We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1936—Committee.

Contributions 145–269 of 269. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1936
Enacted

No. 20 of 1936 ›

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is not accepting that motion.

Comment on this

Will the Chair accept the motion that the President be sent for, or will the Chair have regard to the Standing Orders with reference to the dignity of this House?

Comment on this

Might I ask how long we shall have to wait before you will be prepared to accept a motion in these circumstances?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair will not give a ruling in advance.

House counted and 20 Deputies being present.

Comment on this

Before you rule, Sir, on the point of order raised some considerable time ago by the Minister, might I point out that in discussing this amendment, the conduct of the Minister, his failure to answer the points put forward by two Deputies on this side of the House, is relevant to the attitude that the House ought to take up towards this amendment. Arguments were put forward by Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Mulcahy in favour of the amendment. The Minister refused to deal with these arguments. He had several opportunities of doing so. He might have done so after Deputy Morrissey sat down. He invited then further discussion. Deputy Mulcahy intervened and once more the Minister could have given reasons why this amendment before the House should not be accepted by the Government. He could have pointed out what was unsound in the reasons put forward by Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy Morrissey. He did not do so. The only articulate expression of opinion that we heard from the Minister was, mainly, in the form of interruptions to the Deputies in question. One was the plea—I suggest it is to a large extent a quible, a matter of mere words—that as the word apprentice ship was not mentioned here, therefore the amendment before the House was in no way connected with the matter that was before the House 12 months ago in connection with apprenticeship. But apprenticeship is training, a very important type of training. If apprenticeship is not training then again — I was in a similar difficulty yesterday—I fail to know what apprenticeship is meant to be.

I suggest, Sir, that when the Minister asked for reasons he might at least have the courtesy to listen. I suggest that the conduct of the Minister is disorderly, and I ask your ruling on that point: that when we are addressing the House the Minister should at least listen.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair cannot compel the Minister to listen.

Comment on this

The Chair can at least ask the Minister not to indulge in conversation when arguments are being addressed to him.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair cannot compel the Minister to listen.

Comment on this

I again point out to you the way in which, from the start, the Minister has treated this particular matter. If training is not apprenticeship, why do people pay a fee for an apprenticeship? It is quite obvious that it is regarded as training, and why there should be exemptions for certain grades in this country who are undergoing training, who are taking out professional courses—why exemptions should be made for children of that class and no exemptions made for the children of the labouring classes, why no voice should be raised, even on the Government Benches, on their behalf, and why it should be considered that the man who is not rich enough to send his son for a profession should get no exemption, even though his son or daughter is undergoing a course of training subsequent to the primary period, a course of training that is absolutely necessary for the acquirement of a trade or profession in which that young person is to spend his or her life: why that person should not get exemption and why a person, for instance, going on for medicine or the higher branches of engineering should get exemption does, I submit, require very careful consideration by the House and, if not by the Minister, certainly by those who are interested in the proper development of training in industry in this country.

I think that for a long time now, since the establishment of the State, there has been a fair amount of effort to stress the importance of training of all kinds, to try to raise, so to speak, the level of technical training to the level of other types of training. Why should not every help that the Government can give be given? In vain, efforts have been made to know what the attitude of the Minister and of the Government is to the case put forward by Deputies Morrissey and Mulcahy. I see no reason why there should be this disrespect for, this looking down upon, technical training: why there should not in that particular case be exemption and why help should not be given. Training of that kind is quite as essential to the future participant in the industrial life of this country as is university education to the future professional classes, and the main purpose of the amendment is to restore a certain amount of equality in that particular matter. For that reason I recommend it to the House. I think it does require not merely the careful consideration of the House, but I should be very much surprised if the House, if left to itself, would not give it very hearty support.

Comment on this

With regard to the Minister's reference to the amendment that it does not refer to apprentices, I would ask the Minister to read the words: "Undergoing training by any person (hereafter referred to as ‘the employer') for any trade, profession, or vocation." If that does not mean apprentices, I do not know what it means.

Comment on this

It is very difficult to discuss a matter here with any sort of rational approach because some of those who venture to put down amendments do not, apparently, appreciate the meaning or significance of words. Deputy Morrissey charged me with discourtesy to the House because I had refused to deal with a matter which had been discussed in the House last year, and with the arguments in favour of which I ought to be perfectly familiar. I asked Deputy Morrissey to tell me what the House discussed last year. The Deputy, of course, did not know what the House discussed last year. He said that his amendment had been discussed in the House last year.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

I beg the Deputy's pardon, it is on record.

Comment on this

I said no such thing.

Comment on this

I beg the Deputy's pardon, it is on record. I asked him to show me where the word "apprentice" appeared in this amendment. He stood up and referred me to certain words in his amendment, but among them the word "apprentice" does not appear. The proposal which was discussed here in the House last year referred to "indentured apprentices." That was the phrase used in the amendment which was under discussion and which was rejected by the House last year but it does not appear in Deputy Morrissey's amendment to-day. Why not? Because the Deputy had not sufficient originality to try and put, in his own words, the proposal which he wished the House to discuss. The proposal which appears on our Order Paper is part of an amendment which was discussed in the British House of commons some weeks ago and which the Deputy lifted holus-bolus and put down here in order to show a certain section of the people how much concerned he was about their welfare; but he could not sit down and give one half hour of his time to think out a form of words that might meet the situation. He expects that the Minister is going to waste his time discussing a proposal lifted, as I say, out of the records of a discussion elsewhere, and then flung at the House without a single argument to commend it. Deputy Mulchay jumped in after Deputy Morrissey to make confusion worse confounded. The whole of the Deputy's speech was related to the advantages of higher education and why we ought not to encourage it. There is not a word in this amendment about higher education. Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan's speech—Saladin turned Crusader—was the gem of the debate, because the Deputy said that this amendment was designed to assist the children of the labouring classes. The Deputy's colleague has been telling us all through the week that the labourer in this country receives something between 18/-, 23/- 24/- and 25/- a week.

Comment on this

I mentioned 18s. 7d. in the new industries.

Comment on this

Very well, 18s. 7d. in the new industries. How many 18/7's received during the year will put a labourer, the father of one of these children, into the category of an income-tax payer?

Comment on this

That has nothing to do with the principle.

Comment on this

It has something to do with the principle and with the amendment. The Deputy's colleague, with all the ponderosity, the mental ponderosity, which characterises him has recommended this amendment to the House as something which is designed to benefit the children of the labouring classes. The labourers, according to Deputy Mulcahy, earn 18s. 7d. a week. Will the Deputy produce to this House that unique specimen, the labourer who is earning 18s. 7d. a week and who pays income-tax and who will come within the terms of the income-tax section? I think if the Deputy is able to do that, he would die as rich as Barnum and will supersede him as the greatest showman the world has ever known. Where is this labourer with an income of 18s. 7d. a week who is called upon to pay income-tax?

Who is it pays income-tax in this country? Deputy O'Sullivan was not here to listen to me, but let me again cite some examples from the category of income-tax payers. Unless a married man with two children has an income of over £400 a year, he does not pay any income tax in the Free State under the present régime. If he had been living in the halcyon days when Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan was here instead of there, and the standard rate was 3/6, he would have been paying £6 6s. To-day, if he has two children and an earned income of £400 a year he does not pay anything, and it will take quite a big revolution in this country before there is any child the son or daughter of a labourer who has £400 a year earned income. I think I have disposed of that sort of sentimental tosh which Deputy John Marcus O'Sullican trots out to the House in support of this and other amendments.

We know the sort of speech the Deputy is always prepared to make on a resolution of this sort. I believe at one time the Deputy had quite a reputation as a philosopher. He turned from his earlier avocation and became an historian, and we, of course, know that the muse of history is often allied to the muse of rumour. Now he has become a politician, where few regard the truth except those who have the responsibility for Government and sit on these benches. Surely the Deputy might learn another speech when he comes to discuss financial proposals in this House? He gets up here and talks day after day, and all of us know his heart is not in his work. He has learned a speech by rote from the Complete Speechmaker and he makes an oration which, I have no doubt, if I had the book from which he conned it, I would say was headed "Speech for any Budget, or for any section of a Finance Bill." That is the sort of thing we have had from Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan this afternoon.

The Deputy was in a position at one time, in days when taxation was so much lighter and so many other things could have been done, when there was so much more money at the disposal of the then Administration than there is at our disposal now, to do quite a lot of things of this sort, but he never did them. Remember this, that if we were to accept the proposal contained in this amendment, it would cost us a considerable sum of money and it could lead to further demands for further concessions and would mean that whatever we lose by making these allowances we shall have to make good, not at the expense of the income-tax payer, but at the expense of the labouring classes and the children of the labouring classes for whom Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan has expressed so much concern this afternoon. The Deputy was in power here from 1923 to 1931. Why did not Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan, Deputy Richard Mulcahy and Deputy Morrissey, who was running with them if he was not actually one of their team—why did not they during that period press upon the Government the desirability of making the concession which is asked for here? Now they are full of concern, but when they had the power it did not give them any concern at all. I do not know if it would be quite Parliamentary for me to say that they did not give a damn about the children of the labouring classes, but if it cannot go on the record, at least it expresses very tersely what was the position when Deputy O'Sullivan, Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy Morrissey had power to influence the financial policy of the Government.

This is not as simple a thing as appears on the surface. We are asked under certain circumstances to do certain things. I may say that since a similar matter was mentioned in this House, not last year but two years ago, I have given it the closest possible consideration. I have come to the conclusion that it would not be possible to grant a concession on those terms. In this year's Budget we have gone very far. We have increased the children's allowance—not merely in respect of children who happen to be engaged in trade or in respect of children who are being educated, but in respect of every child. We have raised the allowance from £50 to £60, and I think that is a very substantial concession in a year like the present. We are asked now to go further. We are asked to give the concession where a child is required to devote the whole of his time to training for a period of not less than two years. That misses the whole point. The reason why this concession was given originally was to encourage people to educate their children. Of course, Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan, who was Minister for Education in the last administration, has not yet grasped the full ambit of the concession. He and Deputy Mulcahy have been talking as if the concession were confined to those who are enjoying the benefits of University education. Of course it is nothing of the sort. It is given in respect of any child who is receiving full-time instruction at a university, college, school or other educational establishment. There is quite a number of children in this State who are at school after the age of 16 years, and who are not students of a University. Most of those who are studying for the leaving certificate are over the age of 16, or may be over the age of 16. They are benefiting, and they are not going to a University and do not intend to go to a University. They will go into trade or they will go into commerce, or they will go into the Civil Service. The reason why the concession was given in the first place was in order to encourage people to educate their children.

The position, of course, is quite different in regard to people who have children who may be employed. In effect, what this amendment asks us to do is to grant the concession in relation to children who are employed; in relation to the boy who is fortunate enough to get inside the closed borough of a trade. Mind you, that word "apprentice" is not mentioned here. It is not mentioned because if it were mentioned it would be quite impracticable to grant the concession in respect of what were described last year as "indentured apprentices," because the term has no legal significance, and neither has the phrase that is used here. The parent of a boy—it does not matter how wealthy the parent may be—who is assumed to be engaged in any avocation is to receive an allowance in respect of that particular child. What happens to the parent of a boy who is not fortunate enough to get inside the closed borough, or to the parent of a boy who is not disposed to work? Of course that particular boy will notsay that he is not disposed to work. He will say that the one ambition of his boyish soul is to become a bricklayer or a tailor or an engineer or a plasterer— to get into one of those trades which, as I said before, are virtually closed boroughs—but that he cannot do it, and he does not want to thwart the natural abilities which he has; he wants them to flourish and expand. But at the back of his mind he has no desire to work or train or equip himself. Supposing we are to do as Deputy Morrissey says, how are we going to confine it to this, the really fortunate section of the taxpayers? Mind you, the whole thing has been put up to me under the guise of a concession to the working-class people of this country. If there are any working-class parents who would be benefited by this concession—I contend that there are not, because I gave the House figures which show quite clearly that the ordinary artisan in this country does not in any conceivable circumstances, if he is a married man with a family, become chargeable for income-tax—how are you going to justify giving this concession in regard to the boy who is fortunate enough to get inside the closed borough and be in training for a trade, and refuse it to the father of the other boy who has not got the same chance or to the father of the boy who is not disposed to work?

The whole thing, as I said before, is quite impracticable. Again I repeat that in this year's Budget we have given a very substantial concession by increasing the children's allowance from £50 to £60. We cannot do more. If we are called upon to do more we can only do it—again I want to repeat and emphasise this—at the expense of the great majority of the people of this country, that is, at the expense of the people who are not fortunate enough to enjoy sufficiently high incomes to be called upon to pay tax on them.

Comment on this

The Minister gave as his first and, I may say, his main objection to this amendment the fact that it had been lifted bodily from the British House of Commons; that it was all amendment which was moved to the British Finance Bill. I thought myself that it was quite a good amendment, and that it went some way to meet the objections of the Minister as to the necessity for some redistribution, so that the door would not be opened too wide. The Minister tried to make capital of the fact that it was an amendment which was moved in the British House of Commons. Of course, he overlooks the fact that Section 4 in his own Bill deals with a section of an Act passed in the British House of Commons in 1920, and that the whole code of income-tax legislation in this country was lifted bodily from the British Government. The Minister's next objection to it—of course, it is part of an article which we had last week or the week before last in the Fianna Fáil bulletin—is that it would cost a good deal of money; that the money would have to be found at the expense of the social services for the poor people, and that it would be found nowhere else. Might I suggest that he might find it out of the £2,000,000 he was going to save in taxation or the additional £10,000,000 he has added on?

The Minister has not tried to meet the amendment. I suggest that the reason why he has talked so much around the amendment was that it was more difficult for him to make a case against this amendment than the ones previously moved. The Minister found fault with the amendment because the word "apprentice" did not appear in it, and then proceeded to tell us that the word "apprentice" had no legal significance at all, and even that the phraseology of this amendment had none. It is quite clear that the Minister is not prepared to give the same concession to persons who apprentice their children to professions or trades as he gives to parents whose children go to a University. That is the net point, and all the Minister's talk around the subject is not going to get away from it.

Comment on this

It is quite obvious, Sir, that in the course of his speech the Minister did realise that the amendment does include apprentices. He says he has given consideration to the matter since it was last before the House. All he has told us is that, as a result of that, he does not feel inclined to make any concessions. He has given no reasons; he has only said that he is not going to do it. He is satisfied that he will not give the concession but he has not told the House the grounds on which he bases that refusal. He has refused to do that, and the House is still wondering on what grounds the Minister makes the discriminations, or stands for the discriminations, that now exist in this particular code. One is that, in the ten years in which his predecessors were in office, they did not do it. Am I to take it that it is the settled policy of the Government that even in minor matters—I know that in major matters they are doing the very opposite, even in financial major matters—am I to take it that in minor matters they are determined to make no advance whatsoever beyond what their predecessors had made?

There is a reference in another part of the amendment to the amount of any earnings being taken into account, but this is an instance of a person being in training, training that is supposed to be for a trade. I presume the father is not a person of great wealth, at all events, or a person who can afford to give his children the educational advantages that have already been provided for. That was the gist of the case made to the Minister. I now see that the Minister accepts as the proper wage for the workman 18/- a week. That was the wording of his statement—that that was the typical and normal labourer. Leaving that aside, however, is there any reason why the parent, whose child is undergoing or receiving training of this kind, should not get relief as well as the parent who is better off and who can afford to send his child to a regular educational establishment? It is training in both cases.

I have not that contempt that the Minister seems to have for this particular type of training. I never had it. In introducing the Technical Instruction Bill in this House, I made it perfectly clear that mental training of any kind was important for this country and that it was a mistake and a piece of snobbery to rate certain kinds of mental training higher than others. Now, there is a certain kind of training given here. It may be apprenticeship, it may be indentured apprenticeship, that is included, but it goes farther than that. There is no reason why it should be confined to that. Why should not that type of training be measured along with the other type of intellectual training to which the Minister has referred? That is the case the Minister has not met and that he has not attempted to meet. He has met it with an argument that, coming from the Minister who has imposed the amount of taxation that he has imposed, does not seem to us to be meeting our point at all—and that argument is that he cannot afford it.

Now, for a Government, famed for its extravagance like the present Government, to bring forward an argument of that kind in itself shows the weakness of its case. He gives no indication as to what the amendment would cost, what the burden would be, or what would be the number of people who would be likely to find relief under it. All kinds of arguments are put forward about people who are usually inclined to waste their time. That class of person seems to have become a fixed idea with the Minister, and now, because a certain number of people, apparently, do not want to work or to learn a trade, therefore, according to his argument, the number of people who do want to work or to learn a trade are not to be helped.

Comment on this

I wish, Sir, with your permission, to make a few supplemental remarks to what has already been said on this amendment standing in Deputy Morrissey's name. The amendment that I had on the Order Paper—No. 4—embraced a somewhat similar, if not identical, principle to that contained in Deputy Morrissey's amendment, and I regret that circumstances, over which I had no control, precluded me from being here to move that amendment. Consequently, I must take Deputy Morrissey's amendment as it stands. The principle is the same. It came as somewhat of a surprise to me to learn that people who were attending, say, a university for lectures, and who were, at the same time, apprenticed to either a profession or trade, were not entitled to the relief in the relevant section of the Act of 1920. I had always understood that that section was, shall we say, administered, if not interpreted, in a very liberal spirit. There had been no public demand that I had ever heard in reference to the subject matter of the amendments in my name or in Deputy Morrissey's name.

Comment on this

I should like to know, Sir, to which amendment the Deputy is referring.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are dealing with amendment No. 5.

Comment on this

If the application of the proposed new sub-section or the relevant section of the Act of 1920 is not relevant to either a profession or a trade, then, Sir, I am in your hands. That is the topic to which I am addressing my remarks.

Comment on this

The Deputy misunderstands the Minister. The Minister only means that he thinks the Deputy is not entitled to question him at all on this matter.

Comment on this

I understood, Sir, that I was dealing with Deputy Morrissey's amendment on the question of giving relief to people who were apprenticed to a trade or profession as if they had been, within the terms of the Act of 1920, receiving full-time education at an educational establishment.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has not ruled the Deputy out of order.

Comment on this

I understand, Sir, but the Minister interrupted me and I was not sure where I stood. Apparently the Minister has learned some of the tricks of the advocate's trade and, when he meets a point that he fears he cannot deal with, he interrupts.

Comment on this

The Deputy has had some experience of that trade.

Comment on this

Yes, certainly, I have had some experience of being able to deal with that sort of point. At all events, however, I have not had the pleasure of hearing the Minister's explanation on this point.

Comment on this

Neither has anybody else.

Comment on this

We awaited his explanation with some interest, but I am afraid, after this stage of the Bill goes through, we will be awaiting his explanation still—without interest. This amendment was put down in the British House of Commons and I suppose the Minister will say that Deputy Morrissey is copying the British Labour Party. I put down my amendment without any consultation with Deputy Morrissey, because it occurred to me, from a case brought to my knowledge by one of my constituents, that it was an injustice that required to be remedied. But the attitude of the British Chancellor of the Exchequer was in striking contrast, I understand, with the attitude that the Minister has taken up on this amendment. He received it with complete sympathy but regretted that the circumstances of the time would not permit him to meet it.

Comment on this

The Deputy can have all my sympathies if he accepts also my regrets.

Comment on this

I understand that up to the present the Minister did not express even sympathy with the amendment, until I pulled out that observation. To that extent, there is this difference between the British Chancellor of the Exchequer of a Conservative Government, who expressed sympathy with the Labour view, and the Minister for Finance here, who, up to the present, did not express any such sympathy. The point, as I understand it, is that the British Chancellor of the Exchequer would accept it only that he could not afford it. That the Minister for Finance was not in sympathy with the amendment was I think the natural deduction, as I understand, to be drawn from the observations made by him. At all events, neither he nor the British Chancellor of the Exchequer is affording this relief which is required in my view in the interests of ordinary decency and justice. It will cost the Exchequer very little. The Minister has not told us how much it will cost. Such as it is, the Minister says it would fall on the labouring class. I am told the Minister said so in his answer. I would like to know how it will fall on the labouring class. Does the Minister take up the attitude that his Parliamentary Secretary took up last year and say: "Why should not the tax fall on the working class?" That was the attitude of his Parliamentary Secretary last year when taxation was imposed by the Minister in the Budget. Why should not these taxes fall on the working class? If the Parliamentary Secretary was correct, why should it not fall on the working class? Apart from that aspect, how does the Minister suggest that the cost of the scheme suggested in the amendment would fall on the working class?

There is only one possible explanation of that remark, and that is that the Minister has so heavily taxed everybody in the community, even to the working class, that there is nobody left to take on the residue but the working class that has not yet been taxed by the Minister in his depredations in the Budgets and the Finance Acts of the last few years. I cannot see any other explanation why the principle behind the Act of 1920 should not apply, whether in part or in whole, to people receiving instruction and education or those apprenticed in trades or professions. During that period in a young man's life he is a liability on his parents, and it was in order to meet that situation that the provisions of the Act of 1920 were inserted by the British Parliament. They will not be extended by the Minister in the circumstances of this country, when it is eminently desirable that people should be apprenticed to trades of an expert character. If there is any substance in the policy of the Government, or in the claim that they make that they have established some industries here —let us take it that some of their claims are correct, and let us take it as a hypothesis that there is to be industrial expansion—you must have expert people trained in industry, or if not you have to bring over foreigners. We have the claim of the National University graduates that they should be employed in these industries that are supposed to be established here. Assume that they are here, you must have specialists trained if they are to be a success and if you are not to be providing employment for foreigners.

In order to get factories started, in many instances expert assistance had to be brought over and, incidentally, at very high salaries. I mentioned the sugar factories, where very high salaries are paid to the managing directors. In order that they will be able in the future to take up positions in these factories, you have got to make a start now by apprenticing young people to trades and industries. If you do not train the youth of the country now, in 10 or 15 years' time you will be carrying on the same policy, of bringing over foreigners to do expert work that ought to be done by trained Irish experts. One of the ways in which assistance can be given, not merely to ordinary people in trades, but assistance towards the establishment of something in the nature of Irish industries is by giving a benefit of this kind. This is a practical test of the sincerity of the Government in their industrial policy. There are large numbers of people unemployed here at present. One of the greatest problems that will face this country for some time to come is the problem of what is to be done with young people from 17 years upwards who are leaving secondary and primary schools. The Government refused to raise the school-leaving age, having adopted the policy that the school-leaving age as it stands is sufficient. We are in favour of raising the school-leaving age, so as to contribute in some way towards a solution of the very pressing problem that exists of providing some sort of hope for future careers for young people from the primary, secondary, and even technical schools. If they could be assured of some training in trades or professions, and if there was some inducement held out to their parents to put them into trades or professions, considerable advantage would accrue to the community. One of the ways in which the Government might, at small cost to the Exchequer, show their sincerity is by giving this small relief in reference to people apprenticed to trades and professions, limited, if the Minister likes, to any class, as an earnest of his intention to meet in some way the problem of young people leaving school and the problem of unemployment that must be solved by any Government. I suggest that the way to have any decent industries, and the way to have people employed in these industries is to have them manned by Irish people. This is a method by which a beginning could be made, but the Minister did not express even sympathy with the amendment until it was dragged out of him by the observation I made at the opening of my remarks.

Comment on this

The Minister, above every other Minister, should know something of what the cost of education means to parents. He has had to do with a big body of civil servants throughout the country, and I am sure he has had drawn to his attention the examination into the distribution of expenditure in the incomes of a certain number of civil servants in connection with an examination into the cost of living that took place some years ago. Some 63 budgets were submitted by members of the Civil Service with a view to indicating how expenditure ran in the various classes of incomes. The incomes ranged from £300 and under to £400, from £400 to £500, and from £500 upwards, and taking the average incomes as £250, £350, £450 and £600 of persons in the Civil Service, the expenditure on education is recorded as £5 on £250; £7 10s. on £350; £18 on £450, and above £40 on £600 and over. There was a rise in the figures from £5 on £250 to £40 at £600 as expenditure on education. We see from that something of the desire to spend such moneys as can be made available on education. It has been the complaint in the past that instead of education being directed towards trade or technical lines, there was too much clerical or office work about it. Even with the development of technical education since the new Act was introduced some years ago, that tradition of office work has stuck to a great extent to these schools generally throughout the country. If, as Deputies have said, there is anything behind the protestations of the Ministry that they want to prepare the people of the country for a better class of industrialisation, then certainly some sympathy should be shown for the position indicated here, that people who have money show only too great an anxiety to expend it on their children's education. That being the attitude on the part of the parents, the attitude of the Government should be to hold out any inducement that would indicate to them that the education of their children should, as far as possible be directed along technical lines. The Government should be prepared, by such assistance as can be reasonably given in accordance with the principles they have already laid down in respect to giving relief on educational expenditure, to give them the relief that has been asked for here in order to induce a greater tendency towards education on the technical side.

Comment on this

I had not intended to reply, but the last speech coerces me to get on my feet again. It is quite clear that there is no proper appreciation of the position in the minds of the Opposition. First of all, let us remember what we are considering. We are considering an allowance granted under the income-tax code. I have already given figures to this House to show that unless a married man who has two children has an earned income of £400 per annum or over, he does not have to pay any income-tax. Therefore, so far as the overwhelming body of the people of this country is concerned, they pay no tax. I think our population is about 3,000,000. I doubt if, in present circumstances, the total number of our citizens who are assessed for income-tax exceeds 100,000. That is to say that roughly income-tax payers are less than 3 per cent. of our population. These are rough and approximate figures, but at any rate they will help the House to visualise what the position is. Deputies will, therefore, understand the significance of my statement when I say that until the average head of a family in this State has a total income, all of it earned, of more than £400, he is not likely to be called upon to pay income-tax at all. The plea has been made for this amendment that it is designed to encourage people to see that their children are properly trained for industrial occupations. What is the proper way to train them and prepare them for normal industrial occupations? It is to give them the best possible primary and technical education the parent can. The original purpose behind this children's allowance was to encourage parents to see that their children were educated. educated in the broadest sense, as distinct from the manual training which a person will get in a workshop. With the growth of technical education, a boy who desires to become apprenticed to a trade will be much better served if he delays going into that trade a little and instead spends a year or two at a technical school. Technical and secondary education is to be had nowadays in any of our urban centres. It does not matter whether the boy is going into an industrial occupation or into commerce. Technical and secondary education is to be had in most of our towns and cities at very little expense, so far as fees are concerned, to the parents. There is nothing in the income-tax code confining the benefits of the concession which at present exists to parents who send their children to the universities. It is very difficult to discuss these matters intelligently——

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

—— if the people who are advocating the concessions are themselves not familiar with the existing position. We have heard Deputy Costello, Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Mulcahy. They all argued on the basis that the existing concession is confined to the parent who is able to send his boy or his girl to a university college. That is not a fact.

Comment on this

Nor is it a fact that my argument was based on that.

Comment on this

The fact is that the concession is granted to a parent of a child over the age of 16 years who is receiving full-time instruction. Deputy Costello argued about the part-time or half-time case. There are sound reasons why the concession cannot be given in that case. An essential condition is that the boy or girl should be receiving full-time instruction at a university a college, a school or other educational establishment and that covers vocational educational establishments as well as primary and secondary schools and university colleges. The reason it was given was to induce parents to give their children a better opportunity for education. As I have said, it has been argued here that we ought to extend it, or rather, not that we ought to extend this concession but grant another one on an entirely different basis, that, instead of including parents to see that their boys or their girls are properly educated before they send them for technical or commercial training, we ought to induce them to neglect the long-term advantages which a good education will give to a boy or girl and snatch at the short-term advantage by putting the boy or girl into a job in which that boy or girl will get a few shillings and thus relieve the parents of their ordinary obligations to their children.

The whole basis of the concession, as I have said, is to induce parents better to educate their children. Remove that inducement by widening the limits within which these concessions may be given and you at once adopt an attitude which is not consistent with, and which I think would negative, the general policy which was behind this concession originally. No boy or girl going into any technical occupation loses anything by spending a year or two extra at a vocational school. Any boy who goes to apprenticeship, whether to engineering or otherwise, knowing something of trigonometry and of draughtmanship, and knowing something about physics and mechanics and natural philosophy generally, if properly trained, is going to receive the greatest benefit from the manual training which apprenticeship is intended to give him, and it is only manual training that apprenticeship is likely to give him. He is going to benefit by having this training. The purpose of the inducement at present is to give the boy that training. The amendment now before the House would negative the advantage that the State seeks to secure for those children by granting this concession. Apart from that altogether, there are other reasons why, in principle, this amendment could not be supported.

We all know the difficulties in drafting amendments for the purpose of giving effect to certain proposals. In the wording of this amendment there is nothing defining training or specifying the amount of training that would be required. It is quite possible we might have one boy put into a draper's shop and running messages. If we take the case of two brothers, one might be a draper and an income-tax payer and the other might just as well be an income-tax payer and a grocer too. One of these boys might be in the draper's shop, another in the grocer's shop running errands and the parents of each might claim reduction in income-tax, on the grounds that both were receiving vocational training, as this amendment is drafted. There is nothing in the amendment and I propose to ask the House to reject it.

Comment on this

On each occasion the Minister gets up he demolishes the case he made on his previous incursion into debate. I gathered from his previous statement that the particular objection he had to this amendment was the immense cost it would involve to the State. If there is any validity in portion of the argument to which we listened, surely it was that it would involve the State in very little cost indeed. If the Minister could spare a little of the heat which he brought into this discussion, and turn his attention to his own argument, he would see that he tried to demonstrate to the House how so few people of a certain class are in position to take advantage of this amendment—and he mentions this in the speech which he has just concluded— because they do not pay income-tax. The Minister in his responsible position as Minister for Finance refuses to give the House the necessary information when he speaks of the immense cost this would be to the State.

Comment on this

I did not use the word "immense" in any part of my speech.

Comment on this

I wish the Minister would keep quiet.

Comment on this

I say the Deputy is putting words into the Minister's mouth that he did not use.

Comment on this

We find it hard to put words into the Minister's mouth that he ought to use.

Comment on this

Why not talk about the children of the labouring classes?

Comment on this

May I ask you, A Chinn Comhairle, to try to keep the Minister in order when other Deputies are speaking? We listened to him and did not interrupt him. I must appeal to the Chair, for the sake of the dignity of the House, to keep the Minister in order. How many people are there paying income-tax who are likely to avail of this particular concession? A certain type will—the thrifty type—and it is the thrifty type that is going to be hit by the proposal of the Minister. The Minister gave a long disquisition on certain types of education. It may have been relevant to the amendment, but I doubt if it was. It certainly was not relevant to any part of the case put forward by any of the Opposition. I admit it is most useful that young people should get full primary education and full technical education. Even if they have such education, that may not relieve them of the necessity of entering into apprenticeship and learning a trade and learning something which the Minister so much despises— a kind of hand-work or handicraft, which they would learn in the workshop. I value that very highly, not merely as a necessity for the acquiring of particular trades, but also highly as a method of training.

Again, I protest against the snobbery that would limit education to a particular type. It is because the Minister really refuses to put any value on that particular type of training that I am supporting this amendment. There is no reason why any young man should be an expense to his parents because he remains at a primary school up to the age of 16, if necessary, or takes a post-primary course after 14 years of age in a technical school or a vocational school. There is no reason why, when parents make sacrifices of that kind, and then send the child to be apprenticed, that relief should not be given to them to the extent that the State can afford.

The main argument brought forward by the Minister was the argument that was used by the Chancellor of the Exchequer in England. But there is a tremendous difference between the circumstances in the two countries. Incidentally, the Minister indicated what that difference was, namely, that it is very few people indeed, comparatively speaking, who will be in a position to take advantage of this concession. The better-off class are already provided for, and the Minister is satisfied, apparently, with that. His idea is that a labourer with 18/- a week is already provided for, but there is a class not provided for. Parents may have gone to the expense of educating their children as far as possible in a post-primary or vocational school, and may then send them to a technical school. Why should these people not get the concession which the richer parents get who send their children on for University education? The Minister made no case against the amendment. The case he attempted to make, at the conclusion of his speech, demolished the case he made at the beginning.

Comment on this

The Minister, in introducing his Budget this year, referred to his intention of giving this relief of £60 in respect of children. I had proposed in the amendment, which I was, unfortunately, unable to move, that that allowance should be extended to a certain type of children who, though not technically receiving full-time education, were receiving what was, in fact, full-time education. The Minister made great play in his Budget speech with this relief. He told us that he was going to rake the pockets of the taxpayers, to put his hands deep down into their pockets under an earlier section of the Bill which enables him to go back for arrears of income-tax to the beginnings of the code in respect of people alive and, in respect of people dead, to the year 1922. He was going to collect by that process £50,000, and he proposed to apply that sum to the financing of Section 4 of the present Bill. The Minister did not tell the House at that time that the British Government proposed to insert a precisely similar section in their Bill. There is a precisely similar section in the British Finance Bill of this year, and it occurred to me that perhaps that was not pure coincidence, that there might be a very real reason why the Minister was forced to give this concession in respect of Irish children. I should like if the Minister would give me the real reason why this provision appears in the present Bill.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy be good enough to give us the hypothetical reason?

Comment on this

It is not my business to give hypothetical reasons. I want the real reason from the Minister. I discovered, by a glance at the British Finance Bill, that there is a precisely similar provision there. That struck me as peculiar. I put it no further than that. Will the Minister say if that is due to mere coincidence or, if not, how it comes about? Section 4, as a whole, is almost identical with a section in the British Finance Bill. As a matter of curiosity, I should like to know what is the explanation of that singular phenomenon? It may be that it is pure coincidence. If it is not, I should like to know what is at the back of it. The Minister made a great parade of the fact that he was going to give this relief and endeavoured to justify the quite unwarranted and unjustifiable provisions of Section 1 by alleging that he was going to finance the reliefs under this section by means of them. I should like to know why the Minister did not deal with a specific class of case to which I referred—a case which actually occurred. A person was under what would be popularly called "full-time instruction" at an educational establishment, but because he happened to be technically engaged as an apprentice, his parents were deprived of the allowance under the Act of 1920. Why did the Minister not meet that case which, in justice and decency, was deserving of consideration? Is the Minister not going to reply?

Comment on this

I am waiting to hear if any other points are to be raised, so that I can deal with them in a single reply.

Comment on this

When the Minister cannot give an answer to points raised, he always states that there is nothing in them. I shall put the points again if necessary.

Comment on this

What I said was that I was waiting to see if any other points would be raised by other Deputies on this section.

Comment on this

They are waiting to hear the Minister.

Comment on this

I do not know whether I can become Deputy Costello's mentor in the matter of the Constitution.

Comment on this

I should not be surprised at what you would do with the Constitution.

Comment on this

Without reflecting on the Deputy's eminence at the Irish Bar, which is well deserved——

Comment on this

You had already said that it was disreputable.

Comment on this

If there is one defect in the Deputy's forensic equipment, it appears to me to be want of knowledge of our Constitution, because I have read in the papers that he has put before the Supreme Court most untenable propositions in regard to the Constitution. He wants to know why it is that a section in almost identical terms with a section in the British Finance Bill appears in our Finance Bill. Do I understand that that is one of the points the Deputy is anxious to raise? Deputy O'Sullivan is endeavouring to restrain his colleague.

Comment on this

He thinks it so funny that he does not want me to interrupt you.

Comment on this

I should like the Deputy to interrupt me. We know that Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan has to make three speeches on every section of the Bill, and I should like if he would make one now. Apparently, Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan has become suddenly modest. He is blushing.

Comment on this

He is trying to restrain unseemly laughter.

Comment on this

The Deputy's interruptions are generally unseemly. Deputy Costello asked if it was pure coincidence that the increase in the allowance granted in respect of children in this year's Finance Bill was the same as that granted in the British Bill. The answer is "Yes." It happened that we found ourselves in command of the necessary resources as a result of last year's very satisfactory Exchequer income and the improved position of the country, to increase the allowances granted to income-tax payers in respect of children under 16 years of age and in certain circumstances in respect of children over 16 years of age. It was purely a coincidence that we decided that this should be done. But it is satisfactory to note that what we thought, after careful consideration of all the factors and circumstances, was the best and most equitable way of granting relief to the general body of taxpayers appealed also to the Minister on the other side who had the same responsibility as I had and who also decided that if they had a little money to grant relief to income-tax payers that this was the best and most equitable way of granting it. It is satisfactory to me to find that the investigation which took place on the other side in regard to their problem led to the same conclusion as the similar investigation which took place on this side. That is the first point. The second point is this—that the Deputy has asked if there was some esoteric significance in the fact that the relevant section in our Finance Bill was worded in almost identical terms with the equivalent section in the British Finance Act. The Deputy made a point about that.

Comment on this

No. We did not make a point about it; we drew your attention to it.

Comment on this

I grant the Deputy did not make a point. He drew attention to it, but though he did not make a point, he tried to make a point. I presume what he tried to do was to show that sub-section (1) of Section 21 of the Finance Act of 1920 was to be construed and have effect as if it were part of this Bill.

Comment on this

It is precisely the same wording.

Comment on this

I gather that that is the whole kernel of the Deputy's remarks and quintessence of his speech. Why is it phrased in that way? I said that I might have complained that the Deputy should have been a little better informed as to the contents of our Constitution——

Comment on this

I know it by heart.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will turn to Article 73 he will read this:—

"Subject to this Constitution and to the extent to which they are not inconsistent therewith, the laws in force in the Irish Free State (Saorstát Eireann) at the date of the coming into operation of this Constitution shall continue to be of full force and effect until the same or any of them shall have been repealed or amended by enactment of the Oireachtas."

That is, the Principal Act in regard to this question of children's allowances, the Finance Act of 1920 by Article 73 of the Constitution was made part of the general body of our statute law. If we proposed to amend that Act in 1936 we could only amend it by citing that Act in the section which proposes to make the amendment. That is why this section is identical with the section that appears in the British Finance Act of this year.

Comment on this

That explanation of the Minister drove Deputy O'Sullivan out of the House. I am not surprised. I have never heard a more definite and complete piece of nonsense than I have listened to from the Minister in the last few minutes. I was waiting for a definition of the Constitution and the Minister in a sort of whisper paid some tribute to my knowledge of constitutional law and practice. In a speech which the Minister made some time ago he referred to me as being disreputable in my attitude and variable in my opinions. I am glad he has changed his views on that and on other matters. However, I will pass from that. There was one thing that pleased me in the Minister's slightly hysterical observations. He said the reason why this allowance is given in respect of children this year is because the Government were in a position to do so as a result of last year's satisfactory Exchequer income and the improved position of the country. I was glad to hear the Minister saying that. I expect the Minister will now announce to the House that on the Report Stage he will move to delete Section 1 of this Bill from the Finance Act for this year. Because when justifying Section 1 of the Bill which gave power to the Minister to put his hands down deeply into the taxpayers' pockets and to open up transactions long since closed, he said that he inserted this section in the Bill in order to finance the relief given in respect of children. In his opening Budget statement the Minister said that he wished to remove the absurd power in the hands of the Revenue Commissioners to reopen transactions now closed.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are now dealing with Section 4, not Section 1.

Comment on this

The point, Sir, is this: that the Minister said he proposed to exercise the powers given by Section 1 in order to get £50,000 in the coming year. I am speaking subject to correction, but as far as I remember he said that that £50,000 was to be devoted towards financing the giving of additional relief to children under Section 4 of the Bill. Section 4 is a section which gives relief in income-tax in respect of children. In his speech on the Budget the Minister stated that he proposed to finance this additional relief by the powers which are now contained in Section 1 dealing with income-tax. But we have the fact here to-day that the Minister states that he does not require these powers because of the improved position in the country and the very satisfactory Exchequer income—

Comment on this

I have not said that.

Comment on this

Yes, these are his words and I suggest to the Minister that the only conclusion he should come to now, notwithstanding the fact that Section 1 of this Bill has been passed, is that on the Report Stage he will move to delete Section 1 because the powers sought under that are for the purpose of raising £50,000 for the financing of the allowances in respect of children. Owing to the satisfactory Exchequer income and the improved position in the country of which the Minister tells us he will not want that Section 1 now. That is a very satisfactory statement if he will but follow it to its logical conclusion. We are all for giving relief in income-tax in respect of children. Personally I read that section with delight for it means something to me personally. But I have some regard for my constituents. The vast bulk of the income-tax payers are living in the constituency that the Minister and I represent and these people are entitled to some consideration. It is now no answer to say that it is only people with under £400 a year who are getting relief. I welcome the Minister's statement that the reason why he brought this relief section into the Bill was because of the increase in the Exchequer income and the improved state of the country. I am glad that the Minister has discovered that the statement he made in his Budget speech was wrong and that he does not require, in order to finance this Bill and to rake in this miserable sum of £50,000, to reopen those past transactions in the case of income-tax arrears and go back to 1922 in the case of dead people and to go back years before that in the case of living people. Now we have it that the Minister can under Section 4 of the Bill give this relief. I ask him to draw the logical conclusion from his own statement and to delete Section 1.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:—

Before Section 5 to insert a new section as follows:—

Section 3 of the Finance Act, 1935 (No. 28 of 1935) shall be and is hereby annulled.

This amendment proposes to delete Section 3 of the Finance Act, 1935. That was the section which, I think, would be regarded in any Parliament of the world as a joke from the way it is framed. It has in it the extraordinary fraction used for the first time of something being five-fourths of something else. The general effect of the section is to increase, for income-tax purposes, the valuation of houses and rateable hereditaments by 25 per cent. This amendment was put down 12 months after the Finance Act, 1935, was passed for the purpose, if possible, of putting an end to what we believe is a provision which has caused hardship and injustice to a class of people who deserve consideration at the hands of the Minister, namely, people who are thrifty.

We believe the operation of the section has caused very considerable hardship to classes of the community who would be described in other countries as, perhaps, middle class or, if I might quote the phrase of a well-known man, now dead, the late Mr. Arthur Clery, "the lower rung of the upper middle class." The Minister has no particular interest in those people. They are the class of people whom he referred to a few moments ago as the people with an income of £400 a year and two children. They are the class of people with smallish incomes, around £400 or £500 per year, many of them civil servants, many who, out of their income, or perhaps by effecting a policy of insurance on their lives, have bought their houses in the hope that, by saving out their fairly meagre income of £400 or £500 per year, they would be in a position before they came to the end of their days to pay off the amount of money required to purchase their houses. They bought these houses in recent years, many of them small villa houses in suburbs around Dublin, where building operations have been going on. They bought the houses at a time when they were valued recently under the provisions of the existing Valuation Acts, with the bias in the mind of the Commissioner of Valuation and his staff that, in modern circumstances, the valuation which should be put upon these houses should be fairly high.

It is not the case that the section hits houses valued many years ago, the valuation of which, by reason of changed circumstances and different times, is entirely out of all proportion or relation to what ought to be the modern valuation of property. The vast bulk of the houses which have been hit by this section are newly-erected houses, occupied by people with smallish incomes, more or less struggling people, people who have to keep up a certain appearance, people who have to try to put something by for the rainy day. Having purchased a house on the basis of a certain valuation, and paid a certain purchase price on that basis, they find that suddenly by a section of an Act of Parliament introduced last year, not merely have they to pay income-tax on a valuation increased by 25 per cent., but that, by virtue of that section of the Act itself, the market value of the houses has been depreciated. That was a very considerable hardship. By merely introducing that section thousands of people find that not merely have they to pay an increased income tax, but that the asset which they had put aside in a thrifty way, as a provision for themselves and their families, had been depreciated, by the action of the Minister in his rapacity to get in more taxation, by a very considerable amount in market value. The Minister has had 12 months' experience of the working of this section. We have been informed of the injustice which has been brought about.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy cite one case?

Comment on this

I will not cite any particular private individual's circumstances. The Minister must know them as well as I know them. Complaints have been made to us about the hardship of this section. The section is merely another method of increasing income-tax.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy give me the facts in one case without mentioning names?

Comment on this

I am dealing with the general principle applicable to this section which inevitably causes injustice. First of all, it increases the valuation of houses, which had been recently valued, by 25 per cent. Presumably, when that valuation was made in the last five or six years it was the highest valuation that the Commissioner of Valuation could fix upon it. It was, therefore, a valuation that was determined in accordance with the Valuation Acts in modern circumstances. Artificially, for the purpose of income-tax it is deemed by the section to be increased by 25 per cent. The net result is not merely to put an additional tax on the people who own the houses, but to depreciate the market value of these houses by that further increase in circumstances for which there was no justification.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy give me an instance of hardship?

Comment on this

The Minister knows perfectly well that the general principles to which I am referring have their application in particular instances in connection with thousands of houses in his own constituency. He can get the circumstances from the Revenue Commissioners, if he likes. I am not going to give him any private information conveyed to me or my collagues by constituents. The Minister introduced this section last year on the plea, in my recollection, that it had been thought that legislation would have been introduced into this House to enable the property of the country to be revalued and that it was merely anticipating that for income-tax purposes. The real truth of the matter was that he found himself unable to increase income-tax, not because he did not want to increase it, but because it would not pay the Exchequer to increase income-tax, either last year or this year, by reason of the existence of the double taxation relief agreement between this country and Great Britain; and he had to resort to this method of indirect taxation on small property-owners, on thrifty people, who have bought houses in the last five or six years.

I say this section has worked hardship and injustice. In principle it is entirely unjustifiable. If taxation has to be raised by a tax on income, then do it in a straightforward fashion by increasing the income-tax. Do not let the Minister say that he is not going to increase income-tax because he has such regard for income-tax payers: because he thinks it would not be for the benefit of the trade. Let him give the real reason—that he is afraid of it by reason of the fact that money would be lost to the Exchequer in consequence of the operation of the double taxation agreement that exists between this country and Great Britain. Do not let him resort to this indirect method of effecting an increase in income-tax and, at the same time, trying to cover his tracks from a political point of view.

Comment on this

I desire to support the amendment. Last year, when this proposal was first introduced by the Government, I described it as one calculated to penalise the thrifty. The same can be said of it this year. If its introduction last year caused hardship, it is surely indefensible to continue it this year. I understood last year that it was to be a temporary measure, but that does not seem to be so, seeing that we have it before us again this year. I do not know why the Minister should wish to discourage people from purchasing their own houses. That surely, is a desirable thing to do. House-building not only provides substantial employment, but it helps to make available more houses for those badly in need of them. This proposal also alters the basis on which people who are now buying their houses have to make their calculations. There is no doubt whatever but that this proposal will discourage people from entering into agreements to purchase their own houses, while it will also operate as a hardship on those who have already entered into purchase agreements. I do not think that a tax such as this should be inflicted on the section of the community that it affects.

The Minister has asked for examples of cases where this tax has caused hardship. While people have expressed their individual objection to the tax, it would be hard, I think, to bring them to the point in which they would be prepared to say and hold themselves out before their neighbours as suffering from a hardship that they could not bear. In my opinion this is a tax that should not be continued. I rather thought from the Minister's remarks last year that it was to be only a temporary measure, but, apparently, like a good many other things that were said to be temporary, it has now come to stay.

Comment on this

I cannot accept this amendment. The purpose of this provision was to ensure that property-owners would pay their due and equitable tax upon the incomes derived by them, or on the annual value enjoyed by them in respect of property which they own. Play has been made in the House that this proposal has occasioned hardship. I have asked Deputy Costello, and I presume Deputy Dockrell took the request as being addressed to him also, since he referred to the matter in his speech, to cite to me one single instance in which this provision had worked inequitably or had inflicted hardship. It is not necessary to mention names. Deputy Costello seemed to think that he must cite the names of the individuals concerned. That is not necessary at all. Let him give me the facts, let him show me any single instance in which hardship has been inflicted or any injustice done. I am advised by the Revenue Commissioners that in no single case which has come under their notice has any person been asked to do more than pay tax upon the actual income which was enjoyed by him, taking one year with another, from the letting of property, or the annual value which was enjoyed by him because of the possession of such property, and if any single instance of hardship has not come under the notice of the Revenue Commissioners or if it has not been brought to their attention. I have asked Deputies to bring it to my notice, and I repeat again that it is not necessary to mention names. I can say this, that if there was such a case of actual hardship it is fully covered by the provisions of the section which would prevent any inequity or any injustice being done.

The real fact is that property in the State, whether it was built prior to the war or subsequent to the war, is considerably under-valued. We hope to bring in a measure which will redress this anomaly : to put those who own hereditaments in this country, particularly in urban areas, upon a more equitable basis as compared with their fellow citizens who have to pay tax upon the full amount of the income derived by them, whether from the exercise of a profession or as a result of gainful employment, or in any of the other ways in which income may be derived, except the ownership of property. We are not doing any person any injustice in placing property owners on the same basis as the general body of taxpayers in the country, and the existing provision in the statute does no more than try to do that, leaving an ample margin in favour of the taxpayer to cover any contingencies or any inequities that there may be in individual cases.

Comment on this

I understood when this tax was originally introduced—this strange vulgar fraction of ours—that there were principally two arguments put forward in support of it, one of which has just been referred to incidentally by the Minister, namely, the desirability of a revaluation of the country as a whole. The two reasons were: first, the inequalities of the present valuations owing to the developments that have taken place since the original valuations were fixed, and, secondly, the increase in the general value of property. I gather that the Minister relies on the advice that he has received from the Revenue Commissioners so far as reason No. 2 is concerned, that the value of property in the Saorstát has gone up over a number of years since the present valuations were fixed. Personally, I do not think that the procedure adopted here by the Minister is calculated favourably to affect the value of house property. Men who yesterday were induced to buy houses, every inducement held out to them, urged to do so, people pointing out what an excellent thing it was to be the owner of a house, suddenly find that they are singled out, though the Minister attempts to deny this, for special treatment, not favourable treatment, but the contrary type of treatment, by the Minister. I think in itself that is against what I might call general policy. No matter what the revenue may get out of it—I think, if my memory serves me right, £60,000 was mentioned by the Minister last year—I find there is never any consideration of the effect of general policy, whether or not it is good policy to do these things.

Turning to the other argument that I have heard frequently put forward, namely, the inequality between the valuations of different houses, certain important aspects arise. Houses that at one time were valued at the same figure, as the result of recent developments no longer have an equal value. It may be that one is half the value or, if you like, twice the value of the other. It seems to me that this arbitrary fixing all round of an additional 25 per cent. to the valuation already fixed increases the injustice that is done to one type of taxpayer. There are many cases where houses are not relatively so valuable now as they were at the time that the valuation was originally fixed, and yet this additional imposition is introduced. Let me emphasise once more that there is definite injustice done to different types of householders. This whole procedure is bad in itself, and to the ordinary taxpayer it must look nothing else except an expedient to raise money.

Comment on this

Precisely, that is what all taxes are for.

Comment on this

Quite, but at least you might endeavour to justify it by trying to do justice between the different types of taxpayers. To me this is purely a dodge to raise extra money which it is inadvisable to raise in other ways for the reasons mentioned by Deputy Costello. As the Minister for Finance and the President expressed it on more than one occasion here in reference to the ordinary raising of taxation, if a certain tax had gone to the limit, the further raising of that particular tax would not be reproductive so far as the Revenue is concerned. On these grounds, therefore, I think there is no case made why this absurd provision should remain any longer on our statutes. As usual, the Minister has confined himself to vague general statements. He never deigns to give the House any solid reasons for the proposals he puts before it, nor did he give any solid reason for the step he induced the House to take last year. He did not give any justification last year, and he is not giving any this year. I suppose it would be useless to expect the Minister to do anything in the present case.

Comment on this

The Minister accused me of not giving him any specific instance of hardship and injustice, and he proceeded to say that the Revenue Commissioners had assured him that in their administration of this section in the 1935 Act they had come across no case of injustice, and they had extracted from the taxpayers under Section 3 of that Act nothing other than a tax which would be produced by a letting from year to year or on the annual valuation. That statement from the Minister meant precisely and absolutely nothing. The Revenue Commissioners merely administered the Act. They are directed under Section 3 of the 1935 Act to collect the tax as if the valuation of the house was increased by 25 per cent. They look through the lists of valuations, increase them by 25 per cent. and make the necessary assessments and adjustments. They have nothing to do with whether there is hardship or injustice. I have never suggested that the Revenue Commissioners were not administering the law in accordance with the provisions of the Act.

I contend that this particular section in its inception, its conception and its working is an unjust section. The Minister asked me to give a specific instance. Take the case of any person who purchased a house before the Minister introduced his 1935 Budget. I submit that that section has done that man, whoever he is or whatever his station in life, an injustice. If he is paying income-tax he has to pay an increased tax on a purely fictitious and artificial valuation of his premises. The Minister suggested that this was done to remedy an inequity between various classes of the community. I drew the Minister's attention to the person who purchased a house and paid a certain figure on the basis that the valuation was a certain amount. The Minister ought to know, in connection with the ordinary business affairs of life, that when you are purchasing a house one of the relevant considerations is the valuation. I will give the Minister a present of a little legal information. If on the face of the particulars of sale of premises sold by public auction there is a mistake in the valuation of the house, that sale could be set aside. So essential in connection with the purchase price, the fixing of a purchase price of a house, is the element of the valuation, that if it is wrongly stated in the particulars of sale by the vendor, that sale can be set aside.

If the Minister wants any specific instance, he can get it from the Registry of Deeds; he can get that information on the telephone; he can ask the Registry of Deeds what transactions by way of purchases of houses were registered prior to the introduction of the Budget in 1935. In every instance the purchaser is suffering an injustice. In the case of every house that was let in this country prior to the introduction of the 1935 Budget, the owner is suffering an injustice. He let it on the basis that he had to pay a certain amount of rates and taxes, and he suddenly finds, when the Minister introduces his Bill, that his rent is decreased. If the arrangement is, as sometimes happens, that the rent is to be inclusive of rates and taxes, then he loses in that connection. If the rent is over and above taxes, that means over and above all taxes except income-tax, the owner is still hit. The Minister may go to the Registry of Deeds, or to any house agent, and ask how many houses were let before the introduction of the Budget last year and in respect of every one of these persons a grave injustice has been done. We ask, not that that injustice be remedied, but that further injustice should cease by the deletion of the section from the Act of 1935.

Comment on this

The Minister has made great play that there has been no injustice done to any person who has purchased a house. I should like to compare the case of two people, A and B. A has, let us say, £700 to invest, and he purchases a house. He entered into that transaction after making careful calculations as to the yield he would get from purchasing that house. On the other hand, B decided that he would not buy a house, and invested the money in some security which gave him a certain yield of interest. Does the Minister deny that as between those two people, A and B, the action of the Government has worsened the yield from one class of security as against another. What we complain of on this side of the House is that there is a discrimination as between one type of investor and another. I do not suggest that there is any personal bias or anything like that on the part of the Minister, but it is most undesirable to single out one section of the community for a tax that does not fall on the rest of the community. I think if the Minister wants to look for injustice he need not go past that aspect of the matter.

Comment on this

On Section 5, this is an extension of the allowance for wear and tear of machinery as applied to professions. I understand that the Minister, when he was introducing his Budget, made great play of this section as one of those under which he was giving substantial relief to the community. I want to be quite sure that he is not taking back with one hand what he has given with the other. In the case of professional people who would come under this section it has been the practice to allow replacements of their machinery. I should like to ask the Minister whether it is now intended to continue to allow replacements of machinery and also to allow wear and tear of existing machinery? If it is not, I am afraid he has left people very much as they were. However, I hope he will answer quite clearly as to whether the existing practice of allowing renewals is to be discontinued, or whether it will be continued along with this new allowance for wear and tear of machinery.

Comment on this

I do not know what Deputy Dockrell means by giving away with one hand and taking it back with the other. This particular concession extends the same allowance in the case of plant and machinery used for the purposes of a profession as is at present given for wear and tear and obsolescence of plant and machinery used for the purposes of trade. That is the purpose of the section. It will cost us this year about £3,000 and, possibly, next year it will cost us £6,000. But there is only one concession given. People can either have it in this form—and I have told the Deputy what it is going to cost—or they can have it on the present basis of replacement, but they cannot have it both ways. Deputy Dockrell or any other trader has not got it both ways, and there is no reason why professional people should have it both ways either. They can elect to have it one way or the other, but they cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this

Well, then, is it not like Pat's blanket—as broad as it is long? A person is now going to lose the replacement allowance and he is going to get wear and tear. I described it as taking away with one hand what he had given with the other, and the Minister found fault with that description. Perhaps I would not have described it in that way if he had not so enthusiastically heralded the allowance that he was making to professional people and the amount it was going to cost the Exchequer. My recollection is that the figure was £5,000——

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

——but I will not quarrel with the Minister when he says it will cost £3,000 this year and £6,000 next year. In any case, I am afraid the professions are not going to get anything over and above what they have been getting for a series of years.

Comment on this

Of course I do not know whether it is a case of Pat's blanket; I never wrapped myself in that symbolical garment. I certainly never mentioned the figure of £5,000 in my Budget statement, and I did not make any great ado about this. I merely mentioned that it was going to cost the Exchequer £3,000 this year and £6,000 next year. As to the advantages or otherwise of the concession to the people concerned, I never put myself in the position of judge. All I know is that the demand for this concession came from them, and I suppose they know what suits them best and whether or not they are going to get anything out of it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

Before Section 6, but in Part I, to insert a new section as follows:—

Section 4 (which relates to relief from double income tax on profits from the business of shipping) of the Finance Act, 1927 (No. 18 of No. 27), shall apply in relation to profits or gains arising from the business of air transport in like manner in all respects as it applies in relation to profits or gains arising from the business of shipping, and, in order to give effect to such application, the said Section 4 is hereby amended as follows, that is to say:—

(a) by the insertion in sub-section (1) of the words "or the business of air transport" after the words "business of shipping," and

(b) by the insertion in sub-section (6) of the words "the expression ‘business of air transport' means the business carried on by an owner of aircraft" after the words "owner of ships", and

(c) by the deletion of the word "definition" where it occurs in the said sub-section (6) and the insertion in that sub-section of the word "sub-section" in lieu of the word so deleted.

This amendment is to enable the Government to enter into arrangements with other States for the granting of relief from double income-tax on profits from the business of air transport. It applies to the business of air transport the power which already exists in regard to shipping.

Comment on this

When the Minister refers to enabling the Government to enter into arrangements with other States, does he really mean with Great Britain, and, if so, why not say so?

Comment on this

Because there are other States concerned.

Comment on this

What other States, for instance?

Comment on this

I am not in a position to say at the moment, but the Deputy will understand that there are many other States—the United States of America for instance.

Comment on this

Have you got a double income-tax arrangement with America, or is there the slightest likelihood of it? Was I not absolutely right when I said that this section is brought in only with reference to Great Britain, and had not the Minister better say so?

Comment on this

The Deputy is very ingenious, but I wish he would not talk about double income-tax agreements. On the last section, he was in error in regard to a remark be made in that connection.

Comment on this

It is surprising that the Minister did not point it out.

Comment on this

Oh, well now, after all, I allowed——

Comment on this

The Minister ought to speak up; we cannot hear him.

Comment on this

The Deputy can come down, and perhaps he will hear better. He generally sits beside Deputy Belton.

Comment on this

Let us all hear what the Minister has to say. This is not a conversation between two members of the House.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy come down where he can hear.

Comment on this

I cannot hear what the Minister is saying. Perhaps other Deputies can hear.

Comment on this

Their hearing may be better than the Deputy's. However, I was merely saying that this relates to double income-tax on profits on the business of air-transport. It is a provision that has been introduced into our statutes in compliance with an international convention. It has nothing to do with the double income-tax agreement with Great Britain except in so far as it applies to Great Britain as well as to other States. As a matter of fact, I think we have the same thing in regard to the United States and, possibly, Denmark. Deputy Costello is mixing this up ——

Comment on this

I am mixing up nothing.

Comment on this

Again, I would like to emphasise that Deputy Costello is mixing up the 1926 double income-tax agreement with Great Britain with something else.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:—

Before Section 6 in Part 1 to insert a new section as follows:—

Any provision of any Act or rule which authorises a claim for repayment of income-tax to be made within a specified period shall be and is hereby amended so as to authorise the making of the claim within a period of 15 years after the end of the year of assessment.

This amendment is so eminently just, so entirely reasonable in its scope and in its intendment that I have not got the slightest hope that the Minister will accept it. The Minister has taken power under the first section of the Bill to reopen all arrangements and agreements with income-tax payers—to reopen all past transactions and all previous assessments. No arrangement or agreement is binding upon the Minister. No burden of proof is imposed on the Minister before he can reopen these transactions. No burden of proof is imposed on him before he can exercise the very drastic powers he has taken under Section 1 of the Bill. The Minister can go back, in reference to any transaction dealing with income-tax with a person who is alive, from the time when that person purports or is supposed to have earned a single penny of income up to the present moment, notwithstanding the fact that the court may have made previous assessments and notwithstanding the fact that agreements may have been made and honoured for many years and that all the references and records of transactions in connection with the case have been entirely lost and destroyed. That is the power the Minister takes.

The power asked for in this amendment merely seeks that the unfortunate income-tax payer, if an error is discovered over a period more than that allowed at the present time, which, I think, is six years, should have authority and right to go back and should have the right to get that error remedied and his over-payment to the Exchequer repaid to him. The period of 15 years is put in merely to draw the attention of the House and of the public outside to the extraordinary contrast that exists at the present moment between the rights of the taxpayer and the rights of the Revenue. It might appear that 15 years is a long time to go back on a past and closed transaction. In normal circumstances, I would not have asked the House to authorise any such reopening of transactions after such a length of time. I think that, in normal circumstances, six years, probably, would be sufficient, but I think that in matters of this kind there should be some reciprocity and that the injustice is so compelling and calls out so compellingly for remedy that some effort, on the part of the Minister, should be made to remedy that injustice.

Now, there have been actual cases where errors have taken place in assessments, and admittedly so, and because six years was the period existing—although it was admitted even in law, and in justice certainly, that repayment ought to be made and reconsideration ought to be given on behalf of the taxpayer—the Revenue Commissioners took refuge in the law and stated: "We cannot do anything because of the law and because of the control of the Comptroller and Auditor-General." If the Revenue Commissioners have power, as they have been given power under Section 1 of the Act, to reopen transactions long since closed—not merely so far back as 1922, but so far back as 1913 and 1912 and subsequent to the War; any period, in fact, that the Revenue Commissioners think right in reference to a living man —I think it is a small thing to ask that a taxpayer should be entitled to reopen cases that have been closed since the establishment of this State. That is what this amendment proposes. As I have already said, I put it down without the slightest hope that it will be accepted. I have no doubt that it will not be accepted, because, as I have said, it is so fair, just and reasonable, and we are coming to the stage now, in connection with income-tax and taxation generally, in this country— and I speak here now with all the gravity I can command—that injustice in connection with income-tax is at such a point that it has become almost morally open to taxpayers to take steps to evade their liabilities. I make that statement with the full knowledge of the responsibility I have in making it— with the full knowledge that I have of the methods that are being employed to extract taxes from the people at the present moment.

The Minister ought to know, because I have made my position clear in this House again and again in connection with Budget proposals and discussions of Finance Bills, that I do not stand, and that nobody on this side of the House stands, for anything in connection with evasions of tax by methods of fraud. Of course, the amendment I wrote down on the paper to-day made that clear again. I have never stood, in this House or anywhere else, for fraud or the condonation of fraud, but the person who is best able to evade the taxes that are being imposed by the Minister and his Government; the person who is best able to evade the exactions of the Minister's officials; the person who is best able to meet the methods of those officials, is the gentleman who does not stop at fraud. The people in whom I am interested are people who, years ago, made what they conceived to be, on proper evidence, a fair return of their income-tax in the circumstances then existing, and I am advocating in this amendment that, if a mistake arose, or if a mistake is discovered subsequently—a mistake, perhaps, due to the depredations of the Minister and his officials in the exercise of the powers conferred on them by Section 1, if it becomes law—if, as I say, a mistake is made and discovered as having taken place more than six years ago, all that this amendment asks is that that mistake should be remedied and that payments made by a taxpayer, which he was not bound to make, and which he made in circumstances under which he was not liable to make them, ought to be refunded to him and that he ought to get back from the Revenue that amount.

The amount of money that will be involved as a result of the inclusion of this amendment is infinitesimal. I will say now that I am not interested in the amount of money that is going to be got back, nor am I interested in the particular people who may be affected by this amendment. I think that the number of people that will be affected by it will be so small as to be negligible. I am interested, however, again, in directing public attention to this unjustifiable exercise of governmental powers, in favour of the Government, to enable them to rake money from taxpayers who will not be able to produce the necessary evidence to rebut claims made upon them, by reason of the stale demands that will be made, and to leave, as the Government intends, such a state of affairs that on one side there is the Minister and his officials with that power, and, on the other side, the taxpayers who have not the power to reopen any transactions over a limited period of six years. That is so unjust as to require no further comment. I have no hope that the Minister will accede to this. What I have hope of doing is of so harnessing public opinion outside against this Government, or any future Government that stands over proposals of the kind embodied in Section 1, that neither will be able to stay in power one day to cause hardship, injustice, torture of mind or uneasiness amongst honest taxpayers.

Comment on this

Any indication from the Minister?

Comment on this

I think Deputy O'Sullivan was not listening to Deputy Costello's speech, because the Deputy virtually admitted that the proposal did not require an answer. He said he had no hope that this or any future Government would adopt such a proposal.

Comment on this

I said nothing of the sort. I said I had no hope that this Government would adopt it, but I further implied in my concluding observations, that any Government which would sponsor any such proposal should not be allowed to stay in power.

Comment on this

I merely read into that remark that the Deputy has resigned himself to the prospect of not having any other Government than this in office.

Comment on this

That would be a shocking contemplation.

Comment on this

I am afraid that is the position.

Comment on this

I am resigned to stay where I am.

Comment on this

Admittedly the Deputy has no hope that the amendment will be accepted. The amendment does not deserve to be accepted. After all, what is the real position? The only person who knows all the facts about his income is the income-tax payer. On the part of the Revenue Commissioners they have generally to make some sort of investigation, the results of which depend on the honesty of the taxpayer in the first place. If he is not as honest as he might be, or if he is more ingenious or more intelligent than the Revenue Commissioners, they may have difficulty in ascertaining what his true income is. Again, it is the taxpayer who has all the facts, and if he, with all the facts in his knowledge, fails to make a claim within such a time as will enable the real facts to be ascertained, then it is he should suffer the penalty, and not the Revenue —not the general body of taxpayers.

Comment on this

Is the Minister suggesting that the Revenue Commissioners are entitled to retain taxpayers' money to which admittedly they are not entitled? That is the point of my amendment.

Comment on this

I say that any claim not made within the proper period is going to be a very difficult claim to investigate. If it is not made within a reasonable time, the delay has probably arisen, by reason of the desire of the taxpayer who makes it to allow such a period to elapse that it will be difficult to discover the real facts. Apart altogether from that, again I come back to this: that it is the taxpayer who knows the facts, and if he fails to make a claim within the proper time he ought to suffer the disabilities that his negligence imposed upon him. On the other hand, if the Revenue Commissioners are not able to make a correct assessment within a limited period it is almost inevitable due to the fact that the true amount of the taxpayer's income has not been disclosed to them. Therefore, they should not suffer the loss, because it is not their fault that they have not been able to ascertain it. It is the fault of the taxpayer who did not make the real disclosure. There is no parallel between the case of the taxpayer and the Revenue Commissioners. The taxpayer has it within his power to make a claim on the true facts of his income. He knows them, and can disclose them; and if he fails to do so within a proper and reasonable time the fault is his, and the disability and the penalty should be his. That is the position and the Deputy knows that.

Comment on this

We have had the usual flippancy, but no attempt to deal with the situation. There was a time when the Minister was arguing against Section 1. Certainly his argument was much more against Section 1 than against the amendment. The Revenue Commissioners and the tax-collecting body in this State are very efficient, and act as a machine. It is quite possible that in his capacity as Minister he does not realise that. But is any other Deputy unaware of it? The Revenue Commissioners seem to ignore very often the ordinary conditions of life in this country, especially the conditions under which business is being carried on. The Minister said that the only person who knows exactly what his income is is the taxpayer. That is all right so far as a person whose income is made up of salary is concerned. He knows his income, but I doubt very much whether the majority of persons, prior to recent activities on the part of the Revenue Commissioners, had any idea of their actual income. Many of them did not keep books or accounts in the way in which the Revenue Commissioners apparently believe that they are kept. Every Deputy knows that men have been compelled by the Revenue Commissioners to get in auditors, not for this year or for last year, but for the last 15 years, as a result of threats of various kinds by the Revenue Commissioners. I have been told, as other Deputies have been told, by men that they had no idea up to this how they stood, or what their actual profits and losses were. That is the way in which men conducted their business, and it is completely ignoring the actual situation as it prevails in this State, for the Minister or the Revenue Commissioners to pretend that up to ten or 15 years ago the ordinary business man knew what his income was. He had no idea what it was and could not form an approximate idea, because he did not keep accurate accounts. Now, as a result of the activities of the Revenue Commissioners, and of the new powers given them by this Bill, investigation has revealed to taxpayers that they were entitled to certain reliefs that they were unconscious of and that they had a right to claim. The injustice came out after examination by the Revenue Commissioners. The Minister was quite right when he said that there was no parallel between the position of the Revenue Commissioners and the taxpayer. There is not. The balance is altogether on the side of the Revenue Commissioners, and against the unfortunate business man, who is constantly asked to keep accounts stretching over ten, 15 or 20 years concerning every item of his business. That is supposed to be fair and just because the State makes the demand, and because the State is all powerful.

Comment on this