We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Land Purchase (Guarantee Fund) Bill, 1935—From the Seanad.

Contributions 204–404 of 404. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Purchase (Guarantee Fund) Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 39 of 1935 ›

And did they not do it?

Comment on this

Why did they fail to pay £716,000 last year? Is it dishonest the people have become or is it bankrupt? The Deputy should take his choice of the two. The situation staring us in the face is that the people are not able to pay, and the Government knows that as well as anybody else. The amounts previously withheld were nothing. They never amounted to more than a fraction of a penny in the £. Now we are confronted with a different situation. Now we have the people who promised derating, and went in with a great flourish of trumpets to do everything for the farmers, coming along and saying: "We are going to take the last drop of blood. We are going to take the last penny you have. We are going to sell the last cow you have in order to see that the Government will have revenue."

Comment on this

Deputy Brennan knows a good deal more about the finances of local authorities than most of his colleagues, and that probably accounts for the fact that his speech marks the reduction of the main figure used by the Opposition by rather more than 25 per cent. Until Deputy Brennan spoke, the figure of £1,000,000 was being repeated ad nauseam. Deputy Brennan was too wise to make use of that figure, and he has brought it down to £716,000. That is a considerable improvement, I think, from the point of view of the good sense of the debate. I wonder is there any great reason for using either the figure of £1,000,000 or the figure of £716,000. The Government have never said that if that amount of money is not collected by a certain date the ratepayers will be responsible.

Comment on this

They have.

Comment on this

The Government have never stated that if the land annuities are not paid by a certain date they will abandon the collection of such annuities, and that they automatically go on the rates. I wonder if Deputy Brennan or any other Deputy has authority for quoting any figure in connection with the liability under that head at the present time?

Comment on this

Might I correct the Deputy for a moment?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

The Government last year actually withheld £716,000. Those are the figures given in the House.

Comment on this

Would not the Deputy be good enough to explain to the House the significance of the two figures which he quoted—first, that the Roscommon County Council expected that £29,000 would be withheld, but, in fact, only £26,000 was withheld.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

The point being that £3,000 of arrears had come in between the date on which the Roscommon County Council formed its expectation and the date on which the grant was released.

Comment on this

If I might correct the Minister; the Roscommon County Council was notified that at that particular time not £29,000 but £39,000 were outstanding, and that that would have to be withheld unless certain payments were made.

Comment on this

And they were made.

Comment on this

But at the relevant date £26,000 were withheld.

Comment on this

And if part of that £26,000 is paid this year that money will go back to the Roscommon County Council. What on earth then is the use of talking about the pending bankruptcy of the local authority, and of quoting such figures as £1,000,000, £716,000, and all that sort of thing? Does not everybody know that there have been certain difficulties in connection with the collection of land annuities in recent years that are not likely to recur? There is no use in mincing words about it; Deputy Brennan knows very well that propaganda and conspiracy existed——

Comment on this

The people had been led to believe that they would not have to pay.

Comment on this

Even though those things have practically ceased for some time, the driving force of such agitation still leaves its effects, and probably accounts for a substantial share of the arrears. There is, further, the fact that in a period of transition, when to a large extent the whole basis of agriculture is being changed, it is inevitable that people will find themselves in temporary difficulties. I think Deputy Brennan is not without knowing that there are people in Galway, for instance, in Mayo, in North Cork, West Cork, and so on, who to-day are in a position to pay the annuities, when two years ago, say before the establishment of beet factories in their areas, it was extremely difficult to do so.

Comment on this
Mr. Broderick

Question! The Deputy should mention counties that he knows something about.

Comment on this

In face of all that, I consider it a rather senseless proposal that merely as a side issue the question of doing away with the Guarantee Fund and making such a big change in our financial system should be raised here and debated in this Party spirit. If the principle of the Guarantee Fund is to be debated, and if there is a better system to replace it, then it ought to be debated on its own merits, and not merely as a side issue to a Bill that has practically nothing to do with the principle of the Guarantee Fund. The principle of the Guarantee Fund was always unpopular. Long before the present Government came into power I heard a group of farmers at a cross-roads on a Sunday afternoon talk on the subject, and I remember very well how heated they were in their indignation that, faced with big difficulties in paying their own way, they were having also to pay for their neighbours who, judging from their remarks, were not very worthy neighbours, and did not deserve great help from anyone. It was always unpopular, and inevitably would be so.

Comment on this

You established the principle when you got into office.

Comment on this

In a period of depression, when people find it difficult to pay their own way, it is not at all easy for them to accept the principle that they must also pay for their neighbours. But I should like to see the principle put to a much fairer test than it has been put to in recent years before I would consider proposals to abolish it, and particularly I should like to see the alternatives that the Opposition would put up to the principle of the Guarantee Fund.

Comment on this

Settle the economic war and you will want no Guarantee Fund at all.

Comment on this

At all events, the debate had shown one thing; to-day, at least, there are not the same crude and ridiculous protests against the principle of retrospective legislation; there has been less shouting about the odious proposal that the Dáil should decide to correct an error of its own making, to correct an error that was admittedly of its own making, an error that nobody denies crept into the legislation of the Oireachtas. At all events, we have heard a great deal less of that to-day.

Comment on this

You may thank the Chair. It was out of order to-day.

Comment on this

When the subject was before the House on a previous occasion we had Deputies yonder tediously copying one another in repeating statements about the terrible danger to individual liberty, the terrible danger that would arise if this principle were accepted—the principle by which the Dáil, having discovered a mistake in its legislation, took the first opportunity of correcting that mistake, and did not allow it to be threshed out in the courts at public expense. At all events, I say we have made that much progress.

On the general question of the Guarantee Fund, I personally have an open mind as to whether or not it is desirable that it should be continued. I have not heard any proposals for a better system, and I am sure that in present circumstances no attempt is being made to arrive at a fair judgment upon the system of the Guarantee Fund. There have been extraordinary circumstances in this country during the past two or three years. There have been extraordinary political, social and economic circumstances, and they have contributed to the creation of an atmosphere in our public life which is not in accordance with the realities of the life of the individual farmer. Obviously the differences in the arrears between one county and another are not the result of different economic circumstances in those counties, and the proposal that the retrospective part of this Bill should be dropped and that we should start now with a clean slate seems to me so childish that I do not think anybody puts it forward seriously. The idea that one county, having made a great effort to pay its way, where the farmers have accepted their liability in this respect, should now be penalised, because in another county there was undoubtedly agitation and propaganda against the payment of annuities and because farmers deliberately withheld their annuities.

Comment on this

And Fianna Fáil farmers as well.

Comment on this

Are these two counties to be put in the same position? Surely, that is not a proposal that is contemplated seriously. I have heard proposals against this Bill——

Comment on this

It is hard to let that go unchallenged. The people are in a bad way.

Comment on this

There seem to be two of us in possession.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Fagan can make his own speech and allow Deputy Moore to make his without interruptions.

Comment on this

Deputy Moore has been talking about my county.

Comment on this

I was not referring to Deputy Fagan's county or any county in particular. I was endeavouring to discuss the question as reasonably as I could.

Comment on this

It is very hard for anyone living in my county to keep his temper listening to Deputy Moore's speech. The people in my county are all drained out. They are in poverty and hunger.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If Deputy Fagan wants to make his statement let him make it in the proper fashion and not by way of interruption of other Deputies.

Comment on this

But all the farmers in my county are clean broke.

Comment on this

I have heard that one reason why people in Westmeath are broke is because they backed the wrong horse.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance smiles with his £1,000 a year. In my constituency the children of the farmers are crying for want of food and clothing.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I must insist on Deputy Fagan allowing Deputy Moore to proceed. Whether Deputy Fagan's indignation is serious or simulated he should not interrupt other Deputies. He will be given an opportunity of speaking himself.

Comment on this

We have the Minister for Finance there with his £1,000 a year smiling while the children of the farmers in my constituency are hungry. I could not silently watch him with his £1,000 a year smiling.

Comment on this

£2,000 a year; £1,000 for himself and £1,000 for his wife.

Comment on this

And everyone of us is broke.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We must have order on this matter if we are to have any debate. It is not Deputy Fagan's usual practice to interrupt. I hope he will allow Deputy Moore now to proceed.

Comment on this

I can only say that, in my opinion, a great deal of the opposition to this Bill is simply due to the desire to bring up again the question of the economic war. The people have spoken their minds on that question already and Deputy Dillon and his followers are making a mistake if they think that the threats of general bankruptcy are going to cow the people. There is one thing upon which the people are apparently resolved, and that is, that no threat of bankruptcy, no matter from what source, whether from England or from some of their own neighbours, will compel them to give way on the question of the economic war. That is, at all events, my judgment as to the present situation. I do suggest that Deputies Brennan and Dillon and others are making a very big mistake in endeavouring to make the people believe that they are not being allowed to avail of the opportunity of securing substantial wealth or at all events of securing greatly increased wealth. There are very few on the Opposition Benches who really believe that that position is there for the people even if the economic war were settled to-morrow. It would be a very disastrous thing if people were encouraged to believe that through public policy in this country they are not only being impoverished but are being prevented from enjoying fruits that are there for the plucking. This is a big question and I suppose it would be irrelevant in this debate to debate it fully. But, to my mind, at all events, the speech of Deputy Dillon in which he talked of the terribly disastrous financial position that is arising in the country, and the consequent threat to the poor and destitute, was reckless and anti-social to a very serious extent. I think the Deputy could contribute more towards helping the people in their present struggles than by telling them that they are on the verge of disaster and that their bad circumstances are entirely due to the action of the Government that they have elected. Whatever Party politics may justify, they would not justify us in preaching a doctrine like that. I, for one, regret that that should be the tendency of the debate to-day.

Comment on this

Before speaking on the matter before the House— the recommendation of the Seanad which the Minister for Finance has proposed should be rejected—there are two or three small points that I would like to deal with. First of all I have been informed that the Minister for Finance expressed his great regret when concluding his speech that I was not in the House. I would have read it too. I have always made it a point to hear what the Minister has to say on any subject that interested the Dáil. But, owing to something over which I have no control, I am at the disadvantage that I did not hear the Minister's speech. I will attempt to deal with the matter on its merits alone and I would welcome any criticism that the Minister may be able to make on my contribution. I wish to avail now of the opportunity of answering Deputy Donnelly's statement standing over what he considers his principles. I rather regret the discourteous way, whether he intended it or not, in which he referred to Cork and Louth. The Deputy said that we were imbued with the spirit of faction. I ask Deputy Donnelly or any other man on the Government Benches to say what in normal times they would say as to standing over the principle of making one man responsible for the debts of another. It is against that principle that Cork and Louth are at war, and I make no apology for our action. We on the Cork County Council, and, I am sure, the same can be said of Louth, weighed down by the anxieties of our public service, took every constitutional means to establish that principle, and we will continue to do so until this or some other Government recognises that a man is responsible only for his own liabilities. That is our answer to Deputy Donnelly.

Unpleasant scenes frequently occur and have occurred. Painful remarks were made to-night. I deplore that, because anything that tends to reduce the power of the National Assembly to deal in reason and courtesy with every question that arises, lessens the dignity of the Assembly and lessens its efficacy. With regard to the question that is before the House, the rejection of the recommendations of the Seanad, I regret the Minister refused to listen to us or to give effect to our appeals. Deputy Moore has just gone out. I think he implied, if he did not say it distinctly, that we were actuated by a desire to discredit the Ministry. I think that is the implication of what he said. He also said that there was very little merit in our action. As a matter of fact, we had but one desire and that desire lives to-day as acutely as when we joined issue and it is not confined to any section of the Cork County Council, either Labour, Fianna Fáil, Independents or the Opposition Party, but it is the unanimous wish of the whole council. It was based on nothing of a political nature; it was based purely and simply on an economic point. It was purely and simply an economic question and we did what we considered was right. I submit that because there was quite a possibility that we were right, this measure has been introduced. As a matter of fact, we hold that there was quite a probability that we were right, but we will not debate that question now.

The matter that is uppermost in everybody's mind is the maintenance of public services at their present pitch. If this Bill passes without the small recommendations that the Seanad has sent down about the retrospective clauses, it will have very serious reactions. Let me quote the words of a Ministerial communication: "It is essential to the maintenance of the county services"—the collection of the annuities. That means that without the collection of the annuities those services cannot be maintained. How can Deputy Donnelly or Deputy Moore, or anybody else, find fault with us? What is the possibility of collection? With all our resources and with all the energy we can command there is, in the case of our own levy, an amount of £83,000 outstanding. How can we collect the unpaid annuities? What machinery have we to do it? The Minister has the entire resources of the State under his control and if he fails, how can we succeed? If we do not succeed and if these things are not paid then, according to the Minister's letter, the essential services of the county will be seriously menaced. There is no hope of our collecting them.

Some Deputy on the opposite benches said that nobody here had made a constructive suggestion. I make no apology for holding on the main principle that we were correct. Government spokesmen have always referred to the great credit of the country. If they claim that, what is the difficulty of borrowing money to pay all this? Remember that neither you nor any Government can discredit this country. The credit of the country, the finances of the country, were built by former generations who utilised their thrift and energy, and made use particularly of the English markets. The trouble to-day is caused largely by the policy of the Government in regard to those same markets.

I will ask Deputies opposite to visualise what the destruction of the public services would mean. Remember that the public services enter largely into the lives of the ordinary people. Those responsible for public services have to make arrangements for maintaining hospitals of all kinds, granting home assistance, maintaining roads, and so on. All those things come under the local authority, and if by any possibility the finances of the local authority fail, you bring more acute miseries on the people than would any other activity on the part of the Government. So far as our own county is concerned, I regret the Minister refused to give effect to the appeals made to him for justice or equity on the principles of the Bill when it was before the House. I am equally satisfied that he is not going to give us any consideration now in regard to the retrospective clauses. It is, therefore, an appropriate time to point out to him the consequences for the entire country which will follow on the Minister's refusal of all claims for justice, even to the extent of the Seanad's recommendations. As far as the law can do it, he is imposing on the shoulders of ratepayers who have paid their rates a general responsibility for unpaid taxation. The Minister has apparently admitted his inability to collect taxation from those who have shirked their responsibilities. The only power he has is to mortgage the amount of money passed by this House for the relief of the public services. He has the power now—he is making it clear cut and defined—to withhold all that money.

This is going to have a very serious effect on us, and it might possibly destroy our whole public services. It is not my intention to go over the many points I placed before the House when the Bill was first introduced. I frequently wonder do the Ministry entirely understand how this thing will affect the local authorities? The several county councils in the Free State undertook office to administer the affairs of their counties under conditions which have now considerably altered. Various statutes and actions of the Ministry have now rendered the position of councils exceptionally difficult. I do not wish to refer too much to the principal cause of present difficulties, such as the great reduction in the revenue of the ratepayers at large and their difficulties in meeting their obligations to the local authorities. It is at this critical moment that the Minister has decided to aggravate the ratepayers' difficulties.

We undertook office on notification from the Minister for Local Government that we were to get certain sums. Previously we were entitled to estate duty grants, agricultural grants, etc., and in addition we received 50 per cent. of the cost of the maintenance of the mentally afflicted in the various mental hospitals. Now the estate duty grants have been absorbed into the Central Fund, and instead of a 50 per cent. grant for the cost of the mentally afflicted we are now getting only 20 per cent. and the ratepayers have to face the remaining 80 per cent. We have been instructed in many cases to increase our expenditure. We were always in favour of vocational education, and our former voluntary contribution of £5,000 or £6,000 has now been changed into a compulsory liability which this year in Cork County amounts to over £13,000, and that will increase by an annual sum of £1,500 up to a maximum of approximately £18,000 per annum.

There were many other important things which were normally controlled on a voluntary basis but which are now mandatory. Take the question of housing, for instance. The Cork County Council unanimously pledged itself to spend £500,000 on a housing scheme. All the principal and interest there will have to be defrayed, because it is quite clear the assistance we were going to get will not be forthcoming. I suppose I might be told that there I am touching on future matters, so I shall leave it out. But the fact is that the ratepayers are now called upon to face the full cost of services that they never had to face before. They had undertaken all that, with the promise from the Ministry that they were to receive a grant amounting to 40 per cent. of their entire expenditure. Now that is withdrawn and the ratepayers are left to face the entire liability.

There was another point which, I think, has been completely overlooked and it is this: Whenever we were notified by the Ministry to give credit to the ratepaying community it was always the agricultural community that was intended. So that if we require the sum of £500,000 or £600,000 for housing, for the great county of Cork, the cost of that falls upon everybody. But the Minister comes along and advises us, or instructs or notifies us, that we must give credit for £200,000 to the agricultural community. The rate is struck on everybody in the month of March, and collected so far as it is in our power to do so; but the following February we are notified that the Minister for Finance has deducted a certain sum from the grant for local services. Here we are up against inequality. In the first instance the agricultural community is to get relief but the ordinary householder will get no relief. When the so-called grants are withdrawn, the levy to make them up falls upon the general ratepayer. If the Minister refuses to accept these recommendations made in the Seanad, it means, in our county, that householders in Charleville, Mitchelstown, and in all the suburbs of Cork who have already paid their rates, will be compelled to pay £42,000 more to make up what the Minister has deducted from the grant. Other people will also have to pay their share in making it up, and the people who actually paid their rates already will also have to help to make it up. Deputy Donnelly accused us of vexatious and factionist action in this matter.

Comment on this

It is not good for the character of Cork and for councils in Cork to advise people not to pay their annuities.

Comment on this
Mr. Broderick

I can only answer for myself in that matter, and I challenge any man, inside or outside this House, to show that by any word or act of mine I prohibited, in any form, the working of the law.

Comment on this

I accept that on the part of the Deputy but not on the part of his colleagues.

Comment on this
Mr. Broderick

I am not aware of such acts, but may I point out to the Deputy, and to the Minister, that it is nothing but a miserable, flimsy pretext to put that kind of argument forward as an excuse for iniquitous action of this kind. A few misguided enthusiasts—perhaps men suffering under great mental excitement—may have been guilty of a few acts of that kind. Is that sufficient cause for this National Assembly to bring forward this legislation at this particular time? That kind of argument may be good political propaganda; it may be a good excuse, but it is unreal.

Comment on this

It does not apply to my county.

Comment on this
Mr. Broderick

No; but Deputies opposite pick out poor Cork.

Comment on this

It does not apply to Leix and Offaly.

Comment on this
Mr. Broderick

At any rate, Cork can always look after itself, and is prepared to accept full responsibility for its action. When Deputy Donnelly talks about factionist action on the part of people in North and South Cork, I ask him how can he defend the demand that men who have already paid their rates, in full, must make up the sum of £42,500 in order to pay their neighbours' annuities.

Comment on this

That includes the cottage tenants who have also paid their rates already.

Comment on this
Mr. Broderick

Yes, it includes the cottage tenants who have paid their full rates, and it will mean an increase for every cottage tenant in Cork of 11/1 on their cottages.

Comment on this

It would mean no increase to them if the new land league, instead of urging people not to pay their annuities, urged them to pay them.

Comment on this

They have already paid them three times over.

Comment on this
Mr. Broderick

I have a very high regard for the Ministry and for the institutions of the State, and I have too much regard for the courtesy of debate to say really what I think of that kind of argument. I think the Minister will agree, on reflection, that that kind of low-down political correction is really unworthy of him.

Comment on this

I do not agree.

Comment on this
Mr. Broderick

Every man in Cork County, worthy of his salt, has stood up for constitutional government in the past and now and every time. If we are in disagreement with the law —and I disagree with the policy of making one man responsible for another man's debt—we will use every constitutional means in our power to give effect to that disagreement. I asked already does the Minister expect us to collect the unpaid annuities. We cannot collect our own taxation at the present time and the demand made on us to collect other people's debts requires no other answer than that. I do not think I have much more to add. The Minister quite clearly sees what the whole thing means. I have pointed out this thing is a very severe threat to the public services not only in the County of Cork but to every other county in the State. If this Act comes into force in its full unqualified rigour, if it is to be applied in its full meaning, I certainly feel it means the destruction of our local services. We are called upon to face this liability for unpaid taxation, if you like, at a most crucial moment when, amongst other things, we are concerned with a great scheme of £500,000 to carry on our housing programme. Is that the moment to add another serious item to our revenue? I appeal to the Minister, before it is too late, to delete these retrospective clauses from the Bill. I do not think the local authorities can stand them. I have in no way referred to the economic conflict; but if the Minister and the Government feel that the country is merely passing through a transition stage, and that everything is going to come right and that although the cattle trade is destroyed, everybody is growing wheat and beet, then what is the trouble in getting over this temporary difficulty?

There is plenty of money in the country. It was not put there by your activities or by ours but by the energy and enterprise of the people. There are, probably, £150,000,000 in the country. That money is frozen at one end. I put forward the suggestion to borrow the amount of the national liability to the local authorities and pay it over to them. Otherwise they cannot function. I very rarely suggest ulterior motives. But if the Ministry desire to wipe out all local authorities and to establish a managerial system—if they have a sinister motive of that kind— they are proceeding on the proper lines. If they really mean that this country is to be governed democratically, that local authorities are to be free to express public opinion, that this country is to be built up on those ideas, then you have got to help the local authorities through what you claim is a transition period. If the amount voted by this House to cover the national liability to the local authorities is to be held in mortgage for unpaid annuities or national taxation, then the position of the local authorities is hopeless if this is to go on for an indefinite period. If, as the Minister and his associates claim, this is only a transition period; if, in three or five years, we are going to flourish, when all the stable industries of the country are gone and we have these new industries, why not help us over the transition period by paying us the full amount of the Government's liability?

Before sitting down, I have to pay my tribute to our own local authority. Unlike other bodies, we have concentrated on the maintenance of our public services. We may have our own little passing differences, but they are rarely acute. We have our own political ideas, but every man, no matter what Party he supports——whether it be Labour, Government, Opposition or Independent—concentrated on the purpose of giving the best service he could to the public. In my position as chairman it will fall to me to levy that increased rate of practically £250,000. I know that in levying it and in adding it to our annual expenditure, I shall be signing practically the death warrant of a considerable number of ratepayers who pay their rates. Neither the Minister nor I, with all the powers at our disposal, can hold liable the shirker who is not paying his rates. When it comes to the signing of that warrant I shall have seriously to consider what my attitude is to be to those services from the point of view of the county as a whole and of those ratepayers whom we have done our best to serve but on whom we are called upon by Ministerial policy—I should not like to describe it as tactics—to levy an amount which is impossible. The Minister knows now, though he has not informed us, what he is going to deduct from us. To the £179,000 of last year we must add £83,000 of uncollected debts of our own. I do not think that I shall be far wrong if I estimate the annuities deduction for this year at £75,000 or £100,000. When it comes to May or June we shall have to face sums of £179,000, £83,000 and the deductions of the Minister in addition to our own liabilities. Does any man with a sense of justice or right, or with any sense of proportion, think that I should sign for that huge figure and impose it on the ratepayers of Cork County? Remember that nobody can levy on the man who will not pay. You are compelled to levy on the people who have already paid and, as I have already told you, the people in the suburbs of the cities persist in that action. The time will come when that action will bring its own regret.

Comment on this

I have been accused this evening of refusing to vote. At the last meeting of the Dáil, I voted on four separate occasions for this Bill. There was one hopeful note struck here to-night, and I wonder how far it represents the opinion of the Opposition Benches. Professor O'Sullivan told us that this was an exceptional, non-recurring charge. Does he mean that this campaign against the payment of annuities, which was so prevalent in my county, is now going to cease, and that he and his colleagues are now going to advise these people to pay up their annuities? Or is it that he thinks that, because of the Government's agricultural policy, the farmers are getting more prosperous? I wonder which of the two arguments is right, and which of the two arguments Deputy O'Sullivan meant when he said that this was a non-recurring charge. I cannot disabuse my mind of the belief that there was a very definite campaign, of which this is the unfortunate aftermath. I cannot close my eyes to the fact that ratepayers who, in December, 1934, had 7 per cent. of their rates paid in my county, had, in December, 1935, over 30 per cent. paid. I wonder how farmers who were unable to pay in 1934 were able to pay in 1935. How is it that in one particular area the rate collector could only collect, up to a definite date in 1934, 7 per cent. of the rates, while on the same date in 1935 he had over 30 per cent. collected? There is no use in blinding ourselves to the fact that this campaign was going on, and that it was a campaign not alone against annuities but against rates.

Comment on this

In Cork.

Comment on this

I am not speaking of any other place at the moment. That is the place we are most concerned with. Deputy Brennan, when he alluded to this taxation, completely forgot that the bond-holders under the 1923 Act are still being paid in full out of the collected and uncollected annuities under the guarantee given by the Cosgrave Government, while those who purchased under the 1923 Act are relieved of 50 per cent. of their annuities. He quite forgets that portion of the Bill. Not alone under the 1903 Act, but under the 1927, the 1931, and the 1933 Acts, all these bond-holders are being paid in full whether the annuities are collected or not.

Comment on this

What is the amount?

Comment on this

Roughly, £1,000,000 per year. They have to be paid in full.

Comment on this

Who pays them?

Comment on this

The annuities, as far as they go. The annuitants under the 1923 Act, if they all paid, would only pay one-half, because they were relieved of 50 per cent. of it. That is the position which Deputies opposite ignore. Deputy Cosgrave, when the 1923 Act was going through the House, insisted upon the Guarantee Fund being made liable. When Deputy Gorey brought in an amendment, Deputy Cosgrave objected to it and spoke against it. You cannot ignore these facts. When you say that this money is being collected for taxation, or something like that, you completely ignore these facts, and completely ignore the land that is being taken over now from ranchers and others for division. Who will pay the bond-holders in these cases? Where is the money to come from?

I take it that when Deputy Belton, after completely mesmerising the Party opposite into this campaign against the payment of annuities, was removed to a quieter spot, the Deputies opposite, now having a little regard for their responsibilities, are finished with that campaign. Can we take that assurance from Deputy O'Sullivan's statement to-night—that that campaign for the non-payment of annuities is now finished? When he said that this was an exceptional, non-recurrent charge, does he mean that this campaign is finished? It is Deputies like Deputy Holohan, going through the country and preaching that, who have put us in that position to-night, and brought about that £716,000 in unpaid annuities. These are the people responsible.

Comment on this

You were responsible for making the farmers pay three times.

Comment on this

That is the campaign that is responsible for the present position.

Comment on this

It is not responsible. Your policy is responsible.

Comment on this

There is no good in talking thrash. Either Deputy O'Sullivan admits that there was a campaign, and that that campaign is now definitely at an end, or else he admits that the Fianna Fáil agricultural policy is right and that the farmers in future would be more prosperous and better able to pay. Which of the two did he mean when he alluded to this definitely as a non-recurrent charge? What did the rate-collector in County Cork find out when he was only able to collect 7 per cent. of the rates up to December, 1934, and 31 per cent. up to December, 1935? Either that there was a campaign against the payment of rates or that the farmers in his area were more prosperous.

Comment on this

The farmers are not more prosperous anyway.

Comment on this

If they are not, the campaign is over and you have decided to pay up.

Comment on this

The sheriffs are going around taking all the people have.

Comment on this

You can make your speech afterwards. That is the position as I view it. The thing that troubles me far more is the result of all this. That is what we have to set our minds to and find a way out of.

Comment on this

Hear, hear. Come down to brass tacks.

Comment on this

I make no bones about it; I was never any lover of holding the Guarantee Fund or any other fund responsible at any time.

Comment on this

Why did you not vote against it?

Comment on this

That is my business. I thought I did see a way out when the legal adviser to the Cork County Council advised us that we could get away with it, and I voted for getting away with it. I make no bones about it. If I can relieve the ratepayers of my county in any way, I will relieve them. If I saw any opportunity of putting that on other people I would put it on them.

Comment on this

You are reversing your attitude.

Comment on this

Good old Cork.

Comment on this

You were damn quiet in the other counties when we drove the Black and Tans out for you. Deputy Donnelly and others came for shelter to Cork and should conduct themselves.

Comment on this

Send Corkmen to the Six Counties.

Comment on this

We went there before when the Six Counties men ran out of it.

Comment on this

Better tell that to the Minister for Defence.

Comment on this

Please remove the Border.

Comment on this

We can deal with it anyhow.

Comment on this

By shoving it on to someone else.

Comment on this

As I have stated, I make no bones about my reasons for voting for the action to be taken. If I saw any means of relieving the people of Cork of this burden I would relieve them. I cannot see any way out of it. Deputy Cosgrave on another occasion alluded to the large amount of uncollected annuities in 1923. At that time he found a rather clever way out—that the compensation for property destroyed, which was being levied on the rates, should be spread over a number of years at 6d. in the £. He found that way out at that time. Perhaps some way out can be found now in connection with this particular matter. I entirely agree with Deputy Broderick that if the whole of that burden is going to fall on the ratepayers of Cork this year they will be unable to pay. It is the unfortunate aftermath of a definite campaign introduced by Deputies opposite.

Comment on this

You can relieve the burden by voting against it.

Comment on this

If Deputy O'Neill took his part it would be all right, instead of going round the country in a blue blouse like a big baby. Deputy O'Neill should be the last man to open his lips here about it. I ask him not to make me say any more about it.

Comment on this

You can say what you like here.

Comment on this

They are all Corkmen.

Comment on this

I suggest that a way out could be found in that manner. If, as Deputy O'Sullivan says, and as I think he believes, this is going to be a non-recurrent charge, and we are not going to have any more of these campaigns for the non-payment of annuities, then this burden could be met by spreading it over a number of years in the shape of a loan. I think that that is a way out and that it could be very well met in that manner. It is the only way out I can see. Realising as I do that there are still large numbers of unfortunate farmers who have not purchased their holdings, who were forgotten when the other Acts were brought in, and who are now, under the 1933 Act, getting an opportunity of purchasing, realising also that there are large areas of ranch land in this country that must be divided up, and that money must be provided for all this, I think, to use the words of Deputy Cosgrave, that the Guarantee Fund should be held liable, and I think that any twisting that has been done here in this matter, which may have been done for the advantage of one political Party or another, should go by the board. I think that we should set ourselves together at this stage, realising that certain amount of damage has been done, by misguided people, if you like; I will not call them by any harder name.

Comment on this

In Cork?

Comment on this

And elsewhere. You had a few of them around your country, too.

Comment on this

I challenge you to quote one case.

Comment on this

There is a Deputy sitting in this House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not come into this debate.

Comment on this

I am not concerned with the fight between Deputy Davin and the Minister.

Comment on this

It is not a fight; it is a history.

Comment on this

I would certainly suggest that the way out is, that this money should be raised by way of loan and stretched over a number of years. It could be met in that manner, and I do not see any other way out of it. I put that suggestion confidently to the House as one way of meeting it. As I stated before, when Deputy Cosgrave discovered, in 1923, that he was £500,000 out in the land annuities, he took that way out. He knew that the ratepayers could not pay all the arrears of annuities and at the same time meet their ordinary rates.

Comment on this

He was afterwards found out. He was put out for that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Davin can tell us that afterwards. He should allow Deputy Corry to make his speech.

Comment on this

If I were to speak for a week, I could not refer to all the misdeeds for which Deputy Cosgrave was put out. It would take me a year. I am not going to go into that now, but I put forward that suggestion as a fair way out, and the only way out that I can see.

Comment on this
Mr. Broderick

I did not wish to intervene in this debate, but I thought it only fair to reply to Deputy Moore's reference to the good position of the farmers on the western seaboard. It struck me as rather strange that Deputy Moore should travel from Wicklow and leave out all the counties surrounding him—Wicklow, Dublin, Louth and Wexford. He did not refer to them at all; he had to refer to Mayo, Galway and the western coast. I suppose Deputy Moore is of the opinion that the farmers who, as was said of old, had to go to hell or Connaught, could live on potatoes and salt. There is no getting away from the fact that Deputy Moore's policy has put a number of farmers on the western seaboard into that position, and there is no getting away from the fact that the farmers in Galway and Mayo are suffering. The Minister for Finance may tell us here that they have so much of the rates paid. I know the reason why they are paid. The annuities are paid in the same way —through the sheriff. You will find many instances in Galway where the sheriff has called in the case of non-payment of annuities, and where even milch cows are being taken. The children in houses in the west of Ireland have been left without even milk for their tea through the action of the present Government.

That is the position, and Deputy Moore will tell us it was all propaganda. Who started the propaganda for the non-payment of annuities when the farmers were well able to pay in this country; when the farmers were getting at least £7 a piece more for their cattle; when the farmers of Galway were getting £6,000 per annum more for the sheep they exported? That was the time they were able to pay, and who were the gentlemen who went through the country saying: "Do not pay your annuities; do not pay your rates?" What was the idea in County Galway some years ago when military guards had to be sent out with every rate collector throughout the county? What was the idea, and what were the threats behind that? They were nothing but Fianna Fáil threats the whole time. This question of the non-payment of annuities was a Fianna Fáil plot from the start, and the non-payment of rates was theirs also. I know the western seaboard well, and I know how the people there are suffering. I know that the farmers of Galway have suffered to the extent of £600,000 per annum through the loss they have sustained by the 10/- per head on the sheep they exported from that county. It may be information to the Minister to hear that in County Galway we produce threequarters of the number of sheep produced in this country. Out of one year's export— the 10/- per head, and the 5/- per head that his inspectors draw from the small butchers for every sheep killed in this country—we could pay our two years' rates. That is the position in Galway. That is on one stock alone, and I should like the Minister to consider that. The Government might think that we in County Galway are very prosperous because we have a beet factory down there. Whatever the farmers get from beet, they earn it. That is all I can say. Then we have people like Deputy Moore coming from Wicklow to say a word about what is happening in Galway.

I should just like the Minister for Finance to look at one resolution at the recent Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis. I will quote from the statement of a very reverend clergyman there:

"The Very Reverend S. Kelly, P.P., Knock, Spiddal, said he had asked the Minister for Agriculture last year not to impose this 5/- tax on mountain sheep which were worth from 9/- to 10/- each."

That is now the position in the County Galway. On a mountain sheep of a value of 10/-, there is a tax of 5/-. Every sheep that is killed in this country has to bear a tax of 5/-. We have gentlemen going around the country all drawing fairly decent salaries finding out the number of sheep every butcher buys, and every butcher is compelled to pay 5/- for each sheep he kills. It is also clear that on every sheep exported there is a cross-Channel tax of over 10/- demanded by the authorities, and then Ministers tell us that the country is prosperous.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General cited another case, in addition to those already dealt with and disposed of, in attempting to prove that retrospective legislation had already been passed in this State. I accept first the disclaimer that had been already made. The fact is that I cited those cases, and if they are any proof what is alleged about them is evidence enough to satisfy anybody that the Government knows on what it is engaged in the present Bill. Whatever dispute there may be in the cases mentioned, there is no doubt in the minds of anybody in this country and there is no doubt in the mind of any member of the Government, that this is retrospective legislation. The Attorney-General this evening read extracts from the speech of the Minister for Finance in 1931. He ignored—or perhaps it escaped his attention—the speech that was delivered by the present head of the Government on that occasion. As reported in column 1395 of the Dáil Debates for the 2nd of July, 1931, volume 39, the present head of the Government, then Deputy de Valera, said:

"I want to say, as far as I am concerned, and I think the other members of my Party, that we are not satisfied with the exception of pending cases. We are opposing on principle...."

Then later on he said:

"The law is as it is, and what it is is to be determined by the courts and not by the wishes of the Minister or anybody else. That is the position...."

Later on he said:

"I am referring to this whole principle of trying to nullify the law as it is, by the power of a majority Party, to make it what I want it to be, and try to anticipate the judgment of a court by changing the law when cases are pending."

That was a pronouncement made by the present head of the Government at that time. He was then in the Opposition. We can test the value of the case that he made to the House by examining the voting lists. I find that he was joined in the vote by only two Independent members of the House and that in the majority vote there was not alone the majority Party but the three Parties. There were the Independent members, there was the entire membership of the Labour Party that was present in the House at the time, and there was the Government Party. It was fairly clear on that, having regard to what is being said about retrospective legislation, that the House was not convinced that it was introducing or passing retrospective legislation at that time. What was the issue that has been avoided in connection with this whole question? The issue on that particular occasion was this: in the case of an estate belonging to a person who died testate or intestate it was discovered after death that the payment of income tax had been evaded during the lifetime of the deceased person. And the law as it was understood to be was that the State had the same rights as an individual in respect of a period of six years to reclaim repayment. The amendment was to the effect that that right would be continued. The case came before the Circuit Court judge, and it was then on appeal. It had not been decided as yet and the point that was put up was that it was only fair to the remaining taxpayers that the same right should run against the estate if the person had departed this life as there was when he was alive. But there were no penalties involved. There was no loss to any person. There was no injustice done to anybody. The State simply entered into possession of what was its, according to the law which had to be vindicated.

What is the case here? We have the principle of opposition to retrospective legislation. We have furthermore got the vote that was taken here in this House at the time, when persons were convinced of not alone the legality but the justice of a claim of that sort against the estate of a deceased person. The people who were responsible for enunciating opposition at that time have taken a different attitude to-day. What is their position at the present moment? The law is this: that at present, subject to litigation in the courts —and it is well known to the Ministry that the court would decide against them——

Comment on this

How would that be known?

Comment on this

Did not the Attorney-General state in this House that he had advised the Minister for Finance that he could not assure him that they were to win?

Comment on this

That is not the same as assuring him that they were to lose.

Comment on this

I would put a lot of money on that particular decision and I do not know anybody outside Grangegorman who would put money on the other side. If there be no apprehension on the part of the Ministry that they will win the case then let it go on.

Comment on this

If there is no apprehension why the Bill?

Comment on this

To resolve doubts. What is the position with regard to this? Have we considered the first principle? They have absolutely abandoned that now. They are no longer standing on principle. As far as they were concerned that was a Party vote and the vote registered against it was not a Party vote There were three Parties voting against them.

Comment on this

Were the Government Whips off or on?

Comment on this

I had forgotten all about the case. The Minister had better ask some person whose sense of recollection is better than mine. But whether on or off, those in favour of the motion comprised three Parties, with the exception of two Independent Deputies, and the Fianna Fáil Party only was against it.

Comment on this

I notice the tellers for the motion were Deputies Duggan and Doyle.

Comment on this

And who were the tellers against it?

Comment on this

Deputies Gerald Boland and Allen.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Party could only mobilise two Independents along with their own Party while the majority Party could mobilise three Parties. So much for principle—for the principle on which they were standing. What is the principle in this Bill? The question is that where the bailiffs and extra police with a decree from the Land Commission fail to collect the annuities through whatever cause — either inability to pay or, taking the phraseology that we hear so much about, objection to pay—then the people who have paid are going to be charged with the debts of those who have been unable to pay. Let us examine the case for a moment. A person is not only to pay his own annuities but also to pay the annuities of those who have defaulted.

Comment on this

I would remind the Deputy that the principle has been accepted.

Comment on this

We are restricting the section now and we are dealing with that portion of it which pertains to the amendment. What is the period under review? The period consists of the year 1934. What was the position of the farmers during 1934? They were able to sell approximately 46 per cent. of their fat cattle as compared with what they were able to sell in 1933—100 per cent. In 1934 the British markets were closed against them and they were able to sell half the number that they were able to sell in the previous year. That has escaped the attention of the Ministry. Though I do not represent an agricultural constituency I had letters from every part of the country asking me was it possible at all to get a sufficient number of licences to enable the writers to sell their cattle so that they would have money to pay their rates. Would any member of the Ministry stand up in the House and say that during that period we got no communication from anybody who had stock and could not sell them? Is it not inevitable that under the circumstances there would be a piling up of arrears?

Mention has been made by Deputy Corry this evening of the Guarantee Fund having been started by me in the 1923 Act. That is perfectly correct; but the circumstances of 1923 and the circumstances of 1935 are entirely different. Nobody knows it better than the Ministers themselves. Ministers do not go about the country saying that the agricultural industry must be made prosperous, that its prosperity is absolutely essential for every secondary industry in this country—Ministers do not go saying these things as the Minister for Agriculture has been saying about the farmers, that they are having a hard time—unless there is truth behind the statement. There is a remarkable difference between the year 1923 and the year 1935, and there is much difference between the undertaking by land annuitants before 1923 and after 1923. They were signed in very different circumstances from the circumstances now obtaining. Will the Attorney-General advise me that if I get his name to a bill for £100 in the bank I can alter the terms of it without his consent or that the bank can postpone the date of payment? He knows it is not the law and it cannot be done and that it breaks the bill.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Since 1923 the tenants do not sign agreements at all.

Comment on this

The tenants up to 1909 signed agreements and the Guarantee Fund was a condition to the whole bargain. If they failed to pay, the Guarantee Fund operated. In principle the circumstances now are altogether different. There are at the present moment four countries collecting annuities. They are paid on the polls of the cattle that go to Great Britain: they are paid on the polls of the cattle that go to Belgium and Germany, but nobody gets credited with them because the cattle are sold at the British price and the British price has the annuities deducted before the farmer gets paid; and then they are being collected there. When Deputy Corry mentioned that we are liable for the dividends on the land bonds, he wanted to know how much it was. It is approximately £1,200,000 a year and the half of that sum is assessed in the Land Commission Vote. But the Government puts into its own Treasury £1,500,000 of the annuities that are in dispute with Great Britain and uses them and, just like all other people who find themselves in difficulties of their own making, they want to know what is the way out of this and where are we going to get the money. Show us, they say, how we can get it from any other source.

I will just put one point to the Government in that connection. This aims to get them the money they want, but it does not ensure that local government is going to be carried on; it does not ensure that the local authorities are going to collect it. In fact, the whole business from beginning to end would remind you of the poetical description of a certain individual — I do not remember all the words or the person —"Providence fortunately fashioned him hollow, so that he might conveniently his principles swallow." Remember, it is not the first time an attack was made on the local government of this country, and the very same means were adopted by the other people to paralyse local government. It was sought to be done by making it impossible to balance accounts financially. Already some difficulties have occurred in different parts of the country by reason of the situation that has arisen out of the Government's policy. If local services break down, the responsibility will be on the Ministry, because they were warned in time and they know themselves as well as anybody that this is entirely due to their policy and nothing else. They have made certain charges against the farmers about refusing to pay. I do not believe these statements about a campaign against the payment of annuities. We heard the same about rates and six County Waterford farmers were paraded before the Military Tribunal. They were kept three or four weeks in jail and then the Military Tribunal found them not guilty. Have you prosecuted any farmers——

Comment on this

We have, and the Deputy is aware of the fact that we have.

Comment on this

We prosecuted one who is the vice-chairman of the Cork County Council.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

We prosecuted several hundreds who were cutting telegraph wires and so on as a protest against the collection of the annuities; we prosecuted several hundreds in a couple of months last year.

Comment on this

And you have none now. This is going to affect £1,200,000. I have often referred to the fact that after 20 years there was a sum involved of £600,000 and now after three gales there is a sum of £1,200,000 due here.

Comment on this

Not now.

Comment on this

There is a sum of £1,200,000 due from the three gales— November of 1933, May and June of 1934, and November and December of 1935. The actual amount is £1,185,000 for those three gales. It may be that you will get in this money. It may be that by reason of the collection of a sum of money beyond the capacity of the people to pay you are going to paralyse their business and, if that is so, it will be a costly experiment. I hope that Deputy Corry's proposal is not going to be adopted in this case. It would be against all the canons of municipal finance to borrow in respect of charges that are assessed in this fashion. From the point of view of law, the ratepayer has a life of 12 months. You have no right to charge next year's rates with the responsibilties that fall on this year's. If this be a debt that you find difficulty in meeting, recollect that your difficulty is not less than that of the local authority in trying to raise the money. I say it is beyond their capacity.

Comment on this

I listened to the Attorney-General speaking at considerable length this evening, but I missed any reference to the position in Mayo. The Attorney-General is a Mayo man, and I often listened with great pleasure when he was referring to the financial position in Mayo, to the honesty and probity of the people of Mayo with regard to their payment of annuities and rates. As a Mayo man, I have the greatest possible admiration for the Attorney-General when he refers to these facts. These are facts of which I am very proud. But the Attorney-General made no reference to these things this evening. I admit he is not a representative of Mayo in this House. He is a representative of some institution that, I understand, in the very near future will cease to have any representation in this House. I will be sorry, for the sake of the Attorney-General, because he seems quite honest and straightforward in his admissions with regard to having advised the Minister for Finance that in the cases before the courts by Louth and Cork there was hardly any doubt but that they would succeed. If I am doing him any injustice, I speak subject to correction. I think, anyhow, that was his statement.

I heard the Attorney-General making a reference to restrospective legislation and he tried to draw an analogy between retrospective legislation relative to the payment of income-tax and retrospective legislation with regard to the payment of land annuities. I think there is no analogy whatsoever. I think the person who is in a position and is liable to pay income-tax should be very proud to pay it. His position is entirely different from the position of migratory labourers in County Mayo who, as the Attorney-General is fully aware, have to cross to England to earn their livelihood and to bring back with them sufficient to pay their annuities and rates. In the very recent past I had some very peculiar experience in connection with this Bill. On the 6th January a notice of motion was due to be considered by the Mayo County Council at a meeting of that body. The chairman of the council is a member of this House. I quite understand his position and do not blame him. I rather sympathise with him, because I fully realise that as a member of this House he was relying upon what he thought was the fact. A notice of motion is entirely different in its character and meaning, of course, to an ordinary motion, because a notice of motion to be effective must be given 14 clear days before the meeting of the council at which it is to be considered. The object of that is because the secretary, if he is not satisfied that proper notice has been given, can reject it as not in order, but if he receives it within the specified time of 14 days he is bound to accept it. The secretary having received this notice of motion sent a copy of it to each member of the council within the 14 days specified, according to the standing orders, but the chairman in order to save his own face and that of his followers had to rule it out on other grounds.

Comment on this

What have we to do with the action of the county council in Mayo in connection with this matter?

Comment on this

I am coming to that point. It was a notice of motion protesting against this Bill. The chairman ruled out that notice of motion although proper notice was given and one of the reasons he gave for ruling it out was that it was not in order because the Bill to which it referred, and which we are considering here to-night, was then law. I refer to that as propaganda and as the kind of stuff that is handed out to the people as a rule in order to deceive them. Personally, I have the greatest possible respect for the chairman of the county council, but for his ruling on that occasion I have nothing but the greatest possible contempt.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This House is not discussing the action of the chairman or other members of the county council. The House is now discussing the retrospective nature of this Bill.

Comment on this

That is what I am coming to.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would like to hear the Deputy relate the attitude of the Mayo County Council to the retrospective character of this Bill.

Comment on this

That was what was before the county council, but the chairman ruled it out because he said the Bill was law. He should have been aware that it was not law. I am referring to the retrospective character of this Bill. I see what the effect is going to be so far as Mayo is concerned. Subsequent to the striking of the rate last year, the sum of £17,240 was deducted from the Agricultural Grant. That sum, I claim, was legally due to the ratepayers of Mayo. But this deduction was made subsequent to the date on which the rates were struck, and no provision could be made for the previous years' rates. Consequently, the sum of £17,240 has to be provided for in this year's rates. As a further consequence, the ratepayers will have to pay, as a result of the rate increase that will be necessary, an additional 1/5 in the £. That is what the deduction from the Agricultural Grant means. We all heard much about the Mayo annuitants and ratepayers in the past. I was glad to hear the Attorney-General pay a well-deserved tribute to the annuitants in County Mayo. They hold first place in regard to the payment of rates and annuities. As a Mayo man, I was very proud to hear our Attorney-General, who is also a Mayo man, pay that tribute to the people of Mayo, but now what do we get in return? This deduction will mean increased rates for the people of Mayo. We heard many suggestions with regard to propaganda as to the non-payment of annuities. Was such an allegation justified in regard to Mayo? Has there been any attempt made to establish an organisation in Mayo to induce people not to discharge their liabilities or obligations according to law? Such is not the case. But I want to bring home what the position to-day is compared with what it was. If the Mayo County Council is to have £17,240 deducted from its grant, what is the only conclusion to be come to? First of all, if the Attorney-General is ever seeking to represent the people of Mayo in this House in the future, I think it is right that the Mayo people should take stock of his action now in regard to this matter. They should ask themselves if it is just that they should be mulcted in this amount of money, having already discharged their obligations promptly.

The Attorney-General got up and spoke with pride, and in terms of great praise, for the people of Mayo; it was well deserved praise. Now we see the position that has been created. No one can allege that there was any person who endeavoured to mislead the people of Mayo not to meet their obligations. I do not think the Attorney-General suggested that anything like that was done in Mayo. But, notwithstanding that, and the fact that the people of Mayo met their liabilities in that prompt way in the past, they are certainly not able to meet these new obligations imposed on them now when £17,240 is deducted from their grant, and which means an addition of 1/5 in the £ this year in their rates.

To try and draw any analogy in respect to retrospective legislation in connection with income tax as compared with land annuities is a gross absurdity. I am not suggesting for one moment that the people of Mayo met their obligations as a result of anything they succeeded in making out of the land. A very big percentage of the people of Mayo cross every season to England to work as migratory labourers. It is the result of their work there that enables them to meet their obligations. There is no county in the Free State that contributes more in the way of tariffs, unless Galway, than Mayo, because it is the congested area with a huge population that contributes most in this direction. Needless to say, a man with a little holding in Mayo, with a wife and ten children, is contributing as much to the payment of tariffs on the necessaries of life as a man in Roscommon with a valuation of £100. That is conclusive evidence that it is the congested counties that are making the greatest contribution to the millions that come into the Exchequer as the result of tariffs.

That is a fact known to everybody. Everyone with any sense of reason knows that every farmer in Mayo who has anything to sell has to do so at the lowest possible price, while his requirements in the way of tea, sugar, tobacco, clothes, boots, hats—everything necessary for his house and family—is bought at the highest possible price. Never before did the people of Mayo have to pay higher prices for necessary commodities, except in war time. Take the case of flour. We are paying 9/-per sack more for flour than we would be paying with normal competition. We have not normal competition. We have protection and control, and the control is tantamount to dietation. We have a veritable dictatorship and nothing else. I want to enter my protest, as one of the representatives of Mayo, against the decision to deduct £17,240 from the ratepayers of the county in respect of last year. The Bill before the House is a most cruel infliction on the people of that county, who met their liabilities very well in the past.

Comment on this

The last time this Bill was before the House I tried sincerely to state the position of the county councils and bring it to the knowledge of the House, apart from the polemics which are usually indulged in here. So far as one can ascertain privately outside in the Lobbies, individual Deputies of all Parties are agreed that county councils are in for a very severe time indeed, in view of the provisions of this Bill. That is a mild way of describing the position of the local authorities. The position of a county council cannot be summed up here adequately in view of the tremendous difficulties with which they are to be confronted. Everybody knows that there is nothing more crushing or demoralising than for two or three persons to come together, look at one another and say: "What can we do when we have no money?" I can appreciate how the Minister for Finance feels when demands come in from other Departments and he sees that cash is short and that times are hard. But he has his remedies. How will county councils feel when this Bill goes through? I cannot see public men offering themselves for local bodies in the future if they have to shoulder the responsibilities now being placed upon them. It was really a sad thing, in connection with local bodies, to see certain work which required to be done and certain bills by doctors and officials which required to be paid having to be held up for a considerable time until a certain amount of money was gathered in. If that was the position some time ago, what is going to be the position now? Certain important works will have to be put aside, and certain rate collectors who would like to do their work in a decent, respectable way, who would like to cajole and win over ratepayers to good citizenship instead of bludgeoning them, will have to be got rid of. They will not be able to bring in the amount of money that the conditions will require. I am afraid that the county councils will have to be reconstructed and that personnel and staffs will have to be changed. If we have to set out to make good this sum from those who have already paid, we will have to introduce new methods. The county councils as a body cannot be expected to take the place of the squad. That will be the effect of this Bill.

I cannot express in language which I believe would be understood or accepted in this House what I believe will be the position of the county councils if this measure is passed. A lot of county councils will collapse. They will not be able to face up to the task, and you will not get as candidates for local bodies men who want to assist both from a national point of view and from a local point of view. I am not sure that this meeting is not a mere farce. My opinion, after listening to some of the speeches made from the Government side of the House, is that it was a mere waste of time for us, as members of the Opposition, to come here long distances and to ask to have our words accepted seriously. It is said that in 100 years in another House a speech never won a vote, and in 2,000 years a speech will not win a vote in this House.

Comment on this

As a representative of Cork County, I must enter my protest against the retrospective clauses of this Bill. Members of the opposite Party have spoken of precedents for this legislation, but there is no precedent for it because the conditions now and the conditions which obtained at the time of which they speak are quite different. This burden is being imposed on the people for a debt which the President has admitted on more than one occasion has been collected from the farmers in a more painful way than that in which it was extracted heretofore. I challenge the Minister for Finance or any Deputy on the opposite side to contradict that statement. It is quite enough for a person to pay a debt once, without being compelled to pay it secondly. No purpose is served by trying to convey to the people of the cities and towns, who have no experience of agriculture, that the farmers are in a better position than they were four years ago. It is simply ridiculous to talk in that fashion. The farmer-members of the Government Party know that quite well, if they had the honesty to stand up and admit it. The Minister for Finance, speaking in the Seanad, referred to certain persons in Cork County who he said had conspired to prevent the collection of the land annuities.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The conspiracy, real or alleged, regarding the land annuities cannot be debated.

Comment on this

On this motion in the Seanad, the Minister for Finance used this very same argument.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The matter under discussion in the Seanad was not these commendations; it was the whole Bill.

Comment on this

Am I not justified in putting forward arguments here to show that as a result of these retrospective clauses an extra burden will be imposed on the people I represent?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Quite in order.

Comment on this

The Minister tried to convey to the people that these annuities were not already paid. I maintain that they have been already paid, and more than paid, and while we are not allowed to argue that certain people have refused to pay annuities, I say that the same argument could have been used during the land agitation. There were people in those days, too, who could not pay their rents, but their neighbours, who were not so down-and-out, stood by them. In 1906, I and five others stood up to Sir George Colthurst in an effort to compel him to give us the benefit of an Act passed for our benefit. He selected six of us who were able to pay our rents then better than we are able to pay them now, and he sold our farms in Cork Courthouse and we let them go to the Defence Union in Cork at £5 apiece in order to stand by the people. The same position is being created to-day by a Government which calls itself an Irish Government. I have been with some of these unfortunate people during Christmas. I met some of these people, the most industrious in the world, and it would make you grieve to hear of their sorrowful condition. As a result of Government policy, they have been driven to desperation, and I challenge the President to come down with me and meet those people. I will take him down at my own expense and let him discuss with them their position now as compared with their position four years ago when the Government came into office.

Deputy Moore talks about the benefits conferred on the people in certain parts of the country. Deputy Moore is a happy man. He is a bachelor and he does not know what it is to have to maintain a family. He gets £1 a day here to live and he can get his grub in Dublin for 30/- a week. I should like to see him going down the country and studying the condition of some of these people who have to maintain families and he will realise the hardship which he and his Government are imposing on those people. Deputy Corkery at the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis said—I have not got the quotation now but I am sure he will stand over his speech—that the position was becoming impossible for some of these people, and he asked the Government to set up a commission to inquire into the matter. I now ask Deputy Corkery to have the manliness to make that statement in this House, and to ask the Government, before imposing this burden on the people, to set up a commission and find out for themselves what is the real position in the country. I am not here to bluff at all; I was associated with these unfortunate people during the land agitation, but, God knows, I never expected that by getting our freedom we were going to make slaves of the people of this country.

Deputy Corry talked about the gentlemen in receipt of £1,000 a year and the excuse they give now is that they want to save the taxpayers. They want to save the taxpayers, but they want to compel the unfortunate tenant farmers to pay their annuities over and over again. In many of the cases I mention, the annuity is not more than 50/- a year, and when I was amongst them I asked them how much they used to realise before the economic war started from the spare cattle they produced and each of them said from £50 to £70 a year. Deputy Moore and others talked about the substitutes they have given to those farmers, but what substitutes have they given to these people? They have increased the burden on them. Those people could not carry on at all if they did not buy feeding stuffs, and to-day, for the mixture which the Government advocates, they have to pay 5/- a sack extra. In a great many cases, it means a burden of probably 10/- a week on these people. I put it to the Government that they should accept Deputy Corkery's proposal and set up this commission and find out for themselves the real position in the country.

There is no good in suggesting to these people that they should grow wheat or beet or tobacco. They are not in a position to do so. They find it pretty hard to grow potatoes because the land they hold is simply land reclaimed by themselves and their forefathers from barren mountains. There is not an article which these people consume at present which has not been increased in price as a result of Government policy. They have to pay 10/- to 12/- extra for their sack of flour; they pay 1½d. a lb. at least extra for sugar; they pay 4d. a lb. on tea; and ½d. an ounce on tobacco. Those of them who are not in a position to get turf have to pay 10/- per ton extra as a result of the Government's policy in giving a monopoly to British coal in this country. I find it very had to find any article going into any farmer's house on which a tax has not been put during the term of office of the present Government. I am sure, as other Deputies have said, there is very little use in appealing to the Government, but I support Deputy Corkery's demand that a commission be set up to inquire into the position of the farmers and I will stand or fall by the decision of that commission.

Comment on this

I do not wish to add very much to this debate, but references have been made here, particularly, I think, by the Attorney-General, to the fact that the only thing the farmers were asked to pay was half the annuities. There have also been references, which were promptly ruled out of order, to a campaign that never existed, but which was alleged to have existed with regard to the non-payment of annuities. There was, of course—I will not say a campaign or conspiracy——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If it has been ruled out of order, it is still out of order.

Comment on this

That is the reason I do not want to refer to it. There was a protest, not against the payment of annuities, but against paying annuities four or five times over. That was the root of the whole thing. I will not follow it very far, because I do not think it would be very much use or add anything to what has already been said. The whole fact of the matter is that Cork has come in for a good deal of notoriety. Deputy Donnelly, I think, went back through the years of history and accused us of having always been out for disunity and of trying to break up the great united national advance. I am afraid that even in this debate we cannot get away from the fact that this is essentially a Cork Bill. Looking over the original debate here, I find that this Bill was carried by four votes. On that occasion, I made a great appeal to four Fianna Fáil members of the Cork County Council on the other side and, if they had done their duty, as they promised the people of Cork they would do, this Bill would not be before us now—it would have been beaten.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not before the Deputy now. What is before him is the acceptance or rejection of three recommendations. The Deputy seems to be in a retrospective mood.

Comment on this

With regard to these retrospective sections, I want to come back to the evil that will be done to the County Cork by the rejection of these recommendations from the Seanad. We have heard very clearly from Deputy Broderick what it means for the county. It means more for Cork County than it means for any other county in Ireland owing to its size and importance. One of the Fianna Fáil Deputies, Deputy Corry, has tried to argue or, rather, has howled through a sort of argument in favour of relieving the ratepayers if it can possibly be done, but if Deputy Corry and the other three Deputies associated with him on that side had done their duty by the ratepayers, that necessity for howling would not have arisen. He has told us that he is forced into this attitude by reason of this campaign, but this Bill is going to flagellate not only what he calls the Blueshirt element of the farmers of County Cork, but even the persons who voted for him, his own Fianna Fáil farmers, because the ratepayers of the county must stand up to the rates irrespective of what Party they follow or what policy they adopt. I merely mention this to show that when this Bill becomes law and when it proceeds to impose this burden on County Cork, of which we have heard from the chairman of Cork County Council, we must place the blame at the proper doors. The blame is to be placed on the four Fianna Fáil Deputies of the Cork County Council. They are like the four horsemen of the Apocalypse, going to carry destruction not only to Cork County but to every county council in Ireland and, so far as I can see, to smash the whole system of local administration in this country.

Comment on this

As a member of the Cork County Council, I wish protest in the strongest possible manner against the rejection of these recommendations sent down by the Seanad. As Deputy Broderick, who was chairman of the Cork County Council, pointed out, the rejection of these recommendations will mean the imposition of £250,000 on Cork County this year. The Cork County Council will have to levy that £250,000 along with the great burden that has been placed on the people of Cork already, something like £760,000. That will bring the total to over £1,000,000. It was stated here this evening that there was a campaign in County Cork against the collection of annuities and the payment of rates. I say now that there was never a campaign directed against the collection of annuities or of rates.

This heavy burden which is about to be placed on the farmers of Cork who have already paid their annuities makes them liable for the arrears of people who are unable to pay. Not alone does it make liable the farmers who have paid already, but it makes liable householders in unurbanised towns and villages of the county. There is also the position of the workers, the cottiers, to be considered. They will be faced with an extra burden of something like 11½d. in the £ next year. I say that is most unjust. I would ask the Minister if this Bill is passed through the House, as retrospective legislation, to go further. If these recommendations are rejected, and the Bill passed, as I am sure it will, that result will be secured with the help of four Fianna Fáil Deputies from County Cork who gave their pledge to the ratepayers of County Cork that they would look after their interests as members of the county council. It is with the help of these Deputies that this burden of £250,000 is going to be placed on the hard-working industrious people of County Cork. As I have said, there was no campaign against the collection of annuities or the collection of rates. The people whom Deputy Corry accused this evening of campaigning against the collection of rates and annuities are the very people—the hard-working industrious farmers of the county whom I represent—who are keeping not alone the local government machinery of the county going but also the institutions of the State. Were it not for them, and the hard work they are putting into the growing of beet and wheat, there would be little use in the Government erecting a factory in Mallow. There would be little use in building that factory were it not for the supporters of this Party who are maintaining that factory by growing beet.

I say that this is the most unjust Bill that the Fianna Fáil Party has passed in the three years that have elapsed since they got power in this country. There is one hopeful effect of this measure that I see. This is to my mind the winding-up Bill of the Fianna Fáil Party. If it does cost the country £2,000,000 it will be very cheap for the country if it has as its result the hunting out of office of the Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

Lest all the tears on this measure be shed for County Cork I think we had better at this point switch on to the North and see if any county other than Cork has a grievance in this matter. I took very little part in the discussion on this Bill when it was previously before the House and I intend to be very brief to-night. I only wish to make a few points on it. At the outset, I think the recommendations of the Seanad are very reasonable indeed, and that the Bill should not be retrospective. I am speaking now from the standpoint of County Monaghan. In the discussion in the Seanad, and possibly in this House, I think, it was remarked that in the matter of arrears of annuities, Monaghan ranged amongst the counties that had the least amount of arrears. Our council provided last year for a possible £1,500 of arrears of annuities. As I have said, it is one of the counties which has the lowest amount of arrears. At the same time, we are debited with arrears amounting to £7,800 for the last year, an amount equal to 8d. in the £ on the rates. There is no indication, as far as I can see, that there will be any improvement in the collection of annuities for next year. If we have to strike a rate of 8d. in the £ to meet the deficiency for 1935 and another 8d. in the £ to meet the deficiency for the coming year, that will mean that we shall have to provide a total of 1/4 for these deficiencies in the next rate estimate for the county. That is a very substantial amount and the Government should take it into consideration.

Possibly we stand in a better position than most counties on the question of arrears, but even that amount will make a substantial demand on the rates. Inside this House, and outside it, I have heard Deputies again and again blame the British Administration and the Cosgrave Administration for the method in which they dealt with the arrears of annuities. That method of taking the money from the grants was condemned in all moods and tenses as not being an equitable one. I do not profess to be able to put my finger on the records, but I go this length and say that it was my impression when the 1933 Land Act was going through this House that the Government meant to make a change, and to have a more equitable distribution than their predecessors in this matter. What is said now is that the Guarantee Fund Bill meant to make it clear that it was to be retrospective in its effects. I submit that that is very unfair. Farmers who will be the sole victims in regard to arrears of annuities are not the people who created the trouble. I do not say that they are all free from blame, but anyone who has a substantial stake in the country, anyone who owns land and tries to carry on farming did not press for withholding the annuities or for what has arisen. The cause of the default was not in the hands of people who had a stake in the country, who are now popularly described as "the men in the front line trenches." In that way I say it is unfair that they should be made responsible for the whole of the deficiency.

I am not disputing that the Government represents the different classes in the State but, if in their wisdom they embark on a certain policy, it is most unfair that one section of the community should have to bear the burden. If times were prosperous with the farming community there might be an argument for that. I am sorry to have to refer again to the position farmers are in, as regards ability to pay not only their own annuities but the annuities of those who default. Since the Government came into office the cost of every item in their means of living has increased. Only last week flour cost 16/6 per cwt., when the right price would be 12/-; sugar cost 4/6 a stone, when the right price would be about 2/4. The correct price of meal mixture is £5 a ton or 10/- a bag, but in County Monaghan it is 15/- or 15/6 a bag. I do not suppose that Monaghan is worse off than other counties. All the implements used in agriculture have been taxed, even the spade, which is the lowliest implement in use; also plough parts, forks and manures. Almost every article, whether of wear or food, is dearer, making in one way or another for a higher cost of living. On the other hand, what is produced on the land brings a lower return. I submit that to put not alone future arrears on the ratepayers, but to make this charge retrospective, is most inequitable. Farmers can only meet their liabilities from what they produce they can only pay the annuities out of what is produced on the land. Owing to the special import duties operating in Great Britain everything produced on the land brings in a lower price. It was pointed out here to-day that we are getting £6 a head less for full-grown animals. That question has been ventilated in the past couple of months. To put the whole burden of this economic dispute on poor struggling farmers is beyond reason.

It will have the effect of seriously upsetting local government administration. As the Government professes to be a popular Government, carried on by the will of the people, I am sure it is not their desire that there should be commissioners or dictators in several counties, and that they are prepared to carry on local government administration by local representation. If these burdens are thrown like bombshells upon the counties it will make conditions intolerable, and I do not think we can have smooth running of local government machinery in future. The efforts of those who are trying to carry on agricultural schemes are being undermined by questions like this. People responsible for the striking of rates are hesitating now, because they feel they are putting an undue burden on the shoulders of those who have to pay. It is rather queer that in the year 1936, after all the struggles— whether one agreed with all the methods or not—of the farmers for ownership of their land it is now impossible for them to hold it. In my opinion we could get no more effective way of dispossessing the tenants than by making it impossible for them to meet their demands out of what is produced on the land. I do not want to make any speech in bitter terms. I am speaking of facts. I have reason to know the bulk of the people that I work amongst in the course of my business, and I say that the Government should seriously consider the position in which these people find themselves. I have never been one to obstruct the Government, but when things are becoming impossible, and when it is very hard for our people to carry on, I respectfully say to the Government that they should not let this Bill be retrospective. Whatever may be done in the future, let us not have to budget for bygone things. If the Government does that I think the country will take it as a gesture that they have at heart the interests of those who are struggling hard at present, and they will have no cause to regret it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister to conclude.

The Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) rose.

Comment on this

Is not this Committee Stage?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Even in Committee, if no other Deputy offers, the Minister in charge is called upon to conclude. If any other Deputy wishes to intervene now I shall see him.

Comment on this

This debate, like the conversation between the carpenter and the walrus, has concerned itself with many things. Let me recall the attention of the House, however, to the ostensible purpose of this discussion. It is to consider recommendations which, it is assumed, have been sent back to us by the Seanad that, in sub-section (1) of Section 1 and sub-section (2) of that section, the words "whether before or after the passing of this Act" should be deleted, and to substitute therefor the words "after the passing of this Act." Now, what would be the effect of accepting the Seanad's recommendations? It is clear that, if we leave out the words suggested, that would prevent the validation by this Bill of what has always been the practice in this State. The Bill has been condemned on the ground that it is an example of retrospective legislation. What it proposes to do, however, is not to upset the established order, not to interfere in any way with what has been the uniform practice, but merely to declare that what has been done with the full knowledge of this House, with the full knowledge of the public authorities involved in this litigation, with the full knowledge of those who have been the beneficiaries of the public moneys, will be declared, since it is alleged that doubts exist in regard to it, always to have been valid and legal.

It is nonsensical, of course, to try to put a Bill with that purpose on the same plane as the retrospective provision of the Finance Bill of 1931. Deputy Cosgrave, in the course of his speech this evening, referred to that particular measure, and tried to justify it. I think the House might be interested to know the grounds upon which at least one member of the Oireachtas, who was then in opposition, opposed it. The proposal then was to deal with the estate of a man who was dead—of a person, not recently deceased, but who had been dead, I think, for such a time in fact that the assets of which he died possessed had been distributed to his heirs. Here is what I said in opposing the Measure:—

"For one thing, the deceased is no longer in a position to put himself right with this State. His widow and dependants are, possibly, not in a position to redress the wrong which has been inflicted. They may find it difficult to provide for themselves, let alone to pay, if you like, for the sins of the father; and, for that reason, there is a good deal to be said for the law as it originally stood."

Now, not merely was this the position, that here was the case of a widow and orphans and of an executor who had distributed assets; not merely was that the human element in the situation, but there was also this: that the executor in this case had actually got a decision of the courts in his favour. Here the position, as I shall show, in regard to this Bill is quite different. For one thing, the courts have not yet decided the point of law involved, and it is not true to say that the Executive has been advised that the decision of the courts is likely to go against them. There is, as the Bill itself admits, some doubt in the matter, but the doubt is not a grave one. Nevertheless, the circumstances in which this action has been launched make it, I believe, imperative on the part of those who are responsible for asking the Dáil to vote public moneys in this matter to take steps to terminate this litigation and not to allow it to proceed further.

Let me remind the House of what the facts are. Every year since the establishment of the State, the Dáil has voted certain sums in relief of the rates on agricultural land, and every year, in voting those moneys, the Dáil has understood that these grants were hypothecated for the purposes of the Guarantee Fund. In the course of the earlier stages of this measure, I have already referred to the statements which were made by several members of the Government as to the position in which they thought the Guarantee Fund was placed by the Land Act of 1933 and by the Land Purchase (Annuities Fund) Act of the same year. Nothing was said by any Government spokesman—certainly, nothing was said either by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health or by the Minister for Finance, who has personal responsibility for asking the Dáil to vote these moneys—to lead the Dáil or the local authorities or the local ratepayers to believe that the position was in any way changed or that the basis upon which these grants were being made to the county councils was being altered. On the contrary, speaking in the Seanad on the 22nd March last, on the Second Stage of the Central Fund Bill, when this question of the Guarantee Fund was raised in relation to the question of the Agricultural Grants, I said:—

"So far as we are concerned, the Guarantee Fund is going to operate. We want to make it quite clear that the man who wilfully withholds his annuities is not penalising the central Government, but is penalising his honest neighbours who are willing to meet the obligations they undertook when they applied for and were granted a parcel of land by the Land Commission."

On this basis, and with this view——

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir, I think we were prevented from discussing the general purposes of the Guarantee Fund—that is my recollection of the discussion—and the Minister himself was the gentleman who drew our attention to it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Quite, but the Minister—I am waiting to hear the conclusion of his argument—is, in the opinion of the Chair, arguing that this Bill should be retrospective.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir, that is the purpose of my argument. On this basis, and with this view of the position, the Government asked the general taxpayers to provide sums ranging from £1,750,000 to £2,198,000 each year since 1932. That was the position until May of this year when two counties, Cork which was to receive £226,000 and Louth which was to receive £39,000, commenced a suit to declare that the Guarantee Fund did not apply to these grants. Now, these were people who already were the beneficiaries of the Dáil to the extent of over £265,000. Having enjoyed the benefits of the arrangement by which these grants were voted, on the understanding that they were hypothecated to the Guarantee Fund, they now took an action to repudiate their obligations.

Comment on this

The Minister is not now dealing with the retrospective clauses.

Comment on this

I am going to show why if I will be permitted.

Comment on this

You will be permitted to show why.

Comment on this

I said they now initiated an action——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It must be clearly understood that there must be no reflection on the Chair direct or indirect. There is only one method of challenging the ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this

Having, as I said, enjoyed the benefits of the arrangement they now proceeded to repudiate their obligations under it. The Government was responsible for providing these moneys.

Comment on this

On a point of order, may I suggest that the plaintiff, who is at present before the courts, having repudiated his obligations, is prejudging the issue that is still before the courts?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair stated when the Bill was originally before the House that it was regrettable that a certain court case had to be referred to, but I am afraid that was inevitable.

Comment on this

I am not objecting to the case being referred to—that certain people have repudiated their obligations. It is the manner of the reference to the case that I object to, not to a reference to the case.

Comment on this

Quite obviously Deputy O'Sullivan does not want to hear the argument as to why the retrospective provisions in this Bill ought to be adopted by the House.

Comment on this

That is what we are waiting for.

Comment on this

This was the position: two public authorities had secured from the Dáil upon a certain understanding £265,000 of the taxpayers' money. The Dáil, having voted it, these authorities came along and asked the courts to declare that the understanding which had always governed these grants, the understanding which had operated since 1923, because from the point of view of the Opposition it is important to know this: that until Section 12 of the Land Act of 1923 was passed by the Dáil it is doubtful whether the Guarantee Fund existed in this country or not.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The existence of the Guarantee Fund does not arise.

Comment on this

But, in any event, since the Guarantee Fund did exist, and since the Dáil saw fit to apply it to these grants, could any Government which had been responsible for asking the Dáil to vote public moneys upon certain conditions stand by and allow those who had accepted the grants upon these conditions to go to the courts and ask the courts to break the contract, because that is what is involved here? That is why I say that it is nonsensical and hypocritical to endeavour to put this Bill, and the purpose of his Bill, upon the same plane, say, as the retrospective provision in the Finance Bill of 1931 which endeavoured to reverse the decision of the courts given in favour of a widow and orphans and of an executor endeavouring to discharge his trust to a deceased person.

I say these county councils have moved the courts to relieve them from the obligations which, it is understood, they were under in regard to the Guarantee Fund in relation to these grants for the relief of local taxation. But, at whose expense are they going to do it? This question has been discussed in this House by the Opposition in a frame of mind that would suggest that they believed that, if the county councils were going to be relieved of all their obligations in respect of land annuity arrears, we were going to get a free gift of £716,000 from some undesignated source. Of course they know — Deputy Haslett knows and Deputy Davis knows and other Deputies who sit in this House for constituencies in which on the whole the people have endeavoured to discharge their responsibilities to the extent of their ability know—that that is not so: that if we did not make this legislation retrospective, and that if we did forego £716,000 of public money in favour of the defaulting counties someone would have to pay it, and that those who would have to pay would be every man, woman and child in this country—the general taxpayers.

Now, I have referred to the position in the County Monaghan and the County Mayo. Let us see what justification there would be for making the general taxpayer in Monaghan and Mayo shoulder a large part of this £716,000. In Monaghan the amount of arrears of land annuities uncollected on the 31st July last represented 7 per cent of the total collectable since November, 1933. In Donegal the arrears were 8 per cent. and in Mayo 11 per cent. On the other hand, in Cork they were 43 per cent. and in Tipperary 51 per cent. Now, I say that in Monaghan where the arrears were only 7 per cent., in Donegal where they were only 8 per cent. and in Mayo where they were only 11 per cent., we may assume that at any rate in these counties the honest people had paid to the best of their ability. In so far as they did fail to pay, the ratepayers of these counties had been penalised, as Deputy Haslett has just recounted to the House, by the fact that their share of the Agricultural Grant had suffered a corresponding reduction. I assume that Deputy Haslett will agree with me that, having paid once, the ratepayers, who are also taxpayers, in County Monaghan ought not to be asked to pay twice.

Comment on this

It is the same way with the annuities—we paid three times.

Comment on this

I say that, in so far as the annuitants of county Monaghan had failed to pay, the ratepayers of that county had already been penalised to the extent, we will assume, of about £6,500—that is the amount of the accumulated arrears that stood against them. In Donegal it was £9,000 and in Mayo it was, I think, about £22,000. In addition to having paid this, if the contention of the county councils of Cork and Louth were accepted by the court, or if, having been accepted, we had deferred bringing in this Bill until after the decision, and had omitted the retrospective provisions in accordance with a recommendation which might then come from the Seanad (if the Seanad were in existence), or in accordance, say, with and amendment to be proposed by Deputy Haslett or Deputy Davis—what would be the position of the unfortunate ratepayer in County Monaghan, who is also a taxpayer?

I have gone to the trouble of making some calculations and I find that if the position in respect to arrears of annuities—when we came to give effect to the decision of the court and the provisions of this hypothetical measure, which did not contain these retrospective provisions— had been as it was on the 31st July of last year, every man, woman and child in County Monaghan would have additional taxation imposed upon them at the rate of 9/- per head and, instead of that unfortunate county having to pay something between £6,500 and £7,000—I want to make the figure as comprehensive as I can—in respect of defaulting annuitants, that it would have to find £30,000. That is the position which Deputy Haslett has been advocating to-day— That instead of having to pay £6,500. Monaghan would have to pay £30,000.

Then we had Deputy Davis and the Mayo County Council. Deputy Davis was pathetic. He looked like a sorrowful knight as he stood there complaining and bewailing the sad plight of Mayo. He told us that it was a congested district, heavily populated by people in very poor circumstances, who contributed in tariffs and by way of indirect taxation more than their fair share of the burden of the whole community. Yet what was Deputy Davis advocating except that Mayo, which, in present circumstances, might have suffered in accumulated deductions a loss of about £22,000 of the Agricultural Grant, was now to exchange that for a burden in indirect taxation amounting to £88,000.

Deputy Davis had a great deal to say about the chairman of the Mayo County Council. If the chairman of the Mayo County Council prevented that body from passing a resolution demanding that the retrospective provisions of this Bill should be deleted, then the chairman of the county council did his duty to the ratepayers and the taxpayers of Mayo, because he prevented that county council from being stampeded by the dishonest propaganda of Deputy Davis and those associated with him into demanding that the burden upon the people of County Mayo should be increase fourfold, because that would be the effect if the retrospective provisions of this Bill were to be dropped. In short, what the county councils of Cork and Louth were demanding, what Deputy Davis is pleading for, what Deputy Haslett has advocated, what the Opposition, including, I think, Deputy Broderick of Cork, are going to vote for, is that county councils which have already discharged their obligations in relation to land purchase should make themselves responsible for the debts and obligations of other county councils which have endeavoured to repudiate their liabilities in that regard.

Deputy Davin and Deputy Broderick said they did not stand for the principle of making one man responsible for another man's debts. Deputy Broderick, and the other Deputies of the Opposition who have spoken this evening against this Bill, are supportings the county councils in what amounts to a demand that the men and women of Monaghan, Donegal, Mayo, Cavan, and all the other counties in which people have endeavoured to pay their land annuities and discharge their obligations to the Land Commission in respect to the holdings which they are purchasing, should be responsible for the debts of the men and women of Cork and Tipperary who have not paid.

As far as we are concerned, we are not going to ask the general body of the taxpayers to accept responsibility for the obligations of ratepayers in certain counties. Those ratepayers were always thought to be liable to the Guarantee Fund for the payment of the annuities. Every year, as I have already stated, the Dáil voted large sums of money to assist those ratepayers on that understanding. Every year recourse was had to the Guarantee Fund to make good any deficiency in the collection of the land annuities, and advances to the county councils were reduced accordingly. It was on the understanding that this was the correct position of the law, that this was the position as accepted by the Dáil, and that this was the position as the recipients of those grants were understood to accept it, that those grants were made. Yet some of those people who have received benefits on foot of that understanding come along afterwards, and ask the courts to declare that this understanding is illegal, and should not be honoured— but, mark you, only after they have benefited by it. I say that good faith, honourable dealing and honesty demand that the provisions of this Bill should be made retrospective, and that those people should honour the obligation upon which they accepted the money.

I am not, and the Government is not, minimising the seriousness of the position which has been created in certain counties. I hope that this discussion will be beneficial.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

——and that it will bring home to the ratepayers that the people responsible for the position in those counties are those who have refused to pay their annuities. Although we have heard a great deal about the sad plight of those communities, we have not heard anybody who is opposing this Bill get up and say that those people ought to pay their annuities. We have not heard Deputy Dillon get up in this House, or address those outside it with whom he is associated, and say that the vice-chairman of the Cork County Council, or ex-Deputy Brooke Brasier, or Mr. Cussen, or any of the other people who served a term of imprisonment for conspiracy to prevent the collection of annuities, should abandon this dishonest campaign.

Comment on this

They have paid their annuities three times over and you well know it.

Comment on this

Nonsense!

Comment on this

Many suggestions have been made——

Comment on this

A Chinn Comhairle, I think it is unfair for the Minister to introduce the names of outsiders who are not here to defend themselves.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not advisable to introduce the name of any outsider who has no remedy against privilege.

Comment on this

I think it should not be allowed. It is in very bad taste. The people whose names he has mentioned are honourable men who were helping to build up the State when he was trying to break it down.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants me to go further I will tell him about certain Deputies in this House who might pay their rates and annuities.

Comment on this

Then say it out; do not half say it.

Comment on this

There are no such things as annuities now. It is a land tax.

Comment on this

Many suggestions have been made as to how this position might be dealt with. I say it is grave; I say it is serious; but I say also that the remedy lies in the hands of those who man the county councils which are principally affected. It is extraordinary that the problem does not arise in the same acute form in regard to the collection of land annuities in counties like Monaghan, Cavan, Donegal or Leitrim.

Comment on this

They have the great smuggling industries.

Comment on this

It is extraordinary that it arises in an acute form in only certain counties. As I said, the people who are in power in those counties have the remedy in their own hands. We have been asked here by Deputy Broderick of Cork—whose reasonableness in this matter I think everybody in the House will acknowledge, but who is put in the position of the devil's advocate, trying to do his best for his county and for the body over which he presides in a position in which I am sure he finds it not with his consent and not with his connivance—to deal with this by granting a loan. What would that be but to give effect to the principle which he himself has already repudiated—the principle of making one man responsible for another man's debt? If there is a loan it is the general taxpayer who will have to foot the Bill. It is he will have to make provision every year to pay off the loan, and to pay interest on the loan. It is on the general taxpayers, many of whom do not own, as I said before, a square yard of earth in this country, upon whom the burden will fall heaviest. As we do not accept the position that the general taxpayer should be called upon to redress a situation which has been created by a section of recalcitrant annuitants in this country, I certainly do not think that we can consider or would consider the proposal of Deputy Broderick.

Comment on this

And Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry's proposal, if I understood it correctly, was that the Cork County Council might be given authority to raise a loan. That is quite a different matter.

Comment on this

He supported Deputy Broderick.

Comment on this

Deputy Broderick's proposal was that a loan might be given by the Government of this £716,000. I understand that Deputy Corry's suggestion was that in order to deal with the position in which it now finds itself the County Council of Cork might be authorised by the Minister for Local Government to raise a loan for its own immediate needs. That is quite another matter, because the people and the ratepayers of County Cork would be accepting responsibility, and would have to bear the expense of that. It would be brought home to the ratepayers that the people who were imposing the additional charges for interest upon the ratepayers of the County Cork were those who had associated themselves with this campaign for non-payment. We are asked in short to deal with the whole of this position as if it were an exceptional crisis. There is a very serious objection to that, because that in another way amounts to a demand that the general taxpayer—who has been adversely affected already, who has been grievously and seriously affected already by the non-payment of those annuities, because we have had either to increase the general burden of taxation in order to make good this deficiency or we have had to borrow money to make it good—should now be asked to indemnify those who have been responsible for the non-payment agitation against the consequences of their campaign of sabotage and the damage it has caused.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have prevented two Deputies from discussing an alleged or actual campaign for the non-payment of annuities and the Minister should not discuss it further.

Comment on this

It has been argued here—I am not certain whether you were in the Chair at the time—that we ought to raise this money and make a free grant to the county councils of this £716,000, because we had failed to pay, and that after all it was not fair that the man who had paid should be called on, as has been said here to-day by some Deputies, to pay twice and even three times. I have a great deal of sympathy with that position. From the point of view of the man who is aggrieved by it, I do think that he has a right to feel very strongly. I do think it is a terrible position for the man who has paid his annuities and his rates to look across the road and see there his neighbour perhaps who has not paid one penny, and he has to pay the full burden of that other man's default.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I agree, but Deputy Davin's position is not to relieve the man who has already paid his annuities but to increase the burden on him.

Comment on this

Collect the annuities yourself.

Comment on this

Not only to increase the burden, but to put it on him as a taxpayer. It is really only the difference between tweedledum and tweedledee.

Comment on this

Do your own job.

Comment on this

Very well. It has been advocated from the benches opposite that we ought to remit £716,000; that we ought to delete the retrospective provisions of this Bill because we have not done our own job. We have tried our best to collect the annuities and we will collect them. But there is one thing that we think would be more effective than special squads and bailiffs and sheriffs and that is to make these people who have not paid their annuities, and who have been responsible for creating this position through not paying their annuities and who have given a bad example to the general body of annuitants, responsible directly for their actions. I understand that many of these defaulting annuitants who have been responsible for £716,000 of arrears, are men of substance and I think that before this year is out we may be able to bring a measure into the Dáil which will satisfy the demands of the Party opposite. A measure by which the responsibility for non-payment will be brought home to these people. A measure by which any person who has been aggrieved in any way by the non-payment of the annuities, whether as ratepayer, recipient of home assistance or as one of the workers under the county councils who, we were told to-day, will be paid off if these annuities are not paid, will be given the right to go to any of the defaulters in the area and demand that he should make good the loss that that person has sustained. I hope when we do that we will receive the unanimous support of this House.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does the House desire that the vote on the three recommendations should be taken together?

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 71
·
Níl 63
Result _

Do you agree with this result?