Finance Bill, 1936—Committee.
Contributions 1–144 of 269. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 20 of 1936 ›
The Minister has simply denied that the average yield from income-tax has decreased. I think the Minister, in asking the House to pass an income-tax rate of 4/6 in the £ ought to give the House some information. The total yield per 1/- of income-tax in the year 1931-2 would appear to be £1,170,000, but the yield per 1/- since the income-tax rate was raised to 4/6 has substantially diminished. I suggest to the Minister that it has diminished by at least £170,000 in spite of the fact that he has been having a very large screw put down on the income-tax payers of all kinds. It is a matter of interest that the House should hear from the Minister what are the reasons why this fall in the capacity of the income-tax payers to pay income-tax has come about, and whether he has any remarks to make.
Do I understand the Minister is refusing to reply?
Comment on this
It is not necessary. The House has an opportunity of hearing the Minister. The House has never heard the Minister say anything except that certain reliefs were given to people with small salaries. I should like to ask the Minister what is the total of that relief which has been given. It is a matter of interest to the House to see that, on the surface, at any rate, in so far as the figures provided by the Minister are concerned, the income-tax payers are not able to make the same return per 1/- income-tax as they were able to make before the present economic state of affairs came about. It is a matter upon which the Minister should say something to the House because the facts are that there has been a drop of about £750,000 or £800,000 that the House would have expected would have been raised in income-tax if the income of the people was sustained in the same way as it was in the year 1931-2. Although the rate of income-tax has been raised by such an amount as would warrant getting in more than we did last year by the sum of more than £750,000 that £750,000 has vanished. It could only have vanished, apart from what the Minister said in regard to any reliefs that have been given, through a falling off in the income of income-tax payers. When the Minister is asking the House to pass such a large income-tax rate as 4/6 in the £ we are entitled to hear some explanation from the Minister of the manifestations that the income of the income-tax payers in the country has fallen.
Comment on this
I have asked the Minister on several occasions in a reasonable way for some comment on this very serious aspect of our finances, not only of our national finances but of the domestic finances of our people. We are dealing this year with a Budget which has put a burden of taxation on the people higher by probably £200,000 than the Emergency Budget of 1932-3. We have every indication throughout the country of the way in which farmers, labourers and wage-earners are hit by the present conditions. Here we have a burden being placed on income-tax payers that was in fact reduced—had to be reduced —a year or two ago by reason of the fact that it was apparent to the Minister that the income-tax payers could not bear the taxation which was being then imposed on them. With even this reduced tax of 4/6 it is obvious to the Minister and must be obvious to the Government generally that there is a substantial fall in the capacity of income-tax payers to bear this tax. Surely when we are starting off on what the Minister himself promised last year was going to be our first normal Budget, and when the size of that normal Budget is bigger than the Emergency Budget which the Minister first introduced four years ago, we are entitled to hear from him some comment on the situation disclosed by the falling off in the returns for income-tax.
Comment on this
I do not know if this section is the one which makes Schedule A operative, but I should like to protest against the continuation of the purposes of the Schedule A assessment in that last year it was made on five-fourths, and this year it is continuing at that rate.
Comment on this
I think, Sir, on this important matter we ought not to pass Section 1 without hearing the Minister.
Comment on this
I really think the Minister ought to give us some indication of the reasons that have compelled him to have income-tax remaining at what it is. When the Minister was in opposition I remember the very forcible case he made from this side of the House that the income-tax levy at that time was a handicap to the extension of industry in this country. I am sure the Minister does not forget all that himself. As a matter of fact, the Minister was very impressive in pointing out that, unless there was a very substantial reduction in income-tax, there could not be expected in this country any expansion of industry. The Minister seems to have forgotten all that. He appears to think that the right thing to do now is to extract, in any way he can, all the money that can be extracted by way of income-tax.
Surely, when the Minister says that there is a dwindling-off in the income-tax returns, and when he is not able to collect what he thought he would be able to collect on a certain figure, he ought to see that there is something wrong and to realise that it is the writing on the wall. If we are to have any faith whatever in his sincerity and to hark back to what he said when he was in Opposition, there is every reason for him to be nervous of the present situation. If the Minister has any information, I think he ought to take the House into his confidence and tell us exactly what he thinks of the position that exists in the country at the present time. The Minister knows the way in which the farmers are crippled at the present time, and he knows the way in which they have had to be spoon-fed. He knows that that spoon-feeding is at the expense of the nation, and that it has to be done in order to keep the farmers on their feet at all. Will the Minister tell us how long is that going to continue, and does he think that he can keep up that position indefinitely either by increasing income-tax or by maintaining it at a figure which is not making a proper-return? Surely, the Minister will realise that we are entitled to some information on the matter and that we ought, at least, to have his mind on the present situation in the country?
Comment on this
I should like to add a further word, Sir, as to why we must regard the situation disclosed by the income-tax returns as being so serious. We do know that the wages of agricultural labourers throughout the country have been very substantially reduced, but in spite of a growing population in the country there were less agricultural labourers employed last year than in 1931. We know that farmers' prices for the produce that was their main source of income are practically halved. We know that their condition is such that farmers, generally, throughout the country, for the last two financial years, have ended up owing the Land Commission and the county councils £2,250,000—a position they were never in before— and that for two years' running now, that position has been stabilised. Yesterday a reference was made to the large number of farmers in the country who, from the point of view of the Land Commission, are not able to pay their way. We have now final information from the Minister for Industry and Commerce with regard to the position of those industrial concerns that are covered by the Census of Production, and we know that such additions as have been made to the number of industrial workers in these industries in the last three years of the Fianna Fáil régime were additions to industry at average wages of 18/7 a week.
Comment on this
Well, Sir, it shows how heavy the burden of government is, if any portion of it has to be borne substantially, on the one hand, by farmers, and, on the other hand, by agricultural labourers or by the new additions to the wage-earning classes in industry. We now have our first normal Budget. The first normal Budget shows an increase in expenditure over the emergency Budget, and, from anything that the Minister has indicated to us, the burden of government is going to increase rather than to decrease, and any increase in the burden of government must be borne by an increase in income-tax rather than by an increase in the costs of the various necessities of life that have borne the burden of taxation in the last two years—costs that are daily becoming more burdensome to the people of the country, who are in the position that they are spending less on clothing, less on boots, and less on the necessities of life than ever they spent before.
Comment on this
But, Sir, the position disclosed in the Minister's statement is that we are going to have an increased cost of government, and income-tax payers seem to be the only people that will be able to bear an increased amount of the cost of government, but, according to the Minister's figures for last year and this year, these people are shown to be people who are less able, to-day, to bear the burden, even of the present income-tax, than they were in the year 1931-32. Knowing that, and realising that, the Minister sits silent before the House when asked to face up to that situation and when asked to relieve our fears, if he is able to relieve them, and to deny the statements we make with regard to the fall in the capacity of the income-tax payers to pay income-tax, if he can deny them. However, it is a nice sample of one-Chamber Government that we should be treated in this way not only in connection with the most important measure that comes before the House in the year, but with a measure in connection with which we have to take into consideration not only the taxable capacity of the taxpayer, but the cost of government generally and the cost to the taxpayers of their own subsistence and the maintenance of their homes and their families; and not only their capacity to pay to-day, but their capacity to pay to-morrow. As I say, it is a nice sample of Ministerial responsibility and of what one-Chamber Government can be in this country.
Comment on this
Perhaps it is no harm, Sir, to point out in connection with this debate that the Minister has evidently decided to adopt this year the same attitude that he adopted on the Finance Bill last year, which, it will be remembered, led to a very protracted discussion in this House in an effort to draw a statement from the Minister or to elicit some information from him. We were accused, at that time, of obstruction, because we tried to get some information from the Minister, and I think it is only right to state now that, if this debate is to be similarly protracted in an effort to extract information that the Minister should volunteer to the House, the Minister himself is responsible for it, and nobody else. This is the most important measure that this House has to consider in the year. It has been the practice in this House, since its foundation, that, on the Committee Stage, the Minister in charge of a Bill would give a short explanation to the House in moving each section of the Bill. The Minister for Finance departed from that practice last year. He ignored it, by refusing to give the House any information, and apparently is adopting the same attitude this year. To say the least of it, that is not treating the House the way it should be treated. Deputies are entitled to get information on any Bill brought before the House, and particularly a Bill such as this, that is going to inflict such heavy taxation on the people. I suggest to the Minister that, in fairness to the House, and for the proper expedition of business, he should conform to the practice that has been followed for a number of years.
Comment on this
I should like to suggest to the Minister, whether it is necessary for him to reply or not, that he should with becoming dignity fulfil the high functions of a Minister by replying to queries raised by Deputies on this side of the House. After all, the Minister's position is recognised as the most dignified after that of the President, and it seems to me that he is failing in his duty to that position, as well as bringing a certain amount of disrespect on it for successors, if he continues his present attitude.
Comment on this
I am willing to answer any points raised in debate, but I am entitled to wait, in consideration of the dignity of the House, until the points are made.
Comment on this
I am perfectly willing not to speak again on this section if the Minister will make some attempt to answer the questions which we put to him. But I should like to ask him: Is the situation so bad, and what he has to say so flimsy, that he is not prepared, in accordance with the ordinary rule of committee discussion, to hear any word of criticism of what he may now have to say? I am prepared to give the Minister a chance of acting in a dignified way on this section.
Comment on this
Why does not the Deputy set the example? He has been like a jack-in-the-box on the Front Opposition Benches for the last 20 minutes. He was up four times in 20 minutes.
Comment on this
I will allow the matter to be put to the House after this section; but it is a most astonishing thing that we should be asked, on the discussion in Committee of a measure of this kind, not to say a word about what the Minister may say.
Comment on this
I must make that position clear. In Committee, particularly in Committee on Finance, the Chair has not power to call upon a Minister to conclude, nor can the Chair ask a Minister to reply.
Comment on this
As the Minister raised the point particularly, I take it the precedent that we propose to adopt on this occasion is not a precedent that will in any way bind us in any other matter.
Comment on this
In regard to that, all I can say is that prior to 1932 the Minister reserved, particularly on the Finance Bill, the right to deal, when concluding the debate, with points made by the Opposition and there are sound reasons for that. The time of the Dáil is very valuable. It ought not to be abused by Deputies who think that the proper function of occupants of the Front Opposition Benches is to rise not once but four times, and to launch interrogatories at the Minister after they had time to make them in debate—first of all on the general Resolution, then in the debate on the Committee Stage and also on the Report Stage of the Resolution.
Comment on this
At this stage I call the attention of the House to this fact, that the text of the Finance Bill is almost a verbatim copy of the terms of the Resolutions which have already been debated in the House, not once but three times, and, Sir, it was the invariable practice, prior to 1932, of the then Opposition, which had regard for the value of the time of this House, and which was anxious to permit the business of the House, in so far as the legitimate purposes of government were concerned, to be carried on without obstruction, and particularly in regard to this resolution relating to income-tax, to allow it to go to the Vote of the House without any prolonged or discoursive discussion.
Comment on this
The reason was that then we had an intelligent Opposition which did on the preliminary stage elicit all the facts required. That is the reason why any Deputy or any Minister is entitled to reserve to himself discretion as to when he will intervene. No Minister is called upon to rise in debate and to give information that more properly ought to be elicited by form of Parliamentary Question. For the purpose of eliciting merely information not for discussion of the merits pro and con of any measure, but to enable an intelligent discussion to be carried on, the House has devised the special procedure of Parliamentary Question. If Deputy Mulcahy was really concerned about this question of income-tax, he could have taken the trouble to put down a Parliamentary Question which would have elicited all the information that he thought he required in order to conduct a discussion on this question of income-tax with value to the House and to the country. I have refused to violate or to permit what I believed was a violation of the procedure of the House, by giving information during the course of a committee discussion which in my view would be more properly elicited by the form of Parliamentary Question, and which, if it is put down, I am perfectly prepared to give. That, Sir, is the reason for the attitude I have adopted to-day. There is no question of obstructing or being unwilling to give information. There is merely this, that those who undertake the responsibility of opposing a measure which the Government thinks necessary for the proper provision of the public services will, at least, fortify themselves before the debate with the information which they think they require in order to carry on these debates intelligently.
On the general question as to why it is necessary to maintain income-tax at the present level, a full exposition of that position was given by me in the course of my Budget statement. I pointed out that the House had decided that present services were to be maintained at the present standard and at the present level, and that in order to maintain these services at that standard and at that level, it was necessary to ask the people to contribute a certain amount of taxation. We have divided that taxation between taxation upon incomes and property and taxation upon commodities. The House, and particularly the Opposition, I may say, did not disagree with the Government in its decision to maintain these services at the present level, and it must now face the responsibility for imposing the necessary taxation. So far as the general rate of income-tax is concerned, I think that income-tax payers in this country have a right to congratulate themselves that we have been able to provide for these services without having to increase the rate of income-tax. To-day it stands at 4/6. We have been able to maintain it at 4/6, and that must be remembered. In connection with the point made by Deputy Mulcahy, that the yield per 1/- of the standard rate appears to have fallen off, it is true that the standard rate to-day is 4/6 as compared with 3/6 when we came into office.
Comment on this
There is one thing about the Deputy I admire. I often admire his parliamentary industry while at the same time I pity it because it seems to be very much like the efforts of poor Mother Partington who tried to keep back the tide with her broom. For the last four years he has been trying to sweep back the tide of social reform in this country with a broom, with the broom of the empty vapid speeches which he makes here hour after hour and day after day upon every motion that comes before the House until, Sir, when he has uttered one sentence, or given us one set of figures, we know inevitably what is going to come next. When he tells us about the 600 people less who are employed in agriculture, we know that inevitably he is going to talk next about the £10,000,000 that this Government has disposed of during the last four years. I venture to say that, if we were to change places, I could get up in the Opposition Benches and make the same speech, possibly a little more effectively, which Deputy Mulcahy makes every day in every month that the Dáil is in session in this country. That is all beside the point. I say that I admire the Deputy's parliamentary industry while I pity it because, Sir, he comes along here, entirely without the proper equipment—without the proper factual equipment that any person who presumes to lead such an Opposition as sits opposite should have—and makes a foolish speech. He has asked me to-day why it is that the yield of income-tax, though the standard rate is 4/6 in the £, appears to be less than it would have been if the conditions of 1931-32 still obtained. In reply to a question which was put down by Deputy Maguire, which I answered some weeks ago, I gave the Deputy information which would have enabled him to answer that question. May I refer to these figures again in order to show why it is that, although the standard rate is 1/- higher, nevertheless the yield of income-tax would seem to have correspondingly declined, or rather would seem not to have increased by a corresponding amount?
The House of course will appreciate that income-tax payers constitute a sort of pyramid. Underneath we have a large broad stratum of people with comparatively small incomes who pay comparatively little. Above that there is a stratum, more restricted in extent, of people who pay slightly more and so on until we come to the top where there are one, two or three comparatively limited classes, who pay greatly increased amounts. With that fact before them the House will appreciate, when I give Deputies the figures which I am going to give now, why it is that, though the standard rate of tax has been increased, the yield of income-tax has not increased by a corresponding amount. I gave these figures to the House once, in answer to a Parliamentary question; again just a week ago on the Second Reading of this Bill, and I am now going to give them to the House for the third time. I hope that this time Deputy Mulcahy, and those who are associated with him in the Opposition, will be capable of assimilating and understanding them. In 1931-32, this halcyon year to which Deputy Mulcahy so often harks back, a married man enjoying an earned income of £325 and who had to maintain himself, his wife and two children had to pay 7/10 income-tax each year when the rate was 3/6 in the £. To-day that man pays nothing. In 1931-32, if the same person had an income of £350 he paid £2 7s. 3d. in income-tax. To-day he pays nothing. If his income were £375 he paid £4 6s. 7d. To-day he pays nothing. If he had an income of £400 he paid £6 6s. 0d. To-day he pays nothing. If the same person instead of having two children, had three children and had an earned income of £375 in 1931-32, when the standard rate was 3/6, he would have been paying £1 19s. 4d. To-day when the standard rate is 4/6, simply due to the fact that we have had regard to the position of a man who has family responsibilities, he pays nothing. He would have paid £3 18s. 9d. if he had an income of £400 in 1931-32. To-day he pays nothing. If he had four children in 1931-32, with a standard rate of 3/6 in the £ and an income of £400 per year, he would have paid £1 11s. 6d. To-day he pays nothing. If he had had, as is quite common in this country, a family of five children in 1931-32 and had an earned income of £425, he would have paid £1 3s. 7d. in income-tax. To-day with a standard rate of 4/6 in the £, he pays nothing.
I think that if the House ponders over these figures even Deputy Mulcahy—I am not quite so sanguine about Deputy Morrissey—will apprehend why it is that although the rate of tax to-day is 4/6 as compared with 3/6 in 1931-32, nevertheless the yield from income-tax has not increased correspondingly with the increase in the standard rate.
Comment on this
I am telling the Deputy that they amount to a considerable sum and that they are enjoyed by the great body of people who have comparatively small incomes, much less income even than Deputies receive here, not as income indeed, but as an allowance towards their expenses.
Comment on this
It has this much to do with it, that I hope it will bring home to the Deputy an appreciation of the circumstances under which people live outside, with whom he has lost contact, with whom his Party has lost contact, and for whom he is not entitled to speak.
Comment on this
They amount to a considerable sum as I have said already and they fully and adequately answer the question which the Deputy put to me, why it was that although the standard rate was 4/6 in the £ this year as compared with 3/6 in 1931-32, there had been no corresponding increase in the yield from income-tax. Again I want to come back to the point which I made early in this debate, Three times already the House has had an opportunity of discussing this Section of the Bill.
Comment on this
The Deputy, after all, is not the judge in this matter. The majority of the House is. The Deputy is one of those on the benches opposite who talked about the sacro-sanctity of majority rule. The majority of the House has decided quite clearly that it has had all the information it wants on this matter. It has been given completely, not merely upon the discussion of the Bill, and on the resolutions, but in the discussions that have taken place here, year after year, ever since the standard rate of tax was fixed at 4/6. I suggest that no one wants any more information for the purpose of being able to discuss this matter intelligently. The Deputy's attitude is merely for the purpose of holding up, and obstructing the passage of the Bill.
Comment on this
Surely you must be appalled, A Chinn Comhairle, at the procedure as announced by the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
I understood that the question would be put, when the Minister for Finance had concluded, without establishing any precedent.
Comment on this
I want to make this point. It is rather serious that the Minister has made the case that the should not be a discussion upon the Finance Bill. The Minister has made the case—and I want to emphasise it lest the Minister has something else at the back of his mind in regard to Single Chamber Government—that the House should be satisfied with the discussion on the Budget, and that the sees no reason whatever for discussion on the Finance Bill. That means that he sees no reason whatever for giving any information on the Finance Bill. The House should take notice of that attitude and see the lines upon which the Minister's mind is running.
Comment on this
This section, as I already explained, is to enable us to make certain adjustments in regard to the Local Services (Temporary Economics) Act, 1934. These adjustments are likely to work both ways either by reducing income-tax in some cases or increasing it in others.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment No. 1 standing in the name of Deputy Costello. As I understand it, there were statutory limitations beyond which a person's account could not be gone into in order to impose income-tax in certain circumstances. The Minister now proposes to delete the statutory period, and to make it possible to go back and investigate the accounts of any person arising out of any circumstances over any period of time. Deputy Costello's amendment, if adopted, would mean that it would be only possible to go back in circumstances in which there was fraud or wilful neglect established. I take it the Minister himself would be inclined to accept that and I should be glad to hear if that is so.
Comment on this
I am not in a position to accept this amendment. I do not know whether Deputy Costello, who put forward the amendment, was himself aware of what happened. I think the amendment would, in effect, go much further than Deputy Mulcahy has said.
Comment on this
If that is so, and the Minister is not accepting it, I would be prepared to withdraw it so that Deputy Costello would have an opportunity of putting his case to the Minister at another stage.
Comment on this
I was going to suggest that the first part of Deputy Costello's amendment could be moved and that the real question arises on that.
Comment on this
Quite. I take it that if the amendment read:
(2) Sub-section (1) of Section 21 of the Finance Act, 1920, is hereby amended by the insertion after the words "full-time" the words "or part-time"
and stopped there, the House would agree to that course. There are two points involved in amendment No. 4 and one definite point in amendment No. 5.
Comment on this
Does that mean that on the Report Stage we would have to discuss this all over again?
Comment on this
The second portion of Deputy Costello's amendment No. 5 covers the point raised explicitly in amendment No. 5 by Deputy Morrissey. I suggest that the lines dealing with apprenticeship should be deleted from Deputy Costello's amendment. That would save Deputy Morrissey's amendment.
Comment on this
The object would be to enable that part of amendment No. 5 which covers the point more fully to be moved. If amendment No. 4 were moved as it stands on the Paper, and the House rejected it, amendment No. 5 could not be moved.
Comment on this
I quite appreciate the reasons why Deputy Costello is not here at the moment and I would facilitate him by holding over the amendment standing in his name to the Report Stage. But I am concerned that if the House devotes time now to the principle involved in Deputy Costello's amendment No. 4, and in amendment No. 5, there should not be a repetition of all that on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey's amendment deals with apprenticeship. If that matter were then decided the second or latter portion of Deputy Costello's amendment could not be moved on any later stage.
Comment on this
I have Deputy Costello's permission to enable the first part of his amendment to be taken.
Comment on this
What I am concerned about is that we should not have a second discussion or repetition of this discussion.
Comment on this
I formally move, on behalf of Deputy Costello, the first portion of amendment No. 4.
Comment on this
I hope it is quite clear that we shall not be able to discuss the second portion of Deputy Costello's amendment.
Comment on this
It will be taken when amendment No. 4 has been disposed of. Amendment No. 4 is being taken, with deletion of the last two lines, and will read:
Sub-section (1) of Section 21 of the Finance Act, 1920, is hereby amended by the insertion after the words "full time" the words "or part time".
Comment on this
That places me at a disadvantage. I do not know where precisely we shall stand. Shall we discuss amendment No. 4 now and vote on it or shall we reserve the discussion for amendment No. 5?
Comment on this
Would not the proper course be to take amendment No. 5 before amendment No. 4? If the Deputy wants to debate amendment No. 5, he can make his case.
Comment on this
It is. When the Deputy takes the responsibility of moving a motion or amendment, he is bound to give reasons for his action.
Comment on this
That comes very badly from the Minister, who has been moving section after section without giving any reason whatsoever. I have moved the first part of amendment No. 4 on behalf of Deputy Costello.
Comment on this
Will the Minister give his reasons for not accepting it? If he refuses, I shall not move it at all and it can be moved on Report Stage.
Comment on this
What happens amendment No. 4 in its present form if amendment No. 5 be rejected by the House?
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle put the matter to the House and the Minister raised no objection.
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle did not put the matter to the House. I want to know what exactly the position is before anything is decided.
Comment on this
The matter is very simple. Amendment No. 4 is not moved. Amendment No. 5 has now been moved and any point in amendment No. 4 decided on amendment No. 5 cannot again be tabled.
Comment on this
In that case, I want to put the question to the House. The Minister is, apparently, in a difficulty which he has only just now discovered. It has made him quite hot and a little more insolent than usual.
Comment on this
The Deputy has to remember that, when he seeks concessions, he asks for them, not demands them.
Comment on this
I do not ask any concession from the Minister. I should be very sorry to do so because it would only provide the Minister with an opportunity of being more insolent than usual. I am moving the first part of amendment No. 4 on behalf of Deputy Costello.
Comment on this
Protest when I am finished. I am moving the first part of the amendment down to, and including, the words "part time."
Comment on this
The Deputy should be satisfied to take amendment No. 4 as not moved since objection has been taken to amending without notice. It may be moved at a later stage in so far as it is not covered by amendment No. 5.
Comment on this
I am not going to ask the Chair to say now, because it would not be right to do so, whether the rejection of amendment No. 5 would prevent amendment No. 4 from being moved on the next stage. However, in view of the attitude taken up by the Minister, I have no choice, in order to safeguard both amendments, but to put the first part of amendment No. 4 to the House.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey is asking the permission of the House to move amendment No. 4, as he proposes to amend it, and he is entitled to do that.
Comment on this
I think that the Deputy should withdraw amendment No. 4 and have it moved on Report Stage so far as it is not covered by amendment No. 5.
Comment on this
It is no pleasure for any person to be in the Chair when the Minister is in the mood in which he is now. The Minister is just as irrelevant and disorderly while occupying the Front Ministerial Bench as he was when in opposition.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5. It is rather a pity that Deputy Crowley would not give the House the benefit of those words of wisdom which he uttered on the back bench. This amendment is one which speaks for itself and I am sure the Minister does not want me to elaborate it. This matter was brought before the House on the Finance Bill of last year. One of the Minister's reasons for not accepting it was that he had not had sufficient time to consider it. He promised to look into the matter before the present Finance Bill would come before the House. The object of the amendment is to secure the concession extended to others for parents whose children are apprenticed to trades or professions. As the law stands at present, it is only when children are sent to the universities that parents get this concession. The amendment is fairly tightly drawn because the Minister pointed out last year that the amendment then tabled would open the door too widely and that there would be too many demands for the concession, resulting in substantial loss to the Revenue. For that reason, the amendment is restricted as much as possible. I should like if the Minister would tell us whether he is accepting the amendment or not or whether he has had time fully to consider the matter. I think nobody will dispute the fairness of applying this concession, which is given to parents who send their children to a University, to apprentices, particularly in view of the declared policy of the Government on the industrialisation of the country, and in view of the shortage of trained and skilled men in this country, which is so much that we have to bring in a number of the natives of other countries.
Comment on this
The Government is not prepared to accept this amendment but I should like to hear other arguments in support of the amendment and of its principle.
Comment on this
We are anxious not only to learn the Government's attitude on this amendment, but also their reasons for not accepting it. The Minister for Finance asks for additional reasons why this amendment should pass and that additional income-tax relief be given to parents who are bearing the cost of the higher education of their children in this particular way.
Comment on this
I am saying that I am prepared to urge on the Minister and on the Government further reasons why this amendment should be passed and that further relief should be given to parents who are bearing the cost of the higher education of their children. I take it the Minister does not disapprove of parent doing their best, according to their means, to give the highest possible education to their children. I take it that with the position as it is in the country and in view of the various discussions we have had about the difficulty of getting Irish technical experts in the sugar factories and other factories throughout the country, that the Minister realises the importance of the amendment, and that he does remember the ideal that has been held up in Fianna Fáil propaganda throughout the country about the great industrial development there is going to be here and the brains that will be necessary to direct that not only administratively but technically. I take it too that the Minister realises that nobody can better prepare the way to provide the educational requirements to meet developments of that particular kind than the parents who have children who have the capacity to absorb higher education. If the Minister knows anything of the cost of even primary education or secondary education he will realise that parents with large families have a very heavy burden to bear in meeting the heavy expenses involved in a three or four years course of University education as well as meeting the expenses in the case of apprenticeships in engineering, architecture or anything like that. I take it that the Minister's Department will have some estimate of what this would amount to. The Minister, in dealing with Section 1, declined to give the House any information——
Comment on this
I want to discuss the capacity of parents to give their children higher education, and I do want to say that if a labouring man, or an agricultural labourer, is in the position by any hook or crook of giving higher education to his children he should be assisted to do that, and so should the farmer and so should a member of any other section of the community. The Minister has indicated the type of relief that recent actions of the Government have given to persons with families. A very small amount has been saved to these people, but except relief of this particular kind is given you are going to deprive quite a large number of children—whose parents cannot without some additional assistance give them the benefit of University education—of getting this University education. If there is any bona fides at all in the Minister's contention that we are having higher industrial development here and that we do want better trained technical brains to assist in that development, and that we do want these to be Irish brains, and that we want them quickly, the Minister will approach this matter in a sympathetic way. We would like to know if his position is that that relief must be a class reservation for people to whom the amount of money they spend on their children's education is of little concern because of the size of their incomes? If this is not to be a class reservation, the Minister will give more consideration to the amendment. The Minister knows that the income of every class in the community has been reduced and the capacity of every class, except those very well off, to give their children a higher education is substantially reduced. I am putting these arguments to the Minister and I would like to hear on what grounds the Government are refusing to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Are we not to have the attitude of the Government on the matter stated to the House?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy able to advance a single reason why the Government should change its disposition in regard to this matter? If so, I shall be glad to hear that reason. I am very anxious to hear any argument from the Deputy in support of the amendment. If the Deputy has considered this amendment at all, will he place before the House his reasons why it should be passed, or why it ought to be adopted by the Government?
Comment on this
If the Minister is not going to treat this amendment seriously and if he is not going to give any reason to the House for opposing it——
Comment on this
I would appeal to the Chair if it has any control over the Minister to ask him to behave himself. If the Minister is not inclined to treat this seriously and to refrain from play-acting, he should be compelled to do so. This is a serious and important matter. There is an amendment down on the Paper and certain reasons have been advanced in support of that amendment. The weight to be attached to these reasons is a matter of opinion. The Minister may consider that the reasons put forward are not sufficient or he may consider that they are bad reasons or that they are badly put, but these things have nothing to do with it. We are not all as glib as the Minister and in any case we are entitled to be told what is the reaction of the Minister to this amendment; whether he is prepared to accept it and, if not prepared to accept it, to give the reasons for its rejection. That is all we are asking.
Comment on this
I have already indicated to the House that I am not responsible for the fact that Deputy Morrissey did not hear when I told the House that I was not disposed to accept this amendment, but that the Government was anxious to hear those in favour of it. We have heard Deputy Morrissey and we have heard Deputy Mulchay. If there is any other Deputy who can add anything to what they said, I should like to hear him and to deal with him.
Comment on this
Might I remind the Minister that when this matter was before the House last year the Minister's plea was that he had not had sufficient time to consider it and he promised the House he would look into the matter before the next Finance Bill—that is the present Finance Bill. Apparently, the Minister has attempted to carry out that promise to make fuller inquiries into the matter to see if it could be given effect to and perhaps he will now give the House the benefit of those inquiries.
Comment on this
May I point out that, notwithstanding what Deputy Morrissey has said, I do not think it would add to the dignity of the House if I were to keep bobbing up and down in this debate, but I would like to ask Deputy Morrissey to tell the House what was before the House last year. The amendment which is on the Order Paper is not the amendment which was before the House last year. Possibly, Deputy Morrissey has not grasped that fact yet.
Comment on this
The Minister is simply play-acting. The amendment was not worded in the same way, but the principle was the same.
Comment on this
Might I interrupt the Deputy just to ask one question? Will he tell me where in the whole length of the amendment he has down in the Order Paper the word "apprentices" occurs?
Comment on this
I must protest against this. I do not know, Sir, whether you have heard the explanation of the conduct of the Minister. I doubt if the House has.
Comment on this
I am glad you are not. I would be sorry if anyone was responsible for the Minister in his present state. I would not for a moment think of imputing such a thing to the Chair. I would be extraordinarily out of order if I did anything of the kind. Luckily, I have only been in the House for about 20 minutes. If the proceedings before I came in bore any relation to what I have been a painful witness of in the House for the last 20 minutes, I am glad I was not here during the opening stages of the debate. The conduct of the Minister in the present instance is lamentable from the point of view of the House. Two Deputies of standing—any Deputy in this House is a Deputy of standing —but two Deputies whose views certainly require attention have stood up here and put forward their views. These views have been treated with open contempt by the Minister. I suggest that is an abuse—I admit that the Chair cannot remedy it, but merely because the Chair cannot remedy it and deal with the conduct of the Minister, does not make it less an abuse of the position which the Minister holds in this House. An amendment has been moved. The Minister may object to the form of the amendment, to the words of the amendment, but at least he might have addressed himself to the subject of the amendment. He might even have used this opportunity——
Comment on this
Is this in order? Might I ask what the Deputy is supposed to be speaking to; whether there is a motion before the House to censure the conduct of the Minister in debate for failing to comply with some standing order, of which I am not aware, that if one Deputy or two Deputies, whether of standing or otherwise, speak, the Minister is bound to reply, or whether the Deputy is trying to discuss an amendment on the Order Paper?
Comment on this
I have not yet heard sufficient from the Deputy to decide.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present.