Public Business. - Finance Bill, 1936—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 200–408 of 408. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 20 of 1936 ›
The Deputy is not the only member of the Party opposite who will have to groan, if I know anything.
Comment on this
I am going to tell the Deputy about the 8d. a stone on flour to which the Minister made no reference. That is the one fact he kept away from.
Comment on this
No, the millers are great philanthropists, and they are going to pay this £150,000 to the Government—I know that the millers are noted for doing that, and I am wondering whether their sense of gratitude would bring them to the point of paying up to the tune of £150,000 yearly.
Comment on this
Therefore, as the millers do not pay it, consumers of bread and flour must be paying it. Otherwise where is the Minister going to get it? This is going to be a greater puzzle than the 5/- a ton on coal.
Comment on this
If the Minister would address himself to this matter, and get away from the fantasy of protection, the guaranteed price, and of the amount of wheat we are growing, I suggest he would be getting a little nearer to realities. When the Party opposite ask us to face realities we put a few points before the Minister. I ask the Minister for once to try to face the points that have been made, and not to be putting up skittles of his own to knock down.
Comment on this
I have often heard the Minister for Industry and Commerce being disingenuous and irrelevant, and I have heard him on occasions being disingenuous but reasonably effective, but I am afraid we heard the Minister at his worst this evening. We heard him being extremely disingenuous, remarkably ineffective and extremely irrelevant.
Comment on this
The Minister's worst was very poor, I am sorry to say. I do not think, if he wants candid criticism, he has often been so poor. The Minister started off with a very nice case. What proposition did he set out to prove? That the increase of the tax of 2/- on flour does not cost consumers anything.
Comment on this
The bread tax costs the ordinary family 2/- a week. I am dealing with the bread tax as a whole.
Comment on this
Here is where the Minister is completely disingenuous. He knew we were discussing the bread tax as a whole.
Comment on this
We are entitled to discuss it, as a whole, because this is one of the items which go to make up the bread tax, and this is the only way in which we can bring the bread tax up for discussion in this House. The Minister knows that the amendment was brought in, in order to discuss the bread tax, but, disingenuously and entirely ineffectively, he tried to dodge that issue. The Minister endeavoured to pass the major proposition. He said that flour was as dear in 1932 as it is now, and that by taxing it, it is not going to be made any dearer. That is an idiotic statement. I beg pardon, that is unparliamentary. The Minister is not doing his own intellect complete justice when he puts that argument before the House. I think the Minister might now give us an example of endeavouring to do himself justice. Let him use his own mind, let him do himself justice, let him deal with these questions which we have put to him and let him answer this plain, simple, straight question I put to him: when agricultural wages are driven down should not the cost of living to the agricultural labourer be reduced as much as the Government can reduce it? I put this plain straight question to him very sincerely and the Minister will not answer it by rubbing his fevered brow to get inspiration, as I see him doing at the present moment. Let him answer that question plainly and straightly. When agricultural wages are driven down, is it fair and is it right or, I again say, is it even moral, to tax the necessaries of life for those people?
The Minister asks why we do not talk about farm labourers, and says that we had confined ourselves to the towns. I have not mentioned a town or city. The people in whom I am interested are the small farmers in my own constituency. These are the people who are being hit by the price of flour. These are the people on whose behalf I here denounce this increase in the cost of living by Government taxation of food. Let us have it out with the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Let him tell us whether he thinks it is fair to raise the cost of flour—I do not want any comparative figures—over what it would be if untaxed at the present moment when agricultural wages have been driven down and when the small-holders of this country, the ordinary country people, have been reduced to poverty by the action of the Government in depriving them of a market for their stock.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy means when he refers to the price of flour "as it would be" if there were no restrictions on its importation. Flour is taxed in Britain for the purpose of subsidising wheat production in Britain.
Comment on this
The difference is that Ranks get 10/- per sack more for their flour milled in Limerick than they get for their flour milled in Liverpool.
Comment on this
Does the Minister deny that this tax on wheat results in an increase in the price of a cwt. of flour of about 10d.?
Comment on this
So far as I am aware, the tax of 6d. per cwt. on wheat will result in an increase of 10d. per cwt. on household flour.
Comment on this
Can you not find agreement amongst yourselves even as to the amount of the increase?
Comment on this
The Minister has at his disposal technicians of various kinds and I have no doubt before he advised the Minister for Finance to impose this tax he consulted his technicians to ascertain what increase in the price of flour this tax would produce and, in the light of that information, fixed the amount of the tax. On a rough calculation, speaking purely as a merchant without any experience as a miller, I understand that a tax of 6d. per cwt. on wheat involves an increase of 10d. per cwt. on flour. Do the Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party take the view that in existing circumstances, whenever a country woman goes in to buy a cwt. of flour, she should pay 10d. to the tax-gatherer as she passes out of the merchant's door?
Comment on this
Let us take the Deputies opposite at the value which Deputy Briscoe puts upon them. Do they think that they are worth 10d. a bag to the country?
Comment on this
I take that standard of value set up by Deputy Briscoe himself and I ask Deputy Moane to go down to his constituents. Let him bring Deputy Briscoe with him, put him up on the platform and say,"Is he worth 10d. per bag?" If they think he is, then I will say that the Minister is justified in imposing this tax. If the people want to say that, then the will of the people should prevail. I put a little test before to Deputy Tom Kelly. I suggested that he should go down to his friends at the corner of York Street and talk about bread, sugar and tea. He said that, having maturely considered the suggestion, he would stay where he was. Deputy Tom Kelly is "Honest Tom Kelly" in this city, and I have no doubt that if he went down to the corner of York Street be would tell the people the truth but, in the circumstances, he thought it wiser to stay in Dáil Eireann. I think he was right. What about Deputy Moane starting for the West of Ireland, bringing Deputy Briscoe with him, and making that comparison? I shall tell you what I shall do. If Deputy Moane goes down to the West of Ireland, takes Deputy Briscoe with him, puts him up on a platform and asks the people "Is he worth 10d. a bag?" and if the people agree that he is, we shall never again say a thing about the increase of 10d. per cwt. in the price of flour.
Comment on this
The Minister tells us that even the British Government taxed wheat in order to develop wheat production. We were informed by the Government Press the other day—some time in the month of June—that the price of the 4lb. loaf in London was reduced to 7½d. That was about the 5th or 6th of June. Here the price is 10d. The Minister was not here when I was speaking to the amendment and I should like to put to him again the point I made in connection with it. I quite agree that a reduction of 6d. per cwt. on wheat is not going to bring a sufficient reduction either in the price of bread or flour, but this was the only opportunity we had in the Finance Bill of making any attempt to bring about a reduction in the price of bread or of flour.
Comment on this
It is not so much a question of the Cereals Bill as the Bread Bill with which the Minister will be dealing some time later. The Minister has sat still for two years while he had in front of him on his table, or I hope somewhere near his table, a statement from the Commission which inquired into the price of flour that in the first quarter of 1934 the millers made unreasonable profits to the extent of £34,640. Nothing has happened since. It would be some kind of a sign that the Government were going to operate their Bread Prices Fixing Bill in a way that would bring down prices, rather than raise them, if they took this 6d. per cwt. off wheat coming into the country because it is the top of the dam that the Government has raised to keep up the price of flour and bread in the country. Will the Minister tell us why bread should be 10d. per 4lb. loaf in Dublin and elsewhere in this country, and 7½d. in London?
Comment on this
Wait until we get the Bread Bill. Obviously there is reason why a Bill to regulate the price of bread is going to be introduced.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that we are now about to reject an amendment calculated to remove the tax from the raw material of bread, surely the Minister might disclose to us how he proposes to reduce the price of bread.
Comment on this
The Minister might tell us that in view of the fact that the increased price of bread has been brought about by the Minister's colleague in the increased price of flour. It seems extraordinary to increase the price of bread by one piece of legislation and then for Ministers to come forward, looking like whitened sepulchres, saying we are going to take means whereby we will reduce the price of bread. There are only two ways by which the price of bread can be reduced; one is to reduce the impost on flour and the other is to subsidise the production of bread. One wants to understand the bread trade to get at prices accurately. When we speak of 5d. we must remember that the producer sells bread at 5d. less the retailers' discount, which fluctuates between 10 and 15 per cent.
Comment on this
I want to direct attention to the price of bread and the price of flour, particularly for the benefit of Deputy Tom Kelly. I believe by calling attention here now, and as I did on the earlier stages of the Finance Bill, to the Bread (Control of Prices) Bill, Deputy Tom Kelly will discover that there is a nigger in the wood pile, somewhere, and, having directed his mind to that fact, I will undertake to show where the nigger is, and I do not think that Deputy Kelly will have to strain his eyes very much to find him.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 28:—
Before Section 14 to insert a new section as follows:—
The Finance Act, 1935 (No. 28 of 1935) shall be and is hereby amended by the deletion in the First Schedule of reference No. 25, and all references thereto in columns 2, 3 and 4.
I move this amendment for the purpose of ascertaining from the Minister the amount of additional employment given as a result of this tariff in the prayer-book industry and to what extent further production of prayer books and missals has taken place, in view of certain Press complaints made recently as to the application of the tariff to certain classes of books of a cheap kind which are not being printed here. I should also like to know whether any use is being made of the licensing provision with regard to this duty.
Comment on this
I cannot say what extra employment has been given by this duty, but the Deputy may take it that it is small. The duty was imposed following a report of the Tariff Commission and it was designed to ease the situation in respect of unemployment in the bookbinding trade. Some classes of religious books are printed and bound here, but whenever there is any difficulty in getting religious books of the kind to which the duty applies, the licensing provision is being used to allow in the printed sheets, free of duty, to be bound here. I do not think it is correct to say that any difficulty has been experienced in procuring the cheaper class of books. A number of the cheaper classes of books—books which sell about 2d. each —are both printed and bound here. It was probably in connection with the dearer classes of books that difficulty was experienced. The duty is not one of great importance, but I do not think it is one which should be removed. The bookbinding industry in the Saorstát was, at one time, quite considerable. It has declined very much, due to a number of causes. It has probably declined in all countries. The result was that a large number of really skilled bookbinders were unemployed. Although this tax has not done much to lessen that unemployployment, it has relieved it to some extent, and I do not think it can be said, against it, that it has caused much inconvenience. Therefore, I am in favour of maintaining it.
Comment on this
Do I understand that licences to import free of duty are given only in isolated cases, in which definite application is made and that nothing has been done to systematise the giving of licences in respect of a particular range of books or publications not produced here?
Comment on this
There are certain classes of religious books the quantities of which required in any one year are so small that it would not be practicable to have them printed here. In respect of this class of books, licences to import the sheets free of duty are given. The binding of them can be done here quite well.
Comment on this
Except on individual application for particular classes of books which cannot be printed or bound here.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:—
Before Section 14 to insert a new section as follows:—
The Finance Act, 1935 (No. 28 of 1935) shall be and is hereby amended by the deletion of, in Part I, Second Schedule, reference No. 2, and all references thereto in columns 2 and 3.
This amendment deals with customs duty of 6d. per yard on linoleum, without any provision for licensing. It has, in fact, come to be a revenue tariff. The statement made at the time was that it was intended to set up a factory for the manufacture here of linoleum. I should like to know what progress has been made in that connection. Again, I should like to point out that the tariff is purely a revenue tariff and, as was pointed out before, bears unequally on the working-classes who buy the cheaper class of linoleum. Linoleum imported at 7/6 per yard bears a customs duty of 6d. while linoleum imported at 1/- a yard bears the same duty of 6d. That is inequitable.
Comment on this
There is a factory now working which is producing linoleum in sufficient quantities to supply all the requirements of the country, with the exception of certain very expensive classes of linoleum on which this duty of 6d. is not of great importance. The factory is located in Tipperary and employs a considerable number of men.
Comment on this
I cannot say the exact number, but it is over 50. They are all men and, consequently, the industry is of considerable importance to that town. It is probable that some expansion of that industry will take place but, even as it stands, it is now in an unimportant industry. It is now in full production and able to supply all the country's requirements in linoleum.
Comment on this
That is a situation which rather alarms me. If the Minister says he has induced somebody to establish a factory in Tipperary which employs over 50 persons and which, on that basis, is capable of supplying all the linoleum requirements of the country at the present time, then I think he has done a very imprudent thing. At present, there is a terrific amount of building going on and if the Minister studies the output of the big linoleum factories in Great Britain, he will find that the experience there bears out my contention. If you are going to establish a factory with a capacity to supply an inflated demand for linoleum at present, when we get back to normal the capacity of that factory will be out of all proportion to the national requirements.
Comment on this
That is a matter for the firm. I do not think that it is likely to arise for a long time to come.
Comment on this
When the State interferes in trade the State must accept a certain liability for the result of its own actions. If the State induced a number of men to go into the production of a commodity which ceased to be used, it would not be enough for the Minister to say that that was a matter for the people who went into such production. If they went into it at his express suggestion, they would be entitled to turn to the Minister and say that the business had completely evaporated, that they had lost their money, and ask him what he was going to do about it. Is the Minister prepared to stand by the statement that the factory in Tipperary is capable of supplying all our present requirements?
Comment on this
If it is, then it is floated on an altogether inflated estimate of the normal requirements of this country in respect of linoleum. When the housing boom is finished and a sufficient number of houses built to accommodate the population, the demand must inevitably fall substantially and then you would have a very undesirable situation developing. I have not as yet had an opportunity of seeing samples of the Tipperary product. I hope I soon will. I know nothing about the quality and am not in a position to tell the House anything about the Tipperary product, but I sincerely trust that the factory has not been founded on the basis of supplying the present demand which, in view of the abnormal activity in house-building, can only be temporary.
Comment on this
I take it, then, that the Minister did not discuss that aspect of the question with those who ought to know, because he must remember that this is completely a monopoly.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 30:—
Before Section 14 to insert a new section as follows:—
The Finance Act, 1935 (No. 28 of 1935) shall be and is hereby amended by the deletion of, in Part I, Second Schedule, Reference No. 3, and all references thereto in columns 2 and 3.
In regard to this amendment, I would put the same case to the Minister.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 31:—
Before Section 14 to insert a new section as follows:—
The Finance Act, 1935 (No. 28 of 1935) shall be and is hereby amended by the deletion in Part II, Second Schedule, of Reference No. 16, and all references thereto in columns 2 and 3.
This is purely a revenue duty and I would like to ask the Minister, after 12 months' experience of the duty as a revenue duty, if he would make some attempt to justify it. It does seem an extraordinary thing to follow the worker into his house. We have been discussing the effect on the workers of the taxation imposed on them. Last year there were £2,000,000 more taken in customs duty than in the year 1931-32. One of the last things that the Revenue people did in scraping up the various amounts that went to make up that £2,000,000 was to enter the house of the workingman and put 5 per cent of a tariff on wallpaper as a whole. I would like now to hear the Minister make any attempt to justify that after 12 months' experience.
Comment on this
For the sake of £3,500 is it worth going to all the trouble of collecting this revenue?
Comment on this
I would put this point to the Minister—wallpaper is bought in very small quantities. It is sometimes bought to match the paper that people have already bought but of which they did not get enough. The inconvenience that is caused in the collection of this revenue is out of all proportion to the amount of the revenue collected. Furthermore, I think the Revenue authorities will tell the Minister that the class of people who go in for wallpaper are principally people who live in the poorer class of house. Wallpaper has gone out of fashion for the purpose of interior decoration. Wallpaper is only used now in labourers' cottages and small rural houses. It is confined almost exclusively to these. I put it to the Minister that a revenue of £3,500 cannot justify the trouble to the customs authorities, to the merchants importing the paper, or to the people who use the wallpaper. I suggest to the Minister that the sensible thing to do would be to drop this tariff. It is helping nobody and the time and trouble expended on collecting it are almost as much as the tax is worth.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister is not working so close to the pin of his collar as to plead that the loss of this £3,500 would upset his Budget.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
Before Section 14 to insert a new section as follows:—
The Finance Act, 1935 (No. 28 of 1935) shall be and is hereby amended by the deletion in Part I, Second Schedule, of Reference No. 6, and all references thereto in columns 2 and 3.
The tax that this amendment touches is even worse than the wallpaper tax. This is one of the cases where the Government went round to discover on what they could put additional taxation and as a result of that investigation they put on a tax of 2/- a cwt. on rice. The Minister for Finance indicated to us last night that if he had to give certain income tax reliefs in connection with the education of children that it would be the working classes who would have to pay for it. Two Ministers have indicated that it is to the working classes that the Minister for Finance has had to go to bear the greater part of his Budget burdens. After 12 months' experience of this tax of 2/- a cwt. on rice I ask the Minister for Finance what he took in revenue on rice, and whether since it was put on he has not got the figures of the amount collected with a view to dropping it this year.
Comment on this
It is about £8,000. That is all from raw rice. I do not believe there is any rice-flour paying a revenue duty because that is being manufactured here.
Comment on this
This tax is put on rice which is very often the main type of pudding that is used in certain class families and it is on this the Minister puts a tax of £8,000.
Comment on this
It is an index of the extraordinary condition to which the finances of the country and the country itself are reduced.
Comment on this
Does the Minister for Finance adopt the view of the Minister for Education that it is time that the poor paid their share of the taxation? This is the kind of tax that is designed to soak the poor. When you work this down to the individual rice pudding the extra cost of the individual rice pudding is infinitesimal and that is the real argument that weighed with the Government in imposing this tax. It is a case of shifting the tax from the rich to the poor. It is the sort of tax that every Tory Government in Europe tried to impose.
Comment on this
If the Government, by their maladministration of the affairs of the country have acted in such a way as to make it necessary for them to abandon the hope of getting any more taxation out of the rich and if they are then driven to this inequitable taxation of the poor, that reflects very gravely upon the Minister and the Government. We have the Minister for Education now saying that the policy of Fianna Fáil is that the poor ought to be made pay their share. That is the philosophy of every Tory Government in Europe and it always has been the policy of the skilful Minister for Finance in every Tory Government that ever existed. They have always contrived to impose a tax that will gather, from people of modest means, revenue for the exchequer without taking much out of the individual pocket at any given time.
Comment on this
I think the Minister, in his new-found dignity, is becoming detached from those people who used to be his and my neighbours when he and I lived on the north side of the city, both of us living in areas surrounded by the poor.
Comment on this
I do not know whether it was because of that the Minister moved, or because he is getting grand. I suppose the purlieus of Capel Street or George's Street are no longer consistent with the dignity of a Minister of the Crown.
Comment on this
In the good old days rice was consumed in the tenement houses of Capel Street and George's Street by persons who might be properly described as our neighbours and in the circumstances in which they live I do not think the Minister would say that 2/- per cwt. put on rice represented only 1d. per year to a family of five or six people. I do not think it represents much. As a matter of fact, it represents very little per family, but it is a pernicious form of taxation designed to extract revenue out of the poor, designed to carry into effect the Minister for Education's view, that the poor ought to be made to pay. The British Chancellor of the Exchequer has the same view. He thinks that it is high time that the poor were made to pay their share. In fact, he says they feel they will be honoured in undertaking their part of the burden. There was never a Tory Chancellor of the Exchequer who did not think so.
Comment on this
The Chair checked me for irrelevance. If the Chair will allow me to spread out into the question of old age pensions and social questions, this debate on rice will become rather diffuse.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance is greatly daring. Far be it from me to liken him to a frog, but there may be some in this House who would jump at the simile. Let us leave the frog and old age pensions and concentrate on rice. I want to ask the Minister does he share with the Chancellor of the Exchequer of Great Britain the view that the poor ought to be proud of the opportunity of bearing their share of taxation? I do not accept the philosophy, and I shall be glad to know if the Minister for Finance does.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I intend to leave the next amendment until Deputy Costello is here. It affects workers.
Comment on this
The people who make them. I should like to give an opportunity to the Minister to hear about it from somebody else.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 33 on behalf of Deputy Costello:
Before Section 14 to insert a new section as follows:—
The Finance Act, 1935 (No. 28 of 1935) shall be and is hereby amended by the deletion in Part VI of the Eighth Schedule of reference No. 16 and all references thereto in columns 2, 3 and 4.
This is a matter which I think is very pertinent. This is exactly the same kind of tariff as the tariff that was put upon curry powders. It is going to do nobody any good but it is going to cause a great many persons considerable annoyance.
Comment on this
The fact is, so far as I am aware, that a number of persons get a modest income from making up golf clubs for individuals. It affects very few people, but certain people like to have golf clubs made in that way.
Comment on this
This proposal applies, so far as I am aware, not only to golf clubs but to component parts thereof.
Comment on this
I am informed that it is the practice to import the heads of golf clubs and the component parts thereof, and get them made up by individual craftsmen in this country. The result of stopping that practice is going to benefit nobody.
Comment on this
If you tax the component parts, the persons who assemble these parts here cannot import them. The Minister may not know it, but the fact is that certain persons ply the trade of importing parts and assembling them here.
Comment on this
The Minister may not know it, but I am informed that this is going to result in considerable hardship on individuals, (1) the class who like to have golf clubs made in that way, and (2) an infinitesimal class who do the business of assembly. As I say, it does not make much difference one way or the other, except that it is going to annoy those particular persons who have that peculiarity, just as the curry powder tax is going to do nothing but annoy the tiny section of the community who like to import curry powder that is made by some particular craftsmen in some particular part of the world.
Comment on this
Both Ministers have developed to perfection the bureaucratic mind. They conceive themselves to be entitled to interfere with the daily life of any citizen, and to make no apology for it. In fact, the grand old gospel of the eggs and the omelettes is preached again. We had the President proclaiming the doctrine that you cannot have omelettes without breaking eggs.
Comment on this
On this occasion the eggs are a few individuals; on other occasions, the eggs are a considerable class of persons. Ministers feel themselves entitled, being bureaucratically-minded, to break into anybody's home and put inconvenience upon him, simply because it suits the whim of the moment. This tax on the component parts of golf clubs is just a silly whim of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Somebody came to him and said, "You ought to put it on," and he said, "The logical thing is to put it on; they can be made here and, therefore, to be logical I must put on a tariff."
Comment on this
This tariff will not help the manufacture of component parts here a bit. It is not going to mean increased employment for one individual.
Comment on this
This tax is not going to put one extra man into employment in any one of these four firms.
Comment on this
It is annoying people, and will further annoy them when they cannot get the parts brought in.
Comment on this
The component parts of the finished article are always held by the Revenue Commissioners to be partially manufactured.
Comment on this
This is not so simple and should not be taken so lightheartedly as the Ministers take it. I should like the Minister to hear Deputy Costello on the matter. There was a 50 per cent. tariff put on golf clubs in the Finance Act of 1934, and that helped a rather widespread class of people engaged as golf professionals and assistant professionals in various golf clubs. They had already done a very considerable amount of the manufacture of golf clubs, if the assembling of various parts and the carrying out of certain additional work on the shafts and on the wooden club heads is taken into consideration. The 50 per cent. that was put on in the Finance Act of 1934 assisted golf professionals very much, but the tariff that was put on in the Finance Act, 1935, on component parts, has done a very considerable amount of damage to the manufacturing work of golf professionals. I heard of one particular case where a professional gave an order to one of the companies that the Minister speaks about for some iron heads. When they were supplied he found that they were bored in a manner that was entirely out of date. I believe he refused to take delivery of them. Would the Minister say if he has made any examination as to the type of iron heads that are being produced. Has he had any consultations with anybody representing golf club professionals, all of whom manufacture clubs and assemble clubs? Has he received any complaints from those who are assembling golf clubs in the country and producing the finished article? I, personally, have heard very general complaints. The Minister says that there are four firms engaged in this particular class of work. Would he give the House some idea as to the amount of employment they are providing?
Comment on this
With regard to the Deputy's last point, I do not think that I have any figures. There are these four firms manufacturing golf clubs in the country. The market is not very large, but, so far as I know, they are producing in sufficient varieties golf clubs to supply all requirements. It is true that there are golf professionals who like to be able to buy any new type of club that is advertised because there is a certain number of golfers who insist on buying a new set of clubs every time that a new brand of club is put on the market in the belief that, if they possess it, it is going to improve their golf. That type of trade for golf professionals is, no doubt, restricted. But there are varieties of clubs being produced and, so far as I know, the alteration of the duty has not had any adverse affect on golf professionals. What had an adverse affect on them was the development in production by ordinary sports firms before the change was made, when the shaft and head were brought in separately and put together, and clubs were sold by sports outfitters and other traders. That development in the sale of golf clubs has, undoubtedly, affected golf professionals. It would have affected them in any event. In the past, of course, almost every golfer bought his clubs from the club professional but, in recent years, the mass production of clubs sold through sports outfitters has interfered with that position. That position was not in any way altered by the original duty. It has been, to some extent, altered by the subsequent duty but, again, not to any great extent. There is still a very substantial sale of clubs through golf professionals and the ordinary sports outfitters.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 34:
Before Section 14 to insert a new section as follows:—
The Cement Act, 1933 (No. 17 of 1933) shall be and is hereby amended by the deletion of Section 36.
The object of the amendment is to try to get some light on the great mystery of cement. This matter has been raised by way of Parliamentary Question on a number of occasions since November last. I have already drawn the attention of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to the fact that between November, 1935, and the beginning of February, 1936, the price of cement sold in the City of Dublin went up from 38/- to 44/- a ton, an increase of 6/- per ton in that period. The Minister, in a Parliamentary answer, has indicated that there was no reflex of that disclosed in the import price of cement. He has given the average price of cement imported in November, 1935, at 25/7 per ton, and for January, 1936, the price quoted by him is 26/3 per ton. That represents an increase in the import price of cement of 8d. per ton. But here in the City of Dublin, in that three months' period, cement had gone up by 6/- per ton, and I understand by 5/- per ton in various parts of the country. I have before me a notification addressed to a builder in Galway from a cement selling firm in the City of Dublin. It is dated 18th June, 1936, and it states:—
"We are compelled to advance the price of British cement by 8/6 per ton from this date, as the manufacturers have increased their price to us by this amount. The price of Continental cement remains unchanged at the moment, but we are daily expecting notification of an increase in the price of this also."
That, apparently, refers to an increase in the import price that is about to take place during the month of June. There was no increase in the import price of cement from February to May. As a matter of fact, the average import price of cement in February was 27/7 per ton and in May 26/11, so that there was a reduction of 8d. per ton, as the figures that we get from the Minister and from the trade returns show. If we have the position that, for some reason which I hope the Minister will be able to explain, the price of cement advanced from 38/- to 44/- per ton in February last, that it is now going to be advanced by another 8/6 per ton in respect of British cement and by some unknown amount in the case of Continental cement, my argument is that a situation has been arrived at comparable to the coal situation. Therefore, I submit that the 5/- a ton which the Minister is charging in respect of the import of cement should be dropped. If another 8/6 is to go on to the price of British cement, it means that within a few months the price of cement here will have been increased by 14/6 a ton. In view of what all that means to the building work that is going on in the country, and because of the way in which we are dependent on building to give employment, my case is that the 5/- in respect of licence fees should come off.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not merely moving to eliminate the licence fee, he is moving to repeal the section of the Act under which it is imposed, and that is something which could not be agreed to. The question of the licence fee is always an open question. I do not think that we would be justified at the moment in coming to any decision about it. The whole situation is an utterly abnormal one, due to the strike at the port of Antwerp and to the rather unusual cement situation existing in Great Britain. At some stage the question of the amount of the fee may have to be considered, but I certainly could not agree to delete the section of the Act which authorises the imposition of the fee, because that was designed for a particular purpose.
There were two objects to be achieved by it. The first arose out of the fact that when the Act was passed the price of cement here was abnormally low. It was by far the lowest price prevailing in any European country of which I know, and that was due to the fact that, whereas the cement market all over Europe was controlled by cartels, this market was free and the various producers were in competition, with the result that the price of cement was very low, much lower than we could hope to make it on any economic basis. The Act provided for the establishment of factories to make it, and we contemplated stepping up the price of cement from the price then prevailing to the price at which it would be available when Irish factories were in operation, with benefit to the Exchequer and in a manner which would prevent any sudden dislocation in cement prices. Secondly, there was the reason that the total amount of cement to be produced here will be less than present requirements, and it would be undesirable that there should be any difference in price between the imported cement and the home-produced cement.
The power to impose a fee— variable from time to time—or, under other circumstances variable in respect of country of origin or from port to port was obtained in order to prevent any such difference in price between imported and home-produced cement arising. That was the idea of having that power and it is desirable to retain that power. The situation in respect of the price of imported cement has changed considerably since that Act was passed. The reference which the Deputy read to the price of British cement being increased by 8/6 a ton is only of academic interest, because the situation which led to the repeal of the quota order in respect of cement and the cancellation of the arrangement under which we agreed to purchase a certain quantity of cement from Great Britain was that British cement producers were not interested in selling cement at the prices prevailing here. There is apparently something like a cement famine in Great Britain and, at the moment, very high prices for cement are ruling there. Having regard to the demands and the prices, the British exporters were not interested in sending cement to this market at all.
On the other hand, there was a temporary difficulty in relation to Continental supplies, arising out of the Belgian port workers' strike. That situation is over now and Continental supplies will be again available. The situation under which the various Continental manufacturers were in competition with each other in this market appears to have ended. The Danish. German and Belgian cement cartels have come to some understanding which will prevent them competing in respect to prices here and, therefore, the price of Continental cement has been moving upwards and may continue to do so.
The relation between the price at which cement can be imported and the price at which it can be manufactured here is very different to what it was when the Cement Act was introduced. We can make cement here as economically as they can make it in any coun try, and the cement factories that will be established here will be as up-to date and as well directed as cement factories in any country and, consequently, there will be no uneconomic element whatever in the price of Irish cement. We may well get to the situation when the price of Irish cement will be lower than the price at which cement will be imported, if the abnormal circumstances now prevailing in the cement market continue, but it is unlikely that they will.
However, it is clear that we should retain this power in order to ensure that any difference between the price of imported cement and the price of home-produced cement will be secured for the benefit of the Exchequer, because if it is not so secured it will not go to the consumer. The standard price will be the price of the Irish product which will be supplied in far larger quantities than cement that will be imported, and consequently that section should be retained even though the situation in respect of the fee will vary from time to time, and the fee will fluctuate from time to time. It was never contemplated that we would fix a fee at one amount and keep it at that amount; it was always intended that it would vary as circumstances in the cement market varied and even as they varied in exceptional circumstances from port to port or in respect of the country of origin of the imported cement.
The amendment moved by Deputy Mulcahy must, therefore, be resisted, but in resisting it I am indicating that while the existing fee will be maintained for some time and could not be changed until a clearer view of the future of cement prices is obtainable, and while the Budget has been prepared on the basis of a particular revenue from that source, a revenue which must be secured, nevertheless there is no reason to assume that the fee cannot be changed as circumstances change during the period between this and the commencement of the production of the new factories to be built. When the new factories are built the fee will be varied in relation to two figures, whereas it is now only varied in relation to one figure, and will be designed for the purpose of ensuring that imported cement will be sold to consumers at the same price as Irish-produced cement.
Comment on this
The Minister, when he first spoke, seemed to me to have made up his mind that he was going to reduce the licence fee on cement, but I am afraid as he went on his heart appeared to harden. The deletion of the section, I think, was not intended— it was merely to obtain an expression of opinion as to whether the 5/- tax was now justified. The Minister for Finance suggested to us on this side that we should ask Parliamentary Questions and that, of course, if we put down Parliamentary Questions everything would be well. A few days ago I addressed a question to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and it was as follows:—
"To ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce if it is intended to enforce the quota of British cement for the Second Quota Period; if he will state if the present price of British cement has had any effect on the allotted quota, or has one-third of our total cement requirements to be taken irrespective of what is the cost of this commodity."
The Minister replied:—
"Steps are being taken to revoke the quota order regulating the importation of cement."
Now, I would like to ask the Minister where that leaves us, because, as a trade, I do not think we know exactly where we stand.
Comment on this
The proposal before the House is in relation to a section which gives the Minister power to charge a fee. There is nothing in it about quotas or anything of that sort.
Comment on this
Some of the amendments tabled to this Bill purport to delete sections of a previous Finance Act. About the admissibility of such amendments the Chair had no doubts. Amendment No. 34, however, aims at repealing or annulling a section of a Cement Act. That section had apparently a double purpose. The Deputy was, in the opinion of the Chair, entitled to propose to annul the portion that related to a licence fee, seeing that the fee is revenue. Beyond that the Deputy could not go. The Chair took it that the purpose of the Deputy was to elicit information, and allowed the amendment. Deputy Dockrell, however, has departed from this amendment and proceeded to discuss quotas. That is a question for the Minister for Industry and Commerce and is not relevant to the Finance Bill.
Comment on this
With all due respect to your ruling, Sir, there are two duties on cement. There is a 5/- duty which Deputy Mulcahy has moved to delete. There is also another duty on cement, namely, the 20 per cent. ad valorem duty, reduced to 10 per cent.——
Comment on this
If this amendment is passed it will naturally reduce the price of cement to the consumer. As to the other duties, as a matter of fact I do not think most people know just in what position they are.
Comment on this
If there is a duty of 20 per cent. On cement that duty is onerous. But if there is a duty of 20 per cent. on cement, plus a duty of 5/-, the duty of 20 per cent. is all the more onerous. Therefore, we have to discuss the two duties on the one commodity when dealing with either, in order to direct the attention of the House to the fact that we are not asking to have cement made free of all duty; that it is already bearing a heavy duty, and that we only advocate the removal of the 5/- in view of the fact that cement is already carrying the additional heavy duty to which Deputy Dockrell makes passing reference.
Comment on this
Not merely that, Sir, but may I point out that Deputy Dockrell has not addressed himself to the question of duties. He has been dealing solely with the question of quotas, and with the reply to a question relating to quotas which he asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
The question is wrapped up with the price of cement. Of course, I will bow to your ruling, but what I wish to point out to you before you express a definite ruling on the matter is that Deputy Mulcahy wishes to do away with the 5/- duty on cement. I have started by pointing out to the Minister that I have asked for information on the question of cement. If the Minister had borne with me I would have gone on to show that as far as the 20 per cent. emergency duty—reduced to 10 per cent.—is concerned, some people are rather doubtful as to whether it has been put back again by the putting away of this quota. The quota for British cement has been done away with. Apparently that leaves us as we were, but some people — myself amongst that number—want to find out how far we are affected by the alteration of this quota. I am afraid I intended also to refer to the coal-cattle pact, of which cement formed a part, and as a result of which the duty was reduced from 20 per cent. to 10 per cent. If you wish to rule, Sir, that I am out of order, under a motion to do away with a duty of 5/- on cement, in referring to other duties on cement which are imposed by the Government, and imposed in my opinion in quite a wrong way, of course I will bow to your ruling, but I wish to ask you for a definite ruling.
Comment on this
The reason why I referred to the quota question was because it leads up to the other. I merely wished to read out that question and point out to the Minister that I had proceeded in the manner laid down by him for discussing the Budget amendment. He said that in that way we would obtain the maximum of information. People in the cement trade do not know where they stand. I intended to refer only very briefly to the coal-cattle pact.
Comment on this
May I again point out that the purpose of this amendment is to amend the Cement Act by depriving the Minister of power to charge a fee, and that consequently a whole discussion on the cement business would not, I suggest, be in order.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy inform the Chair what section of this Bill imposes the duties to which he refers?
Comment on this
They would be the emergency regulations on cement which were altered on 18th February of this year.
Comment on this
On a point of order, that would be a relevant question under the old procedure, but under modern procedure we do not impose tariffs in the Finance Act. We impose tariffs by an Emergency (Imposition of Duties) Order. They never come before the House in a Finance Bill, and you cannot amend the Finance Bill to delete them. The only way you can come at them is by raising the question on the Finance Bill by an amendment of this kind, and then referring to the duties which were imposed by Emergency (Imposition of Duties) Order and subsequently confirmed by Statute, which in my respectful submission under the rules of order of this House ought to be looked upon as addenda to the Finance Bill which is introduced at the end of the financial year.
Comment on this
The Deputy has made a statement which of course is not based on the facts. The Emergency Order in question has already been before the House and been confirmed by Statute of the House. All this question of cement and the coal-cattle pact which Deputy Dockrell proposes to deal with has already been discussed by the House and decided upon.
Comment on this
The Minister takes that view, apparently on the grounds that the Minister for Industry and Commerce answered the question a couple of days ago. I do not know where the quota, the licence and the emergency duty, begin and end. They are absolutely interlocked. Before you can get a ton of cement you have to pay your licence fee of 5/-. Before the cement comes in you have to pay your ad ralorem duty of 10 per cent. The Minister has made certain quota orders, and then told me that they are done away with.
Comment on this
By the Minister for Industry and Commerce, administering an Act passed by this House. That Act is not under review now except in so far as affected by Deputy Mulcahy's amendment, that is to a very limited extent of the annulment of a fee. It is just the point that I put a few minutes since. The House is not entitled to advocate the annulment of any Act or portion thereof unless it operates to bring in revenue. Licence fees on cement do contribute to revenue. The matter to which the Deputy has just referred could not be brought within the scope of amendment No. 34.
Comment on this
No, but surely when we are arguing that a certain burden of taxation should be lifted off a certain commodity, we may go on to say that while we admit that a case may be made against us, if that commodity carried no other burden, we want to direct the attention of the House to the fact that this commodity is already bearing several other burdens. Now you will, likely, ask what has the quota got to do with it. It has this got to do with it: that there is an emergency imposition duty put on Continental cement, but not on British cement, and the quota order compels us to buy so much British cement, thus forcing us to pay so much to the Minister, and forcing us to bear the burden of whatever may be the increased cost of the British cement, and we have got to direct the attention of the House to the fact that the forcing of this country to buy cement, which carries an emergency imposition of duties tax, has been made the reason for advancing the cost of both classes of cement in this country.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon's argument, though quite logical, is not valid. The amendment before the House is limited to one small point, and surely the Deputy would not argue that he is entitled, on that amendment, to discuss duties in general?
Comment on this
No, Sir—except in so far as we can satisfy the Chair that these duties are being used as revenue-raising devices, and only in so far as we can satisfy the Chair that that is being done.
Comment on this
You, Sir, seem to have some difficulty in thinking that I am discussing the Cement Act. I do not wish to discuss it. Deputy Mulcahy moved his amendment, and the Minister replied, and I regretted that he could not reduce the price of the licence fee. What I do wish to discuss, however, is the price of cement in reference to the action taken by the Government.
Comment on this
Sir, this amendment is designed to prevent the Minister from continuing to levy any licence fee on the import of cement, and it is right for the House to remember that a licence fee is simply a new name invented by the Fianna Fáil Government to cover up the time-honoured description of a tariff. In this case, this extraordinary power has been conferred on the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that, without any reference to the House, so far as I am aware, he can fix any tariff he likes on the import of cement by fixing the import price of cement per ton. Our case is that, although a defence might be made for this imposition along the lines suggested by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, what we complain of is that this licensing provision, which contains the power to exact a fee, is used contemporaneously with other Acts through which additional taxes are placed on imports of cement, and we feel that we are entitled, when discussing this specific figure of 5/- per ton, to ask the Minister for Finance to explain to us what is the exact position of imported cement, at the moment, taking into consideration the various measures which he, or his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, has operated for the purpose of raising the price of cement.
Comment on this
Very well, Sir. I want to make this case, Sir: that the cement merchants of this country are being harried by their customers on the ground that they are charging too much for cement.
Comment on this
The only relevant question subject for discussion is the question of a 5/- licence fee on cement.
Comment on this
Very well, Sir. I want to know will the Minister afford those cement vendors, who, I am satisfied, are doing their best to give cement at the lowest possible price at which they can afford to keep their houses open— under circumstances to which we cannot refer within the rules of order— some relief by reducing or abolishing the import licence fee? The Chair will probably say that this amendment was put down for the purpose more of ascertaining what would be the fee in the future than of amending the Cement Act itself, and I ask the Minister now to take into consideration the fact that cement is one of the raw materials of housing and that an increased price of cement means an increase in the price of labourers' cottages, and in the cost of practically every public work that is undertaken as a result of a vote of this House. I ask the Minister to abolish this 5/- licence fee and to do away with the whole system of licensing these imports. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has made the case that he had to have this power in order to accustom the people of this country gradually to the fact that, when cement is being manufactured in this country, it is going to be a great deal more expensive than ever before. I do not think the people will be at all grateful to him for his solicitude for their feelings in that connection. I think the attitude of the people would be that they would rather have cheap supplies, so long as they could get them, than to have to bear the burden of home-made cement when we have to bear it.
There is an old saying, that you should not bid the devil good morrow until you meet him. I can assure the devil that he is no more welcome when he does arrive, even if he is being heralded by several couriers who run in front of him. The Minister's only defence of this arrangement is that it is a kind of herald announcing the arrival of worse times when cement is manufactured here. The Minister for Industry and Commerce admitted that the burdens on cement at present are altogether excessive, and he indicated that he thought a strong case might be made for reducing the licence fee substantially. I urge the Minister for Finance to abolish it completely, and to allow the people to have the benefit of whatever the price of cement may be in the market of the world.
Comment on this
I should like to be sure of your ruling in this matter, Sir. I understand your ruling is that in reference to this 5/- we cannot refer to other duties on cement. I understand that you have also ruled against reference to the quota.
Comment on this
What I ruled on was reference to the quota or to the administration of the Cement Act, except in so far as the amendment touched it.
Comment on this
I do not wish to refer to the Cement Act, and I think I can get on without the quota when endeavouring to make my case clear. I am sure, Sir, you will call me to order if I transgress. We do not know the position in which we are left in the cement trade. There is at present a licence fee of 5/-, and there was an emergency duty of 20 per cent., but that was reduced to 10 per cent. under the coal-cattle pact, which allowed one-third of our cement requirements to the British. What I am anxious to find out is, how far all reference to cement has been taken out of the coal-cattle pact. Has the 10 per cent. gone, and are we back again to the 20 per cent.? That is one point I wish the Minister to deal with. I do not know if I can refer to the fact that taking one set of trade from one country and giving it to another, and then having to hand it back again when there is a strike, and when expenses have been increased, can only lead to increased prices.
Comment on this
And with the present duty as affected by the quota order. I do not know if the duty which was reduced to 10 per cent. can be taken as unilateral action. Perhaps that is outside the scope of this question.
Comment on this
I understood that one reason why a duty of 5/- was put on was that at the time cement could bear it, and that it was a matter of revenue. As the duty is now being continued I think it is most unfair. The Minister for Industry and Commerce stated that it was quite possible the duty would continue until the Irish factories were established. Is this a cloak to keep on the 5/- so that the Irish people and those who use cement will not get a shock by having this 5/- duty brought to their attention? The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that possibly cement could be made here as cheaply as any place else. Let there be a start made in that direction by taking off the 5/- duty. Then we can see where we are and consumers should be prepared to pay something extra for the Irish product. At the time the duty was put on in November, 1934, Continental cement was delivered in the West of Ireland for £2 2s a ton. In 1935, it was £2 7s., and in February, 1936, £2 12s. 6d. Does the Minister not consider it an injustice to keep on the 5/- duty now, seeing that he started that the duty was only put on when cement could bear it? Can cement bear the 5/- duty now that the price has gone up by 10/6 a ton? When dealing with the British cement quota Deputy Mulcahy said that there had been an increase in the price of Portland cement by 8/6 a ton since 18th June. If the Minister for Finance happens to become good friends again in the course of a month with the British and if we have a new arrangement, what will happen to the 8/6 a ton plus the duty? We were told by the Minister and by Deputies on the Government Benches that the little advance does not affect building. I know that the Minister for Finance does not know much about the building industry, but it may enlighten him to know that cement that previously cost £2 2s., delivered in the West of Ireland, now costs £3 5s. a ton.
Comment on this
I appeal to the Minister to consider this matter. The advance in prices is sufficient without having to pay the duty. The advance in the price of cement necessary to build a labourer's cottage, including the duty, represents about £10 10s. on each cottage. If the 5/- duty was taken off, there would certainly be a reduction in prices there. It is certainly most unfair to people who are paying all the time, to people who are building, to have to pay an excessive price for cement. As building work is going on on new land holdings, on labour schemes, and on out-offices, it is unfair that the duty has to be paid. The argument of the Minister for Industry and Commerce was that it was put on when cement could bear the duty. Now that it cannot bear it, it should be taken off.
Comment on this
I found when I got lorry loads of cement that one lot cost 46/6, the next lot of Portland cement 52/6, and the next day some other cement came along at a different price. Can we get British Portland cement or Continental cement as we wish?
Comment on this
The last refuge that a Parliamentary Opposition has, if a Minister declines to give information, is to divide. I admit that it wastes Parliamentary time, and it is a course that we do not wish to be taken except when absolutely necessary. Where Ministers are prepared to give full information, we have no desire to press for a division, but where they remain silent, and refuse to give justification, we will challenge a division every time.