Adjournment Motion.
Contributions 1–180 of 561. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I doubt if the House, within the last couple of years, has ever been asked to adjourn in a period of greater uncertainty. The adjournment will be for the space of some months, months that in many ways, as we are led to believe, may be decisive for the future of this country. There is uncertainty in practically every sphere affecting the lives of citizens; uncertainty as to the future national status of the country; uncertainty as to the economic prospect that faces the country and, if possible, more uncertainty than usual on the fate of the principal industry of the country. It seems to have been the deliberate policy of the Government for a number of years to foster such uncertainty. I will admit that before they came into office, and also during their tenure of office, as a political Party they have battened to a certain extent on it. It seems to have been their policy to do nothing to allay but to do everything to increase that uncertainty. It is an uncertainty that is extremely unhealthy.
If you turn your attention to the economic war, if you read the statements recently made by the Vice-President and by his nominal chief, who really is the one man in the Government so far as these things are concerned, namely, the President, can anyone tell the policy of the Government? I know the Vice-President on all occasions, especially for the last couple of years, has encouraged the idea that there is going to be a settlement. On the other hand, except the facts have become definitely established, and the people can physically, so to say, see the negotiations going on, the President denies the existence of any negotiations. What is the present position so far as that most important of all problems for this country is concerned? Members of the Government challenge other Parties on their policy, but they are the Government and they refuse to give any indication of their policy in any of the vital issues that confront the country. You cannot judge what their policy is either from their statements or from their actions.
The Vice-President, as usual, hints, almost states, that we are on the eve of a most magnificent settlement. We have had that type of statement for nearly four years. That statement is immediately blown upon by the President, who, at the most, asks the people to be satisfied with a vague promise that he will make a good settlement. When? Surely the time has come, now that this war has been on four years, to let the people know on what lines he intends to settle, to let the people know what are the obstacles that prevent him from settling, why it is that he is apparently unable to meet the desires, not merely of the country but of people high placed in his own Party, for a settlement. I am there assuming that the statements of the Vice-President, if they do not represent fact, at least represent good will on his part on this question of a settlement.
Turn to their agricultural policy and you have the same uncertainty. What is the attitude of the Department of Agriculture—I mean the present Minister for Agriculture and, perhaps, even still more correctly I could say the Government, speaking through the Minister—what is their policy as regards the cattle industry? At one period we were told they stood for an increase in the number of cattle and, a short time afterwards, we were told that that was the wrong policy, that we must have less cattle. Now, we have a statement from the Minister boasting that he is exporting more cattle than ever. What is the policy? Is it not the deliberate tactics of the Government to play fast and loose, not merely with the resources, the prosperity and the safety of the country, but with the credulity of the country? Again and again with cynical indifference, with cynical contempt, they have dangled the carrots before the Irish people. That is the way the Government Party at least look at it— dangling a carrot; that is the way they regard the Irish people. We have promise after promise in all these major issues, but no effort to fulfil them. All this policy is supposed to be subordinate to their great policy of establishing the national status, but can anybody tell what their policy even in that connection is? What do they want for this country and how are they going to achieve it?
I admit that the present Government can go to limits which we would hardly expect even from them. I think it was last week-end I saw in the papers that the Minister for Finance challenged the republicans as to what they wanted. Did they want a republic for the twenty-six counties? Was their policy a republic for the thirty-two counties, and if so how were they going to achieve it? Were they going to make war on Ulster in order to achieve it? From his military knowledge, he demonstrated the futility of a policy of that kind. Remember, this is a question being put by the body which claims to be the Government, by a Minister of the Government, an important member of what claims to be the largest Party in this State, to what they regard as an unimportant faction. Those are the very questions which have been put up to themselves again and again and which they have always refused to answer. A couple of days after the Minister for Finance flung that challenge to the republicans of Wexford, a question was put to the President in this House about what his policy was as regards the status of this country in the future, and the only answer which could be got from him was "wait and see." Yet, the Minister for Finance could challenge the republicans to answer those questions which he himself and his chief refused to answer. There is deliberate uncertainty. There is refusal to let the people of Ireland, whom they pretend to serve, into whatever secrets they have-if they have any-about the future status of this country.
What is to be our attitude towards the Commonwealth? They have been asked that question again and again. They have been asked it by the members of this Party, and by other members of this House who do not belong to this Party. The same question in a different form, approached from a different angle if you like, has been put to them by the Republicans. They refuse to answer. Their policy is: "Wait and see." They can challenge the unimportant faction which has the impertinence to oppose them in Wexford, namely the Republican Party, as to what the Republican answer is to those questions. But they themselves, even though they are the Government, even though it is their business, before it is anybody's business, to formulate a policy, have refused to formulate a policy. No matter where you turn, in all the principal items of policy you have nothing but uncertainty. If the question is plainly put to them whether they intend to avail of the advantages that ought to be got from membership of the British Commonwealth of Nations no answer can be got. The Republicans can get no answer; Fine Gael can get no answer, and of course they would not think of answering the Labour Party. They know there is no necessity to do that. The most they would get from the Labour Party is a friendly warning, as Deputy Davin on one occasion gave them.
But have they a policy? If they have a policy, do they think it in keeping with their new professions of democracy that they should conceal that policy longer than is necessary from the people of this country? We all read, with a certain amount of satisfaction from one point of view, a statement made by the President of the Executive Council some days ago in Galway. May I say straight away that I regard that statement, the mere issuing of that statement, the sentiments conveyed and the principles laid down in it, as important, and it was well that these principles have been laid down. I think that the State—perhaps even the Party in the long run-has reason to congratulate itself that at last that statement was made. I do not criticise it on the grounds that it could have been put together, every single sentence of it, by the use of the scissors and the paste, from the speeches made by the members who now sit on this side of the House when they were members of the Government. I do not think there is a single paragraph, a single sentence, in that statement of the President that could not have been taken, word for word, from the statements and from the enunciations of policy of their predecessors in office. I hope that the fact that that statement is made, not so much by the President of the Executive Council as by the head of the Fianna Fáil Party, even in the year 1936, is for the advantage of the country. But if I look upon that statement as an important statement, and if I welcome it as an advance, surely it is all the greater criticism on that Party and on the leader of that Party that we had to wait until 1936 for this excellent enunciation of those excellent principles.
Comment on this
I am dealing with what I consider an important contribution to the political life of this country. I cannot misinterpret the Deputy in the rather ludicrous fashion in which the Minister for Finance misunderstood his interruption yesterday evening, but I cannot take his interruptions too seriously. It is important that that statement should have been made, but I repeat that I know no more severe criticism of that Party, and of the head of that Party, and of his leadership in politics in this country, than we are able to greet the statement as an important contribution, that we have to wait until the year 1936 for that particular enunciation of principles. I am taking it at its face value. The testing time will come for that Party and for the man who made that enunciation of principle— not when he himself has the majority, but when other people have the majority. Let us hope that he will then have the same reverence for those principles which he has for them now that he has the majority and now that he is head of the Government. If we could be sure of that, there would be a tremendous advance made in the political life of this country. But I am just a bit uneasy, and for this reason: I remember in a debate in this House, when he was President, the same leader stated from the Front Bench opposite that he was in favour of and stood by the principles of democracy and majority rule. That was a statement which I was remarkably glad to hear on that occasion, but it made me very uneasy when he followed up that statement with the further statement that he had always stood for that principle of majority rule. Well, if he is going to honour those principles enunciated two days ago in the same way as he had frequently honoured majority rule, then the statement has not the full value that I should like it to have. Still, taking the statement as it is, it is now laid down— and I attach the greater importance to it precisely owing to the extraordinary history of that particular Party in this matter—that resistance by force of arms to the lawfully established Government here has no justification. In the matter of inflammatory speeches, in the matter of carelessness of words which may mislead the youth, the enunciation that no body of men have a right to use force against the lawfully established Government of this country we have a statement of sound principle, and the fact that that statement comes from a Party that for so long had scant respect for these principles makes it all the more important. "The sad thing," he says, "about the present position is that people who may be regarded as responsible and who are old enough to have experience and sense come out on public platforms and, in the most irresponsible manner, use language the effect of which must be to incite young people to a course of action that could have no other end but that of bloodshed and anarchy"—a perfectly sound piece of advice, and all the more telling, coming from the quarter from which it comes; all the more telling and valuable when we remember the number of times we had cause to complain that, however logically certain language might be explained away, the effect on the young could have been only one thing, and that is the actual thing that had occurred—bloodshed.
We have, as I say, a position of uncertainty. There is one—just one— slight solace in the mass of uncertainty that the country is facing at the present moment, and that is the uncertainty that the Government itself is facing. From the point of view of the country that is, if I might quote from a statesman whom the Government seems now to honour by copying the author of "Wait and See"—the one bright spot—the uncertainty as I say— the more than uncertainty, if that is a permissible expression—of the Government position itself. There is uncertainty created everywhere. There is uncertainty in business as a result of this continuous interference; an interference that has grown by leaps and bounds; that has increased, so to speak, with compound interest since the Government came into office. So far as the business of this country is concerned, whether it be agriculture, horse-breeding, manufacture, salesmanship, and so on, the one idea of the Government is that they are not doing their duty unless they interfere. The very challenge they sometimes issue to their opponents—"What did you do for so-and-so when you were in power?"—betrays their type of mind. They cannot let things alone. They think they are neglecting their duty if they are not interfering. We see that everywhere.
This afternoon we were dealing with the Fifth Stage of a Bill, and, with all respect, despite the different statements I have heard, that Bill does create uncertainty so far as land tenure is concerned. Not merely does that Bill do it, but the statement made by the present Minister for Lands increases that uncertainty. I ask the members of the House, when the country sees certain powers taken by the Land Commission, powers which undoubtedly, whatever may be said about it, do interfere and do trench upon fixity of tenure in a way that has not been done before, or, to avoid controversy, to a greater extent than has been done before—when they see that and connect that up with statements made again and again, not on one occasion merely, not in a mere burst of eloquence such as one might expect from the Minister for Finance, but apparently a deliberate statement made time and again by the Minister for Lands, the man who is responsible for lands at the present moment, about taking land from the people if they do not work it properly—how can there be anything except growing uncertainty in the minds of the ordinary farmers of this country in that respect? They say they need these powers in order to deal with some abuses that they say are present, but what they do not realise is that they are undermining a principle that is more important than the remedies that they themselves are suggesting. That is a thing they never can grasp either here or in anything else. In order to have an immediate gain, or, if you like to put it from their point of view, in order to remedy an evil that is obvious for the moment, they will undermine a principle the undermining of which will mean a tremendous amount of damage and loss to this country in the long run. That is what they are doing as regards the land.
It is not a question as to how much has been done up to the present. It is the question that, as a result of what is now being done and as a result of the statements made by the Ministers of the Government, you have, naturally, a fear as to where it is going to stop. Even a Deputy this evening who defended that policy said that there was no other question on which he got so many letters from his constituency. What does that prove? It proves the very danger of opening the gate. Everybody who is familiar with life in this country knows perfectly well that it is the very land scarcity and the very land hunger evidenced by these letters, to which a reference was made even by a Deputy defending the Bill, that in itself is a proof of the danger of interfering with the principle at all. Once start interfering with that principle and you cannot stop.
Comment on this
They did not. Excuse me, Deputy. The 1923 Land Purchase Act did what all other Land Purchase Acts attempted to do, and it had the purpose of definitely saying that when a man had his land vested he was secured in the ownership of that land. The Land Purchase Acts were the culminating point of a long attempt to settle the land question in this country, and the basis of the settlement—the fundamental principle of the settlement—was that once land was vested the farmer was the owner of that land and he could not be disturbed. The principle was not disturbed in 1923—the principle that once the land was vested the farmer was the owner of the land and could not be disturbed. The 1923 Act had the same fundamental principle as all the other Land Acts, and it is a great mistake to hint, as was partly hinted this evening, that even landlords recognise that there is no absolute right in property. To equate the system of landlordism in this country, which was inherently vicious, and proved itself in practice to be particularly vicious, with ownership by farmers is completely unsound. When such a comparison is even hinted at, no wonder the farmers grow uneasy.
As I say, we have this interference everywhere. I understand that there is a little controversy going on at the present moment between the Labour Party and the Government. It generally occurs only at by-elections, so possibly we need not attribute too much importance to it. We, on this side of the House, have often had to call attention to one particular fact, and that is that no matter what the intentions of the Government were, no matter what the individual views of the members of the Government were, the policy that they were adopting was, or at least —shall I put it more accurately—portions of their policy were, if not leading to Communism, at least making smooth the way to Communism.
I think that is clear. It has always been clear to me, especially so far as their policy in the opening years is concerned. Their statements are a little more careful now; I am not aware, however, that their action so far as land is concerned has improved. But we were always scoffed at by the President when we pointed out that danger. I think the scoffing was joined in by the Labour Party even.
Comment on this
I might as well, because the Labour Party never does. We now have a member of the Government and the leader of the Labour Party at loggerheads as to which of them is the Communist. The Attorney-General warns Deputy Norton, and I presume he knew why he thought it necessary to issue a warning. We must assume that the Attorney-General of the Government so loyally supported by the Labour Party, with which the Labour Party has been in such close touch for a number of years, knew what he was talking about. He warns the Labour Party of the dangers of Communism and of the path they are treading towards the united front. What is the challenge thrown out by the leader of the Labour Party who ought to be in a position to know since he has been in close touch with the Government Party for a number of years, giving them advice and friendly warnings occasionally? What is his answer? That he knows as a fact that members of that Party have trucked with the Communist Parties in other countries.
Comment on this
I do not know whether I have the actual Press issue here. If I have I shall quote them; if I have not I shall not; but I can tell the Deputy where he can find them. He will find it in the Independent's“Late News” of yesterday or the day before. There a challenge is thrown out by Deputy Norton to the Attorney-General to deny that. Does the Attorney-General know that there were members of his Party who had that communication with Communists in other lands? Did Deputy Norton all these years know that?
Comment on this
He apparently is. Am I to assume that the Labour Party knew there were negotiations going on between members of the Government Party and the Communist Parties in other lands?
Comment on this
You can attack people who are absent. It is very easy to attack people who are absent. I have never heard that any member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party ever entered into any negotiations with any such body.
Comment on this
That members on the Government Benches were in touch with certain people at certain times.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the challenge that was thrown out by the Deputy's Leader. We did not support a Party partly composed of Communists through all these years as the Deputy's Party professedly did.
Comment on this
All those years with that knowledge in their possession they supported that Party. It is a pretty controversy. Let them decide it between them. The Attorney-General has his opportunity this evening and Deputy Norton has his of meeting the Attorney-General here where they can have it out between them. We are waiting to know whether they will avail of that opportunity. There is plenty of time for that to be decided by the two Deputies who can make the charges facing each other. On the economic war all the country is asked to do is to solace itself with the prophecy that there is going to be a good bargain. Are you making it? "No!" When are you making it? "Wait and see!"
You are going to have a Constitution. Is it going to be Republican? "Wait and see." Is it going to be within the Dominions? "Wait and see." Every other Party must have definitely made up its mind, but the only Party that refuses to give any information to the country is the Government Party. The Vice-President is here. In the goodness of his heart, having the welfare of the country at heart, he was apparently misled into a statement that we were on the eve of a good bargain—negotiations were going on and should not be interfered with. I have excused that statement on his part, because I recognise that he realised that such a bargain is necessary to the country. I think the Vice-President, although he occasionally waves the Republican as distinct from the Dominion tricolour—and it is not easy always to know which particular one he is waving—does recognise that a settlement is necessary. Any statements he has ever made seem to show that, and any statements he has ever been asked to explain away seem to show that. He is in charge of the House this evening. Are we to take his view that we are on the eve of that settlement, and that steps will be taken to lead to that good settlement immediately, and is the President completely ignorant of what is going on? Those are questions on which he ought to enlighten the mind of the country. After all there are few things in which the country is more interested. I firmly believe that the bulk of the people at the moment are much more interested in this than they are in the Constitution-mongering with which the Minister's Party are trying to befool the country. But not even in the Constitution situation will they give any lead or will they tell the country what their policy is. Is that sound? Is it wise at a time of unrest in the country, unrest with which they themselves have had to deal, to keep the country in that position? There was a statement made yesterday by the Minister for Education, acting for the moment as Minister for Industry and Commerce. "Public psychology," he said, "is the most important element in insurance." Deputy Flinn finds it apparently difficult to understand it, but I can assure Deputy Flinn that that is the statement. I agree with it. Confidence, that feeling of confidence which the people ought to have, is of great value. Can anybody say that the Government is promoting that feeling of confidence in any important sphere of public life in this country at present? Is it not doing the very opposite? Here are a few of the main questions the country is faced with; and only a few. I mention them merely because I think they are indicative of the policy of the Government in every sphere. I ask members of all Parties to consider, not what I have said, but to consider these questions, because they are the questions in which I believe the people are interested and about which the people ought to know the mind of the Government. After all this is the place to find out the views of the Government on any of these important matters, but in all of them we have failed up to the present to find out what their views are—if they have any views.
Does Deputy Davin want the actual quotation from Deputy Norton?
Comment on this
"Labour," added Mr. Norton replying to the criticism of Mr. Conor Maguire, Attorney-General, "knew the dangers of Communism, and had never had any association with it. I publicly challenge the Attorney-General," he said, "to say the same about some members of the Fianna Fáil Party who have openly trucked with Communism and openly advocated it inside and outside this country."
That is perfectly definite at all events. It may be that the Deputy seems partly anxious to suggest that Deputy Norton never said it.
Comment on this
May I point out that we never gave our support to that Party opposite. The Labour Party has given consistent support to that Party—now denounced as in part Communist—notwithstanding statements of that kind.
Comment on this
I read with a certain amount of concern, and I am sure other Deputies are in the same position, the recent rather hysterical speeches made by the President, and by some of the Ministers, in connection with matters on which I would like to have more information, and which, I think, are pertinent to the discussion on the Motion for the Adjournment. We all read with a great deal of regret the sensational speech, or as it was described to me by some Fianna Fáil supporters, the Hamar Greenwood speech, made by the Minister for Finance in Balbriggan during the course of the recent City and County Dublin municipal elections. The part of that speech that I want to refer to is a statement that I think was never previously made by any Minister in any Government in this or any other country, in which he dealt with the pending trial of a prisoner, then in the hands of the Government, and prejudged, apparently correctly, the decision of the Military Tribunal concerning that prisoner. We also had threatening speeches made by the President. The people were threatened with a general election if they did not maintain for him the clear majority in this House which he held up to recently, but which he lost as a result of the resignation of one Deputy in his Party. In some of the speeches made by the President he referred to the Constitution which he said would be produced to this House during the autumn session, and submitted to the people at the next general election. In the course of another speech concerning the Constitution the President said it was likely to be referred to the people by way of referendum. I am just mentioning these two rather conflicting statements of the President, for the purpose of ascertaining from whoever replies, what the present policy of the Government is in connection with the Constitution.
Has the Government made up its mind to restore the referendum machinery in the Constitution? We all remember that on one occasion, shortly after the Fianna Fáil Party entered this House, they rightly endeavoured to make use of the referendum machinery then in existence for the purpose of ascertaining the views of the electorate upon an important question. The then Government Party, now the Opposition, took the necessary steps at that time to remove the referendum machinery from the Constitution, and we had very strong protests from Deputy de Valera, as he then was, and a very definite assurance, on many occasions, that if he was in office the referendum machinery would be restored to the Constitution. I want to know quite definitely whether it is the intention of the Government to refer the Constitution, when it passes through this House in the autumn, or during some coming Session, to refer it to the people by way of referendum, or whether it is the intention to mix up such an important question with many others that have to be referred to the people during a general election. Although my colleagues may not agree with me, I think one of the greatest blunders that was made was that the Treaty was not referred at a particular period to the people, and their wishes on it taken. I dare say that if the Treaty had been referred to the people at the time, we would have avoided the consequences of the terrible civil war that followed. At the time the majority of the members of the Dáil decided to accept the Treaty. I am very definitely in favour of referring all major political matters, and particularly a matter which only arises once in a generation, to the people, to enable them to say yes or no on big political issues of that kind. I wonder do the President and his colleagues think it is necessary that the Fianna Fáil Party, as a Party, should maintain a clear majority over all other Parties in the House, in order to complete their political and economic programmes.
As far as I could read from recent speeches of some of our new political leaders, there is very little difference between them. If one takes up the speeches of Professor Hogan in Galway and the speeches of Fianna Fáil speakers, or of the Minister for Local Government, there is very little, if any, difference between the Fine Gael and the Fianna Fáil Parties on some big political issues that are now being discussed. From statements made yesterday by Professor Hogan— made I am sure with the authority of his leader, Deputy Cosgrave—he welcomes the coming together of the two main Parties. May I express the hope, which I am sure is the hope of a big section of the electorate, that that very desirable coalition will take place in the near future. There are many things in common between those who sit on the Government and on the Opposition Benches. Many things promised the people by both Parties were never fulfilled. The old Sinn Féin Party of which all front bench Deputies on both sides were members promised town tenants when we got freedom that they would get everything they were looking for. Deputy Cosgrave was head of the Government for ten years, and during his term of office nothing was done for the town tenants. When in opposition, members of the present Government promised to do for town tenants what Deputy Cosgrave was not then willing to do. We had a remarkable statement from the Minister for Finance some time ago, definitely stating that it was not the intention of the Government, during its term of office, to bring in any measure making provision for the purchase of their houses by town tenants, and a majority vote to back that was secured at the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis. There are many other matters, affecting the well-being of sections of the people, on which both Parties could agree, and the sooner they come together and do many of the things they promised in the past the better it will be for the electors as a whole. Personally, I welcome some of the statements made recently by some of our new political leaders, and I hope it is an indication of a change for the better on the part of those who have been pretending to speak—Deputy Dillon for instance—for the Opposition Party.
Before the Government took office they promised that they had a very definite plan which they were prepared to put into operation for the purpose of solving the unemployment problem. I want to know from whatever Minister replies on behalf of the Government, if they are satisfied that they have made any progress along the lines which they said they had for solving this problem before they took office. On March 24th of this year there were 140,000 persons registered at the local labour exchanges. Speaking at Enniscorthy the other day the Minister for Agriculture said that the Government had done its best to try to find employment for the people who were willing to work. He went on and made the remarkable statement that while waiting for employment they saw to it, to use his own words, that anybody who could not find employment was not left in want. I wonder was the Minister for Agriculture conscious of some of the things that he voted for in this House during the last three or four months. He voted for a period Order, made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce some months ago, and as a result of that Order coming into operation no less than 72,000 persons were removed from the list of those entitled to maintenance under the Unemployment Assistance Act. On May 25th the number on the register, as the result of the operation of the First Period Order, was 109,000, and on August 4th that number was reduced to 69,000. I want to know from the Minister, or from the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, who was once described in this House as the Minister for Unemployment, whether the 72,000 persons who have been removed off the register as a result of the two Period Orders, have found useful work, and if so, for how long?
The Minister for Industry and Commerce in defending the bringing into operation of the two Period Orders definitely expressed the opinion here that all those who were being struck off the maintenance list were in a position to secure work, and he indicated that £2,500,000 had been set aside to provide work for some or for all of those struck off the register. I want to know from the Parliamentary Secretary how much of the £2,500,000 has been allocated to the various local authorities, or to different Departments of State, for the purpose of providing work, and how many people are actually at work as a result of the spending of that money?
I want to see how many of the 72,000 persons struck off the register are actually working at present as a result of the provision of £2,500,000 this year for the relief of unemployment. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will give us figures which will enable us to arrive at a fair conclusion as to the merits of this important matter. Apart altogether from the suffering and want which exist, notwithstanding the statement of the Minister for Agriculture, there is considerable criticism and complaint in connection with the miserably mean way in which the Unemployment Assistance Act is being administered so far as those now entitled to receive unemployment assistance are concerned. The means test, which has been applied very rigidly, has made it utterly impossible for many able-bodied men with dependants to secure the necessaries of life with the small amounts they are granted under the terms of the Act. The evidence is there for anybody who wants it. The various boards of health are compelled to supplement the miserable sums provided under the Unemployment Assistance Act for many of the 69,000 who are still on the register and entitled to assistance. The President, in making his policy-statement in this House shortly after he took office, promised that he would either provide work for the unemployed or provide them with a decent standard of maintenance. Is it suggested that, even now, with the amount paid to those still in receipt of unemployment assistance, it is possible for an able-bodied married man to maintain himself and his dependents in decency and comfort? If so, why should it be necessary, as it is necessary, for these people to fall back on the local authorities and the ratepayers in order to have supplemented the miserable sums paid under the Act? If there was any meaning to be taken from the pledge given, it was that those for whom it was not possible to find work would be maintained by the State and the taxpayers and not by the local authorities and the ratepayers. They were to be maintained in a decent standard of comfort while waiting for work to come along.
Comment on this
Would the Minister for Agriculture write to the secretary of the Wexford Board of Health or somebody else in authority and find out whether the statement he made in Enniscorthy on Sunday night week— that they saw nobody left in want—is accurate? The minister does not appear to know the facts in regard to his own constituency. Innumerable cases have been brought to my notice where people were struck off the register and told to travel three or five miles and perform a type of work to which they had not been accustomed.
I have sent these cases to the Department of Industry and Commerce. On appeal, some of these cases were allowed by the officers appointed by the Minister. But, while these complaints were being investigated and while appeals were pending, the people concerned in Wexford and elsewhere were in want. The statement made by the Minister for Agriculture—that they saw nobody in want—would not be made by any Minister or any member of the Fianna Fáil Party or any member of the House who had knowledge of existing conditions.
I have been listening to most of the discussion on the Land Bill, which passed its final stage to-day. I am an enthusiastic supporter of the Land Bill. I supported it in silence with greater enthusiasm than those who supported it by speech. I heard the Minister for Lands repeatedly make the statement that it was the intention of the Government to give land to those able to work it and to take it from those who refused to work it. Does the President or the Minister for Agriculture know the reason—I think the Minister for Agriculture knows— why many large and small farmers are unable to work their land to the best possible advantage even in their own personal interest, apart from the national interest?
Comment on this
No, it is because of the rotten banking system and the lack of provision of working capital which would enable farmers to work the land to the best advantage. It was suggested in the discussions here, in which Deputy Belton took part, that since the passing of the 1933 Act it was impossible to get accommodation for farmers to enable them to work their land. So far as I am aware —and I am in fairly close touch with the small farmers——
Comment on this
——I do not know any bank which has been in any way generous in lending money on the security of land since the passing of the 1923 Act. Deputy Belton ought to know that as well as anybody else. Deputy Belton knew when he was representing a rural part of the country something about the condition of the farmers, but since he came to represent the North City of Dublin he has got a purely city outlook, and I do not think that he is competent to talk in the same manner about the present condition of the farmers. I admit that Deputy Belton is a good working farmer and a good employer, but he has absorbed the city outlook since the north city adopted him as one of its representatives.
Comment on this
The present Government is responsible for the setting up of a Banking Commission. That Commission consists of a pretty large army of bankers and was set up about two years ago. I wonder could we get anything from the Vice-President, or some of his colleagues as to the present position in regard to that particular Commission? Have they so far submitted an interim report? If so, will we be furnished with particulars as to the nature of the recommendations made by the Commission? When is the report of the Banking Commission, interim or final, likely to be published? Whether this country is associated with the Commonwealth, or is an independent Republic in future, it is not going to help the farmers of the country one iota to work their land more profitably or to get better credit facilities for the working of the land. The future prosperity of the farmers, the workers, and indeed the whole of our people, is bound up with the future of the banking system and the extent to which this Government or any future Government will provide better facilities for the farmers of the country to work their land to better advantage. Does the Government believe that the Agricultural Credit Corporation, for instance, serves that particular purpose or that the granting of loans by the Agricultural Credit Corporation on an annuity basis at the rate of 5 or 6 per cent. interest is a proper way to meet the reasonable needs of the farmers of this country in regard to applications for loans? The Government is able to borrow, and has borrowed money from the people at the rate of 3½ per cent., and a State institution like the Agricultural Credit Corporation insists on getting 6 per cent. from some of the same people, on money borrowed for agricultural purposes on an annuity basis. I think some profit must be made by the Agricultural Credit Corporation in carrying on operations under these particular conditions. I notice the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance is smiling. I know he is an expert in finance and an expert on other matters such as income-tax. I should like to know whether he is of opinion that the Agricultural Credit Corporation meets the reasonable needs of the farming community, or whether the farming community are being provided with loans under reasonable conditions by that particular body as at present constituted.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Finance have power to nominate certain representatives on the Board of the Agricultural Credit Corporation and, if I am correctly informed, the Government can control the policy of the Agricultural Credit Corporation.
Comment on this
In any case, if the farmers of the country are to be asked to work their land in the national interests or even in their own personal interest, they will have to be given cheaper money.
Comment on this
The same thing applies to the Industrial Credit Company, which is responsible to some extent for financing some of our industrial concerns. I should like to see these two bodies, as at present constituted, scrapped. That is the reason that I am asking for some information in regard to the report of the Banking Commission. I am wondering whether the Banking Commission, referred to by some people as the Bankers' Commission, have made any recommendations in connection with the existing constitution of the Agricultural Credit Corporation and the Industrial Credit Company. I have had cases brought to my notice where the Industrial Credit Company refused to underwrite shares for purely Irish companies that were established under the auspices of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Deputy Norton asked a question about four months ago in the Dáil as to whether a certain firm had complied with the conditions laid down under the Control of Manufactures Act before the Minister sanctioned the issue of a licence to that particular firm. Deputy Norton was told quite definitely, after putting several supplementary questions, that the firm had not complied with the conditions of the Control of Manufactures Act, that, in other words, it was given a special licence. That particular firm composed of a number of foreigners—and by foreigners I do not mean Englishmen—got a licence from the Minister for Industry and Commerce. They applied to the Industrial Credit Company to underwrite their share and the Industrial Credit Company agreed to do so. Later on an Irish firm, whose board consisted of a number of well-known Irishmen, applied to the same concern to underwrite their shares in the same way and they were turned down.
I make the point that there is something radically wrong with that concern, which has some responsibility to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance for its administration. I understand the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance have the right to nominate some of the members of the Industrial Credit Company. The Minister for Industry and Commerce issued a licence for the establishment of a certain Irish industry, the board of which consisted altogether of Irishmen. The representatives of the Minister on the Industrial Credit Company, which is a semi-State concern supposed to be set up for financing our new industrial concerns, refuses to underwrite the shares in the case of the Irish concern and actually agrees to underwrite the shares of the foreign firm that came in here under a special licence. There is, I submit, something radically wrong in the constitution or control of the Industrial Credit Company when a thing like that can happen, and I should like to see it reorganised or scrapped altogether. If we are going to have Irish industry and have it financed by Irish citizens, let us have a clear-cut policy defined for the Industrial Credit Company. One would at least expect that they would treat an application from an Irish firm as favourably as an application from a foreign firm.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy suggest that the Minister for Industry and Commerce should not issue a licence in relation to any company in respect to which he was not prepared to say that the Industrial Credit Company must underwrite its shares?
Comment on this
If the Control of Manufactures Act professes, as it does to me, the industrial policy of the present Government, I think in the first instance the Minister for Industry and Commerce should not issue a special licence to foreigners who were not prepared to comply with the conditions laid down in the Act. If the Minister for Industry and Commerce sanctions and gives every possible assistance to the establishment of an Irish industry, he should have sufficient influence with his representatives on the Industrial Credit Company to make that company underwrite the shares of an Irish company.
Comment on this
Again would the Deputy say, if the Minister is prepared to issue a licence to any particular firm, whether he must, at the same time, take the responsibility of guaranteeing to underwrite its shares? That is the issue.
Comment on this
I know he cannot do so personally because he claims that he has no direct control over the administration of the Industrial Credit Company but he should be able to exercise sufficient influence on the board of that concern to see that they do not go contrary to his own industrial policy. I think I have made myself clear to the Parliamentary Secretary.
Comment on this
It was not set up in our time. It was set up between the two of you. You have all your money in it.
Comment on this
I am not going to be put through a sort of courtmartial performance by Deputy McGilligan. Deputy McGilligan knows that the same people operated this particular section or department during his Ministry.
Comment on this
I am appearing for Deputy Davin this time. He is making a mistake—I am not against him.
Comment on this
I want to refer, and I think it is pertinent to a discussion on the Motion for the Adjournment, to the recent attitude of the present Government, in condoning or actually helping in every possible way the lowering of the standard of wages paid on State-aided schemes. Cases have been brought to the notice of this House on the Estimates for the different Departments in which it was shown that the Minister for Lands, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance were responsible and accepted responsibility for lowering the rates of wages previously paid to persons employed on afforestation, peat development schemes, land improvement schemes and arterial drainage schemes. I brought to the notice of the Parliamentary Secretary for Lands in this House, and so have Deputy Pattison and other Deputies here, cases where the rates of wages paid on afforestation schemes have been reduced during the last two years. I want to say quite emphatically that we do not stand for lowering the rates of wages paid on State-aided schemes particularly when the cost of the necessaries of life has gone up so enormously as it has in the last few years.
Comment on this
I am glad Deputy Anthony has put that question to me. I would remind the Deputy that in this House on a particular occasion I moved that the Vote be referred back in the case of the Minister for Lands. I would like Deputy Anthony to ask two Deputies, who sit on the Opposition side of the House, what their action on that Vote was; I want him to ask them what they were doing in this building on that occasion, and why they refused to go into the Lobby and vote. I wish to remind the Deputy that if they had voted with me on that occasion my Motion would have been carried as an effective protest.
Comment on this
If those two Deputies had come into the House and voted for my Motion the Vote would have been referred back.
Comment on this
Apparently what Deputy Davin is talking about is a dead-heat. It was not a win at all.
Comment on this
That was the most effective thing I could do as a protest against the lowering of wages paid in that particular Department.
Comment on this
I will give Deputy Cosgrave the names of the two Deputies of his Party who walked out on that occasion.
Comment on this
I am not interested in that matter. They may have been paired to save their faces. One of the Deputies who walked out of the House actually took part in the debate.
Comment on this
All that may be very interesting to the Deputy but it does not seem to be relevant on the Adjournment Debate; neither is a rehash of the Estimates relevant.
Comment on this
I am sorry that I was drawn into this by Deputies Cosgrave and Anthony. I want now to draw attention to the fact that the State Departments of Lands and Forestry, the Board of Works—the board of no works I call it in regard to some matters——
Comment on this
I do not. I was saying the Department of Lands and Forestry, the Board of Works, and the Peat Development Section of the Department of Industry and Commerce succeeded in getting licences, or succeeded in getting permission authorising them not to apply the Conditions of Employment Act to the workers employed in the Departments mentioned. If this Government passes a Conditions of Employment Act for the purpose of improving the conditions of the workers employed by private employers in the country, they should at least give good example themselves and conform generally to the conditions laid down in that Act. It is a bad thing for any Government to dictate to outside employers as to the conditions that have to be given to their workers and at the same time seek to obtain a release from the responsibility of doing the same or better for their own employees. I think the Government should be the best employers in the country and should give good example with regard to the conditions of employment and wages. I think it was very wrong for the Minister for Industry and Commerce to refuse to apply the Conditions of Employment Act to certain workers employed in certain State Departments——
Comment on this
I want to draw attention to the petty and mean way in which the Widows and Orphans Act is being administered.
Comment on this
These are matters for the Estimates. The Deputy will realise that it would be impossible for the Minister to deal with items already raised on the Estimates if again raised on the Adjournment Debate.
Comment on this
On matters of principle I am not ruling the Deputy out. But details of Estimates are not suitable matters to raise on an Adjournment Motion.
Comment on this
This Government promised that they would bring in an amending Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Bill which would relieve the ratepayers of the country of their obligations of maintaining widows and orphans who were deprived of their breadwinners.
Comment on this
That Act in its working has disclosed the fact that thousands of necessitous widows and orphans have been completely cut out from any consideration under it. The application of the means test has resulted, in hundreds of cases, of widows and orphans being obliged to go back to the boards of assistance to get a supplementary payment in order to maintain themselves in decency and comfort. The main reason why I raised this question on the Adjournment Debate is this—the Minister for Local Government and Public Health in a speech in the country and also in the course of a subsequent statement in this House promised to introduce an amending Widows' and Orphans' Bill. I want to know from him if it is intended to bring in such a Bill and pass it during the coming Autumn session? It is for that reason that I have referred to this matter.
I want to refer to another matter of national importance. We have all read with horror some of the reports received with regard to conditions in Spain. There have been allegations that during recent weeks priests and nuns and religious communities generally have been massacred by the Government and the citizens of that country. We have diplomatic representatives who are supposed to be in touch with Spain and with the other countries of the world. When the Vice-President is replying, I would like to hear from him whether any inquiries have been made through the diplomatic channels as to what grounds there are for the blood-curdling reports appearing in the English and Irish papers with regard to outrages and massacres in Spain, which appear to be specially directed against the Catholics of that country? If so, whether any protest has been made by this Government to whatever Government, if there is a Government at present, who is responsible for the conditions that are supposed to exist in that country. I am not quite sure whether there is a Government in control of any part of Spain at present. But if the conditions which have been reported in the English and Irish papers are anything like correct, I think it is the duty of this Government to make a protest to whatever Government is responsible for such atrocities as have been reported to have been committed in Spain during the last few weeks. I should like, at any rate, to hear from the Vice-President whether any inquiries of any kind have been made, or any action taken, or any protest of any kind made regarding the reported atrocities in Spain. I think it is a matter upon which the people of the country are entitled to receive some information and I hope the Vice-President will say something on the matter when replying.
Comment on this
Very remarkable developments have been taking place in our political life during the last month or two. Like Deputy Professor O'Sullivan, I want to take the opportunity of asking a few questions and making a few comments with regard to the matters of high policy that have been canvassed in County Galway, County Wexford, and elsewhere. They will be addressed not only to spokesmen of the Government but to the spokesmen of the Opposition. I have read with great interest the suggestion that a coalition between the two big Parties was something that we may look for. I certainly think it is something greatly to be wished for. But if such a coalition is to take place, it is all important that it should take place upon principles and upon a policy that will be of benefit to the country, and not the contrary.
The President has announced that if the result of the Galway and Wexford by-elections is such as to give him a shock, he proposes to force upon the country an early general election. The first remark I want to make is to suggest that if he does receive a shock from the results of the County Galway and County Wexford by-elections, it will be because the people of the country want to see the financial dispute with Great Britain brought to an end. The lesson he ought to draw from any such result is that it is his business to get down to the question of effecting such a settlement. There is no disguising the fact that he could do it better than anybody else. If another Government comes into office and makes a settlement with Great Britain, that settlement will be denounced by the members of the present Government Party as a betrayal of the interests of the country. If, on the other hand, the settlement is made by the present Government, I am sure that they can rely upon that settlement being accepted by the members of the present Opposition.
Comment on this
I am talking about the financial question; not the political question at all. If, as regards the financial question, the present Government agree to some compromise, agree to pay a portion of what the British are claiming, instead of the whole of what they are claiming, it never before occurred to me that it was possible that that settlement would be objected to or opposed by the Opposition.
Comment on this
That is irrelevant. I am talking of the possibility of a settlement being arrived at, the possibility of the present Government offering the British something less than what they are at present paying to the British. I think that that would be an exceedingly business-like thing for them to do.
I think that any sort of reasonable offer would probably be accepted. I think it would be greatly to the advantage of the country if that was done by the present Government. I think that a Government formed by the members of the present Opposition would be in the unpleasant situation that anything they did in this matter would be denounced as a betrayal of their country.
Comment on this
Furthermore, there is no blinking the fact that the interest of the British in conciliating the clean-cut separatists here of the Fianna Fáil Party is obviously greater than conciliating those who are already their friends.
Comment on this
That is the difference. If you ask Miss MacSwiney about that she will have something to say about it.
Comment on this
Reading the recent speeches on the Opposition side about the way the question of the financial dispute with Great Britain ought to be tackled, it occurs to me as very doubtful whether a good way to get a satisfactory settlement with Great Britain is to say: "We admit we owe you this money, but you did not pay your war debt to America and therefore we are not going to pay you." I question very much if that method of approach would be at all more hopeful than the very bad method of approach followed up to the present by the Fianna Fáil Government. I have always held, and still hold, and it was often strongly expressed by the late Mr. Patrick Hogan, that there is a very big difference between a commercial debt and an inter-governmental debt, and that essentially the land annuities debt was a commercial debt rather than an inter-governmental debt.
The British would obviously reply to any such arguments as those recently suggested in Opposition speeches, first, that our debt was a commercial debt; secondly, that they had only stopped paying their war debt to America because other countries, owing them very much more than they owed to America, had stopped paying them, and that they regarded the whole war debt question as an indivisible question; and, thirdly, that the Americans had, in effect, made it impossible for them to pay the debt because they refused to take any British goods, because they put on a sky-high tariff. A creditor country on the scale on which America was a creditor country after the War cannot expect to be paid her debts if she puts up sky-high tariffs and prevents a fairly free flow of trade.
I have no doubt that if Deputy Cosgrave returned to office he would set himself vigorously at once to make a settlement of this financial dispute and that he would make some sort of settlement. But I think it would be for the benefit both of Ireland and Great Britain and the relations between the two countries that a settlement should be made by the Government at present in office, if they can be at all brought to make one. I accuse President de Valera of running away from his responsibilities if, after receiving a clear indication from the electorate in these two by-elections that they want the question settled, he proceeds to a general election in the hope that all responsibilities will be taken off his shoulders and put upon the shoulders of Deputy Cosgrave.
Comment on this
Deputy Professor O'Sullivan referred appreciatively to the recent speeches of the President on the subject of the I.R.A. and law and order. I share his satisfaction at these speeches and an even greater satisfaction with the action that has been taken in banning the I.R.A.
I have noticed that attacks have been directed upon the President from various quarters, including Labour quarters, for trying a political murder case before the Military Tribunal. I want to say here that if the Military Tribunal is not to be used for trying political murder cases there is no use in its existing at all. That is exactly what it is most needed for, because there is not one of us here who does not know that you cannot get a satisfactory trial of a political murder case before a jury in this country owing to the amount of intimidation that there is.
Comment on this
And if anyone is to attack the Government for using such machinery for the trial of political murders it must not be those who have done less than any other Party to create a horror of political murder in the minds of the people of this country. Those who have spent a large portion of their time educating public opinion denouncing crime, denouncing the use of arms against the State and denouncing violence, such people might be entitled to object to the use of such machinery as the Military Tribunal, though I should think them wrong in doing so. But people who have never stirred a finger and who have sought popularity by conniving at everything the I.R.A. did, who never denounced anything when it needed denouncing, those are people who cannot be listened to when they come to complain of the use of special machinery such as the Military Tribunal for dealing with political crimes.
Comment on this
I have said already that the Labour Party had done less than any other Party in that respect.
Comment on this
That is my deliberate opinion. Leaving out ex-Senator O'Farrell, who is about as popular with the Labour Party as I am with the Fine Gael Party—leaving him out I have never seen myself any satisfactory speeches from Labour representatives denouncing political crime in this country as it ought to be denounced.
Comment on this
The Deputy was not in the House when we did it, and did it on many occasions, and will do it again when the Deputy is out of the House and out of the country.
Comment on this
The Labour Party had plenty of time to do it since I have been here, and it has not been done.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy is not serious in saying that the Labour Party have done less about that than any other Party? What about the Party opposite?
Comment on this
Deputy MacDermot was allowed to accuse the Labour Party of doing that. If I was out of order in following his bad example, I withdraw.
Comment on this
I never accused the Labour Party of that. I have accused it of negligence and cowardice, and that is all.
Comment on this
If the debate were allowed to proceed without running comments I think it would be better.
Comment on this
I now turn to the question which I regard as the paramount question of all others, the question of the unity of Ireland. It is a subject that has become lately the height of fashion. In theory, we are all agreed that it is the thing that matters most. It is figuring prominently in the by-elections and an enormous amount has been said and written about it during the last few months. All this would be very satisfactory if we were facing the realities of the problem, but unfortunately it seems to me, at any rate, that most of what is being said is either futile or actively mischievous.
I propose to ask the House to analyse the points of view on this subject of three Parties. Take the I.R.A. Party to begin with. They aim at shattering the authority of this Assembly and the authority of the Belfast Parliament, and of reducing the country north and south to a state of anarchy. If Great Britain, as they hope, is involved in a foreign war there is to be a period of frightful disorder. There will be a liquidation of the more conservative parties in all parts of Ireland, and a dictatorship of an all-Ireland proletariat. I imagine there are few members of the Dáil to whom that programme makes any appeal. We do not want a unity in ruin or a unity in Communism or a unity in the extinction of everything that is decent and of good report in the country. One thing, and one thing only, can be said in favour of the I.R.A. policy on this, and that is that it is intelligible, and that the deeds of those who advocate it are consistent with what they say.
Fianna Fáil, on the other hand, stand for order; there was a time when they did not, but now they do, and they not only stand for order here in the Free State but they are against, as I hope and believe, the incitement of disorder in the North. They have admitted that physical force exercised upon the majority in the North is not the proper road to unity. They have stated that, in the event of a European war, they do not propose to endanger this country by allowing a foreign power to use it as a base for attacks upon Great Britain.
Comment on this
Clearly, therefore, they can only look for unity on the basis of goodwill, and how do they go about obtaining this goodwill. First, by consistently proclaiming the ideal of a thirty-two county republic, by calling themselves the extreme republican party and by claiming to be clear-cut separatists—according to a recent speech of Deputy Cooney —and by teaching the people to believe that republicanism and freedom are interchangeable terms, that sovereign independence is impossible within the British Commonwealth and that Australia, Canada and South Africa are on a lower plane, with a status less free and less dignified, than say, Austria or Portugal or Peru. Secondly they seek to gain the goodwill of the North by preaching the gaelicisation of Ireland in defiance of Davis's doctrine that we should aim at an Ireland neither Gaelic nor Saxon but Irish. Their third happy thought for the conciliation of the North is to carry on and promote continual anti-British propaganda not merely as regards our own past and present relations with Great Britain, but as regards British policy and influence in every part of the world.
Beyond these things I cannot find that they have any policy at all for working towards unity except it be the administration of our own affairs here to the best of our ability so that the northerners may come to look upon us as a prosperous and well governed community. I am prepared to admit that the proofs recently given by the Government of their determination not to tolerate political murder and the claim to use arms against the State is an advance towards unity. If every important Party here is firm about these matters, the northerners will certainly think better of us than they have done hitherto. But that is not enough. It is not enough to counterbalance the separatism, sincere or insincere, about which I have just been talking. No substantial headway can be made towards winning over the North until every important Party in the Free State, besides being firm about murder, has clearly and boldly discarded separatism.
This brings us to the policy of Fine Gael. They, at any rate, are anti-separatists and, I think, anti-republican; but some recent utterances have seemed to suggest that they wish to substitute some other link for the link of the Crown. If so, they also, in my opinion, are setting their backs upon unity. I believe the sentiment of the North about the Crown is immensely strong. Deputy General Sean MacEoin described it as "hog wash" two or three days ago and, in support of that, he cited a famous remark of a Northern clergyman about kicking the Crown into the Boyne. I wonder if he remembers on what occasion that remark was uttered? It was a protest against the disestablishment of the Church of Ireland. Well, the Church of Ireland was disestablished and the Crown was not kicked into the Boyne. A few wild and whirling speeches of that sort cannot outweigh the actual events. I quite admit it is not always easy to disentangle loyalty from self-interest and that, in particular, the proceedings of Lord Carson and his friends in the few years preceding the European War cannot be brought within any definition of loyalty that I, personally, would accept. But the Orangemen always had this excuse, an excuse which has been given the colour of justification by the Sinn Féin movement, that Home Rule or any form of self-government within the Commonwealth was alleged to be merely a stepping-stone to separation and the renunciation of allegiance to the Throne.
If I were to use such an expression as "hog wash" in connection with the arguments of any member of this House, I should apply it to the arguments of those who seek to prove that no important part is played by sentiment in determining the attitude of the Northerners to ourselves. Sentiment has been immensely powerful with us and we see it at work all over the world, even causing men to do things and to maintain loyalties that are in conflict with their material interests. Why should the Northerners be different from all other men? Until other Irishmen take into account the sentimental attachment of Northerners to the Crown, they are not facing realities. If what Professor James Hogan calls our ideology prevents us from recognising the Crown, then our ideology is irreconcilable with unity. The Northerners have their ideology too, and they will have to sacrifice a good deal of it to come into even an all-Ireland Dominion. Nobody who knows them and is honest with himself can believe that they will sacrifice the Crown.
Supposing, however, that Fine Gael are still, as I think, anti-republican, what else can we glean of their views on the subject of obtaining unity? We heard some months ago from Deputy Cosgrave that this would be one of the subjects that he would raise with the British when he came back into power, and we have lately had information as to the manner in which it would be raised. The British are to be told that partition is being maintained by them in defiance of the spirit of the Treaty, if not of the letter, and that we expect them to hand over to us at once all powers at present exercised in respect of Northern Ireland by the Imperial Parliament. I believe that I feel as passionately about Irish unity as any man in this country and no one could condemn more severely than to do the part which several British statemen played in the past in bringing about partition. Nevertheless, I can only describe this proposed demand on the British Government in one way—it is a summons to them to commit a gross betrayal on the basis of a manifest falsehood.
So long as we maintain the separatist ideal, to hand over their friends in the North to our military and financial control would be regarded all over the world as a gross betrayal. To compel the Northerners to adjust themselves to the Commonwealth framework of Dominion self-government is one thing; to expose them to the certainty of separation from the Crown and from their kith and kin whenever the Party which stands for a Thirty-two County Republic comes into power, is quite another thing. I stood for a compulsion of the North in 1912, but I certainly could not stand for it in the circumstances of to-day. I believe that such an act would cover Great Britain with dishonour, and that any British Government that proposed such a thing would be swept out of office.
I said a betrayal based on a falsehood. What is the falsehood? The falsehood is the statement that the British are now maintaining partition, in the sense, of course, not merely of defending Northerners against attack, but of actually putting pressure on them to stand aloof from us. Once again let us face the realities. The majority in the North are dead-set against an Irish Republic. They value the British market for their ships and for their linen; they realise that we have no alternative market to offer them. They are proud of the Commonwealth and their connection with it. They are attached to the Crown. They believe themselves, quite falsely, to be a superior race to us, and, on top of all their very real motives for valuing the British connection, they have raised a huge superstructure of prejudice and bigotry. If a British Government were to desert them and take the troops out of the country, I believe that they would fly to arms in their own defence hoping, not unreasonably, that British public opinion would rally to their aid.
This is something that cannot be too much emphasised—the beginning of wisdom in regard to the North is to realise that it is the Northerners themselves whom we have got to persuade. There are those who say that it is unreasonable to expect us, the great majority of the Irish people, to sacrifice our wishes to a minority, even if we knew that we could win them over by doing so. My answer to their argument is that it represents the outlook of the leader of a faction and not of a statesman. If we look at the interests of Ireland as a whole, if we take into account all the facts, and not only some of the facts, we shall not need to sacrifice our wishes; we shall form our wishes in such a way as to achieve a peace without victory and to make a harmony out of discords.
And sometimes we are told, "Prove to us that the North will come in if we drop republicanism and then we will think about it." Of course nobody can prove that; we can only, as rational men, form our conclusions as to what is probable. It is said that even when nothing more than Home Rule was in contemplation, the Northerners refused to touch it. That is quite true, but why? Their constant cries were, "Home Rule means Rome Rule" and "Home Rule means Separation." The first of these we have proved to be unfounded. Not only does the Church not attempt to dominate our counsels in this Assembly, but there is no country in the world where there is less religious intolerance, and responsible representatives of the Protestant community in the Irish Free State are eager to testify this to their Northern co-religionists. There remains the second cry, that Home Rule means separation. We can show that to be unfounded, too. It is entirely up to us. Bigotry and prejudice die hard, but they must die in time if all foundation for them is removed. There would be a psychological revolution in the Free State if it were realised, as it ought to be realised, that we are free to secede from the Commonwealth; there would be a psychological revolution in Northern Ireland if it were seen that, being free to secede, all important Parties in the Irish Free State were agreed on the desirability of not seceding, and were prepared to accept the responsibilities and the loyalties of the Commonwealth partnership as well as its benefits.
In all relevant senses the Northern question is a racial question. Deputy Cosgrave denies this, but I submit that it is superficial and misleading to deny it. It is very possible, if a chemical analysis were made of an Orangeman's blood on the basis of race, if such a thing were conceivable, that that analysis would reveal a very similar mixture of elements to what an analysis of the blood of an average member of this Assembly would show. But that is not what matters. The Northern Unionist feels himself kith and kin with the British. He shares, as a general rule, their religion, and he is proud of their history. He feels himself to be of a distinct race from us, and we confirm him in his opinion by our anti-British propaganda, and our extravagant craze for Gaelicisation. Therefore, for all practical purposes, the problem is a racial problem, and we shall never solve it until we realise that it is a racial problem. There was a racial problem in Canada; there was a racial problem in South Africa. Look at these countries and see how they have dealt with it. The Dutch are more numerous than the British in South Africa; they are brave; they are determined, and they have a long republican tradition. But they want to see their country flourish materially and spiritually. They have seen a way to do it without sacrificing an iota of liberty; they have taken over the King as their own King and not as the King of a foreign nation.
I believe that would be the solution here. It is we, and not the Orangemen, who seek reunion. It is we who must take the first step, and must sweep away the foundations of their fears and suspicions. The year 1937 will offer exceptional opportunities. If we play a free and equal part at the Coronation, and at the Imperial Conference which is to follow it, we shall not only make a more dignified figure than hanging about on the back stairs, but we shall take a big step forward towards Irish unity. The Egyptians are in the act of making a Treaty of External Association with the British Commonwealth. We might, perhaps, satisfy our ideology by doing likewise —and I imagine that the Government, in spite of being such clean-cut separatists, have something of the sort in mind, but if so, partition must continue. The Northerners will see, if we can not, that we shall have less freedom, less power, and less prestige as a satellite State than we could have as a partner in the Commonwealth.
The late Mr. Patrick Hogan once said that the one sort of person whose mentality was unintelligible to him was the person who wanted to be in the Commonwealth, but drew the line at saying so. I echo his words, and I only regret that such a mentality is so common in this country. We want British markets; we want Commonwealth openings for our young people; we want the services of British diplomatic representatives all over the world—say in Spain at the present moment; we want to strengthen, not to weaken, our associations with the Irish communities in Australia and Canada. We want these things and many others that flow from the British connection, but we want at the same time to go on pretending that we are under duress. What was good enough for Sarsfield, Grattan, Tone, O'Connell, Davis and Parnell, is not good enough for us. We prefer to see our country cut in two rather than sacrifice our shibboleths, rather than lose the cherished sensation of grievance, rather than stand upright in the world, free from all stigma of oppression. When is this country going to show itself fit for self-government?
Comment on this
I could congratulate Deputy MacDermot on the speech which he has just made if it were not that there pervades that speech a defect which pervades every speech which Deputy MacDermot makes in this House, and that is the fact that Deputy MacDermot has not his roots here, and has not had his roots here for years. He does not speak with either the sincerity or the material practical mind with which a man will speak who knows that, whatever mess this country gets into, he has got to stay here and make his life and his being here. The Deputy came here suddenly, and a constituency elected him. The Deputy will, I am sure, stay here as long as that constituency continues to elect him, and then will we hear or see anything more of Deputy MacDermot? I doubt it. The Deputy announced in this House that he would prefer experimentation to go on. I criticised him on that occasion, saying that the man who would like to see experiments going on was not always the man who would suffer if the experiments proved unsuccessful. The man who could clear out, the man who could avoid the mess, the man who had no stake in the country, was going to be more careless about seeing that the experiment was properly conducted with a view to its success than the man who was going to live here whether the experiment was a success or a failure.
Deputy MacDermot to-night voted for the Land Bill—the Bill which gives the Government, as Deputy Dillon says, more power than the ancient, bad, hated, detested and shot landlords. He does that because he will not be affected by it. This may seem personal. I thing that personalities in politics are a good thing. If we find that people are playing around with politics in this country, and can see the reason for it, it is surely right to say so, so that the people can understand who are the sincere persons in this country, who actually feel that the policy they are putting forward is good for the country, or who are in an experimental humour, ready to trifle with and traffic in the lives and property and good repute, and even the sentiment of the folk in this country. Hence I am going to pass over anything that Deputy MacDermot has said with regard to the viewpoints of this Party on a settlement with England. This Party has made settlements before. This Party, if called on, will make them again. This Party will stand the test of public opinion with regard to them. This Party has been honest with regard to what it has done. This Party has never attempted to promise more than what it thought reasonably it could perform. This Party is not now engaged in running away from the electorate whom they intoxicated with promises, and the effect of whose intoxicated delirium they are now afraid to meet.
There is only one question that is worth considering at this time, and that hinges around the name of, up to very recently, an unknown citizen of this country, one Michael Conway. Michael Conway might have been hanged yesterday. Michael Conway would have been hanged only for the cowardice of the Executive Council. If he had been hanged, the Executive Council could have been hanged, because it was the Executive Council that brought Michael Conway to the course of error which they afterwards set up a tribunal to inquire into, and it was one member of the Executive Council who went out on a public platform to give a lead to the tribunal that was going to try Michael Conway. If that man had died yesterday the Minister for Finance ought also to have died. The Minister for Finance is lucky that he was not haled before a court for contempt of court. The Minister for Finance has the weakness and characterlessness of his own Attorney-General to thank for that. The Minister for Finance in any ordinarily governed country would certainly have been made leave politics. The Minister for Finance in no ordinary democratically governed community would have been able to find a bunch of people to sit with him as his colleagues on the same bench after his scandalous attempt to do what was never attempted to be done in this country before.
Comment on this
Well, was the Minister for Finance pulled up for it? However, we will see later what was the occasion to which the Vice-President refers. I know nothing of it.
Comment on this
He was pulled up in the House here? Well, I am only adopting the same principle with the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
At any rate, there is one thing that nations have kept themselves away from, even in war— at least, one hears that it is done, but no nation has yet boasted of having done it or has come out openly or said that it has been done—and that is poisoning the wells.
Comment on this
The Minister is reduced to a very small point when he refers to a gold mine when I am speaking of the time when a man's life was going to be put in danger by a military Tribunal and when the Minister himself had said——
Comment on this
——that he had the evidence, which would be produced, and that that would be the end of the man who did the shooting. I said a moment ago that nations do not poison the wells. The wells of justice ought to be kept clean also. I want to know if there was ever any case in this country in which, when a man was about to stand his trial, a responsible member of an Executive Council said "You will get the proof and it will be a sorry day for those responsible. It will be their last shooting." I said on a previous occasion that if that statement is analysed it comes down to this: "I am here, Minister for Finance, speaking as a member of the Executive Council. I have had put before me the evidence on which Michael Conway is going to be haled before the Military Tribunal. I have read it. It connects him with the crime and it connects him with the crime so well that he ought to be found guilty and it connects him so well with the crime that, when found guilty, he ought to be hanged." That is said before the trial comes off, and the Minister is still the Minister and the Attorney-General is still Attorney-General and has not thought that that is worth while mentioning as a matter of as bad a contempt of court as ever was committed.
The Minister knew what he was speaking about. The Minister had previously, in 1931, queried what the Military Tribunal was going to consist of—"Officers—officers in the pay of the Executive Council; officers selected to do the dirty work of the Executive Council.""Bloodhounds" was the phrase he used—"the seven bloodhounds of the Executive Council." And he is the Minister who pays the salaries. He is the man who, for some reason not known to this House, has been selected to fill the responsible post of Minister for Finance. He is the head of the establishment of the Civil Service. He pays the salaries, and yet this is the man who, in 1931, before any officer of the Tribunal was named, could describe these officers as the bloodhounds of the Executive Council. He is the Minister who holds the purse-strings and on whom these men's careers depend, and he is the Minister who thinks it proper, as such Minister, to come out on a platform at a public meeting and to say, when a man was on trial for his life: "You will get the proof and it will be a sorry day for those responsible. It will be their last shooting." And that is regarded as fair-play, even for a murderer, and for a man who, under the conditions that hold in this country, is supposed to be innocent until he is found guilty. When that man, with the suspicion of murder against him, is about to be brought before this court—not independent, according to the Minister; not surrounded by all those helps and all those aids which ordinary communities have given to judges so as to make them independent in their conduct; not speaking to judges who may not be removed from office or whose salaries may not be interfered with; but to men easily amenable to pressure in the circumstances of their position, he says: "I have seen the evidence and I am a member of the Executive Council. It is good enough for me. You will find that evidence produced and it will be a sorry day for those responsible. It will be their last shooting."
That was the culminating scandal of a career indulged in by all the members of the present Government—duplicity and hypocrisy, the prostitution of patriotism, a leaning towards the weaknesses of men, the harping on sentimentality, and an attempt to disrupt anything that was being built here in the way of fair institutions for this country. The Minister whose tongue wagged so furiously on that occasion did not let it fail to wag on other occasions. The President could speak to one of his, up to recently deluded, followers in Galway the other night. He can criticise that lady about doctrines that she holds. Who briefed her I do not know, but if she had been made go through a course of the debates in this House she could not have been well advised to have taken a course more likely to embarrass the President than the course she did take. The President arrogates to himself the power to put questions to her—she who was his disciple, she who was more than his disciple, she who, learning from him, taught a lot of others and brought others to a particular point. The President is keen against murder. The President is keen against anybody condoning murder. The condonation of murder that is alleged against Miss MacSwiney is that she said: "If anybody was shot by the I.R.A. he was shot as a spy." Is that condoning murder? If that is a condonation of murder, then listen to this from President de Valera. In the month of November, 1931, he was not content with speech-making. He gave an interview to a representative of the United Press of America in October of that year, which was released for publication on the 12th November, 1931. He said that the politicians of the Cosgrave régime were then feverishly trying to work up a scare. What was the scare founded on? "Certain recent happenings," he said, "had provided them with just the opportunity they had been seeking." Now, remember Miss MacSwiney's phrase: "If anybody was shot by the I.R.A. he was shot as a spy." Here is what the scare was founded on, according to the President on that occasion:
"Certain recent happenings have provided them with just the opportunity they have been seeking. Last January a young man was shot for being, it was said, a Government agent provocateur acting amongst the I.R.A. In March a police officer was shot in Tipperary. In July another man shot, who, it was said, had been led by the police into giving information concerning his comrades.”
Is that condonation? If Miss MacSwiney is condoning and attempting to justify the murder of Egan at Dungarvan, was that an attempt to justify and condone the murders of Carroll, of Curtin, and of Ryan? "In July another young man shot who, it was said, had been led by the police into giving information concerning his comrades." If Miss MacSwiney, as I say, had been briefed by people reading these debates she could not have used, for President de Valera, a phrase more ugly than that of saying that that man was shot because he was an informer.
In the year 1928, there was a debate in this House on the review of prisoners' cases, and in the course of that debate I asked the then Opposition if they would give information, if it came into their possession, likely to lead to the arrest of the murderers of Kevin O'Higgins. What was the answer? Deputy Little thought it was unfair to try to put a whole Party in a position in which they are required to give a certain undertaking. It was absurd to say to any Party that they were to act as if they were officers of the police or the Government. Deputy Cooney was not pleased with that. It seemed to be leading too near to assent to what I was asking. I retorted to Deputy Little: "He does not admit it is his duty to give information," and Deputy Cooney said "To become an informer." So that if knowledge of the murderers of Kevin O'Higgins came into the possession of Deputy Little, he had his doubts whether he would reveal it to the police, but Deputy Cooney had none. Deputy Cooney thought that to pass on that information to the police was to put himself in the position of an informer—an informer about a murderer, an informer to the police, an institution of the State. And then the President can wax eloquent because Miss MacSwiney talks about a man being an informer.
One of the things Michael Conway did was to refuse to recognise the court, a practice lauded by the Minister for Finance. The Minister for Finance, speaking on the Juries Protection Bill, 1929, said it was a procedure that had been sanctified by all the martyrs in Irish history. The present Minister for Industry and Commerce thought that this method of arraigning a man, getting him to refuse to recognise the court and sending him away for six months was a farce and likely to bring the law into disrespect. He said that such a law never could have respect, that one man with any strength to stick that out could bring the whole State into contempt and could bring the whole administration of law and justice into contempt. "I hope," he said "that if this measure passes such a man will be found." He was questioned by Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald afterwards and he said "I hope somebody will be found to fight that section. I would be prepared to do so myself." The Minister for Finance lauds the practice of standing mute and refusing to recognise the court. The Minister for Industry and Commerce thinks the section can be brought into disrepute and the whole of the law brought into disrepute with it, and, if nobody else will do it, the Minister for Industry and Commerce is prepared to do it. And men have got their six months recently for doing what these two Ministers asked them to do. "A practice sanctified by the example of good and noble men" was the phrase of the Minister for Finance.
Michael Conway was tried, and, in the end, the tribunal found that he was on a certain road, that a certain car passed along that road, that he had an opportunity of joining that car and that there was the mark of his finger-print on the panel of the door. There was no allegation made against Michael Conway that he drew a revolver on anybody.
Comment on this
Might I interrupt the Deputy? I do not want to stop the Deputy in any line of argument he wishes to adopt but I wonder is it permissible to discuss the details of this trial in this House?
Comment on this
I kept a fairly close watch on Deputy McGilligan's statement and so far I do not think he has referred to the administration of justice by the court.
Comment on this
He is certainly bordering very close upon it in his references to finger-prints on the panel of the car.
Comment on this
I am not going to say that the tribunal were not justified in everything they found. It is necessary to see what they did say. They found that the Chrysler saloon was the car used; that the finger-print found was that of the accused; that the accused could not have had access to the car until it was seized; and that he was on a particular road and so could have joined it. That was what was proved against him. That is the proof which the Minister for Finance thought was sufficient to justify his hanging, and the Minister for Finance announced that beforehand. I want to go to another case— the case of a man who went to a house with a weapon, who drew that weapon, and who was shot by the person who defended the house. The Attorney-General paraded him for what? For murder or attempted murder? For entering a house to commit a felony? Not at all. For having arms without a permit. The Attorney-General will remember the case of McWalter, without a doubt. It has been discussed here often.
Comment on this
Yes, and the Deputy probably knows all about it.
Comment on this
I know quite a lot about it, but I know mainly what the Attorney-General told this House about it. I have it here. Let us get the contrast. Here is a man to be hanged, on a lead given by the Minister for Finance, and there is what the Tribunal find about him. Take the other case. Of course, the thing about it is that it happened only in 1932, whereas this is 1936. In 1932, there was this man, MacWalter, who went to the house of another man, who had a weapon on him and ammunition, and who was shot. Here is what the Attorney-General, in 1932, said about him:
"Now, as regards McWalter himself, he was so seriously wounded in the attack upon that house that he nearly died in hospital."
The man who, so far as we can make out, went with murder in his heart to another house, and because the defender of that house shoots him, the Attorney-General takes pity on him. The Attorney-General continued:
"He was under arrest in hospital. The moment that he was well enough to be arraigned before a court, that the Guards reported that he was well enough to be brought before a court, I had him brought before a court. Having regard to the evidence before me, and to the whole situation, weighing it up as carefully as I could and without the slightest sympathy for McWalter, I decided that the best and wisest course was to bring him up on a charge for the possession of firearms."
For that, he got six months, and "as far as I understand," said the Attorney-General, his heart still bleeding for this man, "his six months in prison have been spent between life and death in hospital." He did not even spend the full six months in hospital. He was released before his time was up.
Comment on this
This occurred, Sir, about four years ago——
Comment on this
Yes. This occurred four years ago, and it has been debated in this House on several occasions. The Deputy, I think, knows far more about that case than is on those reports, and I wonder if he is in order in raising it at this stage, and am I entitled to reply?