Public Business. - Finance Bill, 1936—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 1–199 of 408. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 20 of 1936 ›
I rise to support the amendment which has been proposed by Deputies Davin and Keyes. I think that it is one which ought to commend itself to the majority of this House and one that will be endorsed by the whole electorate. Let me say a few words on behalf of the pint of porter, which is the poor man's beverage. It is indeed, much more than a beverage or stimulant; it is, in fact, a food. As they say in my backward part of the country, there is "atin' and drinkin' in it." I heard a very distinguished physician say that porter was a real Godsend to the farmers and workers and that it saved many of them from an early grave because, even if they over-indulged in it occasionally, it made no great difference because they get a remedy in the morning air and they worked off not only the alcohol but a lot of other waste products which, otherwise, they would not have got rid of.
In support of the amendment, I shall, with your permission, A Chinn Comhairle, appeal not only to Irish history but to the Irish song-writers. I shall appeal also to several modern authorities on literature. It is a well-known fact, which cannot be controverted, that the ancient Celts and Gaels were the real discoverers of brewing. As you know, in ancient Ireland the cuirm-thigh or ale-house, was a most important institution in the country and I need not say that the bean na leanna has become proverbial. As a matter of fact, in ancient Ireland the only people who were entitled to brew beer were the flaitha. The flaith was, more or less, a prince or peer and a good prince or a good peer, as he may be called, if a decent sort of fellow, always distributed his brew on Sundavs and festivals to his friends or followers. Hence, as the Ceann Comhairle knows very well, the word "flaitheamhail" has come to mean "generous." In connection with that, I recall an epigram uttered here in Dublin many years ago by a very clever man. He said, "In ancient Ireland only peers were brewers and, in modern Ireland, only brewers are peers." I do not wish to detain the House very long, but I want to appeal to some of our song-writers in support of the amendment. One song-writer says:
"It is little for glory I care;
Ambition is only a fable.
I'd as soon be meself as Lord May'r
While there are lashings of stout on the table."
Another writer sings in this fashion:
"Irish stout I have no doubt
In either wood or bottle,
And well brewed ale will never fail
To cool a thirsty throttle."
I hope these words will appeal to the Minister for Finance. I know he is a very temperate man, but he realises, I am sure, that the moderate use of alcohol is quite legitimate. If necessary, I can quote authority from the Bible on that point. I can also appeal to modern writers. A famous English poet has said that "Nothing can equal the welcome of an inn." Dr. Johnson says that "a tavern chair is the throne of human felicity." The late Gilbert Chesterton, who was such a great ornament to literature and whose death we all regret, says truly that "the most democratic institution in the world is the common public house." He goes on to say that every man who conducts himself there and can pay for his drink is as good as another. It would be a very good thing, he says, if statesmen would occasionally drop in there and hear the comments of the man-in-the-street on their policy, their politics and their tricks.
In view of these circumstances, I do hope that this amendment will be accepted by the Minister and the House. The Minister knows, as we all know, that the price of stout or porter — call it what you will — is oppressive. A large number of people have to consume it. I appeal in this regard to the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, Deputy Hugo Flinn, who cannot deny that some of the hardest worked men in Cork — the coal heavers, who are engaged in a gruelling type of work —have to depend for maintenance of their vigour and health during the day on bread and porter. That is well known to the Parliamentary Secretary, and I am sure he will endorse what I have said, at least, on that point. I reiterate that I hope this amendment will be accepted by the Minister and embodied in the Finance Bill before the House.
Comment on this
I think it would be important in a discussion on this amendment that the House would hear from the Minister something of the policy of milk and light beer about which the President made an important pronouncement in 1932. At that time he emphasised how valuable it would be for the general well-being and health of the people of the country if light beer and milk could be substituted for tea as the more or less standard beverage of the people. The Minister for Finance must be aware that since 1932 the average price for the cheapest tea has gone up by 10¼d per lb. The Department of Industry and Commerce published the figures for three months and these figures show that between mid-February, 1932 and mid-February, 1936, the average price per lb. of the cheapest tea has gone up by 10¼d. That is important from the point of view of the ordinary economy. I would like to ask the Minister if in the Army or in any section of the Gárda an attempt has been made by the Government to carry out in any sort of a planned way the substitution of light beer or milk for tea and whether they have any particulars to put before the House as to whether the substitution of milk is more costly the substitution of beer, and what results if any, or what enquiries if any have been made by the Government with a view to developing and promoting the policy announced by the President of substituting tea by light beer and milk. The Minister, I am sure, will appreciate that at the present time there is hardly any prospect of any great development of that substitution although tea has increased by what must be an enormous figure in the eyes of the ordinary housekeeper who has to run a house for the average family. Therefore I think it would be well while on this question that we would hear from the Minister for Finance what he has to say of the policy of substituting light beer for tea as a beverage in the homes.
Comment on this
I wish to support this amendment. Since 1932 this amendment or a similar amendment has been before the House in some form on the Finance Bill every year. The amendment has always been met with the excuse that the exigencies of the Exchequer could not bear the cost involved. I do not think that is a good defence in itself. It is only at the best a justification for the maintenance of that tax and that tax is too high. I think that in the debate last week the Minister told us that the cost-of-living figure, taking 1914 at 100, was now about 150 and that it had fallen from a higher level to that figure. Let us take 1914 as related to this amendment. I am sure the House would be interested in learning that the cost of porter to-day as compared with 1914 has gone up by 1,190 per cent., at least the duty has gone up by 1,190 per cent. Assume that beer was essential for various classes of the community, particularly people working in the docks, people working in factories or people working in steel works and other such employment where the labour is very heavy and arduous and such as to demand that the people working would require some liquid refreshment during the day. Very often these men take with them to their work in the morning a piece of sandwich or a piece of bread, butter and jam. With this they get one pint of porter for their lunch. Is it fair that men in such circumstances are to be taxed at this high rate simply because of the exigencies of the Exchequer?
I know of no other tax that was imposed during the Great War except this and the corporations profit tax that is in existence to-day. We should be told why, under these circumstances, this tax is being maintained. I know, of course, that when I say something in favour of the remission of this tax, a lot of pious resolutions will be passed and my name will be involved in them. But these resolutions have no terror for me. I am just as big a teetotaler as the ladies and gentlemen who pass these resolutions. The acceptance of this amendment would be an act of justice, first, to the licensing trade and, secondly, to the people in the main who consume the least in the matter of food. These people are crying out against this very high tax. Surely an increase of 1,190 per cent. over 1914 is a heavy burden to bear. I wonder if anybody in this House or outside this House will defend the justice of that tax with this increase of 1,190 per cent. I would like to know how the increase in the wages of these working people compares with this increase of 1,190 per cent. in an important article of their food? Not only is there this enormous increase here but there is an increase in all other items above the 1914 figure. Is it because we have an extreme right wing in this matter and an extreme left wing that we are to have this high increase in the price of the working man's drink? I know of no greater curse than these two extremes, the left wing and the right wing, in the matter of teetotalism. Both are so blind that they are unable to see that the happy medium lies between. On the one side you have got the rabid teetotalers, who are all fanatics. They do not themselves drink. If you sat at dinner with them you would find that their liquid refreshment would be either water or buttermilk. They are so fanatical in their teetotalism that they forget that the happy medium lies between. The main mass of the people do not belong to one wing or the other.
Whether we like it or not, people will drink. The only thing to do is to endeavour to see that they will not drink too much, and it is for this House to see that the drink is sold at a price which will prevent them from drinking too much, while at the same time ensuring that those who need it will still be able to get it. In other years in this debate I quoted examples from America. I am not going to go over these now because the example of America on the question of drink is sticking out as a sign to anybody who wishes to read it.
In this connection I want to say that I read in the paper on Tuesday night the report of a case in the Dublin Police Court. I would like to direct the attention of the Minister for Finance to that case. A woman who attended a meeting down the country on Sunday week last was given, on her way home or before she arrived at her home, "Biddy" or red wine. Having drank it she proceeded home and kicked up a row with her husband. In the morning following she left her husband and children; it appears some other woman was alleged to have got their meals for them during the day. When the wife came back in the evening, having partaken of this bottle of "Red Biddy" or a portion of it she kicked up a row. The affair finished in the police court on Tuesday. At all events this bottle of "Red Biddy" started this case. What was behind that? This is some sort of red wine. It appears that it is stuff manufactured from some ingredients and then highly fortified. What the ingredients are I do not know, but it appears that it can be sold at a cheap price. It is fortified by something that is highly injurious to the people who drink any considerable quantity of it. I would like to know if any attention has been paid by the Government to that side of the drink problem? Has there been an increase of 1,190 per cent. tax on these ingredients? I would support the Minister in increasing the tax on that stuff to 1,190 per cent. Recently I have been making inquiries here in the city about this "Red Biddy," and I am not quite sure that I have got any definite data as to the volume of business done in it. I made some inquiries in Belfast. The thing is so glaring in Belfast that the facts are well known. I understand that in parts of Belfast this stuff is consumed by the poorer classes, especially the women folk among the poorer classes, and the results there are dreadful——
Comment on this
Would the Deputy relate that to the amendment which purports to reduce the duty on beer?
Comment on this
I am trying to relate it. The Minister should increase the tax on this material and reduce the tax on legitimate and sound material that would do the people no harm. That is the case and it is quite simple. The result of this taxation is that it is driving the people to take this other stuff. What the constituents of this stuff are I do not know, but it is being permitted to be made and sold and drunk with great injury to our people. I am not prepared to say what is the extent of the evil that it is doing in this city, but I am informed that in Belfast the results are very degrading. The only case of it I have seen in the courts here is the case I referred to which was in the courts on Tuesday.
Apparently, somewhere between where the procession took place and this woman's house, when she was going home in the evening some person handed her a bottle of this stuff. I take it it was somebody who took advantage of this occasion, when a large crowd of people had assembled on a Sunday, to distribute it, at what price I do not know. I take it the price was not exorbitant and, apparently, a ready-made market was got for this cheap article. I repeat that, while I do not in any way favour indulgence in strong drink, the people have a right to it and that they will get it in some form or another. I want to see them getting it in a form which the State can control and under which the State can guarantee that the people who consume it are getting a sound article which will not be injurious, if taken in moderation. For that reason I support the amendment.
Comment on this
I am aware, of course, that the proposed amendments —I presume that both amendments are being discussed together—would have considerable sympathy not merely from those quarters of the House from which they have been urged, but possibly from every quarter and every Party. Indeed, if it were merely a question of sympathy, the amendments would have a much better chance than they have to-day. But these amendments do two things: they not merely, in effect, propose that the duty on a certain commodity should be reduced, but they would also, if carried, impose upon me the heavy obligation of increasing the tax upon some other commodity in order to make good the deficiency which would be inevitably created in the Exchequer revenues.
Though we have heard a great deal here about the beneficial effects of the beverages referred to, we have not been told about any of the detrimental effects which might follow if ordinary articles of food, like tea and sugar, were made dearer for the general mass of the people. Of course, there have been pathetic stories told about the hefty dock labourer who must have his pint or two. I am not without sympathy with the amendment, I am not a dyed-in-the-wool teetotaler by any means; but I have to consider as to whether, in fact, even if the Exchequer position permitted it and we were to accept these amendments, there would be anything like the general increase in consumption of beer, stout, and porter which those who have advocated these proposals tell us would more than make up for any loss of revenue that might otherwise be expected to ensue. If you reduce the price of the pint by 1d., and the ordinary workers' wages were to remain at their present standard, I question whether he would be able to buy at the very most more than one or two pints extra per week.
We have been told here that, if we granted a remission, there is no fear that there would be any increase in drunkenness; that the tastes of the people have changed. I listened last night to a speech by Deputy Morrissey in support of this proposal. It seems to me that it is more calculated to secure its defeat than anything else, because he told us that at a time when we might have expected people to increase greatly their consumption of beer and stout, if it were cheaper, the workingman had no place to spend his leisure hours except in a publichouse; that he had not a decent home. I am not going to say that every working-class family in this State is housed as we should like it to be housed, but at any rate the housing conditions have been very considerably improved. The Deputy went on to say that at that time there were no cinemas and no cheap transport and nothing like the same provision for the entertainment and amusement of the people that exist to-day.
Comment on this
I was saying that at that time there were not all the other inducements for the worker or for any other person, because I do not want to be taken as implying for a moment that the change for the better in the habits of the community that has taken place applies to any one class of society. What I have said in regard to the worker applies also in regard to those who might be much better circumstanced. There are many other ways of spending spare money now, if one is not inclined to save it, than there were in the days when the consumption of beer and stout was much higher than it is to-day. These other ways all make a demand upon the spare cash of the worker.
I am not going to believe for a moment that if we were to grant the reduction which is asked for here that there would be anything like a commensurate increase in the consumption of beer and spirits. I have examined this problem very carefully and I am satisfied that if we were to accept the first amendment it would cost the State at least £250,000 this year, and £500,000 in the following year. The problem that the House has to address itself to is this: whether is it better to find that £500,000 as we are finding it to-day out of the beer and spirits duty or that we should go and put another ½d. or ¾d. per lb. on sugar. It is all very well to talk, as I have said, about the poor workingman and of every other person who consumes beer and spirits, and to say that he finds the price of his favourite beverage a bit high. But it is much better, I think, that it should be kept high rather than that we should have to come along and increase the cost of food to his wife and family, because really that is the second part of this amendment though it is not put down in black and white on the Order Paper. That is what the House would have to vote for: for a reduction, if you like, in the duty on beer and spirits, or for an increase in the duty on tea or sugar. With that proposition before me, I can only ask the House to reject both amendments.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 20 put.
Do you agree with this result?
I agree that amendments Nos. 22 and 23 could be discussed together. I do not know that there is very much to hope for so far as these amendments are concerned, in view of the attitude of the Minister and the Government towards the amendment which has just been voted upon. I think it is only right that these amendments should be put before the House and that we should point out that the duty upon spirits in this country has been increased by nearly 500 per cent. There is, I think, a good case to be made for a reduction of that enormous increase. This matter has been brought up before, not only in this House, but also in the British House of Commons. It has been brought up there year after year, just as it has been brought before the Dáil. In 1934 the British Chancellor of the Exchequer, Mr. Chamberlain, admitted that the duty on whiskey was too high. He said that that duty had been imposed at a time when the source of their indirect taxation was very much more limited. Of course, that could be said with much greater truth so far as this country is concerned. Mr. Chamberlain also said that if they were imposing duty in 1934 they would not impose anything as great as the duty that spirits are called upon to bear at the present moment.
A good case can be made in connection with Irish barley. So far as I know, all the spirits distilled in this country are distilled from Irish barley; all the distillers here use Irish barley exclusively. I think at one time the Irish distillers were able to use about one-third of our total barley production. What they use to-day is a very small percentage of the total crop. I do not know whether it is much good delaying the time of the House on these amendments. The Minister's attitude towards the last amendment was that he was not in a position to grant the reduction asked for and that he saw no hope of the present Government ever being in a position to grant any reduction in the case of beer or spirits. The Minister, I take it, will give on these amendments reasons somewhat similar to those he gave for refusing to accept the last amendment.
The Minister asks the House where the money is to be got otherwise. He asked the House to assume that there would be a loss to the Revenue in a full year of £500,000. The Minister seems to consider there would not be any increased consumption as a result of the reduction and he said that he cannot see where else the money can be got. The Minister and the Government have shown themselves to be very resourceful in the last three or four years for the purpose of getting revenue. They have shown that they have been able to discover sources to tax that were never thought of by any previous Administration. The Minister was resourceful enough, in any case, to put himself and his Government in the position that they were squeezing something in the neighbourhood of £10,000,000 a year over and above the amount extracted from the taxpayers by their predecessors.
I am sure if the Minister has the will to accept this amendment and grant this reduction it will not be beyond his powers to get alternative sources of revenue, alternative sources that will not affect the cost of living of the poor. Although the Government have succeeded in extracting about £10,000,000 over and above what was looked upon as normal taxation five or six years ago, they still maintain there has been no increase in the cost of living. If the Minister can succeed in getting additional taxation to the amount of £10,000,000 without increasing the cost of living, then I think we can safely leave it to him to get £500,000 without further increasing the cost of living.
Comment on this
On the Second Reading of the Bill I directed the Minister's attention to the position of the mineral water manufacturers and I suggested that he should consider if the heavy duties which are imposed, particularly on sweetened waters, could be adjusted.
Comment on this
If there is such a duty, the Deputy might discuss it on the section, but he must not discuss it on an amendment aimed at reducing the duty on spirits.
Comment on this
I am rather an unsophisticated member of the House still. I thought this might be the appropriate place to raise that matter, seeing that soda water sometimes goes with the whiskey.
Comment on this
I have supported a similar amendment on a previous Finance Bill and I desire to support this amendment this year also. Deputy Morrissey was quite modest when he said that if the Minister had the will he could find the money. I am not concerned with whether the Minister has the will or not. I do know that the duty devolves on him to remove this tax. Those of us who remember the imposition of the tax will recall that it was imposed purely for the purpose of financing the European War; that is the only reason why it was imposed. That reason has disappeared. It certainly has disappeared in our case. We are not responsible for one penny of the cost of the European War, and hence there is no justification for the maintenance of this tax as it at present stands. To say that the money cannot be found is no answer. No matter what tax is imposed, no matter to what height it is raised in a national emergency for the defence of the State and its citizens, each succeeding Minister who comes before this House ever afterwards can say: "I cannot reduce the tax. If I did, I would have to impose a tax on something else." That technique is far too detailed for me; it is far too neat. I would ask every Deputy in this House to vote against this tax, because it would be quite easy in the future to raise a national emergency in order to make an excuse to tax some body of citizens, and having got it imposed by way of an emergency then defend it by saying: "I cannot reduce it. If I did, I would have to increase the cost of living of the poor." What is done is this: the Ministers get hold of those devices for imposing taxes, and then retain them, the money being wasted. There is no such thing as retrenchment, or putting taxation back on an equitable basis. There is no defence for this particular tax, which was imposed as a war tax.
I am not saying at all that spirits and liquors should flow through the streets. That would be as abnormal as the amount of this tax, but there are many very poor middle-class people who often require spirits for their children in case of sickness, and owing to the cost they cannot get it. What is the cost? If you want a bottle of whiskey, gin or rum, to have in the house in case of sickness, you put down £1 and get a few shillings change, but for practical purposes the £1 is gone. Take the middle-class family, living on the margin line, and having to bear heavy taxation—they are the people really hit—are they to have no consideration given to them? Having bought their houses, in discharge of their duties as good citizens, in order to have a permanent home on the soil of this country, thereby showing their thrift and their economy, their houses are now taxed at five-fourths. Everything else is taxed in proportion, and on top of that there is this duty. Remember that is the class of people in this community to-day who are really ground down. They have only small marginal incomes, which are being swept away in taxes and rates. This tax was an emergency measure imposed for the purpose of fighting the European War, and there is no defence for maintaining it at this figure.
Comment on this
A Chinn Comhairle, I just want to say a few words in support of this amendment. On the last amendment I referred to Irish history and to Irish poetry, fruitlessly. I am going to do the same now with, I am sure, the same result. It is well known that at one time our ancestors had the monopoly of distilling, and I need not remind scholars of Irish history that the word "whiskey" is a corruption of the Gaelic "uisge beatha," which means water of life. During all the centuries the people have been accustomed to "a drop of the erathur," as it is called, and they have enjoyed it thoroughly. Now the price has become so appalling that only the sick person can afford to buy it, and even then he can only get it in dribs and drabs. Our great national poet, Tom Moore—I am glad to see that modern scholars and writers are beginning to realise that he was really a national poet—said:
"Fill the bumper fair!
Every drop we sprinkle
O'er the brow of care
Smoothes away a wrinkle!"
I commend this very seriously to the Minister for Finance. Another Irish poet said:
"Whiskey, drink divine!
Why should drivellers bore us
With the love of wine,
When we've got thee before us!"
I am sure that the Minister, who is conversant with Irish history, with Irish lays, lyrics and legends, will remember all about the "Cruiskeen Lan" and the "Little Brown Jig" and the "Jug of Punch," and bear those things in mind. Being, as I am sure he is, a patriot, I hope he will do something to relieve the burden which is at present being laid on the consumers of whiskey. Everybody knows that in recent years the country has become extremely temperate. A famous Bishop said to me long ago "Father Mathew was a great man and a wonderful man, and he did a great deal of good in the country, but Lloyd George did more than Father Mathew ever did by putting this tax on beer, wines and spirits." However, as the people have become very abstemious, in my humble opinion there is no necessity at the present time for the continuation of the existing taxes, and I am sure that the Minister for Finance, with all the ways and means at his disposal and with his financial craftsmanship, will be able to relieve the public of at least a share of the burden in respect of distillation in this country. I think, as Deputy Morrissey said, that he can do so without inflicting any terrible harm on the State and without in any way increasing intemperance in the country.
Comment on this
I was expecting that some Deputy on the opposite side would take part in this debate.
Comment on this
Of course the Minister has refused to give Deputies a free choice as to their manner of voting, but even though they were compelled to vote with the Minister it would be interesting and perhaps useful to the House to have the views of various Deputies for and against those particular proposals. There is no use in elaborating very much further the arguments made in regard to the beer duty. They apply equally to Deputy Morrissey's proposal on the spirit duty. Perhaps we cannot make the same argument about whiskey and brandy being a necessity for the poor man as much as stout, but if whiskey or brandy is not the poor man's beverage it is very often the poor man's medicine. It is prescribed very largely by doctors, particularly in the winter months, in epidemics of influenza, and in other cases. We all know that very many doctors prescribe whiskey or spirits as a medicine for poor people who find it extremely difficult to purchase it. When you come to think that a glass of whiskey costs, I think, 1/8 retail, it must be realised that, when a poor person is ordered that as a medicine, it is an extremely difficult matter to purchase it.
Wine and spirits have been used, I suppose, in all times. There is even a Biblical reference which says that we must drink wine for our infirmities, and not water. I think that, in those days, it was considered good for people and good for certain infirmities. I believe that some reduction in this particular duty is necessary if ever the poor man is going to taste the liquid again. However, there is a further fact to be considered, and that is that people who want spirits, and who cannot get legitimate spirits at a fair price, will resort to every subterfuge to get other kinds of spirits. They will resort to poteen. That, I understand, is what some people have been driven to drinking as a result of the high duties.
Comment on this
Yes—as Deputy Burke says, methylated spirits. Now, I am sure that we all hope that a stop will be put to the manufacture of these illicit spirits, and I feel sure also that a great deal of the trouble that has existed in this country as a result of drunkenness is due to the manufacture of these illicit spirits. I also believe, however, that we are never going to end that trouble so long as this high duty remains on the manufacture of legal spirits. So long as that high duty remains, I believe there will be a great incentive to break the law. So long as legitimately produced brandies and whiskies are at such a prohibitive price there will always be that inducement to break the law. I think Deputy Burke referred to the old saying to the effect that, if you cannot have punch, you will have something else. It is a fact, undoubtedly, that a lot of the old people used to drink punch. Possibly, the Minister knows the joke of the old saying, but it is as true now as it was on the day the saying was first made, and I think that, perhaps, a reference by the Minister to the list of vices that were punished would bear me out on that. It was not drinking people, in the old days, if they did drink too much, who committed most of the other vices that nature makes us all fall into, occasionally, one way or the other.
Comment on this
Perhaps in the same direction as the Minister. However, I did not really intend to make very much of a further appeal to the Minister, but I do say that a tax imposed as a war measure at a very high figure ought now to be reduced. As I have said already, war taxes have been reduced in most other countries, and even in England they have arrived at the point where they felt that they could safely reduce the duties on spirits and beer. I dare say, therefore, that we also have come to that point, or at least that we ought to have come to the point where we could do something of the same kind. When the Minister said that the proposed reduction would cost something like £500,000 in the next year, I do not know if he had made any allowance for an increased consumption. I think that the Minister said that there would be no increased consumption. If that is so, the argument of those people, who are opposed to this proposed reduction on the ground that it would lead to an increased consumption of drink and possible drunkenness, falls to the ground. I think that the same argument would apply in the case of whiskey and spirits generally. I do not believe that the small reduction in whiskey or spirit taxes, generally, that is proposed here, would lead to any great extra consumption of spirits, but I do believe that it would certainly help poor people, who needed spirits for medicinal purposes, to have whiskey or brandy, and there are innumerable cases, as any doctor in the House can testify, where whiskey or brandy is a necessity medicinally. The House, I think, has made up its mind on this particular matter of the reduction of the duties on whiskey and spirits generally, and I wish we could influence the Minister to take the broad view on this matter. However, as that does not seem possible, I do not propose to say anything more on the matter.
Comment on this
Some of the Deputies who have spoken already on this amendment do not seem to be quite clear in their own minds on the difficulties that exist in connection with this matter. I think I ought to make an exception, in this connection, in the case of Deputy McMenamin, who said that in the course of what he called this technique, a Minister for Finance could easily take the course of putting it up to the House that, if concessions of this sort were advocated, he could not reduce the tax because there would be no means of knowing what alternative tax would be imposed in order to make up for the deficiency in the Exchequer revenue. He asked us to ignore that. I am simply asking the House to imagine itself in the position of an ostrich whose political technique Deputy McMenamin seems to have adopted of burying its head in the sand. We have no option. We may as well make up our minds to that. If we are to reduce the duties on wines and spirits, then we must increase the duties on other commodities.
Comment on this
One of these would cost £160,000 per annum in the current year and the other would cost £385,000 in the current year. We simply can not afford either of these, and I think the country is fully prepared to endorse our attitude. I do not know whether Deputy Mulcahy himself would be prepared to say that we ought to grant a concession which would cost us £385,000 and make up for that deficiency by cutting the old age pensions. One way, perhaps, which might appeal to the Deputy, would be to wipe out the provision made for widows' and orphans' pensions.
Comment on this
Why should he have to do that when he takes into consideration that, in tax and non-tax considerations alone, he has substantially more than £7,000,000 for spending to-day than the previous Government had? Goodness knows, we would like to know what is happening to some of it.
Comment on this
The Deputy heard all that at length on the Budget. We have increased the social services almost 50 per cent. above what they were in 1931-32. There was over £4,300,000 last year, and in the present year there is an increase of almost £1,000,000.
Comment on this
I was referring to the social services. There was over £4,300,000 last year and almost £1,000,000 more of an increase this year in the proposed expenditure on these services. In addition, of course, as the Deputy is aware, additional assistance was given to farmers in the form of export bounties and subsidies amounting to more than £2,000,000. I think even the Deputy will have to admit that in the compilation every penny piece of the £7,000,000 was dealt with in the debate which took place on the other sections. He is now concerned when he comes to the House to get facts to back up statements he made. I cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
We had this fact, that in spite of the assistance the Minister says he gave to farmers, farm labourers had about £1,000,000 less in wages last year than they had before Fianna Fáil began to assist the farmers.
Comment on this
I wish to support the amendment. The Minister stated that it was difficult to find money. That may be true. The Minister seemed to emphasise the fact that the granting of the concession would mean a loss of revenue approaching £385,000 in a full year, and he asked the Opposition what means were to be adopted to provide that money. I wish to put this question to him: What amount of extra taxation has been placed upon the shoulders of the people to set up new industries of a very doubtful character, as against industries that were already established here for years, and that wanted no props from this or any other Government, but simply wanted to get a fair chance to live? I wish to put this aspect of the situation to the Minister, that he has imposed millions of extra taxation upon all sections of the people, including the very poor, to set up new industries. The fact remains that many of them are being set up at the expense of the general public. Here is an old industry and it gave a very large amount of employment, notwithstanding the views expressed by some people that it does not give much employment in comparison with the output. I wish to remind these people that this industry has been the means of increasing the National Exchequer by several millions yearly, and that the real advantage of it is not gauged by the amount of wages paid annually. It must be gauged by the amount paid into the National Exchequer, out of which comes money for old age pensions, provision for relief schemes, as well as other means of providing employment. In addition, the raw material used in this industry is mainly Irish, which cannot be said of many of the other industries that have been set up. I refer to barley. Everyone knows that if the present tillage policy is to be made a success, barley is one of the most important crops that could be grown by farmers, as it is peculiarly adaptable to the soil of this country. For that reason alone, seeing that it gives employment to the farming element, the Minister and the Government are entitled to give some remission of the amount of excise duty paid on whiskey. It is well known that the use of whiskey is advocated by the medical profession. While I am not in favour of increasing the sale of alcoholic drinks, nevertheless, my answer to certain people is that many of the crimes committed here are committed by people whose boast it is that they never took a glass of whiskey in their lives. I am one of those who believe that it is very bad policy to kill an old industry that is in existence, unless we are prepared to set up another one in its place. For that reason, I am prepared to support the amendment, as I think the time has arrived when there should be a reduction in the enormous burden that this industry has carried since the days of the Great War. Whiskey now costs 10½d. a half-glass against 2d. in pre-war days, while the price now paid for barley is no greater than the price paid in pre-war days. That is an extraordinary state of affairs. It is the duty of the Government to do something for this old-established industry which, in the opinion of many people, is giving very much needed employment, and would give more in future if it only got half a chance or half the facilities that other industries are getting, for which, to use the Minister's own words, millions of extra taxation had to be imposed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:
Before Section 14 to insert a new section as follows:—
"The Finance Act, 1935 (No. 28 of 1935), shall be and is hereby amended by the deletion of Section 16."
The section of the Finance Act of 1935 which this amendment proposes to delete is Section 16. It operated to put a duty of 75 per cent. On cutlery. There is in fact a duty of 100 per cent. on cutlery and the only information we have had is that in spite of a duty of 75 per cent.—in effect a duty of 100 per cent.—the imports of cutlery, so far as value is concerned, have not been affected at all. The total value of cutlery imported in 1932 was £27,000; in 1933, £38,000, and in 1934, £46,896. We find that in 1935 the total value of cutlery imported was £46,350 or substantially the same as was imported in 1934 before this very substantial tariff was imposed. I should like to find out from the Minister what the explanation of that is. We should like to get some information as to what is happening in the cutlery industry here and to what extent the tariff is being used to raise money for purely revenue purposes. This is just one sample of these very heavy tariffs. There is another duty, as well as this particular tariff, which raises the total duty well above 75 per cent. As I say this is but one sample of the effect of very high tariffs. Cutlery is coming in to the same value, at any rate, at which it came in before the tariff was imposed. We should like to know what is happening in the industry and how much people are paying as a result of this very high tariff.
Comment on this
People are paying nothing as a result of the tariff. It is producing practically no revenue whatever. The manufacture of cutlery in the Saorstát was commenced towards the end of October last year, and consequently the importation of cutlery during 1935 was not affected. The fact is that a firm for its production has been established here. That firm is now in operation and is employing from 60 to 70 men. They are, of course, not yet in full production. There are certain classes of cutlery that are not yet being produced here. In respect of these classes, licences to import them free of this duty are still being issued. It is anticipated that the full range of cutlery, in the quantities required, will be produced in the course of this year in which case, of course, the import figures to which the Deputy refers will be reduced very considerably.
Comment on this
Has the Minister made any examination of the situation with a view to seeing why it is necessary to have such a high tax?
Comment on this
I explained that last year. I explained that one of the reasons why such a high duty is necessary is because some of the countries engaged in the exportation of cutlery subsidise it. Any lower duty than that in operation would be ineffective. The maintenance of the duty at this rate is essential to the development of the industry. The industry is an important one and is giving a good deal of employment. Its products are of very good quality, and there is no complaint about the price at which they are sold.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister this question. I believe the Minister's tariff policy is ill-advised and irresponsible inasmuch as he does not consider all the relevant facts before he proposes his tariffs. But assuming that this House is committed to a policy of putting on a tariff of 100 per cent. where, in the opinion of the Minister, a 100 per cent. is necessary, can he tell me why it is necessary to put 100 per cent. on cutlery when his colleague in the Executive Council thinks it inexpedient to give another Irish industry—ship-building—a tariff of 40 per cent.
Comment on this
The Minister's philosophy of putting 100 per cent. tariff on cutlery rests on the ground that tariffs are necessary to get something done in this country and that tariffs must go on. I submit there is evidence that that is not the philosophy underlying these tariffs. If it was it would be comprehensible and the matter might be debated on its merits, or at least we would know where we were. But we see a far bigger individual job being sent away to Great Britain with whom we are at present engaged in an economic war. When we see that sent out of the country because a British firm can do the job 40 per cent. cheaper than an Irish firm, then I feel that we are on completely different ground. Why is it desirable to put 100 per cent. on knives and refuse to put 40 per cent. on ships?
Comment on this
Except in so far as the action in one case suggests comparison with the other. Why put 100 per cent. tariff in the one instance and refuse any tariff in the other?
Comment on this
The argument put forward by the Minister is that 100 per cent. is put on in the case of cutlery in order to keep so many people employed in producing these knives and that that is worth a tariff of 100 per cent. I think a case where a number of people would be necessarily kept employed in repairing the Muirchu is one well worth a tax of 40 per cent. If the Minister tells us that the criterion by which to criticise each individual tariff is the effect it has on keeping people in employment, why should it not arise in the case of the Muirchu.
Comment on this
The Deputy must realise that the introduction of a criterion by which to criticise a tariff policy would involve the whole policy of tariffs. That issue might have been debated on the Second Stage of the Finance Bill but is irrelevant to an amendment relating to a duty on cutlery.
Comment on this
If the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who are at present engaged in conversation, would make up their minds I could proceed.
Comment on this
Yes, the rules of common courtesy. However, I leave that. I want to know why the Minister put on the tariff of 100 per cent?
Comment on this
If this tariff was put on to put a certain number of men into employment, I want to know how much tariff the Minister is prepared to put on to get any given number of men into work? Or is it only when a certain number of people come to the Minister, hat in hand, and adopt a sufficiently obsequious manner and ask for a tariff, that they get it? I am not prepared to endorse that kind of action, out of which the consumer gets nothing. That is the situation at present, as it seems to me. I have argued in this House on divers occasions that citizens who stand in similar circumstances should be entitled to demand the same rights.
Comment on this
You must, of course, Sir, decide, and I leave the matter at that. I advise the Minister to further consider this matter.
Comment on this
Deputies opposite are supporting an amendment to remove a tariff which if removed would put 70 men out of employment. They have not given a single reason for doing that.
Comment on this
We have ascertained that there are 70 men in employment, that there is no increase in the price of cutlery to the people, because, during the year, cutlery has not been produced and has been allowed to come in under licence. Beginning in October, the production of cutlery was started, but the price has not been increased, and will not be increased. Are we clear that the Minister has told us all that?
Comment on this
I am moving to take off the tariff because, as shown, it has no influence at all in reducing the amount of money that went out of the country for cutlery, and because, so far as we know, it is taking money out of the people's pockets and putting it into the Treasury. The Minister denies that. He implies that all the cutlery sought to be imported was imported free on licence. I am moving to reduce the duty here, to 75 per cent. of the value of the article. The Minister will not deny that this is not the only customs duty on cutlery coming into the country. Will he deny that?
Comment on this
This is not the only tariff on cutlery. There is another tariff of 25 per cent. on cutlery and, so far as the duties against British goods are concerned, there is now an additional 10 per cent., so that, in so far as cutlery from Great Britain is concerned, the deletion of this section would leave a duty remaining of 35 per cent. and, in respect of other countries, a duty of 25 per cent. Inasmuch as as much money went out of the country last year for cutlery as went out the year before, I think there is good reason for moving to take off the tariff. The Minister has now told us that the factory has gone into production and that 60 or 70 men are employed. He has also said that the price of cutlery is not going to be increased. Personally, I should be prepared for the moment to take that statement and withdraw the amendment. I do not think that pressing the amendment would do any good but it has given the Minister an opportunity of making that statement in which the House will be interested and which Deputies can for a time ponder over.
Comment on this
I should have given that information in reply to a Parliamentary Question at any time.
Comment on this
We have now got an invitation from the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce to address more Parliamentary Questions to them than we have been doing. I thank them for the invitation because there was a time when we did want information and, not only was there no invitation to ask for it, but it was unavailable to us.
Comment on this
This is the kind of conduct that protracts debate. The Minister is here to give information.
Comment on this
If the information is forthcoming, business will be expeditiously disposed of. If it is not forthcoming, business will be held up until the House gets the information.
Comment on this
The question before the House is the proposed deletion of Section 16 of the Finance Act, 1935.
Comment on this
And with respect, I submit, that, in order to enable me to make up my mind as to whether the duties imposed by that section should be withdrawn or not, I am entitled to inquire what other duties are imposed by order or statute. The Minister has a clear parliamentary duty to give me that information.
Comment on this
At the beginning of the debate, the Minister did not know what other duties applied to cutlery. He has just found out and, having got that information, I suggest that he should relay it to me. The Chair might, in certain circumstances, think it rash to suggest that the Minister for Industry and Commerce does not know whether duties are attached to commodities or not. However, only a few days ago, the Minister was asked whether or not a duty attached to wallpaper and he angrily retorted "No," whereupon there was dismay amongst his experts and he was obliged to stand up and say that there was a duty on wallpaper.
Comment on this
The Deputy who moved the amendment has asked leave to withdraw it. It can only be withdrawn, however, with the unanimous consent of the House. Deputy Dillon has withheld his consent.
Comment on this
I want information to which the House is entitled. I want an answer to the question I put and it is the Minister's duty to give that answer. We are entitled to information as to what the total of the duties affecting cutlery is at the moment. The Minister has that information on his desk and I ask him to give it to the House. I think it is an act of gross disrespect to refuse to do so. It is not open to the Minister to pick and choose as to whom he will give information and from whom he will withhold it. I ask again what are the present duties affecting cutlery?
Comment on this
Am I to understand that the Deputy has been speaking in support of an amendment to delete certain duties and that he does not know the amount of the duties?
Comment on this
I am asking the Minister to state the amount of the total duties. Certain duties were imposed on cutlery by the section which this amendment proposes to delete. Certain other duties were imposed by statutory Order and by other statutes. I ask the Minister to inform the House what these duties are. Deputy Brady will have to vote on this amendment in a moment. Deputy Brady does not know what duties attach to cutlery. Deputy Mrs. Concannon does not know what duties are imposed upon cutlery. Neither does Deputy Jordan nor Deputy Moore.
Comment on this
The Deputy is going to be asked in a moment to trot like a sheep into the Lobby. I want him to trot into the Lobby in an informed state of mind.
Comment on this
If I put down an amendment, I would take care to know what the circumstances governing that amendment were. I would not put down an amendment in an irresponsible way.
Comment on this
I did not put down any amendment. As an humble Deputy in this House, in the same position as Deputy Moore, I decline to walk into the Lobby like a sheep. I want sufficient information to enable me to make up my mind and to decide what Lobby I shall go into. Deputy Moore is in the deplorable position that he is going to go into the Lobby without knowing anything about the duties.
Comment on this
That is like the conceit of Deputy Dillon. He wants to get information for the benefit of other people.
Comment on this
Is it useless repetition to ask for information to which the House is entitled? The Minister has the information on his desk and refuses to communicate it to the House, although he has been categorically requested to give it by Deputies.
Comment on this
To show that Deputy Dillon is not unreasonable in his attitude, I could not swear at present as to what the duty on cutlery is.
Comment on this
I have given the House a certain amount of information as to what I think the duty is. Now, I shall tell the Minister how I got that information.
Comment on this
I looked up the debate on the Finance Bill of 1935, and I could not get satisfactory information as to why the duty of 75 per cent. was put on. We have, according to the import list, a duty on cutlery and component parts, of 25 per cent. full, and 25 per cent. preferential, and an additional duty of 75 per cent. full and 50 per cent. preferential. Then we had the coal-cattle-cement pact, and now the coal-cattle minus the cement pact, and that appears to our minds to interfere with certain duties on articles that might include cutlery.
Comment on this
Look at the difficulties in which we are. I asked the Minister for Finance what duties did remain on articles after the reduction of the penal duties from 20 per cent. to 10 per cent. I had to wait several weeks for that information, and had to hold back the question on the Order Paper. In the end I got the information by letter, and I have it here that
"the rate of emergency duty on United Kingdom goods, on iron and steel goods not otherwise liable to duty, subject to duty under the Emergency Duty Order No. 5 of 1932, was reduced from 20 per cent. to 10 per cent."
I felt under the impression that cutlery could be described as iron and steel goods, and——
Comment on this
——that if they were not dealt with by the Emergency Duty Order No. 5, they were covered by the statement issued by the Minister for Finance that they were subject now to an additional retaliatory duty reduced from 20 per cent. to 10 per cent.
Comment on this
Yes, that is what I understood from the letter. The Minister took, I think, about four weeks to find out what he could make out of the coal-cattle-cement agreement, and then he gave us this information. Approaching the question humbly enough, I make a deduction from it. I make the deduction that not only is this duty that is mentioned in this list imposed, but that there is also a retaliatory duty on cutlery coming in from Great Britain, and that, therefore, if this amendment of mine were passed, there would still be a 25 per cent. retaliatory duty on goods coming into the country from Great Britain and Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
Does the Minister say that that is correct—does that mean that there is now a 10 per cent. duty?
Comment on this
If that cutlery is at 25 per cent. and 75 per cent. now, did it not take you a long time to get that out?
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment No. 25:—
Before Section 14 to insert a new section as follows:—
The Finance Act of 1935 (No. 28 of 1935) shall be and is hereby amended by the deletion of Section 17.
This is one of the high power statutes. Section 17 of the Finance Act of 1935 imposed a duty of 75 per cent. on clocks coming into the country. We have the position now that the value of imports of clocks has fallen from £24,000 to £16,000 between 1934 and 1935. I would like to ask the Minister for some information as to how many persons are employed in the industry. Has he any information as to the total value of the annual production? I understand that a duty is being collected on clocks coming into the country. Is the Minister issuing licences for the import of clocks free of duty for clocks of the kind not manufactured by the companies manufacturing clocks here? Are these licences issued on the application of the importers free of duty?
Comment on this
There are no licences issued for the importation of clocks free of duty. There are a number of firms engaged here in the assembling of clocks. I cannot give the figure as to the number employed in the industry but it is not inconsiderable taking all the firms together. Returns in regard to that industry will be published in due course. The duty was imposed by the Finance Act last year. The figure as to the imports for last year would be no indication as to the extent to which these firms could supply the requirements of the country.
Comment on this
But last year's import figures indicated that £ 12,000 had been taken in revenue duties out of the pockets of people who had to buy clocks of that kind that are not yet manufactured by the companies manufacturing here.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 26:
Before Section 14 to insert a new section as follows:—
Section 18 of the Finance Act, 1935 (No. 28 of 1935) shall be and is hereby annulled.
This amendment proposes to annul the duty of 6d. per lb. on tea. To my mind a very extraordinary situation seems to have arisen with regard to tea. The Minister for Industry and Commerce publishes figures from time to time showing the average prices of those various commodities that particularly affect the cost of living of the people. The position is remarkable in regard to tea in respect of which he publishes the average prices of the cheapest tea sold in the various towns throughout the country and the average price of the dearest tea. The average price of the cheapest tea has risen by 10¼d. per lb. between mid-February 1932, and mid-February 1936, while the import price for tea in the same time during the two years 1932 and 1936 has fallen by 1d. per lb.
Comment on this
The average price of the tea landed at the port has fallen by 1d. per lb. The average price of the dearest tea has fallen by 1¾d., so that here we have a situation in respect of a commodity of general use and which to a very large extent is the staple beverage of the people and the price of that beverage has risen for the majority of the people by 10¼d. per lb. And 6d. of that tax goes to the Government. I do not want again to go over the various classes of people in this country on whom the burden of taxation is falling. The Minister for Finance indicated, when dealing with the question of relief of income-tax in respect of children who are undergoing certain types of education that the cost of giving that relief—that is to say, the tax which would have to be imposed to give that relief—would fall on the labouring classes, and I have repeatedly indicated what is the condition of the labouring classes, particularly amongst the agricultural community, at the present time. In that situation I submit that the tax of 6d. per lb. on tea is about the most inequitable tax that you could possibly have. I have repeatedly pointed out that the previous Administration realised that. It was a tax that fell very inequitably on various classes of the people, and was borne to the greatest possible extent by the poorer classes until they removed it. It is now being restored to the extent of 6d. per lb. One extraordinary circumstance that has accompanied that restoration is that the price of tea, when we take the 1d. reduction in the import price, has gone up by 5¼d. per lb. as well.
Comment on this
How is it that the tax going on not only runs up the price of tea in four years by the amount of the tax, but by an additional 5¼d.?
Comment on this
I am giving the Minister the benefit of a comparison with the 1932 price. The import price of tea between 1932 and 1935 fell from 1/5 to 1/4. That 1d. fall is not reflected in the price the people pay. If we take, as we might take, the 1935 price as compared with the 1931 price, the fall is 4d., because the import price of tea in 1931 was 1/8 and it was 1/4 last year. So that I am putting the mildest possible case, that over the price paid in February, 1932, the people buying the cheapest class of tea paid 10¼d.
Comment on this
In 1936. I should like the Minister to be clear on it. In mid-February, 1932, the price paid for the cheapest tea was 2/1¼. That had risen by 10¼d. in mid-February, 1936. Sixpence of that was tax. Not only is there 4¼d. to be accounted for of an additional rise, but there is 1d. to be accounted for also by which the import price of tea actually fell. If the Minister wants to carry it further, there is an additional 3d. to be explained in the high price of tea to-day, if he takes the 1931 import price of tea as the foundation.
Comment on this
The Deputy is relating the average price to the price for a particular class of commodity.
Comment on this
I am relating the price quoted by the Minister as the average price for the cheapest tea paid by the community and, as it were, found by an examination of the price of the cheapest tea bought in a number of towns in order to arrive at what is the general position with regard to the cheapest price of tea.
Comment on this
Let us assume that the people are buying a better class of tea. That is one explanation.
Comment on this
There is another explanation and that is the true explanation. The incidence of the tax which the Minister put on tea fell either upon the palates of the people who drank the tea or upon their pockets. So far as the rich people are concerned, or the people in a condition of moderate prosperity, the tax fell upon their palates, because the different blenders reduced the quality of the tea in the blend and left the prices at what they were before the Minister put on the tax at the special request of the Minister for Finance. Deputies will remember that he begged the people not to pass on the 4d. tax because we were fighting a struggle to the death with Great Britain, that victory was to be won in a period of six weeks or two months, and, if the tax was passed on it might shake the foundations of the Irish nation. It was not passed on. The only persons to whom it was passed on were the poor of the Cities of Dublin, Cork and Limerick, who buy cheap fannings. These fannings were the lowest grade of tea that money could buy and there could be no depreciation of their quality, with the result that the whole tax had to go on to them and they suffered in their pockets. I am not pretending that the people who bought a better quality did not suffer in any way. They did not get as good tea as they got heretofore. They simply put cheaper tea in the blend. It was the poor who were buying the cheapest tea that could be found in the market who had to find the extra 4d. or 6d., according to whether the tea came from the Dominions or the Dutch colonies.
The result of the Government policy has been a very substantial fall in the consumption of tea in rural Ireland. I have tried to get a figure out of the Minister for Finance but he is very coy. He keeps making the same answer and says it is an answer to the strict letter of the question put, but he feels bound to warn the Deputy that it leaves a considerable lacunae if information is really sought as to the total consumption of tea. If the Minister knows that I want to ascertain what the total consumption is——
Comment on this
Surely Deputy Dillon, who has such a command of English, ought to be able to frame the question which he is trying to ask and he will get an answer?
Comment on this
I do not want to make any reflections upon the Revenue Commissioners, but I am not always satisfied that classical English will extract from the Revenue Commissioners the precise information that we require. However, that need not be investigated here. The Minister is responsible to the House and not the Revenue Commissioners. If the Minister knew what I wanted——
Comment on this
I wanted information as to how many lbs. of tea were consumed by the people. The Minister wanted to cover up his tracks, to conceal the fact that the consumption of tea has declined. It declined because the people had not the money to pay for it. The reason they had not the money was because the Minister was impoverishing them. These are two facts. The third fact is that the quality of tea consumed by the people of rural Ireland has fallen materially during the last three years. A person who used to pay 4/4 for tea four or five years ago is now paying 3/4. The person who used to pay 3/4 for tea is now paying 2/4. The person who used to pay 2/4 for tea is now paying 1/8 or 2/-. He would pay less if he could get cheaper tea, but he cannot.
I beg Deputy Kelly, who represents a city constituency, and Deputy Mrs. Concannon, who holds herself out as a representative of the women of Ireland, to remember that the people who are actually paying the tax out of their pockets and not simply depreciating their standard of living are the poor. The people who are buying the lowest grade of tea that they can get, because they cannot afford a better one, are the people who have to contribute to the tax-gatherer who stands at the door of every grocer's shop the 4d. or 6d. that the Minister levies on every poor person who buys a lb. of tea.
Comment on this
I am not familiar with the Dublin tea trade, but I should say the poorest people in Dublin ought to be able to get tea at from 1/7 to 1/8. I can conceive an exceptional fanning being available for 1/6, but I do not think any grocer will be profiteering who finds himself unable to offer tea at less than 1/8, even for the cheapest grade. I am going to make a suggestion in connection with the tea tax. The President spoke last night of being honest with the people, letting them know exactly what was being done and inviting judgment on it. Will the Minister consider arranging in future that this tax should be collected by way of stamps: that each customer, having bought his tea and paid for it, would then be invited to pay for a stamp to be reminded that when he was buying tea he was being privileged to contribute 6d. on each lb. of it to the development of the grand Fianna Fáil policy that we have in this country? I feel sure that if the President is right—that the people are so anxious to know everything and that he is so anxious that they should know—the Minister would be glad to tell the working-class people of this country that he is extending to them the privilege of paying their share of the expense of the Fianna Fáil policy. The Minister for Education said some time ago in this House: "Why should they not be made pay?""Is it not right," he said, "that they should be made pay their share." If that is the policy of the Government, why not tell the people that honestly? I was down in Deputy Tom Kelly's stronghold last night, addressing a meeting at the corner of York Street. I wonder would he go down there, amongst his own friends, and tell them that the Party that he is supporting is putting a levy of 6d. a lb. on tea, 2d. on sugar, 1½d. on the quartern loaf and 5d. per lb. on butter. Would he tell them this: that, because he knew them to be enthusiastic citizens of this State, they would regard it as a privilege to make their contribution of 2/- a week to the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party? I suggest that Deputy Kelly, who rejoices in his native borough in the cognomen of "Honest Tom Kelly," should go down and dole out some of that honesty in York Street. I have no doubt but that the Minister for Finance would be glad to escort him. When the Deputy has done what I suggest he should do, and when both start running from York Street, we will be above at the corner at Stephen's Green with a barrage ready to receive them.
Comment on this
I would remind the Deputy that no one but Fianna Fáil candidates has yet been elected in the County Dublin.
Comment on this
In one of the first speeches made in this House by Deputy Dillon, he pleaded for a tax on tea as one of the most suitable and harmless taxes that could be imposed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:—
Before Section 14 to insert a new section as follows:—
Section 19 of the Finance Act, 1935 (No. 28 of 1935) shall be and is hereby annulled.
Section 19 of the Finance Act of 1935 puts a duty of 6d. a cwt. on wheat imported into the Saorstát. This is one of the ways of keeping up the price of flour and the price of bread. I submit that this is the simplest, the easiest way by which the Government could indicate that they realise the enormous increases that have taken place in the price of bread and flour to the people and that they are going to see that these increases are not going to last. There is a Bill before the House to give the Government power to fix the price of bread. We should get an indication now that they are going to fix the price of bread at a rate lower than that applying to bread at the present time.
The Minister for Finance is, no doubt, aware that, when calculating the official cost-of-living index figure, something over 57 per cent of that figure is covered by the cost of food to the people and one-third of that is covered by items such as bread, flour, tea and sugar. We have indicated that the price of the cheapest tea between February, 1932 and February, 1936, had risen by 10½d.; that the price of sugar has risen by 1/2d. a lb.; that flour has risen 4½d. a stone and that the 4 lb. loaf has risen by 1½d. The Government have tolerated the continuance of that kind of thing for the reason, no doubt, that they set out to raise the price of bread and the price of flour; but there is very little excuse for the Minister for Finance tolerating the increase in the price of the 4 lb. loaf to 1½d. more than it was in the beginning of 1932, before Fianna Fáil came into office.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce has been presented with the statement—and I have no doubt that he has brought it to the notice of the Minister for Finance and the Government as a whole—that in the first quarter alone, the quarter to March, 1934, the millers made very considerable profits over what the Commission that was inquiring into the matter considered reasonable profits. Dealing with the matter in page 35 of their Report, the Commission say:
"It represents a contribution of £34,640 to millers over and above the profits to which they were, in our opinion, entitled."
Here we had a group of flour millers, according to a report presented to the Minister very early last year, and the Government have been informed that these millers made, in the first quarter of the year 1934, £34,640 profit above the margin of profit that would be considered reasonable. The Government have taken no steps to deal with that situation. They sat idly by and they allowed the situation to develop to the extent that people are paying 1½d. more on the 4 lb. loaf than they were paying before Fianna Fáil took office. It must amount to an enormous additional taxation, hidden taxation taken out of the pockets of the people.
The wheat policy was being financed by direct contribution from the Exchequer up to last year, but the extent of that contribution was becoming so great that the Government hid it, ceased the system by which it was made a direct contribution from the Revenue, and planned so that the people would have to pay the increased charges for the wheat policy over the counter. No doubt 6d. a cwt. on imported wheat is a very small thing in the matter of revenue, but it is an important factor in keeping up the level at which both flour and bread will be sold to the people. There is a very grave situation indicated there in view of the unnecessarily high price that is being paid on two of the most important items in the whole cost-of-living index.
I have said that food represents 57 per cent. of the total cost-of-living index. Bread and flour together represent nearly one-fifth of what the whole food component of the index represents. That gives some measure of the burden of increased prices on the people and I move that the 6d. should come off the wheat imports as a small indication to the people that when facing the question of fixing bread prices the Government will move in the direction of having them fixed at a lower level.
Comment on this
The Minister, on amendments discussed some time ago, expressed considerable concern that the House should take any action which would in any way compel the Government, by way of alternative taxation, to increase the cost of living. This is a matter to which I have had to draw the attention of the House on several occasions during the last year. Deputy Mulcahy has quoted certain figures regarding the increase in the price of a 4 lb. loaf and regarding the increase in the price of flour. Of course the House is aware that in the rural parts of Ireland people make their own bread at home; it is mostly home-made bread that is used. Flour is bought by farmers and others in half sacks in the towns and villages. It is bought in smaller quantities by the poorer people. Deputy Mulcahy quoted an increase of 4½d. per stone. I do not know exactly where that figure was got, or what are the comparative periods.
Comment on this
Mid-February 1932, and mid-February 1936, as quoted by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The price was increased from 1/10 to 2/2½.
Comment on this
So far as the rural parts of this country are concerned there was an increase of 8d. per stone. The price of flour increased from 1/6 to 2/2. It varied in certain parts from 2/1 to 2/2. The poor people who have to buy flour in half-stones found they were saddled with an additional 8d. per stone. In working-men's homes, where there are large families and where all the bread is made at home, 4 stones of flour are very often used in the week. That gives the House an idea of what the additional cost means to an agricultural labourer with a comparatively small wage. On flour alone there is an additional 2/8 per week; if you like, an additional 1/4 per week or an additional 2/- — the increase depending altogether on the size of the family. Of course there was an increase also in the price of bread. I do not think there is any justification whatever for this particular tax. Deputy Mulcahy has quoted from the report of the Commission regarding the profits made by millers in this country. I do not think anybody in the country doubts for a moment that millers are making very large profits, particularly over the last two or three years. About a fortnight ago the newspaper which is controlled and directed by the President of the Executive Council, in an attempt to prove its contention that this country was prosperous and was growing more prosperous, quoted the price of shares in certain firms in this country, and referred to the way in which the price of those shares had advanced over the past four years. One of the firms quoted to prove the contention that the country was growing more prosperous was one of the principal flour-milling bakery firms in this country. We were informed in that article that the shares had increased from 50/- to £5 14s. 0d. each.
I would ask members of the House to turn that over in their minds, remembering, as I say, that as a result of this tax and the other dealings of the Government the consumers are compelled to pay from 6d. to 8d. per stone extra for flour. That is a statement which cannot be contreverted. It is a statement that can be substantiated. It is a statement which I have made on more than one occasion, both in this House and outside it. I have gone to some trouble to make sure with regard to that particular figure. I say that in my opinion this is perhaps the most unjust tax that was imposed in last year's Budget. There were a great number of taxes imposed on the necessaries of life, and I think it will be agreed that there is no greater necessity than flour, particularly in the homes of the poor, where bread is used for every meal. In the case of the better-off people in the larger homes there is a greater variety of food, and for that reason perhaps this tax does not hit them as badly as it hits the poor people, in whose homes bread is the staple part of every meal of the day.
Comment on this
It is really very surprising that any Deputy who represents a rural constituency, at any rate, should manage to steel his heart and subdue his conscience sufficiently to follow the Minister for Finance into the Lobby upon the motion which we are now discussing. This is a motion which comes to the relief of the very poorest members of the community, and since the interests of the Minister for Finance and the interests of the Executive Council are concentrated, not upon the welfare of the poor, but upon the welfare of the shareholders in milling and other companies, I take it for granted that this motion—a motion in relief of the poor—will be opposed by the Minister for Finance. He has not spoken but, from my general knowledge of the Minister for Finance and my general knowledge of the Fianna Fáil Party, I take it for granted that a motion which comes to the relief of the very poorest persons in the country will inevitably be opposed by the Party which is now in office. Deputy Mulcahy quoted certain figures from the cost-of-living index, but we must always bear in mind that the cost-of-living index is not at all an indication of the cost of living of the very poor in this country. The cost-of-living index is an index which has been weighted to suit civil servants. There never has been an index to the cost-of-living figures in this country weighted to suit the working classes. If a proper cost-of-living figure, weighted to suit the working classes, were introduced, the weight which would be given to the price of bread, to the price of flour and to the prices of the necessaries of life, would be very much heavier than the weight which is given to those items when an index to cost-of-living figures is produced weighted solely for the Civil Service. We have it on the Government's own figures—admitted by the Government themselves—that the wages of agricultural labourers have fallen by at least an average of 3/- per week. At a time when agricultural wages are being reduced, and must be reduced—it has been admitted even by the Chairman of the Labour Party that agricultural wages have been reduced of necessity because the farmers in this country cannot pay any higher wages—because the farmers are compelled, as a direct result of Government policy, to reduce the wages which they pay to their farm labourers, is it fair, is it just, is it moral even, that the Government, which on the one hand by their policy is indirectly foreing down the rate of agricultural wages, and on the other hand by their direct policy and the taxation which they have imposed upon the principal necessary which an agricultural labourer has got to buy, should further reduce the real purchasing value of those wages? After all, what a wage means to the working man is solely what he can purchase with the amount of wages he receives.
Deputy Morrissey has now given figures which cannot be controverted. As a matter of fact, I think that Deputy Morrissey has rather understated than over-stated his case. We may take it that the cost of living of the ordinary agricultural labourer, rearing an ordinary family, has been put up by 2/- per week in the cost of flour. Therefore, you may take it that if the Government policy means, indirectly, a reduction of wages by 3/- a week, and, directly, a reduction of the purchasing power of wages by another 2/-, it means a loss of 5/- a week on an average to the agricultural labourer in this country.
Now, surely, there ought to be some sense of fair play in the Executive Council, or at least in the Fianna Fáil Party; and surely, when they see, as they must see—they cannot be blind —that their policy has been the direct cause of a reduction of, on an average, 3/- a week in agricultural wages all over the country, instead of getting at that agricultural labourer, whose wages have been cut down, and instead of acting on the policy of saying "There is a fellow down there, and let us jump on him," surely this is a time in which, if they had any sense of fair play or decency, the Executive Council would take a very different attitude and, instead of putting on taxes, would, owing to the poverty that exists among the agricultural community as a result of their policy, take this opportunity of removing every single tax off food, but, above all, off the prime necessity of life, because the staff of life, the staple food of the agricultural labourers and the small farmers of the country, is grain. That is their standard food. What has happened? That is being driven down. Their wages are being driven down, and, at the same time, the cost of bread is going up. What must happen as a result is an underfed population, and you are going to have little children wanting bread because you have made bread too dear. You will have a population growing up underfed because, at a time like this, you have put up the cost of living for the poor. You might raise the cost of living at a time of tremendous prosperity or at a time when agricultural wages were booming up, but, to increase the cost of living, at a time when the cost of agricultural wages are tumbling down, is unfair and unjust, and, I do not hesitate to stigmatise it, Sir, as immoral.
I have certainly spoken, Sir, on the assumption that the Government will refuse this motion. According to their past history, I know that they talk about themselves as a poor man's Government, but it seems to me that, when they get a chance to do something for the poor man, their only idea seems to be to know what else they can extract from his pocket. Their attitude seems to be that, although they have made these people poor already, they will make them poorer.
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was dealing with the cost of living generally. The cost of flour fluctuates from time to time and it fluctuated considerably during the time the previous Government was in office. Taking the cost of living generally, however, the general cost-of-living figure now is lower than it was in 1931. Deputy Morrissey's and Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's arguments, again, fall before the facts. I have often referred before to the innumerable tragedies in this House when beautiful theories advanced by certain Deputies come into contact with ugly facts. Deputies opposite do not like facing facts, but it is only necessary to face the facts in order to destroy their arguments because all their arguments are based upon conceptions of the facts that are wrong. The cost-of-living figure now is lower than in 1931, and the remission of this duty would not affect the price of bread in the slightest—this duty of 6d. a cwt. on wheat. That would not influence the price of bread in the slightest.
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney talked about hungry children crying for bread because of this tax. We had all these rhetorical references from the Deputy about the consequences of an ill-nourished population on the future of the race as a result of this tax. As a matter of fact, the remission of the tax would not alter the price of bread by ¼d.
Comment on this
It would not alter the price by ¼d. Let Deputy Morrissey take the prices of wheat in the Corn Trade News for this week, and for a number of weeks past. If Deputy Morrissey does that, I shall be very much surprised if, comparing one week with another, there is not, in each week, at least 6d. per week in the fluctuation in the prices.
Comment on this
Therefore, this tax, which brings in £150,000 a year, is of a character which does not influence the general cost of living to any degree whatever. It has, however, a protective effect. It is important that we should grow our own wheat and secure for the growers of wheat here a good price, and that, I think, is appreciated by most of the people in this country, if not by the Deputies opposite. That protective duty is very small in relation to the world price of wheat which fell so much in 1929, and subsequently, that it was the prime cause of the world depression. The addition of 6d. a cwt. does not bring the price anywhere near the minimum price we have guaranteed the wheat producers of this country. In so far as we are succeeding in getting an increase of wheat production here, an increase that Deputies opposite and their Party always told us was a physical impossibility, this tax is becoming of less and less importance, because 35 per cent. of the flour being milled this year is being milled from Irish wheat. It is not so many years since the ex-Minister for Agriculture, and many of his agricultural experts, asserted, with all the authority which their positions gave them, that the land of this country would grow thistles, would grow weeds, would grow dandelion, would grow grass—anything except wheat. They said the climatic conditions were such that wheat could not grow here. It is growing, and in increasing quantities every year, and in due course this tax will be merely historic relic.
Comment on this
Will the Minister tell us how many acres of winter wheat could not be put in last November?
Comment on this
How many acres were put down and how many might be put down? If the Deputy subtracts one figure from the other he will get his answer. Being in my own country I cannot pose as a prophet, and I could not possibly attempt even to estimate a figure which would answer the Deputy's question.
Comment on this
The area under wheat is increasing, and the effect of the Government's plan for the development of wheat production has been very beneficial in all the wheat-growing parts. It has given the farmers in these areas a new cash crop, one which they can grow with the certainty that in the harvest they will be able to dispose of it at a remunerative price. I think that is a good thing for the country, and a good thing for the farmers, who know that it is a good thing. All the talk we have on occasions from the benches opposite, about the effect on consumers of agricultural produce of the Government's agricultural policy is intended for town consumption only. They make the mistake of thinking that people in the agricultural community are illiterate; that they do not read the newspapers, but they are going to find out some day to their astonishment that the speeches they deliver for town consumption are being read by the rural population. Deputies opposite cannot have it both ways. They cannot go around saying that the Government are ruining the farmers because the price of farm produce is too low, and, at the same time, contend that we are ruining the towns because the price of farm produce is too high. They have to stand by one thing or the other. If they stand for an increase in agricultural prices, they may get increased support amongst the farmers, or if they stand for lower prices for agricultural produce in the towns, they may get support from the workers. So long as they are trying to do both things they are not going to get any support, as the result of the recent County Dublin elections illustrates.
Comment on this
——and having made a couple of blunders realised that he was blundering and got to the general question. He stated that this tax will not add anything to the cost of bread or flour. A sum of £150,000 is going to the Government out of this tax. Is it the Minister's contention that the millers are paying the £150,000 to the Government, and are not passing it on? Does the Minister contend that?
Comment on this
Exactly. The Minister would like to proceed by way of speech because he will find some difficulty in answering. The Minister wants to get away from the point. A sum of £150,000 is involved for wheat which is to be imported, notwithstanding the Government's wheat policy. If the consumers do not pay the £150,000 to the Government, who pays? Does the Minister contend that millers whose shares have increased from 50/- to £5 14s. 0d. will pay? Does the Minister contend that millers will pay this £150,000 and not recoup themselves from the consumers? It is nonsense for the Minister to try to relate this to the guaranteed price. What has that to do with it? The Government is not contributing to the guaranteed price. They are making the consumers pay it. This is a case of transferring it from the Exchequer and making it a direct charge on the people. Whatever difficulty there is in making up the guaranteed price is solved by the direct charge on bread and flour used by consumers, and not by any contribution from the State. This tax is for revenue purposes only, and is not passed on to the people who grow wheat. The Minister spoke of this as a measure of protection for the wheat growing policy. I should like the Minister to explain that. Does any other Deputy understand it in that way? I do not think there is, except Deputy Briscoe.