Committee on Finance. - Turf (Use and Development) Bill, 1935—Money Resolution.
Contributions 1–142 of 283. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 42 of 1935 ›
I move:—
That for carrying into effect any Act of the present session to make provision for promoting the more extensive production and consumption of turf for domestic and household purposes, and to make provision for divers matters ancillary to or connected with such production and consumption, including conferring on the Minister for Industry and Commerce powers to acquire land and construct transport works and conferring on the Turf Development Board, Limited, powers in connection with the matters aforesaid, it is expedient to authorise the payment out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas of any expenses incurred by the Minister for Industry and Commerce being expenses which are required by the provisions of such Act to be paid out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
I should like to get some information as to what the cost of this measure is going to be. The general lines of the measure indicate that it is intended further to develop the co-operative societies, and to force the purchasing of turf from these co-operative societies to the exclusion, so far as certain coal buyers are concerned, of the people who, up to the present, have been earning a living by selling turf. The history of the co-operative societies is not such as to indicate that there has been any very satisfactory development there. A very considerable amount of compulsion is indicated in connection with this measure, and I should like to know whether the delegation that went to Russia and to Germany have brought back any schemes dealing with compulsion that will make the putting into force and administration of this Bill cheaper than it appears on the face of it to be.
A very considerable amount of money has been spent already in fostering and developing the sale of turf through co-operative societies, and the position that has been shown since the co-operative societies began to be formed, and the Turf Board came into operation, is that less turf is being cut and, if we refer to public Departments, less turf is being used by public Departments. If we refer to 1935, the year for which the Minister is not yet able to provide us with the amount of turf cut, we find that less turf is being carried by the railway and the canal companies.
Comment on this
I have been informed by the Minister's Department that, during the year 1934, the amount of turf carried by rail was 16,671 tons which, in 1935, fell to 13,637 tons. In 1934, the turf carried by canal was 8,709 tons and, in 1935, 6,525 tons. That is a fall of about one-fifth between those two years, to the extent of 5,218 tons.
Comment on this
I am not questioning the Deputy's figures as between 1934 and 1935. I thought the Deputy was comparing the 1935 figure with an earlier year. I explained the circumstances as to 1935.
Comment on this
It is linked up in this way; that less turf was cut in the year 1932-33 than in the year 1931-32; less turf was cut in the year 1933-34 than in the year 1932-33. The Minister cannot tell us what was the amount in 1935, but the railway companies and the canal companies carried less turf in 1935 than in 1934. Deputy Moore asked for the figures as to the use of turf by the public Departments. The consumption of turf by public Departments, other than the Department of Defence, rose from 303 tons in 1931-32 to 1,069 tons in 1932-33, to 6,337 tons in 1933-34—the first year in which the board and the approved societies came in—and in the following year fell to 5,333 tons, and in the year 1935-36 fell further to 4,622 tons. So that, in the two years from 1933-34 to 1935-36, the use of turf by public Departments had fallen by one quarter of the 1933-34 consumption. In the case of the co-operative societies——
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir. I am not quite clear as to what is in order in a discussion on a Money Resolution, and I should like to know, Sir, to what extent this debate can range over general questions such as the Deputy has raised.
Comment on this
Technically, discussion on a Money Resolution is confined to the expenditure proposed to be authorised by the Bill. Deputies may discuss matters which they would desire to see in the Bill involving further expenditure. The Deputy in possession prefaced his remarks by stating that he wanted to question the costs of this measure. I presume he is developing that point; but if Deputies were to duplicate a Second Reading debate now it would be, I suggest, straining our procedure and practice.
Comment on this
This is a compulsory measure, and we have not been told anything as to what it is going to cost. As to the costs up to the present on this scheme for developing approved societies and assisting them through the Turf Board, during the last three years, £132,158 have been voted, but actually only £50,192 were spent up to the end of last year—that is, apart from the expenditure in connection with the purchase of the Turraun Works. There has been that expenditure, with a most unsatisfactory development in the cutting of turf by co-operative societies, a falling off in the original use of turf by public Departments, and the measure is intended, I take it, to force the further development of approved societies, to force an increased cutting of turf by them, to force the disposal of more turf by the Turf Development Board, and to take areas and make them declared areas for particular purposes. Then, inside these areas, certain restrictions, under a most elaborate series of fines, are going to be placed on people generally—turf and coal sellers, coal users, and a lot of other people like that. I am simply bringing out this point for the purposes of the House, so that it can estimate the focal points that are going to give rise to the cost of carrying out this measure and with a view to letting the House see where these focal points are, for the purpose of extracting from the Minister, if possible, what particular costs are going to arise in connection with this particular measure.
I shall be as brief as possible. I have no desire to develop a Second Reading type of argument, but I have a desire to have made clear, for the House, as I say, what are the focal points of policy in this Bill and where costs in the administration of the measure are likely to arise, with a view to getting some idea what these costs are going to be and how they are going to be provided. At any rate, co-operative societies are the societies that the Minister wants to develop by this measure, and I want to refer briefly to certain aspects of the co-operative societies' achievements since they were started. I shall just take five counties: Donegal, Mayo, Galway, Clare and Kerry. These five counties got two-thirds of the total sacks distributed. They contain one-half of the total number of co-operative societies organised. There was expended in those areas £35,000 out of a total of £87,000 voted for relief work in the bogs, and we have the result that two-thirds of the sacks, plus half of the co-operative societies, plus £35,000 expenditure on bog work, brought about in those five counties a fall in turf cutting to the extent of 242,147 tons in 1934 as against 1931, and if we are to judge by the consumption in public Departments, and by the falling-off in the railway carriage in 1935, their achievement was less during last year.
Now, the Minister is going to use that particular type of machinery in the western counties to prevent people who want coal from getting it, to force people who want coal, if they do get it, to take a certain amount of turf, and to use them to put out of the work of selling turf a large number of people in these districts who have been depending as part of their small yearly income on sales of turf. The work that is before the Minister in the matter is indicated by the very elaborate scheme of fines that he finds it necessary to produce in the measure intended to operate as a piece of compulsory machinery in an appointed area. I do not think that any measure before the House has ever had such a list of fines. In the first place, coal retailers have to be registered. There is a fine of £10 if they do not show their registration certificate in their premises. There is a fine of £50 for anybody, who is not a registered dealer, selling coal. There is a fine of £50 if they sell coal other than at registered premises. There is a fine of £1 against any person who purchases coal from other than a registered retailer. There is a fine of £1 a ton for failure to sell the proper turf quota with coal. There is a fine of £1 a ton for failure to buy the proper turf quota with coal. There is a fine of £1 a ton for selling unapproved turf. There is a fine of £1 a ton for knowingly taking unapproved turf. There is a fine of £1 a ton if coal retailers do not, on application by the Minister, within, I think it is, seven days, give a review of all their purchases for a period of two months.
Comment on this
The Chair would like the Deputy to relate these fines to the Money Resolution that the Committee is being asked to sanction.
Comment on this
These fines are an indication of the problem that the Minister thinks he has in putting this Bill into operation, and I will stop where I am with the remark that I am only half way through the list. As well as dealing with the people inside, the Minister proposes, by a scheme of new small boundaries and boundaries within boundaries, to control the turf and the coal business. It is quite possible that anybody who has a sack of coal may have a swarm of inspectors after him to know where he got it. If there is no coal in the neighbourhood of the house, and if he happens to have a bag of turf, he is liable to be visited by inspectors to know whether or not the turf is approved turf. I think I have said sufficient to indicate that there is a most elaborate system of compulsion proposed, which will involve an elaborate scheme of espionage.
Comment on this
I submit that, as the Dáil has approved the principle of this measure, it is out of order to discuss it now.
Comment on this
Is it out of order to make an effort to find out what will be the cost of putting this Bill into operation?
Comment on this
I am enumerating a number of points for the purpose of finding out what this thing is going to cost.
Comment on this
I am very anxious to know where the money is going to come from. We cannot say what this thing is going to cost without having some picture of the things that are going to give rise to cost. If the Minister objects to hearing these things, I appreciate it. It is no wonder that he would object. I am prepared to sit down, now that I have given him suggestions as to the type of information we want, and I will listen patiently while he indicates to us what this measure is going to cost.
Comment on this
I seems to me that it would, perhaps, be better, and I might save the Minister the trouble of rising to his feet so often on points of order, if I were to say at the outset with regard to this Money Resolution that I think the House ought not to pass it because it is not going to benefit the turf industry or those engaged in the turf industry. On the contrary, I believe it is going to do them positive injury. Having said that, and having made my attitude clear, I hope the Minister will not be troubled putting points of order to the Chair.
Comment on this
I am anxious to get this matter clear. I am not familiar with the procedure relating to debates on Money Resolutions. I have had no experience yet of a debate like this. I think when the Dáil approves the principle of a measure, it should not be possible for Deputies to urge the rejection of the Money Resolution on the ground that they object to the principle.
Comment on this
The Dáil on the Second Stage approved the principle of the Bill. The Committee is now asked to vote money to implement the Bill. On this Resolution, Deputies are entitled to discuss the cost, how it arises and its possible extent.
Comment on this
It is quite clear, even though the Dáil does approve the principle of a Bill on the Second Reading, the Dáil is at perfect liberty at any time to throw that Bill out altogether.
Comment on this
The fact that the Dáil approves the principle of a Bill on the Second Reading does not mean that the Dáil is committed to pass the Bill merely because it approves the principle, or that the Dáil is prevented from questioning the money that will operate the measure. The Minister seems to have got it into his head that because the Dáil adopted the principle on the Second Reading, the Dáil must not question that principle any further during the remaining stages.
Comment on this
I would like to get some information from the Minister regarding the question of cost. I would like to know how much of the cost does he estimate will be met by registration fees. Will the Minister give us an idea of the amount of money he hopes to get in the shape of registration fees, and to what extent that will meet the expenses of this Bill? I would like to know to what extent the money looked for under this Resolution is required to meet what I would call the sack problem. I am anxious to know whether the Government, under this new Bill, propose to proceed to purchase sacks, to sell sacks, or to hire sacks in the manner they have been doing since the inception of the turf scheme. Can the Minister give us information as to what losses he estimates in regard to the provision of sacks? I am anxious to know whether the Minister proposes to continue to charge the high price his Department has been charging for sacks, and to continue the high hiring rate for sacks where they are not purchased outright.
I would like some idea as to what he has in mind with regard to registration. In this Bill we are asked to approve that retailers shall be registered and we are asked to give the Minister power to fix a registration fee; but we have no idea as to whether that will be £1, £5, £10 or £20. We are asked to provide this money to make provision for promoting the more extensive production and consumption of turf. I hope to be able to show the House that it is not going to do any such thing. I think the figures already quoted by Deputy Mulcahy give us some idea of the tendency, notwithstanding all the activity and the large sum expended in the way of propaganda and the setting up of secieties and so on. If this Bill is passed, and if it were possible to put it into operation—I do not believe it is possible to put it into operation—it would do more real damage to the turf industry than anything that could be conceived by anybody outside the Department.
There are people in this country who to-day are making a living out of turf. They are getting by the sale of their turf at least double the price they will be allowed to get if this Bill becomes law. We are asked to vote money to put into operation legislation that will deprive those people of their means of livelihood. I can only speak of cases in the South of Ireland. I do not know what the custom is in the West or the midlands. In the South, particularly in my own county, there are small farmers living on poor land adjacent to bogs. They go into the bogs about this time every year and they spend the summer cutting and saving turf. In the winter months they bring that turf into the towns and they sell it in small loads or, as more frequently happens, they bring it from door to door and sell lots for 3d., 6d., or 1/- to the poor people. In that way they are making at least double the amount that they will be allowed to make out of the turf if this Bill becomes law. Should this legislation operate, they will not be able to sell their turf in the way I have described.
The Minister may say there is nothing to prevent them from bringing the turf to town, but the fact is that the people will not buy it. The poor people who have not ranges in their kitchens have to purchase turf in order to bake bread. They also have to burn coal. It is recognised, I think, that for general household purposes, and particularly for cooking purposes, coal is more economical than turf. I do not think anybody will dispute that. But those persons, when the Bill becomes law, cannot get coal without also taking turf from the coal merchants. If they have to purchase turf at the same time that they purchase coal, then they will not require turf from the man who spends his whole summer cutting and saving turf, in order that during the winter time he may make sufficient money to enable him to live on his miserable patch of land.
Comment on this
The Deputy is travelling down The Old Bog Road and away from the high road of finance.
Comment on this
I am trying to show the reasons why this money should not be voted. I think I cannot convince the House that this Money Resolution should be rejected unless I can show Deputies that the voting of it would be a positive hardship rather than a benefit to the turf industry.
Comment on this
Even if it were, I want respectfully to submit that on a financial motion such as this it is impossible to give adequate reasons for its rejection unless one can quote very definite and specific cases of hardship which will be brought about as a result of its passing. But there are other reasons apart from these. There are farmers living within three, four, five or six miles of the ordinary provincial town. A great many of these farmers have in the last ten, 12 or 15 years installed ranges in their kitchens. Here, again, I am speaking of the custom in my part of the country. These farmers purchase coal to burn in their ranges, and the usual procedure is that they go to the nearest bog and purchase a clamp of turf. That turf is drawn home by members of their families as they require it. If this Bill becomes law that cannot be done. Either the coal that they require must be dropped altogether or else instead of buying a clamp of turf they will have to go into the nearest town and buy that turf, plus all the additional expense that would be put upon them in that way. Then I want to come to the greatest hardship of all and that is with regard to those who get turf direct from the bog, and there are people who to-day are purchasing turf from those who get it in the bog. They are retailing that turf in the towns. They are purchasing it from what I might call private turf-cutters rather than from the co-operative society. That is because a particular turf-cutter may have got particularly good turf. One knows when one buys it from a co-operative society that one has to take certain chances. It is those people who are getting their turf and selling it in that way who are going to be hit. It will be found that most of the real, genuine turf users will be hit when this Bill becomes law. I will be told that there is nothing to prevent those people from buying their turf in bulk and becoming members of the co-operative society. What will happen then? They will get a net sum of in or about 11/6 a ton for their turf. I want to say here and now that 11/6 a ton for cutting, saving and delivering turf is the nearest thing I have ever heard to a starvation wage.
Comment on this
What is a ton of ordinary good quality turf? It is two good horse-loads of turf, and we are told that people in this country want this Bill and are looking for it to enable them to get 5/- or 5/6 for a horse-load of turf. They will get 11/6 for it, but because of the particular system of transport and everything else some people will pay three times that amount for the turf. But the man who does the work first of all what does he get? He pays a pretty substantial sum for the turf bank. He has to hire labour if he has not sufficient labour of his own, and he is to get for the turf the net sum of 11/6 a ton.
Comment on this
I am saying that the people, who are now at liberty to get turf and realise 20/- a ton and, in some cases, as high as 25/- a ton for it by being allowed to sell it themselves, will be brought in and forced into the co-operative society where they will be compelled to accept 11/6 a ton for it. That is the hardship these men are faced with. They are to be paid 11/6 as against the £1 to 25/- which they are now able to get.
Comment on this
I want to show this House what the position is. We are asked to vote for this Resolution on the grounds that that money is required to help the turf industry of this country.
Comment on this
The Deputy appreciates the fact that all that was discussed on the Second Reading. The principles of the Bill were then discussed. The money is required for this, and the discussion on the motion should deal with that money, that is, with the cost of this measure and with objections to that cost, but not with the principles with which the Deputy is now dealing.
Comment on this
I take it that it is proper to discuss what additional taxation a person deprived of a business like that will have to bear through being deprived of his business.
Comment on this
The general application of that argument would entitle a Deputy to get down to the individual trader or taxpayer on any Money Resolution. The Deputy will have an opportunity of discussing those points on the relevant sections. That would be more relevant and orderly.
Comment on this
This Money Resolution reads:—
"That for carrying into effect any Act of the present session to make provision for promoting the more extensive production and consumption of turf for domestic and household purposes..."
I am submitting that it should not be carried into effect, and in order to carry my point as far as I can, I am submitting that this motion is not going to lead to "the more extensive production and consumption of turf for domestic and household purposes," but that it is going to lead in the opposite direction.
Comment on this
On the Second Reading the House approved of the principle contained in that Resolution, but granted no money. The Committee is now asked to vote the money for the purposes of the Bill. It is not a correct procedure to repeat now the arguments advanced on the Second Reading.
Comment on this
The Minister knows about Friday morning. The Minister put across a few slick deals in this House in order to get Friday morning. He is most to blame for having this discussion on Friday morning. I want to submit that I am entitled to argue and give the House good reasons why this Resolution should not be passed. That is my position. In order to do that, with all respect to your rulings, Sir, I think I am entitled to show that the House, if they vote this money, will do a positive injury to the turf industry.
Comment on this
That is the point upon which the Chair differs with the Deputy. The Deputy is thoroughly conversant with the practice and procedure of this House. He must realise that in his contention it would be legitimate to duplicate the Second Reading debate. The principles of a Bill are fixed on Second Reading. On the Money Resolution reasons may be advanced why the money should or should not be voted. If the Deputy were allowed to discuss the principle of this Bill as a reason against voting money, that would involve reopening the Second Reading debate.
Comment on this
May I submit, Sir, that even on the Fifth or last stage of the Bill I am entitled to submit reasons why the Bill should not be passed.
Comment on this
I say even on the last stage. I do not want to waste the time of the House by going to the Fifth Stage if I can get the House to see that they ought to drop the whole thing now, as it is only a farce, a gesture, which even the Minister does not believe he can put into operation.
Comment on this
I should like to know something about the specified areas. I want to know whether it is going to be more costly to specify, say 12 or 20 areas, rather than have one area for the Free State.
Comment on this
It is an argument against Friday morning sittings. Two or three Deputies always waste time.
Comment on this
I am entitled to get information as to the Bill and I know the Minister does not want to give it.
Comment on this
I do not think so, because these specified areas are mentioned in every section and run through the whole Bill. Then there is the question of the number of inspectors. Not only are we to have inspectors, but officials authorised by the Turf Board and every member of the Gárda Síochána. I submit that all these things are going to make a big difference in the amount of money required for the enforcement of this measure— the number of areas and sub-areas; the number of times the Minister may decide to reduce, alter, or add to an area already prescribed; the number of premises his inspectors will have to visit to open sacks to see whether they contain turf or coal; whether it is approved turf or approved coal; whether it is being supplied by a registered or non-registered coal retailer; the number of inspectors necessary to enforce this Bill; and the amount of additional money required under this Money Resolution to see that 2 cwts. and not 2½ cwts. are sold without turf. The whole thing is so preposterous that I do not want to be forcing the point against your ruling, Sir, or straining your ruling in any way. I do not believe this Bill is seriously meant and I do not think the time of the House ought to be wasted upon it. The Minister does not believe it himself. He ought not be bringing us here on a Friday morning wasting time on what is merely an empty gesture in order to frighten the people down the country by telling them they will be compelled to burn turf in grates that would not hold a lump of coal, not to say turf.
Comment on this
I thought at one period of the debate that the Minister was going to take a hint from his colleague and become once more the bold, bad buccaneer. He was rather mild in his speeches on the Second Reading, but there was a display of temper to-day which we did not expect. I did not quite grasp the cause of it until he came out with the reference to Friday morning. At first I did not grasp the significance of the interruption but now I understand that the suggestion is that there is a certain extra publicity given to the proceedings on a Friday morning. The Minister naturally objects to that in connection with this Bill. While Deputy Mulcahy was answering a question put by a supporter of the Minister, the Minister tried to stop the Deputy in the midst of that answer. The Minister does not want publicity for this Bill or for the fact that Government Departments are using less turf. We are in full agreement there, at all events. I can understand his point of view, and I can understand the efforts he made to try to prevent information getting over to the public. We know that information has no effect on the Minister. We know that statistics, costs, or anything else have no effect on him, but he objects to their getting over to the public and objects to Friday morning debates because he thinks they may get over to the public.
It is obvious that the Minister thought that the passing of this Money Resolution by the Dáil was a purely formal matter. His interventions in the debate are an indication of that. The fact that he gave no information whatever at any stage up to the present as to the cost of the Bill is proof that he regards the money side of it as so purely negligible, in the sense of being formal, that the Dáil need not be informed. He could have given information to the House. He had an opportunity afforded him by the Resolution, if he was unable to give even an estimated amount of the costs, of at least giving some indication of the type of expenditure he envisages under the Bill, but he did not do it. When an effort was made to point out to him that this Bill was an elaborate Bill and that every section involves expenditure, for otherwise it could not be administered, the Minister tried to prevent that question even being put to him.
If this debate on the Resolution has taken the particular form it has taken, the responsibility largely lies with the Minister who, up to the present, has given no information about his plans. Not merely has he given no information on the type of expenditure he envisages under the Bill, on the amount of expenditure that he envisages in the next 12 months or two years, but he has given no information on the plans he has in mind which will lead to expenditure. Anybody reading his introductory speech on the Second Reading and his reply to the debate will see that he refused to give information as to the extent, be it great or small, to which he intended to operate the Bill or expected to operate it.
How is it possible for the House, without the slightest help from the Minister at any stage, to form any idea of the costs involved? The Minister tries to convey, on the one hand, that this is a serious measure intended to be operated to a considerable extent, and the next moment he certainly conveys the impression that it is merely a gesture, that there is nothing serious behind it, and that he does not intend to operate it to any extent. Faced not merely with these conflicting statements of the Minister, but with the fact that the Minister, apparently, has no definite mind at all on the matter, how can the House be asked, with any show of reason, to vote money, not merely vague in amount, but completely indefinite so far as the purposes for which the money is to be voted are concerned?
All the information we get concerning what we are now asked to sanction is in a general way contained in the Money Resolution itself. Anybody can see that nothing could be more vague or general than the Money Resolution. Money has already been spent by the Minister's Department in the promotion—so it is alleged—of the turf industry. Is that to be continued under this Bill? Again, there is no information. Is all the propaganda and publicity, which cost a certain amount of money for the last couple of years, still to be continued, and if it is, is it one of the matters referred to as being ancillary to the increased production of turf? If it is, the Minister, whom nobody could accuse of being reticent or hesitant in the way he speaks in this Dáil, gives no information here. Money was spent on propaganda. Is it irrelevant to point out to the House that, so far as the figures at our disposal seem to show, money has been wasted?
The Minister declared, in a child-like fashion or in a copy-book headline fashion, that you cannot take statistics of two years and compare them. He objected when Deputy Mulcahy pointed out that there was a considerable falling off in the production of turf between the years 1931 and 1934 and said: "You cannot base anything upon that." The next thing the House had a right to expect after that small debating point had been made by the Minister was that he would give the figures of the several years, from 1931 to 1935, and show that the tendency to which he referred was an upward tendency. Did the Minister show that? He did not even attempt to do it. When the Minister has not figures before him he is never at a loss to give figures, and when he does that they are always rather striking. He did not even suggest that if we take the figures for the years 1931 to 1935, they would show an upward tendency. If there was any real point in the objection he made to Deputy Mulcahy's statistics he had an opportunity of proving it and driving it home by producing the figures for the intervening years. If the Minister had not time to do that when Deputy Mulcahy spoke he could have brought them forward to-day to show that there was some justification for asking for this money.
Is publicity one of the things we are still spending money on? The money, we are told, is for ancillary purposes. It is quite useless—judging by results till now—for the purposes of this Bill, but technically, and to the Minister's mind, it comes in under it. "Ancillary" it has not been in fact. The figures quoted show, if they show anything at all, that it has not led to an increase in the consumption of turf. But the Minister always holds that the statistics produced by his Department do not prove what they seem to prove —he never tells us what in fact they do prove. All he says here is that they do not indicate what the position is with regard to turf development, but he does not say what they do prove. The only way he can show that these publicity efforts do not come under this Resolution is by acknowledging that up to the present his publicity efforts have been a failure. I admit there is one particular Department in which the Government is supreme, namely, propaganda. But not for commercial purposes; purely for political purposes.
I think the House has really been treated very cavalierly by the Minister's irresponsibility in dealing with what is described as an important measure. Has the Minister any idea of the expenses? Will he tell us, as we have been so frequently told by various Ministers when Bills are introduced into this House, that no extra officials will be employed? Is that the contention of the Minister? If we got this information we should be in a better position to deal with the matter. We will have to wait to hear the Minister's reply, and then we can make up our minds how to deal with the matter.
It has not been unusual in this House, when Bills of this kind, with compulsory powers and so on, are introduced, to be told that no additional officials will be necessary. That is a statement very frequently made. Unfortunately experience seldom fits in with the rather optimistic forecasts of Ministers. It is not easy to see how— I am assuming for the moment that the Bill is seriously meant—with the elaborate powers put into the hands of the Ministers in this instance, there is not going to be very elaborate machinery of administration. Unless the Minister takes the line that officials already existing can deal with the matter — and our experience would lead us to expect some such statement from him —then many additional officials will be required. It is not easy to see, if the existing officials of the Minister are doing their work at present and have sufficient work to do, how the amount of additional work imposed by this Bill is going to be done without considerable addition to the staff of the Minister.
There are a number of points that might be urged against this Resolution, but, for my part, I prefer to deal with them when we come to the particular sections, and I shall raise them there. Not the slightest attempt has been made by the Minister to supply the information which the House is entitled to expect, or even to give the vaguest hint of what the amount of money involved in the administration of this Bill if it becomes an Act is likely to be.
Comment on this
I did not come into the House until towards the end of Deputy Mulcahy's speech, but I heard Deputy Morrissey and Deputy O'Sullivan speak on this motion. While listening to them, it struck me that, during the ten years they were in office, not much consideration was given to the people in the bog areas. At this stage, Deputy Morrissey seems to be greatly concerned with the injury that this Bill will do to the people in the turf industry.
Comment on this
I am relating it to the speeches to which I have listened. I think I shall be able to relate it to the cost of the Bill.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey said that 11/- per ton would yield only a starvation wage to the producers of turf. He said he knew that the price of turf, without these measures which the Government were taking, was from £1 to £1 5s. 0d. per ton. He seemed to suggest that the steps the Government were taking to deal with turf would make conditions worse. I think that there is a great necessity for the steps the Government are taking in this Bill. The improvement works being carried out, through the medium of the Turf Development Board, in the bogs of the country and the large amount of drainage being done, have induced people to go in more extensively for the production of turf.
Comment on this
Kildare was a county that depended, to a great extent, for the past 50 or 60 years on turf. Great areas of the Bog of Allen depended solely on turf. A considerable trade was done in turf from the Bog of Allen, through the Grand Canal, to Dublin. I saw that trade and I saw it dead during the régime of Cumann na nGaedheal. For five or six years, thousands of tons of weather-beaten turf were ricked up on the canal sides around Allenwood because it could not be sold.
Comment on this
What can be discussed on this motion is the expenditure involved in the administration of this Bill. Deputies may not go back and discuss what a previous Government did or did not do. Whatever is said must be related to this motion and to expenditure under the Bill.
Comment on this
I am coming to that. All that turf was cleared away and then a vast amount of money was spent on the drainage of bogs. That has induced many more people to go into the turf industry. Unless these steps which the Government are taking to widen the market for turf were put into operation, I believe the market would be glutted.
Comment on this
I could give you the names of people in Kildare who had to do that. What price did the Curragh give for turf last year?
Comment on this
Deputy Belton is at liberty to make his own speech and he should allow Deputy Harris to proceed.
Comment on this
There is a much greater production of turf on account of the drainage to which I have referred. The bogs were practically inaccessible at the time this Government carried out their drainage schemes. That drainage will, to a very great extent, increase the production of turf. I do not know whether you, Sir, will allow me to answer some of the points made by Deputy Morrissey. He spoke about the man who went into the town with his load of turf and sold it from door to door, and he said that this scheme was going to injure him. I say it will not, because he usually sold his turf to the smaller people who purchased coal in quantities of less than two cwts. Until the turf scheme came into operation, that man's market was practically gone, because all the turf being taken by the Turf Development Board was going into the towns, where there was a surplus.
Comment on this
If we are to widen and extend the use of turf, this Bill is necessary and the people are anxious for it. Turf is a good fuel and, 100 years ago, a great deal of turf was burned in Dublin. My attention was called to a question which was raised in the British Parliament regarding the development of the turf industry, and how that was affecting their trade in coal.
Comment on this
I think that there is a good case for the Bill and that the expenditure of the money under this motion is necessary. One thing will have an effect in increasing the production of turf; that is, that the Government is determined to guarantee a market to the people in the bog areas for whatever turf they produce. We know the effect of guaranteeing a price to the farmers for wheat and this guarantee will have a very good effect on the production of turf.
Comment on this
The last remark of Deputy Harris pretty well gives the show away on the Minister. To give a guaranteed price for turf shows, if there is any foundation for the statement, what is visualised in the Money Resolution—that this is going to be made a paying proposition whether it is an economic one or not. In voting for this Money Resolution we are giving the Minister a blank cheque to pay a price for the production of turf, whether it is economic or not, and whether the business justifies production or not. Deputy Harris stated that the people from County Kildare had been for years retailing turf to the poor people in the City of Dublin. Has he examined the ramifications of this Bill to see how that trade will be affected?
Comment on this
Very good. If I am a retailer of coal, and if I buy quantities of coal from merchants, by the Minister's Order, I must take a certain amount of turf which has not been disclosed in the Bill. Powers are given the Minister to say how much turf I am to take. I send out the coal in bags. What am I going to do with the turf? It is going to lie in my yard. But I am going to let out that turf at a cut throat price to the very people that the Kildare retailers were in the habit of supplying. I know what I am talking about, because I am in the trade in that small way. That is what is going to happen. We are asked to spend money on buildings and on the making of roads. I quite agree with Deputy Harris that it is a good thing to make bog roads and to drain the bogs. That is necessary, apart from any production of turf on a national scale. Even though on the Second Reading of the Bill the House accepted the principle of producing turf, the Money Resolution is not interpreting that. It calls upon us to examine the Bill to see if it is a business proposition to give a blank cheque to the Minister. The Minister should give the House some idea of the amount of money involved, if he has any idea of the amount. He referred to speeches made here to-day as Friday morning speeches. I do not think I would be far wrong if I called this a Friday Morning Bill. It is purely a publicity and propagandist stunt. I should like to hear of any practical people with any intelligence behind the Bill. It has not been disclosed that there is any new method of producing turf. Those who know bogs know what it costs to make roads in to them, and realise that while it is possible to cut and save turf inside on the bogs a wet season may come and the turf cannot be got out. I wonder if the Minister is asking for power in this Bill to make roads regardless of the cost.
Comment on this
The Money Resolution says: (Money Resolution quoted).
The Minister is taking power to bury money in the bogs. He does not give any idea of the amount, and has produced no evidence from what might be called bog or turf experts. Deputy O'Sullivan said that the Minister had stated that there would be no increase in staff. I think the Turf Controller has £1,000 a year, and we are not going to have an official with £1,000 a year and no staff. There is going to be an army of jobs behind this, if the proposition is serious. Of course, it may not be serious. If it is not serious there will be no jobs. I wonder does the Minister comtemplate a more extensive production or consumption of turf for domestic or household purposes by subsidising turf? If turf is sold cheaper by registered coal retailers than it is sold commercially, then the ordinary turf producer and vendor is injured, because if a man is buying turf at £1 a ton, and if it is sold as auxiliary fuel with coal at 10/- a ton, obviously the consumer of turf is going to change to part coal, part turf, as he will have cheaper fuel. In that way, if the price of turf is not maintained at the commercial level, this Bill will help the consumption of coal rather than increase the consumption of turf.
Deputy Morrissey made a very good point about the position of people who have ranges and who have to buy coal for cooking purposes, and who, perhaps, cut a certain amount of turf for other household purposes. Will people who have a surplus of turf of their own production, if they have to buy a ton of coal for use in ranges, have to buy some turf as well? I do not think this Money Resolution should be adopted by the House. While the extended use of turf would be desirable — and the House has sanctioned that principle—at the same time the country is entitled to know at what cost we are going to have an extended use of turf. When there is no limit, or even an approximate limit to the amount of money required, and when no new methods of producing turf on a large scale have been adopted, I think the Dáil should go very slowly indeed in authorising the expenditure of money for turf production. Deputy Harris said that good work had been done for drainage by the Turf Board. Very well, proceed with the drainage works. They should be a charge—not so much on the National Exchequer as this Money Resolution proposes—but according to the Drainage Acts on the local rates and on those who are going to benefit directly by these works. I do not see why money voted here for turf production should be asked for on the basis of the case stated, that the Turf Board has already done drainage work in particular localities.
If it has done nothing but help the drainage of a particular locality, then that drainage work should be carried out by a drainage rate and not by a charge on the Central Fund. If no other argument can be put up for this Resolution but that, it is a sufficient reason why Central Fund money should not be given for the benefit of a locality, particularly when recourse can be had to legislative machinery for drainage work. Every Bill or every Resolution that is brought before this House is, to a large extent, debated on a comparative basis—what has been done in a certain period as against what has been done in some other period. Deputy Harris said that during a certain period the people retired from the bogs in County Kildare but at a later period they tramped to the bogs again. I know very many farmers in Kildare——
Comment on this
I am only going to the extent of replying to what Deputy Harris said. I can get the names of farmers from Kildare who, when they found their land was no use to them —the good grazing lands of Kildare —trekked to the bog and cut turf.
Comment on this
That has nothing to do with the Resolution before us. Deputy Belton should know that.
Comment on this
I do not want to go any further into that matter. I only mention it because the facts are known to me and in reply to the case made by Deputy Harris, that because of the gold mine that was discovered—not in Wicklow this time, but in Kildare— people went out for that gold. I want to point out that they did not go of their own volition to the bog. They went there because, owing to the economic conditions brought about by the policy of this Government, they found that they could not make a living on their land.
Comment on this
It is absolutely true. I can get the names of farmers down there who did that and who found that they could not get their turf off their hands. Then they went to Deputy Harris so that he might try to get the Board to take it from them.
Comment on this
I do not know whether Deputy Belton or I am in order on this, but I want to remind the Deputy that when he went down there he got out of it very quickly.
Comment on this
When you went down to Robertstown you got out of it very soon, and you did not go down there again. You went very near being chucked into the canal that day.
Comment on this
I wonder is the Deputy speaking with knowledge? I wonder were the few toughs who tried to kick up a row——
Comment on this
Deputy Belton's adventures in Robertstown are surely not relevant to this Resolution.
Comment on this
I think that the weighty point which the Deputy endeavoured to make has been pretty well blunted. Of course it would not be in order now to go into a detailed discussion of the Bill or the principles of the Bill. We are confined within the narrow limits of a request for authority to spend a certain sum of money, an undefined sum of money, to sink it in a bog. If the Minister knew anything about bog areas, he would understand the significance of sinking money in a bog. The House would be foolish, to the point of madness, to give any Minister authority of this kind, to sign a blank cheque for him to spend money ad lib. in a bog. I presume that when the previous Bill was brought in here under which the price was fixed at 10/- or 11/6 per ton—and I am glad I opposed it——
Comment on this
Turf was in some form at any rate before the House. I cannot remember exactly what it was, but a price of 10/6 per ton was mentioned for turf. I doubt if any turf was sold at such a low price. Deputy Morrissey's testimony bears cut my knowledge of the situation. I wonder is the Minister basing his estimate as to the money he requires on an assumption that turf will be produced and sold—and an increased amount produced and sold—on the basis of 10/6 or 11/- per ton? Does he not know from experience that that price did not work? Deputy Harris admitted that the Curragh Camp could not get turf at 10/6.
Comment on this
The nearest railway station—and the Curragh is as near to the bog of Kildare as bog centres usually are to a railway station. Yet the price had to jump from 11/6 to 16/- before a sod of turf could be got into the Curragh Camp. Was that to satisfy the bogmen of Robertstown? I wonder was it I or Deputy Harris was in danger of being thrown into the canal?
Comment on this
I said that the price paid by the Curragh Camp for turf delivered was 16/- per ton before ever the price was fixed at 11/6. 11/6 was the guaranteed price.
Comment on this
It was the price guaranteed by the Government to the producer. While the last Government were in power there were thousands of tons of turf ten years there and they were not guaranteed anything for it.
Comment on this
The Deputy should remember that it is now twenty minutes to one and that he has been speaking for 40 minutes.
Comment on this
There is nobody so hard taught as the person who will not learn. It is time the Minister spent some time on a bog.
Comment on this
Why did the Minister waste the time of the House by bringing in a Bill of this kind on a Friday morning?
Comment on this
I would not have brought it in on a Friday morning if I could have brought it in at any other time.
Comment on this
The cat has come out of the bag. His head and front paws are out now. We were told in this House that turf could be produced, as an economic proposition, and delivered at 10/6 per ton to the nearest railway station. Now we are told by Deputy Harris that it was agreed by the Army, and I presume the Army means the Government, to pay 16/- per ton for turf brought into the Curragh. I wonder what was the cause of that?
Comment on this
It shows that the House here was misinformed by the Minister on that occasion. The Minister who made the statement here that 10/6 would be an economic price for turf, and that we would have increased production at that figure, while at the same time the Government agreed to give 5/- or 6/- more per ton for turf required for the Army, now wants a blank cheque to produce turf under similar conditions. Does he not know that there is an economic limit to the production of any article? Does he not know that you can increase employment in anything? You can do that by digging down the Dublin mountains, but would it pay the nation ultimately to do that? The Minister can formulate a scheme, and if he gets a blank cheque from this House he can start producing more turf. He can get a market for that turf by subsidies, plus compulsion. He has got compulsion in the Bill, and now all he wants is money to make bog roads, to acquire bogs, to build sheds, and to provide transport that will dump the turf anywhere at any price and make the taxpayer pay whatever difference there is. That is, in essence, the Money Resolution before the House, and in my opinion the House should not adopt it.