Land Purchase (Guarantee Fund) Bill, 1935—From the Seanad.
Contributions 1–203 of 404. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 39 of 1935 ›
The aim of these recommendations is to delete the retrospective provisions of the Bill. One debate should embrace all the recommendations. There will be separate divisions if desired.
Comment on this
Those recommendations have drawn from the Government Deputies some most interesting reactions. Perhaps the most interesting of all is that drawn from Deputy Patrick Smith. The Attorney-General will look with pride upon his colleague, and I shall be interested to hear to-day whether the Attorney-General of this Government will endorse and adopt the language of his trusted colleague, Deputy Smith, of Cavan. In the Anglo-Celt, of Cavan, dated Saturday, January 11th, Deputy Smith is reported as follows in a discussion which took place at the Cavan County Council on the question of whether or not they should protest against the enactment of the legislation which is before us to-day:
"Mr. Smith, T.D., said that there was no change in the procedure with regard to the annuities, but Cork and Louth County Councils had taken an action in the High Courts on the question. A number of the High Court judges were now old and feeble men and the Bill now before the Dáil was an attempt to remove any ambiguities in order to ensure that those old men might not be put to unnecessary trouble."
Does the Attorney-General of Saorstát Eireann adopt that view? Does the Attorney-General recommend this Bill and the rejection of those recommendations to this House on those grounds? If he does not, will he take occasion to-day to describe Deputy Smith for what he is, and in so describing him will he arrange with the Leader of his Party, the President of the Executive Council, to tender his apologies to the people of County Cavan for having forced that gentleman on them? Or are we perhaps deluded; is that the mentality of the Fianna Fáil Party? Have they made up their minds, in accordance with the Presidential dictum, that if anyone disagrees with them let him be abolished? Have they made up their minds to abolish the Seanad because it does not agree with them, and to deride and insult the judiciary in public in order to prepare the public mind for the abolition of an independent judiciary in this country? Are we to understand in future that any judge who is not to be intimidated upon the Bench is, in the judgement of President de Valera, an old and feeble man, unfit to discharge his judicial functions, and therefore no doubt a person suitable for early abolition—suitable for abolition under a Constitution which can be amended in ten minutes by this House?
Comment on this
The matter before the House consists of three recommendations dealing with the retrospective provisions of a certain Bill, and not with the abolition of the Seanad or the judiciary, nor with the opinions of individual members of any Party.
Comment on this
And the argument put forward by the spokesman of the Government Party in Co. Cavan in defence of this Bill is that the judiciary are old and feeble men, incompetent for their work, and that it is necessary to do their work for them by Acts of this Orieachtas. I challenge the Government now to adopt or reject that argument.
Comment on this
Might I point out that matters which might be held to be relevant on a public platform are not necessarily relevant in this House?
Comment on this
If they do not reject it, let them explain to this House what the full imputations are, and reassure the country that this is not the beginning of a campaign to discredit the judiciary with a view to their ultimate abolition in order to make way for a De Valera dictator in this country. The Attorney-General has a perfectly simple task before him, and that is to get up in this House and tell us whether he adopts what Deputy Smith said in Cavan, or whether he shares my view that Deputy Smith is not fit to represent Cavan or any other county or constituency in this country. He cannot escape from that dilemma; he has got to say either one thing or the other. Those recommendations are principally directed at the retrospective character of this legislation, and I want to direct the attention of the House to a net point. It is a very important point which is slightly obscure, but it is nevertheless fundamental. There is all the difference in the world between the Executive coming to this House and saying: "A judicial interpretation of an Act has given the legislation of this country a certain meaning which we did not realise was enshrined in it. We, therefore, desire to introduce amending legislation in order to alter the Statute Book" and what the Government is now doing. They are now saying that to the person who conceives he has certain rights under existing law and who has moved to vindicate those rights against the Government in the Courts of the country:—"we apprehend that he has those rights but we are going to take care that he does not get them." That is what the Government is trying to do at the present time. That is an evil and an indefensible type of retrospective legislation; and I do urge on Deputies that though they may snatch an advantage at this moment, through that particular advantage they are going to do something that is going to establish in this country a very evil precedent. It is not the first bad precedent that they have established. I have had occasion to point out to them on several occasions that they were establishing bad precedents, but this is the first time that they have deliberately sought to undermine the independence of the judiciary. I couple this new departure with the statement of Deputy Smith of Cavan who is Assistant-Whip of the Fianna Fáil Party. I put before the individual Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party that there is growing up in their midst a frame of mind which they may not be strong enough to curb, unless they dissociate themselves from it right at the beginning.
I leave it to more experienced lawyers and to those who have a very lucid grasp of constitutional law to elaborate the evils that may flow from this retrospective legislation and I pass on to another aspect of it which will appeal to everybody who is intimate with rural conditions in this country. Irrespective of the fact that this Bill is going to lay a burden upon the rural ratepayers of this country of over £1,000,000 sterling, I want to put to the Government the question I asked them already: Where is the money going to come from? How are the people going to get it? The Government have admitted their own inability to collect the money. They cannot collect the land annuities from these people in arrears and they are now passing the duty of collecting these moneys on to the local authorities. If the Central Government, with the machinery at its disposal, cannot collect those moneys how does the Government expect that the local authorities can collect them?
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I say that we are not discussing in general terms the responsibility for the collection of these moneys.
Comment on this
I submit, Sir, that when Deputy Dillon was referring to these moneys he was only referring to the sum that it was proposed to collect this year.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Sullivan quite properly submitted another view-point. Deputy Dillon is in order in pointing out the consequences of the retrospective clauses of this Bill.
Comment on this
It is an old, time-honoured gag that when the barbs are going home an attempt is made to prevent the development of the argument but it will not work this time. The Minister must reconcile himself to that now. The point is that the Government cannot get the money and they have done their best. They have sought to excuse themselves for their failure by making the case that there was a conspiracy against them. But when the figures came to be examined it was found that the Government was failing to get these moneys in the constituencies where their supporters were in the vast majority. Now it is unthinkable and no reasonable person would suggest it that the supporters of President de Valera were trying to undermine the Government of President de Valera in this way. Therefore, it is clear that the failure of the people to pay is solely because they are unable to pay.
Comment on this
They have paid the annuities already. Why is Deputy Dillon apologising for a debt that is not due?
Comment on this
Quite. When he does I would wish to hear Deputy Belton without interruptions. The reason the people cannot pay these moneys is, as Deputy Belton has interjected, that they have already paid them through the medium of the tariffs which have been imposed on all agricultural products from this country by the British. I have refrained from stressing this matter unduly, but it is common knowledge that the reason why the people cannot pay is because of these penal tariffs. They have been paying these moneys for the past 50 years and as long as they were able to pay them they paid them on the nail. They cannot do it now because their means of livelihood have been taken from them.
Comment on this
I have said they cannot pay them now and the Government are passing on these debts to the county councils, who are asked to collect these moneys. They are passing them on to the local authorities. It may be that the Government have some "joker" up their sleeve which is intended to provide the people with this money. Is it the other half of the coal-cattle pact that is going to pay them?
Comment on this
Well, it is possible the Government have made some advantageous arrangement with the British whereby the people are going to be provided with markets for their produce which will enable them to pay these moneys. If that be true, the Government ought to tell us about it now and give us some indication as to the measure of relief the people are going to get.
Comment on this
Surely if we charge the Government with trying to collect these moneys from people who are not able to pay, they are entitled to reply: "That may be so at the moment, but if you read to-morrow's papers you will see that an arrangement is being made whereby markets are being made available for these people, and they are getting free entry into those markets with their cattle through the coal-cattle pact."
Comment on this
It is on the financial capacity of the people to pay that the whole opposition to this Bill rests in this regard. When I was going away from this House last December, I ventured to prophesy, from my knowledge of the country, that this year in rural Ireland Christmas would be the gloomiest and the poorest that we have had in our time. I challenge the Deputies who know rural Ireland to tell the House what sort it was this Christmas throughout the West of Ireland, the North-West of Ireland and the South-West of Ireland. I tell the Deputies that in all my experience of Christmas I have never seen the country people get so little in the way of extra comforts or Christmas fare as they got this Christmas.
Comment on this
That observation of Deputy Kelly's throws a flood of light upon the whole situation. Deputy Kelly is a man who if he were put out on a country road would have to get someone to bring him home. He has never been out in the country, if the Deputy had not the cobble-stones of the city to guide him, he would lose his way in ten minutes. I submit that he, like many others living in the City of Dublin, does not know what is happening in the rural parts of the country.
Comment on this
I submit to the House that the people are unable to pay these annuities and they are unable to pay them because their livelihood has been taken away from them by the action of the Government. I admit that the City of Dublin is enjoying the same kind of prosperity as obtained in the cities of Sydney and Melbourne just before the whole of Australia collapsed in financial ruin seven or eight years ago. If Deputy Moore or a few more of his colleagues who may be interested in questions of this kind will ask competent observers to tell them what conditions were obtaining in Sydney, Melbourne and Adelaide just before the whole agricultural community of Australia went bankrupt, they will be told that there was every evidence of business prosperity and the circulation of money in urban centres.
Comment on this
Precisely, and that is just what is happening here. Did you ever observe a more prosperous Christmas business in the Cities of Dublin and Cork as you had last Christmas? In rural Ireland, however, there is a very different picture in regard to the purchasing power of the people. Any money in circulation is flowing into the hands of wage-earners, permanent officials, factory workers and employees of one kind or another in the cities and towns, but the unfortunate people in the country are seeing their incomes steadily dwindling. We are being assured by Ministers for Finance, Ministers for Industry and Commerce, Attorneys-General and so forth, who abandoned the country for their own good, perfectly legitimately, many years ago, and took up their residence as professional men in one department of life or another in the City, that it is ridiculous to talk about general poverty or a decline in the standard of living. They here, living in the City of Dublin, never saw Dublin more prosperous. But they have lost touch with their own people, and they are being deluded by the completely fictitious picture which the big cities are presenting at the present time.
There is no connection between the state of affairs obtaining amongst the bulk of the population in the City of Dublin and the state of affairs obtaining amongst the bulk of the population in rural Ireland. The conditions of living for the bulk of the population in rural Ireland are sinking steadily; the people there are having to do with less and less. Life in rural Ireland and in the rural parts of every modern country in these modern times is a very tedious business. It is dull. There is very little artificial amusement for people in the rural parts such as is available to a city dweller. If this present business goes on, and if the people on the land are not only going to be condemned to a dull and tedious life, but are to have added to that tedium and dullness the anxiety of being unable to meet the demands made on them, being unable to meet their rates or taxes, unable to pay their debts or unable to buy the simple luxuries to which they were always accustomed, then I warn you that you are going to create in this country what there is not in any other country in the world, and that is a rural proletariat who will be so sick of the conditions under which they have to live that they will make up their minds that they will follow anybody who will upset the existing dispensation and offer it something else, whatever it is. They will be satisfied that nothing can be worse than the conditions under which they are existing at the present time.
Let me remind you that the rural population is the sheet anchor of stability. It is the one thing that every constitutional Government always falls back on when agitators start stirring up the population and threatening the very foundations of civilisation. Be careful, when you have gentlemen in Rathmines Town Hall exhorting communism, and when you endeavour to fall back, as you could heretofore, on the rural population, that you will not find them ready to answer: "You have reduced us to such a condition that we do not give a damn what there is in this country: bad and all as the doctrines preached at Rathmines are, they could not be worse than the results of the system you have thrust on us in the last four years."
Comment on this
What has happened in the last four years is not relevant to what is now before the House.
Comment on this
I have disposed of that, and I propose to pass on to another matter. I see Deputy Jordan there, and he is a man who comes in contact with the people and knows, of his own knowledge, and it is within the knowledge of his colleagues in trade, that their purchasing power is the measure of the people's prosperity one year as compared with another. I put it to Deputy Jordan, or to any other member of the Fianna Fáil Party engaged in business in rural Ireland, that the capacity of the people to buy is steadily declining. There are two exceptions to that declining capacity to purchase. One is in respect of cigarettes and the other is in respect of drink; and those exceptions, I submit, are due to the maladministration of the dole. There are thousands of men, and we all know it——
Comment on this
The Deputy must get away from general economic conditions and the maladministration of the dole or any other Government funds and concentrate on the matter before the House.
Comment on this
I am arguing a neat point, a perfectly neat point, and that is that the people have not got the money to pay. It will be advanced against me: "How do they go to football matches or buy cigarettes?" I will be told that Dublin is booming and the people are getting plenty of money. Unless the Chair desires that we should take full advantage of the Committee Stage of the Bill and make forty speeches, my remedy is to anticipate arguments that may be advanced against me—that were advanced against me on previous occasions—and answer them now. I submit that is reasonable, and I propose to do that. I wish to avoid doing anything that would appear to be an abuse or a desire to obstruct or protract the business unduly. Surely that point will be raised, "How is it the consumption of cigarettes was never higher than at the present time? That does not bespeak a scarcity of money."
One Deputy on the Government Benches did remark: "How can you say there is a scarcity when there are so many people paying thousands of pounds to see football matches?" These isolated facts may be quoted and unless those living in the country and coming in contact with the people explain their significance, they may give an entirely false impression to the Executive Council responsible for the carrying on of the Government. I admit the consumption of bottled stout and cigarettes is as large now as it ever was—the consumption of cigarettes is larger than it ever was. The reason that the consumption of cigarettes tends to increase is because the dole money, in so far as it is being paid to young unmarried men who have no family responsibility, is being largely spent on cigarettes. That is not peculiar to this country, because the same thing is true of Great Britain, where the Imperial Tobacco Company increased their sales during the period of deepest depression and unemployment in Great Britain.
Any honest observer of what is happening in the country must admit that the purchases which a family man makes are steadily declining and that the people in the country are doing with less than they ever did with before and they are concentrating whatever purchasing power they have more on essential necessities, and what were luxuries to the country people are not now being bought or are being bought in very much reduced quantities. That is evidence of a steady decline in the standard of living of the people. That is, in my view, clear and irrebuttable evidence of the incapacity of the people to find an additional sum of £1,000,000 to finance the retrospective clauses of this Bill. One sometimes gets tired of repeating the same arguments in trying to drive home to the minds of men like Deputy Moore what ought to be understandable to a child of 14 years. But you cannot get away from this fact, that an individual small farmer in the country has a certain sum of money and that money must be used for the purchase of food, clothing and the payment of his rates and taxes and expenses. Now, you may alter the proportion of that sum which will go to each purpose, but Deputies will agree with me that the more you take out of that purchasing fund in respect of taxes, rates and expenses of that character, the less the individual farmer will have to spend on foodstuffs and luxuries and clothing. He has to buy food to live, and one legitimate object of every decent Government is to reduce the unavoidable expense of a farmer to the lowest minimum so that his surplus for the purchase of luxuries and the purpose of raising his standard of living will continually grow.
At the present time we are confronted with a situation where we have increased prices of flour, bread, tea, sugar, butter and Indian meal, which have all been advanced from 20 per cent. to 50 per cent. in price as a result of Government action. In order to buy these subsistence articles the farmer has to disburse from 20 per cent. to 50 per cent. more than before. At the same time cattle, farmer's butter, eggs, sheep and pigs are all cheaper than ever before.
Comment on this
All cheaper than they have ever been before, and I invite any Deputy of the Fianna Fáil Party to give facts and figures to contradict that if any one of them will dare.
Comment on this
Everything the farmer buys has been made dearer, everything he sells is cheaper, and at the same time the county councils are looking for £1,000,000 and the Government are inviting them to get the money wherever they can get it. There is no faith in the Government in this matter. I think it was Senator MacEllin, or some other Senator, who said recently that the plain fact was that this money had to be got from somewhere, "and we are going to get it." Deputy Smith, having dealt with the judges of the High Court at a meeting of Cavan Co. Council, as reported in the Anglo-Celt of Saturday, the 11th December, when referring to the case taken into the courts by the Louth County Council, said if the council succeeds the money must come from somewhere. That is their argument. My answer to that is you simply cannot get blood out of a turnip, or water from a stone, and that when the Government is driven back to proclaiming that expedient it is proclaiming its own bankruptcy to the world at large.
I ask Deputies to open their eyes to the facts before it is too late. The Government spokesmen get up and say the plain facts of the case are there; there is no use arguing against the Bill; the merits do not enter into the discussion, the money has to be got and it must be got from somewhere. When we can prove that the Government are turning for that money to sources from which it cannot be got then the Government stands indicted out of its own mouth, of bankruptcy.
Suppose they do not get the money. Suppose we are right. Suppose that although it is to be found somewhere they do not get it and cannot get it in a legitimate way what are they going to do? I have told them before what will happen, and I ask the members of the Labour Party to watch this and see if I am not right. There is one fund out of which the money can come, and one fund out of which it is going to come, in the long run, and that is the county council estimates for the boards of health all over the country.
Comment on this
The point is that the county councils are faced with the fact that they must get this money. Many of the county councils will have the courage to say: "We will not scourge the people; it is absolutely impossible to collect this money. We have exhausted every expedient, and the money is not there." These county councils will be dissolved. Commissioners will be sent down to take their place. They will examine the position and they will find that the money cannot be got. They will examine the rates and the estimates for the rates; and then, in their capacity as commissioners of the boards of health they will face the facts, and they will take the money out of the estimate for the boards of health. If they did not attack that estimate the commissioners would have to face up to other expedients. They would have to ask themselves whether they would have to take it out of the county hospital, the surgical hospital, or out of the wages of the workmen employed by the council. But all these are vested interests and could draw public attention to their position, or the workers could get the Transport Union to start a strike. But all this trouble and bother can be avoided. There is one body in the country who cannot fight or who cannot be organised, and who by their character of destitution are not capable of vigorously protesting against their ill-treatment, and those people are the recipients of outdoor relief. It will be decided that those in receipt of 5/- must be content with 4/- and those now getting 4/- must do with 3/-. I challenge any members of boards of health, in this House, to say that they have not heard that argument already used. I challenge any such Deputy to say that when there was a proposal to reduce the board of health estimate that that point was not raised.
This Bill is going to be financed out of the destitution of the poor, because they are the one class in the country who cannot defend themselves. They are the one class whose voices cannot be heard here, for whom there will be no one to speak so long as the Government feels it essential to get this money. There is not a Deputy sitting in the Fianna Fáil Benches who does not know that. They are the one section of the community who will pay the penalty, and who because of their simplicity and destitution, will be less able to understand that this reduction is made in their relief because of the efforts that are being made to finance the Land Purchase (Guarantee Fund) Bill of 1935. It will be blamed on the county councils and on the boards of health, but the one person responsible is the one person who walks out with an accolade of patriotism. Everyone will forget that the Minister for Finance and the Attorney-General who, in their efforts to upset the courts and to deprive the citizens of their rights so as to raise for the Exchequer money that they could not legitimately collect, are taking it out of the pockets of the destitute and the poor, closing their eyes to the fact that there will come a day when the destitute poor will have no contribution to offer to Fianna Fáil. Then we will have succeeded in establishing that destitution and bankruptcy with which the country has been threatened so long and which is being forced upon it by the Fianna Fáil Party at the present time.
Comment on this
We should all—on this side of the House, and I hope also some Deputies on the other side—press the Government to assent to the recommendations passed by the Seanad. There are two aspects to this matter. The first is the judicial aspect. There should not be legislation of a retrospective character passed while, as in this case, an action is pending in the courts. If only for that reason, these recommendations ought to be accepted. The retrospective clauses in this Bill, in addition to encroaching on a pending case in the courts, have the disadvantage that they will impose an extra financial liability on certain people. If this House were asked to pass a Bill imposing a retrospective financial liability on practically every citizen of this State, I venture to say that not a single Deputy would vote for the proposal. If, for instance, Deputy Kelly or other city Deputies were asked to vote for retrospectively doubling the rent of every house in the city, or of every occupied room in the city, would they do so? If Deputy Kelly votes against these recommendations to-day, he will be doing something akin to that.
I do not want to enter upon a discussion regarding the economic war or other matters which have been ruled out by the Ceann Comhairle. But I do want, if I am within the rules of order, to refer to the conditions which will arise if these retrospective clauses are not deleted from the Bill. Deputy Dillon said, more or less, what I should like to say about the condition of the farmers and of the people who will eventually be affected by the operation of these retrospective clauses. The effect will really be that certain people will be asked to bear all the burden of these retrospective clauses, amounting to £1,000,000 or more. Two classes of the community will pay all of this sum. One class will be those people who, in previous years, were fortunate enough to be able to lay by a certain sum which is not yet exhausted. The man who belonged to that class was, up to now, able to pay out of these savings certain sums which other people were not able to pay—his annuities and, perhaps, his rates. To another class these commitments are so small that the payment does not materially affect them. It has been said that in Mayo and parts of Galway there are no arrears of annuities or rates. Why are there not?
Comment on this
Because their payments are so small—amounting in many cases from £1 to 5/—that they are not material to the yearly budget of the people concerned. Some of them are migratory labourers. The payment of rates and annuities would not affect a week's earnings. Some of them are in receipt of Government assistance in various forms, a very small amount of which would suffice to pay their rates and annuities. If they had not paid their rates and annuities they would probably be disqualified for the benefits which they receive. In the main, the people who are going to suffer by the passing of this Bill are the middle classes—the people who are neither very big nor very small, the struggling honest men who found it difficult, perhaps, to live before this Government played the devil with their finances, the men who, by hard work, were able to make ends meet and who when the bad times—brought on them by the Government—came, were not able to pay their annuities. If these retrospective clauses are not deleted, you will have, in addition to the huge sum of unpaid annuities which exists at present, practically an equivalent amount of unpaid rates and, eventually, the total collapse of the social services. The people who will, in the end, suffer will, perhaps, not be the ratepayers but the humble persons for whom the social services were set up, the people in receipt of outdoor relief to whom Deputy Dillon referred. They will be the sufferers. Some of them have had their relief reduced in my county from 4/- to 3/- and 2/- and others from 4/- and 2/- to nothing. Some of the labourers on the roads are unpaid for three months because the money was not there to pay them. If you heap on top of the present rate this huge sum of £1,000,000 or more, what prospect have you of collecting any rate in the days to come? If Deputy Kelly, Deputy Donnelly or Deputy Mrs. Concannon were asked to apply a retrospective liability of this character to the citizens of Dublin, would they comply with the request? They know they would not. Because this Bill affects, in the main, the hardworking agriculturists, Deputy Kelly, Deputy Mrs. Concannon and other City Deputies can view it with equanimity.
Deputy Dillon has argued—Deputy Belton argued likewise by interruption—that the farmer has paid twice. I do not want to argue that question. But if this Bill, with its retrospective clauses, is passed, he will not only have paid twice but in many cases more than twice. Remember that these retrospective clauses are going to react on the rates and in many counties the burden of rates is greater than the burden of annuities. I know of many cases in my county where the amount collected as rates is greater than the amount collected as annuities, because the valuations are higher. If on top of that you are going to place a burden on these people of from 1/6 to 3/6—in the coming years it will be more—what amount of the rate will be collected and what will be the effect on the rapidly diminishing number of farmers who are able to pay either rates or annuities? The number of people who are able to pay either rates or annuities is going to get smaller every day and the burden on the diminishing number is going to be increasingly heavy, until eventually you are going to reach a stage when local services must collapse with all the dire consequences that Deputy Dillon pointed out and which I should like to emphasise. We had the spectacle a year or so ago of the Government attempting to collect the annuities through the sheriff. There has not been so much of that of late, but a new set of circumstances has arisen. The rate collector is now seizing for the rates, and when the rate collector has collected what the sheriff left over when attempting to collect annuities, the position of many farmers will be that they will be unable to pay any subsequent annuity or rate.
If the recommendations are not accepted, the position is going to be that the increased rate is not going to be collected. The number that cannot pay, as I have already said, is increasing, and the number who will be conceivably able to pay with this added liability will be so small that the amount collected will be altogether insufficient to carry on the local services in any county. The burden of it then must inevitably fall on the people whom every Deputy would least wish to see it fall upon, the unfortunate unpaid road workers and, above all, the unfortunate people who, in the present circumstances, are in such necessity that they must get outdoor relief.
We have always had people on outdoor relief. A certain number of people always had to be provided for out of the rates, but that number has increased, notwithstanding all the other aids with which the Government has attempted to bolster up conditions. The number is going to increase every day. To my mind, it is immaterial whether the recommendations are accepted or not. There is going to be a collapse in rate collection; there is going to be increased suffering amongst many unfortunate poor people who are in receipt of relief; and there are going to be many workers unpaid if they are employed by the local councils—probably they will not be employed. At present, many of them are employed in the hope that they will get the money in two or three months' time, but they will not be employed even under these conditions if the retrospective sections of this Bill are not wiped out. I should like to appeal with all the force I can to Government Deputies at least to press on the Ministry to make this Bill less obnoxious to the people by accepting the recommendations of the Seanad. I appeal to City Deputies, like Deputy Tom Kelly and Deputy Mrs. Concannon, if an appeal is of any use——
Comment on this
——not to impose a burden on unfortunate country people that they would not dare to impose on city people if such a suggestion were made. Deputy Tom Kelly says he does not think there is any use in appealing to him—I do not believe there is. Deputy Kelly, for one, is an honest man. He admits that he is bound by the tie of Party considerations to vote for this even if in his heart he believes it is unjust. But there are times when Party ties should not bind any Deputy to violate his conscience. It must be within the knowledge of every country Deputy, at least, that times are such that the unfortunate ratepayers on whom this burden is going to fall are unable to meet it. That is borne out by the numerous resolutions passed by county councils within the last couple of weeks and the almost universal disapproval of this Bill. There cannot be a Deputy of any political complexion to whom it has not been brought home that this Bill is obnoxious to practically every class in the community, so far as the country districts are concerned, and to a great many in the cities, because city people are not so devoid of sense that they do not know that eventually the ills that fall on the country people are going to fall on the dwellers in the cities and towns.
I suppose it is idle to appeal to Deputies who are so bound by Governmental Whips that they will accept almost any legislation no matter what havoc it plays with the finances of the State, what misfortune it brings to any unfortunate agricultural worker or holder, or what suffering it brings to any poor, needy person in receipt of outdoor relief, or to the sick poor. At the present time, when people are in a desperate position, there should be someone man enough or woman enough to stand up and say: "I stand for Party discipline to a certain extent, but the limit has been reached," because the limit has been reached. Before the debate closes, I hope that we will have some expression of opinion from some Fianna Fáil Deputies and that they will join in our appeal to the Government that the retrospective portion of this Bill is wrong from the moral point of view because it interferes with a case pending in the courts—I do not want to elaborate that, because it has been elaborated before—and that the recommendation should be accepted primarily because of the financial burden that this will place on people who are already in such a condition that they are unable to meet their current liabilities, not to speak of any retrospective addition.
Comment on this
As one might anticipate from what has already happened in the course of the discussions on this Bill, we have had from the Deputies who have already spoken a protest against these sections on the ground that they interfere with the decision in a case pending in the courts and on the ground that retrospective legislation is something almost unprecedented and very highly objectionable. I am not going to go over the ground I went over in this already explaining to Deputies my views as to the occasions upon which retrospective legislation is justified. I should like, however, to advert to this fact, that the recommendations we are discussing were moved in the other House by Senator Blythe. In the course of a rather cautious statement on that he said that there were circumstances in which retrospective legislation might be justified. At column 1560 of the Seanad Debates of 31st December, 1935, he is reported as saying:
"There have been very many Bills with retrospective clauses, and, as Senator Johnson has said, there will occasionally have to be Bills which operate retrospectively, but retrospective legislation should only be resorted to in case of necessity, and it would require some very serious reason to necessitate such legislation in the circumstances which prevail at present to take a case which is actually at hearing out of the hands of the court."
The caution displayed by the Senator in his remarks is probably due to the fact that he had in mind a discussion on a retrospective piece of legislation, or a Bill which was in the process of being converted into a piece of legislation in 1931, when he had to face from the Opposition of the day criticism on the ground that the legislation which he proposed was retrospective in character and interfered with a case then pending in the courts. I referred in the discussion here in the House on the Committee Stage of this Bill to the defence which Senator Blythe then made for his introduction of a section with retrospective effect into the Finance Act, but the circumstances so closely resemble the position with reference to the cases now pending before the courts and the proposals embodied in this legislation that I should like to refresh the minds of the House on them, and particularly the minds of some Deputies who sit opposite and who voted for the retrospective legislation then introduced. It was discovered in 1931 that a section of the 1925 Finance Act had not the effect which the Revenue Commissioners believed it had during the intervening period from 1925 to 1931. They were claiming from the executors of certain estates six years' arrears of income tax, and somebody had the hardihood to challenge it in the courts. It was challenged and went before the Circuit judge, Judge Shannon. Judge Shannon held that the interpretation placed upon the Statute by the Revenue Commissioners was wrong. A case stated was asked for, and while the case stated was pending in the High Court, the Finance Bill came along.
Senator Blythe—then Minister for Finance—and the Government of the day introduced a section retrospectively to validate all that had been done by the Revenue Commissioners. In the course of the discussion on the section, Deputies who were here on that occasion will recollect that no attempt whatsoever was made to justify the introduction of this bit of retrospective legislation on the ground that the House had intended to enact the legislation in the way that Senator Blythe wished to have it. No case was made such as we have made here. We have made the case here that this is a perfectly honest piece of legislation in this way, that, at the time the Land Bill was before this House, this House and the other House—and this House when the views of the other House came back here before it—acted on the assumption that the law as now intended to be embodied in the Bill before the House was in fact the effect of the Bill then before the House. Senator Blythe made no such case in introducing his bit of legislation. In the discussion he defended it and answered the charges which were made against it. Apparently he must have forgotten all he had then said when he had the hardihood to introduce those recommendations in the Seanad. As reported at col. 1376, vol. 39, Official Debates—I think I quoted this passage already on the Committee Stage of this Bill—he said:
"Deputy O'Connell raises the point about cases where there was a decision in the Circuit Court. I am really in doubt about that matter. He really only got a Circuit Court decision and there would have been an appeal to the High Court and another to the Supreme Court, and there is a great difference of opinion amongst counsel as to what would be the result."
As a matter of fact the case stated was pending at the time.
"In certain cases if there was not a great deal of money involved we would wait until the Supreme Court had finally decided the matter and we would not bring in any legislation while the law was unsettled."
There are certain Deputies listening to me who have paraded into the lobbies——
Comment on this
The Attorney-General is in the happy position that he was not in the House at the time. Senator Blythe went on to say:
"This is a matter that involves big sums. The revenue would be held up by people who would await the outcome of the litigation and revenue would have to be found by other means. It would perhaps be a couple of years before a decision would be obtained and revenue which ultimately would prove to be payable would be held up during that period. We act really before there is a final determination as to what the law is on the matter."
Deputy O'Sullivan was one of the Deputies who went into the lobby in favour of this section, and there we have a clear statement from the Minister for Finance as he then was: "We act really before there is a final determination as to what the law is on the matter." I have been attacked in the Seanad as standing over something which is almost unprecedented and most reprehensible for a lawyer to do. Senator Blythe's statement goes on:
"In the particular case that was before the Circuit Court, the amount involved was not large."
Later, Senator Blythe explained that the sum involved would at most amount to £100,000. According to Deputy Dillon the amount involved here is a million pounds. If Senator Blythe felt that he was then entitled to come here and intervene while legislation was pending, and when the amount involved was £100,000, surely we have ten times a better case to come here when the amount involved is a million pounds. I have been told that we are interfering with the courts. Senator Johnson in the Seanad raised his hands in horror at a passage in a speech of mine here, which he quoted, in which I said that this House had the right to pass such legislation as it thought fit. He really wondered did I mean it had the right——
Comment on this
——or did I only mean that it had the power.
Comment on this
What were the words which the Attorney-General used in this House? My recollection is that he said this House had the right to interpret what the law was. I may be wrong.
Comment on this
The passage which Senator Johnson quoted from my speech, and which I take it is correctly printed here, is as follows:
"If, as has frequently happened, the House has not made clear by its legislation what precisely are its intentions, then this House has the undoubted right during any stage of litigation, either before an action is commenced, during the hearing of the proceedings, or after an action has been concluded, to say what, in its view, the law was intended to be."
That startled Senator Johnson so much that he hoped what I meant to say was not that it had the right, but that it had the power. I argued here in this House and pointed out to this House that this is the supreme law-making Assembly. The courts are there to interpret the law. I never said they were not. In the case in which the last Government felt itself bound to come to the House they were faced with the fact that the Circuit Judge had held that the view upon which the Revenue Commissioners had been acting for a period of six or seven years was not what the House intended the law should be, and Senator Blythe and Deputy Cosgrave —then President Cosgrave—came here and stood over legislation declaring what the law had been intended to be by the House in 1925. They were not able to advance a single quotation from the debates on the earlier Acts to justify them in saying that the House had so intended the law to be.
Comment on this
I am rather afraid of Deputy Cosgrave's bona fides in wishing to interrupt me, but if he desires to do so I will give way.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Cosgrave was not here during all the time I have been speaking. I referred to the fact that, in regard to the quotations which I have just given from Senator Blythe's speech, I had already given them during the Committee Stage in this House.
Comment on this
If the Deputy had read the Dáil debates he would have seen it there.
Comment on this
I would like to have had a little earlier notice that this case was going to be cited. The other cases I have dealt with to the satisfaction of the House. This is new to me.
Comment on this
Not to the satisfaction of the House because the House did not adopt the argument.
Comment on this
This passage is worth quoting, though it may take Deputy Cosgrave by surprise. It is from the Official Report of the 2nd July, 1931, and the speaker is Mr. Blythe, the Minister for Finance, now Senator Blythe. He said:
"With regard to the question of respect for the courts, no disrespect is involved in amending the law, whether amending the law retrospectively or not. Very frequently people discover, as a result of the courts carrying out their function of interpreting and applying the law, that the law contains something which it was not generally believed to contain and steps are taken to amend the law. Sometimes it is amended only for the future. There are cases where there are strong reasons for amending it retrospectively, but there is no disrespect for the courts in that."
Senator Blythe seems to have forgotten that statement when speaking recently in the Seanad. Then he went on:
"The function of the courts is to interpret and to apply the law as they find it. If, as a result of the interpretation of the courts, the legislature thinks the law is not in a satisfactory position, there is absolutely no disrespect for the courts in the legislature exercising its function to alter the law. There is no more than there would be in the court finding that, for instance, the legislature had not succeeded in carrying out what members or even the bulk of them expressed as their views at the time."
Comment on this
Further on Mr. Blythe said:
"and when the legislature exercises its function in any respect in which it thinks it right to do so, there is alsolutely no disrespect to the courts involved."
I wonder if Opposition Deputies will stand over these words now. Proceeding further, he said:
"With regard to the case of people who have cases before the courts and have won them, some Deputies stated that there was no reason for treating them exceptionally. I think there is good reason for treating them exceptionally."
Furthermore, in the course of the discussion, as reported in column 1377, of Vol. 39, Mr. Blythe said:
"As a matter of fact, both here and in England legislation has had to be introduced with retrospective effect. In the present year's Finance Bill in Great Britain, pending a decision of the final court, a section was introduced because they feared that a decision might be given which would have upset the practice as it had existed for 40 or 50 years. Before the court had announced its decision at all, a section was introduced to continue the existing practice if it proved to be necessary. You can get the most extraordinary results if the whole meaning of legislation is going to be revealed by some court decision to be entirely contrary to what was intended and to what it was believed to be. In those cases no injustice is done if what everybody has been doing is confirmed as right."
In the division on that matter I notice amongst the names of those who voted for the motion were those of Deputy Anthony, Deputy Breannan, Deputy Corish and Deputy Davin. I also noticed the names of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenny, Deputy Vincent Rice, Deputy Thrift and Deputy Alton.
Comment on this
Deputies might look the matter up. The names may carry weight with the Deputy opposite. They include Deputies on these benches.
Comment on this
The Deputy did not. Well, of course, that may be.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton is not committed in any way in the vote. I have quoted at some length and gone very fully into the matter because these recommendations on the Paper to-day originated from Senator Blythe who solemnly and sanctimoniously proposed them in the Seanad. If we are brought back to discuss them here it is well to know that there are strong arguments and circumstances which justify retrospective legislation. I do not know whether any purpose is served by going into the other aspect of the matter which has been raised here to-day by Deputy Dillon with thunderous eloquence. We have had it all here before. But I have already explained in connection with that aspect of it that the House has got to make its choice. It is not a question of retrospectively imposing a burden upon the ratepayers. It is a question of choosing as to whether there will be a burden on the ratepayers or on the general taxpayers. It has got to be recollected that the effect of the Bill here is to enable the general taxpayers to withhold from the county councils certain moneys.
For years back it has been understood by every county council in the country, by every Deputy in this House and by every ratepayer in the country that these grants from the Central Fund will reach the various county councils in proportion to the extent to which the annuities have been collected. The amount that will go to each county council has been always understood to depend upon the way in which the annuities in that county have been paid. The principles behind that particular legislation have been discussed over and over again. I know that the historic side was gone into. We had a Bill here before and we had the arguments repeated against that particular provision for the existence of the Guarantee Fund. Everybody knows that that had always been accepted as a recognised procedure in this House. Deputy Cosgrave has not referred to the previous discussion in 1923 when one of his own Deputies tried to insist that the Guarantee Fund procedure ought to be abandoned, Deputy Cosgrave swept him aside and said that this was the accepted procedure, that it was reasonable and fair that when there was default in a particular county that that county only should suffer for the default in the payment of the annuities, rather than that the general taxpayers all over the country should have to foot the Bill.
That is the defence which was put up for the Bill, for the retrospective provisions of it. The case is being made that the retrospective effect of the Bill will be to throw a burden of £1,000,000 on the ratepayers. That is, I am sure, a gross exaggeration, because bad and all as the annuitants may be, I do not believe that they will fail to the extent of £1,000,000 to honour their obligation to pay the halved annuities which are now all they have to pay.
Comment on this
The question, in my opinion, has not been fairly put by Deputy Dillon or any of the other speakers. There seems to be a suggestion that there is an attempt here to saddle the ratepayers with this money without adverting to the point to which I have drawn attention, that if the money is not to be got by the ratepayers, and each county is to suffer in accordance with the failure of the annuitants in that county to honour their obligations, it has to be got from the general taxpayer.
Comment on this
I put it to the Attorney-General, would it not be more honest for himself and his Party to approach the British Government, who have already collected more than the land annuities?
Comment on this
I suppose it is impossible to prevent the discussion going along the lines it has already gone, or to prevent the attempt to extract as much political capital out of it as possible. This provision of the Guarantee Fund has always been unpopular and it is nonsense for Deputies to say that the Government is introducing something which has never been thought of before.
Comment on this
The Attorney-General is widening the discussion considerably now. Previous speakers did not refer to the Guarantee Fund. In this discussion the debate should be limited to the recommendations aiming at deleting the retrospective provisions of the Bill.
Comment on this
I agree that I have travelled beyond the scope of the recommendations and I am sorry. I certainly do not want to widen the discussion. I urge upon the House that it ought to face the issue. If this money which is affected by these retrospective sections is not to be found, if these recommendations are to be adopted it will mean that in proportion to the extent to which the Minister is prevented from resorting to the Guarantee Fund, he will have to resort to the general taxpayer and raise the money in another way. I urge that these recommendations should not be accepted.
Comment on this
The Attorney-General, in his unfortunately not successful attempt to widen the discussion, did raise rather interesting points. He was really trying within the rules of debate, but was not allowed to do so, to get at the real heart of the situation. I gather from the answer of the Chair to Deputy Belton that we shall not be able, despite the efforts of the Attorney-General, to get at the real core of this whole trouble that has given rise to these recommendations.
Comment on this
Yes, in going outside that. There are two things involved here, the retrospective character and the actual effect of the words proposed to be deleted. I think you will agree they are two separate questions. The recommendations from the Seanad propose to delete certain words. We are in favour of the deletion of these words from the Bill for two reasons: first, on the grounds to which the Attorney-General devoted most of his attention, namely, the objectionable character of the retrospective legislation involved. We are also in favour of deleting the words because, if they are kept in, the particular words that the Government propose to keep in, they will at the present moment impose an intolerable burden on the people who are already overburdened. These are the two questions involved in these particular proposals.
Like Deputy Cosgrave, I have not had an opportunity of studying the particular case raised by the Attorney-General, but I think he will admit there was nothing wrong in the thesis laid down by Senator Blythe that retrospective legislation is wrong in normal circumstances and that it should be avoided as much as possible; that there may be cases in which it may be, practically speaking—everything taken into account—impossible to avoid retrospective legislation, but in such circumstances a strong case must be made out for it. I hold the Attorney-General has not made a case for this retrospective legislation and the other members of the Government have not made a case. Our whole contention is the opposite, namely, that even if the retrospective character were absent, if it were merely a question of amending, there is no case for the present legislation. The case is not analogous to the case he quoted and, further, much as I would like to, I cannot accept the Attorney-General's presentation of the case. It is one thing to face the situation of the last 12 months as we find it as a result of Government policy, and another to upset the practice of 40 years. Custom gives a certain amount of ethical value to a legal interpretation, and the fact that a legal interpretation has been accepted for a number of years gives it a moral character that this particular piece of legislation proposed by the Government and supported by the Attorney-General is entirely lacking in.
The Attorney-General, who was repeating the case made by the Minister for Finance, suggested that it is a choice between collecting the money this way or in some other way. Our contention is that there should be no such choice, that the taxation should not be there, the burden should not be there. It was the Government policy that put on this burden and they should not expect the neighbour of the land annuitant whom their policy has made bankrupt to make good his default in the present circumstances.
Comment on this
If a land annuitant, as a result of the Government policy, is unable to pay, his next-door neighbour should not, in present circumstances, be made pay for him. It is the Government policy that has reduced a large portion of the farmers to the position of being unable to pay.
Comment on this
Did not the Government policy apply to the next-door neighbour as well as the man who has not paid?
Comment on this
It is a fact that all the people are not bankrupt.
Deputy Donnelly will not be satisfied until everybody is bankrupt. That is all he wants. I am sure he will admit he is now supporting a piece of legislation that will bring that about; that will put all farmers on a footing of equality—in bankruptcy! Every farmer would, when this legislation is passed, be on that footing of equality. But that is one of the reasons why we object to this particular portion of the Bill. We object to the Bill as a whole, but we object also to this part of it.
I can understand circumstances quite well, in which retrospective legislation is necessary. If it was a question, for instance, of defending the rights of the courts of this country against outside courts, or if it was a question in which national obligation or honour was involved I could understand it. Even the case cited by the Attorney-General is differentiated from the present, because of the number of years of working that have elapsed. But no case is made, and no attempt has been made to justify the present procedure by the Government. The Attorney-General at the very close of his speech protested that we were making political capital out of this. We are doing our duty in pointing out to the country what the Government are attempting to do. If there is any political capital to be made out of this by anybody it is because the charges we make are true, and the Deputy knows that.
Comment on this
It is not merely the supporters of our Party that object to this particular piece of legislation. I think it will be found that the objection is a little more widespread than that. Why? Because the people in the country know the situation that they are being asked to face at the present moment. Look at what this House has done in backing up the Government with its help. An appeal was made a short time ago by Deputy Bennett when he pointed out the claims of the country were higher than those of any Party, and he was met with laughter by supporters of the Government. Even Deputy Donnelly smiles at the moment. What is it that the Party opposite have done? There are parts of the country where, as a result of Government legislation, and Government policy, the people are not in a position to pay their annuities. There are certain portions particularly hard hit—some more than others. No one will tell me that Dublin is as hard hit as the County Kerry by the present economic war. What is the Government proposal in this matter? Their proposal is to go down to the portions of the country that have been very hard hit already, and hit them harder still. As a result of the economic war the land annuities that at present remain unpaid are abnormally high. What is that the result of? It is the result of the general policy of the Government as approved by this House—what is called through a misnomer the national policy of the Government. They are proposing to place a higher burden on countíes already hard hit, and the more these counties are hard hit the higher the burden. That is the Government's proposal. If there was ever justification or if there ever was an occasion on which retrospective legislation was justified, this, preeminently, is not such an occasion.
I admit this case is differentiated from all other proposals, because there is not only no justification for the present retrospective clauses in the Bill, but as long as the present economic war lasts there is no justification for the Bill at all. The idea of the Government seems to be that the more you bring a man down the harder you must hit him. The Government propose, as the result of non-payment of the annuities due to the policy of the Government in the last 12 months— when they have made almost bankrupt the agricultural community, and when they have hit certain portions of the country harder than others — to put a still further burden on the people. That is the Government's idea of legislation on these lines, and especially of retrospective legislation along these lines.
Everybody must know now that if there is an abnormal amount of arrears of annuities we are dealing with an abnormal situation. If there is an abnormal increase in the number of defaulters, and especially in certain portions of the country, it is because of the economic conditions prevailing in the country. It is precisely the key industry of the country, upon the success of which depend all other industries, that you propose to place this further burden. You have already burdened it with high taxation and rates and now, because the Minister for Finance finds it inconvenient to carry out his promises about reducing taxation, because the Government will not take a sensible step, so far as the big question is concerned of making agriculture a paying proposition, his only remedy is to put it into a worse condition. Is not that the whole effect of these clauses so far as this year is concerned?
There are grounds for opposing the Bill, and there is a special reason for opposing these clauses. As long as the economic dispute continues, and as long as it continues to make itself felt in the agricultural life of the country, surely there are special reasons for not putting additional burdens on those people, but rather for taking them off Take the position of the ordinary farmer in the country. He is asked to pay higher rates. I have mentioned the case before of a man who told me that his ordinary rates to-day are two-and a-half times more than a couple of years ago. As to the value of his produce—from the point of view of getting money for it—I shall not attempt to say how much he is out of pocket. He pays his annuities to the Government. He feels that in the past 12 months he has more than paid them to the British Government, and now you are asking that man to pay the annuities of somebody else. That is what this Bill proposes to do, and that is what is being done when everyone knows and when even the Ministers themselves admit the lot of the farmer is hard, and very hard. Everybody is convinced of that except Deputy Tom Kelly. Deputies are in possession of their senses if they are not in possession of the liberty to vote, and they should, at least, make representations to the Government about the unwisdom of this proceeding. I am not going to pretend that what is disturbing me is the damage this will do to their Party. What I am concerned with is the damage to the country, which will be very serious. How does anybody expect local services to be carried on in these circumstances? I do not say that it is the aim of the Government to bankrupt local services and gradually supplant them by central administration, but I say that, if that were their aim, they could not go about it in a better way than they are doing at present. There are other methods by which this burden could be met, and there was no necessity to introduce retrospective legislation. We may have doubts as to whether the Minister for Finance has not some nest-eggs. He may not tell us how they are going to hatch out. If he has any such, I suggest that they could not be put to better use than to meet an exceptional non-recurrent charge of this kind. They would be better utilised in that way than by being devoted to the questionable uses to which he is likely to devote them.
The whole difficulty is caused by the policy of the Government and by the condition to which they have reduced the country. It is not one unfortunate person or one unfortunate part of the country that has been hard hit and is now to be hit harder. You are facing a situation brought about not by circumstances peculiar to one county but by a general cause affecting the whole country. You are facing a national crisis which has to be met not locally but centrally. I contend— nobody who knows the country would attempt to controvert the contention— that now is not the time to put additional burdens on the farmers or to put additional difficulties in the way of the local authorities. That is what you are doing. It is within the competence of this House to amend legislation. I am not quite convinced that the passage quoted from the Attorney-General by Senator Johnson is quite as innocent as the Attorney-General pretends, because if he will read that particular passage—that is the only part of the speech I have before me— he will find that there is a suggestion that it is almost the business of this House to interpret legislation.
Comment on this
I defended myself against that attack when Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney made it.
Comment on this
The words, I suggest, are susceptible of that meaning, but if the Attorney-General says that he had no intention of conveying that meaning I accept his statement. But the words were not carefully chosen.
Comment on this
I made quite clear that that was not my meaning.
Comment on this
If the task is one for the courts alone, then let the courts attend to it. When this action was taken, a number of people scoffed at it and said that there was no foundation for it. If there was the slightest belief that that was so, why not let the case go before the courts and let the courts say whether or not there is foundation for it. Deputy Dillon quoted a speech of the deputy Whip of the Fianna Fáil Party. I suggest that that speech is not a bit more absurd than some of the reasons I heard put forward for this Bill from the Ministerial Benches. We were told by a Minister that the real purpose of this Bill—this is about as good an argument as any that has been put forward from the Government Benches —was to save expense to the county councils! That argument was put forward from the Ministerial Bench. It is not a bit better as an argument than that put forward by Deputy Smith, but it is quite as good as any argument advanced from the Government side of the House for the retrospective clauses of this Bill.
Comment on this
One is compelled to ask why is such legislation as this necessary and, if found to be necessary now, why it should be made retrospective. Government spokesmen informed us on various occasions in this House that, because of the default of a number of farmers in different areas, notably in the County Cork, it was necessary to introduce legislation of this character. The Attorney-General quoted from a speech made by Senator Blythe in the Seanad in which he said that retrospective legislation should only be resorted to in cases of necessity. Neither the Attorney-General nor any of his associates on the Government Benches has adduced any argument to show why this legislation should be made retrospective. The Attorney-General suggested that if the local bodies and the ratepayers were not compelled to pay, the general taxpayer would have to foot the Bill. The general taxpayer has had to foot the Bill for the delinquencies and defaults and for the extravagance of this Government. The general taxpayer has been compelled to pay about 12/- per sack more for his flour and 5/- per ton more for his coal, etc. These are some of the burdens borne by the general taxpayer and I submit that a very good case can be made for the general taxpayer having to bear the burden inflicted on the agricultural community by the Fianna Fail Government and their official Labour allies. The case has been made that if the annuitant did not pay some other member of the community would be penalised and compelled to pay for his defaulting neighbour. Surely the Attorney-General and those associated with him must know that never have the farmers gone through a more trying period than during the tenure of office of the present Government. I can only describe this measure as one of the most iniquitous introduced either by a native or Imperial Government during the last 50 years.
Another question I should like to put to the Minister for Finance is, has he when introducing this legislation, and particularly when seeking to make it retrospective, given any consideration to the capacity of the people to pay? The burden of taxation is increasing year after year. The present Minister for Finance threw up his hands in horror on one occasion when Senator Blythe, who was then Minister for Finance, introduced a Budget for something like £21,000,000. President de Valera then told us that it was a burden the people could not bear and that it was an appalling thing that the people should be taxed to that extent. In face of all these protestations of solicitude for the taxpayer we now find that taxation has gone up by almost £4,000,000.
I am just as much concerned with the agricultural labourer in his cottage as with the farmer. It must not be forgotten that, no matter what argument may be used to the contrary, the humble labourer would be as much affected as the farmer by the operation of this measure. Many people, when discussing this measure, not alone here but elsewhere, appear to think that nobody but the farmers and the agricultural labourers will be affected. But surely the merest tyro in national economy must know that anything that adversely affects our chief industry is bound to affect and percolate right down into the industrial centres in the towns and cities. Surely the Minister does not want to penalise the farmer who has paid. There may be some annuitants who could pay and did not pay. There may be and are good reasons operating in the case of some farmers who have not paid. But, is it because a farmer was not industrious, frugal, thrifty, or in some other way was not a capable or good agriculturist, that the thrifty, frugal and good farmer should be made to pay for such a delinquent? I submit that this is a most unjust measure and should not be put into operation.
Comment on this
I did not intend to intervene in this discussion, but for want of courage to speak the truth the wail and the whine have gone up that this Bill is necessary because the farmers either will not or are unable to meet their obligations. They have met their obligations.
Comment on this
The question of what obligations the farmers met does not arise. The only question for discussion is the retrospective aspect of this measure.
Comment on this
I quite agree, but that case has been made on these recommendations and I do not want to labour it any further. It is strange that this machinery, which has worked for 40 years or more and which was not questioned, should break down in the last two years. The Attorney-General said that the operation of drawing on the Guarantee Fund to meet unpaid land annuities was present in the minds of the Government and every Deputy, and I think he went further and said every citizen, when the 1933 Land Bill was going through the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
And the Attorney-General did not get much further with that argument, as the Deputy knows.
Comment on this
If any Deputy got latitude here, Deputy Anthony has no reason to complain. It is strange that it broke down on that. The law was not amended in any way. If the law was sound before 1933. it must be sound now. Deputy Broderick's little action in the court should not be able to upset the Government, yet the Government come along with this precautionary measure.
Comment on this
Of course, the whole nature of the thing was changed. The Government tried to draw money out of the Guarantee Fund to meet Government taxation not land annuities. That is the whole snag.
Comment on this
I appreciate that within the strict, narrow limits of order we must confine ourselves to the retrospective aspect of this. In last year's Finance Act there was retrospective legislation. The Minister for Finance was concerned with a test case in the courts. I think, as a matter of fact, that a Circuit Court judge had given a decision adverse to the policy the Minister for Finance had been pursuing, and which his predecessor had been pursuing, in the matter of profit ground rents. The Revenue authorities had been making the case that profit ground rents should be capitalised and should represent income for the year in which those profits were created. A test case was brought in the courts and a decision given, I think by Judge Davitt, that the Revenue authorities were wrong. The Revenue authorities, under the guidance of the present Minister for Finance and his predecessor, had taken that view of assessing income. Last year the Minister for Finance inserted a clause in the Finance Bill placing beyond doubt the intention of the Revenue authorities, but he did not seek that that should apply retrospectively. Of course the Minister will appreciate that I have no grievance because he did not seek to apply it retrospectively, but I cannot quite follow why he wants to apply this Act retrospectively, or why he should not accept the amendments by the Seanad.
The Attorney-General took a long time to adumbrate on the point that if this Bill is not made retrospective—if those amendments are carried—something like £1,000,000 will fall to be met by the taxpayer. Who else will meet it whether the Bill passes or not, and whether those amendments are adopted or not? Apparently, the Attorney-General is unaware of the manner in which local authorities and county councils build up their budgets. Is he not aware that when arrears occur now or in the past, even when the arrears were in what were really land purchase annuities and the Guarantee Fund was raided to meet the deficiency, the arrears at the end of the financial year were made good in the Estimate for the following year, and that Estimate was not confined to the agricultural ratepayers but spread over the whole body of ratepayers? If the rate-paying capacity of agriculture breaks down under this, those arrears due by the agricultural ratepayers will be spread over the non-agricultural ratepayers and they will have to pay them. You can follow that up to its logical conclusion. If you bankrupt the agricultural ratepayers who will pay the rates or who will pay the arrears? They will all have to be borne by the back that will be able to bear them. The only argument which Deputy Donnelly could adduce was that because one man was able to pay his rates they all should be able to pay them; because one farmer was not bankrupt none of them should be bankrupt. That is the only hope which Deputy Donnelly holds out. I should like to have a talk with the Minister for Finance, and probably we in the Dublin County Council will ask him to see some schedules which have come before me as chairman of the county council, and see the appalling condition of affairs there. If he wants the job of disgracing honest people who have always kept their heads high he can do it. I will not do it for him or anybody else. What hope is held out for all this? I was listening to the Minister for Agriculture saying that the only way to get a price is to kill half your stock. Those are the conditions we are up against and I would defy any farmer there, if there is a farmer there—
Comment on this
I do not want to cross the Jordan again. I should like to hear Deputy Victory on the prosperity of my native county of Longford. He can go to the Longford banks and ask them about it. The Deputy has pathways made to them on behalf of his constituents. I defy him to contradict it. Some of the loudest shouters in support of the present policy in that county and in the county of Dublin are those who are nearly beyond redemption.
Comment on this
In regard to both counties, I will give the names to the Deputy in confidence if he questions what I am saying. I have seen the schedules for both, and I know what I am talking about. I have interviewed the bank managers on behalf of many people in both counties. That is no secret. Everybody in this House knows that is the condition in the country, and then we hear this tripe about retrospective legislation which is to take the marrow out of the bones of agriculture in this country to pay £1,000,000 that is not due. I wish Deputy Dillon stood up to it and said "We have paid this and who can contradict it? Who can contradict us when we say that the British Government have collected it?"
Comment on this
The worst rack-renting landlord that ever cursed this country never sought to collect the rack-rent from a neighbouring farmer if the other farmer did not pay, but the rack-renting landlords under President de Valera, Seán MacEntee and the rest are doing it now, supported by Deputy Donnelly, and by Deputy Corry, who claims to be a successful and prosperous farmer, and to stand for the hard-working farmers of Cork. They are supporting them in this, when they know in their hearts that they are wrong, but they lack the moral courage to stand up and tell the Front Bench there that they are wrong. They are afraid to lose their jobs, because many farmers there, if they had not the jobs, would not have any farm in present circumstances. What is this money for? Let us go back, by way of the magic wand, to what I might call the pre-de Valera era. Let us go back four or five years, when the £6 a head was not skimmed off the price of cattle, but went into the pockets of agriculture, and was paid as it had been heretofore. But that £5,000,000 is shipped away to-day as surely as it was five years ago. Should not that close the deal? If the recipient of that £5,000,000 says "We have got it all," where is the need for the drain on the Guarantee Fund? For arrears of what? Arrears of annuities which the one man who has got this money, the British Chancellor of the Exchequer, says has been paid already. Is there anybody on the Government Benches so dull in intelligence as not to appreciate that point? There is not a single occupant on those Benches who does not realise the truth of that matter as well as I do, but they dare not speak. People are selling their country for a job here. That is the position of the Fianna Fáil Party to-day. They are selling their country for £1 a day. Then we have been told about half the annuities being remitted. That has broken down of course. The Guarantee Fund mechanism collapsed because it was never intended to be used to meet deficiencies in taxation. And agriculture has been paying £2,000,000 for the last two or three years under the 1933 Land Act. That does not represent half the land annuities, for the farmers are losing £2,000,000 which is really raised by taxation on the land. When the taxation was not coming in the Minister raided the Guarantee Fund and he was getting away with it. He got away with it until the Cork and Louth County Councils challenged him in the courts. Then he got the wind up and rushed in here to get legislation passed in order to cover up his tracks. But it is a waste of time on the part of the Government to try to make a case. They charge that the previous Administration used the Guarantee Fund and that it has been used for forty or fifty years without question. Well, it has been questioned. The propriety and equity of it have been questioned, and a good deal in the circumstances that obtained could be said for it. The real reason why this thing broke down was not that the operation of the Guarantee Fund was bad in itself, but because the Minister used it to do a job that it was never intended to do, that is to collect taxes. I hope Deputies will not think that this is a "sod picnic." I hope they will realise that this is playing with the economic life of the country. I hope that even if they are callous enough to vote to have these grants taken from the Guarantee Fund, they are not sufficiently callous to ask that, in addition to other increases and burdens on the agricultural ratepayer caused by the cumulative effect of their piling on charge after charge on that community, there will be a loss by the danger of adding a burden to the arrears already existing, wiping them out as a loss, and starting with a clean slate now. If the Government Deputies do not realise the necessity of that, they will have to do so later on. I am speaking with some little knowledge of the constituency that the Minister represents. If these heavy charges are put on the County Dublin, we will meet the Minister. We are not going to increase rates there. We will meet this charge by cutting the estimates and letting the Minister find employment in the County Dublin for his dupes. It will not be found by selling the last cow and the last bed of the people that the Minister's policy has plundered in the constituency he now misrepresents.
Comment on this
I am a little bit disappointed at the length of time this debate is apparently going to take. I thought that at the end of an hour or two there would probably be a division on these recommendations. But that, apparently, is not going to be the case. We did not come here to hear a repetition of the arguments that we have heard over and over in this House. It seems to me that we are destined never to get any peace either inside the House or outside the House. Because when we go on holidays and take up a paper to look probably at some sporting event we find a letter from Deputy Cosgrave and attacks and correspondence all through the Press. That annoys us just as we are annoyed here by Deputy Belton's speech.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton has a great monopoly of brains as far as agriculture is concerned. Apparently all the Beltons have that monopoly. I saw an advertisement in a paper this morning and when I read it I wondered if Deputy Belton had inserted it. It is a kind of medicinal cure for everything. It is called "Beltonia." I would ask the House to listen to this——
Comment on this
"There will come deliverance from pain and helplessness caused by any form of disease which robs the workers of millions of pounds in wages and salaries... and costs the nation a huge sum." On reading that would one not think that he had been reading a speech of Deputy Belton's? On the last occasion when the Dáil adjourned the Deputy charged that the rank and file of the Government Party were selling the country in order to keep the President and the members of the Executive Council in office. They were doing that for £1 a day. Now this is getting a bit too much and at times it is going a bit too far. I would put this to Deputy Belton for myself personally that as far as I am concerned if I thought the country was going to suffer by any legislation that was introduced by the Government I would not remain here. As regards the £1 a day recompense that we get here I would refer Deputy Belton to one copy of "Irish Nationality" that was issued in this country when I was sacked for my activities for Sinn Fein, and I was sacked from a better job than Deputy Belton ever had.
Comment on this
Nonsense. Your ignorance on that point is on all fours with your ignorance on other matters.
Comment on this
The Deputy from the very first has been making these appeals from this side of the House. He is inviting Deputies here to do a certain thing but I can tell Deputy Belton that the rank and file of this Party will give their allegiance to our Chief. It is to him we will give our allegiance and if the day comes when we have to alter it let us act together on a clean sheet. That is our attitude. Every time he makes a speech in the Dáil, Deputy Belton refers to the farmers. He represents one of the constituencies of Co. Dublin.
Comment on this
In his own constituency, talking about this question of taxation and who is to pay——
Comment on this
Deputy Belton talks about the farmers. Why is there so much anxiety in every constituency in Ireland to get more land when there is an estate being divided?
Comment on this
We see letters appearing in the papers and we see other letters from people looking for more land.
Comment on this
On the borders of Louth—and I am sure Deputy Coburn will bear this out—and County Monaghan, one of the counties that have taken an action against the Government, land was offered recently by an auctioneer, and what was the amount paid for it in County Louth? It was at the rate of £6 per acre.
Comment on this
What has this to do with the matter under discussion?
Comment on this
With all respect, I am trying to answer arguments that have been raised here, that as a result of legislation brought in by the present Government the farmers are in a position that it is impossible for them to pay anything and that the addition of this burden will bankrupt them. I think that is a perfectly fair synopsis of the argument.
Comment on this
One would think that this is the first time that the rates have been made security for the annuities. Under the Ashbourne Act and the Wyndham Act was it not always done? If my memory is correct, I believe that Deputy Cosgrave leans in that direction, because, when the 1923 Act was going through, Deputy Gorey moved an amendment that the rates be no longer responsible for making up the amount due by defaulting annuitants. Deputy Cosgrave, who was then President, refused that amendment and spoke against it. If I am wrong in that, I will willingly accept contradiction, but I think that was the attitude at that time. One would think this was the first occasion upon which a decision on these lines had ever to be adopted.
There is another matter which I would like to mention—it may be touch and go whether or not I am in order. These recommendations have come back from the Seanad for the one purpose of torpedoing this Bill. If these recommendations are accepted, a big part of the Bill might as well never have been passed here. During the discussion on this Bill, and in connection with other Bills, we were taunted with the smallness of our majority. As Deputy Dillon and others have said, when the other Parties got together we had only one or two of a majority over all comers. That is true. But by one of a majority in the Seanad these recommendations have been sent back here. The position is worse in the Seanad than it is here, because the one of a majority in the Seanad occupies a certain position. I do not want to trespass too far on that, but if we want to go back into ancient history we will realise how marvellous it is in Ireland that history always repeats itself. When a Government is trying to do anything for a country, or when a man is trying to do anything for a country, it is peculiar how history repeats itself. In this particular instance the same two counties, Cork and Louth, were the two counties that raised the flag of faction against Mr. Redmond and Mr Dillon when they were trying to do something for the country. The same gentleman whose casting vote in the Seanad sent these recommendations back here was the man who fought the old Irish Party in East Limerick as a factionist.
Comment on this
You blackguarded the old National Party, the Party that was a credit to the country.
Comment on this
I am certainly not blackguarding them now. I often read in the provincial papers, and so did Deputy Belton, long lists of defaulting annuitants. The very men who are now coming along trying to torpedo this legislation are the men who backed up that system of legislation years ago. Must there not be some finality? Deputy Belton and Deputy O'Sullivan talked about the agricultural community being saddled with a burden. Deputy Belton should take a walk through his own constituency and maybe he will realise that if the general taxpayer has got to make good these deficiencies, the poor man in Dublin pays as much in general taxation as the farmer. The poor man in Deputy Belton's constituency has to pay as much for his tea and sugar as the person who resides in Cork. Deputy Belton must know that in his own constituency in Dublin City North there are many poor families living in places where the rent amounts to £80 a year.
Comment on this
I would like to see the farm of land that one of these unfortunate people would get for £80. I am voting for this Bill because I believe it is right. I believe a lot of the argument we have listened to has been exaggerated. I believe, too, that there is a lot of dishonesty behind a lot of the things said in this House. I will back the Government, the President and the Minister, in putting this thing through, and so will every Deputy on these benches, notwithstanding all the talk to the contrary.
Comment on this
The Deputy who has just sat down said he believes there is a lot of dishonesty behind all this. I should like to say that I never heard a more dishonest speech than the one delivered by the Deputy. If I might say so without offence to the Deputy, I never heard a more ignorant speech— ignorant on the subject—than the one we have listened to. The Deputy never once got down to what the Bill means, because he does not know.
Comment on this
On the last occasion when I spoke on this matter I pointed out that if the North Tipperary County Council, when this Bill becomes law, has to make good the amount of the grants withheld by the Government for last year, it will mean 2/1 in the £ on the rates. Deputy Donnelly said that that was bunkum. The Minister for Finance said it would mean nothing of the sort. Of course Deputy Donnelly does not know anything about it. He does not know whether it would mean a penny, 2/1 or 4/1. The Deputy is confused in his ideas about this Bill. Apparently the Deputy is not aware of the fact that this is not to make good annuities, but to make good taxation. It is for revenue purposes. The Deputy did not seem to grasp the fact that this is for revenue purposes and not to pay annuities.
Let me give the Deputy a couple of figures that have an important bearing on the matter, the figures given in this House by the Minister for Finance in reply to a question by Deputy Brennan. So far as the County Tipperary is concerned, in February 1935, the amount withheld from the South Tipperary County Council was £91,376. The amount withheld from the North Tipperary County Council was £44,132. Does the Deputy consider that it is fair at this particular stage to pile that down on the ratepayers of this country? It is rather peculiar, to say the least of it, that during the whole course of the passage of this Bill through the House we had not a speech from any farmer on the far side or from any person who is in daily touch with the people to be affected by this legislation, and particularly by the retrospective clauses, if we except Deputy Corry, who made a long rambling speech. At the end of his speech we did not know whether he was for or against the Bill. He took very good care that he was not going to go on record as voting in favour of it. Having made that speech, he got someone to pair with him. He succeeded on the first occasion, but on the second occasion he did not succeed in getting a pair, although he went out of the front gate, meeting members coming into the House and asking them to pair with him.
Comment on this
Well, the Deputy went outside the House anyway; he may have gone to the front gate. I am making the point that he was anxious to pair, because it proves beyond yea or nay that there are Fianna Fáil Deputies living in rural areas and in touch with the people in those areas who are against this Bill and know that it is an unjust Bill. They know in their hearts that this Bill cannot be put into effect without cutting the social services. Is there any member of the Party opposite who will get up and honestly say that there is a county council to-day in the Free State that can pay this additional rate and keep going?
Comment on this
Is there any member of the Party opposite who knows anything about local politics, who believes that they can collect £1,000,000 additional? At any rate, every Deputy opposite knows that every one or nearly every one of the county councils in the Free State is working on an overdraft from its bank. Is it not a fact that certain county councils were unable to meet the wages of their workmen? Is it not a fact that, in one particular case, they were unable, for a short period, to pay their poor relief? And is it not a fact that in one case it was only by sending deputation after deputation to the bank that they succeeded in carrying on? Are bodies such as these, working on overdrafts, and only able to continue their services because of overdrafts, to be asked to pay an additional rate amounting to something from 2/- to 4/- in the £?
I suggest to Deputy Donnelly that he should consider these facts. He told us he is not concerned with facts and that he is going to follow his leader. We know that. That kind of thing is the unfortunate curse of this country. Unfortunately the Deputy is more often following the President when he is wrong than when he is right. He told us that when he can no longer follow his leader he will walk out. I am rather surprised at that. I gave Deputy Donnelly credit for having much more intelligence than that. Let Deputies not forget that by this legislation they are putting this amount of £1,000,000 extra on the rates in order to meet further activities of the Government. Is there any Deputy in this House with a knowledge of the local authorities of the country who is not aware of the fact that additional money has to be provided at present to meet the increased cost of living, to meet an increase of practically 11/- per sack for flour and an increase of from 17/- to £1 extra per ton for coal compared with 12 months ago? The same applies to butter, sugar and all other items, and the people are expected not only to meet them but actually to provide an additional £1,000,000. Deputies opposite are silent when these things are brought forward though they know better than I do that the Government has been strangling the local authorities for all these years.
Comment on this
The Deputy is getting uneasy. He is one of the ablest speakers on the other side, and he knows better than most of them how to face up to a bad case. But there are some cases so bad that even Deputy Donnelly with all his ability cannot attempt to defend them.
Comment on this
An ignorant speech on this particular subject. He told us he was prepared, in company with the rest of his colleagues, blindly to follow his leader.
Comment on this
He allows his sense of loyalty to blind his intelligence. I suggest to Deputy Donnelly and members of the Party opposite that they should consider this whole matter seriously. The majority of them in touch with rural areas have considered the facts. They know the effect of this Bill, as well as we do, and in their hearts they are as much against this Bill as we are, but we heard only one speech from a farmer Deputy opposite—made by Deputy Corry—who is not prepared to back his speech with his vote. That shows what the Deputy's opinion was worth. We had other speeches from Deputies opposite whose knowledge of agriculture is not greater than mine. I do not profess to know much about agriculture, but I am in touch with the people who have suffered and will have to suffer if this Bill is passed. I am satisfied that the cost cannot be met by increased rates and I am very much afraid that what will happen is this: that county councils, when they are compelled to meet the demands imposed on them by this Bill, will be forced to cut their social services and the poor people and the workers will suffer in the long run.
Comment on this
I am afraid the remarks which Deputy Morrissey made in respect of Deputy Donnelly and his ability to study the situation apply with equal force to every member of the Government Party opposite. But no one seems to have taken into consideration on the Government side what is the actual state of the country with regard to the local authorities. Deputy Donnelly told us this was not the first time the rates were made liable for the payment of annuities. It is the first time rates have been made liable for Government taxation. That is perfectly true. It is the first time that a British or an Irish Government has endeavoured to make money out of the people in that way.
Comment on this
Let me explain. If the British Government insisted on the Guarantee Fund and if the predecessors of the present Government insisted on it, it was for the purpose of ensuring payment to the stockholders of money raised for them. It went out to them.
Comment on this
No. The purpose of the Guarantee Fund may not be discussed. We are dealing only with the retrospective provisions of this Bill.
Comment on this
I do not wish to contravene the ruling of the Chair. Deputy Donnelly used an expression which was used by more than one other Deputy—that one would imagine that this was the first time this was being done. It is the first time. I want to impress on the House that this is the first time the rate-paying community has been made liable for Government taxation.
Comment on this
Are we entitled to discuss whether the annuities are payments in respect of land purchase or taxes?
Comment on this
If the Deputy were allowed to pursue that matter, then other Deputies would be entitled to reply.
Comment on this
The matter is not really open to discussion, because the Minister for Finance and the House know that what I am saying is perfectly correct.
Comment on this
The recommendations before the House are no more than an endeavour to save not alone the unfortunate people who have already paid their rates and annuities, but whatever little self-respect is left in the Government. The Minister for Finance told us in the House recently that he had mortgaged our future in order to get us over the position in which we found ourselves last year, when he made available certain moneys to us so that the pressure of that £716,000 would not be so heavy for the time being. I should like to know from the Minister if, in putting these retrospective clauses in this Bill, he considered what the position of local authorities was. In reply to a question some time ago we were told that, in 1931-32 the amount of arrears carried forward was £123,000; in 1932-33, £129,000; in 1933-34, £176,000; in 1934-35, £339,000, and in 1935-36, £364,600. Add to that that none of these local authorities has made full provision for the withholding of the grants, that the Minister, by this retrospective legislation, hopes to get in or has already collared £716,000, and that a sum of £364,000 has been carried forward as against £123,000 in 1932. What, then, will be the position of the local authorities? Deputy Belton mentioned that, because the people have already paid their annuities, they are apparently justified in refusing to pay the further annuities. There is a lot to be said for that. This is the first time people have been asked to pay a debt twice.
Comment on this
We have quite enough to do to look after our own business. They are able to look after their own business and you have evidence of that in the coal-cattle pact.
Comment on this
They do not need anybody's assistance. They come out winners every time. If the annuities are unpaid to the extent of £716,000, why is that so? There must be some reason for it. Deputy Donnelly says, in effect, that the farmers are as well off as ever they were, and that, if they were not, they would not be looking for more land. I am amazed at Deputy Donnelly putting up that type of argument. There is nothing stable in this country but land and, after all, a few acres of land to a young man is something.
Comment on this
I advise Deputy Donnelly to inquire from the secretary of the county council of the county which he represents as to what are the prospects of continuing social services and of making provision for roads and employment, as has been done in the past, if this retrospective legislation is to have effect. Who is going to foot the bill? I do not know exactly how much Leix County Council have been deprived of by means of the withheld grants but, in Roscommon, we were actually docked £26,000, which represents 1/9½ in the £. In addition, we have, as pointed out by Deputy Morrissey and several other speakers, new and increased services of every kind. We have new hospitals being erected at tremendous cost and new housing accommodation at tremendous cost. The cost of maintenance of all these services has to be borne and, in addition, the farmer who has paid has got to carry the burden of his neighbour who, through Government policy, is not able to pay.
I was at the fair of Roscommon on Monday and I should like Deputy Donnelly to take a note of my experience. We hear a lot of talk about the halving of the annuities. The Attorney-General told us that the farmers have only to pay half annuities. There was a slight omission there. They have only to pay half to us. But they have to pay the whole to Britain. A neighbour of mine—a poor man—had three head of cattle in the fair. They were two-and-a-half-year olds and he got £22 for them. He was lucky to get that £22 but, under present conditions, he lost £18 on them—three sums of £6 each. His annuities were £16 and were brought down to £8. Has not that man a great advantage in having his annuities halved and his three cattle sold at a loss of £18? The Minister for Finance will then tell us that they have halved the annuities of the farmers.
Comment on this
And if he did, the people would have had an open market which would be quite a different matter. By this retrospective legislation, the Government are ensuring that not alone will the ratepaying community in future be responsible for the debts of their neighbours but that the Government will be entitled to hold what it has already got outside the law. I say "outside the law" deliberately. I am sorry that Deputy Corry has left the House. He used to be very loud in his denunciation of salaried people. He used to tell us about bloated officials and how, when his party got into power, they were going to tackle these people. Now Deputy Corry sits silently while these bloated officials are allowed to go scot-free so far as this matter is concerned. Deputy Corry and his neighbours, if they have their rates and annuities paid, will have to bear the responsibility of the nonpaying members of the community.
The Minister for Finance and the Attorney-General asked, "Is it fair to put this particular load on the taxpayers considering that the farmers have failed to pay"? I ask Deputy Corry, is it not fair to let some of his bloated salaried officials carry part of this load rather than put it back on the farmers? Is there any reason why the farmers should carry it all? The Minister for Finance says that this money was advanced on a community basis. It was not. There was no such thing as a community basis in the advance of the money. The money was advanced to buy out the landlords and, as far as the tenants were concerned, it was advanced individually to everyone of them. The only reason that Great Britain put in the provision of the Guarantee Fund was to ensure that she would get the money to pay the stock-holders, because she mistrusted the Irish people.
Comment on this
If he did put it in, there is one thing he did not do—he did not get any advantage out of it, neither did his Exchequer. It was not then Government revenue. Every penny of it went to pay the stockholders.
Comment on this
I am not. I know well the ground I am on. We had the Attorney-General quoting a case to show that it was not the first time retrospective legislation was introduced in this House. Of course it was not. One would imagine from the manner in which the Attorney-General spoke that there was a complete analogy between the two cases, but there was not. If the Attorney-General told us what the other case really was, the House would know where they were. I know what the other case was, and there is no analogy between them as far as the circumstances are concerned. The other was a case dealing with people who, it was found after their death, according to the legacies which they left, did not make a proper declaration of their incomes previously. This is a case where people are not able to pay, and have been declared by the Minister and by the Land Commission as not able to pay, because if they were able to pay they ought to have collected the money off them. This is a case where the people are not able to pay and where the load which they are not able to carry is being put on their neighbours.
To my mind there is no justification for the retrospective portion of this Bill. The unfortunate position in which we find ourselves is, I maintain, due to Government policy. I should like to know why the Minister for Local Government, who must stand sponsor for local authorities here, does not appear in this House, or why at the Executive Council meetings he does not demand justice for the Departments which he represents. Why must the Minister for Finance be allowed to be the Shylock of the Government Party to demand his pound of flesh irrespective of what happens to local authorities?
I have been on local authorities for a great number of years, and I ought to know something about them. I do say that with this legislation in force and the circumstances of the people as we see them to-day, as illustrated by the non-payment of annuities and by their inability to meet their demands, and with the calls already on the people, we are going to have a breakdown in local administration. Nobody will regret that more than I will. It cannot possibly stand. Anybody who has examined the situation must see that. We have increased Estimates, we have an increase in the carry forward of unpaid rates, an increase in the writing-off of irrecoverable rates and, in addition, we have this demand for £716,000 for last year. What are we going to have for this year? The Minister can tell that, but will possibly say that it would be out of order. Probably it would be out of order, but it would be very interesting to Deputies and the local authorities to know what are the deficiencies this year as far as unpaid annuities are concerned.
The unfortunate position that the farmers find themselves in is that, while this Government collars £716,000 outside the law for last year, and while Great Britain collars the whole of the annuities, and together with that the police pensions and the local loans out of the farmers' cattle, we have the Government saying: "In addition to paying that we will make you pay to us £716,000 which some of you failed to pay last year." As was pointed out by Deputy Broderick on the Second Reading, neither this Government nor their predecessors deserve any credit for these grants. They belong to local authorities by right.
Comment on this
Before the Act of 1898, in the Grand Jury days, there were county cess and poor rates, and a certain portion was paid by the landlords. Then the landlords were bought out and grants were made available in substitution for the landlords' portion. These are some of the moneys which the Minister proposes to hold. Not alone that, but he proposes to make the unfortunate farmer who is endeavouring to pay his way, pay for the other who is not able to pay his way.
The Government ought to stop and think—I am afraid that is a thing they have not been doing. If local government fails, it will be the saddest day that ever came. There is no use in thinking that you can force people to pay unless you first give them something to pay with. There is no use in telling people that we have withheld £5,000,000 from Great Britain. We have not withheld it. Even if Great Britain was not collecting it, and if we lost, to the extent to which they are collecting it, in another way, then you are not holding it either, because you could not hold anything until you have it. You must have it before you can hold it. Whatever money the people of the country may have left by for their sons or daughters, whatever money pays their rates or annuities, was made on the British market. Even from the returns furnished to-day we see that that old British market does not appear to have gone yet. We are increasing our exports there, but at what a price—£6 per beast.
The position in which the local authorities find themselves is not a happy one. I am afraid the New Year's gift which they are getting from the Government will not help them to make provision for the social services. As far as Fianna Fáil are concerned, the Bill has done this much good—it has exploded all their promises and all their fallacies. In 1931 and 1932 when Fianna Fáil were coming in here we were to have derating; we were going to hold the annuities, and we were going to spend those on the annuitants.