Insurance Bill, 1935—Recommittal.
Contributions 461–705 of 705. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 35 of 1935 ›
I have repeatedly represented to the Government that where sections of Bills are largely legislation by reference memoranda should be circulated with the Bills explaining the nature of the references made. The Minister for Finance has taken the precaution of doing that in connection with certain financial resolutions we have had before us. But, in view of the fact that we are now the solitary representative of the deliberative Oireachtas, I think it is right that we should understand what we are passing in Section 7, which says:
The following portions of the Act of 1909 are hereby repealed as on and from the commencement of Part II of this Act, that is to say, sub-section (2) of Section 28, paragraphs (b), (c) and (d) of Section 31, paragraphs (b) and (c) of Section 32, paragraphs (a), (d) and (e) of sub-section (1) of Section 33, and paragraphs (b) and (c) of Section 34, and the Eighth Schedule.
I do not believe the Minister or the Attorney-General or any Deputy knows what any of those references are. Then the section goes on:
Section 36 of the Act of 1909 is hereby repealed as on and from the commencement of Part V of this Act.
The following portion of the Act of 1909 is hereby repealed as on and from the commencement of Part VII of this Act, that is to say, in sub-section (1) of Section 3 all words from the words "Provided that" to the end of that sub-section.
The Collecting Societies and Industrial Assurance Companies Act, 1896, is hereby repealed.
Not a single Deputy knows what any of these references mean. I think it is highly desirable, when schedules of that kind are mentioned in a Bill of this character, that a memorandum should accompany the Bill setting out what these references are. Is the Minister in a position to give us in résumé what these appeals represent, what effect they have on the existing law?
Comment on this
The general question about memoranda can be discussed on another occasion. In the main, these repeals are effected because fuller and better provision is being made in this Bill to deal with the particular matters to which these various sections and subsections relate.
Comment on this
Everybody knows that. We all know that the Minister purports to put something in the place of most of what is repealed in the section. But the Minister has carefully refrained from stating that everything here repealed is replaced by something else. For all we know, some of those repeals are alterations in the law without any substituted legislation. The Minister says that better and fuller provision is made. That is a matter of opinion. The purpose of discussion in this House is to make up our minds whether that is true or not. The Minister is impatient of that; he says it is obstruction.
Comment on this
I think Deputies have an obligation to read measures before coming here to discuss them. They should know what they are about before discussing them. When I was in Opposition I would not be caught out like that. I would know what section was being repealed.
Comment on this
That is the first time to-day the Minister agreed with anything Deputy Costello said.
Comment on this
Deputies are under an obligation to read and carefully consider every Bill put before them, and my submission is that they can do neither one nor the other when a large part of the Bill put before them is legislation by reference.
Comment on this
It is not the business of Deputies—nor can Deputies be reasonably expected to do it unless they are professional politicians with nothing else to do—to take out the Act of 1909 and go through it as this section would require them to go through it, or to take out the Collecting Societies and Industrial Companies Act, 1896, and go through it to find out what its effect was. I submit that the House is entitled to expect from the Minister, where he finds it convenient to legislate by reference in that way, a memorandum explaining the section which he has deemed it expedient not to set out.
Comment on this
Now that the Minister is no longer in Opposition, presumably he knows the Bill even better than he would have known it when he was in Opposition. He himself says in answer to Deputy Dillon, that the reason why those various parts of the Act of 1909 are being repealed is because fuller and better provision is being made in the Bill. I want to test him on that. I want to test him by asking him the question: What fuller and better provision is being made in the Bill by reason of the repeal of sub-section (2) of Section 28 of the Act of 1909? I will tell him what it is about; it is about Lloyds' insurance. The Minister need not pretend that he has read it; we will assume that he has read it. Will he tell us what better and fuller provisions are made in this present Bill for Lloyds' underwriters than were made by Section 28 (2) of the Act of 1909?
Comment on this
And they are fuller and better? Would the Minister then say, if there are no provisions being made for Lloyds', what is the effect of this Act on Lloyds' underwriters?
Comment on this
As the Bill stands at present, Lloyds' underwriters would not be entitled to carry on any of the classes of insurance business to which the Bill relates.
Comment on this
In connection with this whole problem of issuing licences to insurance companies, the question arose on an earlier section as to how far the Minister can prescribe the form of application for those licences, and in how far can he by regulation prevent persons getting licences by stipulating a fee in excess of what it is reasonable to ask them to pay.
Comment on this
It is a question of convenience as to where the matter will arise. I want to ask the Minister now, on the section which makes it unlawful for any person to carry on an assurance business in this country without an assurance licence, is he in a position to tell the House now what it will cost to get an assurance licence? Unless we hear what an assurance company will be required to pay to get one of those licences, we cannot make up our minds whether we will make it illegal to carry on a business without one.
Comment on this
As in every other Act, the fee will be fixed at the amount necessary to cover the cost of dealing with the application—the cost of the purely clerical work involved.
Comment on this
Of course, the Minister will remember that under the Cement Act a fee was prescribed which was for the purpose of levying a duty on cement.
Comment on this
Exactly, and I wanted an express statement, which I think I have got from the Minister now, that no such procedure will be followed in this connection.
Comment on this
If that is the assurance the Deputy wants I can give it to him right away. This is not put in for any revenue consideration.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:
Before Section 9 to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) It shall not be lawful for any person to negotiate a contract of assurance in Saorstát Eireann save under licence (in this Act referred to as an agent's licence) granted by the Minister under this part of this Act.
(2) Every person, who negotiates a contract of assurance in contravention of the foregoing sub-section of this section, shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding twenty pounds.
I think it would be convenient to discuss amendments Nos. 14 and 24 together. Amendment No. 24 is really complementary to No. 14.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 14 prescribes that it shall not be lawful for a person to carry on assurance business without having a licence, and amendment No. 24 provides for the granting of those licences and the conditions under which they will be granted. I realise that those amendments are to some extent revolutionary, and I know that they do not recommend themselves to a number of Deputies even on my own side of the House; at the same time I think a case can be made for them. The object of amendment No. 14 would be to exclude from the insurance business the bird of passage who has no intention of making insurance his career, and at the same time preserve the insurance business for those who are making insurance their career—to preserve it for the whole-time insurance man. It may be said, as it has been said to me by different persons, that they would prefer to trust their premiums to people they know, like their bank manager or their local auctioneer or somebody of that kind who is in insurance business just as a side-line, than to entrust those premiums to the particular type of agent with whom they might be familiar.
I take a statement of that kind as being an argument in favour of this provision, because I believe that this provision, if given effect to, would wipe out the very type of agent whom those people had in mind. If you make the insurance business something in the nature of a profession, at any rate something that is carried on under licence, and if you exclude the part-time agent whose main income comes from other sources, the undesirable type of agent will very soon disappear. Furthermore, when there are the provisions that follow later on, and an agent has hanging over him the threat that for any misconduct he may lose his licence and be put out of business, it would have, I should say, a very salutary effect. The Minister himself, speaking at an earlier Stage of the Bill, said there was too much intensive canvassing, and that many of these agents were inclined to make fraudulent statements with regard to the policy they were trying to sell, in order to secure business. I believe that, if a provision of this kind were made, by which agents were licensed, that type of agent would soon be wiped out. I believe, first of all, that he might be the type of person who would be slow to pay the licence fee which is prescribed by amendment No. 24, and that if, in addition to any other penalties, there was the danger to him, if he desired to carry on the business, of losing his licence, it would prevent him indulging in the practice of trying to persuade policy-holders that he was giving them something better than he really was giving them.
Now, in a sense, this is not so very revolutionary, inasmuch as we have certainly had precedents in this House for making certain trades or professions exclusive to certain individuals. I understand that there is on the stocks at the moment a Bill making the auctioneering business to some extent exclusive. I was hoping that Deputy Haslett would be here, because I understand that he is very much opposed to the provisions of these amendments which would wipe out the part-time agents, because auctioneers do a good deal in the way of part-time insurance business. If Deputy Haslett had been here, I was going to put it to him that what was sauce for the auctioneer goose ought to be sauce for the insurance agent gander, and I was hoping that I could persuade him that, if he hopes to get a Bill through the House making the auctioneering business exclusive, he ought to support the insurance agents in making their business a whole-time business and exclusive to that extent.
There is an argument that can be used also with regard to many of these part-time agents who do work in the ordinary branch business. I think it is fairly generally known that very many of these agents are rather inclined to discourage the persons whom they wish to entice into taking out policies from doing business with the Irish companies. For the most part they are the agents of foreign companies, and, naturally, they are going to try to sell to the prospective policy-holder the insurance policy of the company for which they are agents. It is also to some extent objectionable that many of these agents are in a privileged position where they can practically force people to take out policies, and that they use those positions to gain an advantage that they might not otherwise gain, and to gain an additional income to their ordinary income. They are in a position, at least, that the ordinary agent is not in, in canvassing insurance. The ordinary agent has to sell the insurance policy for what it is worth. He has to make his arguments and to show the value of the policy, whereas many of the others in privileged positions have a big stick to hold over a person in order to make him take out a policy. It would not be quite so bad if they were agents for Irish companies, but I should say that 95 per cent. of them at least are the agents of foreign companies.
I think there is a case for having the agents of companies licensed, and I think that the effect of having them licensed would be to secure better service for policy-holders. You would provide, in time at any rate, a better type of man entering into the insurance business—a better type of agent, who would give more direct information to the prospective policy-holder, and the policy-holder would benefit to that extent.
Comment on this
Deputy Lynch is correct when he says that a number of statutes were enacted providing for the setting up of registers for persons engaging in different professions and for confining these registers to persons with particular qualifications, or recruited in a particular way. He will remember, however, that when the doctors and dentists and veterinary surgeons had been covered by such legislation, and demands for similar measures came pouring in from architects, engineers, hairdressers, auctioneers and valuers, opinions in all parts of this House rather reacted against such legislation——
Comment on this
——and, in fact, none of these measures ever appeared here except the Auctioneers and Valuers Bill, which appeared here in 1931 and has not got beyond the Second Stage since then, because, I think, of the feeling which existed and evidently still exists among members of all Parties that the restriction of entry into these occupations should not be effected, however desirable it might be to control the activities of persons engaged in these occupations or to improve the conditions under which they work. If, therefore, Deputy Lynch has in mind the idea of putting insurance agents into the same position as veterinary surgeons or dentists or doctors, and elevating insurance work to the status of a profession and confining it to certain classes of people, then I think I would have to oppose him on principle. In so far, however, as his main desire is to improve the conditions under which the majority of insurance agents work, and to give them an opportunity of getting a better livelihood out of the insurance business by providing that the business should be carried on, in so far as it is possible, by persons who are working wholetime in it—even though the number of such persons might be restricted—rather than that it should be carried on by a much larger number of persons to whom it was only a sideline, I have sympathy with that idea. My objection to the Deputy's amendments, and my objection to any proposal for the implementation of that idea which has been conveyed to me, is a purely practical one. I think that this proposal of the Deputy's is completely impracticable and that it could not possibly work. After all, he suggests that the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in his discretion, should issue a licence to a person to act as an insurance agent, subject to his being satisfied on certain points, into which I shall go later. Now, take the very first suggestion: that the Minister should have discretion in the granting or withholding of a licence. The Deputy sees at once that it would be a very difficult position for any Minister to be in, because no matter how he arranges to have every application determined, it is bound to be alleged against the Minister, as Deputies who sit in this House regularly know, that he is allowing political considerations, or personal considerations, or some other extraneous considerations, to influence his judgment.
Every person who is refused a licence will have a grievance, and is going to say that the refusal was due to some other cause except his unworthiness to have it. He is going to allege political victimisation or something of that kind, and in the eyes of the Opposition everyone who gets a licence is bound to be a Government supporter. It can be seen that that procedure is ruled out. It is doubly ruled out when the Deputy sets out the ground upon which the Minister would have to consider each application, first, that "the Minister is satisfied that the applicant is a fit and proper person to hold such licence." How is the Minister to satisfy himself that the applicant was a fit and proper person? He could not do that. Yet this is what follows: every person to whom he issues the licence is deemed in consequence of that to be a fit and proper person to hold a licence. The Minister is not merely giving permission to carry on the business, but the fact is, he is giving a certificate that he is "a fit and proper person" to do so, when he may be nothing of the kind. The Minister would not be in a position to check up the fact that he was a fit and proper person, and some person who was defrauded by a dishonest agent would feel that he had a grievance because he trusted that agent on the strength of the fact that he held a Minister's licence that he was "a fit and proper person," and so on with the other consideration:
the applicant is not engaged in any other business and is devoting or is about to devote his whole time to the assurance business.
Again, the question of the machinery comes in, because it would require very elaborate investigation before the Minister could honestly give the certificate that that was a fact in relation to any applicant. The actual provision of the fee is a minor matter. Therefore, the objection to the Deputy's proposal is that practically it could not be done in that way. I am saying that, although I am in sympathy with the idea, in so far as it can be ensured, that insurance business should be carried on by persons who are engaged whole-time in it, rather than by bank managers and auctioneers—not forgetting the lawyers, who supplement their incomes from that source by occasionally acting as insurance agents.
I say that on consideration of the whole matter, even if there were not the other factor to which the Deputy alluded, and which in present circumstances has some force, that these spare-time agents are, in the main, agents of external companies, and exercise considerable influence in turning insurance business from native companies. In accordance with the Government's general policy of regulating conditions of employment in particular occupations in the interests of persons following these occupations, action on the lines suggested by, the Deputy would be in accordance with our views, and while such action would be logical, my difficulty is that no practical method has been suggested to which obvious objections could not be advanced, and consequently I feel that it is undesirable to put any such provision in this Bill. In any event a provision of this kind should be embodied in a conditions of employment Bill of some kind relating to clerical work or to work of that class rather than in an insurance Bill, just as statutory provisions governing conditions of employment in say, a railway workshop are not in the Transport Act but in the Conditions of Employment Act. When the general code, to which reference has been made, designed to cover conditions of employment in all occupations is extended, it may be possible to make some provisions covering persons in the insurance business, but I do not quite see how these provisions can meet all points that the various agents' associations are anxious to have met.
Comment on this
I am entirely opposed both to the suggestion put forward by Deputy Lynch and to the principle embodied in it. It is the sort of amendment, of course, on which it is possible that an amount of nonsense could be talked. I am not saying that it is put forward by Deputy Lynch for that reason, but the amendment is one, not in favour of the employees but of the big companies. That may come as a surprise to the Minister. I think the Minister would be most delighted if such an amendment were carried, and so would the companies, because it would save them a great deal of trouble, a considerable amount of money by way of commission, but would do the employees no good whatever. That is not the principle I object to. I object to it on two grounds, that it is an endeavour to create a new privileged class, and as a consumer, using the word in its broadest sense, I object to being further fleeced. We are being fleeced by the Minister, right, left and centre, on every possible commodity. The fact that there are numbers of gentlemen, including those much-condemned gentlemen, the lawyers, acting as agents is the greatest possible protection for policy-holders, and would be policy-holders. They can get better terms than they would get if there was only a privileged small class of fixed canvassers available, with whom they had to place their orders whether they liked them or not. There is nothing to be said for the amendment. I should say that a number of people who have had the misfortune, of trying to earn their living as agents for certain classes of insurance have very great difficulty in doing so, and consequently if their field of operations was confined to themselves, they feel that a great benefit would be conferred upon them. The Minister fell into the trap. He talked glibly about sympathy with Deputy Lynch while all the time turning down the amendment by suggestions of an irrelevant ground. There is no Conditions of Employment Bill in which a provision of that kind could be properly inserted. This proposal would be in favour of the employers, and not in favour of the employees, and it is into that trap that the Minister walked.
Comment on this
In opposing this amendment, I suggest that one fact has been lost sight of. Those who have been mentioned as agents for insurance companies, bank managers, solicitors, and auctioneers, are able to perform certain service to persons effecting insurance which I think Deputy Lynch did not appreciate when he proposed the amendment. A person who has a place insured has perhaps a very hazy opinion of the insurable value of the premises. A bank manager is continually dealing with advances and has got a very sure idea of the market value, and is probably able to suggest that the place is either over insured, under insured, or is not insured at all. Solicitors and auctioneers are probably in a similar position. It has been claimed that this business should be reserved for a whole-time insurance agent. I suggest that such a person does not exist at the present time. The whole-time insurance man is in the direct employment, and is the servant, of one of the insurance companies. I do not see how a sort of direct whole-time insurance agent is going to be created. If he is a person of real insurance ability, who spends his whole time following up insurance business, it will not be very long until he is absorbed into the service of an insurance company. The three classes that have been mentioned have to deal with property from time to time, and are more or less experts valuing it, in transferring it, or in some other transaction in connection with property. People who have property to insure may not be able very readily to lay their hands on the class of whole-time insurance agent that Deputy Lynch has in view. If they went and asked for expert advice and did not take it, the insurance agent might feel aggrieved at such action; whereas if some passing reference is made to the value of a property during the period that it is under review by a bank manager or solicitor, it is quite another matter. For that reason I oppose this amendment.
Comment on this
I think that Deputy Dockrell seems to have completely misunderstood what I endeavoured to point out. He looks on the agent in this amendment as some person who is a vacuum and who is not attached to any insurance company. By an agent I mean a person who is employed by an insurance company and who canvasses for an insurance company.
Comment on this
Of course, either a salary or commission. It depends on the particular insurance company. Some have canvassers who are paid salaries; others have canvassers who are paid a small salary and a commission, while some agents are paid entirely on commission. The agents to whom I am referring and the agents for whom I am trying to provide are persons employed by existing insurance companies. I do not accept Deputy Costello's view that this provision would be of no benefit to the agents. He said it would be of benefit merely to the insurance companies. I agree it would be of benefit to the insurance companies, but I think it would be of far more direct benefit to the agents. It would be of benefit to the companies to the extent that the persons who would be employed by them would be of a better type than the persons they are getting now.
Comment on this
The agents would be well able to look after themselves in that respect. The companies would benefit to the extent I have indicated, and they would also benefit by the fact that they would not be let in for the misrepresentation of the agent to policy-holders. The amendment is intended primarily for the benefit of the agents. I have made my case for it, and I do not think that anything Deputy Costello has said can change my views.
Comment on this
It amused me to observe the flash of friendly recognition that passed over the countenance of the Minister when he heard a proposal being made that would permit him to dragoon another section of the community. That element in Deputy Lynch's amendment appealed strongly to his soul, and it was with grief that he could think of no practical way of operating it. It would be such a joy to him to get another body of persons whose every action he could control. In my humble judgment, this amendment has nothing to recommend it in theory or practice. I think it is fundamentally rotten from both points of view. Deputy Lynch, who is familiar with my emphatic style, will excuse the strength of the language which I use. This amendment is designed to facilitate the Minister into dragooning people in their everyday work in a manner which I think is highly undesirable. It is an amendment which will react almost exclusively to the advantage of insurance companies, who will have their agents in a strait-jacket. The companies will inevitably say: "Whereas we have given you 20 or 30 per cent. heretofore, you have such a large area to cover now, and so much more a fertile field, that we propose to reduce your commission. If you do not like it you can lump it, as we can get another man." It has this additional difficulty. Instead of reducing the number of agents, it might eventually operate to increase the number of agents and make things far worse than they now are, because what is to prevent one of these legal agents, who would be created by Deputy Lynch's amendment, employing agents of his own?
Comment on this
Yes, if he is prepared to pay a fee of £5 each for them. Read amendment No. 24, which provides that each agent must pay a fee of £5 on the granting of the licence, and an annual fee of £5 during its continuance.
Comment on this
Yes. He will not get a licence unless he pays an initial fee of £5 and an additional £5 for every year afterwards that he has the licence.
Comment on this
But he would not carry out the contract. The making of a contract of insurance is defined by the Bill and if I were a sub-agent to an agent I would take good care not to carry out the contract. I would go in to Deputy Lynch, if he were a shopkeeper, and I would say: "I know a man who will insure your property very advantageously. Will you give your business to him?" Deputy Lynch would ask me who he was and I would describe him. I would say: "If you take out the contract of insurance with him, this is what he will sign but this is not the contract. I will read you the notes I made when I was looking at the contract." Deputy Lynch would then say: "I shall be glad to deal with him on these terms." I would then trot over to the legal agent, supply him with the particulars I had received from Deputy Lynch, and he would then draw up the contract and I would carry it back to Deputy Lynch. I would be merely acting as a messenger between the legal agent and Deputy Lynch. Can the Deputy prevent that? Where are we going to draw the line? Are we going to provide that if a policeman sees a person crossing the street he must ask that person the purpose for which he is crossing the street? If we do not, how are we to prevent people obliging their neighbours and accepting a honorarium for obliging them? That cock will not fight and it is a good job it will not fight because, if it did, it would provide the Minister with another opportunity to dragoon yet another section of the community.
Comment on this
I am sorry that the Minister cannot see his way to accept this amendment. I think it has a great deal more to recommend it than the reverse. I do not at all accept the view that it would create a specialised class of insurance men, or that it would increase the price of insurance. On the contrary, I think it would effect a reduction, and in proof of that, I might point to the instance of the Public Bodies Mutual. They have no agents in the accepted sense of the word. Consequently their rates are much lower. In my opinion this would be a move in the same direction. There would, of course, be agents still operating, but we would not have the same plethora of agents that we have at present.
Comment on this
I think they should be made a special class or a privileged class. Why should we not put insurance on as high a plane as the law or any other profession? I see nothing at all against it. With regard to the special advantages to which Deputy Dockrell has referred, in the case of men insuring through bank managers. I cannot see the point of that argument at all, because it seemed to refer to fire and general insurance. I think if a man is insuring his premises, he, as the person who bought the premises, knows its value better than the bank manager. On the question of the character of the people with whom you do your insurance, I do not think that there is a whole lot in the argument that the types of people referred to here have been the desirable types. I do not think my experience would support that, and I have had some experience in this regard. I have seen things happening that were very little short of blackmail on the part of these people—things which could not be attempted by the agent. Nobody could get after these people because, usually, the victim had his head in the lion's mouth and, if he squeaked, the jaws closed upon him. There is a good deal to be said for this proposal, and I regret that the Minister cannot see his way to accept it.
Comment on this
I should like to know from the Minister what the definition of "person" is in this section. Apparently, there is no qualification as to place or nationality. A person resident in another country and owning property here could, evidently, be arrested by a Customs official who discovered in his bag a policy or covering-note in respect of that property effected outside the country. Surely, people who are not resident here should be able to effect insurance on their property here without being, so to speak, outlaws.
Comment on this
I am not sure what the Deputy's point is. Is he referring to the possibility of a person ordinarily resident outside the country effecting an assurance policy with a non-licensed company?
Comment on this
The section says: "It shall not be lawful for any person... to effect or to endeavour to effect any contract of assurance ..."
Comment on this
Does it refer only to a national or would Mr. Posanski, who has applied for a naturalisation certificate, come under it? Does it mean a national or does it mean a resident?
Comment on this
A person to whom this Act applies who effects a contract of assurance with an unlicensed company will commit an offence. The Deputy is talking about a person ordinarily resident outside the country?
Comment on this
But if he comes into this country he becomes a person effecting a contract of assurance with an unlicensed company. I can see no difference in the section between that person and a person resident all the time in this country.
Comment on this
I should like to be sure about the matter. The Minister answers me by saying that this person would not be a person covered by the Act. I should like to be sure about that.
Comment on this
The section clearly refers to a person who effects an assurance policy with a company which has not got a licence.
Comment on this
The point Deputy Dockrell makes is that if anybody comes in here with a contract note, he is guilty of a technical breach of the law because he has effected a contract of assurance with a non-licensed company.
Comment on this
That merely emphasises Deputy Dockrell's case. The phrase "ordinarily resident" is used in sub-section (2) but it is not used in Section 9.
Comment on this
It is only an offence so far as the company is concerned if the person be ordinarily resident here, but it is an offence for a person not ordinarily resident to have a contract of assurance with an unlicensed company.
Comment on this
Suppose I have property here, and I go over to Switzerland and effect in Switzerland a policy of assurance with a Swiss company, when I come home am I guilty of an offence?
Comment on this
Is it the intention under Section 9 that a national should not be entitled to go abroad and effect a policy of assurance on his own life while abroad with a foreign company which does not do business in the Irish Free State?
Comment on this
If I bring a motor car to Germany and effect a policy of insurance there against my liability arising out of accident while in Germany, when I come home with my motor car I am liable to a prosecution. Is that the intention of the section?
Comment on this
Obviously, the Minister has not properly considered the effect of this section. For his own benefit, I ask him to get his legal advisers to look up Earl Russell's case on the question whether a man can be guilty of bigamy, having committed the bigamy in the U.S.A.
Comment on this
No, I will vote against this. I must vote against the scope of the section as it stands. I can understand a Minister prohibiting a national of this State from entering into an assurance policy in this State with an insurance company in another country but when the section prevents me from insuring my life in Switzerland for a period of one month while on a holiday in that country and, on returning home, renders me liable to a prosecution it is quite a different matter.
Comment on this
In the case of motor insurance sub-section 2 of Section 10 makes it clear that Deputy Costello would not commit an offence by entering into a contract with an assurance company against a liability that would arise while in Germany.
Comment on this
Sub-section (2) of Section 10 says that if a foreign company issues "in respect of a liability, loss or damage which will arise (if at all) in Saorstát Eireann, or accepts from any person ordinarily resident in Saorstát Eireann a premium in respect of a policy so issued ... if the issue of such instrument of insurance or the acceptance of such premium was done in the course and as part of the carrying on of a business which is assurance business," then that foreign company is deemed to be carrying on business here.
Comment on this
The section does not say that. The section reads: "ordinarily resident in Saorstát Eireann," and this is followed by "or".
Comment on this
Then that company is deemed to be carrying on business, and under the circumstances it is an offence for the person concerned.
Comment on this
No, because sub-section (2) of Section 9 says that every person who carries on any assurance business in contravention of this section shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding £50.
Comment on this
Section 9 says it shall not be lawful for any assurance company or any other person to carry on in Saorstát Eireann any assurance business save under and in accordance with a licence.
Comment on this
That section says that if a company issues an assurance policy it is carrying on business here either with or without licence. If it does not get a licence, then the person insuring with the company is committing an offence.
Comment on this
There are three phrases as far as Section 10 is concerned: "a person ordinarily resident in Saorstát Eireann"; "in respect of a liability, loss or damage which will arise (if at all) in Saorstát Eireann," and "or accepts from any person ordinarily resident in Saorstát Eireann in respect of a policy so issued." These three are in Section 10 and not one of them appears in Section 9. Section 9 deals with the prohibition of insuring with an unlicensed insurer. Section 10 was supposed to be co-relevant to that. Section 9 is clear and distinct from these three points. It says: "It shall not be lawful for any person (otherwise than in the course of reinsurance) to effect or to endeavour to effect any contract of assurance with an assurance company or other person which or who is not the holder of an assurance licence entitling such company or person to effect contracts of assurance of the kind ..." Take a foreigner coming into this country who has already effected a policy of insurance with a German company——
Comment on this
That is not in the section. If it were in the section there would be some point in quoting it. Does the Minister intend to make it an offence under sub-section (2) of Section 9 for a German to come here having in his possession a policy of insurance effected with a German company? Surely not?
Comment on this
There is special provision in the case of motor insurance, where there is an insurance contract made by a person coming in here on a visit. But in respect of any other class of insurance this Bill operates only where the insurance is against a liability that will arise here.
Comment on this
Do we understand from the Minister that he only wishes Section 9, which creates a criminal offence, to be applicable in regard to an insurance effected here? If that is so, then we know where we are.
Comment on this
Supposing I go abroad and I discover that I can get a very valuable life policy at a very low rate from a German company? I am in Germany at that time, and I accept a fully paid up policy for one premium. Is that unlawful when I come back here?
Comment on this
Why should it be unlawful? Is the Minister now walking into a situation that he has not realised?
Comment on this
The principle is that the business must be done by companies licensed for business in this country.
Comment on this
In other words, the Minister wants to create a monopoly for companies who operate in this country, whether they are British or Irish.
Comment on this
We are confining business to companies which are licensed, and that includes all companies doing business at present.
Comment on this
Supposing while in Germany I effected a policy of insurance, am I guilty of a criminal offence, or is it intended to make me guilty of a criminal offence?
Comment on this
If a person resident in another country effects an insurance with an insurance company not licensed here on any property that is in this country, has such a person then making a visit to Ireland committed an offence on putting his foot on our shores? Is that right?
Comment on this
The Bill applies to people coming within the jurisdiction of this country—to no one else.
Comment on this
Do they not come within the jurisdiction of this country the moment they come in here? In other words, had not the person effecting such an insurance better keep clear of our shores?
Comment on this
I am assuming that the Deputy has a policy with an Irish company. English law forbids any person in `Great Britain insuring except with an English company.
Comment on this
Does the Minister mean to say that English law forbids any person insuring except with an English company?
Comment on this
Yes. It does not prevent him taking out an ordinary policy. It only applies to industrial insurance.
Comment on this
Take the person Deputy Dockrell has referred to. That is the case of the man who comes over here from Germany. Take the case of such a person who gets boisterous through indulgence in alcohol. Cannot he be arrested if he enters into a contract with a shopkeeper here?
Comment on this
The Minister may say nevertheless. But how does it happen that the Act does not involve that man? Does not the Minister agree that there must be some purpose in introducing into Section 10 the phrases, "a person ordinarily resident in Saorstát Eireann,""liability, loss or damage which will arise (if at all) in Saorstát Eireann,""or accepts from any person ... in Saorstát Eireann a premium in respect of a policy so issued"? There must be some purpose in introducing these phrases into the section.
Comment on this
At any rate, somebody hereafter construing that Section 10 with limitations and Section 9 without limitations would come to a different reading of it. Does "a person ordinarily resident in Saorstát Eireann" mean a person ordinarily resident and only such person? If it does, why not say so? Is it not intended to mean every person whether ordinarily resident or not?
Comment on this
Obviously it cannot prohibit an Englishman from doing insurance business with English companies.
Comment on this
Surely we are entitled to more than a mere expression of opinion? An opinion is worth nothing more than the reasons given for it. What is the reason given in this instance? We are told that the word "person" without limitation means everybody. Is that right?
Comment on this
So that this has application to persons who are only ordinarily resident here. If it has that limitation then they are prevented from doing any sort of insurance business, not in regard to property in the Saorstát or risks that may arise in the Saorstát, but from doing insurance business of any type once they leave the country as long as they can be caught up hereafter. If a Saorstát national goes abroad for a period and wants to effect some short-term insurance for the period during which he is abroad, and comes back with that particular term——
Comment on this
No, likely to arise outside. That phrase, by the way, is not in the section either. Let us take it that "person" means only a person within the jurisdiction of the Saorstát. Does the Minister mean that if a person within the jurisdiction of the Saorstát goes abroad and effects any type of short-term insurance and comes back before the whole period is expired, he is supposed to be caught by Section 9? I take it that he is not, that there is no intention of affecting that man injuriously with regard to that class of insurance. But is it clear that it does not affect him?
Comment on this
If it is fooling, then it all arises out of your foolish section, and the worst thing to do with a foolish section is to lose one's temper over it. The phrases are either inherent in the section or they are not intended to be there. If they are inherent in the section we should be able to discover them. I suggest there is a danger of people being caught who are not intended to be caught at all.
Comment on this
I will give the Minister the benefit of my opinion of all the reasons. I say that Deputy Dockrell need not be a bit afraid about what he fears. The section does not do what he thinks it might do. On the other hand, the section does not do what the Minister says he intends to do by it.
Comment on this
Good, sound reasons. On the section, supposing a person here, an Irish national, wants to insure his life and for some reason there is a combination of the insurance companies operating here in the Irish Free State against him and they will not insure his life, a good, sound life. He is able to effect an insurance through Lloyd's or some other agency not licensed to carry on business here. Is it intended, in those circumstances, apart from what Section 9 does, to prevent an Irish national from laying off an insurance on his life which he cannot effect here with any existing company?
Comment on this
What will happen suppose you desire to cover a risk that no Irish company will take? I refer now to any licensed company operating in Ireland. I have had experience of trying to get a risk covered by companies who will be licensed under this Bill and none of them would cover it. Eventually, I got it covered by Lloyd's and it was necessary to get it covered at the time. If this Bill were in operation I would have suffered a loss which would completely wipe me out of existence because I could not cover it by insurance. It amazes me if it is not the Minister's intention to make some exception in respect of that. He says it is only fooling around to try to clear the ambiguities of Section 9. There is no doubt that Section 9 is so drafted as to avoid doing most of what the Minister desires to have done and to effect at least two results which nobody intends and nobody wants. However, the Minister is irritated and I assume that between now and the Report Stage the proper amendments will be brought in to set the matter to rights.
Comment on this
To make the section effective, to do what the Minister wants done and to prevent it doing what neither the Minister nor the House desires to have done. There is no reason to reiterate the arguments. Possibly, when the Minister's mind is in a more clear condition he will be able to apprehend what the difficulties are.
Comment on this
Question put: "That Section 9 stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
Amendments Nos. 17 and 18 have the same subject matter and might be discussed together, but as amendment No. 18 is somewhat wider a separate decision will be given if claimed. Amendment No. 17.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:—
Before Section 10 to insert a new section as follows:—
No Government Department, Government owned or controlled company or public authority shall place any fire and accident business with any foreign company until either such body has entered into an agreement with a Saorstát Eireann company or companies to insure with it or with them such business or such portion of the business as the company or companies may agree to accept or such company or companies have refused to accept such business or any portion of such business.
In proposing this amendment I wish to say that I am sorry Deputy Norton is not here because his amendment, No. 17, has much the same object in view. The object of my amendment is to see that Government Departments, and companies and bodies generally under the control of the Government, will give preference to Irish insurance companies where they have insurance business to dispose of. The general provisions of this Bill are anything but favourable to the Irish insurance companies, and in order to make up for what those companies are going to lose as a result of its passing, it is only right that the Government should be prepared to give them some quid pro quo.
It is up to the Government, in a matter of this kind, to set a headline to the public generally. If the Government are not prepared to stand by the Irish companies and assist them, then they cannot expect that the public are going to give a preference to the Irish companies. In the past, local authorities have certainly been very sympathetic to the Irish companies. The Irish National Government has not shown the same disposition. As a matter of fact, it has been the other way about. The Irish companies have always shown a disposition to support our Government, whatever Government was in office, particularly in such matters as the floating of National Loans. No institutions in the country came more readily to the support of whatever Government happened to be in power at the time of the floating of National Loans than the Irish insurance companies. They were the first to come forward with very heavy subscriptions, subscriptions out of all proportion to their capital funds. I think that shows clearly the importance of having Irish companies that are sympathetic to the Government. I think it is only right that there should be some reciprocity, and that the Government, so far as it can, should assist the Irish companies with business within its disposal.
Comment on this
The Deputy puts forward this amendment as a means of compensating the Irish fire and accident offices for what he states they are going to lose under the Bill. The Irish fire and accident offices are not going to lose anything under the Bill; on the contrary, I think that they are going to gain considerably and that the provisions of this measure will result in their getting a much larger proportion of the fire and accident business arising in the Saorstát in future than they have got in the past. The principles of the Bill have been discussed, and the Deputy is no doubt aware of them. We are proposing to allow this business to be carried on by any licensed company that conforms to the provisions of the measure, and the reinsurance provisions in the Bill will mean that a much larger proportion of all such business arising here will be retained within the country and a very considerable part of it will find its way to the Saorstát offices. Under these circumstances, I am not disposed to accept the amendment.
I think the other provisions of the Bill to which I have referred are ample to ensure that the Irish fire and accident offices will get as large a proportion of the business as they are able to handle, and I think it would be objectionable to restrict the activities of foreign companies in the particular manner proposed. The matter of restricting foreign companies in fire and accident business was very carefully considered, and, for the reasons I stated in the course of the Second Reading discussion, it was decided not to restrict them otherwise than as proposed in the Bill, and certainly not to prohibit them from doing that business here. The circumstances under which that decision was taken may change at some time, and if, at any period, the Government in office consider it desirable to impose fresh restrictions upon these companies, it should, I think, be done directly, and not in the indirect manner the Deputy suggests in this amendment. The limitation of the classes of persons who might do particular kinds of business with certain licensed companies would be a difficult thing to control and is, I think, objectionable in principle. We believe that the Bill as framed will confer considerable benefit upon the Saorstát fire and accident offices, and that it is not necessary to insert any additional provisions of this kind in order to effect the same purpose.
Comment on this
Would the Minister give any specific instance of how the Saorstát fire and accident offices are going to benefit as a result of any provision of this Bill—the reinsurance part or any other part? I cannot see it at present.
Comment on this
I indicated that the Government's intention was to ensure that, through the reinsurance provision, a proportion of all fire and accident business arising in the Saorstát would be available for Saorstát companies, and that in that way these companies would be enabled to get whatever proportion of the total business their resources permit them to handle. That proportion will increase continuously as the Bill comes into operation, and in consequence of these provisions, the growth of strong Irish companies doing this class of business will be promoted.
Comment on this
It enables it to be done, but it does not do it.
Comment on this
The Minister asked precisely, with regard to the question of redundancy and the question of amalgamation, to be shown where amalgamations were compulsory under the Bill. Can the Minister now answer Deputy Bourke and say where what he speaks of is definitely pointed to in the Bill?
Comment on this
I explained that the Bill enables that to be done, and, when introducing the Bill, I explained that it was intended to use the provisions of the Bill in that manner.
Comment on this
I am not sure that I am entirely in favour of Deputy Bourke's amendment in all its details, but there is this clarity about it, that it says that Government Departments, Government owned or controlled companies, and public authorities must place fire and accident business with a foreign company, only after there has been agreement with a Saorstát Eireann company or companies to insure with it or with them such business or such portion of the business as the company or companies may agree to accept. Deputy Bourke's amendment aims at this, and says that, so far as Government Departments, Government owned or controlled companies, or public authorities are concerned, they must, first of all, approach, not the Reinsurance Company of Ireland, which may be some peculiar abnormality of which we have no conception of the moment, but some of the ordinary fire and accident companies of Saorstát Eireann origin, or companies described as being of Saorstát Eireann origin, and offer the business to them, and they can take whatever proportion of it they like. That is a concrete proposal. The Minister says his intentions are to achieve a similar result. How? Is it through the reinsurance company?
Comment on this
Would the Minister explain what section enables that to be done? It is not Section 84, is it? The sections from Section 72 on allow for the formation of this reinsurance company, but where is the section which even hints that the reinsurance is going to be put out on commission amongst the existing Irish companies, or does it do that?
Comment on this
The Reinsurance Company will carry on as an ordinary reinsurance company. It will effect these reinsurance treaties on a reciprocal basis. Perhaps I had better read for the Deputy what I said in introducing the measure, at column 1723 of the Official Debates:
"It is proposed that every licensed company, Saorstát or foreign, shall enter into reinsurance treaties with the Reinsurance Company ceding a proportion of its Irish reinsurance business. The terms of the Treaty and the proportion of the business to be ceded will be agreed by the board of the company. The company will at its own option cede risks reinsured with it giving preference to the Saorstát companies wherever practicable. As all treaties at present granted are reciprocal, it will be seen that the external companies will be giving up a portion of their business by ceding to the Reinsurance Company unless the company enters into reciprocal treaties. In this way a certain amount of the Irish business and the profit attaching thereto will pass into Irish hands. This method will provide proper insurance facilities in general and for compulsory insurance in particular, and the business ceded to the Saorstát companies will help them to establish themselves. When this stage is reached the advantage of a Saorstát company over an external company in securing Saorstát business will, it is believed, enable them to obtain a proper share of that business, and expedite the arrival of the day on which the limitation of the business to Saorstát companies will be practicable."
Comment on this
There is no section in the Bill which says that the Reinsurance Company will operate on that policy, but it can operate on that policy.
Comment on this
It need not, but it is intended that the Reinsurance Company should understand, when established, that it is the desire of the Government that it should operate on these lines.
Comment on this
I suppose there is no way of forcing it except by appointing as directors of the company persons who are prepared to operate on that basis.
Comment on this
It is not the amendment. We are discussing first the compulsory section: there is no objection——
Comment on this
I object on principle. It is the wrong way to go about increasing the business of the Saorstát companies, at the expense of the external companies, to confine a section of people to business with Saorstát companies.
Comment on this
This amendment, and that of Deputy Norton, have the same principle behind them, in that both classes of insurance should be limited in that way. I think it is an objectionable way of dealing with this problem. The principle in the Bill is preferable and is designed to increase the business of the Saorstát companies and enable them to build up their resources.
Comment on this
I am definitely against clear-cut compulsion. But this says that with regard to certain business and certain people only connected in that business you give the Saorstát companies first place. They need not take that business. They need only take such proportion as they wish. If the Minister is not shy of that all I can say is that he has a horrible past to look back upon.
Comment on this
There is grave doubt as to whether this portion of the Bill will come into operation at all.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister should have any objection to a proposal of this kind. Every country that has established insurance business gives preference to its own nationals. Various countries which have had to build up their industries in competition from outside have taken a much stronger line. A beginning has to be made somewhere. I think this is a very moderate proposal.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:—
Before Section 10 to insert a new section as follows:—
Every foreign company licensed to carry on fire insurance in Saorstát Eireann shall reinsure either with a Saorstát Eireann company or with the reinsurance company to be set up under the provisions of Part VI of this Act a proportion not less than one-third of every fire insurance policy in excess of £2,000 effected on any property in Saorstát Eireann.
This amendment is on very similar lines to the last, with the exception that the reinsuring company is also given benefit. It cannot be held to militate against foreign companies because they will have to secure the business. We are asking that Saorstát companies ought to derive some advantage in view of the Minister's statement that he is sympathetically disposed towards the Irish companies, and he should accept this amendment.
Comment on this
I will qualify that It will come into existence except alternative proposals are brought into operation that will be equally satisfactory.
Comment on this
And the proposals in the Bill, subject to that, are better than a concrete proposal?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:—
In sub-section (2), after the words "company which", line 45, to insert the words "or a person whether resident or doing business".
So far as the section was originally drafted it purported to exclude foreign companies from issuing policies of insurance here, but it did not exclude persons who are acting, in fact, as agents for foreign companies inside Saorstát Eireann; so it is suggested that the words "or a person wherever resident or doing business" should be inserted in addition to foreign companies in sub-section (2). I am not quite satisfied in my own mind that the insertion of these words is necessary and I would be glad to hear the Minister on the position.
Comment on this
I would be prepared to accept the amendment. I think it is desirable to have these words inserted. Perhaps the Deputy would bring the amendment up at the next Stage when we can reconsider it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:
At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—
Soliciting or canvassing any person in Saorstát Eireann, whether through the post or otherwise, shall, when done in connection with any assurance business, be deemed to be the carrying on of assurance business in Saorstát Eireann.
The object of this amendment is to ensure that a company which is unlicensed for the transaction of insurance business in this country will not be allowed to display, or otherwise solicit, business from persons intending to take out an insurance policy of any kind. In the moneylenders' legislation, at present in force, certain restrictions are imposed. On reflection, now, I do not think that moneylenders from abroad are forbidden to advertise here, but the form of their advertisement is very restricted. However, it ought to be made illegal here to solicit any person to do business with an unlicensed company in the Saorstát.
Comment on this
I do not think the amendment is desirable. It might create certain difficulties. Persons like solicitors, accountants and others, advising their clients upon insurance business, might possibly be held to be soliciting or canvassing and, therefore, guilty of an offence under Section 8. It would be better that this provision was not inserted. It is not necessary and it might create difficulties for the class of people to whom I referred.
Comment on this
It is withdrawn then on the distinct understanding that solicitors, accountants and others may canvass in carrying on insurance business. I call the Minister's attention to sub-section (1) of Section 8 prohibiting any person from carrying on insurance business except in accordance with the licence of the Minister.
Comment on this
What is the purpose of sub-section (1)? Why do you want business entirely transacted outside the Saorstát to be deemed to be carrying on business inside the Saorstát?
Comment on this
The business is not deemed to be. It says a Saorstát company which carries on business.
Comment on this
Notwithstanding that the whole of such business is carried on outside the Saorstát, it is deemed to be carried on inside—why?
Comment on this
It is a Saorstát company for that purpose, and we are, therefore, giving it the rights which a Saorstát company has under the Bill.
Comment on this
In effect the Bill says that any company doing business of a particular kind on the 31st October, 1935, shall be entitled to a licence, and that applies both to foreign and Saorstát companies. After that date a Saorstát company, in order to get a licence, must conform to certain conditions set out in the Bill. A Saorstát company which has been doing business before that need not conform to these conditions. It is entitled to a licence on application. Any Saorstát company acting under this section would be entitled to have a licence without conforming to these conditions, even though at present the whole or part of the business is done outside the Saorstát.
Comment on this
I am only on the point: is there a group of a Saorstát Eireann type doing the whole of its business outside the Saorstát?
Comment on this
I want to ask one last question on Section 10. Apparently there has been difficulty from time to time as to what and where is Saorstát Eireann. We have it in the Constitution, we have it in the Control of Manufactures Bill, and we have it in a variety of things introduced under various Finance Acts and, according to the phrase used, it has been "Saorstát Eireann," or "the area then known as Saorstát Eireann," or "the area then comprised in Saorstát Eireann." What is Saorstát Eireann under Section 10? Is it the whole of Ireland, or the Twenty-Six Counties?
Comment on this
It is the area comprised in Saorstát Eireann at the date on which the Bill becomes law.
Comment on this
Why was it thought necessary to put in that phrase in the Control of Manufactures Bill, and not here? You have used the phrase "Saorstát Eireann" and there is no limitation with regard to the time or whether the judging of the Saorstát is at a particular period when an offence is committed, or at the time, under the Control of Manufactures Act, when the thing is done.
Comment on this
Sub-section (2) of this section relates to something which is in existence now or may exist in the future. In my recollection of the various measures in which I was responsible for that phrase, such as the Control of Manufactures Act, the necessity for it arose out of the fact that the qualifying condition, such as the condition which required a person to be born in the Saorstát, was something which commenced to operate before the Saorstát was established, and before the area of the Saorstát became defined. A particular section of the Control of Manufactures Act says that a facility or concession is available to any person born in Saorstát Eireann, or the area which is now comprised in Saorstát Eireann, and the necessity for that qualification is quite clear in that case, because, of course, a person might be born in the area long before Saorstát Eireann was constituted.
Comment on this
There are two sections in the Control of Manufactures Act relating to what are called nationals and qualified persons. They hinge on the phrase "Saorstát Eireann", or "the areas of jurisdiction of Saorstát Eireann." In sub-section (1) here you have it that a company is deemed to be a Saorstát company although the whole of its business is transacted outside Saorstát Eireann. Is that the Twenty-Six Counties?
Comment on this
That must obviously be whatever area constitutes Saorstát Eireann at the time being.
Comment on this
That applies to Saorstát Eireann in any Act, and yet it was thought necessary to insert a limiting phrase.
Comment on this
In the Control of Manufactures Act and other Acts, where some such definition as I have given arises, a qualified person is a person born in Saorstát Eireann or in the area now comprised in Saorstát Eireann, and that obviously related to a time before the existence of the Saorstát. That does not arise in this case.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Minister should have a look at the Interpretation Act and a lot of the difficulties will be solved.
Comment on this
It should have solved some of the difficulties in the other Acts. I never could understand why it was thought necessary to bring in that phrase in the other Acts in view of the Interpretation Act being there, which defines Saorstát Eireann as having application to the area for the time being within the jurisdiction of Saorstát Eireann.
Comment on this
At an earlier stage we raised the question of fees, and it has to be borne in mind that under an earlier section the fee may be prescribed by the Minister. The Minister subsequently stated that he was determined that the fee would only be commensurate with the cost of administration. Can he now give anything like a round figure to represent it?
Comment on this
I have to get the consent of the Minister for Finance, and I have not yet consulted him. I give my assurance that there is no intention of using this provision to raise revenue. That sub-section is put in, as similar sub-sections were put in a multitude of Bills, because it has become an established practice, on an application for a licence, or some application of that kind, to require by fee recoupment of the cost of consideration of the application; that is, the cost of the stationery or clerical work involved. That is the only consideration which led to the insertion of the sub-section.
Comment on this
I take it the Minister will further be prepared to give the House an undertaking that the fee prescribed for one company will be the same for every other company?
Comment on this
As far as I can see from sub-section (7), which says, "On every application under this section for an assurance licence there shall be paid such fee as the Minister, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, shall prescribe...", it does not clearly state that the Minister shall first prescribe a fee for all companies, and then that all companies will be called upon to pay that fee. It leaves it open to him to prescribe a different fee for each company. I want to have it made clear that the Minister will prescribe the same fee for every company, so that there will be no possibility of this power of fixing fees being used hereafter for the purpose of excluding somebody from entering business by making it very high for one entrant and comparatively low for another.
Comment on this
In any event, that could not arise so far as the fee is concerned. No company can get a licence except a Saorstát company which conforms to certain conditions, and such company cannot be refused a licence except on stated grounds, and subject to appeal to the court, etc. The main group of applications for licences will come immediately after the Bill becomes an Act, and the conditions under which a licence will be issued are stated definitely and fully in the Bill. There is the right of appeal again given from the Minister's decision. It is not intended to have different fees for different companies.