Adjournment Motion.
Contributions 181–369 of 561. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
The Attorney-General is entitled to reply to anything raised in the House. The Chair is in this difficulty, that it does not know the circumstances surrounding the case that Deputy McGilligan mentioned.
Comment on this
The Chair does not know the circumstances surrounding it, and neither does the Chair know the relation that Deputy McGilligan is endeavouring to establish between that case and some present case.
Comment on this
The context is this, that Martin Conway is mentioned by the Minister for Finance on a public platform when he is about to be tried. There is no question of his shooting anyone. There is a question, apparently, of being in the company of people who shot murderously and foully. But when one went to a house with arms, and in making an attack shot himself, the Attorney-General though it was fit to let that man off with six months.
Comment on this
I am not going to yield to the Attorney-General unless there is a point of order. He can make his speech later. Deputy Finlay said in that debate:
"As I understood, the offence was breaking into a house, or attempting to break into a house, with intent to commit a felony. The matter is entirely one of inference for a jury to draw from the surrounding facts in connection with a particular crime. In connection with McWalter, the position was this: The evidence showed that he attempted to break into a house. He was found outside in possession of firearms, and surely any reasonable person would come to the conclusion that there were facts established there, and that it was for a jury to say whether there was intention to commit a felony."
The Attorney-General would not let that man go to a jury. He took him up for having a gun without a permit and he was given six months. That is the only difference. That was in 1932. The Attorney-General is correct there. The mood was to play with these people, to pretend that they were fine fellows, and to encourage them in crime. In 1936 the mood is different. It took more assassinations of a foul type to bring the Attorney-General to the point of view that he apparently has now, and that he would be rather ashamed to hear that case mentioned.
Comment on this
The Deputy should be ashamed to mention it.
Comment on this
The Deputy must know that in point of fact when that case was dealt with I was not in the country at all. I merely accepted responsibility for it.
Comment on this
May I take it that the Attorney-General would not have taken that action? It is time he said it after four years' silence.
Comment on this
I understand the Deputy has been informed of the fact, but he makes that challenge.
Comment on this
I raised that case three times in this House and the Attorney-General had his chance.
Comment on this
I informed Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney of the fact and he never raised it again. He accepted my explanation.
Comment on this
The Attorney-General heard me raising it three times and he never thought it his duty to say that.
Comment on this
He might have gone to a public meeting and said it, like what the Minister said about Michael Conway. He could easily have done that. He would have less scruple about bringing it before a court than he had for bringing the Minister. The difference is that that was 1932 against 1936.
Comment on this
Withdraw what? I made the statement that it was not properly done. The Attorney-General said it was not of his doing. I withdraw one to make another. Did the Attorney-General think it was part of his duty to make a public apology for what happened in the McWalter case? Did he make a protest that his office had been scandalously abused in his absence? Did he ever say a word to any one that he thought it might be even a question of resigning? Never. The Attorney-General has been threatened recently, according to the newspapers. Why? I can see a great deal of reason for threatening very many people in this country who are in sheep's clothing, as the Attorney-General is. That it would be thought worth while by any one to threaten passes my comprehension. The Attorney-General spent a good deal of time recently trying to suppress a paper called An Phoblacht. He appeared in the columns of that paper on one occasion when he sent a subscription to the Party that he is now trying to put down, with the phrase that, he at least, would never serve the Irish Free State. I can imagine people who thought the Attorney-General sincere feeling annoyed that the paper in whose columns he proclaimed himself as never likely to serve the Irish Free State, is now being suppressed by him, when he is in the service of the Irish Free State. It is one of the ill-memories of this country that people who from time to time have taken particular lines in politics said goodbye to them when position and preferment were offered. Poor Michael Conway, the dupe, could go very near the scaffold. Where will the man who said he would never serve the Irish Free State go eventually? I have talked of condonation of murder. It is a good thing, even in 1936, when the year is more than half gone, that we should get definite and clear-cut condemnation of murder. We have not got it yet.
Comment on this
I am talking about condemnation. The Minister is hard of hearing as well as hard of understanding. I am talking of condemnation of murder. When did we get a clear-cut, unreserved condemnation of murder? Is it on any date from August 11th? It is certainly not earlier. I remember that the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, when only about a year in this House, was asked by a member of the Labour Party as to whether his was a constitutional Party or not. What was his answer? "A slightly constitutional Party.""We are," he said, "coming into this House to pursue certain tactics, but we are first and foremost a republican Party aiming to be a republican Government, and if those tactics do not succeed——" At that point he was interrupted by Deputy O'Connell, the leader of the Labour Party, who said, "It took you five years to find that out." What was his answer? "For five years," he said, "we were on the defensive. Now we are recruiting our strength, and if we get strong again, we will see whether we shall take the old offensive once more." He was speaking in this House as a member of a "slightly constitutional Party," and his colleagues used the same phraseology. They said, more or less—I am quoting now a mass of things in the gist—that they accepted majority rule, not because it was something sacred, but because there was a law of order about it; they said that they did not accept this House as having a proper title to govern; they said that the title to govern lay outside this House, and that the people helping to maintain that Government outside this House were the men who were best carrying on the old and honoured traditions of Irish nationalism. That persisted up to the year 1931.
Remember, Miss MacSwiney is held up to public odium and scorn because she talks of the I.R.A. We are told to make a distinction between the old I.R.A. and the I.R.A. that now exists, and we are given certain distinguishing signs. Miss MacSwiney is implored not to use the word "spy" against every member of the police or every agent of the police. Miss MacSwiney is implored not to try to create against the forces of this country the odium bound to be created by calling them "Imperial," or British troops or forces. Who started all that? Who are the first people to call and persist in calling the men recruited here to uphold our institutions "colonial troops" except the people opposite? Now, Miss MacSwiney is asked not to bring this odium on these "decent, young Irishmen." That is what they have now become. The I.R.A. are now to be crushed. They are people who must be condemned. They are now a murder gang. What were they in 1931? Here is what the President said on the 15th October, when the Constitution (Amendment) Bill was under discussion:
"It was only men who had been inspired with the principles which drove them to face the odds in 1916, and who made them a part of their faith, who would have attempted it (a forlorn hope). These are the men who we want to crush now. These are the men who are represented as terrorists, those who never thought of themselves. They are simply the rats that are to be squelched. These are the people who were ready to give everything they had for Ireland, and well we know it, and now they are being deserted by the majority of their people; they have been deserted by old comrades who can no longer see any hope of success in the line they are adopting, by people who were with them originally, but are so far away from them now that the road which they are following is leading diametrically in the opposite direction."
The President asks Miss MacSwiney to condemn murder. What did he say of the people guilty of those three murders in 1931, to which I referred earlier? Here is what he said:
"These men are misguided, if you will, but they were brave men anyhow; let us at least have for them the decent respect that we have for the brave. They have done terrible things recently, I admit, if they are responsible for them, and I suppose they are. Let us appeal to them and ask them in God's name not to do them. You sneer at that. It would be more effective, probably, than all your coercion and all your threats, all the shame and slime that you tried to pour upon them to-day."
These men were misguided, but they were brave men, anyhow, men for whom we were to have the decent respect we have for the brave. Now, in 1936, they are the rats to be squelched. Is not the President pouring to-day the "shame and slime" on them to which he objected in 1931? Why the change?
One of the changes is supposed to be that the I.R.A. won respect and its title when it functioned as the Army of the people, acknowledging the authority of and obedient to the control of the people's elected Parliament and Government. Did they always behave in that way? In a recent case before the Military Tribunal, a prisoner brought there was able to show that the instructions he was acting on and which brought him before the Tribunal were the very instructions given him by the man who is now Minister for Defence—Deputy Frank Aiken. The President thinks that the I.R.A. won respect and its title when it functioned as the Army of the people, acknowledging the authority of and obedient to the control of the people's elected Parliament and Government. Will the President search the records got in the dump at Kilakee? If he looks there, he will find a communication for which Mr. Frank Aiken, then Chief of Staff, was responsible. Apparently, the situation was that the I.R.A. were not satisfied with the lump of government they had—the people outside this House who were pretending to function as a Government. Apparently, they wanted to act on their own. The Chief of Staff, poor man, had to steer between the horns of a very ugly dilemma. He could not repudiate his Government. At the same time, he could not tell these people that they must be subservient to them. What did he say? He said: "A dangerous and undesirable isolation of the Army from the people is coming about." Having addressed an exhortation to them on these lines, he wrote on the 18th July, 1925, as Chief of Staff:
"The Army has given allegiance to the Government as the Government of the Republic. If, at any time, the Government took action inconsistent with its status as the Government of the Republic, the allegiance of the Army would automatically lapse."
Comment on this
The Deputy is obviously quoting. Is not the House entitled to know what he is quoting from?
Comment on this
It is on the records of the House, but what I am using is the note which I used in the discussion in 1931 on the Constitution (Amendment) Act, No. 17.
Comment on this
The Minister is in a mood in which he will probably have to deny everything I say to-night because of that statement at Lucan. That is what was said and written and that record is in the possession of the Government. The I.R.A. were not always obedient and subject to the control of the people's elected Parliament. There was their reason for diverting— if at any time the Government took action inconsistent with its status as the Government of the Republic. Then, the allegiance of the Army was automatically to lapse. These misguided youths say now that the action taken by you, people, is inconsistent with the status of the Government as the Government of the Republic. They now claim that they have Deputy Frank Aiken's authority for saying that the allegiance of the Army has automatically lapsed.
One could give thousands of these quotations. One would only have to go back over the old debates from 1927. Right on from 1927 to 1931—this cannot be denied—the present Government, then the Opposition, persisted in one course of conduct. They were out to destroy the institutions of the State. They asked people to try to break down the administration of justice. They applauded them for standing mute in court and refusing to recognise the court. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that, if nobody else could be found to break the law, he would break it and bring the whole administration of justice into contempt. The I.R.A. were kept in the background. Men who are now Ministers played up to them and, further, sought to get sympathy for them and sought to get their support. The President says it is impossible to have certain trials run before juries because juries were being coerced by the gun. A paper called The Nation, which Deputy O'Kelly, as Deputy O'Kelly, used to publish, put in a notice from a correspondent applauding the fact that a certain juror had been shot and was lying in Steevens's Hospital. The Minister for Finance said in this House within the last 18 months that there was a time when he thought it was proper to intimidate juries, but he did not hold that view now.
Comment on this
These are the people who are responsible. They connived at and encouraged these people. They did more than encourage; they helped in every material way the people attempting to break down all these institutions. It was they who placarded the forces of this country as "Imperial troops." It was they who tried to create the atmosphere that everybody who was a police agent or spy should get what spies ordinarily get, and tried also to encourage the belief that any man who gave information about any crime to the police of the State was an informer of the old type and suitable for the treatment meted out to informers of the old type.
The I.R.A. have now got to be treated like rats, to be squelched. Any why the change? Why has there been a diversion of policy? Have the I.R.A. changed or have the Government changed? Why was the shooting of a certain juryman given publicity to in the columns of The Nation and not condemned then? Why is it now a matter to be referred to by the President in his speech in opposition to Miss MacSwiney, in stating that, of course, these people could not be brought before a jury because the jury could be easily intimidated by the gun? Where has the change come? Deputy MacDermot was able to refer here to certain other changes. There used to be a phrase mouthed by people, who had very little sense and certainly no understanding of the change in political relations that had taken place, that England's difficulty was always Ireland's opportunity. That Party when it was in opposition was brought up on that slogan and some of them have not even forgotten it yet. Suddenly the President made a change, out of the blue, no consideration for the change, no negotiations that one can hear of, no special benefit accruing to this country from the change. The President announces that he can say for his Government, and that he thinks he can speak for any other Government that would be likely to follow them, that no Government here could ever think of having the coasts of this country used for aggressive action against England. That was certainly a reversal of the old form of that Party. Possibly it went too far. The Vice-President went to Donegal and spoke there as reported on the 20th July. He believes that England should still quail a little at the thought of what the Vice-President would do if Partition is not ended before the next European War comes along.
If we take the President as spokesman of the Party for the time being, the President has announced that big change in international politics as between this country and the ancient enemy, England. The Vice-President told us at the Galway election that there were important negotiations going on. What about we do not know. The President has got over his horror of being associated by personal proximity with British ministers. At Geneva and elsewhere he can meet them and be on friendly terms with them. He can proceed to settle the affairs of half the world in association and on friendly lines of agreement with the British. In a variety of ways of which these are only a few outstanding examples it looks as if the President is beginning to see that there is more reason in some of the things he used to condemn than possibly some of the I.R.A. would yet see in these things. The I.R.A. were to be tolerated and were tolerated, were petted and pampered by the Attorney-General and the Minister for Justice, who had it in their power to bring them to heel, as long as they were useful. But at this moment when it looks as if the President is likely to make a swerve one way or another we have this policy suddenly announced and harshly and peculiarly operated against the I.R.A. They are no longer friends of the Government; they are enemies to be put down and squelched.
What is the President doing? What are the negotiations that the Vice-President spoke of? Has the Vice-President taken any steps to perfect the defence policy he laid down in this House? It was very sketchy but the orientation was good. It was peculiar, coming from the President. It was good to see at any rate that he had some line of policy. Whether the details are good or not we cannot say until we see them. He gave us some hint of a policy and briefly it was this: We cannot enter into an alliance with any other country. There is no country that wants us except one. We will arm Volunteers here. They are not of much hope in the case of a world war and an attack on our shores but it is the best we can do. After that, we will live in this comforting hope, that there is one nation that has more interest in seeing that no other nation attacks our shores than any other nation. Let us get that in concrete. We will not make an alliance with any country. We will rely on the British, whose interest it is to see that nobody attacks our shores. That is the defence policy but it is not the defence policy that most of the members opposite were brought up on. It is not the defence policy the President ever gave a hint of having prior to the autumn of last year. But there are negotiations going on about something according to the Vice-President. He had been asked about what and he has refused to say, but they are important enough to be trailed as a red herring before the people of Galway. It is possible that the I.R.A. were anxious to know what the negotiations were about. It is possible also that the President and his associates felt that it was better to prevent the I.R.A. from becoming too inquisitive before some bigger swerve, some more violent change took place, and so driven by circumstances, mysterious because the reality of them we do not know, the President comes to this decision, that he is not merely against murder but if a man is suspect of it, he is going to allow a Minister to go on a public platform and prejudice the case. He is going to see that if any man is put before the Tribunal that he previously thought was not independent by reason of its position under the Constitution, the case will be irregularly referred to in public beforehand and if there is anything in the intimidation of language from a man supposed to be cognisant of the evidence in a particular case, then that will be slapped down heavily in the balance against the unfortunate who comes before that Tribunal, long before he is brought there. That shows that the capacity of the present Government for blundering has not been exhausted.
We naturally welcome the change of mind even though one might deplore the tragedies that have been necessitated to bring about that change of mind on the part of the Government. The Government now are stern and definite in their repudiation of murder and murder gangs. At any rate the people of the country should be satisfied that if men are going to be sent to their trial and death for murder there will be this public security that they will get a fair trial. If there is not such security the hanging of men charged with murder will do more harm than good. The thought of the whole world has combined in this—that judges must be made independent in their functions before they can command respect; these judges must be made independent in two ways—they cannot be removed from office and they cannot have their moneys taken from them while in office. While you have such independent judges there is a well-recognised rule with regard to contempt of court which forbids any man to say prior to the trial anything calculated in any way to interfere with a fair trial. If that is so in the case of independent judges how much more so must it be in the case of men who hold office under the Executive Council and whose moneys come under the control of the Minister for Finance? How much more reason is there, therefore, in the latter case for putting a bridle on the irresponsible tongue? What absolute need is there when trials of this sort are going forward that men who cannot control their tongues should be locked up along with the prisoner——
Comment on this
——so that nothing they can say will filter through outside and will not affect the minds of the people who are trying to give a fair trial. The Vice-President is amused.
Comment on this
Michael Conway was not. Michael Conway protested against the statement of the Minister for Finance. The Vice-President would laugh at Michael Conway.
Comment on this
I am thinking of this time last year when Deputy McGilligan was saying: "please I did not say what you thought I was saying,"
Comment on this
This is a serious matter. We had a virulent tongue let loose at Lucan when the Minister said that he had read the evidence and that the man would be condemned to death. Is that a thing to be laughed at?
Comment on this
At any rate the Minister is not laughing any longer. That is something gained. But the prisoner thought it was grave contempt of court and a deliberate attempt to prejudice the trial. That is what the man said. Let the Minister look it up. If there is going to be any more of these trials we must remember that the phrase did not apply only to the Egan case. These men will be brought forward. That speech is still there. The Attorney-General has done nothing to clear people's minds of distrust and anxiety as to how these trials are conducted. One can, at this time, let one's mind run back for quite a number of years, in fact over the whole period since 1921. During that period there has been nothing in this country but division and strife. That was caused, maintained, encouraged, developed and continued by the men who have now recanted through the mouth of their President in Galway the other night all that they did and stood over in the last 14 years.
Comment on this
Since 1921. That recantation does almost apologise for every crime that that Party allowed since 1921. These "bloody instructions" we have been taught, "always return to plague the inventor." We saw the inventor squirming at Galway. These people had taken him seriously. They believed him when he said they were decent, brave young men. Because people believed him when he said that they thought he was going to allow them go to any extreme. The people who followed him felt that they had as good a right as he had to say when the time had come to stop shooting. He says "at a particular moment I withdrew the Oath." At that moment all the guns should have dropped from their hands. These people have always said that they were taught by him to say that this Parliament was a British institution and never would they enter it. They heard him say that they would all be in their graves before he would ever take the Oath and they saw him taking it within a week. These people were deluded, but they had their own views as to when matters could be brought to a conclusion. He thought the time had come. They thought the time had not yet arrived. He thinks it has arrived; we thought so in 1922. He told them they were decent, brave, young men, and they believed that when they had crossed the line there was no reason why they should stop.
The President is not obeying the law even at the moment. The I.R.A. objects to this institution because it is founded on the Treaty. The President himself taught them that phrase, but he has now founded himself on the Treaty which he taught these people to condemn, he has set aside part of the law himself, while he condemns these people to death for breaking another part of it. The President knows he has set aside the law. There is a certain situation here with regard to the Governor-General and with regard to Association. The President thinks that can be put on one side. But the I.R.A. think other things can be put on one side. The President thinks they are committing crimes at a particular time. They think he is committing a crime now; he taught them to think so himself. I would rather have their verdict than his anyway.
Comment on this
A Chinn Comhairle, your ruling has permitted what might be a discussion on the whole history of this country since 1922. That discussion having been permitted to Deputy McGilligan, I may be permitted also to refer to the matters the Deputy has brought into the discussion. But first before going to any other topic I want to challenge Deputy McGilligan and to say that at no time, anywhere, did President de Valera or any of his Ministers condone murder or condone those who committed murder nor were they a party to murder like the members sitting opposite me now. Their hands have never been stained by murder—stained by the blood of their countrymen. We are charged over and over again with that in this debate. President de Valera is charged with it and Deputy McGilligan knows it is a lie and that there is no foundation for it. The Deputy had better look into the history of himself and his Party, not himself because he never had the courage to——
Comment on this
He never had the courage. He was never in the I.R.A. There are men associated with him who had the courage to join the I.R.A. He never had the courage to do anything but slander men in this House and outside of it who had the courage to join the I.R.A. That is what I know of him.
Comment on this
If I am not mistaken the statement has been made charging the members of the late Ministry with condoning murder. I would like to know if that is in order?
Comment on this
That statement was made. It was not in order and must be withdrawn. No Party in this House can be accused of murder or accused of condoning murder.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan made that statement over and over again and it has not been withdrawn.
Comment on this
I have been listening during the last hour to Deputy McGilligan repeating that statement over and over again.
Comment on this
I said that the Vice-President's organ, The Nation, published in its news a phrase gloating over the fact that a juror had been shot. That is a fact., I have the quotation here.
Comment on this
You said that the Minister for Finance stated to this House about 18 months ago that at one time he believed it was right to shoot jurors, but now he believed it no longer. I am not going to stigmatise that as a lie, because it is not necessary, when Deputy McGilligan makes a statement like that, to put on it its proper name.
Comment on this
I used the word "intimidate" in that connection; not "shoot." That is the word that was used.
Comment on this
It is not parliamentary to accuse any Deputy or Party in this House of condoning murder.
Comment on this
In deference to your ruling, Sir, I withdraw it. I ask the members of the House to bear in mind the slimy tongue of Deputy McGilligan. He talked of trading in slime. I use his own eloquent phrase, and I leave him to wallow in his own slime.
Comment on this
There is nobody better able to do it than the Deputy. There is nobody who does it every time he speaks in this House with greater practice than Deputy McGilligan. It is a sorry business when Deputy McGilligan has to go back to 1920 and 1921 to rake up slime. Every phrase of his was casting odium on the man who is now his leader and sits beside him, and on many of his colleagues for their acts in 1920 and 1921. President de Valera talked, and would talk to-day, of the brave men of the I.R.A. There were brave men, and there are brave men, probably. I do not know them as I used to know them. Ex-President Cosgrave does not know them as he used to know them. But he was one of them, and Deputy McGilligan was not. He was always where he could safely slander people with his slimy tongue—he never took any risks.
Comment on this
That statement is true. So far as my knowledge goes, he was never in any danger at any time of his life.
Comment on this
His reputation is before us. Deputy McGilligan has a slimy tongue and can get up and defend his reputation, if it is attacked, where it needs defence.
Comment on this
No, but the President's is. It is a thing of value not alone to the President, but to this State. The President at no time stood for murder or condoned murder or encouraged people to murder either before 1920, that Deputy McGilligan referred to, or at any time afterwards. I hate to go back. I used when in Opposition often remind the House, and I am often twitted with it since, of the awful things that happened here and that the members of the late Government were primarily responsible for from 1921 onwards. I often did that. I was told often that it was unwise to do it, but I felt very keenly the horrible crimes that blackened our nation and our race which were committed by people in responsible positions or that were condoned by people in responsible positions in this State.
Comment on this
He said people in authority committed certain crimes. That is the statement he made.
Comment on this
Nor need I go back to dates long anterior to that and subsequent to it. The Minister lost nobody in that business.
Comment on this
I lost many good friends. I know Deputy Cosgrave has lost some and I regret it most sincerely. I did not start this talk of murder to-night. I did not challenge, nor did anybody here challenge, anybody with condoning murder until the slimy tongue of Deputy McGilligan started all this raking up of old sores and history in order to try and blacken the fair name of the President whose boots he is not fit to shine. Whatever may be said about the President, he is a man of courage anyhow. He took his life in his hands many times, as did Deputy Cosgrave and some of his colleagues, but never Deputy McGilligan.
Comment on this
He stood behind and used the vile tongue which the House knows he possesses to blacken the character of a decent man, such as the President is. Nobody is better fitted to do it; nobody is usually paid for doing it. The President at no period of his career ever poured slime —to use the Deputy's word—on the I.R.A. I have often listened to him since we came into this House in 1927 discussing these matters about the I.R.A. and their records and doings, and he pleaded with the then Government, up to 1932, to be forbearing and patient with these men, to give them time. It is always in my mind that he often stated that we cannot in five years, or maybe in ten or 15 years, get away from our history from 1918 or 1919 to 1923 in a hurry. We should realise that.
We cannot forget the teachings of all of us on both sides of the House, Deputy Cosgrave, Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald as much as anybody else, all of us on that side of the House as well as on this, what we taught and what we stood for and what we condoned. We cannot forget these things, and even if we tried to forget them, as we ought to do, we cannot induce all the country to do it, much as we would like to do it, I think, on every side of the House. We will never do it as long as the slime of Deputy McGilligan is allowed to percolate around—never if he has a chance to keep the dirt and filth and horrors of that period still before the minds of the young men of the country in particular. We cannot, as the President often stated here, much as we would like to, get all the country simply to cut themselves off from that past that is not all full of honour and glory for us. And, therefore, he pleaded as we plead. We pleaded as a Government, and have done so ever since we came in here, for forbearance and patience for those whom I regard and the President regards and has always regarded, in regard to certain actions, as misguided young men. For four years we practised that forbearance. We were challenged time after time in debate here by ex-President Cosgrave and his colleagues to denounce the I.R.A., to proclaim the I.R.A. and to use the full measure of the law against them. We practised what we preached when we were in Opposition. We practised forbearance. We said to the House and we acted on it "We will take our time, we will try and teach these young men what we think they ought to know, the line we think they ought to follow, and we will be patient." Things have happened, things will happen and may happen again because of the teachings and the example of Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Mulcahy and of President de Valera and of Deputy Seán T. O Ceallaigh and of all of us at a certain period.
Things will happen. We cannot shut our eyes to them. There are people who will believe these principles. They will try to put them into practice, not taking into account the big fundamental changes that have taken place, but we think, and we have acted on it, that forbearance, patience and quiet example was the best line to follow with those people. The Deputies opposite would appear to be quite annoyed and quite discontented now when we have not continued to follow that line. From one point of view they seem to be pleased that we have brought upon ourselves the wrath of those who remain, a small number I think, as adherents and supporters of the Irish Republican organisation. I think they rushed these two by-elections in Galway and Wexford because they thought that they could use the I.R.A. for mean political Party purposes and to defeat us, hoping that those people would in their wrath be against us for doing what they have been clamouring for so long that we should do. Now, we have done it for certain good reasons. Our patience became exhausted, and we had to take certain action when the lives of citizens were taken. We could not any longer show any tolerance or forbearance when the lives of citizens were taken as they were taken by, as we believe, members of an organisation. The Opposition used that opportunity for mean Party political purposes, and if there is any man who dictated the mean part of it. I think it is Deputy McGilligan. I believe that, because, whatever may be said of others, I believe that, like the I.R.A. men whom I have known, they have courage anyhow. Usually they will not squeal. They will face the consequences, but Deputy McGilligan would never put himself and never did put himself in the way of having to face any risk.
It was amusing to hear a man with the slimy capacity of Deputy McGilligan talk of putting a bridle on tongues. No wonder the House laughed. No wonder they enjoyed the joke. Was there ever a person in this House or outside of it who has a greater capacity for slime, for filth and dirt than he has? He is no credit to his Party or to the House. I admire people who can say hard things. I have said them myself. Others, on the other side of the House, have said them, and said them to me. I enjoy the man who can get a hard blow in. I do not mind how hard it is. I will try to get my own back off him, but mean personal slime and abuse is something that I think there is no value in to any individual or to any Party. Deputy McGilligan wallows in it up to his chin, and I am sure he enjoys it. He quoted, he did not quote as far as I remember, but he referred to instructions issued by the present Minister for Defence to the I.R.A. The present Minister for Defence was Chief of Staff to the I.R.A. Is there any disgrace in that? He was Chief of Staff even after this Free State was established. He was in a very important position in the Republican Army before the Free State was established, a very important position in which he risked his life every hour of the day over long periods, a thing that Deputy McGilligan never did. In the 1920-21 period we did not start the fight against the State, to tear down the State, and Deputy McGilligan knows that well. Between the Parties that had been in the Dáil up to the time of the Treaty there was a Pact arranged on both sides. We arranged the Pact with the Treaty Party, and while we were waiting for the new Government to be formed, and the Dáil to be assembled, the civil war started. Those of us who took the opposite side on the Treaty did not start the civil war. We repudiate the suggestion that we were responsible for starting the civil war, but at any rate when it did start some of us took our part in it and took the risks. We fought and lost. We were beaten. That is the plain fact, that we were beaten and we acknowledge it. During that period some of us tried to end the régime that was then in control because we believed that they were illegally in control. They had seized power and were not the real Government authority. We believed that, and, even after the civil war ended and for some years, we tried hard to bring down that Government and we failed.
It is no disgrace to own up that we were beaten. We went to the people and asked the people to back us in the fight against recognising that Government as a proper Government, and we were beaten by the people. Then the murder of Kevin O'Higgins occurred—the Lord rest his soul. President de Valera, and several of those who are now with him in his Executive Council, realised that that condition of affairs could not go on, and what was to us an important decision was arrived at. We came into this House and recognised it, protesting as we did against the oath of allegiance. We took the earliest opportunity of abolishing the oath of allegiance. That is all ancient history. But, while we broke away from our colleagues and came in here and recognised this House—it was a big break with us, a very big and important break with us and with our past—we have to remember those we left behind. We have to remember those whom Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Mulcahy left behind; those who did not make the break that Deputy Cosgrave or that we made. They were just as much republicans as we were and swore an oath to the republic. Deputy Cosgrave, Deputy Mulcahy and the others—they made their break; we made it later, in the meantime having fought all we knew how and having been beaten. We had not the money or the arms of the State or of England behind us to beat our opponents.
Comment on this
We got beaten— that is acknowledged. I, at any rate, am prepared to own up to facts. But we must rememer those we left behind and we cannot expect everybody to make the same change at the same time. I do not know them, but there are, I am sure, men amongst those who do not see as we see now or as Deputy Cosgrave saw earlier that certain actions that were taken were wrong, imprudent, misguided. We have been forbearing, we have been patient, and we hope still to show patience and forbearance, but not with murder, and never was there any forbearance or patience shown with murder, at any rate, since we came into office or before it. It is no discredit to the Minister for Defence, Mr. Aiken, to issue orders as he did issue orders. Thanks be to God, he was man enough to issue his orders at times when there was risk, when there was danger in it, as Deputy McGilligan well knows. He was not there to back up even the men who founded this State. He was always on the safe side, where his tongue was the only risk that was involved. It is extraordinary, after all we have listened to since we came into this House in 1927, to find, now, Miss MacSwiney taken into the arms of the Opposition. She is now the hero of the Opposition.
Comment on this
So well you can. After your speech to-night the hero is Michael Conway and those who act with him and the heroine is Miss MacSwiney. Will you say that to Deputy Cosgrave about Mr. Moss Twomey?
Comment on this
If the Deputy had had been here, Deputy McGilligan might not have been allowed to proceed along that line; but he was not here and we got the whole history from 1921 on. I, at any rate, was in the habit of mentioning it long ago, but I did not mention it since I became a Minister.
Comment on this
I wanted to know if the Minister claims to be in the state of grace since he took over office?
Comment on this
No, unfortunately; I wish I could say that. I am nearly always in a state of disgrace, judging by the comments of my friends here on the Opposition and the newspapers. If I am not in disgrace, I am in hot water.
Comment on this
I am afraid that the Opposition are going to get a very serious disappointment with regard to the elections. They believed in acting with indecent haste, as their friend the Irish Times said to them—indecent haste rushing these by-elections before the bodies of the two Deputies of their Party were cold in their clay. They rushed the by-elections because (1) Michael Conway was being tried, and (2) the Government had denounced the I.R.A. “Now,” said Deputy McGilligan, probably, “is our chance.”
Comment on this
"Now is our chance," they said. "We will rush this, and the I.R.A. situation is bound to swamp the Government." You are going to get the biggest drop you ever got in your political life, and I am no prophet. In both Galway and Wexford you will get a drop. I do not like wallowing in the slime, so I will leave Deputy McGilligan's speech. We were asked by Deputy O'Sullivan about the Constitution. That matter has been referred to a few times in the House and a few times in the course of the by-elections. The President has promised to bring in a Constitution Bill in the autumn, and he has promised to give ample time to the Dáil and to the country to know the contents of that Bill and to discuss it. When ample time has been allowed for the Constitution Bill to be known in every detail, he has promised to have a General Election in which that will be a main item. I think the House and the country may hold their patience until October to see the contents of that Bill, and I think no useful purpose could be served by discussing it at this stage.
Another matter that was discussed by several speakers was the economic war and the prospect of settling it. We are as anxious to settle that economic war as anybody. We are just as anxious as anybody in the country to have a satisfactory settlement, but we will not settle until we get what we regard as a settlement satisfactory to this country and to this Government. When we reach that, when we are near reaching it even, the country and the Dáil will be fully informed. We are not blocking the road to a settlement by what we would regard, at any rate, as any condition which this country has a right to put down before a settlement is reached. We are told we could make a satisfactory settlement. I have yet to learn that a settlement satisfactory to the Government and to the country could be made on terms that this country could accept with honour. We are told that the Opposition could make a settlement in very quick time. We are told by many of their speakers here and outside that if the people would only give a chance to Deputy Cosgrave again, what a magnificent settlement he would make. I think the answer to that is "Once bitten twice shy". We know the damn bad nought settlement he made before, and I do not think the country is prepared for a second chance at the same price.
Comment on this
Would the Minister tell us what effort has been made by this Government to bring about a settlement?
Comment on this
Every effort consistent with maintaining what we regard as the rights of this State and of this Government.
Comment on this
There is always something doing. Not a month passes that something is not done in some way or other.
Comment on this
A number of small points were raised by Deputy Davin about widows' and orphans' pensions and unemployment assistance. With regard to widows' and orphans' pensions, Deputy Davin knows that were it not for the existence of this Government you would not have widows' and orphans' pensions now. I have said here in the House, not at the inspiration of Deputy Davin or anybody else in his Party or any other Party, that as soon as we could possibly do it, with the legislative programme we have, we hope to introduce an amending Bill making arrangements for extending the Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Act so that a much greater number of widows and orphans would benefit.
I do not think there is anything else that I need refer to, except to say that the Act under which Michael Conway was tried was brought in by the late Government, and was condemned by us because, as the President said here in reply, I think, to the leader of the Labour Party, we did not trust the Opposition to use such a machine when they were the Government. We did not trust them, knowing their record, knowing their history. We did not trust a machine of that kind into their keeping. We put that machine out of operation when we took office. We were optimistic enough to believe that the necessity for its use had gone for good, but, as the House and the country knows, within a year or two we had to invoke that machinery——
Comment on this
——because we found there was no other legislation, no other Act on the Statute Book, that gave as the power to deal with the situation we were up against in about August, 1933, when Mr. Cosgrave, the then leader of the Party, abdicated in favour of Mr. General O'Duffy.
Comment on this
I think it is just the proper word to use in regard to Deputy Cosgrave, who thought he ought to have been for all time the monarch of the Free State; who was the most disappointed man on earth that he was ever put out of it——
Comment on this
——and who regrets night and day that he is not still President of the Executive Council; at least so all his friends tell us. He abdicated. I think that is a good word; or maybe he got a little push. He handed over the Party to one who tried to use the Party, until, I think, Mr. Seamus Hogan, and I do not know who else—Deputy MacDermot helped —found him out and showed him up. At any rate, we were forced to use that machine because of the menace of the Blueshirt organisation.
Comment on this
Will the Minister bear with me for a moment? The General has nobody here to speak on his behalf. Could he not leave his name out of it?
Comment on this
Deputy Cosgrave does not accept responsibility for anything the General did at that time?
Comment on this
That is another question. I am prepared to answer for all my own acts and for a number of the General's, but I say, in justice to him, that he has no one here to answer for him and he ought to be left out of it.
Comment on this
The Minister's recollection is at fault. It was not on General O'Duffy's Blueshirts it was used first. It was on a few of us farmers who assembled at a sale.
Comment on this
Who cared anything about you? There was no risk so far as Deputy Belton was concerned. Deputy Belton would never menace anything worse than a beefsteak. During the period when Deputy Cosgrave was only vice-president of his organisation, there were hundreds of grievous illegalities committed by the Party of which he was a vice-president, and I think Deputy MacDermot was another, if I mistake not. During that period, in December, 1933, alone, five members of the League of Youth were convicted of unlawful possession of firearms. In 1934 over 350 members of the League of Youth were convicted of offences such as treefelling, road-blocking, and interference with railway lines. In 1935 there were some hundreds more.
Comment on this
That is not correct. There were people seriously injured in a train wreck in Waterford.
Comment on this
Deputy Murphy's house was attempted to be burned by the organisation of which Deputy Dillon was a leading member. A barrack in Kildorrery was attacked with arms by members of Deputy Dillon's organisation. That was the reason why that machinery had to be invoked. Unfortunately it still has to be invoked. But if we had our way, if the wishes of the Government were possible of realisation, of course that machine would be scrapped, but as long as life is menaced in this country, whatever means are necessary to protect life in this country will be used to the full by the Executive Council.
Comment on this
On the 29th of last month, Sir, I addressed a question to the President of the Executive Council in connection with the trial and sentence of Michael Conway, and on that occasion I received a reply from the President in which he said:
"The Executive Council is satisfied that Michael Conway was given a fair trial and that every opportunity was afforded him to submit evidence on his behalf, had he so desired."
I asked the President, in a Supplementary question, if he would say why he now believes it is right and proper to arraign a man on a capital charge before the Military Tribunal, seeing that in 1931 he was opposed to this tribunal being given any such powers in respect of life or death over a prisoner. The President, in reply to that Supplementary Question, said:
"My view in 1931, I think, was quite clear from what I stated at the time, that I did not trust the Executive Council of the day with these powers, that I indicated that another line of policy was possible, and the change is due to the fact that that line of policy has been tried."
In going on further, the President, in a later supplementary, said, when he was asked whether any persons with legal qualifications constituted the tribunal:
"That court has been trying various cases for a considerable time, and any unprejudiced person looking at the conduct of that tribunal in the cases submitted must come to the conclusion that if a person is not guilty of an offence he certainly will get before that tribunal as good a chance of acquitting himself as he will get before any court."
There, Sir, we had a declaration by the President of the Executive Council which seems to me to constitute a declaration of repentance by the Executive Council for having opposed the Constitution (Amendment) Act (No. 17) of 1931. The President in 1936, after his justifiably bitter and fierce denunciation of that Constitution (Amendment) Act of 1931, says now that he is satisfied that a person will get a fair trial before this Military Tribunal, and the President now definitely declares in this House that, five years after the tribunal was established, he for one is perfectly satisfied, not merely with the manner in which the tribunal is constituted, not merely with the qualifications of those who constitute it, but that he is satisfied that any person can get a fair trial from that tribunal even if the person is arraigned on a capital charge. In my opinion, that is a most amazing declaration from the President of the Executive Council.
Comment on this
For the purposes of this debate the Military Tribunal is a court. It has been duly constituted by the Oireachtas. The decisions of that court are not open to review or criticism here. The Dáil has no judicial functions, is not a court of appeal, and has no right to review the decisions or the transactions of that or any other duly constituted court. As to the personnel or the constitution of the court, that also is established by law, embodied in the Constitution, can only be changed by rescinding the Act which constitutes the court, or by express motion tabled for that purpose.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, the proclamation, as an administrative measure, can be withdrawn.
Comment on this
The withdrawal of the proclamation is a very different thing from discussing whether or not an accused person gets a fair trial at that court. That is a matter that may not be discussed in the Dáil.
Comment on this
But, Sir, I have not alleged that anybody got a fair trial there. The only person doing that is the President, and I do not propose to pass any judgment as to that, in this House at any rate, whatever I might say outside.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir. I suggest that the Deputy is out of order in the expression he used, that he has not suggested that anybody got a fair trial.
Comment on this
I put it to you, Sir, that the question as to whether a trial before the tribunal is a fair trial or not is, according to your ruling recently given, Sir, out of order.
Comment on this
Quite, Sir. I am perfectly clear as to that, and I have not said anything at all about the kind of trials persons got before the Military Tribunal. All I have done is to quote from the President where he said that the Executive Council were satisfied that Michael Conway was given a fair trial before the Military Tribunal. That is the only evidence we have of what kind of trial, in the opinion of the President of the Executive Council, can be got before this Military Tribunal. But I, Sir, am not passing any judgment on the Military Tribunal in his particular case or any other particular case.
Comment on this
The President did. He is the only person who has done so. Not merely has he given his own opinion on it, but he invited the public generally to look at the cases that went before the Tribunal and to feel convinced—apparently, by his assurance— that if a person is not guilty of an offence he will certainly get before that Tribunal as good a chance of acquitting himself as he would get before any court. These declarations are not made by me. I have not at all introduced the question of the kind of trial people get before the Military Tribunal. If I wanted to do that, Sir, I might only quote some speeches made by members of the present Executive Council, but I do not even propose to do that——certainly, not at any great length, Sir. The answer by the President to my question on the 29th of last month is a definite declaration that whatever reservations the President of the Executive Council had in accepting the Constitution (Amendment) (No. 17) Act, he certainly has none now. We may take it, therefore, that the President to-day warmly embraces that Constitution (Amendment) Act of 1931 as an instrument under which a person can be tried, not by judges, but by military officers who constitute the court, and that that person can get a fair trial. That is the declaration of the President to-day, and this declaration comes after a bitter denunciation by the President and members of the Executive Council, that this particular piece of legislation, before it became an Act, and while it was passing through this House, was the most abominable piece of tyranny that the House was ever asked to pass.
Comment on this
On any legislative measure passing through this House very strong opinions are often expressed quite legitimately by Deputies. Once a Bill becomes an Act, however, these opinions may not be repeated. The Act in question is an Article of the Constitution and is not now open to criticism. The Deputy is out of order in criticising the Act as there is not before the House any motion to repeal or partially rescind or amend it.
Comment on this
But, Sir, I am not criticising the Act. What I have said is that the President, who now warmly embraces the Act of 1931, which he then described as a Coercion Act, is now, apparently, wholeheartedly in favour of the administration of the Constitution (Amendment) Act, and, in my opinion, the Act is being used with all the rigour and all the severity with which the President forecasted in 1931 it would be used by the last Government. We were told then that the legislation passed was undesirable legislation, that it gave to the Executive Council of that period powers greater than were possessed by any European dictator.
Comment on this
The Deputy may not indirectly criticise an Act of this Oireachtas. What was said when the measure was going through is a very different matter and was then quite in order.
Comment on this
Do you rule, Sir, that I am not entitled to call attention to the declarations made by members of this House in 1931, and contrast those declarations with their actions now to show their inconsistencies as members of this House? I am not criticising the legislation. I have so far definitely refrained, because of the line taken by previous speakers, from making any comment on the Constitution Amendment Act. What I have said is that that Act, when it was passing through the House, was denounced by the members of the present Executive Council who are using it to-day and using it with such thrilling satisfaction——
Comment on this
The Deputy must know that Deputies are free to criticise, and criticise severely, any legislation in course of enactment. Once legislation has been enacted it must be accepted an Act of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
On a point of order. May I not compare what President de Valera said in this House in 1931 with what President de Valera says about precisely the same thing in this House in 1936, just as I would be entitled to compare what the Minister for Finance says in Skerries with what the Minister for Finance says in Dáil Eireann? Surely I am entitled to make that comparison?
Comment on this
Is it the same thing? You, Sir, have already pointed out that when a Bill is going through the House there is freedom of discussion which ceases the moment it becomes an Act.
Comment on this
Nobody has yet criticised the Act, so far as I have heard. I have heard Deputy Norton say that President de Valera, when this was a Bill, used certain terms about it and he is contrasting that with President de Valera's view of it now. Surely those two things are fit and open to be contrasted in this House?
Comment on this
I do not propose, as I have already declared on half a dozen occasions, apparently ineffectually, to make any reference whatever to the contents of the Act because I believe my action in doing so would be ruled on unfavourably by you. What I intend, however, to do, and I think it is properly in order if I may humbly say so, is to compare the declarations of the President on this Act before it was passed through this House and his actions and views to-day.
Comment on this
The Deputy may not quote opinions expressed when a measure was going through this House as the opinion of the Deputy or Minister on the Act. Every Bill introduced is open to criticism, almost unlimited criticism. Acts may not be criticised. The distinction is obvious.
Comment on this
May I submit, Sir, that if the President gets up and says, when the Public Safety Act was passing through: "This is an abomination," and a year later, when the Act is in operation, says: "This is the finest Act that was ever passed by this House," am I not entitled to rise and say that some trifling inconsistencies manifest themselves between the two statements that this is the most loathsome machinery ever brought before a legislature and that it is the grandest Act ever passed?
Comment on this
The Deputy is putting a hypothetical question relative to quotations that have not been made.
Comment on this
I want to say that the whole administration of this Act by the present Executive Council is in strange contrast with their views on the equipment which was being given to the Executive Council in 1931. In that year we had declarations by the President and by the Minister for Finance, who mustered up all the fury he possessed to declare that this was a fiendish piece of tyranny which ought not to be passed, and when the Minister said that, and when the President said something similar, I believe that both of them were right in 1931, but to-day——
Comment on this
I am not criticising the Act as administered. What I am saying is that the very Ministers who said that in 1931 have now given us a certificate that this Act is a satisfactory Act, and that you can get a fair trial under it, and the public generally are invited to observe the impartiality of the tribunal. That was the atmosphere in which the 1931 Bill was passed. The House will note the strange change of attitude on the part of the Executive Council since then. On that occasion, they did not want any Executive Council to get the powers which they now have under this Act. At that time, they did not want to be armed with the dictatorial powers which are in the Act. They said "The normal law of the country is good enough for us and we do not need these extraordinary powers to carry on the administration of this country." That was the attitude in 1931. In 1936, we were told not only that the Act is desirable, but that it is a good Act, and that everybody charged before the tribunal, no matter what the type of offence with which he is charged, can feel sure of getting a fair trial there. I want to say I do not believe that these statements by the President of the Executive Council represent the position. I want to say that I am not satisfied that it is necessary for the Executive Council to have these powers and I want to go further and say that these powers are being used with a severity and ruthlessness which is not justifiable.
Deputy MacDermot, of course, this evening availed of the motion for the adjournment to deliver one of his supercilious and patronising speeches, in the course of which he delivered the usual sermon on British Imperialism from prepared notes. Deputy MacDermot, who is not too long acquainted with recent political happenings in this country, discovered that the Labour Party did not condemn political murder. Let me tell Deputy MacDermot that the members who constitute the Labour Party in this House have lived in this country since 1916. They have gone with the nation through the travail since that period. Many of them have fought in the National movement. They know this nation, they know its people; they know what political murder is; and when Deputy MacDermot was enjoying the snug comfort of another country, the members of the Labour Party were here sharing the trials and tribulations of the people, which Deputy MacDermot took good care to avoid. Speeches of that kind, from one who looks at Ireland from Paris or some other part of Europe, are altogether out of place here. If Deputy MacDermot still feels that he must deliver Imperialistic, supercilious, and patronising speeches here, he ought to try to import into them, at least, a little knowledge, even if he cannot import into them a little modesty.
In dealing with a matter of this kind, I want to say that, so far as political murders are concerned, they have always been condemned by the Labour Party. Whether they were political murders of 1936 or political murders of any other year, the Labour Party has, in my opinion, rightly and justifiably condemned political murders of any kind. In respect to the political murders which were committed in Cork and Dungarvan, the Labour Party has condemned them, and I condemn them again, as unjustifiable, as diabolical outrages on two citizens, and as something which cannot be justified on any pretext whatever. It seems to me to be nothing short of amazing that you can find in 1936 any group of men who can imagine that they are serving any good cause or promoting the cause of this country by murders of that kind. That declaration by me is not different in substance from declarations which were made from these benches many years before Deputy MacDermot came to Ireland. There seems to me to be a strange inconsistency in the whole attitude of the Executive Council to-day compared with the attitude they adopted when in Opposition. The Vice-President said this evening that they wanted to act with restraint and forbearance, yet we find the Attorney-General formulating charges against men that are not known to the ordinary law; charges which, in the main, consist of artificial offences created by the Constitution (Amendment) Act, 1931. The Attorney-General knows perfectly well, and ought to know better now, after having listened to the Vice-President's speech, that these people who have been arraigned by him on alleged offences under the Constitution (Amendment) Act, 1931, are persons who will not answer the questions which have been addressed to them, because the purpose of the questions has been to felon-set these people. Yet the Attorney-General very definitely makes the charge against them of refusing to answer questions, knowing that in that way the felon-setting kind of arrangement means that these people can be tried by this Military Tribunal, of which the President of the Executive Council now thinks so much. We were told in speeches made in the Wexford and Galway by-elections that trial by jury is impossible in this country. I ask the Attorney-General when was trial by jury given a chance since 1932. Will he tell us one case since 1932 where a person was arraigned before a jury, on a charge which ought to have justified his being condemned, where the jury refused through fear or intimidation to convict the accused? Mention one case since 1932 where you have tried to work the system of trial by jury.
Comment on this
Let the Attorney-General explain his own administration. The Deputy can help him afterwards.
Comment on this
The Attorney-General will welcome your help afterwards. Deputy MacDermot comes to the assistance of the President, and Deputy Anthony to the assistance of the Attorney-General. The Deputy can help the Attorney-General afterwards. I am sure he will be impressed by the Deputy's profound want of legal knowledge.
Comment on this
I will support the Government and President de Valera when endeavouring to preserve order.
Comment on this
We were told that trial by jury has failed; that it is not possible to get convictions by juries.
We were told that by a Government which has not produced a single case to show that trial by jury has failed during their period of office. Will the Attorney-General tell us of a single case where a person has been tried by jury, and has been acquitted, when, in his opinion the facts of the case were such as justified the conviction of the prisoner? Can we be told that by the Attorney-General? Then we will be able to ascertain whether this ramp, that there cannot be trial by jury, is not just an excuse by the Executive Council to use the Constitution (Amendment) Act which was passed for them by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. One would think, judging by the rantings one hears from some political platforms that the only task of a jury was to convict. One would imagine that a jury had only one function, and that that was to satisfy a thirst for vengeance on the part of an Executive Council. The function of a jury is to try a man and to ascertain his guilt, and, if not guilty, to acquit him. If the jury has any reasonable doubt of his guilt, they must give the accused person the benefit of the doubt. One would imagine from speeches made by members of the Government Party that a jury had only one function, unless, according to these hysterical speeches, there was a thirst for vengeance running right through the speeches made in the recent municipal elections in Dublin by the Minister for Finance. I do not want to refer, although I wish it was in order to do so, to the trial of Michael Conway before the Military Tribunal.