Insurance Bill, 1935—Recommittal.
Contributions 1–222 of 705. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 35 of 1935 ›
I move amendment No. 1:—
At the end of sub-section (2), line 21, to add the words, "provided that in case of any inconsistency between that Act and this Act the provisions of this Act shall prevail."
This amendment stands on the Order Paper in order to clear up doubt. I suppose it is an accepted principle that an Act of Parliament repeals every previous Act, in so far as it directly contradicts it. Nevertheless, it is deemed expedient to add schedules to many Bills setting out the sections of other Acts which it is intended to repeal outright. You sometimes apparently get cases in which there is an inconsistency between an early Act and the most recent Act, potential litigants are not quite clear as to their rights, and test cases ensue in order to establish which Act should prevail. It is, therefore, thought advantageous that a specific note should be made in the first section of the Bill that when the Act becomes law, in the event of any inconsistency manifesting itself hereafter, the terms of this Act should prevail.
Comment on this
I do not think there is any necessity for this amendment. If during the course of the discussions on the various sections of the Bill any necessity for a provision of this kind is shown, I am prepared to have the matter considered, but I cannot at the moment see how the necessity for it arises.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider putting in such parts of the 1909 Act as he wishes to have clearly made the law of this country at the present moment, so that the one Act will form the one code under which people dealing with insurance matters in this country will operate, and will be enabled to know clearly and precisely what their duties and their rights are, without having reference to a previous Act which was passed prior to this State being established? Would it not be a simple matter for the Minister to select, with the aid of the Parliamentary draftsman, those provisions of the Act of 1909 which he wishes to operate, and put them in on Report or another stage, so as to have one Bill dealing with insurance law in this country?
Comment on this
I will give the matter consideration, but I am not quite sure what difficulties will arise in that connection.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider the definition of the word "policy," which may possibly cause some trouble and inconsistency? I intend to raise the matter later on the definition clause, under Section 3. There might possibly be an inconsistency there; I mention that as one particular instance. In the Act of 1909 there is no comprehensive definition of the word "policy." There are definitions dealing with certain kinds of policies.
Comment on this
If the Minister would indicate his intention of seriously considering, between now and the Report Stage, the proposal to make this Bill a codification of insurance law in this country, then the necessity for my amendment would not arise. If he does not do that, I think the case mentioned by Deputy Costello admirably illustrates the point I have in mind. A word such as "policy" has been used in the 1909 Act, and has become the subject of statutory definition, or, what is more elusive, has probably become the subject of judicial definition, and we may find that what purports to be the statutory definition of the word "policy" in this Bill conflicts with the judicial definition of what the word "policy" has meant heretofore, or the part definition of what "policy" was in the earlier Acts. Therefore, it would be highly desirable that whatever appears as a definition in this Act should prevail against any other definition that was existing. However, if the Minister indicates his desire to consider the matter at his leisure, I have no desire to press the amendment at this stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:—
In page 5, lines 30-31, to delete the words "Industry and Commerce" and substitute the word "Finance".
This Bill undoubtedly represents the queerest piece of Nosey-Parker legislation that has ever been introduced into this Dáil. There are practically dictatorial powers given to the Minister under the Bill, powers of a kind which should not be entrusted to any Department, and least of all—judging by the way in which the Department of Industry and Commerce has handled this measure from the beginning—to the Department of Industry and Commerce. It scarcely seems conceivable that any representative Government would bring into a legislative assembly very far-reaching and important legislation of this kind, without previously consulting those people who are most vitally concerned with the consequences of that legislation. One would certainly believe that before embarking on such a very hazardous course the Minister would have consulted with the representatives of the various companies who are responsible for the insurance industry in this country. Probably, outside of agriculture, there is no industry in this country so important from the point of view of the amount of employment it gives, from the point of view of the very many and varied interests which it touches, and from the point of view of its importance to the nation and to the Government. One would certainly have thought that the Minister, before introducing this Bill, would have taken those people into his confidence, or at all events would have consulted them. One could scarcely conceive the Minister bringing in a Bill, for example, dealing with banking in this country, a business which, in many respects, is not as important as the insurance business, and completely ignoring the joint stock banks and the people responsible for carrying on that particular business in the country. That has been the treatment given to those firms by the Minister in embarking on this particular piece of legislation. The Minister, apparently, in his career in this House, has adopted a technique of his own.
Comment on this
The amendment we are considering is amendment No. 2, which purports to substitute the Minister for Finance for the Minister for Industry and Commerce. It seems to the Chair that the Deputy is making a Second Reading speech on the policy of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
I am merely justifying my reasons for asking to have the administration of this measure transferred to another Department. As I say, the Minister in this, as in other respects, has shown that he has very little consideration for the industries with which he is tampering. Apropos of the general attitude of the Minister towards industries, it just occurs to me that I read a letter in the Irish Independent of yesterday, in which the Minister is criticised for adopting exactly the same attitude towards another concern in this country. I will just read a brief extract from the letter, which is signed “J. Morgan, Director, A. Morgan & Son, Ltd., Dublin”:—
"It stands to sense that both our bureaucracy and our statesmen were completely without practical experience when the new policy of trade agreements, quotas and new markets was adopted, and one would have thought they would at least have moved cautiously and have claimed assistance in the new ventures of the experienced traders whose life-long trading arrangements they were about to shatter and destroy; but our experience of the Department of Industry and Commerce has been that it moves recklessly, blusteringly and arrogantly, and that it only asks for your views after it has `adopted a scheme' and at a time when it is too late to save itself, because of time limits prescribed by an Act."
We are confronted with a similar situation. A Bill was rushed through this Dáil. First of all, I suppose about 18 months ago the headings of a Bill were introduced, and a First Reading was given to it. We were expecting from day to day that a Second Reading would follow, but it dragged on from month to month, and the various companies were waiting; none of them was consulted about it. Eventually a Second Reading was given to a different Bill to the one originally introduced. It was bad enough to have the companies generally treated in that cavalier fashion, and if that treatment had been universally imposed there might have been some palliation of the Minister's conduct, but unfortunately there appear to have been leakages. It is a well-known fact that about the time the first measure was introduced two important foreign insurance companies were about to leave this country, but, apparently, as a result of whatever information they received— reassuring information that nothing detrimental to their affairs would take place by way of legislation——
Comment on this
——those companies remained in this country and built palatial offices here. There was an Irish company in a very similar position——
Comment on this
I am just explaining what the position is, and why I object to the Department of Industry and Commerce having control of the administration of this measure.
Comment on this
The Deputy may object, but he cannot, on an amendment, go through the whole Bill, and the characteristics of the Bill, as a ground for the objection.
Comment on this
I must make a case for transferring the functions to another Department. I am making a charge of favouritism in that particular case. I say that as a result of the information those companies received they built up palatial offices in Dublin. Apparently they have no fears of what the consequences to foreign companies in this country are going to be. At the same time, an Irish company was in a similar position—anxious to improve its buildings and waiting from day to day, after purchasing its buildings, to know what would happen. That company had plans and specifications drawn up. It had incurred considerable expense in getting rid of tenants and in various other ways. The thing dragged on from day to day, as I have said, and at the end of it all the Bill is introduced, and it is discovered that, after that measure becomes law, all the work of that company will be useless and that it will be at considerable loss.
Again, another thing has happened during the interval between the introduction of the original Bill and the Second Reading. Another company was established in this State and, apparently, that company got such very pertinent information that it was able to draft its Articles of Association so as to fit exactly into the proposed Bill. That company was floated for a certain amount of capital—perhaps £100,000 of subscribed capital— and £56,000 of that capital was subscribed by the Industrial Credit Corporation, and I assume that that was done with the cognizance and, probably, with the approval of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. At the same time, another £5,000 of the capital of that company was subscribed from Public Bodies Mutual Insurance Company—a body that was organised specifically for providing funds for public bodies. On the whole, this Bill has had a very shady origin and I do not think we are entitled to entrust the Department of Industry and Commerce with the carrying out of this particular business. Apart altogether from that, I believe that the Department of the Minister for Finance is a more suitable Department for the carrying on of this business than the Department of Industry and Commerce, because insurance is a business that will take, in the nature of things, more of a financial colour than a commercial colour, and also because I believe that you will find in the Department of Finance officials more competent to deal with this matter of insurance than you will find in the Department of Industry and Commerce. Besides that, the tendency being, of late, to increase to an alarming extent the number of officials in the Department of Industry and Commerce, I feel that, if this matter is left in the hands of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, you will have almost as many officials appointed to deal with the administration of this measure as you will have officials losing their positions in the various insurance companies as a result of the passage of this measure. Those, Sir, are some of the arguments that I had in mind in putting down this amendment.
Comment on this
I was interested to hear the Deputy telling the House the faults of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and I was sorry that he did not complete his speech by telling us the virtues of the Minister for Finance, which, evidently, would complete the reasons that he had for introducing this amendment. Perhaps the Deputy will do so now if I invite him to do so.
Comment on this
I have nothing, personally, against the Minister for Industry and Commerce in introducing this particular amendment.
Comment on this
Surely, Sir, the inference is clear that anything would be better than the Minister for Industry and Commerce? I should like to hear the Minister for Industry and Commerce rebut that.
Comment on this
I have invited Deputy Bourke to complete his reasons for introducing this amendment.
Comment on this
Is it possible, Sir, that the Minister for Industry and Commerce thinks to discharge his obligations to this House by remaining silent after the pretty glaring expose of his activities by Deputy Bourke? Has the Minister any answer to the allegation made by Deputy Bourke that the Minister afforded secret information to a body which floated a company in this city with Articles of Association clearly designed to conform to a Bill which had not yet been completed, and has he any answer to the allegation that that body is still waiting for some further favours from the Minister? Surely the Minister has some reply to that? Are those allegations well-founded or are they not well-founded? If they are well-founded, surely this House is entitled to some explanation of why it is that certain individuals are entitled to preferential information from the Minister's Department and that others are refused it?
Comment on this
Does Deputy Dillon accept Deputy Bourke's statement that a certain insurance corporation was given £56,000 out of the Trades Loans Fund with the authority of the Minister's Department?
Comment on this
I accept or reject nothing, but I say that, when statements are made in a considered manner and with the moderation that Deputy Bourke has displayed, it is the duty of the Minister to inform this House whether these allegations are well-founded or not. I say that the Minister, in view of such allegations, is bound to tell us whether he admits the impeachment brought against him or, if he does not admit it, that he is bound to disprove it. Deputy Bourke has taken the correct steps to state what he has stated. There are no other steps for him to take except in the presence of the Minister and on an occasion when the Minister has ample opportunity of dealing with the matter. Does the Minister accept that?
Comment on this
Does Deputy Dillon expect the Minister to waste his own time and that of the House in refuting the kind of allegations that have been made?
Comment on this
I expect the Minister to speak for himself instead of putting up some of his innocent supporters to reply for him.
Comment on this
Perhaps I can end this by saying that all Deputy Bourke's allegations are as stupid as most of Deputy Dillon's allegations. The only allegation that I can relate to any known fact is the allegation that an insurance company got a loan of £56,000 under the Trade Loans Acts. That is entirely incorrect.
Comment on this
I should like to state that it is correct, and if the Minister cares to look up the books, he will get that information in Dublin Castle for a fee of one shilling.
Comment on this
Surely Deputies are aware that particulars of every trade loan given must be laid before the Dáil and that Deputies can look up the records of all loans made under the Trade Loans Acts since their inception.
Comment on this
I was referring to the Industrial Credit Corporation.
Comment on this
It is, in fact, true that the capital of this company was subscribed by the Industrial Credit Corporation.
Comment on this
Deputy Bourke has stated that that amount of capital was subscribed by the Industrial Credit Corporation.
Comment on this
The Minister does not deny it. If Deputy Bourke had read the letter from Messrs. Morgan and Company completely it would have been seen that they commented on a similar comment made by the Minister a few days ago in reply to another matter that I raised. I had brought the Minister's attention to a certain matter, and the Minister's reply was to the effect that there was no truth in any of the allegations made by Deputy Dillon, and that he had no time to investigate stupid allegations of that kind. With that, the matter passed. These are almost exactly the same words as the Minister has employed to-day. On the day following what I have referred to, a letter appeared——
Comment on this
No, Sir. I agree. My only point in bringing up this matter is to show that the Minister's reply to Deputy Bourke is not worth the breath he used on it.
Comment on this
Surely, Sir, it is relevant for me to say that the reply of the Minister is unsatisfactory? May I say that? And may I also go on to say that the terms employed by the Minister, in his reply to Deputy Bourke, were exactly the same as the terms he employed in his reply to me a few days ago. When, on the following morning, an expert, in a letter——
Comment on this
Well, then, Sir, if it has been ruled out of order, I shall look forward to another opportunity of raising the matter.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Keyes I move amendment No. 4:—
In page 8, line 14, to add after the word "business" the words "provided the Minister may on application of any trade union unregistered in Saorstát Eireann but which operated in Saorstát Eireann for a period of not less than ten years prior to October, 1935, extend to that trade union the exemption conferred on a registered trade union by this Act and the Assurance Companies Act, 1909."
Comment on this
The intention of the amendment is to safeguard the interests of some thousands of organised workers who belong to trade unions not at present registered here. These unions are amongst the oldest established in the country, covering various types of workers, such as railwaymen of all grades, woodworkers, printers, vehicle builders, engineers, plumbers, painters, furnishing-trade workers and others. Added to the ordinary trade union benefits, such as strike pay, each of these unions gives friendly benefits such as death benefit, retirement benefit in certain cases, accident benefit in some instances, and in other cases small payments during illness. In one union that I have in mind there is refunded to the member, by way of retirement allowance or bonus when he finally retires from his employment through old age or on pension, a certain proportion of his total contributions to the union. If he dies whilst a member his widow or nearest relative receives a certain payment in proportion to his years of membership of the union. If his wife predeceases him, half the same amount is paid to him. If he should lose his life through accident during his employment or on his way to work, his dependents are entitled to a lump sum payment.
The amendment seeks to preserve to members of this type this kind of benefit. If it is not adopted, then the vested interest which they have created, in some cases by very long membership ranging up to 35 or 40 years will be cancelled forthwith and a very grave and unjustifiable hardship inflicted upon a very deserving body of men. I am informed that the estimated value of the existing benefit to members of such unions would not be less than £1,000,000. It should be stated that this is really not insurance in the ordinary sense of the word. For instance, there is no such procedure as medical examination, or any actuarial processes which apply in the case of the insurance company. The arrangement merely means that the union in its general desire to help its members as far as possible in circumstances in which they are not otherwise protected, pays out these benefits in addition to extending the protection which a trade union normally gives to its members. In no case could the individual concerned get anything like the same benefits for the same contribution from any insurance company. In fact, in the vast majority of cases there is no particular allocation whatever of either the contributions or the funds in respect of these benefits. They are merely in the nature of a bonus, which the member is entitled to receive as a result of the general trade union contribution he pays. They are, however, benefits which are very highly appreciated, and any attempt to interfere with the arrangement would be very keenly resented by those concerned and would result in very serious hardships to many thousands of deserving people and their dependents.
Those who belong to trade unions whose headquarters happen to be in the Free State are left their present rights and privileges. It is presumed that there is no desire to extend less favourable treatment to the other workers concerned who are covered by this amendment. Moreover, the manner in which foreign insurance companies and their shareholders have been protected is surely the strongest possible argument for the acceptance of this amendment, because here no shareholders at all are involved but merely the insured. The type of benefit they get is such as they would not normally get from any insurance company, because they would not subscribe for it. It is in fact a bonus which some unions are able to pay after discharging their normal trade union liabilities to their members. They are in no way in competition with the insurance companies; therefore there is no question of the financial rights or interests of any other existing organisation. I understand that the Executive of the Trade Union Congress has explained the meaning and the effect of this amendment very fully to the Minister and his officials, and I hope he will see his way to accept it, and thereby preserve the very valuable rights of existing members of trade unions not registered in Saorstát Eireann.
Comment on this
The measure as it stands exempts from its scope any business lawfully carried on by trade unions registered in the Saorstát under Acts relating to trade unions. The purpose of the Deputy's amendment, and of certain representations made by the Trade Union Congress, is to ensure that the Minister shall have discretion to grant exemption also to certain bodies which are acting as trade unions but are not registered as such under the Trade Union Acts. I have given the matter consideration, and I think there is a good case to be made, on the lines advanced by the Deputy, for taking such power. If the Deputy will hold his amendment over until the next stage, I will undertake to have tabled for consideration then an amendment which, I think, will have the same effect as his, that is an amendment designed to give the Minister for Industry and Commerce power to grant this exemption to unregistered trade unions in certain conditions and in certain circumstances.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputies Norton and Murphy, I move amendment No. 5:—
In page 8, line 17, after the figures "1924" to add the following words: "and the issued shares of which company are to an extent not less than two-thirds (in nominal value) thereof and carrying voting rights (whether immediate or to arise in certain future circumstances) in the beneficial ownership of a person who is or of two or more persons all of whom are citizens of Saorstát Eireann."
The wording of this amendment explains it, and I should like to hear from the Minister if he has any objection to accepting it in principle.
Comment on this
I am afraid the purpose of the amendment is not clear. The effect would be merely to put a couple of insurance companies which are registered here, but not owned here as the term is defined in the amendment, into the position of foreign companies. I am not quite sure what difference it would make. The companies concerned, as far as I can see, would be entitled to get licences in accordance with the provisions of the Bill, and the only effect of the amendment would be to ensure that they would go about getting those licences in one manner rather than in another. I think the amendment is unnecessary. The companies are registered here, and, as such, are treated in the Bill as Saorstát companies, but in so far as they carried on business in October, 1935, would be entitled under the provisions of the Bill to apply for a licence in any event.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:—
In page 8, before line 18, to insert the words—the expression "national company" means an assurance company registered in Saorstát Eireann under the Companies Acts, 1908 to 1924, and incorporated in Ireland not before the 24th day of April, 1916, and not later than the 7th day of January, 1921, and which for the purposes of this Act save as is otherwise provided shall be a "Saorstát Eireann Company" save that the provisions of paragraph (b) of sub-section (4) of section 12 and the words in paragraph (a) of sub-section (9) of section 12 beginning with the word "and" line 59 and ending with the word "business" line 61 do not apply.
As the Bill stands, and unless it is very seriously amended at this stage, or at a subsequent stage, it will really sound the death-knell of Irish insurance companies. The Irish insurance companies have had a very difficult struggle, and are competing under a very heavy handicap with companies with much greater resources. Though they went through their formative years at a time when restrictions on insurance were much less than they are at present, and when the premiums charged were much higher than they are to-day, the Irish insurance companies had one advantage, and only one advantage, in competing with foreign companies: that they could appeal to the patriotic sense of the Irish people and use the slogan, "support Irish industry." The fact that these companies were giving preference to Irish employees and had invested their money in Irish industries, and so far as possible assisted a native Government and the national outlook generally, made an appeal to the Irish people, and enabled the Irish companies to get business against the very keen competition of the stronger companies. By a system of licensing insurance companies, this Bill will to a great extent, if not completely, do away with that advantage. Once a company is licensed to do business in this country, to all intents and purposes it becomes an Irish company, as no one is going to inquire very far back into his antecedents one way or another. A person henceforward will insure with the company that can offer him the greatest advantages. It is on that basis that insurance will probably be done in future. To that extent Irish companies will suffer by this system of licensing.
Then the partition proposals in this Bill by dividing up the Irish companies will destroy their identity. Once the company has had to submit to this Solomon's judgment, it will be very hard to identify the original company or to know into which particular section these companies have been divided up and stirred about by the Minister's Irish stew of amalgamation. It will be very hard to recognise the parts that will emerge without their original label. Again, everybody who knows anything about business, will recognise that goodwill is a most important item in any business, perhaps even a more important item than capital itself. It is quite a usual thing—and nobody should be more familiar with it than the Minister for Industry and Commerce—to see a particular business house changing hands several times in one generation while the same name remains over the door all the time, for the simple reason that a certain goodwill attaches to that particular name. There is probably no business in the world that is more affected by the factor of goodwill than the insurance business, because it is a very widespread business and touches the interests of a great number of the public. If a company carries out its business in a satisfactory manner and gives satisfaction to the people who are doing business with it, everyone who comes in contact with that company becomes an advertising agent for it. In like manner, if a company does not give satisfaction to its clients, the people who are dissatisfied can do immense injury to that company; and the company that is endeavouring to give satisfaction, once it loses this factor of goodwill, is losing something that is extremely important for its successful working. Under the partition proposals in this Bill that element of goodwill will be completely lost, and the Irish companies to that extent will be the losers, because the great English companies and the foreign companies will still retain their name. Their goodwill will not be affected, whereas the Irish companies will lose whatever prestige they have built up during the last few years.
There is another important point in these partition proposals, namely, that they are going proportionately to increase very greatly the overhead charges of the Irish companies. Anyone who has any knowledge of the business of insurance companies realises that the great difficulty with which they are confronted is to reduce their expense rates. You may start at one end of the problem and by increasing your business, which is a fairly easy thing to do, you do not mind the factor of expense, but by increasing your business in such a way that at the same time you increase your expenses proportionately, you are worse off in the end than at the beginning. If you approach the problem from the other end by reducing expenses you may possibly find that you are reducing your income still more, so that you are still faced with the same dilemma. In the case of companies that are doing both classes of business, their overhead charges are generally distributed between the two branches of the business and if you cut off one branch you will be faced with the position in which the other branch will find it very difficult to maintain its overhead charges. A number of the officials in those companies are supported by salaries paid from both sides of the business. In the same way a great number of offices can only be maintained by reason of the fact that a share of the business is fire and general, and another share of it is life. If you cut off one or other of these classes of business it will mean that various local offices will have to be closed down and the business of that extent will be reduced.
There is another important aspect, which makes it also necessary for the Irish companies to escape from these partition proposals. That is, the fact that every penal clause in this Bill, everything that makes insurance in this country more difficult than in foreign countries, militates to a greater extent against the native Irish insurance companies than against the foreign companies and, to that extent, is a fillip to the foreign companies. Most of the foreign companies do only a small portion of their business in this country, some of them only about 10 per cent. They can afford to lose on their business in this country for a number of years if, by doing so, they know that the Irish company which is being subjected to the same conditions will be driven out of business. The Irish companies, unlike the foreign companies, have no subsidiaries in other countries on which they can depend. If conditions are such that they cannot carry on a profitable business here, the Irish companies will be forced out of business while the foreign companies in competition with them would be prepared to lose a considerable sum of money in order to see that result brought about.
There is another part of the Bill to which I have an amendment down alongside one by Deputy Dillon, which will enable all Saorstát companies that were composite companies before the Bill was introduced to continue as composite companies. I do think that special consideration should be given to those companies that were established here in the period between the 1916 Proclamation and the acceptance of the Treaty in 1922, that is, during the period of the struggle for independence. Most of these companies and societies—I have not included societies in my amendment— were started more from patriotic motives than from any other point of view. They were not started solely as commercial concerns. The money was subscribed in the same spirit by a number of people as that in which they subscribed to the National Loan and it was part of the Articles of Association of these companies that they should invest in Irish industries. At a time when there was very little encouragement or inducement to invest in Irish industries, when there was if anything a certain animus against these industries, it was a very good thing to have institutions that had fairly substantial funds and were prepared to support those industries. Very often from a financial point of view these concerns were not of a type to attract investors. Some of them did carry on to success but a great many of them did not. At all events, these industries, with a more or less Irish-Ireland outlook, got substantial support from these Irish companies. In the same way men who had participated in the national struggle and who were victimised, for one reason or another, found a refuge in these companies as officials, although frequently they might not have been as competent as men who would have been selected solely on grounds of ability or because of their knowledge of the insurance business.
Again, these companies carried on under very considerable handicaps at times. Their directors and high officials were frequently on the run or in jail for political offences. Their head offices were frequently raided and their position was made exceptionally difficult. However, the companies survived that difficult period but then they had to undergo a period equally as difficult, the period of the civil war. Subsequent to that they were plunged into the world-wide depression which meant a big loss on investments. Having survived all these difficulties, it is certainly a hardship that our own Government, a Government which has come into office pledged to carry out a programme of fostering and protecting native industries, should introduce a measure such as this. It is certainly very strange that the death blow for Irish insurance companies should come from a Government organised on these particular lines. The irony of the situation, as I see it, is that it is probably those companies which have done their best to avoid the irregularities which the Minister will probably adduce as a reason for insisting on this partition proposal, which have not utilised their life fund to bolster up their fire accident fund or vice versa, which have kept their accounts separate and tried to carry on in that way—these are the companies which, in my opinion, are going to suffer most. Those companies which have kept their business in such a way that one side has been supported at the expense of another, to the extent of the other portion becoming completely atrophied, will lose nothing by having the diseased limb cut off. That limb was no good to the company, at any rate, as regards the support of overhead charges. Those companies which have tried to keep both limbs solid and sound, which have tried to carry on in a regular way, will find this major operation, as it was described by Deputy Cosgrave, a very serious matter. Those companies have been in the habit of standing on both feet. Both were sound and healthy feet and, if one is cut off, it will be very difficult for them to maintain the top-heavy body which will be left.
No consideration is shown in any portion of this Bill for the shareholders of these companies. Those who subscribed to the capital of those companies did so partly from patriotic motives but that is no reason why their capital should be confiscated in this way. The people who subscribed to the National Loan did not expect to make anything out of it but, when a national Government was established, it immediately repaid that loan. Some consideration should be shown to the people who invested in these companies. Their capital will, to all intents and purposes, be confiscated under this measure if it goes through as designed by the Minister.
Comment on this
The purpose of the amendment, as I read it, is merely to provide that Saorstát composite offices will be entitled to continue both life and non-life business. The larger part of the Deputy's remarks seemed to me to be entirely irrelevant to the amendment. It is quite true that a number of insurance companies were established here by people whose main motives were patriotic, that business was secured for them by the use of the slogan "Support Irish industries" and that that business was given to them for patriotic reasons irrespective of the merits of the policies which these companies were offering. But I cannot quite see what that has to do with this amendment. The slogan "Support Irish industries" is a good one. The great majority of the people who use it are entitled to use it. But if that slogan is used to secure business for a company which is insolvent, if it is used to induce people who are not in a position to get accurate information as to the financial position of a particular enterprise to put their savings into that enterprise, when it is certain they will lose them, it is a dishonest slogan and one that can be used to trap and defraud people. When we come to consider the provisions of this Bill—the first measure dealing with insurance introduced in this Dáil since its establishment—we have got to leave these considerations aside and consider the purely business matters, that must be our first concern. The job of this Dáil is not to make things particularly easy for the insurance companies. Our primary task is to protect the people who have dealings with these companies and see that the average person, desiring for any reason to insure himself, gets a fair deal.
One of the fundamental provisions of this Bill is the section which provides that a company which is carrying on life assurance business must not carry non-life classes of business as well. That is a fundamental provision of the Bill. It is, in our opinion, an essential safeguard for the people who are effecting life assurance. It is a provision which should obviously appear in the first Bill dealing with insurance introduced here. It is, in fact, the law in a number of European countries and, in our opinion, it should be the law here. During the course of the Second Reading debate, I stated the primary reasons which induced us to introduce this provision. Force of circumstances would, I think, compel this Dáil to introduce that provision at some stage and, in our opinion, it is preferable to make the change now than later, when it might be much more difficult.
The Deputy seeks to secure exemption from that general principle for companies which are "national companies," as he defines them. We do not think that that should be done. We think that the considerations which justified the introduction of the principle regarding the division between life and non-life classes of business apply with equal force to those national companies and the principle should also be made applicable to them. The general principle as to effecting that division hardly needs any defence at this stage. As I said, it was discussed here on Second Reading and the Dáil approved of the Bill containing that provision. Since that is so, I think it would be entirely wrong, at this stage, to introduce an amendment which would exempt one class of insurance companies from its application, leaving it to apply to all the others: The amendment on that account cannot be accepted. We think the Dáil should maintain the principle embodied in the Bill—that these two classes of business, which are distinct and separate and which are carried on on separate principles, should be carried on also by separate companies. That is one of the main purposes of the Bill and it would be a fundamental mistake to exclude any class of company from its scope.
Comment on this
I agree that our duty is to see that the Irish insured person gets a square deal from any insurance company with whom he does his business, whether it is a German company, a British company, or an Irish company. However, I do not want this House to be left under the impression that the only people who have to be watched in this manner are Irish companies. I do not know the details of the affairs of all the Irish companies, but any Irish insurance companies of which I have knowledge are solvent companies and have no apology whatever to make to the Minister for Industry and Commerce for engaging in the business in which they are at present engaged. They have carried on their general business, their ordinary branch business, and their industrial business in accordance with the strictest standards of rectitude that have ever been enforced in Great Britain or elsewhere. There may be companies in this country of which the Minister has a more intimate knowledge than I have to which that would not apply. The companies which I know of have set for themselves a higher standard than many foreign companies which are at present operating in this country. We ought to get clear on that, because it is not right at this stage, or at any other stage of this debate, that a note should creep in that Irish companies are insolvent wrecks and that the only companies operating here deserving of the name of insurance companies are British or Continental companies because that is not true.
Comment on this
There are more ways of killing a cat than by choking it with a pound of butter. There are ways of suggesting it. We are told that our concern is to watch over the interests of insured persons. It certainly is, but let nobody draw from that the conclusion that anybody who transacts his business with Irish companies requires the vigilance of the State to protect him. I want to make it perfectly clear that, with regard to British, German, and Irish companies, there are two classes, the solvent and the insolvent companies. It is a gross injustice to the solvent companies that they should be lumped with the insolvent companies, whether they are in Ireland, in England or in Germany. The Minister says he cannot entertain this amendment because the principle was discussed on the Second Stage, and the House having adopted the Bill on the Second Stage, he cannot see his way to remove this part of the Bill now. The Minister never, at any stage, gave any adequate reason whatever for divorcing the fire and general business from the ordinary life and industrial business. What Deputy Bourke has said about increasing the overhead charges, and thus causing great embarrassment to Irish companies, is perfectly true. It is the company which has submitted itself to the rules with the strictest propriety, by maintaining two separate funds, and maintaining both branches of its business in a strictly healthy condition, is to suffer most because of this change. The ones that have not been complying with the regulations laid down are going to suffer nothing from this new departure, because they abandoned that part of their business. So that instead of hurting them this new departure will only relieve them from embarrassment. I think I have heard at no stage of this Bill any adequate reason advanced for the course suggested by the Minister. The Minister says that this division is of universal practice on the Continent of Europe. I am not in a position to confirm or to controvert that statement. All I know is that it is not a universal practice in Great Britain, and I do not believe it is a universal practice in the United States of America. These are the two countries in the world at present which have the most solvent insurance institutions. They are the two great countries whose insurance companies are receiving risks from the four corners of the earth.
The insurance companies of most other countries of the world are exclusively national, except in so far as the German companies specialise in the business of reinsurance, so that that argument does not carry much weight. If we go by the experience of the world we will find that the experience of the world is against the proposals in this Bill. No adequate reason has ever been advanced for imposing this divorcement upon Irish companies or upon British companies in so far as they operate in the Saorstát. If this is persisted in I feel that we are going to do insurance business in this country a very great injury. Remember, if we do the insurance business as a whole serious injury, it is only the very strongest and biggest of the companies that are going to survive. The big companies are provided for in this Bill. They will be the British companies and foreign companies that can afford to get hard knocks and survive them. The solvent Irish companies, which have kept the claims of their policy-holders foremost before their minds, are the ones that are going to feel the hard knocks most. It is quite likely that some of them may go to the wall, and we will be told, when they do go to the wall, as we were told before on other matters, that you cannot make omelettes without breaking eggs, and that these are a couple of eggs that have been broken in the course of carrying order and rectitude into the insurance business in this country.
The Minister has defended the general principle. Would he now explain its special application? The section which provides for the granting of temporary licences for two kinds of insurance in the Saorstát says, in (b) (4) of Section 12, that the Minister may grant such licence if, but only if, he is satisfied that—
"such licence is required by such company only pending the amalgamation of such company with one or more other Saorstát Eireann companies and the transfer of the said other assurance business of such company to some other Saorstát Eireann company."
So far as I can understand that section, it provides that the Saorstát insurance company which is in the process of shedding its fire and general business under the provisions of this Bill must dispose of it to a Saorstát company.
Now I come to sub-section (7) of this Section 12, dealing with British or other foreign companies operating in this country for a licence under this Bill to carry on both classes of business, and I find the Minister—
"may grant such application if he is satisfied that such company complies with the conditions set forth in whichever of the said two next preceding sub-sections applies to such application, and that such licence is required by such company only pending the completion of arrangements for the transfer of the assurance business or businesses to which the application relates to some other assurance company or companies licensed under this Act to carry on such business or businesses."
So that it would appear that an Irish company finding itself under the obligation to dispose of its general business is confined to disposing of it to another Saorstát company. Whereas the British company requiring to dispose of its business can dispose of it either to a Saorstát company or to a foreign company licensed under this Bill. We can all foresee what is to happen. The British companies can transfer all their business to one company operating in that way, and they will probably do it by negotiations amongst themselves and do it on an agreed basis. The Saorstát companies cannot do that. There are only five such companies in this country, and any one of them which gets the wink from the Minister for Industry and Commerce to stand out can effectively collar the general business of all four others, and that company can do that at its own price. In many cases it may mean that solvent Irish companies will have to part with their fire and general business for virtually nothing at all. I want to ask the Minister why it is that this differentiation is made between the methods whereby a Saorstát Eireann company and a foreign company may dispose of that part of their business of which this Bill requires them to divest themselves.
Comment on this
I suggest that we deal with that aspect of the matter on Section 12, when we come to it.
Comment on this
If the Minister is going to take up the attitude that he resents inquiry and discussion——
Comment on this
I am merely suggesting that we should put things in their proper places. I suggest that these matters will more properly arise on Section 12 when we reach it.
Comment on this
The general question of dividing the insurance business has arisen on the definition section, and there are certain points that it is necessary to have cleared up. The first Committee Stage was taken for the purpose of allowing the Minister to reprint the Bill and include certain Government amendments, and there are still certain points that are rather obscure. I suggest that it will help the discussion materially if the points now raised by the Opposition are answered by the Minister, and if, having explained any blatant or patent obscurities, he adds that he wishes to postpone the remainder of the discussion on the point as clarified by his statement, then the Opposition will be very glad to accommodate him. Perhaps he will explain now the difference between the method prescribed for the foreign company of disposing of one half of its business and the method prescribed for the Irish company.
Comment on this
I would much prefer to deal with that aspect of the question when we come to Section 12, which is the relevant section.
Comment on this
On the section, I want to draw the Minister's attention to the definition of the word "policy" that appears in the Bill at the foot of page 7. The definition as it stands is extremely comprehensive and would almost, if not quite, go to the point of saying that you can have a policy of assurance effected by word of mouth or even by conduct; in fact, the definition goes so far as to say that you can have such a policy provided the evidence is in some document. It was my intention to put down an amendment to this definition, but, owing to the rush, it was not in time. I am drawing the Minister's attention to this matter now in order that he may have it examined. In the Act of 1909 there is no comprehensive definition of the expression "policy of assurance." There are a number of definitions of various kinds of policies, such as policy on human life, and that as defined in Section 30, paragraph (a) of the 1909 Act, and in paragraph (b) there is also something else which is deemed to be included in the expression "policy." How do these two definitions fit in with the definition in this Bill? That is one point.
The second point is this, and it is the real fundamental point. I submit to the Minister that the complete terms of the contract of assurance, whatever that may be, should be within the four walls of the document itself; that the document which constitutes a policy of assurance, whether on life or in connection with any other class of insurance should speak for itself, and both the policy-holder and the company issuing the policy should be in a position to determine their respective rights and liabilities by reference only to the document itself. The definition clause here would enable people to bring in acts or conduct or words spoken prior to the making of the alleged contract of assurance, or even subsequent to the contract, because the definition of "policy" provides that it will include a document which is evidence of a contract of assurance made verbally or arising from conduct.
I find it a little difficult to understand the necessity for such a wide definition of "policy" there, and I submit that the Minister ought to adopt the definition of "policy" that is in the Stamp Act. It is the definition used for revenue purposes. It is a very simple definition and would include everything that ought to be included. I cannot see any reason why acts of the parties not put into writing at the time of the making of a contract of assurance should in any way affect the interpretation of the contract or the rights and liabilities of the parties to the contract. Neither do I see any reason why the conduct of the parties should be considered relevant in any way to a contract which ought to be entirely in writing. Contracts of assurance for small or great sums are of importance to the parties concerned and it is of paramount importance that the policy-holder should know what his rights and liabilities are. He can only know that by looking at what is in writing. If the law ultimately is determined by this House to be that the conduct of the parties or something said or done prior to or subsequent to the making of the contract is taken into consideration then an element of grave uncertainty will be introduced. Will the Minister give us the reason why these words were brought into the definition of the word "policy"?
Comment on this
Deputy Costello's point, I take it, is mainly directed against the words "or acts or words".
Comment on this
The definition of "policy" includes a document which is evidence of a contract of assurance made verbally or arising from conduct. The point at which evidence other than a document comes in is in the second line, in the words "or acts or words". I am not disposed to quarrel with the Deputy when he states that the definition is fairly wide. It is wide. There may be considerations which justify having a wide definition such as is here. I am, however, in possession of an entirely open mind on the point. It is, perhaps, not unusual, if very rare, to have insurance effected by means of a conversation, verbally, even on occasion by a telephone communication. Whether we should have that verbal contract brought within the definition of the word "policy" here is a very doubtful point and I am disposed to think that on the balance it is better not to have it and to keep the evidence of the existence of the policy confined to a document, as the Deputy suggests.
Perhaps if the Deputy would leave the matter over until the next stage, and if he cares to introduce another amendment then, I will undertake to give consideration to whatever definition he suggests. In the meantime I will myself be examining the possibility of contracting the definition. I am anxious to have as little ambiguity as possible, and particularly in this section of the Bill where definitions are set out. On that account my sympathies are entirely with his point of view to have the words "or acts or words" taken out. I will be disposed, therefore, to consider sympathetically whatever amendment is suggested in that respect.
Comment on this
I am obliged to the Minister for his consideration of the points I have put forward. I would like him, in regard to the matters I have mentioned, to consider, having regard to any advice that he may get from his legal advisers, whether it would be advisable to make an expressed prohibition against any contract of insurance unless it is in writing. There is an old saying that it is better for the law to be certain than to be just. Therefore, I think that the liabilities and rights of parties to any alleged contract of assurance should be evidenced by a document. It is much better for the parties to it that that should be so. I will adopt the Minister's suggestion.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 8 and 12 deal with the laying on the Table, and with the annulment or approval of regulations. Amendment No. 12 is somewhat more detailed than amendment No. 8. I suggest that amendments Nos. 8 and 12 might be debated together. Separate decisions can be given if claimed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:—
At the end of the section to add the words "but no regulation made by the Minister shall become operative unless and until it is laid before, and approved by, Dáil Eireann."
The purpose of Section 8 is to reestablish, in regard to this Bill, the practice which is in process of being slowly whittled away. Originally Parliament did not delegate its functions to make law to anybody, but with the growing complexity of legislation Parliament has delegated certain of its duties to administrative Departments of Government for the purpose of clearing up ambiguities which may have been left in an Act as it left the Oireachtas, or of providing for any unforeseen contingencies in accordance with the general principle underlying the Act of Parliament. But Parliament has never gone so far as to divest itself of all authority in regard to such regulations. Originally it required that such regulations would lie on the Table and be recommended by Ministers to the House within a given time, and that the House would then approve of them or reject them. If the House approved of them, nothing done under them to the date that the House rejected them would be held subsequently to be invalid. The next stage was that the bureaucratic machine imposed upon Parliament a scheme whereby when any such regulations were laid upon the Table they, within a given time, became law unless a resolution was moved by somebody in the Parliament to reject the regulations. We are at that stage now. This Bill proposes to go a step further. Section 5 says that:
The Minister may by order make regulations in relation to any matter or thing referred to in this Act as prescribed or to be prescribed, and for the prescription of which no other provision is made by this Act.
I want to reintroduce the principle that such regulations must lie upon the Table and get the approval of Parliament. As my amendment stands, I require the Minister to lay every regulation on the Table of the House, and to provide that the regulation will not become operative unless the House has adopted it. That is to go back to the pure doctrine of parliamentary government. But if the Minister indicates his readiness to follow the existing practice, that is, to leave the regulations made under this Bill on the Table for 21 days and to allow them to become law in the event of no resolution being passed rejecting them, I would be prepared to accept that compromise.
Comment on this
Whatever case the Deputy may have had for moving similar amendments to other Bills, I think he has no case here. The only matters to be prescribed under this Bill are matters of form and procedure. If the Deputy examines the Bill carefully he will find that there is nothing in the Bill to be prescribed which can in any sense be deemed to be a delegation of legislative powers from the Dáil to the Minister. In Section 3 the actuary's qualifications are to be prescribed; in Section 11, the form and manner of applications for assurance licences and the fees payable; in Section 16, the form of assurance licence; in Section 19 the form and manner of the application for the alteration or revocation of assurance licences; in Section 63 the form of consent for a transfer from one company to another; in Section 67 the fee to be paid in reference to disputes. These are all matters of administration only, and it is not necessary, I think, to adopt this procedure of having regulations laid before the Dáil, and, therefore, capable of being anulled here. There is nothing in this Bill which confers on the Minister any wide powers to act by regulation. I am glad the Deputy has been making up the history of the tendency to delegate powers. I presume that he has been reading the recently published report of the British Committee on the subject.
Comment on this
I have been reading the recently published letter of Messrs. Morgan on the question of bureaucracy, but I shall pass away from that. I will certainly challenge a division on this in order to avoid establishing a precedent. If the Minister's remarks were well founded, and that it were true that nothing but purely administrative matters arise in connection with this section, I would still oppose it, because it is introduced here by the bureaucratic mind in order to establish a precedent on which it will be able to build a further edifice of bureaucracy, designed to take away from this House, still more and more, its authority.
I can hear the Minister, or his successor, inspired by the bureaucracy behind them saying, in connection with some Bill, "but there is a provision in the Insurance Bill giving the right to make regulations without any obligation of laying them on the Table; there is nothing new in this procedure." I can imagine the then occupant of the Minister's office expressing amazement at some protests against a Bill giving general power to the bureaucrats to make law by regulation, because he will say "we got that power in the Insurance Bill and no harmful results ensued." The Minister says that these are purely administrative matters. There is the regulation prescribing the form of licence. Does that include the conditions?
Comment on this
The Minister now says that it cannot. I can very well imagine that if the Minister wanted to include conditions, over and above the conditions envisaged by the Bill, they might be worked in within this power of prescribing the form. But the Minister is entitled to prescribe the fees. Let us suppose that the Minister wants to stop any additional licence being issued hereafter, is there anything to prevent him from prescribing a fee of £1,000,000? That is not impossible. I am sorry that there is no representative on the Labour Benches at the moment. I know a trade union which prescribes a fee of £30 before you can be registered a member of it, not, I agree, in order to get the £30, but in order to prevent persons registering that it does not want admitted to that particular craft.
Suppose an insurance company wants to admit no one else into the business, why not prescribe a fee of £1,000,000 on any application for a licence? That would make the insurance business a closed borough. The Minister might prescribe by regulation anything he desires. I do not know whether the process of reductio ad absurdum is a good method of making the House understand the position. There is no reason why the Minister should not prescribe that the actuary should be a man of red beard and white eyebrows. The Minister could prescribe certain professional qualifications which would point out the individual he wanted, and this House would have no particular right in the matter at all, because the Minister would have the right to make these orders without submitting them to the House. The Minister might reply that the matter could be raised on his Estimate. Yes, but that would be a year or nine months after the regulations came into force, and after the man with the red beard and the white eyebrows had got the job and had been doing what the Minister wanted him to do from the date of his appointment.
I would indicate to the Minister another objection to this provision in this way. The devil we know is bad enough but the devil we do not know might be much worse. After all, other people who may be the Minister's successors will have to administer this Bill. The Minister gives me no confidence whatever, but his successors might command less of my confidence. I strongly object to any such powers being put in the Minister's hands. I urge upon the Minister that he should not make himself responsible for advising this House to abandon its right to pass judgment upon any regulation he makes affecting legislative rights of the citizens of this country. That is what he is asking us to do here. He is not entitled to get powers of this kind. I do not see why he should be entitled to supersede the powers of the Oireachtas. I do not see why he should claim powers to make regulations in regard to anything and everything he likes. The Minister is trying to get complete and irrevocable control over Irish insurance for all time. That means State socialism, and the Minister is certainly moving in that direction. He has tried to get these powers over flour, over factories, and over several industries. In my opinion he is trying to get power by regulations over Irish insurance business and to control that business for all time. I object to this most barefaced effort which the Minister is making to secure that power.
Comment on this
This section does not set a new precedent, nor is Deputy Dillon a pioneer defending democracy against the exercise of such powers. If he reads the British Blue Book recently issued, he will see that this procedure has been followed since the time of Henry VIII.
Comment on this
It has long been the policy of the Minister to defend himself by covering himself with the folds of the flag of Cumann na nGaedheal, but this is the first time I have seen him trying to shelter himself under the folds of the Union Jack. Are we to tolerate every crime because a precedent is set for it by the British Government?
Comment on this
I repeat the argument that because the Minister has wrapped the Union Jack round him, and is proposing that we should follow British policy, I am not prepared to trust him.
Comment on this
I strongly support the amendment, and I do so on the general principle that Deputy Dillon has enunciated. I do not intend at this stage to enter into the Government's tendency towards bureaucracy as evidenced in the last few years. I hope at an early stage to give the House an opportunity of discussing these matters with appropriate procedure. But my point of view is that the Bill is bad, as well on general principles as in its tendency towards bureaucracy. I do not see why the ordinary procedure of laying regulations before the House cannot be adopted here.
Comment on this
I take Section 11. The Minister apparently overlooked that section when he told the House that matters prescribed under Section 11 are merely matters of form. These matters of form may involve people in criminal proceedings, and that certainly is not a matter of form. Subsection (2) of Section 11 provides not merely that the Minister may prescribe the form and manner in which application for an insurance licence should be made, but should state the class or classes of assurance business which the assurance company making such application proposes to carry on, together with such other particulars as may be prescribed.
Comment on this
Precisely, by these very regulations which, unless the Minister changes his position, will enable him to put a complete catechism to any person or company applying for such insurance licence. He may ask any questions, relevant or irrelevant to the subject matter of the licence, and any replies that may possibly be misleading may be the subject matter of criminal proceedings. Anything which may lead to criminal proceedings is, in my submission, no formality. These are very wide powers that the Minister proposes to take. He does not propose the form in which the application for a State licence must be made or the class of information that may be given on application. He proposes to give himself power to ask any questions, whether about the colour of the eyes of the employees or any other notion that the Minister may take into his head. If any person refuses to give information as to the colour of the eyes, or gives any information that may be misleading, that person shall be guilty of a criminal offence. As I say, anything that leads to criminal proceedings is no formality. Deputy Dillon already drew attention to the fact that by subsection (7) the Minister may prescribe the fee to be charged, and that the due payment of such fee shall be a condition precedent to the entertainment of the application by the Minister. The very fact that the Minister has power to prescribe the fee——
Comment on this
With the consent of the Minister for Finance, in whom Deputy Bourke has so much confidence.
Comment on this
Deputy Bourke may have more confidence in the Minister for Finance than in the Minister for Industry and Commerce, but I have no confidence in either. They are both engaged in the same conspiracy.
Comment on this
Whether the Minister likes that kind of flattery or not, the fact remains that he has taken power to prescribe the fee without so far having given any indication whatever as to what the amount of the fee will be. I propose to raise that matter when we come to Section 11. I only touch on it now because it is relevant to this discussion. We do not know what the amount of the fee is that may be prescribed. It may be prohibitive and of such a nature that only very wealthy companies could afford to pay it, but it is a condition precedent to the granting of the licence. I think the people of this country are entitled, through their representatives in this Dáil, to protest against such a position as that. Once this section is passed there is no machinery in the Dáil for the introduction of a Private Bill by which the amount of the licence duty charged by the Minister could be reduced or effectively reduced.
I submit that these are very cogent reasons why the normal and proper procedure, in our view, should be followed under this section and the regulations to be made by the Minister be placed on the Table of this House, where, if they require it, they may be criticised or, if necessary, set aside, but where, at least, they should be made public. There is no obligation, as things stand at present, to make these regulations public. They may be made and, like some regulations which have been made by Departments, nobody may know anything about them until they find themselves prosecuted under their provisions.
Comment on this
They can only be prosecuted for making false statements on the prescribed form, and, therefore, before there could be any prosecution there must be at least knowledge.
Comment on this
A person may be dragged before a district justice for something he has stated on a prescribed form which is misleading in the view of the Minister. He may be dragged before a district justice without having heard of it.
Comment on this
The Deputy suggested that somebody could be prosecuted under regulations the existence of which he had not heard of. I say they must be made on the prescribed form and presented to the Department in the prescribed manner before any question of prosecution could arise.
Comment on this
Is that the only argument the Minister is able to give in favour of the retention of these powers? Can he answer any of the arguments put forward by Deputy Dillon or myself?
Comment on this
I do not think I ever introduced a Bill here in which I asked for less powers in respect of the making of regulations than under this Bill.
Comment on this
I say they are not. Are we to take it that the Minister is not going to give any reasons?
Comment on this
I am asking the Dáil to say that it does not want to waste time discussing on some sections of the Bill such matters as the form and the manner in which an application of one kind or another shall be made; to say that these things can be done by administrative regulations, as they have been done since the time of Henry VIII and are done at present by all Parliaments in all countries. I am quite certain that, despite the Deputy's lack of confidence in the integrity of the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, he will have at least sufficient wisdom to see that he does not use these powers for the purpose of imposing upon any citizen an obligation which that citizen is unable to carry out.
Comment on this
I wish to press the matter. As is well known, the Minister is a past master at the art of making vague, general statements. He has made one of them now—that Parliaments in all parts of the world from the time of Henry VIII did this sort of thing. I put it to the Minister that he had not directed his attention to this fact when he told us that he did not wish the House to waste time in discussing matters of form. Surely, if he does not accept Deputy Dillon's amendment, he ought at least to accept the suggestions contained in amendment No. 12—that these regulations come into force automatically unless they are set aside subsequently by a motion in the House. Surely, that is a matter that ought to commend itself to the Minister, if his only reason for not wishing to concede what Deputy Dillon or the mover of the other amendment seeks is to ask the House not to waste time on matters of form. The House will not waste any time on matters of form. If any of these regulations which are made seriously affect companies carrying on business, it ought to be within the right of a Deputy to direct public attention to these matters by discussion in the Dáil. If this power is taken by the Minister, there will be no opportunity of directing public attention other than the method I have indicated.
Comment on this
I observe that we have moved out into the continent of Europe. We are told that not only has the British House of Commons done this, but every Parliament in Europe. I often thought the Minister had a good deal of affinity with Hitler.
Comment on this
That is apparently what the Minister was forgetting—that the countries to which he turns for support are countries which are progressing towards the happy day when there is no Parliament. Can it be possible that this suggestion has arisen out of the Minister's sub-conscious mind, and that he is thinking that the happy day might dawn here when there will be no Parliament, no obligation to answer awkward questions? I submit that that is what is at the back of this whole proposal. The Minister does not want to be bothered by Parliaments. He thinks it is waste of time to discuss matters of this kind in a democratic Parliament; that it ought to be done by regulation by intelligent bureaucrats such as he represents. We take a different view. We believe that you, Sir, have some useful function, that the Chair is valuable. We believe that the institutions for which we stand are worth something. The Minister does not share our view. We invite the members of the Fianna Fáil Party to go into the Division Lobby and endorse the Minister's pious hope that the methods of Hitler and Mussolini may be given free play here.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 9, 10 and 11 propose the setting up of a Fund for the Compensation or Pension of assurance employees. Amendments Nos. 24 (d), 36 (f), 77, 78 and 80 also deal with the question of compensation. As duplication does not make for orderly debate, I suggest that the wide principle of compensation might be decided on amendment No. 9. The decision on amendment No. 9 should govern amendments Nos. 10, 11, 24 (d) and 36 (f). Decisions might be taken on amendments Nos. 77, 78 and 80 without debate later on. Some of those amendments are really subsidiary to amendments Nos. 9, 10 and 11, which stand in the name of Deputy Fionan Lynch.
SECTION 6.
The following amendments were on the Order Paper:—
9. Before Section 6 to insert a new section as follows—
(1) The Minister shall keep a separate fund (in this Act referred to as the Fund) to be called and known as the Assurance Employees' Compensation and Pension Fund and shall maintain and manage such fund in accordance with this Act.
(2) There shall be paid into the fund—
(a) all fees payable by agents under the provisions of this Act; and
(b) all moneys payable by foreign companies into the fund under the provisions of this Act.
(3) All compensation and pensions payable under this Act shall be paid out of the fund.
10. Before Section 6 to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) Any sums standing to the credit of the Fund which are not required to meet current expenditure shall be transferred to the Minister for Finance and by him credited to an account (in this Act referred to as the Account) to be called and known as the Assurance Employees' Compensation and Pensions Investment Account.
(2) Any sums standing to the credit of the Account shall be invested and kept invested at the discretion of the Minister for Finance on behalf of the Fund in all or any of the following ways, that is to say, in the purchase of any stock, fund or security in which trustees are authorised by Section 18 of the Adaptation of Enactments Act, 1922 (No. 2 of 1922) to invest trust funds, or in the purchase of any stocks, shares or securities the principal and interest of which are guaranteed under statutory authority by the Government of Saorstát Eireann, and any interest received from such investment shall be credited to the Account.
(3) If at any time the moneys in the Fund are insufficient to meet current liabilities the Minister for Finance shall out of the Account issue to the Fund such sums as may be required for the purpose of discharging such liabilities.
11. Before Section 6 to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) The accounts of the fund shall be kept in such form as the Minister, with the approval of the Minister for Finance, shall approve or direct.
(2) The accounts of the Account shall be kept in such form as the Minister for Finance shall approve or direct.
(3) Within one year after the expiration of every year of account, the accounts kept in pursuance of this section for that year shall be submitted for audit to the Comptroller and Auditor-General, and when examined and certified by him shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9. Amendments Nos. 9, 10 and 11 really form one amendment, and they would, if accepted, be Sections 6, 7 and 8 of the Act. The object of these amendments is to provide a fund which will be available for the payment of compensation to employees of Irish insurance companies who may become or who almost certainly will become redundant as a result of the Bill becoming law. I hold that the setting up of a fund as provided for here is the only practical way of providing for the compensation of those employees. Amendment No. 9 provides for the moneys which will come into the fund, those moneys to come from licence fees to be paid by agents, and a contribution to the fund from the life income of ordinary industrial or foreign insurance companies. The Minister has said, and it has been reiterated from all sides of the House, that the object of the Bill itself is to secure policy holders—to secure better benefits for them if possible, and at any rate to see that the investments they make when they take out policies will be safeguarded. The only way by which you can increase the benefits that Irish companies will give is by a reduction of their overhead expenses —their ratio of expenses, as it is called. The ratio of expenses of the Irish companies is naturally much higher at present than that of the English or foreign companies which are far longer in existence. In the early stages of those foreign companies their ratio of expenses was probably at least as high as the present ratio of the Irish companies. The decreasing of the ratio of expenses of the Irish companies will obviously necessitate a reduction in staffs. There is no other way that I can see by which the ratio of expenses will be reduced, and it is desirable that it should be reduced by about 15 per cent. to 20 per cent.
At the present moment, I understand there are about 1,500 whole-time employees of the Irish companies. If the amalgamation proposed in this Bill is carried through, in about five or six years' time that number should be reduced to something between 500 and 600. That will mean that something in the neighbourhood of 1,000 persons, who are now engaged in the insurance business in the employment of the Irish offices, will become redundant. The Bill makes no provision whatever for these employees. There is no provision made for them by way of compensation or anything of that kind. Now, the fund, as I have said, is made up from two sources. I have no doubt that the agents of the companies will gladly pay a licence fee towards that fund, because of the benefits that will accrue to them from it. Apart from making provision for compensation, Section 9 provides that this fund should also form a permanent superannuation fund for insurance employees. I take it also that the contribution from the foreign companies—that is, 2½ per cent. of the gross premium income from life and industrial assurance—will be strongly opposed. I think, however, when we are dealing with insurance here, that it would be just to give the Irish companies that measure of a handicap from their foreign competitors.
I have already said that these foreign companies have been in existence for a long time and that their ratio of expenses, with huge permanent incomes, is considerably lower than that of the Irish companies, and I think that they could very well afford this 2½ per cent. contribution to these agents and insurance employees without in any way passing it on to the policy-holders. As it is, with these companies there is a very great variation in the ratio of expenses. For instance, for the year 1934, the ratio of expenses of the Prudential was 23.34; of the Pearl, 31.04; and of the Refuge, 34.68. These are three of the biggest companies operating here, and that shows that there was a difference of 11 per cent. between two of these-companies in their ratio of expenses, and yet the benefits to the policy-holders were identical in all the cases. I might say, that they are all identical in this, too, that, whereas these companies, operating in this country, pay no bonus to their policy-holders here, they do pay a bonus to their policy-holders in Great Britain and Northern Ireland. The policy-holders in this country pay exactly in accordance with the same tables as the policy-holders across the Channel and in Northern Ireland, but these companies do not treat their Saorstát policy-holders as equitably as they treat their policy-holders elsewhere. I think that, in those circumstances, and especially in view of that differentiation in the manner in which they treat their Saorstát policy-holders, it would be quite legitimate to tax them to the extent of the 2½ per cent. proposed in this amendment of mine, or in a later amendment, so that they may make that contribution to this fund which will provide for compensation for those persons who will lose their employment if and when this measure becomes law.
Comment on this
Deputy Lynch, evidently, is trying to do more than kill two birds with one stone with this series of amendments of his. Evidently he is trying to kill a whole flock of birds, but I am not quite sure which particular bird he is most anxious to get. He is proposing that we should set up a fund, the primary purpose of which is to provide pensions or compensation for employees of insurance companies, and he is proposing to constitute that fund by taxing the premium income of foreign companies and instituting a scheme for the registration of insurance agents. If I may suggest a doubt concerning his main purpose, I do so because I think he is less interested in setting up the fund than in the manner of constituting it, and that the tax on the income of the foreign companies, or the institution of a register of agents, is probably the principal objective at which he is aiming. I do not think we should provide, in this Bill, a fund under State control for the payment of pensions to persons employed in the insurance industry, any more than we have any such fund for the payment of pensions to persons employed in the transport industry or any other industry in respect of which as good a case, if not a better case, could be made out for the inauguration of a pension scheme. Neither do I think that we should provide in this Bill provisions for the compensation of any persons, employed by an insurance company, who may become disemployed in consequence of an amalgamation scheme approved by the Minister under Part V of the Bill.
There may, or there may not, be an amalgamation scheme—I think there will be—but if so I think the question of the disposal of the staffs of the amalgamating companies should be considered then, and not now. It may be considered preferable to deal with the problem of redundant staffs otherwise than by the payment of compensation in cash. In any event, I do not think we should impose, as the Deputy suggests in another amendment, upon the amalgamating companies a statutory obligation to provide that compensation in cash, because of the nature of employment in the insurance industry and the difficulties that might arise in consequence. We have had this question of the institution of a register of agents considered here before, and representations have been made to me by parties interested in the institution of such a scheme. These parties, however, in my opinion, have consistently refused to face up to the main difficulties that arise in that connection, and the principal objection to it is the difficulty which the Minister for Industry and Commerce, under any circumstances, would have in determining who should or should not be entitled to practise as an insurance agent. Neither do I think should we have imposed by this Bill a tax on the premiums of foreign companies. If there is any reason, other than an insurance reason, for that tax, then it should be imposed by a different kind of measure altogether. There is no insurance reason for it in my opinion.
If it were considered good policy to prevent the operation here of foreign insurance companies, the Bill would have so provided, but, having decided that it is not possible in present circumstances to prohibit foreign insurance companies from carrying on business here, I do not think we should create that position by roundabout methods; by the introduction in the Bill of provisions applying to foreign companies which would make it extremely improbable that they would, if not impossible for them to, carry on. We have decided that it is desirable in present circumstances to allow foreign companies to continue to do insurance business here. If that point of view is accepted by the Dáil, then I think the Dáil must logically accept the consequential view, that they should not be subject to any differential tax or restrictions which would impose obligations on them that did not apply to other persons engaged in insurance business, in consequence of which they might decide not to carry on, or which might so operate as to make it impossible for them to do so. I am, therefore, opposed to the Deputy's proposal on all three points. I do not think we should constitute such a fund, and even if we had a different attitude in this respect, and decided that such a fund should be created, I do not think it should be constituted by the methods which the Deputy suggests. The setting up of an insurance agent register would be so difficult as to make it foolish to attempt it and probably in the circumstances arising if it were established we would have all sorts of allegations as to the manner in which the Minister exercised these powers which the Deputy proposes should be conferred upon him. Certainly it would be impossible for the Minister to carry out the Deputy's proposal completely without very great difficulty indeed. Neither should we adopt the Deputy's suggestion of a tax of 2½ per cent. on the premiums of foreign companies.
Therefore, I am in the position that I must resist the amendment. May I say that in doing so I have given considerable attention to the redundancy in insurance employment which exists at the present time. As I pointed out during the course of the Second Reading discussion, there are too many people trying to get employment in the insurance industry, and any improvement in the organisation of the industry is bound to result in certain redundancy of staff. I do not think that that surplus staff need constitute an insoluble problem. It would be a problem for a time, but would then disappear. There are various ways of dealing with that problem, but I do not think we should commit ourselves concerning it on this Bill in the manner the Deputy suggests by the payment of compensation in cash. I think there are preferable ways of dealing with it, and that we can consider the matter more satisfactorily when proposals for amalgamation actually arise, and when the details are under consideration. At that period, as I indicated in the past, it would be my intention that employees of the amalgamating company would be fairly dealt with.
Comment on this
It is very interesting to hear the Minister when he reiterates the fact that he and his Government are committed to the principle that foreign companies can carry on their business here without differentiation between them and Irish companies. It is also interesting to know that he failed to appreciate the case put up on behalf of a register of agents. I submit that has nothing to do with the series of amendments we are discussing, because while the Ceann Comhairle asked the House to consider the principle of compensation, the Minister carefully refrained, in any portion of his speech, from touching in any way on the principle of whether or not employees in an insurance company, whether British or foreign, should be compensated if they were deprived of their livelihood as a result of the operation of this Bill. Personally, I am against the principle of a register of agents. But I submit that has nothing to do with the principle of compensation, of which I am in favour. May I remind the Minister that on the Second Reading of this Bill he made this statement:
"And it is my intention that persons who are dependent for their livelihood on insurance employment and are affected by this measure will be fairly dealt with."
He prefaced that statement by the remark that much of the criticism of the Insurance Bill then being discussed had centred around the question of staff and he gave the assurance I have just quoted. The whole object of this series of amendments which we are discussing is to ensure that by some means or other these employees will be, as the Minister said, fairly dealt with. I take it that the scheme put forward by Deputy Fionan Lynch is not one to which he is particularly wedded, but that he is wedded to the principle that the employees should be compensated in some way. The Deputy merely suggested that as a way in which it could be achieved. It would appear that all Parties take the view stated in the House on the Second Reading, and are wedded to the principle of compensation. The Minister said that the employees would be fairly dealt with. To-day, when discussing this and the other amendments with which we are dealing, he dealt with details, referring to the register of agents, a tax on foreign companies, and every other point he could think of, but he never once mentioned the principle of compensation. He did say that there might or might not be an amalgamation scheme between the Irish companies, and that if there was he would see that the redundant employees were fairly dealt with, or words to that effect. That was the only contribution I have been able to extract from the statement he made, and he prefaced it by saying that there might or might not be amalgamation.
Comment on this
I do not understand the Minister's point, that it will never arise. Supposing amalgamation is not possible, will there not be far more employees put out, I suggest, than by the provisions of the Bill? If amalgamation does not arise what is going to happen to the companies? Are they to be refused a licence and the whole lot put out? The Minister knows far better than I do what the views of the Irish companies are on amalgamation, and surely he cannot avoid the principle being discussed by a mere passing reference to amalgamation. Is he or is he not going to carry out the promise made on the Second Reading, that persons dependent for their livelihood on insurance employment who are affected by this measure will be fairly dealt with? If he is, how is he going to carry that out? We have had a Second Reading, and a Committee Stage, and we are now at a further Committee Stage, and so far there is no indication from the Government of their intentions with regard to the employees.
Comment on this
I am surprised to hear the Minister express the view that there is very little likelihood of a redundancy arising from the passage of this measure.
Comment on this
I would be more surprised if I read in the daily newspapers a statement by the Minister that there was not a necessity for making provision for the payment of compensation. I should like the Minister to carry his mind back to the period when the railway amalgamation policy was before the House during the life of the last Government, and during the life of this Government when the policy of amalgamation of national health societies was brought forward by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health. Then, as a result of a general expression of opinion from all Parties represented in this House, it was agreed that reasonable compensation should be provided for those who lost their employment as a result of the passage of these measures. I have been given information which I believe to be correct that in one town in County Tipperary there are at the present time 12 insurance agents collecting £60, weekly premiums. Does the Minister think, that after the passage of this measure, employment will still be found for these 12 people in Tipperary who are in receipt of a weekly wage——
Comment on this
This Bill pre-supposes the absorption or the amalgamation of existing companies. Otherwise, we are wasting our time here. If that is not the object, what is the reason for bringing in this Bill? Anybody who has made any study of the matter knows perfectly well that redundancy will arise, and if redundancy arises as a result of the absorption of some companies, then I think in fairness to the people who will be deprived of their employment, compensation should be provided for them. I do not agree with the detailed proposals put forward by Deputy Lynch as to the way in which the money is to be raised, but I think that is a minor matter as compared with the principle that compensation should be provided for those who are rendered redundant and that a section should be inserted in this Bill for that purpose. I would strongly urge the Minister to reconsider his attitude and to remember how eloquent he and other Deputies were when they were in Opposition in favour of this very same proposal in other Acts. I would also ask him to remember that since the Government came into office the Ministry, as a result of pressure from all parts of the House, agreed to provide compensation under the National Health Insurance Act for agents and others who lost their employment as a result of the coming into operation of that measure.
Comment on this
Consistency makes debate in this House a good deal simpler than it otherwise would be, but I find it very hard to follow the line of reasoning which the Minister has pursued to lead him to the axiom that once you have agreed that foreign companies may continue to function here, you must stipulate that they must function on exactly equal terms with companies carried on by Irish nationals.
Comment on this
I understood the Minister to say that once we made up our minds on the principle that British and European companies were allowed to be carried on here, we were bound by the view that we could not impose upon them any burden which we did not ask an Irish company to carry.
Comment on this
I understood him to say any burdens which were not imposed on Irish companies. If he said that, it would be rather difficult to reconcile it with the attitude of the Government in regard to the tobacco industry where he deliberately imposed burdens on a foreign company which firms of Irish origin were not called upon to bear. If the Minister hesitates to accept that doctrine, we shall pass from it. I want at this juncture to register an emphatic protest against a principle that was first enunciated in this House by the President of the Executive Council, namely that you cannot have omelettes without breaking eggs. I do not consider that this Legislature is entitled to smash the whole livelihood and family establishment of a citizen of this State without compensating that individual for his loss. If the community makes up its mind that it wants to establish a new order in any branch of the nation's life, the community has the right to do it within certain limitations, but it should be remembered by this House that while we are omnipotent in the legislative sphere, there is a law higher than any law we pass, a law which binds and restricts us in our legislation, and that is the law of natural justice.
I say that this House has no right to smash a man's means of livelihood, to break up his family and put him on the street in order to accommodate the remainder of the community. I do not believe that any act of this House which confiscates a man's property has any validity. We have the power and we have the right, where the community good demands it, compulsorily to acquire the property of any citizen provided we give him fair compensation for what the community takes from him. We have no right to take his property and to console him with the reflection that he is one of the eggs that had to be smashed in order to make our omelette. If compulsory amalgamations take place under this Bill, these amalgamations will take place because we compel them. They may result in men being deprived of their means of livelihood, men who have built up in their own small way a very valuable goodwill and a very valuable business——
Comment on this
The Minister will allow me to say what I have to say, and he can then rebut me afterwards. Take an agent who goes out in the field, to build up a book for an industrial insurance company. He may have a rival in the particular area in which he is operating. They engage in the friendly rivalry of trade, each man acquiring his own clear debit. The debit which that individual has built up for his company is that individual's little business and his livelihood depends upon it. Now if we are to compel amalgamation amongst the two companies who employ these two men——
Comment on this
The Minister has powers under certain sections of the Bill to make a company to get out or to amalgamate.
Comment on this
The Minister has power under the Bill to compel a company to wind up or to amalgamate.
Comment on this
He has power to compel any company, which has not complied with the standards of solvency set up by this Bill, to amalgamate. I propose to make my case and the Minister will have abundant parliamentary time to rebut it, but it is disorderly, and it is not helpful, continually to interrupt. These two men who have built up their respective debits find that, by the operation of a statute of this House, their companies are amalgamated. One of the primary purposes of the amalgamation is to make it possible for the work these two men were doing in the past to be done by one in the future so that solvency, according to the Ministerial standard, would be established for the amalgamated company. From the community point of view that may be a mighty good thing, something for which everybody in this House would stand, something into which this House would conscientiously go and carry through, but what I am asking is this, that if that community good is to be achieved, an individual engaged in a perfectly legitimate enterprise, such as an insurance agent, will get such compensation as an independent tribunal would adjudge to be fair and honest for what he has lost. We are in this House prone to get detached from the ordinary everyday life of the people who live around us. It is all very well for us to take a lofty view of each problem, but we ought to think of the situation that will arise if one of the victims of this legislation happens to be our next-door neighbour. If a man who has two or three children, who is buying a house and who has made certain commitments on the basis of his earning capacity, is informed some morning that that earning capacity has ceased, his only recourse is to unemployment assistance. I ask the House to bear in mind that we are dealing with insurance agents and that these are men who have no craft, men who are not skilled, in a wide sense, and who cannot readily pass from one employment to another. They have, probably, no professional qualifications. They have, almost certainly, no trade qualifications and they are left high and dry. It is very hard for the simplest manual labourer to reconcile himself to going on unemployment assistance or outdoor relief, but it is ten times harder for a man who has lived in moderately comfortable circumstances and has accustomed his family to considerable amenities, to tell them that they can have none of these in future and that he has to go out and seek work as a day labourer. In rural Ireland, the circumstances of which I am particularly familiar with in this regard, that is going to happen in respect of a number of agents in the event of the provisions of this Bill becoming effectively operative.
Comment on this
Does the Minister deny that in certain circumstances he can require a company to wind up or amalgamate?
Comment on this
Does the Minister deny that he can fix a company with notice that it must wind up by a certain date or amalgamate under a scheme to be approved by him?
Comment on this
The Minister has no power to wind up a company under the Bill. In the case of an insolvent company, the Minister has power to make application to the High Court.
Comment on this
Do not quibble any longer. I thought that was the point on which you were getting out.
Comment on this
The Minister knows that the case we make here is absolutely unanswerable and, for that reason, he desires to confuse it by irrelevant interruption. I put it to the Minister that under the Bill an individual may be obliged to deprive his family of what they had been accustomed to and what he had hoped to make permanently available for them. Speaking on behalf of the agents of rural Ireland, whose circumstances I know and understand, I say that some of them with whom I am personally acquainted will have no alternative but to go out and look for work as day labourers. Owing to their mode of life, bad day labourers they will make. They are not accustomed to heavy physical work and they will find themselves at a discount in the market for unskilled labour. I say that this House has no right to interfere in the lives of citizens in that way. I say that this House has no right to smash the lives of individual families in that way, and I say that there is an absolute obligation on us to provide reasonable compensation for those people if, for the common good, we have to deprive them of their existing means of livelihood. The Minister himself has accepted that principle because, speaking on the Second Stage of the Bill, he used these words:—
"It is my intention that persons who are dependent for their livelihoods on insurance employment and who are affected by this measure will be fairly dealt with."
All I ask is: what did the Minister mean by saying that? Surely, if he is going to repel a series of amendments designed to provide compensation for those persons to whom he himself referred—those persons who are "affected by this measure" and whose livelihood depends on insurance employment—the obligation is on him now to tell us what his plan is, because the only indication he has given us of what is in his mind gives rise to the gravest alarm in my mind. On the Second Stage of this Bill, I dealt with this question and used these words:—
"There is no fund available to the Irish insurance offices out of which displaced employees can be fairly compensated."
Deputy Davin referred to the fact that we accepted the principle of compensation in national health insurance legislation. We did, but let us be careful now lest we be carried too far by that analogy. There is no fund at the disposal of the Irish insurance companies to finance compensation. They have had an extremely difficult job to build up their businesses and a lot of people forget, in that connection, one of the most vital matters in respect of this whole problem. A lot of people are inclined to say, "Why is it, if British and Continental companies were able to build up huge reserves to meet emergencies of this kind, the Irish companies never did so?" The answer is one which ought to be present to the minds of Deputies— that the foreign companies built up their businesses during a period when there was virtually no State regulation. A great part of their reserves accrued from practices which were then legitimate in the narrow sense of the word.
Comment on this
The Minister is beginning to ramble. I do not mind the Minister interrupting me when he shows any degree of intelligence, but he has now started to ramble. Practices in operation in the early stages of the great insurance companies of the world, practices which are not now within the law and have not been within the law for the past 20 years, made it possible for them to build up very large reserves. The Irish companies were never able to build up these reserves, because they were all founded after very considerable reform in insurance law had been enacted. They built up their business under a comparatively stringent insurance code, with the result that they have no vast reserves out of which compensation of the kind we have in mind can be financed. I want to make the case that if the State butts in and breaks up a man's means of livelihood, then it is the obligation of the State to compensate him for it.
Comment on this
I do not want to go into a long discussion as to the constitution of the Irish National Health Insurance Society. The Deputy ought to know that that body is organised on a mutual basis and passes on any profits it makes in the form of statutory benefits to the insured parties. It was not designed to make a profit. There is no capital invested in it and it has nothing to do but administer the funds which come into its hands by way of premiums.
Comment on this
The Deputy says the State should pay compensation. Let him cite a case in which the State ever did pay compensation in these circumstances.
Comment on this
Let me tell the House why the Minister introduced it. He introduced it for the purpose of discussing irrelevancies in order to rebut an unanswerable argument.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy mention one case in which the State paid compensation under similar circumstances?
Comment on this
I say that, in the exist ing situation, the obligation is on the State to pay compensation and, when I have made that argument, the Minister can answer it.
Comment on this
I am not concerned with the case made by any other Deputy. I am pointing out that there is a danger in establishing too close an analogy between the National Health Insurance Society and the companies with whom we are dealing, because the plain fact is this, that if you apply the same compensation proposals to the Irish insurance companies that you applied to the national health insurance societies, you are going to burst all the Irish insurance companies. These are the facts: There are rights in the employees and there are obligations which it is our duty to place on the proper shoulders. My object in placing those obligations on the shoulders of the State is threefold. First, I believe the State is responsible and, therefore, the State should pay; secondly, I do not want to make any proposal to this House which will result not only in the legitimate compensation for the employees being jettisoned, but would also result in destroying the business at which the employees have to make their livelihood— that is to say, to wipe out the Irish insurance companies altogether. It would be a desperately irresponsible thing to adopt a scheme which would saddle the Irish companies with such proposals as would be almost impossible for them to meet. In the third place the reason why this proposal should commend itself to this House is this: We have had bitter experience of the general vague proposals which saddle the Exchequer with a liability the full extent of which it is very difficult to envisage, because it may go on and it may grow. But we know the full possible extent of the liability which this proposal will put upon the Exchequer. Its limit is the total number of persons employed at the present time by the Irish insurance industry. If the full staffs employed on Irish insurance were wiped out that would be the full limit of the responsibility on the Exchequer. In practice we know that it is to be very small indeed, and it is going to be very small for this reason—that while certain persons are going to lose their jobs many of the companies to be amalgamated will say that it is the common experience of insurance companies that the normal wastage in the staff is high. People pass out of employment, they get married, they get other jobs. There is a good deal of transitory employment and there may be other wastage. That consideration would have to be carefully examined. When the assessment of compensation comes to be made the insurance companies will say to themselves: "If we had to anticipate maintaining the staffs for ever we might have to be more trenchant in our returns, but we are anticipating that we are going to lose a certain part of our staff through normal wastage; it is better to retain a slight surplus of skilled operatives than to cut the staff down to the minimum that would be efficient at the moment of amalgamation and then in four or five years to find ourselves recruiting unskilled operatives to fill the vacancies that will arise through normal wastage and other causes." So that we may hope that everybody who from the strictly efficient point of view may be dispensed with, will not be dispensed with, and we may be certain that perhaps 50 per cent. of the employees who on the strict letter of efficiency would be cut out, will be retained and that all we have to deal with is the 50 per cent. that are going. When we come to examine their cases, some of these may be very young, just starting, and have very little claim at all upon the bounty of the State, because they will be equally adapted for employment elsewhere. We will find others to whom the change will be a hardship and they will require compensation to tide them over the period while they are equipping themselves for some other employment. A very small minority will become a charge upon the State, as we will have interfered with their earning their living at a period late in life for them. On the whole, taking everything into consideration, the liability from the State point of view is going to be extremely small, but the liability on the insurance company that is striving to keep itself on the strictest level of actuarial solvency might be intolerable. To refuse them any compensation would be a glaring and intolerable injustice, and so I very strongly urge on the House that it should insist that the Minister should, on the Report Stage, give a definite undertaking that some compensation scheme will be brought before this House to be financed by the Exchequer. I do not know on what amendment that is to be decided upon, but if it is decided upon this amendment I want to make it clear that I cannot agree with Deputy Lynch on the details of the scheme he suggests for dealing with the compensation fund. If some scheme of compensation is not brought forward I am prepared to vote against the section.
Comment on this
I am not, of course, entirely wedded to the scheme embodied in amendments Nos. 9, 10 and 11 to Section 6, but I am willing to let the scheme be settled on the proposals set out in amendment No. 9. Personally, I believe that this is the best method of going about it. I think it is absolutely impracticable that the Saorstát companies should have to be carrying compensation burdens that would be particularly unfair to them, burdens too which they would be quite incapable of carrying. It would also be unfair to ask the promoting company in the event of amalgamation to carry the burden of compensation to meet the matter of the redundant employees. I say that because they will have as a liability, first of all, the large sum that will be borrowed—£500,000—and I presume they will have to make arrangements for the repayment of that sum by principal and interest.
Comment on this
In that sense then it will be something on which they will have to pay interest.
Comment on this
Very well. If the Minister is satisfied that the promoting company can carry the burden I am prepared to leave it at that, but I consider it is entirely wrong for him to suggest that this 2½ per cent. on the foreign companies operating here is going to drive any of them out of the country. The figures as to the variation in the rate of expenses of these companies will give the House an idea of how this matter will operate. The expenses vary from 23.34 per cent. in the case of the Prudential to 38.26 per cent. in the case of the Royal Liver Friendly Society. Where there is such a variation in the routine of expenses of these companies paying exactly the same benefits to the policy-holders, I do not see how 2½ per cent. additional added to the routine expenses is going to make the slightest difference to them. I do not think that one of them would dream of leaving the profitable ground they have here if their operation costs had this 2½ per cent. added to them. When these companies differentiate between the treatment of policy-holders here and the treatment of policy-holders in Great Britain and Northern Ireland I do not think they would have anything to complain of if we gave that much advantage to the Saorstát companies as against them. The Minister can be very vague when he likes. He has stated that there are too many people in the insurance business. At the same time, he questions whether there will be any redundancy. He said that it depends only on whether or not there will be amalgamation and there may or may not be amalgamation; he hopes there will be. I think that inevitably there is going to be redundancy, if it is only because of the provision in the Bill for the partitioning of the life business from the general business. That in itself, to my mind, will create redundancy, and in that way you will have persons unemployed. If you enforce the provisions contained in Section 12 (4) (b)——
Comment on this
——in my opinion it will lead obviously to redundancy; there will be persons unemployed as a result of its operation. At the moment there are 1,500 whole-time employees in the Saorstát companies. It is estimated that if all the provisions of the Bill become law, if amalgamation becomes a fact, the number employed whole-time by the companies will be reduced to 600. No provision is made in the Bill for the 900 who will become redundant and who will lose their employment. The Minister tells us that it will not be an insoluble problem, that it will be only for a time and will ultimately disappear. But during the period when these people will be out of work what is going to happen to them? What provision is being made for the people who will be rendered unemployed? Some may be fortunate enough to get employment in other spheres and some of them may die, but for the vast majority what is the prospect? It must be remembered that as regards men engaged in insurance work over a number of years, when they reach the age of 40 years they are usually unfit for any other type of employment, and their position will be rendered very difficult when their means of livelihood is taken from them, as I foresee it will be under this Bill. Inevitably large numbers of them will become unemployed. If the principle of compensation in regard to these persons is enshrined in the Bill, I will be quite satisfied. I am not wedded to the actual words set down, although I still believe that they constitute the most practical way out. If there is any other way found of dealing with this matter along the lines I have suggested, it will meet with approval on this side of the House.
Comment on this
Let us be clear on the extent of the problem we are facing. The Minister pretends to believe that there will be no redundancy, or that there will be very slight redundancy. He seems to be agitated to-day at the thought that there is anywhere in this Bill a clause which may bring about redundancy. He told us on one occasion that there are far too many people in this business. I think his words were that there are too many people employed in the industry at the present time to permit of its being conducted on sound lines. He turns his back now on his Second Reading speech and he tries to avoid that aspect of it. There are three possible ways in which redundancy may be caused. He may present a petition for the winding-up of an insolvent company, in the first place. Secondly, amalgamation may take place with or without such modifications as the Minister may care to impose. Thirdly, as Deputy Lynch pointed out, the whole tendency of the Bill, with the partitioning of the life and industrial assurance business from every other type of assurance business drives towards amalgamation and ultimately towards redundancy.
If that is not certain, there are his own phrases when closing on the Second Reading, and I think he then accepted in the tenor of that speech the particular analogies put before him by Deputy Norton. Deputy Norton took the phrase used by Deputy Kennedy, that the management expense ratio was going to be forced down, as in England. A question was asked how it was done in England, and the answer in the main was by reduction of staff. In the main it will be that way here, too. The Minister may talk about not having so many companies running up expenditure here running after the same little bit of business. How did they get after that little bit of business? With their separate staffs, and the biggest economy that will be made through this measure will be on the staffs. I would personally hesitate to impose on the State any big burden by way of compensation, and I would hesitate if I thought the number of staff likely to be rendered redundant was going to be large. I do not know whether immediately it is going to be large. I believe that, as the years pass by, what would be the throwing of people in employment out of that employment will be met in another way, namely, that as the wastage occurs other people need not be recruited. It closes an avenue to employment, but it does not throw out of employment people already in. I do not think the problem is a very serious one in the sense that there is not going to be a very big number. The burden is not going to be a very heavy one.
Comment on this
It was a wise provision from the point of view of the people who became redundant. Take the case of the transport amalgamation and the people who were five years continuously engaged on the whole-time operation of certain vehicles. I think at a high level it would work out about £70.
Comment on this
I suggest there is a standard of compensation already set, and the Parliament of the Free State from time to time has accepted as a principle that when the State intervenes to cut down a field of employment for people who are already in a particular branch of employment, there should be compensation payable. That was done in the case of the Railways Act of 1924, the electricity undertaking arising out of the Shannon Development and the Road Transport Act of 1933. The principle was also observed when the bus companies were amalgamating and at the time of the National Health Insurance amalgamation.
We are asked who is to pay the compensation. I thought the Minister would have welcomed the proposal with regard to the 2½ per cent. on the foreign companies. I remember the Minister, when he was dining with the New Ireland Assurance Company, talking of these people as little alien outposts, hostile to the country's development, concerned only with the profits they could draw from the Saorstát business. Those were wild and woolly words; there was no semblance of truth in them at all, but yet they were words that the Minister thought fit to use on that occasion. I thought he would have welcomed Deputy Lynch's idea of putting a 2½ per cent. tax on them. Deputy Lynch was arguing in order to show that there might be something in the way of equalising the handicap under which the Irish companies suffer. It was a suggestion the Minister would have jumped at on another occasion.
I agree that it should not be put on any of the other companies; I do not think it should be shared by the companies; it should go on the State. There is no analogy with the other examples that have been suggested. Take the case of the electricity concern. A huge board was established, which was pretty nearly a State concern. It had very many of the attributes of a State concern. The only thing that prevented it being entirely a State concern was that it was thrown out at arm's length in order to permit people to run it in a commercial way. At the time of the railway amalgamation the argument was used that the railways could gain enormous sums by economies which were then being put before them, and it was a small thing to ask them in return to meet the compensation bill caused by the redundancy of certain men.
Comment on this
If it can be said that any company here is getting a monopoly it is a good argument, but without that there is no analogy.
Comment on this
I will wait until that point is reached. If it is, then I think there will be a great case for shifting the burden from the State to the monopolistic group. But let us wait until that time comes. I do not see that in the Bill or anywhere else. As regards the transport undertakings, there was the open statement in the House that what was aimed at was to hand over the carrying of passengers and goods on the roads to three companies so that there would be a monopoly within their own respective zones. If there was anything of that sort here, then I think the monopoly should bear its burden on its back, but there is no such thing here. The State is interfering here; it is shutting those people out of employment, and should meet the burden. The Minister told us there is nothing here enabling compulsory amalgamation. The tendency of the Bill is towards amalgamation. The whole intention of the Bill is towards that. Even if there was only in the Bill amalgamation of the type brought about by the goodwill of certain companies, then I think we should meet that and make proposals to that end. Deputies should remember that this House loses its grip on this measure once it passes from it. The Minister is not even going to prescribe the things that these amalgamated companies may do. He is allowed to make a movement in that direction to them, but this House will not hear of that or know what he is going to do with regard to redundancy, if redundancy is brought about by amalgamation.
The whole object of this is to drive towards a separation of business, to a better consolidation and to fewer hands in the insurance business. The Minister has told us that there are too many people employed in the industry at the present time to permit of its being conducted on sound lines. That is not in reference to amalgamation, but in regard to the generality of the Bill. The Minister envisages redundancy. So do we all. The difficulty I see about this measure is that one unfortunate tendency. I do not know what the country is exactly developing towards: whether it is making towards a certain goal with deliberation. We started in this country with a legal decision rather than by an Act of Parliament, so that we have the whole licensed trade made a sort of closed corporation as far as this House is concerned. In a variety of measures we have made transport closed. As far as the Minister is concerned in regard to certain industries, we are making these closed also. There are going to be certain closed boroughs in the future in which it will be as hard for anyone to get into as it was in the old days of the rigid guilds. I suppose the rest are going to be left to the unemployment insurance fund and the unemployment assistance fund. Here in this Bill we find the same tendency: the closing up of avenues of work and the shutting out of competition and of enterprise.
Comment on this
I do not know that we are doing that. The Minister seems to halt between the two attitudes. Sometimes he tells us that there is going to be redundancy and a reduction in the ratio as between the cost and the economies effected.
Comment on this
I learned to avoid this sort of thing. As regards one of the amalgamation proposals for which I had responsibility, I regret it because, in the main, it worked out against the humans who were employed in the industry. I say that very tendency is here. With the bit of experience I derived when a Minister, I am in favour of compensation for people who are thrown out of their occupation by State intervention. If the burden is small, that is all the more reason for facing up to it. If there is going to be a vast number of people thrown out, and if the burden is going to be a heavy one, either upon the foreign insurance companies or insurance generally, or on the State, there is at any rate a weighty argument against any proposal for compensation; but if we are told by the Minister that, although there are too many in the industry, it is not an important consideration: if the burden of paying this compensation is going to be light, then we should shoulder it. If, however, it is going to be an enormously heavy thing, then the argument is against it
Comment on this
If I intervene now I think it may help to clarify the position in the minds of some Deputies. The essential difference between the Transport Acts, the Electricity Supply Act and the National Health Insurance Acts, to which reference has been made, and the Bill now before the Dáil, has not been mentioned. Each of these Acts provided for compensation for certain persons losing their employment in consequence of their enactment. The essential difference, however, between the provision in any of these Acts and this Bill is that they give power to effect, because of considerations of public policy, the acquisition, amalgamation or the elimination of solvent concerns, of concerns which were making profits, and which could look forward to enjoying those profits with reasonable continuity, the employees of which had also reasonable security in their employment which entitled them to compensation.
Comment on this
Does the Minister think that the State acted considerately in regard to the railway companies?
Comment on this
A number of the railway companies were not making profits, but they were guaranteed their profits by local authorities, as in the case of the baronially guaranteed lines.
Comment on this
I say that they had a reasonable certainty of continuing in operation, and that the employees had a reasonable certainty of being continued in their employment.
Comment on this
By your legislation you wrote down the debenture stock of the railways by 20 per cent.
Comment on this
We could not guarantee that any particular bus company was likely to continue in operation, but provision was made that the employees of the company who lost their employment were to be compensated——
Comment on this
——if not employed by the concern to whom its licence was transferred. I want to concentrate the attention of Deputies upon the essential difference that each of these Bills gave power to deal with solvent concerns, and that power was given because of considerations of public policy.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy keep silent until I develop my argument? He can talk as much as he likes afterwards. The railway company in 1924, when amalgamation was effected, was a much more solvent concern than it was eight years later and, in any event, the railway company itself believed that, given certain facilities, it could make a reasonable profit.
Comment on this
I do not want to get side-tracked off my main argument which is that these Acts gave power to deal with solvent concerns, or at any rate solvent concerns were brought within their scope. Power was taken to effect this amalgamation, acquisition or elimination irrespective of whether these concerns were solvent or insolvent, and that was done for reasons of public policy. This Bill does nothing of the kind. A company which is solvent and which carries on its business in strict accordance with the law—that is in accordance with the provisions of this Bill when it becomes law—cannot be interfered with by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. If Deputy Dillon says that is not so, will he refer me to the section which gives power to interfere?
Comment on this
We will deal with that consideration. The suggestion, I take it, is that because there may be amalgamations of companies under Part III of the Bill, the Bill should provide for the establishment by the State of a fund from which compensation can be paid to any employees of the amalgamating companies who may not be employed in the amalgamated company.
Comment on this
I will deal with Deputy Lynch first. I am not quite clear as to what he intends because his amendments, so far as I have been able to follow them, provide for the creation of a fund and for the revenue of that fund, but they do not seem to provide for payments out of that fund. I have not been able to find an amendment which defines the classes of persons to whom payments are to be made or the circumstances under which they are to be made. Is that right? There is no such provision?
Comment on this
I take it then that Deputy Lynch intends that any employee of an insurance company who can show that he loses his employment consequent on the enactment of this measure, through any cause, is to get compensation and other employees in certain circumstances are to get pensions. The only amendment the Deputy has in relation to amalgamations seems to me to provide that the costs of compensation are to be paid by the amalgamating companies. That is amendment 78.
Comment on this
That, of course, is an alternative, if this fails.
Comment on this
The Deputy apparently contemplates that if a company is wound up under this Bill as insolvent, wound up because it is insolvent, the State is to provide compensation for the employees of that company. That is Deputy Lynch's proposal and I am anxious to know if it has the support of the Deputies opposite.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Chair asked for an accommodation with the House and suggested that a series of amendments could be taken in one discussion for the purpose of deciding the general principle of compensation. In deference to an agreement of the House, all parties have been proceeding to discuss the principle of compensation without advertance to the various proposals of Deputy Lynch's implementing the principle. One or two of us have completely dissociated ourselves from Deputy Lynch's proposals. As I understand, we are having a Second Reading discussion on the principle of compensation.
Comment on this
I propose to deal with the principle of compensation. Deputy Lynch's principle of compensation is that every person now employed by an insurance company, who loses his employment in consequence of any of the provisions of this Bill, is to be compensated. I am anxious to find out if Deputy Dillon and his associates on the front bench accept that principle in toto. If there is an insolvent company, so insolvent that it cannot meet its liabilities, and if that company is wound up under this Bill and prohibited from carrying on further business, Deputies opposite are concerned to see that the employees of that company get compensation for the loss of their employment. If we read in the paper to-morrow that Company A, an Irish insurance company, had smashed, that it had ceased to carry on business, that it was going to be wound up and that it was unable to meet its liabilities, do Deputies opposite think that I should come immediately before the Dáil with a Supplementary Estimate to provide compensation for its employees? Do they think that my concern should be for those employees or for the 100,000 or 200,000 people who had given their money on trust to that company, and whose policies have become less valuable than the paper on which they were printed? Is that the Deputy's point—that our concern should be for the employees of these insolvent companies, because it is only insolvent companies that can be affected by the provisions of this measure?
Comment on this
What about redundancy as a result of the partition for instance?
Comment on this
I will deal with that in a minute. The Deputy has just reversed his argument in that regard, because when he was discussing the division of business he argued against it on the ground that it was going to cause unnecessary duplication of business and apparently duplication of staff. That is the obvious consequence of that proposal. It is not going to lead to any reduction in employment in the insurance business. It may lead to certain minor increases in employment in the insurance business.