Spanish Civil War (Non-Intervention) Bill, 1937—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–163 of 441. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 4 of 1937 ›
My compliment to the President was premature. He moved the guillotine motion and is proceeding to get this Bill passed to-day. It was all camouflage saying that the Second Stage only was wanted to-day. When introducing the Bill yesterday he said that he only wanted the Second Reading passed. It is fairly obvious that when he gets the Second Reading to-day he will substantially get the Bill. He can do presumably what he wants to do. He can do what has been prompted should be done by Deputy MacDermot. It has been stated that the Bill is urgent. It has also been stated that the question of recognising Governments in Spain does not arise. I say that that question does arise, because by passing this Bill we are recognising the Red Government in Spain and none other. Deputy O'Sullivan called attention yesterday to a quotation from a speech made by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, in which he stated that the fight in Spain was between Fascism and democracy. The democracy that our Government proposes to recognise will be understood when I give details received from a most reliable source in the handwriting of the head of General Franco's Intelligence Department which states:
"The actual composition of the Madrid Government is not known, but we believe it is virtually non-existent. We know, however, that of those who are spoken of as governing, only Largo Caballero, Alvarez del Vayo, Aiguade e Trujo belong to its Parliament..."
If I had a Spanish tongue like some people I could get it round these names, and there would be no laughing in the Gallery. Only three members of the Government junta in Madrid were elected Deputies at the last General Election.
"And the rest, whose names we do not know, are active members of the C.N.T. (National Confederation of Labour), F.A.I. (International Federation of Anarchists), the Communist Party, and others.
"This is the nominal Government, because the actual effective Government is constituted by Rosenberg, Russian Ambassador, Antonov Qusenko, Russian Consul General in Barcelona, and a group of Russian tacticians who accompany them."
That is the Government we have been recognising. It is to that Government the Minister for Industry and Commerce camouflaged a cargo of old bulls a couple of weeks ago, and then had the audacity to deny it in writing, saying that they were going to Gibraltar when, according to the "Shipping News," they were going to Valentia. That is the Government we are recognising in Spain, and that is the Government we are recognising under this Bill: a Government that has to its credit all the atrocities I enumerated. We are, we have been told, an independent nation. The President stated that we have a perfect right to pursue our own foreign policy. Why do we not do so? Is our conception of a nation only that of a parish pump? Has it not gone beyond the threadbare howl for a republic for the Thirty-Two Counties that the Minister for Industry and Commerce shouts now and then, but that he has no more notion of achieving than of reaching the moon? That suits the mob. When we see a chance of acting independently as a nation, why do we not take it? Why do we not strike out on an independent foreign policy? Why do we not say to the British that we have a foreign outlook? Why do we not say to the British, as one man, the late General Collins, did during the Treaty negotiations, when he told Lloyd George and Lord Birkenhead that Ireland was a mother country? Why did not President de Valera tell the British that Ireland was a mother country; that Ireland has sent her sons and daughters throughout the world; that they have colonised the British Empire; that they have colonised South America to a large extent and that they have colonised the United States of America? Why did we not show a foreign policy that was racy of Irish soil? Why did not the Government of this country, that has sent missionaries to the ends of the earth— that has missionaries to-day in the South Sea Islands, in Africa, in China, in Japan, in Siberia, in North and South America—show the world that we have a foreign policy worthy of a nation which has sent out those missionaries to spread the Gospel of Christ throughout the world, instead of allying and recognising ourselves with a Government that has set before itself the task of wiping out Christianity in Spain, and making Spain the jumping-off ground for the conquest of Europe for anti-Christ?
Why did not our Foreign Minister tell the British Foreign Minister: "We in Ireland have a view on this; our view is that Christianity must prevail?" There are two Governments in Spain claiming recognition. One stands for a Christian social order. Why should we not recognise that, and recognise it not upon the mentality disclosed here by Deputy MacDermot a couple of days ago and accepted by President de Valera? Namely, that regardless of the social order, regardless of the outlook, we will consider only geographical limits, and the day that 51 per cent. of Spain is shown to be under the control of General Franco we will consider recognition, but presumably if he loses two per cent. of that, and the forces of anti-Christ recover it, anti-Christ will be recognised by this Government. I was not surprised at Deputy MacDermot expressing such sentiments or such ideas, because his radicalism, I fear, outweighs his Christianity in these matters. He has interjected here several times that all nations in Europe saw the necessity for promptitude in this matter and are all prepared to take this action, so why should we delay? Again I repeat for him, and in order to put it on the records of this House, that we are the only country in Europe, in the world, that is predominantly pro-Christian and pro-Franco as far as Spanish affairs are concerned that has not recognised Franco. There is nobody in this country who wants to recognise the Reds—nobody worth speaking of.
Had our Foreign Minister struck out an Irish foreign policy he would have made the name of Ireland felt throughout the world. The British Foreign Minister would have had to hesitate before showing any signs of friendliness towards Communism. It would have helped to fashion English foreign policy, and it would have helped to fashion it on Christian Catholic lines. In the British Commonwealth of Nations Ireland is the most predominantly Christian Catholic country. All other Christian countries in the Commonwealth, particularly Catholic countries, look to Ireland for a lead in these matters. They have looked on this occasion and they have not got it, thanks to the Government. Thanks to President de Valera, they are not going to get it here to-day, but there were enough here in this House to force President de Valera and his Party to adopt the guillotine before they could get their way. There are over 20,000,000 Catholics in the British Empire. They were looking to us for a lead—a lead which they have not got. Had we given that lead they would to-day be a solid block on the side of Ireland; in the event of any crisis within the Empire we could rely substantially on their support. We have alienated that to-day. Now, what support have we got? We got no support. By our action here to-day we have curried no favour except the favour that will come from Communists, from Jews and Freemasons. We have alienated Christian Catholic support in this supposed Christian Catholic Chamber. Not only that, but those who have been mouthing about Republicanism, those who have been mouthing about a free nation in this country, have refused to exercise the freedom that was given to them. The Minister for Foreign Affairs has refused to function as Foreign Minister. He has sat like a little boy on the doorstep, until he was told by the British Foreign Minister what to do, and then he rushed into this House to do it. Because there were a few Irishmen here who said "No; we want to examine this; we want to examine what it is all about," the guillotine was adopted. The bell rings, all his henchmen walk in, and the guillotine goes through. Thank God, they had to use the guillotine. In conclusion, A Chinn Comhairle, the Minister for Industry and Commerce laughs. I will give him an opportunity to laugh.
Comment on this
I will give him an opportunity to laugh; we will see whether he will laugh. I happen to be President of one of the largest political organisations that ever existed in this country. This measure that is being discussed and decided on here to-day will be put in College Green at a public meeting in the Minister's constituency. I challenge him to come on the platform. I challenge him to come on the platform and tell his constituents that this Bill which we are passing here to-day is right, and ask them for a mandate on that Bill. I challenge him to face his constituents in an open debate in his own constituency. I will abide by the result, and I have no special friends in the South side of the city. His bluff and bluster and doubtful statements will not avail him there. It will not do for him to say that the "Clonlara" went to Gibraltar when he knew it was going to Valencia. Out in public we will have to get the truth when we are face to face. Now let him come and defend this Bill before his own constituents. He will get the opportunity. Perhaps we may have an opportunity of hearing the Minister or some of his colleagues to-day.
As a final word, I am not opposed to this measure going through, and going through quickly. The amendment which I have put down here has not been put down to impede the passage of this Bill. It has been put down in order to put Ireland right in the eyes of the world when we enter this Non-Intervention Pact. France is openly Communistic.
Comment on this
How are 800 men able to get into a train at Paris, go straight to Marseilles and have a boat waiting for them to take them to Valencia? How is that done? And this is the Government that said: "We must have non-intervention." Will Deputy MacDermot deny that? I will put a man on the platform on College Green who was one of the 800, the 800 dupes that went to Valencia and Madrid to fight with the Reds. On the 19th November last, when I was on Franco's side in Madrid, he was an armed soldier with the Reds, and I will produce him on the platform. Deputy MacDermot might as well throw off his pinkness and say "I am a Red." We should have people getting down off the ditches and coming into the open, coming on the side they really belong to. Let us see your colour; let us see your flag.
Comment on this
We know the Minister's flag and we know his colour. He has shown it, but we would wish that he had shown it with more truthfulness, because it is bad enough to have a Red Minister, but it is worse to have a Minister whose word you cannot accept as true, a word that has been proved to be false.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy must withdraw that. It is an understood matter in this House that when a Minister makes a statement, it must be accepted as true. The Deputy must withdraw that.
Comment on this
I am not referring to a statement made in this House. I am referring to a statement written by the Minister outside.
Comment on this
It is equally true to say that what a Minister states or puts in writing must be accepted as true.
Comment on this
It was outside this House. He made a statement, and I have a printed authentic document here which shows that the Minister's statement was not true.
Comment on this
I am not challenging the statement, but your reference to the statement as being untrue. Does the Deputy withdraw that?
Comment on this
The position is simply that the Deputy must withdraw his statement that the Minister made a statement which was untrue.
Comment on this
May I make a submission on a point of order? While we gladly accept your ruling that, in order to preserve the amenities of this House, a statement vouched for by a Deputy or a Minister must not be controverted as a deliberate lie, may I respectfully submit that to ask Deputies of this House to accept as correct——
Comment on this
That is quite different. That is not really a point of order. The difference is not a difference of opinion between accuracy or inaccuracy, or between correctness or incorrectness, but a definite statement made that the Minister had made an untrue statement. I must have that withdrawn. The Deputy can substitute "inaccurate" or "incorrect" if he wishes.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister is satisfied with that. We will say that and much more in College Green, and there will be no withdrawals.
Comment on this
The point I wanted to make clear was that there has been agreement that the urgency of this Bill is obvious, but that we should set down in that pact our attitude in accordance with our views on the general situation, because all other nations are doing that. England is not recognising the Franco Government, and has been a bit partial to the Red Government. France has been openly supporting the Red Government, with direct lines of communication, regular train services and regular aeroplane services, and they even retreated across the border at Irun. It was alleged that French artillery helped the Reds at the battle of Irun. Armed men got across into France—they were carried around the Pyrenees and got into southern France—and that at a time when France was advocating non-intervention. France, recognising the Reds, is entering this pact. That is quite in accord with the sentiment of France. Russia is doing the same. Germany is entering into the pact, too, but before she did so, she took a stand in conformity with German public opinion on the matter, and she recognised the Franco Government. Italy and Portugal did the same. Why do not we, in the exercise of our independence in foreign affairs, do what the people of this country want done, namely, recognise the Franco Government and then enter the pact? What is going to happen by recognising the Franco Government? Suppose the hammer and sickle as the emblem came over here, if we were engaged with a struggle with the Reds here, would the Government struggling against the Reds not deserve recognition until they could show the conditions laid down by Deputy MacDermot and accepted by President de Valera?
In a word, I hold, and so does the majority of this country, that we should recognise the Franco Government, enter into the non-intervention pact, and then co-operate with the rest of the members. It has been stated here that this matter is urgent to stop war. Was there ever such piffle heard in any sensible Assembly? Who for a moment in his sober senses believes that this will stop war? What is stopping war? Simply that they are not ready to start war, and the moment the lot of them are ready to start they are going to start. Deputy MacDermot knows that quite well. What are £400,000,000 of a special loan for? Picnics, is it? What are Russia, Italy, Germany and France arming for? The Olympic Games? The thing is nonsense. They are simply afraid of war. Some of them are not ready for it and they make a virtue of necessity, and say that this non-intervention pact must go through and that this, and this alone, will preserve the peace of Europe. Our contribution to it is that a machined majority in this House will endorse this pact, make it law and ally itself with the Red Government of Spain. This will be the first time in the history of Ireland and of the Irish people when the Catholics of this country will be penalised in the way they are being penalised under this Bill. Even in the Penal Days during the religious wars in Europe Irish Catholics were not penalised for joining European armies to fight for what they then thought was religion. They were not penalised by the penal Governments who in the past ruled this country. To-day under this Bill Catholics are going to be penalised. The young fellow who may feel inclined to go out and fight for religion in Spain will be shadowed everywhere, he will be only a ticket-of-leave man, the police will shadow him and he can be shoved into jail for two years or fined £500, and that simply because he attempts to go out and fight for what his conscience dictates. A young man in this country can go out and fight for any atheistic government, for a Mohammedan government or for the savages, but he cannot go out and fight for a Catholic people in their fight against atheism. That is the essence of this Bill and that is what we are voting on to-day. The only saving feature about the whole matter is that it cannot be got through without the guillotine because the opposition to this Bill sponsors the refrain of public opinion that is surging up in opposition to it and that will surge and increase in volume and that will grow faster than the sponsors of the Bill imagine. Even though we have paid a terrible price to find out some people, perhaps after all it was worth it because their bluff is called and the mask is torn off their faces.
Comment on this
Sir, there were moments during the speech of Deputy Belton when I almost formed a suspicion that he did not like me. I am, therefore, all the more touched by his kindness in offering me some disinterested and dispassionate advice about my political future. It is and has always been at once my strength and my weakness in politics that I care nothing at all about my political future. If I, a mere individual as I am, unattached to Party, have any claim upon the attention of the House or the country it is because I speak out what I believe is true without caring what its effect may be upon my political fortunes. The speech of Deputy Belton was in many ways unusual. I listened to it with the patience and attention that were due to the leader of the Christian Front. It may be that in the minds of some of us his political character is more suggestive of the atmosphere of a Corsican vendetta than of the Sermon on the Mount. But still he is now the leader of the Christian Front. It may be that although I understand that the wider distribution of property is the remedy urged by Christian Fronts in other countries for the conditions that are apt to produce Communism—it may be that, in spite of that, Deputy Belton is the one Deputy in this House, alike under this Government and under the preceding Government, and even before he was a member of this House, who has resolutely, outspokenly, consistently and courageously opposed all schemes of compulsory land distribution.
Comment on this
What I have said is within the recollection of the House. Deputy Belton was as strongly opposed to the Land Bills introduced by the late Deputy Hogan for compulsory purchase as he has been to the compulsory purchase Bills brought in by the present Government for land distribution.
Comment on this
On a point of correction. I want to say that is not so. I do not mind what Deputy MacDermot is saying, but my action on the Land Bills is a matter on record and I want to contradict what the Deputy has said.
Comment on this
Then it is contradicted. Nobody will bother about what Deputy MacDermot may say on that matter.
Comment on this
It is a matter on record that can be tested by reading even the debates on the last Land Bill, and what he then said about the Bill introduced in 1923, introduced by the late Deputy Hogan. It may be that Deputy Belton was the first to conceive the happy idea of treating an oath as an empty formula, an idea that would have been of infinite service to the Catholics of this country in the Penal times if they thought fit to take advantage of it. These are the things we associate with Deputy Belton's past, but now he is the leader of the Christian Front and as such he is entitled to the patience and attention with which I and others listened to his speech——
Comment on this
I claim the right to contradict the aspersion cast on me by the Deputy. These statements are not true. The Deputy suggested that I was the first to look upon the oath as an empty formula. On that occasion I took no oath——.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton will please sit down. That is not a point of order.
Comment on this
It is the first time that I have heard a remark made in this House as purposely offensive as one which the Deputy made in his speech to-day. He spoke of my Radicalism taking precedence of my Christianity. If I require any references as to my Christianity, it will not be to Deputy Belton I will go despite the fact that he is the leader of the Christian Front.
Sir, nine-tenths of this debate has been conducted as if what we had to decide in this House was who was right and who was wrong in the Spanish civil war, and what was the issue about which the people there were fighting. The questions before the House are the questions of non-intervention and diplomatic representation. It seems a great pity that our time should be wasted by going into matters so irrelevant as those that have been gone into in this debate, and gone into at such length; but in consequence I am compelled to say a little about them.
I have long ago stated, both in this House and in the country, that my sympathies in this struggle in Spain are with the Government of General Franco. I believe I was one of the first Deputies, if not the first Deputy, in this House to point out in a public speech that the Spanish Government before the civil war broke out had forfeited their claim to the obedience of the citizens, and had forfeited it by their failure to protect life and property — their failure to defend the citizens against damnable outrages. While I questioned and still question whether the amount of suffering that has been caused by the military measures that were taken by General Franco and his colleagues did not outweigh the good that is likely to be achieved, and while I cannot help wishing that they had instead taken the more constitutional means and that they had relied upon public opinion in Spain to back them up in their fight against the horrors that were being committed, and that they had the patience to wait for constitutional victory over the scoundrels who were committing desecration of churches, murders, robberies, and burnings, nevertheless whether they were right or wrong in taking up the sword I felt all along that there could be no doubt that those who cared not merely for Christianity but those who cared for order, decency, civilisation and ancient culture as against barbarism and cruelty could have no choice but to range themselves in sympathy with the Franco Government.
That is not to say that I consider that the whole truth is told about events in Spain when it is alleged that this is a fight between Christianity and Communism. That is not the whole truth. There is a fight in Spain between Christianity and Communism but it is confused by other factors. We have the circumstance that the most practisingly Catholic part of Spain, namely, the Basque country, has thrown in its lot with the Valencia Government. We have the circumstance that, in the passion of civil war, a considerable number of Basque priests have been executed by the Franco Government. We have the fact that a great many of the people associated with the Franco side care little or nothing about Christianity.
Comment on this
Will you give us proofs of executions of priests by the Franco Government? I gave my proofs.
Comment on this
In the very pastoral from which Deputy Belton quoted or, if not, in a pastoral or open letter by the Cardinal of Spain, he himself alluded to these executions, and said they were due to the fact that these priests had been too active politically on the Valencia Government side. I am not entering into the question as to whether these priests brought their fate upon themselves or not. I merely say that, while I maintain that the issue in Spain is irrelevant to our Bill, that issue, although it includes a struggle between Catholicism and Communism, is confused by other factors. Fascism does come into the picture. It comes into the picture so much that the German and Italian flags are found everywhere flying along with the flag of General Franco's Government. It comes into the picture so much that there are as many volunteers from Italy and Germany fighting in Spain as there are from Russia. It comes into the picture so much that the individual to whom we are proposing, if we oppose this Bill, to send further hundreds of young men, is General O'Duffy, an open and declared Fascist now, whatever he may have been in the past; a man who has attended Fascist conferences in various countries in Europe.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Ceann Comhairle called me to order for mentioning the name of a man who was not in this House, and who could neither prove nor disprove what I had said. General O'Duffy is 1,500 miles away, and I think that it is very bad taste on Deputy MacDermot's part to say that General O'Duffy is a Fascist or a non-Fascist.
Comment on this
General O'Duffy himself has boasted of the fact a hundred times. Heaven knows, when I had the misfortune to belong to a Party under his leadership, I had struggle after struggle with him to suppress his Fascist tendencies.
Comment on this
Any such suppression is a thing of the distant past. General O'Duffy has, with perfect candour and courage, given his views on Fascism over and over again. He has asserted that Parliamentary democracy has been proven a complete failure in every country except Great Britain, and he has stated that in Great Britain it survived only because of the popularity of the Prince of Wales. Little did he foresee that the day would come not so long afterwards when the democracy of Great Britain would show its independence and strength by actually getting rid of that Prince of Wales from the Throne of England. I would further say that if General O'Duffy's military capacities are at all on a par with his political capacities, I do not envy any person the state of his conscience when he contributes to sending the flower of our youth to serve under General O'Duffy's banner.
Comment on this
That is quite worthy of you. You have a good record as a soldier yourself, by all accounts.
Comment on this
What about Fianna Fáil Deputies of the old Sinn Fein Party? Does Deputy Donnelly agree with all that.
Comment on this
This sensitiveness and tender sense of honour on the part of some of the most abusive Deputies in this House is really touching.
I repeat that I hope General Franco's Government will win and that I believe General Franco's Government will win. I have always believed it would win. I think that there is a certain value in the justice of a cause as contributing to victory. I also believe that order, method and discipline are bound, in the long run, to triumph over disorder, faction and the various other faults of temperament and organisation that the people associated with the Valencia Government have shown. The suggestion that there is anything in my views about the Spanish trouble which I would hesitate for a moment to declare on any roadside in County Roscommon or that there is anything in my views which I have not so declared, I utterly repudiate.
One of the real points we have got to decide is whether or not we are in favour of this Non-Intervention Bill. Another point we have to decide is whether or not we are in favour of diplomatic representation with either the Caballero Government or the Franco Government. Personally, I much regret that the question of diplomatic representation has been drawn into this discussion at all. If I were in favour of immediately recognising the Franco Government and immediately withdrawing our representative from the Caballero Government, I should still vote for this Bill. What about this Bill? What is the attitude of the Opposition and of Deputy Belton towards this Bill? I do not yet know whether they are in favour of the Bill or not. Deputy Belton said, about ten minutes before he sat down, that, apart from the question of diplomatic representation, he would have no objection to this Bill going through. About five minutes before sitting down, he said that this was a Bill to impose most unjustifiable restrictions on young Irishmen —restrictions that were never imposed in the old days when they could go and fight for the Catholic faith in any country in Europe. In the name of Heaven, which is his view and which is the view of the Opposition? After listening attentively to every word spoken on the subject, I am still at a loss to know.
The President, in introducing this Bill, did not set himself up as a champion of Christianity against Communism. He did not so set himself up on a pedestal but, in my opinion, he would have a thousand times more right to do so than either Deputy O'Sullivan or Deputy Belton.
Comment on this
In my view, Communism in this country is a negligible force. In my view, Communism in this country is a weaker force than it was five years ago——
Comment on this
——and in my view the credit for that state of things is largely due to President de Valera.
Comment on this
Aside from the question of Communism in this country, looking at the question of Communism in the world as a whole I say that this measure that we are asked to pass is a blow against Communism. Communism everywhere at the present moment is a receding tide, It is on the retreat. It has had to be partly abandoned even in Russia. It is being partly abandoned even in Mexico. During the last six months, since the Blum Government came into power— the Blum Government is not a Communist Government and France as a whole is not a Communist country— Communism has declined enormously in influence in France. I do not believe that Communism is in the ascendant in any country, and I believe that it is pretty nearly on its last legs in Spain. But, if that is so, there is one thing that could recover for Communism all the ground that it has lost, and more than all the ground that it has lost, and that is a general European war. Communism as a widespread danger had its birth in the last European War. The misery, the poverty, the discontent and the fury against authority in every country that would be aroused by the results of another European war would be more likely to lead to general Communism than anything else that I can think of, and this is a Bill that is for the express purpose of contributing to the prevention of such a conflagration. Therefore, I say that every vote for the Bill is a vote against Communism, and every vote against the Bill is a vote for Communism.
Comment on this
But not only is the policy of non-intervention an anti-Communist policy in the world in general, but I maintain that as things now stand they are greatly in favour of the Franco Government in Spain. To my eyes at any rate, and I doubt very much if Deputy Belton will contradict me on this, the victory of General Franco is certain unless new factors are brought into the situation.
Comment on this
Exactly. Deputy Belton says he was sure of that six months ago, unless new factors are brought into the situation. This Bill will secure that new factors are not brought into the situation. It has been suggested by Deputy O'Sullivan that this Bill may not be effective: that people may evade its provisions. Of course, that may be said about almost any measure you may bring in on any subject, but, so far as we can see, suitable steps are about to be taken to secure that it will be effective. There is only one exception to that. It was suggested by Deputy O'Sullivan that volunteers would continue to pour across the frontier from France into Spain. France has agreed that its frontiers bordering on Spain should be under international supervision: that there should be foreign observers there to report on what is happening. Portugal has refused that. Portugal, of course, is solidly pro-Franco, and, therefore, if there is any effort at evasion of the provisions of this Bill, it will be on the Spanish-Portuguese frontier, and, so far as we can see, any evasion that is likely to happen will work in the interests of General Franco and not against him. Therefore, it is with the greatest earnestness and the greatest confidence that I appeal, not only to the members of this House who are voting here to-day, but to the people of the country as a whole, to realise that the policy of non-intervention is a sound policy, a Christian policy, and an anti-Communist policy.
Now, let us turn to a very much less important matter—the recognition of the various Governments. There has been a great deal said which seems to imply that President de Valera and his colleagues have a horror of the idea of recognising General Franco's Government. I do not believe a single word of it. I have no doubt that they will be prompt to recognise General Franco's Government at the moment when it becomes in accordance with international usage proper to do so. The recognition of a Government by having a diplomatic representative accredited to it is not a certificate of merit for that Government. At the time when persecuting Governments in England were burning and disembowelling Catholics, Catholic Governments had ambassadors accredited to England. At the time when the Spanish Inquisition was burning Protestants, Protestant Governments, nevertheless, had representatives accredited to Spain. The presence of a representative is no kind of certificate of merit, and I wonder very much whether, assuming that there are still some Irish citizens unfortunate enough to be within the area controlled by the Valencia Government, they would be very grateful at the efforts that are being made to withdraw from them such assistance as our Minister to Spain might possibly be able to give them.
Comment on this
Even where he is now. But, to tell the truth, the presence or the non-presence of Mr. Kerney at St. Jean de Luz seems to me a matter of almost trivial importance. I cannot shut my eyes to the fact that the sort of language Deputy Dillon, yesterday, and others have used to the President about the wickedness of keeping a representative accredited to the Valencia Government is almost word for word the language that was used and published in the newspapers of the world four or five days ago by General Goering in his speech about the Vatican's wickedness in doing the same thing.
Comment on this
Far be it from me to do so. I am pointing out that General Goering, Deputy Belton's friend——
Comment on this
——took it upon himself at the very time, incidentally, when the Nazi Government in Germany was meting out disgraceful treatment to German Catholics, to reproach the Vatican for keeping a representative accredited to the Valencia Government. I do not know exactly when the moment will come and when it will be suitable to withdraw our representative to the Valencia Government and accredit him to the Franco Government. I think it will make mighty little difference to the chances of success of General Franco. People have been talking here as if the war will be all over anyway if only we accredit a representative to Franco instead of to Caballero. The importance of the thing has been grossly exaggerated. Language has been used which has implied that we as a Catholic country were taking a line unparalleled by other Catholic countries. What about Poland? What about Belgium? What about Austria? What about the Catholic States of South America, all of whom, I believe, with the exception of San Salvador, still recognise the Caballero Government to the extent of having representatives accredited to them.
Comment on this
In the hope of being able to give some assistance to their citizens who are in the area of control of the Caballero Government.
Comment on this
Sooner or later— sooner rather than later, I hope—this Government will recognise the Franco Government, and then Deputy Belton and his associates will try to "kid" the country into believing that it is they who, by their efforts, have bullied President de Valera into doing so. Deputy O'Sullivan made a speech on this subject with his usual finesse, but in substance he was trying to do the same thing as Deputy Belton was trying to do—and, I venture to say, a discreditable thing—and that is to cash in electorally on Christianity. I have not the smallest doubt that, if the Opposition were in the Government seats, they would have followed out exactly the same line of policy that the present Government have followed out in regard to the Spanish war—not the smallest doubt. In reply to a quiet interruption, which Deputy O'Sullivan happened to dislike, he suggested that I was a person who was addicted to balancing too delicately the pros and cons of a question.
Comment on this
That was an accusation that arose out of the debates on the Second Chamber. I am not ashamed to have experienced doubts and difficulties about that very difficult question, and I, as one who favours a Second Chamber system, and who, when the members of that Front Bench ran away from the responsibility of taking part in a constructive attempt to provide a Second Chamber, did take my part——
Comment on this
——I am glad, as one who is in favour of a Second Chamber system, and I must say that I thank Heaven to-day——
Comment on this
——that the Front Opposition Bench have not got, at the other end of this building, a subservient Second Chamber to help them in this discreditable business of cashing in on Christianity.
Comment on this
We listened last night to Deputy Belton quoting a whole series of pastorals and episcopal letters and indulging in self-glorification because of his intimate association with Cardinals, and if anyone over there ventured to giggle, when he grew specially pompous, a suggestion was made that they were giggling at Christianity. Heaven knows, I am no anti-clerical, nor do I want to see an anti-clerical party in this country, but if anything could conduce to the creation of anti-clericalism, it would be the kind of speech we heard last night and this morning in the name and the pretence of Christianity.
Comment on this
Sir, when the President moved the closure this morning, I was asking the House to try to consider the issues, joined between the Parties here, dispassionately. I must say to my colleague, Deputy MacDermot, that when he takes upon himself to tell me and my colleagues upon this bench that we are trying to cash in on Christianity, it becomes difficult to preserve that moderation which should characterise our discussions. I repudiate, as a contemptuous slander, made by a man who knows it to be a contemptuous slander, that allegation.
Comment on this
Under your direction, Sir, I withdraw the words. There can be no doubt, however, that if I am directed to withdraw that description of the foulest vituperation I have ever heard in this House, then, at least, the man who uttered those words, in my respectful submission, should be asked to consider them twice before applying them to public men who, so far as I know, have done nothing in their public lives to deserve such a shocking allegation. Deputy MacDermot turned with anger on Deputy Belton when Deputy Belton did use words which, I felt, passed the bounds of good taste. The worst that Deputy Belton said, however, pales into insignificance beside the language of Deputy MacDermot. There is no politician in this country so base as to attempt to make about his colleagues such an allegation as Deputy MacDermot has felt himself entitled to make here to-day, and there is no man who can make that allegation against any honourable man in this country and claim his friendship thereafter.
Comment on this
We have listened, and listened in respectful patience, so far as this bench is concerned, to a long discussion of the merits of differences that Deputy MacDermot and Deputy Belton may have had in the past. We have listened to Deputy MacDermot holding up his erstwhile colleagues to insult and ridicule for the edification of the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, and it made me shudder to watch those members of the Fianna Fáil Party hang on his words and rejoice as he fouled his own nest and bespattered his own colleagues, as he gave his ex-parte version of what the decencies of public life have always required in this country to be regarded as confidential—the discussions that went on in his own organisation when he was a member of it. Deputy MacDermot expects us to get up and challenge what he said, in order to edify, in the news, and to divert the members of Fianna Fáil, but our personal honour requires no vindication in this country.
Comment on this
I will not. I will not give way to the Deputy. He will have another opportunity. I have no desire to get into a long wrangle with him about the difficulties of the Fine Gael Party, about the difficulties that beset us when we were colleagues at one time. There is no man who did not have difficulties and differences at one time or another, but at least they were always able to deal honestly and honourably with their colleagues of to-day and yesterday. They learned to part, when they deemed it their duty to do so, but they always tried to avoid that kind of one-sided recrimination which gives no opportunity of answering in the matter. However, that is not the business we are here for to-day, Nothing would have drawn from me those words. I have studiously avoided ever meeting Deputy MacDermot, since he left the association, in any kind of public controversy but neither he nor any other man will tell me or my colleagues that we have cashed in on Christianity without being told what he is as publicly as he has made the charge.
We have been asked to declare our position, to say whether we are in favour of this Bill or not. This Bill standing alone forms part of a policy which we sincerely endorse. We believe in a policy of non-intervention in Spain because we believe that that policy will in the long run redound to the advantage of General Franco and the Burgos Government. We have supported the Fianna Fáil Government since the beginning of this unfortunate war in implementing the policy of non-intervention because from the first day we believed that that policy would assist General Franco and the forces that were fighting with him. To-day we are not confronted with a Bill of that character standing alone. We are confronted with the introduction of a Bill to prohibit the sending of volunteers from Ireland to Spain. It is common knowledge that 90 per cent. of any volunteers that would go from this country would go to General Franco but, at the same time, we are confronted with the fact that our Ambassador who left Spain, who came home and reported to this Government on the conditions in Spain before he left it, has been sent back, not as an observer, not as a person who has a knowledge of Spain and who is not accredited to any Government. He has been sent back accredited to the Caballero Government.
I put to any open-minded Deputy on the Fianna Fáil Benches, this proposition: suppose they picked up this morning's newspaper and read that in the Dutch Parliament it was announced that there was going to be a prohibition on volunteers proceeding to Spain and that an Ambassador was despatched to the Valencia Government of Caballero, would not the general impression amongst people who knew nothing of domestic politics in Holland be: "Well, if there is any bias in Holland it is towards Caballero. They are stopping whatever contact there has been between Holland and Franco and they are sending their ambassador back to Valencia"? The Prime Minister of Holland would say that that was an ignorant comment, but the general impression in the world and amongst the masses of the people would be that Holland was leaning towards Caballero. And at this moment the action that it is proposed to take here is going to create in the world the general opinion that Ireland is by no means sure that Franco is right and that, in fact, if there is anything in it, Caballero has the right end of the stick.
We heard the Basque country referred to by Deputy MacDermot. He says to us: "Do not be sure that Franco is the champion of Christianity; look at the Basques." We all know that in the Basque country there is a very peculiar Nationalist movement which is prepared, in the extremity of political fervour, to bargain with anybody who will promise them independence of the Central Government of Madrid. These unfortunate people, carried away by their frantic devotion to this ideal of Basque independence, have apparently entered into some kind of deal with Caballero that if they help him, he will give them autonomy when the fight is over. That is used now in order to suggest that here is a great Catholic people, right beside the scene of conflict, who are not at all sure that Franco is on the right side and that in fact they are helping the other side. Ireland is one of the very few nations left in the world to-day which is not afraid to proclaim that it is a Catholic country and, mind you, there are very few left. Austria is perhaps the only other one, with the South American Republics. Deputy MacDermot mentioned Poland. The vast majority of Poles are admittedly a great Catholic people, but whether their Government would claim to be a Catholic Government of a Catholic people is something I do not know. This country, gloriously and notoriously, is a Catholic country.
Our material help to one side or the other in Spain is comparatively insignificant, and must be, because our resources will not extend to anything very formidable, but our moral support throughout the world can be immense. We have a spiritual empire of 25,000,000 souls, scattered all over the world who are closely associated with this country and who will unquestionably look to this country as a kind of guide on the merits of the situation in Spain. If it is going out to the world that we are in great doubt as to the rights and wrongs of this struggle, that for the time being we are driven to keeping in with Caballero, surely that is going to carry confusion into the minds of everybody whom we wish to be a champion of the Burgos Government wherever he may dwell? Think of the Irish in the United States. Think of the Irish all over the Commonwealth of Nations. Their influence is immense. If their influence is swayed to one side or the other, what is it going to mean? Surely it is vital that Ireland should do nothing ambiguous at a time like this, lest that great volume of opinion should be adversely affected in a time of very great crisis.
The President spoke here last night, and the Irish Times to-day is greatly pleased with him. In its leading article to-day it states:—
"President de Valera has not spoken better for a long time past than in the speech wherewith he moved the Second Reading yesterday. It was not an occasion for impassioned appeals but for plain facts, and he set forth the plain facts of the situation with lucidity and quiet force.... We congratulate Mr. de Valera's Government on its clear vision and on its willingness to act in concert with the whole civilised world."
That speech, which "set forth the facts of the situation with lucidity and quiet force," contained this pregnant phrase. I quote from the Irish Press of to-day:
"I am anxious that we in this country should play our part in trying to shorten this conflict in Spain by preventing the export of arms to the combatants, and also by preventing recruitment by the various sides who are fighting out in Spain, a fight which, for most of them, at any rate, is not the sort of fight that we think it is, but is a fight of one `ism' against the other."
Do the Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party believe that those who are fighting for Franco, or the vast majority of them, are fighting for one "ism" or another in the sense that the President used that term? I am prepared to accept those words, but not in the sense in which the President spoke them, or in the sense in which the Irish Times praises them. They are fighting for one “ism” or another in Spain, Deism or Atheism, Godism or no-Godism, and that is a fight in which I believe every member of the Fianna Fáil Party would be prepared to join in, and, I like to think, on the right side. But I think it shows a complete lack of appreciation of the situation which confronts us if the President thinks that this is a struggle between one dictatorship and another. I and all those who are colleagues of mine in this Party, detest equally Hitlerism, Mussolini-ism and Stalinism, but we also know that it is the well-tried tactic of the Comintern of Moscow to describe everybody not prepared to accept the letter of Marx's doctrine as a Fascist. Everybody who is not prepared to get on Stalin's band-waggon is a Fascist. And there are some well-intentioned people amongst us so anxious to disclaim any suggestion that they could be described as Fascists, that they are prepared to go almost any length in order to earn from the agents of Moscow the encomium of being described as a democrat. It is that constant dripping of jibing and jeering the word “Fascist” at persons not prepared to accept Communism which is one of the most effective weapons in the armoury of the Third Internationale at the present time. In this time, when everything that we have been accustomed to look upon as permanent is crashing about us, it is more vital than it ever was before that we should with courage, and without the same delicacy of shyness, testify to our faith.
If any man at the present time dares to come out and denounce Communism for the despicable and detestable thing it is, he is first described as a Fascist, and he is immediately put on the defensive; because he denounces the beastly philosophy of Communism, he is put on the defensive, not only by the Communists, but by all the pink democrats in this country and in every other country, to prove that he is not a Fascist. And there are some simple people in this and other countries who, instead of rejecting that challenge to prove that they are not Fascists simply because they confess the truth of their faith, proceed to protest there is no Fascism in that confession of faith, and before long they find themselves defending what they ought to regard as fundamental and unquestioned truth against a controversy that suggests they ought to be ashamed of confessing to such beliefs. Many of them slowly find themselves falling back until they begin to doubt the very foundation upon which the whole philosophy of life is based. And, once having lost these sheet anchors, they are adrift, and the mentality that can let these sheet anchors go, too often finds a happy home in whatever happens at the moment to be the most clamorous mob. So, new recruits are got to that endless army of Communists, semi-Communists, radical liberals, friends of the people, friends of the peasants, defenders of the workers, mild socialists, radical socialists, red socialists, pink socialists and the 101 other factions out of which the mosaic of Communism is designed at the present time.
We, all of us, are prepared now to assist in the effective enforcement of a policy of non-intervention, but we must emphatically reject the attempt of the Government to pass this Bill and at the same time to despatch an ambassador to Valencia. Recall your ambassador and we are prepared to co-operate in whatever we believe will be effective to prevent intervention. Leave your ambassador at Madrid and it is our clear duty to make known to the world that whatever the apparent inclination of the Government Party in this country may be, a solid Parliamentary Opposition and the vast majority of the Irish people have no desire whatever to send an ambassador to Madrid or to entertain an ambassador from Madrid in this city. We want the Spanish ambassador in this city given his papers and told to go home; we want our own ambassador recalled to Dublin. We want the world to know that, in so far as we are prepared to support non-intervention, we do it because we believe that it will be the most effective method of helping the Burgos Government to prevail in Spain.
We want the pinks and the semireds and the muddleheads in this country to understand that there is no use wobbling at this stage in regard to the Spanish situation. Your sympathies must be on one side or the other, either for Caballero or for Franco. There is no use talking in wild vapourings about Communism, Fascism, democracy or anything else. The issue in Spain, the fundamental issue, is God or no God. Fully 95 per cent. of our people desire to see an administration prevailing in that country which believes in the existence of God. They are quite content to leave over the minor political issues that may be at stake until that supreme issue is determined.
It is necessary, lest attempt should be made by unscrupulous agents of the Comintern in this country to misrepresent our position, to repeat very categorically and immediately after the statement I have just made that we detest Hitlerism, Mussolini-ism, and Stalinism equally, that we are proud of the title "democrat," and when we rejoice in that title it is not the title "democrat" as conferred by Moscow, meaning the gullible tool of anyone prepared to shout "Fascist" at him; we rejoice in the title of "democrat" conferred upon us by democrats, a democracy of the kind that is prepared to face Communism with whatever weapons it may be necessary to use in order to destroy it, and at the same time democrats standing for a democracy which will be strong enough, resolute enough and clear-minded enough to smash Communism here or elsewhere without resorting to the methods of Fascism or any other kind of dictatorship which at the present time is so frequently called into being where the Communist menace manifests itself. That, to my mind, is one of the terrible dangers of the present situation.
Deputy MacDermot says Communism is a receding tide the world over. He says it constitutes no menace in this country at all. Every spiritual guide of the people takes a different view. I think one of the great menaces of Communism at present is that Communism begets Hitlerism and unless the democracy of this country and of Great Britain and the other democratic countries clear their minds on the kind of fundamental issues that are at present presenting themselves in Spain, Communism will beget Hitlerism, because there will be no clear resolute purpose in the democracy to defend fundamental things against attack, whether made from the right or from the left. I want to clear the field on fundamental issues. I should like all sides in this country who believe in democracy to be clear on these fundamental issues. I say that superior to any political issue that can be raised in this country or any other country is the supreme issue whether God is in Heaven or not. That is the issue in Spain at present. That issue has to be clearly and finally determined before we get down to a discussion of the minor question of the political philosophies which inspire the participants in that country. We know what ours are. We are prepared to defend them against attack from the right or from the left. We are prepared to defend them from undermining operations by those who long to be on the left but have not the courage to wrap that standard around them. We are prepared to defend them against the persons who would receive with acclamation a resolution to condemn Communism, but would deem it most expedient to withdraw that resolution when Communism was associated with Fascism in the general condemnation. We are prepared to accept any resolution any time condemning both these systems with an equal emphasis.
We believe that the action proposed by the Government to-day in presenting this Bill for approval and at the same time emphasising before the world our diplomatic relations with Madrid is going to mislead the entire world as to our position. Against that we emphatically protest. Withdraw your Ambassador, and we will help in the work of non-intervention. Leave your Ambassador in Madrid, and we will offset your gesture by making it clear in this House and on platforms in the country that, no matter where Mr. Kerney is, the hearts of the Irish people in the Spanish conflict are in Burgos.
Comment on this
I am supporting the amendment. I feel that the attitude of the Government as expressed in the Bill which we have now before us is neither dignified nor Christian, especially at the present time and in present circumstances. I feel, too, that it is the duty and should be the duty of the Government of the Irish Free State to take the first opportunity that presents itself to make it manifest to our own country and to the countries of the world that this is essentially a Christian country. It should also be our duty, following from that, to assist General Franco in his efforts to combat the anti-God forces arrayed against him. We have heard from time to time from various platforms in this country that Communism will never take root here. The same thing is being said of other countries. The same thing was said of Mexico and the same thing was said of Spain. We have had it stated time and time again in this country that Communism has no roots here and never shall have roots here.
Deputy Dillon spoke about the various colours of the Communists, the various grades of Communists. There are the pinks and the reds and the pale pinks, etc. That there is at present in this country a Communistic movement cannot be gainsaid. Let us take only one or two recent incidents that occurred in this country. After two great meetings, two of the largest meetings ever held in this country, one in Dublin and the other in Cork, to protest against the atrocities in Spain we had a meeting some time ago of the Irish Labour Party at which a motion was submitted condemning Fascism. Some delegates from the County Tipperary branch of the Irish Labour Party present moved an amendment that Communism should also be condemned, and what happened? The motion and the amendment were discussed apparently in camera and, by consent, both motion and amendment were withdrawn.
Comment on this
In other words, the delegates there of the Irish Labour Party refused to condemn Communism.
Comment on this
Is it in order for a Deputy to make a deliberate misstatement as to what transpired at a conference?
Comment on this
I correct the words "in camera” and make them “in public.” The fact still remains that they did not——
Comment on this
There is a Bill before the House which has no relation to social conditions in this country. There are two amendments, neither of which deals with our position here. The purpose of both amendments is to request the Government to take a certain line of action. As I have said before to-day when the Deputy was not present, if this debate is to develop into a discussion of the social and other conditions in this country and the action of the individuals or Parties in this State, the discussion would be prolonged and quite irrelevant.
Comment on this
Do I take it, therefore, from that ruling that Deputy Anthony will not be allowed to repeat deliberate misstatements?
Comment on this
A precedent, I submit, has been created to-day, and even yesterday when Deputy Belton and others were allowed to discuss the amendment and to establish reasons why it should be carried.
Comment on this
I did not start with a misrepresentation. I accepted the Deputy's correction. When I said that the amendment and the motion were discussed in camera, I said I accepted his explanation.
Comment on this
You are telling another lie. That is one for you. I said they refused to condemn Communism.
Comment on this
That is a deliberate lie. I must characterise it as a deliberate lie by Deputy Anthony.
Comment on this
Do you imagine it is reasonable to ask any person to listen to lies of that kind without protesting? I will not do it.
Comment on this
I submit that I am entitled to make my position clear. Deputy Anthony said definitely that the recent Labour Party Conference refused to condemn Communism. I said that was a deliberate lie. It is a deliberate lie, and I will not withdraw that statement as applied to Deputy Anthony's remarks.
Comment on this
It is quite unparliamentary. The words "deliberate lie" must not be used in this House. Deputy Anthony used the word "lie." Both Deputies must withdraw the word "lie."
Comment on this
If Deputy Anthony withdraws the statement that he made, that the Labour Party Conference refused to condemn Communism, I will withdraw my statement, but if he persists in that statement——
Comment on this
The Chair will hear no more about the conference. The Deputy must withdraw the words "deliberate lie."
Comment on this
If I might be allowed to intervene. Deputy Norton has made a protest which the Chair considered unparliamentary. Could he not be prevailed upon to make the ordinary amende honorable made in these matters? I do not want to enter into the merits of the controversy, but he has made a protest which was couched in language which the Chair considers unparliamentary. Surely the language might be withdrawn. That is all the Chair has asked.
Comment on this
Deputy Anthony's statement has been allowed to stand. I refuse to withdraw while he is not compelled to withdraw it.
Comment on this
If I might, contrary to all precedent, put it to the Deputy, he has now stated that an incorrect and an untrue statement was made by Deputy Anthony. It would have been quite parliamentary to refer to the statement in that fashion at the outset.
Comment on this
The expression will stand so long as the Deputy will not withdraw what was a deliberate slander on the Labour Party, whose only offence is that it expelled Deputy Anthony from membership of the Party.
Comment on this
I will save the Minister doing that, as I prefer to leave the House, rather than allow a statement of that kind to pass unchallenged.
The Deputy then withdrew from the Chamber.
Comment on this
In support of my argument, I want to point out that various bishops in their Lenten Pastorals called attention to the menace of Communism. It cannot be said these spiritual directors of the people are not in touch with the feelings of the people. They must have good and valid grounds for warning them against the inroads of Communism. Some of them suggested that Communism was present in various parts of this country. While, to-day, Catholic institutions, priests and nuns may be bearing the brunt of the Red atrocities in Spain, it is not in Spain alone that they will have to do that if Communism is allowed to spread, because all Christians will be attacked in turn. The Protestant faith is no more safe from the inroads and outrages of Communism than the Catholic Church. I know that there is a very strong feeling amongst all professing Christians in this country against Communism. It is well known that in at least four or five centres there are Communist agents.
Comment on this
I told the Deputy that conditions in this country are not to be discussed on this Bill. The Bill relates to Spain, and requests the Government to take certain action regarding Spain.
Comment on this
My contribution to this debate would be very brief and I would have finished long ago only that I was interrupted.
Comment on this
I understand that a statement was made to-day, that there was no Communism here because of the activities of certain people, and that that was allowed.
Comment on this
The statement was made by Deputy MacDermot, that owing to the activities of the present Government there was no Communism here.
Comment on this
The Chair has not heard it. I have given my ruling that social conditions here are not to be discussed.
Comment on this
If you were not present when the argument was used surely it would be permitted in debate to use a counter phrase. I propose to use one.
Comment on this
I only want to make a suggestion to the President that he might respond to public feeling in this matter because there is an intense feeling amongst the Irish people that the forces led by General Franco should win in this terrible conflict. I believe the President must be aware of the fact that the majority of professing Christians in Ireland believe that this is a fight between the forces of God and the forces of anti-Christ.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton seemed to be very angry with Deputy Anthony for the reference he made to happenings at the recent Labour Party conference, but all the anger of Deputy Norton about "deliberate lies" will not get away from this fact, that there was on the agenda——
Comment on this
That incident is closed. There has been sufficient trouble over such irrelevant matters.
Comment on this
Deputy MacDermot delivered a speech here to-day to which I intend only to make a passing reference, as it has been very adequately dealt with by Deputy Dillon. In the course of his speech, Deputy MacDermot dealt with conditions in this country. I want to submit that these conditions were practically the basis of his speech. Deputy MacDermot re-echoed words used by the President not very long ago, and I want to relate them to the Bill and to the amendments, because of the effects, not only outside, but inside this country, if the amendment in the name of Deputy O'Sullivan is rejected. Unless the amendment is accepted, there will be an incentive to those carrying on Communistic work to continue doing so, and a very bad example will be set the youth of the country. Deputy MacDermot, in re-echoing the words of the President, said that whatever trace of Communism there might have been here five years ago, there was practically no Communism here now. Speaking last week, two days after the bishops' pastorals had been published in the newspapers, Deputy Norton spoke of the scare stories about Communism, and how grossly exaggerated they were. For the first time in this country the key-note of all the pastorals of every bishop, from the Cardinal down, was the menace of Communism, but, of course, Deputy Norton is in closer touch with things in this country than the whole bench of bishops. Deputy MacDermot, speaking out of the depths of his intimate knowledge of Irish conditions and of the Irish people, tells us there is no danger. Do not believe what the bishops tell you: they know nothing about it. "Take my word for it," says Deputy MacDermot, "whatever Communism was there five years ago has ceased to exist as a result of the operations of the present Government." So far as I am concerned, if I want to get a correct view of conditions in this country, I prefer to take those impressions and those views from the Irish Hierarchy rather than from Deputy Norton, and certainly not from Deputy MacDermot. The Deputy went on to tell us also that there were fewer Communists in France to-day than there were even six months ago; there was less fear of Communism in France. I have no doubt whatever that the Deputy can speak with much more authority about the conditions in France than he can about conditions in the Irish Free State. But the remarkable part of the whole thing— and it shows, I think, more clearly than anything else the sorry plight of the Government and the Government Party —is that the Government Party took Deputy MacDermot to their bosom and applauded him. They must be in a very sorry plight, indeed, over this matter, when they need the championship of Deputy MacDermot, and when they receive it with open arms and with applause.
Another point from Deputy MacDermot's speech was that, having listened to Deputy Professor O'Sullivan, Deputy Belton and some other speakers, he did not know whether they were for or against the Bill. I should like to ask Deputy MacDermot, or the President, is he for or against the reasoned amendment to the Second Reading of the Bill in the name of Deputy Professor O'Sullivan? Is Deputy MacDermot in favour of our having an accredited representative to the Red Government in Spain? The President and his Party obviously are. The President and the other members of the Front Bench are very fond of talking about mandates from the Irish people, and about carrying out the will of the Irish people. We have heard that here and in the country over and over again during the past five years. Will the President or any other member of his Party dare to assert that it is in accordance with the wishes of the Irish people that we should have an accredited representative to Valencia? I do not believe that even the President would dare to make that assertion. Are we to take it that the Government view of the situation in Spain has been correctly put by Deputy Hugo Flinn, the Parliamentary Secretary, when he said, "The fight in Spain is a fight between Fascism and democracy, and the Fianna Fáil Party has no use for Fascism"? Link that up with the President's "isms" last night, and connect those two things with the leading articles in the Government Party organ over the past six months. Does the President agree or disagree with those leading articles?
Comment on this
I spoke to-day already on that matter of the Press. Ministers are responsible for their ministerial statements, but neither collectively nor individually have they any responsibility in this House for leading articles in any paper.
Comment on this
I am not trying to put responsibility for the articles upon the President. I am putting a straight question to the President, which I am sure the President understands quite clearly. Does he or does he not agree with those articles? Do those articles reflect Government policy in this matter? That is a question I am entitled to put, and I suggest, Sir, that it is a question to which the people of this country are entitled to an answer. Fascism versus democracy! Listen to this, from what is regarded as the official organ of the Vatican, on the situation in Spain:
"Eleven bishops and over 15,000 priests have been killed—that is to say, from 40 to 50 per cent. of the Catholic clergy. In nine dioceses the assassination ratio is 80 per cent., and at Malaga 90 per cent. Almost all the churches have been burned down."
Fascism against democracy, and Fianna Fáil has no use for Fascism! We are entitled to be told by the head of this State, by the person who has authority to speak for the people of this country, where exactly the Government stands. The President's only contribution to this debate was the few words he said yesterday evening in introducing the Second Reading of this Bill—what has been described by the Irish Times as a very lucid statement. Does the President deny that the Caballero Government has murdered priests and bishops and nuns, and destroyed churches? Does the President, knowing that, believe for one moment that the people of this country desire to be associated even in the remotest way with the Government that is responsible for that? That is the net issue. All the word-splitting and all the undoubted ability of the President so to couch his phrases that it is utterly impossible afterwards to repeat them without being met by the President himself with the charge of misrepresentation, is not going to get away from that plain, straight issue. If the President believes, as he must believe, that he is not acting in accordance with the wishes of the Irish people, then I suggest to him that if he still believes in democracy, if he believes that he is head of a democratic State, he has no option but to accept the amendment which stands in the name of Deputy Professor O'Sullivan.
Comment on this
No; I am ready to go on, but I should like to hear something from the other side. The faith that is in them is a silent one!
Comment on this
I should like to say a few words on this Bill. Deputy Donnelly, of course, coming from the Six Counties, is a great champion of Catholic rights and Catholic principles in the North, and he is very safe here in the legislative assembly of the Irish Free State. As a very humble member of this House, having read this Bill and read the amendment, I should like to ask the President a straight question, and being fond of a person who gives a straight answer naturally I want no quibbling. I want to put this question to the President: What are the difficulties, if any, existing at the moment which prevent the President from accepting this very reasoned amendment set down on the Order Paper by Deputy O'Sullivan? In other words, would acceptance of this amendment interfere in any way with the provisions of this Bill? That is a straight question, and, if the President would answer it, it would enable him to have this Bill passed within an incredibly short space of time, and he would be able to prove to the world at large and to the Irish people in particular that he can rise to an occasion, and that he can see the point of view as put forward by the members of the Opposition. I do not speak on this Bill as a mere politican. I speak on it as an Irishman and a Christian, leaving out altogether the question of Catholicity. I want the President to tell me here and now, unequivocally and without hesitation, by what right is he spending the money of the Irish people in sending an accredited representative to the Government controlled by Caballero, who has been guilty of horrible crimes, of mauling our Catholic bishops and priests, and insulting nuns, more particularly that body of pure high-minded nuns known as the Little Sisters of the Poor, of which my eldest sister, I am proud to say, is a member; a Community that have devoted their lives to the care of the sick and the aged. Here we have the President of our Irish Free State sending a representative to that Government. Again, I ask the President is it essential that we should have that representative. Seeing that he finds it necessary to introduce this Act of non-intervention in the Spanish Civil War, surely it would be more consistent on his part, if, simultaneously with the introduction of that Bill, he would sever connections altogether with both parties if necessary in Spain. I think I have now put the position fairly squarely and honestly. I am not even asking the President to recognise or to send a representative to the Franco Government, although judging by his past declarations one would imagine that he would be the very first man in this country to recognise the Franco Government, and to send an accredited representative on behalf of the Irish people to that Government. That is all that is in this entire debate and that is all the answer required to be given. The President can have his Bill, if he has the moral courage to accept the very reasoned amendment of Professor O'Sullivan.
As I say, I am speaking here to-day, not as a politician and not as one of those narrow-minded men who wish to obtain political kudos by criticising the President's actions on this or any other Bill. I want to assure the President that there are many honest men in this country who may possibly disagree with him politically, but who, when the time comes, can give him credit for any good he has done, whether socially, internationally or otherwise, for the people of this country. I feel on this particular occasion as many thousands like me feel who are as good Irishmen as the man who waves the flag and shouts "Up the Republic", and when it comes to a question of defending the faith and defending this nation against all comers who are out for the destruction of law and order, I will not be in the back ranks. I say the President is in duty bound to accept this amendment unless he wants to make it clear to the peoples of the world that the Irish people are behind the Red Cabellero Government.
Speaking again as a non-politician, I could not help but almost weep when listening to the gloating there was over the references of Deputy MacDermot to General O'Duffy. If there is any man who has less cause to speak a good word of General O'Duffy, it is I, but, recognising that the men on those benches fought with him years ago, and seeing their attitude to him to-day during Deputy MacDermot's speech, I could not help but recall the words of, I think. Shakespeare:
"Blow, blow, thou winter wind,
Thou are not so unkind as man's ingratitude."
I could quote from the Official Records of this House tribute after tribute paid by Deputy MacDermot to General O'Duffy, and yet to-day we had the spectacle of men on the Fianna Fáil Benches, who looked upon him as a hero some years ago, gloating over the sordid references made to him in his absence by Deputy MacDermot to-day.
I speak as a humble member of this House and as one representing the honest workers of this country, and not the professional workers, the overwhelming mass of whom I know are in favour of severing all diplomatic relations with the present Government in Spain. If I were asked to put forward an argument as to whether the Caballero Government demands the support and co-operation of the people of Spain, in my own commonsense way, I simply apply this acid test, that no President and no Government, neither Mussolini, Hitler nor any of the other dictators referred to, could govern a country for one hour unless they had the support and co-operation of the decent, working classes of that country, and it is because Mussolini has that that he can govern Italy and because Caballero has not that that he cannot govern Spain. I make an analogy here with respect to the President's own position. If any small section of people in this country started a rebellion to-morrow, I guarantee that the present Government could subdue that rebellion inside seven or 14 days, for the simple reason that they would have the hearty co-operation, not alone of their own political friends, but of every man who stands for the preservation of law and order.
Therefore, there is no use in members of the Fianna Fáil Party and of the Labour Party speaking here, and outside, like the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, with their tongues in their cheeks, and saying that the present fight in Spain is a fight between Fascism and democracy. It is not a fight between "isms" to use the President's own words. Leaving out the question of Catholicity altogether, it is a fight between Christianity and having something approaching the state of affairs that at the moment exists in Soviet Russia. What is the use of trying to mislead the people? Again let me say here and now I am sorry the leader of the Labour Party is not here, and I am sorry that the members of the Labour Party are not here, that if I had a choice between Mussolini as leader, as President of the Irish Free State—if I had to make my choice as between him and the man representing Labour, that representative of sloppy sentimentalism in the form of cheap sloppy democracy, I would vote a thousand times for Mussolini. I am a trade unionist and a working man, and I know that under a man like Mussolini you will have protection and law and order and nothing will be taken by the waster from the thrifty section of the community. Therefore, I have no use for what I call this double dealing, this thing of speaking with your tongue in your cheek about Fascism. I fear nothing in laws. The best way to defy the law is to obey the law. As far as I am personally concerned that would be my policy—to obey any law passed by a Government that has been elected by the majority vote of the people. Therefore, I say there is no use in endeavouring to mislead the people of this country in trying to make out that the present fight in Spain is a fight between Fascism and democracy. It is nothing of the sort. Even without relying on the testimony of those who by virtue of the positions they occupy, and whose advice we are bound to take—without relying on that testimony, without even doubting for even one moment their word—I apply the acid test to the Caballero Government. Again I say that without the support of the Spanish people, General Franco could not start his rebellion in that unhappy country.
I would say in conclusion, as an ordinary humble man, that if the great powers that constitute Europe to-day were sincere in their declarations in the cause of peace it is not these non-intervention Bills they would introduce into their respective legislative assemblies. They would place on a higher plane the cause of humanity, and they would bear in mind the suffering of the unfortunate women and children who have no concern and no responsibility for the present conflict in Spain. If they were sincere, what they would have done long ago would be to come together and issue a note signed by every great power in Europe, a note to the Spanish people, to the warring sections there, and tell them: "It is certain that this will have to stop, or else we will go to Spain and stay there to protect the women and children and the bishops, priests and nuns until such time as the warring sections come down to common sense and elect a Government that will command the respect of the majority of the people of Spain." That is my view without equivocation and without putting any clauses or qualifications in the matter at all. If the people of these nations were sincere in their declarations of peace, that is what they would do.
The President may not listen to my appeal, but again I say it will not injure him one iota if he accepts the amendment put down on the Order Paper by Deputy O'Sulivan. Rather will it strengthen his position. After all, is it not time? Surely there should be some occasion when a measure such as this or any other measure of the kind should have the unanimous support of all Parties in this House. Are we going to continue eternally this wrangle from one side of this House to the other? Matters which after all are of little material importance to the people of this country are very important to the religious beliefs of the majority of the Irish people. I cannot for the life of me see why the President did not at the outset accept this amendment. If he did he could have his Bill straight away. So far as I can see, there is absolutely no objection to what is outlined in this Bill. The President can have his Bill and get contact with the other 25 nations, and I hope their combined efforts will be successful. That is all I have to say. They will have the unanimous good wishes of all right-minded people, not alone in this country, but in every country in the world, in helping to bring this unhappy fight in Spain to an end.
Comment on this
Are we to have no speech from the Government Benches at all? We want to hear the Government views.