We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Insurance Bill, 1935—Recommittal.

Contributions 223–460 of 705. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Insurance Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 35 of 1935 ›

All right; go on for a minute. I want to find out where you yourself saw unemployment according to your Second Reading speech.

Comment on this

I am going to deal with my proposal in a minute, but I am anxious to get clear the principle on which Deputies opposite are standing. That principle is that where an insolvent company ceases to do business, the State is to provide, out of State funds, compensation for the employees of that company and not compensation for the policy holders, not compensation for the shareholders. The people who gave their 1/- a week or 2/6 a week——

Comment on this

That is tripe, and you know it.

Comment on this

——in premiums to that company are not to be compensated. There is no proposal in this list of amendments tabled by the Deputies to provide them with compensation, but compensation is to be provided under any circumstances under which unemployment arises to persons now employed by insurance companies. That is what Deputies opposite require. I do not think we should do it. I do not think there should be any obligation on the State to provide compensation for those people out of State funds. It has never been done. It was not done in the case of the railways or the omnibus services; it was not done in the case of the electricity undertakings; and it was not done in the case of the national health societies. In each of these cases, there was, however, this provision, that, where compensation was payable, it was to be provided by the amalgamated company, the company that got the benefit of the legislation. There is a certain amount of sense in the proposal submitted in Deputy Norton's name relating to this matter contained in another amendment later on. I do not say that I am accepting it. I think there is an argument against his proposal in principle, as there is against the proposal put forward by Deputy Lynch, but it is a more sensible contention than Deputy Lynch's contention, because at least Deputy Norton says that the circumstances that may lead to the amalgamation, or may result from the amalgamation, must be taken into account and there is no point in providing now for the creation of a fund and the imposition of taxes for the purpose of that fund to provide for compensation to be paid in cash. The necessity for it might never arise.

It is necessary again to emphasise that the only power which this Bill proposes to give the Minister for Industry and Commerce which could be used to effect amalgamation is power to apply to the High Court for an order to wind up an insolvent company. It is not the Minister who decides that the company is insolvent; it is the High Court decides it. The Minister is given power to apply for that order. That is his power, and it is the only power he can use to effect amalgamations.

Comment on this

And Section 12, subsection (4).

Comment on this

It is desirable, in my opinion, that that power should be exercised in that way, and, in relation to these Saorstát companies, created in the main upon national enthusiasm, as Deputy Burke pointed out, into which people were induced to put their savings upon the plea of "Support Irish Industries" that we should provide, not for their compulsory winding-up, but for their amalgamation under a scheme which is going to preserve, not the interests of the employees in these companies, not the interests of the shareholders in these companies, but the value of the policies held by the policy-holders. That is our intention. Amalgamations may take place, and, because of amalgamations, there may be a problem created by the fact that there are more people trying to get a livelihood out of insurance business at present than that business can support. That business, particularly industrial assurance business, is developing in that way. Companies are continually advertising for new agents, and trying to attract people to them as agents in the insurance business, with the result that there is a much larger number of people engaged in insurance business than would be engaged if better and sounder methods of carrying on the business were in operation. The problem of redundancy exists at the moment, and may create special difficulty in connection with the amalgamation scheme under Part III of the Bill. That difficulty however, can be resolved by other methods than by the payment of cash compensation. I am not leaving out as a solution of the problem payment of cash compensation, but I think it should be paid by the amalgamating company coming under the scheme, or by the amalgamated companies, but, in my opinion, it is better to deal with that problem, if it arises by other methods.

These methods suggest themselves immediately to Deputies. It is possible, under the policy of amalgamation, to secure the carrying of redundant staffs until the growth in business, the increase in premiums resulting from amalgamation or normal wastage will rectify the position. My opinion, therefore, is that any question of unemployment, resulting from an amalgamation scheme, should be dealt with by the amalgamation scheme as put forward, and that there should be an obligation on the part of a company putting forward a scheme to offer proposals as to how it will deal with the problem of their staffs. I think the problem can be dealt with better than by the provision of cash compensation, because under the manner in which insurance is carried on the assessment of the compensation to be paid in individual cases would be very difficult.

An attempt was made to justify the amendment `because of the proposals in the Bill for the division of business. Preventing a company doing a life business from doing other classes of insurance business as well may result in unemployment. It is extremely improbable that it will. Any Deputy familiar with the circumstances will see at once that in certain respects this proposal may actually necessitate the recruitment of additional staffs. It has been argued by the insurance companies that it may make the carrying on of certain classes of insurance very difficult, and that in certain classes of insurance business there will be duplication. But I do not think it will mean that the persons concerned will not be employed in the insurance business in future. Other provisions of the Bill will operate to create for them wider opportunities for employment in the Saorstát than previously.

I am, therefore, resisting this amendment, or any proposal to put upon the State the obligation of paying compensation, or providing the means for paying compensation, to persons employed in the insurance business who may lose their employment because of the operation of this measure. If they lose their employment because of the wiping out of insolvent companies we have no obligation to them. Insolvent companies disappear in every business, and will again, and no one ever suggested that the State should compensate their employees. Insolvent insurance companies have disappeared. If this Bill should result in insolvent insurance companies ceasing to operate we have no obligations to their staffs. So far as the proposal may result in bringing out the redundancy of staffs and disemployment, these staffs should be dealt with under the amalgamation scheme, either by making provision for the payment of compensation or for the employment of these redundant staffs during whatever period may be necessary or in some other way. There are no grounds in this Bill which, in my opinion, would justify the inauguration of the elaborate scheme which Deputy Lynch suggests or any similar provision.

Comment on this

The most amazing statement made by the Minister in his speech was that in which he wants the House to believe that the power given in the Railways and Transport Act was power given for the purpose of eliminating solvent companies. But the Minister took jolly good care that he did not explain, even from his own point of view, what a solvent concern meant. Does he mean a concern that pays a rate of interest to its shareholders? If so, neither were the railways that were taken over under Deputy McGilligan's scheme, or that were compulsorily amalgamated under the Minister's own Act of 1933, or the present concern in a solvent position either then or now. The Minister ought to know, and if he does not, Deputy McGilligan can tell him that the principal amalgamated company of the Free State does not now pay dividends to its shareholders on certain of its shares. I am concerned to know from the Minister whether he holds the view that the railway concerns were in any different circumstances and could be regarded as solvent concerns. If the Minister does not know I would like Deputy McGilligan to answer that.

Comment on this

It is very easy to answer.

Comment on this

The Minister admitted that there are insolvent companies, whether British or Irish, to be wiped out, and, therefore, he admitted that a number of their staffs will be deprived of their employment because of the coming into operation of this Bill. I am not seriously concerned where such people are getting compensation from, or whether that compensation is to be provided by the State or the benefiting concern. Personally I believe that compensation paid in such circumstances should be provided by the company that gets the benefit of the increased business, namely, the amalgamated insurance company. We were told by Deputy Lynch, and I am not prepared to accept his opinion, that the Saorstát insurance companies would not be able to bear the burden of the small compensation we are asking for under the terms of this amendment. Anybody who knows anything about Irish insurance companies will be able to recollect the name of an Irish insurance company which some time ago sold its shares to another concern. Everyone with any knowledge of the activities of that body, and every shareholder, knows the amazing amount of compensation paid to the people who lost their seats on the board of directors and the increased amount paid to Irish shareholders who sold their shares in that company to another body of people. I do not know whether Deputy Lynch remembers the name of the company which carried out that operation. If so, would he say how many other Irish companies are in the same happy position? Would he say how many companies that will get increased business by a Bill of this kind would not be able to pay an amount of compensation to their Irish staffs?

Comment on this

Did not the Irish shareholders get back their money? I think the Deputy is out of date with his information.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello knows the name of the company.

Comment on this

You are out of date in your information. It is an exclusively Irish company at present.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy will admit that the body of patriots who sold out their interests in that concern, at a particular period, to another body of people received a fairly decent profit on the transaction——

Comment on this

I know nothing about it.

Comment on this

——and that amazing amounts were paid by way of compensation to the directors who lost their jobs on the board before it was handed over to another body of people.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is exaggerating slightly.

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy will correct me.

Comment on this

I know nothing about it.

Comment on this

He will probably be able to give more accurate information on this matter, if he will give it.

Comment on this

Why do you say so?

Comment on this

Will he say that a company so circumstanced will be unable to carry on after providing compensation to such a small number of employees as will become redundant?

Comment on this

I say it would be unfair to put that burden upon them.

Comment on this

I say that the benefiting concern should bear the burden of any compensation to be paid.

Comment on this

I shall deal with that.

Comment on this

That was the policy that the Deputy's Party supported in connection with the Railways Act and the Transport Act, but with this difference I admit, that the railway company concerned got a monopoly. But this Bill is leading to a monopoly.

Comment on this

It is far from it. Where is the monopoly in this?

Comment on this

The monopoly does not appear on the face of the Bill as it stands, but it is clearly brought in with the object of giving some Irish company at a particular period in the future a monopoly of insurance business here.

Comment on this

Putting the British companies out?

Comment on this

Personally I am in favour of giving assistance by legislation, or financial assistance, if necessary and justifiable, to solvent Irish insurance companies to build up their business in fair competition with any foreign company. I do not think that the few decent Irish companies are competing under fair conditions at present.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy say he sees in this Bill——

Comment on this

I am not going to be cross-examined by Deputy Dillon on a matter of this kind. I want to say that, in my opinion, Deputy Dillon deliberately twisted the meaning of amendment No. 9, which stands in the name of Deputy Lynch, for his own good reasons in the interests of the shareholders of the insurance companies, and tried to lead the House away from the main principle of the amendment moved by Deputy Lynch. Deputy Lynch sought to secure the acceptance of the principle of compensation for redundant officials of the Irish companies.

Comment on this

Where was the twist?

Comment on this

Deputy Lynch made it clear that he was not sticking hard and fast to the details contained in amendment No. 9.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon said that.

Comment on this

Deputy Lynch did not emphasise, as Deputy Dillon did, that that burden should be wholly borne by the State.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon said that that was his special difference with Deputy Lynch.

Comment on this

I am not sure that the barrister Deputies opposite are entitled to cross-examine me on this matter. With your assistance, Sir, I am not going to engage in cross-talk either with Deputy Dillon or with Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We shall hear the Deputy without interruption.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan knows much more about the meaning of this measure than Deputy Dillon will ever learn. He was in the Department of Industry and Commerce for a number of years and had to listen to representations from solvent and insolvent insurance companies. As far as I am concerned, and as far as the members of this Party are concerned, we do not want to prop up any longer, at the expense of the insurable population of this country, insolvent companies, whether Irish or British. We voted for the amalgamation of businesses through measures passed in this House, with the full knowledge when doing so that these Bills, whether the Railway Bill, the Transport Bill or the National Health Insurance Bill, were bound in the end to lead to redundancy and to loss of employment by a number of people concerned in these industries. We supported these Bills on the condition that, in all such cases, where the State deprives persons of employment, provision should be made in these Bills for the payment of reasonable compensation to the persons losing their employment. I say again that I am not seriously concerned as to whether the compensation comes from the State or from the benefiting concerns, but my personal view is that it should come from the benefiting bodies—the insurance companies that are going to get the benefit of the increased business.

In the case of the National Health Insurance Act, the Minister for Local Government, after a good deal of pressure both from this House and the Upper House, which has now disappeared, ultimately agreed that compensation should be paid to the part-time agents who lost their employment. In that case the Minister made provision for the payment of compensation to people whom he knew were not making their livelihood in the main out of the small incomes that they received for acting as agents for national health insurance societies. I strongly press the Minister to make provision for the payment of reasonable compensation to persons who will lose their full-time employment as a result of the operation of this measure. I appeal strongly to the Minister and to his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, who is now sitting on the Front Bench, and who knows more about the implications of this measure than even the Minister for Industry and Commerce, to give this matter more careful and more sympathetic consideration than it appears to have received up to the present. I ask the Minister to take it back on the case made by Deputy Lynch and not on the case made by Deputy Dillon. Deputy Dillon made it quite clear to the House that he was not in favour of the payment of compensation to redundant officials, although he agreed with the principle, simply because it would interfere with the income of the shareholders of the companies here.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin at this juncture has gone loco.

Comment on this

I take the meaning which any ordinary man will take out of the plain language used by Deputy Dillon, who tried to get across the Minister and to destroy the good effect of the case made by his colleague, Deputy Lynch. That is my opinion of the speech made by Deputy Dillon, at any rate. I am not deliberately giving any exaggerated version of the speech he made.

Comment on this

I can only suggest that you momentarily went out of your mind.

Comment on this

The final word of the Minister, in reply to the very effective case made by Deputy Lynch, was that he was prepared to ask the amalgamating companies when they are submitting a scheme for amalgamation or absorption to indicate what compensation they are prepared to provide for those who would become redundant, or whether they would make provision for the employment of the people who would lose their employment in these insolvent companies that are going to disappear. I am not prepared to leave it to the goodwill or the generosity of the directors of the amalgamating companies. I think we should have clearly shown in a section of a Bill of this kind the nature of the compensation provisions and the extent to which compensation is going to be provided for those who will lose their employment as a result of the measure brought in by the Minister. It should be contained in a Bill of this kind, just as in any of the other measures which provided for the amalgamation or absorption of other business companies.

The Minister talked about the effect of the Transport Act. The Minister and his predecessor, Deputy McGilligan, had the owners of these small so-called transport concerns coming on deputations, both before Deputy McGilligan left office and as soon as the present Minister came into office, telling them that if they did not give them protection in some shape or form they would be bound to disappear and that they were insolvent. Whenever I raised in this House the question of the wages paid by those large or small bus concerns I was told that I was slandering those people who were owners of those concerns. I was told, in other places, that they could not afford to pay more than 15/- per week to the conductors who were operating in and around the City of Dublin. What has happened under the operation of that measure? The unfortunate employees who had less than five years' service did not receive any compensation. But there are Deputies in this House who know—and the Minister for Industry and Commerce himself knows better than anybody in this House— the amazing amounts that were paid in compensation to the owners of those broken-down buses which cannot now be used in or around the City of Dublin. I have been given, and given on good authority, the amounts that were paid in compensation under the terms of the Transport Act.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is travelling very far.

Comment on this

The point I want to make is this: why take such an interest in the owners of concerns that are supposed to be insolvent and not take any interest in or make any provision whatsoever for the redundancy that will arise under the terms of this Bill, even though it may affect so-called insolvent insurance companies? I am making a case here that the Minister should reconsider the whole position from the point of view of the redundancy that is likely to arise. I would ask him to give an undertaking—or I would ask the Minister for Agriculture to give an undertaking on his behalf—that this whole matter will be reconsidered in the light of the discussion which has now taken place, and that a section will be inserted in this Bill at a later stage making it quite clear to the employees who may become redundant what they may expect from the persons responsible for carrying the burden of the payment of compensation. There was a clear issue here on the principle, and on that I hope the Minister will make his position much more clear than he made it in the speech which he has just delivered. I would invite the Minister for Agriculture to give this House the benefit of the experience he has had in the insurance business, and the benefit of the conversations which he must have had with his colleague the Minister for Industry and Commerce on this matter. I would ask him to say "yes" or "no" to the question as to whether they are prepared to make provision in this Bill for the payment of compensation to persons who will become redundant and lose their employment as a result of the coming into operation of this measure. I want "yes" or "no" as an answer to that question.

Comment on this

I am in favour of this amendment by Deputy Lynch, having for its object the payment of compensation to those men who may lose their employment as a result of an Act passed by this House. I think it is only a matter of common justice that men who are deprived of their living should be compensated by the State. I was surprised to hear the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Of course, one has got accustomed to the fact that, if it suited his purpose, he would argue a hole through a pot, but in this particular instance he argued the whole bottom out of the pot when he stated that there is nothing in this Bill which gave any Deputy the right to get up and say that amalgamation will take place.

I should like to ask the Minister if all those employees of the various companies concerned, notably the Irish companies, have been going round the country on a wild goose chase, organising meetings and interviewing Deputies of the various Parties during the last four or five months? Were they so devoid of common sense, and did they know so little about the sections of this Bill and what this Bill purports to put into effect, that they took all those precautions if they did not see in this Bill a danger of their livelihood being taken away from them? Yet, we have the Minister, in answer to Deputy Dillon and Deputy McGilligan, getting up in this House and saying: "Point out to me any section in the Bill which will do away with any of those companies or prevent any of those companies from functioning." Surely the Minister knew the position deep down in his heart when he stated: "If I have to choose between safeguarding the interests of the policy-holders of this country and the putting out of operation of insolvent insurance companies there can be only one opinion," which means that insolvent companies must go. That is the Irish Minister who, at the cross-roads of the Twenty-Six Counties of this country, has been telling the Irish people to insure in Irish companies, and we have it from the same Minister this evening that there are insolvent Irish companies in the Irish Free State.

Comment on this

We all know it.

Comment on this

He says that, and Deputy Davin says the same.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

We want no more camouflage about this question. "Why should we pay compensation?" says this Irish Minister for Industry and Commerce. Everybody knows that certain Irish companies, which exist at the moment, have been created as a result of the propaganda that has been carried on throughout this country for the past eight or nine years by the Government and its supporters. The child on the street knows that; it is no secret. Yet the Minister stated here this evening: "If a company should become insolvent to-morrow morning, or next week, why should this Dáil be asked to put into this Bill a section which will be the means of paying compensation to the employees of that insolvent insurance company?" If I read anything into the speech of the Minister it is that he knows deep down in his heart that at the moment there are Irish companies—let him not say "companies," or let not Deputy Davin say "companies"; Irish companies are the only companies referred to—which are insolvent. Of course the Minister and his Government are getting afraid of the day that something terrible will happen in this country, and we want to go on now and prevent the compensation of those men who have given years of hard work in the building up of those companies, and the employees who have left the service of other companies to go into those Irish companies, mainly on the propaganda carried on by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Government during the last eight or nine years, in order to build up what they say are purely Irish companies in conformity with the general policy pursued by the present Government. Nobody can get away from that fact.

I am not one of those who ever claimed to be as Irish as the Minister for Industry and Commerce, or any member of that Government opposite. I am not supposed to be an Irishman at all, of course. We always had very Imperialistic interests and we were always full of Imperialist ideas, but still as an Irishman I should be slow to give voice to the sentiments expressed in the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce here this evening, when he went very far to cast any suspicion he could upon the existing Irish companies of the Free State. Everybody knows and must agree that where, as a result of legislation, a man's livelihood is taken away from him, it is the duty of the Government to make provision for that man. Those companies have not asked for this legislation. They are prepared to carry on in the future as they have been carrying on in the past. They are prepared to pay their employees in the future as they have been paid in the past, and if by any Act of this House those companies are not in a position to do in the future what they have been doing in the past, then I say it is only a matter of justice on the part of this Parliament to pass a law which would enable those people to be compensated for the loss which they will sustain as a result of their means of livelihood being taken away from them.

I never was more amazed than I was this evening when listening to the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. He himself will be surprised when he reads it. I do not think the greatest supporter of a British company could make the speech that the Minister for Industry and Commerce made here this evening. It was a speech in defence of what I might call the foreign companies. As he himself says, in effect: "I do not care about the shareholders, I do not care about anything—I am going to defend the policy-holders." It is fine compensation and fine thanks that those men, who have spent so many years in building up Irish insurance companies, are getting now from the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I think it is very little thanks that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is giving to all the agents of those companies who assisted him during the last general election and during the previous general election and who helped to put into power a Government that, to-day, is going to take away their means of livelihood from those men. It is a fact—and no man knows it better than the Minister for Agriculture—that the agents of the New Ireland Assurance Company, of the Munster and Leinster Assurance Company and the other assurance companies were the best canvassers for him and his Party throughout the length and breadth of this land in the last general election and the previous general election; and these men are now going to be thrown overboard and their means of livelihood taken away by the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

I do not care three straws, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce said in effect this evening, about the shareholders. I am concerned with the interests of the policy holders, many of whom, as a result of the propaganda carried on by the Government and by members of the Government Party, were induced to transfer their policies from good solvent English insurance companies to certain Irish insurance companies. Now, after all those years, those people are going to be deprived of their livelihood. I say, without fear of contradiction, that it is up to the Government, and especially the Government now in power, to see to it that, before this Bill leaves this House, a section or clause will be incorporated in the Bill safeguarding the means of livelihood of those men who will lose their employment as a result of this Bill if it remains as it stands.

Comment on this

I could not get the hang of what Deputy Davin was saying at all, because, apparently, Deputy Davin has completely lost track of this discussion. Our position is perfectly clear, and that is that we are in favour of the principle of compensation, but that we are not in favour of saddling the amalgamated companies with the cost of it—for two reasons: first, that it may smash the amalgamated company, thereby disemploying all the people who are working in that company; and secondly, because, if it were by way of annuity, it would result in the annuitants losing their annuity because the company would be forced into liquidation through its inability to pay. I do not mention the policy-holders in that connection, because I think the companies would go into liquidation before an insolvency was upon them that would force them to give the policy-holders less than the actuarial value of their several policies. Deputy Davin, however, is following a very dangerous line if he is going to lead the Labour Party down the alley of saying that compensation for the disemployed employees must be levied on the companies. I warn him now that, if he follows that line, not only will he do the employees out of their compensation, but he will shake the whole foundation of the existing Irish insurance companies. Now, I ask Deputy Davin to inquire into that situation before he pursues the line that he has been advocating in this House any longer. If there is going to be compensation for redundant employees levied on the Irish insurance companies there will not be a single Irish insurance company left in this country in the next ten years, with the exception, perhaps, of the Hibernian Fire and Accident Insurance Company, which does not do life or industrial assurance.

Comment on this

What about the New Ireland Assurance Company?

Comment on this

Well, I do not like to mention any names, but I say that if adequate compensation for redundant employees is going to be levied on the Irish companies, then I can see no fund to which they can turn in order to provide that.

Comment on this

What about the increased business they will have?

Comment on this

Deputy Davin is on the wrong track. There is no monopoly here. There is no question of giving a monopoly here. You have got the Pearl Insurance Company, the Prudential, the Norwich Union, the Royal Liver—dozens of great life and industrial assurance companies operating still in this country and perfectly free to go on operating The amalgamated companies that are going to be established as a result of this Bill are going to have formidable and ferocious competition to meet just as in the past, and all that this Bill is going to do is to make them solvent as on the date of the amalgamation. This Bill will not eliminate any competition or will not make the competition lighter than it was before. Deputy Davin, however, does not seem to be able to get that into his head.

Comment on this

Will they not take over the business of the insolvent companies?

Comment on this

In the name of common sense, of what value will that be to them?

Comment on this

It will mean a reduction of overhead charges by the reducing of staffs and so on.

Comment on this

And what about the loan by the Minister as his contribution in exchange for the ordinary shares? Of course, the Deputy has not examined the problem.

Comment on this

Surely it is not a loan.

Comment on this

Which? The Minister's contribution?

Comment on this

The Minister's contribution is going to be a loan in exchange for the ordinary shares, and no penny of interest can be paid on the capital of the amalgamated company until a sum is built up adequate to meet the amount of the money advanced by the Minister in exchange for the ordinary shares, and if a company that had an actuarial deficiency of 18/- in the £ on its policy claims were taken over by a solvent company, the Minister would have to take over the amount necessary to make the amalgamated company solvent. In my opinion, at any rate—and I know it is the opinion of others—the amalgamated company would not be free to pay one penny of interest on its ordinary shares until such time as it had accumulated a reserve sufficient to meet the amount of money subscribed by the Minister.

Comment on this

Is not the solvency of that company guaranteed by the Minister from the time of the amalgamation?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think it is guaranteed under amendment No. 9.

Comment on this

No, Sir. However, I warn Deputy Davin that he is barking up a mighty dangerous tree if he is trying to put this on to the Irish insurance companies, because the net result is that he is going to do the employees of these companies out of the compensation they are entitled to get.

Comment on this

If it goes into this Bill, they cannot be deprived of the compensation.

Comment on this

They will be done out of it. How can they get compensation from a fund that does not exist? You can pass this Bill or any Act of Parliament you like, but if the money is not there you cannot give it to anybody. Possibly, the Minister for Agriculture will pass an Act of Parliament in a short time to get meat-juice out of turnips. He can get the Act of Parliament passed, but he will not be able to do it. The Deputy may think that, by legislating to get blood out of a turnip, he will be able to do so, but he will not be able to do it because there is no blood in the turnip to get out.

Comment on this

That is schoolboys' talk.

Comment on this

It is not. It is the literal truth, and if the Minister for Agriculture had the courage to intervene in this debate—and, of course, he will not do so, because he would be afraid of the Minister for Industry and Commerce—he would tell Deputy Davin very much what I am telling him now, which is that——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy has a wholesome fear of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

——if there is no money in the Irish insurance company to provide for a fund of the kind Deputy Davin has in mind, it cannot be provided by the company. The Minister for Industry and Commerce asked for a clear statement from the Opposition as to where we stand on the principle of compensation. The Minister loves to call for these clear statements from his opponents, but he is very reluctant to give them himself. I want to be quite clear with the Minister on this matter. We stand for compensation for any person who loses his employment as a result of the operations of this Bill. The Minister whacked the desk and asked if an insolvent company was wound up were they to be concerned? The whole object of the Bill is to avoid wiping them out. If an insolvent company is wound up I ask the Deputies to remember that the policy-holders are going to suffer. Suppose we wind up an insolvent company to-morrow and there is an actuarial deficit of 10/- in the £, the policy-holders are only going to get 8/- in the £ out of what they are actuarially entitled to. The whole object of this legislation is to avoid winding up. and if the only effect is to wipe out a company and to leave the policy-holders to carry the baby, this legislation is going to be of no effect at all. We all know perfectly well that there are insurance companies in this country which are insolvent. We all know that the object of this legislation is to prevent these insurance companies crashing.

It is right that at this stage the public should be informed that the reason for this legislation is because there are insurance companies of such kind and that if they did crash the State would have to come to their assistance. The whole position of these insurance companies is such that we could not possibly allow them to go crash. Let us be clear on that. There are numbers of persons in very responsible positions in this State intimately associated with these companies. There are numbers of persons in very responsible positions who urged the people in the name of patriotism to put their money into these companies, and rightly I think the State has consistently taken the view since it was founded in 1922—not since Fianna Fáil came into office— that if all went to all it would have to come in to save a crash, if a crash threatened. With that in mind, companies that were insolvent years ago have been allowed to carry on, and I think rightly allowed to carry on, because it was felt that there was a chance they would pull themselves together, and come out of the wood as all the big insurance companies in Great Britain have done in their day. Not a single one of the big insurance companies in Great Britain was solvent within a decade of its foundation; they were all insolvent, and they all came back to solvency and to the prosperity that they now enjoy, through a period of great difficulty and great doubt.

Comment on this

Are they all solvent?

Comment on this

I am talking of the great insurance companies, and I say that not a single one of them but was insolvent in the early years of its existence. They have all attained mighty wealth after having gone through a period of difficulty. Irish insurance companies were admittedly insolvent, and I believe some of them are still insolvent. I believe some have been insolvent for the last eight or nine years. I think the Government then and the Government now rightly took the view that they ought to be allowed to carry on, always knowing that it would be left to someone else to carry the baby if a catastrophe occurred, hoping all the time that everything would come all right, and that the Government or the State would see that the policy-holders were all right. In pursuing that line they left open the doors of employment with insurance companies to young persons starting out on their careers. It was not for these young fellows who were looking for jobs to assess the solvency or the insolvency of any company with which they could get a job. They took the jobs, built up their books, and many of them are now married and settled in life. It was the policy of the State to allow these companies to continue to function long after they might legitimately have been wound up for insolvency. Are the young persons who were invited by the State's complacency to go into these jobs to be sacrificed now because the companies have become insolvent? They were insolvent eight years ago, and if wound up then boys who went into that business would never have gone into it, but would have prepared themselves for other walks of life or made jobs for themselves. They did not do so, because they believed that if the companies were allowed to carry on they were solvent companies. They are now faced with the situation that they have accepted responsibilities of one kind or another on the strength of the jobs they got. Consequently these men are entitled to compensation. That is my position as regards insolvent companies. In regard to Irish companies, a most peculiar situation arises. We deliberately, and in my opinion properly, tolerated their insolvency in the hope that in time they would come all right. We must now accept responsibility for that, and recognise that this legislation is designed to put Irish insurance on a solid foundation, to make a clean sweep of insecurity and doubt, and the foreseeable possibility of collapse, and that we are going to make sure that any casualties that arise will be adequately and properly looked after.

Comment on this

The Deputy said that he stands for compensation for any employee who loses his employment as a result of this Bill. If we were to withdraw the licence from a foreign company on the ground that it is insolvent, will the Deputy suggest that we should compensate its employees in the Saorstát?

Comment on this

I think it is extremely difficult to envisage the contingency the Minister mentioned ever arising.

Comment on this

One that might arise.

Comment on this

If the Minister asks me if a foreign company becomes insolvent and is compulsorily wound up——

Comment on this

Prohibited from carrying on business here.

Comment on this

The licence withdrawn.

Comment on this

——I find it difficult to answer that question without reflection. We may invent new difficulties and new troubles in order to put artificial obstacles in the way of compensating employees who are going to be made redundant by this Bill, but I am not going to commit myself to deciding every point the Minister raises at this stage, because I have not submitted any comprehensive scheme for compensation.

Comment on this

Might I remind the Deputy that what he said was that he stands for compensation for any employee who loses his employment as a result of this Bill?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy qualifying that statement now?

Comment on this

Not through the operation of the Bill in future.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan is qualifying the statement for him.

Comment on this

No. It is a sound statement to do it in that way.

Comment on this

My belief is that we should clear the ground as far as is foreseeable to secure ourselves against future catastrophe, and in the process of doing that, in my opinion, the casualties should be compensated. If the Minister wants to make an imbecile or idiotic point, as to whether we should make provision for people for whom it may be necessary in two or three years, I do not think that point relevant. Naturally, a line is drawn beyond which the impact of the Bill is not to operate. These are details for which to devise a scheme to carry that out. This has been clearly explained by those defending the principle and it is silly to drag in fortuitous difficulties which cannot arise and artificial cases which have no real existence in the problem which confronts us at present. That disposes of compulsory winding up. The Minister went on to imply that the only real redundancy that could arise would be as a result of insolvent companies being wound up, and their business terminated. He deliberately sought to veil the provisions of Section 12 (4), where a perfectly solvent company is operating life, industrial life, fire or accident. The Minister says to that company, "Divide your business into two. Either sell the life business or dispose of the fire and accident business." A company which is perfectly solvent, and able to carry on a reasonably comfortable business with one head office, might find the situation entirely different if it was obliged to dispose of half of its business to someone else. It might then find that the only hope of maintaining itself in the solvent condition it was in when the Minister sought to interfere, was by amalgamation with some other company. It is forced by the operation of this Bill into amalgamation. When it amalgamates the principle of economy in the expense ratio is going to result in a reduction of the staff. I say these people are entitled to compensation. I suggest that their unemployment has been precipitated by the action of the Minister. What is going to happen in regard to this Bill, as far as amalgamation proposals are going to operate, and indeed in all human probability in so far as the compulsory winding-up will operate, is that they are going to use those parts of the Bill for the purpose of clearing the ground immediately after its passage, but having been once used ordinarily they should never be used again, because there will be close surveillance and immediate warnings, and precautions can be taken long before an insurance company approaches the position of insolvency. That is the whole object of this Bill. There might happen to be drastic work undertaken immediately the Bill becomes law, and it is on that occasion I want the casualties to be properly looked after.

Comment on this

I want to emphasise what Deputy Dillon has said in one respect. The Minister has made an amazing statement here, contrary to what he said on Second Reading, that there is not likely to be much unemployment or disemployment caused by this measure. When he was closing on Second Reading, after the particular matter had been discussed here, he said: "There are too many people employed in the industry at the present time to permit of its being conducted on sound lines." Later he talked about the burden that would be cast upon an amalgamated company by reason of excessive staffs. He tells us now that amalgamation will not take place under his authority or through his compulsion, and that whatever redundancy takes place under these amalgamations should be left to these amalgamations to clean up for themselves. I think the answer to that is that this House should deal with that matter, that this House should lay down conditions regarding compensation which should be part of the terms of amalgamation when these matters do arise. The Minister has made the amazing statement with regard to Section 12 that it is likely to increase work. That is on the lines of the Spanish-oranges-and-eggs type of story. We can leave that to his telling. There is nobody going to believe it, and it is not worth arguing about it.

The special point, which the Minister has made, which requires consideration is this matter of insolvent companies. It may seem to be an equitable suggestion that if a business fails because it is not able to keep up with the strain of competition, then there should be no provision made for those cast out of work, that you do not in the ordinary way of business deal with it but take it as a necessary happening. There were companies, as has been pointed out, started here under a particular impulse. They were kept going here because of the strength and the enthusiasm of these impulses. When these companies were looked into by the first Government that came to investigate them here, the situation was seen to be a pretty bad one, and although there was a danger facing the continuance of these companies, that danger or risk was accepted and accepted exactly on the terms to which Deputy Dillon has referred. These companies were so definitely bound up with a particular movement, with a particular surge in Irish affairs, that whatever we might say of their weakness, if any of them came near the point of collapse it would be a matter of State intervention.

Whatever good points there might be behind the continuance of these weak companies in the hope of nursing them into a proper financial condition, it was no answer, say to some dozen or 100 assured people who came within the grip of these weak insurance companies 10 or 15 years ago, that they should have been wound up and the only answer that could be given was that the resources of the State were behind them. Transfer that argument to the case of the employees and they are in exactly the same position. The companies were allowed to carry on and these men entered their employment. If the axe had been allowed to fall when the neck was ripe for the block, these people would not have been diverted to that type of employment. They are entitled to the same consideration as the shareholders.

The Minister referred to this as though it were a matter of a business concern falling by the wayside. That same phrase entering into another Minister's head about 1923 or 1924 would have produced from the present Minister then the fiercest indignation and tirades. Anybody armed with the powers of the English insurance commissioner about the year 1925 and who proposed to cut out four or five Irish companies, for that reason would have been regarded as a traitor to the best interests of the country and would have been maligned by nobody more than the present Minister—speaking in ignorance, of course. He would have condemned it resoundingly and vehemently. The employees are exactly in the same position as the shareholders. Are they not deserving of the same consideration? They are not to be cast aside as a separate company that could not stand the stress of the times. Again, these are people who could not have had any knowledge themselves of the danger they were in, because a lot of the difficulties surrounding these companies have not been something that the employees might have seen. There has been some overcrowding in the ranks of those employed in the insurance companies, but a certain amount of their difficulties arose from a bad investment policy. If, however, anybody had classed it as a bad investment policy five years ago, he himself would have been classed as definitely unpatriotic for giving expression to such a statement. The impact of this Bill on insurance is one that is going to lead to redundancy because the situation undoubtedly is that there are too many people employed in the insurance business. If the licence is to be withdrawn and if no term of years is to be put upon it, but that it is to be withdrawn simply because of insolvency, what is going to happen? Is it because it is found insolvent hereafter or now? In the case of the Railways Bill, a period of seven years was fixed within which there would have to be compensation for any redundancy arising out of the amalgamation. Deputy Davin then criticised the limitation that was put upon the period during which compensation would be paid on redundancy but it was thought, at any rate, that any redundancy as a result of the amalgamation would have shown itself within that period.

Comment on this

I argued that it could be deliberately deferred by the company, and it did happen.

Comment on this

The Deputy did prophesy that it would happen, but I do not know whether it did. The Minister speaks of the licence being withdrawn from a foreign company because it is insolvent. If he means one that is now insolvent, I put it in the same position as an Irish company. It was allowed to carry on. There was no reason for allowing a foreign company to carry on if it could have been shown to be insolvent. If it was a company that at one time had been a native company, and had been bought out, then peculiar considerations would apply, or if there was some interlocking between it and a native company somewhat the same considerations would apply. If it refers to an outside or English company, after the Bill has its first impact on the company, then I think there is no case for compensation. The State has had its interactions on the whole matter, and we will have seen what the results may be. I do not think that there is any analogy at all between the company whose certificate is withdrawn because of something in the Bill, and one which should have been declared insolvent a few years ago.

Comment on this

Will every company not be conducting its business under a special certificate?

Comment on this

A certificate of solvency? I do not think so.

Comment on this

Will it not be conducting its business in the future under a licence?

Comment on this

I do not see how that would have any effect. The licence will be given to people, to start with, but the licence does not carry an assurance that the company is going to continue to be solvent. It takes its chance. The Minister will say it gets a better chance. If it fails——

Comment on this

It will be the moral responsibility of the Government.

Comment on this

By no means, and, therefore, there should be no compensation. But it is redundancy about which I am speaking. The redundancy is brought about by the action of the Government in the interest, in the main, of the insured people. There is undoubtedly a case for compensation in those circumstances, and we have always accepted that principle. I do not know of any measure by which people were put out of employment, whether directly under the Bill or by the Minister saying: "There are to be amalgamations, and I foresee that that will mean redundancy," or by the Minister giving power to a group, established by him, to take over the business of other people, in which that principle was not accepted. The Electricity Supply Board were not forced to take over any concerns. They were given the power to do so. They were practically a Government concern and they were huge monopolists. They were told that one of the conditions in taking over the businesses of others was that they should compensate employees of a certain type. No point was ever made in this House, and it cannot be made now retrospectively, that the principle which operated in the minds of people who voted for compensation in previous years was whether or not the businesses to be acquired were solvent or insolvent.

Deputy Davin referred to the railway companies. One might have a certain delicacy in referring to the railway companies a few years ago, but, speaking now, there can be no delicacy in alluding to their position. In 1924 they represented themselves —it was not what was said about them, but what they said—as insolvent. The situation with regard to the railway companies was that the whole country was clamouring to get the rates, which were 150 per cent. over the pre-war rates, reduced. The attitude of the companies was that, although they knew the retention of the high rates was driving business from them, any attempt to lower them was going to make them completely insolvent.

Comment on this

What does "solvency" mean in relation to a railway concern?

Comment on this

The Minister was not here when Deputy Davin raised this question. I say, in reply to his question, that a solvent railway company is one which can pay dividends on its stock. So far was that from being the case that, when the Minister came to the aid of the railway company in 1933, he reduced their stock to one-tenth of what it previously was and made the case that that meant no difference because they had not been paying even on one-tenth. Having brought the railway company to the position in which the debenture-holders could have come in and closed down on the property, the company being so completely insolvent, the Minister interfered with the debenture-holders' rights and prevented them from exercising them in the legal way, as well as reducing the value of that property. Then, he tells us that, by analogy, that was a solvent concern. I do not agree with the Deputy about the bus concerns. The Deputy may disagree with the results, as found, but the terms of reference were clear. People were to be compensated for pecuniary loss. You could not find that there was pecuniary loss if a man had been making a loss when he was in the business.

Comment on this

The owners of the so-called insolvent companies got big compensation.

Comment on this

Not the owners of insolvent companies.

Comment on this

The so-called insolvent companies.

Comment on this

The facts showed that they were not insolvent.

Comment on this

They called themselves insolvent to the Minister.

Comment on this

Not even to the present Minister. They represented that they would be insolvent if certain cut-throat competition were allowed to continue.

Comment on this

The ex-Minister knows well what they said.

Comment on this

I know that, through the stress of cut-throat competition, certain of these companies went to the wall and what had to be cleared up was the cream of the whole lot. The people who had to be compensated were the people who had risen to the top in the competition.

Comment on this

The owners of the redundant buses.

Comment on this

They may have been redundant buses but they were able to make profits for their owners. The basis on which compensation was given to these people was the profit which they were able to show, by the accounts, they had been deprived of. The employees were, at any rate, given something. I do agree that any of them who got over the many hurdles found that the sum was very small. The hurdles were very numerous and hard to get over, but still there was some scheme of compensation. The principle was accepted, while it is not accepted here.

Comment on this

What about the "five-year" hurdle?

Comment on this

The people who were not over five years in that employment were ruled out by the Act. That was accepted by the majority in this House. If a man was not in the job for five years he was not thought to be in the industry long enough to qualify for compensation. This measure is on all fours with most of the measures about which different members of the Dáil and different Parliaments took exactly the same view. If, by State action, people are driven out of employment, whether directly by the Bill or because of powers given to certain people by the Bill, compensation should be provided for. If there is going to be no unemployment, the Minister is right in saying that the clause will never be put into operation. But the House has always guarded itself against the plea of injustice by associating with all these confiscation or amalgamation measures clauses with regard to compensation. There may have been hurdles to be got over and the compensation may have been small but we have always salved our consciences, when we brought in measures here providing for State intervention and feared that the field of employment might be encroached upon, by providing for compensation.

I should have liked to discuss further the question as to who should bear the burden of compensation. Deputy Davin has the clear view that this tends towards a monopoly. I do not see any monopoly in regard to this matter. It may come later but it will not come in the period during which compensation should be paid. This will not be a question of pensions; it will be a question of gratuities or lump-sum payments. I do not think you can put it on all the companies left in existence. There will be a considerable amount of competition to be faced—and a good thing, too. There is nothing in the way of a monopoly. That being the situation, if the State is responsible for disemployment, even if the State is under suspicion of being responsible, or under the suspicion of bringing about a remotely possible situation in which people will be put out of employment, then the State ought to include in the Bill a clause which will become operative only if and when redundancy occurs through its activities or the activities of people given power by this measure to produce redundancy.

Comment on this

In the course of his speech of about half-an-hour ago, the Minister said he was anxious to know the principle on which this Party was standing in reference to this question of compensation to employees. I shall give it to him in one sentence—a sentence out of his own speech on Second Reading:—

"It is my intention that persons who are dependent for their livelihoods on insurance employment, and who are affected by this measure will be fairly dealt with."

That is the principle on which we stand and that quotation is from the Minister's own speech. The Minister endeavoured to avoid giving the principle on which he stood. Having tried to side-track the issue by reference to the details of Deputy Lynch's amendment, he ultimately came down to three points—(1) that he would pay no compensation to any employee of an insolvent company; (2) if amalgamation took place he would put the burden of compensation on the amalgamated companies, and (3) that there would be no necessity to give compensation to any employees because, if partition took place in the businesses of insurance companies, there would be no unemployment by reason of the partition. I understood that the Minister's arguments boiled down into these three points. That means that, unless and until there is a scheme of amalgamation, there is to be no provision for dealing fairly with employees. It is only in that state of affairs that the Minister will intervene.

I do not know if I have entirely misread this Bill. I agree with what the Minister has iterated and reiterated, that there are no provisions in this Bill for compulsory amalgamation. The Minister thinks that there may be compulsory amalgamation of Irish insurance companies. I am not sufficiently in touch with the concerns of Irish insurance companies to say whether or not that is so. The Minister thinks there will be amalgamation. So far as my knowledge goes, I think there will not. Then, Irish companies will be thrown back on Section 12. What is the position under Section 12? If this Bill is passed in its present form, no insurance company, British or Irish, can carry on a composite business. Some offices carried on a life business, including industrial assurance and general insurance—accident, fire, burglary and all the rest. Once this Bill comes into force, a company must, as I read the provisions of the measure, decide whether it will carry on for the future its life business or its general business. It cannot do both.

As most companies will elect to carry on their life business, they are then left with something which they have built up for some period of years. It may or may not be an asset. Whether it is an asset or not it is there. There are some employees who have been concerned in the working of that branch of their business. What is to become of them? That company is going to carry on the life business; it is going to drop the other. It is going either to unload it on some other company which is to carry it on, or leave it drop—leaving it to some other companies to collect that business without giving any purchase price to the company that built it up. Whether any company is going to purchase this, or whether any company can be got to purchase it, or whether the business is going to be left there at large for other companies to take it up, without paying any purchase price, there is, in either event, bound to be unemployment, because if a company takes it up having purchased it from the company which dropped it, then that new company will probably be in a position to carry it on without taking on to their staff one additional person. If any company does not take it up, there is in either event bound to be considerable unemployment as a result.

I cannot see how the Minister can say that the situation created by Section 12 causes no trouble under this Bill. The Minister says that it is extremely unlikely that unemployment will result. On the contrary, I think it is extremeuy likely that unemployment must result. I cannot at all follow the Minister in coming to the conclusion he comes to, that no unemployment will be caused through this measure. Unemployment is bound to be caused in the way I have pointed out. As I understood him, Deputy Davin is in favour personally of compensation. The Deputy rather inclines to the view that something along the lines of Deputy Finian Lynch's amendment should meet the case, or that the amalgamating companies should bear the burden. The principle that is operating in the Deputy's mind is that whoever gets benefit from this Bill should pay the cost of the compensation. If there is no amalgamation, as is very likely under this Bill, then who is to bear the cost of the unemployment that will ensue from the operation of the partition of the business? Nobody. Deputy Lynch suggests the details of a scheme. His suggestions and his details for carrying them out do not commend themselves to me. We take up the position that because the State has interfered with the business of insurance in this country the cost of that should be borne by the State, because we feel that nothing but disadvantage is coming to the Irish companies or the British companies through the operations of this Bill.

There is one advantage from the Bill. There is a problem to be met and to be dealt with by this Bill—a problem we do not want to dwell upon—the problem of the insolvent companies. So far as an effort is being made by this Bill to deal with that problem then that is something that is to be done in the public interest. Nobody wants that business. Who wants to bear the burden of some insolvent company? What is the business worth? Who is going to buy an insolvent business as a business proposition? If these insolvent companies are to be transferred to other Irish companies that business is going to be forced on them directly or indirectly. Nobody is going to take that business gratuitously. What does the Bill do? It interferes with all of that business. The Bill interferes with the British insurance companies and foreign companies doing business here. The British and foreign companies who are carrying on business here do not want the Bill; they want to be let alone. As regards the Irish insurance companies, I am aware that, before this Bill was brought in, they wanted and had some reason to expect certain benefits from this Government. That was their outlook. They thought that the present Government by reason of their promises and because of their policy in industrial concerns were going to give them something equivalent to tariffs or bounties for their business as Irish industrial concerns. They were under the impression—quite wrongly as it now appears—that they were going to get some benefit under the Bill. But they are getting no benefit. I think I am correctly stating their attitude if I say this: that as they have not been getting what they thought they were getting from the present Government, they would prefer to be let alone rather than be interfered with by the Bill. We have then the position that the British companies want to be let alone, and the Irish companies, in default of getting what they expected, want to be let alone. Both groups are seriously interfered with by this Bill.

In whose interests then is it being introduced? As I gathered from the Minister's statement it is being introduced in the interests of the policy-holders—in other words a section of the public. Deputy Davin himself to-day used the phrase—I think I have taken him down correctly—"This Bill is saving the insurance population from themselves." That is what this Bill is doing. It is preventing certain Irish concerns going insolvent and thereby bringing discredit on this country and discredit on business in general. It is protecting the policy-holders, according to Deputy Davin, from the dangers of these insolvent companies. According to the Minister the primary purpose of this Bill is to protect the policy-holders.

Therefore, the persons who will be getting benefit from this measure are the public, or a big section of the public, and not the companies whose business is being interfered with, whether they are British or Irish. There is, therefore, no case to put the burden of paying compensation on either the companies, whether they are British or Irish concerns, or on the policy-holders for that matter. If there is to be compensation, and we and apparently everybody except the Government think that there should be compensation for any persons who may be disemployed as a result of the operation of this measure, then the logical conclusion should be that the persons who benefit by it should pay for its operation. The persons who will benefit are the public as a whole, and, consequently, I suggest that Deputy Davin, having hit on the right principle, that the persons who are getting benefits from the operation of the measure should pay compensation to the people who are disemployed as a result of its operation, should revise his opinions, disagree with himself and come to the conclusions that we have put forward. It is rather amusing, in one sense, that Deputy Davin, whose Party, perhaps surreptitiously, stands for the socialistic doctrine, should now be arguing very heatedly in this House against the idea of the State paying compensation in these circumstances.

Comment on this

I did not do so.

Comment on this

It is rather amusing to listen to the Deputy arguing in that manner, while others, who may not be in agreement with the policy of State control in every direction, should be asking the Minister to pay compensation out of State funds to the persons who will be disemployed when this measure is put into operation. Apparently, Deputy Davin and ourselves are now in full agreement on the principle of compensation. On the details we have, perhaps, disagreed, but now that his attention has been directed along proper channels, perhaps he will see his way to agree with the main arguments which we put forward.

The Minister asks us to state clearly what is our principle in relation to this question of compensation. We want that persons who are dependent for their livelihood on insurance employment and are affected by this measure will be fairly dealt with. Those are the Minister's own words, and we use them to state our principle on this question of compensation.

Comment on this

I merely intervene now because statements made by me on the Second Reading have been quoted twice out of their context. The statement that Deputy Costello has quoted clearly relates only to the amalgamation provisions of the Bill. I was then dealing with the amalgamation provisions of the Bill and, in relation to them, I made that statement, that persons who are dependent for their livelihood on insurance employment and are affected by this measure will be fairly dealt with.

Comment on this

There is nothing about amalgamation in that sentence.

Comment on this

I will read the whole paragraph. The Deputy is not quoting from the Official Debates, but from a pamphlet issued by insurance agents—I happen to have a copy of it. In column 1721 of the Parliamentary Debates I am reported:—

"It has been suggested that amalgamation may result in the wholesale dismissal of staffs of the amalgamating companies, but this suggestion is entirely without foundation. I do not think that the provisions of this Bill will result in any number of persons losing employment, and it is my intention that persons who are dependent for their livelihoods on insurance employment and who are affected by the measure will be fairly dealt with."

There is some more in the paragraph, but it is clear that the reference relates to the amalgamation proposals. Deputy McGilligan quoted me from the same pamphlet as saying that the question of the redundancy of staff is not an important consideration. The full sentence reads:—

"The industry as at present conducted is peculiar in this respect, that it is under no necessity to restrict the number of persons who can at any time be taken on as agents, since they may be paid wholly or mainly by commission, and the question of redundancy of staff is not an important consideration for the company."

Comment on this

What is the point of that?

Comment on this

Merely that I was misquoted.

Comment on this

Assuming that the Minister was misquoted and to the extent he says the sentence that I quoted from him, and which I again say embodies the principle for which we stand, is entirely divorced from its context. Assuming again that it only relates to amalgamation, will he deal with the point that I have put, that, irrespective of amalgamation, the partitioning of staffs in itself is bound inevitably to lead to a considerable number of persons being put out of employment?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy concerned with the staffs employed by the Saorstát companies or the staffs employed by all the companies?

Comment on this

I am concerned at the moment with the staffs employed by the Saorstát companies. I am assuming that this thing will not affect British companies.

Comment on this

Certainly it will affect British companies.

Comment on this

Then I am concerned with all companies, Saorstát and British.

Comment on this

The Deputy suggests that when this State, for the protection of its own citizens, enacts legislation to provide that companies doing insurance business here should do it on a certain basis, that foreign companies doing business on a different basis, who are made to conform to our law, should be put in this position, that if the change results in any disemployment amongst their staff, the taxpayers of this country are to be made responsible for whatever amount is involved in compensation. That is an amazing proposal.

Comment on this

It may be, but the Minister's statement is still more amazing. There are large numbers of Saorstát citizens employed by British insurance companies in this country. Large numbers of people gain their livelihoods from that business. Large numbers of Saorstát citizens are keenly and vitally interested in the business carried on by the British insurance companies. The Minister must remember that we are only a State for the last 12 years, and a lot of Irish people put money into British insurance companies when there were no Irish companies. Apart altogether from that, I think, as a matter of pure justice, that when the Legislature interferes in the operations of an insurance company, whether British, Irish, Czecho-Slovakian or anything else, that has been lawfully carrying on its business here, deliberately and with the consent of the Legislature of this country, for a considerable number of years, and in strict accordance with the ordinary principles of private international law, there ought to be compensation.

Comment on this

Does that apply to insurance companies only?

Comment on this

It applies as a general principle to any interference on the part of the State.

Comment on this

If, for instance, we put a tariff on boots and shoes imported here in order to protect the native industry, and a commercial traveller engaged by a foreign firm is disemployed in consequence, should that commercial traveller be compensated by the State?

Comment on this

Even though he is an Irish national?

Comment on this

We have made our position in relation to these tariffs abundantly clear. Very grave hardship has been caused by the Minister's economic and industrial policy in this connection, and in ordinary justice he ought to compensate.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy suggest State compensation for commercial travellers and so forth?

Comment on this

We have pointed out on numerous occasions that the Minister's policy has been carried on to the detriment of many Irish nationals.

Comment on this

The policy of the Party opposite seems to be developing very rapidly.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 26
·
Níl 40
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I take it that amendment No. 12 is not being moved.

Comment on this

Is the Minister giving an undertaking to lay every regulation on the Table?

Comment on this

On amendment No. 8 I pointed out that the only matters to be prescribed are matters of form and that none is of sufficient importance to justify this procedure of laying on the Table. They are such matters as applications for licences, for the alteration or revocation of licences, and some other matters of that sort. They do not relate to matters of substance.

Comment on this

I may tell Deputy Davin that I informed the Minister that they were not matters of form but that they were matters of substance.

Comment on this

As Deputy Davin knows, my opinion is a lot better than that of Deputy Costello's.

Comment on this

Did the Minister see what a man named Morgan had to say of his opinion in the Press this morning? He did not think much of it.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding that, my opinion is still better than the Deputy's.

Comment on this

This amendment was given very favourable consideration by the members of our Party, and it was felt that the Minister, who was asking for very drastic powers, should be obliged to lay on the Table——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When amendment No. 8 was moved, it was suggested by the Chair that, if no objection was taken, Nos. 8 and 12, being similar in principle, could be debated together. Unfortunately, no Deputy moved No. 12, but the discussion ranged over both. However, the Deputy is entitled to a decision on it.

Comment on this

I am sorry; I happened to be called out of the House to the telephone at the time.

Comment on this

There was a division taken on it.

Comment on this

On No. 8, but was there a distinction made between No. 8 and No. 12?

Comment on this

They were discussed together.

Comment on this

The decision was obviously taken on one only.

Comment on this

But the contention put forward by Deputy Costello and Deputy Dillon was that if I was not prepared to accept the principle of No. 8, I should accept the principle of No. 12, and, on that basis, I argued against the acceptance of either.

Comment on this

And the House divided on No. 8, which is against having regulations operative until approved of by the Dáil. There is, however, something more or something less in No. 12.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is quite so. The point put by the Chair was that, as these amendments were the same in principle, they could both be discussed simultaneously, with separate decisions if claimed. That suggestion was accepted by the House. The Deputy is, however, entitled to put amendment No. 12 now. To reopen the debate that took place on No. 8 would not be proper procedure.

Comment on this

I want to say that the debate did not take very long, because it was the only period I was absent from the House since business commenced at 3 o'clock. I was only absent for a short period, but that is the reason why I was not aware of the ruling, if you can call it a ruling, given by you, Sir. If you say that I am not entitled to initiate a discussion on the merits of the amendment——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair will hear Deputy Davin. The discussion, however, should be brief, as the point has already been debated.

Comment on this

The Deputy was out of the House.

Comment on this

For only a very short period.

Comment on this

Half an hour.

Comment on this

I was called to the telephone. As I say, this is a matter which was given careful consideration by the members of this Party, and it is a matter on which we feel fairly strongly. I should like to hear from the Minister his reasons for not accepting the amendment. If the regulations to be made are of such minor importance as the Minister suggests, I do not see what great objection he can have to putting these regulations on the Table of the House for discussion, if necessary, in the House.

Comment on this

As I explained before, the only matters to be prescribed in the Bill are matters of form.

Comment on this

Will you give us the sections?

Comment on this

I propose to do so. The regulations will provide for items of administration which are of no importance in relation to the provisions of the measure. Under other Acts we have power by regulation to provide for various steps which might be regarded as having relation to legislation, but that does not arise on this Bill. In fact, I invite the Deputy, as I invited the Deputies opposite, to indicate the particular sections in the Bill under which power to prescribe the various matters in respect of which they think this overriding safeguard is required. Under Section 11 we take power to prescribe the form and manner of an application for an assurance licence, the information to be supplied by the applicant and the fees to be paid.

Comment on this

Is that all that is in the section?

Comment on this

The form and manner of the application and information——

Comment on this

"And such other particulars as may be prescribed."

Comment on this

The information that is to be given.

Comment on this

The colour of the employee's eyes.

Comment on this

Under Section 11, we take power to prescribe the form and manner——

Comment on this

Where is that?

Comment on this

"Every application under this section for an assurance licence shall be in the prescribed form and be made in the prescribed manner, and shall state the class or classes of assurance business which the assurance company making such application proposes to carry on, together with such other particulars as may be prescribed."

Comment on this

The last phrase widens it.

Comment on this

That is merely the information to be given by the applicant.

Comment on this

"Such other particulars" would surely include information as to how the employees were to be dealt with?

Comment on this

No; this is an application for a licence. It has nothing to do with amalgamations or revocations or anything else like that.

Comment on this

It will have a bearing on it.

Comment on this

No; it has no connection with the question of employees. Under Section 16, the form of the assurance licence is to be prescribed; under Section 19, the form and manner of applications for the alteration or revocation of a licence are to be prescribed; under Section 63, the form of consent to transfer from one company to another; and under Section 67, the application fee to be paid on reference of disputes under that section. These are purely matters of administration.

Comment on this

They are such matters of administration as may lead to a criminal prosecution.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

Yes. It says: "guilty of an offence under this section."

Comment on this

In respect of a false statement.

Comment on this

It is leading up to a criminal offence. Is that right or not?

Comment on this

There can be a criminal prosecution if false statements are made.

Comment on this

In regard to these prescribed particulars?

Comment on this

So that a matter which may lead to a prosecution is going to be done by the Minister himself and the House is to know nothing of it?

Comment on this

That is so under the section.

Comment on this

Nobody is compelled to give the information.

Comment on this

If a man wants to get a licence, the Minister may impose on him the rendering to him of certain information, and he may suffer a criminal prosecution as a result of the impact of that section on him.

Comment on this

He may suffer a prosecution if he gives false information.

Comment on this

Within anything the Minister may ask him under that section?

Comment on this

Relevant to the application.

Comment on this

Under that section.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:—

Before Section 6 to insert the following new section:—

The Minister shall as soon as possible after the expiration of each year prepare and present to each House of the Oireachtas a report of his proceedings under this Act during such year.

The administration of this Bill when it becomes law will be a matter which will concern the whole of the insurable population of the country and, therefore, warrants, in my opinion, the preparation and circulation in the manner indicated of a yearly report to the Oireachtas and, through the Oireachtas, to the country. I think that Deputies are entitled to ask for the production of such a yearly report and I hope the Minister will see his way to sanction it.

Comment on this

At the present time statements of assurance business deposited by companies under Section 27 of the Act of 1909 in respect of each accounting period are published annually in an official report and presented to each House of the Oireachtas. The publication of that report will be continued in future, and it will set out, in summary form at any rate, the additional returns and statements which are required to be made under this Bill. I think that publication will serve the purpose the Deputy has in mind in moving this amendment.

Comment on this

It will include in future a report on the working of this Bill when it becomes an Act?

Comment on this

It will not.

Comment on this

Statements of assurance business, amplified as they must be, in accordance with the provisions of this Bill, will be published in respect of each accounting period in future as in the past, except that in future more information will be contained in the report.

Comment on this

I put it to the Minister that the intention of the amendment is to secure in the manner indicated, or, if necessary, in some other way, a yearly report on the operations of this Act.

Comment on this

The operations of this Act might cover a multitude of minor things, and I do not think there should be the statutory obligation to publish an annual report in relation to such matters. My information will be statements submitted by the insurance companies. These statements will be published in summary form together with the fuller information for which this Bill provides.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin ought to understand what is at the foot of this opposition to his amendment. Under the 1909 Act the Minister is not bound to make any report upon anything.

Comment on this

It is made every year.

Comment on this

It has not been. It is waste merely to produce the amount of the valuation in the report. The Minister does not get over that by saying that the Act of 1909 gives an abstract of all this in the paper laid before the House. The Minister may make a report. The Deputy wants in his amendment to use the words "shall make a report."

Comment on this

A report is published every year, and it is the intention to continue that.

Comment on this

If that is the intention will it do any harm to change the word "may" into the word "shall"?

Comment on this

The word "may" often means "shall."

Comment on this

The amendment is refused for the reason that it is not thought desirable by the Minister. The Minister has power to lay this report. He has that power from the old Act; and he may add to it, but the Deputy wants the report laid before the House. The Deputy has this good point in this amendment, that whatever the report may be, as long as it proceeds from the Minister, it is ground for debate. If the Minister merely brings in a formal report there is no possibility of debate. If the report discloses things that are of some moment to the public, then, there can be a debate upon it in this House. The virtue of this House is publicity and debate.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say why he refuses to accept the amendment?

Comment on this

Because it goes much further. The amendment asks that we should issue a report of all the proceedings, but some of them are of very trivial importance indeed.

Comment on this

The word "all" is not used in the amendment.

Comment on this

If the Deputy does not mean that we should report on all these proceedings, the amendment should be qualified.

Comment on this

The benefit of the amendment is that the moment the Minister is found to be deficient in his report a debate could be urged upon him.

Comment on this

In my opinion there should not be a statutory obligation to publish the report. The existing practice gives all the information which may be required. The report was published every year, and will continue to be published in the future, subject to this, that more information will be included in the future than in the past.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say what is the ground for his opinion that there should not be a statutory obligation on the Minister to report to the House?

Comment on this

Because of the trouble involved in the keeping of records and the preparation of the report, in relation to the value of the report itself. All the available information the Minister gets is in fact published.

Comment on this

Does that mean that in the case of private citizens only there should be any amount of statutory obligations, particularly in regard to income-tax, but that there should be no obligation upon the Minister, because he is a Minister, and because the collection of information would give some trouble.

Comment on this

Where is the waste and trouble? Records will have to be kept in relation to the returns, and not even the time of the new civil servants would be wasted. The Minister has advanced two concrete arguments against this amendment. One is that this is done, and the other is that it should not be made statutory.

Comment on this

It is done in relation to the important things.

Comment on this

The Minister will not accept the amendment because it would impose upon him the obligation to do what he is now doing, and then there is his argument that it will be far too troublesome.

Comment on this

More than that. The Deputy's amendment says "the Minister shall as soon as possible after the expiration of each financial year" publish a report.

Comment on this

Why not? A good deal of elasticity could be given to the phrase "as soon as possible". The Minister would be up against criticism of the report. But the collation of reports from information supplied takes time. Everybody is patient with regard to such reports. There is no question of taking civil servants away from other urgent duties to prepare this report. The report generally is published, and I do not see why we should not impose the obligation now that there is so much Government departmental direction in these matters. I ask the Minister to qualify what he has said. He said there always is published, not only an abstract of the accounts but also comments by the Minister.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

He said the report from the Board of Trade is published. It often might have been. The fact that there was any report might have awakened people to the importance of insurance. But it is not accurate to say that there has been a report by the Minister on matters referred to in the 1909 Act. Deputy Davin is right in asking that there should be published a report of the proceedings during the year. If that could be joined up with the 1909 Act it would be still more desirable as an amendment.

Comment on this

I think the Minister took an exaggerated view of the amendment. The amendment asks that "the Minister shall as soon as possible after the expiration of each year prepare and present...a report of his proceedings under this Act during such year". That leaves it to the discretion of the Minister, and his advisers, to furnish a report "as soon as possible." There is no fixed date by which the report should be placed before members of the House after the expiration of the particular year. I take the view that the Bill is one of the Bills introduced during the last year that causes a good deal of annoyance to people. It affects agents, and it affects people all over the country. I think the circulation of an annual report would be very likely to have a very good effect from the propaganda point of view upon the people of the country. If the Minister does not furnish this report Deputies will be forced to put down a large number of questions from time to time, with a view to getting information. That could all be avoided if the Minister furnishes this report.

Comment on this

In respect of what portion does the Deputy want that?

Comment on this

In respect of the major operations of the Bill. The report would also reduce the amount of correspondence coming to his Department or to his officials, as well as probably from the insurable public and Deputies, who have no other means of getting information except by correspondence or, finally, by questions to be answered in the House by the Minister. I think the Minister is taking too serious a view of the demand contained in the amendment. I do not think that it would have any greater effect than, probably, engaging the time of one of his officials for a week or two in every year to compile and prepare for printing a report on the lines indicated. The nature of the report is very largely left in the hands of the Minister himself.

Comment on this

I will agree that, in respect of the sections concerning the determination of disputes, it might be desirable to publish information, much the same as information that is at present published concerning appeals under the Unemployment Insurance Act to the Umpire. As Deputies who read the Trade Journal are aware, we periodically publish, without giving such information as will identify the parties, particulars of appeals taken to the Umpire, so that the nature of his decisions will be known and act as a guide to courts of referees, unemployment insurance officers, and the general public in connection with these matters. In relation to these sections dealing with the determination of disputes, the publication of similar information in a similar way might be considered. But even there I do not think there should be a statutory obligation to publish, which is a very onerous matter in relation to a Bill of this kind, because it means not merely an official spending a week preparing a report, but that all the records of the Department dealing with all matters relating to insurance must be so kept that a report of the proceedings taken under the Bill is possible.

Comment on this

Is not that desirable?

Comment on this

It is not desirable. Read the section dealing with the amalgamation of companies. What report do you think could be published under that section? That a particular scheme was received, that certain objections were voiced, that the scheme was amended in a particular way, and again objected to. Does the Deputy think that all that information should be published? These may be part of the Minister's proceedings under the Bill—the most important proceedings under the Bill —but that information could not, I think, very well be made public, except in very rare cases, without very definite damage to particular interests

Comment on this

One of the pieces of information that might be usefully included in this report, if it were published, would be the regulations which the Minister refused just now, through his voting power, to lay before the Dáil.

Comment on this

I have not refused to publish them.

Comment on this

These would be one of the useful pieces of information some of us might want to have and which could be included in this report. The information that is supplied in accordance with Section 27 of the Insurance Companies Act, 1909, so far as I can see, not having any great practical knowledge of the working of that section, is designed for the purpose of preventing any possible information from being given.

Comment on this

That section says that the Board of Trade shall lay annually before Parliament the accounts, balance sheets, abstracts, statements and any other documents under the Act. I could not conceive any collection of documents more calculated to conceal rather than to give information than abstracts, accounts and other documents. The real purpose of Section 27 is not to supply information to Parliament or to the public. The sting is in the last part of Section 27. It is to enable the Board of Trade to extract information from the companies that they do not want to give under the threat that it will be laid as a foot-note to the abstracts and documents that the Board of Trade is reporting to Parliament every year. That is the purpose of the section, in my view—not for the purpose of giving the public any information but for the purpose of extracting information from the insurance companies themselves.

Comment on this

I would not say that that is the purpose, because the whole purpose of the Act was to implement the principle in relation to insurance business of freedom or non-interference, but full publicity. That was the principle of the Act of 1909 and, to a large extent, is the principle of this Bill—to give the companies freedom to operate within certain limits and to ensure that there will be the fullest possible publicity as to their proceedings. These reports, which will be considerably amplified under the provisions of this Bill, will be put in that form every year.

Comment on this

Perhaps I was incorrect in saying that the purpose of Section 27 was as I indicated and that I should say the practical effect is along the lines I indicated.

Comment on this

Will the Minister, on the next Stage, indicate the nature of the extended report which he is prepared to make after the Bill comes into operation?

Comment on this

It will be similar to the present report, except that the information will be amplified, as provided for in the relevant sections to this Bill. In form it will be the same, but the information will be fuller and in a form which will be of greater value to those who study these documents.

Comment on this