We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Land Bill, 1936—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–216 of 415. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1936
Enacted

No. 30 of 1936 ›

When we were discussing this section before the adjournment last night we endeavoured to point out its various effects; its effects on the county councils through the impossibility of their being able to recoup all the amounts withheld from their grants. The Minister in his reply dealt with a new aspect of the matter when he said that there were certain derelict farms in the country and that the arrears on one of these farms was so much that the farm could not be taken over because of the amount of the arrears. The Minister gave a specific instance of a farm of 190 acres with arrears of £200. And then Deputy Corry at the back said that there were numerous instances in his constituency of larger farms than 190 acres and that these huge tracts of land were derelict. When challenged to name any particular tract so that it could be identified, the Deputy failed to line up.

I would like to proceed to argue the question of these 190 acres. It is inconceivable to me that 190 acres of land is not worth arrears of £200. No matter where it is situated, even in the poorest part of the country, if it is land that would be suitable in any circumstances for division or for any sort of farming whatsoever it is worth £200. I do not assume that this land is mountain land. I have a recollection of a case recently where the Government proceeded to distribute mountain land amongst allottees, land on which I personally would not like to be compelled to live, at least on 15 or 20 acres. They did purchase it at a greater price than that at which this land referred to by the Minister would have to be purchased. The Minister said that this 190 acres of land would not be worth £200 for distribution to various small holders and others. With an imposition of £200 on this farm at what figure would the annuity have to be fixed per acre?

The House has to remember that in taking over land compulsorily for arrears of rent there is no payment to be made by the Land Commission. There is no money to be expended by them in development work, whereas in taking it over in the manner in which it has been taken over in other cases, large sums of money must be spent on housing, drainage and so on. If this land is taken over for the £200 arrears, that figure will wipe out all the arrears; this would roughly work out at about 1/- an acre annuity. Surely a farm of 190 acres is worth 1/- an acre to the future purchaser. The Minister did not say it was his intention to divide this land. His intention, he said, was to find a purchaser. That would mean turning somebody who had a farm already into a big farmer by adding 190 acres to his holding. The object of the Bill has been to make the acreage of land now held by people smaller a good deal than this farm of 190 acres of land. It is not at all impossible to my mind that, if there were any purchasers falling over each other for this 190 acres of land, they will reconsider the matter when they realise that the conditions under this amending Bill may mean that having improved this land to the Minister's satisfaction it might be afterwards taken from them for sub-division—in fact it is quite likely it would. It would be a nice little grab of 190 acres for division in a few years' time when some subsequent Government comes in. I do not say the present Government will do it now, but some Government may be there in five or six years' time which will say, "You got this 190 acres for nothing; we have no sympathy with you; we will take it from you and give you nothing," or perhaps they will give 1/- an acre which he paid for it. That is one aspect of it. There is another aspect. It is holding out a great temptation, if not to the present, to future Ministers to take political advantage of this. If a man is in arrears and any Minister wanted to do him good turn, if he was a strong supporter of his, there is nothing to prevent the Minister from taking over the man's farm for the arrears and handing it over to someone else who will give it back to that man.

Comment on this

What is to prevent him from giving it back to the man himself?

Comment on this

Nothing. Then there is another aspect. You are wiping out arrears which do not belong to the Land Commission, arrears which have been deducted from the various local authorities. You are wiping out the possibility of their ever getting one tittle of that money back. That is a real danger. It is wiping out an asset. I should like to know more about this 190 acres. This land is not so devoid of value that some day some particular portion of these arrears could not be got in some way.

There is another danger in this. I hope the Minister's intention is not to proceed immediately to seize land for arrears all round. If he does, most of us will be in the position that our land will be speedily seized. Some of us have been trying for two or three years to meet our liabilities, and we have not been able. If this policy is proceeded with, I will be one of those whose land will be taken, because I admit that I am in arrears. For the last couple of years it was not possible for me to meet all my commitments in rates, annuities, etc. I intend to pay them; I do not want anyone to pay my just debts for me. This year I hope to be able to pay a little more than last year, because the coal-cattle pact gave us some relief. I hope eventually to wipe out all the arrears. But there are many farmers in a worse situation than I am, and they will find it difficult in the coming year to pay off their arrears. We ought not to advance the principle now that their land will be taken from them for the arrears.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think this is the section which empowers the Land Commission to take land.

Comment on this

It deals with arrears.

Comment on this

It amends the section which empowers the Land Commission to do so.

Comment on this

I hope it will not be the practice of the Minister or of any other Minister to proceed on these lines, at least until it is proved that the tenant is absolutely hopeless and has made no attempt to do anything in the matter. I do not think the powers which the section gives in wiping out arrears are necessary unless the land they propose to take over is of such quality that it could not be used for any agricultural purpose or was incapable of being distributed to allottees. In either of these two events it is worth something. Any land that I know of will be worth something for some purpose. I cannot conceive that it would be necessary to wipe out a debt of £200 on 190 acres of land. It should be possible to sell the land so as to get that much for it. It should certainly be capable of being divided amongst migrants or somebody else. I do not know the position of this land, but I make bold to say that there was worse land than this farm divided. As to Deputy Corry's statement that there were several derelict farms in his constituency, I should like to have some definite particulars of these. When Deputy Corry was asked to give particular instances he failed to give them. There was nothing whatever in Deputy Corry's speech except what I might call his usual claptrap—getting up and making statements for which he has not a scintilla of evidence. This section should be withdrawn. It is a mischievous section and we shall oppose it.

Comment on this

The Minister in introducing this Bill said, when referring to this particular section, "We are now taking power to sell these holdings or parcels discharged from all or part of the arrears, and, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, to write off as much of the arrears as we find it impossible to recover." The procedure, as I understand it, is this: that the Land Commission, after several attempts to collect these arrears, put up these holdings for sale and they failed to sell them. They then applied to the divisional commissioner for an order to resume possession of the holdings and the order was granted. Now I assume it is the Minister's intention, when the Bill becomes law, to put up the holdings for sale again or to dispose of them otherwise for cash. If he does not get a sufficient amount of cash to cover the arrears, he will apply to the Minister for Finance in the ordinary way for authority to write off the balance of the arrears of Land Commission annuities. There is just one point about it. This is the first time the Land Commission sought power to wipe out arrears of Land Commission annuities. It is the first time the Land Commission have come before the Dáil for the purpose of getting power to wipe out arrears of Land Commission annuities.

Comment on this

No, in 1933.

Comment on this

It is the first time they have definitely in a section of a Land Act sought power——

Comment on this

No, it was taken in 1933.

Comment on this

It is the first time they have sought power to wipe out arrears of Land Commission annuities in this particular type of case.

Comment on this

You could call these current arrears.

Comment on this

In any event, I want to protest against giving the Land Commission such power in this particular type of case. This is a power that could be used indiscriminately. It could be used by an unscrupulous Minister for the purpose of facilitating members or supporters of his own Party in default in the payment of Land Commission annuities. It is a power that, I think, should be definitely limited to a particular class of holding on which there is an accumulation of Land Commission arrears which the Land Commission has been unable to recover after pursuing a certain recognised procedure. I agree that, where there is a derelict farm, the Land Commission should have power to take possession of it and to dispose of it in accordance with the spirit of the land code. There is a big number of these derelict farms in the country at the moment. The Minister mentioned two last evening, but I daresay these were just two cases that occurred to his mind. I am quite sure that there must be a big number of derelict farms in every county in the Free State at the moment. That is scarcely to be wondered at, and the number is bound to increase as long as the Fianna Fáil Party is in power, and as long as farmers find it impossible to make ends meet under the policy that is being pursued by the present Government.

If possession of these farms is taken by the Land Commission, they should be disposed of in a sympathetic way, and unless there is something very serious against the original owner he should be given the first consideration. If the actual owner himself is not a suitable person to manage and cultivate land, then the qualifications of his son, if he has one, or the qualifications of his wife in the cultivation and management of land should be taken into consideration. The original tenant may have bought out the land under one of the earlier Land Acts. He may, for instance, have bought out under the Ashbourne Act and may have paid off practically the whole of the advance on this particular holding. In these circumstances, it would certainly be a grave injustice to the original owner to deprive him absolutely of the benefit of the payments which he has already made. He may have bought out under the Land Act of 1903 or the Land Act of 1909, and have paid off practically half the total advance made. In such circumstances it would be grossly unfair to deprive that man absolutely of the benefit of the payments which he has already made.

I, therefore, submit to the House that the original tenant should first of all be taken into consideration unless he is the type of man who is altogether unfitted for the cultivation or management of land. His case should be first considered, and if he himself is unfitted, then his son or his wife may be qualified to undertake the management and cultivation of land. After the original tenant, I would say that the land should be utilised for the purpose of relieving congestion. I do not believe in making gifts of big farms of land to people for the payment of a mere nominal sum which may or may not wipe out the amount of arrears of annuities that has accumulated. The Minister is taking power in this section to make a present of such land to some friend or supporter of his Party.

Comment on this

Where is that in the section?

Comment on this

It is not in the section, but what I mean is that a lot more can be read into the section than what appears in it.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy should be a bit more careful. He is showing very bad example.

Comment on this

I would like to know from the Minister how many such farms there are in the State at the moment. I am sure that the Minister has already got his officials to prepare a return showing the number of derelict farms in the country. I am sure, too, that there are a number of derelict farms of which the Land Commission has not resumed possession. I want to know from the Minister now the number of derelict farms of which the Land Commission have actually resumed possession.

As Deputy Brennan has pointed out, this is not a matter which affects the Land Commission alone. This section also affects the local authorities, and they will have to suffer a loss in the rates consequent on the fact that the annuities have not been paid, perhaps in some cases, for quite a long number of years. And not alone does it affect the local authorities, but it may also affect the Board of Works, because drainage and other charges due to it on the holding may also be unpaid. But it hits the local authorities especially hard because they have had no responsibility whatever in the matter. They were not responsible for allowing the tenant to remain in possession for a number of years without paying his annuities. They were not responsible, in the first instance, for putting the tenant into possession of the land. They have had absolutely no control at all in the matter, and in these circumstances it is particularly hard that the general body of the ratepayers should suffer because of the negligence of one man or the inability of one individual to pay his land annuities.

This section, in some respect at all events, is probably a necessary section in order that the Land Commission may be able to dispose of the derelict farms which they have in their possession. While I say that, I urge that the latter portion of the section should be amended, so that the power which the Minister is there seeking will only apply to a particular type of case, and to that type of case only in very special circumstances and under very special conditions. I certainly do not believe in giving the Minister indiscriminate power in all these cases to wipe out the arrears of unpaid Land Commission annuities. That power should be definitely limited to certain circumstances and to certain conditions.

Comment on this

I would like to know from the Deputy what limitation he suggests.

Comment on this

I would suggest that this power to wipe out arrears should only apply to the particular type of case in which the Land Commission have made every possible effort to dispose of these farms and to realise, if possible, the amount of the unpaid arrears of Land Commission annuities on them.

Comment on this

That is the case that is being made for the section, and Deputy Roddy is justifying the section by suggesting that limitation.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

This is a section that, I think, should never have been thought of.

Comment on this

Deputy Roddy, if he were really honest about the matter, would justify the section. As Deputy Belton has said, in the speech and in the suggestions that he has made, Deputy Roddy has outlined what the section is intended to do and has justified it. I do not mind some Deputies talking through their hat about land, but I do think that Deputy Roddy, with his experience, should give a good example. Deputy Bennett said this was some sort of a conspiracy, and indicated that the Minister in charge of the Land Commission for the time being was taking power to take over land to give it to his friends.

Comment on this

I did not say that. I suggested that was a possibility.

Comment on this

Deputy Bennett suggested that was what the section was for.

Comment on this

The Deputy will find that what I say is correct when he reads his speech.

Comment on this

I spoke about the possibilities.

Comment on this

I have the Deputy's words before me, and what he said was that this was to give the present Ministry some political advantage. Now that is all right for Deputy Bennett and might be all right for Deputy Roddy at the cross-roads, but it is not good enough for this House. Deputy Roddy knows perfectly well that the Minister for Lands has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with the persons to whom land is allotted, and he had no business, having been in charge of the Land Commission himself at one time, to say that sort of thing. It is not good enough, and I hope he will drop it. He also talked about an unscrupulous Minister taking over some land with arrears on it and giving it for a nominal sum to some political supporter. The Deputy knows hang well that that cannot be done. Another thing about this is that Deputy Roddy should know the necessity for it. He has had enough experience in the Land Commission to know that, during the last 15 or 20 years, there are some lands that have gone derelict. I indicated what this section was for—that there are some lands that have become badly overgrown with rushes or something else, and lands in grass that have not been grazed for a number of years, that they have deteriorated to such an extent as not to be worth the arrears due on them. Deputy Belton said last night that the most arrears that can be on any land would be three prior to 1933 and three since. That would be six, plus a couple of years' rates.

Comment on this

The pre-1933 arrears were funded.

Comment on this

They were attached to the land. If we cannot wipe them out they have to remain attached to the land as a prior charge. Then you would have rates and you might have Board of Works charges of various sorts and other things to attach to the land that are not a mortgage on the owner but are a mortgage on the land and cannot be got rid of. Last night I indicated that in County Wexford there was a farm of 190 acres with a poor law valuation of £182, a farm that has been derelict for years. The drains were allowed to be stopped up and the whole land has gone back into rushes. I would bet that Deputy Belton would not take a present of it, let alone give £200 for it, but there are men in the locality who have been using it as a commonage for a number of years who would give something for it. As it is, it is a continuing burden on the State, on the taxpayers and ratepayers. It is going from bad to worse and there is nobody getting any good out of it.

Comment on this

Is it arable land?

Comment on this

At the moment it is not; it is all covered with rushes.

Comment on this

Is it capable of being made arable?

Comment on this

All land is capable of being made arable.

Comment on this

I beg to differ with the Minister. Some land might be overgrown with timber and in other respects it might not be possible to make it arable. Would it not be far and away wiser for the Land Commission to drain that land, lime it themselves, get rid of the rushes and then divide it? Would not that be a more sensible procedure?

Comment on this

Every T.D. in this House and every person in this country is an expert on how to run the Land Commission. I wish to the Lord some of them got a chance for a year or two and then we would see how things worked out. The Land Commission have had a certain experience in dealing with these derelict farms. They have advised me that this section is necessary and I am prepared to take their word for it. They have given me cases of derelict farms that have deteriorated to such an extent that that factor, together with other factors that Deputies must be aware exist throughout the country, brings about the position that the land cannot be sold at the price of the arrears. The best farm in the world might be situated in County Dublin, but if the drains were allowed to get stopped up and the land was allowed to become overgrown with rushes and if the neighbours wanted it for nothing it would be a pretty valueless proposition.

The Land Commission want this power. Where the circumstances are such that the farm is not value for the arrears of the annuities and they have to take that land into their possession, they want to be able to reduce the arrears to such an amount that it will be valuable to someone to put the land into production and relieve both the taxpayers and the ratepayers. We have discussed this long enough, and I have made a reasonable case, and unless there is somebody trying to make a case of conspiracy, for-which there is no foundation, I do not see how anyone could object to it. I do not see the slightest reason for an objection. As Deputy Belton said, Deputy Roddy made a case for it in one portion of his speech.

Comment on this

I described this Bill as a grabber's Bill, and I submit to the House that Section 9 is the grabber's section. It is put in here to convenience the land grabber. It is the old game. There never was a landlord yet who evicted a tenant who did not start offering the land grabber an inducement to enter into possession. He went amongst the respectable farmers, but they would not touch him with a 40-foot pole. Then he went amongst the rag, tag and bobtail, and eventually he would succeed in getting his men. These were the emergency men. They were usually got in the back streets of Belfast in the days I well remember. They were brought down in charabancs and deposited on the farm. They would stay there for seven or eight years, and then they gradually found their way back to the back streets of Belfast and we would put back the evicted tenant on the holding. We used to have celebrations on such occasions—a day out. We passed several Bills through Westminster and in this House to reinstate evicted tenants on such farms as we have here, farms into possession of which the emergency men were bribed to go and farms off which those same emergency men eventually faded away.

The Minister is in a conciliatory mood to-day and he winds up by telling us that he has accepted this section on the recommendation of the Land Commission and he is prepared to take their opinion on these matters. The Minister must try to remember that he is responsible to the House. The Land Commission is not, and it is not open to us to discuss the motives that may have moved the Commissioners to make certain recommendations to the Minister. It would, therefore, be better if that argument were dropped from our discussions for the remainder of this Bill. It is a bad thing to leave absolute discretion in the Land Commission to wipe out all arrears of annuities on certain given parcels of land unless some conditions are laid down by this House which will restrict that discretion in accordance with the will of Deputies here. We who live in the country know of cases where farms have become derelict and on which considerable arrears have accumulated and there is no reasonable prospect of those arrears ever being paid. That has happened in the case of a delicate man, a man who was no longer, able to work his land. He allowed his land to run down, and he had, in fact, fallen into hopeless arrears and there was no prospect of getting out of them.

I am now speaking of the pre-Fianna Fáil period. It also happened very often where a woman was left with a smáll family. Her husband died and she had nobody to work the land for her. That class of person would fall into hopeless arrears and the land would deteriorate when there was no man to work it. It would also arise in the case of a farmer who was no good.

I believe, however, that in the majority of cases men would get into difficulties through no fault of their own. I would be prepared to give the Minister or the Land Commission power to wipe out the arrears on land of that kind on condition that it was intended to vest the holding in the son of the tenant or in some person to whom the tenant would consent. I can imagine a man who had broken down in health entering into a family arrangement and consenting to let his nephew carry on if he had not a son. In this case we ought to give the Land Commission power to wipe out the arrears and allow the man to get on his feet again. Suppose we had derelict land, and there is nobody of that class in whom the land can be vested and the Land Commission, under Section 37 of the Act of 1927, resume the holding. I say it would be infinitely preferable, although it might not be the most expeditious way of dealing with that land, that the Land Commission should repair the land themselves—put it in condition—and then deal with it as land which they had acquired in the ordinary way for the relief of congestion in the area.

This note of warning should be sounded, that if we are going to give power to the Land Commission to facilitate them in taking holdings from farmers who, through no fault of their own, have got into arrears, and making those holdings peculiarly attractive to grabbers, you are going to raise a great deal of ill-feeling in every district where those holdings are acquired. The Minister says that it is ridiculous to suggest that he would use any personal influence in the matter. I think, as a matter of fact, that the Land Commission, in reaching their final decisions, act reasonably fairly, and I think it is right to say that now. I have said repeatedly in this House and now reiterate it, that there is a great deal of interference by way of inspection and annoyance of that kind going on through the irresponsible intervention of Fianna Fáil T.D.s and Fianna Fáil Cumainn in the country. I believe that it is as great an annoyance to the Land Commission as it is to the tenants.

Comment on this

Where is that in the section?

Comment on this

Deputies like Deputy Corry, who have no sense of public responsibility, are continually persecuting their neighbours by getting inspectors to go down and examine their land with a view to acquisition.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not under section 9.

Comment on this

No, Sir, not under Section 9, but quite possibly Deputy Corry might get active in connection with Section 9 and the sections of the land code which it purports to amend.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies should be clear on this. In discussing an amending Bill, the basic Act may not be discussed except in so far as it is affected by the proposed amendments. This amending section deals with only a very limited aspect of resale.

Comment on this

It deals with Section 37 of the Act of 1927, which is the first section under which the Land Commission have power to take back a holding——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Unless the Chair is very much mistaken, the purport of the section is to provide that sale of holdings be effected discharged from arrears, "discharged from arrears" being the key-words in the section.

Comment on this

It purports to amend Section 37, and raises the whole question as to whether it is desirable for the Land Commission to depart from its old procedure in selling those farms charged with the arrears, or whether they shall take them and vest them in a new tenant, charging the tenant with the arrears, or whether, as proposed in Section 9, the Land Commission shall take them and vest them in the new tenant, discharged from all arrears. I say that that power should be very carefully restricted. I believe that unless it is, considerable evils will flow from this new departure. I quite admit that you can make a good case, in the exceptional case, for powers of this kind, but how often have we heard from Ministerial Benches the lesson preached that you cannot pass good law to deal with the exceptional case? In dealing with the land code we ought to consider the general rule rather than the exceptional case. To make it a general rule that the activities of the land-grabber should be facilitated, or that we should create in this country a new race of emergency men, is something which I would greatly deplore.

To facilitate the restoration of land that has got into an unusable condition is something we would all wish to help in doing. I feel that in a case of that kind it would be infinitely better for the Land Commission to go in on the land which has arrears upon it, and, out of the Improvement Vote, to spend so much money as may be necessary to restore that land to an arable condition, and then to sell it charged with whatever arrears were upon it, except in a case where they saw an opportunity of reestablishing the original tenant purchaser through his son or through a relative to whose name that tenant purchaser would consent. In that case I would be prepared to wipe out the arrears and let the tenant purchaser's son in on the place if he showed signs that he was capable, by his own hard work, of pulling the farm round and meeting the obligations devolving on the tenant purchaser of such a holding. I have not the slightest doubt that if the Minister would accept our view in this matter he would find that the scheme we outline here would work better and avoid a number of evils the possible development of which he perhaps at the moment does not anticipate.

Comment on this

I have listened to both sides of this debate, and I do not see very much difference between the conclusion which Deputy Dillon came to just before he sat down and the case made by the Minister. I am against the wiping out of arrears if originally it was a fair contract. The man who does not mind his business should not be able to rely on his neighbour, who does mind his business, to pay his arrears. There are special circumstances of late years. We are not dealing with them——

Comment on this

I am viewing the matter, not in the circumstances of to-day, but in times of normality when we have no economic war. The case put up by the Minister is that those lands were derelict prior to the economic war. I asked him last night—and he did not deal with the matter—what is preventing the Land Commission from buying those lands when they are put up for sale, and dividing them amongst landless men? Will the Minister give us all the facts? Is there a boycott of the sales, or do the Land Commission find themselves in the position that they cannot sell the land even at a sacrifice? If they cannot sell it at a sacrifice, will they be in any better position when the little bit of arrears is wiped out? I submit that they will not. If this farm is worth £180 a year of an annuity, might I ask is that the original annuity or is that the revised annuity?

Comment on this

The valuation.

Comment on this

What is the revised annuity on it?

Comment on this

I cannot tell you.

Comment on this

That is very material, because we have been considering arrears at the rate of about £200 a year. Deputy Bennett went into calculations that the service of that, if funded, would be about 1/- per acre per year. It would be important for us, if we are going to consider this farm that the Minister has in mind——

Comment on this

I only gave it as an indication to the Deputy—not to discuss the principle of it.

Comment on this

It is in discussing the principle of it that I should like to know the amount of the revised annuity, because the Minister told us yesterday that if put on the market it would not fetch the arrears—that they could not get anybody to take it even on the revised annuity. I do not think I am substantially misquoting the Minister. If it is not worth the annuity, how much further on will it put the Land Commission to wipe out the arrears of the annuity? Nobody will take it and nobody could live on it. If it is not worth the annuity, that annuity is in the nature of a rack-rent, and nobody could live under a rack-rent. It is trying to revise the whole annuity on the basis of what the land is worth, and write off the loss as part of the working costs of the Land Commission. I do not think that the Land Commission should have such power or should ask such power. Contracts have been entered into, and people should carry out those contracts. The Land Commission, which is charged with the collection of those annuities, should do their work and collect them. It is their funeral that the annuities are too high, and circumstances have been produced which have made the annuities too high—circumstances that imposed on that land a land tax equal to half the annuity. That is the trouble. That burden must manifest itself, here, there and everywhere. A couple of days ago it manifested itself in a Milk Bill that was put before this House, and now it manifests itself in a section such as this, the purpose of which is to wipe out arrears simply because people cannot pay their annuities in the conditions under which they have to work at the present time. One could talk for a week about this, but I think we have talked long enough on this section.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I wish, at least, that the Minister had talked intelligently enough on this section, because, if he had, we would not be still talking about it. I hope that this question will be put to a division. I am going to vote against it, not for any qualified reason, but because I disagree with the section altogether. I do not agree with Deputy Roddy that it should be given a qualified approval. I am against the whole principle of the section.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any statistics as to the comparative number of derelict farms, or is any information available in the Land Commission in connection with this matter?

Comment on this

I have not the information at the moment.

Comment on this

I think the present Minister was in charge of the 1933 Act that was passed in this House, and I believe that, on that occasion, he made a promise to the effect that, if certain arrears of annuities were to be written off as irrecoverable, certain payments would be made to the local authorities in the areas concerned. That promise, I admit, has been redeemed in part, but I should like to know whether or not the Minister is prepared to do the rest. Is the Minister prepared to say now, in relation to this particular section, that again he will promise that some part at least—a substantial part—will be made good to the local authorities?

Comment on this

That is a question for the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say how the Minister for Finance comes into it? The Minister for Finance is not concerned in the finance of this proposition at all, but the local county councils are concerned in it. I suggest that the Minister should insert there "the secretary of the county council." I will not suggest that he should insert "the chairman" of the local county council, but would he insert there the words "a county council" instead of the words "the Minister for Finance"?

Comment on this

I shall not accuse the Minister of having this particular section inserted from any unfair motive, but I will put this to the Minister: Is it not manifestly unfair that he is going to take upon himself the power to re-sell this property at the expense of the local authorities if the loss of that money is not going to be made good to the local authorities?

Comment on this

If it is to be written off as irrecoverable, what position will the local authorities be in then?

Comment on this

I think, Sir, that Deputy Belton has spoken enough already and that he has been answered sufficiently.

Comment on this

Perhaps I have, but what answer has the Minister to make?

Comment on this

I have given all the answers that I can give.

Comment on this

Very well.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That Section 9 stand part of the Bill"—put.

Tá 43
·
Níl 30
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I am not very clear as to the meaning of this section. Perhaps the Minister would be good enough to give us a brief explanation of it.

Comment on this

This clause is intended to remedy an omission from certain sections of the 1931 Act of references which should have been made there to compounded arrears of rent. It was intended that the provisions of these sections of the 1931 Act should apply to bonds issued in respect of compounded arrears of rent in the same way as they apply to bonds issued in respect of standard price. The clause does no more than give statutory authority to the intentions of the legislature and to what has been the practice of the Land Commission since 1931. It is intended to rectify a difficulty which has been experienced since 1931, and to amend the procedure in several sections of the 1931 Act relating to the adjustment of accounts, rendered necessary by (a) the reduction of standard purchase annuities or the dismissal of proceedings, as a result of which land bonds have been issued in excess of the proper amount and (b) the increase of standard purchase annuities in consequence of which the estate concerned is to be credited with additional land bonds of the same series, as if they had been issued on the appointed day, together with interest from the appointed day.

Comment on this

Now we are all looking wiser.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Minister has not helped us to understand the section very much better. It appears to me that land bonds could only be of interest to us when they are over-issued, because when they are over-issued, they are a liability on the local authority. This section and the succeeding section appear to me to emphasise the difference between the State and the individual. The State, when it under-issues land bonds, can absolve itself, but if the individual does not pay his debts or does not carry out the terms of his contract, or pay the full amount required of him under the terms of the contract, he has to purge his offence in Arbour Hill or Mountjoy. This is certainly a convenient way of getting out of a difficulty, but I still do not see the necessity for the section.

Comment on this

I cannot parse the section for the Deputy. It is purely a matter of technical drafting.

Comment on this

Can the Minister quote a typical case in which this section would operate?

Comment on this

The lawyers of the Land Commission advised me that this section is necessary in order to carry out the intentions of the 1931 Act. I am not a lawyer and I cannot parse it for him.

Comment on this

As I understand at, Section 13 of the Act of 1931, sub-section (3), provided that where the Land Commission had initiated proceedings for the acquisition of land and land bonds had been issued, and it was subsequently found that their proceedings for the acquisition of the land were dismissed, the Land Commission were then obliged to recoup the Land Bond Fund. Section 10 of this Bill empowers by statute the Land Commission to do the same thing in regard to land bonds issued in respect of compounded arrears of rent. Does it apply in respect of land bonds issued in excess of those necessary to meet claims for compounded arrears of rent? The last question I want to ask the Minister is whether this Section 10 is by way of being an indemnity section and does it purport to legalise certain things that have been done since Section 13 of the 1931 Act came into force, which were in fact not in strict accord with the letter of the law?

Comment on this

The Land Commission found difficulty because compounded arrears of rent were not specifically mentioned in the section referred to, and they were advised that it was better to change the law in that regard. It is necessary for the purpose of the Land Commission to treat these compounded arrears of rent in the same way as the standard money, and to get over the legal difficulty it is necessary to have the 1931 Act amended in this particular way.

Comment on this

Are we to understand that the Land Commission, apprehending that legal proceedings might be taken, which, on the words of the Statute of 1931, they would not be in a position to meet, want an indemnity section in this Bill?

Comment on this

I think it is a matter of the Comptroller and Auditor-General rather than a matter of legal proceedings.

Comment on this

Section 10 is in fact an indemnity section for what has already been done and is intended to alter the law for the future?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

And it does clearly provide that past acts are now made legal?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister is in a position to tell us whether any representation was made by the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor-General, and, if so, in what form?

Comment on this

No. The Land Commission anticipated that the Comptroller and Auditor-General might at some time.

Comment on this

No representation has been received from his office?

Comment on this

I understand not.

Comment on this

I understand this section refers to payments between the gale day and the dividend day. The Minister apparently is amending Section 51 of the Land Act of 1931, which provided that payments would be made at certain specified periods. I am anxious to know why he is repealing that section. Have all the payments been made? That section was specially introduced into the Act of 1931 to facilitate payment of these sums by tenants whose holdings were vested under that Act. Are the operations under the Act complete and is the section no longer necessary?

Comment on this

The sums mentioned in the 1923 Act, amounting to 1/6th, were halved.

Comment on this

Have the payments all been made?

Comment on this

They were infinitesimal, and have all been made.

Comment on this

In fact we are reverting to the procedure under the 1923 Act, which was set aside under the Act of 1931. Are we to understand that all proceedings under these two sections have ceased or are we reverting to the old practice?

Comment on this

To the 1923 procedure.

Comment on this

Which is set out in Section 38?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

This is a matter on which nobody who was not in daily touch with the Land Commission could offer an opinion, but it was apparently thought in 1931 that these two months' gale which amounted to ? of the total annuities did present a form of obstacle in certain cases sufficiently formidable to justify funding. It was in the light of that that Section 51 was introduced which it is to be noted laid down a statutory scheme, but left a discretion in the Land Commission to make rules for the way in which these sums should be funded. What is the point now, when the Minister's predecessor in office canvassed the House that it was better to give discretionary powers to make rules, of going back to the statutory procedure in Section 38 in the Land Act of 1923, which proved unsatisfactory in the past? Am I wrong when I say that under Section 51 of the Land Act of 1931 the Minister has power to change the rules without reference to the House at all? If that be correct, why does the Minister come before the House to amend Section 51 at all? I direct the Minister's attention to the last paragraph in Section 51 in the Act of 1931:—

or of a sum equivalent to purchase annuity is payable shall, notwithstanding anything contained in those Acts, be paid at such times (not being earlier than such first gale day) and in such instalments as shall be prescribed by rules made by the Land Commission.

That seems to give the Land Commission power to adapt rules to the situation. Why go back to the old procedure?

Comment on this

This Section has been brought forward by the Accountancy Branch as, in their view, the sums are very small. They cannot amount to anything more than ? of the annuity, which has been halved, and instead of making up the books to have payments made in six instalments, they would be paid in one. It is purely a matter of accountancy. There is always a difficulty, as it means a lot of staff work when the Land Commission has to deal with 80,000 people. They say there will be no hardship imposed on the individuals concerned in paying in one instalment rather than in six.

Comment on this

The House was asked to give its approval to administration by the Land Commission and to let them arrange matters by rules. I thought that was sensible. We gave the Land Commission power to deal with the matter by making rules. The Accountancy Branch did not go to the Commissioners but, understanding the everyday reactions of the rules made under this power, they come to us, who cannot pretend to be fully conversant with circumstances that might arise in connection with the section. Has the Accountancy Branch asked the Commissioners about this, and has it been told that the Commissioners would prefer to leave the rules as they are? Is the Accountancy Branch coming to us behind the Commissioners in order to make their job easier?

Comment on this

No, this came through the Commissioners.

Comment on this

This astonishes me. I am familiar with the activities of permanent officials for a long time, and they are a most admirable body of men, but this is the first time in recorded history that permanent officials have divested themselves of the right to legislate. I have never known such a case before, and the Minister must excuse me if he finds me a little querulous.

Comment on this

I am advised that in some cases the payment amounts to only 3d. or 4d., and it is foolish to spend civil servants' time sending out accounts four or five times, instead of getting it in a lump sum.

Comment on this

I agree. Why not do it under Section 51?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

Does this apply to a case where there was an agreement with the Land Commission that the sum you are bulking was to be paid in instalments, and that the last three or four instalments are to be paid together?

Comment on this

No, to future cases. All the cases under the 1923 Act were dealt with under the Act of 1931. This is for new entrants.

Comment on this

It is not retrospective.

Comment on this

It is not breaking any contract.

Comment on this

Sub-section (2) avoids making this retrospective.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 16:—

In sub-section (2), page 8, line 8, to delete the figures "1931" and substitute the figures "1933".

This is a drafting amendment to correct a mistake in the figures.

Comment on this

I should like the Minister to consider the advisability of including others in the list to be published under Section 31 as well as under Section 9, as I fear that there are certain classes of tenants that will have to come under this section with regard to discharging arrears. The Minister is aware that the British Legion purchased land at a very exorbitant price in 1920. The annuities were fixed on the basis of the purchase price paid for the land. These annuities are now absolutely exorbitant, and the House may as well face the fact that they should either be adjusted or the land taken over by the Land Commission and sold. I would suggest to the Minister——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I do not mind Deputies going a little bit out of order, but if we are going to wander over a subject where it does not belong, we are never going to get an end to the Bill. I submit, on a point of order, that the question of revision of annuities generally is not in order on this section.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair agrees with the Minister.

Comment on this

Does not this section deal with the revision of annuities which are based on judicial rents?

Comment on this

The Deputy's point is out of order, in my opinion.

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny this section is designed to do two things, one of which is to extend the power of the Land Commission to revise annuities which have been based on a judicial rent, and the other, to apply that procedure to cases which have been declared by the courts to be exempt from such procedure?

Comment on this

This section has nothing to do with the revision of fixed annuities.

Comment on this

This fixes the standard price.

Comment on this

That is quite a different thing from fixing the annuity. It is entirely out of order to discuss the revision of annuities on a section to which that matter does not belong.

Comment on this

I should like to have this cleared up. We are dealing with Section 13?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Section 13 begins with the following words: "Section 38 of the Land Act, 1933, shall apply and be deemed always to have applied in the case of a holding," etc. Section 38 of the Land Act of 1933 is described in the margin as follows: "Power to the Land Commission in certain cases to reduce the standard purchase annuity of a holding." Does it do that or does it not? If it does, what is the use of telling me that you cannot talk about the revision of standard purchase annuities on Section 13 of the Bill? This is very involved legislation and the Minister has alleged that certain Deputies knew nothing about it. The Minister has all the officials of the Land Commission to advise him but yet he does not seem to know what is intended by certain sections of the Bill.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The point that affects the Chair is this. If every type of tenant, on whom it is alleged that the annuities press heavily, were to be debated on this section, the whole administration of the Land Commission would be open to debate. My opinion is that the principle is at stake here and not individual cases, except by way of illustration.

Comment on this

Individual cases are referred to in sub-section (2) of this section.

Comment on this

A certain class of case is involved.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

In Section 13?

Comment on this

Yes, in sub-section (2).

Comment on this

So far as we are concerned, this is a deliberative assembly and this is the only section on which I can bring before the Minister my plea to include a certain class of cases.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If such individual cases are dealt with in the section, the Deputy is in order.

Comment on this

The Land Commission are taking power to revise certain classes of annuities under Section 9 of the Land Act of 1931. There is another class of case which the Minister knows about. I am not specially appealing for them, but I should like to see an end to this chopping and changing in our land law. The Minister knows the class of case to which I refer. He knows that the rents are utterly uneconomic. I am only asking him to consider the advisability of reducing the annuities in a certain class of case. This is the only place in which I can deal with that matter and I am merely endeavouring to assist the House.

Comment on this

I raised this matter previously here upon the Second Reading. I would certainly support the contention put forward by Deputy McMenamin on this section. As a matter of fact, the Minister himself, speaking here on Section 9, in which he took power to wipe out arrears in certain cases, gave as an instance one particular case which would, in my opinion, have to be dealt with under this particular section. You have all over the country derelict holdings which were purchased at a period when greatly inflated prices were being paid. These holdings are not security for the amount of money paid for them and the annuities on them cannot be paid. I shall give you one definite case, a case of a holding of 64 statute acres, on which the poor law valuation was £127——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I think as this section does not apply to holdings which were vested in the tenants, as it only applies to holdings which were vested in the Land Commission, it is entirely out of order to discuss this matter of the revision of annuities on lands which have already been vested in the tenants. I do not mind discussing that problem at some stage, but if we are to discuss it let us discuss it in its proper place and have done with it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It has been submitted that certain cases——

Comment on this

Where does the question belong?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order. It has been stated that the cases to which Deputies desire to refer are included in this section. I cannot see that. The Chair does not presume to know all the technicalities of every Bill. The Minister has stated that holdings vested in tenants do not come under this section. The Chair must be guided by that statement. If the cases referred to by the two Deputies who have spoken are not involved, then their remarks are not in order.

Comment on this

I accept your ruling, Sir, but I put it to the Minister that he might consider these cases to which I have referred along with those dealt with in the section.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Some Deputies who did not accept the ruling on the point maintained that certain references were in order.

Comment on this

May I submit that if a section is introduced in a Bill here, purporting to give the benefit of a reduction in annuities to a certain class of persons, and if Deputies are precluded from putting down an amendment to that section because that would involve a charge on the Exchequer, they have no remedy except to rise in their places and say: "We would have wished to propose an amendment to include another class of persons, but the rules of order prohibit it. We therefore desire to make an appeal to the Minister that this class of persons should be brought within the benefits proposed to be conferred by the section." I submit that is not out of order, and that if the Minister attempts to persuade the Chair that it is out of order to make such an appeal, he is endeavouring to mislead the Chair. Section 38 of the Land Act, 1933, gave power to the Land Commission to reduce annuities in certain cases where they believed they were in excess of the value of the land. That provision was applied to a certain class of persons. This section proposes to extend that class so as to include those persons who are paying judicial rents. We say that you should not only extend it to that class of persons but that there is a third class of persons in addition to those provided for under the Act of 1933 and in this Bill. We want to see that third class provided for, and I submit we have a perfect right to ask the Minister to extend these benefits to that third class, when we would not be allowed to move an amendment for that purpose.

Comment on this

I have no objection to having that problem discussed, but there would be no one more violent than Deputy Dillon if someone suggested that lands vested in tenants and those vested in the Land Commission should be treated in the same manner. Purely on the point of procedure, I have no doubt that this matter is out of order, but I have no objection to its being discussed if it is discussed here and now, and if we have done with it then. I do not want to be going on for a week.

Comment on this

This is the only place I could find to raise the question.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy had put in an amendment, there would have been an opportunity of raising the matter on the Money Resolution.

Comment on this

And on Second Reading.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

As the Minister is prepared to deal with the point raised now, the Chair waives the technical objection.

Comment on this

I raised the matter on Second Reading and this is the only section, in my opinion, in which it can be dealt with now. This section deals with those who purchased under the 1923 Act. The cases in which we are interested are cases in which the purchase agreements were entered into before the 1923 Act. Some of them date back to the 1903 Act. They are cases of derelict holdings which are lying all over the country and which are a burden, as the Minister said on Second Reading, on the ratepayers and the taxpayers. They will remain a burden and a running sore until legislation is introduced to deal with them. Even if, under Section 9, the Minister wipes out all the arrears, these holdings will be no better off because, as I said before, no man in his senses would walk in and pay the annuity which is payable in respect of them. These holdings have been derelict since 1924. Under the 1923 Act, the Land Commission came along and benevolently clapped arrears on them. They are lying there still and they will be a constant drain on the ratepayers and a burden to the Land Commission and the taxpayers until some amendment of this type is brought in to remedy the situation. That is my anxiety on this section. I am anxious that the position should be rectified.

The Minister alluded to the situation when he said that there were farms derelict for a long time which, at one time, had been very valuable. Then he said that nobody could be got to take these lands owing to the amount of arrears due in respect of them. Unless he reduces the annuity, he will get nobody to take these lands even after the arrears are wiped out. The Minister was right, under Section 9, in relieving the ratepayers of a big burden under that section, but the position will remain much the same if he has not these lands revalued and the annuity revised. He cannot deal with the matter in any other way. I do not propose to deal with the manner in which the annuity was originally fixed. It was, however, fixed at an enormous figure, for which the lands are not now value and for which they were not value in 1924. I know five or six farms which have been lying derelict since 1924 and which will be lying derelict in 1994 unless some amendment of this description is brought into operation. No man would take a gift of these lands.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy referring to the valuation or to the annuity?

Comment on this

To the annuity. I know a farm of 74 acres which is now bearing a halved annuity of £66 18s. 0d.

Comment on this

That is the amount of the annuity after it has been halved

Comment on this

Yes. It was £129 previously. I could go on quoting cases for a month in which a similar state of affairs exists. The Minister has given us a list of similar cases under the 1923 Act. When that is the position in respect of holdings purchased under the 1923 Act, how much more necessary is it to go back and deal with holdings for which a far higher price was paid to the landlord? The unfortunate tenants find it absolutely impossible to pay these annuities. This is not a matter of to-day or yesterday. It goes back to 1924 and to the war years. I alluded on Section 9 last night to an estate on which a large number of evicted tenants were reinstated. After three years' torment, they ran for their lives. They knocked three crops of oats out of it and cleared. The whole estate is lying derelict there since. An odd fool comes along and takes a turn for a year or two. Then he "hops" it. The trouble with us is that the unfortunate ratepayers are being "nailed" in the Agricultural Grant on the one hand and in the rates on the other hand. No rates can be got off the estate while every year the Land Commission comes along and cuts the Agricultural Grant. That has been the position for a number of years. This section should be extended to embrace not only the 1923 cases but the 1903 cases as well. If the position is not rectified by legislation, it will continue sæcula sæculorum.

Comment on this

I should like to give the House a concrete example. In the case of the Cloncurry Estate, Lord Cloncurry was prepared to accept £17,000. Through a wangle—to use a vulgarism—Lord Cloncurry was paid £37,000 for that land. That amount was charged on the lands and the tenants are expected to pay it. It cannot be done.

Comment on this

Who got the benefit of the wangle?

Comment on this

That is another day's work.

Comment on this

The Minister tried to make a fine distinction between persons in whom land has been vested and provisional vesting under Section 9 of the Land Act, 1931. I do not think that it is worth while trying to set traps of that kind for the Opposition, because they will not work. We all know that revision of annuities could not be undertaken if land was vested and, under Section 9, the procedure was carried out while the land was provisionally vested. This section proposes to amend the existing law with a view to making this procedure available to the Land Commission in connection with land purchase annuities calculated and founded upon judicial rents. So far as I am aware, most of those judicial rents were arrived at under the procedure provided under the Ashbourne Act, 1885. They were accepted as fair rents by the vast majority of tenants in whose favour they were fixed. I am told, however, by those who know the situation intimately that there are isolated cases in which, for some incomprehensible reason, the standard purchase annuity, calculated on the basis of 65 per cent. or 70 per cent. of the judicial rent, is excessive. Discretion requires to be vested in the Land Commission to deal with that situation. I think the House is entitled to ask the Minister to give us examples which would induce us to depute this power to the Land Commission. The Land Commission thought they had this power and purported to use it. The matter was tried out in the courts and they were prohibited from attempting to use it further. They were informed that so far as they had tried to use it they had acted ultra vires and their action had no effect. This section now proposes to give them the power in future and to come back to cases where the courts already refused to allow them to use that power. We should not allow them to go back now and to take up these cases again where the court has already refused or prohibited them from attempting to use that power. Surely the Minister ought to give us some cases justifying this section. I have no doubt that some cases exist analogous to those referred to by Deputy Corry. I think the Minister should give stronger cases, rather than, as he has done, ask us here to give him wider powers than he already enjoys.

Comment on this

With regard to Deputy Dillon's request for cases, I want to say that I did give a half-dozen cases in my Second Reading speech in which the Land Commission found that the judicial rent fixed was altogether greater than what they, having regard to what they thought the tenant could pay, would fix. I showed in a great number of cases that the Land Commission were compelled to reduce the annuities based on the judicial rent by 50 per cent. just in order to put on the tenant a burden which he could meet. I do not propose to read these cases out again. The Deputy can see them for himself.

On the problem of reducing the annuities I must say it is one in which I cannot see daylight. You have, I suppose, about 400,000 vested tenants. If we take power to review all these, if we take power to reduce the annuities below what they are at present, these 400,000 vested annuitants would all apply to have them reduced and it would be impossible to deal with them. If there were some standard of value in which we could assess claims coming on now it would be all right. In the 1933 Act I did my utmost to get some standard of value by which we could measure whether the rent was too high or not. In the 1933 Act you reduced the general body of land purchasers by 50 per cent. in their annuities and in a number of special cases we reduced the annuity by 55 per cent., knowing that there was a general knowledge in the Land Commission that the annuities fixed upon estates bought out in those cases were greater than the annuities in other cases. We took that rough and ready method of doing something for the people who were hardly pressed. I got hundreds of cases and viewed them myself to see if there was any relation at all between the land annuity and the poor law valuation. I found there was no relation whatsoever. In one case the poor law valuation was £1 per acre and the annuity was only a few shillings. In another case one would get the poor law valuation at £1 an acre and the annuity would be 30/-. I found there was absolutely no relation at all between the two. If there was a general relationship between the poor law valuation and the land purchase annuity we could say: "Well, we will revise everything; we will revise every farm where the land annuity exceeds the poor law valuation." But there is no use in tackling it in that way. In some of the cases where the Land Commission thought there was most hardship the standard of the purchase annuity was less than the poor law valuation. Until there is a general revaluation of the agricultural land in the country for rating purposes, there is no way of dealing with this particular problem other than by having a general revision of land annuities. That means a whole new land purchase scheme for 400,000 annuitants. That is an impossible task. If it were an urgent and pressing task, if the hardship were felt by large numbers of the community, I would say: "We will have to face it," but I think the burden on the people we are trying to place on the land and whose holdings we are trying to rearrange is more pressing just now. More general damage would be done to the community by leaving over the work of trying to place people on the land than there would be done to the community by leaving this question of the annuities unrevised even though there are numbers of people whose burdens are a little too heavy. I think less damage would be done by leaving the annuities on 400,000 holdings as they stand than there would by discontinuing the work of placing people on the land. I did not jump to the conclusion that this was an absolutely impossible task in the present circumstances. I did not jump to that conclusion. I examined it and consulted with the Land Commission. I got the figures dug up and found it was not possible without a general revision of the land annuities. But look at what that would mean. A general revision of the land annuities would engage all the staff of the Land Commission. Seeing that the work on which they are engaged is so urgent in the national interest this revision of the land annuities is a thing I could not recommend to the House just now. I do not think the House would agree with it. In this Bill, however, we have done certain things to wipe out arrears in cases where the holding fell into very great arrears. That is the very best I can do. And I certainly could not undertake in this particular Bill to do anything more.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister that under this section he cannot review the type of cases mentioned by Deputy McMenamin. I know the Land Commission is familiar with the type of cases mentioned by Deputy McMenamin. It has been familiar with them for years past. This is not the first occasion in which that case has been made in the Dáil. I am sure it has been made in innumerable cases to the higher officials of the Land Commission. It is, undoubtedly, an outstanding case and, if it is not possible in this Bill, I think the Minister in some subsequent legislation should make some provision to cover the tenants on the Cloncurry Estate. That land was bought at a ridiculously high price. The annuities were fixed in proportion to the price paid for the land. The result is that the tenants, no matter how hard they work, will always be handicapped and will find it difficult to meet a rent of that kind, encumbered as that rent is with high rates.

Comment on this

If I understand Deputy Corry aright I think he referred more to cases where the arrears were being piled on also. I presume that the half annuity to which he referred of £66 on a 64 acre farm, included arrears as well. If there are derelict farms where the annuitant fell into arrears, I think where the Land Commission gets an opportunity of handing such land over to a good type of man that they should cut their losses and wipe out all the arrears. I think if they had such power it would be a great advantage.

Comment on this

We are taking that power to-day in this Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Having that power should, I think, meet very many of these cases to which Deputy Corry has referred.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I am not referring now to the cases which Deputy McMenamin mentioned. I am referring to the type of cases where the holdings are derelict, where one annuitant has gone bankrupt and the holding has been for years in arrears. A new person takes the land, and he is saddled with all those arrears in addition to his current annuity. That is what I understood from Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

No. I already pointed out that under Section 9 the Minister had taken power to wipe out these arrears. I am also aware that Deputy Lynch voted against that section. What I say is that there is no use in halving the arrears and still leaving the annuity in the position that was the primary cause of these arrears accumulating. The moment you wipe out the arrears some poor fool will come along, take the holding, and he will be put into possession. In three or four years' time the ratepayers will be in the position that they will have to pay the annuity again for him in the same way as they did for his predecessor. That is what will happen. I ask the Minister to limit the matter to holdings where half the annuity is more than a quarter of the valuation. In the instance which the Minister has given here in his statement to the House, the value of the annuity is in no case more than a quarter of the valuation. I suggest that the Minister should take as a basis any holding where the halved annuity is more than one-fourth of the valuation, or some basis of that kind. It will give these unfortunate people some chance—at least not these people in particular, but the ratepayers who are paying the piper. It is all right for the Land Commission to take one of these estates and say: "It is a lovely little place; we will give it to Jack to-day and then give it to Jim, and then back to Jack's brother," and carry that on for a number of years. That is what has been going on for the last 15 or 20 years since the estate was pawned over in the first instance on the Land Commission and on these unfortunate tenants. Some fellow got a pocket of money out of it, and went over to spend it in Monte Carlo or Piccadilly. I know the objection that the Land Commission have.

Comment on this

What is it?

Comment on this

That under the section as it stands they cannot get after the person who is getting away with the money. But in the case of these tenants for whom we are appealing, the Land Commission and the taxpayers will have to lose the difference. That is the whole thing. I like to call a spade a spade and to have frank talking. That is the objection there is to the suggested amendment. The objection is not because of any difficulties. The objection is that in Section 13, as it stands now, amending Section 38, the Land Commission can get after the land bonds and extract the difference from the land bonds, so that the State loses nothing. In the other case, the State will lose the difference. I suggest that it is only right and proper that the State should lose the difference, as it was State officials in the first place who made the valuation and bought the place and piled on the burden. It should not be thrown on the ratepayers of any county to pay for the mistakes made in previous years by any State department.

Comment on this

Could the Minister solve it in any way? So far as I can understand, there is a general agreement on both sides of the House on certain aspects of this Land Bill, and that is as to whether annuities are unreasonably high. That is agreed. I think the Minister will agree with it. I am not a great authority on Land Acts, but if it is beyond the power of this House to solve the problem which we know exists and which ought to be remedied, then I think we cut a very bad figure as an assembly. I only intervened to say that I think the Land Commission and this House ought to rise to the occasion and solve the problem which has been put up from both sides of the House.

Comment on this

The problem is not insoluble, but it is insoluble in present circumstances. It is not impossible to measure a mile, but we must have some sort of a yard-stick to measure it out. It is not impossible to value land, but we have not the yard-stick in the Land Commission that will enable us to tell, by looking at the poor law valuation and the standard purchase annuity, what annuity is too high and what annuity is fair. If we had, we would do it very quickly. I have indicated, both in the 1933 Act and in this Bill, that I am prepared to go as far as I can towards relieving the burdens on farmers which are heavy in relation to the burdens that other farmers have to bear. In the 1933 Act the Land Commission for the first time took power to reduce an annuity. Up to then, no matter what the annuity was, for no reason could you reduce it. In 1933 we took power to reduce the annuity where land was submerged. I am not saying that there was anything virtuous in doing that; it was the common-sense thing to do, and we did it for the first time. We have power to reduce the annuity where lands are submerged.

In this Bill we are taking power, where arrears have accumulated on lands and the Land Commission cannot sell them even for the amount of the arrears, to wipe out the arrears. If I could see some way of dealing with the Cloncurry Estate and a few other estates——

Comment on this

And the Corry Estate.

Comment on this

And the Corry Estate and a few dozen other estates that the Land Commission know have too high an annuity fixed upon them, without bringing the whole 400,000 land annuitants to the doorsteps of the Land Commission, I would do it. We cannot see how it can be done. We have no yard-stick to measure what substance there is in any complaint which comes to us with regard to an annuity being too high. We cannot say to a man who writes saying that his annuity is too high: "From the data we have in the office we can say it is perfectly fair." We have no such standard. If we had a complete revision of poor law valuation for rating purposes, and if the poor law valuation had any relationship to the value of land, it might be possible to do something. We know it has not. I think that one of the most urgent problems we have in dealing with land and a lot of other matters is to get a proper valuation. That is not a matter for my Department. I do not know whether it can be done or not. We have no easy way of meeting these particular cases which have been pleaded. I only wish we had, but I cannot see it.

Comment on this

I would like to put this to the Minister: This House exists for the remedying of wrongs, and where there is a suggestion of wrong, of an injustice, and complaint is made to this House, then the House should listen to it and, if possible, try to remedy it. That is the trust that is imposed on this House. Deputy Curran has made the suggestion that it should not be beyond the power of the Dáil, with the help of the officials of the Land Commission, to deal with this. The officials of the Land Commission are men of ability and experience, and I think if this difficulty was referred to them they would be able to solve it. It concerns a limited number of people. I made the suggestion to the Minister, which he refused to adopt, that he should include the classes listed in Section 24 and get this matter settled.

Comment on this

That would not satisfy Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

We have accepted a trust on behalf of the people, and that trust is to remedy a wrong when it is brought to our notice. That is what we are here for. Surely we are not going to take up the attitude of sticking our toes in the ground like mules, and of refusing to discharge the trust that has been imposed on us. I have suggested a way out to the Minister. No difficulty as regards valuation arises, and yet the Minister will not adopt my suggestion. I again appeal to him to look into this between now and the Report Stage, and consult his officials with a view to seeing if a way out cannot be found.

Comment on this

I also suggest to the Minister that he should hand this problem over to the Land Commission and ask them to find a solution for it between now and the Report Stage. It is their job. They are the people who did the damage in the first instance, and, consequently, I think that those who inflicted the wound should find the cure for it. Of course, if it were left to me I would find a formula in five minutes for the settling of these cases, but I know very well that my formula will not be accepted. I hope that what I suggest will be done, and, if it is not, then I think that the tenants on any estate who feel that they have a grievance should be allowed to go before the Land Commission Court and have their case tried out. If they are not able to prove that they have a grievance, let them pay the piper. No man is going to go before the Land Commission Court unless he feels that he has a good case. These people should be allowed to go before the Land Commission Court as if they were first purchase tenants seeking to have a fair rent fixed. They will not go to the court unless they feel they have a good case, because if they fail to establish that they will have to pay the costs, and the costs in the Land Commission Court are no small thing. That is the remedy that I would respectfully suggest to the Minister as the way out. Let these people have the opportunity of getting a fair rent fixed. That would meet all objections. If the Land Commission officials are able to find a better remedy, then let us have it before the Report Stage. If what I suggest is done you will not have the 400,000 people whom the Minister speaks of going before the Land Commission Court, because, in view of the costs that would be involved, no man will take his case there unless he feels he has a really good case.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider conducting the fair rent procedure, such as he proposes to do in the case of judicial tenants, in respect of the restricted class of persons to whom Deputy McMenamin has referred? I fully understand the Minister's difficulty. He has agreed that there is a good case to be made for the restricted class of persons for whom Deputy McMenamin speaks, whatever may be the case for the much larger number of tenants for whom Deputy Corry speaks.

Comment on this

I have a much stronger case than Deputy McMenamin.

Comment on this

The Minister, at least, admits that conviction has been carried to his mind in regard to the restricted class of persons for whom Deputy McMenamin speaks. He has, perhaps, not had time to examine the larger class for whom Deputy Corry speaks. Once the Minister is satisfied that there is a good case in respect of the people for whom Deputy McMenamin speaks, I think he should deal with it, and if, hereafter, Deputy Corry can make an equally good case for the larger class of tenants that he speaks for, then we can deal with it.

Comment on this

I am not going to allow my tenants to hang until you are done with yours. I know, if Deputy Dillon was on this side, what he would do for the tenants I speak of.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry is anticipating the results of the next general election, but let us not deal with that question now. After the next general election the Deputies will take their appropriate places in this House and elsewhere.

Comment on this

And the Deputy's place will be outside.

Comment on this

I am speaking of the Minister now as a body corporate who continues in the House whatever Government is in office. I hope the Minister will accept the suggestion that I have made, and deal now with the restricted class of persons for whom Deputy McMenamin speaks, not closing the door to the larger class for whom Deputy Corry speaks if an equally good case can be made later for them. If necessary, a further amending Bill can be introduced to deal with their case, should it arise. I would ask Deputy Corry not to take up a dog-in-the-manger attitude, not to say that if he cannot get his people provided for now, he will not let the Minister provide for the restricted class for whom Deputy McMenamin speaks. Rather let him say, in the spirit of Solomon's judgment: "If I cannot get my people provided for, then I will be glad to see that those for whom Deputy McMenamin speaks have justice done to them, and I will look to Deputy McMenamin in the hereafter to help me with my tenants in the same spirit as I have helped him." If Deputy Corry does that, and if he knows that his clients have as good or a better case, then, surely, he will be strengthening that case immensely by getting legislation to remedy the evil in the case of the persons in whom Deputy McMenamin is interested. Naturally, the Minister is reluctant to reopen the whole settlement and to have a roving commission in the case of all those who hold tenanted land. That would be a desperate enterprise. What would happen would be that every tenant purchaser in Ireland would come up making a case. If that were to be allowed, Deputy Corry knows that 95 per cent. of the applications would be rejected as unreasonable. The remaining 5 per cent. would be the exceptional cases that the Deputy has in mind. I suggest that, instead of doing what Deputy Corry asks, of throwing the doors open to the entire tenant purchasing population of Ireland, we should now deal with the restricted class of persons for whom Deputy McMenamin speaks.

Comment on this

I would like to point out to the Deputy that the class of tenants that I am speaking for are the same class as Deputy McMenamin is pleading for. The only difference is that they are on different estates.

Comment on this

I suggest to Deputy Corry that he is a bad tactician. If he would help the restricted class of persons for whom Deputy McMenamin speaks, we would help him hereafter.

Comment on this

The Deputy is a baby in these matters and knows nothing about them. I am sure that if the Minister meets one case he will meet the two. I have suggested a way out to him, and that is to allow these people to come before the Land Commission Court. If the tenant has not a good case, then he loses and pays the costs. If he has a good case, his case goes through and he gets relieved. In my opinion that is the only way out of it and the only hope of meeting it. I suggest the Minister ought to meet it in that manner or else hand the whole thing over and we are prepared to leave it to the Land Commission officials, let them advise something and have it brought forward here on the Report Stage. Deputy Dillon should not be trying to halve a cherry about which he knows nothing; he should try to learn a bit of sense.

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider Deputy McMenamin's case?

Comment on this

I have dealt with that for at least half an hour. There are more wrongs in the world than one. I believe the Land Commission are at the present time engaged righting the most urgent wrongs we have, and I would not be responsible for turning them on to a revision of all the cases in regard to all the land that has been purchased. Remember that there are 400,000 land annuitants involved. It would be an impossible job to ask the Land Commission to do at the moment.

Comment on this

We are not making a suggestion of that kind; it would be too ridiculous.

Comment on this

You are not making the suggestion, but that would be the effect of the point you have referred to.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 17:—

In line 18, to delete the word "in" and substitute the word "to", and in line 19, before the word "have" to insert the word "applied".

This is purely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

The procedure outlined in this section is somewhat peculiar. It sets out that where the landlord and the tenant of a holding to which Part II of the Schedule to the Land Act, 1923, applies, agree on the standard purchase annuity, the Land Commission may subsequently proceed to reduce that standard purchase annuity. The latter portion of the section provides that the Land Act of 1933 shall still apply, even though a standard purchase annuity has been agreed on with the approval of the Land Commission. I suggest that that seems to be rather a ridiculous procedure. I think that before the Land Commission give their approval to the agreement between the landlord and tenant, the holding should be examined to see that it is value for the annuity fixed on it. The section should be redrafted for the purpose of covering that form of procedure rather than the procedure now outlined.

Comment on this

I think what has been attempted there is that while they may recognise in certain cases the agreement arrived at between the landlord and the tenant, they will still keep in the Land Commission's hands the power to revise it so as to prevent possible fraud. If the landlord and tenant agree to a certain rent which may be for the landlord's benefit so that he may get away with more purchase money than the estate is worth, then the Land Commission consider they should have an opportunity of revising the rent if in their opinion it is not a fair rent.

Comment on this

But that can be prevented without this elaborate procedure. An agreement is reached in regard to the standard purchase annuity; that agreement must be approved by the Land Commission. Following that approval, the Land Commission may, one, two or five years afterwards, apply Section 38 of the 1933 Act and reduce that annuity. I suggest the section should be so amended as to provide that in a case where the landlord and tenant shall agree to the standard purchase annuity the Land Commission shall inspect the holding and satisfy themselves that it is value for the annuity agreed upon before they give their approval to the arrangement.

Comment on this

That would be a lot more trouble.

Comment on this

Why would it be?

Comment on this

You would force the Land Commission to agree to every rent payable by a tenant to a landlord rather than a rent that, in the opinion of the Land Commission, would be justified.

Comment on this

The Land Commission have, in the first instance, to give their approval to the arrangement in regard to the standard purchase annuity. The Land Commission are now in the position of being forced to give that approval even though the holding is not inspected and they are satisfied the annuity is a reasonable one. But they reserve the power to themselves, probably years later, to reduce the standard purchase annuity. I submit that is unfair to the owner. In the very first instance the Land Commission should have the holding inspected in order to satisfy themselves that the annuity fixed has a fair relation to the value of the holding.

Comment on this

Does not this section purport to be a substitute for the procedure laid down in Section 25 of the 1927 Land Act, which amended previous Land Acts? It seems to me you have abundant powers under Section 25, which provides that where the landlord and tenant purported to agree to a standard purchase annuity under Part II of the Schedule of the 1923 Land Act, it was open to the Land Commission, if they were not satisfied that the holding was security therefor, to serve notice on the parties and make an order refusing to advance the purchase money and thereupon fix the standard purchase annuity in the manner provided for in the 1923 Act in cases where there was no agreement between landlord and tenant.

If the Land Commission refused to agree to the rent agreed upon between the landlord and the tenant, they could give notice and then resort to paragraph 2 of Part II of the First Schedule of the 1923 Act, which provided that the annuity would be fixed by the Land Commission on the report of their inspector, regard being had to the position of the holding, the rent and all the other circumstances of the case. Is not that correct? If you have that procedure at your disposal, what more do you want? Is not that a very much better procedure than a procedure which restricts you to fixing the standard purchase annuity at a given percentage of what you believe to be a fictitious and fraudulent rent? The procedure under the Act of 1927 empowered the Commission, where they believed that there was a fraud to be perpetrated, to upset the whole thing and act on the report of the inspector. The Minister wants to restrict himself to reducing the standard annuity, funded on the fraudulent rent, by such and such a percentage.

Comment on this

It is not the 1927 Act that is in question. It is Section 2 of the Land Act, 1929, and that limited the fixation of standard purchase annuities by agreement between the landlord and tenant to some time prior to the introduction of that Act, in order to avoid fraud. The Land Commission then were empowered to recognise that agreement if it had been entered into prior to 1929, and we want the same powers in regard to agreements that have been arrived at since, provided that there is always in the Land Commission's hands power to reject such agreement if they think it is fraudulent.

Comment on this

How many of such agreements would there be? Is it not possible for the Land Commission to do as I suggest—to have the holding inspected before they give their consent to the arrangement between the landlord and tenant? Does not that simplify the procedure considerably, and is it not an infinitely better procedure than that outlined in the section? Does the Minister consider it fair to an unfortunate man to keep him in suspense for a number of years before definitely deciding what the annuity is to be on the holding?

Comment on this

The Minister says that the Act of 1927 has no effect? What is the law to-day? I say that Section 25 of the Land Act, 1927, has not been repealed. There is nothing in Section 2 of the Act of 1929 which repeals it. As the law stands at present, the Commission can use their powers under Section 25 of the Land Act of 1927. Sub-section (2) of Section 2 of the Land Act of 1929 actually refers to the Schedule to the Land Act, 1923, as amended by Section 25 of the Land Act, 1927. Section 25 of the Land Act, 1927, provides that where the Commission is not satisfied that the land is fair value for the standard purchase annuity agreed upon between the landlord and tenant, they can have resort to the procedure under paragraph (2) of Part II of the Schedule to the Land Act, 1923. If you have that power, what additional power do you want? Is not that power a very much better power than the one you seek to get under the section here before us? Can the Minister tell us if Section 25 of the Land Act, 1927, is still in operation, and if the Commission are acting under it?

Comment on this

The Commission are acting under the powers that were conferred on them under a later Act, that is under the Act of 1929, and they want the same powers now in regard to agreements that have been entered into since. That is all that is in the section.

Comment on this

But why do they want to set aside Section 25 of the Land Act, 1927?

Comment on this

Where have they set it aside?

Comment on this

They are taking alternative powers to deal with exactly the same kind of case.

Comment on this

This is amending not the Act of 1927 but the Act of 1929— an Act passed two years later.

Comment on this

Yes, and my submission is that this amendment, as far as I can see, is directed to the purpose of adapting the Act of 1929 to deal with a situation which has already been provided for by the Act of 1927.

Comment on this

Then ask Deputy Roddy why did he introduce the Act of 1929?

Comment on this

Wait a moment now. I say that the section we have before us now is designed to adapt Deputy Roddy's Act for a purpose for which Deputy Roddy had made provision in the Land Act of 1927. Is not that so? I want to know why you are doing it. Surely the Minister will tell us why we are setting aside Section 25 of the Act of 1927?

Comment on this

I have done my utmost to explain to the Deputy. I cannot do any more.

Comment on this

This reduces Parliamentary debate to an absurdity. I have pointed out that Section 25 of the 1927 Act is so framed as to deal with the exact kind of case that is advanced as constituting the necessity for amending the present law. I pointed out to the Minister that Deputy Roddy deliberately refrained from putting a provision of the kind contained in Section 14 into the Land Act, 1929, because he found himself already armed with the powers under Section 25 of the Land Act, 1927. There must be some reason for legislation; there must be some justification for it. If every contingency is already provided for under the existing law, surely the Minister must make some case for desiring further to amend it.

Comment on this

I have already explained twice what we are trying to do under this section. It is there in black and white. It is not one of the difficult sections. We are extending the powers that were taken in 1929—two years after the Act to which the Deputy is referring—to cover agreements that have been entered into since 1929, in the same way that the 1929 Act took power to deal with agreements that had been entered into prior to the introduction of that Act.

Comment on this

I move amendments Nos. 18, 19, 20 and 21, which are merely drafting amendments:—

18. In sub-section (1), page 8, line 28, to delete the words "purchase money" and substitute the words "standard price", and after the word "holding" to insert the words and brackets "together with the compounded arrears of rent (if any)".

19. In sub-section (1), page 8, line 29, after the word "agreed" to insert the words "after the passing of this Act".

20. In sub-section (1), page 8, line 29, after the word "advance" to insert the words "to the purchaser".

21. In sub-section (1), page 8, line 32 and also in line 49, to delete the words "purchase money" and substitute in each place the words and brackets "standard price and compounded arrears of rent (if any)".

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendments Nos. 22, 23, 24 and 25 impose a charge on public funds, and cannot be moved.

Comment on this

I move amendments Nos. 26, 27, 28 and 29, which are merely drafting amendments:—

26. In sub-section (2), page 8, lines 57 and 58, to delete the words and brackets "(as defined in the next following sub-section of this section)".

27. In sub-section (2) (b), page 9, lines 8 and 9, to delete the words "revision of the purchase annuity to be charged on such parcel" and substitute the words "amount so payable by him", and in line 11, after the figures "1933" to insert the words "in relation to the revision of the purchase annuity on such parcel".

28. In sub-section (2) (c), page 9, line 20, to delete the words "actually so paid" and substitute the words "so payable", and in line 21, to delete the word "tenants" and substitute the words and brackets "tenant or (where such allottee or tenant gets the benefits mentioned in the next preceding paragraph of this sub-section) which would have been so payable in cash by him if he had not got those benefits".

29. In sub-section (2), page 9, to add at the end of the sub-section a new paragraph as follows:—

(d) the transactions mentioned in the foregoing paragraphs of this sub-section shall not be regarded for any purpose as a redemption or a partial redemption of a purchase annuity, and accordingly nothing contained in Section 22 of the Land Act, 1933, shall apply or have effect in relation thereto.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 30:—

To delete sub-section (3).

We are deleting this sub-section because it is already covered.

Comment on this

I move amendments Nos. 31 and 32 which are purely drafting amendments:—

31. In sub-section (2) (b), page 9, line 49, to delete the words and brackets "(which have not been redeemed)."

32. In sub-section (2) (c), page 9, line 54, before the word "purchase" to insert the word "original."

Comment on this

The Ceann Comhairle mentioned to me that amendment No. 33 is covered by amendment No. 34, which goes further. Amendment No. 34 is to delete sub-sections (2) and (3); amendment No. 33 is to delete sub-section (2). I dislike this section in its entirety.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Deputy not moving amendment No. 33?

Comment on this

No. I am moving amendment No. 34:—

To delete sub-sections (2) and (3) and insert in lieu thereof the following sub-section:—

(2) No proceedings shall be instituted for illegal seizure against any county registrar in respect of any seizure made by him prior to the 1st day of August, 1935, under a warrant issued by the Land Commission under Section 28 of the Land Act of 1923, in any case in which the said seizure would have been valid had the foregoing sub-section been in force at the date of the said seizure."

I dislike the whole of this section. I think it is introducing a very bad principle. It is endeavouring to alter the legal position between certain citizens of this State. It goes a great deal further, indeed, than that, because, in sub-section (3), it actually goes as far as to declare that certain decisions, certain judgments, arrived at between parties who have litigated in this State, shall be treated as null and void. I do not think that a worse principle could be put forward in any piece of legislation than that, when the rights of parties—the rights of individuals— have been settled by the courts of this country, this House is to come along and say that the sums which are due by one individual to another—due as a result of a tortious act of that second individual—are to be treated as null and void. As I say, I dislike the whole principle which is embodied in this section. However, I have put forward an amendment here which, even though that amendment has enshrined in it a principle which I do not like, I have still put forward in the hope that the Minister will accept it, not because it will do away with the whole of this section, but because I feel that it will do away with some of the most objectionable features in this section.

Now, the section itself, Sir, is a retrospective section. It declares that, where in the case of seizures made by the sheriff, the sheriff has added on sums of money as expenses which he was not justified in adding on, the seizure shall still be deemed good, and the injustice done to the party against whom the seizure was made shall remain without remedy, or, if a remedy has been taken and a judgment of a court given in his favour, that that should be set aside. My amendment is to the effect that no action shall be brought for illegal seizure against any county registrar in respect of any seizure made by him prior to the 1st day of August, 1935, under a warrant issued by the Land Commission. Now, I have deliberately taken the date, the first day of August, 1935, for this reason: There may have been—there were—doubts in the minds of certain sheriffs or county registrars who are now doing the duty of sheriffs as to whether they were, or were not, justified in adding on these sums, but the complete illegality was not clear until the decision in the case of Halpin v. the Irish Land Commission was decided. The judgment in Halpin v. the Irish Land Commission was given on the 30th day of July, 1935. It was reported in all the daily papers in the Saorstát, and fully reported, on the 31st July, 1935. Therefore, on the 1st August, 1935, every sheriff or every county registrar, who made a seizure, must have been perfectly aware that, if he were charging certain sums which, heretofore, sheriffs had been in the habit of charging, he was doing so illegally and wrongly.

Now, if there is any case to be made for preventing an action being taken against a sheriff who is acting bona fide, who is adding on sums varying in amounts from comparatively small sums up to sums of £5 or £6 for expenses, which he was not entitled to charge—if there were any case to be made for a county registrar or sheriff who did so unwittingly and unknowingly prior to the decision in the Halpin case—there can be no possible reason or no possible excuse for a sheriff or county registrar who deliberately went on breaking the law, deliberately went on making persons pay, under Land Commission warrants, sums which he was not entitled to get. If my amendment is accepted, every sheriff who acted bona fide, every sheriff who acted in a belief that he was justified in doing what he did do, has got his protection unless a judgment has already been obtained against him. I cannot see, however, any possible reason why a sheriff, who goes to the house of an individual who owes, let us say, £10 annuity—the sheriff being entitled to charge the sum of 3/-, precisely, on that £10—should come along and make that man come in and pay £13 or £14. The sum of £10 was what the man owed in law and, if the sheriff is entitled to charge 3/-, that would amount to £10 3s. Why, then, should that man be charged £13 or £14? That has been done, and done knowingly. If my amendment is accepted, no sheriff will remain unsafeguarded except a sheriff who has acted knowingly in such a way, and if a sheriff has come and seized and, through his court messengers, has extorted money from individuals that he had no right to get, why, in Heaven's name, should that man receive protection from this House? After all, when a sheriff, who is entitled to charge 3/-, comes in and makes a seizure on a tenant farmer— an ordinary countryman—against whom the seizure is being made, and charges £3 or £4, what knowledge has that farmer of his rights? He does not want his stock seized, and so, if he can do so at all, he puts up the money. Now, this House is to say that he has to pay £2 or £3 or, in some cases, larger sums; and, very often, in certain cases, such as mountainy regions where you are a very long way away from a town, the sums may be very high indeed because sheriffs were illegally charging expenses on the distance they had to go. Now, if those persons are to ask for their money back, this House, as the section stands, is to say: “This money has been wrongfully extorted from you and we are going to deprive you of your remedy.” There is no question of the sheriff doing it bona fide if my amendment is accepted. It is the sheriff who, knowing he has no right to take money, has taken money whom I say this House should not safeguard, and for that reason, I put it as strongly as I can that my amendment should be accepted.

There is the other principle—the setting aside of judgments of the court. I think that judgments of the court have been very few. If it becomes a question of indemnifying a sheriff who acted bona fide, let the State indemnify him. If the Minister comes in here with a vote, saying that the sheriff has acted bona fide and that he should not be made to pay this out of his pocket, I will give him support, but it is not right that, where a judgment has been obtained, this House should declare that a judgment obtained in our courts, ascertaining the legal rights of individuals between themselves, may be treated as a scrap of waste paper. That is what this section is asking us to do; that is what in express terms paragraph (b) of sub-section (3) asks us to do. I put it to the Minister that this amendment is one which gives every safeguard to every sheriff which a sheriff ought to get. After all, as I said in my Second Reading speech, and I repeat now, there should be respect for the law and it should not be confined to one side of the House. Respect for our courts, and for the decisions of our courts, should be as great on the Government Benches as it is on the Opposition Benches. It is not a Party matter. It is a national principle that is at stake. I know that heretofore in connection with this Bill, the Minister has not accepted any amendment. I do not know whether he has definitely made up his mind that in no circumstances will he ever accept any amendment coming from these benches. That may be his principle, but if it is, it is a very bad principle. I sincerely hope it is not his principle, and if it is not, I put it as strongly as I can that this is an amendment he ought to accept.

Comment on this