Committee on Finance. - Air Navigation and Transport Bill, 1936—Committee.
Contributions 1–157 of 305. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1936 ›
I propose amendment No. 1:—
In sub-section (1), page 6, line 10, to insert after the word "for" the words "or in connection with".
The object of this amendment is to make it clear that the definition of aerodrome in the Bill shall cover the position of hangar, workshops or other adjuncts to an aerodrome as well as the aerodrome itself.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:—
In sub-section (1), page 6, line 24, to insert before the word "borough" the words "or other".
This is to ensure that other boroughs besides county boroughs shall be included in sub-section (1) of Section 2.
Comment on this
Clause (a) "the council of a county borough" is considered not to be complete and the expression "or other" is being inserted between the words "county" and "borough" to make it clear that a borough such as Sligo, which is not a county borough, will come within the scope of the definition.
Comment on this
What have the local authorities to do with this? What section has this definition reference to?
Comment on this
Part V, which deals with the establishment and maintenance of aerodromes, under Section 36 and Section 41. Under Section 36 the local authority may have power to establish and maintain aerodromes, and under Section 41 to acquire land for the purpose, so that there is definite provision. There are other matters such as the formation of committees representing different local authorities to co-operate for the provision or establishment of aerodromes or for other matters. There is provision under Section 47 for the setting up of committees and under Section 48 for borrowing. So that there are a number of sections in Part V which deal with local authorities.
Comment on this
Under this section the Bill, except Part III, shall not apply to any State aircraft. Power is taken in sub-section (2) to apply such provisions of the Bill, other than Part III, which deals with the provisions of the Warsaw Convention, as may be found desirable in future.
Comment on this
The Warsaw Convention applies provided, however, that the State aircraft is engaged in the carriage of persons, luggage or goods for war. The others do not apply.
Comment on this
I think at present they are being finally transferred to the jurisdiction of the Saorstát Government.
Comment on this
Then that means that we do not allow any legislation of this House to affect regulations by an authority that is outside the House? That is the meaning of Section 4.
Comment on this
That is the general lighthouse authority. Is it not clear that Section 4 means that, while the present position remains, nothing done under this Bill can interfere with an authority outside this House?
Comment on this
The matter is at present under consideration, and I assume that, in the event of a settlement being reached, this section will not prevent another authority from assuming the jurisdiction.
Comment on this
I am not speaking of that. The situation at the present moment is that the lighthouse authority is an authority not paid by and not under the control of this House. We are establishing a new service, and, in the Bill establishing the service, we are making a general rule that no regulation made under the Bill can in any way affect the general lighthouse authority. Surely my summing-up is correct—that we are now saying to this House: "In passing this Bill you cannot affect the authority of the Lighthouse Board, which is outside the authority of this House and not subservient to it."
Comment on this
I do not think we are likely to interfere with them, even if they were within our control.
Comment on this
That is only an evasion. The point is that we are definitely asking the House now to say that this House cannot, under this Bill, do anything contrary to the wishes of an authority outside this House—an English authority at the moment.
Comment on this
I presume that, if any adjustment is required, Section 4 can be very easily dealt with.
Comment on this
Section 4 is introduced in the present circumstances. The present circumstances are that the body controlling Irish Lights is not subservient to this House. The Minister wants this House to pass a Bill and say, "Nothing contained in the Bill passed by this House can interfere with the authority of that extra-Irish body." Let us know where we are.
Comment on this
That is absurd. This particular section is only in connection with the regulation of aerial transport and has not anything to do with the question of national rights.
Comment on this
If it has nothing to do with national rights, and there is no conflict between aerial navigation and the lighthouse authority, why is the section there? So far as the section has any meaning, it is this: If there is any conflict between the lighthouse authority, which is an English body, and the company established under this Bill, the English body, the lighthouse authority, must prevail.
Comment on this
The object of it is to ensure that the rights and powers and privileges of the lighthouse services, which are essential to the safety of shipping, shall not be interfered with by the powers conferred by the Bill.
Comment on this
Which, as adapted under the Adaptation of Enactments Act, referred to Irish lighthouses and the control of Irish lighthouses, but this does not. This is not adapted by the Adaptation of Enactments Act. This is a new Act. The section is as I have described it.
Comment on this
It is exactly the same: "Nothing in this Act or in any orders or regulations made thereunder shall prejudice or affect the rights, powers or privileges of any general or local lighthouse authority." That is the section.
Comment on this
The Minister does not pretend to be as innocent as that. That Act cannot be read alone. It must be read with the Adaptation of Enactments Act. As so read, it means that nothing in the Act shall allow interference with the Irish lighthouse authority, if and when established. This Act is only an emendation. This Bill says that we are not to prejudice or affect the rights, powers or privileges of any general or local lighthouse authority, and when there is an Irish lighthouse authority, it will have the effect that the Minister read. But, at the moment, the situation is that the House is asked to say "You can pass all the Acts you like but one of the prohibitions you are to ordain for yourselves is that you cannot interfere with Irish Lights and Irish Lights are at present controlled by a British body.
Comment on this
I should like the Deputy to quote the portion of the Adaptation of Enactments Act which deals with the point he has raised. The Deputy says that the rights of the future Irish lighthouse authority were preserved and guarded under the Adaptation of Enactments Act. Perhaps the Deputy will quote the portion of the Act he refers to?
Comment on this
There is no question of getting the Minister to refer himself to a few court decisions. Under the Adaptation of Enactments Act every Act passed by the British having a reference to matters inside the Free State had to be construed as if the words "Free State" were written in. The difficulty here is that this particular measure is taken away from the shelter of the Adaptation of Enactments Act. This is plain and straightforward. The general lighthouse authority in relation to this country is a British authority. That might have come to an end sooner if it had not been for the nonsense of the economic war. It would have come to an end years ago.
Comment on this
Why did it not come to an end when the Deputy was Minister for Industry and Commerce?
Comment on this
It did not come to an end because the service would be too costly an undertaking for this country.
Comment on this
This refers to the general lighthouse authority, and the general lighthouse authority is a British authority. Deputy Briscoe's patriotic soul, when asked to pass this, says this is a new Irish board, but you cannot do anything contrary to the regulations of that British body.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy would show how this interferes with the rights of the body which is to be set up.
Comment on this
If this body passes an order or a regulation that is found to be in conflict with the orders and regulations of the British lighthouse authority, then the British lighthouse authority wins by this Bill of ours. That is all.
Comment on this
This section means that the Minister may not make a regulation in regard to lighthouse matters if it is in conflict with what the general lighthouse authority has done.
Comment on this
Would the Minister reconcile an order made under Section 6 with Section 4? If the Minister makes a regulation that is found to be in conflict with, or that prejudices in any way the powers and privileges of the general lighthouse authority, will it overpower the general lighthouse authority?
Comment on this
The lighthouse regulations should be dealt with as a separate matter. The Minister is scarcely going to endeavour to prescribe regulations for lighthouses under Section 6.
Comment on this
But suppose he makes an order in regard to air navigation which has a prejudicial effect upon the powers of the general lighthouse authority, will it be good?
Comment on this
Can the Minister tell the House what he proposes? Does he want the regulations of the Minister to be supreme no matter whether they are in conflict with the general lighthouse authority or not, because if he does he will have to change Section 4?
Comment on this
I did not introduce the Bill. Whoever is responsible for it had sufficient imagination to write down in Section 4 that
"Nothing in this Act or any order or regulation made thereunder shall prejudice or affect the rights, powers or privileges of any general or local lighthouse authority."
Somebody, apparently, thought there might be a conflict. Somebody had imagination enough to arrive at that conclusion, at the possibility that there might be a conflict between the regulations made under this Act and some of the powers or privileges of the general lighthouse authority. Under Section 6 the Minister is taking power to make regulations in relation to a variety of things. I am asking the Minister to decide this for me: If the Minister makes a regulation which affects or prejudices the privileges of the general lighthouse authority, a British board, will the regulation win or will the general lighthouse authority win?
Comment on this
I think that, within the jurisdiction of the area of the Saorstát, the Minister's regulation, if properly made, will at least have a reasonable chance of succeeding.
Comment on this
Deputy Kelly says this is an Irish board manned by Irishmen. It may be an Irish board manned by Irishmen, but this House does not appoint it, and the Minister has no control over it.
Comment on this
The point that the Deputy has been trying to make all the time is that this is a British board. It is not.
Comment on this
There are many Irish boards over which this House has no control. The Dublin Corporation is one.
Comment on this
Deputy Kelly as a member of this House cannot criticise the Irish lighthouse authority.
Comment on this
Of course, I can. I can criticise anybody I like.
Comment on this
The order part of it can be considered afterwards.
Comment on this
The Deputy can be disorderly at any moment he likes, but in an ordered way there can be no criticism of the Irish lighthouse authority because this House does not appoint it, it does not sack anybody belonging to it, it does not pay anybody belonging to it, and this House does not regulate how the lighthouse authority acts. Under this Bill, which Deputy Kelly probably is backing, we have it specially laid down that no order or regulation made under it can affect any of the privileges of the lighthouse authority.
Comment on this
The Deputy's point was that it was a British board.
Comment on this
The point is this, that the general lighthouse authority is a British board. That has been admitted.
Comment on this
The position, at any rate, is that the general lighthouse authority, a British board, is being established under this measure in at least a superior position, so that if there is any regulation made by the Minister within the confines of the Saorstát which in any way affects or prejudices the privileges of this British board, then the Minister's regulation falls to the ground under Section 4. There is no shadow of question about that.
Comment on this
The Minister thinks that Section 6 is more powerful than Section 4. If you want to have it that way, then it is much easier to fight this than the economic business and you can wipe out Section 4. But you cannot have Section 4 and Section 6 together and pretend that Section 6 is the one that wins. Section 6, in the teeth of Section 4, cannot carry a regulation made by the Minister under this Bill if that regulation prejudices the privileges of a British board—the Irish Lights.
Comment on this
If the Irish Lights were in the hands of the Free State the position is that Section 4 would have to stand.
Comment on this
Of course, it would, and that is a good situation, but why bury your heads in the patriotic desert? At this moment, and for some years to come, the authority ruling Irish Lights is a British board and is going to be a British board, and as long as that situation lasts the Minister for Industry and Commerce by an Act of this House has to bow himself, to yield before a British authority in its regulations. That is the situation.
Comment on this
The Deputy is trying to make a big point out of something that does not exist. He knows quite well from his experience as a Minister what the position is with regard to the Irish Lights. He knows quite well that even if the Irish Free State had control of the Irish Lights Section 4 would have to stand as it is in the Bill.
Comment on this
At the moment the British authority rules the Irish Lights, and as long as that authority rules the Irish Lights the situation is that the Irish Free State Minister for Industry and Commerce cannot make any regulation which affects or prejudices the privileges of that British body.
Comment on this
I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce is not likely to make regulations governing the question of lighthouses. I have already explained to the House that the whole question of the possession of Irish lighthouses is under consideration and the British board, which Deputy McGilligan seems to be so fearful of, but which, nevertheless, he was compelled to recognise during his term of office, is maintained largely by dues collected from ships.
Comment on this
Not one part of every hundredth part of the expenditure is collected by way of dues from ships around the coast here, I venture to say. If that is the case, why do we not take over Irish lights? Is it not because it is too expensive and we cannot collect the dues from ships?
Comment on this
It is much easier for the British Government to maintain the lighthouse and lightship services because of its extensive commerce.
Comment on this
The reason the Deputy's Party, when they were in power, would not take over Irish Lights was because they were too expensive.
Comment on this
The transfer of the authority over the Irish lighthouses to the Irish Free State Government.
Comment on this
Nonsense. The transfer could be got to-morrow if you are prepared to bear the expense.
Comment on this
No, because it would mean half a million a year. We might have wanted to have control of the Irish Lights service, but we did not want to pay for it. You can get control of them immediately if you are prepared to meet the expense.
Comment on this
The Dublin Corporation have elected six persons to be members of the Irish Lights Board. That is not a sign that it is a British board.
Comment on this
I think it is. Anyway, it is a sign that the Dublin Corporation did not know what they were doing.
Comment on this
They knew quite well what they were doing. It would be a good job for you if you knew as well.
Comment on this
With regard to Section 9, what are the likely expenses falling for payment by any Minister other than the Minister for Finance? Where does the Minister for Justice come into this?
Comment on this
I imagine that certain police work would probably be necessary in carrying out the regulations.
Comment on this
The regulations in connection with the control of aircraft will be largely in the hands of the police.
Comment on this
The Deputy will find under Section 12 a number of matters in-regard to which the Executive Council make provision. These are largely matters which arise under the Paris Convention. I have not a copy of the Convention at hand.
Comment on this
No. My point is that part of the Bill deals with the application by the Executive Council of certain provisions of the Paris Convention with a view to achieving something. Surely it is possible to state, shortly, what the object is and how that object mainly is to be achieved?
Comment on this
Adopt and adapt. On one occasion the Deputy was asked a series of questions with regard to the training of air pilots, and I recollect that he referred me to the Paris Convention.
Comment on this
The Deputy should have knowledge of the Paris Convention. Where is the use in wasting time about it?
Comment on this
I suggest it is only right that the House should have information, and we can get it if the Deputy will assist me in asking the Minister questions.
Comment on this
The sense of it is to have uniform behaviour on the part of all Governments with regard to several things concerning air navigation. One of the items is concerned with the training of pilots and giving them licences. Certain qualifications have to be acquired by air pilots; certain tests have to be gone through, and all these things are based on agreements adopted internationally. These were put on paper and called the Paris Convention, where they were agreed to.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would not give two points for it, will he volunteer to give us some information about it?
Comment on this
Perhaps the House will have an opportunity of getting an answer from the Minister responsible.
Comment on this
The convention, as Deputy Briscoe has pointed out, was the first ever to secure international agreement and uniform treatment on the question of aerial transport. Some of the matters dealt with I will summarise. The general principles of the International Convention laid it down that every Power has complete and exclusive sovereignty over the air space above its territory; that each contracting State undertakes in time of peace to accord free passage above its territory to the aircraft of other contracting States; that each contracting State may prohibit flight by aircraft over certain areas of its territory, and that each contracting State may conclude special conventions, not contradictory to the general principles of the International Convention, with non-contracting States. It went on further to deal with the registration of aircraft, the certification as airworthy of aircraft, and the provision of the personnel of aircraft with certificates of competency and licences to be granted in conformity with the conditions laid down.
Article 15 deals with the conditions under which aircraft of a contracting State may cross the air space of another State and provides that each contracting State may make conditional on its prior authorisation the establishment of international airways and the creation and operation of regular international air navigation lines with or without landing on its territory. The convention also deals with the documents to be carried by aircraft engaged in international navigation, prohibits the carriage of explosives and of arms and munitions of war and entitles each contracting State generally to apply restrictions as to carriage of articles including photographic apparatus. It defines State aircraft and prohibits the flight of military aircraft across the territory of contracting States without special authorisation. One of the most important provisions is the setting up of the International Commission for Air Navigation which is a permanent commission placed under the direction of the League of Nations. The Saorstát is a member of the International Commission. I think these are the main features of the convention.
Comment on this
Is there anything in it about it being open to a Government to make it a condition of passage from and to its coast that the company should be State-owned or should be under monopolistic control?
Comment on this
Does that mean traffic originating in its own area, or traffic which originates in its own area but goes outside and lands elsewhere?
Comment on this
Is it on continuous voyage? The whole tendency of the last part of this Act is to give monopoly control to a particular company. I understand that certain people who wanted to inaugurate air services in the country were refused permits by the Minister. The Minister, at any rate, pretended that he had power under the Paris Convention to make it a condition precedent to any passage out of this country and back to it that there should be a licence, and that he could, therefore, make it a condition of the licence that there should be State supervision, State control, and even monopolistic State control. Is that right?
Comment on this
I presume the Minister can attach such conditions to the licence as he may think proper, and as the company is largely monopolistic, I take it that he can embody monopolistic conditions in the licence.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Minister for Industry and Commerce did say to various people who wanted to establish services in this country that they would not be allowed to do it, and could not do it without a permit from him; that when he was challenged about that permit point he referred to some International Air Navigation Convention. Is it the Paris Convention, and if so what is the paragraph?
Comment on this
The Minister has made an Order as the Deputy knows—the Air Navigation (International Lines) Order —under which the authority of the Minister for Industry and Commerce must be sought and obtained before a service can be established, an international service or a service to or from the Saorstát by either a Saorstát or a foreign company. I think I explained on the Second Reading that it is proposed to exercise those restrictive powers contained in the Bill, and a regulation under this Order was made by the Minister in 1935 in favour of the national company.