Committee on Finance. - Turf (Use and Development) Bill, 1935—Money Resolution.
Contributions 143–283 of 283. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 42 of 1935 ›
Before we leave the County Kildare, there is a point that I would like to make. Deputy Harris says that there is a very considerable amount of development in turf cutting in the County Kildare as a result of Government activity. I would like the Deputy to be a little more explicit on that. A very considerable amount of money has already been spent, and the House is now asked to vote more money. We are anxious to find out what is the amount of money that is going to be spent, and what is going to develop from it. As regards the County Kildare, in 1934-35 the Department of Defence took 8,284 tons of turf, and in the following year they took 6,061 tons from the Turf Development Board. If only 50 per cent of that went to the Curragh, it would be 4,000 tons in the first year I mentioned and 3,000 tons in the next year. But, in the County Kildare, in the year 1934, they only produced 1,601 tons more than they did in the year 1931, although more than £5,000 was spent in bog drainage before the end of March, 1935. If the Department of Defence are taking that amount of turf from the County Kildare, and if that county is producing, over the 1931 figure, substantially less than the Department of Defence are taking now in spite of the additional increased cost, will the Deputy comment to us on that situation, and indicate to us how it has come about?
Comment on this
There are no records available, but there has been a big increase in the production of turf in the County Kildare. Before the drainage of the bogs in the county, the people in many areas departed from the use of turf. That was because of the water-logged condition of the bogs. When the drainage was carried out, the people went back to the use of turf. More turf is now being sold in the rural areas, but there is no record of these sales.
Comment on this
The Minister has given us information as to the amount of turf brought from the bogs every year.
Comment on this
He has no records, and the Development Board have no records, although I have put it up to them that they should get records to show the big increase there has been in turf development.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy must be aware that the average farmer in the County Kildare has a turf bank. During many years a great number of these farmers drifted away from using their turf banks and took to using coal. During the past three years, as Deputy Harris has pointed out, turf has come back into use, and instead of using coal they are now using their turf banks. They have reverted to the use of turf in their own homes. There is no record of that anywhere. It should be obvious to Deputy Mulcahy what the drainage of the bogs has meant to the farmers and the hardships they endured before that work was undertaken. Because of those hardships they dropped using turf, but since the drainage was carried out they are now back to its use again. Surely that fact ought to be obvious to the Deputy. When he gets statistics of that kind, what inference does he draw from them? Does he mean to say that actually the use of turf in the County Kildare, or the production of turf there, has been declining?
Comment on this
Of course it is obvious nonsense, but on this as on other matters the Deputy has never understood any statistics that I have put before him. He is incapable of understanding statistics, and he should stop this.
Comment on this
Is there anything really to be gained by quoting figures and attempting to build a case on them when the facts are there within 30 or 40 miles of the Deputy for him to see? Surely it would be worth his while to take a run down to Kildare—it would be only a recreation for him—and see the facts for himself. Again, I say that Deputy Mulcahy has ignored the big fact that all over the County Kildare— I am sure the same thing has happened in other counties—many householders who had ceased using turf, owing to the difficulty of winning it, are now using it because of the better facilities that obtain.
Comment on this
This Money Resolution has been presented to the House, and nobody appears to be particularly happy about it, not even the Minister. He appears to have the Friday morning feeling himself.
Comment on this
The Minister does not appear to be happy at the reception which his Money Resolution is receiving. As Deputy Morrissey has said, there are certain facts relating to the Turf Bill on which we ought to have some information, and this Money Resolution should afford the opportunity for getting the information. It is difficult for Deputies to discuss this Money Resolution without referring to some of the matters that were dealt with on the Second Reading of the Bill. That difficulty was clearly demonstrated by Deputy Harris when he attempted to justify, or to condemn, this Money Resolution. I was not certain whether he meant to justify it or condemn it. The Deputy spoke for ten minutes, and did not make it clear to the House as to whether or not the Minister was justified in bringing forward this Money Resolution. If ever there was a Money Resolution which the Dáil was entitled to discuss and to criticise it is the Money Resolution which is to finance this Turf Bill. The Minister has given us no indication as to what the cost of it will be. He is not, apparently, even able to make a guess at the amount of expenditure which this Bill will entail. If one may refer to the Bill for a moment one can say of it that in almost every line it teems with expense. It would be almost impossible for anybody to compute what the ultimate expenditure under it will be. In the first place it embodies a revolutionary extension of the principle of compulsion. That in itself will lead to expenditure which would be needless in relation to other Bills. The Bill proposes to compel persons to purchase turf. Not only that but it proposes to curtail the operations of people engaged in other businesses as well. There are going to be penalties in the Bill for not buying turf; there are going to be penalties for not selling turf; there are going to be penalties even for not buying or selling coal in certain cases. There are going to be restrictions upon people who might sell coal or might not sell coal, as well as upon people who might buy or might not buy turf, and there are fines in all those cases. One does not know what might be the extent of the money required to provide salaries for the officials who will be necessary to operate this measure.
The effects of this Bill will, perhaps, fall more heavily on people in the cities and towns than on country people. Perhaps the people in the cities and towns will realise for the first time the effects of compulsion as applied to their ordinary trade and households. This Bill embodies principles which if carried out might entail an extraordinary expenditure of money. For, I think, the first time in relation to the cities and towns there is going to be restriction on the liberties of the subject. We are somewhat accustomed to that in the country districts, but the citizens in Dublin and other places are going to get their does now. Possibly, their resistance to this compulsion will be greater than the resistance offered by the country people, and will cost more. The Minister does not know what he is up against. He does not know the amount of money for which he is asking the House to give a blank cheque, as Deputy Belton said a moment ago. If the Minister, in proposing this Money Resolution, had made some attempt to give the House an outline of the probable expenditure, there might not have been so much criticism offered during the debate. But the Minister himself apparently felt incapable of even guessing what amount of money might eventually be expended under this measure. Even if the House were satisfied that the amount of money to be eventually expended was going to be productive of good results, they might with some reluctance agree with the proposal of the Minister, but as the matter stands there can be no feeling of satisfaction in anybody's mind.
If you are going to take the revolutionary course of compelling people to do what they do not want to do, compelling people to buy one article when they want to buy another, naturally you are going to have opposition—open and concealed opposition—and the amount of money required to enforce the principle cannot be readily computed. Certainly all over the cities and towns there will be concealed opposition, even if there is no open opposition. There will be attempts made in every household to defy the Minister in his efforts to put this Bill into operation. If all goes to all the people will—I will not say offer violence—be compelled to resort to subterfuge to defeat the Minister in his operations. In this country you cannot easily compel people to do exactly the opposite to what they want to do. If you want to advance the production or sale of anything, the greater freedom you offer in the production and sale the better. I do not think that the objects of the measure, which appear to be a development in the production and sale of turf, are going to be greatly advanced by the measure which the Minister proposes to operate, or by the money for which he now asks here.
As I said in the beginning, the House generally has taken this Bill almost with consternation. I believe the citizens of the country have received it with consternation. If the debate here is any line on the popularity of the measure it has been very expressive. There has been no joy expressed from any side of the House at the proposal for the expenditure of this money. The Minister certainly has not shown the House the appearance of a Minister who was himself overjoyed with his proposals, or who anticipated any great results from the expenditure of the money for which he asks the House. This expenditure is in reality an attempt to bolster up the operations of a board which the Minister set up, whose operations have, in fact, been a failure. It is an attempt to make the citizens of this country do something which nobody has a right to ask them to do, in order to make the operations of this board more successful than they have been. I think, Sir, that the House ought not to pass this Resolution.
Comment on this
I also wish to enter my protest against the passage of this measure. I should like to say that it is just on a line with some of the other measures introduced by the Government. They have passed them through this House, but they have failed to put them into operation. Deputy Moore said that people stopped using turf because the bogs were not drained. Does Deputy Moore wish to convey to the House that if people in the County Kildare want to get turf they cannot find a bank in which they can get turf without having the bogs drained? I should like to say that I know something about bogs.
Comment on this
I drew turf out of bogs with a ciseán when I was not ten years old. After all, a man with that experience must know something about it. I do not know that there is any part of this country where things are so bad that people could not find turf if they thought it was a paying proposition. In 1921 I myself stayed for a week in a house in a particular townland where there were only two other houses. Those people could go out with their ciseán and bring in turf out of the bog. That very year they were not able to save the turf, and the couple of trees which they had for shelter around the house had to be cut down. I never make a statement here except I am prepared to stand over it. We are told that there is a great increase in the production of turf. I myself believe that people who have open hearths should be encouraged in every way to use turf. I think it was on last Saturday night fortnight that I was reading in the Kerryman a debate which took place at the Macroom Urban Council with regard to the question as to whether grates or ranges should be put into the workers' houses. Deputy Corkery said that ranges were very good for using turf. On that particular night I happened to go into a neighbour's house. The man of the house, his wife and four young men were in the kitchen. When I went in the man of the house said: “Come and sit on the range.” There was a turf fire in it. I did sit on the range, and was quite comfortable sitting on the range. I said that this would be very useful in the debate on turf, but that I would probably have to bring the man forward in order to prove my statement to the Minister. You can go into places in which there are ranges where turf is being used, and you can find the cat sleeping in the range. We use turf in our place and we put in a range. A great many other farmers put in ranges. They knew their business, and they found it was cheaper to use coal than to produce turf, even though the turf was only three miles away from him. What does the Minister for Industry and Commerce know about turf? When a farmer is busy he may get a few fine days which he will want to devote to saving his hay. On those days he would want to be at the bog, with the result that he would never be able to foot his turf. Go to Derrynasaggart, on the borders of Kerry——
Comment on this
I am only showing the ridiculousness of imposing a measure like this on the people and pointing to the hardships that will be imposed on them if they are compelled to use turf. There is also the question of price. We were told by Deputy Harris that turf was delivered to the Curragh at, I think, 11/-. Deputy Mulcahy said it was delivered at 16/-, but I was in a dairy shop in Townsend Street within the last two months when a chap came in selling turf. I forget whether his price was threepence for three or four sods, but we worked out the cost and found it was £2 1s. 8d. a ton. I say that the Minister should do something to prevent the poor people of Dublin being robbed as they are being robbed.
Comment on this
You have permitted this thing to happen since you came into office and it is not the first time I brought it to your notice.
Comment on this
Have you not got a Board to inquire into these costs? You are paying the officials of this Board.
Comment on this
They are being charged it by people who will not be selling turf in accordance with the scheme of this Bill, unless the amendments moved by the Opposition are carried.
Comment on this
Our purpose is to put this Bill out of action altogether if we have the power, because the whole thing is ridiculous, and nobody knows it better than the Minister himself. Deputy Harris talked about the guaranteed price for turf and for wheat. What is the effect of the whole policy of guarantees? Is the whole thing not imposing hardship on the poor and on everybody in the country? I do not want to go into the price of flour as a result of the policy of encouraging the growing of wheat, but everybody knows that the poor of this country are paying from 6d. to 8d. a stone extra for their flour because of it. The same applies to turf. What does the whole policy lead to? The Minister may smile, but he knows in his heart that this Bill is never going to operate, because he could not operate it. I do not think our objection to this Bill can have any great effect on the Government, and all we can do is to offer our protest against it.
Comment on this
No, Sir. The Minister had several opportunities of intervening and giving the information asked for, but up to the present we have had no statement from the Minister. I understand that Committee procedure applies to this Resolution.
Comment on this
I may state at the outset that I would be in favour of the voting of any moneys designed to develop industry and consequently provide employment, but I should like, before voting for this Resolution, to have a little more information as to the cost of this scheme and also as to its success. From my experience during the past few years, I have come to the conclusion that the Government at present is on the high road to a policy of what I would call glorified socialism. Before many years pass there will be only a very small section of the people of this country that will not be more or less dependent on the Government for a means of living. For that reason, I should be very careful in voting for the expenditure of money unless I am assured that the money will be put to good account. At the present time, rightly or wrongly, I have a shrewd suspicion that the voting of the moneys under this Resolution will be nothing more or less than the legalising of what I might call illegal payments.
I expect the bulk of this money will go to counties with bogs, for the development of those bogs. There are certain counties in which there are no bogs, and, if I say that the cost of this scheme will be £20,000 or £30,000 or £5,000 or £10,000, the Minister would find it very difficult to defend his action in allocating a few thousand pounds to Kildare, to Cavan, to Galway and to Cork and leaving out counties like Louth and other counties in which there are no bogs. I would make my voice very much heard and make a claim for a portion of that money. Of course, the means adopted by the Minister would close my mouth, because the obvious question he would put to me would be: "Have you a bog in Louth? If you have not, you cannot get any money." Consequently, the meaning of all this, in my opinion, is to throw moneys into certain counties in order to enhance the reputation and prestige of the Fianna Fáil Government and to bring everybody under their wing who has occasion to get any of this money. Rightly or wrongly, I have that view, and it will take a good deal of explanation on the part of the Minister to get rid of that view.
I am not very much impressed by Deputy Harris's statement as to the development of turf. What I want to know is, if, and when, these moneys are voted, can the Minister give the House an idea of the approximate sum necessary to put this Turf Development Board on its feet, because that is what it means? It has not been a success up to the present on the Minister's own admission, and it is in order to ensure that they will have the necessary financial resources to make it a success in the future that he asks for this money. I want a little more information from the Minister, and I should like to know can he give reasons or arguments that will ensure the House that, taking everything into consideration, and with ordinary luck, this new venture will be a success and give a return for the moneys spent?
The next point about which I should like to ask the Minister in connection with this Money Resolution is this: Is he prepared to give the House information as to the means that will be adopted by this Board to make a return, if any, of the cost of the scheme, and also, assuming that the scheme is a success, to pay off the capital sums that will be advanced to that Board as a result of the passing of this Resolution? In other words, will it be carried on in the same way as an ordinary industry that gets an advance under the Trade Loans Act? I presume they have got to pay it back, and will the Turf Development Board be asked to pay back any of the moneys that will be voted if and when this Resolution passes? Again, I should like to have information from the Minister as to what effect the spending of this money will have on other counties. What effect will it have on people engaged in a business such as, say, the coal trade? The Minister knows that there are certain important harbours in this Saorstát through which large imports of coal come in annually, and if the use of turf is going to be extended to any considerable extent, what effect is it going to have on those imports and on the financial position of the various harbour authorities? As I said in the beginning, I am not averse, by my voice and support, from helping industries in other counties, but I think I would be betraying the trust reposed in me by the people of County Louth if I did anything that would be inimical to their own interests. I should like to know what effect, if any, the passing of this Resolution will have on other parts of the country that will gain little or nothing by the passing of this Resolution.
Now, this whole question of the development of turf, of course, is a very big question. I suppose it is one that requires great thought and consideration, and at the moment I am not in a position to go very deeply into the matter. Again, however, I would ask the Minister to be fair to the House and give us a little more information. I know that down the country, at the cross-roads, the idea lying behind all this question of the development of turf is to compel the people in the towns and cities, whether they like it or not, to use turf. Certain remarks of a semi-ignorant character have been made such as: "We will let the people of Dublin see that they have got to use turf." Possibly, these people would like to visualise a state of affairs something like what Deputy Mrs. Concannon depicted when she spoke of the lovely turf fires burning in every home. Possibly, they would even like to see Sweet Peggy going along the roads on her low-backed car. I suppose they would like to see us go back to these times and to see motor cars abolished. After all, if we are going to take that attitude, let us go the whole hog and let us go back to the conditions of 200 or 300 years ago and do away with the mechanisation of all kinds and get back to the Stone Age. Let us go back to the days of the hob-nailed boots and all that. Having those opinions in my mind, and knowing the mentality prevailing in certain districts in which bogs are situated at the moment, and knowing that a very large proportion of these moneys will find its way into the pockets of these people, I should like to know, apart from all this, whether this question of the development of turf is going to react on the prosperity of the country, and I should like to know that if we vote moneys here, representing counties that are going to get very little, if anything, out of this development of turf, at least we will have the satisfaction that the money is going to be spent in a proper way. I think it is up to the Minister to give us a little more information as to the probable cost, the number of officials and inspectors necessary, the means he proposes to take to appoint these people, and everything in connection with the whole scheme.
As I stated, the Minister will find, possibly, that the House will be sympathetic. The only thing I am anxious about is to see that we are not going to spend money for the mere sake of spending it and that we are not developing bogs that, possibly, are past development. The draining of bogs and the making of bog roads are very useful works, but, as has been pointed out here, those things could be done without having recourse to the setting up of a Turf Development Board or without having recourse to the Turf Bill at all. They could be done through the ordinary channels of the Drainage Board. I should like to know what effect also this will have on other industries. I do not want to go into the whole question of registration and so forth, about people having to be registered before they can sell a bag of turf, and so on. According to the terms of the Bill, nobody will be able to take turf now at all unless he is registered. There seems to be no freedom whatsoever. Everybody will have to register. Whether they will do that through the usual channels of the Fianna Fáil clubs I do not know, but, to my mind, it leaves the way open to them to do that, and I do not think that is very much in the old spirit of self-reliance when every man could do his own job in his own way. I think that this matter of registration is a bad blot on the Bill. I think it is a bad thing that they should have to be registered and that they cannot sell their materials in the open market but must be registered and subject to all the conditions incorporated in this Act. That is all I have got to say on this Bill, Sir.
Comment on this
I do not think there is any necessity to discuss the general mechanism in connection with this Bill. I was rather amazed at the attitude adopted by the last speaker. The burden of his complaints seemed to be that under this Bill money is going to find its way into the bog areas to the exclusion of those areas that have not got bogs. I think that is a very unfair attitude entirely. We all know that the bog areas alone have not benefited, at least to the extent that one would desire, from the general agricultural and industrial development policies of the Government, and that is, of course, because of the very nature of the circumstances in those areas. This, in my opinion, is an attempt to rope in these areas, and I think that areas such as County Louth, that have benefited very considerably by the industrial policy and that are going to benefit still further by the erection of, say, alcohol factories, ought not to begrudge a little of the money that may be put to the advantage of the bog areas. I think it is a very ungracious attitude to take up. The last speaker seemed to deduce from the desire of the Government to foster the production and consumption of turf in this country that we are going to go back 300 or 400 years. Incidentally, in the course of his remarks he praised, in a general way, mechanisation, and under this Bill, for the first time, a new element of mechanisation is going to be introduced into the turf business. On that aspect of the question I have an open mind myself. I do not think the Minister can tell the last Deputy or anybody else—I am sure he is not satisfied in his own mind—what results are going to accrue from the operation of this Bill. I think that would be asking too much. But, in so far as it is an experiment and indicates a desire on the part of the Minister to put some earning in the way of the people in those areas, even if he has to introduce new methods for that purpose, his efforts are praiseworthy, in my opinion, and, whether we have doubts as to the ultimate success of it, I think the experiment ought to receive the unanimous approval of the House. It is, in my opinion, very ungracious and very begrudging on the part of representatives of areas of the country that have been blessed by nature with good land and other facilities, that they should criticise this effort on the part of the Government to aid areas that have been less fortunate. I think the opposition to this Bill will be received very badly by very many people in the country.
Comment on this
Deputy Bartley has, generally, made a very sensible speech about the whole matter, except in so far as he has said that because the Minister's intentions are good, no matter what misgivings we may have about the Bill, we ought not to oppose it. I think that would be a very bad principle. It does not matter what the Minister's intentions are, if we think this measure is not going to work satisfactorily or that it will not be useful, not alone is it our privilege but it is our job to show up its defects——
Comment on this
——and prevent, as far as we can, the expenditure of this money for a purpose in regard to which we think there will be no return. My fears about the Bill may possibly be a revelation to Deputy Bartley. I contend that there is going to be no advantage, but rather will there be a decided disadvantage arising out of the expenditure of money under this Bill. It will be a disadvantage in the case of the small bog owner, the man who has been ordinarily and consistently cutting his turf, using it and making a little money out of it. If there is to be any advantage gained at all, it will be, as Deputy Bartley feared, as the result of the new element of mechanisation and in no other way. Deputy Bartley knows more about bogs than the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and possibly more than I do. At the same time, I know enough about them, much more than the Minister does. I know enough about the subject to feel that we are entitled to be told for what purpose we are voting this money. We are entitled to know in what way the money is going to be expended by the Minister.
He ought to tell us if there is some safeguard for the small man, the individual peat-cutter who has been endeavouring to supplement his little earnings by the sale of turf. I would like to ask Deputy Bartley, who knows a whole lot about this question, if in his area there is a lot of turf on hand unsold and that cannot be sold? No, there is not. One would imagine from reading this Bill, which we are financing under this Money Resolution, that we have thousands of tons of turf and cannot get rid of it and, consequently, we must insist on every person who buys coal buying turf, and it must be bought from approved places, not from the man who cuts it unless, as Deputy Coburn pointed out, he becomes a member of a co-operative society or possibly of a local Fianna Fáil club. There is another aspect of this matter. When we are voting this money I think we are entitled to ask what will be the reactions of the provision of the money on the farming community? We had the President, on St. Patrick's Day, broadcasting to America and informing America and the whole world——
Comment on this
No, not about this Money Resolution, but if the Minister has any fear that I am not going to relate it, I will disappoint him, because I am going to relate it. The President broadcast to America that by an arrangement which had been made with Great Britain we had got an increased quota for our cattle. Quite recently when I asked the Minister for Agriculture about this matter he said we had got an arrangement, if we purchased more British coal. We are going to provide State money to-day so that we will not purchase anything like the amount of coal that the Minister for Agriculture hopes we will purchase. What will be the reactions of the whole thing?
Comment on this
Exactly—none—because the Minister does not intend to operate this measure. Deputy O'Leary is right, he will not be able to operate it. So the Minister feels that there is going to be really no reaction whatsoever to the position as regards the use of turf and coal. That is the Minister's mentality in bringing a motion such as this before the House. He wants the House to vote money, notwithstanding that there will be no results. Is that what the Minister means? He says there will be no reaction to the coal trade in this country. In that case the whole Bill will go for nought. At present we are purchasing all the turf that is offered for sale in the country. The Minister introduces a Bill that will prevent us purchasing coal unless we buy a quantity of turf, and he tells us that that will have no reaction in regard to coal. In that case the whole Bill is a fraud and is merely a type of window dressing—that is, if we take the Minister at his own word. The House, therefore, is being asked to vote money under false pretences.
There will be no reactions, says the Minister, in relation to a Bill which Deputy Bartley and Deputy Harris think is going to be of great benefit to the people of this country. The position is this, that we will still get the same quantity of British coal as in the past. The President hopes to increase coal importations because he wants to increase our cattle quota. As against all that, the Minister for Industry and Commerce tells us there will be no reactions arising from this Bill. That is the type of mentality that we have behind this Money Resolution. I think it would be really superfluous, it would be a mistake, for me to add anything to that. I commend the Minister's attitude to Fianna Fáil and to the people in this country who think the Minister for Industry and Commerce is doing something for the turf situation, for the turf-cutters and the bog-owners. We have his own word for it that there will be no reactions. I will leave it at that; it would be a pity to spoil it by further comment.
Comment on this
It has already been made clear by one of the leaders of the Opposition that I am not concluding. I am glad Deputy Brennan's speech was made. It was most informative. Until Deputy Brennan arose, I was under the impression that the unusual verbosity of the Deputies opposite was due to the fact that it was a Friday, because they know from experience that if they speak on Friday they can command double publicity. Once there is a possibility of that, the flow of their eloquence is very hard to dam. The flow continued unusually long this morning.
Comment on this
As I was saying, the flow continued unusually long this morning. I was on that account curious to find out what was the policy of the Party opposite on this Bill, the reason they picked out this measure, out of all the measures that have come before the Dáil this year, in order to initiate their policy of obstruction.
Comment on this
The Deputy told us that it was because the operations of this Bill may reduce the imports of coal. That is why he is opposed to this Bill and why he is opposed to voting any money to give effect to it, because he says it may reduce the imports of coal.
Comment on this
The Minister assured me there would be no reaction to the coal situation by the passage of this Bill.
Comment on this
I said there would be no reaction under the coal-cattle pact because of this measure, but at that stage the Deputy was arguing against this Bill because its operations, he said, would reduce the imports of coal.
Comment on this
The Deputy was not asking for anything. He was making a statement. Is the Party opposite opposed to the Bill on the grounds that it will reduce the imports of coal or not?
Comment on this
This debate is not going to conclude with my speech this evening. Therefore, I invite the Party opposite to hold a plenary session before Tuesday next, and there, after hearing the views of their own members, to arrive at some decision as to what their policy on this Bill is to be.
Comment on this
Shall we be allowed to fall in with the Minister's wishes and give him our answer on this measure? If not, Sir, I suggest his remark just now is irrelevant and out of order.
Comment on this
If any Deputy is going to complain of my remarks on the ground of irrelevancy, that finishes me after what we have heard this morning. The speeches since 11 o'clock to-day have astonished me. Surely, the Opposition have not the sole right to be irrelevant in matters of this kind.
Comment on this
And if they have wandered down the paths of irrelevancy since 11 o'clock this morning with great gusto, we are inclined to follow them to find out where they are going to. After all, is it necessary to remind Deputies of what we have been told? We had Deputy Morrissey talking about the reactions of this Bill upon certain classes of turf producers. We have had Deputy Brennan talking about its reactions on the coal-cattle pact and we have had Deputy O'Leary telling us about his having sat down without ill-effects to his person on a range in which turf was being burned. I gathered, however, despite all the irrelevancies and inaccuracies that crept into the speeches of the Deputies opposite, that they are opposed to the provision of money for the encouragement of the more extensive production and consumption of turf for domestic and household purposes.
Comment on this
We are opposed to this Vote because it will not encourage the greater production of turf.
Comment on this
Surely if there was one thing standing out, and very obvious from the speeches of the Deputies it is, that they are opposed to the voting of the money needed for the expenditure under a Bill which will increase the production and consumption of turf. Are Deputies opposite in favour of increasing the production and consumption of turf?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy speaking of the Party policy or is he giving us his own policy? Can we get it authoritatively from any member of the Party opposite that it is the policy of that Party to encourage the more extensive production and consumption of turf? Is that their policy or is it not?
Comment on this
I am trying to convince Deputies that a certain Motion before the House should pass. I am trying to convince them that it is good national policy to encourage and increase the consumption of turf as household fuel. I think that is a very good policy. Is it their policy? If it is their policy, I think I can convince them that this Bill is a good one and that this Money Resolution should pass. If it is not their policy there is no good in my arguing in favour of the Resolution.
Comment on this
Convince me that this Bill and this Money Resolution will encourage and increase the consumption of turf.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister will defend his Bill and his Money Resolution. He has not yet tried to do so.
Comment on this
He will, unless he is convinced that it is a pure waste of time to try to convince Deputies opposite. It would be an obvious waste of time to try to convince Deputies opposite that this Bill is a good Bill if they are opposed to the principle of it—the principle of increasing the production and consumption of turf. If they are opposed to the whole idea of the Bill, I am not going to waste my time and the time of the House arguing about the details. If they accept that idea, if they will agree with me that it is a good national policy to develop our internal sources of domestic fuel, then I am prepared to argue and I will endeavour to convince them——
Comment on this
We have to take Deputy Belton now seriously, as we read in the Press that the Party opposite are negotiating for his return.
Comment on this
I assume from past experience that the Irish Press was correct, and I merely proposed to treat Deputy Belton seriously
Comment on this
The money which it is sought to make available by this Resolution is not, however, a very large amount. It is obvious that Deputies opposite have a very loose idea of what the Bill is about. Deputy Coburn has certainly very loose ideas about it.
Comment on this
The actual amount will depend upon the extent to which the Bill is brought into operation.
Comment on this
The expenditure under the Bill will depend upon the number of areas which are made appointed areas for the purpose of the Bill. The expenditure upon the headquarters staff will depend on that; the number of additional appointments that will have to be made under it will depend upon the number of appointed areas. The total increase, however, will be comparatively small. There are, of course, provisions in the Bill which will empower the Minister for Industry and Commerce to buy land. The amount of expenditure under that head will depend upon the amount of land he wants to buy and the prices to be paid for it. Under these circumstances, it is obvious that no definite figure can be given. At any rate, the amount of money to be paid for the land to be bought under the Bill will have to be voted by the Dáil.
Comment on this
Amongst the things that we have been told by the Deputies opposite was that the price we are paying for turf constitutes a sweated wage for the workers.
Comment on this
I say that the price is a good price. It is a higher price than the producers of turf were getting before this scheme came into operation.
Comment on this
We are paying a price of 11/6 a ton for turf delivered on the canal bank or at the railway station and, sometimes, at a loading point in the bog. A guaranteed price of 11/6 per ton for turf is a good price. Turf can be purchased in many parts of the country at present for a much lower price than that.
Comment on this
In many parts of the country. A very large number of local authorities have standing contracts for the delivery of turf at a much lower price.
Comment on this
I could not give one straight off, but I know there are a number of local authorities buying turf, delivered in farmers' carts to their yards, at a lower price than is being fixed for the co-operative societies of 11/6 per ton. Three men in a team can produce between them sufficient peat to give 18 tons of air-dried peat per week.
Comment on this
Eighteen tons by three men. Having regard to the circumstances prevailing in the bog areas, the remuneration received by those engaged in peat production is quite good, and they are very glad to get it. If Deputies opposite have any illusion about that, I invite them to go to the areas where the co-operative societies are working, and inquire. It is a very extraordinary thing that those Deputies in the Parties opposite who represent the areas in which this peat development is taking place to an appreciable extent do not come here to speak against this Bill. They are conspicuous by their absence from the House. We have had Deputy O'Sullivan, Deputy Belton, Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Bennett——
Comment on this
I invite him to go to the bogs in Tipperary and get in touch with the co-operative societies working there, and tell them that he voted against this Bill.
Comment on this
Against the principle of providing money to enable the scheme to work. He will be very welcome, I am sure.
Comment on this
What does the production of 18 tons of turf by three men mean? At what point will the turf be left by these men? Does the Minister merely mean cutting and spreading on the bank?
Comment on this
I say that three men will cut and spread sufficient peat to yield 18 tons of air-dried turf in a week. I invite Deputies opposite to vote against this resolution. I invite them to vote against the Bill. I encourage them to maintain their opposition to it, and by this day 12 months they will be denying that they ever did it. It will not be the first occasion on which they voted against a Bill and denied afterwards that they had taken that line. I prognosticate here that in 12 months' time two-thirds of the members of the Party opposite will be going around their constituencies indignantly denying that they ever opposed the Bill or that they ever voted against the provision of money for a turf development scheme. I shall be very glad to have it on record here that their opposition was not merely formal—the action of a Party opposing the proposals of those in power, irrespective of what the proposals were, but that they had obstructed this Bill for a whole day and had adopted tactics designed not merely to oppose, but to impede the Government in giving effect to their programme in that respect. Let us get that upon record. It will be a good thing to have it put upon record. I can see the propaganda department of Fianna Fáil digging up that record in 12 months' time and placarding the country with it, or at least some constituencies——
Comment on this
——because they will be denying that they ever did it. How many people are going to be employed in consequence of the turf scheme, Deputy Belton wants to know. It is my ambition to see employed in the production and marketing of turf a much larger number of people than is employed in any other industry in this country, except agriculture. I believe we can do it. I believe we can put from 40,000 to 50,000 people in employment on turf. It is going to take a long time to do it, but we can do it and we are starting now. We are starting now in spite of the opposition of the Party opposite and we will continue to do that despite their opposition. As we make progress in the doing of it, whenever we meet with that opposition we will try to defeat it then as we are doing now. As soon as the scheme begins to make progress and men get employment, as soon as it becomes popular in certain areas, as soon as it may mean a loss of votes to oppose it, the Opposition will forget that they ever opposed it.
The Motion before the Dáil in relation to this Bill is a formal Motion. Usually, the Money Resolution moved before the Committee Stage of a Bill is passed without discussion. It is certainly most unusual to have a whole day's debate of a Second Reading kind upon a Motion of that description such as we have had. I must assume from the unusual tactics adopted by the Opposition that their antagonism is so great they have decided to resort to obstruction. It is well we should know that Deputy O'Leary got so heated that he was able to inspire his Party to take a vigorous line upon something. We have been trying by a process of trial and error to find out the policy of the Party opposite. We have not been very successful up to the present. We know now one or two things that they stand for. We know one thing that they are against. They are against taking action to encourage the increased consumption of turf as a household fuel and against providing money for that purpose.
Comment on this
The Minister was asked some questions about the cost of the measure. We have been treated to a Second Reading speech by the Minister in which we were asked to speculate upon what the cost is likely to be. The more the Bill is put into operation the more money, we are told, is going to be spent. The Minister gave no idea as to what the cost will be either in the stage where we will have 100, 200 or 400 persons employed, or the 40,000 to 50,000 persons which he has in mind. The Minister must have some information on his brief as to what the measure is likely to entail in the way of cost. He must have some idea as to where he is going to acquire the bogs for the purpose and some idea as to what he is going to pay for them. Is the House not entitled to that information?
We had a speech from the Minister which began by asking what the policy of the members of this Party was on the measure. That policy is not before the House. It is the Minister's policy which is before the House. The Minister has introduced a Bill which, apparently, he is so much ashamed of, or so unacquainted with its provisions or the ultimate cost which it is going to put upon the taxpayers, that he is not in a position to give any figure from a single sovereign to £5,000. If that is his opinion of a deliberative Assembly, I think he will find that the people will not approve of it. We are entitled to know more about what the Minister's intentions are with regard to expenditure under the measure.
What are his own views as to the extent of the expenditure in respect of the policy he has in mind? Does he mean to convey that he is going to employ 40,000 or 50,000 persons in the course of a few years? He has something in his mind. His speech was really a political speech, and not worthy of the Dáil. It might be worthy as an address to one of his own branches in Dublin, but it was not certainly a speech that the House should expect to hear in connection with a Money Resolution. Can we get any figure as to what the Minister's intentions are in connection with the expenditure under this measure, say for 12 months—for any 12 months he likes to take? Assuming this Bill does not come into operation for three years, what are his intentions in the following financial years? He said we would get certain information on the Estimates. Of course, we will. Are we to be told when a Money Resolution is brought in and money is proposed to be expended that, outside what may be considered on the Estimates, we are not entitled to get any information? Will the Minister give us some idea, when he has exhausted present supplies, what the cost of the co-operative societies was and when he intends to move his operations towards the west, the north or the south? Will he tell us whether provision is to be made for the people's needs in those areas? What scheme has he in connection with the working of the big bogs and what sum of money will it cost? Will he tell us what sum he proposes to expend in connection with the bogs? We all know that the Minister has no knowledge of agricultural conditions, but he has his Department, to give him information to put before the House, in regard to this measure. He has not done that.
Comment on this
I was not a bit impressed by the simulated indignation of the Minister in connection with this Bill. I know it is in accordance with his usual manner, but I know he was completely bogged about this matter. I am entirely in favour of, and in agreement with, a policy for the development of the turf industry in this country, but this Bill, in my opinion, is an undoubted restriction upon human liberty. The Leader of the Opposition said that in the United States of America Pussyfoot and men like him got a measure passed prohibiting the citizens from buying certain products. That was denounced by the Catholic Bishops and all moral theologians in America at the time. Now, the Minister for Industry and Commerce comes forward here with a measure which compels people, not to refrain from using certain commodities, but to use them.
Comment on this
This, in my opinion, and in the opinion of Deputies on every side of the House, is a very unusual demand to make. It is against every principle of human freedom. Take a man living in Dublin, who has to buy a certain amount of coal. Now, in addition to that, he will have to buy a certain amount of turf. Where is he going to put that turf?
Comment on this
The Money Resolution, I respectfully submit, deals with this Bill.
Comment on this
Quite; but it is not in order to discuss everything in the Bill on the Money Resolution.
Comment on this
What I wish to submit is this: The Bill cannot pass unless the Money Resolution is approved by the House, and, therefore, in debating the Money Resolution we are entitled to consider the whole scope of the Bill.
Comment on this
If the Chair differs, I submit to the Chair, as I always do, though I feel it might be wrong at times.
Comment on this
I feel the Minister is very angry this morning, because I have some idea he is anxious to get out to the Show for the evening. I think that explains many of the things he said, but did not mean to say, this morning. I do not wish it to go forth that I am in any way against this Bill or anything that benefits the country; on the contrary, I am entirely in favour of it. But I do believe, and am convinced, and I know something about it, that this Bill will not in any way either increase employment or make turf more popular in the country. There is no use in the Minister threatening that there will be a record here of how votes will be cast. That is an argument in terrorem. The Minister forgets a lot of things he himself did and said, and a lot of votes he gave, and a lot of promises he made in his earlier days; yet now he menaces Deputies on this side of the House. As I have said already, I am entirely in favour of turf development within due limits and in the proper way. In my part of the country the fact is there is not a sufficient amount of turf to supply the ordinary farmers with fuel.
Comment on this
Is that a long way from it? Unfortunately, I do not understand the Rules and Standing Orders of the House, and the only way I can get to understand them is following the example of Parnell, by breaking them. I hope that before I leave this House, which may be possibly in a short time, I shall have learned something about them.
Comment on this
I am against this Money Resolution, because I think it will be money mis-spent. It will not give an adequate return, and instead of developing this turf industry, and instead of providing employment for 50,000 or 100,000 people, some of whom will, as Deputy Coburn said, have to be brought from the United States according to some of the Deputies opposite, it will do more harm than good to the project the Minister has in mind, and which I am sure he wishes to achieve.
I move to report progress.