We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Bread (Regulation of Prices) Bill, 1936—Committee.

Contributions 1–169 of 341. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Bread (Regulation of Prices) Bill, 1936
Enacted

No. 17 of 1936 ›

I move amendment No. 1:—

To insert at the end of the section the words: "the word ‘flour' means any flour obtained wholly or mainly from wheat."

Throughout the Bill the word "flour" is used without reference to wheat, and it is considered desirable to have this definition of "flour" in order to make it clear that the flour referred to has been obtained wholly or mainly from wheat. It is purely a matter of definition.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy O'Neill I move amendment No. 2:—

After line 13 to add the following words:—

For the purposes of this Act "bread" shall be deemed to be of two kinds (a) plain or batch bread and (b) fancy bread;

"plain bread" or "batch bread" means the baked product of wheaten flour or meal, with the elementary ingredients of water, salt, yeast and not baked in a tin or container;

"fancy bread" means bread containing other added ingredients such as fats, malt, milk, fruit, spice or sugar and baked in tins or containers;

"a loaf of bread" means an integral portion of bread weighing not less than two pounds.

The object is to have discussion and some enlightenment from the Minister. Really the amendment is relevant to a later section that Deputy O'Neill proposes to add about a certain further definition, that bread shall be of two types, either plain or fancy, and a definition of these types. The definition as given will have to be the subject of some modification as it is limited in a particular way by the use of the phrase "baked in tins or containers." The purpose of the amendment is really to be seen by reference to amendment No. 3. In the Bill as it stands the Minister takes power, whenever he thinks fit by order which is to be referred to as a bread (price) order, to fix the maximum price of bread of a specified kind, which has this definition for the Minister's use, "defined in such manner and by reference to such things as the Minister shall think proper." That means that when making a price order he can make it vary according to the list of things set out and, in addition, whatever else enters into his head. Deputy O'Neill proposes to remove that. If there is to be any distinction between a maximum price order it shall have reference only to classification between plain bread and fancy bread, instead of having the multitudinous things that the Minister might put in.

Comment on this

I think it is better to leave the Bill as it stands. It is not necessary to have the first part of this amendment, which states that bread shall be plain or fancy bread because bread can be defined under the provisions of Section 3 (2). We gave consideration to the desirability of having in the Bill a definition of plain bread and fancy bread, as is now proposed by Deputy O'Neill's amendment, but it was decided, from the point of view of securing the effectiveness of the measure, and good administration generally, that it was better not to insert that definition in the Bill, but to take power to define the particular class of bread to which any order made would relate. I am disposed to maintain that position, because the Bill has been framed on that basis, and to attempt the change which Deputy O'Neill suggests would require an alteration of the whole framework and, in addition, we feel would prove a matter of administrative difficulty. In relation to this Bill it is necessary to bear in mind that we have already come up against considerable legal difficulties in giving effect to the report of the Prices Commission. Despite the fairly wide provisions of the Control of Prices Act it became impossible to control the price of bread under that Act, and it is in relation to these matters that difficulties arose, and in a very special way on matters of definition. If we were to put into the Bill what purported to be clear-cut definitions of plain bread and fancy bread, it might be found subsequently that these definitions could be avoided, or orders made under the Bill rendered inoperative, in consequence of some failure to link up these orders with the definitions, or to relate them to the particular class of bread which would be considered as coming within the scope of the definitions. It was considered a better arrangement, from the point of view of drafting the measure, as well as of administering it when it becomes an Act, that each Order should have within it a definition of the class of bread to which it relates. I, therefore, think no difficulty would arise.

Comment on this

With regard to the definition of classes of bread, to get back to the basic position of the matter, we have been discussing a Bill regarding bread prices, but nobody has been able to define what bread is. We are talking about something the definition of which is not known. The Minister will recollect that in some prosecutions under the Bread Act of 1838, a lot of trouble arose over the definition of what was bread. That Act rightly said that all bread should be sold by weight, except fancy bread and French rolls, but it never defined what bread was or what fancy bread or French rolls were. My idea in furnishing a definition is to avoid similar trouble in future. I am with the Minister in saying that, as far as possible, people who are buying bread should know what they are going to get. With regard to the classification, the object of this Act and the Minister's primary idea, were to see that the public got bread at a fair price. The object of the Prices Commission was to see that the public got what constituted good wholesome bread at a fair price commensurate with the cost of materials and the cost of production. I want if possible to define what bread is, and let the Minister confine his legislation altogether to bread. What I consider as bread is a product made up of the elementary ingredients of flour, water, salt and yeast. I am quite prepared to fall in with the Minister's idea that in legislating for a matter of this kind we ought to confine ourselves to bread, and it is to help the Minister that I have put forward this definition.

Comment on this

The Deputy put his finger on the trouble when he mentioned that in previous legislation of this kind the fault lay in the definition of the article.

Comment on this

That was not what was reported.

Comment on this

I put it this way. There is an anticipated difficulty that a definition of bread in the Bill might prove to be, in some respects, an incomplete definition, that certain bread sold as ordinary bread might be outside the definition, and consequently not subject to control.

Comment on this

That is why prosecutions broke down in years past.

Comment on this

We are trying to avoid that by having no definition in the Bill, and by fixing the price in an Order which prescribes the type of bread to which it relates. We would then have the position that if that description should prove to be incomplete or ineffective, it could be remedied by new legislation. You get precisely the same result by the procedure in the Bill which sets out that the Minister shall make an Order fixing the price, and in that Order shall state the class of bread to which it relates.

Comment on this

That is what I want to have. I have been trying to find a definition of bread, and I have discussed this matter with several people well up in the law. I have found that there was no actual definition of bread in previous legislation. The most elementary definition I could find was that bread was a product made from corn, but that definition would include stirabout and rice pudding. I would ask the Minister to define the class of bread and to confine his operations under the Act to nothing else but bread. The Minister may say that there is no necessity to define bread any more than there is to define water. Perhaps not, but bread is something that is manufactured and sold. Water is not manufactured and sold, though bread, like water, is an elementary necessary of life. I would ask the Minister to confine himself to legislating for bread, and let the fancy bread take care of itself.

Comment on this

It is in relation to ordinary batch bread that the powers are required, but the Deputy knows that what was regarded as ordinary bread was considered to be fancy bread on occasions. Therefore, we are taking power to define bread——

Comment on this

You are not.

Comment on this

——in the Orders fixing the price.

Comment on this

You are taking power to define the kind of bread for which a price is fixed, but not what bread is. Let me put this to the Minister. So far as the Minister's Orders with regard to price may have widespread effect, he has got in a number of provisions that ensure that. He may make even conditions in regard to the element of price relating them to where the bread is sold, whether it is sold at the place where it is got out, at the bakery, or some other place. He can make a variety of conditions regarding the maximum price in, relation to different types of bread, in areas, and in relation to variations dependent upon the price of flour. But the Minister seems to think that he is going to be handicapped if he has got to say somewhere or other what bread is or what it is not. If it is possible to add something to the ordinary ingredients named in the definition, then bread to which that addition is made is taken out of the category to which the Order applies. What he is entitled to do is to fix the price at which bread of a specified kind is to be sold. If by adding something doubt may be cast on whether the article sold is in the category of bread or not, by putting that something in, you take that article out of the control of this measure altogether. Very good. Deputy O'Neill puts forward this definition, which I think is closing in on the problem. There are going to be two types of bread. You can limit one and say that everything else is over the top. Deputy O'Neill defines plain bread or batch bread as the baked product of wheaten flour or meal with the elementary ingredients of water, salt, yeast, and not baked in a container. I am not sure about that last phrase, but let that pass. Fancy bread is defined as bread containing other added ingredients. If you have a definition of that type, it is very hard to say that something which is usually called bread can no longer be called bread because there is something which is not ordinarily found in bread added to it. I do not know the Minister's difficulty in this. So far as his statement indicated it, he suggested that there may be something added to ordinary bread, and then the whole measure fails because that bread contains something which was not in the definition. All apparently he can do is to define the kinds of bread to which an Order relates, and if bread does not come within these categories it escapes.

Comment on this

We are taking power to describe the type of bread to which an Order relates.

Comment on this

I am still very insistent on this amendment, because I am acquainted with this business. I am surprised the Minister did not retort on me and ask me when did bread cease to be fancy bread and come into the region of cake. There was a very important case decided here some years ago when bread control was in force during the war years, and it was then proved that any baked product in which flour was the chief ingredient and to which there was added any sweetening matter in the form of sugar, or other sweetening substance, came into the region of cake. I want to insist and to impress upon the Minister that if he wants to make this Bill a success he must begin with an elementary definition of bread and confine it to bread and not mind about different kinds of bread and shapes of bread. The more elementary he can make his order the better. I am now talking of the main principle, which is the control of prices and the giving to the people of a sound loaf at the lowest possible price.

Comment on this

I am satisfied that the procedure adopted in the Bill is the best. Deputy Mulcahy on the Second Reading complained of the delay in introducing this measure. A large part of the delay arose out of the consideration of this particular point. It arose out of the very question the Deputy has raised whether there should be a definition of bread and if so, what definition.

Comment on this

Can the Minister now define bread so as to bring in cakes and pastry?

Comment on this

We can define bread if the commodity is within either of the definitions set out by Deputy O'Neill.

Comment on this

Can you not go further than that? There might come a time when the commodity might be held by a court not to be bread at all.

Comment on this

We are not defining it at all.

Comment on this

You are defining it "In such manner and by reference to such things as the Minister shall think proper."

Comment on this

We have to describe the article that the Order relates to. We take that procedure because we recognise the possibility of a definition not covering the particular article we want to cover.

Comment on this

You may want to cover pastry but you should not be allowed to do that in a Bread Bill.

Comment on this

No, we want bread, and anything that would be held not to be bread cannot come within that scope.

Comment on this

Is there anything that can be described as bread in the definition?

Comment on this

Things that may possibly be conceived as bread would come in.

Comment on this

Can you give us one?

Comment on this

Let me confine myself to some definition. If the Minister confines himself to the dictionary definition he will find himself at sea. The dictionary says ordinary bread which might mean currant bread or corned bread or stirabout. I think the Minister would be well advised to take an ordinary elementary definition. Bread is a very elementary article made from flour with ingredients of water, salt and yeast. That is bread. The Minister has shown a great deal of bravery by attacking this question at all. The last Act passed in relation to bread was in 1838. There has been nothing done since. The Minister is aware there were a lot of abuses in the bread trade because of this want of definition. If there was a little more definition, of an elementary character, the matter would become clear and the Minister will find that everyone wants to work in with him. He should stick to an elementary, clear, fundamental definition. That would be the proper course to take.

Comment on this

The best course is not to make a definition at all.

Comment on this

That is what I object to. Since the Act of 1838 we have gone on for nearly 100 years. Two commissions were set up here but not a single individual came before them to say that there was any abuse. For over 100 years people have been content with the Act as it stood. Some seem to think it failed, and two commissions were set up; yet as I said they could not get a single consumer to come before them and say that anything was wrong. Here now we have a Bill with a definite purpose and the Minister takes power under it to define bread in a manner in which he could bring in things that are not bread at all.

Comment on this

We could not bring in anything that obviously is not bread.

Comment on this

No, of course you could not bring in vegetables, but there are things on the border line. There can be no great difficulty in saying what bread is. You are going to define prices, and the maximum prices that are to be charged in relation to bread. You may have an Order in operation as to where bread is to be sold; the price of flour and any number of things are set out, but nothing in relation to what bread is. Let us know what it is. Let us know what is what we call in the Free State plain bread. If not you will be calling other things, such as fancy bread which contains other ingredients not contained in plain bread, bread.

Comment on this

If we fix a price for fancy bread at all—and that may not be done, because according to the recent Commission's report they had no evidence of an undue price for fancy bread—but if there was a price fixed for fancy bread the baker would have very little difficulty in getting outside the definition to which the Deputy referred. The Deputy will remember that a baker in the South of Ireland added a little fat and described the product as cake or fancy bread, and was deemed to be outside the Order.

Comment on this

The Minister is suggesting that the bakers of this country are going to put fat into their bread in order to get outside the order.

Comment on this

No, I suggest it was done once.

Comment on this

Why not call this a fat regulation of prices Bill?

Comment on this

Because it is a bread regulation of prices Bill.

Comment on this

And you do not know what bread is.

Comment on this

We will describe it in the Order. If that does not describe all classes of bread that we want to catch, then a new Order will be made bringing within its scope all that is outside and should be. That is the simple method of administration.

Comment on this

Yes, but it is not necessarily a bread prices Bill. It may be a fat and beet prices Bill. When we are dealing with bread we ought to know what the commodity is. I am asking the Minister to tell me something that is going to happen and to tell me what is bread. He has not done so. I do not know what complaint there was of delay in bringing in this measure here. For my part there was not enough delay in bringing it in. I think it would have been better postponed for another five years. We were promised a report from the commission in May, 1933, but we did not get that report until August, 1935.

Comment on this

Meantime they reported on flour.

Comment on this

That commission, although sitting for two years, could not get a solitary consumer in the Irish Free State to come before them.

Comment on this

What does that prove?

Comment on this

That there was no complaint with regard to bread.

Comment on this

But with regard to prices.

Comment on this

The Minister thinks that, in order to get out of the Price Order, bakers are going to upset the whole tradition of their trade and are going to try to make the public take something else to which their taste is not accustomed. They are to do that in order to get out of the Price Order. That is folly.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

The Minister says he is not going to define "bread" but is going to define different kinds of bread. Bread is bread. There cannot be different kinds of an elementary article like bread.

Comment on this

There can be plain bread and fancy bread.

Comment on this

They are not different kinds of bread.

Comment on this

Even under the Deputy's definition there could be different classes of bread.

Comment on this

There is salt water and there is fresh water, but they are the same elemental article.

Comment on this

And there is hot water and cold water.

Comment on this

If the Minister is going to define "classes of bread" in this way, he is going to define things that are not bread.

Comment on this

Does not the Deputy's amendment provide for two classes of bread?

Comment on this

Not two classes.

Comment on this

Then two kinds of bread?

Comment on this

He says "shall be deemed to be".

Comment on this

I want to make the matter easy for the Minister, and, if he takes my advice, he will accept my definition.

Comment on this

I have gone into this matter very thoroughly and, if we provide a definition, some particular baker is going to take advantage of his competitors by devising a method of getting out of the definition. In these circumstances, we should have to be coming back with an amending Bill each time a difficulty arose. It is better to leave this question of what constitutes bread to be determined when making the Order. If there is any doubt as to what the Order covers, it can be resolved by the court.

Comment on this

It is extraordinary to have to wait for the courts to define bread. For a hundred years and upwards the courts have been pointing out that there is no legal definition of bread. We have the power now to provide a definition in simple terms and, if we do so, it will be in the interest of the trade, of the public and of our legislation. It will make the job of the Minister much easier than it would be.

Comment on this

The absence of a definition in previous legislation was not without cause. It was owing to the fact that previous Governments had the same difficulty.

Comment on this

Owing to the absence of a definition, there has been confusion regarding both the sale of bread and the manufacture of bread. If the Minister is going to make Orders without first having defined what bread is, he is going to lead himself into a lot of trouble.

Comment on this

I think that, to make the Bill effective, we should avoid a definition.

Comment on this

I have more experience of the matter than the Minister has.

Comment on this

This is a question of devising an effective method of fixing prices.

Comment on this

You may know more than I do. But I have 40 years' experience.

Comment on this

If we put in the Deputy's definition, we shall be staking the effectiveness of this Bill, when it becomes an Act, on the accuracy of the definition. If the definition is wrong or if, by any device, it can be evaded, the whole Act will fall to the ground.

Comment on this

It is so elementary that it could not be evaded.

Comment on this

The Deputy admitted a short time ago that it was done.

Comment on this

Because there was no definition.

Comment on this

Is the addition the Minister thinks will take place something that will make the article not bread?

Comment on this

It might make it fancy bread or plain bread.

Comment on this

Is it something that will make the article to be sold not bread?

Comment on this

I am not thinking about that.

Comment on this

I am thinking of the difficulty that will arise if you have a higher price for fancy bread than for plain bread. If, by the addition of fat, sugar or any of the things mentioned in Deputy O'Neill's amendment, a baker could get his plain bread outside Deputy O'Neill's definition of plain bread and into the category of fancy bread, he would be entitled to charge a higher price or, perhaps, any price he liked.

Comment on this

But the public would be assured of getting wholesome, plain bread at a reasonable price.

Comment on this

Because you properly define bread. If the public want fancy articles, let them pay fancy prices for them.

Comment on this

I am considering a case in which there might be only one baker in a town. A combination of bakers in a town might also upset the definition of plain bread and give the public no choice but to buy an article which was, in fact, plain bread, but which came within the legal definition of "fancy bread." To guard against that, it is necessary to have this device and to avoid a rigid definition of "bread," while giving the Minister power to define in the Order the classes of bread to which it relates.

Comment on this

Not merely the classes of bread but the classes of anything other than bread.

Comment on this

It must be bread.

Comment on this

What is bread?

Comment on this

Bread.

Comment on this

You are back again to the same difficulty.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister as to whether he proposes to accept the definition of "loaf." I suppose there is no use in asking him to accept these definitions in any form.

Comment on this

I propose to define "loaf' under the description of "bread." The Deputy's definition would exclude from the operation of the Bill the 1-lb. loaf, which is not uncommon in many parts of the country.

Comment on this

You have set your face against accepting the definition?

Comment on this

I have been considering the question for six months.

Comment on this

I have been at it for 40 years, and I want you to avail of my experience. I think it is even more important to define "loaf" than to define "bread." I am not going to exclude the small loaf or 1-lb. loaf. I want to go back to what the Minister and his advisers are aiming at—that is, that the public should get in all cases what they want. When a man asks for a loaf of bread from a vanman or in a shop, it is generally accepted that he wants 2 lbs. of bread. This definition would ensure that where a person sells a loaf he sells an integral portion of bread weighing 2 lbs. That is intended to avoid some of the tricks the Minister alluded to a little while ago. The Minister is aware that under the old Acts a person could go into a shop and ask for a loaf of bread. If it were a plain loaf it should, under the Act of 1838, weigh 2 lbs. If there were a suspicion that the loaf did not weigh that amount, the shopkeeper could put it on the scales, and if the weight were short he could cut a chunk off another loaf and put it into the scales to make up the weight. That is capable of great abuse, because nobody buying bread is going to ask to have it weighed. I want to have it settled that when a person sells a loaf of bread, whether in a shop or from a van in the street, the person purchasing it will get 2 lbs. of bread.

Comment on this

I am taking power under Section 4 to make it illegal for bread to be sold save in weight of 1 lb. or multiples of 1 lb. That provision will be enforced by the inspectors of weights and measures.

Comment on this

That does not prevent your accepting my definition of the word "loaf".

Comment on this

The word "loaf" does not appear in the Bill.

Comment on this

It will have to appear in your Order.

Comment on this

The price will be fixed per lb. and the loaf must be 1 lb. or multiples thereof.

Comment on this

The "loaf," the Minister says, must be that weight. You make an Order and say that bread must be sold by weight. A person goes into a shop and asks for a loaf of bread. He takes that loaf home. The loaf is 2 lbs. weight and he pays the standard price—5d.—for it. When he goes home, he finds that the loaf does not weigh 2 lbs. An inspector is appointed, and under the Minister's order he goes into a shop next day and buys a loaf of bread. According to the Minister's order he asks the shopkeeper for a loaf; he weighs it and finds it only weighs 1 lb. 12 ozs., and he then says to the shopkeeper: "I will prosecute you," and the shopkeeper says: "No; you asked for a loaf and I gave you a loaf." There was no question of the weight. That is what will happen.

Comment on this

As the law stands at present that would be the position. If this Bill becomes law there will be no such thing as a loaf. The bread must be sold as a 1 lb., a 2 lb., a 3 lb. or a 4 lb. loaf or some multiple of a lb. If somebody sells anything that is not a 1 lb. or a multiple of a 1 lb. loaf he is acting illegally.

Comment on this

What is a multiple of 1 lb.? Is not 1 lb. 12 ozs. a multiple of 1 lb.?

Comment on this

Does the Minister really mean by that that if the loaf is a ½ oz. over the 1 lb. weight, it will be an offence on the part of the baker?

Comment on this

It will not be an offence, but it will be an offence to sell as a 2-lb. loaf a loaf that is less than 2 lbs.

Comment on this

That is not what is in this section.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister to accept that definition of a loaf.

Comment on this

I am satisfied that the way to avoid this trouble is to leave out the word loaf altogether and to sell it by weight.

Comment on this

In spite of the Minister's orders they can have any weight they like, and he will afterwards find out that.

Comment on this

The fairest thing is to relate your price to the weight.

Comment on this

A person goes in for a loaf of bread and he gets 1 lb. 12 ozs. He has no case because he asked for a loaf of bread. He did not ask for 2 lbs. of bread. That is what will always happen.

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy O'Neill. If people come in and ask for a loaf or for two loaves of bread and they are given a certain quantity it is difficult to say that a shopkeeper has done anything wrong. The custom is they always ask for a loaf.

Comment on this

It is evident that the Minister is not going to use my wisdom at all. He is set against my amendment.

Comment on this

I think it is better to put the obligation on the baker.

Comment on this

When the Minister issues his orders he will find that I am right.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 3 is consequential on amendment No. 2 and it goes out.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:—

In sub-section (2) (b) to delete all after the word "price" in line 20 to the end of the paragraph, and substitute the words "and where such variable price is fixed it shall be in accordance with a scale, made in relation to the standard price of flour by the Minister, after consultation with four representatives nominated by the Irish Association of Master Bakers.

This is an amendment that gives the Minister power whether he uses it or not to fix the price after consultation with four representatives nominated by the Irish Association of Master Bakers. The Minister may say the millers' representatives are a statutory body. I think that in the working of his orders he should have an understanding with the people concerned. That would be the usual thing to do.

Comment on this

When the Minister consults the Flour Millers' Association he does not do it for the purpose of determining what should be the proper price of flour. When the Minister comes to fix the price of bread he is carrying out a different function altogether. If you put on him the obligation to consult with the Master Bakers before fixing the price of bread then in effect you are putting on him an obligation to carry out a new investigation. We have set up a Prices Commission. They have heard evidence and they have given their opinion as to the prices of bread and, in consequence of their report that an excessive price had been charged in particular areas, this Bill is being brought forward. In operating the Bill we mean to take their report and recommendations as our basis and not before making our order to carry out a new investigation covering which they have already covered. If provision were put in the Bill whereby the price of bread would be again investigated in relation to any change in the circumstances that might alter the Prices Commission's findings.

It is the Prices Commission that will be investigating this matter and not the Minister for Industry and Commerce. He will act upon the conclusions of the Prices Commission. They will send their report to him. This report will have regard only to the prices prevailing for bread throughout the country. Therefore, although the Minister would be available at any time to consider representations made to him by the Master Bakers' Association, he should not be under a statutory obligation to consult them, because, if so, that would mean that he would have to investigate the Prices Commission's report and carry out a new investigation himself.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I take it that amendments Nos. 4 and 5 are being discussed together.

Comment on this

No. Amendment No. 5 has reference to a specified area, and No. 4 has to do with the price of flour. There is a difference.

Comment on this

The millers are a statutorily defined body, and the Minister is going to approach them, not only about what the price of flour should be, but what it is. I think he should be bound by statute to do so. Bread is related to the price of flour, but flour enters into the price of bread to less than 50 per cent. of the cost. There are other matters that enter into the production costs to a greater extent than 50 per cent., and these matters vary in different areas. That is the reason why I ask the Minister to take cognisance of the particular costs in these areas.

Comment on this

If the situation should arise in which there was reason to believe that the other elements entering into the cost of bread referred to in the Prices Commission Report had changed, I think the Minister should ask the Prices Commission to inquire into the circumstances and report, and he should act upon this report.

Comment on this

How long did the Commission spend in investigating the price of bread?

Comment on this

The report on the price of flour was not completed until the end of 1934, and it was only after that that they took up the price of bread.

Comment on this

They reported on the prices charged, but never took any action with regard to flour.

Comment on this

I did not make any statutory order.

Comment on this

The Minister did not take any steps to investigate the price of flour. Flour here is 11/- a sack higher than in Great Britain or Northern Ireland.

Comment on this

It is not right to say I took no action. I will not say that the action was effective, but when we came to see what effective action should be taken we were up against other problems. I think Deputy Dillon, if Deputy McGilligan listened to him, was not very far from the mark when indicating the only possible line of action, if we cannot get the voluntary adjustment which I hope to get.

Comment on this

To make the efficient people pay for the inefficient people is a most preposterous and shocking proposal.

Comment on this

I want to protest in connection with this measure at the idea that bakers are a frightful lot of unscrupulous and unconscionable profiteers, and that the flour millers are not, because they are protecting a great industry and carrying out a great cereal policy. The bakery industry is a much more important industry than the flour industry, and there are nearly twice as many people employed in it. The bakers have no say with regard to the price or the quality of flour that they buy. They are restricted in their market. They must buy flour in their own area, and buy it at any price the miller likes to charge. because there is no competition. When this Bill was being brought in the Irish Press came out with a shout about bread profiteers before there was any investigation. Anyone who looks at the prices will see that the bakers are not charging unreasonable prices.

Comment on this

In fact, I will go further and say that the bakers in some areas are charging less than the maximum price that the Prices Commission recommended.

Comment on this

Cork was aimed at especially as a terrible place, while Dublin was said to be a grand place— they were doing what the Prices Commission wanted. At that time there was bread being sold in Dublin at more than 2d. per pair above the Cork price, and there was no talk about it, and they were producing a low price bread to put dust in the eyes of the Prices Commission. The Minister should consult with some of the representatives of the bakery trade with regard to this matter. I want to deprecate any antagonism between the trade and the Minister. It would be better for them to work together. Both the Minister and the bakery trade seem to be in the hands of the millers.

Comment on this

It would, I think, be quite reasonable to expect whoever is Minister for Industry and Commerce to give consideration to whatever representations are made to him by bakers in one form or another, but I think it would be a mistake to put upon him that statutory obligation to consult, because I think that would, in fact, come to mean an obligation to carry out personally, or through his own officers, an investigation which has been already conducted by the Prices Commission.

Comment on this

The difficulty is that the Prices Commission at the time they made the Order, which is the basis of this legislation, in August, 1935, had investigated the price of bread all over the country and they found that different conditions prevailed as regards costings and the production of bread. Still they wanted to make an Order applicable to the whole country, irrespective of districts. That shows the foolish things the Prices Commission are likely to do.

Comment on this

They are fixing the maximum price.

Comment on this

Yes, and the maximum was not fixed on the maximum condition of costs.

Comment on this

They claim it was.

Comment on this

I know for a fact that it was not, because they fixed the same price for places other than Cork, and Cork makes the best bread in the world. It is bread that costs the most to produce, and costs and wages are higher in Cork than in any part of Ireland, Great Britain, or even the world. Still the Commission took no cognisance of that fact. They fixed the price for bread made on the smallest little turf oven in Connemara or Kerry on the same level as bread made in Cork, where the highest quality of bread is produced. The Minister is going to alter that to some extent by fixing prices for different areas, but he says he will not consult the bakers in the different areas, only the Prices Commission. We have the mentality of the Prices Commission. They think in a straight line. It is a good thing to do that sometimes, but they ought to have regard to the circumstances that obtain in various areas where different conditions prevail. If the Minister is only going to consult the Prices Commission, he ought to try to get some better advice than he got hitherto. He would find it much easier to deal with some intelligent body like the representatives of the master bakers, whose intelligence is very much higher.

Comment on this

After all, there exists an organisation which has now become highly developed and really efficient in the matter of carrying out an investigation of this kind.

Comment on this

What is that?

Comment on this

The Prices Commission.

Comment on this

You do not mean that?

Comment on this

I do. They have built up a machine under their control which is an effective machine, and if there is to be any question of investigation into prices or costs generally, or in a particular area, surely it is that machine that should be utilised rather than a new one to be improvised for the purpose.

Comment on this

In dealing with the master bakers, the Minister will be dealing with men who are masters of their business, and not road makers or furniture makers or anything like that.

Comment on this

I should like to get this on to another plane. In Section 2 the Minister takes power to fix the price of flour. He binds himself, in the most rigid way, that before making any order under this section with regard to flour he is to consult the Milling Advisory Committee. He is going to take power to fix the price of flour, and before he fixes the price, or as often as he changes it, he has to consult the Milling Advisory Committee. He is going to fix a maximum price for bread. It is suggested to him, in a limited way, far too limited in regard to one sub-paragraph, that he should consult with the Association of Master Bakers. He says: "No, it is wrong to put the statutory obligation on me to consult that body." Why? He has already put upon himself the obligation statutorily to consult the Milling Advisory Committee before he fixes the price for flour.

Comment on this

I am not fixing the price of flour, that is the point; at least, not fixing it in the same sense as prescribing a maximum price.

Comment on this

Let me read what the Minister proposes to do. Section 2 reads: "Subject to the provisions of this section, the Minister may, whenever and so often as he thinks fit, by order under this sub-section fix, for the purposes of this Act, the price of flour for any specified area, and the price so fixed shall, so long as such order remains in force, be, for the purposes of this Act, the standard price of flour for such area."

Comment on this

That means ascertain and declare.

Comment on this

I do not care what it means. The Minister is going to fix the price of flour. It may be ascertaining and declaring. But before he fixes, ascertains and declares, or fixes in technical language, before making any order, he has to consult the Milling Advisory Committee. When we turn to bread, he is going to fix a maximum price for bread. He is taking power to fix it with regard to bread of specified kinds. He is going to fix it with a series of variations regarding places, regarding different kinds of bread, and having regard, possibly, to variations in the price of flour. Deputy O'Neill says, and I think with too much limitation, that before he fixes the price, where that price is to vary according to the price of flour, he should consult the Irish Association of Master Bakers, not get an agreement with, or go into a long investigation with them, not insist on the master bakers going through an investigation that the Minister may think the Prices Commission had better be told to do; not any of these things, but to consult with the Irish Association of Master Bakers. The Minister thinks it is a hardship to have that imposed on him by statute. Why? He is going to fix the price of bread. A later amendment asks the Minister that, in case he is going to fix a maximum price for bread, he should consult, not get agreement with, but consult with the Irish Association of Master Bakers.

Comment on this

What will be the object of the consultation?

Comment on this

That those people who are in the trade, and who may see reactions from a special prices order that the Minister may not see, may be allowed to put the educated view of people in the trade before him, and only that. There is no question of getting agreement.

Comment on this

I want to put this: The Minister either takes the Prices Commission's report and says "There is the Prices Commission's report; I am acting upon that," or else he proceeds to turn down the Prices Commission's report.

Comment on this

Or may say to himself, as any reasonable or sane man might say, that a report made in August, 1935, may not hold good for ever.

Comment on this

Nobody is claiming that it will hold good for ever.

Comment on this

Why not give the master bakers an opportunity of stating that the circumstances have changed and that a scale fixed at a particular time was not a proper one now?

Comment on this

They can say that to the Prices Commission.

Comment on this

Well, get the Prices Commission to consult the master bakers before making the order. I do not care how it is done. I would rather have it done in the way set out here, because the Prices Commission is a body which I have always derided. It was given an impossible task to do, and it has failed even to approach that task. It has not got any public confidence. The Prices Commission has been in being now for almost three years. It has made, I think, three reports. The only thing it has done is to help to bring down the price at which coal was to be sold to two bellmen. It made a fatuous report on flour which the Minister has definitely put aside. The Minister does not even accept that in his measure—to a great extent it is not accepted. One of the things that it did explicitly say was that a price order should be made for the whole of the Saorstát and not for any area. The Minister will not accept that. One of its reports, the one about flour, the Minister is ashamed to have mentioned in the House. He will not act on it. The Commission will be subjected to complete derision if he ever does act on the lines recommended in its report.

Comment on this

I think that the report of the Prices Commission on flour is a very valuable one, and if the flour millers had acted on it we would have had no complaints.

Comment on this

It has been in the Minister's possession for over a year, and it is so valuable that I have never heard him, until this evening, even attempt to defend it.

Comment on this

I told the House long ago that I had an assurance from the Flour Millers' Association that they were going to fix their prices in accordance with that report.

Comment on this

What they said was to rob the efficient people and to elevate the inefficient people.

Comment on this

That was only one part of it.

Comment on this

That is a principle that the Minister will not get across this House. Although I think it is a bad intermediary, let the Minister if he likes say that, before making an order fixing the price of bread, he will consult the Master Bakers via the Prices Commission. Let him if he likes cloak himself behind the Prices Commission. I should prefer that the Minister would consult the Master Bakers directly. All that Deputy O'Neill's amendment asks is that if a prices order is going to be made varying the price of bread in accordance with the price of flour, that then there will be consultation with the Master Bakers. The Minister thinks that is a handicap that should not be imposed on him.

Comment on this

That it is an obligation that should not be imposed on me.

Comment on this

The obligation to meet people in the business and to allow them to say, whatever may have been the rights or wrongs in the past, that the standard fixed by the Prices Commission and reported on in August, 1935, should be altered, and to suggest that that standard should not operate. The Minister thinks that there should not be an obligation on him to listen to the Master Bakers.

Comment on this

That is not the point. There is no difficulty about listening to them. The Minister has got to do one of two things at the end of the audition. He has got to decide that their representations are right or that the Prices Commission is wrong, or else he has got to turn them down and act on the report of the Prices Commission.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

Or there is the third alternative which should not be there, namely, that the Minister has got to carry out a second investigation of his own.

Comment on this

The Minister need not say that the Prices Commission was wrong. He may hold that it was right in the circumstances in which it reported, but if since that report was made the Master Bakers can show that conditions have changed then it may come to the question of carrying out a new investigation if it be shown that the situation has fundamentally changed. If the situation has changed, let that be shown by direct intervention on the part of the Master Bakers to the Minister.

Comment on this

I would prefer to see the Master Bakers going to the Prices Commission.

Comment on this

Because it will take a year before the information will get to your office.

Comment on this

Is it not much better to keep that protection there for the public even though there is delay for a year?

Comment on this