Death of his Majesty King George V. - Imposition of Duties (Confirmation of Order) Bill, 1936—Second Stage.
Contributions 1–145 of 467. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 10 of 1936 ›
Is it clear that there will be no limitation in the time for the Second Reading of the Bill?
Comment on this
I indicated when this matter was mentioned first that I hoped we would be able to finish the discussion and take all stages of the Bill to-day. I understand that the Whips have been discussing the matter and that it has been indicated that we are prepared to allow the discussion to hold over until to-morrow if it is necessary, but, seeing that we have discussed this question so many times, it ought to be possible to dispose of it to-day.
Comment on this
The motion, "That the Bill be now read a Second Time," and the two amendments will be debated together. The question to be put is: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Comment on this
The purpose of this Bill is to confirm the Emergency Imposition of Duties (No. 97) Order, 1936, made by the Executive Council on the 18th February. That Order, not being an Order merely revoking wholly an Order previously made under the Emergency Imposition of Duties Act, 1932, will, in accordance with sub-section (2) of Section 1 of the Act, have statutory effect for only eight months after the date of making, unless confirmed by an Act of the Oireachtas. The effect of Order No. 97, as the House is no doubt aware, is to reduce by one half the additional Customs duties imposed by paragraph six and the Schedule to the Emergency Imposition of Duties (No. 5) Order, 1932, on certain articles of United Kingdom origin. The articles affected are, as I have already indicated, reference numbers two to seven, inclusive, of the Schedule of the Order and they may be described under the following general heads: (a) ad valorem duties of 20 per cent., which by the Order for which confirmation is now asked are reduced to 10 per cent. on cement, electrical apparatus and component parts and appliances; iron and steel articles, such as machinery, subject to certain exceptions, bedsteads, bicycles, tricycles and component parts; bars, girders, nails and screws; barbed and steel wire; and certain specific duties, principally in regard to molasses and glucose, on which the existing duty of 2/4 per cwt. is reduced to 1/2; saccharine, where the duty of 9d. has been reduced to 4½., and articles, subject to certain exceptions, made from or containing sugar or other sweetening matter, where the former duty of 1/4d. per pound, or 3d. per gallon, is reduced to one-eighth of a penny per pound or 1½d. per gallon.
As to the general question of the effect of the agreement, it is difficult to assess this in monetary terms. While in each case the respective Exchequers will lose by reason of the reduction in the import duties it is obvious that the producers in both countries will gain, and gain considerably, by reason of the extended market which is offered to them. We, on our side, for instance, feel that the new agreement, in conjunction with other measures which the Government have taken, or have in view, will solve the problem of our surplus cattle and will relieve considerably the position in regard to the other agricultural products. I have no doubt that on the other side the British Government, as the other party to the agreement, anticipate that it will have equally beneficial reactions on their coal and cement industries and for their machinery manufacturers generally.
Comment on this
The pact, therefore, will lead to a significant increase in the volume of trade between the two countries. On that basis, it may cost the British Exchequer about £800,000 and ours about £200,000. I mention these figures, however, with the greatest reserve, because of the many incalculable factors which enter into the Estimates. But, though the cost to the public purse on both sides admittedly will not be inconsiderable, neither, on the other hand, will be the public gain.
The agreement has been reached on either side without prejudice to the issues which have arisen between the two Governments. It is an expression, however, of the mutual desire for goodwill and friendly relationship in matters of trade and I am sure that in that aspect it will be welcomed. The Emergency Order, which it is now sought to confirm, gives effect to our side of the agreement, so far as it relates to the reduction of duties, and accordingly I recommend the Second Reading of the Bill to the House.
Comment on this
I move:—
To delete all words after the word "That", and substitute the words—"viewing with the gravest concern the continuing losses to the people occasioned by the dispute with the British Government, the Dáil declines to give a Second Reading to the Imposition of Duties (Confirmation of Order) Bill, 1936, until the Executive Council has given the Dáil an assurance that the Executive Council will now take steps to negotiate forthwith a comprehensive settlement of the matters at issue between the Irish and British Governments."
One would have expected that in introducing a measure which implements, or which pretends to implement, the agreement that has been arrived at between the two Governments, we would have got a much more comprehensive statement on the whole question, particularly having regard to the events of the last three or four years. The basis of this agreement is a violent contradiction of the Government's policy for the last four years. The arrangement, or agreement, takes very elaborate precautions to ensure the payment to the British Government of the sums of money that were in dispute. When this conflict first began the country was told that the main purpose was to ensure, in fact to make certain, that these moneys would not be paid; that even if it were to interfere with our agricultural economy, as it had been known here for generations, even if certain people were to feel the brunt of the enormous losses that would be entailed, nevertheless, the policy of the Government was the determination to ensure a reduction in the value and quantity of our export trade to Great Britain, and the provision, as far as they anticipated—and they were optimistic in their anticipations—of an alternative market for our agricultural produce.
The question before the Dáil is, not whether or not this pact is to be accepted, but rather whether a much better pact should not be negotiated. It is idle for the Government Press to ask such a question as whether or not we are opposed to selling our cattle or exchanging our cattle for coal. That question is put in the early part of the year 1936, when the value of our exports of cattle has fallen catastrophically from what it was when the conflict began and when the imports of our coal bear in relation to cattle something like three-quarters of the total sum involved; whereas, when we began this contest our exports of cattle were in the neighbourhood of £12,000,000 per annum and our imports of coal amounted to £3,000,000. It is well, at any rate, for the country that we are coming to a better understanding of the importance of economic problems and the unimportance of political propaganda in respect of them.
We ought to approach the consideration of this problem bearing in mind what the original intentions were and how far we have departed from them. Agricultural experts, agriculturists themselves, and the vast majority of our people understood and realised the importance of the agricultural economy that there was in this country over a long period, built up with great difficulty and bringing with it a certain prosperity to our people. Some four years ago we were suddenly asked to reverse that particular agricultural economy and to indulge in another. One of the steps recommended and taken was that we should develop our tillage, that we should concentrate upon our tillage and that we should not be too careful regarding the amount of money we were prepared to spend on it. That policy has been indulged in during the last two, three, or four years. It is sometimes described by those in favour of it as a changeover policy.
And what has been the extent of the development of that policy during the period? We have had an extra 70,000 acres tilled in this country. It is quite true that those who are very much in favour of that policy occasionally tell us that we have 200,000 to 250,000 acres under wheat, that our extensions under beet amount to 40,000 acres, and people are led to understand that there has been an extension of tillage amounting to about 250,000 acres. There has been nothing of the sort. The nett increase is approximately 70,000 acres, and what is the cost? It is conceivable that the bounties, subsidies and the other means provided by the Oireachtas for the development of that new form of agriculture amount to something like £6,000,000 per annum—a colossal sum of money. But when examined in relation to the prices that are received for agricultural produce, one is shocked at the enormous fall that has taken place during the last three years. Calculations were made during the years 1911-1913 on a certain parcel of agricultural commodities and that standard had been taken at £100. When the Government took up office here in March, 1932, the equivalent parcel of agricultural produce stood at the price of £113. The average price of the very same parcel of agricultural goods for the ten months of last year, as recorded in official publications, amounts to £81 12s. 0d., a drop of close upon £19 per cent. in respect of 1911-1913. Along with that the agricultural industry has to meet heavy expenses— the enormous cost of living expenses and expenses inseparable from the calling of agriculturists. The index cost-of-living figure is now at 162 as compared with 100 pre-war.
These figures are, on the face of them, sufficient justification not alone for the favourable consideration of the amendment that has been proposed here to-day, but they are an unanswerable case for the acceptance of that motion by the Dáil. Going further into the question of the change, as it is called, one is rather shocked to find the small increase that has taken place in the number of persons engaged in agriculture. That there has been an increase nobody denies. The figures are published by the Government and they can be consulted. But any increase that has taken place that is of moment or importance at all has taken place in the families of persons who are engaged in agriculture, not in the number employed. If we exclude those who are described as temporarily employed, the increase is extremely small. Males 18 years and over employed in agriculture in 1931 were 84,497; the number of males 18 years and over employed in agriculture in 1935 was 84,916. The number of persons temporarily employed in agriculture has gone up from 56,000 in 1931 to 60,000 in 1935. But mark the difference in the wages that have been paid in the period. The average weekly wage paid in 1931 was 24/3. The average weekly wage paid in 1935 was 21/3. So that a larger number of people have had to divide amongst them a smaller amount of money. Obviously on these indisputable facts the financial condition of agriculture to-day bears no comparison with the financial condition of agriculture four or five years ago.
There was a suggestion in the beginning of this conflict that there were alternative markets, and so there were alternative markets, but they are negligible in their value, and although there are no sums in dispute between this country and Germany and although there are no sums in dispute between this country and Belgium and no sums in dispute between this country and Spain, we might as well, so far as prices are concerned, have the same dispute with those three countries as we have with Great Britain. British prices rule the market. It was only last week we were told here in respect of the export of something like £50,000 worth of eggs to Spain last year that we paid in bounties £18,000. In respect of the sale of something like £21,000 worth of eggs the previous year we paid £15,000 in bounties.
Let it be understood that it is not for the purpose of scoring political points that we mention those things. It is because of the compelling necessity of the needs of the country at the present moment, needs inseparable from a continuance of the conflict, that we urge that there should be a better agreement than the one arrived at and that there should be a more elaborate means than this of paying the British whatever sums are in dispute between the two countries.
From an examination of the official publications recording our assets abroad it is to be noted that there has been a reduction in our reserves abroad of a very large figure. There has been a fall from £88,000,000 to £74,000,000. The normal person in the country does not perhaps understand what is meant by sterling balances. Those sterling balances stood some few years ago as high as £91,000,000. I am not taking that figure. I am taking the figure of £88,000,000 and that figure was reduced by something like £1,000,000 from October down to December. The fact is that from whatever cause—and it is admitted that it is due to the low value in money that we have received for our agricultural exports—we have to call upon these reserves that we have abroad in order to offset the adverse balance that has been obtaining in this country for the past few years. A reduction from £88,000,000 to £74,000,000 probably indicates to some people that there are five years during which we can go on in the same fashion. But it has a bigger moral than that. Once those reserves are being eaten into you are not alone reducing the wealth of this country, but you are bringing about serious damage to its credit.
The situation has certainly changed during the last three or four years. This Pact is an admission on the part of the Government that they cannot do without the British trade. All the criticisms we listened to during the General Elections in 1932 and 1933 were all for popular mob consumption. We are now getting down to brass tacks. The Government have subscribed to the fact that this cannot go on and, so far as trade, industry, employment and the wealth of the people are concerned, we keep our place in that market. They have bartered the whole of our coal requirements, one-third of our cement requirements, iron, steel, electrical apparatus and other goods and our complaint is that, having been brought to a realisation of the importance and the necessity of our export trade, they do not go a step further and negotiate a settlement which will ensure for the agricultural industry a price more commensurate with its needs and requirements.
Those palliatives which have been introduced and those bounties which have been paid have, in their main incidence, affected a negligible number of agriculturists. Take the principal item, the extension of the sugar-beet growing. There are 55,000 acres utilised out of approximately 12,000,000. There are only 55,000 acres deriving the benefit of that particular extension. What is the cost? I know what the Government estimate of the cost is. It is £25 an acre. Let us remember that, having provided for the owners of the 55,000 acres the bounty of £25 an acre, there are approximately 12,000,000 other acres in respect of which it is impossible to make any such contribution. Tobacco, about which we heard so much, is a negligible industry in so far as the number of acres utilised is concerned. There are less than 1,000 acres and the cost is approximately £20 an acre.
In the course of the lessons that have to be learned in connection with this problem now facing this country, a problem the evils of which are not to be met with to-day, but which will affect the country long after this Government has passed away, we had the inauguration of a new system of disposing of our cattle. I refer to the slaughter of calves. At a time when the cattle breeds in this country had no equal in any part of the world, this Government authorised the slaughter of 660,000 calves. Anyone who considers the position must be shocked when he realises the loss to the country through the slaughter of these calves. If the slaughter of the calves had taken place at no cost to the State the position would have been bad enough, but when one learns that the slaughter actually cost the country £200,000—it cost £200,000 to commit that crime against nature—why, it seems almost unbelievable.
For some years a controversy has been going on in this country regarding our currency. Though the Government have been four years in office, they have taken no steps to disconnect our currency from sterling. We are in what is called the sterling block. There is another block called the gold block, and then there is the American dollar. By this time Ministers must have realised that the sterling block is something of importance in the normal world economy, and that any money that leaves that block does not strengthen it, financially or otherwise, unless enormous advantages are derived by its leaving; in other words, for goods that could not be procured elsewhere. The extension of our external markets during the last three or four years at the price of £10 for £1 is a weakening of that sterling block where we have parked our reserves, liquid and cash and otherwise, and where the vast savings of our people have been invested for generations. It may be a matter to smile at, but it is a matter of some importance, more especially when one realises that in respect of the sterling block which you are in and of you are trying to make a bargain and you are recommending this bargain as having been made with advantage to our people.
One is astonished in looking over the returns and seeing the enormous sums paid out from this country for the non-sterling block people and the small amount of money that comes into this country from those people. This particular pact would remind one of a reluctant patient of a dentist who, having found where the dentist lives, almost backs into him, takes the chair, opens his mouth, points out to the dentist where the tooth is that he wants extracted, and then commends his soul. That is what the Government are doing with regard to the disputed sums in connection with this pact. The whole proceedings are painful. The collection of the moneys is painful, but they are submitting to it. The pact has one particular weakness. It has very much the appearance of having been a Treasury arrangement on both sides. The Minister informed us that the British may lose £800,000 per annum in connection with this transaction. If they get within the deduction of £800,000 from £5,000,000 they are at no loss; they have collected their whole sum. They have not made and they never made provision for what is called the sinking fund of the land annuities, so that the pact, so far as they are concerned, gets the last penny. It is on the face of it quite clear that the whole scheme had in mind the one thing, getting in the money, getting it in, if you like, as easily and as inexpensively and as advantageously as it could possibly be got in respect of the sale of British goods.
There is an item in connection with the pact which does not appear in the Bill but which I propose to put in order by saying that the comprehensive settlement envisaged by my amendment would bring it within the ambit of this discussion. There has been a reduction from 40 per cent. to 20 per cent. of the duty on horses.
I have not heard a single person throughout the length and breadth of this country who does not condemn this pact in respect to its indifference to the horse breeding industry. That industry has been built up here over decades of years through the initiative, enterprise and knowledge of Irish breeders. It is in respect to that industry the greatest blow has been struck by reason of this conflict. Not alone has there been a reduction in the number of horses sold and in the price received per horse, but we have also lost some of the best stallions in the world. One of them, by reason of this conflict is dead, a loss not alone to this country, but a loss to the horse breeding industry of the world. There is, perhaps, no animal produced on a farm which gives such employment as the horse. The maintenance of a first class thoroughbred, the Minister for Agriculture was informed some 12 or 18 months ago, took three acres of tillage. Recent events indicate that it is quite likely that a number of buyers who used to come to this country to purchase horses will not do so any longer. This industry, built up over decades of years, has now got a staggering blow. It would well have paid the Ministry, in the making of the pact, to have made some arrangement as a result of which the duty on horses would have been eliminated altogether.
In conclusion, I should like to say that there is a very distinct difference between the Government point of view on government itself and that of the Opposition. My view about government in this country—and I think it is shared by my friends here—is that a contract entered into by a Government in this country binds its successors until it is altered by agreement or denounced. Any other system is bound to break down. It is bound to bring discredit on the country and bound to introduce an unsatisfying and indeterminate character to Government agreements. We say that a favourable settlement is possible, in this instance that it is not alone possible, but that it is almost mandatory upon both parties to the dispute. We say that there is an atmosphere in respect to a settlement now which did not exist previous to this Government taking office, that there are more favourable prospects of a settlement than perhaps existed at any time for the last few years. Recent events of themselves, together with the making of this pact, indicate that, on the British side at any rate, there is a different outlook in respect to the importance of exports from this country. Whether that entered into the making of this pact or not, I do not know and I am not going to venture an opinion, but I do say that it is the duty of this Government, having regard to the state of affairs existing in the agricultural industry, having regard to the fact that the livelihood of the people who are engaged in that industry is at stake, and also having regard to the possibility of an improvement or continuation of the secondary industries of this country, to bring about that settlement. If the mind of the Government has gone so far as to make this settlement, which they certainly would not have made four years ago, we say to them that it is not a satisfactory settlement, that it does not end anything, that it does not even make for a more favourable future settlement. Having regard to all the circumstances, to the importance of the problem and the fact that so many people are so vitally concerned with its proper solution, we say that it is the duty of the Government to negotiate a final and satisfactory arrangement with the British Government.
Comment on this
In order to have the main motion and the two amendments before the House, I shall have to call upon Deputy Belton to move the amendment standing in his name.
Comment on this
I therefore move:—
2. To delete all words after the word "That" and substitute the words "the Dáil declines to give the Bill a Second Reading because
(a) it offers no reduction of the gross burden of the economic war which has resulted in a substantial increase in taxation and in the cost of living, and
(b) it abandons the principles for which the economic war was stated to have been embarked on, and
(c) it does not provide for a comprehensive settlement of the dispute between this country and Great Britain."
I shall not have an opportunity of answering the bluff, bluster and misrepresentation that is inevitable from over there. In moving this amendment, which is perhaps somewhat different from the amendment moved by Deputy Cosgrave, I shall take an entirely different line from that which he has adopted. I consider that the business of this House to-day is of no less importance than when the Dáil met at the end of 1921 and the beginning of 1922 to decide whether this country should accept or reject the Treaty. The same principle is here to-day. In my view it is not a matter for decision or discussion here between one brand of economic policy or another, much less a discussion between one form of agricultural policy and another. The question before the House and the country to-day is to consider the greatest betrayal in Ireland's history. A little less than four years ago a dispute arose with Great Britain. The previous Ministry were censured, calumniated and blackguarded all over the country, because it was alleged against them, that they signed a secret agreement with the British. Where is the agreement that we are called on to consider here to-day? Why is it not put before us? Who signed it, and what were the considerations for its signature? There is not a word about that. The members of this House, like a lot of infant children, are being asked to consider a pact, to accept or reject it, without the considerations and the exact terms, or without any knowledge of the persons who signed it on behalf of this country and Great Britain. Whatever is to be said about this, those who signed the Treaty stood up to it. A document was produced, and two men in particular who put their signature to that document stood up to it and gave their lives for it. Now the Government, apparently, is ashamed to produce this pact; and I am not surprised. Less than four years ago the Government claimed that the people gave them a mandate to withhold, from the British, the annual payments contracted for by a previous Government. The Government claim they got that mandate four years ago. They claim further that they got a renewal of that mandate at the 1933 election, and that they got a further renewal of the mandate in 1934, when the Government Party won the local elections. Why is that mandate not now being honoured? We are told that an agreement has been entered into and the advantages are as follows:—Cattle under six months' old, on which there is a special duty will have that duty reduced from £1 5s. to £1 per head. On cattle up to 15 months the duty is reduced from £2 10s. to £2; cattle 15 months and up to two years from £4 to £3; cattle two years and upwards, not mincers, from £6 to £4 5s.; and, two years and upwards, mincers, the duty is reduced from £3 to £2 per head.
Here we have what we are told is a pact, a solemn agreement between two countries. We have not seen the pact but we are told of it. I presume it exists. The Minister for Finance moved the Second Reading of a Bill which will give that pact the force of law in this country. In considering this pact there surely must have been some discussion when the rate of the British penal tariffs was reduced from one figure to another. I should like, when members on the Front Government Bench come to speak on this matter that some one of them would apply himself to this point for that is the whole point of the matter. Let us take one figure and that will settle all. Take the figure of £6 per head, which was the tariff on the older cattle. What was that £6 per head for? To pay the land annuities, and these land annuities were paid at that rate of £6 per head on cattle when a certain number of cattle were going over to Britain. Now more cattle are going over to Britain.
It is quite obvious if a dozen articles are paying a tax to realise, let us say, £24, the tax will be fixed at £2 per unit. If the number of articles is doubled from 12 to 24, then £1 per head will suffice to realise the £24, and to do the same thing. I challenge any member of the Government to stand up and say we have won one penny piece upon this deal. We are sending them more stuff. Britain has over and over again said, through the mouth of her Chancellor of the Exchequer, that what she wants is the amount she considers due to her and no more. We have saved nothing. The Minister for Finance, who moved the Second Reading, did not say that we were going to get a reduction in the gross amount. I am at a disadvantage in not having heard Government speakers upon this, but I hope they will deal with that point and state, in open discussion, the gross value, if any, that this, country gets out of this pact; but even if there is no monetary advantage to this country, as I say there is not, it is beside the point I want to make.
The whole point is that when the President accepted this pact, or agreed to stand behind it and vote for it here to-day, he accepted the right of the British to put this levy on our goods going into Britain in order to pay the land annuities. The President smiles at that. Now this country has been fooled long enough; it is not going to be fooled for ever, and I shall be very interested to know if the President tries on here to-day what he did in his wild, rambling interview with Reuter's representative, and published in his own private paper. The £6, and eventually all the other items produced, must have been taxes, and the President was agreeable to have them amended from £6 to £4 5s. 0d., and so on, in order to enable the British to collect the land annuities. Now when it was agreed that they should collect the land annuities in that way, the matter of principle is gone. When they agreed to that the matter of principle that the President and the members of the Fianna Fáil Party told the people, up and down the country, they would stick to when they started the economic war—the principle that we did not owe this money and that we would not pay it—is gone. If not, why did the President agree to accept the levy upon our goods of £4 5s. 0d. instead of £6? Did he ask the British what was this for? It is simply the acceptance of the principle of paying the land annuities.
The question, then, comes down to this: Which is the better way of paying annuities? Would it not be better for the Land Commission, functioning in the ordinary way, to collect these annuities and send them over by cheque or whatever arrangements might be made? What is the difference? We are accepting, in this pact, the principle of payment. You cannot get away from it because there is a reduction in the amount levied. The matter must have been discussed when you have a figure reduced from £6 to £4 5s. 0d. You have even the odd 5/-. There was no guess-work about that. That was worked out mathematically. It is a very serious matter for this country if this pact is accepted. I am not going to come down to discuss this on the plane laboured in a leader in the Irish Press a few days ago—that because the northern farmers felt they had a grievance, and that the position of their cattle in the British market might be affected by more cattle going from the Free State, this must be a good deal for the Free State. It is far above any little trade in cattle.
Then we come to coal. We are giving to Britain the whole market in coal. We have got nothing on our side of the account. Whatever little reduction there is in the amount levied is made up by the increased number of cattle that will go over. The Minister for Agriculture is aware that, I think it was at the end of 1933, the British got alarmed at the amount they were collecting, and they fixed a quota from 1st January, 1934. I am right in the month; I think I am right in the years. In any case it is immaterial; it is the principle I want to convey to the House. They instituted quotas; they reduced the number of cattle that went over, and yet they found that by the 1st March of that year they had collected about £1,000 more than they claimed was due to them. They then kept matters adjusted, and nowhere have I seen that any responsible British statesman said that they had not collected all that they claimed. On the contrary I think it has been said repeatedly by responsible British statesmen that they had gone fairly level and collected their full demand. Last year we had in operation the Coal-Cattle pact. On foot of that it was claimed that 150,000 more cattle were exported. On each one of those 150,000 cattle a levy was paid to Britain. I pressed the Minister for Finance here on Thursday last, by supplementary questions, to give us information as to the extra amount collected by Britain because of the extra number of cattle that went over last year. He did not know. It is quite clear that in this country there is no record taken of the amount the British are levying on our goods going over. It is quite evident that Britain has a surplus at the present moment, because of the amount of goods that went over from here and on which a levy was collected last year. Under this pact, when in operation, more cattle will be exported to England, if too many calves have not been slaughtered already. Of course it is only now we are beginning to feel the loss in cattle population through the slaughter of calves a couple of years ago. Assuming that we have the surplus cattle to export, a large number of cattle will go over this year, and this again will increase the surplus that Britain will collect by her special duties. Britain simply made a mathematical calculation.
She estimated: "So many cattle and other things will come over during this coming year; we have so much surplus on hands from last year's pact, and we are quite safe in reducing the special duties on Free State cattle coming into Great Britain to the figures of £1, £2, £3, £4 5s. 0d. and £2, and those levies will give us our full demand for land annuities, local loans, and pensions." In passing, I just want to make this comment: with that unequivocal declaration by the British, repeated over and over again, what justification has our Government for collecting the annuities from the farmers of this country?
Comment on this
I did not say anybody asked it. I ask it now and I asked it before to-day. Just before I got up here, I got a message asking me if I could go out and intervene in the case of a respectable farmer in County Dublin. The bailiffs are in possession of his house for non-payment of annuities. Under the pact we are asked to pass here to-day the Government have agreed to levies on our goods going into Britain, in order to pay those annuities, while another wing of the Government puts the bailiffs in the houses of farmers who are paying, have paid, and are going to pay those annuities under this agreement.
Comment on this
Who is too lazy to work? It is well known that the interrupter does not make his living on farming. It is much easier to get commission on an insurance book than to follow a plough.
Comment on this
I should like to ask Deputy Corbett if the unfortunate agricultural labourers in Galway, who cannot find work, are unable or unwilling to work.
Comment on this
If people are willing to work there is plenty of work for them.
Comment on this
Let Galway remember that its representative here informs the House that the whole trouble with the farmer is that he is too lazy to work.
Comment on this
There may be better workers in Galway than I know of. I know that the gentlemen opposite have standardised the value of a week's work at 27/-. That is paid almost beside me. Why should I pay 35/- a week? Let Labour consider and digest that. Why should we in the Dublin County Council pay 43/- a week and pay the sheriff to collect the rates? For the last 11 years during which I have been a member of the Dublin County Council——
Comment on this
I consider this of equal importance with the Treaty of 1921. I consider it of not less importance. I should be glad if Deputies who had the privilege of being Deputies of that time would develop the matter from that angle. The same principle is at stake. What is the economic war? Have we not been told all over the country that it is the age-long struggle for Ireland to get fair play? That war was precipitated in 1932 and has been going on until now. We were looking for and expecting a settlement, and what do we get? The coal-cattle pact. That is not a trade pact. No Iunatic would sign it as a trade pact. Do you think I would sell my potatoes, oats or cabbage, and I will not leave room for an interruption by the Minister, and will say my rhubarb also, to any persons and take something from them on condition that they confiscate 30 or 40 per cent. of my goods? If the Minister for Agriculture has any friends engaged in the buying of agricultural commodities I should like to see him send them to me and ask for a trade pact on those conditions. Will he send them down to his native County of Wexford which he represents and try and do a deal with the Wexford farmers for barley or oats or anything you like on condition that the purchasers in Dublin will confiscate 30 or 40 per cent. of their goods and pay them for the rest at the Dublin men's price? That is precisely the position.
In a very slipshod way cement is chucked in here. I am sorry that Deputy Dockrell is out of the Chamber at the moment. I hope he will develop this, as he probably knows the course of the cement trade better than any other Deputy. A fair computation on a beef-cement basis would be that Great Britain should take 1 cwt. of beef from us and give us 1 cwt. of cement. Will she do that?
Comment on this
It is a thick-headed case if you like. That is not a joke. If we want to make a deal for this country on equitable terms, let us do it on the basis of a fair price. Continental cement is coming in here at about——
Comment on this
Some Minister should have explained the background of the items in this proposed pact. The market here of about 336,000 tons of cement was arranged last year between the Belgians, Danes, Swedes and Germans. The Belgians got 60.5 per cent., the Danes 30.5 per cent., and the Germans and Swedes—the Germans to do the carrying—9 per cent. When they made that agreement they put up the price 6/- per ton on the price ruling last year. Last year Great Britain had about 14,000 tons of our trade out of a total of 336,000 tons. Now she is going to get an increase to about 100,000 tons and she will get about 40/- per ton for it. We have not been told whether there has been any consideration as regards price. If we give Great Britain one-third of our cement market, which amounts to about 112,000 tons, we must control the imports, and when we import, roughly, about 224,000 tons, in order to leave the gap for Great Britain, we cannot import any more from the Continent. Great Britain, then, has a monopoly of that 112,000 tons of cement. She can regulate the price and we must pay it or go without it. Even if we reduce our consumption of cement we are not exonerated, because this pact is to give Great Britain one-third of our entire market, whether that market increases or decreases, and we have no guarantee as to price. I put it to the Government that a fair exchange would be an equal price on a gold basis per cwt. of cement and of beef without any confiscation. That would be an equitable trade agreement and one that we could enter into.
With regard to coal, we could enter into an agreement with Great Britain for certain grades and standards of coal at, roughly, 1½ cwts. of coal for 1 cwt. of beef. Then we would see what we were doing; then we would have made a complete bargain from a trade point of view. But that has not been done nor is it proposed to be done.
I hope that the sense of this House will reject this pact, and that it will reject it as an insult to the House and to the country. You asked to be elected to settle the economic war and you have given us only this pact. If there had been no friction between the two countries one could understand the pact being made. But fancy such a pact between two countries supposed to be at war! Fancy for a moment Italy and Abyssinia going to make a trade pact now. If you make a trade pact, where is the war? What do you get? Nothing. What does the other fellow get? A monopoly for his goods here. The President stated in this House that another Government may pay this money to Britain but that his Government never will. And now he comes in with the flag lowered in this pact. He proposes to pay Britain this money and surrenders the whole case for which he has asked this country to make such terrible sacrifices in the last three and a half years. I should like if Deputies would think about it. If instead of proposing this pact the Government came here and told us what Britain would give them; if they came here and gave us the details and said: "We will not accept it; we ask for a united front in this House." If the economic conditions that produced the economic war were discussed between us and Great Britain I would be surprised if the Government would not get unanimity in this House to tackle that question in a business way. If you can sit down with Britain and discuss the rise and fall in the special duties that she has imposed on our cattle in order to collect the land annuities, and you admit her right to levy those duties, why do you not settle down to discuss this entire question of the land annuities that is between ourselves and the British? What sacrifice of principle would it be for this House if, instead of ratifying this pact, it made a gesture and it intimated that the Dáil is prepared to send a number of representatives—two, three, four, five or ten, or whatever number you like—to meet an equal number of British representatives to discuss the whole question of the economic war? What would be wrong in that? There would be no surrender there. If you were prepared to discuss the matter on level terms with the British there would be no surrender. But instead you go through officials, through the High Commissioner and through civil servants and you urge a pact which is a surrender of the principles for which you claim to be standing. Then you come here and ask this House to ratify that, and your President gives an interview to a foreign newsagency, talking tomfoolery about what the Irish nation wants and about the things it wants, while at the very same time this big flag is being hauled down and trailed in the mud by this pact. That is what is being done behind the lines.
I would appeal to the members of the Government to consider this matter very carefully. Through what is little better than mob law, the Government are collecting the land tax after allowing the British Government to get away with the annuities in this way. The Government have the backwash of that now coming home to them. Deputy Everett to-day said that home assistance cannot be paid in Wicklow because of the deductions made from the Guarantee Fund owing to default in the payment of the land annuities. But Deputy Everett voted for that double payment of land annuities. We were told the other day in the County Dublin that £9,000 was being deducted from our proportion of the Guarantee Fund. About £130,000 is due in the rates we are collecting, and we are collecting them now by the sheriff. Before the term of this pact runs out the army of Carpenters, O'Neills, Paddy Killeens, Sergeant McManuses, and Fitzpatricks, who have been picking up the good cows of Munster for a few shillings apiece for the last three and a half years and pushing them over the Border—that army will have to be augmented in order to collect all this Government loot. I ask the Government Deputies to face up to it now. It is about time they did. What happened last year in Cork, Waterford and Tipperary is now starting to be repeated in Dublin, and perhaps my friend from Galway will not feel it until this process moves West. Now is the time to face up to it. I am sorry to have to say it, when you feel you have been beaten, and I do not say that from any political prejudice or bias.
Comment on this
As a statesman, if you like. But I would be sorry to be put on a level as a statesman with the Minister for Agriculture, who stated here last week that he did not bother himself about currency matters—that he had no time for that. Imagine a Minister of any Government setting no value on currency matters.
Comment on this
The Deputy is misquoting me. He had better look up the Official Report.
Comment on this
By no means. I said I had no time for Deputy Belton's views on currency; that is what I said.
Comment on this
The Minister was dealing with the profit he was making out of his trade in cattle with Germany, and I asked him how much of that profit was due to the fact that Germany was on the gold standard and that we were on a depreciated standard. It was then he made the remark that I attributed to him just now. Did those who engineered and signed this pact make any provision, or did they ask the British Government to give us any protection in the British market for our bacon, eggs, poultry and pork and other commodities in which we are competing with Denmark in the British market? I have not heard in this House or outside it, nor have I seen the Minister to say a word about the handicap that we have to suffer in the British market owing to the fact that Denmark is on a more depreciated standard than ours. The Minister knows that the exchange value of the Danish kroner was 18.159 to the £, and he should know that the present exchange value is 22.42. Our exchange value with sterling is always at par, so that the Dane has an exchange advantage over us of 25 per cent. I challenge the Minister for Agriculture to show whether by act or voice he has ever moved to rectify that handicap against which we have to compete. If he sets no value on currency, the sooner he takes cognisance of its all-important, its transcending value, the better. New Zealand has the same advantage, and the Argentine has a 60 per cent. advantage. All the while we here are fiddling about, trying to overcome obstacles such as the British penal tariffs, and survive.
Comment on this
The Deputy would have no hesitation in giving his views on that if the question of depreciation or appreciation of the currency was relevant to the debate. The President and his two colleagues laugh. Will the President introduce a motion in Government time that will make that a relevant matter for discussion? If he does I will very quickly give my views on it; but the President will not give his, neither will the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Minister for Agriculture. They will shout for a Republic, but they will stay anchored to British sterling.
Comment on this
The President laughed at the suggestion that it was not relevant, and I ventured a little further than I otherwise would have gone. Now that you have spoken, Sir, I will not travel on that wrong road any longer. I shall be interested to hear what the Minister for Industry and Commerce has to say on the question of lowering the duty on iron and steel. I looked for competitive prices quite recently and, in the last prices I got for iron goods, British iron goods beat Irish goods in price. They were of quite as good quality, even though there is 75 per cent. of a protective duty on the Irish goods. These are going to be reduced. If the prices were honest on both sides and the British prices could jump a tariff wall of 75 per cent., and compete with the Irish-produced article, when that tariff wall is lowered how long will the industry that has been built up within the last few years survive? I leave that to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to explain.
I am opposed to the Second Reading of this Bill because, as I have stated in my amendment, it abandons the principles for which the economic war was stated to have been embarked on. You have compromised on the principle. Now, it is only a question of amount and, when it is only a question of amount, sit down and ascertain the amount. There is no more principle involved. There is a slight difference in my amendment and the amendment moved by Deputy Cosgrave. In his amendment he states: "Until the Executive Council has given the Dáil an assurance that the Executive Council will now take steps to negotiate forthwith a comprehensive settlement of the matters at issue between the Irish and British Governments." I would not accept a promise from the Government. I would not give a Second Reading on a promise by the Government to take steps to settle the economic war. It is long overdue and the Government should submit to the House the terms on which they propose to agree to settle the economic war with Britain. In the last two or three elections they said to the electorate: "Elect us and we will settle the economic war; we will withhold the annuities." I fear that if we give a Second Reading to this Bill on the promise of the Government to negotiate a settlement, the House will be let down by the Government, just as the country has been let down by the same Government in the rash promises they made, not one of which they have kept.
When you abandon the principles for which you claim to have been fighting, then there should be no patchwork settlement considered or accepted by this House. In fact, it is an insult to this House and the country to put up a patchwork settlement. Put up, as is claimed in the two amendments, a comprehensive settlement, and then we can consider whether it is worth accepting or whether it should be rejected. But nothing else should be accepted meanwhile. That is the view I take. I can say this to the Government, that I felt sure it would come to the point we have reached to-day. There was a difficulty in rousing this country to a sense of its duty until a certain point had been reached, because in this country the Party that waves the flag highest and sounds the tin can loudest will always get the largest following. Some of the bubbles had to be pricked and the principal bubble is now being pricked, or it has now burst.
Comment on this
You have agreed to pay the annuities. A Deputy behind me says that the farmers are burst. If they are, they have only to thank themselves, because 50 per cent. of them put the Government in here on the promise that they would settle the economic war. It is the best day's work the Government ever did for this country, when they would not settle the economic war, to come out in the open and deliberately lower the flag. They are forced to do it and they are doing it in this Bill. Now, the country can see the Government for what they are and judge them by their promises and by their accomplishments. If this measure goes through, I am quite satisfied that the farmer who defended his homestead against the tyranny of evicting landlords in the past, the farmer who faced the battering-ram and the sheriff's bailiffs in the defence of his home, is not going to allow those new emergency men from around Jonesboro' and Dunleer, who are coming in to buy the seized stock of the farms, to carry on much longer. The farmers are going to move forward right now.
We shall see, when the few farmers who are opposite go down to their constituents, what explanation they will give for agreeing to paying England the land annuities through tariffs. That, in my opinion, is the principal item in this pact. The proof that it has been considered and accepted is in the revision of the tariffs. Last year, though obviously the matter was considered, we had not that proof, because the tariffs had not been revised. They are being revised this year, which shows that they must have been discussed and the new ones accepted. These tariffs are here for a purpose, and that purpose is the same as if the Land Commission transferred a sum over to the British Government, as had been done before the advent of the present Government to power. I am satisfied that the passing of this pact, and the acceptance of it by a vote in this House, will be a signal to the farmers of this country to forget their political differences. I shall be very much surprised if that will not be manifested in every county in the Free State before a month. If we are going to pay annuities, we are not going to pay them by a tariff on our cattle on the one hand and by direct payment to the Land Commission on the other hand, and suffer a reduction on the home market at the same time of £4,000,000 or £5,000,000 on our gross sales for the year. If the annuities are to be paid there will be one payment and that payment will be a direct monetary payment.
The Government said they would never pay these annuities, but they are now eating their own words. This Bill, in my view, is the death-warrant of the present Government. If they cannot produce anything better than that after four years they ought to go out of office, and the sooner they get out the better. They will find when they go down the country that they will get a very different reception from the reception which they got on the last two occasions that they sought the votes of the people. Why should they not? The intelligence of the people would have evaporated if they allowed this humbug to go on any longer. They were told that the present Government would never accept the principle of paying these moneys to the British, and here the principle is accepted in this Bill. The big thing in the Bill, I repeat, is that the Government has accepted the principle of paying the British. All the other trimmings that can be woven around that central fact are of very little importance compared with it. I shall be terribly interested to see how many of the Government spokesmen will deal with that point. I shall be very glad to see how they will wriggle out of it. It will take all the bluff, bluster, and misrepresentation that the Minister for Industry and Commerce can command to get around that. It is put up very straight to him now and let him answer it. The Minister for Finance will try to get out of it, but he cannot get out of it because it is there. I am harping on it because I do not want Ministers to evade it and run off on some other question such as whether we could grow beet or tobacco or whether we could produce snuff.
The cause of this war, in reference to which we hear so many military terms, was that we would not pay the British these moneys. Now we have agreed to pay them under the pact, and the Party which accused Deputies on this side of the House of being Imperialists, and who said that we wanted to deprive the people of their natural birthright, is the Party that puts forward this pact. They talked about confiscation, and we had all this rigmarole that we read of 40 years ago about the land of Ireland being for the people of Ireland to have and to hold. If the land of Ireland belongs to the people of Ireland and is held from God alone, etc., why are we paying these tariffs to England? Why are the Government that shouted "No surrender" for years and taxed the producers in this country in such a way that they can only collect rates and annuities with the aid of the sheriff—after I have finished here I have to interview a man in whose house the sheriff is at the moment——
Comment on this
They are on the way to a man who was on the Minister's platform in the last election but he will never be such a fool as to be there again. I shall be very interested to see how that point will be tackled and how it will be answered. I have no doubt that it cannot be answered. I have no doubt, either, that the farmers of this country are going to speak in no uncertain way in the near future, particularly those farmers who were deluded and deceived by the present Government in the last few elections. These men have sought explanations of the discrepancies between the election promises and the actual facts. These men are now disillusioned. Perhaps it is a godsend, a blessing in disguise, that the accumulated stupidity of the Ministry produced this abortion, the coal-cattle pact, and that it will provide the epitaph which, on some glorious day, we shall write on the tomb over the Fianna Fáil Government—"R.I.P. Killed by the second dose of the coal-cattle pact."
Comment on this
I cannot cover the very comprehensive field covered by Deputy Belton in his speech. He took us to New Zealand and the Argentine.
Comment on this
He discussed the value of the kroner, currency, and other things. I shall confine myself just to a few of his arguments. This is nothing but a trade pact, the same as the Government made with Germany recently, the same as the Government made with Belgium and with Spain. It is a trade pact with Britain and nothing else.
Comment on this
Deputy Fagan, I dare say, stands for Deputy Belton's arguments as to the non-liability of the landholder to the State for any obligation whatever. That has been defeated here and in every country in the world. If there is no liability on the holder of land to the State for the rights and privileges he enjoys of holding land, then the State can step in and take sites for cottages or other buildings, and can give the occupiers of uneconomic holdings sufficient land to make them economic. The Opposition seems really to be concerned with the question of how much the occupier will get for the land, and that they are dealing with a free market in land. Where is the standard of morality there, and where is the logic in that? What right have such people to put a price on land if they deny their liability to the State? They talk about the action of landlords in the past but they want to be in the same position as the landlords were in the past. But the fact is that the landlords are gone and we can never again go back to that system.
Comment on this
Deputies opposite are talking about an economic problem that was there for generations.
Comment on this
Their economy is the economy that came in with the famine in 1847. It had been there for generations, but you cannot send the people away to-day in the coffin ships.
Comment on this
The lands were let go out of production in Westmeath. We heard yarns here about farmers being broke. Many of them are broke, but when did they start to get broke? They started to get broke because of the depression following the Great War. Many of them are sunk in the banks of Meath with frozen debts which they are unable to pay.
Comment on this
The farmers were able to pay their interest until the Fianna Fáil Government got into office.
Comment on this
May I ask Deputies to listen carefully to Deputy Kennedy's speech. It is really well worth listening to.
Comment on this
Thank you, Deputy O'Sullivan. Deputy Cosgrave spoke about the amount of employment given on the land. When you carry out drainage schemes or repairs to bog roads, or carry out work in connection with the development of peat etc., you are of course carrying out agricultural work. This Government has found work for everybody, and they have provided them with sustenance when they had not work. Will anyone deny that?
Comment on this
The Deputy will have a right to put his own ideas before the House in due time but he ought not to interrupt Deputy Kennedy.
Comment on this
Deputy Cosgrave spoke about popular, mob consumption, and about certain things consumed by the mob. Of course he is above that kind of thing. But the mob are with us and must be provided for and the full resources of the State have not been harnessed yet or not nearly so to provide for the mob. A much greater mob can be provided for than the present scanty population of the Twenty-Six Counties. We could support four or five times that population. This Government has the right to do that, and it is out for it, and it is making history in that direction.
Comment on this
To the blind everything is blind. Deputy Cosgrave also spoke about outside investments that depreciated from £88,000,000 to £74,000,000. But that applies to every country in Europe. It applies to a much greater extent to America, and the question is has it been stopped yet? Has it been stopped in the States and stopped in Europe, but it is a far away argument from the main point with which we are concerned here. Deputy Cosgrave said there was an additional 55,000 acres of land in tillage. I contend that an acre of tillage gives far more return than an acre of grazing. An acre of tillage would sustain a family, or go near to sustaining a family. Will Deputy Fagan deny that? I must say I was not fully prepared for Deputy Belton. He gave such a comprehensive survey of everything that I cannot follow him through all his arguments. I was only concerned with what he said about the annuities. I finish by saying what I said in the beginning: this is only a trade pact, the same as the Government has made with Germany and Belgium and consequently it should get the full support of the House. This is the second trade agreement with Britain which is beneficial to this country as the previous one was beneficial. It is also well that we should realise that this is a free nation, bargaining with another free nation— a thing that never happened before in 700 years.
Comment on this
I wonder whether the Government as a whole are quite as ashamed of this pact as the manner of the Minister for Finance when introducing it would lead us to believe. I think this House has rarely heard a more shamefaced introduction of any important measure than we listened to to-day from the Minister for Finance. I could understand if, adopting the general policy of his leader, the President, he said nothing. But he did try to say something about this particular measure which he has recommended to the House. Apparently in his cold blooded opening statement it was impossible for him to work up the slightest enthusiasm for the particular pact he is recommending to the House, and no wonder.
I have no doubt that by the time he comes to reply he will have got a fair amount of fire and eloquence to come back with, but I do believe that the Government themselves know that the position they are in and the pact they are recommending to this House is not a position and is not a pact that can be stood over. One thing, however, emerged clearly from the Minister's very brief statement, and that is that at least the Government have secured that the economic war is to go on. This pact has been made, according to the Minister, without prejudice. What does that mean? The war is to go on. We have secured that. That is the final touch, so far as the Minister's speech was concerned. That is the principal message he had to give to this House and to this nation. The agreement was made without prejudice. Translated into ordinary words what does that mean? That the war is to go on.
This is a fantastic kind of war. While the war is on the two parties to the war enter into negotiations with each other, the one side consenting to the number of casualties which the other side can inflict on it. And yet the war goes on. We say to the British: "Last year you inflicted more casualties on us than you undertook to inflict; therefore, this year inflict less." But remember, that is not to bring about peace between the two countries. The war must go on. This is, as I say, one of the most fantastic wars in history that is now being waged by this Government and by the Government of Great Britain. They make a pact which, as Deputy Belton has very clearly demonstrated, practically agrees to the amount that Great Britain is to levy out of the produce, particularly the agricultural produce, which is sent from this country to Great Britain, and yet they are too proud to make peace. All that they will do, as I say, is to make an agreement as to the exact amount of casualties that will be inflicted by Great Britain on this country. That is what the pact means. It is because it means that, because it is a refusal on the part of the Government, even at this hour, to face up to the real situation, that we put down the amendment which is on the Paper. We see here in this particular pact the same callous disregard of both the interests of the people and the honour of the country. The war is to go on! We have achieved that. That is what we are particularly proud of. That, apparently, was the one thing that the Government was keen on—seeing that no matter what agreement was come to with Great Britain, as regards the trade between the two countries, the war was still to go on. The deal was made without prejudice. And yet this has been described as a business deal. It has been described by Ministers as a business deal. It is described even in this House as an ordinary pact. It is not an ordinary pact, because it is made between two countries that are professedly at war, one with the other. How can that be an ordinary pact? It is not an ordinary pact, because one of the circumstances which influenced one side to the bargain was the scaling down of the amount that the other side would pay by way of duties. There was a discussion of that. The figures must have been debated between the two parties. You may say that that is not an agreement between the two Governments, namely, that in this way the amount withheld by this country from Great Britain is to be collected. You may say that, but every person in the country knows that the realities are on the other side. What else does it amount to except that?
Camouflage it as much as you like, we are accessories to that collection, and we are trying to throw dust in the eyes of the people. The Minister for Finance, in his very brief introduction to this Bill, most characteristically, and yet in a way that throws light on the whole situation, passed over one side of the bargain altogether. He told us of a number of instances in which there would be a decrease of from 20 per cent. to 10 per cent. in the duty on British goods brought into this country. I am not aware that he dwelt on what we were getting from Great Britain in return for that concession. That modesty on the part of a Minister who generally is not slow to express his views, even in strong language, was certainly striking. No wonder he was ashamed. How could he pretend that it was anything—the very figures show it in effect if not in mere words— except an agreement with Great Britain to collect that much? It amounted to saying to the British: "That is all you say is due to you. Very good; collect it off our produce going into your country. You are collecting at the present moment more than you said you would ever try to collect. Scale it down to the amount of the moneys withheld and we will give you a concession in those other matters." Get over it by words if you like. What is that but being accessories to the collection by Great Britain of those land annuities and the other withheld payments?
Great Britain set out to collect a certain amount. She never held that the Government there was in any way liable to the bondholders for the sinking fund. The amount she set out to collect was something about £4,300,000. The fact shows that the duties she put on realised more than that. Apparently she was quite ready to keep her word that she would only collect the amount withheld. Therefore there was always there, for any Government that would merely ask for it, an obvious concession that the amount of duties on our produce going into England should be scaled down. That stood out from the very moment it became clear, as it did from the British returns, that £700,000 more than the amount which Britain wanted to collect was actually being collected. From that moment the scaling down of the duties was inevitable, and we have now let our policy be determined by the fact that Britain agrees to scale it down to the amount she said she would collect in return for the moneys withheld. To call this a mere business pact, such as that between ourselves and Spain, is simply doing what the Government always does—ignoring the essential facts of the situation. But it reveals one thing. It reveals the complete bankruptcy of the Government policy, a policy which unfortunately has nearly meant the bankruptcy of the country as well. The one thing that ought to be clear now, not merely to "Free Staters" and "Fianna Fáil-ers" but even to republicans, is that the bankruptcy of the Government policy has been demonstrated. All for what? To get in by this agreement to a market that we were told again and again was gone. The Minister for Industry and Commerce several years ago told us that we were entitled to a larger share than we had in the British market without paying anything whatever for it. We are now paying, and paying pretty dearly, even to keep our hold on a portion of the share of that market that we had before.
The head of the Government, speaking in a town in which he does not always make important speeches, namely, Ennis, in the month of August, 1933, said: "The British market would never be the same as it was in the past. The cry to restore that market was just as a child might say `give me the moon'." The children are ready to pay now for their bit of the moon. It is no longer childish; it is now statesmanship and good business. I can say for everybody on this side of the House that we should be delighted if we thought that business considerations on business matters really influenced the conduct of the Government. How can we believe anything of the kind when we see them trying to cover over the wound and leaving the wound unhealed, and probably in a more unhealthy condition in the long run than it was before?
The following day, speaking in this House, the President, as reported in Volume 49, Column 610, of the Official Reports, said: "So far as I can see, the British market is gone for ever." That is the policy that was announced and these are the considerations that were the basis of that policy when this economic war was started, and when it was already over a year in operation. "The British market was gone, and gone for ever." They are now lowering the flag that they hoisted in this House some three and a half years ago in order to keep some grip on a market that is no use, on a market that is gone for ever. As to our dependence on that market, the President was also glad to say in the same place that he thanked God that that situation is changed. Has any Party in this country demonstrated more clearly than the Government Party, and has any policy demonstrated more clearly than the Government policy, our dependence, to some extent at least, on that market? What does the pact we are discussing mean except our dependence on that market? We were promised various other alternative markets. We were told that they were to be had, and on one occasion the unfortunate Minister for Agriculture told us he had them, but he would not reveal them. That was about two and a half years ago. These alternative markets of any value are yet to be found.
As I say, this pact is a clear indication of two things: (1) of the value of the British market that should have been clear to everybody in this country from the very start; (2) of how essential that market is to the prosperity of this country. That is the significance of the wretched pact we are discussing to-day. What is this pact for in the midst of war? Is it to enable us the better to fight that war, to keep it on a little longer—the war that the Minister who introduced this Bill to-day boasted in his speech at Bantry was already won? There were several statements from the two Ministers, whom I see sitting opposite, three years ago that they thanked God that the worst was over. I do not want to weary the House with quotations from their speeches, but everything they said when this war was embarked upon has been falsified and everything they said has been gone back on now.
The Minister for Finance said:—
"Every organ of economic thought in Great Britain has stressed the fact that, whatever the temporary inconvenience caused to Irish producers may be, a tariff, whether it be 20 per cent., 40 per cent., or 100 per cent., if they choose to erect it as high as that, will be paid inevitably by the British farmers and consumers."
Has the experience of this country in the last three years borne out that statement, or has it borne out what was clearly pointed out from this side of the House, that this tariff would be paid and paid only by the Irish producer? It should have been obvious to anybody at the time who wanted to look at the facts, but that is the last thing that Ministers want to look at. As I say, the war was won as far back as 1932—the worst was over! Deputy Donnelly thinks it was won in 1932, but we are still fighting it.
Comment on this
It was won in 1932! I know that Fianna Fáil cannot distinguish between not losing a war and winning it. It is the same thing to them. It is the same thing whether we continue waging it or not. Being at peace and at war is the same thing. On the 6th December, 1932, the Minister for Industry and Commerce said: "I think the worst is past." I am satisfied with the Minister's words. I am not commenting upon them. I shall let the country judge as to the value of them.
Comment on this
The Minister is going to be more vocal in interruption than he was in introducing the measure. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said:—
"I think the worst is past. I think the effort of the British Government to force us to accept their views in the dispute by economic pressure has already defeated itself. From this on we can contemplate a continuing improvement in the position, and the necessity, if I might use that term, for an agreement with Great Britain at all is, day by day and week by week, growing less urgent."
We had a pact 12 months ago, and we have another pact to-day.
"We have already passed the worst of the position, and that fact will enable us, under present circumstances, to contemplate entering into agreements with other countries, involving the concession of special privileges in our market for the goods of these countries formerly supplied from Great Britain."
So that is the pact we are discussing to-day—the very opposite of what we were told in 1932 was to happen. Even Deputy Donnelly appreciates that. To continue the quotation:—
"——such agreement to have much longer duration than it would have been possible to contemplate last August."
But the Minister for Finance was not to be outdone so far as hope is concerned, by his colleague the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The Minister for Finance, as reported in column 1018, Volume 45, 7th December, 1932, says:—
"I should like to emphasise the statement made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce last night, that so far as the economic disturbance arising out of the land annuities dispute is concerned, the worst is over."
Comment on this
We pointed out here again and again on the various debates on agriculture that even if one looked with favour on the Minister's policy of increased tillage, that meant in the long run an increase in the number of cattle. Increased tillage means the rotation of crops and more cattle. And the very man that drove that home in answer to our criticisms was the Minister himself. The Minister got up on those benches and said that was his policy and it had always been the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party— more tillage, therefore more cattle. But the exigencies of a sound agricultural policy are one thing and the exigencies of the Fianna Fáil Party are an entirely different thing. The same Minister who preached that doctrine here scoffed at his critics because they did not recognise that that had always been the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party. That same Minister some months afterwards said that the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party was more tillage and less cattle. Their policy was to diminish the number of cattle by the slaughter of calves. What is his policy to-day—is it more tillage and more cattle or more tillage and less cattle? His policy has got another dinge in it. The Minister is kicked about from pillar to post. The Minister is not allowed to have a policy. One day he is preaching the slaughter of calves and another day he is trying to resurrect them. He is trying to see that more calves are produced. He says: "Produce as many calves as possible." He says to produce the best quality of calves possible for the country. For what? For slaughter. It is to admit the entry of a larger number of cattle into Great Britain. That is another confession that, so far as the main industry of this country is concerned, the Party opposite has no policy. It changes its policy from year to year. It changes, not in answer to the dictates of a sound agricultural policy, but to the mere politics of the Party. Once more one can see from this pact that cattle are to be a source of wealth. What becomes now of the policy of the slaughter of calves? What becomes of the slaughter of the future wealth of the country? If this pact means anything, it means a larger number of cattle being exported to Great Britain. That may be a relief. But consider the heavy tax on cattle. It shows one the condition to which the policy of the Government has reduced the farmers of this country. Why cannot the Government that negotiated this pact do what the amendment requires them to do—enter on a really determined and honest attempt to get at the root of the whole matter and settle the whole dispute? The Government is conniving—to put it no higher than that if you like— deliberately conniving at the collection of these annuities by the British Government. Why not face up to the whole issue and do what the farmers of the country are expecting them to do—make a decent settlement of the whole dispute?
What were the principal attractions of the original coal-cattle pact when it was first introduced into this House? The condition of the people of this country at that time was so bad, especially the condition of the farmers was so bad at that time, that any relief, even at the high tariff then existing—any relief in the way of an increased market for their cattle was distinctly valued as a benefit for them. Why? Because their position had been made practically impossible by the continuance of the Government policy. The great advantage the coal-cattle pact seemed to have in the minds of the people of this House at that time was that it gave some relief to the farmers, and that was why Deputies gave it a kind of qualified blessing. It seemed also to present some evidence that the eyes of the Government were being opened and that they were really willing to enter into business negotiations with the other party to this dispute. That was the real hope that was held out and entertained during the intervening months by many farmers in this country. And now this is what we have got. All Deputies in this House, no matter to what Party they belong, must have known of the rumours that were circulated and fostered before Christmas, rumours promoted by various members of the Government Party and by their friends through the country, that a settlement, and a good settlement, was coming. I know that we on this side of the House expect to hear that cry every three months. We expect to hear a cry about the marvellous settlement that the country is going to get. Is this the marvellous settlement that Fianna Fáil told the farmers and others through the country was to come? Is this the big settlement? Then, if so, there must be considerable cleavage of opinion in Government circles on that particular matter. I don't believe there is, and, if there is, I do not think it will amount to anything. But if there were a cleavage of opinion in the Government Party, this is just the kind of settlement that one would expect—a half measure, a postponement and a shrinking from the real issue, and a refusal to dig down to the root of the matter and to see whether the evil could not be plucked out by the root. Why must the Fianna Fáil Party always leave things unsettled? This is not even a half settlement. The Government are a Government of half measures at all times. They are half in the Commonwealth and half out of it. They are half Republicans and half Free Staters. This pact is not even a half measure. The Government must, however, always have a carrot to hold before the unthinking. They must make an effort always to placate everybody—Free Staters, the Fianna Fáilers, and Republicans. We are watching this war. We have now been watching it since the summer of 1932. After three and a half years what is the position? That the Government that have waged this war now reveals the strategic weakness of its own position. If Great Britain wanted to collect £1,000,000 a year more than she is actually collecting, she could do it merely by keeping the same duties on and increasing our quotas. Such is the condition to which the farmer here has been reduced, that he would be bound to accept that; he could do nothing else. She does not want to do that. She said she would raise so much, £4,200,000, and she is doing that, and we connive at her doing it.
The one thing you have done by these pacts of yours is to reveal the extreme nakedness of the land, so far as this side of the war is concerned. People in the country and we on this side of the House have been condemned to see the principal sources of our wealth deliberately frittered away, and now there is not even national honour or a pretence of it to be safeguarded in return for that. The agricultural industry is being played with just as the Minister for Agriculture is being played with. He is treated as a kind of shuttlecock between one Minister and another, now announcing one policy and, later, announcing a policy the direct opposite. That is the way the whole industry of agriculture has been treated, and the farmers are expected to rejoice. As a matter of fact, they are being scoffed at by the members of the Government Party when a word is said about the plight to which that Party has reduced the farming community.
So far as the interests of this country are concerned, the abiding and the lasting interests of this country, there is nothing in the pact to make it worthy of the acceptance of the Dáil. So far as national honour, if that was ever at stake—I do not believe it was; I believe it was a mere veil behind which the Party opposite could deploy their forces—is concerned, there is nothing to recommend this pact to the House. In these two respects, in safeguarding and advancing the interests of the country, the Government can at least boast of this. They stand now where they have always stood; they have not advanced one step in trying to save this country or in trying to uphold this country's honour.
If this Party had the propagandist urge that always distinguishes the other side, certainly the conduct of the Government in this matter would resound through the whole country, but not to their credit. Deputy Belton, in the course of his penetrating analysis of this pact, asked the question: Having boasted of the mandate they got to continue the economic war, why is that mandate not being honoured? This is the answer: Because the farmers were driven to the last ditch and the Government found it out and some temporary relief, at all events relief of some kind, was necessary. It was only temporary, it only affected the surface, but that temporary relief was offered by the pact of last year and is again offered by the pact of this year. It is temporary relief for the farmer, but it enables the Government still to carry on the war. It enabled the Minister for Finance, introducing this Bill, to say that this matter is agreed on without prejudice to the matters in dispute as between this Government and the British Government. In other words, the farmer finds himself, as a result of the efforts of the Government to come to some kind of agreement with Great Britain, not in a much better, if any better, position than he was before.
I am not going into the question of the withdrawal of the bounties. The farmer finds himself now in exactly the same position of despair that he was in before, with this addition, that he now knows that his despair was too well-founded, that any hopes he had that this Government was waking up to the seriousness of his situation were entirely unfounded. If he hopes for anything from them in the future, then he is indeed an optimist. The Government will be in the position to tell the farmers of this country whom they have ruined by their policy: "March bravely forward; the war is still on and, as far as this Government is concerned, it is going on."
Comment on this
The agreement which this Bill, if passed, proposes to confirm is, in my deliberate opinion, an improvement upon the previous position, notwithstanding anything that may have been stated to the contrary by Deputy O'Sullivan. Deputy O'Sullivan has, though not in the same words, repeated at least half a dozen of the speeches that he has made here during the past three years. This agreement is an improvement upon the previous position because it enables more of the surplus cattle to find a market in Britain and to find a better price. It is also an improvement, because I understand it will effect a saving of about £400,000 a year, which was previously paid out as bounties on live stock exported to Great Britain. Do Deputy O'Sullivan and his colleagues object to this agreement because it contains an improvement of that kind? I understand that notwithstanding the fact that the bounties will cease to be paid in future on live stock exported to Great Britain, that the price of certain cattle has improved in our markets to the extent of at least 5/- per cwt.
Comment on this
If the Deputy does as I suggest he will probably get confirmation of that statement.
Comment on this
The price of store cattle in the British market has improved, according to my information, and it is reliable, to the tune of 5/- per cwt.
Comment on this
I understood from Deputy Cosgrave that British prices rule our market here. I took a note of that statement. I think the Deputy has sufficient intelligence left, although he has lost a lot of it, to realise that fact. I would like to mention that the introduction of a measure of this kind should be accompanied, if not preceded, by a white, or if you like a green paper giving particulars of every aspect of the agreement. I strongly object to the contents of an international agreement of this kind being broadcast to the people through what is called or known as the Government Information Bureau. If an agreement of this kind is to be treated seriously and if Deputies are expected to come here to discuss it in an impartial and fair-minded manner, I think they should be supplied officially beforehand, at the expense of the Minister for Finance, with the proper type of information. I hope in future that any agreement made with Britain or any other country will be preceded or accompanied by proper official information submitted in a proper way.
I also am of opinion that an international trade agreement of this kind, even though Deputy Kennedy says it is only a trade agreement, should be conducted between the Ministers of both Governments, either in London or in Dublin, in the same way as the Minister for Industry and Commerce is now conducting, on behalf of this Government, negotiations with the German Government. This agreement and the previous agreement have serious national effects and repercussions involving the saving or spending of millions of pounds of the people's money and I do not see why the President, who is Minister for External Affairs, or the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Agriculture should not meet their British equals in London or Dublin, accompanied by their officials, for the purpose of negotiating agreements of this kind. I go further and say this— and it is no reflection upon the civil servants who are really responsible in this case—that, if the Ministers on both sides could see their way to carry out the duties which the people of both countries imposed on them, we would have a better agreement than the present one. The presence at such negotiations of the responsible Ministers of both Governments would have a certain effect, in my opinion, of political importance and significance, and I believe, if the negotiations were conducted by the responsible Ministers, we would have a better agreement than we are discussing at the present time.
Deputy Cosgrave has put down an amendment which, to me, appears to be an extraordinary one. He proposes that the House should refuse a Second Reading to the Bill. I do not think it is a proper amendment to the Bill, but that is a matter for you, Sir, and your advisers. His amendment proposes that the Dáil "declines to give a Second Reading to the Imposition of Duties (Confirmation of Order) Bill, until the Executive Council has given the Dáil an assurance that the Executive Council will take steps to negotiate forthwith a comprehensive settlement of the matters at issue between the Irish and British Governments." Deputy Cosgrave in his speech said nothing whatever about any aspect of the comprehensive settlement except the issue involved in the financial dispute. Why did he not take the House and the country into his confidence as to what was in his mind when he was calling for this comprehensive settlement, and insisting that such a settlement should be effected before this Bill gets a Second Reading? Does he suggest that the financial dispute is definitely bound up with the future settlement of the boundary and with the issue whether the whole of the Irish people have a right, if they so wish to declare an Irish Republic? Does he want the financial dispute, the question of the Border, and the issue raised by an Irish Republic, all discussed at the same time? Is that what is in Deputy Cosgrave's mind when he calls for this so-called comprehensive settlement? If so, why did he not tell the House and the country what he meant and what he wished the Government to do, in carrying on these discussions with the British Government?
I hold the view very definitely, and have held the view since the dispute started, that the financial dispute has nothing to do with the political or the boundary question, and is a matter that should be settled on its own merits, irrespective of any other issue. Deputy Donnelly says "No". The Government of which Deputy Donnelly is a supporter went to the country and got a clear mandate for withholding the land annuities. Nobody knows that better than the Opposition, and if I were a member of the Opposition, and if the Government got that mandate, I would have come into the House and said "The majority of the Irish people have, rightly or wrongly, given a mandate to the Government to withhold these moneys and I am going to back the majority in their fight against an outside Government who claim the money." I believe, furthermore, that the members of the Opposition in any other country of the world would have supported their own Government on that issue against the wishes of any outside Government. If the members of the Opposition were good politicians, they would have done that in 1932, but even to-day it seems they have learned no lesson from the history of the past four years. I feel bound as a minority member of the House to back the Government in the interests of the people of this country against the Government of any outside country which is trying politically to dominate the people of this country. I say that the issue raised by the financial dispute has nothing to do with the possible future settlement of the boundary question. Much as I, in common with other Deputies would like to see that dispute settled, I am not so politically foolish as to believe that the boundary question can be settled at the same type of conference as that at which we can settle a financial dispute.
Deputy Cosgrave comes to this House and with the air of responsibility which surrounds an ex-President, says there should be a better settlement. He does not venture to tell us what is the nature of the better settlement, which he apparently believes can be secured from the British. He goes on to say that a favourable settlement is possible. Will Deputy Dillon, Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, or any Deputy who speaks from the Front Benches opposite, tell us what is in the mind of Deputy Cosgrave, when he says that a favourable settlement is possible. What information has he from British Cabinet Ministers, or any other reliable source, which would show that such a settlement is possible? I should like to believe it. Has he any information as to the conditions under which the British Government will negotiate a settlement of the financial dispute? This is a matter upon which I want an answer from him, and I also want an answer from President de Valera, or any other Minister: is it a fact that the British Government will not discuss a possible settlement of the financial dispute, until a majority of the members of this House give an assurance that we are going to continue to be a baby member of the British Commonwealth of Nations? Is there any condition attached to the opening of negotiations which will compel us to reinstate the oath in our Constitution? Would Deputy Cosgrave, if he had power from this House to go over and negotiate a settlement, which he says is there for the taking, undertake to bring about that settlement and give as a condition for that settlement, a guarantee as to the reinstatement of the oath in the Constitution?
I want to know what is the obstacle to the opening of negotiations in connection with the financial dispute. If President de Valera could tell this House that the British will not reopen negotiations for the settlement of the financial dispute, until we give an undertaking to have the oath reinserted in the Constitution, I have sufficient faith in the Irish people to believe that the Irish people are not going to cow down to political bullyism of that type. The sooner President de Valera lays the facts before the Irish people the sooner he will have the vast majority of Irishmen supporting him on that issue. Would Deputy Cosgrave, Deputy Dillon, or any other Deputy attempt to negotiate a settlement on that basis? On what basis would they undertake a mission of that kind?
Comment on this
Deputy Cosgrave said at one time, that he could go across and negotiate a settlement in three days. He would spend one day in going across, one day in Whitehall, and one day in returning and he would get a better settlement than he got in 1923 or 1926. He would halve the annuities. He gave that promise in 1932, but even that had not the slightest repercussion on the electorate as to his point of view. I want to know now on what grounds he suggests that a favourable settlement is possible.
Comment on this
I leave Deputy Morrissey and his Party to answer a straight question. Perhaps the Deputy does not know what is in Deputy Cosgrave's mind.
Comment on this
If Deputy Cosgrave, who is a responsible leader and an ex-President of this State, makes a statement of that kind I am entitled to ask him to tell the people of the country what are the grounds he has for making that statement. And what is his answer when he suggests that this Bill should not get a Second Reading? It is that it should not get a Second Reading until there is a comprehensive settlement of the matters at issue between ourselves and the British Government. Perhaps Deputy Morrissey would enlighten us on what that means?
Comment on this
It would be impossible to enlighten me upon the Deputy's policy or the so-called policy of the Blueshirt Party. It has been suggested by Deputies on the Opposition Benches, and by Opposition speakers in the country, that the members of the Labour Party here have a big responsibility in the Government's attitude on this matter. Deputy O'Higgins would say they have the main share of responsibility for encouraging the Government to carry on what they are pleased to call the economic war. The leader of the Labour Party has given evidence of his desire, on more than one occasion, to help to bring about a settlement of the dispute between this country and Great Britain.
Comment on this
I heard Deputy O'Sullivan, in the absence of Deputy Mulcahy, quote another Deputy as being responsible for that. Deputy Mulcahy was not here at the time, and if he had been he could have challenged that remark of Deputy O'Sullivan.
Comment on this
The positive way Deputy Mulcahy makes that assertion would not entitle me to contradict him. The position seems to the Opposition to be that we are the only nation in the world to-day that has committed a breach of some agreement, and that we are the only people whose financial integrity and stability comes into question. And that charge is made because we are withholding the annuities until such time as the British Government should prove by negotiation, arbitration or some other way, that they were entitled to them.
Comment on this
Will Deputy Dillon quote any country in the world to-day that is paying either its war debts or its international debts in full?
Comment on this
I shall leave it to the Vice-President to educate the Deputy in the proper pronunciation of Irish.
Comment on this
I ask is there any country in Europe to-day, that was engaged in the European War, paying in full its international debts?
Comment on this
The Deputy is asking us to pass an agreement whereby we are agreeing with the British Treasury to pay our debts.
Comment on this
——to-day paying in full its war debts? Is France paying its debts? Is Belgium paying its debts? Is Britain paying America its debts? Is any country that was involved directly or indirectly in the war, paying its international debts to-day? Notwithstanding the knowledge that Deputies opposite have of this matter, they come to this House and say that though the Irish people have authorised the Irish Government to withhold these sums until they are satisfied that they are payments which are actually due, that we are shirking our duty in doing so.
Comment on this
I am willing to wait until the conversation carried on between Deputy Belton and his friend is over.
Comment on this
I understand that some of the greatest countries in the world are only carrying out their financial obligations by making token payments. Would Deputy Cosgrave settle the financial dispute between the Free State and Great Britain by making token payments to the British and leave it to some future Government to come along and negotiate a final settlement? I want to know in what way Deputy Cosgrave would have given authority to negotiate a comprehensive settlement of all the matters now at issue with the British Government. I want to know whether he would tie on the financial dispute to the boundary question, and the financial dispute and the boundary question to the question of the establishment of a republic, and whether he would allow representatives of the country to remain long enough in England until they were able to come to a final settlement on all these questions? I am prepared to give every encouragement by vote and voice to the negotiation for a final settlement of the financial question, but I am not foolish enough to think—perhaps here I am giving something against myself away to Deputy Donnelly—that we can get a settlement of the boundary question by the same type of tribunal as we would get a settlement of the financial dispute. The President suggested that the financial dispute might be settled by an international tribunal of lawyers. I have not the slightest faith, for instance, in the body of eminent lawyers who, at the request of the Opposition, made out a case in favour of the British on the question of the annuities. This Government then got six other eminent lawyers who expressed the opinion that the annuities ought to be withheld. But the British were presented with an opinion of six lawyers provided by this country to say that they should be paid. I think that was the last thing any Party in this country ought to have done, that is, to make a case against this country after the majority of the people had given a mandate to the Government of the day that the annuities should be withheld until they were proved to be due.
I have no faith that this question will be settled by a body of international lawyers. Would Deputy Cosgrave be in favour of submitting the matter to a body of Commonwealth lawyers or would he favour an international tribunal, such as this Government were ready to submit it to? I believe the matter will never be settled in that way. I believe it will only be settled by a round-table conference, and never will be settled by any tribunal of international lawyers. I am not prepared, as Deputies who sit on the Opposition side of the House apparently are, to risk the settlement of this case to either a body of lawyers selected from the British Commonwealth or outside the Commonwealth.
This so-called economic war has been carried on for four years, but even if it was only on for a week or a month, I would take the same line. I am not going to risk the possibility of defeat before a tribunal of international lawyers, before whom you may lose your case because it was badly presented. I am also intelligent enough to know that lawyers of an international character would take the risk of favouring a big country against a small one—Britain in such a matter rather than us. This whole international dispute is to me a question of bread and butter. It is a moral issue. Deputies in this House and the Government have the responsibility, in the first instance, of making provision for the proper feeding, clothing and comfortable living of the citizens in this State. I will never subscribe, as long as I am a member of this House, to any Government in this country paying over large sums of money to Britain or to any other country, while there are men and women hungry and starving and without proper clothing and shelter. That is the first duty of any Government. In taking up the attitude which I take up, I say the Government have a right to retain this money until it is proved, whether by negotiation or by some other method, that they are legally bound to pay that money over to the British Government.
Comment on this
From the very day on which I discovered that this financial settlement contained a large sum for the payment of pensions to R.I.C., I protested against it. The R.I.C. unfortunately consisted of a number of Irishmen who fought for the British in the R.I.C. against their own fellow-countrymen in the land war and other wars carried out in this country. They were British forces although they were Irishmen, and I say it was the duty of the British Government—in the same way as they paid the pensions of the British Army who were here in this country—to pay the R.I.C. for the dirty work they carried out on behalf of the British Government while serving the British Government in the R.I.C.
Comment on this
I think the speech of Deputy Davin is one of the most illogical I have ever listened to.
Comment on this
In one breath he alleges that it would be entirely wrong to leave the question of the propriety of these payments to Great Britain to be decided upon by a tribunal of any kind—an Empire tribunal or an international tribunal.
Comment on this
In the next breath he says that he will only assent to the moneys being paid when they have been proved due either by negotiation or by some other method.
Comment on this
I do not want the Deputy to misrepresent me. I stated quite definitely that I favoured settlement of this dispute by negotiation.
Comment on this
I quite agree that the Deputy said that, but he also said he would only consent to the payments being made when they had been proved due either by negotiation or by some other method. How negotiation could prove anything I do not know. It could effect a great deal, but it certainly could not prove anything. The only method of proving whether those moneys are due or not is by a tribunal of some sort. If the Deputy rules that out he rules out proof altogether.
In the course of his speech he gave voice to a doctrine which would have come much more suitably from a supporter of Hitler or Mussolini or of the Soviet Government than from anyone in a democratic country. He expressed the opinion that it was intolerable and unpatriotic for a citizen ever to oppose the Government of his own country when that Government was having a dispute of any sort with another power.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that in no other country in the world would citizens be found so unpatriotic as to criticise the actions of their Government if their Government was having a dispute of any sort with another Power. Does morality count for absolutely nothing? I suggest that considerations of right and wrong have a real importance for people in a democratic country; not indeed for people in a country whose citizens have got to do nothing except to assent to whatever the dictator says. But in a democratic country we have got to think. We have got to use our own judgment. We have got to bow to the dictates of our own consciences. Just as there have been found over and over again in English history English citizens brave enough and honest enough to oppose and criticise their own Government when they considered that Government was acting immorally towards another Government, so I maintain that if we here should think our Government is acting immorally we have a perfect right, and not only a perfect right but a duty, to say so. If we think a debt is due, we ought to say we think it is due, and the notion that there is something unpatriotic in asking one of our own lawyers or six of our own lawyers to pass judgment on the question as to whether the debt is due or not seems to me almost too fantastic to be worth a moment's consideration.
Comment on this
Would there be anything immoral in asking a lawyer to advise and not putting all the facts before him? Those lawyers had not the 1923 agreement before them.
Comment on this
I am not concerned to argue with the Minister about the details of what actually occurred. I am only concerned to deal with the principle which Deputy Davin was seeking to lay down, and it seems to me thoroughly immoral and unworthy of a civilised country.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin also challenged any of us to say whether there was any country in the world paying its war debts.
Comment on this
In full. What is the relevance of that question? What possible relevance has it to our situation? This is not a war debt; it is a commercial debt. This money, borrowed from the British investor, was used to a good purpose. It was not used for blowing human beings into atoms, nor was the money blown away in warfare in any shape or form. It was profitably used, and it is a commercial debt. What Deputy Davin has to show, if he wants to use any argument of the kind at all, is that it has become the general practice throughout the world to repudiate commercial debts, and not war debts. Incidentally, I will have another word to say about the question of war debts later on in the course of my remarks.
Now, Sir, I support this Bill. I should support it with much more eagerness and much more joyfulness if the Government had not done a great deal to destroy the useful results that should flow from it by withdrawal of bounties on cattle and horses. The sufferings of the countryside are obvious to anyone who has got eyes to see and ears to hear. They are not invented by politicians. They have been spoken of, even within the last few days, by Bishops in their Lenten Pastorals. They are a matter of common talk and common knowledge, and I must say it amazes me that the Government should deny to the farmers and the miserably underpaid farm labourers the full relief which this agreement ought to bring them. If they could not have continued the bounties without maintaining the coal tax, then they ought to have maintained the coal tax, and they ought even now to reimpose the coal tax if there is no other way of providing the necessary money for the bounties. I represent here a rural constituency, but even looking at the matter not from the relatively narrow point of view of the representative of a rural constituency, but from the national point of view, I would still maintain that the crying economic need of the hour in this country is to relieve agriculture.
It seems clear to me that the House ought to give this Bill a Second Reading.
Comment on this
Deputy Cosgrave has said that the merits of this agreement are not really the question. Now, things are what they are, and their consequences will be what they must be. Why, then, should we deceive ourselves? Deputy Cosgrave's amendment is, in fact, asking us to reject this Bill.
Comment on this
And what we have to vote on is the question whether the Bill will get a Second Reading or not. The Opposition view with such grave concern the continuing losses of the people that they ask us to reject the Bill. It is very right that we should view with grave concern the continuing losses of the people, and that we should be deeply moved by the sufferings of the farming community, but not so deeply moved as to allow our emotions to cloud our reason. This Bill enlarges the market open to our farmers in Great Britain, and it reduces some of the obstacles which stand in the way of their getting there. It must, therefore, have a favourable effect on the farmers, and no sophistry can convince me that a suitable way of showing our sympathy with the sufferings of the farmers is to deny them any abatement of their sufferings such as is provided by this Bill.
The coal-cattle pact of last year, as Deputy Davin said, was decidedly inferior to the present agreement. Yet, the bulk of the Opposition, including the Front Bench, supported by their votes the coal-cattle pact—supported the confirmation of the Orders by which the coal-cattle pact was made operative. Why have they changed? Why should they repent? Has the coal-cattle pact been a failure? It stands to reason that the situation of the farmers would be even worse if Great Britain had not allowed in the additional cattle. The very welcome and substantial improvement in the figures of our trade balance during the past year was due, in the main, to that pact. Fianna Fáil speakers may sometimes pretend that the change was due to agreements with Spain or with Germany or with somewhere else. But the fact of the matter is that the improvement in our trade balance was caused more by last year's coal-cattle pact than by all the trade agreements with other countries put together. Therefore, it seems to me that we should be taking leave of our senses if we rejected the present Bill.
I was really amazed when I saw that the official Opposition had put down an amendment asking for its rejection. Not only have they done that, but they have, in the country, made statements more hostile to it than they have made here. In fact, Deputy Cosgrave really said very little against this agreement here this afternoon. Deputy O'Sullivan was more robust and called it a shameful measure. But, in the country, Deputy Cosgrave was less conservative about it and said harder things about it than he said here. Deputy Dillon, I think, informed the Irish Independent that the effect of this trade agreement would be to ensure that the Irish farmers and farm labourers would work harder and for longer hours in order to secure lower prices.
I ask: what good object could be served by rejecting this Bill? Is it suggested that our doing so would force the Government to make a larger agreement? I do not think it would have that effect. Indeed, its effect might easily be just the opposite. It appears to be the technique of opposition in this country to insist that each time an Irish Government makes an agreement with Great Britain it is we who are getting the worst of it. There will always be plenty of the Fianna Fáil left-wingers inclined to disparage and resent an agreement with Great Britain. If the Government have also to expect reckless criticism and hostility from Deputy Cosgrave and his friends, may they not come to the conclusion that the only safe path is the path of least resistance and abstain from making further agreements? For, if a general agreement does come, whether of the financial dispute alone, or embracing constitutional issues as well, we shall surely have to give as well as take. It will give ample opportunity to the Opposition for playing politics; or their emotions about the Irish farmer or Irish freedom might again get the better of their commonsense. I feel that the chances of such a settlement would be improved if the Opposition were careful to offer no ground for the suspicion that they are more interested in Party tactics than in the welfare of the country. I am not accusing them of being so—God alone knoweth the heart of man—but I am suggesting that they are giving some opportunity to people to suspect them of it by their attitude to this Bill.
According to Deputy Cosgrave—not Deputy Cosgrave in the House, but Deputy Cosgrave in the country—this agreement takes away our fiscal freedom. What does he mean? Is he unconscious of the fact that for the British farmer and for the Dominion farmer, no less than for the Irish farmer, the days of unregulated production are gone for ever—that in order to secure adequate and stable prices there has to be closer co-ordination of supply and demand? If it is to be regarded as a limitation of Irish independence that we should study the British market with the idea of supplying the British with what they need, and that we should adapt ourselves to the schemes of the British Department of Agriculture, then the look-out for our farmers is a very black one. The new British agricultural policy can be a boon or a curse to us just as we choose to make it. The Government have begun to realise this. They may not admit it, but their fallacies of a few years ago about the British market are completely exposed and exploded. This Bill really represents a triumph for Opposition arguments and Opposition philosophy, and it amazes me that they should be so blind as not to see that, and actually oppose the Bill. Surely the Opposition ought not, in present circumstances, to try to plunge back our economic thought into the darkness from which it is emerging.
Or is it the reduction of tariffs on English goods, or the coal monopoly, that Deputy Cosgrave regards as an infringement of our fiscal freedom? If so, the same thing could be said about the whole system of Imperial preference, or, indeed, about any trade agreement made by any Government anywhere. This agreement is not a permanent one; we can get rid of it next year if we like. It is not a one-sided one. We are getting a substantial consideration for anything we have given. It does not bar the way to the making of a larger agreement. On the contrary, it contributes to the formation of a good habit—the habit of reasonable discussion and reasonable compromise with our friends across the water. I see no excuse for opposing it and I shall certainly vote for it.
There are a couple of points arising out of the agreement to which I should like to call attention. One is, that it confirms the abandonment by the British Government of the point of view taken a few years ago that the present Government of the Irish Free State was one with whom no agreement could be made because of their repudiation of former agreements. I was not and I am not in sympathy with the line taken by the Government either on the question of the Oath or on the question of the annuities, but I recognise that their whole outlook in these questions was based on a different past and different prejudices from mine, and also that in their years of Opposition they committed themselves to many follies which with their present experience they might, perhaps, have avoided. The fact that at Geneva the President simply and frankly accepted his obligations under the Covenant of the League of Nations without dragging in the Anglo-Irish dispute and haggling about it, has, I know, enormously strengthened his position with the British Government and the British public, and will help him a great deal in whatever new attempts are pending to negotiate a settlement.