We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Turf (Use and Development) Bill, 1935—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 156–312 of 312. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Turf (Use and Development) Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 42 of 1935 ›

Is it not plain that the only method of inspection is collective inspection? Surely, an inspector could not be kept at a coal merchant's yard inspecting the turf coming in from day to day? Would you not have this arising then—that, with each purchase of coal, there would be constant complaints as to the quality of the turf, if people chose to make those complaints—in other words, if the merchant were at liberty to purchase the turf from any one of his scores of neighbours? Where those who buy coal have to buy a certain amount of turf with it, the purchaser can complain at any time that, either rightly or wrongly, he is not getting a good quality of turf, and the State would have no defence to make against that. I think they are making him a present of that complaint, and I cannot see how the proposal can be carried out. I do submit, however, as I was saying a while ago, that it would be worth while considering whether a coal merchant could not himself become a producer of turf, provided, perhaps, that he produced a certain minimum quantity of turf. We are always complaining in this country that we have too many distributors. It is a constant criticism in this country that the tendency of our people is to engage in distribution instead of in production. Well, here is an opportunity to encourage our people to engage in production and to encourage production on the part of people already engaged as merchants in the distributive trade. For instance, there are already merchants in this country who own pieces of bog, and I think that it should be possible to have some provision in the Bill to make such people an approved source of supply.

Comment on this

According to Deputy Moore's argument, certain coal merchants could be recognised as approved sources of supply, but the ordinary turf-cutter could not be recognised.

Comment on this

There would have to be a certain minimum amount of production.

Comment on this

Well, why could not the ordinary turf-cutter be recognised as an approved source?

Comment on this

For the reason, obviously, that he could not produce the minimum that might be required.

Comment on this

But a coal merchant may be recognised?

Comment on this

Yes. Obviously, if a coal merchant is producing, say, 500 or 5,000 tons in a certain period, it would be an easy matter to inspect his turf, and I do think that it is a desirable thing to encourage production in that respect, provided that there is a certain minimum laid down. It must be remembered that you might have such a circumstance arising as that, in an emergency, the Minister might have to schedule a certain area that had not been scheduled previously. If there were no co-operative society in that area, then you would have the position that all the turf has to come from the Turf Board or from different co-operative societies. At the same time, it might be possible that the merchant concerned would be in a position to start producing turf for himself—perhaps from his own bog. I should like to hear the Minister's reason for omitting that type of person from the list of approved sources. I think there is a very good case for including such people, provided that there is a certain minimum of production fixed. If a person, in order to have his turf approved, has to pool it into the co-operative society, buy it back from a society, and then re-sell it, I think that is a rather cumbrous arrangement, and, to my own knowledge there are many coal merchants in that position. There are many coal merchants in the position that they own pieces of bog and, if there were the necessary provisions in this Bill, they would be encouraged to acquire a larger area of bog-land. Unless we are to decide that private enterprise is altogether a bad thing, I think there is a good case to be made for including such persons as I have described among the approved sources.

Comment on this

Deputy Moore said that if coal merchants were to be permitted to buy from various sources, the quality of the turf might be poor, and in certain cases would not be uniform. Is it not obvious that if coal merchants are forced to sell turf with coal, and if they get a choice, they are going to get the best turf? As a result, merchants with really tip-top turf are going to do better than their neighbours if they have poor turf. It is in the interests of merchants to get the best turf. It may be an answer that the Minister would refuse to let coal merchants buy from private individuals because by so doing they might get superior quality to turf supplied by the Board. It has to be remembered that certain qualities of turf are, on the average, better than what the Board supplies. I do not come from a turf county, but I know good turf from bad turf. I know that some of the turf I saw supplied by the Turf Board was bad turf, and that I could get a superior turf even in my own county. If I was a coal merchant I should like to be permitted to get the best turf I could—to get turf of really A1 quality. I would regard that as the best part of my business, because I would have an advantage over competitors if I could say that I was selling better turf than men in the next street. This is an interference with good business, and as Deputy Moore says, there is the possibility of getting inferior turf.

Comment on this

I agree fully with Deputy Bennett that a turf society might produce bad turf, and that an individual producer might produce good turf, but the difference in the point of view he has contemplated is that the turf will be inspected at the source, and only the good turf approved for sale under the scheme. Deputy Bennett in that connection must bear in mind that there is going to be a fixed price, and that turf sold by co-operative societies to a coal merchant is going to be sold at a fixed price. There is an obligation to ensure that the quality will be up to standard. We can do that in relation to co-operative societies, because the turf will be available for inspection.

Comment on this

Is there a fixed selling price to the consumer?

Comment on this

Not necessarily. That will vary with the cost of delivery in the different districts. The price the consumer will pay will obviously be determined by certain considerations, and people are going to buy the cheapest article if they want it. In practically every part of the country there is bound to be an alternative source of supply. My objection to Deputy Moore's suggestion is the same as that to Deputy Mulcahy's proposal. There will be no effective means of accounting for turf produced by merchants other than by an examination of merchants' books which would not be reliable. No one could check a merchant's statement that he produced 500 tons or 1,000 tons of turf and sold it in acordance with the provisions of the Bill. It is necessary to have a check on the returns of coal merchants, or otherwise a dishonest merchant might get an advantage over a competitor who conformed to the law. It is in the interests of the honest merchant who tries to carry out the obligation under this or any other statute, that this proper enforcement is necessary.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will realise that the difficulty I have in understanding this Bill is due to the fact that he has never given any opinion of the type of inspection and how much he expects from it.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy mean in that regard? We have had references made to the possibility of a horde of inspectors being appointed. It will not be necessary to appoint a horde of inspectors. In so far as we foresee development this year, or next year, of the provisions of this Bill, there will be no additional inspectors appointed. It is true that to a large extent the Bill will be supervised by the Civic Guards in any area, but, apart from the appointment of a clerk to keep records, no additional inspector will be required for some time. It is, of course, possible that an additional inspector will be needed at some stage when the scheme has developed.

Comment on this

I am sorry the Minister has not cleared up my difficulty, especially in view of the exposition he gave before. I take it that there will be inspection at the source, and that the source is the bogs. Therefore, there will be inspection at the bogs. To me that seems to indicate a considerable amount of inspection. The Minister can make gestures, but the fact remains that there is to be inspection at the source. The Minister nodded when I said that that means inspection at the bogs—any quantity of bogs. There are 32 co-operative societies in my native county. If there is going to be inspection on all the bogs, I do not know how many there will be.

Comment on this

The turf is not produced and sold at the same time.

Comment on this

The Minister nodded when I said there would be inspection on the bogs. Then there will be a considerable amount of inspection. I confess to a difficulty in following the machinery of the Bill, and as to how the Minister intends to work it. A great deal of the delay, I think, is due to the refusal of the Minister to give a picture of what is in his mind. I gather that the only reason he is opposing the suggestion of Deputy Mulcahy is that the check on the merchant will be the amount of turf he buys from an approved source. If that is so, I confess that I misread the Bill. The Minister spoke of evasion and assumes that certain merchants will try to evade the Bill. What is there to prevent a merchant buying turf from an approved source and selling coal to one man and turf to another man, and in that way disposing of his turf, if the check the Minister indicated is to be merely the quantity the merchant buys? Is it not obvious that the purpose of the Bill can be evaded by having, so to speak, side by side coal merchants and turf merchants, selling coal and turf to consumers? The Minister says that there are provisions in the Bill under which that would be against the law. Then he will want inspection elsewhere to see that the purchaser does not evade the law, or that the merchant in selling does not evade it. Control of the amount of turf a merchant buys is not the check that the Minister's suggests if people are determined to evade the law, unless there is an amount of inspection considerably greater than the Minister indicated. In fact, you will have to have inspection at different times, both at the source and at the last stage in the sale to consumers. The provisions in the Bill show that. That being so, I cannot see what is the objection to allowing merchants to purchase turf where they wish, so long as they can show on inspection that they have purchased so much turf. I do not see how such men would be in a different position from the Minister's point of view from persons who purchase directly from the co-operative societies or the board. As to the question about the standard of the turf, it will not be to the advantage of one coal merchant as against a rival coal merchant to sell "compulsory turf," if I might use that phrase, of an inferior quality.

Comment on this

There will frequently be no competition in rural places.

Comment on this

Very often there is. Again we do not know where it is going to be enforced. There are 32 co-operative societies in Kerry alone. I do not know the number of bogs they have but that will require inspection. I wonder how many coal merchants are there? Not so many. The Minister has given no indication of the amount of extra inspection that will be required. Again, I can only say that I see at the back of this a determination to keep out at all costs the ordinary turf-cutter and to permit large scale production at the expense of the small individual producer. I suggest it is rather late in the day for Deputy Moore to appear as a defender of private enterprise in this matter. I think the Minister's answer was quite as effective, or at least as effective, to Deputy Moore's arguments as it was to the case which we put forward. Even Deputy Moore's own distinction between the merchant and the ordinary small producer shows that he also is bitten with the idea of big business, production on a grandiose scale. Both the Minister and the Deputy are misled by the example of big production in Russia.

Comment on this

Sir Horace Plunkett was not a Bolshevik.

Comment on this

I am referring to the economic side of the question. I am leaving out controversial matters. It was the Minister who quoted the example of Russia. He gave it as an example of this particular method of large scale production.

Comment on this

When did I refer to it?

Comment on this

The Minister did not mention Russia in his introductory speech? He did; he referred to what was being done in the way of turf production in Russia and Germany.

Comment on this

Again I invite the Deputy to quote my speech.

Comment on this

All right. I shall find it at some other time and if the Minister looks for it in his speech he will find it too. Apparently judging by his attitude now he must not have intended mentioning it. It slipped out unconsciously. Again I cannot see what the object of the section is unless it be a determination to crush out the small producer.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 56
·
Níl 31
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

On the section, would the Minister give the House some information as to the places in which he proposes to enforce this measure—the areas which he intends to prescribe?

Comment on this

I stated on the Second Reading of the Bill that, at the beginning, at any rate, the only appointed areas will be the places where turf can be sold cheapest and where coal is dearest. Generally speaking, that means the turf-producing areas, and perhaps only districts in those counties which come within that description. A lot, of course, will depend on the volume of production. It is impossible to state in advance, in the beginning of any year, what the volume of production in any area will be, because that will depend, not merely on the number of societies, but on weather conditions and on other factors. But, having regard to the production anticipated this and the following year, it is not likely that there will be very many areas appointed. In any event, it will be possible to confine the operation of the Bill to those areas where turf as a fuel can be regarded definitely as economic in so far as it will be cheaper weight for weight and calorie for calorie than turf.

Comment on this

I am not asking the Minister what his view is as to the relative value of turf and coal per calorie and per price.

Comment on this

Of course it varies.

Comment on this

It varies very considerably. There are people who burn turf. They do so from choice because they like it, but they will not admit that, calorie for calorie, it is at all an economic proposition. They burn it in their living rooms because they prefer it to coal, but they will tell you candidly that from the heating point of view it is not an economic proposition. Will the Minister realise that he has not given us any real indication of the areas in which it is proposed to enforce this measure? He speaks of the turf-producing areas. You may have an area in which there is a very big bog, and it may not be a turf-consuming area at all, in the sense that it does not consume anything like the quantity of turf produced in that area. You may have to go outside that area to dispose of the turf produced.

Comment on this

Not unless the production is higher than it was last year. In 1935, all the turf produced was disposed of without any compulsion at all. It is because we anticipate a substantial increase in production that we contemplate using the powers in this Bill at all. And even in that event a quite mild application of the provisions of the Bill will probably be sufficient to dispose of all the turf produced. Consequently it will only be necessary to operate it in certain defined areas, and then to a limited extent only. It is difficult to say to what extent the provisions of the Bill will be applied, or the size of the areas over which it will operate, in advance of some definite knowledge as to the quantity of turf that will be available to be disposed of.

Comment on this

I did not like to interrupt the Minister on a point of order, but I was going to raise the point of order that he was talking against the principle of the Bill in the argument that he now puts forward. He has brought an excellent argument against this Bill. "He could easily have waited 12 months so far as compulsion is concerned; it is most unlikely that it will be used in the next 12 months, and if used at all then only in the smallest possible doses." This is the Bill that there has been so much hurry about.

Comment on this

There was no hurry. The Bill was introduced last December.

Comment on this

Then, will the Minister say why the compulsory powers are necessary?

Comment on this

I refer the Deputy to my Second Reading speech.

Comment on this

I am dealing with what the Minister said. I am at a loss to know in what type of area he will enforce the Bill. Take the case of a coal merchant in the City of Cork, does he intend to enforce the measure there and will that coal merchant have to sell turf with coal?

Comment on this

In answer to the Deputy's first point, the reason why it is desired to have the Bill passed is for the purpose of encouraging the production of turf. The provisions in the Bill may not be necessary immediately for the purpose of ensuring the disposal of all the turf produced, but, having regard to the experience gained in 1934, it is considered that the co-operative societies will engage more vigorously in the production of turf, and if so they are entitled to know that we are in a position to ensure that the turf so produced will be disposed of. I do not think it will be necessary to operate the compulsory provisions of the Bill in an area like Cork City in the course of the coming year. At some stage, we shall get to the point at which we shall be able to supply turf in all parts of the country but that will not be for some time to come. Increase in turf production is a slow business. Under the best circumstances, it cannot be done readily. If you take virgin bog, before you can produce a sod of turf from it, at least two years' preparatory work must be done. For certain forms of production, even three years' preparatory work is necessary. The Deputy will see that you cannot increase the supply of turf very rapidly. Earlier in the discussion, a Deputy referred to the use of turf in an emergency. The fact is that, if an emergency were to arise and our supplies of coal, due to any cause, were cut off, we could not deal with that emergency except to a limited extent by turning to turf because turf could not be produced sufficiently rapidly to enable that emergency to be met. On the basis of the production we contemplate this year, it will, I think, be possible to dispose of all the turf merely by supplying, under the provisions of this Bill, certain limited areas which I have defined as turf-producing areas—the areas where turf is cheapest and coal is dearest. In these areas, there will, I think, be little difficulty in disposing of more turf than has been used in the past. In any event, the sales arising therefrom, plus the sales that will take place in the ordinary course in other areas without any compulsory powers, will enable us to dispose of the production contemplated this year.

Comment on this

The Minister has vague views about a city like Cork. The Minister must have in mind some particular areas.

Comment on this

Kerry.

Comment on this

That is precisely what I was arguing against on my second amendment. Notwithstanding all this talk, the Minister has shown that there is no necessity for the Bill at all. Now, apparently, all the rosy promises held out are more or less vanishing. The main reason the Minister gives for the Bill now is that he wants to give the turf producers a little more heart than resulted from his efforts in 1934. That is the principal argument he brought forward for these compulsory powers. As a result of their previous attempt to increase turf production, to give a little heart to the turf producers the Minister wants these compulsory powers, which he does not think he will be called upon to exercise for some considerable time. Again, we have this blowing hot and cold. We do not know where we are or what the intentions of the Minister are. Propaganda is the main purpose of the Bill—propaganda directed not at the public this time but at the turf producer.

Comment on this

Is there any objection to giving the turf producer encouragement?

Comment on this

The turf producer's mind is to be turned towards increased production by the promise to apply compulsion to the rest of the community. That is the principal argument used by the Minister. The idea is not to get people to use turf but, by the powers now sought, to hold an umbrella over the turf producers and to erase the effects of the efforts of 1934. I think the Minister might have mentioned about a dozen areas to which he proposed to apply these provisions. The County Kerry, which he has mentioned, is rather a large area. Does he suggest that, calorie for calorie, turf is a cheaper fuel than coal in Killarney or Tralee?

Comment on this

Surely it is in a place like Killarney.

Comment on this

That is not the view of the people there. I am speaking of people who use turf. Eighteen months ago I asked people there that question, though I did not use the Minister's phrase. I referred to "heating power." They were all of the opinion there that, as a heating proposition, turf was not as good as coal. That is the opinion of people accustomed to using turf and coal, and who use turf whenever they can use it. The Minister might give a list of 12 or 13 areas to which he intends to apply these provisions.

Comment on this

One essential factor is missing—the quantity of turf to be disposed of. We shall not know that until later. Assuming that we have the same increase as last year in the quantity produced, which I think is very likely, there will be certain limited areas in these counties in respect of which this scheme will be tried out during the coming winter.

Comment on this

Evidently the criticism levelled at the Bill generally is having some effect on the Minister. The people in the cities were becoming anxious lest the Bill should be applied to them, and the Minister now wants to make clear that he does not want to force it on Cork or Dublin. He is going to select areas where turf is more generally used, and where the people produce turf. The Bill is to be applied to Kerry or somewhere in the Gaeltacht where turf is already extensively and cheaply produced, and where the people are using turf. The Minister, if he brings the Bill into operation at all, is going to try it out in one or two of these districts first. But we do not know how far the area will extend. It may extend to the great bulk of the countryside. We may arrive at the point where the man who is producing turf sufficient for his own use will be affected. If, occasionally, he would like the luxury of a coal fire, he may come into town and buy four or five cwts. of coal. But he will also have to buy turf. So that he will be drawing turf instead of coal to Newcastle. He has already as much turf as he needs at home. If there were any logic in the Bill, one would think that the areas selected would not be the areas where turf is already cheap.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not even got the significance of the phrase about "sending coal to Newcastle."

Comment on this

Drawing turf to the bog might be a better expression.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Sullivan, for instance, may have sufficient turf for his own use down in Kerry. If he buys a few cwt. of coal, he will also have to buy more turf. He will, therefore, have more turf than he wants. I think that that would be unjust. I see no reason why the Minister should select first the areas where turf is already largely in use.

Comment on this

I have been listening very attentively to what the Minister has said about the people of the different areas. I understood the Minister to say that, if and when the production of turf increases, if the sales must be stimulated, certain areas will be appointed. He has mentioned Cork City. Let us take that as a typical case. Is it the Minister's idea that when the sale of turf requires to be stimulated, he will make Cork City an appointed area and will stipulate that of every sale of coal over two cwt., ten per cent., or some such percentage, must be turf, and that in another area, which might possibly be better situated, according to the Minister's idea, for the production of turf and the stimulation of its sale, 20 per cent. will be specified? That seems to suggest that the Minister had in mind that in certain portions of the country, which he will appoint from time to time, turf sales will be stimulated artificially, and other areas left alone.

I hesitate to refer to a section to which we have not yet come, but I am afraid I shall have to read portion of Section 13:—

Whenever a coal retailer sells and delivers, whether in or not in an appointed area, to a purchaser who is not entitled to the benefit of exemption....

Surely that contemplates that, where a person is not in an appointed area, he will have to take a certain percentage of turf? I should like the Minister to explain how that is to be worked, having regard to what he has stated as to appointed areas being fixed from time to time and, presumably, different percentages of turf to be consumed in those areas.

Comment on this

The Deputy's general statement as to the manner in which the Bill is to be operated is about 99½ per cent. right.

Comment on this

In regard to the appointed areas?

Comment on this

If that is so, how does the Minister suggest that anybody in the country can escape from the provisions of Section 13, once percentages are put in?

Comment on this

We will deal with that when we come to Section 13.

Comment on this

Do I take it now that the Minister is going to operate this Bill where there is already a considerable consumption of turf?

Comment on this

That might be correct. There might be an area in which there is a considerable consumption of turf with a town in the middle of it in which there is a very small consumption of turf; but, generally speaking, it is correct to say that the appointed areas are the areas in which turf is produced and used to a considerable extent.

Comment on this

In other words, it is in precisely the type of country town I had in mind when discussing Section 2, the Minister intends to operate this Act. I gather that is so from what he has said on this particular section. So far as the Bill is to be operative then, it is in the small country towns it is going to be operative, and the people who are going to be hit are precisely the people I mention, who are accustomed to bringing their turf there. You will get very little extra increase in turf. However, I will discuss that in relation to the compulsory powers, but you will do considerable damage to these men. It is these men, as I say, who will be hit and they are being sacrificed for an alleged advantage—I do not really know to whom—to the people who go into co-operative societies and sell through the board. That it will produce more consumption of turf, I take the liberty of doubting. Remember that the people who are going to be hit are precisely the men who purchase turf already in the country towns from a private individual, and not the people whom Deputy Victory wants to hit, the people who are too grand to use turf. He wanted this as a kind of guillotine against snobbery. It is not going to be used for that purpose. It is to be used for the purpose of hitting those people and their suppliers who up to the present used turf.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell us what is the difference between an appointed area and a non-appointed area for the purpose of the Bill? In view of what he has said to Deputy Dockrell, is there any distinction?

Comment on this

That, of course, refers to Section 13. I think there is no difficulty about Section 13. The obvious interpretation of Section 13 is that, whenever a coal retailer sells coal to a person in an appointed area, the provisions of the Act apply, whether or not the coal retailer is himself in an appointed area or not.

Comment on this

Do the compulsory provisions apply all round?

Comment on this

Only in the appointed areas.

Comment on this

That is not the way it reads.

Comment on this

Is it the coal merchant or the customer? Which of them is to be in appointed area?

Comment on this

What the section says is whether a coal retailer is or is not in an appointed area.

Comment on this

No, it does not say that, but that is what is meant.

Comment on this

If he sells coal to somebody in an appointed area who is not otherwise exempt, the provisions of the Act concerning the supply of turf apply.

Comment on this

It is pretty obscure.

Comment on this

If the retailer is in an appointed area and the purchaser is outside, it does not apply?

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain the reason for the size of the fine in this section?

Comment on this

It is a moderate fine, having regard to the fact that it is necessary to enforce that provision very rigorously. If we apply the Act at all in an appointed area, the penalty for selling coal when unregistered must be such as to intimidate people from attempting it.

Comment on this

I want the Minister to bear that in mind. I am sorry he did not bear it in mind when answering Deputy Mulcahy earlier in connection with Section 2, because that fine, and the fact that you will have to have control, not merely of the purchases by the merchant, but also of the sales by the merchant and purchases by the consumer, would ensure that there was no evasion of the Act.

Comment on this

This section relates to the selling of coal by an unregistered person. It is a somewhat different matter.

Comment on this

What is the fine in the other case?

Comment on this

Every person selling coal must sell the requisite quantity of turf as well, and the fine is calculated on the basis of the number of tons of coal so sold, but it must not exceed £1 a ton.

Comment on this

Does not the Minister think that that is a sufficient check in addition to the other things?

Comment on this

There are other provisions. There is Section 16 which provides that if the merchant does not purchase turf sufficient to enable him to carry out his obligations under the Bill he can be compelled by the Minister to purchase the requisite amount of turf.

Comment on this

Will not all these other provisions then enable the Minister to revise his ideas as to this section? He has any number of guarantees such as heavy fines, inspection of documents of all kinds, the Civic Guards on the spot and fines varying according to the quantity of coal sold. The Minister certainly has everything that would help to keep a person from evading the Act.

Comment on this

No fine will prevent any person from attempting to evade an Act if he can do so successfully.

Comment on this

Well surely if we from those benches now occupied by the Minister put up that kind of argument in the past we would be told that we were traducing the Irish people. In this matter there is continual inspection of the sales as well as other things. The Minister is not meeting Deputy Mulcahy's point.

Comment on this

I should like to see Section 12 withdrawn. If the penalties in Section 11 are not sufficient to prohibit unregistered coal dealers from carrying on, I suppose the Minister will take other precautions to enforce the Act. What is the object of adding the penalties in Section 12 to all the other penalties? Why should an ordinary purchaser be penalised for an offence of which he is not wilfully cognisant? If a merchant sets up in defiance of the regulations and operates as a coal merchant, surely the ordinary citizen must assume that such a man is legally entitled to operate as such. If he goes in and buys coal from an unregistered person he is to be subjected to the same penalties as the man who sells him the coal. I object to the penalty in this section; there is no necessity for it. I would like the Minister to withdraw the section altogether.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy mixing up the section with some other provision of the Bill? This is a section which prohibits the purchase of coal from an unregistered coal retailer. Having regard to the general scheme of the Bill, it is obviously fair to the people on whom the obligation is placed that some such provision as this should be in the Bill. If you go to a coal retailer and say: "Under penalty you must sell a certain amount of turf with the coal," I think you must at the same time impose an obligation on the turf purchaser to take that quantity of turf. If the Bill is to go through with this provision that is an essential part of it.

Comment on this

The Minister has drafted Section 11 as drastically as he could to prevent an unregistered person operating. That being so, he should not press this section. If a man escapes the attention of the Minister with all these provisions it is natural that the ordinary person in the street will assume that he is entitled to sell coal. It is the same as if a solicitor or doctor displayed his qualifications in his office. That certificate is hung up in a part of the office where nobody sees it. This section is asking the purchaser of coal to take precautions which he ought not be asked to take. If the Minister is going to operate Section 11 he ought to operate it in such a way that it would be impossible for an unregistered coal merchant to carry on.

Comment on this

This is a normal provision in Acts of this kind. There is a similar provision in the Transport Acts. It is illegal for anyone to hire a mechanically propelled vehicle from an unlicensed person for transport purposes. The same applies to agricultural Acts in which registers are established.

Comment on this

I do not see exactly how this section is going to operate. Take the coal merchant who is living in a prescribed area. To carry on business at all or to exist as a coal merchant he must be registered.

Comment on this

It would be illegal for him to carry on.

Comment on this

That is what I am saying. He could not operate at all. What is the point then of this section? The man would be mad to try to operate as a coal retailer unless he were registered. Coal is not like one of those deadly drugs that one could conceal in a little tube.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not see how coal could be boot-legged.

Comment on this

Yes, candidly that is the only explanation. I do not think there is any purpose in having it in.

Comment on this

I wonder could I bring to the Minister's mind an analogy that was once put up here; there was a certain amount of justification for it afterwards? I am not saying that the Act was not successful. I remember when I was introducing the Compulsory School Attendance Bill, it was put up to me by a number of experienced men in the country that one result of the Bill would be to procure the non-attendance in school of children once they reached the age of 14 years, that the children when you met them and asked them "Why are you not at school to-day?" would answer "I am 14." They were compelled to attend until 14 and they would think that the mere fact of reaching the age of 14 was an excuse for non-attendance. Though that Act has been a success up to the age of 14, I wonder if it has been a success after 14. There are places in which the Minister intends to operate this Bill, appointed areas. In country towns compulsion in this matter may have the opposite effect. For instance, the Minister compels a person, who is at present buying a quantity of turf, to buy turf and coal from a merchant. There is just the danger that the person will confine himself to that specified quantity of turf and will not bother buying from the man who sells it as a side line, as Deputy Victory would call it. There is that danger. However, I presume that is a danger that has been taken into account by the Minister.

The point that I raised previously is quite relevant to this particular section, that is, I asked the Minister whether there had been full co-operation between the different Departments. I put forward that point on the Second Reading. The Minister said there had been. Do I gather from the Minister's statement that, for the last three or four years, the Department of Industry and Commerce —and, remember, the Government have been giving attention to this turf problem for a number of years—has seen to it that in the new houses that have been erected in such numbers all over the country grates and ranges have been installed suitable for the consumption of turf? Is that the contention of the Minister? When he answered my question that there had been co-operation, I thought that was what he meant, because that was underlying the question I put. I suggest that, if the Minister or his Department means to be serious about this turf production problem, and anxious to promote the consumption of turf, they would have ensured that there was adequate co-operation between the two Departments— Industry and Commerce and Local Government. I am referring now to houses that have been subsidised by public grants, and I am suggesting that some arrangement should have been made in connection with the houses built during the last couple of years to see that they would be properly fitted for the consumption of turf.

I rather gather from the gesture made by the Minister just now that that has not been done, at least to any considerable extent. I believe I am correct in assuming that. I suggest in that case that it would have been much more advisable that some steps in that direction should have been taken, especially when help was being given through the medium of public money, rather than that compulsory powers, such as the Government are now asking for, should be sought. That would be a more reasonable and, I think, a more fruitful method of dealing with the problem. Deputy Mrs. Concannon raised that point incidentally in the course of the Second Reading debate. I think if the Minister had allowed his mind to run on that particular line, instead of on the compulsory line, he might get better results spread over a number of years. From the point of view of increased production, I believe a policy of that kind would be more effective than this continual use of compulsion. I am very doubtful about the feasibility of the Government's proposals.

There is one matter upon which I would like to glean some information. I am not making any particular point about it. My desire for information on the matter is partly stimulated by certain remarks made by the Minister. He referred recently to turf being utilised for the production of power. That problem, I presume, was fully considered by his Department and turned down—or was it turned down?

Comment on this

The question of the utilisation of turf for the production of power has been receiving very careful examination. In that connection I do not think it would be practicable to use hand-won turf, but we may be able to secure the mechanical production of turf for that purpose in the future.

Comment on this

When the Minister spoke of mechanisation, the use of machinery, I thought he had left these things out of account. I understand the Minister's Department and other Departments are co-operating towards the establishment of a new electric power scheme, and that that is being done without any reference to whether or not we are to utilise turf in the immediate future.

Comment on this

The Deputy will appreciate that an ideal combination for the production of power is a hydro-electric scheme and a turf scheme.

Comment on this

But from what we have been told it would appear that the Minister will have to rely on a dry season in order to operate the turf scheme. Surely you are not going to set up a turf power-producing station merely for the purpose of waiting for a dry year in order to operate it?

Comment on this

There must be a standby plant.

Comment on this

But that will not be enough, if you are going to use turf in the sense in which you have referred to it—using it as it is being used in other countries. Has the Minister in mind the utilisation of turf in the Pigeon House?

Comment on this

I take it the Minister has in mind establishing a big plant where the turf is produced, in the middle of the country, in such a place as that where he had lunch last Saturday. I am not to be taken as objecting, but it must be clear to the Minister that the new hydro-electric scheme will certainly postpone any such project for some time. It is not the type of plant that you can set up and use only occasionally; if it is to be productive it must be a plant that will be continually used. What I am anxious to know is what consideration has been given to that matter and why it was determined not to develop along these particular lines in the places where you have turf in large quantities and where you have not immediately on the turf area a large turf-consuming population. That would get over to a large extent the question of transport. That was one of the points the Minister referred to during the Second Reading debate and it was one of the reasons why he was anxious to operate this measure particularly in the turf-producing areas so that the cost of transport would be cut down as much as possible. Surely, one of the advantages of producing power from turf in the centre of the big bogs is that you can get over the cost of transport? You already have the transmission lines. I presume that with some modification it would be possible to utilise existing transmission lines. I merely want an assurance that that question has been fully considered. Perhaps the Minister will tell us how we stand in regard to that matter and what is the relationship to the existing hydro-electric schemes.

I have objected to the particular powers that are being taken by the Minister. We are half-way through the Committee Stage of this Bill and I must confess that Deputies are still in the position that they do not know precisely what are the Minister's intentions as to the use of these compulsory powers. If anybody in the House wishes to say that he intends to use these powers in the most oppressive manner, he can find statements in the course of the Minister's speeches to back that up; if a Deputy wishes to say that this is merely a stunt on the part of the Minister and that he has no intention to operate this measure, he still can find statements made by the Minister to back that up. That is why I suggest we should not lightly give powers which tend to have a wide ambit, particularly when we have such very vague indications from the Minister as to how he is going to use them. I suggest that to do so would be a very wrong thing.

Comment on this

As regards the production of electric power, we can leave that matter over because an Electricity Supply Bill will have to come before the Dáil in the course of the present session. So far as the production of power from turf is concerned, there is no technical problem involved; the only question is the price at which the turf can be delivered into the bunkers at the power station, and that question cannot be answered satisfactorily for some time to come, at least until the problems associated with the mechanical production of turf have been solved. The question of the equipment of the new houses with grates and ranges suitable for the utilisation of turf is one that, naturally, has given us concern. A number of houses recently erected in certain parts of the country have been so equipped. The answer to the Deputy's question in this connection is that it has not been made a condition for the receipt of financial assistance for house-building that the houses should be so equipped. That will come, undoubtedly and, in fact, with the enactment of this measure and our being able to see more clearly ahead the future development of turf production. The question will have to be taken up with the Department of Local Government at an early stage. It was considered undesirable to do so until the position of the turf scheme, as a whole, was more clearly defined. Another matter raised by the Deputy was the Government's intention in respect to the powers of the Bill. We would hope it would not be necessary to use the compulsory powers of the Bill. In any event these powers will be only utilised to the extent that is necessary to enable the actual turf produced in the season to be disposed of. There certainly will be no unnecessary utilisation of these powers for the purpose of creating an artificial scarcity of fuel. At the end of the producing season it will be possible to ascertain, with a fair degree of accuracy, the amount of turf available for disposal, and the amount that can be used in the ordinary way without the powers of this Bill. It is only if there is a surplus to the extent that only with the use of these powers could it be disposed of, the compulsory powers will be utilised at all.

Comment on this

That is what I might call the key section of the Bill. I do not propose to go very deeply into it, and I do not know whether the point was debated fully or not on Second Reading, as I was not here. Under this particular section a coal merchant may not sell to anybody more than two hundredweights of coal without at the same time selling to him an equal quantity of turf. In another section—Section 19, I think—sub-retailers have not that privilege.

Comment on this

A sub-retailer does not have to sell turf with the coal. A sub-retailer is regarded as a householder for the purchase of coal.

Comment on this

I am referring to Section 19, and sub-section (c) there says:—

(c) This Act, and, in particular the provisions of this Act relating to the compulsory purchase of turf shall apply to such sub-retailer and to such merchant accordingly.

It seems to me that the sub-retailer is bound by the provisions of the Act when he sells coal.

Comment on this

When he buys coal.

Comment on this

Is there not the same provision for him as for the other, that turf must be sold in the same proportion as coal, as provided in Section 13?

Comment on this

He cannot compel people to buy from him if he sells under two cwts.

Comment on this

I do not think he will have any difficulty in disposing of the turf as turf. I am not clear upon the point, but it seems to be that the sub-retailer is bound as much as anyone else. It seems to me if a bellman has to take turf, whether he wants it or not, he will find it very difficult to sell it. The coal merchant seems to have an advantage over him. If the intention is otherwise, I must confess it is very badly worked. There is one point that I would like the Minister to elucidate. I want to know who is entitled to the benefit of the exemption order.

Comment on this

Any person the Minister likes.

Comment on this

Section 17 provides that any person the Minister likes can get an exemption order. The Minister will give an exemption order to anyone he likes, and he can refuse exemption to people not entitled to the benefit of exemption. That implies that somebody is entitled to exemption. I want to know who is entitled to exemption or is anyone entitled to exemption.

Comment on this

If a Deputy purchased an all-electric house he would be entitled to exemption.

Comment on this

That does not arise at all. What would he buy coal for if he had an all-electric house?

Comment on this

There is nothing in the Bill at all as to who is entitled to exemption.

Comment on this

We can discuss the exemption clause when we come to it. It is obvious that it is desirable to have some sort of exemption, to deal with exceptional cases that undoubtedly will arise in certain cases. For some particular reason—perhaps for reasons of health—it may not be possible for some persons to use turf, and so the power of exemption is taken in the Bill.

Comment on this

Why not have it worded so? Why have it stated that somebody is entitled to an exemption order, when apparently nobody is?

Comment on this

The more I read this section the more difficulty I have in seeing that the Minister's interpretation is the one that an ordinary individual would place upon it. It seems to me that the Minister, according to his statement, intends, when he has made his orders, that nobody else living in any other area is entitled to exemption from the provisions of this Act. That is what I understand the Minister's statement to amount to. I should like this section to clearly set out what the Minister intends. There are several other matters that arise under this section Some people have been talking about the proper grates for burning coal and turf. I do not know whether Deputies are quite clear that to get the full benefit either out of coal or turf you want special grates or ranges for them. They do not vary a great deal. At the same time, the question of whether the bars are horizontal or vertical is governed by whether you are going to burn coal or turf. If you are going to burn turf you would require a bigger fire-box in the range than you would for coal. If you burn turf in a grate or range made exclusively for coal you will not get the same results. To my mind, this is part of the policy of the Government, and it creeps into certain other Acts where they do not seem to have one separate and distinct line of policy. To my mind, the Government ought to have started in on this line—that a person who is going to use turf requires a grate or range of a certain type and could not use coal. The person who is going to use coal, and who has got a grate or range for that purpose, cannot use turf. I do not mean to say that you could not shovel the alternative fuel into them and get some sort of result, but you will not get proper economic working in that way. That brings me to another point—that the Government, in my opinion, are trying to manage the affairs of the country to too great an extent under this section. I suggest to the Minister that, as he is out to promote the sale of a native product, he ought to consider how that could be done with the least trouble and expense to the community. I suggest that turf is not the only native fuel; that we also have coke and Irish anthracite. I should like to see some provision in which coke or anthracite could be expressed in terms of turf and that a person whom it suited could use either of these products.

Comment on this

It is in Section 1. The Bill does not apply to coke or anthracite.

Comment on this

I quite agree; but I want people to be allowed to substitute coke or anthracite for the compulsory purchase of turf. I wish to leave the people the utmost freedom. I am speaking now as a Dublin Deputy. There may be some portions of the country to which my remarks do not apply, but there is a considerable number of people who live upstairs in houses and who have a limited storage capacity and I can imagine turf becoming a nuisance to these people. I, therefore, suggest that where people do not want to use turf they ought to be able to substitute either coke or anthracite. That ought to be allowed and the people given the utmost freedom. I ask the Minister to consider the question why the people cannot be left—inside the provisions of a Bill which is obviously framed to benefit, promote, or stimulate the sales of the native product—to use other fuel if they object to the dust from turf getting on the room or to the smell of turf. I also request that the Minister should make it perfectly clear that anybody who is not in an appointed area is exempt.

Comment on this

I listened to the phrase used by the Minister which, it seems to me, has been used in reference to all the legislation enacted by this House for some time past. He mentioned that it was hoped that they need not use the power which the section confers. It is not the first time that the Minister made that statement. I remember the same phrase being used by the Minister for Agriculture in connection with Acts which he introduced. But, when it comes down to administering these Acts, what is the position? They always use every power which is conferred upon them. We are now discussing a Bill in connection with which the Minister himself does not seem to know exactly what he wants.

Deputy Dockrell referred to the Dublin householders and to the use of coke and anthracite. There seems to be nobody to speak in this House for the rural dweller. Is there no other fuel used in this country except the fuel mentioned by Deputy Dockrell and the Minister? What about all the firewood that is used in this country? In my own district I see people making a living by carting blocks into the town for sale. If Deputy Dockrell's contention is reasonable, and I think it is, is it not just as reasonable to ask for an exemption for the householder who buys what is a native fuel just as much as turf is and which is giving employment to those engaged in the sale of it? Where does the farmer come in in connection with this? Has he not to use the surplus firewood on his land? Under this Bill he will be compelled to buy turf. I only intervene to say that I strongly object to this phrase, that they hope they will not have to use the powers which the Bill confers on them. Why look for these powers if they do not hope to use them? While I think there is justification for the point of view put forward by Deputy Dockrell, I think it is only reasonable to consider the people of the rural districts who have to burn what is a native fuel just as much as turf is.

Comment on this

I gathered from the Minister that, after all, there was not co-operation between the Departments.

Comment on this

I intended to convey something different. I am sorry the Deputy gathered that.

Comment on this

From what the Minister said on the Second Reading, the putting in of a certain type of range was not made a condition. If that is what the Minister means by co-operation, I should like to know what he means by lack of co-operation.

Comment on this

I mean refusal to co-operate.

Comment on this

Not refusal, but neglect to co-operate, is lack of co-operation. It did not even strike the Minister to put it to the Department of Local Government. It is not that they refused—I am not making that charge unless he wishes to make it—but that it was not put up to them. Was it put up to them?

Comment on this

I explained that to the Deputy.

Comment on this

You did not. The statement was merely made that it was not made a condition that ranges and grates of a certain type should be put in.

Comment on this

I said we did not ask that it should be made a condition.

Comment on this

I regard that as lack of co-operation. I do not know what else lack of co-operation means.

Comment on this

I could explain that, too.

Comment on this

I have no doubt. You have one Department which for several years now—since the Government came into office—have had before their minds this magnificent turf scheme; then you have another Department with a housing scheme, and the two Departments work independently. We now gather from the Minister for Industry and Commerce that there is no approach to the Department of Local Government to see that the new houses which are being built on a Government subsidy will have better accommodation for the consumption of turf than the old houses. There is no approach made; they did not even ask the Department of Local Government whether that would or would not be a condition.

Comment on this

What is the most suitable appliance for the burning of turf?

Comment on this

I gathered that there was a more suitable appliance.

Comment on this

The Deputy will agree that obviously the first step to take——

Comment on this

The Minister will agree that it is the business of the Department of Local Government to know that.

Comment on this

We have in fact taken that step. The Industrial Research Council has been working on the matter for some time.

Comment on this

Four years after you started your scheme.

Comment on this

The Turf Development Board was set up in November, 1934.

Comment on this

The idea was there before. It was there from the moment the Government took office, according to the Minister. The logical step would be to see that the houses being built were properly fitted in the first instance. It is quite obvious that the Minister had not thought of it. It was not made a condition. Other conditions have been applied to the giving of Government grants. Roofing of a certain type has to be used, and various other necessary provisions are put in, but here, in a case where it was necessary to make some obvious provision to promote this industry which you say you have in mind, nothing was done. If that is co-operation I do not know what lack of co-operation is. Therefore, Deputy Dockrell ought not to be surprised if anthracite coal is not treated in the same way as turf is treated here. Not only is there a lack of co-operation between the different Government Departments, but there is a lack of co-operation in the different departments of the Minister's mind in regard to those matters. He may bring in another Bill to promote anthracite——

Comment on this

You may be nearer the truth than you think.

Comment on this

——but the idea that he should ever advert in this Bill to what he would do in the anthracite Bill is asking too much. We have heard about not letting your right hand know what your left hand does. The Minister does not let the left side of his brain know what the right side is doing. We need not expect him then to go outside his Department to the Department of Local Government and make any suggestions to them. Before the House grants those compulsory powers it ought to be convinced that they will be productive of good. Nothing that the Minister has said on this Bill would convince any man that those powers are going to be utilised to the advantage of the country. Compulsory powers ought not to be asked for without reason, and the Minister is asking for them without putting forward sufficient reason to induce this House to give them. He comes to this House asking for those powers and saying: "Give them to us. We hope we will not have to use them." You can justify a demand for the most despotic powers in that way. Every despot that the world has ever seen, unless he is mad, would much prefer not to use his despotic powers if the people would only do what he wants them to do without his using those despotic powers; it would be much more favourable for him. The Minister should not get those powers unless he shows the House sufficient reason for asking for them.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister to go to bed with this headache? Section 13 is the operative section of this Bill, and provides that any person who buys more than 2 cwts. of coal must take a specified quantity of turf. If they buy less than 2 cwts. they are exempted from the provisions of this Bill. What is to prevent someone who wants to buy a ton of coal from going to the rural retail distributor and saying: "I want a ton of coal. I am going to order a cwt. at 12 o'clock, a cwt. at 1 o'clock, a cwt. at 2 o'clock, and a cwt. every hour until I have accumulated my ton of coal. I will take delivery of the ton of coal in that way"?

Comment on this

Cwt. by cwt?

Comment on this

And a separate journey with each sack?

Comment on this

Yes. Remember we are dealing with small rural towns, the full length of which in many cases is a quarter of a mile. I am familiar with the circumstances obtaining there, and would have no difficulty whatever in effecting delivery of a ton of coal in individual cwts. to customers in the town in which I live. They could perfectly easily, and have on occasion, asked for delivery of three or four cwts. of coal at separate hours on the same day. They got it as a matter of course. Am I to understand that, having provided for every administrative difficulty which could be thought of in connection with this scheme, the Minister has overlooked this point? I want to warn him that if I want to buy five cwts. of coal, and my alternative is to take it in five separate orders or take with the coal five cwts. of turf when I do not want turf at all, I will simply buy five separate bags of coal. Do not let the Minister imagine that that would present any insuperable difficulty to any rural retail distributor of coal. It will not. Let me take a case in point. Supposing we have five customers for coal at one end of the town, and they want five cwts. of coal apiece. Nothing is easier than to send out five cwts. in the first lot, and drop one cwt. at each house. You can then send out another five cwts. later on in the day and drop one cwt. at each house, and so on until the five cwts. are delivered. In any case you would have to send out five cwts. to each house to meet each individual order, and to avoid the necessity for delivering unwanted turf you simply drop each individual cwt. as you go. In that way the whole Bill ceases to be operative. I just want to give the Minister that headache to go to bed with, because I think if he consults with any of his experts, or with any of his colleagues who are familiar with rural trade, they will tell him that the procedure I have here outlined for him is not only eminently practicable but absolutely certain of operation in the event of this Bill passing. I mention the thing at this juncture because the Bill is a farce and a joke. It is simply another piece of evidence of the growing Hitlerism of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who loves to have the right to tell everybody in this country what they will burn, what they will do, and how and when they will do it. The fact is that he is becoming gradually obsessed with the idea that he can run everybody's business in the country.

Comment on this

I do not tell the people half as much as the Deputy does.

Comment on this

The difference is that the Minister is seeking statutory power to give force to his words, and it is only right for him to realise that there are limitations. He has reached them so far as Section 13 is concerned. The Bill is a joke, and therefore it is unnecessary to put down amendments to try to bring it into line with realities. It is a bad Bill, and if it did operate it would have very undesirable effects, but Section 13 blows the whole bottom out of it in so far as the distribution of coal in rural areas is concerned. I gather that it is the Minister's attention to apply the Bill only in rural areas at the present time; there is no question of applying it in the cities. I think, then, that the House need not seriously worry, because the compulsory purchase of turf with coal will in fact be as rare as the white blackbird.

Comment on this

Perhaps then the Deputy will allow the rest of the Bill to go through without further discussion.

Comment on this

I think it is a useful thing, even if the Bill will not have any serious operation, to bring home to the Minister's colleagues the fatuity of certain of the proposals in support of which he flogs them into the lobby from time to time.

Comment on this

Is there any condition in the housing schemes for the provision of proper apparatus for the burning of turf?

Comment on this

It is not compulsory, but there is a number of foundries manufacturing grates and ranges here who have on the market grates and ranges which they consider suitable for the efficient burning of turf.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

Is it not then the intention of the Minister for Local Government, in connection with mental hospitals and other institutions which are being built, to make compulsory the erection of grates and ranges for the burning of turf?

Comment on this

That may be necessary.

Comment on this

Why has it not been done already?

Comment on this

Obviously the first step is to devise the most efficient types.

Comment on this

The compulsion comes first.

Comment on this

The matter has been investigated by the Industrial Research Council, and a report has already been received. It is a very valuable report, and will be of very great benefit to the firms making those appliances. It will enable them to produce articles which will be much more efficient for their purpose than anything produced here before. That investigation is being continued. When we are satisfied that efficient apparatus is manufactured in the country and is on sale here, we can consider approaching the Department of Local Government with a view to the utilisation of their powers to ensure the use of those articles.

Comment on this