills, and is it fair because they did their job that that should be made the cause of its execution?
When Deputy Norton made his loose, reckless statement—a statement that should have never been made by any man in a Front Bench or a back bench —that the Seanad were the creatures of a political Party, that as long as we were the Government everything went through, and that when there was a change of Government everything was held up, one would think that a man occupying his responsible position would at least feel that there was a responsibility on his shoulders to look up the figures, to ascertain the facts. In the debate on the Seanad, if he had only followed it, the figures with regard to all Bills during Deputy Cosgrave's term as President and all Bills during President de Valera's term as President, altered, amended or held up, were given in a very simple table. One would think that before that kind of wild, unjust, untrue charge was levelled at the Seanad the man making such a statement would at least look up the figures. The facts are that during Deputy Cosgrave's administration of nine years there was a total of 338 Bills, 122 of which were amended. There were in all 1,150 amendments. There were 1,120 agreed to and 30 not agreed to. Just before the Seanad goes let us be fair to it in its last few moments, if we have been foul to it for ten long years. Up to the time these figures were prepared we had two years and five months of the Fianna Fáil administration, and in that period there were 105 Bills sent to the Seanad and there were 465 amendments. We had approximately one-third the number of Bills and one-third the number of amendments. There was about the same proportion or percentage of amendments.
Is it fair for Deputy Norton, for President de Valera, or for the Minister for Finance, to go down the country before simple, honest people, inexperienced in government, inexperienced in the falsehoods of politicians, and mislead these simple, trusting people with statements so false that nobody in the most irresponsible position should utter them, not to mention a person in the most responsible position in which the citizens of this State can place a man? I have said that the President's attitude was unjust to Dáil Eireann and uncharitable to Seanad Eireann and that his utterances were unfair to the people. If there is a case to be made against the Seanad, let a fair, straightforward, honest case be made and do not let a case consisting of a bundle of falsehoods be the mallet that strikes the Seanad to death. The Minister for Finance, a man holding a responsible ministerial position, a man with hundreds of experts, civil servants and clerks behind him, a man with the library at his disposal and a man that occupies such a position that he should know what he was talking about before he stood up to talk— what were his references to the Seanad?
"Every Bill passed was being held up by the Seanad. Most of the men who constituted the majority against the Uniforms Bill in the Seanad were nominated by the last Government as a result of the khaki election of 1923; they were the creatures of our predecessors."
There is a statement of great gravity, of immense gravity, made by a Minister, speaking as a Minister. It is a statement that, if true, would justify the abolition of the Seanad there and then; a statement that, if false, should have brought about an immediate demand for the resignation of a Minister who so abused his position as to state that most of the men who constituted the majority against the Uniforms Bill were nominated by the last Government as a result of the khaki election of 1923. That is the statement, that is the charge.
Let us have the figures and let us view the facts. There were 48 votes recorded in that particular division, 30 against the Bill and 18 for the Bill. Of the 48 Senators, five were nominated Senators; and of those five, two voted for the Bill and three voted against the Bill. There are the facts; these are the figures; that is the statement. We had from the President himself a broadcast statement, on the eve of the election to the effect that—
"A hostile Seanad is constantly attempting to harass the Government by mutilating its measures, or wilfully delaying them."
That statement is on a par with the statement I just read from the Minister for Finance; and both are on a par with the statement made by the Leader of the Labour Party. "Give a dog a bad name and shoot him." We have had 12 long years of that kind of unjustifiable slander, aimed at the Seanad in this country. We had people for 12 long years reading and listening to that type of false, untrue, unnatural and unIrish language. We have had the Seanad bespattered and besmirched by the leaders of the Party opposite all the time. With that type of propaganda behind it should not people believe the utterances of responsible men, and so we are told there is a mandate for the abolition of the Seanad. We are told the majority of the people believe that the Seanad should be abolished. Of course they do! They believe their public leaders; they trust the word of Ministers; they believe that they would not be misled by people holding positions such as they hold. And so you get popular approval for such a measure as this.
If a great political Party was so irresponsible and so reckless in regard to truth, and if they started throughout the country, to slander the institution of the Ceann Comhairle and to utter falsehoods as to how his duty was done, to deliberately give wrong figures and statements with regard to his rulings, and at the end of all that proceed to say that it is costing so much a year, it would not take many months before you would be able to secure a mandate for the abolition of the institution of the Ceann Comhairle. But could that in any sense be regarded as a national mandate? Could that in any sense be regarded as an authority that should be recognised—a mandate secured, or a vote secured, by misleading deliberately the public mind with regard to the activities and the construction and the constitution or the personnel of a House of the Oireachtas?
Remember, the Seanad is not in the public eye in the same way that the Dáil is. The public gallery there is not utilised as it is in the Dáil. Seanad debates are not published in the daily Press or in the local Press as are debates here. It was an ideal hunting ground for dishonest politicians. It was and ideal state of affairs to get at it and, with good prospect of success, to blackguard an institution that in my heart, I believe, was, and is, and has been, over the whole run of its existence, a better House, far better, than Dáil Eireann. And as far as representative government goes, it is at least as representative as Dáil Eireann.
We have this phrase about the ascendancy gang, and the impression conveyed either by deliberate statements or innuendo, that the Seanad is, in fact, a nominated body, or even that it is something like the House of Lords and that people hold their seats there by some right of wealth or hereditary right. Did any one of these people, so anxiously out for the life of the Seanad, ever tell their followers that the Seanad is a body elected by the votes of Deputies in Dáil Eireann and the members of the Seanad? In the real, full sense it is as representatives as Dáil Eireann is, but it is more selective. Its general behaviour and the manner in which it works, and the duties it has discharged certainly call for something better than the silence of the President to-night and the slanders of the President on other occasions.
The State is what the people themselves make it. The State is, in the main, what the builders make of the State. We have had three years of slanders; destruction; three years of slander; three years of wreeking and we are to go further with the wreeking to-night. The only sensible sign of returning decency is the silence with which the resolution was thrown before the House to-night. There are many ways in which shame can be shown. We had it mentioned, time and again, we had sneers from those on the benches opposite that there are members of the minority in the Seanad, and that in the Seanad there is greater representation for the minority than in the Dáil. We are reaching a point in the history of this country which certainly years ago was proud of its Christianity, when we are going to lay down by practice, if not by utterance, that the minority are to have no rights. They are to be cut out of the picture, whether it is by amending representation or by sub-dividing the constituencies with a view to giving a smaller percentage to that group. We have that now in the abolition of the Seanad. Anyone who is not blind can see what is the fibre in the middle of every Act—to trample on minorities in this country.
I have no brief for the minority. Neither now nor in the past have I any direct association or affiliation with the people referred to as the minority. As far as I am concerned, my family for at least three generations back happened to be on opposite sides to the people who are dubbed the minority Party now, but I would say this, out of justice to those men, if the so-called partriots opposite had behaved as well to the new Irish State as the minority did, we would be a happier, a healthier and a more prosperous State to-day. Do not forget that. All you super-patriots over there, with your belated respect for majority rule, would do very well now —having recognised that principle—to start marching in the footsteps of the men who constitute the minority in the Irish Free State.
Comment on this
The Deputy is in a happier position than most of them, because I believe that there is not one of us in this House, of any Party, who has not something which he should regret at least.
Comment on this
When we were the minority we had precious little rights. except the jails and the barbed wire.
Comment on this
We have all got our share of that. That particular thing has been levelled out, and certainly you never got the jail or anything of its kind because you followed constitutional precedents; you never got it because you respected majority rule; you never got it because you came in here to argue your case and take the spin of the coin when it went against you.
Comment on this
You got it because in those days you did not stand for two Houses; you stood for no House. Now there is another aspect of this matter which I did not hear referred to to-night, and I think it is a subject— possibly Deputy Donnelly will agree with me in this—that is at least worthy of consideration. We have a doctrine commonly subscribed to by all Parties in this House, namely, an abhorrence of Partition and a desire for a 32-County State of some kind. Is there anybody over there going to tell me that the abolition of the Seanad, leaving an Oireachtas consisting of one House, is going to give any confidence to anybody outside our frontiers who has been accustomed to any other system? Is there anyone going to tell me that the general trend of legislation—this being a sample of it—as far as it affects minority interests in this country, is going to give greater confidence to the Irish in the North of Ireland to come in than they had heretofore? In all honesty, and far removed from Party spirit, there may be people who believe that this type of legislation is desirable, but there is not one of them that will not admit that this type of legislation and many allied types of Bills that we had before us previously are in fact making Partition more and more permanent; and are putting further back the day when there is any hope or prospect of the six Northern counties joining with us in any form of association.
Comment on this
On another occasion I will take up the Deputy with regard to the Northern elections.
Comment on this
But not just now. I said in my opening remarks that the whole method of handling this matter was unfair to the Dáil and unjust to the Seanad; that if we are to lop off one House a case should at least be made for that. Assuming that the whole position is that whether a case is made or not there is the type of majority to which the Minister for Finance referred here last week, and that the majority vote is going to forge this through, I would say that the exhibition here to-day is some kind of foretaste, some kind of danger signal, some kind of warning as to how things will be managed here when there is nothing necessary to effect legislation in this country but a majority trooping through one or other Lobby there. We have here a motion of possibly the greatest gravity of any motion that ever was introduced. We have it introduced in this slipshod fashion. There is not trust in the House but confidence in the weight of the vote behind. If there was ever a noisy exhibition of abuse and misuse of democratic powers it is the exhibition we have witnessed here this evening. The Seanad is going. The Seanad, which has served for 12 long years, is going by the votes of people who have served this State for only eight years. The least that is due to the Seanad, irrespective of what Parties they belong to, irrespective of its constitution, is a word or two from different Parties and differing Parties in this House to express gratitude to them for the work they have done, appreciation of the services they have rendered, admiration for the impartial and fearless manner in which they have done their work for 12 long years, and, if I had my way, in addition to that an expression of hearty disapproval for the principle contained in this Resolution before us.
Comment on this
A Leas-Chinn Comhairle, I listened with amazement to one of the speeches to which the House has been treated to-night—the speech of Deputy Norton. Seldom, if ever, have I heard in this House such a demonstration of hypocrisy. His attack on the Seanad was based on the fact that the Seanad passed the Constitution (Amendment No.17) Act in 1931. He denounced the Seanad for having passed that, and he leaves out of account the time and the circumstances when that Act was passed. The leader of the Labour Party, who now denounces the Seanad for passing that Act, is one of the people who are responsible for keeping that Act in force. In different times and different circumstances that Act was passed by this House and by the Seanad. It was passed in order to put an end to the committing of murder. It is enforced now and kept in force now for very different reasons and very different objects. I do not know of any case in which it has been applied to put an end to murder in the last few years. It has been applied and put in force in order to put and end to political organisations.
Deputy Norton is one of the people who support the maintenance of that Act upon the Statute Book at the present time. His attitude as regards a Second House and as regards the functions of a Second House is very different from that of Senator Johnson, who led the Labour Party in this House in its early stages for some years. Senator Johnson took a distinguished part in moulding the institutions of this State in its early days. Senator Johnson wrote a letter which was published in the Press yesterday, dealing with a kindred question, which was before the House a day or two ago. He expressed views in that letter which are very germane to the matter the House is discussing at present. He expressed these views on checks to hasty action by a Legislature :—
"There are arguments in favour of abandoning constitutional protection that might be worth discussion, of trusting to the day-to-day good sense of an elected Parliament; but so far, such a proposition has had no public advocacy and, I fancy, at the present stage of our political development it would find few serious advocates. Before approving of the revocation of a written Constitution, the public would do well to insist upon the procedure of the House (or Houses) of the Legislature being so regulated as to prevent a Bill being enacted until it has had full publicity and time given to enable public opinion to be formulated."
I think that is a statesmanlike statement and one that I would expect from a Labour leader of the distinction of Senator Johnson, who, as I say, gave a great deal of good service in moulding the institutions of this State. How different is the attitude of the present head of the Labour Party, who says that the Seanad should be abolished because it passed certain Bills that he disapproved of. Earlier, when the Bill to abolish the Seanad was first before the House, he used language which makes one ashamed to think that at this stage of our political development we cannot keep religious bigotry out of our politics. He referred on that occasion to the Seanad as being composed of soupers, proselytisers and the remnants of the old ascendancy. I say that we should feel ashamed in this House that language of that kind should be introduced into a debate and that the religious faith of any member of the Legislature should be taken into account in discussing the merits or demerits of the assembly to which he belongs. I am referring to a statement by Deputy Norton in which he used that expression as describing members of the Seanad. He told us on that occasion that the bankers, the brewers and the Unionists, the soupers, the proselytisers and the remnants of the old ascendancy would be got rid of. I say it is shameful that such language should be used in this Assembly in describing members of the other House. The Deputy did not repeat that language to-night but it is perfectly obvious that what he had in his mind was the sentiment that inspired these words at the time.
Deputy Dr. O'Higgins referred to the treatment that the minority are getting and to the fact that the representation that they have had in the Oireachtas is being abolished. It may not have been the result of any explicit bargain, but it was certainly implicit in the arrangements made by this country when the Treaty was passed that some representation should be given to the minority, who, owing to their small numbers in this State, could not get that representation even under the system of proportional representation by that the country had adopted. They did get some such representation by university franchise and by the seats allocated to them in the Seanad. That representation is being taken away from them now. It is no answer when I say that that is bad and reactionary to tell me that our people, the minority in the North of Ireland, are deprived of their representation there. Two wrongs do not make a right.
Comment on this
Two wrongs do not make a right, and if they do what is wrong there, we should give them an example of enlightened conduct and enlightened citizenship here. We should not deprive the minority here of the representation in the Legislature which they have enjoyed. From their intelligence, their patriotism, their work for the country, and the wealth which they have invested in it, they are certainly entitled to that representation.
Comment on this
I am not aware that any of these people ever hit Deputy Donnelly with a hammer on the head. Certainly, in this part of the country they did not. Deputy Norton substituted for the Second House the restoration of the Referendum. I remember that peculiar institution as part of our Constitution here. I forget the number of signatures that it was necessary to get in order to procure a referendum on any subject on which the House had legislated. I think it was 70,000. Deputy Minch says that it was 50,000, but whether it was 50,000 or 70,000, any politician who had sufficient money and leisure—for instance, Deputy MacDermot—could easily send out a batch of commercial travellers all over the State, and they could collect that number of signatures in a week and obstruct the work of the Legislature here by getting a referendum, with enormous expense to the State. I think the estimate made at the time the matter was under discussion was £70,000. It would take £70,000 to rid us of the activities of these commercial travellers.
Comment on this
I have no opinion of Deputy MacDermot because I do not know his opinions on any subject. He told us here to-night that he did not know if he would vote for this Bill. He did not think that he was at present prepared to vote for the Bill "unless and unless and unless." That is not new to Deputy MacDermot. He is the political honey-bee who is, at the present moment, hovering over the Fianna Fáil flower, but he may not be very long there. He may be hovering over the Labour flower next week. I am reminded by this interruption of something that I said about Deputy MacDermot when he was the leader of a Party in this House—that he spoke one way and voted another. That is the new political technique which would enable him to say to people who did not like his speech, "Look how I voted," and to people who did not like his vote, "Read my speech."
The Government claim to have a mandate to abolish the Seanad. Undoubtedly, if we could analyse the voting in the elections of 1932 and 1933 and if we could ascertain the opinions of the people who voted for the Fianna Fáil Party I suppose we would get a great number, a majority, who believed that the Seanad should be abolished. The Government undoubtedly got a mandate, but how did they procure it? The method by which they procured it reminds me of what was said in the House of Commons at one time by a distinguished Irishman, the late Mr. T. M. Healy, when he described the methods adopted by the British Government when they wanted to annex territory in some other country, say a patch of Africa. Tim Healy's description of their procedure was that they got a Press Agency to send a cablegram home to say: "King Thebaw is drinking." That was followed up the following week by another cablegram saying: "King Thebaw is drinking still." The pressure was kept up and, eventually, a mandate was procured from the English people because they thought it right, of course, that a person of that kind ought to be suppressed, that his territory ought to be annexed, and that his people ought to be civilised.
Comment on this
He had the same rank as the king of Dalkey Island but, unlike him, he was hereditary.
Comment on this
On the 3rd of January, 1933, the President made a statement which was, I think, issued at the time to the Press in which he said:—
"A hostile Seanad is constantly attempting to harrass the Government by mutilating its measures or wilfully delaying them."
That was the first cable about King Thebaw: "King Thebaw is drinking." On the 9th of January, six days afterwards, the Minister for Justice, speaking at Balla, said, "Every Bill we pass is being held up." That is the telegram to say "King Thebaw is drinking still." The pressure was kept up until in the end the Government did get a mandate, if you like, to abolish the Seanad. It was got by this kind of misrepresentation of facts.
I do not propose to go through the matter which has been dealt with in a very masterly way in a speech on this subject made by the Chairman of the Seanad at the time the Bill was before that House. The proceedings of that House during the years of its existence were analysed by him and figures given which have never been contradicted or refuted. These figures showed that there was not one particle more interference with the legislation of the present Government than there was with the legislation of the Cosgrave Government. Looking at that speech, and reading those figures, I think no person can get up in this House and honestly say that the Seanad did not do its work faithfully and well, not merely under the Cosgrave Government, but under the present Government.
I see the Minister for Finance here now and I think it would be unfair to him not to quote for him the matter referred to already by Deputy O'Higgins. It would be most unfair to the Minister for Finance not to refer to it because Deputy O'Higgins quoted a speech made by the Minister for Finance in which he said, referring to the Seanad:—
"Most of the men who constituted the majority against the Uniforms Bill in the Seanad were nominated by the last Government as a result of what I might call the khaki election of 1923."
What are the facts? The Seanad, in fact, to which he was referring was nominated in December, 1922, and the so-called khaki election did not take place until eight months later. As regards the suggestion that these people were prejudiced or voted in a particular way because they had been nominated by particular persons let us see what the facts are. The voting on that Bill was 30 against and 18 in favour of the Bill. Of the 48 members of the Seanad who voted on the occasion, there were only five nominated Senators and, of the five nominated Senators, two voted in favour of the Bill and three against.
As I said, I do not want to repeat the statement made already except that in fairness to the Minister for Finance he ought to get an opportunity of telling us whether that report of his speech is incorrect because, as Deputy O'Higgins says, he has hundreds of officials at his disposal to get him any information he desires to get or help him with any statement he desires to make on important public matters. It is deplorable that persons in the position of Ministers should have such a small sense of their responsibilities as to make glaring misstatements of fact of that kind and not be man enough to get up and say, "I have made a mistake; my facts were all wrong."
Comment on this
As the Minister for Finance, judging by his speech yesterday, is a convert to the idea of majority rule, I still have hopes that he will be man enough to say to-night, "My statements about the Seanad were all misstatements of fact." That would be the big thing to do, and I hope to see the Minister do so before he leaves the House.
I have very little further to say except this, that if the President proposes to abolish the Second House in this country he is adopting a very dangerous procedure for the future of this State, because a statesman, when he forges a dangerous weapon, should always remember that the weapon may subsequently fall into the hands of some person less scrupulous than any who have gone before; that the dangerous weapon may fall into the hands of some unscrupulous man afterwards. I hope the President, if he intends to get rid of the Seanad, will consider setting it up in some other form by some different form of election, and not put into the hands of extreme people who may come after him a weapon that they may use to the danger and destruction of this State.
Comment on this
Before I call on Deputy Thrift, I should like to say that it has been intimated to the Chair that an agreement has been come to that the President is to be allowed to intervene at 10 o'clock to conclude the debate and that the division will be taken to-night. I merely make that statement so that Deputies will keep it in mind during the remainder of the discussion.
Comment on this
I did not intend to make anything like a speech, but I do not think I should allow the passage of a constitutional measure of this magnitude without making some protest, and a vigorous protest, if possible. I do not regard it as my function to defend in any way the actions of the Seanad and I do not intend at this stage to debate the question of the advantages of a one-Chamber system or of a dual-Chamber system. I believe the President and every member of the Dáil knows my views on the matter perfectly well and, therefore, I do not want to waste time about that. I do want, however, to emphasise as strongly as I can what certain Deputies have contended as against the contention of other Deputies, and that is, that, in my opinion, there can be no mistake at all about what we are asked to decide to-night. It is the simple and sole question of whether we are to have one-Chamber government or two-Chamber government. It is not a question as to whether the Seanad has acted wisely in the past or not, or whether it is likely to act wisely in the future. It is not a question as to whether that is the best type of Seanad, or whether it could be improved or not. The simple question is: are we to have, even for a time, government in this country by one Chamber alone? If the President had seen fit, as I had hoped he would, to bring this measure in the form of a reformation, if he likes to call it that, of the Seanad instead of a simple motion to remove it from our Constitution, I should have rejoiced; but I cannot contemplate with any but the very gravest feelings our taking, even for a time, the position in which we have merely a single Chamber. It is easy to pull down: it is difficult to build up, and if we once put ourselves in the position of only having one-Chamber form of government, I doubt if we shall ever get to the stage of reverting to the dual Chamber unless a complete alteration in the political configuration of the country took place.
I would like if I could get the careful attention of Deputies on that consideration, and to bear with me for a few moments in protesting, as strongly as I can, against what I feel is a growing habit of the Government in this country. In using these words I am not referring merely to the Fianna Fáil Government. I have noticed, in the many years in which I have been here, a growing tendency for a Government to justify its actions by reference to the actions of other bodies, whether in this Dáil or outside, and to defend itself in the measures that it brings forward, or in the steps that it takes, by reference to what the official Opposition or some other body is doing, either inside this Dáil or outside it. Now, I think that is a retrograde line on which to find ourselves, and I would put forward what I conceive to be the function of a Government in bringing forward and justifying any measures which it introduces. I do not see that it strengthens itself in the very least by reference to what has happened in the past or to what has been done in the past by any preceding Government or political Party in this State. The question at the time should be confined solely to a consideration of the measure and an estimation of the probabilities of whether that measure is likely to advance the prosperity of the State and the good of its citizens or the reverse. There has been far too much of an attempt to justify measures simply by saying "you did this or worse in the past" to some of the opponents of those who have put forward a measure. Neither side is free from blame in that respect, in my opinion. I am sure I am saying things which neither side will hear with pleasure.
At the time when the preceding Government introduced retrospective legislation, they were told, I believe, by myself, that the day would come when they would regret having done so, and that they might find others in power who would bring that against them as a weapon in something that they might wish to carry themselves. We have bitterly experienced that in the past fortnight, and, to my regret, the measure passed in the House during the last fortnight has been mainly backed by reference to the way in which the previous Government had themselves, in my opinion, erred.
The Government, in the previous discussions on this measure, have attempted to justify it by pointing to the actions of the Seanad in the past. Now, I contend that these actions have nothing to do with the merits of this measure. It is, what is the Seanad likely to do in the future which has a bearing, and a definite bearing, on whether this measure for the abolition of the Seanad should be introduced, or whether some measure of improvement in the possibility of a Seanad in the future should be introduced or not. I do hold strongly that the evils which are likely to accrue, or which may accrue, from a unicameral form of government are much greater than those which would be likely to accrue if we set ourselves to get that form of Second Chamber which would be likely to do useful service to the State. I heard with deep regret the President say, on a previous Stage, that because he could not satisfy himself that a Seanad set up on certain lines would be likely to be a useful body, that he would not undertake what I conceive to be his duty, namely, to set forth or put forward, the form of Seanad which he thinks would be superior to the present form of Seanad. If that had been done, I think everyone in this House would have been anxious to co-operate with him in trying to secure the best possible form of Seanad that we could have. But, it is quite a different proposition boldly to bring forward before us a proposition to remove the Seanad altogether from our Constitution.
I wish we could get into the habit of thinking forward more, of thinking about the present more, and of refraining more from looking back upon the errors of our opponents in the past. Reference has been made to what are called the minority in this country. Whatever you may think of me, I stand as a representative of that minority, and I conceive it my duty to say what I think about this action and what I believe hundreds of thousands of people in this country will agree with me in believing, what I conceive will be likely to be the effect of this action that you propose to take to-day, upon our relations with the whole country. I feel that, in this last attempt to whittle away any academic provision which was in our Constitution before, and on the strength of which many people gladly gave their whole-hearted co-operation to the building up of this State, you are taking a grave step which will put backward, rather than forward, our development. Now do not misunderstand me. I claim no privilege. I freely admit that the present Government, in their practical dealings, have shown great width of mind and broadness of treatment. I make no complaint whatever of that kind, but I do say that by removing these paper academic provisions, if you like things which, in themselves, mean little and which do not practically affect, to the extent of the weight of a feather, our actual being, we are cutting ourselves off definitely for many years to come from those with whom we would all wish to be united, and making thousands of people in the country say: "Why did I ever lend my support to a separate Irish Free State Government?"
Personally, I do not regret whatever I may have been able to do on behalf of our Government. I believe if the position had been accepted I would have done everything that in me lay, so far as my ability went, to further the prosperity of the country and steadily to move forward government in this country. I do not regret anything I have done with that end in view in the past, but you are, by this measure, putting the final touch to what many people are thinking, that this is frittering away everything in the position which you do not like, in order that you may be free to take advantage of everything you do like, and to boast of doing it, when you say you are whittling away the Treaty. Personally, I would hide my head for shame rather than say that. I cannot conceive how anybody could wish to take advantage of any bargain without being ready to go back to the position there was before that bargain was made. It is not possible, and no one wants that who could do it. But I would not put myself in the position of having it said that one should deliberately settle oneself to whittle away these provisions and calmly make the most of anything there that was good. I cannot understand how you could boast of it. I want you to understand, as the point was made— and I think it is false—that it is not democracy. You may say that it is majority rule. I accept majority rule and have always accepted it. I wish it had been accepted as loyally by everyone from 1921. I have accepted it, and I do accept it, but I say that this is not even majority rule.
I have no hope that anything I could say, or that anyone else in this House could say, would affect in the slightest degree a single vote that is going to be given, because the matter has been settled previously by a majority of the majority. I have no idea of the extent of that majority, but I cannot believe that it was a unanimous vote of Fianna Fáil in favour of this policy. I do not know what the magnitude of the majority in favour of this was, but it is a majority of the majority, to bring the majority in this House to give a majority vote for overruling in that way the wishes of the minority. You cannot call that democracy and you cannot call it majority rule, pure and simple. I ask you to look forward. As I said before, the day will come when you will regret having taken this step. You will not be there always. You will have successors, and if some Seanad is left, even if the present Seanad is left, you would have left your mark on that Seanad, and your policy would be, to a certain extent, perpetuated by that Seanad. By the presence of that Seanad you would have smoothed over any sudden gap that would take place, when you are replaced by your successors, whoever they may be. By the presence of the Seanad you prevent the suddenness and magnitude of the changes that take place when Governments change. You would tend loyally to continue what you were standing for in your government of the country but, by your removal of this Seanad, you are preventing that occurring. You will be succeeded by some body who will have it in their power, by a majority of their majority, to sweep away anything that you might believe you were doing for the good of the country. Is that a position you wish to bring about? That is what you are going to do.
I am not pleading for the Seanad as it stands. It would be an impertinence on my part to attempt to justify or to defend their actions in the past. It is for them to do that, and they can do it much better than I can. I am standing up for democracy and for the majority of the people. If you want that to hold, you will, as far as possible, tend to prevent the majority of a majority being in the position without any check or delay whatever of putting into force anything which their successors may decide is for the best. I intended to make only a few remarks but my intensity of feeling on the matter has rather carried me away. I do not think there is any use appealing, because I am sure your minds are made up. I rose to make as vigorous a protest as I could against what I believe to be a definitely fatal step for the future spirit of goodwill, for future harmony in the country and its future prosperity.
Mr. McGilligan rose.
Comment on this
There are five minutes yet. Yesterday we had a recantation from the Minister for Finance. Does the Minister believe that in later days some other person sitting there will not regret and apologise for what he is now proposing? In the words of a well-known phrase, the things that bring the most regret to people are those that remind them of what happened when it is too late to undo the harm—
"O, call back yesterday, bid time return!"
The Minister told us yesterday what might have happened if he was as wise seven or eight years ago as he is now. When will the President get wisdom with regard to the Seanad, or time to admit what his Minister confessed yesterday after seven or eight years—with men killed and treasure wasted—about majority rule? The President came here three years ago with a programme of Christian socialism, and if the world could be run by moral gesture, and if class distinctions could be referred to Heaven, the President, as the representative of that place, would be the greatest statesman, and would be second only to those other gods and goddesses who meet at Cathal Brugha Street.
Comment on this
When the Deputy was asked to repeal Constitution (Amendment) No. 10, and when we pleaded, it did not get any consideration.
Comment on this
There is another quotation that I might use:—
A fairer person lost not Heaven; he seem'd
For dignity compos'd and high exploit;
But all was false and hollow; though his tongue
Dropp'd manna, and could make the worse appear
The better reason, to perplex and dash Maturest counsels."
That was the Son of the Morning who became chief of the devils. The maturest counsels of the world, in days of maturity and counsel, opted for Second Chambers, and we are going to wipe out the Second House without argument. Can anyone say that there was one reason given on this Bill that would convince any person that a Second Chamber is not a necessity?
Comment on this
The Deputy referred to-day to people being put in jail. The Deputy is giving that treatment to other people now.
Comment on this
You talk about rights being taken away from the minority. You know the rights you gave us.
Comment on this
You are giving those rights to a minority of other people now. Be clear about it. The President could only boast of it.
Comment on this
Go back to the North and fight for the minority. You put 50 miles between you and the North, but you are drawing the £300.
Comment on this
The ordinary fanatic can boast that if the torch of God is in the hands of the infidel, he has paved the way to it with corpses. Look at the corpses. Even the law he himself made he has got to amend here retrospectively when it does not suit his purpose. Even if he had it in his power he would abolish that Second Chamber of his own making—his own Ard-Fheis—because he did not get too good a reception.
At any rate, it is one good thing, as Deputy O'Higgins said, that we did not have any parade of scholarship with regard to this motion to-night. The last time this Bill was debated the President came in here and told us that he had read books—he stressed that twice—and listened to arguments on constitutional matters. He went to the Seanad and if ever any man got stripped in his nakedness and exposed with regard to scholarship, the President was the man. Deputy O'Higgins talked here to-night of the unfrocked priest, but the tattered scholar did not dare to bring forward to-night any example, because when he did pretend to scholarship and threw out a few examples, it was shown how hollow he was. We can pass this—it is going to be passed; but some time later there will be a reaction and some time later maybe the same Minister, who, although a grown man, is only learning some things, will come here and say, as he said the other day of his opposition to majority rule, that he regrets his action to-day, that a Second Chamber is a necessity and that the maturest counsel of the world has something to be said for it which was not broken by anything in the way of argument here.
Comment on this
We would expect some scholarship from a professor of constitutional law and we would expect something better than a tirade such as we have just listened to, just as we would expect, when listening to a professor of history, that we might have had something more than a wild statement about what the world has approved of. I did not, in introducing this, give the arguments which were given before, because I know they would fall on deaf ears as before. There were 41 hours of debate on this matter when it was before the Dáil on the previous occasion. For two months it was before the Dáil. The Dáil Reports and the arguments put forward there were before you if you wanted to refer to them. But no; they were simply a collection of holes, to use the definition of a net given, it was said, by Johnson. That is not the way, I take it, to argue this question. With the exception of perhaps one or two speeches, it was for the most part simply a tirade by the Opposition and of personal attacks, and then we are asked why we cannot debate this question calmly and examine the consequences of our action, etc., etc. The members of the Government, members on our side here, and I gave ample opportunity during the whole evening to Deputies on the opposite benches to tell us in what precise manner a Second Chamber was going to assist us—either the present Chamber or any Second Chamber they could suggest. They have said they have put it up as part of their programme to have a Second House. Will they tell us how that Second House is going to be constituted and what powers it is going to have? I have issued that challenge several times and not one on the other side has attempted to meet it or to meet the dilemma which was expressed in a famous phrase—famous because of the truth in it and not because of the man who first uttered it or with whom it is associated. It was repeated by Deputy MacDermot here to-night as pointing out in an epigrammatic form the dilemma in which they are placed to try to have a Second Chamber and, at the same time, to have an authoritative representative Chamber directly elected by the people. Just try to fashion such a Chamber and you will see the difficulties. The question is: is it worth while having it there? I have admitted myself the same sort of hankering after a Second Chamber that has been expressed by a number of people who are opposed to our action at the present time.
I have said that for many years, and during all that time I have tried myself to see and listened to anybody who had a suggestion to make as to how a Second Chamber would be constituted that would be worth the having. The only value that I can see in a Second Chamber would be that of revision of some kind, and I believe the Dáil, by means of an extra Stage, can give us the same results that we get through the Seanad. It is said that it will be approached from a different angle. Will it? If the Seanad were to continue in its present form, is it not obvious that you are going to have political Parties repeated in that Second Chamber, and if there is a question of a "majority of a majority." will the "majority of the majority" not affect the Second Chamber, as it did in the past, I hold. Undoubtedly it does. Even to-day you can see the Party attitude that is being taken up already—the Chairman of that Seanad anticipating an action of one of the Parties here because of a report in the newspapers, and preventing business which was on the Order Paper from being transacted. Then we are supposed to believe that the Seanad is not a Party Seanad, and that this question of the majority of a majority is not going to operate there as it operated here. Of course it is. From the very start of that Seanad, the majority of the people of this part of Ireland were opposed to it, and they were opposed to it because it was designed, in their opinion, to prevent the nation moving forward to the full possession of its rights.
Deputy Thrift talks of whittling down. That which we are trying to get is ours and belongs to the Irish people. What was taken from us was taken unjustly and we are perfectly entitled to get back our own for the Irish people.
Comment on this
I must say that I was pained—I quite understood and can appreciate the attitude of Deputy Thrift—by the attitude he took up with regard to this matter of whittling down and by his attitude with respect to the treatment of the minority here. Every citizen in this State is treated equally and they are all entitled to be represented to the full extent of their strength in this House. We have kept proportional representation here, not like those elsewhere who denied proportional representation to the people. I was accused here of breaking bargains. I have looked up the record since and I find it no part of any bargain that there should be a Second House here. It was taken for granted. During the period of transition, a period of 12 years, there was special provision made. That period of 12 years has elapsed, and nowhere in that agreement was there any suggestion that this special provision should be continued after that. It was hoped at that time that past political differences would have changed and that what was regarded then as a special minority would have associated itself with some other element or some other Party in the country. I am glad to say that that has happened. I do not see where there is any complaint whatever and, if this question is to be debated, it ought to be debated on the ground: whether the present Seanad is or is not a good one and whether a Second Chamber is or is not desirable. I agree that, at the moment, it is not the first but the second question which is before us.
The Seanad is to be removed. This, for a time, at any rate, is going to be a single-Chamber Legislature. As I have said, nobody has brought forward on the opposite side a single argument except this so-called appeal to the common practice and the common experience of mankind. Examine, historically, the origins of this practice and you will easily satisfy yourself that its origins were largely the result of a fear of the people, a fear of democracy, a fear of what would happen if there was large enfranchisement and that there was a copying of what was called the "Mother of Parliaments" as regards the two Chambers. What is happening in the case of the States established recently—under the conditions of the present time and not under the conditions which obtained at the beginning of the 19th century or the end of the 18th century? Very often it does happen that what is purely an accident—something that is not essential to the system—holds on for a considerable period until it is proven that it is not essential. Nobody has proved that a Second Chamber is essential to the good working of a democratic Legislature.
How is the Second Chamber to be constituted? What are the various ways of constituting a Second Chamber? You can do it by election— direct election or indirect election— or by nomination. If you do it by general election, you will have rival bodies, each deriving its authority directly from the mass of the people. Is it not quite obvious that in a case of that sort, with rival authorities, there is bound to be a clash. You cannot co-ordinate; one must be subordinate. Take, then, indirect election. That has been tried. It has been found, in many cases, a most unsatisfactory way of constituting a Second Chamber. I come to the method suggested by Deputy MacDermot—nomination. I agree with him that if we were able to get an ideal person, removed from political influences, who would select the best people in the country, not immediately associated with political Parties, who would have special qualities which would enable them to bring a new attitude of mind and new experience to bear upon measures before them, it would be all right. But where are you going to get this person removed from political influences——
Comment on this
A President is not independent in these cases. He cannot be. He, also, will be a member of a Party—if we are going to have this Party rule which has been praised so much from the opposite benches. He, also, is a member of a Party, and he cannot get his work done unless he is able to bring his Party with him. Is any person so foolish as to think that the leader of a political Party is in such a position of independence that he could nominate the persons he thinks best? He, also, has to get agreement—just the same as the humblest member of a Party. During certain periods, he may have more influence, but it is not a lasting influence, and when we see what has been done in the past in the way of nomination in such circumstances, we know what would happen. The example of Canada has been the subject of writing by Canadians. They have a type of nominated Senate there and it has not worked out well—in the opinion of Canadians, at any rate. The history of these nominations shows that people are nominated by the Prime Minister for the time being, who puts into the Senate people of his own way of thinking, people who have rendered service to him in a political way in the Party, and so on. For a long period, you had a number of conservative Senators who, as it was said of the House of Lords, were asleep when their own political Party was in power, and only became active when a Government in opposition to them was elected. That is the practical difficulty.
We are all in favour of this ideal Seanad. If you were to come down and speak individually to all the Deputies here, no matter what the logic of the position is—and I hold that the logic of the position is for a Single Chamber—nevertheless, if we could get that ideal Seanad, we would probably vote for it. But we are merely dreaming when we talk about this ideal Seanad; it does not exist. If the Opposition are going to put forward a Second Chamber as a plank in their programme, they should tell the people how they are going to constitute it. The nearest approach would be if there was some individual elected by the people and put in a position of independence of political Parties, so that his authority, for the time being or for a definite period, did not flow directly from the support of a political Party. Then we might possibly have it—when it would be put on such a constitutional person as a personal obligation to nominate people of such and such a kind. If you have this ideal Seanad, this nominated body, if there is a clash between that Seanad and the elected Chamber, the elected Chamber will feel it is outraged if its will, which it will say represents the will of the people at the moment, is thwarted by a body of people not immediately responsible to the people and who would be assumed not to know the people's will as intimately as the elected representatives would know it.
Nobody has tried to argue this question to-night. I did not argue this question because I argued it before. I dealt with election— direct election and indirect election —and nomination. If anybody can suggest any other way let him tell us what it is. As regards the powers of such a Chamber, what are they to be? It is obvious that there must be some final authority somewhere. All you can give to the Seanad is power of delay. What period of delay? The present period is 18 months. When I was arguing this question before—I hold I did argue it, without personalities and on its merits—I pointed out that if you have a delaying power for a long period, the moment the majority of the Seanad are in political opposition to the new Government, they hamstring that Government when it is most important that that Government should carry out the programme upon which it went before the people. They hamstring that Government for one and a half or two years—the most important period of any new administration. If you give a short period of delay, the answer is that the Seanad is no good. When I brought in this period of three months, and two months after that— five months in all—Deputy MacDermot was, I think, one of those who said —I am not quite sure of this, but he will correct me if I am wrong—that it would be better to get rid of the Seanad than to degrade it. We were told that it would be better to get rid of it if it was not going to serve a really useful purpose and the really useful purpose would not, in the Deputy's mind, be served by such a short period of delay as a total period of five months. My own view is that if you could get a Seanad nominated by some independent person who could be trusted to select people who would bring new qualities and a new attitude of mind to bear on measures, revise them, and educate public opinion by discussion—such a Seanad could serve a purpose, provided it had only a short period of delay in which public opinion might be educated. However, I have never been able to get it in anything I have done or thought about it; and, notwithstanding the assertions of the Deputy who just preceded me, I have given some thought to it. I have been much longer dealing with matters of this sort than Deputy McGilligan has.
Comment on this
They were not. However, we can let Deputy McGilligan deal with them on another occasion.
Comment on this
It does not matter. The Deputy may be taking his own experience. He should not always take his own experiences and carry them on to others. They do not always carry on to others. Much more than 14 or 15 years ago I have been dealing with this question—longer, probably, than anybody in this House. It was my business to deal with this question and, like most other people, I took note of the fact that in most legislatures there were two Houses, but it was a question whether a Second House was an essential part of the system, and I have satisfied myself that it is not. Deputy Dillon talks about empiricism. I feel certain, for one, at any rate, that if we do adopt this system there will be a period in which there will be a single Chamber. I hold that that period is essential because, during the period in which we have been in office, in every step forward that we wanted to take in the national interest, the greatest danger we had to meet was the Second Chamber. It was a definite danger. We were dealing with an outside country, and whatever danger was there, it was exaggerated by the Second Chamber.
During this period, as far as we are concerned, we are going to try what can be done by a single Chamber and, notwithstanding these prognostications to which we have listened to-night, I, for one, am perfectly certain that our experience will not be one which will make us in too great anxiety to change it. However, if anyone can indicate to us how to set up a Second Chamber which will serve us and will not be a definite barrier to progress or be simply a reproduction of the conditions in this House, I shall still keep simply an open mind. I do not know whether it is worth while to refer to one or two more or less personal matters that were raised here during the course of this debate.
Comment on this
Yes, I know, but I shall not take more than a moment. At the time when this Bill was under discussion, when we drew the President's attention to the resolution of Senator O'Farrell suggesting the setting up of a committee to examine this whole question, the President said that if a body were to be appointed to examine the question and make suggestions, it should not be a Parliamentary Committee but an outside body. What I want to know is, would the President appoint such a body?
Comment on this
If the Deputy will look the matter up he will find that I regarded the present period as a development period and that I said that, if we did come to frame a permanent Constitution for this country, then certainly the body that should examine it should be an independent body. I think he will find that I referred to this whole period as a necessary period of transition. What that necessary period will be will be different. As I was saying, there were a few personal matters to which, perhaps, I should refer. I do not appear unnecessarily in the House, but when there is any matter concerning myself I am always here. As the head of the Government or of the Executive Government as a whole, I am always within half a minute's call. I have been here on every occasion in connection with every matter which required my presence either as President or Minister for External Affairs, and if it were a matter that concerned me, and where the particular Minister concerned could not be present, I have been here or within call. The next matter to which I should like to refer was a statement by Deputy Dillon. He is thinking of the days of the old Freeman's Journal, when members of the Irish Party used to write the leading articles. I do not write the articles or editorials in the Irish Press. I neither inspired that article nor did I write it.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I am certifying the Constitution (Amendment No. 24) Bill, 1934, under Article 38a of the Constitution as containing only such modification as is necessary owing to the time which has elapsed since that Bill was first sent by the Dáil to the Seanad.
Comment on this
Can the Parliamentary Secretary to the President say what business will be taken to-morrow and what will be the period of the adjournment?