Public Business. - Agricultural Wages Bill, 1936—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 1–146 of 294. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 37 of 1936 ›
I move amendment No. 5:—
To add at the end of sub-section (3) the words "but shall during such incapacity be deemed, for the purposes of Section 13 of this Act, not to be an ordinary member."
As the Bill stands, it would be possible for an acting chairman to promote disagreement by voting against the unanimous decision of the other members of the board and, therefore, have an opportunity of deciding the issue for himself. This amendment is designed to prevent him from doing so—that when he is acting chairman he is not an ordinary member of the board. If the other members agree, the decision is unanimous and he cannot alter that decision.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:—
In sub-section (1), page 6, lines 14 and 15, to delete the words "at the commencement of the meeting of the board held next after" and substitute the word "upon".
This is similar to amendment No. 3.
Comment on this
Is it proposed to have these positions filled by the Public Appointments Commissioners or the Civil Service Commissioners?
Comment on this
They will be filled by the Civil Service Commissioners.
Comment on this
Yes, but perhaps not established. The positions will be filled by the Civil Service Commissioners.
Comment on this
Why not by the Public Appointments Commissioners? Do they only fill positions for local authorities?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:—
In page 7, line 26, to insert after the words "in case" the words "such ordinary members include at least one employers' member and one workers' member and".
There was a certain objection to the Bill as it stands that there might be a unanimous decision of the board with perhaps only the employers' representatives or the employees' representatives present. This amendment is designed to ensure that the unanimous decision is not to be operative unless both employers and employees are represented at that particular meeting of the board.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 7, lines 32 and 33 to delete the words "shall make such order, and" and substitute the words "may, as he thinks fit, either adjourn the making of such order to the next meeting of the board or make such order, and in the latter event".
As the Bill stands, it would appear, although I am not quite certain, that the chairman will have to give his decision forthwith if the decision were left to him. It might be conceivable that the chairman would like to have some time to consider the matter, or make some inquiries before giving a decision, and this gives him power to adjourn the meeting before giving his decision, which I think is useful.
Comment on this
That is in case no agreement is arrived at and it is up to the chairman to fix the wage?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:—
Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
Any order made by the board fixing minimum rates of wages in respect of any wages district shall also fix for that district a minimum fair rate of wages and a minimum economic rate of wages.
Amendments Nos. 9 and 10 hang together and are designed to remove what appears to me to be a fatal flaw in the Bill introduced under existing circumstances. I freely admit that, if we were living in normal times, the amendment which I put forward here might not be necessary. I do not think that in any circumstances it could be harmful but it may not be necessary. I have submitted that no legislation of this Oireachtas can extract water from a stone or blood from a turnip. To adopt the words of the Bishop of Ross, although wages for agricultural labourers at present in many parts of the country are wretched, wretched as they are, the farmers cannot afford to pay them much less increase them. I entirely adopt that view of the situation all over the country. I am solicitous to ensure that, when the machinery of this Bill begins to operate, we shall fix for the agricultural labourers a wage which will compare favourably with that obtained by the agricultural labourers in other countries, and the first comparison that is going to be made is with the agricultural wages that are fixed in Great Britain. We ought to have the same market as the British farmer and we ought to have on our land as good a standard of living as the British farmer has. If these facts obtain, we ought to be able to get for our agricultural labourers as good a wage as is being paid in Great Britain.
Most of our agricultural labourers are either themselves temporary emigrants, or else they are familiar with neighbours and friends who go to England from time to time, and they will expect to get a wage which approximates, in any case, to the wages that are being paid under similar conditions in Great Britain. On the Second Stage, I read out certain figures for agricultural wages paid at present in Great Britain. They vary in different parts of the country from about 29/- to 32/-. It has to be borne in mind that these wages are, in some cases, for an eight-hour day and are subject to substantial increase if the agricultural labourer is doing specialised work.
In Hereford, the minimum wage is 11d. In Warwick, it is 31/- for a 50 hour week, and 8½d. or 9d. per hour for overtime. These are two typical cases. I think that the rate is a little lower in Norfolk and some of the eastern counties, but in every case the wage is for a 50 or 52 hour week, and time over and above that has to be paid for. It is merely sticking our heads in the sand to imagine that the farmers of this country can pay wages like those or anything near them, and I think it will be a deplorable thing if we start our system by fixing wages about 10/- a week lower for agricultural labourers in this country than the rate that obtains in Great Britain. The present average wage in this country is about 21/6 per week. Certain Deputies have said that that rate of wages is going to be raised by these boards and that the process of raising them is going to be financed by the Government's fixing higher prices for the agricultural produce of the farmers. Any such fallacy is folly, because the Government cannot finance increased agricultural wages by fixing higher prices for agricultural produce. The Government is not in a position to fix prices for 50 per cent. of the produce of the land. If you look at the statistics of agricultural output, published in the September number of the "Trade Journal," you will find that, of the total produce of the agricultural industry in 1929-30—one of the last normal years we had—50 per cent. was exported. The value of the total produce was £64,850,000. Of that, the agricultural community themselves consumed £21,000,000 worth, and they sold to industrial workers and provided individuals other than those living on the land with £11,790,000 worth of stuff. The only agricultural produce the price of which can be artificially raised by the Government is that represented by the sum of £11,790,000. There would be no use in raising the price of the stuff which the farmer himself eats. They cannot raise the price of the stuff that is being exported to Great Britain. The best they can do is to maintain it by giving bounties to meet the tariffs on it. But they can, by fixing the price of certain products substantially higher than the economic price, affect the value of £11,790,000 worth of produce out of a total of £64,000,000 worth.
Certain Deputies on the opposite side will say that things have changed greatly since then, that a great deal more stuff is being consumed in Saorstát Eireann by the industrial worker now than was consumed in 1929. What are the facts? In 1934-35 the consumption of agricultural produce by persons other than farmers or farm labourers had dropped from £11,790,000 to £10,060,000. When Deputy Corry says that the right solution for this dilemma is to fix the price of agricultural produce at a higher level and compel the farmer to pay a higher wage, does he realise that in 1934-5, out of a total output of £40,000,000 worth, the Government could only raise the price of £10,000,000 worth, or a quarter of the entire output? No matter what price you raise agricultural products in this country to, it is going to do nothing to help the farmer substantially to increase the wages of his labourer, however willing he may be to do so, because it is not going substantially to alter the amount of profit he makes on his enterprise. Deputies will say that that is incredible, that beet and wheat at the prices at which they at present stand—27/6 in the case of wheat and 37/6 in the case of beet—must give the farmer a fair profit. I do not think that either of them does. Assuming for the moment that they do, let us take the case of Wexford. Wexford is a county in which you had an increase of 17,112 acres of cereal crops between the years 1931 and 1935. In that county, the average of the agricultural labourer's wages fell by 3/6 over that period. The Minister for Agriculture knows Wexford well. Does he allege that his own neighbours from Wexford are sweaters? Does Deputy Corish allege that all the farmers of Wexford are sweating their men, grinding them down and withholding from them the wages to which they are entitled?
Comment on this
Deputy Corry contends that those farmers who have increased their cereal production by 17,000 acres in these years must be making money. He says that these prices are fixed on a remunerative level, that he can make plenty of money by growing wheat and beet and, presumably, the farmers of Wexford can do so, too. Yet, their wages have dropped by 3/6 per week. Take the case of Kildare, which was held up to public odium as the home of the ranchers. Kildare fell in with the new policy. Kildare increased its output of cereals by about 30 per cent. In Kildare the wages have fallen by 6/-per week. Take any county in which the output of cereal crops has materially increased and, in each one of them, you will find that agricultural wages have fallen heavily over the very period during which the increase in cereal production was going on. You cannot escape from this dilemma: either the farmers are grinding down their labourers and are sweating their employees, or else they are doing the best they can under very difficult circumstances, and cannot afford to pay more.
You have reduced, during the last five years, the exports of agricultural produce from £28,000,000 to £12,000,000. You have reduced the sales of agricultural produce as a whole, if you include the produce which is consumed by the agricultural community itself, from £64,000,000 to £40,000,000, but in order to get a true perspective of that situation we ought to make a fair allowance for the fall in world prices of agricultural goods over that same period if we are going to get a fair picture of what the Government of this country has done to the farmer over and above what world trends have done to him.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is the Deputy in order in making the same speech on every amendment that he made last week on the Second Reading of the Bill?
Comment on this
The Deputy's last statement was an effort to show in perspective what the Government has done to the farmers here. To do that certain figures, going back presumably some years, should be gone into. I suggest that that is not relevant to the amendment.
Comment on this
Very well. It is necessary, in justice, to see what the true reduction is in this country as compared with Great Britain. I have quoted certain figures. They are subject to correction. In any case, another occasion for the elaboration of them will arise, but the net result of the situation is that the farmers had £64,000,000 out of which to feed themselves and to get a profit to pay their labourers five years ago. Now, they have got £40,000,000. You have got to ask yourselves, how you are going to deal with that element in the situation. You have got to bear in mind at the same time, that the cost of living, taking all the items which go to make up that cost of living, has declined, but, if you extract from that figure the foodstuffs only, you will find that the cost of living in regard to foodstuffs only has declined much more steeply. That means that the cost of clothing and of the other items which the farmer has to buy, and which are included in the general cost of living index figure, has not declined at all, but has gone up. Therefore, the farmer with £20,000,000 less than he had has to pay much more proportionately for his clothes, boots and so forth, and at the same time we are now going to legislate requiring him by law to pay more to his labourer. It cannot be done, and it cannot be done because he has not got it.
I do not want to recapitulate the figures that the Minister gave us, but he showed that the average income of the individual farmer in this country was reduced from approximately £96 to £55, or £65 if you accept his calculation, so that even on that basis the individual farmer's income is down by £30 per annum. Now, if we cannot get out of the farmer's pocket what appears to us to be a reasonable wage for his agricultural labourer, what alternative is left to us but to step in between the two parties and make up the difference? My amendment cannot propose that course.
Comment on this
I got the opportunity to debate that proposal fully on the Money Resolution. Here is the machinery by which that proposal can be carried into effect. I ask that when the board goes to fix a wage for any district that they would first fix a fair rate of wages and an economic rate of wages. I define the expression "minimum fair rate of wages for any district" as "that rate of wages for agricultural wages in that district which in the opinion of the board is a living wage, taking into account the current cost of living for agricultural workers obtaining in that district for the time being." I submit that no statutory board in this country can fix a wage for agricultural labourers lower than the figure stipulated in that part of my amendment. No statutory board in this country can fix a rate of wages which they have got to go out and say is not a living wage. You cannot, by law, condemn the entire community of agricultural labourers in this country to semi-starvation, and that is what it means if you deny them a living wage.
You have got in this age accurate figures from scientists like Sir John Orr in England on what a living wage is. When I speak of a living wage I do not mean a luxurious wage. When you fix such things by statute you fix a minimum on the clear understanding that, in prosperous times, it should be the duty of every employer to give as much over that minimum as he can afford. When you fix a minimum by statute it has to be fixed at the lowest figure, and in defining a living minimum wage, fixed on the lowest figure, it has to be such that it will keep a man, his wife and family in a normal state of health. I say that you cannot fix any rate of wages for agricultural labourers by statute if you are not in a position to say that it is a living wage. Therefore, there can be no objection to that part of my amendment.
Now, as to the second part, it is nothing but the greatest hypocrisy if we fix a minimum living wage for labourers by statute for any district if we know that the result of doing that is to put half the labourers in the area on the dole. Suppose we fix 30/- as the minimum living wage for agricultural labourers in the County Wexford, and that there is a farmer there who employs three labourers. At the present time the average wage that is being paid to agricultural labourers in the County Wexford is 19/- a week. The County Wexford farmer who is employing three labourers at the present time is paying out in wages £2 17s. 0d. a week. We come in and tell him that, from this day forth, he must pay to these three labourers a total of £4 10s. 0d. a week. The farmer replies that his entire weekly income is £3 16s. 0d. He says there is 19/- for each of the three labourers and 19/ for himself. He says that all he has got is £3 16s. 0d., and that we are asking him by this legislation to pay out £4 10s. a week. He says it cannot be done, and the only result of this legislation is that he has to let one of the men go. I say that, far from conferring a boon on agricultural labourers by this legislation, we are doing them a material injury. I say, further, that unless we face that possibility we are hypocritically closing our eyes to the facts. We are deliberately legislating in the knowledge that we are not facing the facts: that we are trying to assuage public opinion and, at the same time, consciously knocking men out of a job.
I put it to Deputy Allen and to the Minister for Agriculture, both of whom are Wexford men, that the figure I have quoted is the average wage paid to agricultural labourers by farmers in County Wexford. Will Deputy Allen get up and say that, to his own knowledge, his neighbours in the County Wexford are sweating their men, or does he think that his neighbours are paying their men as much as they can afford? He ought to be able to tell us. The Minister ought to be able to tell us. If, as I believe, these farmers are paying their men as much as they can afford to pay them, what is going to happen if we fix wages at 30/-? It can have only one result. There is no use in Deputies saying: "You are telling men to put their employees out of work." Let us be clear on this. Let no farmer put a man out of work in order to induce any Government in this country to abandon the principle of this Bill, a Fianna Fáil Government, a Fine Gael Government or a Labour Government; the Bill is going to be the law of this land, and no matter what happens, the wages of agricultural labourers are, from this time forward, going to be fixed by machinery analogous to that set out in the Bill, no matter what Government is in office, and it is not going to alter that fact in the slightest degree no matter what an individual farmer may do in Wexford, Cork, Cavan or Mayo. I venture to say that all Deputies will join in administering that caution. Who, a Deputy might think, would be induced to victimise a labourer in order to prove the impossibility of working this Bill? This Bill is going to be worked, no matter what the difficulties are. I want the Minister to tell us how they are going to make the Bill work if their general policy is going to be maintained.
Comment on this
Or else let him explain how the Bill will work in existing circumstances without my amendment. There is my amendment and I say that the case I make renders it absolutely essential that an economic wage be fixed by these boards in order that the country may know, firstly, what the labourer ought to get and, secondly, what the farmers are in a position to pay. It is hypocrisy for any Deputy to say that you can fix a wage without reference to what the farmer is in a position to pay, because if you do you will be simply putting men out of a job.
All I ask is that, when the wage is fixed for the area, it should be a wage on which the labourer can live, and it should be a wage that the farmer can afford to pay. I also ask that the chairman or the board should give the public the reason for arriving at their conclusions. Unless that is done, this Bill cannot work properly, or if it is worked it will result in grave suffering for the people or else in a grave injury to the good name of this country through the world. The rates the farmers can afford at the present time are a public scandal. In the words of the Bishop of Ross, they are wretched in the extreme. The rates to which the workers are entitled should be as good as those they are able to get in Great Britain. Bridge the gap between those two. You have to do it before this Bill will work satisfactorily.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is inclined to pre-judge the work of the wages board and the committees. When putting down this amendment he is acting on the assumption that the board will not exercise the functions which it has a right to exercise and that it would not use its common-sense or good judgment. Listening to the Deputy, a person would be inclined to come to the conclusion that the committees would not take into consideration existing local conditions when they would be arriving at the minimum rate of wages to be struck for any particular area. Of course, we have different rates of wages in different counties. We will have different rates-in different areas.
I think an outstanding example would be County Dublin. We will have a higher rate in County Dublin than in County Wexford, and the board will take notice of the existing conditions in Dublin when striking the minimum rate there. In County Dublin the farmer gets a higher price for his agricultural produce as compared with County Wexford. In County Dublin the rate must, of necessity, be higher because the cost of living in Dublin is higher than in Wexford. Here I might state that the purchasing power of the lower rate of wage paid in the other county will be equal to the purchasing power of the higher rate in County Dublin. That is quite evident. I am quite confident that the committees will take all these things into consideration.
Comment on this
Under the last régime, when your Party were in power, you could not describe them as agricultural workers. Those men were roaming the road looking across the hedges into the grass-lands.
Comment on this
In Meath at the present time they are entitled to the term agricultural workers.
Comment on this
If this amendment were to be adopted we would have a position somewhat like this. Let us take a farmer who would be growing wheat and who would be depending upon wheat-growing for a few years as his means of livelihood. One year he might meet with inclement weather, such as this, and he would have an inferior return. In another year he would have a good season and he would have an excellent return.
Comment on this
It is not high treason to say that you may have inclement weather one year and a good season the next year.
Comment on this
I am not saying this year's wheat crop was not a complete success. I say that the weather was rather inclement. Supposing a farmer meets with a bad season in any particular year, apart altogether from wheat, if you like, you will have the position that the workman in that particular year, if this amendment is accepted, would not be entitled to a living wage. That is quite evident.
Comment on this
The farmer one year would have a surplus and the next year he might meet with reverses, but he would be maintaining a steady average. If this amendment were accepted you would have the worker one year receiving a decent wage and the next year he would be in a state of semi-starvation.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy did not hear the discussion on the Financial Resolution. The rules of order forbade my referring to the finances of this proposal on the Committee Stage, but by leave of the Chair I discussed the finances of this amendment on the Financial Resolution.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon tells us that we should fill the gap between the agricultural wage paid in England and the wage paid here.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon quoted figures. I will be content to refer to my practical experience. Some workers who went over on a holiday to England a couple of years ago did some beet pulling. They did not go during the last year or so by reason of the fact that they were unable to obtain an economic wage pulling beet there.
Comment on this
The wage was so low that they would not continue going there, even though they were having a holiday in the summer time.
Comment on this
The rates are definitely lower than they were two years ago.
Comment on this
Perhaps you have it in your statistics there. I merely mention that so that Deputy Dillon can investigate all those matters when he is making a case in favour of his amendment. I think the amendment would not be advantageous at this stage. I believe it would lead to endless confusion and might also lead to bitterness between employers and employees, because if the employees at any time thought they were not getting a living wage, the employers would be blamed, and, consequently, we would have the peculiar position in which employers and employees were set against each other.
Comment on this
It does seem as if Deputy Kelly did not grasp the points Deputy Dillon was endeavouring to make, and which, I think, he made quite clearly. Certainly the amendment as set out does not at all mean the things which Deputy Kelly thinks it means, and there is no reason whatever to imagine that if it were adopted it would interfere with the rates of pay in one area as against another. The farmer's prosperous year or lean year has nothing whatever to do with it. As a matter of fact, the meaning of the amendment is that Deputy Dillon wants to get a true picture of the situation in the country. He simply asks that when the board goes around to fix a wage they will determine what wage the labourer ought to get in order to have a decent living for himself and his family, and, as against that, they should find out what wage the farmers are able to pay in their existing circumstances. How Deputy Kelly can interpret that as he has interpreted it, I do not know, but those are the facts and that is the meaning of the amendment. I am sure that Deputy Kelly, the Minister and everybody else, if they are in earnest about this Bill, want to get a true picture of what is happening in the country to-day.
Deputy Dillon has made the case with regard to the drop in agricultural produce, and, notwithstanding the fact that there have been certain increases in wheat and beet, which are infinitesimal so far as the main agricultural output is concerned, Deputy Kelly and everybody else knows that the value of agricultural output, in other words, the farmers' income, has been considerably depressed and if Deputy Kelly thinks that that is the time for a board to fix a wage as a fair wage, being the amount which the farmer can pay to-day, it will provide a national exhibition of poverty which will not be any help to this country. The amendment, I think, is very fair. It is not going to tax the capacity of the board beyond what it is their business to do—to find the facts of the situation. We are convinced on this side and, no doubt, Fianna Fáil is as convinced as we are, that farmers, at the moment, are not able to pay the wages that a labourer ought to get in order to have a decent living. We want that illustrated by the board and that is all we ask. I think that is very fair.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon's amendment means something altogether different. It is brought in here for the very same purpose and with the very same object as the proposals issued by Deputy Dillon's organisation, when it was the Centre Party, after the General Election in Cork—to reduce the workers wages and make the beggars pay for putting out Cumann na nGaedheal. Deputy Dillon's instructions to the board, if this amendment is carried, are: "You can fix it as high as you like, gentlemen, and you can say that the labourers in my district are entitled to £2 10s. a week," and then come along afterwards and say: "That is a fair wage, but that is all we poor farmers can give." He talks of wages in England, and Deputy Kelly alluded to labourers in Meath pulling beet. I wonder what fair wage would the English farmer pay for pulling beet at 35/- a ton, which is the price in England at present, with no pulp, and what that wage would be compared with the wage the Irish farmer pays for pulling beet at 42/- a ton, which is the price here. I think that is a fair comparison for Deputy Dillon to make before he goes any further. That is the difference in price in England and here. In England it is 35/- a ton, and here 37/6, with free pulp. Let Deputy Dillon make that up.
I made inquiries as to where these figures of wages for the different counties came from and as to who made them up, because I was rather surprised. I admit that there are farmers here and there who would take advantage, and did take advantage, of low wages, and, in my parish to-day, there are men who, immediately after the instructions issued by the Party opposite, reduced their labourers' wages by 5/- or 6/- a week; who, where they had three men employed, put two off, and who were glad six months afterwards to take back those men at the old rate, and in a great many cases were unable to get them at that rate. I am rather surprised at the attitude of Deputies opposite. Three shillings a week is the difference, according to these famous figures, which figures I do not frankly believe. I have been assured that these wages figures are made up by Civic Guards in the different districts, and anybody who has any knowledge of the way in which they make up returns of all descriptions knows what that means. I frankly do not believe one iota of those figures. I know that wages generally in my district at present are 14/ and board for agricultural labourers, and it is hard to get them at that rate in view of the other opportunities they have.
Comment on this
The agricultural labourer is a man very anxiously sought after by builders. He is a good hard worker and a man who will do better work than a city reared man. He is eagerly sought after by builders in towns at present as a builders' labourer and we find it rather difficult to keep our men on that account. What I am amazed at is that, seeing the woeful position of the agricultural labourers when they had only 3/- a week more in the days of prosperity—if you want to call it that—when Cumann na nGaedheal were in office, some Minister for Agriculture of that Party did not dream of setting up a wages board and seeing that the labourers got the benefit of the land flowing with milk and honey under the Cumann na nGaedheal régime. The argument of Deputy Dillon is that wages were reduced by 3/6 per week. Is that the difference between prosperity and hunger in agricultural labour? If not, and if the farmers were so prosperous in the days before this terrible Government came in, it is rather surprising that some good-natured Deputy opposite, with the welfare of the ordinary poor agricultural labourer at heart, did not bring in an Agricultural Wages Bill and make the farmers pay something better out of their wealth in those days.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon has brought in an amendment with which Deputy Corry must deal if he desires to continue.
Comment on this
And I am giving the reasons for it. Deputy Dillon says that there were 17,000 acres of increased tillage in Wexford. I know that there are several thousand acres of increased tillage in Cork. That means that the labourers, who in other days were walking around the roads looking over the fences at the green grass growing and bullocks fattening, are getting some employment at any rate. The men that were idle in those days are being employed now. In fact some neighbours of mine in East Cork, who in the days of the Fine Gael régime were employing only two or three men, are now employing nine and ten, and cannot get enough of them.
Comment on this
I remember saying at one time—I do not like to repeat it as the Ceann Comhairle might not like it—that there were three classes of lies in this country—lies, damn lies, and statistics.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon has succeeded in turning himself into a common nuisance in this House. He will always be a nuisance while he is here and I am afraid we shall have to wait for the general election to rid us of the nuisance. That is the definite object of Deputy Dillon's amendment —to show a way out to the farmer members of the board, to show them a loophole by which they can say "Oh, agricultural wages should be so and so; the real living wage on which an agricultural labourer can live is 50/-or 55/- a week but unfortunately our poor farmers can only afford to give them so much. Let us see if we can bring them up to that." That is the object of Deputy Dillon's amendment. Deputy Dillon is camouflaging it in a very nice way, but Deputy Dillon's camouflage is so well known that it will not be accepted anywhere. Deputy Dillon talks about the Wexford farmers and about how poverty stricken they are. Deputy Dillon seems to have forgotten one fact and that is that within the past three months he went down to Wexford and told all this to the farmers and labourers of County Wexford, and a lot more I am sure, when he had full liberty on the public platform. The farmers and labourers of County Wexford, who, as Deputy Dillon has told us very often, only want to be left alone to do what they think right themselves, told him by the ballot box what they considered was right and sent Deputy Allen to represent them in this House. Deputy Dillon had great hopes when he was removed from the unfortunate mess he was making in County Galway and went down to Wexford. He had great hopes that the particular type of stuff he was going to give out would take better there but I think Deputy Allen should be forever grateful to Deputy Dillon.
Comment on this
If the Deputy has nothing relevant to say on the amendment, he will have to resume his seat.
Comment on this
I do not wish to speak further on the amendment. I have given the reasons why Deputy Dillon is proposing it, and I think these reasons are apparent to everybody.
Comment on this
The Deputy who has just sat down may be accused of many things but he certainly cannot be accused of being consistent. The Deputy is against the amendment. The Deputy is against showing the workers of this country the wages they should get and the wages they can get. Deputy Kelly showed the true mind of the Party opposite when he let the cat out of the bag. He was afraid that if the agricultural workers of this country were shown the wages which they should be in receipt of, but which they cannot receive, even according to his own words, because of present conditions, it might set the labourer against the farmer.
Comment on this
That is what the Deputy said when he was concluding. Deputy Corry is against any suggestion that the gap between the wage which the farmers can afford to pay and the actual wage should be made up, but Deputy Corry boasts of the fact that he himself is making money on the very same principle. How much wheat would the Deputy have grown in the last three or four years if the gap were not bridged by the State?
Comment on this
The Deputy was on his feet for a considerable time and never spoke to the amendment. The Deputy is going to listen to the truth now and he is going to be shown his inconsistency. He is going to be shown that while he is prepared to support a principle that puts something into his own pocket, he will not support that principle when it is going to put something into the pockets of the agricultural labourers. How much would the Deputy grow if the gap were not bridged by the State? The principle is all right when applied to the Deputy and his colleagues, but it is all wrong when it is applied to the agricultural labourers. The Deputy cannot get away from the fact that that is what is in this amendment and nothing else. The Deputy, not that it matters very much, talked of instructions having been issued by the members of this Party to farmers to reduce the wages of the labourers.
Comment on this
He talked about lies, damned lies and statistics, but I need not go so far as statistics to characterise that statement of the Deputy. It was quite clear, of course, that Deputy Kelly had no idea at all of what the amendment aimed at. I can only conclude that the Deputy did not read the amendment, because if he read the amendment I cannot believe that he would have so misunderstood it. We had it from Deputy Corry that the Irish farmers are now making so much profit out of beet-growing that they can afford to pay a much higher wage than the English farmers can afford to pay to their labourers. We had the Deputy, however, denouncing the price paid for beet as being inadequate at a time when the price was much higher than it is now. I said before in this House that Deputy Corry had one voice here and another voice as a member of the Beet Growers' Association. I remember the Deputy on one occasion using a very apt phrase to describe the increase in the price of beet which the Minister offered.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows quite well. Why did the Deputy go on a deputation to the Minister and to the Sugar Board?
Comment on this
I agree, Sir, that I am wandering slightly from the amendment, but with all respect I would have to go a long distance before I would have gone as far as Deputy Corry went. However, I want to assure you, Sir, that I have no intention whatever of trying to follow the Deputy any further. I do say to Deputy Corry that if the principle, which gave him an economic price for his wheat and beet, was good enough then for the Deputy and other members of his Party, it ought to be good enough for them now when it is proposed to apply it to the agricultural labourers of this country. Deputy Corry should not take up the attitude here that he is prepared to stand for a principle if it is going to put money into his own pocket but that he is against the same principle if it is going to put money into the pockets of the worst paid workers in the country.
Comment on this
I only wish to say one word. Deputy Morrissey has alluded to subsidised crops. Is it wrong to subsidise crops? I know I could not be exactly sure how the Deputy voted on that particular matter, but I know that his Party on one occasion voted here that 1½d. a gallon was enough for the farmer to get for his milk. Wheat is not a subsidised crop; neither is beet a subsidised crop.
Comment on this
No—neither the one nor the other. As a matter of fact, this year on account of the inclement weather, and on account of the shortage in yield of wheat, we were able to go to the millers and demand a higher price, and we got it on the principle that the imported wheat had gone up so much in price——
Comment on this
If this is relevant I propose to expose the truth of that transaction, and show that the millers were blackmailed by the Minister into giving that price.
Comment on this
Those are facts which neither Deputy Morrissey nor Deputy Dillon likes. Neither does Deputy Morrissey like any allusion to the low price of beet in England as compared with here.
Comment on this
And Deputy O'Leary is making well out of milk now, and he does not think of the consumer at all.
Comment on this
It is 4d. a gallon now, and there is not a word about it. He was forced to rob them!
Comment on this
Over and over again in this House I have heard reference made to the private business of Deputies. That is a thing which should be put down hard and fast. It is unwanted and uncalled for.
Comment on this
With regard to this amendment, Deputy Dillon seeks to have three rates of wages fixed by this board—a minimum rate of wages, a minimum fair rate of wages, and a minimum economic rate of wages. As we know, under the machinery of this Bill in coming to a decision on the fixing of the rate of wages we try, in the first place, to get unanimity amongst the members of the board, especially amongst the representatives of the farmers and the representatives of the agricultural labourers. If we can get unanimity between those parties, then the chairman need not intervene except as it were to make it a rule of court. If they do not agree, then the chairman has to decide. It is very difficult to imagine that the board would agree to a minimum fair rate, except, of course, as Deputy Corry says, that the people knowing the greater amount would eventually come out of the Exchequer, it would not be anybody's business, as it were, to argue against a high rate. You might get a certain amount of agreement. In the same way, when we talk about an economic rate, the farmer's representatives would naturally be inclined to put that rate as low as possible, because that is all he would have to pay, presumably, under Deputy Dillon's arrangement. There again it would not be to anybody's interest, as it were, to argue against the farmer, and again, therefore, he would possibly get away with a rather low rate.
The position we would have if we were to agree to Deputy Dillon's amendment would be something like this: The agricultural labourer would get a very high wage, the farmer would pay a very low wage, probably much lower than at present, and the State would pay the remainder. I think that would be the inevitable result. We are not setting up that sort of board. We are setting up an arbitration board for one purpose. If we were setting up a board for the purpose of trying to fix the proper economic rate that the farmer could pay, or to fix the proper rate that the labourer should get in order to live, then we would probably have a very different type of board— a board that would be qualified to judge those particular questions, and to come to an intelligent conclusion on them. However, I am not going to argue against Deputy Dillon on that, because he would naturally say to me that if he carried his amendment he would perhaps also amend the constitution of the board so as to get those things right. Leaving that aside, I do not see what the practical gain is to be. If the board is compelled to say: "Here is the economic rate; here is the fair wages rate, and here is the minimum rate we think the farmers should pay," and all that is published, it only gives rise to a further inevitable controversy.
It is very difficult for a trained scientist to make out what should be the proper standard of living for an agricultural labourer, or what is the wage that the farmer can afford to pay. I am sure it is one of the most difficult things for a trained economist to attempt, but it is the easiest thing in the world for the untrained person to criticise, and we will have everybody in the country criticising the figure when it is once published. I am sure you will have all the farmers saying that the board has put the economic rate too high. You will have all the labourers and their sympathisers saying that they put the fair-living wage too low. The only result we would have is an interminable controversy over those figures, that is, of course, as the amendment stands, if the figures are just published, in order, as Deputy Brennan, Deputy Morrissey and others have said, to show the labourer what he should get, even though he is not going to get it, and to show the farmer what he should pay, even though he is paying more, under this Bill. There is not very much to be gained by doing that. If we decide that the Government cannot bridge the gap, there is absolutely no use in going on with this amendment and having those figures published for the sake of some theoretical figure which Deputy Dillon, Deputy Morrissey and others have in mind as the amount that the labourer should get or the farmer should pay. I do not want to go further into that question. I could give other reasons which I gave here yesterday, but I do not want to go into them again. I am assuming, for the sake of argument, that Deputy Dillon is honest in this amendment——
Comment on this
It is perhaps a very wide assumption, but I am going to assume it, anyway. I myself believe that when we are setting up a board like this we want them to maintain confidence. I want Deputies opposite to take a sane view of this matter, and to try to make the board a success. If they do want to make this board a success, let us give them a position in which they can maintain the confidence both of the farmers and of the agricultural labourers. They cannot possibly maintain that confidence if they are compelled to say: "This is what the farmer should pay; this is what the labourer should get; we are taking a middle course, and we say that this is going to be the wage." There you have three targets to be attacked. Let us make it one target—the minimum wage—and let them be attacked on that if anybody wants to attack them, but let it be that alone, and do not leave them open to attack on other counts. Before I leave that point, I think it is rather an old saying that the wise judge gives his verdict but he does not give his reasons. If the board we set up is going to be a wise board they will give their verdict, but as far as possible they should not be asked to give their reasons for determining what they consider a living wage, an economic wage, and all that sort of thing.
Deputy Dillon said that we can only influence, in the way of increasing prices here at home, about 25 per cent. of our output. In discussing this Bill, I have not claimed at any time that we were going to increase prices. If we do improve the lot of the farmer, then all to the good, but whether we do improve his lot or not we think that this Bill is necessary. As a matter of fact, I stated on the Second Reading that for the last two or three years we had improved the lot of the farmer by about £10,000,000 a year, and I further said that we were optimistic enough to think that that improvement was going to go on and that, if it were to go on, we wished to give the lowly-paid agricultural labourer a share in the farmer's prosperity.
Comment on this
Yes, his increasing prosperity. As I was saying, Deputy Dillon talked about 25 per cent., but if he wanted to give the Dáil and the country a proper picture, he might have mentioned that our total exports are not much more than 25 per cent. They are 31 per cent. After all, there is not much difference between 25 per cent. and 31 per cent., but one would imagine that our exports were enormous compared with what we were selling to our own towns and villages.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would permit me to interrupt for a moment. Is it not a fact that in 1926-7 the amount consumed by others than the agricultural community here was over £11,000,000—that is, consumed at home in our towns and villages; that in 1929-30, it was over £11,000,000, and that our exports were £31,000,000 —nearly three times as much?
Comment on this
In 1929-30 the food consumed in towns and villages was £11,790,000, and what was exported was £31,830,000, whereas now the position is that we consume the same amount at home and only export £10,000,000.
Comment on this
Quite right, and that is why I asked the Deputy why he gave those figures.
Comment on this
It is hard to make the Deputy understand. I have to go back to fundamentals with the Deputy. If he knew a little about these things, we might be able to instruct him, but I am afraid he does not. In former years we were importing a great deal of goods such as, for instance, wheat and sugar and other commodities, which everybody knows we are now growing or producing here.
Comment on this
May I remind the Minister that, on his own figures, the community here consumed £33,000,000 worth of stuff in 1929, and in 1934 it consumed only £27,000,000—£6,000,000 less.
Comment on this
Yes, in value, but that is the reverse of what the Minister was saying a few moments ago.
Comment on this
I suppose I shall have to be patient with the Deputy. "In value," as the Deputy said, very decently, but I think it must be admitted that we should take general world conditions into account in such matters as this and that this Government should not be blamed for all the catastrophes. One must remember the way in which general world prices went down and the way in which internal prices went down also, and if the quantities are taken into account, which the Deputy can ascertain by looking at the other page, I think he will find that we did consume as much, if not more, of all these commodities such as sugar, bread and so on; very much more meat and butter and eggs and other such items, but the value may have been less on account of the world fall in prices. I say that we were consuming more here, therefore, as far as the ordinary person is concerned and that our standard of living was better because we were consuming more. On the other hand, in value, what we consumed was less in 1934 than in 1931, but taking that compared with exports, what we consumed was better.
Comment on this
If the Minister is proud of that achievement, God knows I do not know what statecraft is.
Comment on this
Of producing for our own consumption here, and cutting down our imports to that extent. Take one item of which I am very proud. We imported about £1,300,000 worth of bacon in 1931—rotten bacon—from other countries, and for that we substituted our own good bacon, produced here.
Comment on this
No, the pig population is higher than it was, and we are giving our people good bacon now, and not that stuff that came across from other countries. Now, another thing that is unfair about the speeches from the benches opposite is what has been said rather definitely by some of the members opposite, and that is that if this economic war were to disappear, the farmers would pay good wages always and there would be no difficulty at all. I have said, over and over again here, that before the economic war started in 1931 there were many farmers who would not pay more than 17/- a week in wages, and some of them were paying less. These are the men we want to get at and to see that they pay more. I do not know if Deputy Morrissey or Deputy Dillon, who are so much in favour of subsidies in this case, would argue that if we were back to the 1931 conditions we should subsidise the man that was paying less than 17/- a week and enable him, by means of that subsidy, to pay more. I think that that is a ridiculous proposition and that no Deputy would stand for it for a moment except in order to get out of a political dilemma. Many farmers are paying more than 25/-, and the majority are paying over 21/-, but even so there are some farmers paying less than 17/-. Is it the contention of the Deputies opposite that the farmer who has been paying all the time, say, 27/- should get a subsidy, and that the farmer who is only paying 17/- should get a subsidy of 10/- to make up the difference between 17/- and 27/-?
Comment on this
No. Let us take one county, for example, or let us take a parish, if the Deputy likes, and make a flat rate for one parish. In many parishes you will have the position of one farmer paying 27/- and another farmer paying 17/-. The Deputies opposite want to say to the man who is paying 27/-: "We know that you cannot pay that and we will give you a subsidy to help you out"; and to say to the man who is only paying 17/- that they will give him another 10/- in order to make him pay more.
Comment on this
All I can say is that I cannot follow the Deputy's ramblings. However, I shall do my best to follow his plan. Deputy Dillon says that this board, inevitably, will have to condemn agricultural labourers to starvation on the present basis of agriculture—that it will have to condemn them to a starvation wage. Again, I want to know what would be the Deputy's position in 1931, when there was no economic war, or in two or three years' time, if conditions are changed? Would there still be a starvation wage? When the Deputy asks us do we believe that the farmers are paying sweated wages, I say: "Yes"—certain farmers are paying sweated wages and have always paid sweated wages. After all, when you had a position, such as you had in 1931, of some farmers paying 25/- and others paying only 17/-, there must have been sweating there.
Comment on this
Does the Minister say that the 19/- average in Wexford represents, generally, sweating by the farmers in Wexford?
Comment on this
Those who are bringing down that average are certainly sweating.
Comment on this
There may be some who are trying to bring down the average, but the majority are not.
Comment on this
Another thing the Deputy says is that if we fix this wage at a higher level than the average at present paid, it will inevitably lead to unemployment, and he says that that is hypocrisy. These are the Deputy's own words. He says that if we put up a Bill of this kind to improve the lot of the agricultural wage earner, and as a result we cause unemployment amongst the agricultural wage earners that that is hypocrisy. The Deputy's contention is this, that if we increase the price of the agricultural wage by 50 per cent. all round, we will have a decrease of 33 and one-third per cent. in employment. The very same arguments could be used in the case of industrial employment, because I am absolutely sure we could go to some given industry and we could say to that industrialist: "If you reduce the wages of your employees by 50 per cent. you could do a big export business and employ more people." If doing the one thing is hypocrisy the Deputy would not admit that doing the other was hypocrisy. If the Minister for Industry and Commerce brought in a Bill here reducing the wages of our woollen mill workers—I say compulsorily reducing them by 50 per cent. in order to build up a big export business and employ twice as many people, the Deputy would say that is hypocrisy.
Comment on this
It is hypocrisy in the one case but not in the other. What we are doing in this case is to employ the same means as are employed in industry. In industry the labourers are organised and they have a wage. It is because the agricultural labourers are unorganised that they are paid the present low wage.
Comment on this
If what the Minister is saying is true, then how does it happen that the leader of the Labour Party described some of these factories as "sweated shops"?
Comment on this
The Deputy can ask him. Why should I do the asking for the Deputy?
Comment on this
When talking about the wages of agricultural labourers in England we ought to be very clear about the position there. We should be clear with regard to the conditions of local labour compared with the conditions here and should examine the conditions with regard to rents, whether the labourers have plots of land allocated to them, and so on. Naturally, these things should be taken into account, if the board here is endeavouring to put our agricultural labourers in as good a position as the agricultural labourers in England.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say whether there is not wholesale evasion of the Agricultural Wages Act in England?
Comment on this
I do not know. It is certainly so stated in the agricultural papers, but I do not know whether that is true or not. Deputy Dillon will be able to make his own speech without any hints. He talks long enough at any rate.
Comment on this
I do not know if it is in order to discuss the financial idea behind this amendment, but if the Deputy considers the matter he will find that it would be impossible to carry out the ideas in the amendment even if the Dáil had £3,000,000 or £4,000,000 to carry them out.
Comment on this
The Minister said in Blessington, before the general election, that they had plenty of money.
Comment on this
So we have—more than ever the Deputy thought we would have. What is more, the people of Blessington believed me.