Adjournment Motion.
Contributions 370–561 of 561. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
That is comment. As to the question which appeared on the Order Paper, the Chair had doubts about its being in order. Comment may not be made now on the decision of the court in the case, in the guise of a reply to an answer given by the President.
Comment on this
I am not seeking any such subterfuge, and I must take exception to the suggestion that I am. While you were in the Chair the President invited us to examine the cases that came before the court, and I am quite entitled to say that I do not at all accept his views about the matter.
Comment on this
The Minister can make his speech afterwards. Let us hope it will be much more rational than the speeches he delivered at Ringsend and Balbriggan.
Comment on this
I am. While this man was on trial for his life before this Tribunal, we had the Minister for Finance, holding an important office in the Executive Council, using the local elections in the City of Dublin as an excuse for taking the platform to indulge in most reckless and wanton comment upon a case which was then at hearing before the Military Tribunal. It is strange that although other Ministers participated in the elections and made speeches, it was left to the reckless-minded Minister for Finance to come out and to unburden himself of his views on the guilt of the man before the Tribunal. I never witnessed a more outrageous performance while a prisoner was standing trial for his life. A Minister for Finance, in a democratically governed country, where there was proper respect for the majesty of the law and the rights of prisoners, who made an utterance of that kind would be compelled to resign. The retention of the Constitution (Amendment) Act, and the manner in which it is being administered are utterly unjustifiable in the circumstances of to-day. We have not had a single attempt made by the Attorney-General or by any member of the Government to show that trial by jury has broken down. In any event, I want to say definitely that even if trial by jury has broken down in cases where a fair trial cannot be got before a jury, there should be some machinery established, consisting of persons with legal knowledge and qualified to weigh evidence, to try any prisoners arraigned on the charge of murder.
Comment on this
We would not be allowed to discuss that now. We will discuss it with you in Wexford.
Comment on this
The whole attitude of the Executive Council in connection with the administration of the Act is an attitude of panic, which would be justified only in the gravest possible emergency. The panic-stricken manner in which the Military Tribunal is being used shows that the Executive Council do not appreciate the harm they are doing to the country. The attitude of the Executive Council seems to be—"when in doubt do as the Cumann na nGaedheal Party did." The Constitution (Amendment) Act and the Military Tribunal are being used in a manner worse than they were by the last Government. One would imagine that the Attorney-General, at least, would try to preserve a balance in all this welter of panic and confusion. But even the Attorney-General seems to have been inoculated with the hysteria which, apparently, radiates from the Minister for Finance. The Attorney-General, who holds an exalted legal office, seems to be in a state of panic and nerves these days. Taking a rest from trying people under the Constitution (Amendment) Act, the Attorney-General went down to Wexford on Sunday. Seeking recreation from the laborious task of bringing persons before the Military Tribunal, he talked learnedly about Communism and the dangers of "united fronts." He proceeded to warn the Labour Party about the dangers of Communism. That was the role of the Attorney-General on Sunday.
Comment on this
I thought the Deputy was going to tell us about the members of the Fianna Fáil Party who were flirting with Communism. Perhaps he would do so now.
Comment on this
The laborious task of bringing people before the Military Tribunal preyed on the Attorney-General's nerves. He went down to Wexford and got some kind of comfort for his ragged nerves by talking learnedly to the people of Taghmon on the danger of Communism and "united fronts" in France and Spain and a lot of other irrelevancies which had nothing to do with the people of Wexford, with the by-election or with the agricultural, industrial or social life of the people. The Attorney-General warned the Labour Party of the danger of association with Communism. This from an Attorney-General in a Party which, not so many years ago, sent a delegation to Russia while the Communist Party was in control there!
Comment on this
One at a time. If the members of the Executive Council put one question at a time, I shall endeavour to answer it. What is the first question?
Comment on this
The answer might be a bit awkward. I can only reply when I get silence on the part of the Executive Council. The Attorney-General was allowed to make a speech in silence in Taghmon last week.
Comment on this
The Irish Press did not report any interruptions. Does the Vice-President deny that members of the present Fianna Fáil Party in this House were responsible for sending a delegation to Russia?
Comment on this
The Deputy was going to tell us about the mission to Russia. That is what we want to hear.
Comment on this
We were warned by the Attorney-General about the dangers of Communism. He speaks as a member of a Party some members of which were responsible for sending a delegation to Russia.
Comment on this
It may be interesting to the Deputy but it is quite irrelevant. A debate on the adjournment must relate to the actions of the Government since they became a Government. Deputies are not at liberty to go back to the events of 1922.
Comment on this
The hysterical speech of the Attorney-General on that occasion is symptomatic of the hysteria which has consumed the whole Executive Council in the administration of the Constitution (Amendment) Act. I want to close that incident by inviting the Attorney-General to go back to Wexford on Sunday and tell the people there the purpose for which the Commission went to Russia in 1924.
Comment on this
It is not orderly to interrupt the Chair even by way of approval. The Government is responsible only for its actions as a Government—that is to say, since it assumed office. What the Deputy is referring to I know not, but if what I have just said were borne in mind by Deputies it might make for more orderly and more seemly debate.
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I inquire from the Chair if Deputy Davin alleges that a member of the present Executive Council was partially responsible for sending a Commission to Soviet Russia, presumably for the purpose of collaborating with the Government of that country, is it not relevant, when discussing the stewardship of the Executive Council, to point out that it includes a person who has been in direct or indirect contact with the Soviet Government of Russia and is, therefore, an unfit person to be a member of the Executive Council?
Comment on this
It is not clear that the Deputy has raised any point of order. What the Chair has pointed out is that the Government is responsible to this House only since it took up office. Actions of members of the Government prior to that date should not be discussed in this debate.
Comment on this
I shall pass from that matter now. I should like, however, to warn the Attorney-General—to adopt his own word—that when he purports to warn the Labour Party about the dangers of Communism, he ought to look around and see whether he, as a member of the Fianna Fáil Party, is associated with members of a Party which sent a delegation to Russia.
Comment on this
I hope the Attorney-General will tell the whole story in Wexford or will tell us the story here, if he chooses to speak. We should be able to learn more from the Attorney-General's knowledge of Communism as a result of a visit of some of his Party's supporters to Russia.
Another matter I want to raise in connection with this motion concerns the allegations which have been made by persons incarcerated under the Constitution Amendment Act, that they are being unfairly treated, that they are being kept in solitary confinement and that the worst type of military prison life is being made applicable to those people. Statements have been circulated to members of this House by persons who have been detained in Arbour Hill to the effect that they were kept in solitary confinement, occupying each alternate cell so that they might not be able to establish, even illicitly, any kind of communication with the prisoner in the next occupied cell. Allegations have been made that these prisoners are there being compelled to withstand the worst rigours of military discipline. I want to know from the Executive Council whether there is any truth in these allegations?
Comment on this
Obviously matters of administration, particularly of a detailed character, should not be raised on an adjournment debate. Such points should have been discussed on the Vote for the Minister's Department.
Comment on this
If I may submit so, I think that the detention in solitary confinement, as alleged, of over 100 individuals——
Comment on this
As alleged. That is the trouble. Ministers having had no notice are not in a position to reply.
Comment on this
Why have they not an opportunity of replying? I submit they have every opportunity of replying. Allegations have been made that prisoners have been detained in solitary confinement, and in my opinion that is a matter of transcendent importance to this House.
Comment on this
If the Deputy thought so he had a right to put down a motion on that matter, but he has not done it.
Comment on this
Will you give that opportunity to a member of your own Party, some of whom approached me and asked me to put down a motion on this question? They would not do so themselves——
Comment on this
I will bring Deputy Kelly to a member of his own Party who approached me in the matter. Will he be satisfied to hear the story from his own mouth?
Comment on this
I am not obliged to take advice from the Minister for Finance or from any member of his Party.
Comment on this
The Deputy's heart has been bleeding for these men, and we want to stop the haemorrhage.
Comment on this
The Minister's tongue was bleeding at one time for them. We all know what he is capable of in his moments of exaltation, but he does not mention them in recent years. I submit that the allegations which have been made that prisoners have been kept in solitary confinement are matters of the utmost importance to the members of the House and of particular importance to anybody who wants to see that every type of prisoner, no matter what his offence is, is treated in accordance with some humane standards. Allegations have been made that these prisoners are detained in circumstances which impose solitary confinement on them, and that the worst rigours of military prison life are made applicable to them. I understand that while ordinary prisoners in the ordinary jails of the country are liable to have their cells and places of detention inspected by persons described as visiting justices, in Arbour Hill, the military prison, no outside person is allowed to enter it for the purpose of investigating the conditions there. We cannot, therefore, judge by the evidence of any independent person whether these allegations are true or untrue, but, whether they are true or untrue, there is sufficient public interest in the whole question to ensure that we ought to have an authoritative statement by some independent body other than those who are holding these prisoners in captivity. The House or the country has no information as to what the position or the conditions of these prisoners are.
There have been allegations that one prisoner has been driven mad. We have no independent evidence from anybody to show whether a statement of that kind is correct. We should have a statement of that kind from some independent authority whose integrity is such that the House can know what the precise position within the prison is.
It may, of course, be thought as something inconceivable that prisoners in this country can be ill-treated but we have it on the authority of the members of the present Executive Council that prisoners were ill-treated in that place of detention. If they were ill-treated before, in the view of the present members of the Executive Council, it is not unreasonable to assume that there is a slight possibility that they might be ill-treated and kept in solitary confinement to-day. These are matters about which the country requires some information and some assurance, I should say a very definite assurance, from somebody or some authority, who having investigated the matter in an impartial way can give the House and country generally, an assurance that this condition of affairs is not as it is alleged to be by those making charges of this kind.
I pass from that to the serious question of unemployment and say, not withstanding the putting into force of two Employment Period Orders, one of which is reckoned to have deprived 20,000 small farmers of the unemployment assistance benefit and the second Employment Period Order which is reckoned to have deprived 40,000 or 50,000 people of the unemployment assistance benefit, we still have registered at the employment exchanges, approximately 70,000 persons who have satisfied the rigid test imposed under the Unemployment Assistance Act that they are genuinely unemployed. These are 70,000 persons who have survived the rigorous tightening up of the administration of that Act.
Deputies here must be familiar with this question from the many letters they receive from persons who have been deprived of the benefit of the Act under the Employment Period Orders and under the still more unjustifiable and rigorous tightening up of the administration of that Act. It may be said by the Minister that the fact is that the unemployment has been reduced by 70,000 persons by reason of the working of the Employment Period Orders and that that is evidence of another 70,000 people having got work. Those Deputies who know the country and know the towns and the rural areas will have no difficulty in realising that the reduction in the number of persons registered is explained solely by the two Employment Period Orders and the tightening up of the administration of the Act which has deprived approximately 70,000 persons of the benefits which they normally would receive.
We were told, recently, by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that immediately on the issuing of the Employment Period Orders heaps of work would be found in the rural areas. Anybody who comes from the rural areas knows perfectly well that there is very little work to be got there. An effort was made recently to pretend that £2,500,000 had been provided to deal with unemployment over a wide area. Well, at least in the constituency I represent, there is no evidence that any of the £2,500,000 has found its way there. I imagine that the same story can be told by members of the other Parties.
Last week claims were made by the members of the Government Party and by the Minister for Agriculture down in Wexford that the Government was providing work or maintenance for all. But the unemployment figures as revealed by the Government's own returns show a different tale. These returns tell their own story as to the absence of employment throughout the country. Before the recent Employment Period Orders there were 144,000 registered at the exchanges as unemployed. We were told then that if these people were not provided with work they were provided with maintenance. We ought to see what the maintenance is. This maintenance so glibly talked of is 20/- a week to maintain a man and wife and five or six children in the City of Dublin with the cost of living here gone up as it is; or to maintain the same number of human beings in a town with a population of over 7,000 on 15/- a week; or to maintain in the bulk of the towns throughout the country, in the villages and in the rural areas, a man, a wife or five or six children on the miserable allowance of 12/6 a week.
Comment on this
Has not the Employment Period Order been approved of by this House? Are not the allowances statutory?
Comment on this
I am not saying one word about the allowances. If the Attorney-General would discontinue speaking to his colleagues while I am stating my case he would have no need to interrupt me.
Comment on this
I heard the Deputy complaining of the figures as to the amount allowed to a family. Are not these the figures in the Schedule of the Act passed by this House?
Comment on this
I am submitting that the amount allowed to the unemployed is statutory and that the Employment Period Orders have been approved of by this House.
Comment on this
Neither matters of administration nor legislation should be discussed on this motion. The custom now more honoured in the breach than in the observance, was that the Ceann Comhairle was given in writing by the different Parties in this House notice of the two, or at most three, subjects which it was decided to raise on the adjournment motion. The Chair on this occasion received no information. It seems, as Deputy Norton said earlier to-day, to be free for all Deputies on all sorts of issues.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows that the official record is not yet available. I certainly understood that the remark came from the Labour Benches. If I am mistaken I apologise.
Comment on this
In the view of the Chair, the Deputy has discussed them and is continuing to do so. It is difficult to see how the Deputy can quote all these allowances without discussing them.
Comment on this
Can I not tell the members of the House, who probably have never opened and read the Employment Period white paper——
Comment on this
That is a reflection on the Deputy's colleagues.
Comment on this
Yes, and on the Attorney-General and on his colleagues, and he knows it. I am discussing the figures here and I want the House to get this picture, that we have 144,000 persons registered as unemployed and that when considering their position we ought to remember that the Unemployment Assistance Act is being worked so that a man and wife and five or six children in the City of Dublin are given £1 a week to maintain them and that in towns with a population of 7,000 or over they get 15/- a week——
Comment on this
And that in the other areas such a man and his family get 12/6 a week. That is the low standard at which we are paying our unemployed population. It is because of that appallingly low standard that I want the Executive Council to tell the House on the Motion for the Adjournment what they are going to do towards solving the unemployment problem. That problem cannot be solved by means of Employment Period Orders and a tightening up of the administration. I am aware that these allowances are statutory but that does not make them any more helpful. We are entitled to ask the Executive Council what they propose to do to grapple with the problem of unemployment which at one time looked so easy of solution.
We are told that the export of £5,500,000 from this country to Great Britain is an appalling burden on our resources. With that viewpoint I am in the most hearty agreement. But there is an equally appalling burden thrown on the productivity of this country, and that is to be found in the fact that there are 144,000 persons in idleness and denied any opportunity of working. What is the Government doing to create work and try to pool the common resources of productivity? We will not export £5,500,000 to Great Britain because that is a heavy tax on our productivity, yet we tolerate in silence keeping 144,000 people unemployed and feeding them out of the common pool of productivity to which they are contributing nothing. The appalling waste caused by that unemployment problem is a matter upon which we should have some declaration from the Executive Council.
A few months ago we listened to a declaration from the Minister for Finance deploring the corporative and totalitarian States; pinning his faith in private enterprise which thrills the Minister's mind so much. Will he now tell us what private enterprise is going to do to absorb these 144,000 unemployed? Will the Minister tell us what private enterprise will do in this respect and how he will utilise and develop private enterprise so as to get these people something more than the low statutory rates which they are being paid under the Employment Assistance Act? An allowance of 12/6 a week to a man, his wife and five or six children is all that is being given under this Act while the State pays 12/6 a week to maintain one child in an industrial school. We think it necessary that 12/6 a week should be paid for that child to maintain it properly.
Comment on this
I have dealt with this problem of the Military Tribunal and with the unemployment question. The only thing I have to add about the Military Tribunal is that the sooner the Government revoke the proclamation bringing it into operation the better; and the sooner the Minister for Finance refrains from commenting on cases that are sub judice the better it will be for the Minister, for the Government and for the country. The Minister for Finance in 1931 when the Public Safety Act was being passed told us that the people who would constitute that tribunal were bloodhounds and then he became lyrical with a quotation from Shelley.
Comment on this
The Minister gave us a lyrical quotation from Shelley about Pitt and Castlereagh and about the bloodhounds following Castlereagh. These are the same people now that the Minister wants——
Comment on this
The Deputy is as inaccurate about the quotation as he is in the rest of his remarks.
Comment on this
No; the Minister used the words after quoting from Shelley about Castlereagh and his seven bloodhounds, "only in this case we are not going to have seven bloodhounds—we are going to have only five, the five officers of the secret Tribunal." These are the people who are trying prisoners under the Constitution (Amendment) Act and these are the very people that the Minister for Finance cannot refrain from inciting to bring in verdicts in accordance with his own desires.
Comment on this
Has not an undertaking been given that all Deputies who want to speak will get an opportunity?
Comment on this
The debate must be concluded at midnight as ordered. If certain Deputies spoke for over an hour, the Chair is not responsible, as there is no limit to the duration of speeches.
Comment on this
I would not intervene at all, or take up any time of the House, but for the serious allegations made against me by the last speaker, the leader of the Labour Party. As I listened to Deputy McGilligan, and to Deputy Norton afterwards, it struck me that by-elections, particularly when held under proportional representation, make strange bedfellows.
Comment on this
I am not complaining but I think I am entitled to reply, and I am going to elaborate what my complaints are in a moment. When one finds Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Norton following on much the same line, attempting to fish in troubled waters, one begins to wonder how the strange association comes about.
I listened to Deputy McGilligan denouncing the Government, raking up the past, distorting and perverting quotations from the President and Ministers, seeking by every means in his power to arouse old feelings of anger and hatred. And all to what purpose? As the Vice-President said, it can only have been directed to one purpose, and that is to bring some grist to the Party's mill at the present by-elections.
Deputy McGilligan singled me out for attack, and attempted to compare my attitude towards certain offences some time past and my attitude towards them at present. The burden of his song seems to be that we had trifled with crime, that we had been too tolerant, and deserved no credit for what he styled the belated action which we had taken. He sought to make as much capital as he could out of the quotations which he picked out from speeches delivered years ago and which, I submit, he distorted and perverted in a most dishonest fashion. That was the burden of his song—that we had been too tolerant.
Now we come to the leader of the Labour Party. Having announced in the opening of his speech, with a great flourish, that the Labour Party always stood against political murder, he charged me with being inoculated with hysteria—the hysteria, I think he said, of the Minister for Finance. He charged the Government as a whole, and me in particular, with acting in a panic. Apparently these two Parties, both with their candidates seeking votes at the present by-elections, seem to think that they are going to get some additional votes by drawing upon the present situation and attempting to make more difficult the very difficult task which this Government has, and which any Government would have, which had to grapple with a situation such as the Government has been faced with in this country in recent times.
Taking Deputy Norton's charges in their order, he stated that the severity and ruthlessness of which he said we have been guilty were not justifiable. It certainly amazes me when I am charged with being severe and ruthless, hysterical and panic-stricken, and, on the other hand, charged by Deputy McGilligan with being a characterless sheep. How the two things could fit the same person I do not know. Apparently the object aimed at is the same, but the methods of approach are different. This Government is faced with a very difficult situation, demanding the most delicate handling. When the task of the Government is an extremely delicate and difficult one, and we are faced with a critical situation which has to be handled with firmness and, at the same time, with skill, we should at least expect from the Opposition, which has behind it 10 years of responsibility as a Government, some more consideration than we have got in recent months—the climax being, as the Vice-President said, the indecent rushing of these two by-elections in the hope that we had suffered some weakness by reason of our actions in the recent past. In the same way, I think we deserved similar consideration from the Labour Party,
The Labour Party has, through its leader, just now denounced political murders. Deputy Norton then went on to criticise me. Deputy McGilligan has made the bullets for the I.R.A. Party in the by-elections and Deputy Norton comes along to his assistance, both, I suppose, angling for second preferences. It is extraordinary that Deputies should use such a situation for a political purpose.
Comment on this
It does not require explaining to any intelligent person who read the report which appeared in the newspapers.
Comment on this
I do not think it is fair for Deputy Davin to interrupt when I am attempting to deal with charges made against me by Deputy Norton.
Comment on this
I am sorry if I did. I merely felt that the point I was making should be emphasised. Deputy Norton, as I say, went off with a flourish condemning political murders. Then he dealt with our methods of dealing with the present situation, and charged me with bringing people up on artificial offences—in fact, he referred to them as alleged offences—refusing to answer questions. He styled the questions felon-setting questions. I do not think it is necessary at this stage to go into a defence of the provisions of Article 2A, even if the Chair would allow me, as I am sure it would not. I certainly think that at this hour of the day there is hardly an intelligent man in this country who does not realise that extraordinary methods have to be used to deal with certain situations and that the Anglo-Saxon method, shall I say, lauded so much by the Labour Party of trial by jury has failed. It failed in other countries besides Ireland. It is very easy to hold up the fact that prisoners have been charged with refusing to answer questions, parade it as a tremendous grievance, and attempt to make capital out of it and charge me, as I have been charged by Deputy Norton, with being guilty of unnecessary severity and ruthlessness when I put prisoners forward on such charges.
I wonder is it really necessary to go over the ground and take the concrete facts of the situation as we know them in certain counties and districts. Does not everybody realise that certain crimes have been committed by organised groups of armed men, whose powers of intimidation are so great that it is impossible to induce persons who are in a position to give evidence to come forward and give evidence before any court? Deputy Norton must know very well that, not only have witnesses been intimidated, but that jurors have been intimidated. Deputy Norton asked me to give some examples. Now, I do not believe that the Deputy lives in the moon as much as he would like to pretend. I do believe that he is quite conscious of the fact that, in certain cases, jurors have been intimidated.
Comment on this
I am not going back at all to the time when a juror was shot, but I am aware of this fact, that in certain cases recently in this country jurors have been intimidated. I am also aware, and fully believe, that in certain cases verdicts would have been the other way if jurors had the pluck to reach them. I may be wrong in that, and Deputy Norton may possibly be right. The Deputy thinks that I have been seized with unreasonable panic. I wonder if any ordinary, sober citizen believes that, and if it is not fully realised that, instead of rushing to panic measures of this sort, no Government could have been more patient than we have been, or could have given trial by jury a fairer chance. I submit that no Government ever gave the ordinary methods of administration a fairer chance than this Government, and it is in the light of the history of its administration of the law generally during the last four years that it has been hauled over the coals by the malicious and bitter-minded Deputy McGilligan. Deputy Norton, at least, should give it credit for having tried, in every way possible, to rely solely upon the ordinary methods of dealing with crime before it had to resort to extraordinary measures. The concrete cases that I have given from the recent past ought to be sufficient to bring home to anybody who is not virtually blind to it, that if you are to grapple with organisations which organise crime such as the crime of murder and other crimes—crimes of a somewhat similar type which if they did not eventuate in murder were of a very serious kind, and resulted in men being kidnapped and taken away—you must resort to extraordinary measures, because every one, who knows anything about the recent past in this country, must be aware that it is impossible to get a hold of evidence.
Therefore, it became necessary to alter the law here so as to allow questions to be put to persons: to ask them questions about their movements. The questions upon which it is suggested by Deputy Norton that I have sent people wrongly to trial and to prison are merely questions which enable the Guards to ask a man, when a crime has been committed in a particular locality, to account for his movements, or to give such information as is in his possession about the incidents which surround that crime. It is not asking the House too much to believe that when the Guards decide to ask persons questions about these things that they have at least some inkling and some reason for thinking that the persons whom they interrogate are in a position to give information about such matters. I do submit that, despite the fact that it is a principle of English law, a principle which applies here in this country that all persons are presumed to be innocent until proved guilty—and this method of interrogation is not allowable at the present time here in the case of the ordinary courts —that excellent as that principle may be, and well though it may work in ordinary times: that when you have a situation such as we had recently down in the County Waterford and in Cork where men have planned coolly and deliberately and carried out deliberate murder; when they have shown by their attitude, by their daring and their coolness that they are ready to go to any lengths to carry out their purpose, and by the very deeds which they have committed intend to convey to persons who may come forward either as witnesses or to act as jurors that they will have to be prepared to meet the same fate: when you have a situation such as that, is there anything unjust or unfair in going to such persons and asking them: "Where were you on that night?" The Dungarvan crime was committed, I think, on the 27th of April. When men were asked: "Where were you on that date" the reply given was: "I refuse to answer." When asked: "Where were you at such a time?" again the reply was: "I refuse to answer," and so right down along through the list of settled answers to interrogatories supplied from the headquarters of the I.R.A.
All the replies are of a piece, and then we are told here that we are guilty of some outrage upon justice for bringing these men before the tribunal. Is it fair to a Government dealing with a situation such as we have had to deal with, is it fair to me to charge me with trying people for alleged offences when the law and the Constitution say that the Guards are entitled to ask people about their movements? There is the same provision in several other countries, and yet we have all this clap-trap from Deputy Norton.
Comment on this
What about the Minister for Finance finding a man guilty before he was sent before the tribunal?
Comment on this
Deputy Davin is not going to succeed in putting me off by dragging a red herring across the trail. Then we had Deputy Norton accusing me of a thirst for vengeance. Is it necessary for me to defend myself or the Executive Council against that charge because of the recent steps taken for putting Article 2A of the Constitution into operation? Deputy Norton said that was absolutely unjustifiable on my part, and was merely an exhibition of my thirst for vengeance.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan, on the other hand, gets up and charges us with failing to carry out our duty, with being lacking absolutely in courage to carry the thing out with the severity with which it should be carried out, and with failing to do it in time. All that I can say is that adversity certainly makes strange bedfellows.
Comment on this
I will come to that in a moment. Apparently, what I said at Taghmon hurt Deputy Norton very much. If I recollect what I said there it was this: that I suggested to the Labour Party that, in certain countries on the Continent in recent times, organised labour had become the victims of Communist strategy and that they had been lured into becoming members of what had come to be known as the Popular Front: that there was the example in Spain and in France, and I warned the Labour Party that I thought they should be careful. I had read some of their pronouncements down in Tralee where they talked about tearing down the present system: that there would never be any happiness in the country until the present system was destroyed. I suggested to them that they ought not to go on making wild statements of that kind lest use might be made of them by others. The reason why I mentioned that was because I felt that certain members of the Labour Party had been coquetting with certain extreme parties in this country, and because I knew, as a matter. of fact, that one leader of a certain group here in Dublin had asked for a United Front. I warned the Labour Party about the danger of it.
Am I so far wrong that Deputy Norton should get so wildly excited about it? What about his own recent action in connection with the commission that we had to ban? Was not that coquetting with certain people? Why has the Deputy not had the courage, if he believes in the recent complaint which he voiced about the treatment of prisoners, to put down a motion in the Dáil about it? First of all he allowed himself to be associated with that commission which he must well know was going to afford comfort to those people at a time when the Government was forced to take drastic action in order to restore ordered conditions. I do not think that was a proper proceeding on the part of a leader of a constitutional Party in this House. When we declared that commission illegal, and when the Deputy raised a question about it in the Dáil, he was invited by the President to raise it in the House, but he has not done so. Perhaps I am confusing one thing with another, but at any rate before the commission was banned a straight invitation was given to the Deputy to raise the matter in this House. It was intimated to him that if a substantial number of Deputies wanted to have a commission to investigate the treatment of prisoners, that would be gladly and readily granted.
What has happened? There was no step taken in regard to that until to-night, at the end of the debate and, as the Ceann Comhairle said, without any notice, we were charged, for the purpose of the by-elections, with the ill-treatment of prisoners. I do not think that is fair or proper and we have a right to resent that. I am not in a position to deal with the treatment of prisoners, but I do not believe there is any ill-treatment. There have been complaints. There are always complaints.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that a member of the Executive of Fianna Fáil was on the Mansion House Commission?
Comment on this
Is it a fact that the leader of the Labour Party, a member of this House, was on it?
Comment on this
If I am asked to investigate allegations of ill-treatment, I see no reason for refusing.
Comment on this
There are other Deputies who want to speak and I have no desire to take up the time of the House. I do not want to say very much more. Deputy Norton seemed to think I ought to have kept my head in a crisis. He charged me with suffering from ragged nerves and he said that I went to recreate myself by making speeches in County Wexford. I do not think I am suffering from ragged nerves at all. I think the history of the recent crisis and its development step by step has been plain and open to everybody and everyone who has followed the attitude of the Government towards this organisation during the last four years and has witnessed the manner in which the Act was administered since the I.R.A. was banned, must admit that, despite the indications given that the Government intended to be firm and drastic in this matter, they nevertheless tempered justice with mercy. I suppose Deputy Norton thinks that we should have waited for another murder or two to happen.
Comment on this
I protested in this House against political murder before you ever came into the House.
Comment on this
I accept the Deputy's statement, and I do not suggest anything to the contrary against him. Deputy Norton has made quite clear his attitude towards political murder. I am not making any charge against him, as representing the Labour Party, that he wishes to condone political murder.
Comment on this
My own life was threatened by some of the people associated with that Party when I protested here.
Comment on this
I am not making any charges against Deputy Davin, but I will repeat what I said at the beginning. I feel the brunt of this complaint has been directed to a particular piece of legislation, and the putting into operation of that legislation has been an unpleasant and a difficult task, and, when Deputy Davin makes clear the attitude of himself and his Party towards political murder, he ought to follow that up by considering carefully the attitude he adopts towards the measures which we feel forced to take to cope with it and he ought to be prepared to indicate in what other way we could have dealt with it except the way we did, or get out of office. While I sympathise with Deputy Davin's feelings that something I have said may possibly have hurt him, I think at the same time there is on the part of the Labour Party a slight inconsistency between profession and performance.
Comment on this
I maintain there is a slight difference between profession and performance on the part of the Labour Party. It seems to me there is, and I have made my argument for that clear.
Comment on this
If the Deputy looks up any report of my speech, he will find that I did not call them Communists. The paraphrase I gave was almost word for word what I did say. The Deputy apparently did not take any exception to what I indicated to-night I did say. I did not charge the Party with being Communists. I warned them of the danger to which other organised Parties, organised on somewhat similar lines to this Labour Party, laid themselves open in other countries. It was not intended to carry the implication that the Labour Party are Communists; it was to warn them that there is a danger in making wild statements and that there are dangers which may arise which have arisen in other countries.
Comment on this
This debate, which has lasted six or seven hours, has taken many turnings. It opened with the suggestion that there was going to be a coalition between the two principal Parties. As a matter of fact, it was suggested that the coalition had already taken place, but as the debate proceeded there were signs that that coalition was not in existence and, as it proceeded a little further, not only were there signs that the coalition was not in existence, but there were signs that the old coalition that has existed for four years between the Fianna Fáil and the Labour Parties seemed to have been smashed to smithereens. In fact, the debate for the last couple of hours has been a duel between Fianna Fáil and Labour.
Had there been time, there is a great deal of ground that could be covered in a debate of this kind. An adjournment debate of this type is one of the rare opportunities that Deputies get of dealing with matters that are agitating the country. There are a few subjects that I had intended to deal with at length but, owing to the short time at my disposal, and my anxiety to leave a little time for my friend and colleague, Deputy Anthony, I will deal with only a couple of matters and I will deal with them briefly.
The economic was has been in existence for four years and no attempt has been made to settle it. All kinds of hypocritical statements are made about our not paying the annuities and other payments to Britain. Well, they are being paid. Surely the present Government ought to have learned a lesson in the last year, a lesson in honour, and it is time that we cultivated some code of honour in this country. Within the last year, the Government introduced a Bill giving them power to impose sanctions on foreign countries in certain circumstances. That Bill was given to them by this House. Under that Bill they had power to make an Order imposing sanctions on the particular country that they had singled out for that purpose. They imposed sanctions on Italy, a country that never did any harm to this country, and a country that we were not in a position to do any harm to. But by our shortsightedness, by our want of vision, we showed a great foreign friendly nation what we would do to them if we had the power to do it, and we did that at the dictation of other countries.
Comment on this
I want to know now why the Government, before the Recess takes place, does not withdraw the sanctions and, in fact, repeal that Act. A situation arose in Europe when the Germans reoccupied the Rhine Province. The Locarno powers were convened to consider what steps would be taken to deal with the German breach of the Locarno Treaty. Italy signified her willingness to attend but said: "We will not be a party to sanctions on Germany or any other country while sanctions are being imposed on our country." Why was our country so shortsighted, so bereft of honour, as to impose sanctions on Italy while Britain was imposing sanctions on us by way of economic tariffs? Now our Government is going for a three months' holiday and it still has the power under that Act to impose sanctions on any nation it so thinks fit. I am glad the Vice-President is here. On a motion which Deputy Kent and myself had down here to annul the Order imposing sanctions on Italy, I made reference to what I read in an American paper to the effect that the Italian Government, at a critical time in our history, was friendly to us. The Vice-President denied that.
Comment on this
Legislation of this House authorised those sanctions. There was subsequently a debate on a motion to annul those sanctions. On both questions decisions were come to. The Deputy cannot reopen those discussions.
Comment on this
I am not finding fault with the imposition of sanctions. I did at the time. I was one of the three or four who opposed them, and I believe I was voicing the feelings of the majority of the people of this country on that occasion. But a new situation has arisen, and the sanctions are still on. That machinery is still in the hands of the Government.
Comment on this
There is no amending legislation before the House, nor any motion to rescind. It is rather late—within 20 minutes of the adjournment—to advocate legislation.
Comment on this
Am I in order in suggesting that there was need for the power placed in the hands of the Government and they did not use that power? I am not suggesting amending or new legislation, but I take it that this debate is an opportunity to criticise what the Government has done in the last session or what it has refrained from doing. A situation has now arisen in Spain, a country which at the present time appears to be ruled by priest murderers and church burners. Our Government has a trade agreement with those people. Those people do not control half of Spain at the present time. They are being condemned all over Europe. They are not only attacking Catholicity, but they are attacking Christianity. It is Communism in its worst form. But this Government, which claims to be not only Christian but Catholic, persists in a trade agreement with those scoundrels.
Comment on this
Good eggs for bad oranges—precisely. Those fellows are sure to be paid for the bad oranges, but we are not sure to be paid for the eggs. Even the clearance machinery in Spain has broken down, and that notorious scoundrel of a Jewish adventurer, that curse of Hungary which gave us inspiration 30 years ago, that same Bela Kun is reputed to be in Spain for a number of months, organising and fomenting Communism in that unhappy land. We know the condition it is in to-day. It is a shame and a disgrace to this country, which at least is Christian and, I hope, Catholic, that the Government is going into Recess now for three months, leaving behind it sanctions on the Catholic Christian nation of Italy, while maintaining trade relations—and not only trade relations but a most-favoured-nation agreement— with Spain. The country is already manifesting its hostility to that line of conduct on the part of the Government, and I think, by the time we reassemble in three months, the country will have manifested in a more pronounced manner its hostility to that action on the part of the Government on the one hand, and that inaction on the other. In all probability there will be organisation around that, and it is a pity that the Government did not see its way to take action before it went out of office, or rather before it went into Recess.
Comment on this
I do not know; the signs seem to indicate that there might be an appeal between this and November. To deal with the many matters I intended to deal with would deprive my friend, Deputy Anthony, of an opportunity to speak. I would just conclude by making reference to a matter which I consider very important. During the course of this debate some speakers have waxed very eloquent on the Commonwealth; and showed every sign of wanting a show-down between the Commonwealth versus a Republic. There is one thing which I appreciate in regard to the present Government during the last three or four years, and that is that it has side-tracked that issue.
Sometimes, when we are talking politics rather than policy, some of us will upbraid the Government for talking less of a republic and advocating a republic not so strongly now as they have done in the past; but in office, and here in this House, we should not talk politics or think politics. We should talk statesmanship if we can, but we should think in terms of policy rather than of politics. I am glad that the Government has seen fit not to obtrude the policy or the ideal of a republic by looking for a show-down on it immediately by featuring it here in this House and endeavouring to get a decision on it here in the House. On the other hand, I should be glad if other Parties talked less of the Commonwealth, and if we talked less or if we featured both the Commonwealth and the republic less and considered the interests of the country more and the building up of the economic life of this country more as an independent nation, we would be doing more good for what will ultimately be best for the country. What will be ultimately best for the country may not be in our hands to decide. It may be another generation of Irishmen and Irishwomen who will decide what is best for the country, and if we have done our bit in this country we should hand it down to the next generation, not as a bone of contention but as a foundation on which to work for the development of the Free State. If we do that we will be going a long way to bridge the difference that exists between the Free State and the North and a long way to obliterate the present boundary. It does not matter who put it there. The boundary is there and the more we build up on our side of the boundary, the nearer we will be getting towards its obliteration.
I have many other points to make, but I have not time. Deputy Davin was very keen about the Banking Commission. Well, I said a moment ago that I complimented the Government on not featuring the question of a republic. Of course, the very terms of reference of the Banking Commission breathe anything but the spirit of Separatism that we have heard so much about here. It leaves the golden link of the £ sterling still the link binding this country to Great Britain, and there is no link as strong as a money link. The question of credit facilities not being available to farmers now may have some bearing on the fact that we have not a central bank here in this country; but what is more important than any central bank is that the main industry in this country is showing no margin of profit. We have no profit on agriculture because we are engaged in an economic war, paying a debt that we are trying to fool ourselves we are not paying. Not only is the Government responsible for the situation, but its allies, or its former allies, if we are to take at its face value the more or less of a dog fight that has been going on here to-night between the two Parties, are also responsible. Whether they are the Government's allies now or not, they were, at any rate the Government's allies in doing the damage of destroying agriculture and depriving it of a profit, and when agriculture shows no profit income, it cannot have credit.
In conclusion, Sir, I would draw the Vice-President's attention to the fact that the Government failed to show the world that this country will terminate the special trade agreement that it has with Communist Spain, and perhaps the Minister might also tell us, by way of an answer to this question, when he is going to take notice of the Communist propaganda that is being preached every night in Cathal Brugha Street. It is time that we should take notice of the dangers that are lurking ahead, because Communism, it must be remembered, had a similar beginning in other countries to what is going on here, and that kind of thing ended in the burning of churches and the murdering of priests. We should try to stop that kind of thing before the churches here are burned and the priests murdered.
Comment on this
I find, for once in a way, that I have a good deal of sympathy with the members of the Executive Council, but particularly with the Attorney-General.
Comment on this
During the discussion we heard a good deal of solicitude expressed and manifested for persons who have been brought up and charged under the Constitution (Amendment) (No. 17) Act, but not one half of that solicitude or sympathy was ever expressed for the victims of the organisation which was instrumental in having these murders committed in our midst—the murder of young Egan and of Admiral Somerville in County Cork. Not one half of the solicitude was manifested or expressed in connection with the victims of these murders. Now, the attitude of Deputy Norton and his Party to-night, in so far as we can understand it, in their attempt to capture votes and to wean away voters from Fianna Fáil and the extreme Republican Party, appears to me to be a policy of facing both ways. Apparently, the pale pink Communism of the Labour Party does not appeal to the ordinary working-class people of this State, nor does it make that appeal which it was calculated it would make, and the Labour Party, apparently, are now turning out as full-blooded republicans and they express the greatest solicitude and sympathy with every person who was interrogated. Now, as the Attorney-General pointed out, the system of interrogation exists and has existed for years in many other countries and the citizens of these countries, being loyal citizens, are quite prepared to give answers at any hour of the day or night when they are interrogated by the police authorities as to their whereabouts at a given time. What is wrong in asking any honest man, who has nothing to be afraid of or nothing to be ashamed of, where he was at any given time?
Then we have Deputy Davin, whom I always looked upon as a wonderfully constitutional person in this House, asking some silly questions here to-night about a man being imprisoned and people calling to him and about maltreatment in the prisons of this country. Does he want us to supply these prisoners with wireless sets and playing-cards to play poker with, and moving pictures, and so on? I wonder at Deputy Davin's mentality and that of other people. In my view—and I expressed the same view when Deputy Cosgrave was in office here—this is a time when every honest, decent man in this country should stand four-square behind President de Valera and his Government in supporting the law and order for which this Dáil is responsible.
Every member of this House is either shirking his duty as a public man, or he is acting the coward by shielding himself and by being on the side of the angels, the angels being possibly the persons with the guns in their hands. I have never yet been afraid of a man with a gun in his hand, and never shall. I want to make my position in that connection quite clear, that, so far as I am concerned, the Government will have my vote behind them in any measure they take to enforce law and order in this country. Having said that, I feel that more of Deputy Norton's speech as Leader of the Labour Party might have been devoted to the problems which confront the working-class people of this country every day, rather than that he should coquette with a Party outside this House which is trying to break down the institutions of the State which were built up by President Cosgrave and his Party and which are now being continued by President de Valera and his Party.
If I were asked to epitomise or summarise the principal effects and results that have flowed from Fianna Fáil government in this country, I could easily do so under two or three headings. They are (1) more unemployment and more poverty; (2) increased taxation, local and general, and (3) the impoverishment of our principal industry, agriculture, due to the continuation of the economic war. I should like to emphasise each of the points I have read out, but the time is too limited, due to the longwindedness of a lot of people who took a long time to say very little. It is most unfair to members of this House who sat here all day to be left until almost 12 o'clock without an opportunity of speaking. I myself have risen six or eight times and I have protested already. I know it is not your fault, Sir, because you were not always in the Chair and because the personnel of the Chair is changed so frequently, it is a matter of difficulty.
Everybody knows that the farmers and farm labourers of this country have been impoverished as a result of the activities of this Government, but I want particularly to refer to the position as I find it in Cork. While the industrial policy of the Government is highly commendable in many respects, I should like to point out that it has not had the direction and careful and thoughtful planning that one should reasonably anticipate from the Government charged with conduct of political and economic affairs in this country. I should like to call the attention of the Vice-President to the fact that in the flour milling industry we have had many stoppages of work. We have had mills closing down for weeks on end, and we have had under-employment due to these quota orders, etc. In the boot and shoe industry in the same way, we have almost reached saturation point, and I want to know what it is intended to do with the surplus products. There is a danger in this respect which I see and which other persons who have given the matter any kind of thought or study at all can see. If the mills work to their full capacity, you will very soon have over-production in flour and you will have, as a consequence, men thrown out of work. If the boot and shoe industry works at full pressure, they will be enabled to turn out more goods than will satisfy the requirements of our people. What is going to be done with the surplus? We will have an exportable surplus, and I understand it is the intention of the Government to establish one or two additional boot and shoe factories in this country. Representations have been made to me by many people engaged in those two industries asking me to protest against the establishment of any other flour milling establishment, and also to protest against any additional boot and shoe factories being established, all going to show that there is a feeling that one of these days we shall reach saturation point and there will be no demand for the surplus products of our factories.
One other point, and I am finished. It has been stated time and time again that the President of the State, whom I respect as President of the State, although I am very much opposed to his policy, and some members of the Executive Council know where arms are dumped in this country. I am not making the charge, but it has been so stated over and over again in public. If the President or any member of the Executive Council knows where those arms are dumped, I think it is his duty to show example to other people in the country and have those arms handed over to the responsible authorities of the State, either the police or the military authorities. I welcome the speech made by the President on Tuesday, I think, in Galway, and I welcome the attitude adopted by him in relation to these illegal organisations, and I have no hesitation and no fear in saying so. I deprecate very much the attitude of Deputy Davin and others who questioned the Minister for Finance to-night. The statement of the Minister for Finance, as I read it, was a simple statement of fact. He stated that if the murderers were found they would receive a murderer's fate. In effect that is what he said. I see nothing wrong in that, and I feel, too, that when the Government is endeavouring to govern, it is no time to deprecate that change of front, which I welcome, towards crime and criminals. We should welcome it, and every Deputy should be behind the Government in their changed attitude, as I regard it, towards crime. Having said that, I want to say also that I hope that, as the President has announced his change of front in relation to his political views, if you like, he will also show a change of front in his industrial policy, and that in the light of the experience he has gained already, he will learn to change his attitude and perhaps get some more economic wisdom.
Comment on this
I cannot delay the House at any greater length, as I want to give Deputy Kelly some time.