We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - Agricultural Wages Bill, 1936—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 147–294 of 294. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Agricultural Wages Bill, 1936
Enacted

No. 37 of 1936 ›

If the Minister has plenty of money why does he not give it to the farmers now to help them?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

This gap spoken of by the Deputy between an economic rate of wages and a living rate of wages is purely imaginary. I do not know of any gap between the two.

Comment on this

What is the Minister's objection to the amendment then?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That it is camouflage and nothing else. That is my objection. I say that there is no gap. The point made by Deputy Morrissey as an argument for a subsidy, that we have already given a subsidy for beet and wheat, is in fact more an argument against it. It is an argument against why there cannot be a gap here because by these subsidies to beet and wheat we are improving the condition of the farmers.

Comment on this

Does that apply to the whole of the Free State?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not say it does. But I say that the farmers growing beet and wheat should be able to bridge this gap themselves. Beet and wheat are claimed to be subsidised crops, as in fact is everything else. You could not produce anything in this country at the moment in open competition with the world, because some country or other would beat us in some commodity or other, whether it was wheat or bacon or butter. Everything has to be subsidised.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

My objection to the amendment is that the Deputy knows quite clearly on the Money Resolution before the Committee Stage that the money is not forthcoming to do this thing. Then it is argued by Deputy Morrissey that the farmers and labourers could ascertain what the one is able to pay and what the other is to get. What I say is this, that if this Bill is to work smoothly and if it is to be a success let them fix the wage that the farmer has to pay and that the labourer will accept. It will be a fair wage, at any rate. This thing is not going to improve it.

Comment on this

The Minister has just said in two successive breaths that there is no gap between the economic wage and the fair wage, and in the next breath he says that the gap between these two is going to cost £4,000,000. Now, which of them is it to be? Is there a gap, and will it take £4,000,000 to fill that gap or is there no gap?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Did I not speak for an hour explaining the whole matter to the House and to the Deputy?

Comment on this

Yes, the Minister spoke at great length but it is with his last two sentences that I am concerned. The Minister could speak, I am sure, for an hour and a half more to explain away and to reconcile these two sentences and he would fail to do so.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I said at the beginning of my speech that the board would make a gap between the 17/- and the 30/- a week but there is no necessity for it.

Comment on this

The position is this: the Minister appoints his own chairman— the man he is going to appoint. This chairman is going down the country. There are three independent members of the board and there are the labourers' representatives and the farmers' representatives. The three independent members are going to enter into a conspiracy with the farmer representatives and labour representatives, in order to completely upset the Minister's system of scheme. Unless the three independent members enter into a conspiracy to create this false and fraudulent gap, the fixation of the wages rates falls into the hands of the Minister's nominee, the chairman of the board; and the Minister, in face of that, comes to this House and says: "My chairman who is going to hold office at my pleasure, the man I am going to put into this position, is going down the country to create an artificial gap, the existence of which I do not admit, and the creation of that gap is to cost the State £4,000,000 a year." He will be the queerest appointee ever made in this country, and that is saying a lot. That cock will not fight, and the Minister knows it. Of course there will be a gap, under present circumstances, between the living wage and the economic wage. The Minister knows that it will be no artificial gap. It is ludicrous folly to waste the time of the House making absurd contentions of that kind. Another contribution from the Minister, in the course of the discussion, was that there is no use telling people the reason for any decisions when the situation is that labourers are not going to get what they ought to get, and that farmers will be made pay more than they ought pay. These are the Minister's own words, that there is no use giving the labourers reasons as to what they should get, when they are not going to get it, or giving reasons to farmers as to what they should pay, if they have to pay more than they can. The Minister plainly tells us that he believes the boards have to give the labourers less than they are entitled to get and, at the same time to make the employers pay more than they are able to afford.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I did not say "afford."

Comment on this

The Minister said there was no use telling the farmers the reasons why they are being made pay more than they should pay. If the Minister's test is going to deprive the agricultural labourers of a fair wage and, at the same time, bankrupt the industry, the real service that is going to be done by this Bill is very difficult to evaluate. Of course, the ideal way would be to put the industry on such a basis that when you fix the economic wage and the living wage, you would get the same figure. What I would like to see, and what I believe could be achieved in this country, would be that after you had reached the stage when the figure would be the same, the economic wage would begin to creep above the living wage and we could fix the economic wage higher than the bare living minimum for agriculture. Why not? If we can make agriculture prosperous as a whole, why should not the agricultural labourer be entitled to as wide a margin over a bare living wage as the industrial worker is getting? Out of that industry everything in this country is paid for. It would not be relevant to go into that now. Far from saying that I anticipate that there would be a gap between the economic and the living wage, I look forward to the day when the economic wage will be higher than the living wage. I do not think we should rest content until we have that.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Deputy Moore, for whose judgment I have a perennial and ever-growing respect, should remember that the Minister says that there is going to be a gap, and that it will take £4,000,000 sterling to bridge it. That is a long way from the day when the economic wage will be higher than the living wage. I wonder would Deputy Moore spend the rest of the afternoon asking himself what has reduced agricultural labourers to such a level, that they are £4,000,000 per annum below the ideal that we ought to have set for ourselves. Lastly, the Minister said that there was no analogy between agriculture and industry. There is the futility of the present Government Party. They do not realise that we are all living out of the land; that it is all we have got. You can build a factory or you can abstain from building it, or you can embark on an industrial venture, or put your capital into something else, but the land is there always. It is all we have got, and unless we can devise ways and means of working it profitably we will all go to the wall. There is no use talking about or comparing the condition of the agricultural workers and industrial workers. We have not the option of closing up the land. If we come to the conclusion that an industry cannot pay its way without imposing slave conditions of labour, we can close it down, cut the loss, and put the men working at some other business. We cannot get out of the land. It is all we have got, and if we cannot make a living out of it we have all to cut our standard of living to what the land will allow. The peasants of Central Europe did that after trying a variety of crops and they are now going around in sheep skins and pampooties. Do you imagine that they would wear sheep skin hats if they were in a position to buy hats in Bond Street? They wear them because they cannot afford anything else, and they are glad to have them. I would be long sorry to see Deputy Moore driving through the streets of Bray in a sheep skin.

Comment on this

I can imagine the Deputy in one.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry would not surprise me in caveman's skins, but the dignified figure of Deputy Moore, with nothing else to cover him would distress me. I suggest that Robinson Crusoe looked romantic with a sheep skin around his person, but that garb was not of his choosing; it was imposed on him by economic necessity.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is for Friday.

Comment on this

I had not the benefit of hearing Deputy Dillon's opening statement, but from what I heard of his speech I notice that he repeated the figure of £4,000,000 again and again. There was that colossal difference, he said, between the economic and the living wage.

Comment on this

That is the Minister's figure.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It is not. I protest against that misrepresentation.

Comment on this

What was the figure?

Comment on this

It would not be surprising if Deputy Dillon had some such figure in mind. It is his tendency to exaggerate.

Comment on this

I should have said from £3,000,000 to £4,000,000.

Comment on this

The Minister did not say that.

Comment on this

The £4,000,000 reminds one of a figure of £5,000,000 that has been so much debated in this House. If Deputy Dillon had such anxiety about the future of agriculture, such a desire to see it more prosperous, he had a great opportunity to show his sincerity during the past few years in a practical way, in relation to that £5,000,000.

Comment on this

Tell us about the £5,000,000?

Comment on this

The £5,000,000 was very useful for making speeches about, and similarly the low wages of agricultural labourers are useful for making speeches about. I do not believe the amendment was ever seriously intended; Deputy Dillon is the last man who would propose seriously to entrust a wages board with the task of finding out what is an economic wage. Can the Deputy quote any country in which there has been an inquiry as to what is an economic wage in any industry? How much more difficult would it be to find out what would be an economic wage in agriculture, or what would be a fair living wage? What standard is to be taken? Who is to fix the standard— the labourers themselves or some other class? Would we have the curious anomaly of a class other than the labourers themselves imposing a standard on the labouring class? That would be hardly consistent with the anxiety for democratic liberty.

Comment on this

How can you fix a fair wage then?

Comment on this

I do not think this amendment was ever seriously intended and, as far as the debate has gone, I heard no argument in favour of it. I think it should be rejected.

Comment on this

What does Deputy Moore mean by an economic wage?

Comment on this

I was asking who is to determine what was an economic wage, and where our standard for a living wage was to come from.

Comment on this

The Deputy seemed to me to be using it in the sense of a living wage.

Comment on this

I have no doubt the committees that are to be appointed to investigate this matter will try to come to some arrangement with regard to a fair wage for working men. They will have a problem to decide. What you might call a fair living wage for agricultural workers is fixed at a certain figure by this board, having taken everything into consideration. The same thing will apply on the other side when they come to consider the employers' side and come to a decision as to what is considered to be a wage that the farmer can afford to pay. The Minister seemed to think that it will be easy to bridge the difference between the two. I do not think it will. I think it will be a big problem because, to my mind, it is a big difference. The Minister stated some farmers were paying about 17/- a week. That may be so in a few cases, but I do not believe it occurs in many cases, because I know the farmers are prepared to pay the best wages they can afford to their workers. The people who might, perhaps, try to get sweated labour are very few in the farming community.

There is sure to be a difference between the people who will represent the farmers and those who represent the workers, and how that difference is going to be bridged I do not know. The Minister says he is not going to take the responsibility by giving any help or assistance to bridge that difference. The wages board is not going to improve the position of agricultural workers if the farmer has not sufficient to meet what is considered a fair wage, and I think that they are practically as well-off at the moment, with the exception of some people whom the Minister referred to with 17/- or 18/-per week, as they will be after the board do their best to settle this matter. Any wage that will be fixed by the board will have to be fixed on the basis of what the farmer can afford as a wage that he can make out of his industry. On the other side, there is the question of what will be a fair living wage for the worker. As it stands at the moment, there is a difference there. The average wage of 21/-per week is not a fair one for agricultural workers if it were possible to give them a higher wage. As I say, the people who might take advantage of being able to employ labour at 17/- are very few.

Here is a problem that they will have to consider also. What difference would there be in the work that labourers do every week, one man compared with another? How is that problem going to be solved or got over? You have a number of good workers who are prepared to do a fair day's work every day, who are capable and good, and they are entitled to a decent wage as far as we can afford to pay it. On the other hand, you have a class of people—perhaps they are in the minority—who are careless and do not care how they put in their day, or whether they give a good return or not. Some of the Labour members may resent that statement, but I do not make it to ridicule or run down the labourers in any way. They know it is a fact. There is a big difference between the class of workers we have to deal with. Some are good and some are only very middling. It you put all these people into one category and fix one wage for them, to my mind it will lead to a certain amount of unemployment. If the wage is fixed at a higher rate than farmers can afford to pay, that will also lead to unemployment. I should like to pay my men a better wage if I could afford it. How you are to bridge that difference I cannot understand. If the Minister is not prepared to help in the matter, I do not think the board, no matter how energetically it may work, can do any good.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

As to the £4,000,000 which was mentioned, I made an appeal to Deputies opposite to treat this thing in the best possible way so that we might have a workable scheme. I suppose I was foolish in making that appeal and, as it were, putting all my cards on the table, and that I should have played the political game they are playing. It is ridiculous to say that I stated it would take £4,000,000 to bridge the gap. I said that some farmers were paying 17/- per week, and that to bring that up to 30/- would take £4,000,000. No one would accuse me, if they want to be fair, of saying that the economic wage is 17/- and the living wage is 30/-. I gave that as an example of what it would cost.

Comment on this

Does the Minister think that a wage materially below 30/- is a living wage?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not know. It may be higher. I am not going to judge. That is the difficulty.

Comment on this

All through the various stages of the Bill Deputy Dillon has left us in the position that we really do not know whether he is for or against the Bill. We propose to vote against this amendment and I want to explain why. As far as I can see, this amendment enables Deputy Dillon to face both ways. The Minister told him yesterday during the discussion on the Money Resolution that that is what he has been doing during the progress of the Bill through the House. I think this is evidence of that fact. If this amendment were passed it would appear to me that it would be prompting the wages board to fix a certain wage, the idea at the back of their minds being that the Minister is going to make up some difference or another. I suggest that it is a very wrong principle to put an amendment of that kind into a Bill to prompt people to fix a certain wage.

Deputy Dillon tells us that he is in favour of the agricultural labourer getting a living wage. It strikes me that the only reason he says that is because he thinks, deep down in his mind, that the farmer is unable to pay a living wage. He says that when this Bill is put into operation, if the wages board decide upon a certain wage which the farmer thinks he is unable to pay, the farmer who has three labourers will probably turn away one in order to enable him to pay the other two. I think everybody will admit that there is no farmer keeping a labourer for the sake of keeping him or for love of him, but because he wants a labourer to do certain work and because he cannot do without him. We also know that there is no employer in this country, farmer or industrialist, paying the maximum amount he would be able to pay to any worker. We all know the difficulties that trade unions have in endeavouring to secure a living wage in any industry in this country, agricultural or industrial. For the reason I have already stated, that we believe this amendment would prompt a certain action on the part of the wages board, and prejudice the position of the board, and the labourer and the State, we are going to vote against it. We believe it would be injudicious to put an amendment of this kind into the Bill. As Deputy Kelly already stated, it would prejudge the case.

Comment on this

Deputy Corish is going to vote against this amendment because he has been told to vote against it.

Comment on this

Who told him?

Comment on this

Deputy Corish and his Party have been the tin can at the tail of Fianna Fáil for the past four years and they are going to be whipped into the lobby to-day with them. He says that we are prompting the wages board to fix wages. The wages board consists, in its three independent members, of nominees of the Minister himself, and if they believe that any undue prompting has been done by any ulterior circumstances, they can throw the whole decision back into the hands of the Minister's own nominee—the chairman.

Comment on this

Can he do that with this amendment?

Comment on this

All these determinations can be made by the Minister's own nominee. What objection can the Labour Party have to establishing before the country what wage the farmer can pay and what wage the labourer ought to get? What objection can the Labour Party have to that?

Comment on this

The farmers always had an objection to it.

Comment on this

The farmers would have no objection to it. The Labour Party knows that you cannot take water out of a stone. The Labour Party's suggestion would appear to be that a wage beyond the farmer's capacity to pay should be fixed. That will help nobody.

Comment on this

This proposal will help nobody.

Comment on this

It will create a situation in which the labourer will get a fair wage and the farmer will pay a fair amount.

Comment on this

This is mere pretence that you are out for fair wages. You do not want to see wages regulated.

Comment on this

The ultimate effect of this amendment is that the Minister's nominee will say what amount the farmer can pay and he can then fix the wage, having regard to the cost of living in the area. It is for the Minister to bridge the gap, if there is a gap, and I say there is. There can be no valid objection to letting the public see what the amount of a living wage is and what the wage is that the farmer can afford to pay, assuming that he is paying less than the Minister's nominee thinks it possible to extract from him.

Comment on this

I am tempted to say a few words in reply to Deputy Dillon's gyrations in connection with this whole Agricultural Wages Bill. The Deputy pretends that this amendment is designed to improve the Bill and assist the agricultural worker, and the agricultural employer. Anybody who has any recollection of the antics of the Fine Gael Party in respect of agricultural wages knows that this amendment by Deputy Dillon has one purpose and one purpose only—to deprive the Bill of certain advantages at present contained in it. We submitted a motion a short time ago calling on the Government to establish a board to regulate wages in the agricultural industry. Members of Deputy Dillon's Party submitted an amendment to that motion. The amendment was not to have an agricultural wages board set up with greater speed than we desired. It was not to make the board more effective than we desired. Instead, the whole purpose of the amendment was to set up a commission to enable Deputy Dillon and his followers to carry on the same old cant and humbug about the economic war. The mentality of the Party opposite regarding agricultural wages was revealed when they submitted an amendment having for its object the shelving of our motion and the concentration of the attention of this House on that old war horse—the economic war.

Deputy Dillon's Party has in the past ranted around the country about high rates, and the farmer's inability to pay the rates. When that proved to be a damp squib, the Party chased the question of land annuities and the inability of the farmers to pay the annuities. Then they thought that votes might be gained by inviting the farmers not to pay their annuities. Some members of the Party opposite advised them not to pay. The rates racket is dead. There are no more political tricks in that for the Fine Gael Party. There are very few political tricks left in the land annuities. Now, Deputy Dillon wants to have this fair rate of wages and this economic rate of wages introduced. If the Minister were to accept this amendment I would lay a bet with any other Deputy that within a week of this date Deputy Dillon would be found parading the country talking about the bridging of the difference between the fair rate and the economic rate. The Deputy merely wants another stunt with which he can perambulate the country. That is the whole object of the Deputy's amendment.

In the Bill, as drawn, the Minister is making as reasonable an effort as possible to regulate wages in the agricultural industry. No matter how low the wages are, they should be regulated. The position that exists in agriculture in regard to unregulated wages existed at one time in industry generally. In industry generally, there was a time when employers paid any rate of wages they liked. Industrial conditions and trade union organisation have changed that mentality very considerably and very effectively, and now we have the Conditions of Employment Act, which makes the unorganised industrial employer pay the same rate of wages as the organised and fair-minded industrial employer. Why should we not have the same state of affairs in respect of agriculture? It will not be easy to get it. It may be a long and difficult process. We shall probably have to overcome the same obstacles which had to be overcome before wages in industry generally were regulated. I believe that, with a Bill creating regulatory machinery of this kind, we can ultimately get to the point at which wages in agriculture can be regulated in a manner comparable with wages in industry.

I sympathise with Deputy Holohan's point of view, as expressed in this House. I think that there is a thousand times more sincerity in Deputy Holohan's point of view than in the point of view expressed by Deputy Dillon. I think that Deputy Holohan will admit that there would be very little use in fixing a rate of wages which would be considered to be a fair rate and fixing an economic rate which would, apparently, be much lower than the theoretical fair rate. Every farmer who wants to extend to his worker the best possible conditions is concerned only with the fixation of one wage— the wage it is possible for him to pay, as judged by a fair-minded tribunal set up to adjudicate in disputes between the agricultural employer, on the one hand, and the agricultural employee, on the other.

Comment on this

And the wage must depend on the farmer's income.

Comment on this

If that proves to be a low wage, having regard to the income of the farmer, why are you prepared to vote against this amendment?

Comment on this

This humbugging amendment is designed to wreck the Bill. It is part and parcel of Deputy Dillon's mentality in respect of agricultural wages. The Deputy's Party have shown that they do not desire to have an agricultural wages board established. So far as my recollection serves, Deputy Dillon actually spoke against the introduction of this Bill.

Comment on this

Deal with the amendment on the paper.

Comment on this

There is very little use in doing that, because the Deputy will not listen to what I say.

Comment on this

You are doing very well.

Comment on this

Yes, for the agricultural worker.

Comment on this

I do not know about that.

Comment on this

I shall do very much better when I see this amendment defeated. Deputy Holohan says there is no use in fixing a rate of wages the farmer cannot pay. Nobody wants to fix a rate of wages the farming industry cannot pay. If that problem arises, what must be done is: endeavour to put the farmer in a position in which it will be possible for him to pay a rate of wages which every fair-minded person in the country and the agricultural wages board consider a just rate. I think steps have already been taken to enable the farmer to organise his economy on that basis. Deputy Dillon would tell us that the most prosperous years this country ever experienced were the ten years from 1922 to 1932—that the only people who have ever seen prosperity were the population living here under the Cumann na nGaedheal Administration. Even in the prosperous days from 1922 to 1932, the Deputy's Party did nothing whatever to fix agricultural wages or to establish an agricultural wages board.

They had no intention whatever of establishing an agricultural wages board, even in those so-called prosperous years, to regulate the wages of agricultural workers. If Deputy Dillon cares to look up the statistics published by the last Government, by the Party of which he is now a member, he will find that during those years of so-called prosperity the rate of wages for agricultural workers, as officially returned by the Department of Industry and Commerce, was extremely low, having regard to the so-called prosperity which the Fine Gael Party says existed from 1922 to 1932. If Deputy Dillon takes the trouble to look up the official statistics he will find that from 1922 to 1932 the rate of wages in the agricultural industry was falling, notwithstanding all the prosperity of which the Deputy now talks.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

All of which is quite irrelevant to this amendment.

Comment on this

It may be in one respect, but I submit that I am entitled to show the House——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Why this amendment should pass or should not pass.

Comment on this

——if it is not already obvious to every intelligent Deputy, that this amendment by Deputy Dillon is just a little scheme by him to enable him to have something to rant about in the country during the next few months. That is the whole purpose of the amendment. There is no intention whatever in the amendment to assist the agricultural worker. All that the Deputy wants to do is to try to find something else to talk about, now that the other efforts to raise scares on various issues have fallen, politically, dead, so far as the Party opposite is concerned. I think that so far as the farmers in the country are concerned, and particularly the farmers who want to pay a decent rate of wages so far as it is possible for them to pay it, the kind of agricultural wages board which they want is one which will consist of fair-minded, independent men, living in a world of reality, who, knowing the position of both the agricultural worker and the agricultural employer, will say, having regard to this set of circumstances, that a certain rate of wages ought to be fixed and observed in the entire industry.

We all wish, of course, that our agricultural industry was more prosperous than it is, but the agricultural industry in every country in the world is passing through a period of unparalleled depression. Here, some effort has been made to overcome that depression by the regulation of prices, but I think that further efforts will have to be made in the way of regulating prices, even by the fixation of higher prices, because it is quite impossible to imagine that you can have prosperity in the agricultural industry, or in any other industry, when people are producing commodities and are not able to get for them a price which pays them for their expenditure of capital and of energy. So far as we are concerned, we have always advocated the fixation of fair prices for agricultural produce. I think that a combination of the fixation of fair prices for agricultural produce and the establishment of a fair-minded arbitration board would help, in a large measure, to bring contentment to the agricultural industry and more prosperity for the two elements—labourer and employer —engaged in it. Deputy Dillon's amendment is not designed to achieve that objective. It is a wrecking amendment. It is part and parcel of the mentality which the Deputy displayed recently when opposing the establishment of an agricultural wages board. For that reason I think the House ought to reject the amendment.

Comment on this

It appears to me that Deputy Norton and the Labour Party have allowed themselves to be mesmerised by a very extraordinary interest in the mental state of Deputy Dillon. Really what we are concerned with is not the mental state of Deputy Dillon or his motives. What we are concerned with is the effect of his amendment and not the purpose of it. Now, I supported this Bill from the outset, and I would support the Labour resolution with regard to agricultural wages as against the Fine Gael amendment to it if we had come to a discussion of that resolution. I support this Bill. I would oppose this amendment if I regarded it as an amendment which would have the effect of wrecking the Bill, but I cannot see for the life of me that it would have that effect. The amendment does not provide for any subsidy, large or small, from the Government. It provides just for getting additional information which it seems to me would be of value. For that reason, I intend to support the amendment, although I am entirely in good faith in my support of this Bill, and would support the Bill if this amendment had not been introduced.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment No. 9 put.

Tá 48
·
Níl 61
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

With regard to amendment No. 10, I gave the Chair to understand that we would discuss amendments Nos. 9 and 10 together, and I am prepared to accept the decision on amendment No. 9 as the decision on amendment No. 10.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I move amendment No. 11:—

In sub-section (2), page 8, line 11, to delete the words "area in" and substitute the words "part of"; and in line 12 to delete the word "area" and substitute the word "part".

This is a drafting amendment, because the word "area" has a specialised meaning in another part of the Bill. This is merely to change the word "area."

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I move amendment No. 12:—

To add at the end of sub-section (4) the words "including this sub-section".

This is to make it perfectly clear that an order made under sub-section (4) can be amended. It is merely to make that clear.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I move amendment No. 13:—

At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—

Every order made under this section shall be laid before Dáil Eireann as soon as may be after it is made, and, if a resolution annulling such order is passed by Dáil Eireann within the next subsequent twenty-one days on which Dáil Eireann has sat after such order is so laid before it, such order shall be annulled accordingly, but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done under such order.

This is the usual amendment for the laying of orders on the Table for discussion, if necessary.

Comment on this

Sub-section (2) provides that any minimum rates of wages fixed by the board in respect of a wages district may be so fixed as to apply universally to such district or to any special class of agricultural workers, or to any special area in such district. Has the Minister's attention been directed to the situation which has arisen in Kildare, for instance, where, although there has been a very substantial increase in the cultivation of the subsidised crops for which he is responsible, wages have fallen by 6/-? Is it proposed to make a special area of that kind within the general area, or has the Minister any observation to make which would explain the extraordinary fall in wages in the constituency represented by Deputy Norton?

Comment on this

Where your Blue Shirt friends cut the wages.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any observation to make?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I have no observation to make on that situation at all. Generally speaking, each county would be a district, and a number of counties would make an area. The board would have power to fix a different rate of wages for part of a county, even though the county is a district. They could fix different wages for South Kildare and North Kildare, if they so wished.

Question agreed to.

SECTION 18.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 14:—

Before Section 18 to insert a new section as follows:—

If any person, employed or desiring to be employed as an agricultural worker on time work or otherwise to which a minimum rate fixed under the Act is applicable, makes application to the board for exemption from the provisions of the Act, the board shall grant such exemption, and it shall not be obligatory on the applicant to give any reason to the board.

With the Minister's object in Section 18, I am in entire agreement, but I do not believe that that section will achieve his object, for the simple reason that anybody knowing the nature of the Irish worker knows very well that if they are suffering from any defects, mental, physical, moral or otherwise, no matter what inducement is held out to them, they will not be tempted to proclaim that they are suffering from these defects. The section lays down the particular types of individuals to whom it will apply. I do not believe that 1 per cent. of the people suffering from any affliction will apply for exemption, and the result will be that they will hold themselves out to be people qualified to receive the minimum rates. The consequences will be that they will be registered as unemployed, and will draw the unemployment dole.

I think that must have occurred to the Minister, who, I am sure, can find a more suitable wording than that in the Bill. I think the amendment I suggest would meet the object the Minister has in view. There is no reason why unfortunate people who, through no fault of their own, happen to suffer from some affliction or some defect of one sort or another, should be asked to do this, and, so far as I know, there is no precedent for anything of the sort, unless we go back a couple of thousand years to the time when the lepers proclaimed themselves unclean. That is not a principle which would commend itself to anybody in 1936, especially in Ireland, and to a class of people so sensitive as Irish workers. I think the Minister will agree that the section needs to be amended, and I think my amendment should meet the Minister's object and make the section workable. There is no use in putting something into a section which is not going to work, and I believe this section will not work.

Comment on this

I have every sympathy with the object which Deputy McGovern has in view, which is, clearly, to spare the feelings of persons who find themselves so circumstanced that they have to make application for exemption under the terms of Section 18. I think every Deputy will share Deputy McGovern's feelings in that regard, and I see that the circumstances envisaged create a somewhat difficult situation, because occasions will arise when it will be the cause of embarrassment and distress to individuals, who have to make this application, to come before a board and reveal the intimate personal circumstances which induced them to seek exemption. I am quite satisfied, however, that the terms of Deputy McGovern's and Deputy O'Donovan's amendment would be very much too wide, because it would permit of any man who was competent to get employment entering into a conspiracy with an unscrupulous employer to get himself exempted from the terms of the Act, and to accept work at a rate of wages lower than that fixed as the minimum for that particular district or area. If that were permitted, the whole Bill would collapse and would not work at all.

I strongly commend to the Minister the matter which Deputy McGovern has mentioned, and if any scheme could be devised whereby these exemption certificates could be provided for disabled persons without publicity, such as requiring them to come and state to a board the nature of their disablement, I should be very glad to know of it. Personally, I have not been able to think of a plan, but if the presentation of a general certificate from a qualified physician that a labourer was disabled generally, without specifying the nature of his disablement, would meet the situation, I think the Minister might consider it. Perhaps the Minister could think of a plan himself to meet the very legitimate point Deputy McGovern has raised. I think Deputy McGovern will agree that his amendment, in the form in which it appears on the Paper, is much too wide and would be open to abuse which he certainly would not care to sponsor, and which, I am quite satisfied, he will agree with me should be provided against.

Comment on this

I wonder what Deputy McGovern and Deputy O'Donovan had at the back of their minds in putting forward this amendment. If there was anything calculated to wipe out the Bill it is this amendment. I could imagine some of the advertisements that would appear in the public Press if the amendment were carried. They would run something like this: "Wanted, a general farm labourer; must be prepared to rise early and work late; and must be prepared to apply for exemption under the McGovern clause of the Agricultural Wages Act." I think that would be the position if the amendment were carried. I would not agree with the suggestion as to a certificate from a medical doctor. I do not know whether the Minister can meet the matter in any other way, but I cannot see any great objection to any labourer coming before the wages board and stating his reasons for exemption. If you meet it in any way outside the section, it will undoubtedly be open to abuse. Deputy McGovern's amendment is, on the face of it, ridiculous. It would only mean advertisements of the type I have suggested. As I say, I do not see what objection any labourer would have. I can understand the necessity for exemption——

Comment on this

Not 5 per cent. would apply.

Comment on this

I believe that the case of a man who found himself, by reason of infirmity, old age or any other cause, unable to cope with the ordinary agricultural labourer's work, and who would want to get a smaller job on a farm, would be met very fairly by the wages board. After all, the wages board is going to be a body of hardheaded, fair-minded men, who will understand agricultural conditions, and who will be prepared, I am sure, to meet such a situation fairly. I am afraid that any other way of meeting the situation is going to leave the Bill open to abuse and that is what we must avoid.

Comment on this

I am quite sure that Deputy McGovern was actuated by the motives to which he gave expression in moving his amendment on behalf of a certain section of agricultural workers who, because of some disability, would be unable to qualify for, and be entitled to earn the minimum wages fixed, but he evidently failed to visualise, as pointed out by Deputy Dillon and Deputy Corry, the danger of the amendment. I believe that the passing of the amendment would mean the absolute wrecking of the Act. The majority of the agricultural workers of the country do not suffer from any great physical disabilities that prevent them following their ordinary avocation. The number of people so affected will, I think, be a very small proportion of the entire agricultural workers. It is suggested in this amendment that they are to apply to the board for exemption without stating the reasons, but the reasons are already obvious because the worker makes the application by reason of the fact that, owing to a particular disability, he is unable to earn the minimum wage. What is to prevent such a man, in common with the rest of his fellows, availing of the provisions of Section 18? If there happens to be a man who works for a farmer and who through some physical infirmity is not able to do quite as much as other workers, it will be found in practice, I believe, that the employer, because of associations with the worker which have lasted over a long time, will be satisfied to pay him just as much as he would pay to other workers. I do not think there will be many cases of this sort coming before the board for adjudication. Beyond the fact, as suggested by Deputy McGovern, that a person would not have to go before the board to disclose his complaint, the amendment would confer no real advantage and certainly would not compensate for wrecking the Bill completely. You would have all kinds of conspiracies if the amendment were adopted, such as has been suggested by Deputy Dillon, to wreck the minimum wage.

We find that even in trades in which the workers are much better organised than agricultural workers, there is a tendency amongst some workers to accept a lower wage than that generally recognised and unscrupulous employers have been able to utilise that weakness and human frailty to take into their employment men who are physically capable of earning just as much as their fellows. If that happens amongst organised workers, I can visualise what will happen amongst a comparatively disorganised body such as agricultural labourers. I would suggest to Deputy McGovern, in view of all that has been said, that he should withdraw his amendment and allow the matter to be dealt with by the provisions of Section 18. I do not think that there will be any hardship inflicted on anybody by that section.

Comment on this

I would be quite prepared to suggest an alternative and I hope to have the support of Deputy Keyes for it. He has referred to individuals who are called upon to disclose their complaints. He has stated that there should be some inducement rather than a desire to allow them to work for rates under the minimum wages. That is no inducement for anybody to disclose his disability but, in order to give them an inducement, I would suggest that the Minister should pay the difference between what the man was actually capable of earning and the minimum wage. That is only just and fair.

Comment on this

There would be a plague of "crocks" if that happened.

Comment on this

It would enable the Minister to get over the difficulty.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The disadvantages of the amendment have been pointed out by previous speakers but I just want to allay any fears that Deputy McGovern may have. I do not think this investigation is going to take place in public in the degrading way which he bad in mind. The section first of all says "If, on application." That means, of course, that a person who does not realise his infirmity himself is not going to make application. A person of deficient mind does not realise that he has that deficiency and the application would be accepted from his father, mother, sister or brother or even his employer. If the application comes in, it is not necessary, either, as far as I see from the section, and I do not believe the board would insist on it, that the worker should appear before the board.

The inspector will call and I suppose we can rely upon inspectors being discreet and not making too much fuss about the matter. The inspector can call round in the ordinary way, just have a chat with the person concerned and make up his mind as to whether the exemption is justified. If the board decides on exemption I think the form the certificate will take is: "Exempted under Section 18." There is no reason why they should state what a person is suffering from, and I think, therefore, that all these things that Deputy McGovern was so much afraid of are not likely to happen. There is no reason why a person should be ashamed, because the person himself may not come into it at all. If a person is suffering from a physical deformity he is not usually ashamed of it. If it is a case of mental deficiency, the person does not know, and probably never will realise, that he has got this exemption.

Comment on this

Would the Minister be prepared to bridge the difference between the wage which he is capable of earning and the minimum wage?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That would lead to great difficulties.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

I think the Minister ought to consider altering the wording in some way to make it more workable.

Comment on this

Sub-section (4) of this section seems to be drafted in a form that we have not seen before. It states:—

"In any proceedings against a person under this section the court may, whether there is a conviction or not, if satisfied that such person has failed in relation to any other person employed by him as an agricultural worker to comply with sub-section (1) of this section, order such person to pay to such other person such sum as may be found by the court to represent the difference between the amount which ought at the minimum rate to have been paid to such agricultural worker and the amount actually paid."

Is it not a new principle to put a man on his defence in regard to one particular charge and then proceed to investigate and find a verdict in respect to an entirely separate offence?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I believe it does not mean that. As a matter of fact, that is what I read into it myself. "Other person" means really the labourer in question. What the section means is that even though the court does not convict of the offence, it may order the employer to pay up the wages due. They may acquit of any offence, but they may order him to pay up.

Comment on this

I have no objection to the section in that form as interpreted by the Minister but it does not read like that.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I admit that I read it in the same way as the Deputy did.

Comment on this

Is it not possible to get a simpler form of words, the meaning of which would be obvious to a layman? It was not obvious to Deputy Dillon and he is not a layman.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I am assured it means what I have stated.

Comment on this

It seems strange that "other person" means the same person.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

"Such person" is the employer and "other person" is the employee.

Comment on this

This section gives an officer power to demand and inspect wages sheets or other records of wages paid to agricultural workers. There is nothing in the Bill requiring an employer to keep records.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No.

Comment on this

Supposing he does not keep any records?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

He cannot show them then.

Comment on this

It cannot be read into the section that there is an obligation to keep records?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It cannot.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I move amendment No. 15:—

In page 11, lines 4 and 5, to delete the words "and the committee for each agricultural wages area."

These committees are merely advisory committees and I do not think there would be any use in keeping a provision in the Bill that they should send in an account of their proceedings. I think by getting an annual report from the board we will have covered all the activities of the board and the committees.

Comment on this

When does the Minister propose to bring the Act into operation?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I think we shall have it by 1st May or 1st June next.

Comment on this

Not before then?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Not operative. We will have the boards appointed two months before that.

Comment on this

When is the Minister going to bring it into operation? Sub-section (2) says: "This Act shall come into operation on such day as may be fixed therefor by order of the Minister."

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is the date of bringing into operation. I expect it will be either 1st May or 1st June.

Comment on this

How can you appoint the boards?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The boards are appointed before it comes into operation. They will have to be there two months before it comes into operation.

Comment on this

You have no power to appoint the boards.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I think if the Deputy goes back and examines the Bill he will find that.

Comment on this

The Act has no force of law at all until you bring it into operation by order. Section 24 does not refer to any particular part of the Act. It says: "This Act shall come into operation on such day as may be fixed therefor by order of the Minister."

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Perhaps I have not been correct in what I said. The boards are appointed before the Act comes into operation, but they will have to be there two months before the wages come into force.

Comment on this

How can you appoint the boards before the Act comes into operation? You have no power.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It is actually stated in Section 7 "The Minister shall before the commencement of this Act nominate eleven persons."

Comment on this

Section 24 governs the whole Act. No section that we have enacted here to-day has force of law until, as stated in sub-section (2) of Section 24, the Minister appoints the day for the Act to come into force.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is right.

Comment on this

Can the Minister do anything under any preceding section of this Act until he has done the thing which is stipulated for in sub-section (2)?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Before the commencement of the Act he nominates the board. Of course the board does not act until the Act comes into operation.

Comment on this

Section 24 says "The Act shall come into operation on such day as may be fixed therefor by order of the Minister". I submit that the Minister cannot take any action under any section preceding Section 24 until he has brought the Act into operation. However, I do not want to puzzle the Minister on a point of that kind. Does the Minister want the Report Stage of this Bill to-night?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That was the understanding.

Comment on this

I have no objection unless this point creates difficulties.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I think under the arrangement made between the different Parties it would be better if we had the Report Stage to-night.

Comment on this

I have no objection other than the point I have raised.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I might inform Deputy Dillon that under the Interpretation Act anything necessary to bring an Act into operation may be done before the Act becomes operative.

Comment on this

It is only getting the machinery ready.

Comment on this

I have never before seen this paragraph in a Bill if it did not mean that the Minister was powerless to incur any expense or impose any statutory obligation until by order he brought the Act into operation.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

There will be no expense; that is very definite. I know that on a previous occasion, when I appointed a board, there was no salary until the Act came into operation.

Comment on this

I suppose between this and to-morrow you can draft an amending Bill if you are advised this evening that you are hung up?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I think we are all right on that point.

Comment on this

There is one point which I should like to put to the Minister. I wonder if he could fix the date on which this Act would come into operation as some time before 25th March next?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy means the date on which the wages come into operation?

Comment on this

Yes. It is well known throughout the country that the general time for employing agricultural labourers is 25th March to 25th March.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It varies all over the country.

Comment on this

I do not know that it varies so much; perhaps other Deputies will be wiser on that matter. I know that in Cork County at any rate, and in adjoining counties also, it is 25th March to 25th March. It would make things awkward, I think, to bring the Act into operation in the middle of a year. Is there anything to prevent the Minister from bringing it into operation on that date? Why wait until May or June?

Comment on this

Can the Minister give us a rough idea as to what he proposes to do when the Act is passed?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

When the Act is passed we must notify whoever we think will be representative of farmers and labourers to put up a panel of names. As I explained here on the Second Reading, I think the county committees of agriculture could be asked to suggest the names of farmers for those committees and the board. As regards agricultural labourers, I said I did not think there was any organised body which could be said to represent them. I suggested that at least the T.D.s of all Parties might suggest the names, and preferably that the T.D.s of all Parties should agree to names from a given county. At any rate we have to get the names together. That will take a little time. The county committees meet every month, so it might possibly be a month before we have all the names in. We can then constitute the committees and the board. The chairman of the board having been appointed, and the board having met to make an order saying they were going to fix the minimum wage, it would then take two months before they could make that operative, because they must give two months to the committees to consider it.

Comment on this

Before the T.D.s send in a list would it not be possible to let them know what the areas are?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

They may take the districts to be counties. If an area comprises, say, four counties, I should like as far as possible to have on the committee in that area a farmers' representative and a labourers' representative from each county. It really means that we want, if possible, to get a farmers' representative and a labourers' representative from each county. That may be taken as being about the representation that will be wanted. At the very quickest, therefore, even if we were to get away to-morrow with this job, it will take over three months before the wages can be fixed. There is always a little delay, and that is why I am giving a month extra. There is also the staff to be got from the Civil Service Commissioners. Those inspectors must be got, and that will take a few months also.

Comment on this

What about the cattle inspectors?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

They are gone.

Comment on this

Are they gone? They are rambling around doing nothing.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

At any rate they were recruited for a special job. The Civil Service Commissioners may not think them suitable for this job.

Comment on this

Are they not still engaged and paid by the State?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not under Section 24.

Comment on this