We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Insurance Bill, 1935—Recommittal (Resumed).

Contributions 1–158 of 317. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Insurance Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 35 of 1935 ›

In view of the Minister's policy of having a single Irish company, is this a necessary section or is it for the purpose of allowing the person to transfer from a foreign company to the Irish company, or from the Irish company to a foreign company?

Comment on this

This section is intended to eliminate a certain abuse in connection with transfers, by which people, in effecting the transfers, put themselves at a disadvantage. The whole purpose of the section is to provide that, where such a transfer takes place, the person so transferred shall sign a consent, which, in fact, means that there will be brought to his direct notice the changes which are going to be effected in his insurance— the difference between the policy he is lapsing and the policy he is taking out.

Comment on this

I was stating, in answer to the Minister's point, when we adjourned consideration of the Bill, that this matter had been investigated by the Cohen Committee in England. Though they do not say so, it is well known that the use of the word "transfer" is not really applicable to these cases at all.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

What happens is that a person who is insured in one company ceases to insure in that company and goes off to another. The recommendation of the Cohen Commission states:

"If an effort is made to induce a policy-owner to transfer from one office to another, the office in which he is assured is the best advocate of the reasons against his transferring, and if they receive due notice of an intention to transfer, the matter may sefely be left at that. We recommend that the present section be repealed and a new section substituted requiring a society or company when it receives a proposal for a policy, the premiums under which are to replace the premiums under a policy in another society or company, to send by post a written notice to the latter society or company within seven days of the signing of the proposal. The notice, which should be in a prescribed form, should give particulars of the proposal and of the policy under which the payment of premiums has ceased, or is to cease, on the issue of the new policy. It should be made an offence if notice is not duly given or a policy is issued within 14 days of the service of the notice."

We have, in all this, to remember that we are dealing with people who are not, because of their lack of education, either capable of paying, or are not sufficiently interested to pay, attention to the rather technical details of some of these forms. We have to protect those people. The alert and vigilant people will look after themselves. The Minister's proposal is to make the man who has been insured in one company and who is going off to another company, sign a consent. I suggest that that is not much good. He has already been induced by the agent of the second company to make the transfer. Whether or not it is an accurate case, it must be a good case that has been made to him. It is, at least, one which has persuaded him to make the change. Surely, the best way to balance the activities of the agent trying to get the man transferred is to put on the alert the agent of the company from which the insured person proposes to go. That is the proposal in the Cohen Report, and it is a far better proposal than the proposal here. Make it requisite that notice be given by the proposed transferee company to the transferor company and leave them to get after the matter. If the insured person, in the end, decides to transfer, he will have had the impact on him of two officials—one telling him that he is going into a far better land and the other telling him that he is far better off where he is. He will get an intensive education in the actual points at issue and, if he makes his choice after that happening, it must be agreed that he has had far more freedom of choice, after knowledge, than he would have under the Minister's proposal. The proposal in the Bill merely requires the man's signature which can be easily got.

Comment on this

I stated already that I was not very much concerned whether we adopted the proposals set out in the Bill or the recommendations of the Cohen Committee. We must remember, however, that the Cohen Committee was making a recommendation bearing upon conditions in Great Britain—conditions in which the provision set out in Section 63 of the Bill had been embodied in the existing law and had been there since 1923. No transfers can take place there because the free paid-up policy provisions are in operation. We are only effecting that change here. When the free paid-up policy provisions are in full operation here there will be no such thing as a transfer because, when the policy lapses, the insured person will get a free paid-up policy for a certain amount.

Comment on this

The Minister is not correct in stating that there will be no such thing as transfers. They will take place under more restricted circumstances.

Comment on this

That is so. I am disposed to think that we should have the more elaborate provisions set out in Section 63 in operation here. The recommendation of the Cohen Committee was based on the contention that it was no longer necessary, in the circumstances in Great Britain, to have these more elaborate provisions and they suggested a simpler method of dealing with this problem. There is no legal way of preventing a person lapsing his policy with one company and taking out a policy with another company. What is desirable is that the advantages and disadvantages should be brought to his notice. I think the section in the Bill is better than the proposal of the Cohen Committee but the balance of argument, I admit, is slight. If there is any strong feeling that the Dáil should adopt the recommendation of the Cohen Committee rather than the proposal in the section, I shall be pre- pared to discuss the matter on the next Stage. I feel, however, that it is better to keep these more elaborate provisions, for the present at all events.

Comment on this

Will the Minister put down some proposal which will enable us to have the matter discussed?

Comment on this

I shall either arrange to have an amendment circulated or give intimation to Deputies opposite, so that they may raise the matter if they wish.

Comment on this

Would the Minister have any objection to stating whether the companies asked for this provision or whether it is his own idea?

Comment on this

I do not know what the attitude of the companies to the section is at all. We adopted this provision because some control in relation to these so-called "transfers" was necessary. The provisions in the 1923 Act in Great Britain seem to meet the point to some extent, and we adopted practically the same provisions as they have in their statute in Great Britain.

Comment on this

The Minister has not come to any decision in his own mind against these transfers?

Comment on this

We cannot stop them, because they are not real transfers. The policy-holder in one company allows his policy in that company to lapse, and he pays the premiums to another company. He gets a new policy in the other company in consideration of his premiums. That is what is known as a transfer. There is no legal way of ending it. The change is made because of the representations, very often exaggerated representations, of the agent of another company. The policy-holder will lose by making the change, and it is found desirable to have some provision that the exact consequences of the change will be brought to his notice. He should know what are the consequences to himself of these changes. Deputy Morrissey referred to the case where the agent transfers from one company to another and endeavours to bring all his clients with him.

Comment on this

That is the sort of case that arises.

Comment on this

Yes, that is one of the usual cases that arise, and this is to ensure that the policy-holders will be informed of the effect of the change on themselves.

Comment on this

And take it with its consequences to themselves.

Comment on this

I think that the provisions of Section 63 are better than the proposals of the Cohen Committee recommendation. The only advantage of the Cohen Committee recommendations is that they are less elaborate than this, and provide merely that notice must be sent to the company that is losing the policy.

Comment on this

And that the transfer cannot be effected until a certain period has elapsed. Nobody knows whether the transfer section will apply. What does it transfer?

Comment on this

Sub-section (4) provides that—

the transferee company shall within 14 days after the consent required by this section has been signed, furnish to the transferor company a copy of such consent and a notice of the proposed transfer....

Comment on this

Supposing that one company says: "This is not a transfer; this man lapsed his policy with another company and he is taking out a new one with us; we do not want the man's consent." Unless there is some definition of what a transfer is it is not clear to me how it can be made work.

Comment on this

With either arrangement there will have to be some such definition.

Comment on this

We are not opposing on the undertaking by the Minister to have the amendment circulated or an intimation to us that the amendment will not be made so that we may have it in time to enable us to put down an amendment ourselves.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 144:—

In line 4, after the word "assurance" to insert the words "and any deduction is made from the sum assured other than in respect of arrears of premiums owing upon such policy."

The object of the amendment is to insure that the policy-holder is quite well aware of what deductions are being made. If the Minister can see his way to accept this he will be given the advantage of saving a certain amount of unnecessary detail. I quite agree with the rest of the section. Of course the policy-holder is quite well aware of what premiums are in arrears and he will understand the deductions for the arrears.

Comment on this

I am afraid I could not agree to this amendment. It is important that the policy-holder should be informed from the head office of the company what amount he is to receive so that if the amount actually paid to him does not agree with the amount stated by the head office he can raise the matter with the head office. Circumstances have arisen in which unauthorised deductions have been made. The Cohen Committee report also referred to the matter.

Comment on this

Surely the policy-holder will know himself whether he is in arrears with his payments or not. It would be apparent to him on the face of this document that all that had been deducted from him were sums other than the premiums in arrears about which he knew himself. Would the Minister consider putting in words in the notice to the effect that "the amount of the deductions which do not include the arrears of premiums are as follows"? The provisions of this Bill adequately protect the policy-holders in reference to that.

Comment on this

The Cohen Committee report stated that cases have come to light in which claims had not been paid in full sometimes. The section merely provides that where the company pays a claim, the company can send notice to the person to whom the claim is paid, set forth the gross amount to be paid, the amount of the various deductions, and particulars of the deductions, and explain clearly the grounds on which the deduction were made. That is a clear definition, and it only complicates the notice to leave out of the deductions such matters as arrears of premium. There is no reason why the policy-holders should not get a clear statement of the amount to be paid.

Comment on this

The only object of Deputy Dockrell's amendment is to leave out the arrears of premiums. Everything else is stated. The man himself would know that he was in arrears with his premiums, and he would know the amount of these arrears. I know that there are a number of deductions made every day. Incidentally, they will not be made any more, but there are deductions made of which the policy-holder should be informed. By looking at his assurance book he will know how many weeks he is in arrears.

Comment on this

The purpose of the section is to give the policy-holder a clear statement so that he will know that he is getting what he is entitled to get.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Dillon I move amendment No. 145:—

In line 7, to delete the word "payable" and substitute the word "paid."

Comment on this

That would defeat the object of the section. It is intended that the claimant should be able to raise the question when the amount actually paid to him differs from the amount of the policy and the amount that he had expected to receive.

Comment on this

On this section there is the phrase:

...including an illegal policy and a policy which is ultra vires an industrial assurance company.

There are societies as well as companies and the definition of an insurance company includes societies. It includes "societies" with the addition in the definition section page 8 which reads:

the expression "assurance company" means a company (whether registered in Saorstát Eireann under the Companies Act, 1908 to 1924 ...) which carries on any assurance business, and the said expression unless the context otherwise requires, includes a society, association or other body which is incorporated or otherwise constituted under the law of a country other than Saorstát Eireann and carries on an assurance business.

Is it possible to have "societies" incorporated or otherwise constituted under the law of Saorstát Eireann?

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Dillon, I move amendment No. 146:—

In sub-section (1) (b), line 47, to delete the words "person claiming" and substitute the words "person legally entitled to claim."

I think there is only a small point involved. Whether it is worth making or not, I do not know. Deputy Dillon's intention appears to be that somebody who has a real interest in making the claim should be the only person to the dispute.

Comment on this

But one of the matters in dispute may be whether a particular claimant is legally entitled to claim in respect of a policy. That may be one of the matters in dispute and, therefore, I suggest that it is better to leave the provision as it stands.

Comment on this

If you pass the words "person claiming" instead of "person legally entitled to claim," does that mean that the industrial assurance company can take up the dispute with a person just because he claims, although they might be pretty certain he was not entitled to claim?

Comment on this

The question may arise whether a particular claimant is legally entitled to claim in respect of a policy.

Comment on this

Supposing it is not that matter but something else, it may be beneficial for a company to take as the other party to the dispute a person who claims, although they know that person is not entitled to claim—a sort of collusive dispute.

Comment on this

The person entitled to claim would be claiming in respect of a policy, if he brings the matter forward for determination.

Comment on this

Supposing a dispute has arisen and it is engineered as between the company and somebody who claims, although he has no right to claim, and suppose that dispute is resolved, can the whole matter be reopened when the person legally entitled comes along?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 147:—

In sub-section (2), line 5, to delete the word "validity" and substitute the word "legality."

It is a small point, but it seems to me that where there is a dispute "legality" should be the word.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy is correct in saying that it is a small point, but I am not so sure that he is. I think the term "legality" is wider in its connotation than "validity" and it might increase the number of disputes that would come under the section. I would like to have an opportunity of looking further into the matter. It may be there is not much difference between the two phrases. It may be that the phrase should be "legality," even if it is a wider term. On the other hand, on examination it might appear better to leave the Bill as it stands. If the Deputy will leave the matter over, I will give it further consideration.

Comment on this

"Legality" is used in the British Act.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Dillon, I move amendment No. 148:—

To add at the end of sub-section (2) the words "and in every such case a statement of the nature of the claim shall be delivered to the other party to the dispute at least 14 clear days before the hearing."

This amendment provides that where a dispute arises, the person who is claiming should serve a notice, which may be informal, on the other party to the dispute, setting forth the nature of his claim and the facts and submissions on which he grounds the claim, before the matter should be referred to the Minister. It is only right the other party should know what the alleged dispute is. There may be many cases in which spurious disputes may be raised, but, taking it that the section is passed, I think only disputes of a bona fide character should be dealt with, and, before such a dispute becomes caught in the machinery of the section, the other party should have some idea what it is all about. That is the object of the amendment, which provides that in every case a statement of the nature of the claim shall be delivered to the other party.

Comment on this

I think that is what Deputy Dillon has in mind, but I think he has moved his amendment to the wrong sub-section. It is probable most of the matters referred by the applicants to the Minister can be settled by correspondence with the parties concerned. It is only where an inquiry is necessary, under sub-section (5), and the inspector who is appointed for the purpose gives notice under paragraph (b) to the parties concerned, that any such question will arise. If the Deputy were to move to insert in paragraph (b) an amendment to ensure that at least 14 days' notice will be given at that stage, then I think a case could be made for it.

Comment on this

Has it not also application to this——

Comment on this

At that stage it is desirable to keep the matter informal, because in this country, as was the experience in Great Britain, the great majority of disputes will be settled informally by way of correspondence without any of the procedure contemplated later. It is only where a dispute cannot be settled in that way that an inspector will be appointed and that formal measures become necessary. At that stage there might be a case for requiring a period to elapse after the serving of the notice before other action would follow. I think that period should be provided in sub-section (5) (b) rather than in sub-section (2).

Comment on this

I suggest that it might be put in both. Let me speak on the amendment to the section to which it is at the moment related. In order to get the point clear, sub-section (3) has to be looked at as well as sub-section (2). The point in sub-section (2) is that if there is a dispute, before there is an application to the Circuit Court, both parties may agree in referring the matter to the Minister, and in certain circumstances either party may refer it to the Minister. Once it has been referred, whether properly or not, once that step has been taken there cannot be a submission or an approach to the Circuit Court for the determination of that dispute. Surely it is proper if one party is moving to refer the dispute to the Minister, and the right of approach to the court is then blocked from the point of view of the other party, that he should get notice of that?

Comment on this

So he will. We will write to the party saying we got this complaint from the other party, and making proposals for resolving the dispute either by referring the party to a previous decision or the general practice or something of that kind. In the great majority of cases informal effort to settle a dispute will be made, but it is only where that fails that the question of appointing an inspector, holding an inquiry and sending formal notice will arise.

Comment on this

I am not in touch with Deputy Dillon in relation to this amendment, but I am taking it on the words he has used. He says "in every such case a statement of the nature of the claim shall be delivered." Why is he precise in requiring a statement of the nature of the claim? So that the party without whose assent the matter has been referred to the Minister may decide whether or not it falls inside the exceptions—that it does not come inside the exceptions which preclude it from going to the Minister.

Comment on this

It is not at that stage he would resolve it.

Comment on this

Let us take it that there is a dispute between A and B. A contends the dispute is in relation to a particular matter and he says, "On my own I will refer it to the Minister." B says it is not a matter properly referable to the Minister.

Comment on this

If the Minister proceeds to determine the dispute, an appeal from his decision upon the legal question involved can be taken.

Comment on this

It is by way of an appeal instead of still keeping the matter informal. If B gets notice he may say that the essence of the claim is such and such, and it is therefore outside the type of matter that may be referred to the Minister except by consent. B wants to go to the Circuit Court. Why not permit that to be done still in the informal way? Sub-section (5) may need this as well.

Comment on this

It is quite possible that in the majority of disputes a settlement will be effected in a couple of hours or a day or two, where it lends itself to the informal approach and, therefore, it is undesirable to have the 14 days requirement. It is only where a settlement by these informal means cannot be secured that the rest of the section comes into operation and the matter gets out of the informal plane on to the formal plane. At that point adequate notice to serve documents and so forth is undoubtedly called for. I prefer to keep the preliminary stages entirely on an informal plane, and not to have any requirements that would postpone action for 14 days.

Comment on this

Why should not the second party, in the case contemplated by sub-section (2), have the right informally to say to the Minister: "That is not really one of the matters that should be referred to him at all"?

Comment on this

The dispute cannot possibly be settled without the consent of the other party except there is the inquiry contemplated under sub-section (5). If we cannot get the consent of both parties to a settlement, then we have to go ahead and carry out the inquiry. The experience in Great Britain is that in the great majority of cases disputes lend themselves to this informal treatment and are settled in that way. There should be nothing, I think, in the way of a fortnight's delay before attempting to secure it.

Comment on this

Take two parties to a dispute. One may make up his mind to go to the Circuit Court and makes all arrangements to do so. Suddenly, he is met with the statement that the other party has forestalled him by sending the dispute to the Minister as being one inside the exceptions clause —and then sub-section (3) swings in. In that case he may not go to the Circuit Court.

Comment on this

But the Minister may not accept the dispute as coming within sub-section (2), in which case it cannot be determined in this way. If the Minister does accept it, then it is because he is of opinion that the dispute is properly referable to him.

Comment on this

And properly referable to him by one party without agreement?

Comment on this

May I make this suggestion. If you take out the words "14 clear days before the hearing" and substitute words which will result in one of the disputants getting a statement of the nature of the claim and notification that the matter has been referred to the Minister, that would meet my point. A case such as this may arise. An industrial company, or claimant, may refer the matter to the Circuit Court. The other party forestalls him by referring it to the Minister. The Minister would ordinarily notify the person who had intended to go to the Circuit Court that he must stay his hand pending the Minister's decision as to whether the Minister would take the matter under his own jurisdiction or not. When the Minister has made up his mind to communicate to the second party, I would ask him to send a copy of the nature of the claim to the person whom he was staying from going to the Circuit Court.

Comment on this

My suggestion was that I was prepared to consider the insertion of the 14 days requirement under paragraph (b) of sub-section (5). When the matter in dispute has gone as far as that, it is on the formal plane, and notice of intention to each party is probably required, but at the earlier stage I think the Minister should be free to try to effect an informal settlement of the dispute by agreement between the parties as soon as possible. In the majority of cases it is probable that he would be able to get that. It is only where he cannot get that agreement that a formal determination would be given.

Comment on this

If the Minister takes it under his own jurisdiction, I take it that what will happen is that he will appoint an inspector?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

If the Minister will consider putting in a substantially similar amendment in connection with sub-section (5) that will meet my point.

Comment on this

I will look into it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 149:

In sub-section (4), line 14, to delete the word "may" and substitute the word "shall."

The word "may" leaves a discretion to the Minister. I think it should be made mandatory on him to cause an inquiry to be held.

Comment on this

"May" means "shall" in this sub-section as in the earlier one. It is impossible to foresee the circumstances under which a dispute referred to the Minister would not be determined by him in accordance with the provisions of the sub-section.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean that if at any time anybody refers a dispute to the Minister he has got to determine it?

Comment on this

I cannot see the circumstances under which the Minister would refuse to do that if the dispute were properly referable to him.

Comment on this

But if it is not?

Comment on this

Well, then he will not do it. "May", in effect, means "shall." It means that in the case of any dispute properly referable to him he will determine it.

Comment on this

It means "shall" with reservations.

Comment on this

Will the Minister have to signify his refusal to settle the dispute before a person can go to court, or, if the dispute is referred to the Minister and he sits back and says: "Well, I may settle this and there is no reason why I shall settle it," in a case like that, is the dispute to remain suspended like Mahomet's coffin?

Comment on this

No. In practice, the Minister will do it, and that is why we are enacting the section.

Comment on this

I would again remind the House that, in connection with the civil servants' dispute in which it was provided that the Minister "may" settle certain points and refused to do so on the grounds that he had not time, mandamus proceedings were taken against him in the courts. In that case the courts held that "may" amounted to "shall" within a reasonable time. Are we to assume that it is in the Minister's mind that "may" in this context means "shall" within a reasonable time?

Comment on this

Certainly. I do not think that the Minister will be anything slower in giving his decision than the Supreme Court.

Comment on this

Be careful now.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 150:-

In sub-section (4), line 16, after the word "him" to insert the words "being a practising barrister of not less than five years' standing."

a matter that has arisen on a number of other Bills in connection with questions giving rise to the production of evidence, the weighing of evidence and of comparing the comparative value of statements made by claimants. It has been deemed desirable to take such matters out of the hands of civil servants and to put them into the hands of persons with judicial experience. This amendment was incorporated in the Pigs and Bacon Act when similar arbitrations were under consideration. I suggest to the Minister that it is a desirable amendment to insert in this Bill. It may be necessary to provide that the practising barrister conducting inquiries of this kind should have an assessor to assist him when matters in reference to actuarial calculations arise. Otherwise, I think the amendment is all right.

Comment on this

I think it is better to leave the Minister free in the selection of a suitable person. I think he can be relied on to select the person who would be best able to determine the disputes coming up. It may be that the most suitable person to deal with these matters would be somebody with experience in relation to insurance matters or the carrying on of an industrial assurance business, or a civil servant, an officer in the Department of Industry and Commerce, who had been dealing with these matters previously. I think it is better to leave the Minister free. I know it has been the practice in a number of Acts to put in a condition such as this, but I think that recently the tide has turned in the opposite direction. I have noticed in a number of enactments passed in Great Britain and Northern Ireland and in other Parliaments that provisions of this kind in previous Acts are being repealed, and that a freer hand is being given to the Minister in each case.

Comment on this

That is because the system of bureaucracy is approaching its zenith in England and we want to stop that here. From my experience I am perfectly satisfied that officials in Departments of State would do their best to keep professional men out of matters of this kind.

Comment on this

If the amendment were moved by a trades union representative I could understand that.

Comment on this

It is moved by a trades unionist. Deputy Dillon is a barrister and a member of the Bar Library.

Comment on this

I think the Minister is making a mistake. I yield to no one in my admiration for the permanent officials of the Departments of State within their respective spheres, but, like all other men, they have their shortcomings, and one of these arises from the fact that they are withdrawn to a certain extent from contact with their fellow beings; in fact, they are bureaucrats, and as such very often take extremely——

Comment on this

We have several barristers of four or five years' standing.

Comment on this

I know that well.

Comment on this

You have several B.L.s but no barristers.

Comment on this

We have barristers exercising statutory functions.

Comment on this

I went to discuss the packing of eggs with a civil servant in the Department of Agriculture, and I found he was a barrister. That did not qualify him to deal with the question of whether eggs should be packed on their broad or narrow end. One finds barristers in the most extraordinary places in Government Buildings, but these are barristers gone astray.

Comment on this
A Deputy

No.

Comment on this

They have turned their back on their profession and have devoted themselves to doing invaluable work for the State. Let no note of levity involve any disrespect for the services they render the community. My desire is to bring in a person ordinarily engaged in judicial business for the purpose of hearing claims which, by another sub-section of this section, are sent to the courts of the country, thereby admitting that in certain circumstances——

Comment on this

On a question of law only.

Comment on this

In certain circumstances this section says that the contesting parties can go to the Circuit Court. If one of them proposes to go to the Circuit Court and the other wants to go to arbitration, as the more expeditious and economical method of settling the dispute, he can stay the Circuit Court proceedings by referring the matter to the Minister. I do not want to remove all judical atmosphere or judicial habit from the person who is going to decide this between the parties. Suppose you have a dispute between an industrial assurance company and a claimant, the company may have been in contact with the Department time and time again in the ordinary course of business. Rightly or wrongly, they may feel that the officials of the Department are unfriendly to them owing to some dispute which may have been dragging on about another matter. Suddenly a policy-holder precipitates this procedure upon them, and they have to go to arbitration, believing that the responsible official who is called upon to arbitrate goes into the arbitration with the preconceived notion that this is a slippery insurance company, or something of that kind. The Minister must realise, if he is going to delegate the work to someone in his Department, that common gossip in the Department will be present in that person's mind. If an insurance company has a good or a bad reputation, that must weigh in the mind of the person called upon to consider the respective claims of the policy-holder and the insurance company. If the insurance company has a reputation for high rectitude, the case would begin with the profound conviction in the mind of the assessor or arbitrator that there is no justice in the claim, because this company is a decent company and does not try to put quick ones over on the people. If, on the other hand, the Department feels that this is a company that had to be watched or checked or rebuked in the past, the official deciding the claim will say: "There must be something in it; this company has been giving trouble for years; it is very fortunate that we have a concrete case that we can go into." I say that such considerations should not operate in the mind of the person called upon to arbitrate under this section. Therefore, I want an external lawyer brought in.

Comment on this

There is nothing in the amendment about an external lawyer.

Comment on this

It says a practising barrister of five years' standing.

Comment on this

I knew it was there.

Comment on this

They are immune from all these influences and considerations?

Comment on this

They are coming to the inquiry with a detached mind. They do not know the facts; they know nothing of the two parties.

Comment on this

The Deputy may take it for granted that whoever acts in these disputes will probably be the same person for them all. It is most improbable that the Minister will appoint different inspectors for different disputes.

Comment on this

It ought to be a person who has nothing to do with the administration of the Act. It ought not to be a person who has been in contact with either of the parties to the dispute in previous years.

Comment on this

It may not be. It may be an official from the Attorney-General's office, or the legal adviser to the Department. I think the Deputy can rely upon it that the Minister will appoint somebody with the necessary qualifications to do the job properly, but the Minister should have a free hand.

Comment on this

The Minister's views of what the necessary qualifications are may not coincide with the views of the House. Every other Minister has accepted the view I have put forward.

Comment on this

I know that the Department of Finance has never accepted that view.

Comment on this

For a different reason.

Comment on this

They do not want to pay a decent fee.

Comment on this

The Minister's Department is the only Department affecting the trade or commerce or business of the country which declines, in the case of arbitration between two citizens where the duty devolves upon him to appoint a nominee, to choose somebody who shall not be in ordinary touch with the every-day business of the Department and further declines to choose somebody who will have experience in judicial matters in order that the evidence will get proper and fair consideration.

Comment on this

The Minister in interjecting a remark during Deputy Dillon's speech said that the intention was that there should be a person appointed more or less permanently to do this work.

Comment on this

That is more probable than that a separate person will be appointed for each case.

Comment on this

That is a matter I had intended putting a question upon in connection with the section. I have an absolutely open mind on the subject. I repeat that I object to this section in toto. Assuming the section goes through, and it will go through, I think the machinery set up should be the best possible. I have no doubt that the Minister will, in his own interest, endeavour to get a person whom he thinks will do the job as well as it can be done, but if you consider the machinery set forth to determine these disputes you will find that the Minister is the final arbiter. He is the person who decides, and decides on the report of the inspector. The report will probably be in a document. Possibly, although it is not stated in the Bill, that will be supplemented by an oral interview with the Minister. It may, or it may not be. At all events, the fact that the report is a good one or a bad one is of vital importance to the Minister to enable him to make up his mind.

When an inspector is hearing the parties on both sides, if he is a man who is not conversant with the ordinary practice in court where witnesses give evidence, he will not be able to tell whether a particular witness is or is not telling the truth. Where a question of fact has to be determined, the Minister will not be able to determine that fact, because he will not be able to determine it from some document. The person who determines it is the person who sees the witness. The inspector who investigates and makes the report will be under the obligation to make up his mind as between the two parties. The Minister may reject that if he likes. Under the section, he could ignore the whole thing and say: "Although you believe A.B. I think, on reading your report, that you ought to have believed C.D." That is still open to the Minister and it is one of the objections to the section; but for the purpose of my argument at the moment, what I am pressing on the Minister is that some person should be appointed who has had experience of determining questions of fact. An advocate in the ordinary course of his day's work sees witnesses, cross-examines them and examines them; he hears judges giving their decisions and making up their minds as to which person is telling the truth, and in that way, merely as an advocate, he gains sufficient experience to enable himself to know with a very considerable amount of accuracy whether any given witness, whether he is for him or against him, is telling the truth.

Most of these decisions will be either pure questions of law or questions of fact. If they are pure questions of law, it makes precious little difference because they would probably go to the court, but if they are pure questions of fact, it is of most vital importance that people who are accustomed and trained to deal in facts should be in a position to sift the wheat from the chaff. Trained people are better able to do that than untrained people, and even the best civil servant, in my view, as a practising barrister, has no proper qualifications for doing that. He is hopeless at that, in my view, and I say that without any disrespect to any of the officials. Even a barrister who has practised and has gone into a sheltered occupation in the Government service loses touch, loses his sense of the realities of life and of the realities of a case operating in court, and, mind you, there is a considerable difference between a case running in court and as it appears on paper. While I am supporting this amendment of Deputy Dillon's, I am not doing it at all in the interests of my own profession. The amount of money to be made out of this, from the point of view of my profession, would be absolutely negligible. I am doing it from the point of view of the interests of the parties who are forced to take up this method of determining disputes, and they ought to get the best possible method of having those disputes determined and the best people to determine them for them. It is in their interests that I am pressing this amendment. I think a practising barrister whose daily duty is to deal with these questions of fact is the best person to do it.

Comment on this

I am still of opinion that it is better to leave the Minister free of any such condition. It is certain that he is going to get a person who has all the necessary qualifications. It is inconceivable that a Minister would entrust this work to somebody on whose recommendations he is not prepared to place the fullest possible reliance. On the general question as to whether we could get persons other than barristers competent to do this work, I think we can. Deputy Costello, I am sure, appreciates fully how far this kind of procedure has gone in relation to a number of matters.

Comment on this

In the case of unemployment insurance, for instance.

Comment on this

In respect of unemployment insurance, I am sure that about five times a week I determine the question whether a particular occupation is insurable or not.

Comment on this

And there is an appeal from you to the umpire, who is a barrister.

Comment on this

Not on that matter. There is an appeal to the courts, but since I came into office, I do not think there has been a single appeal. It is, perhaps, a tribute to the wisdom of the judgments given. The procedure is precisely the same here. There very frequently is, and, in fact, in every case I think there must be, an inquiry. An officer interviews the parties, hears evidence, and very often the evidence of the parties is in very violent conflict, as to the nature of the work a particular person had to do, and particularly whether it was agricultural work or partly some other class of work. On his report, setting out the facts of the employment as he saw them, and the evidence of the different parties, a decision is made.

Comment on this

Very frequently, after consulting the Attorney-General's Department.

Comment on this

After consulting the legal adviser to my own Department.

Comment on this

And, subsequently, the Attorney-General's Department.

Comment on this

That happens on occasion. In relation to that Act, a position has been reached where every case that comes up has had a precedent — a similar case has arisen before and a similar decision can be referred to. That will arise in relation to this Act at some stage, too, and simplify the procedure, but I do not think that any difficulties have arisen, and I am sure there are other Acts in respect of which the same procedure is in operation. The limitation of the Minister's power to the selection of a person who is a practising barrister is, I think, undesirable, although, in fact, the person appointed may come within that description.

Comment on this

But surely the effect of this will be that, if the Minister does not have a trained legal investigator, the unfortunate legal adviser in his Department, who, to my own certain knowledge, is over burdened with work, will have an additional burden placed upon him, because he will be constantly consulted, both by the inspector, probably during the course of the investigation, and certainly by the Minister, when the report comes in and before he reaches his decision. I think the Minister will probably find that he will have to increase his legal adviser's staff and the staff of the Attorney-General's Department, but certainly he will have to get legal advice from his own legal adviser and the Attorney-General's Department on practically 99 per cent. of the cases that arise under this section.

Comment on this

That may be quite true of the first series, but after a time we will have cases repeating themselves in type almost continuously.

Comment on this

Well, I am glad I am not in the Attorney-General's Department at the moment.

Comment on this

The Deputy may be again.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 152:

In sub-section (6), line 36, after the word "law" to insert the words "or of fact."

What is the Minister's view on this amendment?

Comment on this

I would prefer the Deputy to vote against the section, because it comes to the same thing.

Comment on this

I am afraid, under the circumstances, it would not leave very much of it, but if the Minister were inclined to accept my last amendment, suggesting that arbitration should be conducted by a barrister of five years' standing, I would have no scruple about withdrawing this amendment. In the existing circumstances, when I do not know who is going to be the arbitrator, or what the nature of the arbitration is going to be, because that will largely depend on the personality of the person conducting it, I feel that there ought to be an appeal to a court of law, so that a judicial person may have the facts and the law in any case where one of the parties thinks it necessary to appeal from the decision of the arbitrator.

Comment on this

The whole purpose of the section is to give the Minister the final decision on questions of fact where a dispute is referred by both parties, or, in the particular circumstances described, by one of the parties. The range of cases where a dispute can be referred by one party is limited. If it is referred by both parties, it is evident that they are willing to accept the Minister's decision on the facts as final.

Comment on this

I admit, if the Minister had accepted the amendment as to the appointment of a barrister, I should have no hesitation in withdrawing this amendment. However, under the circumstances, I withdraw it with great reluctance.

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider between now and Report Stage changing the actual wording of this sub-section? The provisions as they stand at the moment are that the Minister shall, at the request of any party to such dispute, refer any question of law arising in such dispute, etc. I suggest that he should insert there that an appeal should lie from the decision on a question of law. If the sub-section stands, I can see that there will be a considerable amount of wrangling as to what is and what is not a question of law. One party to the dispute will ask the Minister to refer that to the court. The Minister will say, having consulted his legal advisers, already overburdened, as I have said: "Is this a question in law which I am bound to determine or send forward?" and there will be a considerable amount of trouble and worry to all parties, whereas, if the suggestion I make is adopted, it would be left to the court to decide whether a particular thing brought to the court is or is not a question of law.

Comment on this

You do not want to make that too easy. The whole purpose of the section is to give the type of person who does industrial assurance an opportunity of getting a determination of any dispute that may arise between him and his company, without being intimidated by the possibility of costs arising on appeal altogether out of proportion to the value of the policy. Therefore, I think we should have the wording of this sub-section so cast that an appeal will not take place unless there is genuine ground for it; in other words, that the principle of appeal will not be used by insurance companies merely to intimidate policy-holders from availing of the section by involving the first applicants under the section in undue costs.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 153:—

In sub-section (8), line 49, after the word "shall" to insert the words "unless the amount thereof shall be determined by the Minister at the request of the parties."

I think this is a very good amendment. To be sending these cases to the Master of the High Court to be taxed when neither party wants to go there, and when both parties are prepared to accept the Minister's taxation of the costs, would seem to be a peculiar idea, and I think that this amendment is a very sensible suggestion.

Comment on this

But sub-section (7) empowers the Minister to order the costs and expenses incurred by any person of appearing or being represented at any inquiry held under the section to be paid by any other person who appeared or was represented at such inquiry, and sub-section (8) merely enables any persons, if they so desire, to have the costs and expenses taxed and ascertained. I think the question of cost is adequately covered by the previous sub-section.

Comment on this

All I want to ensure is that, if both parties come to the Minister and say that they prefer to have the costs taxed by the Minister instead of going to the High Court, it will be possible for the Minister to do so, and to bind the costs by his taxation if there is prior agreement to submit to him. Is that done here?

Comment on this

Well, not quite—not in that form, certainly. It says in sub-section (7) that whenever the Minister determines a dispute referred to him under this section, he may, if he thinks proper to do so, order the costs and expenses to be paid, and so on.

Comment on this

There is nothing in the sub-section to preclude agreement between the parties whether as a result of an agreement between themselves or leaving it to the Minister.

Comment on this

I think it would be better to leave it as it is. I looked into the matter, and it seemed to me that, having regard to sub-section (7), the matter of costs is adequately dealt with.

Comment on this

Very well. I shall withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 154:—

At the end of sub-section (9) to add the words "provided that no fee so prescribed shall exceed the following scale:—Where the claim does not exceed £10, 5/-; where the claim does not exceed £25, 10/-; where the claim does not exceed £50, 20/-, with an additional sum of 10/- for every additional £50 or part thereof."

This is the sub-section referring to the payment of fees, and the amendment provides that no fee prescribed shall exceed the scale which is set out in the amendment. I think it is a rather good amendment. I think it is self-explanatory, and that there is no need to waste the time of the House. What is the Minister's view about it?

Comment on this

I think it is better not to fix the amount of fees in the Bill. It may be found necessary from time to time, in altered circumstances, to vary the amount of the fees, and it is better to leave it as it is in sub-section (9) so as to avoid the necessity for future legislation on that point. The sub-section is set out in the usual form, and says that the fee shall be prescribed by regulations made by the Minister under this section with the consent of the Minister for Finance. If the Deputy fears that this section will be used for the purpose of getting unduly large fees, he can be reassured on that point, because any attempt to do so would defeat the whole purpose of the section.

Comment on this

I agree. However, if the Minister is prepared to say that the Orders made for the purpose of prescribing the fees in connection with this section are being laid on the Table of the Dáil, I think that would overcome the difficulty.

Comment on this

The idea is to keep the fees as low as possible. The fee shall be prescribed by the Minister for Industry and Commerce with the consent of the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

Well, I do not press the amendment.

Comment on this

I wish to register a protest, Sir, against Section 67 on principle, but subject to that the section is agreed to.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 155 standing in the names of Deputies Keyes and Pattison:—

To delete sub-section (2) and substitute the following sub-section:—

(2) No person (other than a director, a member of the committee of management, the secretary, an assistant secretary, treasurer, auditor, actuary or a person employed in a professional capacity) employed by an industrial assurance company shall attend or be present at any meeting of such company.

Sub-section (2) of Section 69 says that a collector employed by an industrial assurance company shall not attend or be present at any meeting of such company, and the first sub-section specifies other restrictions in relation to collectors. Perhaps the Minister will explain the reasons for the section as contained in the Bill.

Comment on this

I can see no reason why officers and employees of the company other than collectors should be prohibited from attending at meetings of the company, but the peculiar position of collectors as intermediaries between the company and the company's policy-holders makes it undesirable that they should be present at the company's meetings. That objection, however, does not appear to apply to the indoor staff of the company.

Comment on this

I am not particularly interested in this except from a commercial point of view, and I would like to ask the Minister what his view of a meeting is. I would have thought that he meant by that a board meeting because, as it appears, it would practically prevent a collector attending at the premises of the company and talking to several of the officials. As I say, it is from an industrial point of view that I am wondering if the Minister does not mean a board meeting.

Comment on this

Why should not a collector attend a meeting of the company?

Comment on this

Because it is held that a collector, being an intermediary between the company and the policyholder, should not be present at the annual meeting of the company; that he occupies a peculiar position in relation to the company, and it was held that it was undesirable that he should be present. We are carrying into this law provisions that have been in operation already. Perhaps the situation which occasioned them may be in course of modification with the passage of time, but it is probably desirable to retain them at present.

Comment on this

Was this brought over from the British legislation?

Comment on this

From the Collecting Societies Act of 1896.

Comment on this

That Act has been repealed by the Bill, but we are carrying forward this provision.

Comment on this

In that event, Deputy Dockrell's question will have to be answered because, according to this, it would seem that collectors could not attend any meeting. Is this a prohibition against attending a collectors' meeting, let us say, or a general meeting of the company?

Comment on this

A general meeting of the company.

Comment on this

That is not very clear, is it?

Comment on this

Yes, a meeting of the shareholders of the company.

Comment on this

Is a meeting of a board of directors of a company a meeting of the company?

Comment on this

No, that is a meeting of the board of the company. It is set out somewhere and I am trying to find it for the Deputy.

Comment on this