We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Insurance Bill, 1935—Money Resolution. - Insurance Bill, 1935—Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–205 of 406. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Insurance Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 35 of 1935 ›

I understand that there has been agreement that the Minister's amendments will be taken and the Bill reprinted incorporating these amendments, and that then there will be an opportunity of moving the other amendments to the Bill as reprinted. Do I take it that the inclusion of any of the Minister's amendments will not preclude a Deputy from moving an amendment which appears to be in conflict with an amendment now accepted from the Minister?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It will be clearer if I put it this way: When the Bill emerges with the Government's amendments incorporated therein, it may be treated as if it had passed the Second Stage, for the purpose of putting in amendments.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:—

In page 5, after line 43, to insert new paragraphs as follows:—

(h) public liability insurance business,

(i) engineering insurance business,

(j) glass insurance business.

(k) guarantee insurance business,

(l) burglary insurance business.

The Bill in its present form applies only to the classes of insurance business defined in the Act of 1909, as amended by the Road Traffic Act of 1933. There appears, however, to be a good case for extending the provisions of the Bill so as to include certain other classes of business which are set out in the amendment. The classes of business set out in the amendment are important, and I think it is desirable, in the interests of insurers, that the same provisions in respect of control and supervision should apply to them as to the classes of business defined in the 1909 Act. I notice that other Deputies have moved amendments to similar effect, and there appears to be a general opinion that it is desirable that all these classes of business set out in the amendment should be brought subject to the control and supervision which the Bill proposes should apply to other classes of general insurance business.

Comment on this

Can the Minister name any categories of insurance business which remain uncovered by the Bill after the insertion of the amendment?

Comment on this

There are quite a number, such as marine insurance, live-stock insurance, and a number of other insurances, some of which, however, are of a special character, and are perhaps not unusually carried out by specialist companies.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that it is necessary that specialist companies should carry out all the types of insurance which will not be included in the Bill as amended by his amendment?

Comment on this

I think the nature of the business which is involved in these other classes of insurance is such that it is not necessary that the degree of control and supervision which will be exercisable under the Bill in connection with defined classes of business should apply to them also.

Comment on this

Do I take it that while the Minister is bringing in certain additional types of insurance for the purpose of exercising that control, his amendment is not definitely intended to indicate that that is the only type of business he is prepared to bring within scope of the Bill?

Comment on this

If there is an amendment moved on the next Stage, I shall be prepared to consider it.

Comment on this

Would it be correct to say that most of these types of insurance left uncovered are dealt with by lawyers?

Comment on this

Not all.

Comment on this

In this country at present, most live-stock insurance is done through insurance agents. I do not know what type of company actually cover those risks. Marine insurance, I think I am right in saying, is almost completely covered by lawyers. Is the Minister in a position to say, in the case of live-stock insurance, what type of company carries it? Is it the ordinary general company?

Comment on this

No. I believe they are specialist companies—companies which do that class of business almost entirely.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:—

In page 6, line 9, after the word "life" to insert the words and brackets "(other than superannuation allowances and annuities payable out of any funds applicable solely to the relief and maintenance of persons engaged or who have been engaged in a particular profession, trade, or employment or of the dependents of such persons) and also including contracts which are attached to or dependent on contracts of assurance on human life and under which the assurer has no right of cancellation and which provide for the payment of moneys in case of fatal or other accident to or disease of the assured."

This amendment effects two changes. The object of the first part, that is, the part set out in brackets, is to exempt from the provisions of the Bill such staff pension funds, superannuation funds and the like as are not life assurance business within the meaning of the Act of 1909. In such institutions as banks and railways, there are mutual funds which have been established for the benefit of, and are confined to, the staffs concerned who make periodical contributions, entitling them or their dependents to pensions or other benefits, and it is not intended that the provisions of the Bill should apply to such funds. The second part of the amendment deals with accident benefits attaching to life policies. Many life assurance policies include provision for the payment of benefits on accident or disability. They are distinguished from ordinary accident policies by the fact that they form part of a life assurance, and are not subject to cancellation by the insurer. In the case of an ordinary accident policy, the insurer can cancel when renewal is due. If we do not effect this amendment, the other provisions of the Bill, requiring the separation of life assurance from general insurance business, would prevent life companies from giving these accident benefits in connection with life policies.

Comment on this

I take it that the accident benefit referred to by the Minister is the kind of benefit which doubles the value of the policy in the event of the holder dying by accident?

Comment on this

There are various kinds but there are a number of life policies which provide for certain payments in the case of accident or disability, and it is desirable that a life company should be allowed to continue to issue such policies which would otherwise be illegal if this amendment were not effected.

Comment on this

I see no objection in principle to what the Minister is doing, except that it seems to me to open a very wide door. What is there to prevent a company incorporating a life benefit of an infinitesimal size in any given accident policy and thus bring itself within the scope of this amendment and release itself from the obligations of the Bill? For instance, suppose one insures against accident. The Minister's intention is to leave that insurance policy outside the scope of this amendment.

Comment on this

No. The Bill separates life business from general business and prohibits any company which does life business from doing general business. If this amendment were not inserted, the issuing of life assurance policies containing this accident benefit provision would be illegal because it would mean that a life company was doing accident business. In so far as these assurance policies are effected on the life of the assurer and are not subject to cancellation as an accident policy would be, on renewal, there is no reason why we should prohibit life companies from continuing to do that class of business.

Comment on this

Suppose a life company wants to do the accident insurance which the Bill prohibits it from doing, and they issue an accident policy with the proviso in it that the policy carries life insurance for 1/- on the occasion of the death of the insured person, or that a part of the normal premium paid for the accident risk shall be sequestered for the purpose of securing the 1/- life benefit? That is, of course, a purely fictitous insurance in so far as the life part of it is concerned. The effect of that fictitious life value is injected into the accident policy and makes it possible for a life company to issue what is really an accident policy within the terms of the amendment.

Comment on this

Yes, but why should any person take an accident policy in that way? If he wants an accident insurance policy he can get it. If he takes a policy of this kind he must effect it upon the basis of a life policy. The person who wanted an ordinary accident policy naturally would go to the company which could issue him such a policy.

Comment on this

We are ad litem on the line. My suggestion is that in this amendment you are opening a door which the skilful will push more widely open. This amendment will still be an answer to any proceedings brought by the Minister against a life company for having issued such a policy. The insured person need never have been informed about the life policy at all.

Comment on this

The policy must be a contract of assurance on a human life and under which the insurer has no right to cancellation.

Comment on this

But the insurer says this is one life policy and the life premium is covered by the premium which you pay for your annual accident risk. They may say "we are going to give you one premium policy on your life for 1/- and it is going to cost you no more and we are doing that in order to get your business."

Comment on this

Can the Deputy imagine any circumstances in which the insurer who wishes to take out an accident policy would pay a premium for the whole of his life instead of for the particular period during which he wants to be insured?

Comment on this

That would be a whole life period for 1/-. That would be the only element in the policy which survives for the whole life.

Comment on this

That is a very improbable development.

Comment on this

Then my objection is withdrawn.

Comment on this

I would like to know if this applies to superannuation and accident benefit which might be provided specifically by a trade union?

Comment on this

We are specifically providing for that in another amendment.

Comment on this

Is this a counterpart of the other amendment?

Comment on this

No; to Section 6 there is an amendment which specifically excepts trade unions.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

In page 6, to delete all from the word "but" line 9 to and including the word "unions" in line 12.

This is in a sense a drafting amendment, because we felt it better to provide for exemption for trade unions in a specific way. There is an amendment to Section 6 which replaces in the Bill the provisions which are being deleted by this amendment. We consider it more appropriate that the provisions should be in such a section than in the form in which it was included in the original draft.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:—

In page 6, to delete lines 16 and 17 and substitute the words "of less than two months and are collected by means of collectors".

This amendment changes the phrase, "not exceeding two months and are collected by persons authorised in that behalf by the company which carries on such business" to "of less than two months and are collected by means of collectors." This amendment is self-explanatory. I understand the premiums are sometimes collected by other than authorised collectors such as the wife of an authorised collector during the latter's illness or absence from work. The companies are anxious that that practice should not be interfered with by a provision which imposes a statutory prohibition against collection by deputies. That would result in a considerable inconvenience and might interfere with the smooth working of the business in which the collector is engaged.

Comment on this

Does the word "collector" there require definition in the definition section of the Bill?

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

Would not the Minister tighten this amendment by at the same time providing for the collection by deputy?

Comment on this

We are merely defining what constitutes industrial business, and we are defining it as life business in which the premiums are collected at periods of less than two months and by collectors. The only change we are making is to provide that the premiums must be collected at intervals of less than two months. The amendment also provides that the premiums must be collected by collectors authorised by the company, "by persons authorised in that behalf by the company which carries on such business." The purpose of the change is to loosen up the rather tight definition in the original section and to provide a definition of industrial assurance business which will not prohibit the making of the collection by a person other than the authorised collector in the circumstances I have described.

Comment on this

It does not meet the point which is sought to be met in the case of amendment No. 9; but I suppose we cannot argue that under this amendment?

Comment on this

The point in the next amendment is that the Deputy seeks a definition which will confine industrial assurance business to business where the premiums are collected at intervals of one week. There is business which is definitely industrial assurance where the collections are made monthly, and I think it would be a mistake to exempt that business from the control which this Bill proposes to impose. The effect of the amendment is the names of Deputies Keyes and Pattison would be to take this class of business, industrial assurance business, outside the scope of the industrial insurance provisions of the Bill.

Comment on this

I wonder if the Minister has looked into the reaction on those on whom the responsibility of collectting those premiums fall, because of the fact that it is sought to make their business ordinary branch business. Ordinary branch terms apply to the collection of these premiums whereas industrial branch terms ought to apply.

Comment on this

Is it not fairly common that arrangements are made in ordinary branch assurance business for monthly payments, and while the ordinary terms of the company are on the basis of premiums to be paid yearly, half-yearly or quarterly, in many cases the arrangements are made whereby persons who are paid monthly salaries pay their premiums monthly?

Comment on this

There are certain controls in the Bill, but the essential difference between industrial business and ordinary business is that in the case of industrial insurance the collection of premiums is made by collectors. That is an essential difference.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that it is possible to throw on the collector the responsibility of collecting from a householder or assured person the premiums in cases where the premiums is collected yearly, half-yearly or quarterly? In some cases the collector must collect the premiums weekly while the collector's remuneration is fixed on the basis of collecting them yearly, half-yearly or quarterly.

Comment on this

That is a different point to that which we are discussing.

Comment on this

Someone is going to define the word "collector." As the Bill stands, the court should define it, but I think it is more expedient to define it in the Bill. An alternative method of meeting the insurance companies without defining the word "collector" would be to say "and are all collected by persons authorised in that behalf by the company which carries on such business, or their agents."

Comment on this

The word "collector" is defined in Part V of the Bill relating to industrial assurance.

Comment on this

And that definition will cover the reference to that word in Part I?

Comment on this

Yes, Where used in Part I it relates to industrial assurance.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:—

In page 6, line 18, before the word "but" to insert the words "including contracts which are attached to or dependent on such assurances and under which the assurer has no right of cancellation and which provide for the payment of moneys in case of fatal or other accident to or decease of the assured."

The object of this amendment is to make the extension in respect of accident benefits in the case of industrial assurance policies as has already been made in the case of ordinary life assurance policies. It is similar to the amendment we have discussed.

Comment on this

The Minister will look into the point I have made to see if it does not leave a wider door than he at first thought?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:—

In page 6, line 26, to delete the word "further."

This amendment merely provides for the deletion of the redundant word.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 12:—

In page 6, line 39, immediately after the word "upwards" to insert the words "but of less than two months."

This is purely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:—

In page 6, line 52, immediately after the word "sickness" to insert the words "except any contracts which are attached to or dependent on contracts of life assurance business or industrial assurance business and which confer benefits on the assured in case of fatal or other accident to or decease of the assured and under which the assurer has no right of cancellation.

This amendment is consequential on the amendments dealing with the extension of the definition of life assurance and industrial assurance business in connection with accident benefits.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 16:—

In page 6, line 66, before the word "effecting" to insert the word "of".

This is merely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 17:—

In page 7, between lines 3 and 4, to insert the following words:—

"the expression ‘public liability insurance business' means the following and no other classes of assurance business, that is to say, the business of effecting contracts of insurance indemnifying the insured against liability to pay compensation or damages to any person in respect of personal injury, loss, or damage sustained by such person through the negligence of the insured or of his servant or agent acting within the scope of his employment or authority as such servant or agent (as the case may be) and the business of effecting contracts of insurance indemnifying the insured against liability to pay compensation or damages arising out of or in connection with the negligent use or condition of the property, whether real or personal, of the insured;

the expression ‘engineering insurance business' means the following and no other class of assurance business, that is to say, the business of effecting contracts of insurance against loss arising from damage or injury to any boiler or other apparatus containing gas, vapour or liquid under pressure or any mechanical apparatus or other machinery or arising in any other way from or in connection with the use of any such apparatus or machinery, including liability to pay compensation to third parties in relation to such apparatus or machinery;

the expression ‘glass insurance business' means the business of effecting contracts of insurance against loss by or incidental to the breakage of glass;

the expression ‘guarantee insurance business' means the business of effecting contracts of insurance with employers against loss by or incidental to fraud, embezzlement, misappropriation, forgery, theft, or larceny by employees and the business of issuing bonds or contracts of suretyship;

the expression ‘burglary insurance business' does not include guarantee insurance business, but subject to that overriding limitation the said expression means the business of effecting contracts of insurance against loss by or incidental to burglary, housebreaking, theft, or larceny;".

This is consequential on amendment No. 3, and provides definitions of the additional classes of business brought within the scope of the Bill.

Comment on this

It is consequential on amendment No. 3?

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

And it describes the types of business set out in that category?

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 18:—

In page 7, between lines 3 and 4, to insert the words—

the expression "sinking fund or capital redemption business" means the business of effecting contracts of insurance (otherwise than upon human life) whereby the insurer in consideration of the payment to him of one premium, or of two or more premiums paid at intervals of not less than two months, agrees to pay to the insured at a future date or on future dates one sum or a series of sums.

Sinking fund or capital redemption business is not a class of business that comes within the scope of the 1909 Act or of this Bill, but it is referred to in the definition of bond investment business on page 6. It is necessary to have it defined, and that is what this amendment is designed to do.

Comment on this

Give us a short description of what sinking fund or capital redemption business is in practice.

Comment on this

That is what the amendment is designed for.

Comment on this

The amendment defines what the business is in technical terms, but it does not convey to somebody who is not engaged in the insurance business actively what are the circumstances in which contracts of this character are entered into. It might appear that these were transactions wherein a person pays a single premium for the purpose, say, of insuring against death duties.

Comment on this

Against obligations which arise when debentures have to be redeemed, for example.

Comment on this

Or against the obligation to pay death duties when realising capital from a deceased person's estate. These are single premium insurance policies.

Comment on this

They need not be single premium policies. I think the definition describes the class of business involved. If people contract a loan which has to be repaid at the end of a period, they can effect a policy under which the insurance company contracts to provide the amount necessary to redeem the loan in consideration of the payment of premiums in the interval.

Comment on this

This would apply to house purchase agreements with insurance companies?

Comment on this

There is a system whereby I can buy a house and borrow 80 per cent. of the cost from the insurance company and take out an insurance policy on my life on foot of which the insurance company undertakes to discharge the debt due on my house at a certain time, in the event of my death earlier than the date fixed. There is an endowment system and you undertake to pay premiums for 20 years. At the end of that time your loan on the house is extinguished, but there is a proviso that if you die before the 20 years have lapsed the insurance company will pay off the outstanding mortgage on the house. Does an insurance contract of that character come within the terms of this amendment?

Comment on this

No; there is no life interest in this class of business at all.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 20:

In page 7, line 9, after the word "worth" to insert the words "payable or", and in line 10 to delete the words "or given".

This amendment is designed to secure a more complete definition of the word "premium."

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 28:—

In page 7, line 49, to delete the word "either."

This is purely a drafting amendment. It is consequential on the fact that we propose to insert two new paragraphs.

Comment on this

It is certainly more than a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

It is really consequential on the insertion of two new paragraphs in the section.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 29:—

In paragraph (a), page 7, line 50, after the word "validity" to insert the words "or the due continuance and fulfilment".

The object of this amendment is to make it clear that the provisions of the Bill will not operate to interfere with the continuance and fulfilment of existing contracts where the insurer does not obtain a licence under the Bill.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 30:—

In page 7, at the end of the section to add the following word and new paragraph:—

or

(c) any business lawfully carried on by societies and other bodies registered in Saorstát Eireann under the Acts relating to friendly societies or to trade unions.

This is an amendment which is consequential on an earlier amendment to which I referred and it provides for the exemption of the business of registered friendly societies and registered trade unions. It is considered that the exemption, which it was intended to afford in any event, could more appropriately be effected by a provision in this section rather than in the earlier section. The desirability of exempting that class of business from the provisions of the Bill is clear. Certain trade unions carry on minor forms of insurance. They may, for instance, insure a worker against the loss of his tools and it is not necessary to have that business brought under the provisions of the Bill.

Comment on this

I would like some clarification of this position from the Minister. The first intention of the Bill appeared to be to bring the trade unions carrying on business which might be described as life insurance business within its scope, making provision for certain forms of exemption, in the case of a union registered in Saorstát Eireann. It appears that you require a union not so registered to make a deposit as a condition of continuing that kind of business and that condition would apply not merely to unions which definitely do not desire to register but unions which were prevented by the constitutional position here from registering. I would like the Minister to indicate what is the effect of this amendment on the Bill as first circulated. I think his own explanation of the thing is rather inadequate.

Comment on this

There is no change, except perhaps a minor one. The Bill as originally circulated excluded from the definition of life assurance business any contracts described as "effected by societies and other bodies registered in Saorstát Eireann under the Acts relating to friendly societies or to trade unions." That has been deleted, and we are proposing to provide here that nothing in this Act shall affect any business lawfully carried on by societies or trade unions registered in Saorstát Eireann under the Acts relating to friendly societies or trade unions. That widens the scope of the exemption in so far as it extends it to cover business other than life assurance business as defined, but the effect of it is the same and it confines the exemption to business carried on by trade unions registered in Saorstát Eireann. That is, however, a question to which I had given very considerable attention, and it may be necessary to consider it again at a later stage. There are unions operating here which have been deemed not to be registered in Saorstát Eireann, and the effect of the Bill on those unions has to be considered. I should not like to give the impression that I have arrived at a final conclusion as to the best course to adopt in relation to such unions, but in so far as this amendment is concerned it leaves the position unchanged. If it is decided to change the scope of the Bill in relation to those unregistered unions it will require another amendment.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say precisely what types of insurance he has in mind in connection with this amendment?

Comment on this

Any classes of insurance, such as a superannuation fund, provision for the payment of benefit on accident or in similar circumstances, insurance against loss of tools, or any of the things that a trade union might do for the benefit of its members in accordance with the law.

Comment on this

Why does the Minister think it is desirable to exclude from the supervision that is provided for in this Bill insurance enterprises carried on by a trade union?

Comment on this

I do not think it is necessary to have special provisions for the supervision of that business in an Insurance Bill. There are, of course, Acts relating to trade unions, but in any event the requirement of a deposit and so forth would be well beyond the capacity of many of the trade unions concerned.

Comment on this

I can quite see that there are certain parts of the Bill which would not be applicable to the minor activities of a trade union of an insurance character, but I can see no reason why the activities of a trade union in an insurance enterprise, no matter how small, should not be subject to the same type of supervision that the industrial insurance company or the minor branch insurance which is practised by large companies must submit to. On the contrary, I think it is a very good thing that any insurance contracts of that character should be under the strictest State supervision. We have got to bear in mind that the men dealing with a trade union insurance enterprise of that kind are of a type most easily victimised because they ordinarily have not the time or the resources to prosecute legal claims against a trade union or insurance company. Therefore, there should be the utmost vigilance by the State to see that substantial justice is done between themselves and the assuree body. I think it would be better from the point of view of the trade unions and the members thereof if all insurance activities carried on by a trade union were subject to the closest scrutiny that is provided for any other insurance body in the State. We quite agree that they would have to be delivered from the necessity of putting up big deposits such as insurance companies are required to do, because insurance is not the prime purpose of a trade union; it is a side activity. That may be easily done without taking them out of the scope of the Bill altogether.

Comment on this

Supervision is provided for in the Trade Union Acts. My point is that it is not desirable to provide for the supervision in an Insurance Act. There is provision for supervision in the Trade Union Acts, and, although the Trade Union Acts are in many respects antiquated and may have to be revised at some stage, if any further provision were deemed necessary to cover those classes of businesses done by trade unions it is in that code that the provision should be made, and not in this.

Comment on this

Would not Deputy Norton agree with me that in the interregnum between bringing the trade union code up to date it would be desirable if power were vested in the Minister for Industry and Commerce to supervise the insurance activities of any trade union to the same extent as this Bill allows him to supervise insurance companies?

Comment on this

I do not think the position is the same as in the case of an ordinary insurance company. The benefits which trade unions provide, for instance in the form of tool money for a member, or emigration money, or superannuation benefit, or other special kinds of benefit, are not in the nature of contractual obligations. They are a kind of discretionary benefits which are given. The condition of entitlement to them is not related to the fact that a member pays any individual contribution for them, but rather being a member of a society his membership of the society entitles him to consideration in the matter of having such benefits extended to him. But he has no individual contractual rights to benefits of that kind. In practically all cases he does not pay for any special benefits, but gets them in a kind of discretionary way under the rules of the society. I think it may well be argued, in respect of the kind of business which trade unions do, that in fact they do not come within the scope of insurance legislation as conceived and expressed here, because in many cases the element of contract is wholly absent, and that is the main basis upon which insurance is defined in this Bill.

Comment on this

Does not the Minister think that Deputy Norton's statement in regard to this matter strengthens the case for closer supervision? Is it a desirable thing that insurance activities should be carried on by a trade union on an indeterminate and vague basis such as that outlined by Deputy Norton? After all, anybody who has any knowledge of those things knows that if the trade unions are carrying on their insurance activities on a sound basis they must earmark a part of the dues of a member of the trade union for benefits under the various schemes they have in mind. At first glance I cannot approve of a pseudo insurance system which is based on paternalism, leaving discretion in the trade union authorities to give the benefit to one man and withhold it from another, because in my opinion the trade union will be forced into the position of allowing their judgment to be influenced by their knowledge from time to time of what funds they have at their disposal. To me that does not seem to be fair. If two men are paying the same dues to the same trade union those two men should be entitled to the same benefits of every character. A trade union cannot possibly make those benefits effectively available unless they have made a rule of earmarking a part of every man's dues to finance the benefits which it is their intention to confer. I think it is necessary that the Department of Industry and Commerce should have the power of supervising that activity in order to ensure that substantial justice is done as between one member of the trade union and another, and in order to see that the dues of one man will not be sequestered to pay the benefits of another, when the other's dues have not made any contribution towards benefit for the first.

Comment on this

Arising out of Deputy Norton's remark, if there is no contract it is not insurance business, and would not come under this Bill in any event. If there is any need for better supervision or regulation of such activities by trade unions it is not by a section of this Bill that that would be done but by an amendment of the existing Trade Union Acts.

Comment on this

I should like to correct what I think is a misapprehension on the part of Deputy Dillon. I used the term "discretionary" as indicating the power of the union to give a benefit to the member, but the inability of the member to sue for the extension of that particular benefit as a matter of contractual right. In fact, the grant of a benefit of that kind is not given in a discretionary way as between individuals. The discretion is exercised collectively over the whole membership, and the benefit is paid by the whole body of members. The right to pay it, as a right, does sometimes reside within the executive of the union. They can make a grant or not, but once the grant is made it applies to the whole of the membership and it is dependent upon the funds existing from time to time. The matter Deputy Dillon is concerned with is to ensure that all members should be treated fairly. I have had considerable experience of the way trade unions manage funds of this kind. I am satisfied of this: that for the one case in which an insured member would get the benefit of the doubt in the case of a private insurance company, he would at least get the benefit of the doubt a hundred times more in the case of the trade union. Funds of that kind, providing for benefits such as I have indicated, are administered in a rather generous manner. The object sought is to pay the member what it is possible to pay him, having regard to his rights in the matter, and that strict legal procedure which is the feature of private insurance companies, in dealing with policy-holders, is not obtruded in the same way as between a privately insured person and a private company. As the Minister said, the way in which matters of this kind in relation to trade unions might be regulated where regulation is necessary, is in a Bill dealing with the trades union legislation. This is hardly a matter that could be brought into a Bill of this kind, which I take it is dealing with insurance different from that in which trade unions are engaged. If the matter was to be dealt with by legislation at all it should be dealt with in a Bill dealing with trade unions.

Comment on this

I am not at all reassured. Beneficence is a very desirable thing. But, dealing with insurance funds, beneficence alone would not be sufficient. While I am prepared to accept that where there is no contract between a person and a trade union they would not come within the scope of this Bill, yet I cannot see there is any reason in excluding cases where there is a contract between the trade union and the person entitled to benefit. Misguided benefit might involve persons in a very great loss, and short-sighted benefits might involve catastrophe.

Comment on this

There is supervision.

Comment on this

The Minister says there is supervision under the Trades Union Act. I do not know what that supervision is. Perhaps the Minister would in the course of the Recommittal Stage give a resumé of the supervision under the Trades Union Acts which he regards as sufficiently provided for in this amendment.

Comment on this

I express no opinion as to the adequacy of the supervision. Trade unions have always been exempted. They were exempted under the Act of 1909, and they are exempted from this Bill because they are regulated on a different footing. Friendly societies are also exempted and their supervision is exercised by the Registrar of Friendly Societies. I think it is desirable that we should leave that position unchanged in this Bill. I have not expressed any opinion as to the adequacy of the supervision under the Trades Union Act.

Comment on this

The Act of 1909 contained an entirely inadequate provision for the inspection of industrial insurance, and it was as a result of that that the Act of 1923 was passed in Great Britain. That Act never applied here, and this Bill differs substantially from the 1923 Act.

Comment on this

In the case of industrial insurance?

Comment on this

Yes. My complaint is that until the Trades Union Act is amended to bring their insurance activities into line with the provisions of the Industrial Insurance Act they ought to be brought under this Bill for the intervening period and until amending legislation is introduced.

Comment on this

Was that done in Great Britain?

Comment on this

I could not tell but I am not prepared to take my lead from Great Britain in everything that is done. I recognise it would be more suitable that the trade union code should be provided for under this Bill, and then trade unions could be lifted out of it and placed back again, when their own code is amended. In the interval I think they should be brought under this Bill.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 31:—

In page 7, at the end of the section, to add the following word and new paragraph:—

or

(c) any business which is not an assurance business.

This is designed to remove any possible doubt that the provisions of the Bill do not apply to any class of business which is not assurance business. The amendment is designed to remove any ambiguity.

Comment on this

To exclude the kind of operations to which Deputy Norton referred.

Comment on this

The Bill does not apply to anything which is not an assurance business as so defined.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 33:—

In sub-section (1), page 8, line 29, after the word "person" to insert the brackets and words "(otherwise than in the course of reinsurance)".

This amendment is necessary to enable reinsurance to be effected with unlicensed companies to the extent that licensed companies and the reinsurance company are not prepared to provide full reinsurance cover on their own risk, and also to permit reinsurance with unlicensed companies during the period before the reinsurance provisions of the Bill are brought into operation.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 36:—

In sub-section (2), page 8, line 44, after the word "issues" to insert the brackets and words "(otherwise than in the course or by way of reinsurance)", and in line 50 before the word "issued" to insert the word "so".

The necessity for the first part of the amendment I explained when dealing with the last amendment; the insertion of the word "so" before the word "issued" is merely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 42:—

In sub-section (3) page 9, line 58, to delete the word "commencement" and substitute the word "date".

This is merely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 50:—

In sub-section (5), page 10, to delete paragraph (e) and substitute a new paragraph as follows:—

(e) either such company (if it is incorporated under the law of a country other than Saorstát Eireann) complies with the provisions of Section 274 of the Act of 1908, or such company (if it is a society, association, or other body which is incorporated or otherwise constituted under the law of a country other than Saorstát Eireann) has filed with the Registrar of Companies—

(i) a certificate (certified by the proper officer of the country in which such company is so incorporated or otherwise constituted) of the registration of such company in such country, and

(ii) a copy (similarly certified) of the rules or other instrument defining the constitution of such company, and

(iii) the names of the persons forming the committee of management or other body having the direction or control of such company, and

(iv) the names of the secretary and the trustees of such company and of the persons authorised to sue and be sued on behalf of such company, and

(v) the names and the addresses of one or more persons resident in Saorstát Eireann who are authorised to accept on behalf of such company service of any notices, documents, or legal process.

This amendment is intended to meet cases of insurers not incorporated under the Companies Act, 1908.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister if this will also apply in the case of friendly societies and trade unions?

Comment on this

They are exempted from the Act in any event.

Comment on this

This is to prescribe conditions which certain bodies incorporated outside must comply with in order to secure exemption. I take it the Minister is requiring certain outside organisations not incorporated here to supply certain information to him?

Comment on this

And to enable them to carry on business.

Comment on this

Yes, to secure exemption from the rigid application of the Act. Does that requirement extend, for instance, to trade unions who are not now technically registered under the Trade Union Acts here?

Comment on this

Quite. If there was a trade union which carried on insurance business on the qualifying date and desired to carry on business and was prepared to comply with the requirements of the Act, by application for a licence, making a deposit, etc., then there is no reason why they should be excluded from continuing to do it.

Comment on this

That is subject, of course, to the second view which the Minister may take of this when he looks into it?

Comment on this

The second view is on the question whether we should exempt these unregistered trade unions from the provisions of the Act altogether. Any insurer who, in accordance with the provisions of the Bill, can claim a licence is entitled to carry on insurance business if he conforms with the requirements of the Bill in toto.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53:—

In sub-section (6), page 10, to delete all words from the word "assurance" in line 54 to the word "business" in line 57 and substitute the words "one or more than one class of assurance business other than life assurance business and industrial assurance business."

This is a drafting change. We have extended the number of classes of general insurance business to which the Bill applies, and this change is being effected in order to avoid needless repetition.

Comment on this

This goes a good deal further than the amendment to increase the categories of insurance under Section 3, because in Section 3 you inserted amendment No. 3, which increases the categories of insurance business covered by the Bill by five heads, but leaving out marine and live stock and a variety of other types of insurance to which the Minister referred. Amendment No. 53 covers all forms of insurance other than life and industrial assurance business.

Comment on this

A licence is not required to carry on any insurance business except those to which the Bill applies. We said in the original Bill "whenever an application is made by a foreign company for an insurance licence to carry on" certain named types of business, and now we are changing that to read: "one or more than one class of assurance business other than life assurance business and industrial assurance business." There is no change in the purport of the sub-section. There is merely an avoidance of unnecessary repetition of the classes of business to which the sub-section applies.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 56:—

In sub-section (6) to delete all words from the word "of" where it firstly occurs in line 63 on page 10 to the word "business" in line 2 on page 11, and substitute the words "than one class of assurance business other than life assurance business and industrial assurance business".

Comment on this

That is the same thing. I just ask for an assurance that it does not operate to widen or contract the section as it originally stood.

Comment on this

No, except consequential upon Section 3.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 61:—

In sub-section (9) (a), page 11, to delete all words from the word "of" where it firstly occurs in line 40, to the word "business" in line 44, and substitute the words "than one class of assurance business other than life assurance business and industrial assurance business".

Comment on this

That is the same thing.

Comment on this

Is there not needless repetition in the last three lines with the beginning which says "by a Saorstát Eireann Company which at the date of such application carries on neither life assurance business nor industrial assurance business, but which, on the 31st day of October, 1935, carried on one or more than one class of assurance business other than life assurance business and industrial assurance business and did not on the said 31st day of October, 1935, carry on life assurance business or industrial assurance business."

Comment on this

It may not be literature, but I am told it is good law. However, I shall have the draft reexamined.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 66:—

In sub-section (9), page 12, to delete all words from the word "assurance" where it secondly occurs in line 1 to the word "business" in line 5, and substitute the words "one or more than one class of assurance business other than life assurance business or industrial assurance business."

This is the same thing.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 68:—

Before Section 13 to insert a new section as follows:—

Whenever an application has been duly made in accordance with this Act by a foreign company which is a society, association, or other body incorporated or otherwise constituted under the law of a country other than Saorstát Eireann for an assurance licence to carry on life assurance business or industrial assurance business, or whenever an assurance licence has been granted to any such company to carry on either or both of such businesses, the following provisions shall have effect, that is to say:—

(a) any alteration in the rules or other instrument defining the constitution of such company and filed with the Registrar of Companies shall be notified to such Registrar within the prescribed time, and

(b) any notice, document or legal process may (save as may be otherwise required by or under any rules of court or an order of a court or judge) be served by being left with or sent by prepaid ordinary post to the persons resident in Saorstát Eireann at the addresses of such persons as specified by such company under this Part of this Act, and

(c) The Registrar of Companies shall, if satisfied that such company has filed with him the matters required by this Part of this Act to be so filed by it, issue a certificate under his hand certifying that such company has so filed the matters which it is so required to file, and

(d) every such certificate shall be prima facie evidence of the matters stated therein and it shall not be necessary to prove the signature of the Registrar of Companies or that he was in fact such Registrar.

The purpose is to require that insurers not having the constitution of incorporated companies shall notify the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies of any alteration in their constitution. It also provides for the service of a process and for the issue of a certificate by the Registrar of the filing of documents to such insurers. It is consequential, in a sense, upon the other amendment changing Section 12.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 71:—

In page 12, before sub-section (3) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

(3) Whenever the Minister grants to a foreign company an assurance licence to carry on one or more than one class of assurance business (other than life assurance business or industrial assurance business) the Minister shall (without prejudice to any other power of refusal conferred on him by this Act) refuse every application by such company for an assurance licence to carry on any other such class of assurance business unless such company on the 31st day of October, 1935, carried on in Saorstát Eireann that other class of assurance business.

This amendment limits the grant of a licence to a foreign company to such class of business as the company carried on in the Saorstát on 31st October, 1935. I think it is desirable to have such an amendment, because since the passing of the Road Traffic Act, 1933, a number of companies made a deposit of £15,000 and commenced to carry on mechanically-propelled vehicle insurance without, however, undertaking any other class of business. If this amendment were not inserted such companies could obtain a licence and could then, if they wished, proceed to do any class of general insurance business provided for in the Bill.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 80:

In sub-section (1) (b), page 15, to delete all from the word "of" where it first occurs in line 12 to the word "business" where it secondly occurs in line 15, and substitute the words "than one class of assurance business other than life assurance business, industrial assurance business, mechanically propelled vehicle insurance business and glass insurance business".

That is consequential on amendment No. 2.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 83:

Before sub-section (2), page 15, to insert a new sub-section as follows:

(2) Section 2 (which relates to deposits) of the Act of 1909, as amended or varied by this section, shall apply to every sum which an assurance company is required by this section to deposit and keep deposited in like manner as the said Section 2 applies to the sum which an assurance company is required to deposit and keep deposited under that section.

The purpose is to make it clear that deposits for the purpose of the Bill may, as under the Act of 1909, be made either in cash or securities.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 86:

In sub-section (2), page 15, to insert at the end of the sub-section the following word and new paragraph:—

or

(d) an assurance company which on the 31st day of October, 1935, carried on in Saorstát Eireann assurance business other than life assurance business or industrial assurance business and which is not required by the Act of 1909 to make a deposit and in respect of which the Minister is satisfied that the business which such company carries on is wholly or substantially the effecting of insurances against loss of or damage to or in respect of property belonging to, or held in trust for, or used or occupied by or on behalf of a religious organisation or body, including liability to pay compensation or damages to workmen employed by trustees, committees, stewards or other officers or holders of such property.

The purpose is to continue the exemption heretofore enjoyed by the Methodist Insurance Company Limited, the surplus earnings of which are distributed for the benefit of charitable or benevolent organisations within that denomination.

Comment on this

Is that the only organisation affected?

Comment on this

It is, so far as I know.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 87:—

In page 15, to add at the end of sub-section (2) the following word and new paragraph:—

or

(d) an assurance company which carries on glass insurance business and in respect of which the Minister is satisfied that such company carries on no other class of assurance business.

The amendment provides an exemption from the obligation to deposit, where the insurer transacts glass business and not any other class of insurance business. That business is small and the necessity for a deposit does not arise.

Comment on this

Are there many companies affected?

Comment on this

There are certain companies who specialise in this class of business and who do no other.

Comment on this

Are there any of them incorporated here?

Comment on this

There are companies incorporated here which do glass business.

Comment on this

Are there any exclusively glass insuring companies incorporated?

Comment on this

I could not answer that straight away, but there may be.

Comment on this

Does that provision not seem to conflict with amendment No. 3 already passed, which makes provision for the inclusion of this business in the Bill?

Comment on this

We are bringing glass insurance business subject to control in all respects as other classes of insurance business, and we are applying the separation of business provisions to glass insurance business, but we do not think there is any public need to require a company doing glass business only to make a deposit in the High Court. If, however, it does any other business as well as glass business, the deposit must be made.

Comment on this

Is the Minister not giving a specially privileged position to that company? In other words, any company incorporated here as an exclusively glass insuring company is allowed to carry on its activities here, to be exempt from the payment of the deposit and to enter into competition with the existing Irish companies. Would the Minister not consider requiring such company to make a deposit of £20,000 if it is going to continue its activities here? There is a particularly strong case for not putting it in a specially privileged position as compared with Irish companies, which, as the Minister has indicated, carry on glass assurance, and which, presumably, could transact this business in the same way as an externally controlled company.

Comment on this

I am informed the only company doing this business here exclusively is an Irish incorporated company. It is the Irish Plate-glass Insurance Company.

Comment on this

That is new information.

Comment on this

In any event, I do not think there is much need for a deposit in such a case.

Comment on this

I think there is a good deal to be said for what Deputy Norton has put forward. This glass business is regarded as one of the choice businesses in the insurance world. The ordinary Irish company or the ordinary foreign company in doing its business has to take the rough with the smooth. A great deal of the business is non-paying, or badly paying, and this class of insurance is considered one of the plums of the insurance business. I think it is very unfair to give special facilities to any one company who specialise in that particular line, and I think that companies doing general business and facilitating the public generally should be considered in a matter of this kind.

Comment on this

But the ordinary company does not have to make an additional deposit in order to do this class of business. If it is doing other classes of general business, it can do this as well. The only question is whether a company doing this and no other business should be required to make a deposit of £20,000. There is certainly no public need for the provision, nor is this concession, if it can be called a concession, confined to any one company. Anybody who gets a licence to carry on in accordance with the provisions of the Bill can confine himself to this class of business if he wishes.

Comment on this
Mr. Bourke

I am not questioning that. I say that it is unfair to companies doing general business.

Comment on this

But they do not have to make an additional deposit in order to do this class of business.

Comment on this
Mr. Bourke

By picking that out, you are skimming the cream off the whole business.

Comment on this

The Minister said that one company was affected by this proposal.

Comment on this

He said that one company did glass insuring business exclusively.

Comment on this

What I say is that I know there is one company doing an exclusive glass business, but we are not limiting the position in a manner which will mean that only one company will do it.

Comment on this

Is not the purpose of this amendment to cater specially for the position of one company which is not carrying on other types of insurance, but is confining its activities to glass insurance?

Comment on this

In such a case, we do not think there is need for the £20,000 deposit.

Comment on this

Is it the purpose of the amendment to cater particularly for the company doing glass business only in respect of which commodity the Minister does not think it is desirable to have a deposit made?

Comment on this

I think that if we were to insist upon a company which is doing plate-glass business only making a deposit, we would put any such company out of business, but that is not the main consideration. Looking at the question from the point of view of the public interest and from the point of view of the circumstances which gave rise to this deposit system at all, there does not appear to be, in relation to a company doing this class of business only, any necessity to require them to make a deposit of a substantial amount with the Accountant of the High Court.

Comment on this

I do not know that the Minister can insist on the ground that it is not desirable from the public point of view. I do not know that it is undesirable from the public point of view that the High Court of this country should have £20,000 of a company's money deposited with it for use in satisfaction of any disputed claims if need be. Can the Minister say how many companies to his knowledge are operating in this country exclusively in the glass insurance business?

Comment on this

I could not answer that straight away. I know of one company, but there may be some others. There are, of course, quite a number doing the business, but not exclusively.

Comment on this

I want to know if the Minister knows any company doing glass business only.

Comment on this

I know at least one.

Comment on this

What is the name of that company?

Comment on this

The Irish Plate-glass Insurance Company, I think.

Comment on this

Has it any existence outside this country?

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

It is an exclusively Irish company?

Comment on this

I think so, but I am only giving my recollection of the position.

Comment on this

I should like to know if the Minister has inquired closely into this problem, because two points arise. One is the matter referred to by Deputy Bourke. As general insurance is run in this country at present, what is actually happening is that some profitable branches of general insurance are carrying unprofitable branches to a certain extent. Motor insurance is extremely unprofitable, and it is very largely carried on by insurance companies for the purpose of getting other business. Heretofore, when they could do life and general business, they very often did motor insurance for the purpose of getting into a house with a view to getting O.B. business there, and if you are going to allow special privileges to individual companies who undertake to engage only in those branches of insurance which have been proved by experience to be profitable——

Comment on this

We are only dealing with one class—glass insurance.

Comment on this

If you are going to allow that to develop, I do not see how you can refuse to extend a similar concession to any company which is insuring other small individual risks and which says: "It is inconceivable that at any time we should sustain a loss which would make it necessary to turn to our reserve deposit in court to meet it." They could make a case similar to the plate-glass company's case to get exemption from the operation of the Bill. If that happened, you would leave the general insurance companies carrying all the unprofitable business, and being undercut in respect of profitable risks by the specialised companies who were running very small establishments on advantageous terms. That is one problem to which I invite the Minister's consideration.

The second problem is one the answer to which I do not know myself. I do not know if the Minister's attention has been directed to it. The situation in the plate-glass business is very peculiar because my information is that there is some kind of a cartel which deals with plate-glass, and the terms under which the cartel operates are that plate-glass will not be supplied to any merchant who sells it to a consumer below the fixed price. That was originally done for the purpose of preventing prices being cut by excessive competition. The effect of it has been that the plate-glass distributors got a proviso put into the cartel agreement providing that while they must all get the minimum price fixed by the cartel, they could make a salvage allowance for as many square feet of plate-glass as they could cut out of the window that had been broken. Accordingly, if a plate-glass window be smashed you send to a glass merchant and ask him: “For how much will you put in a plate-glass window to replace this plate-glass window that has been smashed?” He looks at the window and he measures out of that window the square feet of glass that he can credit against his customer's bill and he makes an estimate of the cost of putting in the window. When that person is going away he puts his elbow against the window with the result the remaining part of the glass is broken and the next person who comes to give an estimate will naturally have to give a higher estimate. If that is the case, is it possible for a plate-glass insurance company to derive some peculiar benefit—I will not say through collusion because there is nothing dishonourable or dishonest in the transaction—but is there not a possibility of the plate-glass window insurance company operating in conjunction with plate-glass suppliers or with the cartel, or could any special benefit accrue to a company operating as such that would not be available to the ordinary insurance company? I have no reason to think that there is, but I think the facts that I have mentioned to the Minister should be considered.

Comment on this

Any company operating as an insurance company must make a deposit of £20,000, that is any company which does a business to which the Act applies except motor vehicle insurance for which the deposit is £15,000, but it is not considered necessary in the public interest to require a deposit from a company doing plate-glass business only. As regards the question of the cartel, I am afraid that I do not know much about those arrangements, but Deputy Dillon will be glad to hear that in the next six months we will be able to provide him with Irish plate glass, and the more of that that will be broken the more employment will be given.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 89:

In sub-section (2), paragraph (b), page 16, line 19, before the word "direct" to insert the word "either", and at the end of the said paragraph to add the words "or, if requested by such assurance company so to do, direct the accountant of the Courts of Justice to transfer to such assurance company or some person nominated by such assurance company so much (if any) of the said investments as will leave the market value of the residue of such investments on the day of such transfer equal to the said full proper amount."

The purpose of this amendment is obvious—it is to permit the transfer of surplus stocks. That amendment will bring the section into accord with Section 22 dealing with the release of deposits.

Comment on this

That explanation is rather too vague.

Comment on this

If that amendment were not there, it might be held that it would be necessary to release or transfer the surplus in cash, whereas the amendment is designed to permit the remission of the surplus in the form of a transfer of securities.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 102:—

In page 24, between lines 13 and 14, to insert the following:—"the expression ‘industrial assurance company' means an assurance company which carries on industrial assurance business."

This is an extension of the definition section. The expression "industrial assurance company" occurs frequently in this part of the Bill, and it is considered necessary to insert this definition here.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 106:—

In page 24, lines 24 and 25, to delete the words "held by a person who has effected a policy of industrial assurance", and in line 26 to delete the words "such policy" and substitute the words "a policy of industrial assurance".

This is a drafting amendment which makes it clear that the premium receipt book need not be held by the assured person himself. It is often held by a relative so as to be available when the collector calls.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 113:—

In sub-section (2), page 25, line 13, to delete the word "by".

This is a purely drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 114:

In sub-section (2), page 25, line 19, after the word "endowment" to insert the words "or endowment assurance".

This is also a drafting agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 116:—

In sub-section (3), page 25, line 22, to delete the words "not exceeding" and substitute the word "of" and after the word "months" to insert the words "or more".

This is also a drafting agreement.

Comment on this

What is the difference between an endowment policy and endowment assurance policy?

Comment on this

The Deputy had better not throw a question like that at me just now. I will give him a definition when we come to it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 117:—

On page 25, line 25, to delete the words "for either of the following purposes, that is to say" and substitute the words "under and in accordance with this section", and to delete paragraphs (a) and (b).

This is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 118:—

In sub-section (1), page 25, line 49, after the word "free" to insert the word "paid-up".

This is also a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

As the Bill originally stood, it was exclusive of bonus or free policies, and now it is exclusive of bonus or free paid-up policies?

Comment on this

I accept the Minister's word that it is purely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 119:—

In sub-section (3), page 26, line 2, after the word "pay" to insert the brackets and words "(otherwise than in respect of repayment of premiums paid on foot of and under an endowment or endowment assurance policy)".

This is also a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 120:—

In sub-section (3), paragraph (a), page 26, line 5, to delete the words "issued by such company" and substitute the words "which was effected", and in line 6, immediately after the word "child" to insert the words "and for which such company is liable".

The purpose of this amendment is to make it clear that the provisions are to apply to policies for which the company is responsible, whether those were issued by itself or by another company whose business has been acquired by amalgamation.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 122:—

In sub-section (3), paragraph (d), page 26, line 17, before the words "the person" to insert the words "except in the case of a free paid-up policy".

The purpose of this amendment is to make it clear that the requirements of the section are not intended to apply in the case of free paid up policies.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 123:—

In sub-section (4), page 3, to delete all from the words "in respect" in line 24 to the words "such child" in line 28 and substitute the words "where such certificate is applied for for the purpose of obtaining payment from an industrial assurance company of a sum of money payable by such company in pursuance of the next preceding sub-section of this section.

This is merely a drafting amendment; it does not alter the intention of the sub-section in any way.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 124:—

In page 26, sub-section (4) (c), line 39, before the word "policies" to insert the words "paid-up".

This is similarly a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 126:—

In sub-section (4), page 27, line 5, to add at the end of the sub-section the following—"but shall disregard sums paid or payable on foot of bonus or free paid-up policies or in respect of the repayment of premiums paid on foot of endowment and endowment assurance policies."

This is also a drafting amendment to make the wording of the sub-section accord with sub-section (2).

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 127:—

In sub-section (5), page 27, line 7, to delete the word "industrial".

This is merely to delete an unnecessary word.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 128:—

In page 27, to delete line 18 and lines 21 to 30 inclusive.

The effect of this amendment is to validate not only certain classes of endowment policies, but any policy in force at the commencement of the Act which would have been valid if the provisions of this part of the Bill had been in operation when the policy was issued.

Comment on this

I do not quite follow that.

Comment on this

The purpose of the section is to validate certain endowment policies which require validation. Any such policy issued by a company now might be invalid, but it would be valid after this Bill became law, and we are making these policies valid retrospectively. The purpose of the amendment is to validate not only certain classes of endowment policies as in the section, but all policies issued by a company which would be valid under the Bill.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 130:—

In sub-section (1), page 27, lines 36 and 37, to delete the words "or has issued".

This is put forward because it is not intended that the provision of sub-section (1) should have retrospective effect.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 131:—

In sub-section (2), page 27, line 45, to delete the words "with whom such policy was effected" and substitute the words "entitled thereto", and in lines 49 and 50 to delete the words "with whom such policy was effected" and substitute the words "entitled thereto".

This is merely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 132:—

In sub-section (2), page 27, line 46, before the word "surrender" to insert the word "cash".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 136:

In page 28, line 33, to delete the words "assets and liabilities" and substitute the words "industrial assurance business".

This is a drafting change designed to express more clearly the intention of the section.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that that is a better description?

Comment on this

Yes. We went into that with some care, and it was accepted as such by the representatives of the companies with whom the matter was discussed.

Comment on this

I can understand that, but the other point appeared to me to be a strange one. As regards substituting the words "industrial assurance business", what is the corresponding item on the other side of the balance sheet to meet it? Obviously assets.

Comment on this