Insurance Bill, 1935—Money Resolution. - Insurance Bill, 1935—Committee Stage.
Contributions 206–406 of 406. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 35 of 1935 ›
The Minister is taking out the words "assets and liabilities" and he is inserting "industrial assurance business".
Comment on this
As the sub-section stands, it reads—"The following provisions shall have effect in relation to every valuation...made by an industrial assurance company of its assets and liabilities at any time after the expiration of 12 months..." If the Deputy will examine the section he will find it is more accurate to describe it as a valuation made by an industrial assurance company of its industrial assurance business. It is not merely a valuation of its assets and liabilities, but of its business as such, and that is what the various paragraphs of the section are designed to provide for.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 138:
Before Section 53 to insert a new section as follows:—
Whenever the Minister is satisfied that an industrial assurance company which is a society, association, or other body incorporated or otherwise constituted under the law of a country other than Saorstát Eireann is unable to deposit with him an industrial assurance valuation within six months after the time when such valuation should be so deposited by such company the Minister may extend the time within which such valuation shall be deposited with him by such company to any period not exceeding twelve months after the close of the period to which such valuation relates.
I was convinced that this amendment was necessary because it is represented that it would be impossible without a complete reorganisation of the administrative system of the companies to which it relates to comply with the requirements of Section 7 of the Act of 1909, which requires the valuations to be deposited within six months. We are making, therefore, the alternative provision set out in the proposed new section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 139:—
In page 30, to delete sub-sections (2), (3) and (4).
The procedure with regard to general meetings is governed by the Act of 1908 in the case of incorporated companies and, in the case of those not so constituted, it is provided for in their rules, or other instruments of constitution. I think the proposals set out in sub-sections (2), (3) and (4) are not really necessary.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 141:—
In sub-section (4), page 31, line 21, to delete the words "be liable on foot of such policy" and substitute the words "not be relieved because such statement is not true from liability on foot of such policy".
This is a drafting amendment, designed to make the meaning of the sub-section clearer.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 142:—
In sub-section (5), page 31, to delete all words from the words "such company" in line 25 to the end of the sub-section and substitute the following:—
"and a fraudulent statement in some material particular has been made by the proposer and embodied in such proposal, the following provisions shall have effect, that is to say:—
(a) where such proposal has been filled in wholly by any person so employed, such company shall not be entitled to question the validity of the policy founded on such proposal on the ground of any such statement so made by the proposer and embodied in such proposal, and
(b) where such proposal has been filled in partly by any person so employed, such company shall not be entitled to question the validity of the policy founded on such proposal on the ground of any such statement so made by the proposer and embodied in such proposal unless such statement occurs in some part of such proposal which has not been filled in by any person so employed."
This is the amendment which was suggested by the companies and it is, I consider, a suitable alteration of the Bill. It is designed to limit the application of the sub-sections relating to mis-statements to so much of the proposal as is, in fact, filled in by the company's agent.
Comment on this
So if the company's agent persuades the persons taking out the policy to insert the figures representing the age which are, in fact, not correct, that relieves the company of liability on foot of the policy?
Comment on this
What sub-section (5) provided was that "Whenever a proposal for an industrial assurance policy consists of a form of proposal filled in, wholly or partly, by a person employed by the industrial assurance company to which such proposal is made, such company shall not, unless a fraudulent statement in some material particular has been made by the proposer, be entitled to question the validity of the policy founded on such proposal on the ground of any mis-statement contained in such proposal." We are proposing to change that so as to provide for the circumstances of the case in which only part of the proposal form is filled in by the company's agents, in which case the provision that the company shall not be entitled to question the validity of the policy shall apply only in respect of the part of the proposal filled in by the company's agent.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 144:
In sub-section (7), page 31, line 49, to delete the words "or questioned."
It may be necessary to have a question raised in order to provide for the adjustment contemplated by the sub section. Consequently, this is a necessary drafting change.
Comment on this
If this is passed it will probably mean that it will be impossible for an illiterate or semi-illiterate person to be insured, be cause in most of those cases the proposal forms are filled up by the agents of the company. No company will insure an illiterate person and in case of fraud—
Comment on this
The Deputy is now referring to sub-section (5), but if he reads sub-section (5) he will find that it does not operate in circumstances in which a fraudulent statement in some material particular has been made by the proposer. If the company can say that a fraudulent statement has been made by the proposer it can undoubtedly question the policy. If there is not a fraudulent statement, but merely a mis-statement of fact, put in by the company's agent, it is a different question.
Comment on this
Yes. If the agent made his statement in consequence of a fraudulent statement made by the proposer, then the company is protected.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 145:—
In sub-section (2), page 31, line 61, after the word "company" to insert the words "after the commencement of this Part of this Act."
It was never intended that this sub-section should apply to policies issued before the commencement of this Part of the Act, and the purpose of the amendment is to make that clear.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 146:—
In sub-section (1), page 32, line 21, after the word "company" to add the words "on or after the date specified in that behalf in such notice."
Again, it was not intended that this sub-section should be applied retrospectively, and the purpose of the amendment is to make that clear.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 147:—
In sub-section (2), page 32, to delete all words from the word "in" where it secondly occurs in line 26 to the end of the sub-section and substitute the words "proposed to be issued by such company on or after the date specified in that behalf in such notice."
The purpose of the amendment is to extend from one to four months the period after which a company receives a proposal during which it may adjust the terms of the policy to record the true age. Representations to the effect that this change should be effected were made by the companies, and I agreed to effect the change as I thought they had made a reasonable case for it.
Comment on this
Could the Minister say briefly what the case was? I should like to hear the reasons given.
Comment on this
Sub-section (2) provides that:—
"Whenever an industrial assurance company receives a proposal for a policy of industrial assurance and such proposal contains an incorrect statement of the age of the person whose life is thereby proposed to be assured, such company may, within one month after the date on which it receives such proposal, so adjust the terms of the policy issued or about to be issued in pursuance of such proposal as to make such terms conform to the terms applicable to the true age of such person."
Arising out of their experience, the companies gave a number of illustrations in support of their case that one month was too short to enable them to adjust a mis-statement with regard to age. They suggested a longer period, in fact, than a period of four months. The case made by them appears to me to be reasonable.
Comment on this
The case is that it is unreasonable to give them only a month in which to effect an adjustment. In order to understand that, it is necessary to have a knowledge of the working of the business and of the circumstances which might arise to make it unfair to have a shorter period provided. It would take a long time to give a number of illustrations; nor could I do so straight away, because I do not claim to have a technical knowledge of the business. On the basis of their case I felt it was reasonable to allow a longer period, nor do I think any injustice will be done to the insured persons by having this additional provision.
Comment on this
But remember it is only the period during which the company may correct an incorrect statement.
Comment on this
It may also be utilised for the purpose of disputing a policy on the grounds that the age given is incorrect.
Comment on this
In any event they can only do it within four months, as compared with the existing position. They have only that four months period in which to correct any such incorrect statement.
Comment on this
I think four months is a rather substantial extension of the period, while a month might possibly appear inadequate.
Comment on this
I thought there was something rotten in the state of Denmark. I was trying to fit in the Minister's remarks with amendment No. 147.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 147 refers to sub-section (2), Section 56, and not to sub-section (2), Section 57.
Comment on this
The purpose of amendment No. 147 is to make it clear that the requirement under the sub-section is not intended to apply retrospectively.
Comment on this
As the sub-section stood, the Minister could, by notice in writing, interfere with policies that had been issued by the company, whether issued in the past or in the present. Now he proposes to restrict his interference to policies that are proposed to be issued?
Comment on this
That is true, but it was not intended that this provision of the sub-section should apply to policies issued previous to the commencement of the Act, nor do I think it would be practicable to do so.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 148:—
In page 32, at the end of the section, to add a new sub-section as follows:—
"(4) Nothing in this section shall authorise or empower the Minister to require an industrial assurance company to alter either the premium payable under or the sum assured by or the date of maturity of a policy of industrial assurance."
The purpose of this amendment is to make it clear that the Minister's powers in relation to proposals and policies shall not extend to such matters as the amount of the premium or the sum assured. It is hardly necessary to have this amendment inserted, but, as the companies expressed certain apprehensions, I thought it better to remove them.
Comment on this
I thought there was a section in another part of the Bill in which the Minister took power to do that.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 149:—
In sub-section (2), page 32, line 51, to delete the words "one month" and substitute the words "four months."
We have already dealt with this amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 152:—
In sub-section (1), page 33, line 23, after the word "issued" to insert the words "by such company."
This is merely a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 153:—
In sub-section (1), page 33, to delete all words from the word "terminated" in line 27 to the word "thereunder" in line 29, and substitute the words "handed over or given up to such company by reason of payment of the sum assured, or of the surrender value of such policy, or of the issue of another policy in lieu thereof."
This is designed merely to improve the drafting of the section without making any changes.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 155:—
In sub-section (1), page 33, line 32, after the word "possession" to add the words "and may be so returned by delivery or by leaving for him at his last-known place of abode."
This amendment is necessary to prevent any difficulty arising as to whether the company had taken adequate steps to return the policy.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 156:—
In sub-section (2), page 33, line 35, after the word "issue" to insert the words "by such company."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 158:—
In sub-section (2), page 33, lines 42 and 43, to delete the words "owner of such policy, premium receipt book or other document (as the case may be)" and substitute the words "person from whom such policy, book or other document (as the case may be) was received."
The purpose of the amendment is to make it clear that the obligation under the sub-section would refer to the person from whom the policy was received and not necessarily the owner.
Comment on this
Why are the words "premium receipt" omitted before the word "book" in the substituted words?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 164:—
In sub-section (1), page 34, line 3, before the word "the" to insert the words "the person entitled to such policy shall on such forfeiture become entitled to the free paid-up policy hereinafter mentioned and", and in line 4, after the word "such" to insert the word "forfeited".
This is merely a drafting amendment to clarify the meaning of the section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 174:—
In page 34, before sub-section (5) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
(5) Where any benefits which are granted by an industrial assurance company under policies of industrial assurance are revised in favour of or to confer further benefits on assured persons with retrospective effect in whole or in part in relation to any such policies which are in force at the date of such revision, the rights of the persons entitled to such policies shall not, in case of forfeiture thereof, be more favourable to such persons than such rights would have been if such benefits had been attached to such policies at the date of the issue of such policies.
The purpose of this proposed new sub-section is to cover cases where an industrial insurance company gives increased scales of benefit and makes the improved benefit apply to existing policy holders and to make such benefit retrospective. As the Bill stands, it gives the existing policy holders greater free policy rights than they would have been entitled to if the benefit attached to a policy from the date of the issue because of the difference in the nett premium which is taken into calculation. It may be as difficult for Deputies to follow that as it was for myself to understand it when the problem was first put to me. The difficulty will be removed if I give an example. If we suppose that a man aged 20 has taken out a policy for a premium of 1d. weekly in which the sum assured is £8. Under the rules of the Third Schedule when that policy has been ten years in force the free paid up policy to which he would be entitled would amount to £1 15s. 6d. If the company altered the benefit so that under a new policy the sum assured for 1d. a week would be £10, the free paid up policy, after it was 10 years in force, would be entitled to £2 4s. 4d. If the company makes the increased benefits retrospective, so that the sum assured under the existing policy was increased from £8 to £10, then the free paid up policy, owing to the method of calculation provided in the Third Schedule, would be £3 5s. 6d. That is to say, the policy holder, in addition to the increase in the sum assured, would have a right to a free paid up policy greater by £1 1s. 2d. than if the improved benefit had been in operation from the outset. The effect of giving such benefit, in addition to increasing the sum assured, might operate to prevent the company making the benefit retrospective to the obvious disadvantage of an existing policy holder. The purpose of the section therefore is to ensure that if benefits were increased and are applied to existing policy holders, the free paid-up policy rights will be no greater than if the increased benefit operated from the commencement of the policy.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 178:
In sub-section (4), page 35, line 47, to delete the word "four" and substitute the word "fourteen".
This amendment is put forward because it was intimated that the period of four days originally provided in the sub-section was too short. We propose to increase the period to 14 days.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 179:
In page 36, line 3, before the word "post" to insert the words "prepaid ordinary", and to delete the words "principal or head office" and substitute the words "registered office in Saorstát Eireann".
This amendment makes a few minor drafting changes.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 180:
In sub-section (1), paragraph (c), page 36, line 47, before the word "Act" to insert the words "Part of this".
This is purely a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 181:—
In sub-section (1), page 36, to delete the word "or" where that word occurs in line 47 at the end of paragraph (c), and to delete paragraph (d).
It is felt that paragraphs (a), (b), (c) are sufficiently comprehensive.
Comment on this
Yes. The existence of (d) might create certain ambiguities which is undesirable. Any of the classes of persons that we felt should have rights under this sub-section are included in (a), (b), and (c).
Comment on this
This is very different. Were any of the persons or classes covered by (d) included in (a), (b) and (c)? Does the exclusion of (d) represent a change of mind on the part of the Executive Council?
Comment on this
No, but a number of questions were addressed to us as to what was meant exactly by paragraph (d), and all sorts of fantastic cases were put up. I think there was a question about a trade dispute, whether it could be referred to arbitration by an inspector appointed by the section. On reconsidering this sub-section it became clear that paragraph (d) was unnecessary and that, in fact, paragraphs (a), (b) and (c) were sufficiently comprehensive to cover all the classes of persons to whom it was intended the section should relate. There is, in fact, no change of decision.
Comment on this
I take it the words objected to as being words of too wide a meaning were the words "any person aggrieved by a decision of such company." I admit that those words are too wide and should go but is it necessary to delete the words "any person claiming through such aggrieved person"?
Comment on this
They are in paragraph (a), which reads:
"(a) any person who has effected a policy of industrial assurance with such company or any person claiming through such person."
The next paragraphs are:—
"(b) any other person claiming under or in respect of a policy of industrial assurance effected with such company or,
"(c) any person claiming under or by virtue of any provision of this Act."
It seems to me that the three paragraphs cover every possible case that could arise.
Comment on this
Frankly, I am not in a position to say that I can envisage the type of person described as "any person claiming through such aggrieved person," but I fancy it was not put in without some good reason.
Comment on this
It is not the aggrieved person but "any person claiming through such aggrieved person."
Comment on this
Should not that portion of the paragraph be added to the end of paragraphs (b) and (c)? Should not paragraph (b) read "any other person claiming under or in respect of a policy of industrial assurance effected with such company or any person claiming through such aggrieved person"?
Comment on this
It is "any person claiming under or in respect of" as well as "any person claiming".
Comment on this
The Minister is satisfied that it is not necessary to add these words to paragraphs (b) and (c)?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 184:—
In sub-section (6), line 37, to delete all words from the words "and the decision" to the end of the sub-section, and before sub-section (7) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
(7) Where an appeal from a decision of the High Court under the next preceding sub-section of this section is taken to the Supreme Court by an industrial assurance company, such company shall, whatever may be the result of such appeal or the determination of the Supreme Court thereon be liable for and pay the costs of all parties to such appeal.
It was felt that cases might possibly arise in which an assurance company might be anxious to obtain a Supreme Court decision. As the Bill stands there is no appeal from the decision of the High Court. We propose, therefore, to permit an appeal from the decision of the High Court by an industrial assurance company in cases where the company is willing to accept the liability for the costs of the parties to such appeal whatever the result. The whole purpose of the section is to prevent the cost of litigation being used by an assurance company to deprive a person of his rights. Secondly, an appeal from the decision of the Minister to the High Court can only be on a question of law. In the event of a further appeal by a company to the Supreme Court we shall require that the company will pay the costs of both sides so that an insured person will not necessarily lose in consequence of that.
Comment on this
This introduces a new principle into the law of this country. Is there any precedent for a rule providing that people will be denied access to the Supreme Court except they are prepared to pay the costs, whatever the decision?
Comment on this
Yes. There are quite a number of matters in which the decision of the Circuit Court or the High Court is final.
Comment on this
In certain circumstances, but an entirely different situation arises here. Here, for the first time, you propose that admission to the Supreme Court of Judicature can be purchased only by the payment of costs by the assurance company.
Comment on this
I can quite see what is in the Minister's mind, but in fact this introduces a new principle into our law. There is no precedent in the existing law for suggesting that a successful litigant in the Supreme Court should be mulcted for the costs of the case. I can quite see a case being made that it is not fair that a person who ordinarily would have an industrial policy of assurance should be dragged from the High Court into the Supreme Court and faced with these enormous costs for the purpose of deciding a point of law, but let the Minister say that he will assist an appeal from the High Court to the Supreme Court by providing that if the insurance company succeeds the State will pay the costs.
Comment on this
The Minister should look at this from a wider point of view than the point of view of an English assurance company. The British insurance companies do not give a fiddle-de-dee what happens the insured litigant. They do not give a snap of their fingers for the Supreme Court. All that they desire is to get into the Supreme Court in order to get a decision on certain matters which will govern their business here. I am not concerned with the question of mulcting a company such as the Prudential Assurance Company. The costs are of very little consideration to a company such as that. The Prudential Assurance Company could spend £250,000 fighting a case in the Supreme Court and they would not miss it. What interests me is that at the instigation of the insurance company, which does not give two straws for the expense in order to get a favourable decision on a point which is going to arise repeatedly in the ordinary course of their business, we are going to introduce into our law a principle that was never heard of before. If the only purpose the Minister has in mind is to convenience the British companies and to provide them with facilities for taking cases to the Supreme Court, let him tell them he will not do it and that it cannot be done.
On the other hand, if you feel that it is desirable that the decision of the Supreme Court should be taken from time to time on matters in connection with the Bill, and that you feel it would be a grave injustice to persons with industrial assurance policies to make them go into the Supreme Court with the insurance company, lay it down that in cases where the insurance company wins in the Supreme Court, the State will pay the cost. There is no danger of having a jury who may be influenced by the consideration that the State can well afford to pay and give costs against the State in every case which comes before them. You will have the judges of the Supreme Court deciding each issue on its merits and where the verdict goes to the insurance company, after all they have only got their rights. The costs are going to be something trivial from the point of view of the State or the point of view of the insurance company but the integrity of the Supreme Court is preserved and that is something about which I am sincerely solicitous. I have pointed out time and again in this House that once you make a breach in a well-established principle to cover a specific evil, you may think you are doing no harm but in 12 months' time that will be quoted as a precedent for imposing a penalty on some other section of the community in some other court. You open the door to evils, the end of which we cannot see, in introducing an amendment of this kind. I urge on the Minister either to abandon it altogether and leave the final decision in the hands of the High Court or, if not, to allow the existing system obtain in regard to appeals to the Supreme Court with this proviso, that the State will pay the cost in cases where the decision is against the insured person and to the advantage of the insurance company.
Comment on this
I should like to say that I am not satisfied that this amendment is an improvement on the Bill. I approach it from a point of view altogether different from that put forward by Deputy Dillon. I can conceive this right of appeal to the Supreme Court being used by the insurance companies as a threat to the insured persons, the threat of delay. We all know what is likely to happen, that if an appeal is taken to the Supreme Court, 12 months, two years or even four years elapse before you get a decision on that appeal. Does the Minister consider that that would be fair treatment for the insured person? As I say, conceivably the insurance company might do that. It may be said, of course, that it is an exaggeration to say that you will wait for 12 months, two years or even longer for a decision of the Supreme Court but it is not. It has happened over and over again. Even at the moment there is one case in which the public are waiting for a decision in the Supreme Court for over four years. I can conceive this new amendment being used very much to the detriment of the policy holder. I would like to hear some further justification for its insertion, and to be assured that the danger that I have mentioned can be provided against. I am sure the Minister will agree that it would not be desirable if an insurance company were able to take advantage of this amendment for the purpose of ensuring delay and of bringing pressure to bear on a policy holder.
Comment on this
The Minister has indicated that he is submitting this new amendment because the insurance companies apparently want it. Of course it is clear on the face of it that the companies want this amendment inserted. The effect of it, so far as they are concerned, is to give them greater power in dealing with the insured person. If there is nothing in the amendment of advantage to the insurance companies, why do they want it inserted, and why did the Minister go to the trouble of drafting it and of introducing this rather unusual principle? The Minister has apparently been convinced by the companies that not only is it to their advantage, but he has gone to the trouble of introducing a rather novel method for the ascertainment of costs. All this is done because the companies want to get from the High Court to the Supreme Court against an insured person.
Comment on this
Possibly against an insured person. The marginal note to the section reads:—
Decision of disputes between industrial assurance companies and others.
Here are some of the matters which may be decided:—
(a) any person who has effected a policy of industrial assurance with such company or any person claiming through such person, or
(b) any other person claiming under or in respect of a policy of industrial assurance effected with such company, or
(c) any person claiming under or by virtue of any provision of this Act, or
(d) any person aggrieved by a decision of such company or any person claiming through such aggrieved person.
Obviously, most of the disputes under this section will be disputes in which the insured person is the plaintiff, and, from his standpoint, the insurance company will be the defendant. The Minister will decide that matter, but if he so desires he may refer it to the High Court for decision, and its decision shall be final and conclusive, and no appeal to the Supreme Court shall lie from such decision of the High Court. That was the Minister's first intention. Now, the Minister has received a request from the insurance companies to amend the Bill so that they can take the dispute from the High Court to the Supreme Court. It is well to point out that it is the insurance company that is given the initiative in the matter. The High Court decision is to be binding on the insured person, but the company can say: "We are not satisfied with the High Court judgment, and we want to take the case to the Supreme Court." In a case such as that the insurance company is being given another opportunity to delay the implementation of the decision as given by the High Court. Under this new amendment the insurance company is being empowered to delay the matter still further. It is being enabled to use its superior financial resources to get behind a High Court judgment, if it possibly can, and in any case to cause the maximum amount of inconvenience that it is possible for a company to cause to an insured person.
From the point of view of the insured person I think this is a most unfair amendment. It introduces a novel piece of cost ascertainment for the purpose of litigation which may go before the Supreme Court. It obviously puts the company in a preferential position as compared with an insured person. If persisted in, I believe the amendment will work out in a disadvantageous manner from the point of view of an insured person. The Minister, I suggest, should leave the Bill as it was drafted originally, and turn down this proposal of the companies, the effect of which will be to enable them to use their superior financial position to deprive an applicant of a judgment which the High Court had given. As Deputy Dillon pointed out, many of these companies will not care what amount of money they spend in costs before the Supreme Court in order to upset what they would regard as a particularly objectionable judgment of the High Court. As it is the company which is empowered to go to the Supreme Court and not the insured person, I think that the amendment, to which apparently the companies attach considerable importance, is very objectionable from the point of view of the insured person and should be rejected.
Comment on this
I find it rather difficult to follow the remarks that have just been made by Deputy Norton. They were directed to show that this amendment is unfair to the insured person. I may be misreading the amendment, but it appears to me to give a right of appeal to the Supreme Court to either party from a decision of the High Court. In so far as it does that it has my full benediction. Under the Constitution and the Courts of Justice Act it is envisaged, if not as a constitutional right, at all events as being practically a constitutional right, that there should be a right of appeal from a decision of the High Court to the Supreme Court in every possible case. Under the amendment as it stands, if I read it correctly, both the insured person and the insurance companies have the right of appeal, but the insurance company has the satisfaction of paying whether "we lose or draw." I may be wrong but that is my reading of the amendment.
Originally, sub-section (6) of this section provided that whenever the Minister referred a point of law to the High Court for decision, the decision of the High Court should be final and conclusive. That provision has been taken away, and instead provision is being made for an appeal from the High Court to the Supreme Court. In other words, as I read this amendment, leaves the Constitution to operate. The Constitution says that wherever there is a decision of the High Court there is the right of appeal to the Supreme Court unless that right is taken away by law. I do not know whether I am reading this provision correctly or not but, if I am right, then it is a good principle that there should be an appeal from the High Court to the Supreme Court. I think that that was intended by the Constitution. If I am right in that—and I think I am —I cannot see how Deputy Norton can make the point that the insured person, under this proposed amendment, will be subject to hardship, because he will have a right of appeal as well as the company. Deputy Norton cannot always rely on the High Court to decide in favour of the insured person as against the company nor can he rely on the Supreme Court to decide in favour of the company as against the insured person. I think that the right of appeal to the Supreme Court is a right which the insured person should have. If it is given under this proposed amendment to the section, then I think it is a good amendment.
Comment on this
If it is not given, I think it is a bad amendment. I think everybody should have a right of appeal from the High Court to the Supreme Court, and the cutting down of that right is a bad thing and contrary to the spirit of the Constitution. The insured person should have that right of appeal and, if he had not, I think there would be considerable public demand for it in the space of a few months after this Act came into effective operation. Where the amendment is wrong in principle is where it provides that, whatever the result of the case, one party to the litigation is to pay the cost. Deputy Dillon's point, I think, was that that was bad in principle. In so far as it applies to a big insurance company, it makes no difference, but it is introducing an extremely bad principle. It is a good thing from the point of view of the insured because, if the decision of the High Court is against him, he can go to the Supreme Court at the expense of his opponent. He is on velvet and I do not see why Deputy Norton should have any objection on that point.
Comment on this
My point is that it is only when he is successful in the High Court he can be hauled before the Supreme Court by the insurance company.
Comment on this
Suppose he failed in the High Court, he can go to the Supreme Court at the expense of his opponent.
Comment on this
If that be so, I agree with Deputy Norton, but that is not my reading of the section. Perhaps the Minister would tell us what his intention is.
Comment on this
What the amendment provides for is the retention of the right of appeal to the Supreme Court which the Bill, as originally introduced, ruled out. That appeal is permitted but it is provided that if the appeal is taken at the instance of the company, then the costs of all parties, irrespective of the result, must be paid by the company. Whether that is a new principle or not, I am not in a position to argue. In Great Britain, the insurance commissioner may refuse to state a case unless the company concerned agrees to pay the costs of all the parties and that, in effect, brings about the same position as this section proposes to establish. The whole purpose of the provision is to provide a means of determining disputes between insurance companies and their policy-holders which will be cheap and expeditious. At the present time, it is undoubtedly correct that policy-holders are intimidated from pursuing their rights against a company by the fear that, if they get a decision in the courts, they will be involved in certain expense and that, in any event, the company is likely to appeal that decision from court to court to the ultimate tribunal. In order to prevent policy-holders from being intimidated by the fear that that may be the consequence of their resort to the law, we have inserted this section which gives the Minister the right to determine, acting through an inspector, disputes in certain circumstances. It is provided that the Minister's decision shall be final and there can be no appeal unless the Minister, at the request of any party to the dispute, should refer any question of law arising in such dispute to the High Court for decision. The Bill, as introduced, provided that the decision of the High Court should be final, but we are proposing to delete that limitation and to provide for an appeal to the Supreme Court, with this condition attached—that if the appeal is taken at the instance of the company, the company will bear all the costs.
Comment on this
If the Deputy reads the first part of the amendment he will see that it provides for the deletion of the words in the section which rule out an appeal to the Supreme Court. Those words will not be in the Bill, and what the section says is that where an appeal is taken from the decision of the High Court to the Supreme Court by an insurance company the company will bear all the costs. There is nothing in the Bill to prevent the other party taking an appeal.
Comment on this
The section will read: "Whenever the Minister determines a dispute referred to him under this section, such determination shall be final and conclusive and no appeal to any court shall lie therefrom, but the Minister shall, at the request of any party to such dispute, refer any question of law arising in such dispute to the High Court for decision."
Comment on this
The confusion arises from the fact that it is not appreciated that, under the Constitution and the Courts of Justice Act, there is a right of appeal in every case from the decision of the High Court to the Supreme Court unless that right is specifically barred by statute. This provision does not bar that right. In fact, it recognises a right of appeal to the Supreme Court.
Comment on this
I think it is constitutionally preferable that this amendment should be effected, but, from the point of view of this section of the Bill, I do not mind whether the amendment is inserted or the Bill remains as it is. It is better, however, to have the matter dealt with this way, because it is conceivable that important questions of law will arise upon which a company may desire to have a decision from the Supreme Court. I do not think it should be debarred from getting that decision provided it is made clear that the other party to the case, who may be quite a poor person, is not involved in additional cost in consequence of the decision to appeal to the Supreme Court.
Comment on this
There is a lot to be said for the principle enunciated by Deputy Costello, but what I am concerned with is how it is going to work out in practice so far as the policy-holder is concerned. The section, as amended in the way proposed by the Minister, is likely to be abused, and to be abused in such a way as to cause a great deal of hardship to the policy-holder. Without having very much hope of succeeding in the Supreme Court, a company may hold that threat over the head of a policy-holder.
Comment on this
If the policy-holder wins in the High Court, if this amendment is carried the insurance company can say: "Very well, we will appeal to the Supreme Court." That person is held up for 12 months, two years, three years or four years before a final decision is taken on the matter. It is not merely a question of paying the costs that is involved. I think the Minister would agree that the insurance companies have some very good, sound reason for insisting on this particular amendment, or at least for putting it up to the Minister that it should be inserted. I am not suggesting that the companies are not entitled to get the same play of justice as the policy-holders, but I do say that it is likely to be abused and that it is conceivable that, if it were never exercised, it can be used there as a threat to the policy-holders by the insurance companies, and that, if they actually do take a case to the Supreme Court, a policy-holder may be kept out of his money for 12 months, two years, three years or four years. That is the aspect of the matter with which I am concerned.
Comment on this
But surely no company is going to involve itself in, possibly, very heavy costs in a legal action merely to keep some policy-holder out of his money? They may be willing to become involved in heavy costs in a legal action for the purpose of getting, say, a decision which may safeguard themselves against expense or may have a bearing on the whole operation of their business, but in that case the question that would arise would be a point of law and, in such circumstances, they have a good case to support their claim that they should be allowed to get the decision of the Supreme Court on the particular point of law involved if they are prepared to pay the costs of all parties to the case.
Comment on this
The Minister said that a company is not likely to appeal and become involved, possibly, in heavy costs, merely to keep a policy-holder out of his money, but if the Minister knows anything about the working of insurance companies—and he ought to know something about it if he were even following the reports of cases in the public Press—he would know that insurance companies go to law on very peculiar cases.
Comment on this
I know at least that this system has worked very successfully wherever it was tried, and I believe it will work successfully here.
Comment on this
I should like to disabuse Deputies' minds of the idea that insurance companies go to law expecting to be financial gainers as a result of legal proceedings. I have yet to hear of a case of an insurance company going to law in matters of this kind where they did not come out financially the losers. No insurance company goes to law merely to get money as a result of the legal proceedings, but to get some point of law finally settled. It is awkward, both for the policy-holder and the company, to have one legal precedent established in one country and another legal precedent established in another country. Accordingly, when such matters come to be decided in the ordinary Circuit Courts, they sometimes do not know how the matter stands, and it is in the interests of everybody that the best legal opinion should be taken in order to get a disputed point finally settled. I think this amendment was introduced for that purpose, and I think it is for the benefit both of the company and the policy-holder that these points of law should be settled.
Comment on this
I think that, if this Section 6 is amended in the way suggested by the Minister, and if the section stops with the word "decision", in line 37, there still seems to be a gap which, I think, ought to be filled in between that word and the beginning of the new sub-section —numbered 7—which he proposes to insert in this section, because it is not at all clear to me, speaking as a layman, that these two sub-sections will hang in such a way as to make it clear to all that the policy-holder is entitled to go to the Supreme Court in the same way as the company is entitled to go to it. Assuming, however, that the policy-holder is entitled to go to the Supreme Court in the same way as the insurance company is entitled to go there, it seems to me, in any case, to be a highly-doubtful benefit to give the policy-holder the right to go to the Supreme Court. He will not require to go to it if he gets a favourable judgment in the High Court, and it is only in the event of being given an unfavourable decision in the High Court that he will desire to go to the Supreme Court. Deputy Costello argues—and the Minister argues now, after hearing the viewpoint of the insurance companies—that it is desirable that there should be an appeal by both the policy-holder and the company, if either so desire, to the Supreme Court. I do not see, however, that there is any advantage in that appeal from the point of view of the policy-holder. It seems to me to be on a par with telling a tramp that the Ritz Hotel is open to everybody. The tramp probably knows that, but he has not the necessary passport to get into the hotel. In the same way, I suggest that it is conferring a doubtful benefit on a policy-holder to tell him that he can appeal to the Supreme Court. The policy-holder may be aware of that, but he is also aware of the fact that it costs money to go to the Supreme Court, and very often he will have to be satisfied and will have to put up with the High Court judgment because he cannot mobilise the necessary cash to take the case to the Supreme Court; whereas the insurance company, every time it loses in the High Court, will be able, by reason of its superior financial position, to take the case to the Supreme Court and, in that way, by a legal process of extended litigation, the policy-holder will be financially worn down. In fact, and in effect, there is no real advantage in letting the policy-holder go to the Supreme Court because, in most cases, he will be unable to go there anyway.
Comment on this
I suggest that, in most cases he will be interested in whether he gets his money or not.
Comment on this
But when the policy-holder gets a decision from the High Court, why should not the company be compelled to recognise that decision in the manner the Minister first contemplated before the companies got at him and convinced him that he should allow the companies to have another round of the courts by going to the Supreme Court? The Minister was quite satisfied that the High Court was a competent body to decide such matters, in the first instance, but in the meantime the companies have got at him and said: "No, the High Court is not qualified to give the decision, so let us go to the Supreme Court." The Minister wants to say that there is a gloss of equality between the insurance companies and the policy-holder because they have equal rights to appeal to the Supreme Court, but in actual fact they have not equal rights. The insurance company, heavily capitalised and wealthy, can go to the Supreme Court with greater ease than can the policy-holder. Deputy Seamus Bourke says that insurance companies do not engage in litigation with the intention of making a profit, but most of us know that insurance companies have written policies for persons—often very poor persons—collected the premiums, and, when the assured person dies, and his or her relatives claim payment of the policy—and very often it is the only means they have of burying the deceased assured person —the companies have gone into the courts to dispute the age of the deceased person as entered on the policy which they wrote themselves. It is constantly before the eyes of members of this House, through the daily Press, that assurance companies have gone into court often to dispossess a relatively poverty-stricken person who claims an interest in a policy which was written on a deceased person's life. If that will happen in the ordinary course of events, where there is merely a sum of not more than £10 or £20 at stake, how much more is it likely to happen where an insurance company has legal people of its own engaged, to whom the company pays retaining fees and where it is quite easy to get these people, during times when they are not very busy generally, to take a case into the courts in the hope of upsetting the claim of the policy-holder? I think that the very fact that the companies have pressed the Minister for this amendment and that he has had to go through the rounds of introducing an entirely new feature, by measuring the costs of proceedings before the Supreme Court, is evidence that this amendment is valuable to the companies. And they can only regard it as valuable because they see in it another weapon against policy-holders.
Comment on this
I understood the arrangement was that amendments would be inserted now, and that later Deputies could move to reverse them if they wished to, when we got into committee on the Bill.
Comment on this
I think the Minister ought to look into this matter with a view to clarifying it. If the right does lie with insured persons, I think the amendment does not make that quite clear here. The Minister should insert words, at any rate, to make it more explicit.
Comment on this
The point of view put forward by Deputy Morrissey could be met by the insertion of four or five words beginning as follows:—"Appeal to the Supreme Court shall lie from any such discharge but where an appeal," and so forth. That would make it clear.
Comment on this
I think it will be clear when the Deputy has an opportunity of reading the Bill with the change made in it. It does not mean that an appeal to the Supreme Court is prohibited. When these words go in it is clear that an appeal to the Supreme Court is there.
Comment on this
Apart from holding it over, the Minister should reconsider the whole question of entertaining an amendment of this kind.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 187.
In page 38, lines 14 and 15, to delete the words "at the date of such order".
It is proposed to delete these words because it is considered proper that the valuation provided for should be calculated at the date the policy is surrendered, rather than the date on which the order is made.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 190:
Before Section 82 to insert a new section as follows:—
Every assurance company which effects assurance business (excluding life assurance business and industrial assurance business, but including the renewal of any other assurance business, the original contract for which was entered into before the commencement of this Part of this Act) in Saorstát Eireann shall enter into an agreement with the company whereby such assurance company agrees that, if and so far as it reinsures its assurance business (excluding and including as aforesaid), it will reinsure with the company but subject to the qualification that the company may, in the case of any particular risk, refuse to accept the reinsurance thereof unless such assurance company retains such portion of such risk as the company shall direct.
This amendment is put forward in lieu of Section 82 of the Bill, to which objection was taken, and the drafting of which required revision in any event. The proposed new section differs from the section in the Bill in two respects. Firstly, it does not require the assurance company to reinsure life or industrial business with the company. That was not made quite clear when Section 82 in the Bill was drafted. The proposed new section makes it quite clear. Furthermore, it requires the insurance companies to retain for themselves at any rate portion of the risk they reinsure with the company. The necessity for that will be obvious. The change of the wording of the section proposed in this amendment will remove any objections which were advanced on Second Reading discussion and which were subsequently put forward from other quarters.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 199:—
In page 43, before the word "abstracts" in line 16, to insert the words "accounts, balance sheets", and before the word "abstracts" in line 18 to insert the words "accounts, balance sheets".
This is purely a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 200:—
In page 43, line 20, immediately after the word "incorporated" to insert the words "or otherwise constituted".
This is also a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 207:—
In page 43, immediately after the word "showing," in lines 24 and 25, to insert the words "in respect of each class of assurance business."
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 208:—
In page 43, to delete paragraphs (a) and (b) and substitute the following paragraphs:—
(a) the amounts of the premiums and claims (in respect of liability, loss, or damage to arise (if at all) in Saorstát Eireann) of that part of such assurance company's assurance business which has been reinsured by such assurance company during such accounting year, and
(b) the amounts of the premiums and claims (in respect of liability, loss, or damage to arise (if at all) in Saorstát Eireann) of all assurance business which is reinsured with and is accepted by way of reinsurance by such assurance company in such accounting year.
This amendment is designed to make it clear that the companies will be required, when making the return provided for in Section 89, to state only the total amount of premiums and claims in each class of business in respect of their reinsurance business, and not detailed particulars which might be of a confidential character.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 210:—
In page 43, paragraph (a), line 42, after the word "amounts" to insert the brackets and words "(under separate headings relating to assurance business in Saorstát Eireann and assurance business outside Saorstát Eireann)".
The purpose of this amendment is to provide that the particulars required to be furnished by Section 90 shall be furnished under separate heads for business within, and business without, the Saorstát.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 211:—
In page 43, line 43, paragraph (a), sub-paragraph (i), to delete the words "sums received by way of premium", and substitute the words "premiums credited".
The purpose of this amendment is to secure that in making these returns in accordance with the provisions of Section 90, the total premiums taken credit for, in the revenue account, will be shown as required by the section, and not merely the amount of premiums actually received.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 212:—
In page 43, to delete sub-paragraph (ii) of paragraph (a) and substitute the following sub-paragraph:—
(ii) the amount by which the sums received by way of commission exceed the sums paid out by way of commission or by which the sums so paid out exceed the sums so received, as the case may be, and
The purpose of the amendment is to effect a change in sub-paragraph (ii) by providing for the furnishing of a balance figure of commissions instead of requiring separate figures for commissions received and commissions allowed. For various business reasons companies would not wish to have information disclosed as to their commission and no useful purpose would be served by requiring them to give it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 213:
In pages 43 and 44, to delete paragraph (c).
It is proposed by this amendment to delete paragraph (c). Representations have been made that it would be impossible to provide the information exactly without a complete revision of the organisation. The information is not of such vital importance that it would justify the very considerable expense involved and it is proposed to delete the paragraph. Information as to the outstanding premiums taken credit for is retained in paragraph 4 and that is really the material point upon which information is necessary.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 214:—
In paragraph (d), page 44, line 5, after the word "premiums" to insert brackets and words "(ascertained as nearly as may be)".
This amendment is necessary because there may be cases where the outstanding balances in the hands of agents, branch offices, or foreign representatives of a company consist of premiums in respect of several classes of business and merely the amount in toto is known for all classes, and the exact allocation to the individual revenue accounts at the date when the accounts are made up may not be possible. The object of the amendment is to allow the companies some latitude in making the allocation by the insertion of the words “ascertained as nearly as may be”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 215:—
In page 44, line 22, after the word "exceed" to insert the words "in the aggregate".
That is a drafting amendment. The purpose is to make clear that the required certificate need relate only to aggregate value.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 216:—
In page 44, line 23, immediately after the word "assets" to insert the words "after taking into account any investment reserve fund".
This amendment is put forward because it was thought well to make it clear that in certifying the value of investments the existence of any investment reserve fund may be taken into account.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 217:—
In page 44, line 25, before the word "adequately" to insert the words "in the aggregate".
Again, this is a drafting amendment to make it clear that the required certificate need only relate to securities and mortgages in the aggregate.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 218:—
In page 44, line 26, after the word "values" to insert the words "in the aggregate".
That is the same type of amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 219:—
In page 44, line 27, after the word "sheet" to insert the words "after taking into account any investment reserve fund".
That is related to the amendment concerning investment reserve funds.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 220:—
In page 44, lines 27 and 28, to delete the words "different from" and substitute the words "in excess of".
The object of paragraphs (a) and (b) is to secure the explanation only in cases where the balance sheet figure exceeds the market values and the amendment is to make this clear.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 221:—
In page 44, line 42, to delete the word "are", and to delete all words from the word "correctly" to the end of the section and substitute the words "the aggregate value thereof as shown in such balance sheet is not in excess of the actuary's valuation".
This amendment is put forward because it is considered sufficient for the purpose to have a certificate to the effect that the values of reversions and life interests shown in the balance sheet are not in excess of the actuary's valuation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 222:—
Before Section 93 to insert a new section as follows:—
Where an assurance company carries on one or more of the following classes of assurance business, that is to say, public liability insurance business, engineering insurance business, glass insurance business, guarantee insurance business, or burglary insurance business, the Act of 1909 shall apply to such company and to such one or more of the said classes of assurance business as is or are carried on by such company but with and subject to the following modifications, that is to say:—
(a) Sections 5 and 6 of the Act of 1909 shall not apply to such company, and
(b) such company shall annually prepare a statement of its assurance business in such form as the Minister shall from time to time direct, and sub-section (1) of Section 7 of the Act of 1909 shall apply thereto as if such statement were a statement required to be made by a provision of that Act prior to the said Section 7, and
(c) Section 32 (except paragraphs (a), (b) and (c) thereof) shall apply to such company with the substitution in the said section of the words "public liability insurance business, engineering insurance business, glass insurance business, guarantee insurance business, or burglary insurance business" for the words "accident insurance business" wherever those words occur in the said section as applied by this paragraph.
I am proposing in this to insert a new section. I think it is necessary to do so. In consequence of the inclusion within the scope of the Bill of additional classes of business, it becomes necessary to apply to these classes the provisions of the Act of 1909, with the necessary modifications set out. Sections 5 and 6 of the Act of 1909 which relate to actuarial reports and abstracts of valuations, are not relevant to these classes of business and should not apply. Secondly, in (b) the provision requires the preparation and furnishing of annual accounts in respect of these additional classes of business in such form as the Minister may direct. Paragraph (c) provides that these additional classes of business shall be subjected to the same modifications of the Act of 1909 as accident assurance business.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 224:—
In page 45, to delete sub-section (2) and substitute a new sub-section as follows:—
(2) Where an assurance company carries on life assurance business or industrial assurance business or both such businesses and also carries on any other class of business, except sinking fund or capital redemption business, such assurance company shall keep the assets of its life assurance fund and its industrial assurance fund separate from the assets of such other class of business.
The purpose is to modify the requirements of sub-section (2) so as to relieve life and industrial assurance companies from the obligation to maintain separate assets as between the two classes of business or sinking fund or capital redemption business. In other words, within these three groups of business, life and industrial and sinking fund and capital redemption, the obligation to maintain separate assets does not exist.
Comment on this
The only purpose served is to make clear what was the intention when the Bill was introduced. It is not considered necessary that separate assets should be kept by a company doing these classes of business only.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 225:—
In sub-section (4), page 45, to delete all words from the word "of" in line 15 to the word "business" in line 19, and substitute the words "class of assurance business other than life assurance business and industrial assurance business", and in line 22 to delete the words "of the said classes" and substitute the word "class".
This is a drafting amendment consequential on amendment No. 3, that is the inclusion of additional classes within the scope of the Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 226:—
In sub-section (1), page 45, line 25, to delete the word "may", and in line 26, immediately before the word "by" to insert the words "after consultation with such assurance companies as he thinks fit or with any association representing assurance companies, may".
This amendment is to make it clear that the Minister shall, as in practice he undoubtedly would, consult with the companies before making any order under the section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 230:
In sub-section (1), page 45, to delete all words from the word "of" where it secondly occurs in line 29 to the end of the sub-section and substitute the words "class of assurance business other than life assurance business or industrial assurance business."
That is also consequential on amendment No. 3, the inclusion of additional classes of business within the scope of the Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 232:—
Before Section 95 to insert a new section as follows:—
95.—Whenever a form of proposal for a policy of assurance is filled in wholly in the Irish language every policy of assurance issued in pursuance or as a consequence of such proposal and any other document issued in connection with such policy by the assurance company to which such proposal was made shall, if the proposer so requires, be issued by such assurance company in the Irish language.
This is a new section, the purpose of which is to provide that a person desiring to have his insurance business transacted in the Irish language shall be afforded facilities for doing so.
Comment on this
I will look up that point. I think there is a general provision for offences against the Act.
Comment on this
What is the point of all this? If a man wants a policy in Irish, will it not be part of his contract? He can say to the company "I will not take out a policy with you unless you give it to me in Irish." What is the point of putting it into an Act of Parliament when it can be a matter of negotiation and contract between the parties?
Comment on this
The Minister might very well drop this. How did it get in there, and what is the point of it? Surely insurance is a matter of free contract. A person need not enter into a contract of insurance with a particular company unless he gets it in the Irish language. Why put that in the Bill?
Comment on this
We ought to know what is the penalty if a company refuses to do this for the Minister.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 233:—
In page 47, line 1, after the word "Minister" to insert the words "for Finance".
This is purely a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 234:—
In page 48, line 15, to delete the words "OF INDUSTRIAL ASSURANCE", and in line 16 to delete the word "SUCH", and in line 16, after the word "POLICY", to insert the words "OF INDUSTRIAL ASSURANCE".
This is purely drafting.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 235:—
In Part I, page 48, to delete all words from the word "BOTH" in line 18 to the word "POLICIES" in line 20.
This is also a drafting amendment. It deletes certain words which are unnecessary as they are covered by the preceding general heading.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 236:—
In Part I, paragraph 3, page 48, line 26, before the word "shall" to insert the words "in respect of which premiums are payable", and in line 28, to delete the word "the" where it thirdly occurs and substitute the word "such", and in line 29, to delete the word "as", and in lines 29 and 30, to delete the words "the value of such policy is required to be ascertained" and substitute the words "the last premium paid thereon became due".
The purpose of this amendment is to make it clear that the relevant date is the date upon which the last premium payable under the policy became due, and to limit the paragraph to policies in respect of which premiums are payable as distinct from free paid-up policies which are provided for in a separate rule.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 237:—
In Part I, page 48, before paragraph 4, to insert two new paragraphs as follows:—
4. The age of the person whose life is assured under a free paid-up policy of industrial assurance shall be obtained by adding to the age attained by such person at his birthday next after the date of the issue of the original policy of industrial assurance the number of completed years which have elapsed between that date and the date as at which the value of such free paid-up policy is required to be ascertained.
5. The net premium shall be such premium as at the assumed rate of interest and the assumed rate of mortality and at the age of the person whose life is assured at such person's birthday next following the date of the policy is sufficient to provide for the risk incurred by the industrial assurance company in issuing such policy, exclusive of any addition thereto for office expenses and other charges.
This amendment proposes to insert two new paragraphs, the first of which provides for the case of a free paid-up policy as distinct from a policy in respect of which premiums are payable. The second is brought forward from Part II without effecting any change. It is considered more appropriate that that provision should be included under the heading of "General Rules."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 238:—
In Part I, page 48, to delete paragraph 4.
The paragraph is being deleted as being unnecessary.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 239:—
In page 48, at the end of Part I, to add three new paragraphs as follows:—
5. The value of a policy of industrial assurance in respect of which premiums are payable shall be taken to be the difference between the present value, as at the date on which the last premium paid became due, of the reversion in the sum assured, including any bonus added thereto, according to the contingency upon which it is payable, and the present value as at the said date of the future net premiums.
6. The value of a free paid-up policy of industrial assurance shall be taken to be the present value at the date as at which the value is required to be ascertained of the reversion in the sum assured, including any bonus added thereto, according to the contingency upon which it is payable.
7. Notwithstanding anything contained in this Schedule, a policy of industrial assurance in respect of which premiums are payable shall not for the purposes of this Schedule attain a value unless and until such policy has been in force for two completed years.
In this amendment, clauses 5 and 6 replace clause 1 of Part II. They are the same as that clause in intention and effect, but make a distinction between policies in respect of which premiums are payable and free paid-up policies. They are being brought forward to Part I because, being rules of a general kind, they are more appropriate to Part I than to Part II. The purpose of clause 7 is to make it clear that a policy of industrial assurance shall not attain a value until it has been in operation for two years.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 240:—
In Part II, page 48, to delete paragraph 1.
Clause 1 of Part II is proposed to be deleted because the provisions it contains are now being made in clause 5 and 6 of Part I under the heading "General Rules," as I mentioned in the case of the last amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 241:—
In Part II, page 48, to delete sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 2.
The same applies here. This provision is being brought forward to Part I.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 242:—
In Part II paragraph 2, sub-paragraph (2), page 49, line 2, to delete the words "for the whole term of life".
This is a drafting change. It is proposed to delete the words "for the whole term of life" because they are unnecessary in view of the general heading of Part II.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 243:—
In Part II, page 49, to delete paragraph 3.
This paragraph is being deleted, because an alternative method of ascertaining the cash surrender value is being put forward in the next amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 244:—
In page 49, at the end of Part II, to add a new paragraph as follows:—
5. The cash surrender value of the surrendered policy shall be 90 per cent. of the present value, at the date as at which such value is required to be ascertained, of the reversion in the sums assured (including any bonus added thereto) under the free paid-up policy which the surrendered policy would be entitled to receive, or, if the surrendered policy is a free paid-up policy, to 90 per cent. of the present value at the said date of the reversion in the sums assured (including any bonus added thereto) under such free paid-up policy.
This amendment makes provision in lieu of that contained in clause 3, which has now been deleted. It proposes that instead of the cash surrender value of a policy being taken directly as two-thirds of the policy value, it shall be taken as 90 per cent. of the present value of the free paid-up policy to which the original policy would be convertible under paragraph 4. The effect is that the cash surrender value of whole term of life policies is derived from the free paid-up policy value, thus bringing them into line with the method adopted for endowment and endowment assurances.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 245:—
In Part III, page 49, to delete sub-paragraph (2) of paragraph 2.
This amendment is consequential on another amendment, No. 255. Sub-clause 2 of clause 2 of Part III, which is proposed to be deleted because of the provision proposed to be made by amendment No. 255.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 246:—
In Part III, paragraph 3, page 49, line 54, before the word "value" to insert the word "present".
This is merely a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 247:—
In Part III, paragraph 3, page 49, line 54, to delete the words "of valuation" and substitute, within the brackets, the words "(as at which such value is required to be ascertained)".
This also is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 248:—
In Part III, paragraph 3, page 49, line 55, after the word "assured" to insert the brackets and words "(including any bonus added thereto)".
This amendment is being inserted to make it clear that any bonus is to be taken into the calculation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 249:—
In Part III, paragraph 3, page 49, line 58, before the word "value" to insert the word "present".
This also is a drafting amendment, consequential on amendment No. 247.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 250:—
In Part III, paragraph 3, page 49, line 58, before the word "date" to insert the word "said" and to delete the words "of valuation".
This also is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment Nos. 251, 252, 253, 254:
In Part III, paragraph 3, sub-paragraph (a), page 50, line 5, before the word "four" to insert the words "less than five years but not less than".
In Part III, paragraph 3, sub-paragraph (b), page 50, line 7, before the word "three" to insert the words "less than four years but not less than".
In Part III, paragraph 3, sub-paragraph (c), page 50, line 9, before the word "two" to insert the words "less than three years but not less than".
In Part III, paragraph 3, sub-paragraph (d), page 50, lines 11 and 12, to delete the words "one year" and substitute the words "less than two years".
These are all drafting amendments.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 255:—
At the end of the Schedule to add a new Part as follows:—
PART IV.
Basis of computation when Parts II and III of this Schedule do not apply.
Where the terms or conditions on which the sums assured by a policy of industrial assurance are payable, whether as originally agreed on or as subsequently varied, are such as to render the method of calculating the amount of the free paid-up policy mentioned in Parts II and III of this Schedule inapplicable, the basis of computation of the amounts of such free paid-up policy shall be such as shall be approved of by the Minister.
The purpose of this is to make somewhat wider provision than was contained in clause 2, sub-clause 2 of Part III for dealing with cases to which the rules contained in Parts II and III might not be possible of application. It is considered that this wider road is preferable.
Comment on this
I propose to take the next Stage on May 13th, that is six weeks from now. It will give adequate time to Deputies to consider the Bill afresh.
Comment on this
Does the Minister seriously mean that he is going to take this Bill's next stage on 13th May?
Comment on this
It is quite conceivable that Finance business will occupy all the time during the month of May but we may be able to get an occasional hour or half hour for this Bill. I think Deputies would like to have this Bill reprinted with the amendments that are now passed.
Comment on this
I take it that the Minister is not going to ask the House to deal with the Bill earlier than the 13th May?