We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Land Bill, 1936—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 217–415 of 415. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1936
Enacted

No. 30 of 1936 ›

This is an amendment anyway which will get the most favourable consideration. I cannot go beyond that at the moment, but, following the Deputy's Second Reading speech, I went into this question again with the Land Commission to ascertain if they really wanted the powers they have. There are certain retrospective powers which they have and, so far as I can gather, they are not wanted to indemnify the sheriffs against anything they have done. My information is that this whole business of sheriffs' fees began and ended with the Halpin case, and that, once the Halpin case was over, the sheriffs took cognisance of the court's decision.

Comment on this

That is not correct. I advised a particular case. The Land Commission may not know it, but I can tell the Minister of a seizure that was made within four miles of my own home—I can give the name of the party if he wishes—and a charge of £2 was made. The seizure was for £4 and £2 was charged for expenses and all the sheriff was entitled to was 3/-. I advised him to take proceedings. That happened last May and that case was still worse because the man had written up—his rent had just been altered—to the Land Commission so that he might get his receivable order on which he could pay. The seizure was made before the Land Commission had sent him back his receivable order. However, that is another matter. The fact is that £2 was charged where 3/- was the proper sum. The Land Commission may not know that, but that is a case I know of my own knowledge.

Comment on this

As I say, we are still looking into it and I have asked the Attorney-General to help us in the matter. So far as I can see at the moment, we may be able to drop clause (b) of sub-section (3).

Comment on this

Would it meet the Minister if my amendment were postponed to Report Stage?

Comment on this

Yes, I think that would be better. As a matter of fact, we may have to redraft the whole section.

Comment on this

The Minister knows the general principles which were embodied in my amendment. If he adjourns it until Report Stage, I am perfectly satisfied. I want to have the thing put on what I think is a sound basis, because I assure him I am not the only person who thinks attacks on the courts are dangerous.

Comment on this

There is no intention to attack the courts.

Comment on this

It is here.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

Could it not be adjourned to Report Stage?

Comment on this

The Deputy can introduce it on Report Stage, because I intend to recommit the Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister has said that he will introduce an amendment and that is sufficient for me.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 37:—

In sub-section (1), line 9, to add after the word "found" the following words "otherwise than for a temporary purpose".

This amendment is designed to get over, in a certain class of cases, a really impossible condition of affairs. The condition of affairs is this: Somebody owes money for a land annuity, and the sheriff can seize any single bit of property which is on the premises when he visits them. My amendment is to prescribe that he shall not take property which is there temporarily, because some of the things that have happened would astonish the House by their absurdity. Take a case which has really happened. It is not imaginary. A large petroleum lorry was going around and it entered on a premises, the owner of which owed his land annuities. The petroleum lorry was seized by the sheriff and the oil company had to pay up. I believe that actually took place. That is absurd. Supposing Deputy O'Reilly goes on a visit to a friend who owes an annuity and wants to buy cattle. If he arrives in a motor car and leaves it in the yard, when he comes out the sheriff may tell him to clear off as the car has been seized. That is an absurd state of affairs, and it has not been redeemed by the common sense of all court messengers. I want to put in the words set out in the amendment, so that if stock, property or goods which does not belong to the person who owes the debt, is on his land for some little time, they will not be seized. I am not at all sure that it is wise that this indiscriminate power to seize property should be given. I am not sure but it cuts both ways. If it is known that a man owes annuities and rates, and is not in a position to stock his land, he cannot sub-let, because no one will take the land owing to the danger that the stock may be seized. Some land that is under-stocked by persons who owe annuities might be stocked if others were aware that their stock would not be seized for the debt. I am not at all enamoured of the principle, and I can see that there is a good deal to be said on both sides. At one time I thought it was sound, but when worked out in practice I am not at all satisfied that my original conception was right. I do not say that I am completely of opinion that it is wrong, and that there is a very much stronger case against it than could be made in the beginning. I am sure the Minister does not want this to run to the absolute extreme, so that a visitor might discover, if he leaves his overcoat in the hall, that it may be seized for arrears of annuities due by a person he was visiting.

Comment on this

I find myself in agreement with the Deputy to this extent— if we could find words to cover and to exclude goods or chattels there for a temporary purpose, such as the oil van that he spoke of. I am afraid it has been found impossible up to this to exclude even the oil van, and at the same time to include cattle on land on the 11 months' system. The whole purpose of the Act of 1927 was to try to get the land annuities paid so that the owner should not get out of paying while there was stock on the land. The stock would be the tenant's, but it might be there in someone else's name on the 11 months' system. I do not think it is possible to draft an amendment to cover what the Deputy desires, and to leave the Land Commission with the powers that were given them in 1927, and intended to be used by them. As far as I can learn, there have been no reports of grave wrongs done by the section as it stands. In the ordinary way I think the sheriff, county registrar or court messenger would use his discretion.

Comment on this

They do not. I think the income-tax people are just as bad, but I do not suppose that will surprise Deputies. I suggest to the Minister that if he puts the view I have mentioned before the Parliamentary draftsman it is possible that a formula could be got, for instance: "not on the land under any existing contract, or not on the land for the purpose of the owner making profit or gain thereby." Some words of that kind would possibly meet the matter if the Minister thinks the word "temporary" would not be sufficient. If the Minister called upon the Parliamentary draftsman and the Land Commission, between them I am sure they would make some effort.

Comment on this

I do not think there is any use promising the Deputy that it could be done. I am perfectly certain that this consideration was in the mind of the Parliamentary draftsman, and in the mind of the Minister responsible for the Bill in 1927, and that if the particular type of people the Deputy wants to exclude could be excluded by words in the Act, they would have been inserted then. It was left to the discretion of the county registrar not to take things belonging to someone who was there merely for a temporary purpose.

Comment on this

The Minister should reconsider this section, because the county registrars, or the persons responsible appear to seize anything they find on these premises. The effect of the section might be to put a doctor in the position that he could not bring a motor car to such premises, fearing that it would be seized. A clergyman or a doctor might be unable to visit a person who was in arrears until they were sure that a warrant for the arrears would not be executed while they were present. The Minister should find some way out of the difficulty. I wish to draw attention to another aspect of the matter, and to suggest that people who put cattle on such land in good faith should not be liable for more than the amount of the grazing money or the contract. Otherwise these lands would be lying derelict, as no use would be made of them. No man would touch such land unless he was assured that all debts were paid. Apart from the position of people calling with a lorry or with a motor car, the tenants concerned should be able to utilise their land and to make some profit out of it. People who sent cattle there to graze should not be liable for more than the grazing money. Unless the Minister considers that aspect of the case such land will become derelict.

Comment on this

A very serious question arises on this section. The wording of the section is: "A warrant issued by the Land Commission under Section 58 of the Land Act of 1933 shall be deemed to be a judgment of a competent court within the meaning of Section 15 of the Enforcement of Court Orders Act, 1926." We know that these warrants go before nobody before they are issued. They need not be issued by the Land Commission themselves. They are not issued by the Land Commission. They are issued by any official in the Land Commission, and the seal is not necessarily affixed by the Secretary of the Land Commission. If you take the leading case to which I referred a moment ago, Halpin's case, in that case it did not go before the Commissioners who, properly speaking, constitute the Land Commission, at all. The whole thing was done by one of the clerks in the Collection Branch.

A certificate of a clerk in the Collection Branch has to be regarded as having the same force and validity as a judgment of one of our courts. That is entirely wrong. It may be putting the Land Commission and it may be putting officialdom in this country on a very high pedestal, and I daresay officialdom in this country cannot be put high enough to please itself, but this is pulling down our courts tremendously. Besides, I should like to point out to the Minister that, after all, we have a Constitution and that while that Constitution is in existence it should be respected. One of the provisions of our Constitution is that all judicial acts shall be performed by judges. It was held in Halpin's case that this was not a judicial act, even that the putting on of the seal of the Land Commission was not a judicial act, and that in consequence the Land Commission could do it. The issue of the certificate was not a judicial act. Having got that decision, they come along here and solemnly ask this House that a thing which is not a judgment of a court shall be deemed to be a judgment of a court. That, I submit, would be a very wrong thing for this House to agree to.

Comment on this

One point the Deputy forgot to mention was that this was merely a preliminary to bringing a man before the courts for examination as to his means. It is simply a preliminary to bringing him before the court to make him disclose whether he really has any property out of which the Land Commission can recoup themselves for the land annuities.

Comment on this

That is really what makes it so bad.

Comment on this

The point is that it is simply a preliminary to bringing him into court and letting the court examine him as to his means. There would be some objection to the section if the Land Commission took the same powers as the court to examine him as to his means, but this, as I say, is only a preliminary step to bringing the man before the court.

Comment on this

This is an absolutely final certificate from the Land Commission on which there is no going back. It is to have the force of a judgment, and is to be as binding for the purpose of examining a debtor as to his means as any judgment of a court could be. In Halpin's case it was definitely decided that these warrants were not decisions of the court at all, that these warrants were ordinary distress warrants such as used to be issued by landlords for the collection of rent from tenants, landlords who preferred to send their bailiffs or, as they used to be called, their drivers to drive cattle off the land without the intervention of any court. It was decided in Halpin's case that this was a distress warrant, and nothing else except a distress warrant. Now we are told that distress warrants issued by a person who is entitled to seize for annuities is to be put upon precisely the same basis as a judgment of our courts. I would ask the Minister to reconsider this section.

Comment on this

I think it is no harm to bring him before the courts. That is what the Deputy has been asking in other cases.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 43
·
Níl 31
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

This section relates to the appointment of limited administrators. Frankly, I do not understand the phraseology of the section, which is:—

Where in any proceedings under the Land Purchase Acts the Land Commission makes an advance for the improvement of a holding or a parcel of land, and the owner of such holding or parcel is dead and there is no legal representative of such deceased owner or the services of the legal personal representative of such owner are not conveniently available,

then, for the purpose of carrying out improvements to the holding, a personal representative may be appointed by the Land Commission. That may be done although there is a legal personal representative in existence. The representative so appointed will not be under any legal obligation to see that the work which he is appointed to take charge of is carried out to the satisfaction of the Land Commission. Seemingly, he will not enter into any bond or any form of contract with the Land Commission for the purpose of carrying out his duties as administrator of the estate. It is quite conceivable that there will be two legal representatives for one holding. One representative may be in existence, but may not be available at the moment for the purposes of the Land Commission. In that event the Land Commission will proceed to appoint a second representative for the purpose of carrying out improvements to the holding. That representative will not be under any bond or contract to carry out the duties for which he is appointed. I do not understand why the provision has been introduced into the Bill at all.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Does the Deputy contend that there is no necessity for the words "or the services of the legal personal representative of such owner are not conveniently available"? The Deputy does not object to the appointment of a legal representative for the purpose of the proceedings?

Comment on this

I should like to get an explanation as to why the section is introduced. What is the object of it? It seems rather ridiculous to appoint two legal representatives for the same holding. If the first legal representative is not available, the Land Commission can appoint a second one for the purpose of carrying out different duties. That second representative will not be under any bond or contract in connection with that discharge of those duties.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The section is intended to enable something which is purely administrative to be done. When the personal representative signs for the advance, it becomes chargeable upon the holding. The holding is the security for the advance. They are limited administrators for that purpose only. It is merely in order to enable the Land Commission to get through with the making of advances when no administrator existed.

Comment on this

Who ever heard of a limited administrator being appointed when there is an actual administrator or executor, as the case may be, in existence? Limited administrators have been appointed for certain cases in law suits, but an executor may have legal possession of land and another person who need not have anything to do with the land at all, a person who need not be in occupation of the land, seemingly can be appointed for one purpose, that is the purpose of the Land Commission's making advances to him for improvements. Why need he spend that money in improvement if he is a stranger to the place? The land is not vested in him. He is a complete stranger and he has no power over the land. The power would be vested in the executor. Why need he spend one halfpenny of this advance on the land? Or can he spend the money on the land in the way the executor does not like? I think the Minister would be well advised if he cut out the words "or the services of the legal personal representative of such deceased owner are not conveniently available."

I think the Minister will be well-advised to cut out these words. It is a most extraordinary state of affairs. One person is executor of a will. He has got full control. You may as well appoint a personal representative for a living man without his knowledge or consent, or appoint another personal representative to do the work of the executor. It is very much as if you had power to give a power of attorney to a nominee of yours to act on behalf of a living man. That is how it works out. That is an astonishingly new proposition. The Attorney-General will agree with me that he never before heard of anything of this kind in his life. We would like to have some examples quoted as to why it is necessary. We would like to have something of that kind put before us. It may be very difficult for the Attorney-General or for the Minister for Lands to give us that at a moment's notice. We would very much like to have it because it is a very startling proposition. I hold land and behind my back somebody else may enter into a contract making me liable.

Comment on this

Though the Deputy may be 7,000 miles away.

Comment on this

I may be 7,000 miles away, and I do not want Deputy Moore to walk in and deal with my property even though I may be 14,000 miles away. The Deputy, I am sure, would deal with it very wisely.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I am afraid the Deputy is wrong in stating this is a revolutionary proposal of which nobody has heard before for I find it is taken verbatim from the 1929 Land Act, sometimes called Roddy's Act. The very first section of that Act reads:—

Whenever, in any proceedings under the Land Purchase Acts for the exchange or consolidation of a holding or parcel of land for or with other land, the owner of such holding or parcel is dead and there is no legal personal representative of such deceased owner or the services of his legal personal representative are not conveniently available for carrying out such exchange or consolidation, the Land Commission may——

And so on.

Comment on this

Is the Attorney-General reading from a section in this Bill?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The Deputy might reasonably think I was. I am reading from Section 1 of the Land Act of 1929.

Comment on this

Was the Attorney-General in the House at the time and did he allow that to go through?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I was not.

Comment on this

Well, I absolve the Attorney-General so. The Attorney-General will agree with me, however, that this is a most astonishing proposition, apart from whether it has been in existence before or not. Might we hear the cases in which it has been used?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Well, apparently it was made available by that Act. I see the objections that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney raises. The only risk I see is that the person nominated under this section might expend money on some purposes other than on what it was intended the money should be spent. But in practice the money is for improvements and the expenditure is carried out under the supervision and to the satisfaction of the Land Commission, and they make sure the work is carried out. I imagine that in a number of cases the sum would be very small. This is to enable a type of work to be done where you have no personal representative and the estate is not big enough to warrant the demand that administration should be taken out; or where the personal representative may be in Scotland, America or somewhere else. In such cases the necessary improvement works cannot be carried out without a nominee. There must be some person to act as personal representative in order to secure the advance. The principal objection I can see to the proposal is the lack of security.

Comment on this

What is done in cases where the owner is away in Scotland or in America? What has happened then? Suppose the owner is away, let me say, in Scotland and he has left a wife and family at home. Then does the Land Commission appoint a personal representative to a living man, which is rather a contradiction? Or do they give a power of attorney?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I understand that Section 1 of the Land Act of 1929 would enable similar things to be done as are done in this Bill in cases where it is necessary to effect an exchange or a consolidation of a holding. To enable that to be done the Land Commission have power under Section 1 of the Act of 1929 to nominate a certain person—limited to this particular purpose. I should imagine that is a very useful provision. Let us take a case where, as often happens, there are a number of children on a holding. One of them takes out administration and goes off to America and there is a difficulty in finding him. There is available for exchange another holding, or there is land which the Land Commission wish to consolidate. Are the Land Commission to be hung up if they cannot lay their hands on the proper person or, in other words, if that person is not available? It would mean that that person who had a beneficial interest in the holding would lose because this consolidation could not be legally carried out. This section is merely extending the thing a step further and enabling necessary improvements to be carried out. I imagine that the risk the Deputy spoke about of money being expended otherwise than on improvements is extremely remote. The power would be only availed of in small cases. I imagine the practice of appointing a limited personal representative for the purpose of carrying out this work would not be resorted to in any case where there were considerable assets which would justify compelling some member of the family to take out a grant in the ordinary way.

Comment on this

I am not troubling about the limited administrator of a dead person—that is an old and familiar principle—but the appointment of a limited administrator, while there is another representative, either administrator or executor, in existence, is a thing that strikes me as being astonishing.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

It may appear in a way surprising, but take, for example, the case of a holding where the administrator has gone to America, which the Deputy, I am sure, will admit frequently happens in the West in small holdings, and an advance is required to improve the holding. The Land Commission want to make an advance, which, as a rule, does not exceed £40, I am told—probably it will average half that—to the persons in actual occupation to enable improvements to be carried out. Is there anything startling about enabling them to name some of the persons actually on the holding as limited administrator for that particular purpose, despite the fact that there is a legal personal representative, if he could be got? Is there anything really startling about it. The advantages of doing it outweigh the disadvantages? Is it not an advantageous thing to the small holder to allow it to be done?

Comment on this

What is the procedure when you want to make an improvement and not merely the legal owner but the complete owner is out of the country? I do not see any difference between the case in which the owner is out of the country and the case in which the executor of the last owner is out of the country.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I imagine it is rather unusual that the owner should be away. It is not a case that would arise very frequently. If he was away he could appoint somebody under power of attorney to do it.

Comment on this

The Land Commission can carry on in one case but not in the other. I do not mean to dispute the section.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The sole purpose of it, despite the theoretical objections there may be to such an unusual procedure and the fact that the section of the 1929 Act may not be a complete defence, is that the Land Commission have found in practice that there are cases where they have difficulty in allowing necessary improvements to be carried out because they cannot get somebody legally to charge the holding with the money. It is put in to meet that case. I think the Deputy will agree that the advantages outweigh the suggested disadvantages.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain in simpler language than he did on the Second Reading, what actually is the meaning of that section?

Comment on this

Under the 1923 Act, all untenanted land in congested districts counties automatically vested in the Land Commission. It has the effect, whether the Land Commission really want these holdings for the relief of congestion or not, of vesting them. If there are small freehold portions of land, the Land Commission have to purchase them and revest them in the original owner. That means that the owner simply sells untenanted land to the Land Commission, and because it is so small they have to revest it in him. The intention of the 1923 Act was to give the Land Commission power over all the untenanted land in congested districts counties. I do not think it was ever intended, where land was sub-divided into small holdings already, that the Land Commission should go to the trouble of purchasing these lands, advancing land bonds to the owner, and then allowing him to pay off the land bonds on an annuity basis. It has the effect simply of giving the owner a long loan repayable in interest and sinking fund on the same basis as the ordinary annuities fixed upon land. There is no necessity for it. The owner of small portions of untenanted land is in the place where the Land Commission seeks to put a lot of other people. There is no reason, if he is there already, that they should go to the trouble of purchasing his land and revesting it in him.

Comment on this

The Minister promised to make some inquiries about Land Bank and Committee cases, and to let us know how many of these cases were left over, if any. The 1927 Act was devised primarily to deal with these cases. I was under the impression that they were finished long since.

Comment on this

All the applications that came in were dealt with, or are in process of being dealt with.

Comment on this

Are there cases left over?

Comment on this

There are only a few left over, and they are being dealt with. They applied.

Comment on this

It appears to me that this section will have the effect of curtailing considerably the activities, not alone of the Government themselves but of private individuals, in carrying out building schemes in various parts of the State. The effect of the section contained in the Land Act of 1927 is altered considerably by this. It seems to me that it is altered designedly for the purpose of bringing under the control of the Land Commission land which has not building value at the moment, but which will have building value, let us say, in five or ten years' time. The word "potential" has been taken out of the section altogether, and now the land must possess substantial and actual value as building ground. I have heard of a case recently—I have not been in a position to confirm it—where, in the neighbourhood of a certain town in the West of Ireland, an estate was divided by the Land Commission about 12 months ago, and already the urban council are looking for portion of the land for the purpose of carrying out a building scheme.

It seems to me that under this section the Land Commission will proceed to divide such estates and such farms in the neighbourhood of many towns, and that the local authorities will probably, in the course of a year or two years or five years, have to acquire portion of these lands for the purpose of carrying out building schemes of one kind or another. As the section is drafted, it appears to me to cut right across the building policy of the Government which the Minister for Local Government outlined at some length when introducing his amending housing legislation recently. Not only that, but it also interferes with the development of seaside resorts and with building development generally.

Comment on this

The Deputy, I think, is misreading the section. Under the 1923 Act the landlord had the right to object to the purchase of his land if it had a potential building value. With the coming of modern transport, land, wherever situate, has a potential building value. The word "potential" has a very wide meaning, and it enabled a landlord to say: "Well I object to the purchase of this land because it has a potential building value." In this Bill we are defining more clearly what is meant. For the word "potential" we are substituting the words "actual and substantial." If the land has not either a substantial or an actual building value, if it is, in fact, an ordinary agricultural holding, worked in the way that other farms in the district are worked, if it has not been built on, and if the tenant continues to work it as an agricultural holding, there is no reason why he should be excluded from the right to purchase, simply because the landlord under the 1923 Act could claim that the land had a potential building value. That is all that the section is meant to do.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that the definition in this section, "substantial and actual", has the same meaning as the definition in the Act of 1927? The Minister, I think, did not contend that it had. The new definition certainly does give the Land Commission greater power to acquire land which, in the course of time, will become exceedingly valuable as building ground. It appears to me that the section, as drafted, gives the Land Commission power to acquire any land, no matter whether it has a building value or not. It seems to me that when this Bill becomes an Act, and when this section is in operation, the Land Commission will undoubtedly take over land for the relief of congestion which should properly be set aside so as to enable building development to take place on the estate. The alteration in the definition seems to me to weaken the authority of the Land Commission over building ground. Under the section it will not be possible for them to leave aside land which will have a potential building value in four, five or ten years' time. Under the Act of 1927 it was possible for them to do that. Under this section they will be empowered to take such land to meet the needs of congests. The Minister's remarks seem to me to confirm more or less the interpretation that I have put on the section.

Comment on this

There are two classes of land, tenanted and untenanted. Under the Act of 1933, we took power in the case of tenanted land to purchase it from the landlord and to vest it in the tenant, notwithstanding the fact that it had a potential building value. We said then, in effect, that, if there is a substantial or potential building value attached to the land, the tenant in occupation of it for a number of years should get the benefit of the increased value rather than the landlord. Now, some people may object to that on the ground that it should go to neither. Anyway, in 1933, as between the landlord and tenant, we came down in favour of the tenant and took power to purchase and vest the holding in him. Then there is untenanted land. There are the cases of long leaseholders, fee-farm grantees and people like that who apply to the Land Commission for the purchase of their holdings. As the law stands, the landlord can object to the purchase on the ground that the land has potential building value. A few moments ago I described what potential means.

With modern transport conditions a landlord could claim with some justification that land in almost any part of the country, even on the top of mountain, had a potential building value, and that it could be used as a building site. We think that if a farmer is using his farm in the normal way, and if it has not a substantial or actual building value, he should not be deprived of his right, a right that has been given to his neighbours, to purchase his land. In future a landlord will have to prove that the land has an actual or substantial building value rather than a potential building value in order to prevent an occupier, a long leaseholder or a fee-farm grantee from the right to purchase.

Comment on this

I find myself in the difficulty that I cannot construe the word "actual" in the sense in which it is used in the section. Does it mean that building operations have to be actually in progress on the land, or that if building operations are being carried out in the near vicinity, then the land can be said to have an actual building value? I would be glad if the Minister would explain the meaning of the word "actual" in the sense in which it is used in the section; it is not clear to me. It is a very definite term to insert. It appears to me that it would eliminate any prospective value in land if we are going to insist that it must have an actual building value. No matter whose interest is involved, it would be unfair to make terms that would eliminate building value in land, if it exists. There is something to be said, perhaps, for the Minister's contention that potential value could be interpreted in a very wide way, but I am afraid the alternative, actual, could be interpreted in a way to operate against the owner of the land. Actual building value, so far as I can see, means that definite proof would have to be submitted that the land had a building value and that the Land Commission would have to be so satisfied. I think it would be hard to satisfy them except building was actually commenced on it or on land so near to it as to make it definitely certain that the land would be built on. The word "actual" is too strong an alternative.

Comment on this

I understand clearly the difference between tenanted and untenanted land in relation to building ground. I know that the position with regard to tenanted land was affected by a certain provision of the Land Act of 1903, but it seems to me that the development of modern transport as applied to a definition of what is potential building land certainly never entered the minds of the framers of certain clauses of the Act of 1927. I think it is stretching things rather a bit for the Minister to apply modern transport development to a definition of potential in relation to building value. This section does interfere with normal building development. It is true the Minister for Local Government can compulsorily acquire any land he wants for the purpose of carrying out his building schemes. But take seaside resorts and the smaller towns where there is no local authority. In the ordinary normal way these towns will develop and extend in the course of time; additional land will be required for the purposes of development and expansion; numbers of new buildings will have to be erected in the neighbourhood of these towns. It does seem to me that this section, which gives this power to the Land Commission to acquire such land, will interfere considerably with such normal building development. I suggest that the word "potential" should be retained in the section, which should read: "land which possesses a substantial and actual as well as a potential value as building ground." The word "potential" would undoubtedly widen the authority of the Land Commission in regard to the exclusion of land suitable for building ground, and it would have the effect of enabling the Land Commission to set aside land which will be definitely required in the course of years for the purpose of ordinary building development.

Comment on this

With regard to Deputy Bennett's point, it is certainly much easier to define the land of this country that is actual building land than it is to define the land that is potential building land. We want to give the tenant, the long lessee or the fee-farm grantee, the benefit of the narrower definition, actual as against potential, so that he can come in and purchase his land. With regard to Deputy Roddy's point that this will in some way prevent building, at the moment if a man has his land on a long lease it is difficult for him to get the landlord to agree to building and I think, instead of preventing him, it would help to make land available for building.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 40:—

In sub-section (2), line 32, to delete all the words after the word "Tribunal" to the end of the sub-section and in lieu thereof to insert the following words:—

"consider it just, fair and equitable to the person in occupation of the holding, that such holding should be acquired by the Land Commission for distribution; the Appeal Tribunal shall not authorise the Land Commission to enter into possession until the resumption price is fixed".

This amendment seeks to limit the powers of the Land Commission as defined in this section. We think that it is not proper to give powers of resuming land before the ordinary conditions are fulfilled. One of the principal conditions is the fixing of the price. Probably the Minister will say that there will be no improvements made until the farm is actually taken over—it is only a question of waiting for the appeal, and so on. We feel it is indefensible that anybody's property should be entered on, whether it is with the intention of taking land over for division or anything else, until there is in the mind of what we will call the vendor—he may not be really a vendor; he may be an unwilling vendor, if you like—the conviction that the price is just and that it is being finally fixed. It may be that something will turn up afterwards, that changes will be effected in the land that might lessen its value, or the sale might fall through for some reason. Deputy McMenamin and I consider the amendment quite a reasonable one, and I would urge the Minister to give it careful consideration.

Comment on this

The amendment put down by Deputies Bennett and McMenamin does not really effect the purpose for which they put it down, but it is easy to see what the intention is. I really feel that the Land Commission should have these powers. After all, the price will be fixed by the Appeal Tribunal, and we want to endeavour to speed up the division of land. It is sometimes important to be able to go in even a month ahead of the price being fixed, in order to make certain improvements in buildings and get the incoming tenant on to the land at the time of the year that is most suitable. Sometimes you have a case where the Land Commission want to put in a man in January or February, in order that he can do the spring work. If they had not the powers that are here, they would have to delay perhaps until April or May, and the incoming tenant would be at a great disadvantage in preparing for the sowing of crops and so on. I think that it is not a very big amendment to the Land Acts. It is only giving us the same power in regard to these resumed holdings as we have in regard to other holdings. The Land Commission consider it a very necessary amendment. It will enable them to carry out their work much more expeditiously, and to give much more satisfaction to the incoming tenant.

Comment on this

I take it that the Minister is not, in this section, getting any more power than the Land Commission had got in the case of the acquisition of land for the relief of congestion?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that the number of cases in which the Land Commission have gone in before the payment of money has been very small?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That was my impression.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 41:—

In sub-section (1), page 12, line 50, after the word "Commission" to insert the words "after the passing of this Act".

This is purely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 42:—

In sub-section (2), line 3, to delete the words "considered by" and insert in lieu thereof the words "listed for hearing before".

The object of this amendment is to make sure—although I rather gathered from the Minister that it was his intention—that when the lay commissioners hear an objection they will hear it in court. As the section stands, it would seem to me—and as a matter of fact I consulted, I may say, with a very well known real property lawyer to see if his view agreed with mine—that owing to the fact that you have "listed for hearing" in sub-section (3) while in sub-section (2) you have the word "considered", it looks very like as if the intention was that those objections should be considered in camera, and that an opportunity of being heard would not be given to the objector. I rather gathered from the Minister that he did not mean to alter the existing procedure by which the objections are heard by the lay commissioners, so to speak, in court. If that is the case mine is merely a drafting amendment. If it is something more than a drafting amendment I should like the Minister to accept it, because I think it would be a great mistake to depart from the existing procedure.

Comment on this

It is not the intention of the Land Commission to depart from it. I am quite prepared to accept the Deputy's amendment, but I should like the Parliamentary draftsman to have a look at it.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

We will introduce an amendment to cover it on the next stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 43:—

After sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

(5) Whenever the lay commissioners (other than the members of the Appeal Tribunal) shall have made a decision upon any objection or requisition they shall if so requested by the person making the said objection or requisition or by counsel or solicitor on his behalf deliver to the said person or to his solicitor as the case may be a statement in writing of the findings of fact and rulings in law on which their said decision has been based.

The object of the amendment is this: An appeal is given from the lay commissioners to the Appeal Tribunal on a question of law. It is very difficult, in fact it is impossible, to appeal on a question of law unless the lay commissioners give you some findings. You come in with an objection before the lay commissioners, and the commissioners listen to you. You put forward a certain construction of a certain section. The commissioners may put some questions to you, and then questions of fact also arise. You put your witnesses in the witness box, and when the objection has been heard the lay commissioners simply answer you with the simple words "objection upheld" or "objection refused." You do not know the grounds. Whether they are against you in fact or on a point of law, you have not got the remotest idea. Then you make a pathetic appeal to the lay commissioners and say, "Would you please tell me your reasons?" They smile affably at you and say "No." That is the actual procedure which takes place. That is the procedure to which I want to put an end. Let me say I am appearing before the lay commissioners and I put before them a certain contention in law. The lay commissioners, in deciding against me, are probably deciding that my contention in law is wrong. I wish to bring it up to the Appeal Tribunal. I cannot do so because I have no findings of fact at all. What I want is that when they are asked to give the reasons for their judgment in fact and in law they will do so, in order that a person who wishes to contest the validity of their construction of various statutes shall not be hampered in bringing that question to the Appeal Tribunal.

I will give the Minister a little example. I went before the Appeal Tribunal in a case in which I argued that a section which the Minister had himself put into the 1933 Act did carry out the intention which the Minister stated in this House—I personally thought it did—that is to say that land properly farmed could not be taken up except for the relief of congestion in the immediate vicinity. This particular land, I may say, was in the vicinity of the Tuam beet factory. In consequence of being only a couple of miles away from Tuam, the man had grown a considerable amount of beet and had also grown a considerable amount of wheat. The land, therefore, had been farmed in the way in which the Minister certainly did suggest that lands ought to be farmed. There was no congestion in the immediate vicinity. My contention was that this land could not be taken up. I was met with a decision that it was going to be taken up, and it was perfectly obvious to me that the reason was that the lay commissioners had come to the conclusion that they could take up land properly farmed, for the relief of congestion, no matter in what part of the country or in what part of the county the congestion existed. In other words, they did not think themselves controlled—though I thought it was put bluntly enough—by the words "congestion in the immediate vicinity." I wanted to bring that up to the Appeal Tribunal. I could not do so because I had no findings of fact from them that the land was properly farmed. The Appeal Tribunal have got no power, or certainly do not in fact hear any evidence. In order that there may be an appeal in law, I want to have it as a mere matter of procedure—and nothing else except court procedure—that the lay commissioners, when they hear objections, shall state their findings of fact and their findings in law. I submit to the Minister that that is a very moderate and reasonable request. It is only a question of machinery.

Comment on this

I do not know whether any such procedure exists in any of our courts. I am not saying that the Land Commission is a court, but, if the Deputy went into a court and pleaded a case, is it not for the court to give judgment in short without stating whether it arrives at a decision on the basis of fact or law?

Comment on this

Yes, but suppose you have the case of a judge at nisi prius. There are either the shorthand notes or else there are the judge's notes, and these notes are available for the court above. I would not be introducing a new principle, because, even where the findings of fact are available, the court, in most cases where there is an appeal, may differ on questions of fact. You cannot do so here, however. I really am not introducing a new principle and I do not think it will throw any real burden on the lay commissioners at all. It is only when there is a genuine question of law that any counsel or solicitor will ask for the reasons to be stated.

Comment on this

I had not time to consult about this matter.

Comment on this

If the Minister will consult with the Attorney-General or his legal advisers that is all I want, and I hope that I shall not be estopped from raising the matter on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 44:—

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

(6) Nothing in this section shall apply to the compulsory acquisition of land by the Land Commission for the relief of congestion or for the purpose of such resale as is mentioned in the first sub-section of this section where such compulsory acquisition was begun before and is pending at the passing of this Act but, subject to that limitation, the procedure laid down in this section shall apply to all compulsory acquisition of land by the Land Commission for the relief of congestion or the purpose of such resale as aforesaid and shall be deemed for all purposes to be substituted for and to supersede any procedure (in this sub-section referred to as a superseded procedure) for such compulsory acquisition set out in any enactment in force immediately before the passing of this Act, and accordingly—

(a) every reference in any enactment in force after the passing of this Act to any step in a superseded procedure shall be construed as referring to the corresponding step in the procedure laid down in this section, and

(b) every power conferred on the Land Commission by any such enactment in relation or ancillary to the compulsory acquisition of land under a superseded procedure shall be exercisable by the Land Commission in relation or as ancillary to the compulsory acquisition of land under the procedure laid down in this section.

This is a drafting amendment, and its object is to make the section clear. The object is to make clear that the new procedure for compulsory acquisition is applicable only as from the date of the passing of the Act and does not apply to proceedings before the passing of the Act.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 45:—

Before Section 26, page 13, to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) Whenever an objection to a provisional list published (whether before or after the passing of this Act) in pursuance of Section 40 of the Land Act, 1923, or this Act is heard and determined after the passing of this Act by the lay commissioners (other than the members of the Appeal Tribunal), it shall be lawful for such lay commissioners, if they so think proper and whether they allow or disallow such objection, to direct that the Land Commission shall pay to the person making such objection such sum, by way of compensation for the expense incurred by him in relation to such objection, as such lay commissioners shall, in their absolute discretion, fix in that behalf.

(2) Every sum which is directed by the lay commissioners (other than the members of the Appeal Tribunal) under this section to be paid by the Land Commission to any person shall be paid in accordance with such direction as part of the expenses of the Land Commission.

This is a new section completely. It is giving the Land Commission power to recoup expenses of certain people from whom they attempted to take land and whose objection is upheld by the lay commissioners. If the occupier of land fails against the lay commissioners and goes to the Appeal Tribunal, the Appeal Tribunal have power to give him his expenses. The lay commissioners have not that power, and I feel that it is only right that, if the Land Commission puts a man to the expense of serving him with notice that they are going to acquire his land and, if he proves to their satisfaction that he is working his land properly or that, through various pertinent circumstances, his land should not be acquired, he should be recouped to some extent at least. That is what this is designed to cover.

Comment on this

Does this only apply to a case where the objector succeeds?

Comment on this

It applies whether he wins or loses.

Comment on this

In either case?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 46:—

In line 30, to delete the words "for wages."

This is only taking out the words "for wages" in order to make it clear that the Land Commission have power to take into consideration the ordinary grazing rights that are sometimes given to herds.

Comment on this

This section, Sir, is objectionable from some points of view. Hitherto, if there were a herd and his wife, the cases could be treated differently, but now it appears to me that, under this section, there might be severe hardships. I know of cases where a woman held a farm in her own right, and where the husband carried on the farm, let us say, not in a very good way. Let us say that the husband was a drunkard or otherwise incompetent, and the woman's farm—the wife's farm, in other words—turns out to be the sole support of the family. I know of such cases, and I am sure that many of us know of such cases. There would be similar cases due to other causes, such as the separation of husband and wife, for whatever reason it might be. The husband might be living away somewhere else and the Land Commission might conceive it right to take up portion of his land. The effect of this section would be to bring his wife's land under the same category as his.

In other words, her property would be included with his, and she would not get whatever benefits she would be entitled to under the 1933 Act—benefits of exemption and so forth. I think that the separate entity of ownership should be allowed still to exist, and that the wife's land should not be made a portion of the husband's estate. I do not know to what extent this may or may not operate, but I feel sure that there would certainly be a good many cases in which, if this section were put into effect, it would operate to the detriment of the wife and perhaps of the family.

Comment on this

The section, as drafted, will certainly impose a hardship in certain cases. As Deputy Bennett pointed out, in the case where a man and his wife are living apart, it seems unfair to regard husband and wife as one for the purpose of the acquisition of their land. That is one case, but there may be another case where the husband and the wife own two separate holdings and where the holding held by the wife will pass on to some member of her family; or, for instance, there may be cases where there might be a mortgage on the husband's farm, and where the farmer might be a spendthrift and the household has to depend entirely on whatever income is derived from the wife's holding. There are many other examples that could be cited, and it does seem to me that this section will operate unfairly in certain cases such as have been instanced. I realise, of course, that the Minister's problem is to relieve congestion as much as he possibly can, and I also realise that, with that end in view, he must obtain as much land as possible, but in the process of acquiring land for the purpose of the relief of congestion, it is not his desire, I am sure, to inflict hardship unnecessarily, and it is quite conceivable that serious hardships will be inflicted in certain cases. Take the case of a husband and wife who are living apart. They may be jointly responsible for the upkeep of the family, if there is a family, or one or other of them may undertake the responsibility of looking after that family; but no matter how it is, it seems to me that that is a case which merits special consideration and which should not be dealt with in the ordinary rigid way as outlined in this section. In the case of a husband who is a spendthrift, who probably has mortgaged his entire holding so that to-day it is practically valueless, and the family has to be maintained out of the income derived from the wife's holding, it seems unfair to group the holdings together for the purpose of land acquisition. They should be dealt with as separate entities, and the special circumstances applying to each should be taken into consideration.

There are further cases which one could enumerate in which there are special circumstances, and these should be taken into consideration by the lay commissioners when considering the acquisition of this land. I suggest to the Minister that the section should be amended with the object of allowing the lay commissioners to give special consideration to the type of cases I have mentioned, because I think that if the section is allowed to remain as it is, it will bind the lay commissioners to give a rigid interpretation to the law in relation to land acquisition, and it will not be in their power to make exceptions in the cases I have mentioned.

Comment on this

In fact, this is a mere drafting amendment of a section which was included in the 1933 Act. We want to make clear that we intend to take into consideration the joint value of the lands held either by a husband or wife, whether they hold them separately or jointly. This is not a section to compel the Land Commission to take all lands over £2,000 market value. It is a section which gives the tenant the right to object to the acquisition of lands below £2,000. The Land Commission have a certain amount of discretion as to what lands they are going to take, and, if there is some temporary family difficulty, they will probably pass up that particular piece of land for the time and follow some other land. If the wife is living away from the husband, they are two separate holdings.

Comment on this

It is not so stated, either in the 1933 Act or this section.

Comment on this

There is one sure thing anyway—we cannot put into an Act of Parliament everything that is in the discretion of the Land Commission.

Comment on this

You could introduce the words "where fair and just and equitable" or some words to that effect which would give the lay commissioners a wider discretion than they have at the moment.

Comment on this

I think those words are to be assumed in every section in which the commissioners are given powers. They have to be satisfied that it is fair and just, and I think there is no necessity to put in an amendment to meet the very exceptional case which the Deputy quotes.

Comment on this

With all due respect to the Minister, I think there is a very urgent necessity to put in words of that kind. The lay commissioners have absolute power in the acquisition of land. The certificate of the lay commissioners can take land from any person in this country at the moment and their power is now being extended. It was always absolute under the Act of 1933, and, under this Bill, they are given additional powers, so that they actually have absolute authority in the acquisition of land. If the certificate of the lay commissioners that land is required for the relief of congestion is issued, it goes, and there is no appeal except on questions of law or value. There is no appeal to an appeal tribunal; there is no appeal to the Judicial Commissioner; and there is no appeal to the Supreme Court. The lay commissioners have absolute power to say that this land is required for the relief of congestion. There is nothing in the Bill to say that in a case where a husband and wife are living apart, the land held by each will be regarded as a separate holding. It is neither in the 1933 Act nor in this Bill. There is nothing in any Land Act which says so. It is a matter entirely for the discretion of the commissioners and if they, in their discretion, say that it is required, no matter what the circumstances may be, the land is automatically taken for the relief of congestion.

Surely when the Minister has given the lay commissioners such absolute power, it is necessary that the words "fair and just and equitable" or some other words which will give them a wider discretion than they have at the moment, should be introduced into this section. If the Minister is going to give his commissioners absolute power, without any right of appeal whatever, so far as the acquisition of land is concerned, it seems to me that the relevant sections in this Bill should be framed in such a fashion as to give them the widest possible discretion for the purpose of ensuring that absolute fair play is meted out to the owners of this land. I am satisfied that the commissioners will act as fairly as their knowledge of the circumstances will enable them, but you must visualise the position of the commissioners. After all, they are working in offices here in Dublin. Probably they do not visit the country very often, and some of them may not know or understand the circumstances in the country very well. They have to depend entirely on reports they get from their inspectors. An inspector in County Galway is engaged in the putting into operation of a big scheme of land division in a particular townland in which there happens to be a good deal of congestion. There is a large holding of land, let us say, in the centre of that townland which interferes with him, or rather denies him the right of making a perfect job of that problem of congestion on which he is engaged; and that inspector will naturally be very anxious to acquire this particular holding of land. In his desire to find the perfect solution for the problem of congestion on which he is engaged, he may overstep the bounds of fair play in order to influence the commissioners to acquire this holding.

If there was a right of appeal from the lay commissioners, I would be almost satisfied to let the section go as it is worded, but as they are the final authority, so far as land acquisition is concerned, I think this section should be amended so as to provide that special circumstances shall be taken into consideration in their determination of whether or not land is to be acquired for the relief of congestion. The Minister, in his Land Act of 1933, took away the right of appeal which owners of land had to a higher tribunal, and when the lay commissioners say that land must be acquired for the relief of congestion the owner has no redress whatever, except on a question of price and if a question of law should arise. I am sure these men will act according to their conscience as fairly, justly and equitably as they possibly can in every case; nevertheless all of them are not intimately acquainted with circumstances down the country, and for that reason owners of land should be protected in our legislation, in so far as it is possible to protect them. I submit that there is no such protection for owners of land in this section, and I submit, further, that it is the duty of the Minister to see that they are properly protected in whatever legislation is passed through this House.

Comment on this

All I have to say is that the principle of the acquisition of land does not belong to this section. It is a mere minor matter as to whether husband and wife are to be taken as one owner, or to be taken as two owners, if they want to get round the law. If they are judicially separated, I think the Land Commissioners would have to recognise that there were two holdings. If it was a separation of convenience, a separation to get round the law in regard to this matter, or to stop land being taken which the Land Commission considers should be acquired for the relief of congestion, I do not think that separation should be recognised, and I do not think there is any hardship about that.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister to this extent, that this is not the section to consider whether the lay commissioners should be given wider discretion than the law enables them to exercise at present. Nevertheless, it is possible for the Minister to amend this Bill in such a fashion on the Report Stage as to give the Commissioners that wider discretion and authority. The case was made by speakers from these benches that the three F's have gone by the board. Security of tenure is practically gone. It went under the Act of 1933, and this Bill is putting the finishing touches on it. Surely under these circumstances the Minister will agree that the owners of land are entitled to get whatever security legislation can offer them. Every citizen of this State is entitled to protection. Certainly owners of land are entitled to a certain amount of protection in whatever land legislation is passed through the Dáil. On the one side the Commissioners are given absolute power to acquire land for the relief of congestion, without any right of appeal, and, on the other hand, power is being taken in the Bill to acquire land of any class or condition anywhere to enable the Commissioners to relieve congestion. There are special circumstances relating to every farm and to every individual owner of land. As it is framed, the Bill does not take into consideration the special circumstances which apply to individual holdings. In view of the fact that the Commissioners are given absolute power and that power is also being taken to acquire any sort of land anywhere in the State, the Minister should introduce into the Bill as many safeguards as possible for the owners of land. In the exercise of the absolute right that the lay commissioners enjoy every factor should be taken into consideration that is in any way relevant to the holding. It is all very well for the Minister to say that in the case of a husband and wife living apart, and owning two separate holdings, the Commissioners will not take a holding from either party. But that is not in the Bill. The Commissioners have absolute power to take these holdings now. There is nothing in the Bill which obliges the Commissioners to take any special facts into consideration in cases of that kind. Again, in a case of a husband holding a farm of land, which is mortgaged to such an extent as to render it valueless, where the wife holds another farm, out of which the family is maintained there is nothing in the Bill to compel the Commissioners to give special consideration to the circumstances in that type of case. I could quote a number of other instances, but these two are quite sufficient to emphasise the need for some other form of words to be introduced into this section to safeguard the rights of owners of land.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 44
·
Níl 30
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I do not quite understand this section. Perhaps the Minister will explain what it means.

Comment on this

It is a legal clause to make clear what was the obvious intention in the Act of 1933. That is that when land is declared, under Section 32 of the Act of 1933, it should vest in the Land Commission on the appointed day. The section also legalises the action taken in certain cases that were dealt with prior to the decision of the Appeal Tribunal, which held that in the absence of a specific vesting clause from the provisions of Section 32 of the Land Act of 1933, the land did not so vest. It is to make clear that when the Land Commission declare land under Section 32 of the Act of 1933, it shall vest in the Land Commission.

Comment on this

I do not quite understand the section even yet. It seems to me that the Minister has got all the authority and legislation he requires for this particular purpose already. Why introduce this section unless it is intended to set aside a court decision or to anticipate a court decision? Is it intended to upset a court decision?

Comment on this

It is intended to make clear what the intention was in 1933.

Comment on this

What was the intention?

Comment on this

That when the Commissioners declare land under Section 32 of the Act of 1933, it shall automatically vest in the Land Commission. The Appeal Tribunal held that in the absence of a specific provision to that effect it did not vest.

Comment on this

In my opinion, this is the most vicious section in the Bill, because it cuts across the entire principle which governed land purchase in this country. That was, to bring about finality in land settlement. This section cuts directly across that. The whole land agitation in this country was carried on for the purpose of securing finality in land settlement. The Land Act of 1933 was practically the final step in that regard. This section is put into the Bill to cut across and nullify the whole policy and the principles running through the Land Purchase Acts since the Ashbourne Act. Is this House prepared to accept that principle? There is nothing on the face of the section to indicate what it means, but that is what it is going to do. Is there going to be no end to the problem of land settlement and land purchase in this country? This section brings us back to the state of affairs which existed before land purchase was commenced in this country at all. The Land Commission are taking the same powers as the landlords had. That means that there will be no question of finality in land settlement, that it will go on for ever. The section looks quite innocuous on the face of it, but that is definitely the meaning of it. A case was brought before the courts and it was decided that land which was vested under the Act of 1923 could not be acquired by the Land Commission. That provision was deliberately inserted in the Act of 1923 by the late Deputy Hogan for the purpose of bringing about finality in the question of land settlement. That is what everybody has been looking forward to for the last 60 years in this country.

That was the origin of the agrarian trouble. Land reform was based on that condition of things. Step by step, we were proceeding until some day we should reach finality. Here, we are cutting across the whole principle. Does this House believe in finality in land settlement or does it not? Are Deputies who, in the main, are the sons of farmers and the grandsons of the men who fought for this reform and won it, going to allow this principle to be cut across? This is a vicious section—the most vicious section in the Bill. I want to know if the House is prepared to stand by it.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would give us some further particulars regarding this case. There is a rather serious principle involved in the decision to insert this clause in the Bill. If, as appears, a man went into court, made his case and satisfied the court that he had certain rights, the Minister ought to tell us why it is proposed to annual the decision of the court. That is not a thing a Parliament should be called upon to do. In the normal course, if a mistake be made in the drafting of an Act of Parliament and that mistake is discovered by reason of action taken in the courts, the law would be put right but not so as to affect the rights vindicated in court in the case of the individual in question. I do not know the individual who brought this appeal nor do I know the part of the country from which he comes. But are we going to lay down a principle that a man who goes into court against the State, or an institution of the State, does so at his peril? That is to say, if he wins his action against the State or an institution of the State, legislation will be introduced to prevent the decision of the court being carried into effect. If that be the position, then the principle is a bad one and, I think, the Minister will recognise that that is so. If the situation is that something is merely being made right which was neglected in the last measure, then it is a different question. At any rate, the individual who asserted his rights in court has some title to consideration. If my information is correct, a person may succeed in a case against the Land Commission and may not get his costs. That does not appear to be just to the individual and the citizen has certain rights which ought not be absorbed by the State. The main question here is: is this an indication of a principle that is to be accepted, that a citizen who goes into court against the State, or a Department of State, does so at his peril and, if he succeeds, that steps will be taken to deprive him of the fruits of that decision?

The Minister ought to tell us if the question at issue in this case was one of material consequence to the individual. If the matter was merely one which had been forgotten and which is now being made right, we ought to be told that. We are entitled to know also if other cases are pending. There is a strong suspicion that this measure will have successors and, if a citizen should succeed in asserting his rights against the Land Commission, we may expect further Acts to give the Land Commission almost absolute power in con nection with the acquisition and distribution of land.

Comment on this

I do not know how far Deputy Cosgrave would go in claiming that if a court decides that an Act of Parliament means a certain thing, that court decision should bind the Legislature not to bring in legislation to amend what it regards as a defective law. No power is taken in this section or in any other section of the Bill to annul a court decision. The court has the duty of interpreting the law as it is found in an Act of Parliament. That decision must not be held to be a legislative act binding on the Legislature and on all persons for ever. If the Legislature find, after the giving of a court decision, that the law is not what they desire it to be, they have a right to introduce legislation to give effect to their intentions. That is exactly what we are doing.

In a particular case, the Appeal Tribunal held that land acquired under Section 32 of the Act of 1933 did not vest in the Land Commission and that, therefore, the Land Commission could not vest it in other people. The intention of Section 32 will be fairly clear to everybody. Following the decision of the court, we are introducing this clause to provide that, for the future, land shall vest in the Land Commission under Section 32 of the Act of 1933. The person who was successful in this particular case was awarded his costs by the Appeal Tribunal. The Land Commission have paid his costs and that is the end of it. On examining the position, following the decision of the court, we decided to amend the law and to provide that what was intended to be done under the Act of 1933 should be made strictly legal.

Comment on this

Is it proposed to take this man's land now? He has gone before the Appeal Tribunal and he has succeeded there. According to the Minister, he has got his costs. Having obtained that decision, is not the decision of the court annulled if this clause, which has all the appearance of being retrospective, is retrospective?

Comment on this

The question of the acquisition and distribution of land is entirely for the Land Commission. I have not studied the matter at all but, from a purely layman's point of view, I can see a clear distinction between the functions of the judiciary and the functions of Parliament. I do not think that anybody who wants to strengthen the decisions of the courts would claim that a court decision interpreting the law should be given the power of a legislative act binding all persons for all time. The court is perfectly right in interpreting the law against the Executive or against a State Department, if in its judgment it thinks the law should be so interpreted. I do not think the courts would claim that, because they gave a decision in a certain way, Parliament was not entitled to pass legislation to do what it previously attempted to do and failed owing to the decision of the court.

Comment on this

The Minister cannot claim all the virtues on his side with regard to that. What it really amounts to is that when a court gives a decision which is repugnant to or against the wishes or the desires of the Executive, the Executive retorts by altering the law. What is that but annulment of the court's decision? In this particular case I asked for an explanation of the circumstances of the person concerned. This section is drafted for the purpose of getting land, which the law has already decided it would not allow the Land Commission to take. A man has certain rights. He asserts these rights and now you say "very good, you assert them at your peril." When the citizen seeks the protection of the law he runs the risk first of having a judicial decision against him and in favour of the Land Commission. In the second place, if he gets a decision in his favour he runs the risk of having an Act of Parliament passed to take from him the rights he successfully asserted. It is important that we should have the law laid down properly in regard to this matter. How many cases are pending in which citizens have taken the necessary steps to secure their rights against State Departments? These rights are now interfered with. Why deprive a citizen of the right he asserted successfully in the court?

Comment on this

In Section 32 of the Land Act of 1933 the Land Commission sought powers to acquire certain lands for distribution. I think they were perfectly entitled to do so. The Legislature debated the thing at length and decided that it was right that these powers should be enshrined in an Act of Parliament. When the Appeal Tribunal came to consider the words of the Act of Parliament it decided that they were defective and that, as a matter of fact, the Land Commission could not proceed under that section to acquire land, because under that section it had not the power it claimed it had. Following that decision, the activities of the Land Commission to acquire land under the section were completely held up. That case decided the law as it then stood and it was binding against the Land Commission. It was binding to the extent that it prevented the Land Commission from providing land under that section in any other case where they thought they should proceed. But though that decision is binding on the Land Commission it cannot be held to bind the hands of the Legislature for all time. It is a judicial decision interpreting an Act of Parliament. Surely the Legislature is entitled to carry out its original intentions and introduce an Act of Parliament to set matters right. Deputy Cosgrave said he hoped we were not claiming all the virtues on this side. I should be very slow to claim that all the virtues are on this side. Now, with regard to retrospective legislation, I have a list of only a few Land Acts in which sections were brought in deliberately to amend the law so as to provide against certain defects which were found by the courts in the Acts. The Legislature thought these Acts should be amended. Section 3 (1) of the Land Act of 1929 is a section which in fact is retrospective. It was to amend the law in view of a judicial decision.

Comment on this

Did it affect a particular case?

Comment on this

It affected a number of cases because a decision was given in a number of cases.

Comment on this

Did it amount to an annulment of the court's decision?

Comment on this

It was as much an annulment of the court's decision as this section is.

Comment on this

That is not the question.

Comment on this

If the Deputy claims that this section is an annulment of the court's decision, so is 3 (1) of the Land Act, 1929. I claim that neither is.

Comment on this

That is not the question, but did it give rights to a State Department against an individual?

Comment on this

It did. The Land Act of 1923 spoke of fisheries appertaining to the land. The court interpreted this expression in a case that came before it. I think it was probably Deputy Roddy in 1929 who said that they intended something different from what the courts interpreted as meaning something else, and they introduced Section 3 (1) of the Land Act of 1929 to make sure that what was intended to be done under the Act of 1923 should be the law of the land. That was done in face of a judicial decision. They introduced that section for the purpose. That section, as I say, was brought in in the face of a judicial decision. Section 45 of the Act of 1923 is another section that was introduced, in view, as was explained at the time, of a judicial decision. Section 7 (5) of the Land Act of 1927 was introduced in view of a judicial decision, and Section 44 (6) of the Land Act of 1931 was also introduced in view of a judicial decision. Then there was Section 30 of the Land Act of 1927, introduced for a similar reason. I do not mind a certain amount of opposition to a section such as this, but Deputies opposite should not go so far as to confuse the relationship between the judiciary, the Executive and the Legislature. I am as strong as anybody on the opposite side in stating that the judiciary should be free to arrive at decisions and that they should be independent. I think the courts and the judges would not thank any Deputy here for making for the judiciary claims that are altogether untenable.

Comment on this

The Minister has drawn my attention to Section 3 (1) of the Act of 1929. While the first section appears different, to some extent, without examination I am accepting what the Minister says. But that section has some relation to the present cases. Section 3 (3) of the same Act says: "If, on the determination of any such question as is mentioned in the foregoing sub-section"—that is fishery or fishing rights—"it appears to the Land Commissioners or, on appeal to him, to the Judicial Commissioner, that the fishery or fishery rights to which such question relates has vested in the Land Commission but that it is not equitable or is not advisable that such fishery or fishing rights should be so vested, it shall be lawful for the Land Commissioners or, on appeal to him, the Judicial Commissioner, to declare that such fishery or fishing right has not vested in the Land Commission." And so on. There is no such provision in this.

Comment on this

That is in the Act already.

Comment on this

Not at all. Here was a question where justice, equity and fairness arose. No such question arises in the case of this section. There is no equity, for as soon as the Land Commission issues a certificate there is no more about it.

Comment on this

If this section were only a question of annulment of a judicial finding I should be opposed to it. We were assured in the Land Bill of 1933 that, drastic and all as it was, the powers given in that Bill would not be exercised to the full. We were told there was no occasion for our fears, but we fought the Bill pretty desperately to give some right of appeal to the courts. We only got it in a very limited way. Only in a few matters was there a possibility of any landholder appealing to the courts. This was one of them, and he succeeded in breaking what they thought was a cast-iron position to deprive people of their lands. The man who fought his case in the courts deserves the fruits of his endeavours. I for one am not going to be a party to seeing the verdict he got upset.

Landholders were left very little rights from the 1933 period. If we are to accept lying down that a court decision can be upset, if there is any provision left in this Bill that gives any landholder any right to go into court on any question of fact, of law or otherwise—and there will not be many opportunities left—no man will go into court, because it would be useless, as a few days afterwards an amending Bill to upset the verdict given will be introduced. That is the principle we are adopting if we upset this. There ought to be some protection, some last appeal left to landholders, but this wipes them all out. It is useless for any individual to appeal to the courts when he knows that if he wins his case a new amending Bill will be brought in to deprive him of the fruits of his victory.

Comment on this

The Minister quoted Section 44 of the Land Act, 1931. Sub-section (5) of Section 44 says:

Section 11 of the Land Act, 1927, is hereby repealed without prejudice to the continuance, completion and validity of proceedings under that section which are pending at the passing of this Act.

I wonder is it a fair presentation of the case to say that this shall be deemed to have vested, under Section 24 of the Land Act, 1923, in the Land Commission on the appointed day? This is a setting aside of the law— making it retrospective. It is the fundamental right of the citizen to take the law as he finds it on any given date. He is obliged to perform the duties laid down under the law, but he is also entitled to the rights prescribed for the citizen under the law. Under this the citizen has no rights, but he has duties. The Government comes to the Dáil with a measure not only changing the law from the date of the passing of the Act, but making it retrospective. That is a wrong principle. I have said repeatedly in this House that even if it were done thousands of times before I disapprove of it. In this case the proceedings were permitted to continue to completion.

I should like to emphasise what Deputy Bennett said, that this is being introduced because the Land Commission were defeated in a certain case in the courts. They introduced this Bill to declare that the law was not what the courts decided it was at that date and upon which the citizen went into court and succeeded. We are taking away, as from the date he got that decision, the rights he obtained under the law. He took legal advice and went into court and succeeded, and we have taken away that right. Nobody inside or outside this House could defend that principle. No greater form of Bolshevism or nothing more abhorrent than that could be imagined. I have no objection to legislating from the passing of the Act, but every citizen, whether rich or poor, has the right to take the law as it exists on a particular date. He has to obey the law and he has duties under the law, but certain rights are given to him under the law and he is entitled to have them. This section is taking them away. I do not mind legislating from the passing of the Act, because from that date we will know the law, and if anyone violates it he can suffer the consequences. Here we are taking away rights which people had.

It does not matter what the House intended to do under the 1933 Act. The question is what this House did under the 1933 Act. When the House enacted that Act the public were entitled to take it as being what this House did, not what this House intended to do. That is the constitutional right of the citizen. Nothing could be more obnoxious and abhorrent than this principle of retrospective legislation on an important question, preventing the citizen from getting his rights under the law as it existed at a specific date. The citizen has to discharge his duties to the Land Commission or any other Department of State under any law passed by this House. He has to pay income-tax, he has to pay land annuities and he has to pay rates. But if there is some weakness or defect in the law, so that in his opinion he is not bound to pay and he gets a verdict in the courts, then this House comes along and says: "At that date you had not that right." As Deputy Dillon pointed out yesterday, this Bill strikes at the root of fixity of tenure. Let there be no mistake about that. This section goes further and takes away a right that existed under the law at a given date. That is wrong. This House has no right to do that, and it will react upon this House and upon the country.

Comment on this

Since this man won his case against the Land Commission a lot of people who held land under similar terms felt that they were secure and that the Land Commission could not enter upon their land. A lot of people bought land held on these terms and land held in that way went up in value in the market. Now, when this section is passed, the value of that land is gone and people do not know where they are. If the local Fianna Fáil club have their eyes on certain land, all they have to do is to tell the Minister for Lands and another Land Bill will be passed to put people out of their land. Under this Bill nobody is secure in his holding, and the land will be of no value whatever. As I say, a lot of people bought land held in this way because they felt that they were secure and could not be touched. This section does away with all that security. No matter what the Minister or anybody else says, it means that nobody is secure in his holding any more.

Comment on this

Has the Minister nothing to say about this? Is there nobody on the benches opposite to get up and denounce this business? I see Deputy Mrs. Concannon there. She comes from County Derry. I should like to remind the House that the first rights won for the tenant holders of this country were won by the Presbyterian farmers of Ulster—the three F's.

Deputy Mrs. Concannon's ancestors, like my own, took part in that struggle with their Presbyterian neighbours. That was looked upon as a great triumph for the farmers of this country. Is Deputy Mrs. Concannon going to vote for this section? I have a number of colleagues from my own county of Donegal here. One of them was born and lives on what was formerly the Leitrim estate. I wonder is he going to vote for this section? Is he going to forget all the sacrifices that were made by the poor tenantry on that estate to get fixity of tenure? Apparently, Deputies come in here and think that they have no responsibility to the people who elected them. Not only are they prepared to betray the electors who sent them here, but they are prepared to betray their ancestors as well. Again, I denounce this section with all the force at my command.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 45
·
Níl 30
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment No. 47 seems to be a direct negative.

Comment on this

On Section 29, under the Land Act of 1933, the Land Commission were empowered to enter into possession of land in respect of which a resumption order had been made, notwithstanding that the price of the land had not been fixed. That was the position when the Land Commission considered that the land was required for immediate distribution. It is now proposed to go a stage further, and to take possession of the land even at an earlier period for the purpose of carrying out improvements. Probably by the time we get to the next amending Bill, the Minister will take power to enable the Land Commission to take possession immediately on the issue of the certificate by the lay commissioner.

I wonder how far the Minister intends to go in connection with this type of legislation. Under these proposals it may be that the owner will have to wait two or three years before the price is fixed. It is an unheard-of procedure to take possession of land and distribute it before the price is even provisionally fixed. It is imposing a serious hardship on the owner. I assume he will not be entitled to draw interest on the bonds until the price is actually known. The price has to be fixed before he can get interest on the bonds. It may be a year or two after the Land Commission have taken possession before the price is fixed, and only then is he entitled to get interest, which will run as from the date on which possession was taken. He is left in the position that he has only one source of income, namely, the interest on the land bonds. If he had possession of the land up to the time the price was fixed, he would be able to derive some income; but he is debarred from deriving any such benefit from the land because the Land Commission take possession of it even before the price is fixed.

The Minister has power under the 1933 Act to take possession of land for the purpose of distribution. He is going a further stage here, and he is taking possession earlier so as to enable the Land Commission to carry out improvements. Where will the Land Commission stop in legislation of that kind? A private individual selling land in the open market gets a percentage of the price before he hands over possession. In ordinary business no person hands over possession of an article until he knows the price and has a substantial portion of it. The Land Commission is proceeding in a way that is outside the pale of commercial transactions. The tendency in the Land Commission is to proceed further and further in this direction.

This section is open to very great objection on the score that the rights of the owners of land are not respected. This is on a par with the legislation that was enacted in 1933. The owners' rights are not respected at all. The lay commissioners are given absolute power to acquire land for the relief of congestion, and within the scope of this Bill every type and condition of land is bought. While the Minister is anxious to give the lay commissioners the widest power, he has not taken into consideration the interests of the owners of land. On a previous section I suggested that the Minister should introduce the words "just, fair and equitable" in order to safeguard the rights of owners of land, but he refused to do that. The whole trend of his legislation is to ignore completely the rights of owners.

This section imposes a severe hardship on the owners, and I do not think the Land Commission or any other Government Department have the right to enter into possession of land without letting the owner know beforehand what price they are prepared to pay. The Board of Works will not take possession of land until the price is actually fixed. The Department of Education and other Departments would not dream of taking possession of land until the price is agreed upon. The Land Commission is the solitary Government Department in this country with authority to enter into occupation of land and actually distribute that land before the owner knows the price. It is an astounding procedure.

Comment on this

Deputy Roddy is altogether out in his objections to this particular section. I did not want to raise a point of order; I did not want to interfere with the Deputy's liberty to range over even the principles already agreed on in the 1933 Act and previous Acts, which we have debated pretty widely. I merely want to correct the Deputy when he says that when the Land Commission enter into possession of lands without the price being definitely fixed the owner is suffering under a grave disability. This section is amending Section 30 of the Land Act of 1933. Sub-section (5) of Section 30 of that Act sets out:—

Notwithstanding anything in Section 36 of the Land Act, 1931, interest on land bonds advanced as the price of untenanted lands for which a provisional price has been declared under this section shall be paid to the person appearing to the Land Commission to be the owner of the lands prior to the purchase, but the Judicial Commissioner may, on the application of any interested person, direct that such interest or any part thereof shall be paid to such interested person.

In Section 30 of the 1933 Act we took power to fix a provisional price. Deputy Roddy knows perfectly well that, in the operations of the Land Commission, without that section the Land Commission might be held up for five or ten years in acquiring land and finding out who, in fact, is the legal owner. In 1933 we attempted to take lands more quickly, to fix a provisional price, and to pay interest on that provisional price to the apparent owner. The apparent owner is not always the real owner, and it is a long legal wrangle to find out who, in fact, has a complete legal title to the land. I think that was a considerably reasonable section, and it has helped the Land Commission to speed up land division. There is one slight flaw in it. We are entitled to fix a provisional price and go in on the lands for immediate distribution. But Deputy Roddy knows perfectly well that one of the things involved in immediate distribution is to put the lands into a state in which they can be distributed. We are taking power under this clause to provide that the Land Commission can go in, where a provisional price has been fixed, for the purpose of carrying out improvements to roads, drains and fences, and to construct or repair houses. That might really be held to be covered by the Act of 1933, but we are making it perfectly clear that it is the intention of the Act of 1933 to allow the Land Commission to go in to carry on those works when they acquire the land under Section 30 of the 1933 Act.

Comment on this

Does not the Minister think that it is some hardship, if the Land Commission decides to acquire the homestead of a farmer in this country, that that man should have to wait upwards of two years before he gets the price of the land that has been taken from him? What is the man to live on during the intervening period between the date of the fixation of the provisional price and the date of determination of the actual price, when bonds are issued to him? It is true that he may get interest as from the date of entry, but is that interest made available to him immediately? Is he free to draw that as it falls due, or is it held back until the final price is determined?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Then he is entitled to draw the interest on the provisional price. But, as the Minister knows, there is a right of appeal in the matter of price. The final price may be substantially in excess of what the Land Commission first offered, and the interest payable would be proportionately higher. It is quite an illusion to imagine that every person whose land is acquired by the Land Commission under their compulsory powers gets from the Land Commission a capital sum which, invested in gilt-edged securities, will produce an income anything like the income he enjoyed from the land that has been taken from him. It is a matter of very great inconvenience indeed to a landowner in this country if he is put out of his holding. He must get lodgings somewhere. He must provide accommodation for his family. All that costs money. If, while that additional expense is being put upon his shoulders, his income is materially reduced, as a result of the intrusion of the Land Commission upon his property, that man may suffer very serious hardship. All through the land code it has been difficult to reconcile the rights of the landholders with the interests of the congests or landless men. It becomes a matter of applying to this problem not the strict letter of distributive justice, but common sense, and, while we may have to face the fact that we cannot avoid inflicting a certain inconvenience on anybody whose land is compulsorily acquired, we should try to mitigate that inconvenience in so far as we can.

What we object to here is that the Minister now proposes substantially to extend the period between the date when a landowner must leave his homestead and the date when he may expect to receive a final settlement of his claim against the Land Commission. It is a matter of comparative inconvenience. We have a precedent in the Rent Restriction Act, where the court is frequently called upon to decide in the course of an action who will suffer the greater inconvenience—the landlord or the tenant. If the tenant can prove that the inconvenience he will suffer by being removed from his house is far greater than that which the Land Commission will suffer if he is allowed to remain, the law requires the court to preserve the tenant in his tenancy even if the landlord is going to suffer some inconvenience. Here I submit that, by increasing the period of uncertainty which the landholder must endure after the compulsory acquisition of his land, he is called upon to suffer an inconvenience out of all proportion to the inconvenience that congests or other eligible persons would suffer by being delayed for another six or seven months from entering on their new holdings. Remember, the new period of waiting which it is proposed to provide for under this section is the period during which the Land Commission would be carrying out improvements preparatory to sub-division. I submit to the Minister that this is a case where the Land Commission want to sweep obstacles out of their way, and in excessive enthusiasm for expedition in their business they will create suffering which is quite unnecessary, and which, on the balance, cannot be justified. It is a very great mistake to be too radical. I can see that, in a very small number of cases, inconvenience may have been caused to the Commission in the ordinary working of their business by this necessity of forbearing to enter for the purpose of improvements until the price has been ascertained, but I suggest to the Minister that the inconvenience which he is going to cause by the new departure is out of all proportion to any advantage that will accrue to the Commission.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 48:—

To add the following words at the end of the section:—

"provided that where a person has been in occupation of such holding for three years or upwards such holding shall vest in such person."

This section seems to apply to lands held by the Land Commission in congested districts, and proposes to give the Minister certain powers over the vesting of lands. The section is designed, to my mind, to prevent land from being vested in poor occupants who rented or leased it or were granted short grazing lettings by the Land Commission. In his explanation, I think the Minister said that there were certain rights given to those particular tenants, and I think he said it was rather too much to ask that this particular right of vesting should be given to them in addition. They were given the benefits of the revised payments, the Minister said, and, as such, the Land Commission objects to their getting anything further than these reduced payments. I undertook to put in an amendment which, as far as I could put it, provided that any such person who had been in occupation of a holding for three years or upwards would be vested. I think that where some poor person has been put into occupation of land, whether as a leaseholder or on terms of sale, he should be secured to a certain extent there, and it is to secure that object that I ask the House to accept this.

Comment on this

What is the object of this section? What restraint does the Land Commission intend to put on these occupiers? What rights do the Land Commission want to assert under this section? Certainly, if these people have acquired any rights against the Land Commission such as they might acquire against anybody else from whom they hold the land, I should like to hear from the Minister about the rights vested in the Land Commission, and I should like to hear from the Minister that the right of these people will not be compromised by the fact that the annuities are being halved.

Comment on this

I read the Minister's statment on the second Reading Stage of the Bill and, frankly, I still do not know what this section proposes to do. The Minister said that, where holdings were listed and where the Land Commission had certain rights over those holdings prior to listing, it did not seem to him that the tenants should hold certain benefits in regard to the rights which the Land Commission hitherto enjoyed. I do not understand that.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy will allow me to explain?

Comment on this

It was not intended that, when the Land Commission listed the holdings of certain allottees in order to give them the benefit of paying off their interest and sinking fund, the allottees should have the same right as a person in whom the lands were vested. Up until the Act of 1931 the procedure was, not to vest the land in an allottee for a number of years, and certainly not to vest the lands on which they merely gave the tenant grazing rights. Now, the withholding of vesting meant that the allottee was not getting any nearer the paying off of his holding, that he was not paying off his sinking fund; and a procedure was arrived at whereby, if the Land Commission were satisfied, after a number of years, that the allottee to whom they gave the land was working his land properly and was paying up, he should have the benefit of having paid off something of the total purchase price by way of sinking fund. It is really a technical difference between listing and vesting. The Land Commission wanted to give the benefits that go with listing to the tenant without giving him the rights that go with vesting, and we are anxious to hold the rights that the Land Commission have over the land until it is finally vested in the tenant. That is as well as I can explain the purpose of this section. I think it gives the Land Commission a power which they should have.

Comment on this

The Minister says that the object of this is to keep up the difference between listing and vesting. Now, I should like to put a question to the Minister. Let us suppose that the land is what he calls listed in a certain individual for three or four years and not vested. The individual has been paying off sinking fund during that period and then the land is vested in somebody else—some other individual, let us say. That individual is getting the benefit of the payments towards the sinking fund which the person to whom the land had been previously listed has made. Is not that the case? Otherwise, the Land Commission is being overpaid. Accordingly, it would certainly seem to me that, if the Land Commission want to draw this hard and fast rule between listing and vesting when they take up land from a man to whom the land has been listed and vest it in another man, the Land Commission ought to pay back the contributions towards sinking fund and so on that have been made during that period.

This section has got words that I hate. The words I refer to are: "shall not operate or ... shall not be deemed ever to have operated." In other words, it is one of these retrospective sections which are going perpetually through this Bill. I am not going to speak about the evils of retrospective legislation, Sir, because I have spoken about that matter so often on this Bill that I think the House generally knows what I want to say. I think that the House knows thoroughly what views I hold on retrospective legislation and I am not going to repeat them unnecessarily. I should like to know, however, why the Minister is putting, in this section, his bitter retrospective legislation and how this retrospective legislation is going to impinge on the rights of listed individuals. If persons, whom the Minister calls listed persons, have certain rights against the Land Commission and have been paying because they have those rights, are these rights now going to be taken away from them? If not, why are those words, which seem to me to be the most objectionable part of the Bill, inserted here?

Comment on this

Am I right in saying that up to the Land Act of 1931 a listed tenant paid annuities?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

And that, up to that, the Land Commission was empowered to credit such person with such payments up to the time when he would be ultimately vested?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Well, then, that is clear. What I should like to understand, however, is this: What are the rights referred to in Section 31 which the Minister wants to avoid giving in connection with the benefits conferred by Sections 23 and 24 of the Land Act, 1931, coupled with Section 27 of that Act? Is it that he wants to be in a position to say: "If I do not want to list a man as a tenant, I can give him the grazing rights for which he pays the Land Commission a tenancy at £10 a year, and if I subsequently vest him as tenant of that farm, I do not want to give him any credit for the £10 a year he paid while he was merely grazing the farm." Is that the purpose of this, because, in the Minister's statement, he says:—

"It has been suggested that they were entitled to much more and that parties holding from the Land Commission under this agreement are practically in the same position as annuity payers. The Land Commission could not accept such an interpretation of the law and clause 31 had been inserted to make the position clear and to preserve the rights of the State."

Was it that people tried to suggest that an agreement to graze land in the possession of the Land Commission gave them the same rights over it as if they were a listed tenant of the holding?

Comment on this

No, but that would be the effect of the amendment put in by Deputy Roddy and Deputy McMenamin. They put in an amendment providing that where a man had even a grazing right for three years, he would have the same rights as a vested tenant, and that the Land Commission could not take up his holding. The Act of 1931 conferred additional benefits on the allottees, and we do not want the giving of the additional benefit to confer a legal right on the allottee to whom the benefit is given. We simply want to give the benefit gratuitously, but without giving the tenant the same right as a vested allottee.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say why the section is made retrospective?

Comment on this

Because there is a doubt as to whether it was right or not in the past.

Comment on this

In other words, people may have acquired rights which you want to take from them, or definitely have?

Comment on this

They may have acquired rights which it was not intended to give them in 1931.

Comment on this

If the Minister will look at line 19 of Section 31, he will see that it says that: "The inclusion shall not be deemed ever to have operated to deprive the Land Commission which, immediately before the publication of the list"—and that is such a list as is provided for in Sections 23 and 24 of the Act of 1931—"they had in relation to such holding under the agreement or letting under which it was then held." Section 31 envisages the allotting to an allottee of land, and what rights have the Land Commission in that land before listing which they desire to retain after the land has been allotted through publication in the list to an allottee? What are the rights which the Land Commission wish to preserve?

Comment on this

They are the landlords and they have full power over the land. The land is vested in them.

Comment on this

That is what I wanted to get at. That is what I understood to be the construction of the section, that the Land Commission are the landlords and want to preserve rights in the landlord. Take the analogous case. Since the passing of the Land Act, all the landlord was entitled to was the amount provided with regard to interest under the particular Land Act while the land was not vested. Certain rights still remained in it. What were those rights? Let us take a glance at them. In the first place, the land could not vest before it had been inspected. Engineers went over a given estate to see that there were the precise number of acres, roods and perches that the landlord returned as being there. For practical purposes, all his rights to the land had gone to the tenant. Until the Land Commission engineer had inspected the land, and compared it with the return of the landlord in respect of areas and the holdings on the estate, it could not vest. Of course, technically, the landlord still possessed some rights, because, unless all the land which he returned in his schedule was there, he could not get paid for it.

Is there anything else with regard to these lands which the Land Commission wish to retain? Is there any question of sporting or fishing rights? There are no other rights that one can imagine unless we take as an example the case of somebody who goes in to build a house on one of these listed holdings that are in possession of the Land Commission. I suppose that in that case the allottee who was listed would not have the right to apply for an injunction, and the Land Commission would probably have to apply for an injunction to restrain the trespasser from building on that land. One could imagine a case like that, but what arises in connection with these grazing rights? I do not think anything arises. There is a right in the case of a trespasser coming in to build, but that is very far-fetched. The Land Commission legally would be the only authority that could apply for an injunction in that case. I should like to know what it is they wish to retain with regard to grazing.

Comment on this

I want to submit to the Minister that, to say the least of it, he has been disingenuous. He says that it is to be borne in mind that in these lists appear the names of many persons who only got lettings of temporary convenience or grazing agreements, and that it is in order to clarify the position in regard to that that we want to assert explicitly that listing does not interfere with rights of the Land Commission in any land so listed, but does the House observe that this section not only preserves all the rights of the Land Commission in connection with those persons who got a letting of temporary convenience or grazing agreements over land, but it also establishes the Land Commission in full possession of all the rights it had before publication of the list in respect of every allottee, no matter what the nature of the allotment is? Apparently the Land Commission has got it into its head that a person listed under the 1931 Act acquires some kind of a tenant right, and that to resume a holding or to get him out of the land, a procedure similar to that required to deal with vested land would be necessary. Having got that into their heads, they introduce a section here, and the Minister tells us that this section is directed primarily at grazing agreements and lettings of temporary convenience. Let us furnish the Minister with an acid test: Is he prepared to restrict the effect of this section to grazing agreements and lettings of temporary convenience and to exclude from the operation of this section persons listed in the ordinary way as prospective vested tenant purchasers?

Comment on this

They are temporary agreements.

Comment on this

The Minister knows as well as I do that we who live in the country are accustomed to persons getting grazing rights and conveniences over land pending distribution. There must be some distinction. The Minister understands the distinction to which I refer. Frequently in the old days we used to have men in the country who were known as overseers for the Congested Districts Board who would be very often tenants at will of land that the board intended to divide some time later. I have no desire to give them any tenant rights. If you are dealing with persons who have nothing but a grazing agreement pending division, I have no desire to give them tenant right. I want to give the listed allottee any rights which the Land Commission believe he has in the existing state of the law, as settled by the Land Act of 1931. Is the Minister prepared to do that?

Comment on this

We are prepared to give all allottees the rights they acquired under the agreements which they signed when entering upon the land, and no more. If we conferred additional benefits upon them beyond what was in the agreement the additional benefits should not give additional rights. The Land Commission always withhold the vesting of an allottee until they are satisfied that he is a fit and proper person. There is a period of trial during which vesting was postponed on the question of a right of way or of entering upon land for certain purposes, or for taking building materials to neighbouring holdings. The Land Commission had these rights prior to vesting. After the land was vested in a tenant they had to secure his permission to go in. I think it is a good practice not to vest holdings for a certain number of years. No matter how well the Land Commission does the job they may make some mistake with regard to allottees, and we want to have power, so that they will not get land merely to re-sell or to let it go waste, to be able to eject them if necessary. We also want the other powers that the Land Commission retained in the agreement which allottees signed when entering on the land.

Comment on this

My purpose was really to give these poor people some right in the land. I am not quite sure that I have established it, or that the Minister agrees that they have any rights. It seems that the Land Commission are to be in the position of perpetual landlords over these unfortunate people. My desire was to extend to them, what has been conferred on other tenants, some of the real rights of ownership, because the instinct for ownership is one of the greatest things for the people. If they could be assured that they were actually vested in their holdings it would give them a measure of security. However, the Minister does not seem inclined to give way, and as vested rights in any land have deteriorated so much, and as there is a doubt as to whether there is any vested right in anything, it is not worth fighting over.

Comment on this

The Minister might say what were the views that arose in the lawyers' minds.

Comment on this

That listing conferred the same rights as vesting.

Comment on this

As far as my recollection goes these congested holdings under Section 23 of the Land Act of 1931 were in the same position as retained holdings under the Act of 1923.

Comment on this

Section 26 of the Act of 1931 provides that.

Comment on this

I thought that was so. Now the Minister is taking absolutely unlimited power, because a person may be obliged to pay for a considerable time and then have to start off again at a higher rent. Supposing a man is put on a particular holding and has paid off the capital sum due, seeing that he is paying portion of the sinking fund, there is now complete power to raise the amount at any time. Is not that so? Is there not power before the land is vested to alter the rents? After the land has been vested and the man has gone into possession you still want to be in a position to alter the rent if you so wish. You will want the same power to put him out. Does this apply to the case of an exchange of holdings, because if a person exchanges a small holding for a larger one is it not vested in him? If not, it is only listed. It would be shocking if a man who goes out of a small holding into a larger one is merely listed and could be put out. I would like to know what the practice is. According to the Minister's statement it is evidently a matter of practice. If that is the practice, and if an agreement is only going to be listed, and if a man is to have no rights in the new holding, it is certainly astonishing.

Comment on this

I have explained this section often enough. It is to confirm in the Land Commission rights which were inserted in the agreement that tenants signed when they entered upon the land. I may illustrate it like this. If Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney invited Deputy Dillon into his house and gave him a bed for the night, we do not want Deputy Dillon to claim the right to remain there and to take the bed away with him when going.

Comment on this

But if Deputy Dillon were paying for a night's lodging in a hotel that I was running, I would expect him to get a night's lodging. That is what you are taking away from these persons.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

The Minister left me rather in a state of terror about the condition of migrants in congested districts.

Comment on this

Is there no case pending in regard to this?

Comment on this

It was merely a doubt that arose in the mind of someone who was examining the land laws. I do not know that there is even any foundation for it.

Comment on this

While the Minister may have solved doubts, he has certainly created doubts which did not exist before.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 49 is out of order.

Comment on this

This section looks fairly harmless, because it is supposed to exonerate the Minister from the necessity of listing where there is agreement amongst the interested parties. I am not at all satisfied in connection with the sale or transfer of land that it is not very much better to go through the ordinary procedure and to give the fullest publicity in Iris Oifigiúil at each step. It is a matter of record which brings the work of the Land Commission, particularly in the distribution of land, before the public eye, and affords interested parties an opportunity to demand certain information as a right. I believe that it is a useful and a desirable system, and where nothing but some trifling convenience in the administration of the Land Commission is concerned, it is very much better not to depart from what has been the hitherto established practice in land purchase.

Comment on this

The Deputy may rest assured that nothing is going to be done that is hurtful to the people who enter into purchase agreements. This is only doing away with a piece of unnecessary and costly red tape. Persons entering into purchase agreements are secured in their rights.

Comment on this

I do not like red tape, but when you are dealing with property I think it is a very wise thing always to make sure that everybody knows what you are doing. I think when you are dealing with land in all these cases, at least there should be some publication, and this is not a very extensive publication.

Comment on this

This is the only departure from the obligation to list?

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

Do you think that is prudent? You have got a general rule covering all such transactions, and this listing operation marks a certain stage in every transaction in which the Land Commission is concerned. Now you are going to take one small class of transactions out of that general rule and questions may arise as to whether the three conditions set out in paragraphs (a), (b) and (c) have been complied with. One case in which an issue of that kind would be raised ten or 15 years after the transaction is completed would cost far more annoyance and expense than the automatic procedure of listing would involve the Land Commission in. Surely it must be agreed between us that where every transaction is listed the trouble of taking out a certain restricted class of persons is infinitely greater than letting them go the way of all the others. To make trifling exceptions of that kind now, I submit, very largely destroys the value of a listing provision such as has been in the land purchase code for a very long time and which was primarily put there in order to secure that at a certain point in every purchase and sale transaction, the business will be placed on record in a standard way. I submit to the Minister that between this and the Report Stage he might consider whether it would not be better to let the ordinary procedure apply to every case as it has applied heretofore.

Comment on this

I should like to point out to the Minister that if he goes into court in a case in which no notice has been given, he will come out of the court very quickly because even though it is enacted by the House, if a provision contravenes the natural law, and if he interferes with property of any kind without giving notice to the owner of the property, the court will decide against him. For that reason I would urge upon him that no transactions should take place in regard to property without giving the person affected by it some notice. I wish to tell the Minister that even though a provision of that kind is enacted here specifically in legislation, if any point arises hereafter that this has been done without notice to the owner of the land, the Department will not be in court very long. You cannot do it because it contravenes the natural law and the court will assert the natural law above any law made by this House. It is unnatural to take a man's property without giving him some notice of it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 50:—

In sub-section (2), line 1, page 15, to delete the word "final" and also the word "only"; in line 2 before the word "questions" to insert the word "all" and in the same line to delete the words "of law or of value"; and in line 4 to delete the words "on questions of law."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy consider that the same issue is involved in amendment No. 56?

Comment on this

It deals with a different matter, Sir.

Comment on this

I found great difficulty in doing anything with this section that would satisfy me but ultimately I came to the conclusion that I could not draft anything that would be a practical substitute without destroying the entire section. Having come to that conclusion, I came to the decision that the only practical thing I could do was to provide that an appeal should lie from any decision of the lay commissioners on a question of fact as well as on questions of value or of law, to the Appeal Tribunal and to the Supreme Court. It is proposed in the amendment that an appeal shall lie from the lay commissioners on all questions of fact, law and value to the Appeal Tribunal and to the Supreme Court. I do not see why such an appeal should not exist. Land is not a perishable or a moveable article. The land is going to remain there and there will be plenty of time to deal with it after the appeal has been heard. I think that the Land Commission should not object to an appeal on all questions. The Minister for Agriculture decides whether or not the farm is one that is properly used for the breeding of stock. Then the lay commissioners are given power finally and absolutely to decide the fact whether the farm is to be resumed. There is to be no appeal on the question of fact. There are quite a number of things about which I think I have a considerable knowledge but I do not think there is any one thing about which I could claim to be infallible. I do not think there is anything about which anyone could be infallible, no matter how much he knows.

I think it is going too far to give to the lay commissioners the absolute determination of the question of fact in all these cases. If there is to be an appeal on questions of law and of value, why should we not provide for an appeal also on the other question? It will not take very long to decide that appeal. The land has been lying there for centuries and will remain there for centuries yet to come. It will remain there while the appeal is pending to the Appeal Tribunal and then to the Supreme Court. I think if such an appeal is not allowed in matters of this kind people will think that there is something hidden, which the Government do not want brought to the surface. They will think that the lay commissioners because they are given these powers are not permanently fixed in their positions. In other words, it may be hinted that they are removable and that for that reason they are under Ministerial control. It may be that that is not a fact but naturally a person who is affected by this section will arrive at that conclusion. This is a very simple question and if an appeal is allowed on a question of value and of law, I do not see why an appeal should not be granted also on the question of fact.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy has any right to object to the section, because what the Minister for Lands is doing in the section is to divest himself of certain powers he has at the moment. Up to now the Minister for Lands had the right even to say what was bloodstock. What we are doing in this section is to divest the Minister of that power and to vest it in the Minister for Agriculture. That was, of course, the intention in the 1927 Act, but then the Minister for Lands and Agriculture was one and the same person. What we are simply doing is divesting the Minister for Lands of powers that rightly belong to the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

Surely there used to be an appeal to the Judicial Commissioner. In the first instance, the Minister for Agriculture decided whether lands were capable of being used as a stud farm or not, and then the Land Commission decided whether, in fact, the lands were being used as a stud farm or not. Was there not an appeal on that question to the Judicial Commissioner?

Comment on this

Not to the Supreme Court, as Deputy McMenamin desires.

Comment on this

Let us deal with the questions as they are put. The Minister now proposes to remove the right of appeal on the question of fact as to whether the land is being used bona fide as a stud farm or not. The decision of the lay commissioners on that is final. You may appeal to the Appeal Tribunal only on the question of value and law and thence to the Supreme Court only on a question of law. Am I not right in saying that, where the owner of the land disagreed with the Land Commission as to whether the farm was being used as a stud farm, he could go before the Judicial Commissioner and appeal against the finding of the Land Commission that he was not using the land as a stud farm? Does not the Minister propose by sub-section (2) of this section to take away that right of appeal?

Comment on this

The question as to whether land is being used in a bona fide manner as a farm for the purpose of breeding thoroughbred stock must be a mixed question of law and of fact. The interpretation will, of course, be a matter of law, but it will be necessary to find the facts. How you are going to raise a question of law on this section without a decision on the facts I do not know. The wording of the section is “whether any land, whether tenanted or untenanted, is being used in a bona fide manner as a farm for the purpose of breeding thoroughbred stock within the meaning of Section 9 of the Land Act of 1927.”

What is the meaning of the phrase "in a bona fide manner”? Must a farm be mainly devoted to the breeding of thoroughbred stock? It cannot be entirely used for the purpose of breeding thoroughbred stock. I think also that “thoroughbred stock” would bring in not merely a stud farm, properly so called—a stud in which horses are produced—but would also take in any class of thoroughbred stock. You would have a very nice, interesting point as to whether a run of prize poultry were not thoroughbred stock. Though it may surprise you, there is a decision on our books that bees are cattle. It is, I grant you, an old decision, but it is to be found there. There will be a very nice question under this section as to what precisely “thoroughbred stock” is. Taking all the difficulties that may arise on this section into consideration, I think a rehearing on law and on fact might reasonably be given. There will be great difficulty in deciding questions of law unless you have a definite finding of the facts. I do not think that the giving of an appeal on law and on fact in this one section could do very much harm or would take up much of the time of the Appeal Tribunal. If the Minister says that the granting of such a right would not be completely in harmony with the rest of the legislation, I retort that that is no answer. You need not have complete symmetry in a code of law.

Comment on this

I have no special interest in this section, because no thoroughbred stock are bred in my constituency. To me this is purely a question of justice and of law. I wonder what Deputy could tell me the meaning of the phrase "used in a bona fide manner” in this section? Up to quite recently we all thought that to allay our thirst legally we had only to walk a few miles. We found that merely walking the necessary distance to a publichouse did not render a traveller bona fide. I should like any Deputy who thinks he can do so to tell the House what is meant by the “bona fide use” of a farm for any purpose. What does such a phrase cover? No Deputy in the House could tell me what it means in law. I could not even trust myself to do it.

Comment on this

Neither would we.

Comment on this

I am supposed to have got some training in these matters, but I should like to look up a number of authorities and to give considerable consideration to the question before I would venture an opinion as to what this phrase precisely means. Yet the Minister is leaving that question to two lay commissioners without any legal training. I agree with Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney that this is a mixed question of law and fact. One cannot be disentangled from the other. To decide one question properly, the person concerned must have a knowledge of the other. For that reason I think that there should be an appeal to the Appeal Tribunal and to the Supreme Court on these mixed questions of law and fact.

Comment on this

I think that this section ought to be withdrawn. I do not think that the amendment hardly goes sufficiently far. I intend to oppose the section. The breeding of thoroughbred stock is one of the most important industries we have left. Having interfered with almost everything on the land, the Government now propose to interfere with this industry, which is about the last thing left that they can interfere with.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What about the amendment?

Comment on this

Deputy McMenamin is trying to make the section less obnoxious by giving an appeal from the decision of the lay commissioners on questions of law and fact. I support the amendment. It would give some semblance of security to people engaged in the thoroughbred industry. If they felt aggrieved by the decision of the lay commissioners, they could appeal to the Appeal Tribunal. To leave the determination of these matters in the hands of such a body as the lay commissioners is not right. The breeding of thoroughbred horses is a very technical matter and I think that some authority should be provided for in this regard besides the lay commissioners. There should be at least an appeal to some higher tribunal. I support the amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I think that the Minister ought to accept the first portion of the amendment, which would allow an appeal on all matters to the Appeal Tribunal. I would not press the Minister on the point that there should be an appeal to the Supreme Court on any other than a point of law. A substantial case has been made for an appeal from the decision of the lay commissioners on questions of fact as well as of law to the Appeal Tribunal. If the Minister went that distance, he would, I think, meet the case that has been made.

Comment on this

The Land Commission have power to decide much more important things than that and it is not worth while making special provision in this case.

Comment on this

That is an argument on the ground of symmetry, which is one of the most rotten arguments that can be put forward. Because they can have the powers in one direction they should have them in every direction. That is the argument.

I suggest to the Minister that if he comes to think of it his code of law will always be a little better if it is not symmetrical. On the same principle on which the Minister is going, if you have a bed that is too big you can stretch the gentleman out so that he will be long enough to fit in the bed, or you can cut his legs off so that he will be short enough if the bed is a short one. That is not a good principle in legislation. If the Minister cuts these words out he will not be doing any harm. Let him not take symmetry as an argument. This is a definite matter of mixing law and fact. The 20 or 30 cases which will probably arise or that are likely to arise are bona fide stud farms and there should be an appeal in these cases to the Appeal Tribunal. Cannot we be sensible?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is Deputy McMenamin pressing the amendment?

Comment on this

Yes, I am prepared to go to a vote on it if the Minister will not accept the amendment.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 47
·
Níl 26
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I oppose the section. When speaking on the amendment, I stated that bloodstock raising is one of the few things in connection with farming not affected by previous Land Acts. There was some measure of protection left to that industry but if this section does not take it away it gives it a bad shake. Anything that would tend to raise any doubts about the security of our large and small bloodstock farms would to my mind be disastrous. Now we have a new determination in sub-section (1) of this section as to the nature of thoroughbred stock. The Minister for Agriculture is to have the duty of declaring whether the stock are suited to the requirements of the country. The majority of our great bloodstock is not bred to suit the requirements of this country, but mainly to suit the requirements of another country, and our best sale for bloodstock is in another country. If the matter is going to be determined on the lines of whether the stock are suitable or not to this country it will be a wrong determination. I say that the Minister for Agriculture or any other Minister or Deputy is not the person to decide eventually whether the bloodstock produced on any land or stud farm is the right type of bloodstock or not. There could never be agreement between any two men on that matter.

There is no matter on which division of opinion is so great as on that of bloodstock breeding. One man pins his faith to one line of breeding and another man has entirely different views. Under this section the whole future of that industry is placed in the hands of the Minister for Agriculture, who is to declare the nature of the stock we are to breed and to decide whether they are suitable to this country or not. In the past, we have bred innumerable great horses on different farms in this country. The men who bred them were unfettered in the running of their stud farms, as to where they bought their breeding stock, as to the manner in which they used them, and as to what sort of stock they produced. There is no authority that I know of fit to determine, by looking at them, whether a certain type of bloodstock is suitable to the requirements of the country. There have been many famous horses produced here and sold to foreign States which, if examined by one of the Minister's veterinary surgeons, probably would not have been accepted as suitable for breeding here.

I am opposed to any section which interferes in any way with the prosperity of this industry. To my mind, there is in this section a grave danger to the security of our stud farms. There may not be a grave danger to the very big stud farms, because even the Minister would hesitate before venturing to interfere with these. But there will be a danger to the average farmer bloodstock breeder, whom I am particularly anxious to protect, the man with three or four mares who produces, perhaps, three or four yearlings annually. One year perhaps he may not produce two, because luck may be against him. A man like that puts a lot of capital into this industry and is competing against very big interests elsewhere. He is the man who is in danger of being interfered with under this section. The Minister might hesitate to say that the Aga Khan's stud farm in Kildare or Major Loder's stud farm was not an asset to this country, but he might say that the horses that Deputy Fagan was raising were not good horses.

He might decide that they were not suitable to the requirements of this country, and that the stud farm was not carried on on proper lines. The first thing the Minister is to decide is whether, say, Deputy Fagan is breeding thoroughbred stock that is or is not of a nature and character suitable within the meaning of sub-section (1) of Section 9 of the 1927 Act to the requirements of the country. I hope that when the Minister for Agriculture goes to inspect those animals that he will find they are good-natured, and that they will not kick him.

The Minister, I think, is very ill-advised to bring in this section. In previous Acts it was thought proper to protect the interests of bloodstock breeders. I mean those who breed thoroughbred horses. This section might mean anything. It might mean thoroughbred goats, thoroughbred hens or thoroughbred dogs. I am a breeder of dogs, and perhaps it would be open to me to say that I was conducting my farm in a proper way as a breeder of setters, in which, I understand, Deputy McMenamin is interested. But then the Minister for Agriculture might come down to me and say that I was not breeding the proper type of thoroughbred stock. What the Minister is doing in this section is this: he is giving a bad shake to the tenure and security which occupiers have hitherto had in their bloodstock farms. The Minister for Agriculture is to determine the nature and character and, I suppose, the good temper of the animals that are being bred in this country. I do not know what purpose he wants the animals to be available for. The few thoroughbreds that are kept in the country are raced here. The Minister may have in mind the establishment of a race track. That suggestion was put forward recently by some individual interested in racing, and I gathered from what I read in some of the sporting papers that the Minister received him sympathetically. Perhaps that is what the Minister has at the back of his mind in this section—the establishment of a race track in this State, and that the object is to see that horses suitable for running on such a track are bred in the country.

The people who, up to this, have been interested in the breeding of thoroughbred bloodstock would hardly share the view that the Minister for Agriculture is the proper person to decide what particular type of bloodstock should be bred. Individual views count a lot in that industry. There are no two men who will agree on the type of bloodstock that ought to be produced, and it is very unsafe, I suggest, to give to the Minister the powers asked for in this section. I am also strongly opposed to sub-section (2), in which it is proposed to give power to the lay commissioners to determine whether any land, tenanted or untenanted, is being used in a bona fide manner as a farm for the purpose of breeding thoroughbred stock within the meaning of Section 9 of the Land Act of 1927. I say that they are not the men to determine that. That is a matter that should be put in other hands. It might, for instance, be left to a body of prominent racing men.

Comment on this

I am also strongly opposed to this section. Legislation that proposes to interfere with the bloodstock industry of this country is certain to have a very bad effect on it. What we want in this country is more people to breed thoroughbred horses of the right kind. Farmers and others who engage in the industry begin, as a rule, in a small way. Some of the greatest horses that have been bred here have been bred by men who started in a small way, and, therefore, I would urge on the Minister to withdraw this section and not to do anything that would endanger what is one of our greatest industries.

Comment on this

I wish to goodness there was some method by which Deputies could move the adjournment of the debate and not have this thing being talked out as it has been by Deputy Bennett. If Deputy Bennett knew anything about the section he would know that it makes no alteration in the law as it stands.

Comment on this

And the law as it stands is good enough for me.

Comment on this

And for me.

Comment on this

It is ridiculous for anybody to suggest that laymen could decide such matters as are dealt with in this section. Anyone with any knowledge of the breeding of thoroughbred horses would simply laugh at the idea that the Minister for Agriculture was the proper person to decide how animals should be mated to get the best line of blood. A man must have an instinct for that. Neither the lay commissioners nor the Minister would be competent for that job. To prove what I have said that a man must have an instinct for the mating of animals, I may recall that the late Mr. John Gubbins went over to England and bought Kendal, the sire of that great Irish racehorse, Galtee More. It is not the big man in the industry, a man say, like the Aga Khan, who produces the greatest bloodstock, but the small man who has an instinct for the breeding of the best type of thoroughbred horse.

Comment on this

I would also appeal to the Minister not to do anything that would interfere with one of our greatest industries. Irish horses are famous the world over. There are many wealthy people in England who would be anxious to come over here and take large-sized farms for the purpose of breeding horses, because they know—I believe it is due to the nature of the soil—that the Irish-bred horse is the best that can be got for racing purposes, but in view of what is being done by the Government they are afraid to come. I do not think that either the Minister or the lay commissioners should be given the power asked for in this section. As regards myself, I do not feel too secure at present. Six months ago I received notice from the Land Commission that my farm was to be inspected. Previous to that I had intended putting up some more boxes for mares, but following the reception of that notice I did not go ahead with the work. I have heard nothing since from the Land Commission, but at the same time I feel very insecure. The horse-breeding industry is one that gives a very large amount of employment, more, I think, than any other industry, and, therefore, the Minister should not do anything that would make the people who are carrying it on feel insecure.

The young animals have to be fed at least twice a day and men have to be paid to look after them. Everything has to be watched carefully and the rearing of those animals really gives a lot of employment. If you go to any stud farm you will find that there is more employment given there proportionately, than in any other industry in the country. I would strongly advise the Minister to include some section that will give the owners of stud farms a sense of security, a feeling that they will be able to carry on without much interference. As Deputies are no doubt aware, it takes years to make a name for a good stud farm. Ireland is noted all over the world for the breeding of good horses and I believe the Minister will be doing a good day's work for Ireland by announcing that any people who desire to establish stud farms here will never be disturbed.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 46
·
Níl 27
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?