We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Bread (Regulation of Prices) Bill, 1936—Committee.

Contributions 170–341 of 341. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Bread (Regulation of Prices) Bill, 1936
Enacted

No. 17 of 1936 ›

Suppose the Prices Commission report after a year that the standard is wrong and that an order has been made in the meantime? I think the Minister ought to meet the people who are in the business and have consultation with them.

Comment on this

The Master Bakers can have consultation with the Prices Commission any time they want it.

Comment on this

When will the Prices Commission report?

Comment on this

The trouble in this matter is to get the Prices Commission to understand the point of view of the Master Bakers. There is no member of the Commission who has any intimate knowledge of the trade.

Comment on this

I am accepting their report, and I am sustained in that action by the judicial commission which produced a similar report in 1926.

Comment on this

The members of the Prices Commission know nothing about this business. It is a very hard thing to drive anything into their heads. They may know something about accountancy, but they know nothing about the intricacies or technique of the trade. What can anyone engaged in laying asphalt roads be expected to know about the bakery trade?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy cannot discuss the personnel of the Commission.

Comment on this

Surely he is entitled to say that the members of the Commission are not experts in bakery matters.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy were allowed to pursue the particular line he was on, it would mean discussing the personnel of the Commission.

Comment on this

A very important point in this is that the Minister is taking power to make what he calls a variable order. I take it that he has in mind the suggestion made in the Prices Commission report that the price of bread should vary in accordance with the price of flour. I think the procedure that has been adopted in England should be followed here. The system that is in practice there has worked out very smoothly, and I do not see any reason why the Minister should not do something on the same lines here.

Comment on this

The price of bread will vary with the standard price of flour.

Comment on this

It is one of the matters on which the Minister might consult with the Master Bakers. So far as I understand, the Minister is not going to consult the Master Bakers in fixing that variable standard.

Comment on this

It is fixed, and there is no reason why it should be changed. We have the recommendation of the Commission of ½d. in the loaf for every 4/- in the sack of flour.

Comment on this

Our point is that that should be fixed in agreement with the Master Bakers. Once that is done there need not be any further consultation. I would appeal to the Minister to agree to have this consultation with the Master takers. If he agrees to do that it does not mean that he will suffer in any way in his Ministerial dignity.

Comment on this

There is no question of dignity in this at all. If the Master Bakers came to me and said that a reduction of a ½d. for every 4/- in the sack of flour was not a fair calculation, the only answer I can give them is that the Prices Commission report that that is a fair calculation. The Prices Commission that sat in 1926 made a similar report, and I am accepting their conclusions. No Minister can give any other answer to that except he was prepared to carry out a separate and a new investigation on his own, and I do not think he should do that.

Comment on this

It would not take half-an-hour—possibly an hour altogether.

Comment on this

In any event, if there is in existence a body with the powers of the High Court to require the production of evidence on oath, and a staff of trained accountants to investigate that evidence, and if they submit a report, it is obviously much better to accept it rather than that a Minister should again, say in the space of half-an-hour, carry out an investigation and reverse their conclusions. Consequently, we have got to the position that what the standard to be fixed will be, is already known. There will be added to that 4½d. or 5d., as the case may be, certain other amounts as set out in the Commission's report to cover costs other than the costs of flour. There you will get the price of bread which has emerged as the result of a protracted investigation by the Commission, and which is confirmed by reference to the report of the Food Prices Tribunal of 1926 which brought a precisely similar recommendation.

Comment on this

I have already pointed out that there was not a baker in Ireland who could produce bread on the figures laid down. I proved it up to the hilt that no baker could bake bread at the price laid down, not to speak of the selling of it at that price.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy ex-. plain to me why, on a day when the price of bread in Dublin was 9d. or 8½d., in Cork it was 10d., in Clonmel 10d., in Cavan 8½d., in Carlow 9d., and in another place 7d.? Why was there that variation in price when they were all using the same flour?

Comment on this

I will take Dublin as an example. The price of bread in Dublin was 11d. on that very day when the Minister says it was down to 8½d. That one fact controverts everything he says.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the amendment being withdrawn?

Comment on this

I suppose, as the Minister will not budge, I had better withdraw it.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 5, relates to the same point.

Comment on this

It is entirely different—areas.

Comment on this

It deals with the same principle, and it is asking the Minister to apply it to different areas. For instance, if he wanted to make an order affecting Dublin he would not consult the master bakers in Cork. It is the same point.

Comment on this

I think there is another point in it. This Commission, about whose efficiency the Minister is so satisfied, reported distinctly that there was no reason for area discrimination. They deal with the matter on page 17, under the heading "Question of Uniform Prices":

"Under present conditions, in many parts of the country the smaller bakery has to meet the competition of the larger city bakery."

Here is what that efficient body, who have made such a thorough-going investigation so pleasing to the Minister, report:

"A close examination of the economics of baking units, of various sizes and locations, disclosed the following interesting facts:—

"(A) Purchase of Flour.—The larger unit has the advantage of favourable terms for large quantities and, being generally adjacent to mills, its transport costs are lower."

That is one point in favour of the higher unit.

"(B) Output.—The information we have obtained regarding typical units goes to show that the larger concerns have little, if any, advantage over their smaller competitors as a direct result of larger turnover."

You can call that a draw, I suppose.

"(C) Labour.—The country unit (and, generally, therefore, the smaller), as distinct from the city unit, has a decided advantage as regards both the cost of labour and its adjustability to day-to-day conditions."

They are all square at that point.

"(D) Management and Overhead Expenses: The smaller bakery is, generally, part of a mixed general trading unit. The consequent saving on overhead expenses offsets, to some extent, advantages in other respects accruing to the larger unit, which, generally, is confined to baking.

That is something to the advantage of the country unit that the city one has not got.

(E) Distribution: The very high distribution costs disclosed in the accounts submitted to us by large scale bakeries indicate a further advantage, under this head, for the smaller unit.

So they weight the thing in favour of the smaller unit and they draw a conclusion that there should be uniform prices, that there should be a standard price for the Saorstát.

Comment on this

Where do they draw that conclusion?

Comment on this

They say that distinctly.

Comment on this

They at least say that the maximum price that they fix for Dublin is equally applicable in any other area.

Comment on this

They say what I have indicated, distinctly.

Comment on this

They do not make a definite recommendation that there should be only one price.

Comment on this

Does the Minister say that they make a definite recommendation in favour of an area price?

Comment on this

Does the Minister say they do not recommend a uniform price for the Saorstát?

Comment on this

What they have concluded is that the maximum prices fixed on the basis of the Dublin or the Cork costs are applicable in all areas.

Comment on this

Is there a recommendation in favour of varying prices for different areas?

Comment on this

I do not think they deal with that at all.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not realise, under the heading I have read out about uniform prices, that this is not dealing with the matter of the price for the Saorstát or for areas?

Comment on this

What is the Deputy's point?

Comment on this

That they do not recommend in favour of an area price.

Comment on this

I do not think they recommend against it, either.

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell me that they do not? Will the Minister tell me that this is founded upon the Commission's report?

Comment on this

The Commission pointed out in their report that on a day appointed in accordance with their calculations a certain price would be fixed as the maximum price for bread, that in certain areas the price of bread would be below that price and, consequently, there obviously would be no need to fix a maximum price in respect of these areas, if they could be clearly defined.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say, without any quibbling, does he regard that prices report as being in favour of area orders?

Comment on this

No. I regard the prices report as an indication of the Commission's conclusions that the price of bread should be uniform throughout the whole country if the same quality flour in bread was used.

Comment on this

And the same cost of production?

Comment on this

They say the costs of production weigh definitely in favour of the smaller units.

Comment on this

To some extent.

Comment on this

There is one factor in favour of the larger unit. Does the Minister say that anywhere they indicate a conclusion in favour of area orders?

Comment on this

No, or against it.

Comment on this

Is the Minister accepting amendment No. 6?

Comment on this

I do not quite see what the Deputy's point is.

Comment on this

It brings us back again to the definition of the word "loaf".

Comment on this

I am proposing to work on the basis of the pound units. If the Deputy will notice, in Section 4 we are taking power to prohibit the sale or offering for sale in the area to which an Order affecting bread applies, bread covered by the Order unless such bread is so sold or offered for sale either in units of less than eight ounces or in units of one pound or multiples of a pound. That is the test, and the price of bread will be fixed in relation to the pound weight and not in relation to any other unit.

Comment on this

Bread is always taken as quoted per 4 lb. quartern or per 2 lbs. Is the Minister going to depart from that? The reason I brought in the amendment is that in some parts of the country the trade in bread is not in the 2 lb. or 4 lb. unit. In some places the trade is practically all in 1 lb. units, and the making of 1 lb. units is a very much more expensive process than the making of 4 lb. units. In the first place, to get the proper weight you have to weigh each loaf separately, and you will not get the same output from the sack of flour in weighing small units.

Comment on this

I gather that the Deputy's point—I did not understand his amendment—is that you should not fix the price for 1 lb. units at all?

Comment on this

I wanted it to be permissible to charge a higher rate for bread in 1 lb. units than in 4 lb. units.

Comment on this

There is power to do that under Section 3.

Comment on this

But the Minister is going to take the 1 lb. unit, and I want him to take the 4 lb. unit.

Comment on this

The lb. or multiples of the lb.

Comment on this

Where the price of bread is, say, 10d. a pair or quartern, I want it to be permissible for a person to charge more than 2½d. for the single lb. loaf. He will not get four 1 lb. units out of the same amount of flour as he can get a 4 lb. unit.

Comment on this

There is power to do that.

Comment on this

I know there is power, but will the Minister see my point? Will the Minister keep that in view when making his Order?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

I have the same thing in mind in relation to fancy bread. He has already dealt with that in regard to the definition of fancy bread. You can charge practically what you like, because he is not going to define fancy bread.

Comment on this

The price can be fixed. There is a recommendation of the Commission in one respect concerning fancy bread.

Comment on this

If the Minister refuses to accept the definitions, I cannot proceed any further with this point.

Comment on this

The Minister on a particular amendment refused to be absolutely precise with regard to those variations which he may make. There is not the slightest doubt in the world that the Minister takes power to make and has the intention of making Bread (Price) Orders, varying according to the area. The Minister does intend that. The Minister tells me that he has accepted the Commission's report. The Minister will, I am sure, tell me that he has read, thoroughly understood, and gone through the Commission's report. He has already told me in this House that he cannot find anywhere that they recommended in favour of uniform prices for the Saorstát.

Comment on this

I do not think they dealt with that point in a specific way at all.

Comment on this

May I read the Minister one phrase which could not be misunderstood? It is as follows: "We are of opinion that the Minister should make Orders fixing the maximum retail and wholesale prices of the commodity in question, and that such Orders should apply to the entire area of Saorstát Eireann." Can there be any quibbling about that?

Comment on this

There can be refutation of the Deputy's argument.

Comment on this

Possibly, but at any rate that is the Commission's recommendation. The Minister did not know it was there until now. It is the last paragraph above the signatures—"...such Orders should apply to the entire area of Saorstát Eireann." That is after they had in detail gone through the points which I read before. They examined them under the headings of flour purchase, output, labour, management and overhead expenses, and distribution, and having done that, they recommended in the most wholehearted way, in a flatfooted phrase which I do not think anybody could misunderstand, that those uniform prices "should apply to the entire area of Saorstát Eireann." The Minister thinks he is accepting the report when he brings in area Orders. He announced here earlier that he intends to make area Orders. Why? This is a case where the Prices Commission, that expert body to whom the Association of Master Bakers have referred, recommend something to the Minister that the Minister does not entirely believe in.

Comment on this

Who said I was not going to make an Order based on the Commission's recommendations?

Comment on this

I read paragraph (c), sub-paragraph (2), Section 3, which deals with a bread (price) order for areas.

Comment on this

This is permanent legislation.

Comment on this

I went further and asked him—quibbling will not get over this—was it his intention to make Orders for areas, and he said "Yes." He did that on foot of the Commission's recommendations. And the Commission recommended uniform prices for Saorstát Eireann. Yet, the Minister thinks that is a great body, and its report has been so carefully considered that he will not allow the Master Bakers to consult with him to suggest that possibly their recommendation may have gone wrong under changed conditions. That is one thing. Will the Minister answer another question? Under sub-section (1) of Section 3 prices are to be fixed or may be fixed varying according to different sets of conditions,—and then we get a variety of clauses with regard to the place of sale. There is, at any rate, a distinction between sale at the place where the bread is kept by the vendor, and sale by the vendor at some place other than where it is kept by the vendor. There are two balancing clauses there. There is first "that the bread is sold or offered for sale by the baker thereof in a shop owned by him, delivery being taken by the purchaser at such shop." Then there is the varying one: "that the bread is sold or offered for sale retail by a person other than the baker thereof in a shop owned by such person...." There is a distinction, at any rate, permissible there between bread sold by a baker at his own premises and bread sold by somebody other than a baker in that person's own premises. Is the Minister going to make any distinction between sale by a baker at the place where the loaf is baked and sale by a baker at a shop owned by the baker? There will be delivery cost there, and there will be distribution cost. It may not be as great as the distribution cost of a person other than a baker owning a shop from which bread is sold. But there is a differentiation. Does the Minister recognise it or will he allow for it?

Comment on this

Of course the first point raised by the Deputy is, in a sense, a minor point. The Commission undoubtedly recommended on 21st August, 1935, having completed their investigation, that an Order should be made under the Control of Prices Act, 1932, fixing the maximum retail and wholesale price for bread, and that such Order should apply to the whole of the Saorstát. We did not make those Orders. We proposed to do so but we came up against legal difficulties, and because of those legal difficulties we are not acting under the Control of Prices Act at all. We are introducing here a Bill to put on the Statute Book new power to act in relation to the price of bread. It is under this Act and not under the Control of Prices Act that any Orders will be made. We are taking power to make Orders to apply to the whole of the Saorstát or part of the Saorstát, because the new Act is designed to provide permanent legislation for the regulation of the price of bread—not the regulation as at 21st August, 1935, but the regulation of its price at any time the Executive Council considers it is desirable that such legislation should be effected. The various circumstances dealt with in the paragraph under which different prices can be fixed in respect of bread are all those recommended by the Commission, and all those in respect of which I think we should have that power, that is in accordance with the paragraph which the Deputy read out.

Comment on this

That is the sale the Minister is referring to now?

Comment on this

Does the Minister not recognise any possibilities of difference in the price of bread sold by a baker across the counter of the bakery, so to speak, or on premises attached to the bakery, and the price of that same loaf sold by the baker in a shop away from the bakery which is still owned by the baker? Would there not be a distribution or delivery cost attached there, and would there not be necessity for differentiation? The Commission has made recommendations with regard to what they call "sale over the baker's counter." Will the Minister recognise that "the baker's counter" might be either the counter of the place where the bread is baked or the counter of some shop owned by the baker which is not the bakery? Will the Minister recognise any difference in costs, or will he recognise the possibility of a variation in price being necessary? The Commission have only reported on this matter in connection with the sale of bread by the baker as opposed to sale by a retailer who is not a baker. There is delivery to the householder or delivery by a baker to the shop of a retailer, such retailer not being a baker, and so on. Surely the Minister must recognise the difference? Why should there be an allowance for an extra item when the bread is sold in a shop that belongs to a retailer who is not a baker, and why will that cost disappear when the shop is owned by the baker? If there is to be a transfer some distance to other premises owned by the baker, will there not be some difference? My point is that there is no allowance for it in the Bill.

Comment on this

I am introducing legislation hereto give effect to the report of the Prices Commission, and when they made their recommendations there were four circumstances under which variations in the price of bread might be permitted.

Comment on this

The first heading in their report has to do with sale over the baker's counter.

Comment on this

No, sold in his own shop.

Comment on this

Well, over the counter may seem over the counter of the bakery or over the counter of a shop owned by a baker. Does the Minister say that they are the same thing? Will there not be a difference in the cost? Surely there must be.

Comment on this

Perhaps, since I am more familiar with the conditions in this trade, I might be permitted to put Deputy McGilligan's point in concrete form. I have a shop, say, 30 miles from my bakery. That shop is in my possession and I work there and retail bread in that shop. The bakery also has a retail shop. Deputy McGilligan's point is that it is a stupid thing to ask the same price for bread sold over the counter of the shop in the bakery as in the shop 30 miles away.

Comment on this

That is the point. Take it from another angle. Let us take it from the point of view of the four special heads set out at the bottom of page 19 and the top of page 20 of the report—sale over the baker's counter, delivery to a householder, delivery by a baker to a shop of a retailer, such retailer not being a baker, and sale by a retailer. What is the difference in price as between the retailer being a baker and the retailer not being a baker?

Comment on this

That refers to the customer of the baker, and a 10 per cent. discount is provided for.

Comment on this

There will be a 10 per cent. discount from the No. 2 price, but the No. 2 price is delivery to the householder. There is, however, a differentiation made between the sale across the counter where the retailer is a baker and where the retailer is not a baker. Why must there be a distinction and an extra item of cost allowed for a sale across the counter in a shop by a retailer where the retailer is, in the one case, the baker and, in the other case, not a baker? If there is a separate shop there will be separate overhead expenses in connection with the shop. Will they differ if he is the owner, and, if so, will they so far differ as to make it equivalent to the sale across the bakery counter?

Comment on this

It is the custom in the trade.

Comment on this

Indeed, it is not. Deputy O'Neill is one practical example.

Comment on this

Would not an awkward situation arise in connection with Deputy O'Neill's point? Must you not have one price for the bread, as otherwise people will all flock to the baker's shop?

Comment on this

They do not do it at the moment.

Comment on this

Because the price is the same.

Comment on this

The baker only sells bread wholesale.

Comment on this

He sells it retail, too. In the city of Dublin the customer can get it cheaper by going to the baker's shop.

Comment on this

Is there any difference between the price of the bread sold in the baker's own shop apart from another retailer?

Comment on this

But there is a difference between the sale at the bakery and the sale at the shop owned by the baker?

Comment on this

There is none?

Comment on this

I am speaking from my experience of my own town, and there is a flat rate for the price of bread whether it is sold in a bakery shop or a retail shop. Otherwise, the retailers might not expect to sell bread at all.

Comment on this

We have a report that the price in the baker's shop is much too high.

Comment on this

Again, does the Minister mean the shop owned by the baker or the bakery itself?

Comment on this

Well, you will not improve the matter by making a different price.

Comment on this

I should like to have that attended to. Surely there is a point there for consideration.

Comment on this

There is a point I have been considering, following representations from traders' associations in certain small towns where, in order to enable certain retailers to continue to sell bread, the baker marked up his price to the price at which the retailer could sell the bread at a profit. Undoubtedly, the bakers, when selling bread in competition with the retailers, get too large a profit, according to the Commission's calculations. Sometimes the baker did not sell bread in competition with the retailers, and the point advanced by the retailers is that if we insist on the baker selling bread over the counter at a reasonable profit, no retailer will have a chance. I have been looking into that point, with a view to seeing if we could allow a certain amount of elasticity there. But the only practical way to do that is to allow the baker, in respect of that type of bread, to get a higher profit.

Comment on this

Both Commissions have reported that it is desirable to give a fresh impetus to the tendency already observable to have more bread sold in bakers' own premises, whether in the bakery or in a shop owned by the baker, because one Commission definitely reported, and the other rather backed it up, that there are too many people engaged in retailing bread.

Comment on this

But the Deputy can see the point of view of the retailers when they see the trade for other groceries going to the shop owned by the baker who may also be a grocer?

Comment on this

Yes. While the baker bakes bread, he can sell that across the counter or in a part of the premises attached to the bakery. He has very little distribution costs and there should be something for that. That is taken and given to a retailer who is not a baker, but when the baker takes that bread and delivers it to a shop of his own so far away as 30 miles there should be some difference in the price as between the sale in his own bakery and in the shop 30 miles away. That is the only point I am making.

Comment on this

I think it is a point worth considering.

Comment on this

Of course, we have the practice in Dublin where they sell in their own shops at the same price as in their bakery.

Comment on this

In connection with this question of the variable price, the Minister will remember the scale to which I referred previously, inserted by the Prices Commission, on which the prices should be regulated on a sliding scale having relation to the prices of flour. The only thing there is the price of flour, but other things may vary from time to time in such a way as to affect seriously the price of bread. For instance, the Minister has put a very serious tariff on yeast, and I hope he will take into account the increased cost of yeast, which he has increased himself, and also the increased cost of other matters which go into the production of bread. The cost of yeast has become a very serious charge.

Comment on this

Surely this must be looked at in the same way as any other commodity, and it has to be remembered that there are two prices, wholesale and retail. A baker sells to a retailer at a wholesale price because he has no expense. This is the same as any other trade in which there is a wholesale list. Otherwise the baker would have to bring bread into a shop, put paper and twine on it, and record the sale. Was it not better, to have one price?

Comment on this

He should be a retailer, and that is what the Commission does not recommend.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is a printer's error in the numbering of the amendments. On page 2 amendments Nos. 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 should be 7, 8, 9, 10 and 11.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

In sub-section (1), page 3, line 46, to insert after the word "ounces" and after the words "multiples of one pound" the words "in weight".

Comment on this

The Minister said that what he wanted to achieve was that if a loaf weighing, say, 1 lb. and a few ounces was sold as a 2-lb. loaf there would be an offence. If the Minister looks at the section he will see that he may prohibit the sale, by any price order, of bread of any kind unless sold in units of less than 8 ozs. or units of 1 lb. or multiples of 1 lb.

Supposing you sell a loaf weighing one pound one ounce is that a multiple of a pound? Surely not. I think what the Minister means is not less than a pound. I went through the Commission's report and I think most bread is scaled in such a way that it comes out a little in excess of the pound. The Minister does not intend to have it an offence to sell one or two-pound loaves some fraction over that weight. The section makes it an offence to sell unless in units of a pound or multiples of a pound. Supposing a loaf weighed one pound two ounces, surely that is not an offence.

Comment on this

There may be some necessity to recast the wording of the section. The intention is to secure that in the administration of the order the Civic Guards will be able to assume that a loaf is one, two, three or four pounds in weight, and report on the price charged as the price per pound, without having to undertake any of the obligations of weights and measures inspectors in relation to the weight of the loaf, and in order to prevent traders offering for sale a loaf of indeterminate weight in order to evade the obligation to charge a price per pound.

Comment on this

If you accept my definition of a loaf it will make that easy.

Comment on this

A loaf is too wide a term unless you put in that it must be one, two, three or four pounds. Sales of bread take place in one, two, three or four-pound lots, when the obligation of the Bill is complied with.

Comment on this

You could have half or quarter of a loaf. Half a loaf is better than no bread.

Comment on this

I understand the Minister is going to amend this section further.

Comment on this

There may be some recasting.

Comment on this

Take the word "loaf" and you will be all right.

Comment on this

I wanted to ask why insert "ounces." Other legislation has 12 ounces.

Comment on this

It is not intended to fix the price of bread under 12 ounces as that would be too near a pound weight.

Comment on this

Some other countries have taken a smaller unit as being less than 12 ounces.

Comment on this

Twelve ounces would be too near a pound and there would be deception. No one would mistake eight ounces, but a person might mistake 12 ounces.

Comment on this

With regard to sub-section 2, is it the Minister's idea that this Bill will repeal the Act of 1838?

Comment on this

It is not repealed.

Comment on this

It will still operate with regard to the sale of bread.

Comment on this

We are providing in relation to this section that it will have effect, notwithstanding anything in the Act of 1838.

Comment on this

Regardless of weight.

Comment on this

So far as weight is concerned.

Comment on this

So that all bread shall be sold by weight.

SECTION 5.

(1) Where—

(b) any person sells in the area to which such order applies any such bread under any set of conditions specified in such order, such person shall, if so required by the purchaser, give to the purchaser a receipt showing the amount paid for such bread and the weight thereof.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:—

In sub-section (1) (b), line 1, to delete all after the word "shall" to the end of the sub-section and substitute the words "if the sale takes place in a shop and if the purchaser so requires, weigh in the purchaser's presence the bread that is being purchased."

The conditions laid down by the Minister are intolerable and I think he will find that, in practice, they will be unworkable. It might become an intolerable practice if people could insist on getting a printed receipt or a written receipt when sold a loaf of bread, or if a van-man was stopped on the road in some remote district or at a cross-roads. If they took it into their heads to ask for receipts van-men would have a very difficult job giving receipts for every loaf or half loaf of bread they sold. The Minister's idea would be achieved by insisting wherever a sale takes place in a shop that the bread should be weighed in the presence of the purchaser. I am sure the Minister's idea is to see that the public get full weight. The amendment would protect the public effectively, and would give less trouble, while there would not be intolerable conditions imposed.

Comment on this

If the Deputy's concern is due to the fact that the purchaser appears to be given the right to demand a receipt the amendment would cover that right, because the purchaser has a legal right to demand a receipt setting out the commodity and the price. If the Deputy's intention is to avoid the obligation to give a receipt in the case of a sale of bread from a van it does not achieve that, because I understand a baker's van has been deemed to be a, shop—a travelling shop undoubtedly—in the definition of the Act. Consequently the amendment does not avoid that. If we are going to fix the maximum price of bread, we must provide that the purchaser of bread will get, when making the purchase, some document from the seller, if he desires it, indicating the weight and the price of the bread.

Comment on this

What is the object when all the bread will be defined as a certain weight under the Minister's order?

Comment on this

There is not always that compliance with Minister's orders that the Deputy hopes. So far as this is concerned the purchaser has the right in common law.

Comment on this

Yes, but it is not insisted upon.

Comment on this

It is essential that it should be made clear, where the maximum price or weight of the article is fixed by law, and where the customer has some doubts as to whether he is getting the benefit of the enactment. In that case he can satisfy himself by getting the trader to put down on paper what weight of bread is sold and what the price is.

Comment on this

If the trader is selling 100 loaves at 2½d. each, you cannot expect him to make out 100 receipts at 2½d.

Comment on this

It has been the law for a long time.

Comment on this

There is no necessity for putting it into this Bill.

Comment on this

We are making him specify the quantity of bread by weight.

Comment on this

Still you could accept my amendment. All you want to insist upon is that a sale in the shop shall be by weight. I merely want to make it simpler for the Minister.

Comment on this

I think that this is an essential safeguard. The only change the Deputy's amendment would make would be to exempt the trader from giving a receipt where the bread is sold from a van, but it does not even do that, because a van is, in fact, a travelling shop.

Comment on this

The Minister will remember that under the original Act every baker was supposed to carry scales and to weigh the bread in the presence of the purchaser. That practice ceased to be operative. The thing was dropped because it was impracticable. Why does the Minister wish to introduce it again?

Comment on this

Because we have a report from two Commissions that the price of bread is excessively high.

Comment on this

That has nothing to do with the weight.

Comment on this

It has. It is only when the bread is weighed that a person can determine whether he has been charged an excessive price.

Comment on this

I quite agree that prices are high, too high in many cases, because dishonest traders were not giving the full weight. They have been undercutting honest traders by reducing the weight of the loaf.

Comment on this

Is not this a protection to the honest baker?

Comment on this

There is no necessity to go to extremes.

Comment on this

I think it is essential that we should provide that the purchaser of bread is entitled to demand a receipt showing the quantity of bread supplied and the price charged. The Deputy knows quite well that there is not one customer in 1,000 who is going to exercise that right unless he thinks he is being "done," and if he thinks he is being "done" he will kick up a bigger row than to demand a receipt.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:—

In sub-section (3), page 4, line 21, to insert before the word "under" the words and brackets "(including an ex-officio inspector of weights and measures)".

This is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:—

At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—

When weighing plain or batch bread or loaves joined together in the process of baking, the inspector shall weigh not less than six loaves, either together or singly, and take the average of such weight as representing the true weight of each of the loaves.

Comment on this

I do not think I need go into detail in opposing this amendment, because there are obvious arguments against it. I think, however, what the Deputy desires to provide will be the practice. The Deputy can see that there are obvious objections, however, to putting it into the Bill. In fact, the weights and measures inspectors will weigh six loaves as the Deputy suggests, and take an average.

Comment on this

I am satisfied, if that will be the practice. The Minister will realise it would be unfair to take a loaf off a batch, the end of which might have been torn away in removing another loaf.

Comment on this

I agree that it is a reasonable practice, but there are obvious objections in making it a statutory requirement.

Comment on this

How then does the Minister propose to deal with it?

Comment on this

In the form of an instruction to the weights and measures inspectors.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not consider the amendment further on Report?

Comment on this

I should like that the law should stand that the loaf must be of the weight stated.

Comment on this

But if the inspector took a single loaf off the batch, it might easily happen that that loaf would be under weight, while the average of six loaves would give true weight.

Comment on this

It is quite a reasonable thing to ask, but I think the Deputy will see at once that if you put in that proviso it might be used in certain circumstances to defeat the purposes of the Act.

Comment on this

If the Minister says that what I seek to achieve will be the practice, I am quite satisfied.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:—

In page 5, lines 21 and 22, to delete the words "each House of the Oireachtas" and substitute the words "Dáil Eireann"; in line 23, to delete the words "either such House" and substitute the words "Dáil Eireann"; in line 24, to delete the words "that House" and substitute the words "Dáil Eireann"; in line 25, to delete the word "it" and substitute the words "Dáil Eireann".

This is an obvious amendment. The Bill was drafted before the recent constitutional change in the matter to which the amendment refers.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When is it proposed to take the Fourth Stage?

Comment on this

I would suggest that it be fixed for Tuesday though I do not think we shall be able to take it on Tuesday. There are one or two matters into which I promised to look.

Comment on this