Finance Bill, 1936—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–140 of 283. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 20 of 1936 ›
Perhaps the Minister will tell us what will be the financial effect of this section?
Comment on this
Section 7 of the Finance (Customs and Excise Duties) Act of 1933 provided for the payment of road tax at the rate of £20 in lieu of £30 in the case of a commercial vehicle which exceeded one ton but did not exceed one and a quarter tons in weight unladen, and in respect of which it was shown to the satisfaction of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that such vehicles were assembled in Saorstát Eireann in a manner and to an extent for the time being approved by the said Minister. Section 7, paragraph 5, of the same Act, provided for the payment of road tax at the maximum rate of £16 in lieu of the rate of £1 per horse power, limited in the case of private motor car vehicles in respect of which it is shown to the satisfaction of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that such vehicles were likewise assembled in Saorstát Eireann in the manner and to the extent for the time being approved by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The view is now being adopted that this concession should for the future be limited to vehicles which are not only assembled in the Saorstát to the extent required but are also to the extent required by the Minister for Industry and Commerce assembled from parts manufactured in the Saorstát. I should like in that connection to emphasise that certificates issued under the law as it existed prior to May of this year do not lose their validity and will still carry the benefit of the concession to the vehicles in respect of which they were issued as long as those vehicles are in existence. As to the financial effect of the resolution, it is not expected that the revenue derived from the road tax will be affected by it, as it is understood that manufacturers will comply with the amended law.
Comment on this
Does that mean, Sir, that a person who long doubted the commercial prudence of setting up in the motor car assembling business, and who was subsequently induced to go into that business by the representations of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, now finds himself in the position that, having equipped himself to assemble motor cars out of parts supplied from abroad, he loses all the protection by way of horse-power tax that he had enjoyed, unless the motor car manufacturer for whom he acts as assembling agent indicates his readiness to manufacture the parts in Saorstát Eireann? Let us come down to concrete cases. The Ford Motor Car Company has a great plant in Cork which can be used for manufacturing parts. There are two or three other makes of cars which have no manufacturing plant in Saorstát Eireann, but which are represented here by assembling agents. Those assembling agents have laid out very large sums of money to equip assembling plants. Are they now to find that the Ford Motor Car Company will have a substantial preference over them although they were induced to go into the business on the representation that all persons who assemble motor cars in Saorstát Eireann would be on an equal footing?
Comment on this
I should just like to say that the statement which the Deputy has made does not represent the facts. There is no person engaged in the assembly of motor cars in the Saorstát to-day who did not enter that business with his eyes open; who was not told before he undertook that assembly that as soon as Irish manufactured parts became available he would be expected to utilise them in the assembling of his cars. The section which the House is now asked to assent to gives the Minister for Industry and Commerce power to exact the fulfilment of that condition from those who engage in the assembling of motor car parts here. I have no reason to believe, as I have already indicated to the House, that there will be any difficulty in securing the fulfilment of the regulation prescribed by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in this regard. I understand, indeed, that the manufacturers have already indicated that they are willing to comply with the reasonable requirements of the Department of Industry and Commerce in this connection, and that, as I have already said, the section, therefore, will have no effect upon the revenue. There is no desire on the part of the Government, or I am sure of the House, to give a monopoly of manufacture to one firm. That is not the purpose of this section, and it will not be used in that way.
Comment on this
I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce might have attended here this morning to tell us what the facts are. Nobody on this side of the House has had any opportunity of discussing this section with interested parties.
Comment on this
I quite agree. But the Minister, of course, before taking steps in a final form radically to affect the interests of a number of merchants will have discussed this section with those interests, and he could tell us to-day what arrangements have been made to meet the Government's requirements. If it is true, as the Minister for Finance says—he disowns any expert knowledge of the matter; it is primarily a matter for the Minister for Industry and Commerce—that all the persons who are engaged in the assembling of motor cars here have made arrangements to meet the requirements of this section, well then if agreement has been arrived at between the Minister and the manufacturers my primary objection to this section falls to the ground. But I think the Minister will agree with me that it would be a very grave injustice indeed if a man had been induced to enter the assembling business, say, six months ago, and now found that as a result of this section all his arrangements were gone for nought, and that he could not comply with this section and get the same advantages that other assembling plants would enjoy.
Comment on this
The Deputy who has just sat down made use, in the course of his statement, of the phrase "if it is true." He used that phrase and emphasised it, not once but many times. I resent very much that form of address in this House. It is a reflection upon the veracity of the Minister. "If it is true," says the Deputy. Has he any reason to believe that it is not true? He has told the House that he has not heard anything from interested persons in contradiction of what I have said. This section was before the House on the 12th May last in the form of a resolution. It was, subsequently, discussed on the Report Stage. It is almost a fortnight since this Bill got its Second Reading. In the whole of that six weeks not one of the very alert business men engaged in the motor-assembling industry has come to the Deputy and asked him to challenge the section. That is the admission the Deputy has made to the House, and yet he gets up here and, when I tell him that I understand the manufacturers are prepared to comply with the requirements of the Minister for Industry and Commerce in this matter, the only criticism the Deputy can offer, the only argument or debating point that he can make, is "if what the Minister says be true." He has admitted that he has nothing in his possession which would justify him in doubting what I have said, and yet, as I say, he uses an expression here which, in the circumstances as I have detailed them to the House, I think I am entitled to resent.
Comment on this
I should like, Sir, to straighten back on his pedestal this combination of George Washington and Wolfe Tone that my colleague has shaken so badly.
Comment on this
Once back on his pedestal, I should like to ask for a little information from him. From what the Minister says, the requirements that are going to be made on the manufacturers of motor cars are going to be progressive. According as firms manufacturing parts of motor cars extend the line of parts they are manufacturing here, manufacturers of cars are going to be required, by regulations made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, to extend the use of these parts in order to become qualified for the relief under the section. From the 13th May certain requirements have been made on the manufacturers of cars. The section says:—
"... in respect of which it is shown to the satisfaction of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that such vehicle was assembled in Saorstát Eireann in a manner and to an extent for the time being approved of by the said Minister and was so assembled, either wholly or to an extent for the time being approved of by the said Minister, from parts manufactured in Saorstát Eireann ...."
I should like to ask the Minister what is the general range of parts that are available manufactured in Saorstát Eireann and which are covered by the regulations that have been brought into force and are operative from the 13th May? I think the House is entitled to hear, generally, when this change is being made, what progress has been made in the manufacture of motor car parts here—whether it is limited to a small range of the most important parts of the car, or whether it has developed in small parts even to a considerable extent.
Comment on this
I think, Sir, the House would welcome a further statement from the Minister as to what extent this section would apply. It has been the general experience of motor manufacturers that the Free State market did not warrant a manufacturing plant in the sense that it did in other places; for instance, the Ford Company ceased the manufacture of parts in Cork because it was not economic to do so. If this applies all round, it would seem that we are making for a factory which could not be economic. The House, I am sure, would welcome a further statement from the Minister as to whether his Department or the Department of Industry and Commerce is going to insist on all the parts being manufactured here or only certain of the parts that can be economically manufactured here.
Comment on this
Naturally, the Department of Industry and Commerce, in pursuance of the policy which the country has approved and which the Dáil has already sanctioned when, in 1933, it permitted us to incorporate the existing provision in the law relating to motor vehicles duties, will insist that parts which can be manufactured economically in this country will be utilised, and no others. Of course, we are not going to impose an undue burden on any section of the citizens, and I think I can say this: That notwithstanding all the opposition which the Minister for Industry and Commerce experienced here from certain quarters in this House and outside it when he embarked on this task of establishing the motor assembling industry in this country, everyone to-day in the country is satisfied with the result of the Minister's efforts.
Comment on this
I really feel that it would be of material assistance, not only to the House, but to all interested in the business generally, if the Minister for Industry and Commerce would make a short statement clarifying exactly what the position will be under two heads: one, the comparative position of the different types of motor assembling; that is to say, those who have factories capable of manufacturing parts in Saorstát Eireann, and two, those who act exclusively as assembling agents of motor cars manufactured in Great Britain or in the United States of America. We are all aware that, very recently, two or three new models of cars have been put on the market here in Saorstát Eireann from Germany, the United States, and Great Britain. Whether these assemblers will have any facilities whatever for getting parts, suitable for their cars, manufactured in Saorstát Eireann is something that we know nothing about.
Comment on this
The Minister will understand that the situation is that we asked, when the section first came to be dealt with, for an explanatory statement. The position was not made quite clear, and perhaps the Minister can anticipate much of our inquiry, if he would make a short statement on the matter now.
Comment on this
I think a very lucid explanation was given. Under the existing law this concession is given in respect of cars which are assembled, to the degree prescribed, in the Saorstát. The effect of this section is to require that they should be both assembled and manufactured or assembled from parts manufactured as may be prescribed. In so far as commercial vehicles are concerned, there is no difficulty in having bodies for them manufactured here. They were manufactured here before they were assembled. As far as the bodies are concerned, the intention is to ensure that the bodies will be manufactured here.
Comment on this
Yes. We have not yet got to the stage of manufacturing the chassis, but we will in due course. In so far as private cars are concerned the various parts the use of which are prescribed, are manufactured independently of any assembly firm and are available to all.
Comment on this
Then we are to understand that this section does not apply to private cars or hackney cars.
Comment on this
Does any part of the Bill empower the Minister to require that parts of hackney cars will be manufactured here?
Comment on this
When the Minister first embarked on this scheme we all know that one firm, the Ford Company, which had behind it a factory in Cork, manufactured here.
Comment on this
Certain parts could be manufactured by the Ford Company in Cork. There was a long pause then during which a number of other motor assemblers or car agents did not go into the assembly business at all. They were strongly pressed by the Minister to get into the assembly business. He let it be known that if they would not do so he was prepared to ask the Dáil to take steps to eliminate their cars. Then these agents laid out large sums of money in the equipment of assembly plants, on the understanding that they would be put on the same footing as anyone else assembling cars here. Having invested large capital in these assembly plants, I want to know if this section empowers the Minister to make further regulations, which might operate to give a material advantage to an assembler who had behind him a factory in the Saorstát which was adaptable to the manufacture of chassis parts.
Comment on this
Long before the Minister's name was heard of in politics the Ford factory in Cork was manufacturing tractors from the first nut to the finished tractor. A factory capable of doing that is capable of adaptation for the manufacture of any standard parts.
Comment on this
I know that. If the Minister makes regulations requiring any person who wants the advantage conferred by previous Finance Acts, to which the Minister for Finance referred, on those assembling parts manufactured in Saorstát Eireann, the Ford Company can produce these parts. But the Adler, the Morris, the Austin, the Studebaker and the Packard people are not in a position to manufacture in Saorstát Eireann individual parts required for assembly, but they have been induced by the Minister to lay out large sums of money on the establishment of assembly plants, on the understanding, I suggest, that if they were prepared to assemble they would not be required to manufacture chassis parts in this country. Is it the Minister's intention to go back on that implict undertaking, and to differentiate again between the different assembly firms who are engaged in the motor assembly business?
Comment on this
I only want to say that there was no understanding given anyone as to the degree of assembly that would be required.
Comment on this
My intention is to require the use of Saorstát parts, if available. If the Deputy knew the first thing about the business he would know that.
Comment on this
Because it is my business to find out what the Minister's intentions are, and I have every intention of finding out the last word about this. It is 11 o'clock now and if Ministers are going to take up that attitude they will not get the Committee Stage this morning. If they are prepared to give information the business can go on expeditiously.
Comment on this
It is the business of the Opposition to obstruct vigorously until they get information. If Ministers give information we hope to cooperate with them.
Comment on this
Supposing the Minister's attention is directed to the fact that certain makers of cars cannot incorporate in their chassis standard springs and parts, what is the position? Let me repeat that I have had no contact with any motor car company. There are certain makes of car which have a forward drive and certain makes which have a rear wheel drive. Will cars which have a unique form of driving be able to use standard parts that other makes of cars, all of which have the same kind of drive, can use?
Comment on this
The Deputy can be certain that the regulations will not require any firm to use parts if such parts are not manufactured here.
Comment on this
What is the position if the Minister wants them to use springs of Irish manufacture and they cannot get them? He cannot discriminate between different motor assembly plants.
Comment on this
So the Minister will not order the use of any parts in the assembling of motor cars unless he is satisfied a suitable unit is made for every make of car assembled here.
Comment on this
Unless we are satisfied it is a practicable proposition, and that the parts required to be used are made here.
Comment on this
The coach building industry when the Ford factory was working to a greater extent than it is now had a very big annual wage pool. In 1933 it paid £90,000, and in 1934 £150,000 indicating that there was an increase of £60,000. Between 1933 and 1934, however, the figures disclosed that there had been a falling off in the average wage paid to workers from £125 to £108. I do not know whether the manufacture of general motor parts is included in the returns for coach-building or if it is included in the engineering and implement returns.
Comment on this
If so, in the engineering and implement returns there is a more substantial decline in the average wages paid to workers in the coach-building trade. The amount has gone down by about £27, according to the returns for 1933 compared with those for 1931. I should like to know from the Minister if he had any consultation with the motor car manufacturers on the question of wages, if the apparent fall in wages has been discussed in any way, and whether the proposals now made are likely to increase the cost of cars produced. The position requires a certain amount of investigation, when the Minister is, by further regulation, endeavouring to increase the amount of productive work in connection with the motor car industry. I submit that he might find out why wages are tending to fall and whether the development he is considering now is going to raise costs.
Comment on this
I am not aware that there is any tendency of wages to fall, and I feel sure that any figures supplied to the Deputy will not show that. I think the Deputy is making the same mistake that he made on other occasions. He is dividing the number of persons employed in October in the years in which the Census of Production is taken with the amount of wages paid for the whole year. Obviously the average wage figure which that calculation will give is bound to be less than the real figure if the number of persons employed has been increasing during the year, and it has been the case in this industry particularly, in which there has been a substantial increase in the number employed and in the total amount of wages paid.
As the increase does not take place on the 1st January every year, but continuously during the year, any calculation based upon a division of the number employed in October into the wages paid is bound to give a figure less than the actual average wage. That is why the Deputy has got misleading results from his calculation. Between 1933 and 1934 the amount paid in wages increased from £90,000 to £152,000, and the number employed from 890 to 1,760. There has been, of course, a still further increase since 1934, because not merely are new makes of cars being now assembled, but there has been, as the Deputy is aware, a very considerable increase in the sales of new cars, particularly during the last year. There has been no development in the industry, of which I am aware, which would justify the conclusion that there has been a reduction in the average rate of wages. The rates of wages are more or less standardised.
Comment on this
I do not controvert at all that in an industry where the number of employees are increasing from year to year, if you take the number referring to employment and divide it into the annual wage pool, you are not going to get the average wage paid for the year.
Comment on this
You tend to get a lower figure. What I am saying is that by comparing the relationship between the total pool and the employment in October from year to year, you get a tendency that shows the way the average rate is increasing or decreasing.
Comment on this
No. Even that assumption is based on the conclusion that the rate of increase in employment is steady all the time.
Comment on this
The Minister is able by taking a sheet of paper and with more information than is given in the statistics before me, to make his calculation and develop his theory on it, but the position that is before us is that in the implement trades, taking the relationship between employment in October and the total wage pool, the ratio there has decreased in the implement trades much more than £19 a year between 1931 and 1932, much more than £27 between 1931 and 1934, and, in the industry we are now discussing, as between 1923 and 1934, it is down by £13. It is not possible to make any kind of comparison between 1931 and 1934 because of the Ford factory position.
Comment on this
I should like to point out to the Minister that for the last two years representations have been made to me by coach builders here in the city that as a consequence of the importation of cars for commercial vehicles, there has been a large decrease in employment in that particular business, with consequent loss both to the coach builders and their employers. I should like to ask the Minister if he now intends to have cars which are attached to commercial vehicles manufactured in this country.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:—
In paragraph (b), page 12, lines 16 and 17, to delete the words "within 12 months before the importation of the article".
The purpose of this amendment is to delete certain words which would deprive certain persons of the concessions which it was intended to grant under the section. This clause is designed to enable the Revenue Commissioners to exempt certain articles from duty, largely articles which are left to people under certain wills, family heirlooms and things of that description. The point is, of course, that executors are allowed a period of 12 months for the settlement of an estate and for the distribution of legacies. If they have not settled the estate, and legacies have not been distributed and imported within 12 months, in order to comply with the section as it at present stands, the limiting words might impose a very great hardship upon the executors, on the one hand, and would prevent the legatees from obtaining the advantage of the section on the other hand.
Comment on this
I should like to know what is the justification for this extension of an officer's right to seize the books which relate to goods which it is alleged have been smuggled.
Comment on this
It is designed to enable an officer when searching premises to seize and carry away documents which there are reasonable grounds to believe relate to smuggling transactions. That has been the invariable practice already, but we want to make it clear.
Comment on this
This practice has never been questioned in the courts. There was a case in the courts some years ago where another right to search under another Act was questioned.
Comment on this
I take it, then, that the Revenue Commissioners have felt that possibly their rights to take away books relating to smuggled merchandise might be questioned. They are now seeking statutory powers so that they will have a good defence to any action.
Comment on this
Precisely. The section is brought in because we have decided that the law, in so far as it relates to smuggling, must be strengthened.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 36 and 38 are designed to restrict somewhat the effect of what is a very drastic section, and it is difficult to discuss these amendments apart from amendments Nos. 37 and 39.
Comment on this
I should be quite prepared to fall in with that arrangement, and I formally move the amendments. It is a well-established principle of the common law in Great Britain, Ireland and the United States of America that a man is innocent until he is proved guilty. It is one of those fundamental characteristics of our law which distinguishes our law from much of the Continental law. That distinction, in my opinion, is one of the securest foundations of individual liberty we have got. Every person who is brought into court in this country charged with a crime is innocent until the State is in a position to prove beyond any reasonable doubt that he is guilty. We are all familiar with cases in which any reasonable juryman would very shrewdly suspect that the prisoner at the bar had broken the law, but in all such circumstances the trial judge is scrupulous to warn the members of the jury that shrewd suspicion is not enough, and that they must be satisfied beyond all reasonable doubt that the man is guilty. If it should emerge that, in the course of the trial, the trial judge failed to administer such a warning, an appeal to the Court of Criminal Appeal would quash the verdict or secure a new trial. Now this revenue section goes to the root of that principle and gives the Revenue Commissioners the right to go into anybody's premises, point out to the owner a particular article of merchandise and say: "We allege that you smuggled that." The very moment the revenue officer alleges that that is the case that man stands guilty of the charge of smuggling unless and until he can rebut that charge. Sub-section (5) of Section 19 says——
Comment on this
Yes; sub-section (3) says:—
(3) Whenever an officer of customs and excise or a member of the Gárda Síochána reasonably suspects that any goods to which this section applies have been imported into Saorstát Eireann or have been so imported without payment of a duty of Customs chargeable on such importation or without a licence or other special authorisation required by law for such importation, such officer or member (as the case may be) may require any person in whose possession or control or on or in whose land or premises or in the immediate vicinity of whose land or premises such goods are found by such officer or member, to give to such officer or member all information relevant to all or any of the following subjects of inquiry which is in the possession or knowledge of such person and to produce to such officer or member all documents relevant to any such subject of inquiry which are in the possession or custody of such person, that is to say:—
(a) whether such goods were or were not imported into Saorstát Eireann, and
(b) if such goods were so imported, the person by whom and the place and time at which they were so imported, and
(c) if such goods were so imported and were chargeable with a duty of customs on such importation, whether such duty was or was not paid and, if such duty was paid, the time and place of payment, and
(d) if such goods were so imported and a licence or other special authorisation was required by law for such importation, whether such licence or authorisation was or was not obtained.
Sub-section (4) is not, I think, relevant to my argument at the moment; but sub-section (5) says:—
Whenever a person is guilty of any such failure or refusal as is declared by the next preceding sub-section of this section to be an offence under this section, such failure or refusal (whether such person has or has not been prosecuted for such offence) shall, in any proceedings against such person for an offence against or contravention of the laws relating to Customs alleged to have been committed by him in regard to the goods to which such failure or refusal related, be evidence until the contrary is proved that such goods had been imported into Saorstát Eireann by such person and had been so imported without payment of the duties of Customs (if any) chargeable on such importation and without the licence or other special authorisation (if any) required by law for such importation.
It will be observed that this entirely new principle is shrouded here in this endless verbiage.
Comment on this
That may be, but it does not discharge the section from being endless verbiage. The reason for all this is the result of a raid made by Customs officers in Ballybofey because they saw goods in a shop window on which they thought duty was not paid. They demanded that proof should be afforded to them that duty had been paid. My recollection is that when they brought that case into court they were ignominiously thrown out. A very similar case arose in Northern Ireland, and when it reached the High Court the Lord Chief Justice threw it out with contempt and stated that to confer such statutory powers upon the Revenue Commissioners would be a most unjust invasion of the rights of the individual. I put this case, in all seriousness, to the Minister for Finance. We hear, very frequently, in regard to income-tax and Customs, very stringent criticisms of the Revenue Commissioners. The Minister for Finance is responsible for them to this House. But we have to bear in mind the peculiar, autonomous position of the Commissioners, and that, in addition to being autonomous, they have a kind of automatic existence. The Commissioners cannot appear here, and make a case to this House and suggest that in certain circumstances their powers should be qualified. Accordingly, the tendency is to give very wide powers to the Commissioners in order to collect the revenue. They are told they must take drastic steps to collect the revenue. At the same time you may equip them with powers so drastic that they find themselves driven, by the obligation placed upon them by statute, far beyond the limit to which prudent men would care to go, so that in connection with income-tax prosecutions and Customs you may find the Revenue Commissioners labouring under a constraint to act more drastically than common-sense men would act. My contention is that a cases where you do find that a scandal arises, and that people are driven to extremes by reason of the pressure put upon them, the Revenue Commissioners are not all ogres but are ordinary men who have been driven to carry out the law. The responsibility is really ours if we draft law which puts an obligation upon them to go to the very extreme before they begin to temper justice with mercy. It must also be borne in mind that it it is not fair to ask the Minister for Finance to accept responsibility or wide discretion in checking the Revenue Commissioners. The very essence of the system is that they must be autonomous and independent of the Minister and that he will not interfere with them in carrying out their duties.
If this House, by law, directs the Revenue Commissioners to do certain things, situations may arise where individual circumstances would incline the Revenue Commissioners to pause and give special treatment, but when they are referred to the letter of the law, they find they have no power to exercise a discretion in favour of the person concerned. When they bring this matter to the attention of the Minister, he says: "I have neither the power nor the inclination to interfere with the Revenue Commissioners and the Commissioners must act absolutely independently in this matter." They reply: "In our view, as ordinary men, the statute is driving us further than we think it prudent to go." A dilemma arises and, unless the Finance Acts are amended, the Revenue Commissioners are driven into a course of action which sometimes brings about tragedy, with resulting scandal, which may seem altogether inexplicable to the public and may create the general feeling that the Board of Revenue Commissioners are a public nuisance, a public danger and a body of men who have no consideration for the ordinary every-day affairs of their fellow citizens.
For that reason, I want to warn the House against conferring on the Revenue Commissioners a power of this kind, because we all know that reasonable suspicion will enter people's minds as to whether goods have been smuggled or not. Remember, we have got this infernal Border, and, in these small towns around the Border, the customs officer is going continually to suspect—and reasonably suspect—that goods have been smuggled. This section may put upon him the obligation of marching into people's houses in every case, if he is a conscientious man. It is a dreadfully difficult thing for Deputies sitting in this House to bear in mind the conditions which obtain in a small country shop or in a small shop in a country town. I am a small, country shopkeeper myself. If an officer of the Revenue Commissioners came into me, pointed out any article of merchandise in my shop, and said: "I suspect that to have been imported without paying duty," in respect of half the merchandise which I have not imported myself and in the case of some of the merchandise I have imported myself, I should be wholly unable to prove that I ever paid duty on it.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy have any difficulty in telling the Revenue Commissioners where he got the merchandise?
Comment on this
I shall tell the Minister exactly what I should do. As I am a member of this House and have some experience of the Revenue Commissioners, I should say, in the first place, "Under the authority of what statute do you purport to act?" The answer to that would be Section 19 of the present Finance Act. I would say: "I refuse to give any further information until I have an opportunity of consulting my legal adviser." If the officer prosecuted me, I should plead natural justice and bring him before Chief Justice Kennedy, who would send him out on his ear when I had explained that I had been refused permission to obtain legal advice before answering questions which were calculated to incriminate me under Section 19. But what will happen when the officer of the Revenue Commissioners goes into the ordinary, country shopkeeper? He will immediately get hysterical. He will not know whether duty has been paid on certain goods or not. If he does know, he will not have the sense to say exactly what he means and, in all human probability, he will be thrown into such a state of confusion that he will make a false statement— tell a lie.
I have considerable experience of both the Minister for Finance and of the Revenue Commissioners. As a Deputy, I have approached them both in matters relating to individual citizens of the State. I am well aware that the Minister for Finance is not free to interfere in the business of the Revenue Commissioners but, in other matters, when I have made a reasonable case on behalf of a citizen, the Minister for Finance has heard it sympathetically. My experience of the Revenue Commissioners is that when you tell them the truth—I have had dealings with them in connection with my own private affairs and, in my capacity as public man, on behalf of citizens—and when you show a desire to co-operate, no more reasonable body of men could be found to do business with. But if, through inexperience or folly, you get involved in a long string of lies and misrepresentations, the Revenue Commissioners find themselves in a position in which they are not free to exercise a discretion in your favour. Therefore, I say that to give an officer of the Revenue Commissioners the right to go in and put a man on his defence, without first having proved anything against him, is fundamentally unsound and bad—bad not only from the point of view of the common law rights of the people but bad from the point of view of the Revenue Commissioners themselves.
The Revenue Commissioners ought to collect the revenue, but let this House beware lest they turn the Revenue Commissioners into a kind of sub-division of the Detective Branch in Dublin Castle. That is not their job. They are there to prevent evasion of the revenue duties, but they ought not to have thrust upon them the duty of going about excessively poking their noses into people's houses and rooting about inside people's premises. I know that the tendency is to disregard more and more the doctrine that a man's house is his castle, but if you are going to throw open every man's house to a revenue officer, so that he may go in and root around and put the householder on his defence, I say you are going too far and doing a thing which is not going to be in the interests of the revenue. You are going to give rise to a situation in which you will irritate and madden people to such an extent that whatever degree of co-operation the Revenue Commissioners can depend upon at the present time will be withheld from them. The Minister knows that the income-tax law and excess profits law have given rise to such furious public indignation that he himself has been betrayed on certain occasions into using very immoderate language. Of course, that was in his irresponsible days.
Comment on this
The Minister must realise that, silly as he was, there are a great many people nearly as silly.
Comment on this
You have got to take that into consideration and legislate in such a way that you will secure from the public the largest possible measure of co-operation. If you so legislate as to turn the Revenue Commissioners into a kind of monster which, once set in motion, cannot be stopped until it has chased a man into the grave, I think you are doing very grave injustice to the public service, to those who man it and to the efficiency of the machine itself, because you will alienate public sympathy from the Department and create in the public mind the impression that the Revenue Commissioners are Public Enemy No. 1. I do not think that that is a character that ought to be forced upon them. If you make them too Draconian by legislation, they will have to comply with the law and they will be driven to measures that will create indignation on the part of the public. I think that that is a highly undesirable development. I believe that this proposal is going to assist in creating that impression. I think that that is bad, because you ought not to encourage members of the public service to be bursting into people's houses and rooting about for evidence of crime except where it is absolutely necessary in the interest of the public weal. I think that this provision is not going to work effective justice. The cute person will be able to meet it, but the simple person will be thrown into such a state of alarm that he will probably entangle himself in the law instead of shaking off whatever measure of guilt he may have contracted before the arrival of the customs officer. That is one point. I think the Minister ought to consider it and withdraw these provisions. The courts have strongly condemned them, in anticipation, both here and in Northern Ireland.
If I am beaten on that point, I want to make a suggestion in regard to Sections 36 and 38. It is going too far to say that not only will you make a person responsible to this drastic extent when the goods are under his control or on his land or premises, but also if they are found in the immediate vicinity of his land or premises. We continually come across cases in which people who have stolen goods or smuggled goods go out and hide them somewhere in a ditch. We know what happens in poteen cases. The poteen is found on an innocent person's land. I know of a case where it was concealed on land belonging to the parish priest. I believe it was deliberately put there by the poteen maker. I know the man who made the poteen. He was afterwards caught. I think it was deliberately done by him because the poteen laws contain a provision of that kind.
Comment on this
I said that the poteen laws contain a provision that if poteen is found in your immediate vicinity or in your premises you are liable. That is a bad principle because it encourages the guilty person to divest himself of the poteen and put it on the land of a man who has no connection with poteen-making. I know in one case that though the man on whose land the poteen was found suspected the person who put it there, he could not afford to take the risk of making that charge deliberately.
Comment on this
I remember the Deputy started his speech by saying that this proposal of ours contravened a well-established principle of common law. He has now admitted that the law to which he objects has already been given effect to in another statute.
Comment on this
Oh no, not at all. Amendments Nos. 36 and 38 stand separate from amendments Nos. 37 and 39. According to the well-established principle of common law, I think these provisions in the Bill are bad inasmuch as they extend too far the area of responsibility. Let it be "in or on the premises" but not "in the immediate vicinity of the land or premises." In practice, that has worked out unsatisfactorily and it has not operated to bring home responsibility to the guilty parties.
Comment on this
I think the speech to which we have just listened, while very well-intentioned, has been made without full advertence to the seriousness of the position with regard to smuggling in this country. This House has asked the general community to make great sacrifices in order to establish certain industries here and in order to provide revenue to carry on social services. We are not getting the revenue we ought to be getting, and the new industries which have been established are not getting the chance which the House desired they should get because of the serious smuggling carried on along the Northern Border. We have come to the conclusion that if that practice is to be put down, as we desire it to be put down—and the Revenue Commissioners have come to the conclusion that if this practice of smuggling is to be dealt with as we want it to be dealt with—drastic powers of the nature asked for in this section are essential and nothing less will suffice. My submission to the House is that the House, having afforded these industries this protection and having imposed these certain duties for the purpose of carrying on the public services, cannot stultify itself by refusing to give to those who are charged with the administration of these duties the powers which in their view are essential for them if they are to fulfil these obligations. It has been contended that in asking the House for these powers we are running contrary to a well-established principle of the common law in Great Britain and Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
To the well-established principle of common law which has been honoured in Great Britain and Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
What is the position? Up to two years ago it was possible to secure, without definite evidence of importation, a conviction in respect to goods seized under circumstances which clearly indicated that they had been smuggled. A decision was given in one of the courts of Northern Ireland. That decision apparently has been taken in certain quarters to imply that definite evidence of importation must be adduced where proceedings in connection with smuggled goods are taken. Subsequent to those proceedings or to this decision, certain of our district justices changed their attitude in regard to this question of smuggled goods. The decision in Northern Ireland was not, of course, permitted to stand by the Northern Ireland Legislature and the British Finance Act of 1934 amended the law.
Comment on this
I have not got it here, but the Deputy may take it that as far as I know that is the case.
Comment on this
Did the Minister read the decision given a fortnight ago by the Lord Chief Justice in Northern Ireland?
Comment on this
The Deputy has charged us with going farther, and endeavouring to introduce a new principle by placing the onus of proof in certain cases on the person in whose land or premises the goods were found —charging him with harbouring goods that have been smuggled. It is alleged that that is something entirely new in the Customs law. I think the Deputy himself has admitted that it is not a new thing in similar circumstances to put the onus of proof on the person owning the land—to show that he is not in possession of illicit goods found on his land, and that he is not the owner of them. The Deputy has admitted that that is the case already. A similar provision appears in the Customs Consolidation Act of 1876, which places the onus of proof on the defendant in all prosecutions for the forfeiture of goods or the recovery of any penalties under the Customs Act, that is to say, throws the onus on him to show that they have not been smuggled. It is only because it has been recently held, as I have indicated to the Deputy, that this does not apply unless there is definite evidence of the importation of the goods in question, that certain provisions of this section are necessary in order to restore to the revenue authorities the weapon which they had previously and which as they have advised me, is absolutely necessary for the effective stoppage of smuggling.
Let us see what the real position is, because I think the Deputy has failed to grasp it. He has told us that there was a case in Ballybofey where a customs officer saw certain goods in a shop window and went in and demanded of the proprietor that he should be told whence those goods came. That was not the position at all. The position was, and it will remain the position after this section has been adopted, as I hope it will be adopted, by the House, that the customs officer, before he entered the premises, had to go and swear an information that he had reason to suspect that the goods in question were smuggled. It was because I thought that the Deputy had read this section too hurriedly that I directed his attention to the opening passages of sub-section (3), which make it quite clear that, before an officer can go into any premises and question any person, he must be prepared to swear that he has reasonable suspicion that the goods in question have been smuggled. What is he permitted to ask the person? He is permitted to ask him to give any information that may be in his possession as to whether such goods were or were not imported into Saorstát Eireann.
Is there any great hardship in asking a person who is suspected of being in the possession of smuggled goods to tell an officer of the customs—a member of the service which this House has set up to make certain that goods will not be smuggled—where he got the goods. Let me quote the exact words of this part of the section:—"If such goods are found by such officer or member, to give to such officer or member all information relevant to all or any of the following subjects of inquiry which is in the possession or knowledge of such person"; to tell him whether such goods were or were not imported into Saorstát Eireann?
If the police were investigating a burglary or robbery and they found goods which they thought had been part of the proceeds of the robbery in the possession of any person, would they not be entitled to ask any such person where he got the goods? Is not that the common procedure in tracking down crime? It is a crime under the law of this land to smuggle goods. All that is asked is, if a person has goods in his possession, that he should give to the officer all the relevant information he may have in regard to them.
Comment on this
What do you mean by saying that he cannot enter any premises? Can he not enter into my shop any day?
Comment on this
He can enter a shop in Ballybofey to get a pint of porter and on his way say "Where did you get these goods?"
Comment on this
I take it that, if he is on duty, he is not authorised to go in and ask for a pint of porter. I take it that if he goes into the Deputy's business premises upon his own private business, he is not entitled to ask the Deputy any question in relation to public business.
Comment on this
He is not authorised to do that because, under Section 19, he has to act in accordance with the general customs code.
Comment on this
The Deputy is taking up the position that before we can amend the customs law we must reprint, as part of the text of the proposed amendment, the whole of the customs code. I should like to furnish the Deputy with a copy of the customs code and ask him to read it here during one session of Dáil Eireann. I guarantee he would not get one quarter way through it before we adjourn next year, and that all that time we would not have a single word from the Deputy if he occupied all the time reading this code.
Comment on this
In certain cases. The Deputy may try to make points which are not really relevant to the principle at issue, which is, whether an officer of customs is entitled to ask a person, who is in the possession of goods which the officer suspects of being smuggled, to tell him whether or not the goods were imported into the Saorstát. Is there any difficulty about that? If the person takes up an attitude different to that Deputy Dillon suggests and, without having recourse to a solicitor, says: "I do not know, but I can tell you from whom I got the goods," is there any great hardship in asking a person in the possession of goods suspected of being smuggled to tell the officer of customs, if he is not able to tell him whether the goods were imported or not, from whom he got them? The person upon whom the onus of showing whether the goods were imported or not really rests ought to be in a position to prove that the duty was or was not paid and, if such duty was paid, the time of the supposed payment. He will have customs receipts for every one of these duties if he conducts his business properly. I am certain that Deputy Dillon conducts his business properly and that he will not be subject to all the imaginary terrors with which he has tried to endow this section. The person who conducts his business honestly within the law will be prepared, if he has reason to believe that goods have been smuggled, to assist the officers of the law in the discharge of their duty. Again, I come back to the point that I think the House, which has imposed certain customs duties, would stultify itself if it did not give the officers of the State the powers which they advise me are essential if these customs laws are to be enforced.
Comment on this
The Minister, in reply to Deputy Dillon, said it was not unreasonable to give the Revenue Commissioners certain definite powers, where they find goods in the possession of a person, to discover whether duty was or was not paid on them. I would like to put in a word for the amendment more than for the section. To use the Minister's words, it might not be unreasonable to ask a person who is in possession of goods to give certain information, but I am thinking of the person who is not in possession of anything. I have no idea, of course, of how the words "in the immediate vicinity" might be interpreted by the Revenue Commissioners, but take the position that certain goods which are subject to duty are found on land contiguous to my place. If I am asked for information whether the duty has been paid on them, it would be impossible for me, or for people in my position, to give the information, and yet if I refuse to do so I am liable to the penalty set out. That, surely, is not right. I do not think that we should leave it in the power of anyone to put such interrogations to people. People who did not know anything about the importation of the goods might, as Deputy Dillon said, give an evasive answer, and then get themselves into serious trouble. For the reasons that I have given I support the proposed deletion of the words "in the immediate vicinity of land or premises." In the case of a person found in the possession of goods, it is perhaps reasonable that the Revenue Commissioners should have power to get some information about them, but it would be undesirable, I think, to place the unlimited powers asked for here in the hands of any authority.
Comment on this
The Minister has sought to draw an analogy between stolen goods and smuggled goods. There is no analogy between the procedure adopted by the representatives of the law in regard to these two categories of things, because the law specifically recognises that, in many circumstances, the possession of stolen goods is no evidence of guilt whatever. It clearly says that, if goods are bought in good faith, no crime is committed. If they are purchased in market overt they become the legitimate property of the purchaser. They may be recovered, but if bought in good faith they carry no shadow of guilt to the person who has bought them.
Comment on this
And so far as persons affected by this section are concerned, that would still be the position. If he shows that he bought them in good faith he is not liable to any penalty.
Comment on this
As I have said, there is no analogy at all between the two classes of goods. The Minister went on to say that it is a crime to smuggle goods, and that it is no hardship to require persons to tell the officers of the Revenue Commissioners whether they have committed that crime or not. That is all they are asked to do, he says. If a citizen of this State murders his mother-in-law and is brought into the dock, does this House think it would be no hardship to put on him the statutory obligation of telling the judge that he had murdered his mother-in-law? Is it not the very essence of our law that he is entitled to plead "not guilty" and to assert and maintain within the law to the very last hour that he did not murder his mother-in-law? Would it not be a perfect absurdity to make it a statutory crime for a person to deny criminal guilt when put upon his trial?
The Constitution (Amendment 2A) Act can be carried too far. It is bad enough that such an Act should have become necessary in the statute law of this country, but for heaven's sake let us restrict its operation. It is a terrible thing that legislation of that kind has had to be invoked for the purpose of maintaining the very fabric of the State itself, but if we are to carry the Public Safety Act procedure into the Revenue and into every other law, then we are getting straight down to the time of the star chamber. You are doing worse, because you are throwing the cloak of legality over the third degree methods of the American police force. I do not think that any representative of the law in this country has the right to go to a person and convict him by asking him "Have you committed a crime?"
Comment on this
If the officers of the Revenue Commissioners come into me and ask, "Did you smuggle these goods?" and if I say "No," I have committed a crime; if I say nothing I have committed a crime, and if I say "Yes" I have committed a crime. Is that not so?
Comment on this
I admit that I am standing in my own house with the goods and I admit that I have broken the law, but the law of this country provides that if I, as a citizen, have broken the law the State must arrest me, put me on trial and bring home guilt to me beyond all reasonable doubt before I can be made subject to the penalties of the law. But, under the new dispensation, the officers of the Revenue Commissioners can come to me and ask, "did you smuggle those goods?" If I say "yes," I go to jail; if I say nothing I go to jail, and if I say "no" I go to jail. Is that good law? I submit that we are being drawn slowly by the handy method provided by the Public Safety Act to get persons, whom you suspect, into jail. That is the terrible danger of allowing legislation, such as Article 2A of the Constitution, to be enacted, because once you have carried an Article of that character into your statute law, the difficulties of penning it up, and of preventing the principles which underlie it of spreading out and of running through the whole law of the country, are almost insuperable.
Comment on this
In order to clarify the position, let me remind the House that all that we are asking the House to do is to restore the position to what it was here prior to a certain decision which was given two years ago. There is no question whatever of a customs officer or a police officer going and asking a person such a question as "did you smuggle these goods." Let me remind the House again that what the officer is entitled to ask, is, whether or not the goods were imported into the Saorstát. Surely that is a question that is capable of an answer "Yes" or "No." I do not think that there is any undue coercion being imposed by the law which requires a person to answer that question. If the person answers "Yes," he is then asked to state the person by whom they were imported and the place and time. If he has that information in his possession, he can at least answer the first question and tell the officer the person by whom they were imported. That would allow us to carry our investigations further, and with regard to the person who actually imported the goods to ask him:
if such goods were so imported and were chargeable with a duty of customs on such importation, whether such duty was or was not paid and, if such duty was paid, the time and place of payment.
I think that there is nothing unfair in asking a person who is in possession of goods reasonably suspected of being smuggled to answer certain questions. That is all that the section requires.
Comment on this
The Minister did not make any allusion to the amendment. He referred to a person found in possession of goods and said that that person would be asked to give certain information to the Revenue Commissioners as to the possession of the goods if they are found in his premises. The Minister has not replied to the arguments suggesting the elimination of this particular phrase "in the immediate vicinity of whose lands or premises they are found." The Minister attempted to make a case for requiring a person found in possession of goods to give information as to where they were bought and if the duty was paid. He is seeking power in this section to allow officials to visit a man on whose premises or land nothing was found and to ask certain information from him. Let us say that I have land or premises half a mile away from the Minister. Something is found on the Minister's land and then officials come to me and ask me if I know that the Minister has certain goods on his land which are believed to be imported.
Comment on this
The section does not specify whether it is on one side or the other. The point is that I am asked to give information about something found on premises other than mine, found in the immediate vicinity. The words "immediate vicinity" can be defined in various ways. It might mean a place half a mile or a mile away. I submit that the Minister is seeking power that will put practically all the people in the neighbourhood under penal laws.
Comment on this
I want to say a few words in support of the amendment. As a representative of a Border county, I can see that many difficulties will arise if this section is passed as it stands. It is rather peculiar that the Minister should want such powers at the present time. I should like to ask the Minister if smuggling has been on the increase during the past few months and, if so, why has it been on the increase? Is there a sufficient staff along the Border to cope with the smuggling business? I am strongly in sympathy with the views expressed by Deputy Dillon. I venture to suggest that Deputies who do not happen to know much about the Border cannot have the faintest conception of all the trouble that can be created amongst the traders in Border towns as a result of the passing of this section.
We may as well be candid with ourselves. We are not the great people we are supposed to be. There are certain types of people with very narrow minds, selfish types of people, people possibly who want to get their own back on their fellow-man, on neighbouring traders along the Border, possibly as a result of a long-standing agrarian dispute or some other form of dispute between their families, their fathers and grandfathers. A particular man may be in business. What is to prevent an individual giving secret information to the preventive officers that such a man has imported goods, say, from Northern Ireland, thus exposing that man to a visit from the officers, perhaps on a day on which he is extremely busy with other business? I can visualise the feelings of a trader who has to contend with many difficulties that have not to be contended with by traders in other parts of Ireland, having to answer such questions as: "When did you import such an article?""From what country have you imported it, Northern Ireland or Great Britain?""Can you give me the receipts in respect of the duties payable?" and so forth. I can imagine the feelings of such a man, and what his answer would be. I think it would be the usual answer, to go to a hot place, and I believe that would be the correct answer, too.
I think this is really putting the law too far, giving too much power to the Revenue Commissioners, power which in my opinion they do not want to have vested in them. Why should they want such power if the officials are doing their duty? Let us suppose that a man is lucky enough to get a thing across the Border and he is not caught by the preventive officers. I cannot see why the law should be extended in such a way that that man is going to be pilloried, even though he is guilty. This section gives power to the Revenue Commissioners to question a man who is not guilty of smuggling in any shape or form. Knowing the difficulties that traders in those towns have to encounter as a result of the setting up of the Border, the loss of trade they suffer, and the many other difficulties with which they have to contend, I think the least the Minister might do is to show a little sympathy with them, and not make it more difficult for these people to eke out a living. At present they find it difficult enough to make ends meet.
I am honestly of the opinion that this section will create a great deal of hardship, and possibly very bad relations between the preventive officers and the various traders. The Minister may or may not wish that, and quite probably the Revenue Commissioners may not realise the full possibilities of this section. If we consider this matter from a selfish point of view, the point of view of votes, I think if this section is put into operation it will make the Government very unpopular. From the point of view of commonsense alone I suggest that these traders should not be unduly worried by visits from preventive officers, pimping into their business, possibly in nine cases out of ten on information supplied by people who, through a personal grudge, would be only too willing to give information. It is a power that should not be given to the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
To what extent has there been such abuse in connection with smuggling that it is necessary to take these powers?
Comment on this
I cannot give any exact answer beyond saying that there has been extensive smuggling.
Comment on this
In so far as we apply the term "smuggling," we merely use it in respect of the illegal importation of goods into this country.
Comment on this
Across the Border, I presume. How does the Minister expect a person to prove a negative? Is it not practically impossible?
Comment on this
He has to prove a negative. The judge cannot determine that he has done an impossible thing. If the law requires a person to do an impossible thing, the judge cannot say that he has done an impossible thing. There is nothing harder to do than to prove innocence, and that is the reason the general maxim is that a person is assumed innocent until he is proved guilty. The section is presuming to do the opposite. It is asking a man to prove that he is innocent. Practically speaking, that is impossible. There is no question of his being proved guilty; what he has to do is to prove that he is innocent. No person can prove that. It is practically impossible, as everybody knows, to prove a negative, and that is what you are asking them to do. Then, if they cannot do what is impossible, they suffer. The judge cannot save them because you put an impossible condition to them.