We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Death of his Majesty King George V. - Imposition of Duties (Confirmation of Order) Bill, 1936—Second Stage.

Contributions 304–467 of 467. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Imposition of Duties (Confirmation of Order) Bill, 1936
Enacted

No. 10 of 1936 ›

And blockheads.

Comment on this

No, he left that out.

Comment on this

Yes, he left it out. He did not notice the Minister on the Front Bench.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I think that Deputy Cosgrave is not really in touch with the situation when he talks about sterling blocks, and tries to give us an impression that the dollar and the franc, and so on, are widely divorced. I suggest that he should get some advice on this matter before he attempts to instruct Deputies on finance again. Then he went on to his second favourite, horse-breeding, and said that the horse-breeders of this country have been ignored and that we have been indifferent to their interest, and so on. That, of course, is absolutely untrue, because, as a matter of fact, in this agreement that is being made there was no reduction as big as the reduction in the tariff on horses going into Great Britain. That was the biggest reduction made in any item. Deputy Cosgrave, in his speech, even tells us that this economic war has been responsible for crimes against nature, and he quoted two crimes against nature. The first crime was that we are slaughtering calves. I have often mentioned that here before. I do not know where the crime stops in that connection. Nobody on the opposite side can tell me, evidently, where the crime stops. If you slaughter a calf of three weeks old, that is a crime. I imagine it is a crime to slaughter a calf six weeks old, but a line must be drawn somewhere. For instance, the slaughter of a calf eight months old is only an ordinary butchering business, and would be no crime. Perhaps some theologian on the opposite bench can tell us where exactly the crime stops, so that we may be able to do something to meet that situation.

The second crime against nature, that was mentioned by Deputy Cosgrave, was that a blood horse was sent away from this country and died on the other side. That was another crime against nature, according to Deputy Cosgrave. He then goes on and tells us that he believes that this Government should fulfil its international obligations, and he laid down as a principle that a Government should honour the undertaking of its predecessor. In other words, we should honour the undertaking that our predecessors gave to pay over the land annuities and the R.I.C. pensions, which Deputy MacDermot does not think is a war debt—that it is a commercial debt—and that we should honour all these agreements made by our predecessors and pay over these moneys. Then, when he had laid down that principle, Deputy Cosgrave said we should settle. It would be easy, of course, to settle on that basis. There would be no difficulty whatsoever if we paid over the land annuities and so on, and honoured the agreements made by our predecessors to pay over that money. Of course, it would be an easy thing to settle on that basis. Nobody denies it; we could settle on that basis at any time.

Comment on this

Are you not paying it at the present moment?

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

What is the £4 5s. a head for?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Deputies might permit me to proceed, and not try to interrupt when a question is put to them for which they have no answer. I am surprised at Deputy Belton helping them out. I do not think he means to do so, but he is doing it.

Comment on this

I am trying to help out the Minister, but it is very difficult.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Deputy Cosgrave, the leader of a Party and probably the most able man in it, says that we should honour our obligations and that we should honour the agreements made by our predecessors. In other words, we should pay over all the land annuities, all the R.I.C. pensions, and all other sums, and having said that, he says that is a favourable time to settle. It is the easiest thing at all to settle on that basis. I am surprised at a man of the intelligence which the leader of an Opposition Party ought to have, making such a statement.

Deputy Cosgrave says that there is no increase in paid agricultural labour. At any rate, we have prevented a decrease in these times, when, in the big countries, or, at least, in England, in the last year, they had a decrease of 60,000. The numbers went down there from 577,000 to 517,000, while there was a slight increase here. That is something to our credit. I am asked about alternative markets. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that the principal alternative market was the home market. That is true, and I will give one instance, although there are many other instances which could be given. In 1931, under the late Cumann na nGaedheal Government, we exported 311,000 cwts. of bacon and hams. Last year, we exported 501,000 cwts.—almost 200,000 more. In 1931, we imported 450,000 cwts. of bacon and last year we imported none. So that we had a bigger export than we had in 1931, and, at the same time, we supplied our own market to the extent of 500,000 cwts. imported in 1931. That is a considerable market as an alternative.

Comment on this

Do those figures include exports of pigs?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No. If pigs and pork, and all other classes into which pigs can be put for export, are taken, it will reduce that 1,000,000 as against 311,000 by less than 200,000 cwts., so that the 311,000 export in 1931 has been increased, between the home and export market, to about 800,000 cwts. in 1935. Deputy Belton says that if we export more cattle and paid a lower tariff on them, the British will get the same amount of duties. I think that is a sum—is it practice you call it? It is true, though.

Comment on this

Is there a reduction in the total amount to be collected by Britain on foot of the alleged default?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

There is.

Comment on this

Tell us what it is.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not know how much it will be.

Comment on this

You do not know what it is. Is that practice now?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is sharp practice.

Comment on this

Practise it a little while and you will believe it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I was only going to compliment the Deputy on saying something that was true during his speech. I was going on to something else.

Comment on this

Explain the £4 5s. and you will do a lot.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I want to give the Deputy full credit for anything he said that was true. That was one thing he said that was true.

Comment on this

And the £4 5s. represents the land annuities.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is not so. The Deputy said that in 1934 they collected the amount due. I will go back to Deputy Cosgrave because he puts it more clearly than Deputy Belton. Deputy Belton made exactly the same point, but I have it in print from Deputy Cosgrave. It is a most interesting statement which he made on the night this agreement was published, but it looks like the statement of a man who was not altogether satisfied with himself. He says that the British were certain of getting their full amount and they were so certain that they reduced the imports of cattle in 1934. What is more, he says that the British Government had stated publicly that they would not collect one penny more than was due. Remember those two statements. They were so certain of getting the full amount that they reduced the number of cattle in 1934.

Comment on this

I did not tie myself to the year.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

In the next paragraph, he goes on to say that the coal-cattle pact of 1935 was to give them the full amount. Is not that a grand statement from the leader of the Opposition?

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Deputy Cosgrave. I will read his full words. He said:

"The annuities were sent over to the British on the horns of the cattle——"

the same words were used by Deputy O'Higgins this evening and also words which Deputy Cosgrave used later on in this statement

"——an expensive and wasteful method of payment. The new arrangement may well be called a plan to make further and better provision for the payment of the annuities and to remove doubts as to the willingness of our Government to facilitate the British in their collection."

In 1934, they were so sure that they reduced the numbers of cattle but, in 1935, we made an agreement with them to make sure that they would get it.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

And you are making doubly sure by this.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I am glad you all agree with Deputy Cosgrave. Listen to it again. So certain were the British of getting the money that, in 1934, they reduced the imports of fat and store cattle from the Free State. They got it in 1934 after reducing the numbers and then, in 1935, we had to send more cattle to enable them to get it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

They all agree with that logic. It just shows the hopeless——

Comment on this

The reduced tariff.

Comment on this

There was no reduced tariff in 1935.

Comment on this

Will the Minister deny that the British got more than they required last year?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Will the Deputy wait until I deal with Deputy Cosgrave? I will deal then with his wild statements. Deputy Cosgrave says that, in 1934, they were so certain of getting the money that they were able to reduce the number of cattle, but, in 1935, with the same tariffs, we had to give 150,000 more cattle to produce the full amount. Is that not very like the sum he did in Carlow four years ago when he reversed the import and export figures? In this particular case I presume he had the central committee to help him in making the statement. They did not give him very much help. It is a pity not to go on with the statement because there are some good points in it. In the next paragraph he says that this particular agreement is to give them the full amount, with more cattle still, and that it is a way of easing the Exchequer here of the payment of bounties. I should like any Deputy opposite to show me one statement any of them ever made, either here or in public, in which he gave it as his opinion that the bounties went back to the farmer.

Comment on this

Deputy Bennett denied it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It was always said that they did not get the bounty. It was always held that the farmers did not get the bounty. Now, when the bounty is taken away, we are told that it was of great benefit to the farmer. Deputy Cosgrave says we send across the duties on the horns of the cattle. I do not blame Deputy Cosgrave because we have to remember his dilemma. He had to please the farmers by not rejecting this agreement, and he had to carry out his duties as Leader of an Opposition whose function, we were told here on one occasion, is to oppose. I think it was Deputy Dillon who made the statement that the duty of an Opposition is to oppose.

Comment on this

That is quite apocryphal.

Comment on this

He was not first to make that statement. What was the practice of Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Listen to the next statement from the responsible leader of a large Party:

"Any spare time an Irish farmer may have at his disposal he can employ speculating whether it is better to rear and feed calves which will be subject to the new duties or save himself the bother by collecting the Saorstát bounty on the skins of slaughtered calves."

A comedian should not try to be tragic. We all enjoy Deputy Cosgrave here but, when he tries to be tragic, we see through it. He goes on to say "the Government has bartered our coal requirements." Is there any sin in barter? Deputy Belton approved of barter. He was going to barter a cwt. of beef for a cwt. of cement.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

1/6 for a cwt. of beef.

Comment on this

On a point of correction, I am glad the Minister drew my attention to that statement. I did say a cwt. but I meant a ton.

Comment on this

A ton of beef.

Comment on this

A ton of cement for a cwt. of beef.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I knew a mistake was made. The point I am making is that the barter in itself is no crime. The point is as to what you barter. We bartered our coal requirements for one year. That is no crime. If we had bartered six counties for all time, that would be a crime and a serious crime. Bartering our coal requirements for a year is no crime because we get value for it and it is not irreparable.

Comment on this

Where were you when the Six Counties were bartered?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If we had been here, they would not have been bartered.

Comment on this

You were not here and you would not be here now but for me. Were you not above at the Shelbourne? You had too high principles to come in. Now, you have sold them in this coal-cattle pact. It is not the first time and it will not be the last.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If the Deputy had to stick to us afterwards, he would be all right.

Comment on this

I would want to be an eel to follow you.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We bartered a third of our cement requirements and Deputy Cosgrave goes on to say that, in addition, we bartered portion of our requirements of iron and steel, electrical apparatus, sugar and sugar preparations. "For what" he asks. He did not even read the agreement. We did not barter any of our electrical requirements or our requirements in iron, steel or sugar. Again, you have the leader of what is supposed to be a responsible Party making statements which are not true and which, therefore, need not be taken seriously. He says that this is done to allow our Government to pay the land annuities—which the British could collect in 1934, with a big restriction on our cattle, which they could collect in 1935 with 160,000 more cattle. And, now, with more cattle, pigs and bacon, we are allowing the British to collect the duties. Coming to the end of the statement, Deputy Cosgrave said "The agreement proves that it is possible to negotiate with the British." Is not that a wise statement? I shall not make any other comment on it. He goes on to say "It makes it clear that there is a big problem to be solved"—here he becomes almost coherent in his argument—"and what prevents Ministers from attempting to solve that problem?" His whole statement was leading up to this poser—"What prevents Ministers from attempting to solve that problem?" The answer is "Nothing". Any Minister or any Deputy could attempt to solve it. But attempting to solve it is not of much use. To settle is the trouble. Were he to ask what prevents us from settling the problem satisfactorily, I should say "The other Party."

Comment on this

Blame the other fellow. That is a great excuse.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Is it not a good one?

Comment on this

Good enough.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Deputy O'Higgins made a typical speech. When I saw the Deputy get up I wrote down the words "insincerity", "want of courage", "be men and face your responsibilities", "do not delegate your authority". I can always take up these notes and learn what Deputy O'Higgins has said. He always delivers that sort of speech. That was all that was in his speech to-night save that he said we had lowered our prestige— another quotation from Deputy Cosgrave's statement. I do not know why that statement is made. The Deputy talks about this being a secret agreement. He refers to it in that manner notwithstanding that the part of it which we have to implement is brought before the Dáil. Before it was brought before the Dáil, it was published and it was shown that certain duties would be reduced on this side and certain duties on the other side, and that certain quotas would be altered. The whole thing was given in public statements on both sides. Yet, this is a secret agreement. What we would mean by a secret agreement would be an agreement made in 1923, which was not even shown by the last Government to their own lawyers when making their case in respect of the land annuities and which had to be dug up when Mr. Thomas revealed that there was such an agreement. According to Deputy O'Higgins, we should know what went on at the negotiations. The Press should be present. When our delegates met the British delegates, the Press should be there to take notes of what was said backward and forward. In that way, you would have no secret agreement—and probably no agreement at all. He objects because the Minister did not go over—I do not know why—and he said that there was a statement issued by the Vice-President of the Executive Council on his way home from Ottawa to the effect that there was a settlement discussed or made between the British delegates and the Irish delegates in Ottawa, which is absolutely untrue.

Comment on this

I have got it here and I will read it for you.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is what we ask for.

Comment on this

You will get it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I say that the statement is absolutely untrue.

Comment on this

Why was it not contradicted, then?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Perhaps it was.

Comment on this

Then the coal-cattle pact is the best settlement you can make?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I would not say it is the best. Deputy Bennett says the bounties did not reach the farmers. That is at least some consolation to me when we are taking the bounties off—that is all I can say. I never wanted these bounties to go to dealers; I was always anxious that they should go to the producers and, taking everything into consideration, statements made here previously and the statement made by Deputy Bennett to-day, I think it is as well that these bounties should come off.

Comment on this

Why did you give the licences to people who had no right to have them?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I was not giving out licences at all.

Comment on this

They were given to people who had no right to them, and you know it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The county committees are giving them out now. Deputy Bennett asked why not have a full armistice. I suppose he means to drop all Acts, and so on, on both sides—that the duties should be dropped on both sides. I presume he means that there should be no duties collected on the British side or on our side. We are quite agreeable at any time to do that, but on what terms does Deputy Bennett look for the armistice? I suppose he is not going to let his leader, Deputy Cosgrave, down. He is surely not going to let his leader down. His leader said that we should recognise and fulfil the obligations— that we are bound to fulfil them—as a result of agreements made by our predecessors. One of the agreements made by them was to pay over the land annuities, the R.I.C. pensions and local loans to Great Britain, amounting to £5,000,000 annually. If we pay over those we can have the armistice.

Comment on this

And are they not being paid?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No.

Comment on this

Is not England collecting them?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Not at all.

Comment on this

What are the British tariffs for?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We are told that if we pay these over to England we can have an armistice or a settlement any time we like.

Comment on this

That is why you got the coal cattle pact—because you agreed to pay them. That is the position.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister must be allowed to speak. He has been subjected to a fire of interruptions for the last 15 minutes.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I merely want to conclude with a question to Deputy Dillon. Deputy Dillon is, I understand, the vice-leader of the Party opposite. He comes next to Deputy Cosgrave, and perhaps he could answer this question. On what terms would they be prepared to support us in making a settlement? Is it that we should pay over that money in full, because if it is anything less than that we would like very much to hear about it? That is, I understand, Deputy Cosgrave's proposal—that we should pay it over in full, honour our obligations.

Comment on this

President de Valers is a very versatile man. We are accustomed to him here as the passionate defender of Cathleen Ní Houlihan's honour; we are accustomed to him as an object of injured innocence; we are accustomed to him as the amazed victim of misrepresentation, and, finally, we are accustomed to him as the sceptical discoverer of a mare's nest, making his discovery more in sorrow than in anger, sad to have to expose an unscrupulous opponent. He thought he had Deputy O'Higgins on the hop this evening. Deputy O'Higgins said, when all the challenges and questions were being asked by a body of Ministers who were supposed to be recommending a treaty to this House, that he, Deputy O'Higgins, felt entitled to ask at least one question of the persons who were concerned to render an account of their stewardship, and that question was: Why was it that the bridge towards a settlement that had been built by the Vice-President of the Executive Council in Ottawa had been blasted when the Vice-President came home, and who was it that blasted that bridge to settlement away?

The President asked what did Deputy O'Higgins refer to, and he said he referred to an interview given by the Vice-President on his return from Ottawa, in which he said substantial progress had been made towards a settlement, and he thought the foundations for a peaceful understanding had been laid. The President asked for a reference. Deputy O'Higgins, very naturally, was at the moment unable to provide it, although it has been provided in this House on divers occasions in the past. The President was more in sorrow than in anger. He began to suspect something was being put over on the House. He was the watch-dog of our rights, determined that the Irish people would not be deceived, loyal to his colleague who was not to be traduced in silence. Having made soundings, he determined to take the plunge. He began to think: "This fellow has not got the reference.""These words were never spoken," said the President. I must give him credit that he was extremely circumspect before he made the plunge. Not so the Minister for Agriculture. He came blundering down the steps and declared he had heard the Deputy telling a bare-faced lie, or words to that effect.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Words to that effect—that is better.

Comment on this

Now, may I refer the President and his loyal and docile colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, to the Irish Independent of August 20th, 1932? Mr. O'Kelly, the Vice President of the Executive Council, gave an exclusive interview to the special correspondent of the Irish Independent:“We have, of course, no agreement with the United Kingdom, but the path towards a settlement of the dispute with Britain has been smoothed.” Deputy O'Higgins urged, inasmuch as the Vice-President said a path had been smoothed, that a bridge had been built.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins said more than that.

Comment on this

There is plenty more in it, but I thought the Minister might leap into that trap. "Would it be correct to say that the presence of the Irish Delegation at Ottawa helped to pave the way towards a settlement or bring it nearer?" inquired the special correspondent. The Vice-President was in a benevolent mood. "I think I can safely say that is so," replied Mr. O'Kelly, and, encouraged by the smile on the countenance of the special correspondent, he went a little further. "We have had very friendly and pleasant contacts, and undoubtedly we have made progress," said the Vice-President. "We have, I believe, reached a basis of settlement. It is impossible yet to fix the date on which agreement will be arrived at, but it is measurably close." Was Deputy O'Higgins a traducer of the truth when he asked the President who had ruffled the path that the Vice-President had smoothed, who blasted the basis the Vice-President had laid, who made immeasurable the measurable closeness which the Vice-President had attained?

Comment on this

You can measure any distance.

Comment on this

I invite the President to measure that when he intervenes in the debate, and let him remember that it is not always safe to take a leap in the dark——

Comment on this

I am delighted at last to have some idea of what was being talked about.

Comment on this

——because sometimes the reference can be got before the debate closes.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins did not refer to it in those terms at all.

Comment on this

The House will judge whether Deputy O'Higgins was engaged in misleading it or his colleagues when he paraphrased the dulcet words of the Vice-President on his return from Ottawa. I think it still behoves the President to explain to us why these approaches were destroyed. To listen to the Minister for Industry and Commerce is a most astonishing experience. I have said before in this House that there is nothing conceivable to the mind of man which the Minister for Industry and Commerce would not say. He rose quite blandly this evening and proceeded to talk about the agricultural prices index figure in Great Britain and in Saorstát Eireann and he had the vast effrontery to say in this House that the agricultural prices index figure in Great Britain had fallen point for point with that for Saorstát Eireann and that there was now only one point between them.

Comment on this

I said nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

The Official Report will reveal what the Minister said. He said that there was a matter of a couple of points or so between the agricultural prices index figures in Great Britain and in Saorstát Eireann.

Comment on this

I said nothing of the kind; I did not say that.

Comment on this

It was more subtle than that.

Comment on this

Very well; perhaps the Minister will tell us what he did say?

Comment on this

I said that in the 12 months from August, 1934, to August 1935, the agricultural prices index figure in Great Britain fell by six points and in the Saorstát in the same period fell by only one point.

Comment on this

That is my recollection of what the Minister said.

Comment on this

And mine too.

Comment on this

They could fall no further.

Comment on this

Whatever the Minister said I do not want to deny. What he meant is just what he has told the House. I shall take him on that. That is what is important; not actually what he did say.

Comment on this
A Deputy

That is what he did say.

Comment on this

It is astonishing that figures and statistics can be so unscrupulously twisted for the purpose of deceiving the public. The Minister for Industry and Commerce takes a year during which prices have fallen to a hopelessly uneconomic level, to a level which would involve the complete cessation of production if they fell any lower and he compares that with the corresponding figure in Great Britain. "Observe," he says, "there was a fall of something in Saorstát Eireann and something in Great Britain." But he does not go on to tell us what the indexes are. What are the indexes of agricultural prices in this country? Let me read them for the period since the Government came into office. The basis price for 1911-13 is taken as 100.

Comment on this

What index is this?

Comment on this

This index is taken from the report of the Currency Commission. When President de Valera took office the index price was 133.7 and on the 1st January, 1935, it was 83.6, showing a fall of 50 points.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy say he got this figure from the Report of the Currency Commission?

Comment on this

Yes. The Minister will find that in January, 1932, the agricultural prices index figure in Saorstát Eireann was 133.7.

Comment on this

No, 113.7. I shall send the Deputy across the returns.

Comment on this

Very well, I shall take it as 113. I copied it from the document which is in the Minister's hands but perhaps I made a mistake. We can take the Minister's figure of 113.7 as being the agricultural prices index figure in 1932.

Comment on this

No. 3 Merrion Square is wrong this time.

Comment on this

I find from the records that the Minister is perfectly right, but even on these figures there has been a drop from January, 1932, from 113.7 to 83.6, a drop of 30 points. In Great Britain on the relevant date in 1932 the index figure was 122. I quote from the monthly index numbers of agricultural prices, the corresponding figure for 1911-13 being 100. On the relevant date, the English index price figure was 122 and in 1935 the English index price figure was 117. As between the two dates, there has been a fall on the English price figure of five points while, since President de Valera came into office, there has been a fall in the Irish figure of 30 points. Yet these figures are held up to suggest that, in fact, there has been a steady approximation between the prices obtaining in the Saorstát and in Great Britain.

I want, since we are on these figures, to point out that while the index figures of agricultural prices have fallen by 30 points for the last three years in this country, the cost of living based on July, 1914, figure, has remained practically stable. It was 157 in January, 1932, and it is now 156, with the result that the burden which the increasing collapse of cattle prices and other prices in this country has placed upon the farmer is becoming worse and worse. The Minister for Agriculture proceeded to give us some figures and he explained to us in a series of years what the sales of cattle were. In 1931, he said, we exported 770,000 cattle and then he proceeded to show that in the ensuing years our exports plus home consumption in the way of killing and factory canning were substantially the same. I ventured to ask him if he was in a position to tell us, in addition to the number of cattle handled and distributed by Irish exporters, what the prices were. He said he had not got the figures by him, but I shall be glad to give them to him. In 1931 we exported 765,952 cattle of all kinds for which we received £12,660,506—an average price of £16 11s. per beast. In 1935 we exported 669,022 head of cattle and received for them £5,374,080, an average of approximately £8 per head. It is quite easy to keep up our production and sales if we keep the price low enough. But might I suggest to the Minister that, if you reduce the price of cattle low enough, then, instead of making a profit on the increased sales, you will reach the stage of the greater the sale the greater the loss. My submission, which was found fault with, was that one of the consequences of this Bill is that the people of this country will now have the privilege of exporting the land annuities attached to horns of their cattle, in greater numbers than ever before, and that, in fact, if the prices are to remain approximately as they were in 1935—and I see no reason for their advance—the result will be that the people will be working very much harder to lose more money.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not make that proviso.

Comment on this

The proviso "if the prices are to remain as they were." He predicted that, as the result of this agreement, the harder the farmers worked the more they would lose.

Comment on this

Yes; and without attempting to make a sharp answer to Deputy MacDermot, may I say he might have made his observation much clearer and more easy to understand if he was depending on a profit on 20 head of cattle to provide his next meal. Anyone producing cattle would know very well from their past experience what the price was in the last few years, and that the only effect was to increase the number of cattle we sold. There can be no reasonable hope of making a profit on increased export at such a price. I also pointed out, in that connection—and it was in that connection I was speaking —that, taking the year 1933 as perhaps as bad a time as we had in this whole trouble, and as good a time as well, the Government fixed the bounty of 35/- per head on cattle over two years, and £2 on cattle over six months and up to two years of age. Since that time the Government have slowly eliminated these bounties. And now we find that they have finally wiped out all the bounties. The man with a beast up to six months to dispose of is 5/- per head better off than since the economic war began. A man with a beast of six months but under 15 months is 10/- worse off than he was in November, 1933.

Comment on this

Is that the market price?

Comment on this

So far as the Government of Saorstát Eireann can effect it.

Comment on this

Are you quoting market prices?

Comment on this

I am quoting bounties given by the Irish Government as compared with the duty levied by the British Government. In November, 1933, I say that a man exporting a beast between the ages of six months and 15 months was 10/- better off than under the clause of the coal-cattle pact of 1936.

Comment on this

You mean because of the bounty given to the producer?

Comment on this

That must remain a matter of doubt. It is purely a matter of speculation as to whether the relief in the tariffs will go to the producer now any more than in the past. But it is certain, so far as the Government is concerned, that in 1933 they gave 20/-, while under the pact of 1936 they give such a man nothing. Deputy MacDermot feels this is true and that this man is going to do better than he has ever done before—I mean during the economic war. My thesis is that the Government is actually worsening his position if it was possible for them to do so, because in 1933 they were giving him a price that could be got, in face of the British tariff, and a bounty of 20/-. In 1936 they give him no bounty, but they are telling him that, the tariff imposed by Great Britain having been reduced by 10/-, he must take pot luck. That means that that farmer is 10/- worse off than ever before.

Comment on this

Give us the market price on the different dates.

Comment on this

In the case of a man who had a 15 months old and under two years beast the position is the same vis-a-vis the coal-cattle agreement 1935 and 1936. So far as a man with a beast of two years and over is concerned, he is in the same position as he was approximately before the pact of 1936. A man with mincers for sale is about £1 a head better off. It is impossible to forecast what the market prices are to be in the import areas. All I can do is to tell the Deputy what the market prices were at the end of 1931, when they amounted to £16 11s. per head, and in 1935, the last year for which we have available figures, when the price was approximately £8 per head; less than one-half of what cattle were fetching when this Government came into office.

Therefore, I say in face of these figures this coal-cattle pact means that our farmers are going to work harder for the same or for less money than ever, and in fact the more they produce in the way of live stock the greater will be their loss. I assert, at the present moment, they are working at a loss; they are living on their capital and they are spending their savings. Indeed, if you accelerate the rate of export at figures that do not cover the cost of production, you are accelerating the machinery which will make these people paupers, and a charge upon the public purse.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy give a figure which is relevant, that is, the price immediately before the coal-cattle pact of last year, and compare that with the price now? What the Deputy was purporting to do in his interview with the Irish Independent was to describe the net result of the arrangements of 1935 and 1936, and that is relevant to our debate to-night.

Comment on this

Are you the Ceann Comhairle?

Comment on this

The Deputy is of an inquiring turn of mind, and I welcome what I have no doubt is a well-meaning interruption. The best figures I can give him are those furnished by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to Deputy Fagan on 20th February, 1936. As reported at column 965 of the Official Debates, Deputy Fagan was informed that the price ruling for fat cattle at the Dublin market on 15th February, 1934, that is, nearly a year before the coal-cattle pact of 1935, was 25/9 per cwt. Then we come to the coal-cattle pact of 1935. On February 14th of that year the price for fat cattle in the Dublin market is 3/- lower— 22/9.

Comment on this

The coal-cattle pact only began in February.

Comment on this

The Deputy must be of good heart. Fortunately I have later figures. We come to 13th February, 1936, and the price is still 22/9. What the price will be on 13th February, 1937, I do not profess to know, but I do suggest that it will show little, if any, improvement on the figures I have just qucted. Those are the factors relevant to those two agreements, but when we come to discuss the amendment standing in our name other factors of much wider character arise, because if we demur from endorsing this coal-cattle arrangement we do so because we say that it is time the Government did what they ought to do, did what they promised to do all through the General Election of 1933, and that was to settle the whole dispute. When I ask them to do that I ask them to do it because I know the British market to be there available to us, just as they themselves know it is there available to us as a profitable market if we go to look for it. The President used to delight in going down to Ennis and there thanking God that the British market was gone for ever.

Comment on this

When? Get the quotation and it might help things a little bit. I want that quotation. Get it.

Comment on this

Without in the least intending to give the President a short answer, if the President wants to get the quotation he has plenty of people to go and get it for him.

Comment on this

I do want to get it —very badly. We will then get some other things down to earth.

Comment on this

The President has a very dashing lieutenant in the person of Senator Connolly.

Comment on this

I am supposed to have made a statement in Ennis.

Comment on this

The President has a very dashing lieutenant——

Comment on this

Might I ask the Deputy did he not say that I made a statement in Ennis? I am asking for that quotation.

Comment on this

And my reply to the President is, if he wants the quotation, let him get somebody to get it for him. I have no desire to give the President a short answer or to appear discourteous. He is entitled, by his position, to every courtesy in this House, but he is certainly not entitled to try any rough stuff on any Deputy of this House. He has a staff at his disposal to go and get him any reference he wants.

Comment on this

It would be very hard to ask a staff to get something which I believe is not in existence.

Comment on this

Professor O'Sullivan gave the quotation to-night and the President will find it in the Official Reports next week.

Comment on this

He made a statement, but he did not give the quotation.

Comment on this

I am simply asking that I might have the basis on which statements are being made. One statement is cleared up now and we know where we are.

Comment on this

It is not cleared up.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If Deputy Dillon purported to quote the exact words which the President used he should give the reference to that quotation. If Deputy Dillon, on the other hand, merely gave his impression or a paraphrase of what he thought the President said, I cannot press the Deputy for the reference.

Comment on this

Nobody, Sir, suggests that I attempted to quote the exact words used by the President. Everybody knows that those words have been repeatedly quoted in this House in the President's presence.

Comment on this

And on every occasion I have tried to correct those things, with the same result as I am getting to-night.

Comment on this

The President is at present in his aggrieved and outraged mood. He is anxious to hold himself out as the injured and misrepresented party. There is no question of misrepresentation—

Comment on this

The difficulty here is that this speech is not an agricultural price index, and we cannot check it.

Comment on this

——but it is impossible for me to get a quotation at 10 o'clock at night and the President knows it. This market is there, and it is a market in which the price of livestock is apparently steadily improving. Far from being a market which is dwindling or a market into which we should cease to have any hope of sending our stuff, it is one of the utmost value, and one which may be described as indispensable to Irish agriculture. I was referring to the President's dashing lieutenant, Senator Connolly. Senator Connolly attended two meetings in the midlands of the country, at which he rejoiced to think that the cattle trade, which took over 100 years to build up, might be pulled down in as many days. It is extremely difficult to follow the line of policy that the Government is pursuing when you find one group of Ministers negotiating with the British Government to secure increased exports of cattle to the British market, while the President of the Executive Council is giving it as his considered judgment that the British market is gone for ever, and his lieutenant, Senator Connolly, is rejoicing that the cattle market, which took 100 years to build up, can be destroyed in as many days. Surely if the President of the Executive Council on 9th August, 1933, thought the British market had gone for ever, and said so with a full sense of his responsibility, it does not seem reasonable that his Ministers should be negotiating in January, 1935, and again in January, 1936, to get into that very market which in his considered judgment was gone for ever two years before. But that is the situation with which we are confronted at the present time.

We urge this House to withhold from the Government confirmation of this agreement unless and until the Government will enter into negotiations with the British Government to ascertain whether it is or is not possible to settle the whole land annuities dispute. Now the President has himself said in this House that although he has withheld the land annuities, he admits the British Government is getting them. At that time he said that the British Government were getting them in spite of him—that he could not stop them. Now that situation has changed, and, by virtue of the terms of the agreement into which he himself has entered, the numbers of cattle are fixed at such a figure as will guarantee to the British Government on the face of the new rates of duty that they will get the sums in dispute every year. Surely when we reach that idiotic position, at least the time has come for the President to examine the question whether we can settle all outstanding matters with the British Government, or to leave political questions on one side if he cannot bring himself to face them and settle the purely economic questions outstanding. It is very difficult for anyone living in the country to explain to people who spend their lives in the City of Dublin what this economic war means to the people. It is very difficult to bring home to anybody who makes his livelihood in the city—where there is comparative prosperity, where there is brisk circulation of money, where there is a population almost exclusively wage-earners— the atmosphere obtaining in a rural area, where 90 per cent. of the people are producers of primary products, the prices which are affected by the war that is proceeding between this country and Great Britain. I remember before this business began, the market days and the fair days in the country were days to look forward to. They were part of the pleasant side of country life. You brought out your stock on a fair day expecting to get an economic price, and you got it. You sometimes got a little more than you expected, and sometimes a little less. With the proceeds you discharged your liabilities, whatever they were; you probably bought fresh stock, and you provided some amusement for yourself and your family, who might have accompained you on the fair day. Taking the whole of that together, the fair day was a pleasant day. It came once a month; you met your neighbours, and there was a general atmosphere of good-feeling, freeness of money and temporary prosperity.

What is a fair day now? It is a standing nightmare to every person in the country. What was in the past a monthly occasion upon which they got a bit of fun out of life has now become a monthly horror in which people drive cattle into the fair, stand in the usual unpleasant circumstances on a fair green on a wet day, are never asked where they were going, or else bid a price which they know is less than it cost to produce the cattle. They go down from the fair green feeling poorer men than they went into it. They cannot pay their shop debts, or buy stock to replace what they sold. They are quarrelling with their own families. They are depriving their wives and children of things they want to give them, and are doing that because they have not got the money to give them. If Deputies could only understand what it means to take out of the life of the farmer all the pleasant qualities of the fair and market day, if they could only understand what that means in rural life, I believe the significance of this economic war would sink into them a bit deeper.

So long as the pretence is kept up that we are keeping these moneys at home, and that they are going to be used for the benefit of the people, one could understand the mentality behind maintaining this economic war. So long as the war spirit obtained you can understand men saying: "I have worked up enthusiasm; I have driven people into war with Great Britain, but it is very difficult to get people out. There is a great deal of wild enthusiasm in the country now for carrying on the war, and it will take some time to damp that down." That has all gone. It is idle and absurd to talk of fighting a war with somebody when you are actually in negotiation to ensure that they will secure a certain indemnity at stated intervals during the campaign. It is ridiculous to talk of fighting a war when you are in, not annual, but daily negotiation about the everyday affairs of commerce between us. It is absurd to talk of fighting a war and at the same time to establish a warble fly Order to convenience the British Ministry of Agriculture. The war is over. It is now becoming a question of accountancy. The whole war is stopped. There is the closest co-operation and consultation and the freest agreement between the two parties to the dispute. It has now come to this question: how are the annuities going to be paid? Will they be sent over through the cattle, which the President says is an inconvenient and possibly more expensive way of doing the job, or will it be done in another way? You have to go one way. There is a way out of this.

Of course, it is not for the Opposition to tell the Government how to conduct negotiations of this kind. The Government know that it is impossible either for them or anybody else to anticipate the details of any arrangement that might be arrived at. But there is a way out that will save the Government's face, not to talk of any legitimate pride, because there ought not to be any illegitimate pride in connection with this transaction. There is such a thing in this country as face, and unfortunately the Government seem to have an undue amount of that commodity, and it requires a lot of saving from time to time.

Comment on this

Is that a suggestion that the Opposition have all the cheek?

Comment on this

No. The plain meaning of my words is that for silly conceit commend me to the Fianna Fáil leaders. That conceit has to be in some way pandered to if further staggering losses are not to be suffered by our people. Surely it is possible to go to Great Britain and say: "Very well, you hold that Saorstát Eireann owes you this money; we hold it does not. There are two courses open to us, as there are open to every pair of litigants in the world. One is the way of compromise and the other the way of litigation." These can be the only two ends. You can choose litigation, which is the civilised method of resolving differences, or choose war, but they both belong to the same category. You can try the matter out by competition of mental skill or by competition of economic resources, but it is all a struggle of one kind or another. On the other hand, you can compromise. Surely it is possible for the Government now to say to Great Britain: "We do not claim the right to ram down your throat our interpretation of our liabilities, any more than we admit your claim to ram down our throat your interpretation of your rights." But, admitting that the British believe themselves to be honourably and conscientiously entitled to every penny they claim, and admitting, as I think the British will freely admit, that President de Valera believes that there is no liability on the Irish Government to pay the moneys, can we not agree upon one fundamental fact, and that is, that whoever pays the money, somebody must eventually pay the bondholders. England says Ireland must pay them, and Ireland says, "Let England pay them." In the meantime they are not getting paid—not in respect of the sinking fund.

Comment on this

I am afraid that the Deputy does not know that the land stock is a perpetual stock and, as far as the National Debt Commissioners are concerned, they have never made provision for a sinking fund.

Comment on this

There is not any provision for a sinking fund. I know the interest is being paid regularly as guaranteed by the British Government that it would be. It was originally a loan raised by the British Government. Let us not drag into the thing a minor debating point of that kind because the principal matter is——

Comment on this

It is a pity the Deputy should go chasing Deputy Cosgrave's wild hares.

Comment on this

Whether we are wrong or not is a matter of no consequence. The important thing is that the question is asked from the other side: "What would you do to settle the thing if you were in our shoes?" This is what I would do. I would go to the British and say, "Admitting your right to hold your view—and we are freely agreed that neither you nor Deputy Cosgrave were ever a party to any dishonourable or fraudulent transaction, both of you, we fully recognise, were acting in good faith—we hold, and have persuaded the majority of the people to hold, that there is no statutory obligation upon us or any Treaty obligation upon us to pay this money to Great Britain. That is our view. We fully recognise your view and that all the time in regard to this matter you acted in good faith. Can we not arrive at a compromise and share the burden?" Then point out to Great Britain that what might be an equitable share for each side of the dispute must be arrived at in the light of existing conditions and the respective capacities of the two countries. Over and above that the same argument can be made to-day.

The contention has been frequently advanced from these benches that it is not in the interests of the British to make hard bargains. No hard bargain was ever a good bargain. The British are too long at the job to make bad bargains, and making a hard bargain is making a bad bargain. Hard bargains never pay, and it is the greatest illusion in the world to imagine that you do well by getting the last farthing out of the man with whom you make a bargain. The British are too wise to try making such a bargain. Besides, we know from the statements made in public by Cabinet Ministers of successive British Governments that they have no desire at all to make a hard bargain. The President knows that as well as we do.

I doubt very much if the President wants to settle this question. I venture to say that he does not want to settle the economic war unless and until he can draw into the discussion a series of political problems which he will say must be settled contemporaneously. I believe that is at the root of this whole trouble and what was originally a purely economic dispute between two countries is being steadily converted by the President and his Government into a political dispute. If the President wants to open political negotiations with the British Government, then so far as we are concerned he is quite welcome to do so. In our opinion, every constitutional development is desired for this country, including national unity, and these can be steadily achieved in the same way as other developments have been achieved and in the same way as this country has been progressing constitutionally during the past 12 years. On the economic side boundless hardship has been inflicted on our people during the last four years as a result of this dispute. I say there is a very great obligation on the President and his Government to go to Great Britain and ask them to settle and to see if by adjustment the thing cannot be achieved. I believe it can be done.

Deputy MacDermot is surprised because he says the Opposition not only voted for the coal-cattle pact of 1935 but welcomed it. Why then, he asks, have we this volte face over the coal-cattle pact of 1936? There has been no volte face. I very well remember speaking on the coal-cattle pact of 1935 and the attitude of my colleagues and of every Deputy on this side of the House towards it, has not changed in any way. My attitude towards the present proposal has not changed from my attitude on that of the pact of 1935. My attitude was that on its merits that pact was a joke, but it was the first move made since this crazy business was embarked upon. It was the first move made towards a settlement between the British and the Saorstát. This pact is the first admission on the part of our Government that there is no war as our people understand the word “war.” There is a fictitious war being waged in order to deceive the people. In the course of that war just imagine that it is possible for President de Valera to sit down and make a trade agreement with the British Government. I remember on the occasion of the 1935 coal-cattle pact that we deliberately held back and we made it clear to the country that we did not want to embarrass the Government by commenting on the heads of that arrangement. That was because we felt that that agreement was only a prelude to another and more comprehensive understanding. We did not want to hold it up by making comments on its merits or demerits. However, nothing more came of it for 12 months and in the meantime the Minister for Agriculture and other Ministers made it very clear that although any other trade agreements did not materialise during the following months that it was highly likely when the coal-cattle pact came up to be reviewed in January, 1936, a wider scope would be covered. The general tone was that there was no use in making comments or criticism on the situation until we saw the coal-cattle pact of 1936. So it was that the people waited.

Does any Deputy of any experience of the cattle trade in this country believe that the pact we have got now is going to give any material relief to the producers of cattle throughout the country? I do not believe it will. It is possible that you may get an increase of 10/- or a £1 as a result of increased quotas. There has virtually been no quota on store cattle for the last six or nine months. Licences for these can be had for the asking and you could not sell these licences. Deputies will remember that the average price of cattle has been £8 0s. 8d. That price has been below the cost of production and it stands to reason that the more cattle you sell below the cost of production the more money you lose. If that be true and unless there is a substantial improvement in that price, I say that this new pact is not going to secure any benefit for our people at all. This pact has an additional quality inherent in it that the other pact had not. The first pact led everyone in this country to believe that it was to be the first of many and that the cumulative effect of it would be to eliminate the economic war altogether from the life of the country. This pact seems to be built on the foundation that the economic war is going to go on for ever and that that is the normal position to which we should look in the future of the cattle trade—founded on an average price per head of £8 0s. 8d. I tell you that not only does that mean the ruin of the cattle trade but it also means the collapse of agriculture. The Minister for Agriculture has made that matter perfectly clear himself. The Minister has repeatedly said, "More tillage means more cattle." But if it means more cattle it should mean more profit on the cattle. More tillage cannot mean more cattle on which you lose more money. That is a hopeless future for the farmer. Deputies know that unless you have more cattle that are going to yield a profit nobody is going to go on producing them. If cattle are not produced there is no use on the part of the Government in preaching a policy of tillage and rotation of crops. If you have no means of using the crops that are produced, then agriculture stops.

The Government will say as they always do, "These men have been crying panic from the very beginning. They have been crying havoc and nothing has happened." Are we to be blamed for crying havoc in face of what we see? We see this problem from the two points of view, one of which never engages the attention of the Ministers. We see it from the point of view of the man in the country. We see it also from another point of view—the official figures. Anyone living amongst the people in the country can see it from their point of view. We see the changed way, the changed condition, in which the people of the country are living as compared with a few years back. Look at the figures for 1931, the year previous to that in which the President took office. In that year the total trade of this country, combined imports and exports amounted to £86,500,000 and the adverse trade balance to £14,190,000. The total cost of government in that year was £24,000,000. I cannot vouch for the last figures. That is what they were approximately. In 1935 our total trade was £57,000,000, and our adverse trade balance £17,000,000. In 1934 our total trade was £57,000,000, and our adverse trade balance £21,000,000. In that year our total exports were £17,900,000, and the adverse trade balance £21,000,000. In the year 1935 our exports amounted to £19,900,000 and our adverse trade balance to £17,407,000, while the expenses of government were £31,204,000. Is it any wonder that Deputies on this side of the House begin to look with alarm on the condition of our agricultural industry and the Exchequer, when they discover that it takes nearly two years' exports to pay for one year's government expenditure; and when they discover that we are importing twice as much as we are exporting? These figures are calculated to alarm any man.

I ask Deputies from rural Ireland if they do not see what I see, a steady decline in the standard of living, and in the congested areas amongst producers of live stock a steady decline in the amenities to which they can attain. I see it. I see the children getting into poorer clothes. I see children who previously looked well nourished and well fed looking poorer and thinner, and more miserable than they ever looked. I believe that the reason for that is that the people are getting progressively poorer. There is only one method to remedy that situation and that is the recovery for the people of the British market. On previous occasions when I asked the Government to do what was necessary to get that market back, the reply was: "Do you ask us to lower the flag in the face of the enemy?" On every occasion they made the case that they were willing to settle but that they could not settle; that the British did not want to settle. To-night the flag is lowered, inasmuch as the Government are now in conspiracy with the British Government to see that the annuities, and no less than the annuities, go over. To-night there is ample evidence that the Government is prepared to segregate this question from the political question. If they feel incompetent to deal with the political question they could settle the economic question on its own, and we could return to normalcy, reserving the more complex political issues for consideration. Is it that the President does not want to separate the two questions, but wants to keep one alive while the other is burning? Was it for that reason he blasted the previous appeal by the Vice-President? Is it for that reason he forbids a complete settlement, or is it that having taken up a stand Ministers are not to attempt it, as he is prepared to go down shouting to the end: "Either Great Britain must lick my boots or we will never settle"? No one asked President de Valera to lick the boots of Great Britain, and no rational man would ask Great Britain to lick his boots. There is a via media for men of good-will, if they wish to find it. The people on the other side indicated their willingness to settle this business. Every consideration of importance that could affect the judgment of Irish statesmen demands that it should be disposed of.

It is in the light of that fact, and because we believe a decent standard of life, material happiness and reasonable prosperity are available to our people by having the British market, that I would say to the President: "Leave partial arrangements aside until you can make up your mind to settle the whole question." Tell us in the course of the debate what you are going to tell the British, that you want to open up negotiations for a settlement and the Opposition will withdraw the amendment without hesitation. If this agreement of 1936 is merely to prepare the people for a fuller examination by both sides, in order to solve the difficulties, then we are quite prepared to let our amendment go. But if this is meant to be an introduction of the Irish people to a new dispensation of the economic war as a permanent fixture in the economic life of this country, then this Bill should never pass, because its economic life in no department can hope to continue if the economic war is to be a chronic element in it. Ministers know that our amendment is justified in this particular. Every responsible Deputy should realise that far from alleviating the position of the farmers, except the settlement is final, any such recurrence in the economic life of this country would doom the farmers to ruin, and probably not only the farmers—because if you ruin them you will ruin everyone else—but would doom this country to industrial, agricultural and economic destruction.

It would doom it to the same fate that overtook Newfoundland, with this difference, that Newfoundland had a mother country to turn to to get it out of the mess. We are a mother country but we have no one to turn to to clean up the messes we make ourselves. We have to sink or swim according to our own exertions, and the spectre that haunts me, and that haunts everyone whose people and whose property are indissolubly wedded to this country, is that it will be brought down, and that we will be all brought down with it. The reason we are so anxious about and want a settlement is because we cannot get out of the country. Personally, if I could get out I would have got out long ago. Deputies know that most of the members on the front benches of this Party could not leave this country, because they would not be happy leaving it. They belong to it, and they have to sink or swim here. It is legitimate and right that we should want to see our country and our people happy, and for that reason we want them provided with the wherewithal to meet their obligations and to stand on their own feet. That cannot be done if the economic war is not ended. Let Fianna Fáil face that fact. I assure the President that we will give him our support if he undertakes to dispose of this matter once and for all. The President knows that if he settles the business no word will be spoken on this side and no action taken to prevent a settlement and a reconciliation between himself and the British Government.

Comment on this

I move the adjournment.

Comment on this

I move the adjournment.

Comment on this

The President has moved it.

Comment on this

So long as it is quite clear that the President is not establishing a right to get in to-morrow——

Comment on this

There was an arrangement made that the debate would last one day.

Comment on this

The Minister was not here to-day.

Comment on this

Put on the gag.

Comment on this

As I have only a minute to go I think it is hardly worth while beginning now.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The President has not been called upon to conclude.

Comment on this

I wanted to be clear upon that.

Comment on this

I would like very much that this debate would run on lines in which there was going to be some real understanding of the problems that we have to deal with, and of the difficulties that lie in a solution of these problems. I am afraid the Opposition have not helped very much to have the debate on these lines, and I would like, in the few remarks I have to make, to try and bring the House to consider these matters in an atmosphere of reality. I move the adjournment.

Comment on this