In Committee on Finance. - Turf (Use and Development) Bill, 1935—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–155 of 312. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 42 of 1935 ›
On amendment No. 1, Sir, I do not know whether the Minister has made any reply to the argument put forward by Deputy O'Sullivan on this subject. Deputy O'Sullivan made a claim that this section was going to interfere seriously with the income of a large number of people whose domestic economy was based on the fact that they cut and sold turf in certain quantities and that, in many cases, a very considerable quantity of the turf cut by these people was sold in their own neighbourhood through the year, and particularly in their local towns. The proposal in the section would mean that that trade is going to be cut away from ordinary turf cutters. Any person who buys coal in any small town in an appointed area is going to be forced to buy a certain quantity of approved turf. The approved turf will be turf that has been bought from one of the co-operative societies. The Minister has not, as far as I know, made any attempt to show how a turf cutter who has had that particular type of income is going to retain it. It was pointed out to the Minister that co-operative societies have not in any way shown themselves to be an improvement in respect to the turf industry. In five counties, Donegal, Mayo, Galway, Clare and Kerry, where they had half the total of the co-operative societies, two-thirds of the total distribution of sacks, and in which up to December 31st last £37,924 were spent on relief works in improving access to the bogs, the result of the work of half the societies, with two-thirds of the sacks and more than one-third of the money, was a reduction in the quantity of turf cut in the last year of which we have information by 242,000 tons.
Comment on this
I pointed out to the Minister that while he is not able to give the quantity of turf cut in 1934, he has provided figures to show that the carriage of turf by the railway companies and on the canals decreased in 1935, and that the purchase of turf by public offices in the City of Dublin, which was by far the greater part of the purchases from co-operative societies, and through the board, had fallen compared to 1934, and that it had fallen in 1934 as against 1933. The Ministerial Press has indicated that this Bill is introduced to make compulsory a scheme which had proved highly successful when tried in a voluntary way. I should like to hear from the Minister what type of success it had shown.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I submit that the Deputy is not speaking to the amendment at all.
Comment on this
The Deputy's speech would seem to be more appropriate to a Second Reading than to an amendment.
Comment on this
The amendment seeks to secure that the ordinary turf cutter who earned a living, either whole or in part, by cutting and selling turf will not be excluded by the passage of Section 2 in its present form. I pointed out that the section in the form in which it now is would endeavour to collar all the selling of turf for co-operative societies; that the outstanding manifestation in these counties where these societies had been developed had been a very big falling off in the amount of turf drawn from the bogs.
Comment on this
All that was discussed on the Second Stage and again on the Money Resolution. It should not be repeated on a specific amendment.
Comment on this
I submit that I am in order, and that argument would be futile if it hid the fact that the section we propose to amend sought to gather all that local sale of turf in an appointed area, into the hands of co-operative societies, and that the work of these societies in the past, in the areas in which they exist, had been marked by a falling off in the cutting of turf. That is the simple background. The important thing in the amendment is that we seek to secure to the ordinary turf cutter the income and the work he had in the past. We have heard nothing on the subject from the Minister, and we are anxious to hear why he cuts out from the profitable work of cutting and selling of turf, people who made it part of their livelihood in the past.
Comment on this
I see in this House at the moment Deputy Victory, Deputy Jordan and Deputy Hugh Doherty, three Fianna Fáil Deputies from turf-cutting areas, to whom I put this question: do they approve of a proposal which will prevent small farmers in their constituencies from selling such turf as they are in a position to save on the bogs annexed to their holdings?
Comment on this
In Section 2, as usual enshrined under subterfuge, because we are told that all that section is designed to do is to make certain persons an "approved source." The argument is that it is not designed to stop anyone selling turf. Everyone realises that if you make certain restricted bodies an "approved source" for the purposes of this Bill, in the specified area, all turf must be and will be bought from them. A great many people will buy coal who require it, and who do not want turf. Under the terms of the Bill they will be forced to buy turf and they will either have to bury it or to burn it. If they do not burn it themselves they will dispose of it to neighbours, who will dispose of it at whatever price they can get to order to have it taken out of yards and kitchens. That will operate to prevent the casual vendor, who goes through the streets of a town with a crib of turf, and waits for someone to come up and ask the price, and buy it. Deputy Victory spoke on the Second Reading and on the Money Resolution, and being, as he is, an experienced man in the light of rural Ireland, he said turf was a side-line to the agricultural community. The Deputy was perfectly right. It is a side line, and it may make all the difference between living on the verge of starvation, or in a modest degree of prosperity, for a man who has a poor holding and a fair bit of turbary attached to it, if he could send one or two of the boys to save turf in the summer for sale on the streets. Does Deputy Victory want to stop that man from having that source of income? If he does not, he must vote for an amendment which schedules that man as an "approved source." That is all the amendment is designed to do, to ensure that the very persons Deputy Victory referred to when speaking on the Money Resolution, will be allowed to continue selling turf as they sold it in the past.
Comment on this
What reaction has the question of briquettes on this? By Section 2 we are asked to give the Minister the right to prohibit anyone selling turf for the purposes of this Bill unless he is an "approved source." Sales of turf by an ordinary farmer will not fulfil the requirements of purchasers of coal. We are asking that farmers of the type described by Deputy Victory will be put in the same position as co-operative societies, as the board or a limited company dealing in briquettes. Surely that is a reasonable proposal. If what Deputy Victory said on the Money Resolution was true, I have no hesitation in saying that this is a very necessary precaution to take. Surely Deputy Jordan and Deputy Hugh Doherty will tell us in respect of Loughrea and Dunloe whether they are in favour of putting a small farmer with a bit of turbary who sells turf in towns off the streets. If they are not in favour of that, will they explain why they refuse to support this amendment, which does not seek to put such a farmer into any preferential position, does seek to exempt him from the provisions of this Bill, but merely seeks to provide that this Bill will not be used to deprive him of a livelihood upon which he has depended in the past and upon which he must depend in future if he is to be spared from real hardship.
Comment on this
It is the Minister's Bill and it is the duty of the Minister to safeguard the interest of the community from every point of view. Suppose he does not make provision for the inspection of that turf, I would ask the Deputy to bear in mind that, in connection with the co-operative society, the briquette company and the board, the Minister purports to guarantee the quality of the turf. In the case of the farmer for whom Deputy Victory replied and with whom Deputy Jordan and Deputy Hugh Doherty are familiar, no such guarantee exists. That man brings his cart of turf into the town, and stands upon the hazard, seeking a price for his turf from persons who are there to examine it and to judge the condition and the quality of the turf. They make an offer to the vendor proportionate to the quality of the turf which he has to offer. These Deputies will confirm me when I say that you will very frequently see two carts of turf on the streets, one a cart of "spaddagh" and the other a cart of stone turf. The horse cart of stone turf would command 2/- or 2/6 more than a horse cart of "spaddagh." But the Minister does not purport to guarantee the quality of that turf. There is no necessity for his intervention. All the amendment seeks to provide is that if a person brings a certificate from one of these vendors of turf, from whom he has purchased his requirements to a coal retailer, and says: "I have bought the quantity of turf required by the Minister's order, to balance the quantity of coal I now require and in evidence of that purchase I produce the certificate of that person," that will be sufficient evidence to entitle him to purchase the quantity of coal which he requires from the retailer of coal, he having purchased the required quantity of turf already from the vendor of turf on the street.
Comment on this
This amendment appears to me not as an amendment to amend the section but an amendment asking for a new Bill. It is perfectly obvious, if the principle of the Bill is accepted, that the amendment as proposed could not be accepted. The amendment hits at the very root of the Bill. It hits at standardisation. It could not be reconciled with the proposal to guarantee the quality of the turf or to standardise the quality of the turf that is sold to the public. Might I remind Deputy Dillon in connection with another article of Irish produce that he and his colleagues have in the past couple of years shown their impatience with the Minister for Agriculture for not bringing about, more rapidly, collective marketing? They know what individual marketing has done in the case of butter, particularly in the matter of exports. Do they want to create that same problem now in connection with turf, the marketing of which is in its beginnings, so to speak? Do they want to create a position where there will be eternal bickering and quarrelling about the standard of turf that is for sale, one person getting turf that is guaranteed to him and another getting turf that is not guaranteed but that is simply offered to him without anything further than the judgment of the producer?
Comment on this
He need not take it if he does not want to. He can pass on to another cart of turf or go to the coal retailer for his turf.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy will admit that there will be a gain through getting collective marketing, through getting these small producers of turf into an association or society where their turf can be inspected and where the quality can be guaranteed? If the whole principle of the Bill is going to have any effect, it will depend largely on that provision. I do not think that the amendment is intended very seriously. I am surprised that Deputies opposite have not gone all out for what looks to me a much bigger flaw in this section, that is, the omission to make people like coal merchants, for instance, approved sources for turf. It seems to me that an immense case could be made for making country coal merchants, particularly a country coal merchant who has a bog of his own——
Comment on this
I thought he would not, because Deputy Moore's arguments, if they are accepted by the Minister, undoubtedly reveal a purpose on the part of the Minister that has not been revealed up to the present— that he is going to use this Bill to compel these individual turf cutters and individual suppliers of turf to come under his scheme so as to have their turf inspected. That is the very first hint we got of that. I was under the impression that the Minister had no such intention, but Deputy Moore says it is the very principle of the Bill.
Comment on this
To guarantee the quality to be provided by a turf-cutter who sells his turf quite voluntarily? There is no compulsion on anybody to buy turf from him. I wish the Deputy would get that quite clear and the Minister too. As I said upon the last day, my purpose is to secure that individual turf-cutters who come into a country town to sell, as they have done up to the present, turf, by the rail to inhabitants of the town will not be interfered with. This is not going to cut across the principle of the Bill. All I want is that if a town inhabitant says: "I shall buy my turf, as I have always bought it, from John Doody, and I want that turf to be taken into account in fixing the amount I am bound to take when I buy my coal" his wishes will be respected. He is bound to buy so much turf, and that being so, if he is compelled to buy it from an approved source, then he must cut down the amount of turf that he has been accustomed to buy from the said John Doody. It is to prevent that happening that this amendment is moved, and for no other purpose.
There is no question of the quality of the turf. If I am dissatisfied with the quality of the turf offered by the private individual, I can go to the coal merchant and I can take my quota of turf from him. This turf, the Minister assures us, is guaranteed by the co-operative societies. If I have any doubts as to the quality of the turf offered by the person from whom I have been getting it all my life, I have that course open to me. There is no necessity for inspection of the turf that I, as an ordinary citizen, voluntarily buy. It is quite obvious from Deputy Moore's statement, if we take that as representing the mind of the Government, that a much more ambitious scheme is in prospect than the Minister gave us any idea of, that we are going to have turf standardised for everybody just as butter is standardised, though whether it is for an export trade or not was not made quite clear to me. I understood that was one of the purposes so far as butter was concerned.
What I object to is this: if this Bill is going to be seriously operated in the turf-cutting districts, in those districts that are at present turf-consuming districts, it will inevitably interfere with the particular man who depends on that to some extent for making his little farm help him to eke out an existence. It will interfere with his trade, undoubtedly. The Minister, I think, made it clear that large scale production and mechanisation was the purpose in view. He gave us an example of what is being done in Russia in this particular respect. I am not saying that the example was not apropos. It is quite relevant to the policy of the Minister, but I suggest that exactly the same argument could be applied to farming in general; that you could cut out small-scale individual farming on exactly the same ground, because large-scale production is more economic and more productive, and gives better scope for mechanisation. In the very country which the Minister adduced as an example, these are the arguments and these are the reasons that have been operative in wiping out small farming, and substituting for it large-scale production with the help of mechanisation. You are doing exactly the same thing here as regards turf.
I do not know how the Minister in almost two consecutive sentences can say, on the one hand, that you are not interfering with the trade of an individual, and then say that his market is going to be interfered with. Of course, his market is going to be interfered with if this Bill is to be operated. It is only on one condition that his market will not be interfered with, and that is if the Bill is not going to be operated in the turf consuming districts. But, I confess to Deputy Moore and to the House that I have never yet got from the Minister any clear idea as to where the Bill is going to be operated.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy object to the small producer being compelled to join a co-operative society?
Comment on this
Unless the advantage of it is shown to me, and no advantage has been shown. If that is the aim of the Government—to compel the small producer to join a co-operative society, let them make a case for it, but I am not aware that a case is being made. I suggest that you should not interfere with the individual in that way unless you can make a case for interfering, and I am sure that the Deputy will agree with me that a case has not been made. The Minister certainly has not attempted to make a case. I cannot exactly follow the Deputy in treating turf as if it were butter, though, as I have said, I should not be surprised at the Government ending up by mixing the two. You are undoubtedly, in this case, killing the trade of the individual. Why that should be necessary the Minister has not explained. The quality of the turf to be produced or to be supplied by the other two sources does not arise. That is a different question altogether. Here is a case of voluntary purchase, where the buyer determines of his own free will. You prevent him from doing so, and, to a certain extent, you interfere with the trade of the other man. I did not understand the reference of Deputy Victory. I thought I would have his support for this amendment because he was the Deputy who, as I said when speaking the last day, gave me the very good phrase that turf-cutting is a sideline with many farmers. That is precisely the case that I am making. I suggest that the Government are going to kill that side-line. How do briquettes meet the situation? I am sure the Deputy does not suggest that all those individual small farmers should, instead of cutting turf in the ordinary way and selling it in the neighbouring town, devote their attention to turning out briquettes.
Comment on this
The point made by the Deputies sitting on that side of the House is that nothing will do except the best English coal.
Comment on this
Not at all. I thoroughly agree, and the Minister says that he agrees with me, that there is no prejudice against turf in the country, People will burn it where they have been accustomed to its use or where the construction of their houses is suitable for turf burning. I do not think there is any prejudice against turf, and there the Minister, I am glad to say, agrees with me. What I want to ensure is that they will be allowed to buy turf in the place where they have always bought it and from the man who has always gone in for turf cutting as a sideline.
Comment on this
I do not think that Deputy O'Sullivan really put forward this amendment for the purpose that he has stated. I do not think that he is quite as simple as he represents himself to be. He knows quite well that if this amendment were carried the Bill would be completely inoperative, and I submit that is the reason why he has brought it before the House. The passage of this amendment would mean that the Bill might as well be withdrawn. It could not be worked. If the principle of the Bill is that, in certain circumstances and in certain areas, people may be required to use turf, then to put in the provision that they can be released from that requirement by getting a certificate from some person who had cut and sold turf before the 1st December, 1935, the whole thing would be reduced to a position in which any attempt to operate the Bill would be a complete failure. From a purely practical point of view, therefore, it is not possible to devise any scheme by which the individual turf producer can be brought within the definition of an approved source. That is not possible, and even if it were I question whether it would be desirable. The practical difficulty of doing so is so considerable that the matter is not worth considering further.
In any event, let us consider the question whether this Bill is going to have the bad effect on individual producers, which Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Dillon represented. May I say that I am gratified to see the representatives of the Party opposite showing this concern for the individual turf producers, because on occasions in the past when a proposal was brought before the House to increase the use of turf in the country as a fuel they were opposed to it.
Comment on this
It is for the Deputies themselves to say why. I merely record the fact that they were opposed to it, but now their hearts are bleeding for the turf producers.
Comment on this
I accept Deputy O'Leary's contention that his heart does not bleed. In any event, they are weeping crocodile tears, and they can do it quite efficiently, for the turf producers. They have put forward the turf producers, and are asking our sympathy for them merely for the purpose of defeating this measure which is designed to secure a much greater use of turf as a fuel, and a much greater development in the production of turf. Their contention, however, is that we should not attempt to organise the production of turf on a large scale, because by doing so we might act detrimentally to the interests of a limited number of small turf producers in the country. It is not a very sensible point of view. It would be just as sensible to ask that we should shut down all the boot factories in the country and prohibit the import of new boots, because by doing so we would give a lot more work to the cobblers. That is precisely the argument that they are using. Their argument is: "Look at all the work that would be going to the boot repairing shops if all the factories were closed down and if no new boots were allowed to be imported and sold." Deputy O'Sullivan says that because here and there throughout the country there are individuals——
Comment on this
——because in certain parts of the country there are individuals not making a livelihood out of turf, but supplementing their livelihood from some other source by producing and selling turf, that we should on that account abandon everything else, make no attempt to increase the production of turf on an organised basis, and make no attempt to secure that turf of good quality is sold on a commercial scale. It is a very sensible point of view—about as sensible a point of view as we have had from the Party opposite on any question. The individual turf-producer, about whom Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Dillon pretend to be concerned, will be affected by this Bill. I am not questioning that. To some extent he will be affected, but it will be a very, very small extent. To make the assertion, as Deputy Dillon does, that all the turf that is going to be sold will be sold by co-operative societies, or to make the assertion, as Deputy Mulcahy does, that the turf-cutters are going to be shut off from their present profitable business in the sale of turf is just nonsense. The people to whom these individual turf-cutters are selling turf at the present time are, in the main, people who use turf exclusively as their fuel, or who, in so far as they do not use turf exclusively, purchase coal only in quantities of 2 cwt. or less. There are individuals of whom that is not so. I admit that individual turf-producers are going to be affected to some extent, but, in the main, they will not be affected at all, There is nothing in this Bill which prevents them from selling turf, nor will they be affected in fact. They will continue to sell turf to quite a considerable extent and, in so far as we are increasing the market for turf against the opposition of the Party opposite, we are giving them a much greater chance of securing profitable employment from the sale of turf. We are not proposing to compel them to join co-operative societies, but I think it is likely that a large number of them will join co-operative societies. I think that it would be good business for them to do so. But there is nothing in this Bill to compel them to do that. In some districts it might not be possible to get co-operative societies established, but, in the turf-using areas in which this business is mainly carried on, the organisation of co-operative societies will present little difficulty to the great majority of these people. In so far as they are not in co-operative societies already, they will certainly be so organised in a short time after the Bill comes into operation. In due course, as the production of turf is increased and the requirements in respect of the use of turf are enlarged, the operation of the Bill will, perhaps, obtrude more extensively into the sphere of activity of those individual turf-cutters; but that is likely to be some time ahead, and, by that time, everybody will appreciate the advisability of having these people properly organised and the sale and distribution of turf conducted on commercial lines.
To reiterate, the Bill is designed to increase the market for turf. It is necessary, therefore, that we should be in a position to exercise supervision over the turf sold in accordance with the provisions of the Bill. In relation to other commodities, Deputies opposite are continuously pressing upon the Government the view that it has a responsibility for safeguarding the quality of commodities which people are required to use, in consequence of protective tariffs or other measures. The same principle applies in relation to turf. If we put people in the position that they must use turf, there is on the Government or on the organisations acting under the Government, a responsibility to ensure that good quality turf only is available and is available in sufficient quantities. It is not possible to exercise supervision over the quality of the turf produced by a number of individuals throughout the country but we can very effectively control the quality of turf sold by co-operative societies or by the Board. That is why, apart from any other reason, it is necessary to have that provision in the Bill. The individual turf-cutter will not be affected to any considerable extent. To a limited extent, in some areas, he may be affected. In so far, however, as individual turf-cutters in the main sell turf to people who use turf exclusively, or who use coal only in small quantities, their position will not be affected in the least. In so far as the operation of the Bill will increase the market for turf, and increase the profit to be secured from the production of turf, these people are likely to be organised in co-operative societies before long, in which case they will be able to take full advantage of the provisions of the Bill.
Comment on this
The Minister says it is impossible to exercise supervision over individual turf-cutters in respect of the type of turf they produce. That is not necessary. The individual who buys turf will see to that. He is not compelled to buy from these people.
Comment on this
I shall come to that. The amount is what counts. The Minister says there would be a practical difficulty of administration in meeting our view. That is an extraordinary statement coming from a colleague of the Minister for Agriculture, who introduced the Butter Bill and pushed it through last year. We had there the case of the individual producer. It was a much more difficult case than the present case and the Minister's proposals were more objectionable, from the point of view of individual producers all over the country than they would be in the present case. The Minister's colleague, notwithstanding all that was said to him, had no difficulty in providing for inspection and even for inspection of a rather objectionable type—going into people's houses and rooms. When it suits the Minister for Industry and Commerce, administrative difficulties, which he does not explain to us, present themselves and form an insuperable obstacle.
Comment on this
If the Government did a much more difficult thing and a much more objectionable thing in the case to which I refer, then they can do a thing which does not present one-tenth of the difficulty.
Comment on this
I am proposing that the amount of turf sold by an individual turf-cutter be allowed to count as portion of the quota. The Minister says that every proposal to increase the consumption of turf which was brought before this House was opposed by this Party. Because the Minister comes in here and says that he intends to have greater production of turf, are we to be forced to believe that the methods he is adopting will lead to greater production? He had plenty of opportunities on the Second Reading and on the Money Resolution to controvert the figures as regards the turf production which followed his previous schemes. Does he think that because he prophesies that measures he introduces will lead to greater production, we are to accept that without comment? Are we to do that in the light of the experience we have had of the Minister's proposals? He spoke of measures brought in here to increase turf production. Has he increased turf production? Did he increase turf production in the County Kerry in the year 1935?
Comment on this
Why did not the Minister controvert the figures put before him by Deputy Mulcahy on the various stages of this Bill?
Comment on this
In 1934 over 1931, a year when this measure was not in existence, and you had 32 co-operative societies then.
Comment on this
There was less production of turf in that county. What are the Minister's figures to show that there is increased production? All we know is that there has been a constant diminution in turf production, so far as we can judge. The Minister says these figures prove nothing, but he has given us no figures that controvert them. It is not a question of comparing 1934 with 1933, but a question of comparing 1934 with 1931. Have the Minister's efforts been so successful that he thinks any opposition to this is high treason to Irish industry? Surely he has adopted that attitude a little too often in this House. It is his conception of government that because he comes in here and states a thing, it must be accepted, even though the figures supplied by himself seem to point to the opposite conclusion.
With all respect to the Minister, I want to preserve the man to whom he so contemptuously refers by analogy as the cobbler in this business. I want to preserve the rights of the cobbler. We are first told that this Bill will have no effect on the individual and that the individual is not going to be affected to any extent by its provisions. Then we are told that he is going to be affected to some extent. On what does the Minister base his statement that in country towns where there are ranges in most of the houses, and where turf is also burned in the other rooms, there are very few people who buy turf and coal? I wonder on what he bases a statement of that kind. Has it any basis whatever? The Minister is very free with statistics. Was there any investigation made? Of course, there was not. This Bill was introduced without any advertence to the effect it was going to have on the particular class of men to whom I am referring. If the Minister had taken the hint dropped by Deputy Mrs. Concannon, it might have been better, so far as turf production is concerned, than the procedure he is now adopting—to see that there is proper provision for turf burning in the houses. That, however, is a matter which I can discuss more appropriately on another section. There is nothing in this Bill to prevent the individual turf-cutter, we are told, still having turf-cutting as a sideline. Of course, you do not prohibit it. As the Minister says himself, you only interfere with his market.
Comment on this
Indeed? You are preventing people who bought from individual turf-cutters before from buying a certain amount now. Naturally, those people are not going to buy in two lots. They are not going to buy a rail of turf from one man and buy turf from the coal merchant on the other hand. They will buy it all in one lot if they can. It will seriously interfere with such individuals, and I am surprised that there is not more advertence to this danger on the Government Benches. You are undoubtedly interfering gravely with these individuals. They may be cobblers, but there is many a man in the country whose farm is so small that he finds it difficult enough to live on the produce of the farm alone, and this sideline, as Deputy Victory would call it, even though it is a cobbling sideline, if I may use the happy phrase of the Minister, is most useful. It enables a man to rise above the misery line and now the Fianna Fáil Party are going to deprive him of that advantage.
Comment on this
I think Deputy O'Sullivan has dealt with the Minister's observation that this Party has opposed every proposal for the development of turf. I remember Deputy Hugh Doherty, who has now faded out of the House, contesting an election in County Donegal with me in 1933, and I remember expounding my difficulty in fighting for my seat in County Donegal when Deputy Doherty was going around telling the people that he proposed to turn every bog in Donegal into a gold-mine. They were going to produce more wealth than they had ever produced before. I remember saying on that occasion: "This is a perfectly fraudulent promise, but it is just as good as those which Senator Connolly or any of the rest of them have made." Who was right? I was, and Deputy Doherty, depending on the infallible Minister for Industry and Commerce, was proved to be wrong, because, instead of turning bogs into gold-mines, the net result of Deputy Hugh Doherty's activities——
Comment on this
The Minister has made an allegation and I take it that we may rebut it, in passing. Deputy O'Sullivan, speaking for his constituency, told of what he knows in Kerry, and I now ask leave further to rebut the Minister's misapprehension from what I know of Donegal, and to point out that he fooled poor Deputy Doherty, that he deceived poor Deputy Brady, and that he made a fool also of Deputy Doherty of Innishowen. He did not succeed in fooling me——
Comment on this
—and his complaint now is that he did not succeed in fooling me. I point out that I prognosticated that his activities would do damage, and, in fact, the activities of the Minister for Industry and Commerce reduced the production of turf in County Donegal, as between 1931 and 1934, by 64,352 tons. In order to achieve that result, he spent thousands of pounds, and that is the extent to which he turned the bogs of County Donegal into gold mines. We opposed folly, and we pointed out that promises made by the Minister, and extravagances embarked upon by him, would yield no valuable results. That is our duty in this House, and I trust we shall continue to discharge it.
The Minister says this Bill is going to have no effect, or very little effect on the independent vendors of turf. Deputy O'Sullivan has indicated certain reactions which it will have upon them. Let me suggest another reaction which this Bill is going to have on the independent vendor of turf. Under the provisions of this Bill, a person who purchases more than two cwt. of coal must buy a certain proportion of turf to be fixed by the Minister. That means that certain individuals, who do not want turf, will have to buy it, and, having bought it, they must get rid of it because it will block their yards or wherever they store it. They will naturally go to a neighbour who ordinarily burns turf——
Comment on this
I merely want to put this case, that each individual purchaser of coal will himself become an independent vendor of turf. He will be a vendor of turf, not on a free market, but a vendor who has got to sell or submit to suffocation by the accumulation of turf in his house, and he, accordingly, will sell the turf at rubbish prices to get it out of his way.
Comment on this
The Minister has said that the Bill is going to have no reactions on the independent vendor of turf, and I am pointing out that it is going to have very grave reactions, unless he is allowed to become an approved source from whom people can buy turf if they want it. However, I do not want to contest your view of the relevance of what I was saying in that regard, but I say that Deputy Victory ought to tell us now if he stands for the amount of damage which the Minister admits this Bill is going to do to the small farmer who produces turf as a sideline.
Comment on this
A portion of the must be native. If the Deputy objects to that being spread through the country, I do not.
Comment on this
That is precisely the point I am making. I want to leave the right to the small farmer to sell turf as he sold it in the past.
Comment on this
The Minister says that he admits that the Bill is going to do material injury to these small farmers, to whom Deputy Victory referred, but he says it is not going to be serious injury. I say we apprehend that this will do a serious injury. Does Deputy Victory take the view that that injury should be inflicted upon turf-cutters or does he take the view that they should be allowed to sell their turf as they did in the past within the framework of the Bill?
Comment on this
We are trying to get people to burn turf, we are trying to get it standardised and we will gradually accustom the people to burn native fuel.
Comment on this
That is the tragedy of it. Deputy Victory does not know what he is doing when giving his vote on this section. He will go into the lobby now in full faith and with good intentions and yet without the remotest notion of what injury he is doing by his vote. That is just the tragedy of it. I spent the last ten minutes in trying to explain to the Deputy what this section will do. Deputy O'Sullivan too spent some time in trying to explain to Deputy Victory and to others the nature of the section but we have not made the slightest impression upon his mind and he is as much in a fog now as he was 20 minutes ago. We have been trying to clear his mind, but the attempt seems hopeless. He is now going to put the people whom he wants to serve in the ash can. He is voting in the belief that he is doing them a benefit. The pity is that the Deputy is being bamboozled by the Minister. I ask him to apply his mind to this amendment. The Minister is here for the purpose of bamboozling and fooling Deputy Victory. I am now asking the Deputy to try and deliver himself from the fog he is in, to realise what he is doing, to have the courage of his convictions and by his vote to defend the interests of the people who elected him.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey who has been closely concerned with the turf industry in his neighbourhood discussed this question here. He has told us about a merchant who had much experience of the turf industry in North Tipperary and who, in order to get the turf that would satisfy his customers, had to refuse to take turf from the co-operative societies and instead had to go to a turf-cutter in County Clare. Here is a person in Tipperary interested in the development of the turf industry and he had to go outside Tipperary for turf. He was forced to do it. He had to pay 4/- a ton more to that individual turf-cutter who did not get the same facilities from the railway company in the transport of turf that the co-operative societies got. He had to get the quality of turf that this individual turf-cutter had. That individual turf-cutter lived in the County Clare and he paid him 4/- a ton more for his turf. He had to do that because it was the only way in which he could get turf of the particular quality and in the particular condition that he wanted. That particular turf-cutter was upholding the reputation of turf and holding the market for turf where the co-operative societies in Clare, Galway and Tipperary were failing to do it. He is now in effect in future going to be prevented from selling his turf in any area which the Minister wishes to make an appointed area. We will come up against what the Minister means by an appointed area later on. I ask the Minister what purpose, in the interests of turf, either of its reputation as a fuel or its spread and use in the country, is going to be served by putting a man like that turf-cutter out of business? What purpose is served by putting out of business a person who during the last 12 months or more was selling turf from the west of Clare to people in North Tipperary because the co-operative societies in North Tipperary cannot supply the turf that is wanted by the people there?
Comment on this
Is it an advantage to put that man out of business, a man who is cutting turf for which merchants are willing to pay 4/- a ton more?
Comment on this
Am I to understand that the reason was because this individual turf-cutter could not get the same rate from the railway company as the co-operative soceity? Well, I may tell the Deputy that the railway company will charge that man the same as they will charge the co-operative society. They have no right to discriminate.
Comment on this
Whether that was the reason or not, the fact is that this merchant had to pay 4/- a ton more to a private individual turf-cutter rather than accept turf at the lower price from the co-operative society.
Comment on this
There may be, but the Minister must expect that some more people ought to be there or he would not argue in the way in which he argues now. Here you have the case of a private turf-cutter selling turf of a quality that it is bought at 4/- a ton more than the price at which the co-operative society in North Tipperary would sell it. This man is going to be put out of business. By the ordinary working of this Bill the Minister is going to put this man out of business in an appointed area.
Comment on this
Deputy Victory talks about sidelines. I do not know whether it is a sideline or not in this particular case, but I know that the turf-cutter in question sold very substantial quantities of turf, and Deputies Jordan and Victory are now going to put that man and men like him out of business.
Comment on this
If, in fact, people in an appointed area buy any quantity of coal over 2 cwt., they are going to be forced to go to an approved society for their turf. Everybody in that area practically, except the co-operative societies, is going to be forced out of the turf business in so far as the Minister in operating this Bill can force them. I ask the Minister what turf purpose is going to be served by putting out of business in appointed areas men who have shown they were able to carry on the industry successfully?
Comment on this
The remarks made by Deputy Mulcahy show that he has practically no knowledge of the turf business. He said that the compulsory part of the Bill is going to create a position by which turf buying will be done in certain areas by coal merchants.
Comment on this
That, of course, is all wrong. In the countryside where turf is available there are two-thirds of the population whose only purchases of coal are for threshing operations. There are big numbers of farmers who buy 15 tons of turf in the year. They will buy a ¼ ton of coal for threshing and yet Deputy Mulcahy says that, because they buy a ¼ ton or a ½ ton of coal for threshing or for domestic purposes, they will have to buy a certain quantity of turf and that that will so limit the market for the individual turf producers that these turf producers will not be able to sell their produce. That is the merest nonsense. The individual turf producers will be in this position— that the average farmer who burns only turf can still buy from that individual. In addition, I may point out that the small person who never buys more than 2 cwt. of coal is still free to buy it. Of course, the person who buys only a limited quantity of coal, say half and half, possibly will be able to buy partly from that individual supplier. As a matter of fact, this Bill will probably extend the market for that individual seller, because the persons dependent on turf-cutting for a living will almost inevitably join the co-operative society. They will be largely concerned with the supplies to coal merchants, and so on. The small farmer with whom Deputy Dillon is so concerned, who merely sells his surplus of turf, will have a monopoly of the trade I am speaking about in so far as he can supply it.
I thought there might be something in this amendment until I heard the speeches delivered in connection with it, but I am now satisfied that there is no case whatever for the amendment. I believe that those who are dependent upon turf-cutting for a living will welcome the provision that will cause them to become members of co-operative societies. I believe it will give them a certain market for their produce and it will tend to standardise the produce. There will not be the bickering nor the disputes about quality that have prevailed heretofore. I am satisfied that the provision about co-operative societies as a means of administering the Act is a very useful one. I think the Opposition would be well advised not to persist in this line. So far as that part is concerned, they have not established their case; they have not made a case that the individual turf producer is going to be in the least bit affected by it. On the contrary, it is very likely in my opinion, and it should be the general opinion, that his market will be established.
Comment on this
I think that Deputy Mulcahy knows very little about the position of the producer of turf, and whatever Deputy Morrissey says about it is misleading to everybody. So far as my experience of the individual producers is concerned, up to this stage the Government's scheme in connection with turf has vastly improved their position. Prior to the setting up of the co-operative societies and the Turf Development Board, the producers and direct sellers in the bog areas in Kildare were in a very bad way. They were going into the towns trying to sell turf and the towns were not able to absorb all the turf they were producing. Then, with the extra drainage of the bogs, more turf was being produced. The producers were in the position that there was a surplus there and they could not sell it. As regards the purchasers of turf in the rural areas, the farmers used to go to the bogs and buy the turf there and they got that turf at whatever price they liked. Sometimes the producers were glad to get 4/- and 5/- a ton for the turf. When the Government's scheme started, the supporters of Deputy Dillon down the country did all they could to oppose it and keep it from working. They were inspired by political motives, and they tried to organise the turf producers, and they told them that the Government's scheme would put them off the road altogether. That was the type of campaign that was carried out. Deputy Belton went to Kildare to help that out. The experience of the turf producers since is that all the surplus turf has been taken off the market through the Turf Development Board and their sales have been increased.
As regards the bogs in Kildare, I believe those statistics are altogether wrong. Anyone with the slightest experience of the working of the bogs in Kildare must be aware they are wrong. I can say that ten loads of turf now leave the bog for Dublin to the one that left five or six years ago. The types of persons who buy turf from the producer in the local town usually would buy about 2 cwt. of coal. Those persons will not be affected. Then there is the other type of person, the farmer in the rural area, who never buys any coal. Such a person will buy turf every year, 20 and perhaps 30 tons, in the bogs. These people will have to give a better price now than they gave in former years before the turf scheme was made operative. We have heard a lot about the people who opposed the turf scheme in the country areas in Kildare. There were certain people in Kildare who became distributors of turf in a pretty extensive way. They bought large quantities from the producers, but at a very bad price.
Comment on this
They were more in the position of middlemen. The Government scheme has taken those people off the necks of the producers, and the producers see that now. I believe the effect of the amendment would be to make the scheme unworkable. It looks as if the Opposition want to prevent the scheme working. It is a pity Deputy Minch is not here. He knows something about the turf industry, and I would be glad to hear him express his views. He knows well that the turf producers in Kildare are in favour of this scheme. As a matter of fact, the people who have talked most about it are the people who know nothing at all about it.
Comment on this
The sooner the Minister gets a proper statistician and lets him loose in relation to the turf in Kildare, the better for the credit of his turf scheme.
Comment on this
And it would be better for Deputy Mulcahy's credit if he could get lessons on how to read statistics.
Comment on this
If the Minister does as I suggest, it would be all the better for his turf scheme. The Minister told us that in Kildare in 1934 there were only 1,601 tons of turf more taken from the bogs there than in the year 1931.
Comment on this
If I may interrupt the Deputy, I also told him that in relation to turf no definite conclusion can be drawn from the figures for one year as compared with another, the production of turf in any year or any portion of a year being so dependent on climatic conditions that no reliable comparison could be made. It so happened that 1934 was a bad year for production, and production started late in that year.
Comment on this
And the Minister knows that neither he nor I is dependent on one year's statistics. He has shown us that there was less turf taken from the bogs in 1933 than in 1931; less in 1934 than in 1933, and less carried by the transport companies in 1935 than in 1934.
Comment on this
Let us examine the reason why we are asked to spend money and set up elaborate machinery, and interfere very much with people in their homes in relation to such an important matter as fuel. Let us see the reason why we ought to have some more information, taking Kildare as a sample.
Comment on this
No, but ordinary sellers will be forced out of the business, and co-operative societies will take their place. Deputy Harris tells us that living in Kildare, with the bog in front of him, the position is that there is room for tremendous development. But that has not been shown in any way that we can see. So far as the Minister is concerned, he tells us that 1,600 tons more were taken from the bogs in Kildare in 1934 than in 1931.
Comment on this
The amount of turf won from Kildare, turf produced by co-operative societies as well as individual producers, does not arise. The amendment deals with individual producers only. Arguments covering the whole turf scheme in Kildare are irrelevant. If such were allowed, every Deputy might bring up the conditions of his own constituency—an appalling prospect—on this amendment.
Comment on this
There were 3,800 tons taken by Department of Defence in that year. Deputy Harris is asking to have the private turf cutters choked down if the Minister wants to make Kildare an important area.
Comment on this
We are dealing with the scheme that gives the Minister power to do it. The Minister proposes that no householder in Kildare can get a quarter of a ton of coal without having to deal with the local approved society. A man cannot get his coal unless he does that. It is all very well for Deputy Moore to say that there are so many householders who use nothing but turf, and that the individual turf-cutter will do better than in the past. I know that the Deputy, when he takes a certain amount of consolation from that remark, seems to take more consolation when he says that in any case the individual turf-cutter will be only delighted to be forced into the co-operative society.
Comment on this
Deputy Harris referred to selling turf at 4/- a crib. He is the first Deputy I ever heard describing turf as being sold at that price.
Comment on this
The Deputy would find some difficulty in relating the weight of a creel of turf to amendment No. 1.
Comment on this
Yes, Because Deputy Harris professes to represent the conditions of these individual suppliers. But let us pass from Deputy Harris. He has spoken about the peculiar position in Kildare. I am thinking of the people in the congested areas. I am thinking of the people referred to by the Minister for Education, acting for the Minister for Industry and Commerce when the turf legislation was first brought in here. We were told that this legislation was to assist these people whom Deputy Victory described as crushed by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Deputy Victory told us these people were being crushed in the western areas. Do the conditions described by Deputy Harris correspond in any way with the conditions in the congested areas within, for instance, Deputy Jordan's knowledge? Of course they do not. They bear no relation to the condition of farmers in the congested areas who burn turf and who have their own turbary. These people have turf as a side line and bring it in and sell it in the market to town dwellers. These are the people we were thinking of when we put down this amendment.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy go to Donegal or Connemara and ask the people if they want this Bill or not?
Comment on this
The Minister's question is an extremely difficult one. I asked that question of the people in Donegal, and Deputy Doherty was despatched by the Minister to say to the people that the Bill before the House meant that there was going to be more turf sold, more money spent and that the bogs would become invaluable. I said the meaning is that the bogs will not be one bit more used than before, but that the Minister is going to create a horde of officials. Who was right, Deputy Doherty or myself? If I am told in Donegal that the Minister says this Bill does not prevent anyone from selling turf, I have to say that is right. There is no provision to prevent people selling any turf, but the implications of this Bill will mean that people who now sell turf as a side line will no longer be able to sell it. That will come to pass as sure as we are here if this amendment is not adopted. It may not affect Kildare. The peculiar circumstances that operate in Kildare are not known to me, but the conditions that operate in the congested areas are known to Deputy Doherty and to Deputy Jordan. The Minister for Industry and Commerce knows nothing about the congested areas, and I implore him to keep silent about them. He would be as incongruous in a congested area as a white blackbird. He does not know anything about the congested areas; we do not expect him to. I suggest to Deputy Jordan that the picture I have drawn is the true picture. We want to avoid these hardships and I believe this amendment is designed to do that, and unless the amendment is accepted grave hardships will prevail.
Comment on this
Coming from a district where a good deal of turf is cut, I believe this is a reasonable amendment. If this amendment was accepted you would have competition from the turf producers. If the amendment is not accepted, what will happen? A co-operative society is formed in the district, and it may turn out that the retailer has got to buy all his turf from the co-operative society. Down in the West of Ireland we have a terrible dread of co-operative societies. We were not dealt with fairly in regard to them in the past. In the second place it is quite possible you may develop a bog that may not be worth it. If you get a bad bog, such as Deputy O'Leary referred to in Kildare, and if a coal retailer has to buy from that society and to sell that turf over again, how can he do so when in the few homes where turf is used it must be the best black turf?
Comment on this
If the turf which I saw burned in Leinster House last winter is standard quality, I can say that it is only like the waste in some of our bogs. That is the objection I have to co-operative societies; that you will probably develop a bad bog and get some town dwellers, who have to buy from a coal retailer, to buy that bad turf, whereas the ordinary man coming in with his crib of surplus turf can sell it quite freely at present. Why not let the coal retailer go into the open market and buy the turf just as a corn merchant buys corn in the open market? He will buy the best turf and he will get it at the lowest possible price. The person who has to buy from him may be quite sure that he is going to get the best value that can be got for money. There are districts where there may not be a sufficient number of people to join in a co-operative society. The turbary was given to them years ago by the Land Commission or the Congested Districts Board. Every year they sold portion of their surplus turf to the ordinary farmers around and then brought in the rest into the smaller towns to dispose of it. I think this is not fair to them. What I am afraid of under the section is that you are putting a price on bad turf. If the amendment were accepted, the people who have the good turf would always be sure of a price. The danger is that the people who had good turf for sale in the past will not now produce that good turf because, under the section they will only get the same price as the producer of the bad turf.
Comment on this
I quite agree with Deputy Brodrick with regard to the quality of the turf. There should be some protection for the people with regard to that. As has been pointed out, there are a great many in the position of the people whom this amendment seeks to protect. Nothing should be done to put these people in the position that they cannot sell their turf. After all, this is not the first time that the Minister introduced a Bill interfering with the means of living of individuals. Under the Road Traffic Act he handed over the control of traffic to the Great Southern Railways Company, but he made provision for the people who suffered as a result of that. We want to see that the people concerned here will not suffer and have to come before the House demanding compensation for being deprived of their means of livelihood.
Comment on this
Knowing the farmers of Galway as I do, at least those in the Athenry area, and the individual turf-cutters as well as the members of the co-operative societies, I should like to remind the House of this fact, which has not been stated by anybody who has spoken on this Bill—that the people down there who cut turf, if they can produce the standardised turf necessary, and if the price is right, are not going to hawk it around for a smaller price. They will make sure that they will start a co-operative society in their district and unite to get the best price they can from the authorised merchants. If you leave them alone they will do their own business.
Comment on this
Deputy Brodrick put a straight question to the Minister which ought to be answered—why cannot a registered coal retailer be allowed to buy turf from whomever he likes when he is put into the position that he cannot sell coal without selling turf with it? Why cannot the turf, which the registered coal retailer will sell in compulsory quantities with the coal, be bought from any dealer in turf?
Comment on this
There is nothing to prevent a coal retailer from purchasing turf from anybody he likes.
Comment on this
The turf he must sell with the coal under Section 15 is turf that he must have got from an approved source. Why cannot it be turf that he got from any source? It has been made clear that a better quality turf can be got from people who are not in the co-operative societies.
Comment on this
It has been shown clearly to the Minister, not only here but elsewhere, I am sure, that he is depriving people, who earned some part of their living in the past from turf, of part of that living by these proposals. I should like him to answer what is the difficulty that makes him force registered coal retailers to buy turf only from approved sources to sell in this compulsory way.
Comment on this
So that the important thing is supervision and inspectors, and not turf and employment?
Comment on this
On the section, I would again draw the Minister's attention to the fact that under Section 13 he is going to compel coal retailers selling a certain quantity of coal to sell with it a certain quantity of turf in an area which is not an approved area, but he is not going to allow the coal merchant, who is going to sell that turf, to buy it wherever he pleases. He is not going to allow that merchant to choose the bog from which he will get the turf or the type of turf which he may want to get. He is not going to allow the merchant to go into the open market for the purchase of turf. Instead of that, he forces the merchant to go to a type of society on the development of which the Minister has already spent a considerable amount of money, and which societies, at the end of last year, the Minister had succeeded in developing only to the extent of seven in Donegal, 32 in Kerry, five in Tipperary, 23 in Galway, and ten in Mayo, out of a total of 158. Now a further development of societies like that is going to take place at the expense of the State as well as at considerable inconvenience and loss to the people who are engaged in the turf-cutting industry. I think the Minister ought to explain, on this section, why he is deliberately endeavouring to prevent coal retailers buying their compulsory turf from whomever they want to buy it.
Comment on this
It is not correct to say that a coal retailer will be required to purchase from one co-operative society. So long as he purchases from a source that is approved under the section, he satisfies the requirements of the Act; and, if there were any difference between the quality of turf produced by one society as against the quality of turf produced by another society, he is at liberty to purchase from whichever society he chooses. He will not be forced to take turf from any particular society—whether the turf supplied by a society is satisfactory or not. In any event, however, it is necessary that there should be proper supervision over the turf sold. If we are taking power to compel people to purchase turf, it is obvious that there must be adequate machinery to see that the turf is of the proper quality, and it is not possible to do that unless we can be sure that the turf is from an approved source—in other words, a source that will be subject to the supervision of the Turf Development Board. The co-operative societies are being equipped with the necessary machinery for the proper production of turf and they are being provided with suitable storage facilities. The turf, when in store, will be inspected before being sold, and if it does not come up to the standard of quality required by the Turf Development Board, it will not be sold at all under the scheme. Therefore, the coal merchants and others who are anxious to purchase turf, can be satisfied that, when they purchase turf from an approved source, they will be getting turf of a good quality.
I think it is obvious that, if we did not have some such provision as this, there could be wide-spread evasions of the Act, and I think it is equally obvious that this is the only basis on which we could provide against such evasions. In fixing the quota in any area, or in defining a particular area, it is necessary that we should have full knowledge of the quantity of turf that has been produced or that is likely to be produced in that area in a certain time—turf which will conform to the standard of quality which the Turf Development Board has set up. On any other basis there could be many evasions of the Act, and, in fact, the Act could be made a dead-letter by various devices.
Comment on this
If a registered coal retailer is bound, by law, to sell a certain amount of turf with his coal, how can there be any evasion by allowing the merchant to purchase his turf from whatever source he wishes to buy it?
Comment on this
How can we know that, in fact, he purchases turf from anybody, if we have not some such machinery?
Comment on this
What type of supervision has the Minister provided for co-operative societies, and what kind of supervision is he going to exercise under the present system to ensure that coal retailers purchase the proper supply of turf?
Comment on this
The Turf Development Board will have full knowledge of the quantities of turf sold by the co-operative societies to all coal retailers in the area concerned. If, however, you widen the source of supply so as to include a number of people not under the supervision of the Turf Development Board, then there could be evasions of the type I have suggested. For instance, a merchant could say: "Yes, I have sold so many tons of turf and I bought so many tons of turf from such and such persons"; but how could we prove that, unless we had some machinery of the type suggested?
Comment on this
Is not the Minister going to have supervision over the retailers by making them furnish periodical returns?
Comment on this
And if a merchant says that he got so many tons from a co-operative society, the Minister can check that statement with the returns of the co-operative society?