Finance Bill, 1936—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 141–283 of 283. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 20 of 1936 ›
No; I think we ought to have the section as it stands, without amendment. I am advised that any other form than that in which it appears on the Paper would be valueless.
Comment on this
The law of evidence provides that a police officer who is about to put questions to a person whom he suspects to be guilty of the gravest crimes known to the law, the answers to which might incriminate that person, must first say to him: "I warn you that you need not answer my questions now, but, if you do, your answers will be taken down and may be used in evidence against you." Unless he takes that precaution, any answers that are given will be disallowed against the defendant at the Bar. I say that if this House enacts legislation to provide that a person who is admittedly guilty of a breach of the law can be asked by an officer of the law a question which places him in the dilemma that whether he says "Yes," keeps silence, or says "No," he has committed an offence, it is bad law, and is a departure from all principles of human liberty and decent administration. It can be defended if the alternative to adopting such a position is that the whole State will be undermined and destroyed by persons who are using the law not for the purpose of vindicating their liberty but as an instrument to destroy the State. Then I admit that a case might be made for revolutionary departures from the accepted fundamental principles which govern our system of society, but short of such a claim there can be no justification for legislation of this kind. I sometimes despair of trying to make appeals on principle to members of the Fianna Fáil Party, because they seem to have lost all sense of principle, and to have surrendered themselves, body and soul, to the doctrine of expediency, but I certainly will resist a proposal of this kind with all the available resources provided by the Constitution.
Amendment No. 36.
Comment on this
It is presumed that amendment No. 36 will govern amendment No. 38 but not amendment No. 37.
Comment on this
Question put—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
Ordinarily, Sir, I would challenge a division on this section. At the beginning of our debate we had a slight difference with the Ministers and I suggested that, if they were prepared to give the information we asked for, we would cooperate in getting through the business as expeditiously as possible. In the light of that, I am prepared to let the section pass.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 40:—
Before Section 20, page 14, to insert a new section as follows:—
Whenever the Minister for Finance so thinks proper, the Revenue Commissioners may, subject to compliance with any conditions which they may think fit to prescribe, permit the importation or delivery without payment of any duty of customs or of excise of any article required for or in connection with any of the following things, that is to say—
(a) the establishment or maintenance of a transatlantic air service using or involving the use of an airport in Saorstát Eireann, or
(b) the establishment or maintenance of radio or meteorological services or other aids to air navigation ancillary to any such transatlantic air service, or
(c) experimental purposes in connection with the establishment or maintenance of any such transatlantic air service.
Comment on this
Will Section 20 put an end to the necessity for getting a cheque certified by the bank?
Comment on this
Wait a moment. This amendment proposes to insert a new section before Section 20. The purpose of amendment 40 is to provide for the duty-free importation of certain goods liable to customs duty in anticipation of the establishment in the near future of a transatlantic air service using the air services or seaports in the Saorstát.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:—
Before Section 20, page 14, to insert a new section as follows:—
The Revenue Commissioners may, if they so think fit, allow any hydrocarbon oil which is liable to a duty of excise to be warehoused without payment of duty, and may, if and so far as they so think proper, remit duty on any deficiency arising in oil so warehoused where they are satisfied that no part of such deficiency was caused by illegal or improper means.
Although there is a provision for the warehousing of goods liable to customs duty, there is no general legal provision for warehousing of goods liable to a duty of excise, and it is desired to give that power in this case.
Comment on this
With regard to Section 20, I do not know whether the House would permit an amendment to be made at this stage, but in case there should be any difficulty about it, I should like to give notice that, on the Report Stage, I propose to bring in an amendment to delete the word "receipt" in line 41 and substitute therefor the word "posting." The reason is that it may be difficult to prove receipt.
Comment on this
I would sooner leave that to the Report Stage. I am not quite sure that it is a more sensible method than the purpose the Minister has in view. Will the section alter the existing situation under which, if one desires to pay duty by cheque, one must get the cheque certified by a bank?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 42:—
Before Section 21, in Part II of the Bill, to insert a new section as follows:—
The Minister for Finance shall cause to be laid before the Dáil within 21 days of the end of each month a schedule giving particulars of the licences issued by the Revenue Commissioners during that month for the importation without payment of duty of goods otherwise liable to customs duty, and including the name, address and occupation of the licensee, and the number of the articles in respect of which in each case the licence was issued.
The gravest possible dissatisfaction and very grave suspicion exist amongst certain manufacturers in the City of Dublin that discrimination is made between various manufacturers in the issuing of licences. I have had one manufacturer in particular with me who makes various articles of women's clothing, and he indicates happenings in the mantle and gown industry and other articles of women's clothing that suggests that there are manufacturers in the city who are allowed to import certain fabrics or various pieces of partly manufactured clothing which other manufacturers in the city are not allowed to import. The Minister very likely heard of this. There are others as well, and there is a general atmosphere of suspicion that licences are being issued to some people and not issued to others. I have had it put up to me that it is impossible to get information, that it would require a court order to discover documents in Dublin Castle to get to the bottom of this matter, and that there is certain differentiation in prices charged for various commodities that indicates that quantities of stuff are coming in under licences that are not given to others.
It is very essential, in the general situation here, where traders of all kinds are suffering grave disabilities through Government interference, that any shred of suspicion, even if it is nothing but suspicion, should be removed. It is a matter that vitally affects the interests of the State generally, that manufacturers should not be left labouring under suspicions of this kind. They can be completely swept away, if they are nothing but suspicions, if a monthly schedule of the licences granted were placed in the library here. If discrimination was being made we could see what exactly that discrimination was and have an explanation given. Even though the Minister might for particular reasons of his own be pursuing a policy of discrimination, at any rate, we would have a statement of the facts, and to these facts he could add any explanation as to why it was necessary to have discrimination of this kind.
Comment on this
I do not think the amendment could be accepted for two reasons: One, because it would be almost completely impossible to give effect to it without adding very considerably to the staffs of the various Departments and incurring very considerable expense. Furthermore, if the necessary records were to be published it would mean considerable delay in dealing with applications. Apart from that, there are obvious reasons for refusing to publish, in the manner suggested, information which might be very damaging to persons concerned; that is, information of the extent to which they are importing goods of the class dealt with in the return. I do not think that information concerning an individual's private business should be published, nor do I think there are any reasonable grounds for contending that there are circumstances which justify the adoption of that course. If Deputy Mulcahy takes the opportunity, which, I am sure, will be given him, to ascertain the views of responsible organisations of traders on the issue of licences, I think he will find that they will not allege that any discrimination is shown as between one person and another in the same circumstances. They sometimes complain of slowness, and complain of the policy when we do not issue licences as they think we should, but they make no allegation of discrimination. It is undesirable that an individual allegation of that kind should be mentioned without reserve. I think I know the particular person who was speaking to the Deputy. He made that allegation before and sent the Deputy letters.
Comment on this
And sent them to me. My advice to the Deputy is to take anything he says with considerable reserve. In any event, the circumstances in that particular case are different from those described. He is a man who is manufacturing certain articles of clothing. He is the only man doing so, and apparently he is not getting orders from particular firms, and alleges that they must be getting licences. He does not consider apparently the possibility of persons preferring to pay the duty to purchasing his goods. There is no foundation whatever for the allegation he made that licences are issued to Protestant firms and refused to Catholic firms, and other wild statements of that kind. I have had frequent discussions on the question of the licensing policy with important trade organisations such as the Drapers' Chamber of Trade and manufacturers' associations, and I think we have got the system relating to the consideration and disposal of applications on a basis which eliminates all these little causes of complaint. In fact, testimony to that effect has been given by responsible officers of these associations on occasions during the past year.
Comment on this
The Minister refused to grant this concession on the ground that the extra work involved in his Department would be more expensive than the concession would be worth. That is palpably absurd, as there must be a record of licences kept, if chaos does not obtain in the Department of Industry and Commerce. I have no doubt such a record is kept and that there would be no difficulty in ascertaining every licence issued by the Department of Finance since this system of licensing began. The revenue accounts could not be kept in order unless such a register existed. All that would be necessary would be to publish extracts from that register at monthly intervals. The second ground on which the Minister rejects the proposal is, that it would be quite wrong to reveal the quantity of goods that a merchant was importing. No one wants to reveal the quantity of stuff that anyone is importing.
Comment on this
It would be sufficient if the class of article was given in the register showing simply the merchandise the licence referred to, and the name of the licensee. The Minister stated that he had discussed the matter exhaustively with the Drapers' Chamber of Trade and other responsible bodies. I do not know what negotiations have gone on between the Minister and the Drapers' Chamber of Trade. The Drapers' Chamber of Trade represents a very small section of the drapers in this country, as 90 per cent. of the drapers operating in rural Ireland do not belong to it. A small draper down the country has just as much right to live as big drapers in the City of Dublin and the City of Cork. I hereby allege that to my own personal knowledge differentiation has taken place between merchants in this country who are exactly similarly situated. I have no intention of referring to the case of anybody who has given me information, for I have reason to know that if I do so in this House, that person becomes identified in the Department of Industry and Commerce, and, in due course, will get to realise that the Department will give him the strict letter of the law, give him just what he is entitled to under the letter of the law, no more and no less.
There is no valid complaint against the Department so long as it fulfils the strict letter of the law, but merchants who have to depend for their livelihood on getting a licence and on getting a little latitude such as human creatures expect, know that that latitude can be perfectly legitimately withdrawn if the Department makes up its mind that any particular individual is a nuisance. If any individual makes himself the spokesman of such merchants for the purpose of criticising the Department, that individual is in the eyes of the Department a nuisance. I am not suggesting that anything to which he is legitimately entitled is taken from him, but I am asserting that he gets the letter of the law and no more. I do not ask from the Department any more than the letter of the law, but I shall take damn good care to get that. I know I shall get no more; I do not want it, and I will take no less, but I say that there are cases in which discrimination has been used. I say there was a period in which licences were being issued for the importation of thread to certain parties and being refused to others. I say there was a period when persons were getting a licence to import sewing cotton into the country and I could not get it.
I think that if you examine into it closely you will find that the letter of the law was being complied with. I am not sure how far the letter of the law was being strictly complied with there. The Minister had absolute discretion to issue licences in the matter of sewing cotton. There was a period in which he expressed himself as having been satisfied by the Drapers' Chamber of Trade that the Westport Thread Company could not supply the demands of the country. Finally there was an arrangement arrived at under which the Westport Thread Company would import all the thread and distribute it from Westport, but there was a period in which the Minister either gave a licence to members of the Drapers' Chamber of Trade or to certain selected parties. For a short period certain rural shopkeepers brought in thread on licence, and I could not get it at the same time. Whether that was due to an oversight I am not in a position to say. I have repeatedly pointed out to the House that for those who are not engaged in the trade it is almost impossible to understand the difficulties which arise.
Take this case. The Minister decides on the 1st April that he will not issue licences for the importation of a commodity like flannelette. I write on the 2nd April and ask for a licence to import flannelette. There is a delay, and then I get a letter to say that the Minister, having carefully considered the representations made in the application, cannot see his way to recommend the issue of the licence. That is the end of it so far as I am concerned. I have to get the flannelette somewhere else and I pay duty on it. On that day fortnight the Minister changes his mind. He makes up his mind that he is now going to issue licences for the importation of flannelette. My next-door neighbour then writes for a licence. The Minister writes back and says: "Let me have a pro forma invoice for what you want and I shall recommend the issue of a licence." He gets the licence and brings in the flannelette free of duty. Now the picture presented to me is that when a few weeks before I asked for a licence I was refused it. I paid the standard price for flannelette in Manchester and I had to pay a duty of 33? per cent in addition. Having paid that, I cannot sell it at less than 1/2 per yard. It cost me 11 7/8d., duty included. I walk down the street a few days later and I see flannelette being carried from boxes outside my competitor's shop into the window, with a ticket marked 1/- per yard on it.
Comment on this
I say to myself immediately "Here I have been refused a licence but this man obviously got a licence or he could not sell it at 1/-." It immediately occurs to me "There must be some hanky-panky about this." I say to my friends "There is the written evidence. The Minister has refused me a licence." Bear in mind that we are talking about two merchants down the country who are not members of the Dáil and who cannot come in here and put down a Parliamentary Question about the matter. A bitter sense of grievance resides in the man who has been refused a licence.
He feels that his neighbour has a preference over him to which he was not entitled. I say that if the Minister published at the end of the month "Licences in respect to the following persons were issued for the importation of flannelette during the month"— immediately those aggrieved could come forward and say: "Well, we were refused a licence" whereupon the matter could be raised here and the Minister would be afforded an opportunity of saying: "Circumstances altered and I changed my mind." It would be open to us then to say that justice demanded that any duty paid in respect of the importation of flannelette prior to the Minister changing his mind should be refunded. At least all the facts would be before the public and the Minister would be put on his proof to satisfy the House that he was justified in changing his mind in that way.
Now, to go back for a moment to the question of thread, suppose the Minister made an agreement with the Drapers' Chamber of Trade that he should get their co-operation in meeting the difficulty that existed while Westport was unable to supply the demand. The Minister might bona fide have thought that the Chamber of Trade spoke for all drapers in the country and that if he gave licences to everybody named by the Chamber of Trade he had done his duty. Then a number of country shopkeepers might say: “We do not belong to the Drapers' Chamber of Trade and we do not want to belong to it. You have been induced to issue licences to certain persons, not for the purpose of relieving the difficulty that existed but for the purpose of giving the Drapers' Chamber of Trade a boost. They are swaggering round the country and saying: ‘We can get licences and the poor fools who do not join us, cannot get any.’” Unless there is full publicity inevitably misunderstanding must arise. Take a person who is not a politician, a person who is irritated and comes foaming up to the Department, denouncing them horse, foot and artillery. One word will borrow another and eventually he will be met by an official who, acting quite properly, will say: “If you have any observations to make I suggest that you put them in writing,” whereupon the unfortunate applicant storms out into the street and says: “Oh, well, can you expect anything else from Fianna Fáil?” There is a general feeling of dissatisfaction, bitterness and suspicion created by that system. It is an intangible kind of thing, but is a very human thing, and to my mind it is a very unhealthy thing in the public life of this country.
Deputies will say that there is no culpable discrimination, but I wish Deputies would face this from a practical point of view. You take the ordinary small shopkeeper down the country. He writes in a simple letter to the Department. The letter appears to come within a certain category and a stock circular is sent out: "The Minister regrets, etc." He knows a Deputy, or a close friend of a Deputy in this House, and next day he furls his umbrella and comes up here to this House and says to the Deputy: "Will you tell me what I have to do to get a licence?" In turn the Deputy furls his umbrella and the pair set out for Lord Edward Street. That Deputy will know some official who will say to him: "Look here, this is a very decent fellow and he does not quite know what he wants. Will you tell him what he wants?" My experience of most officials is that they are extremely helpful and invariably courteous. That official will sit down and take the utmost trouble to find out what the fellow wants. He may say to him: "Look here, if you ask for a licence in that way for that purpose you will not get it, but if you want a licence, ask for it on this form and you are entitled to it." We are not suggesting any trickery or anything like that. Under the existing regulation, if you approach the Department in a certain way you fall into the category of people whose applications may be rejected, while if you approach it in another way, your application may be considered. If a simple man wrote a letter asking me to go with him, or asking a member on the Independent Benches, he would probably get exactly the same treatment. It may be that the Deputy who is asked by some enterprising merchant to accompany him to Lord Edward Street is a Fianna Fáil Deputy. It may as well be a Deputy on this side of the House, but the licence is given in one case and in the other it is not.
My submission is that the publication of a list at the end of a month, on which appear the names of certain persons who have got licences, would have the effect of giving everybody else, who was refused, the opportunity of making a protest. I feel, in that way, much more substantial justice would be done than is done at the present time. I dealt with this case time and time again, and I repeat now everything I said on previous occasions. I do think that a system of licensing, and of licences being issued in that way in the dark will inevitably lead to corruption, and is going to bring corruption into the public life of this country. These licences can be of very great value. A licence to import a large quantity of goods, which are under a heavy tariff, to a manufacturer, can be worth anything from hundreds up to thousands of pounds. To say that devices of that kind, by which licences can be distributed under cover of darkness can be operated without danger to public morality is to adopt the policy of the ostrich by hiding one's head in the sand. This proposal to have the list of licences published would be an adequate safeguard without doing injustice to any licensee and I strongly urge upon the Minister to put it into operation.
Comment on this
The only thing I want to say is that the circumstances the Deputy has described are purely imaginary. They do not happen—I mean the Minister changing his mind overnight and things of that kind—and I would not like anyone to think that they do. Secondly, the question of granting a licence is not a matter for one official alone. It is not only not a matter merely for one official, but it is a matter for other Departments as well. Licences are issued on the recommendation of the Ministers for Industry and Commerce and the Department of Finance; but, in the Department of Industry and Commerce, the system of checking and counter checking is such that no one official could possibly determine decisions on these matters.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say if what I instanced in regard to the issue of licences to import thread is correct?
Comment on this
Licences were issued to manufacturers, not to traders. The only difference was between these two classes, which are distinct and definite classes.
Comment on this
There were three periods. The first period was while the factory was building, during which licences were issued generally. The second period was after the factory had commenced production, when licences were issued to manufacturers to import their thread, and certain classes of threads were imported by the Westport company and redistributed. We are now at a stage when licences are not issued.
Comment on this
Immediately prior to that period, when certain classes of thread were imported by the Westport company, and distributed, was there not a short period when licences were issued to retailers or wholesalers to import their thread from Great Britain, while others were refused?
Comment on this
I was informed that merchants in the West of Ireland did import thread from Great Britain at the time on licence, when I, personally, was refused a similar licence, and was constrained to buy thread from the Westport Thread Company, although I wrote to the Department about the matter. I now repeat that the Westport company were then asking more for their thread, and are to-day asking more for their thread, than the price for which that thread can be got at Leicester.
Comment on this
I assert it is so, and I ask the Minister to apply to the High Commissioner in London and get from him the price of thread from the English Sewing Cotton Company in Leicester. If he does so he will find that I am right, and that they are selling "My Lady" thread in reels of 170 yards, on an average of 14/9 a gross, while 16/6 is charged in Westport.
Comment on this
In connection with this system of licensing, may I put it to the Minister that the present practice of not stating a reason for refusing a licence is not a good practice, particularly when it is not final? Frequently a licence is refused with the idea of getting the applicant to make a more substantial or a more elaborate case. It is not clear always what ground the Department had in mind for the refusal. It is too much to expect a business man to know the reason for the refusal when it is not set out in the refusal. I submit the Department could well afford to give a hint that if a proper case was made the matter would be again considered.
Comment on this
I have no idea of the class of licence Deputy Moore is talking about. That is not the practice of the Department so far as licences attaching to customs duties are concerned. It may have been done in relation to applications for a licence to import British goods, such as machinery and things of that kind free of the special duty. I take it that is what Deputy Moore is referring to, but in ordinary cases that is not done. In cases of application to import machinery of British origin free of duty the application would, in the ordinary course, be refused until evidence is produced that the same machinery cannot be procured from sources to which the duty does not apply, or some other good reason for the granting of this concession is advanced. These are entirely different circumstances, because the application would be of the kind not likely to be repeated and would relate to a particular industry or class of machinery. Applications for licences to import are considered by the Department, and I determine the circumstances in which a licence is issued. These instructions are followed and there is no discretion whatever beyond that.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I thought that was all that the Minister for Industry and Commerce knew about it. The Minister for Finance may know more.
Comment on this
As I explained on Second Reading, Section 21 is a purely drafting amendment of Section 27 of the Finance Act of 1934. The purpose of that section was to impose a penalty of £50 for breach of any condition in relation to a duty of customs which the law imposes or which the law authorises the Revenue Commissioners to impose. It has been found that the provision applies only to powers conferred by the Act of 1934, to Orders made under that Act and to Resolutions, and that no mention was made of powers directly conferred by other Acts. It is in these other Acts that the powers are mainly to be found.
Comment on this
So far as this particular section is concerned, it would have the effect of ensuring that where goods, in respect of which a person is unable to prove that the duty outlined in Section 19 was paid, are found in the vicinity of a man's house, that the person near whose lands or premises they were found is liable to a fine of £50. Is not that the effect?
Comment on this
Section 21 has nothing to do with that. It is dealing with the penalty for a breach of the provisions of Section 27 of the Finance Act of 1934. The point is simply this, that where a merchant is allowed under the conditions imposed by the Revenue Commissioners to import goods, there shall be a penalty attached for a breach of that provision. It has got nothing to do with Section 19.
Comment on this
Is this a section relating to an incident to which I have referred in this House on more than one occasion?
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce remembers this and assures us this section has no reference to the position in connection with the abuses that arose in the issuing of these licences for bakers' flour, at Dungloe, for which he was responsible.
Comment on this
Would not the Minister at this moment give a slight description of the ramifications of this section?
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon spoke about this incident at least 25 times in the last two years, while I was chained down here listening to him.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 43:—
Before Section 23, page 15, but in Part IV, to insert a new section as follows:—
With a view to providing moneys to meet charges which will fall upon the Central Fund in relation to schemes for the provision of employment and the relief of distress, the sum of £100,000 shall be transferred and paid from the Road Fund to the Exchequer at such time or times in the financial year ending on the 31st day of March, 1937, and in such manner as the Minister for Finance shall direct.
The purpose of this amendment is to give effect to the proposal in the Budget whereby a sum of £100,000 is to be transferred and paid from the Road Fund to the Exchequer in the current year for the relief of distress.
Comment on this
That work would have to be done if this £2,500,000 had not been mentioned at all. The Minister on the hustings talked about providing £2,500,000 for a big employment scheme leaving the people to believe that all this was additional while in reality it is only a transfer from one fund to another. This is one of the ways in which this money is to be found—taking £100,000 out of the Road Fund. Of course, the Government want to get it out amongst the people that they are providing £2,500,000 additional for relief works. In fact, the additional sum provided by the Government is not a quarter of what the local authorities will be compelled to provide for this particular scheme. Is not the Minister aware, so far as relief works on the roads are concerned that the numbers employed on those roads have been reduced in four years from 15,000 odd to just a little over 4,000? I suggest to the Minister that he is not going to give additional employment so far as this particular sum is concerned but that he is merely taking it from the Road Fund where it was intended for employment on the roads and that it is now being used to swell his own total so that he can talk in round figures about £2,500,000 for unemployment.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister in connection with this £100,000 that he is taking from the Road Fund to whom exactly is it intended that this money is to give employment or to whom is employment to be given out of the £2,500,000 of which this £100,000 forms a part? Is this money intended to check the stream of emigration which is going on at present to Great Britain and Scotland? Very recently in the town near which I live every man and woman in one townland went off in one day to Great Britain. I was standing on the platform in Mullingar the week before last and there were three separate or special coaches put on to the train at Mullingar to accommodate the emigrants from Achill. The emigration I have seen from those parts of the country is unlike anything that has happened for a considerable time.
Comment on this
This money is taken out of the Road Fund to provide employment for those otherwise unemployed.
Comment on this
And the only portion that may be discussed is the £100,000 to be taken from the Road Fund.
Comment on this
Yes, this money in the Road Fund designed to keep at home the boys and girls now going to England.
Comment on this
The House has given leave to introduce an Estimate which will deal with this question.
Comment on this
I want to know if this £100,000 is going to be used to keep those boys and girls at home and, if it is, does the Minister think that he is taking a sufficiently large amount from the Road Fund? If he wants to keep those boys and girls at home will he not require to take a lot more from the Road Fund when he has exhausted every other fund? Has the Minister any figures to give the House as to those who are emigrating at present?
Comment on this
How can I advise this House as to how much money we ought to take out of the Road Fund unless I can tell the House how many unemployed persons are seeking relief from unemployment by emigrating to Great Britain? That is the net point. Is the sum sufficient to meet the emergency that has arisen, or is it not? Some investigation must have been made before this sum was determined upon. The only investigation which could be made was, how many people must we provide employment for? My inquiry now is: Did the Minister, in arriving at that estimate, say, "We can depend on Great Britain to take so many of the unemployed and all we need provide for are those who are unable to go"?
Comment on this
That might have some relevance to the gross total and it can be discussed on the Supplementary Estimate which is to come before the House.
Comment on this
When the Minister decided on the sum of £100,000, did he choose that sum with a view to checking emigration? We must remember that the Minister for Industry and Commerce stated that the purpose he had in mind was, not only to stop emigration, but to promote immigration and bring back across the Atlantic the countless thousands who would be necessary to start the wheels of industry turning. Now we are faced with the problem of countless thousands going across to get work in England.
Comment on this
The whole grant for the relief of unemployment may not be discussed on this £100,000.
Comment on this
Is this sum sufficient to check the emigration going to Great Britain? If it is not, I desire to argue that a larger sum should be taken from the Road Fund. It is the policy of the Government to do away with the dog and the bullock and establish employment for all in this country.
Comment on this
Is it relevant to say that this sum is sufficient to stop emigration? What is the sum for? However, I will not trespass on your patience further. The Minister, I take it, is concerned to provide employment for all and sundry. Is he aware that a greater number of boys and girls are going to Great Britain now than ever went to America in the past? I assure him that that is true. I have no doubt that many are not going from Limerick, where the dairying industry is prospering, but from the poorer areas, where, I take it, this £100,000 will be spent—Mayo, Donegal, Galway and Clare—the people are going to Great Britain in greater numbers than they ever went to America. Is the Minister aware of that? Were those facts present to his mind when he fixed on this sum? If so, is he in a position to assure the House that when this money becomes available for expenditure in accordance with the plans he has in mind, it will no longer be necessary for the girls and boys of this country to go to Great Britain and get work there. The second question I want to ask is this: When he proceeds to distribute this £2,500,000 by way of wages on relief works, will he bear in mind——
Comment on this
The Deputy is anticipating a matter which will come before the House and afford an opportunity for discussing the whole question. The administration of the £2,500,000 does not arise on this section.
Comment on this
Am I entitled to ask the rate of wages which will be paid to the persons who will get a share of this £100,000?
Comment on this
I understand that if the Minister proposed to appropriate this money with a view to paying people one penny per week we are not entitled to oppose it. I will not press the matter, but I give the Minister notice that I shall arise, at the appropriate stage, a discussion on the comparative scales of wages he proposes to pay and those available to emigrants going to Great Britain.
Comment on this
I should like to ask why this money is being taken out of the Road Fund and the administration of it put under the charge of a person not normally responsible for the carrying out of the work generally carried out under the Road Fund. Usually the work provided by moneys paid into the Road Fund is done under the supervision and control of county surveyors throughout the country. It is rather interesting to see what was the money spent like that during the last four years. For the year ending March, 1932, £856,000 was spent out of the Road Fund. On 1st January, 1932, the total number of persons unemployed was 29,331. The number of persons unemployed on 1st January, 1933, was 100,987. During the year ending the following March, £1,417,000 was spent out of the Road Fund. The number of persons unemployed on 1st January, 1934, had fallen to 79,414. By the end of the following March, a couple of months later, £1,099,000 had been spent out of the Road Fund. The number of persons unemployed had risen very remarkably by the 1st January, 1935, to 128,000, before there was any inducement to register in respect of unemployment assistance. In spite of the fact that the number of persons unemployed had risen from 79,000 in January, 1934, to 128,000 in January, 1935, the expenditure from the Road Fund between the years ending 31st March, 1934, and 31st March, 1935, had fallen from £1,099,000 to £715,000. For the year ending March, 1936, the allocation from the Road Fund was only £716,000. So that the money actually spent from the Road Fund, under the control of the persons normally expending that money, was reduced by half in the year ending in March, 1936, from what it was in the year ending in March, 1933.
We have no indication yet as to the amount of money that is to be allocated from the Road Fund for normal expenditure on the roads during the year ending 31st March, 1937. I should like to ask how much money is going to be allocated from the Road Fund in respect of construction and maintenance for the current year. I do not see the advantage of taking money from the Road Fund, which would normally be expended under the supervision of the county surveyors, and transferring it to be expended under the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. We require some explanation as to the amount of money that is going to be spent out of the Road Fund during the year, and why £100,000 is going to be spent on special work. I think the question really does arise as to whether it is going to be spent on special wages, because it is being transferred from the county councils, who pay various rates of wages, according to the conditions that have been traditional in each county for work on the roads, to the administration of the Parliamentary Secretary who has indicated to the House that it would be as much as a man's life was worth to stand between an unemployed person and a job at 21/- per week. We should have information on these points before we agree to this taking of £100,000 from the Road Fund.
Comment on this
I wish to support the transfer of this £100,000 from the Road Fund and I wish to do so because my eyes have borne witness to the truth of what Deputy Dillon said a few moments ago. Any Deputy who takes the trouble to go down to Dun Laoghaire or to go to the North Wall on a Friday night will see the boats for England absolutely packed with young emigrants, mainly from the Counties of Galway and Mayo. Thinking that I might perhaps be generalising too much from what I saw myself on one or two occasions, I took the trouble to ask an officer on the ship at Dun Laoghaire whether this was an exceptional phenomenon, and he assured me that for a considerable time past it has been the same thing every Friday night: that the ships for England have been absolutely packed with emigrants, mainly from the Counties of Galway and Mayo.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I submit that a discussion on emigration hardly arises on an amendment to the Finance Bill.
Comment on this
The Chair is not obliged to give reasons. The Deputy knows that the Chair has already ruled that when the motion for the £2,500,000 for the relief of unemployment comes before the House, the matters that are now being discussed will be quite relevant. The Deputy is anticipating discussion on that motion.
Comment on this
I am sorry if I have been out of order. I did not wish to be. I shall not pursue a theme that I see is an unpopular one with the Government.
Comment on this
So far as I could gather, most of the information asked for by the Deputy refers to the administration of the Road Fund which, following the ruling of the Chair, ought not, I take it, to be discussed on this section. I have already said that a full opportunity will be given to the House when the Supplementary Estimate is brought in to discuss the method of financing and administering the Employment Fund. I think that the questions put by Deputy Mulcahy would be more relevant on that Supplementary Estimate than to this section.
Comment on this
This amendment to the Finance Bill has been moved by the Minister for the purpose of indicating to the House that additional employment is going to be given. On the face of it, it does not seem to me that there is any promise of additional employment being given out of the Road Fund by transferring from it £100,000 to be administered by the Parliamentary Secretary, thus leaving the county surveyors with that sum of money less to spend.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have the opportunity of moving an amendment to the Supplementary Estimate to delete the reference to the Road Fund.
Comment on this
What is proposed here in this new section indicates that money that would be normally spent under the direction of one part of the engineering machinery in the State on a definite class of work that we know the general lines of, is now going to be spent on another class of work. Reference has been made to the fact that there are certain areas in the country which, more than others, require to be assisted in this particular way. I submit that we ought to be told the general lines of the work on which it is proposed to spend this £100,000, and in what particular areas it is proposed to spend it.
Comment on this
The section moved by the Minister sets out that the object of it is to provide moneys—
"to meet charges which will fall upon the Central Fund in relation to schemes for the provision of employment and the relief of distress."
Therefore, what the Minister is proposing is to insert a new provision in his Finance Bill to enable him to provide money for the provision of employment and the relief of distress. The Minister is taking the sum of £100,000 out of the Road Fund to do that. Deputies are well aware that the procedure at present is that moneys voted out of the Road Fund are spent under the supervision of the county council officials. I am not at all satisfied that, if this sum of money is transferred to the new Employment Fund to be administered by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, as high a rate of wages will be paid to workers employed on the schemes undertaken as if the Road Fund moneys continued to be administered in the ordinary way by the county council officials.
Comment on this
The Minister seems very anxious to prevent the House from discussing that aspect of the situation on this new section. It is a matter for the House to decide whether or not the Minister is to get this £100,000 from the Road Fund. There is no doubt whatever, in my opinion, that as high a rate of wages will not be paid on works financed out of this money as if the money were voted in the ordinary way from the Road Fund and administered by the county councils. I suggest that the wording of this new section gives the House perfect liberty to discuss the unemployment and distress that prevail in the country.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 44:—
To delete reference No. 3, and all references thereto in columns 2, 3 and 4.
In moving this amendment I feel that I might as well be addressing my remarks to Nelson's Pillar or the North Pole as to the icy heart of the Minister for Finance. At the same time, I shall take the liberty of pointing out that this deals with a proposal to put a duty of 6d. per lb. on white, red and black pepper, ginger, nutmeg, cinnamon, clove, mace, caraway seed, and the other spices mentioned which are used for various purposes in the very poorest households in the country. This is, to me, the worst of the hidden taxes. It means a heavy imposition on people who find it very difficult to balance their weekly budget, far more difficult than the Minister for Finance finds it to balance his annual Budget. In addition, I may point out that the Minister ought to know, with his extensive knowledge of agriculture, that ginger is very largely used in veterinary medicine, and that an increase of 6d. per lb. in ginger adds to the already overwhelming and oppressive burdens which the farmers of this country have to bear under the present conditions. Perhaps, also, the Minister for Finance knows that in certain parts of the country during the cold months, a mixture of pepper and ginger is sprinkled on stout—so it is supposed to have some healthful effect and save people from various ailments. It is known in my part of the country as a "shake of the lad." For the future I am afraid the "shake of the lad" will become a thing of the past, as so many things have become under the present régime. Quite honestly and sincerely I appeal to the Minister that as this 6d. duty will press heavily on the extremely poor people, he ought to consider the advisability of withdrawing it.
Comment on this
That duty applies only to ground spices. Unground spices will not be affected. The grinding of these spices will be undertaken here, and there will be no increase in price.
Comment on this
Anyway, the Deputy's constituents will have no difficulty in getting pepper and ginger to sprinkle on their beer. I want to take this opportunity of correcting a misapprehension that may have been created by some remarks I made on the Report Stage of the Resolutions. I stated then that the grinding of spices was not being done in this country, or that all spices affected by the duty were imported in the ground state. The firm of William Black, Limited, of Shandon Park Mills, Phibsborough, have protested against that statement, and asserted that they have been grinding pepper and spices for some time past, and in fact sold a considerable quantity of ground pepper and spices during the course of the past year. I merely make that statement, as the firm have asked that it should be made. There will be other firms, I am sure, also engaged in the preparation of these ground spices, and there will be no difficulty in getting adequate supplies at present prices.
Comment on this
This just shows the kind of information acted upon in this House. The Minister romps in here and tells us he is going to put a duty on ground spices. He gets quite indignant if any questions are asked in regard to the proposal and he declares that it is a shame that the man-power of Ireland should stand idly by while pepper and other commodities are still to be ground. He declares that the opportunity should be given to the men of Ireland to work. The fact then emerges that the men of Ireland have been grinding pepper and spices for the last six months without the Minister's intervention. Where does the Minister get his information? Does it simply mean that anyone can ramble into Government Buildings and put a proposal before the Minister, or is there any kind of exhaustive inquiry made before tariffs are clapped on? Imagine a tariff being clapped on at the instance of persons who suggest to the Minister that all these commodities were being imported and it then emerges that a firm has been carrying on the grinding of pepper and spices for months.
Does it mean that some inefficient crumpaun, who could not ordinarily compete with anybody, comes in and asks for high protection in order to enable him to establish a business, while an enterprising man, prepared to meet competition and to put in efficient plant to meet competition whence ever it comes, does not come around begging to Government Buildings, but simply sets to work, establishes a little business and forges ahead? Now some incompetent crumpaun is going to be set up under the Minister's ægis to compete with a competent man who starts out on his own to establish a business. The end of it might be that the incompetent crumpaun, under Government patronage, will probably seriously interfere with the business of the efficient man. If that is not tariffs gone mad, I do not know what is.
Comment on this
About 90 per cent. of the ground spices are imported.
Amendment No. 44 put and negatived.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 45:—
To delete reference No. 12, and all references thereto in columns 2, 3 and 4.
This reference in the Schedule proposes what I consider to be a monstrous duty. It is a monstrous thing to tax our offerings at the shrine of Cloasina. It is quite possible that the indirect object of this duty may be to increase the sale of the Government organ.
Comment on this
We have here 18 pages of new duties, or duties that have been altered in some way. The remarkable thing is that out of the 44 items dealt with in this Schedule, in no fewer than 34 does the Minister take to himself power to issue licences for the importation of these things free of duty.
Comment on this
I am glad to have the Minister's correction, and I take it that he accepts the amended figure of 35 as correct. Therefore, in respect of 35 of the new duties, the Minister is not satisfied that we are in a position to produce those articles ourselves?
Comment on this
If that is so, will the Minister explain why he wants power to have them imported under licence free of duty?
Comment on this
Will the Minister give us any information, in regard to the 35 items, as to when home production will commence or when it will be sufficient to meet home requirements?
Comment on this
A great number of these duties will seriously affect the very poorest sections of the people.
Comment on this
Could not this discussion have more properly taken place on the Report Stage of the Resolutions?
Comment on this
It is a great pity the Minister is not in the Chair. If he were he might try to stifle all discussion on matters of supreme importance to the country. Here we have 18 pages in the First Schedule alone, and the Minister apparently is anxious to have it passed without discussion. If the Minister got his way, probably that is what he would like.
Comment on this
It requires at least three days to consider it. It is being moved as a First Schedule to this Bill for the first time.
Comment on this
I submit that a detailed examination comes more appropriately on this Stage. If necessary, I am sure the Ceann Comhairle will reinforce that opinion of mine.
Comment on this
Is the House to be treated in this way? Are members not entitled to exercise their rights, and are they to have no protection from this gentleman?
Comment on this
We adjourned the discussion on the Finance Bill early last night in order to enable the Minister to go out and make an election speech. We ought to have the last few minutes to-day in order to deal with this matter.
Comment on this
If I am not finished before 2 o'clock, I will move to report progress. The Minister has not yet power to amend the Standing Orders of this House. The real reason why the Minister is so angry is that he does not want to have these matters exposed. According to the Minister, we are to pass these items without discussion.