Insurance Bill, 1935—Recommittal (Resumed).
Contributions 159–317 of 317. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 35 of 1935 ›
I think so. What constitutes a meeting of a company is dealt with in Section 64 of the Companies Consolidation Act, 1908.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 156:—
To delete sub-section (4).
The purpose of this amendment is to delete the reference to part-time employment. It is felt that in the reorganisation of the business, having regard to the position of the employees of the company, they ought to be fulltime employees and that arrangements should be made accordingly.
Comment on this
The effect of the sub-section is not what the Deputy intends. The effect would be to allow a part-time employee to employ another person to do a matter that is prohibited by the section. Sub-section (1) reads:—
Neither an industrial assurance company nor any person employed by any such company shall employ any person who is not in the regular employment of such company to procure or endeavour to procure any person to enter into a contract of industrial assurance with that or any other industrial assurance company.
In sub-section (4) we merely define what is regular employment. It is clear that whatever prohibition should apply against regular employees should apply also against employees who are part-time employees.
Comment on this
Will the Minister endeavour to meet what is behind the amendment?
Comment on this
I know what is behind the amendment, but that would relate, possibly, to another type of Bill than the one we have before us, dealing with the regulation and conduct of insurance companies in relation to policy-holders. A conditions of employment Bill relating to the insurance industry would have to be framed differently.
Comment on this
Reference to "collector" appeared originally in Section 43. Sub-section (2) of Section 70 says:—
Every person (other than an industrial assurance company) who employs another person to procure or endeavour to procure any person to enter into a contract of industrial assurance with an industrial assurance company shall be guilty of an offence under this sub-section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding £10.
Section 43, however, says that "collector" means a person,
howsoever remunerated, who makes house to house visits for the purpose of receiving premiums payable on policies of industrial assurance and includes a deputy of or substitute for any such person, and also includes a person who holds any interest in a collecting book.
Comment on this
Suppose a person solicits business or induces a person to enter into insurance with an industrial assurance company?
Comment on this
The Deputy is confusing two things. The term "collector" is commonly used to describe an official of an insurance company. We are using the term "collector" in this Bill only where we mean what exactly is the definition of the word "collector." Undoubtedly it is applied generally to certain persons employed by an insurance company. The word "collector" nevertheless is not used because we do not mean it in the sense defined here. We mean an agent of the company.
Comment on this
How far does sub-section (3) operate? It says:
Every person not in the regular employment of an industrial assurance company who procures or endeavours to procure any person to enter into a contract of industrial assurance with such company shall be guilty of an offence under this sub-section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding ten pounds.
Does that mean that if I say to someone that it would be a wise thing to take out a policy with a company I commit an offence?
Comment on this
I do not think so. I do not think the phrase "procures or endeavours to procure" would cover advice given. It certainly would not cover advice given by a solicitor or bank manager.
Comment on this
It astonishes me. Supposing I go to a person and say that I think it would be a wise thing to take out a policy of insurance to provide expenses which are likely to accrue, and tell that person that he would be well advised to go to So-and-so, am I not trying to procure business for an insurance company?
Comment on this
Speaking personally of what will happen, people will come to me and tell me the facts and ask what they ought to do. In certain circumstances, I may advise them that the best thing to do is to take out an insurance policy and to pay 6d. a week so that they will have a nest-egg to meet contingencies when they arise. If I tell them they had better see So-and-so, ordinarily I would name a certain insurance company. That would amount to an inducement to take out an insurance policy, and it seems from this sub-section that it would make me liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding £10. If that is so I object most strenuously to the section.
Comment on this
The whole purpose of the section is to prevent misrepresentation as to the advantages to be secured by insuring with a particular company, by persons not agents of the company. If they are agents of the company there are other means of dealing with them. It is quite clear that the provisions of the section will not operate to render liable to a penalty a person who gives friendly advice. That is different from procuring any person to enter into a contract.
Comment on this
I am afraid the construction of the sub-section is open to the interpretation given it by Deputy Dillon. It may be far fetched but it may happen. Perhaps a person might in his own interest advise a person to go to a particular insurance company, saying that that company in his view is the best company to trust with money.
Comment on this
The same phrase is used in the British Act of 1923, and I am certain no such interpretation was put upon it.
Comment on this
I claim the right as a free citizen of this State to go to my neighbour and to say that I prefer A B to C D company, and I decline to be made liable on summary conviction to a fine of £10.
Comment on this
Let us be clear on this. Can I go to my friend and invite him to take out an insurance policy with A B company, the office of which is in O'Connell Street, and the agent for which lives at the north side of the city? If I cannot do that I say that I ought to be free to do so.
Comment on this
I am not saying that the Deputy is not free to do so. What we are endeavouring to do is to prevent a person who is not in the regular employment of the company canvassing for business with that company.
Comment on this
Surely we ought to know what our liabilities are in that regard. I would be interested to know what is the evil which the Minister apprehends could arise?
Comment on this
There is so much misrepresentation as to the nature of the cover provided by an insurance policy, the view as a whole is that only persons who are authorised to do so by companies selling policies should canvass persons to take out these policies.
Comment on this
Do you mean to say that a citizen of this State cannot advise a neighbour to take a policy with an insurance company without committing an offence? If any such proviso is in the British Act of Parliament the sooner it is taken out the better. It seems to me to be an absolutely extravagant interference with the normal activities of society to attempt to legislate in such a direction.
Comment on this
Some very gross scandals arose out of the practice of allowing persons not under control of companies to sell insurance for these companies.
Comment on this
That is not what the sub-section says. It is not a prohibition of persons, not in the employment of the companies. The sub-section says that a person may not "procure or endeavour to procure any person to enter into a contract of industrial assurance" in any such company. I say that that can be interpreted to mean that you cannot advise a person to take out a policy in a particular company. I object to such a sub-section strenuously. If there are terrible abuses arising, which nothing but this section can correct, the Minister should tell us what they are.
Comment on this
The section is designed to prevent assurance with any company being sold by a person who is not in the regular employment of that company, subject to its control and acting as its agent.
Comment on this
It does not go beyond that. It is similar to the provision in the 1923 Act in Britain and it is designed to achieve the same purpose. It has been the law there for the last 13 years.
Comment on this
Let us take this case. I live in a small country town in which there are three insurance agents for three different companies. A neighbour of mine is approached by the three agents and that neighbour comes in to me and says: "I am bothered by Pat So-and-so, Tom So-and-so and Jim So-and-so, to take out an insurance policy with them. What should I do?" I say to him: "If I were you I would take out a policy with Jim So-and-so. He represents the best company and you should deal with him. If I were taking out a policy I would take it for so much and I would advise you to deal with Jim." In my opinion that advice renders me liable to prosecution for having procured a person to enter into a contract of industrial assurance.
Comment on this
Surely my advice in that case does amount to procuring a person to enter into a contract of industrial assurance with Jim? See what is going to happen. The other two insurance agents in the town who know the provisions of the law are going to come to me and say: "We shall soon civilise you."
Comment on this
It is all right for the Minister, who lives in the comfortable purlieus of the City of Dublin, to scoff at this, but the agents of the other two companies can come to me and say: "The advice you gave amounts to a criminal offence. If that happens again we shall prosecute you." Surely, this section puts it in the power of any agent in the country to do that.
Comment on this
It is not what the Minister thinks. We are now making a law, and it is what the courts may think hereafter. Such a case as Deputy Dillon envisages might come before the court, and it might be held hereafter by some unreasonable court to be an offence. Apart from that point, I should like to know what are the abuses against which the section is aimed? Are they abuses tried on behalf of the company?
Comment on this
If that is so, I take it the companies carry out the abuses through other people. There is a method through this section of allowing the company to do their evil work and get out of the consequences of the section.
Comment on this
The effect of the section is that everybody who is not under the company's control is liable to assault by the regular agent. Everybody who is under the company's control runs free of the section, so that everybody with malice in his mind, by taking a retaining fee of ¼d. per year, evades the section, while everybody who acts in perfect good faith can have the section invoked against him.
Comment on this
If an agent induces some person to take out a policy by gross misrepresentation, the company cannot say: "He is not employed by us; we have no responsibility for what he said." That is what the section is intended to provide against. The company cannot do that under this section.
Comment on this
This section brings us to Part VI of the Bill. I wish to make a few remarks in regard to it, and perhaps if they are not in order on this section, you, a Leas-Chinn Comhairle, will call me to order. This is a very controversial section. I take it that the ideal solution of this reinsurance problem would be that all the companies should join together. I think that the Minister has said so himself. I understood that certain proposals were made to the Minister. Perhaps if the Minister could tell us before we start to debate the section, how far any proposals have been made, and whether they met with his approval or not, it would save time. I take it that it is agreed by everybody that if there could be some form of agreed measure, under which all the insurance companies would join together, it would be the ideal solution.
Comment on this
I am not in a position to make any statement on that matter and I think we should enact Part VI of the Bill. I have stated already, that if proposals which will achieve the purpose aimed at in Part VI of the Bill, without the necessity of bringing that Part into operation, are put forward, and operated, I am prepared to consider leaving Part VI of the Bill inoperative. I think, however, we should have Part VI enshrined in the Bill, capable of being brought into operation, in case no proposals should be submitted or, if submitted, that they should prove unworkable or unacceptable.
Comment on this
Perhaps I went too far in saying that we should not discuss Part VI. What I intended to ask the Minister was whether he was in a position to say how far the proposals had gone. Certainly I took it from his remarks that the door is not yet closed on proposals and I wish to know if the proposals are still being considered. I do not wish to press him to make any statement if he does not feel in a position to do so, but I take it from his remarks that the door is not yet shut on that solution of the matter. I suppose there is nothing left to us but to go on with Part VI. I take it from his remarks that the matter is at the moment under consideration, but perhaps I should not ask him to say anything more on that.
Comment on this
Is the Minister going to give us any further statement on this general question of reinsurance? So far as my information goes, the power to establish a reinsurance corporation ought not to be granted to him at all. I am informed that Part VI of the Bill is completely unworkable and futile. So far as I am aware, the whole principle of reinsurance depends upon a system of reinsurance treaties. The foundation upon which a reinsurance treaty stands is that the moment any given company signs a cover note, the stipulated percentage of the risk is simultaneously covered by the parties to the reinsurance treaty. Unless that were so, an insurance company taking a risk for £100,000 and intending to distribute 80 per cent. of that risk — which might be assumed to be the fair average of the distribution of fire and accident risks—if they had to wait to negotiate an ad hoc treaty for that risk might encounter a catastrophe. Disaster might overtake them in respect of a risk which was quite beyond their capacity to bear before they had time to pass on the four-fifths of the risk which they intended to dispose of. For that reason. the treaty system has been adopted by all insurance companies. A company knows, the moment a cover note is issued to secure a person in respect of fire or accident risk, that the liability of the reinsurers is opened to the share of that risk that it has been previously agreed to pass on. Under Part VI of the Bill, the proposal is that the Minister shall establish the Reinsurance Company of Ireland and that every Irish company should then be obliged to open negotiations with the company.
Comment on this
Every licensed company. The company is to open negotiations with the Reinsurance Company of Ireland ad hoc for each risk.
Comment on this
Is it understood that the nature of the agreement which is to subsist between the reinsurance company and the companies operating in Ireland will be of the nature of a reinsurance treaty such as is already in operation between tariff companies?
Comment on this
There is provision in the Bill empowering the company to consider a proposal and to accept a part, or all, or none of it.
Comment on this
Deputy Costello suggests that we might deal with this question more effectively on Section 84. I do not want to anticipate discussion. My submission is that, according to the concluding paragraph of Section 84, the company may, in the case of any particular risk, refuse to retain such portion of the risk as they shall direct.
Comment on this
No, those are not the words of the section. The section says:—
refuse to accept the reinsurance thereof unless such assurance company retains such portion of such risk as the company shall direct.
In other words, the company which is reinsuring the risk must retain a proportion of it.
Comment on this
Such proportion as the company shall direct. The reinsurance company will carry on its reinsurance business in the ordinary way.
Comment on this
Let us not get into the habit of contradicting one another across the floor of the House. I shall put my case and the Minister can then reply to it.
Comment on this
It may, but, on the question whether this reinsurance corporation should be set up at all or not, I make the case that certain facts emerge which make it undesirable that it should be set up. I say that the lines on which the Minister proposes to run this corporation strike at the whole basis on which treaty reinsurance is run. The foundation of treaty reinsurance is that, at the beginning of the treaty period you know that, in respect of every risk you take, the treaty amount of the risk will be taken up by the reinsurance companies. The moment you introduce an element enabling any one of the parties to the reinsurance treaty to say, in respect of a given risk: "We revoke our undertaking and will not take the treaty-agreed share of that risk unless you are prepared to undertake further commitments," then the whole foundation upon which treaty reinsurance is built collapses. The very essence of that arrangement is that, at the moment of the writing of the cover note, the reinsurance is effected, even though the party taking the reinsurance knows nothing of the nature of the original risk.
I object to the establishment of this corporation, further, on the ground that a later section provides that every contract of reinsurance shall be guaranteed by the Government but it will be open to nobody to sue the Government to recover the amount of the guarantee. Since the word "guarantee" was first incorporated in the English language was there ever a guarantee of that character? "I will guarantee to pay you something but I make the proviso that you must not ask me to fulfil my guarantee." The use of the words in such a context makes the English language meaningless. I heard no indication from the Minister of the ground on which he defends these proposals and unless and until the Minister is in a position to give us some information on these fundamental objections to the establishment of a reinsurance corporation, I do not see how he can ask the House to vote for the establishment of the corporation at all.
Comment on this
The Deputy's objections to the proposal are based on a complete misconception of the provisions of the Bill. The Bill is intended to provide, and does in fact provide, that the reinsurance company will transact its business on ordinary commercial lines—as reinsurance business is transacted by other companies, that is, not by accepting separate risks but by making comprehensive treaties with insurance companies. The provisions of Section 84 in that respect are quite clear. They state that—
every assurance company which effects assurance business ... in Saorstát Eireann shall enter into an agreement—
these are the words the meaning of which Deputy Dillon does not understand—
with the company whereby such assurance company agrees that, if and so far as it reinsures its assurance business ... it will reinsure with the company, but subject to the qualification that the company may, in the case of any particular risk, refuse to accept the reinsurance thereof unless such assurance company retains such portion of such risk as the company shall direct.
Comment on this
In a reinsurance treaty the reinsurance company provides that it need not accept a reinsurance risk unless the company which wrote the risk retains some portion of it.
Comment on this
That contingency is always provided for. The agreement which the reinsurance company may make with an insurance company may contain that qualification—that reinsurance cover will not apply to a risk in respect of which the company that wrote the risk does not retain the stipulated portion thereof. That all relates to the agreement. It is contemplated that there shall be agreement for reinsurance with each company—an agreement of the ordinary kind which will afford the necessary reinsurance cover forthwith to another company writing insurance business in the Saorstát.
Comment on this
I suggest that having got thus far we might take matters in order and deal with Section 84.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Minister said something about Section 84 with which we do not agree. However, I suppose that can wait.
Comment on this
It is now perfectly clear that we are not going to finish the Insurance Bill to-night.
Comment on this
Well, it is pretty clear that we will not. There are still 30 amendments to be disposed of and on these there is a great deal of controversial matters. We could not get through Part VI quickly if there is going to be a general discussion on these matters.
Comment on this
The amendments to Section 84 inevitably give rise to discussion on the section. There are at least half a dozen amendments which would require separate decisions.
Comment on this
It is suggested that on Section 84 we should have a discussion on the amendments and then a general discussion on the section.
Comment on this
All these amendments, and the various points arising out of them, should be discussed first.
Comment on this
Yes, and then a discussion as to whether or not the reinsurance company should be set up.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 157:—
In sub-section (2) (b), line 20, to delete all words after the word "demand" to the end of the paragraph, and substitute the words "is presented in writing by the officer of the Minister to the manager, secretary or other equally responsible official of the company."
The purport of the section is to provide that the officer appointed by the Minister may enter the premises of a company at any time and there demand to make an inspection of all books, accounts and documents held by the company, and the section states that a demand for inspection shall be deemed to have been duly made by an officer of the Minister "if such demand is made verbally at an office of the company to any bookkeeper or other member of the clerical staff of the company at such office." That is the most mandatory section I have yet seen in any Act. If we are to maintain a shadow of the fiction that a man's house is his castle, how can we pass that section? Here we have a public servant endeavouring to force his way into your premises——
Comment on this
Why I object to this principle is that, as sure as any Deputy of this House is a foot high, this section will be quoted as a precedent to justify officers of the Department of Agriculture in climbing up to the top of my chimney, and it will be pointed out that what was good enough for an insurance office here in the City of Dublin is good enough for Pat Murphy down in the bogs in the country.
Comment on this
If the State ever took on the same responsibility for the Deputy as we are taking on for the insurance company, we should have these powers.
Comment on this
All I ask now is that we should do some repairs to this shattered fabric of a man's castle and require the Minister to present in writing to the manager, secretary, or any other responsible official of the corporation a demand for inspection. In fact, that is what will happen. It is unthinkable to imagine that notice will be given to a clerk or junior officer sitting in an outside office. I want this principle to be observed.
Comment on this
And I want the other principle observed, that when we are taking over responsibility for the Reinsurance Company, we should have these powers.
Comment on this
I want to preserve the other principle—that is, that when the State has taken such a wide degree of responsibility for these companies, it should have the widest possible power to inquire into their affairs.
Comment on this
I do not press the Minister, but I ask whether he will bring in something on the Report Stage to alter this section in the way I suggested.
Comment on this
I do not know what the point of amendment No. 159 is.
Comment on this
It is related to amendment No. 163. The proposal is that every foreign company should offer to the company at least half of its business. The amendment will not be accepted. I think the reinsurance company will have to transact its business in accordance with the usual practice of reinsurance and I would be disposed to resist amendment No. 163.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 160:—
160. To delete all words from the word "but," line 36, to and including the word "direct," line 39, at the end of the section and substitute the words "33? per cent. of every risk which it underwrites.—(Seamus A. Bourke.)
Section 84 seems to me to make it obligatory on the insurance company to reinsure with the reinsurance corporation. At the same time, it gives that corporation power, if it so desires, to select the portion of the risk which, in each case, it will take. A provision of that kind would, in my opinion, make it impossible to continue any reinsurance treaties. In fact, it would create havoc in the whole reinsurance business of the country. To my mind, it reverses the whole idea at the back of reinsurance, because it enables the reinsurance company to decide what portion of the risk it will take rather than give the original company the liberty of deciding what portion of the risk it will lay off. It is really putting the insurance company in the position of being a reinsurance company for the reinsurance company.
Every insurance company has its own books to balance. It is, in that respect, more or less in the position of a bookmaker. Every bookmaker has to balance his books. If he finds he has too much money on a particular horse, he has to lay that money off with another bookmaker. If this Government, which seems to be travelling rapidly in that direction, ever arrive at the stage where they are going to make it compulsory for all the bookmakers in Ireland to lay off their bets with one particular bookmaker and, at the same time, gives that bookmaker the liberty to decide what portion of the risk in any particular case he will take, then we will have the betting business pretty much on a level with the reinsurance business. If a particular bookmaker finds he has £1,000 on the favourite more than he can carry, he goes to the official Government bookmaker to lay off the £1,000 and he is told he can lay off only £200 and carry the remainder of the risk himself. Another bookmaker may have £500 too much on an outsider and he attempts to lay it off and is told he can lay off only £100. That is the type of position the insurance companies will be placed in under this section.
Every company has to act according to its own books. In one case, a company may be prepared to retain 80 per cent. or 99 per cent. or, in some cases, 100 per cent. of the risk and in another case they may not be anxious to retain more than 5 per cent. There are cases where the risk is exceptionally great and from a general standpoint the company is forced to lay off the bulk of it. Even in the case of acquiring business from one particular firm, the business of that firm is often divided into a great many lines. Take the case of the Great Southern Railways Company. The insurance company getting that business would probably have over 100 different lines. In one particular line, such as labourers' cottages, the company would be prepared to take all that risk. In the case of other lines it would not set out to take any more than 5 or 10 per cent. and it wants some insurance institution which will enable it to lay off the particular risk that it is not suitable to retain. If it is not given those facilities the company cannot carry on. If that company is compelled to go to the official reinsurance company first of all and allow that company to pick and choose what it desires to take, then it is unreasonable to expect that they will be able to get any other reinsurance company to cover that business and they may have to carry the risk themselves.
The amendment I suggest permits that a fair proportion, one-third, should go to the reinsurance corporation. It gives them a fair proportion of the business and, at the same time, while not giving the Minister the privilege of picking and choosing, it still leaves it open to the various companies to enter into reinsurance treaties with other reinsurance companies. I submit that it is a favourable provision all round, both from the point of view of the reinsurance company, the ordinary companies, the policy-holders and the public at large.
Comment on this
The Deputy's amendment would be, of course, impracticable. I do not think we could require the reinsurance with the company of such a fixed proportion of risks as the Deputy suggests. I may say at once that it is intended that the reinsurance company to be established under this part of the Bill, if it is brought into operation, will operate as any other reinsurance company, except in so far as the Act will provide that every company doing insurance business in the Saorstát will be required to enter into an agreement with it for the transaction of reinsurance business. It may, perhaps, relieve the minds of some Deputies if I say that amendment No. 116, in the name of Deputy Costello, is, in my opinion, unnecessary, although if the Deputy thinks otherwise and presses that the amendment should be inserted, I am prepared to do so. I think it is unnecessary, but I would be prepared, if the contrary opinion was strongly held——
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to agree to that and, similarly, to the other amendment in Deputy Costello's name, amendment No. 161 which, I think, is intended to clarify the intention of the section and which would clarify it, in my opinion, if inserted. By intimating my willingness to accept those two amendments, I perhaps convey to Deputies better than I could do otherwise, the intentions as to the mode of operation of the reinsurance company. It is possible that this part of the Bill may not be operated if alternative proposals for meeting the desires of the Government are put forward by the companies and brought into operation. In fact, from many points of view, it is obviously desirable that the State should stay out of this business if it can get its object achieved in any other way. Our object is to provide that the greatest possible proportion of every risk written in the Free State will be retained here to the limit that the resources of the various Irish organisations dealing with insurance will permit. That can be accomplished by means of such machinery as this part of the Bill proposes. It could possibly be accomplished by other means, and if other means are preferable to the companies and are put forward in a manner acceptable to us, we are quite prepared to contemplate leaving this part of the Bill inoperative.
But the essential purpose of this part of the Bill, the idea behind the establishment of the reinsurance company, is to ensure that some proportion of every risk written by a foreign company in the Saorstát will be retained here, either by the reinsurance company or by some Saorstát company to whom the reinsurance company has passed on that risk, so that to the limit of the combined resources of all the Irish offices in operation the risk will be retained here to whatever extent is found practicable. I have stated there are other obvious methods of accomplishing that end than those proposed in the Bill, but that would involve the voluntary co-operation and participation of all the companies concerned. If that cannot be procured, then the same end can be met by means of these reinsurance proposals.
I reiterate that the reinsurance company of Ireland, when established, will operate in the ordinary way, entering into agreements with the various companies operating here, agreements of the ordinary kind negotiated between these companies and the board of the reinsurance company in accordance with the circumstances of the concern or the circumstances existing at the time. I do not think any difficulty will arise in that regard. It is certainly not intended to create any undue difficulties for the companies doing this class of business here other than the difficulties inevitable in the changes necessary to give effect to the desire of the Government in this connection.
Comment on this
It goes some distance to meet a number of the objections that we had to Section 84 to find that the Minister intends to accept amendments Nos. 161 and 164 in my name. At the same time I would like to ask the Minister if he is still definitely of the opinion that the last four lines of the section are absolutely essential:
Subject to the qualification that the company may, in the case of any particular risk, refuse to accept the reinsurance thereof unless such assurance company retains such portion of such risk as the company shall direct.
I am informed that a proviso such as that is not usual in treaty arrangements. It would not be reasonable, of course, that the reinsurance company should be forced to accept every reinsurance policy on the terms that are dictated to it by the companies, but at the same time it should not be in a position itself to dictate the terms on which it will accept reinsurance proposals. I would like to know from the Minister if he still adheres to the idea that this proviso is absolutely essential. I accept, of course, his statement that his idea is that this reinsurance company should operate on the same business lines as ordinary reinsurance companies do at the present moment.
Comment on this
That is intended, but a reinsurance treaty at the present time between one company and another is a voluntary arrangement. To a certain extent, that voluntary element is being removed from the relations between companies licensed to do business here and the reinsurance company of Ireland because it says that there shall be an agreement. In these circumstances I think it is necessary to have the qualification to which the Deputy refers which is designed to prevent a company, having a reinsurance agreement with the reinsurance company, writing all sorts of bad risks, passing the whole of those risks on to the reinsurance company and retaining none itself. The object of this provision is to ensure that that cannot happen, and that the reinsurance company, if it has good reasons for doing so, can, in relation to a particular risk, refuse to accept the reinsurance unless a stipulated proportion of the risk is retained by the company writing it.
Comment on this
The Minister's very frank statement has helped to clear the air a good deal. Having signified his intention to accept our amendments, I suppose we may as well tell him now what we think is wrong with Section 84.
Comment on this
I am simply following the example of the two previous speakers. I really do not know where we are.
Comment on this
The Minister says that the words in the last four lines of Section 84, quoted a moment ago by Deputy Costello, have the effect of creating treaty obligations with other insurance companies. That is where we join issue with him. We deny that. The Minister says that he wishes to prevent insurance companies handing over the whole of very bad risks to the reinsurance company while retaining none themselves. It would be absurd if that were allowed, and such a thing is not contained in any of our proposals. If the Minister is going to proceed along treaty lines, I think the way that operates is that while a company can discard a portion of the risk, it must keep at least 1/15th of it. If the Minister made a provision of that sort, a company would know how it stood. It would know that it could not lay off the whole of its risk with the reinsurance company, and therefore would not write it. That would be a business-like arrangement, and it is what prevails at present. But what you cannot have is a case like this: A fire starts in some big business concern and continues burning for three days. During all that time the insurance company may be fighting with the reinsurance company as to whether it held £1,000 or £10,000 of the risk involved in that case. Would not that be a beautiful position for a small insurance company to be in, to be told by the reinsurance company when the premises were well alight: "You are on for £9,000 of this risk, because you know we could not take it on." I think the Minister should realise that companies dealing with a reinsurance company must know where they stand—that they can have certain risks placed without any nonsense. If the Minister agreed to take out this proviso, he would find that there was no intention on the part of any Deputy to suggest that an insurance company should be allowed to plant the whole of a risk on the reinsurance company, retaining none itself. If that could happen it would be absurd. But I think the Minister can see that his proposal will not do either.
Comment on this
I suggest to the Deputy that he is misreading the section. All that it provides is that each company shall enter into a reinsurance treaty of the ordinary kind under which immediate reinsurance cover will be provided in all cases except one.
Comment on this
I suggest that the proper way to meet that would be to set out in the Bill the percentage that a company is to retain, or at any rate, take out of the Bill the proviso that the reinsurance company can refuse portion of a risk.
Comment on this
The reinsurance company will make such arrangements as it thinks proper with a company, subject, of course, to the conditions laid down in the section.
Comment on this
There is the historic case of a reinsurance company refusing to acknowledge a £9,000 risk with a company when insured premises were well alight. That is the sort of thing that I do not want to happen here, and the Minister can quite easily get over his objection to it by saying they shall retain such portion as may be agreed upon, or something like that.
Comment on this
That will be stipulated in the agreement. There is no question of that being discussed after the claim has arisen, because it will be provided for in the agreement between the company and the reinsurance company.
Comment on this
It provides that an agreement shall be made, subject to certain qualifications. This agreement will provide for these things.
Comment on this
Must these qualifications not be written into the agreement as a necessary term of it? In every agreement there will be, either expressly or by force of the Statute, terms that the company may refuse, when a particular risk is received, to accept.
Comment on this
Whatever the reinsureance company fixes in its negotiations with each company. It will be provided for in the agreement.
Comment on this
I do not think the section as it stands means that. Certainly it does not make it clear.
Comment on this
The Minister's statement left nothing to be desired so far as approaching this as a business-like transaction, that this should be carried out as a commerial undertaking. But, if this section contained some such provision as that the insurance company shall retain some portion, a minimum portion, of the risk, not exceeding such-and-such a percentage, that would leave the insurance company dealing with the reinsurance company in a position to say, "I have carried out my part of the bargain, now you carry out yours." A large number of people appear to have fallen into the same error as I did in reference to the last few lines of this section, namely, that it gives the reinsurance corporation the right to do something that was never in any ordinary reinsurance treaty. We are dealing with a Government-backed or Government-owned company, according to this section, whose officers will be cold-blooded and will say, "I cannot go beyond the provisions of the Act; there is your section of it, read it." I appeal to the Minister to make that portion of it right, as it is a very important section.
Comment on this
I understood the Minister to say that the meaning of the qualification was that the particular risk proportion to be retained was to be provided for in the insurance treaty, the treaty agreement. Surely the concluding words of the section as it stands do not mean that: "Unless such assurance company retains such portion of such risk as the company shall direct." As I read the section, as it stands, it will be competent for the company, no matter what terms are in the agreement, when a particular risk offers, to say in respect of that particular risk: "You must retain 50, 70, 80, 90 or any other percentage." But, if the intention is that portion of the risk to be retained should be fixed in the insurance treaty, then surely another form of words must be found to make that clear. The concluding words, "as the company shall direct," must go and be replaced by some such words as "as provided by the agreement."
Comment on this
It is clear that the only difference between us is as to whether the section, as drafted, has the same meaning which I have given in describing it. I am prepared to have the drafting of the section revised, because it possibly could be made a little clearer at the expense of being made a little longer, and it is no harm to have it longer if it is clearer. The intention is that the qualification in the final part of it shall be related to the agreement, and that, when the terms of the agreement between the company and the reinsurance company are being effected, the circumstances under which the reinsurance company will not be responsible for reinsurance, because of the failure of the company writing the risk to retain a reasonable proportion of it, such proportion as is fixed, will be clearly stated. We have to deal with two novel features in relation to these reinsurance treaties. The reinsurance treaties will be similar to the ordinary treaties made every day voluntarily between two companies, except for the two new features introduced by this Bill. One is the provision which requires every company licensed to do this business here, and, doing it, to reinsure with this company and, in consequence of that, I have to prevent the situation rising in which the company will write all sorts of doubtful and bad risks and pass the whole of them on to the reinsurance company.
Comment on this
I agree. The whole purpose of this section is to provide for these two points, to provide that each company shall reinsure with this company, and, secondly, to provide, in consequence, that the company writing the risk shall exercise the usual precautions to prevent unduly bad risks being written. I am prepared to consider the drafting of the section to ensure that the intentions in that regard are fully carried out. In any event, the intimation that I am prepared to accept amendments Nos. 161 and 164, in Deputy Costello's name, makes clear what the intention is. These amendments, in my opinion, are not necessary, except for the purpose of clarification, but as they are pressed for the purpose of clarification, I am prepared to accept them. They will, I think, help also to clear up the intentions in relation to this section.
Comment on this
It will probably be necessary, in any event, as we are incorporating the provisions of these two amendments in the name of Deputy Costello.
Comment on this
Possibly redrafting the section to make it clear will be better than incorporating the amendments.
Comment on this
What I am thinking of doing is to get the section redrafted to incorporate the amendments.
Comment on this
My idea in putting down the amendment is that I am assured that companies which have very good reinsurance treaties think that, when this compulsory reinsurance is put in, they will be left in the position that, when they go to the reinsurance company and are turned down on several lines of business, they will find themselves high and dry and cannot get cover. If the Minister guarantees that that will not take place, or if it can be provided for in any way, I am satisfied.
Comment on this
It is definitely intended that it will not take place. So far as the Saorstát companies are concerned, these agreements will be reciprocal agreements, and involve the passing of business in both directions, that is from the company writing the risks to the reinsurance company, and from the reinsurance company accepting the risks from other companies on to the Irish companies.
Comment on this
It is better to leave over amendments Nos. 161 and 164 and I shall have the drafting looked at by the draftsman.
Comment on this
I think that amendment would be much too rigid altogether. It would not provide for circumstances in which conditions other than those now prevailing might exist. The company, as I said, will have to transact its business on ordinary reinsurance lines and should not be unduly hampered by rigid statutory provisions of that kind.
Comment on this
I see in this section the words—
excluding life assurance business but including the renewal of any other assurance business, the original contract for which was entered into before the commencement of this part of this Act.
It occurs to me that in the preliminary stages it might be very desirable to let many of the short term risks run on. The valuing of them up to a certain point and inviting the reinsurance company to come to terms about something that was half expired would be an exceedingly awkward and difficult matter to carry out. I should like to ask the Minister how far the running of short term risks could be availed of to straighten out a very awkward part of the business. I realise, of course, that some of these risks are not short term, and that they would have to be provided for, but the Minister can quite easily see that, in the case of a 12 months' risk, of which six months had expired, the simplest thing would be to let it run on. Would that be illegal under the section?
Comment on this
No, the compulsory provisions operate only in respect of assurance business effected in the Saorstát after the commencement of the operation of the Act. That includes the renewal of any assurance business, the original contract for which was entered into before the commencement of the Act. Until that business comes up for renewal, the compulsory provisions of the Act do not apply.
Comment on this
No, there is no compulsory obligation to effect a reinsurance of that risk with the reinsurance company. It could be done voluntarily of course.
Comment on this
Yes, the ordinary meaning of the word. Most of these risks are insured on an annual basis and are renewed from year to year.