We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Spanish Civil War (Non-Intervention) Bill, 1937—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 164–288 of 441. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Spanish Civil War (Non-Intervention) Bill, 1937
Enacted

No. 4 of 1937 ›

Is the Minister going to intervene at all?

Comment on this

Not now.

Comment on this

Well, non-intervention is catching on. On Wednesday of this week the President of the Executive Council, in a rather unusual way, proposed to add to the criminal code of this country, and he asked for indulgence in having this measure, as he called it an urgent measure, adopted, and he put himself to a certain extent in the hands of the Opposition Party by his pleas. He met with a willing response, and one would have thought, with the matter developing in that way and the response coming in the circumstances described, that the President would, at any rate, have kept to what he had in fact promised on that occasion. Certainly the House was given to understand that the measure which was introduced would have been in the hands of Deputies that evening. We got the Bill on Thursday morning. A long period passed on Thursday without this measure having been brought before the House by the Government. A measure with regard to the evasion of postage and a measure with regard to the control of imports, neither of which was expressly of any urgency, were dealt with until a late hour on yesterday. At that late hour the President indicated his view that this Bill, which adds effectively and seriously to the criminal code of this country should be passed into law by to-day. Objection being taken to that and some unwillingness expressed, the President agreed to hold over the final stages of this Bill until Wednesday of next week, but accompanied that by the threat, now carried into effect, that the machine would be brought into operation. There was not going to be any proper time allowed for the consideration of this measure.

Comment on this

May I draw attention to the fact that the whole Fianna Fáil Party have cleared out of the House, with the exception of one Minister on the Front Bench; that the whole of the Labour Party has also gone, and that Deputy MacDermot and others in favour of the Bill have gone.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present.

Comment on this

I indicated the steps the President followed in attempting to inform the House with regard to this measure, the way in which a promise was definitely given to the House in regard to the circulation of the measure and how that promise was broken. Of that, we have had no explanation. I indicated how the business was carried on yesterday until a latish hour when, according to the Irish Times, we had “one of the most effective speeches the President has ever delivered” in which, “the plain facts of the situation were set forth with lucidity and quiet force.” We shall see the gaps in the clarity of expression and in force and enthusiasm which have characterised the whole Fianna Fáil Party in their attitude towards this measure. The debate comes on to-day. One would have thought that, in respect of a measure which is going to add to the criminal code of the country, there might have been some appreciation of the fact that a debate running on such a subject at this time was not the best way to attract people who might be expected to know something about the matter—if, indeed, one can think that consideration is ever given to these matters by the Government. We are faced here, in the circumstances I have described, with a discussion on a measure which has a very serious impact, properly done through the criminal code, and which is really an encroachment upon the personal liberty of all the citizens. Personal liberty is a thing we set out to guarantee in our Constitution. We have protected it with the ordinary fortifications. We have given the ordinary gap—that it can be broached by passage of law. But one would have expected that when a constitutional right, about which so many countries are so concerned, was going to be impeded in the way this measure will impede it, if it is passed, some better explanation might have been given of what it was all about than that which we heard from the President yesterday.

Under this measure, a variety of offences is created. Moving from one part of this country to another—with an aim—is made an offence. It is even made an offence after this Act expires. A man may be tried and punished for an offence not merely committed but alleged to have been committed during the time the Act was in force. We set out further to give leave to appoint a number of countries to which the Act will apply and, after that, to make it an offence in this country for a national of any of these other countries to move from one part of it to another, if a certain aim or objective is proven in regard to that person. For these and other offences, a person, if convicted, is liable to a fine not exceeding £500 or a term of imprisonment not exceeding three years. The President yesterday told us with quiet force and with lucidity that

"The Governments represented on the Non-Intervention Committee decided towards the end of September to prohibit the export of arms and ammunition to Spain from their respective countries. It is common knowledge that the prohibition of exports has not been strictly adhered to."

The first statement we get from the President with regard to this Non-Intervention Committee is that they all solemnly agreed upon something, but did not observe the faith to which they had pledged themselves. The President went on to speak of "the considerable number of volunteers who have joined the armies of the two Parties in Spain," and he thought there was "a general desire in this country," if you please, "to see the present conflict in Spain brought to a speedy conclusion"—irrespective of who wins. I should like to see him parading that as a view to an audience of the public. The general desire of this country is "to see the present conflict in Spain brought to a speedy conclusion." It can be brought to a speedy conclusion in favour of one Party if we prohibit volunteers from going to the aid of the other Party. The President gets impartial and the phrase "one `ism' against another" issued later to represent the President's delicacy of feeling with regard to the causes of the conflict in Spain. He was careful to preserve silence, even though speaking with great lucidity, as to what his view on the conflict was or whether he had any desire other than to see the conflict "brought to a speedy conclusion." He then told us: "The presence of foreign volunteers in Spain greatly increased the danger of an international incident which might seriously affect the peace of Europe. The Governments represented on the Non-Intervention Committee, accordingly, agreed that they would prohibit their nationals from taking part in the civil war on either side. They also agreed to assist in the supervision of land and sea frontiers of Spain in order to prevent the exportation of arms and ammunition to that country." He thought that "the Spanish people must be allowed to work out for themselves the form of government most suited to their own ideals and opinions."

The President tells us that he is represented on a body which, last September, decided to prohibit the export of arms and ammunition to Spain and who found that that prohibition had not been adhered to. He now proposes, in common with those Governments represented on the Non-Intervention Committee, to agree further that there should be no sending of volunteers to either army in Spain. He does not tell us of any hope that this agreement will be adhered to any more than the last agreement. He does tell us that there is to be supervision of land and sea frontiers. The framework around that phrase is the President's expression of fear that an international conflict might develop in Europe. Has he anything to say to this House as to his hopes of the manner in which the supervision of the land and sea frontiers of Spain is to be carried out and whether it may not be a very fruitful cause of trouble and, in itself, lead to the emergence of that "international incident" which might very seriously disturb the peace of Europe. Although the President's speech is full of lucidity and quiet force, he has not told us of any of the doings of this committee. We learned, in an incidental remark from him at a later stage, that there were 27 nations represented on this committee. Presumably, we will get, at some stage before this debate closes, a statement of who these nations are. It would not be so interesting to ascertain who are on this committee as to find out who are the absentees. This committee has been meeting at least since August. This House, which is asked after a couple of days' debate to pass this measure enlarging the criminal code of the country, is not given one word of explanation by the President as to anything that happened at the committee —whether any series of questions was submitted to the Governments of Spain or whether any answers were given by them and whether any criticism was made upon these answers if and when they were received. The country might be interested to know whether our representative had to sit dumb during the course of all this discussion or whether he intervened, and with what effect.

The country would also like to know whether the representative of this country followed the lead of the Portuguese representative in expressing, with considerable clarity and great force, his view as to what were the issues at stake, and which of the two sides a preference should be indicated for. As far as I can discover from what has been made public, we are asked to join in a series of suggestions which were put forward at the Non-Intervention Committee, described as the Chairman's Sub-Committee. Who was on the Chairman's Sub-Committee? When did they present their report? What time for discussion was allowed to the Non-Intervention Committee, generally, to realise what were the proposals? What is the system likely to be effective in the attempt to carry them out? We do know that certain great powers—the United Kingdom, Belgium, Czecho-Slovakia, France, Germany, Italy, Sweden and the Soviet Republics—agreed to recommend a series of resolutions. One was:—

"From midnight, February 20-21, 1937, to extend the Non-Intervention Agreement to cover the recruitment in, the transit through, or the departure from their respective countries of persons of non-Spanish nationality proposing to proceed to Spain or the Spanish Dependencies for the purpose of taking service in the present war."

They agreed to furnish to the committee particulars regarding the measures which they proposed to take; that from a date they were going to adopt a system of supervision prepared by the technical advisory sub-committee, and that they were going to bring that scheme of supervision into operation as from a date early in March of this year.

What is the scheme of supervision? Remember, we are asked now to impose penalties upon young Irishmen who leave this country not properly armed with passports, having a certain objective. We are doing that because the Non-Intervention Committee agreed to accept certain proposals put forward to it by the sub-committee. We are asked to do that, and the only argument which relates to it is one that shows that the previous agreements of this Non-Intervention Committee were broken. What is the system of supervision that is to be put in force? Again, as far as we can glean from any information allowed to appear in the public Press, it appears to be this. There are two land frontiers to be watched, one on the French side and one through Gibraltar. Both countries have, apparently, agreed to accept some form of international policing. Portugal, with a long land frontier running alongside Spain, has refused to accept any policing of that frontier by international bodies. The frontier on the French side has been repeatedly crossed. Allegations have been made, and there hardly has been even the trouble taken of denying them, that volunteers in numbers have, with the leave and connivance of the French Government, passed through and crossed the French frontier into Spain. At a date when the export of arms and ammunition was supposed to be a binding covenant on that Government, it is alleged, and there is considerable evidence to show, that arms and ammunition were exported through and across the French frontier. That is now going to be policed.

There is a long seaboard to be guarded, and there again, as far as one can gather from any information that is given in the public Press, there is no agreement as to how control of this is to be effected. There are supposed to be two opposing plans. One is that the coast should be divided into sectors: that the French fleet should guard the sector at one spot, the Italian fleet at another spot, the English boats at another spot, and German ships at another spot. A further proposal with regard to control was that there would be one great mixed fleet of boats of all nationalities. Which is supposed to be the plan, and are other plans to be put up? Is there any guarantee of effective control, seeing that from the mouth of the President we learn that the people who previously agreed not to have arms and ammunition exported allowed arms and ammunition to go through to the rival forces in Spain? Without having any hint given to us as to the likelihood of effective control, we are asked here to make it a punishable offence for Irishmen to proceed with the aim of service in Spain.

I have asked as to whether our representative on this committee made any intervention when a request was sent, I think, in the early stages, on the initiative of the British Government to the two Governments in Spain asking for their approval or for their comments on the plan put forward. An answer came from General Franco, and in the committee on which we had a representative the Russian representative is stated to have "severely criticised the reply received from General Franco." He said that to the vast accumulation of the committee's documents General Franco's was one which he (the Russian representative) described as a compound of folly and of insolence. He went on to describe General Franco as "this pocket general," who was graciously pleased to tell them that he would continue to study the Non-Intervention Committee's communication. The Russian representative asked the committee to be grateful for General Franco's condescension. The General, who was described as a pocket general, had used this phrase. He expressed his indignation at the fact that the British Government did not seem to have grasped the greatness of the national Spanish movement, and continued relations with the so-called Government at Valencia. An obvious point there for an Irish representative if there was any comment to be made as between the two Governments to make it. We do not know that any intervention took place by our representative at that point. General Franco, in December of last year, put forward this as a matter that the committee might have devoted themselves to:—

"Are the Non-Intervention Committee's agents to concern themselves only with the entry of war material into Spain, or are they also to withdraw from the fronts the large stocks of arms bought with gold stolen from the Bank of Spain, and with the proceeds of other robberies from banks and private houses?"

In a later communication to the assembly, General Franco suggested that if there was going to be any supervision of arms and ammunition and any prohibition of volunteers, the committee might also go on to another point: it might pay special attention to aircraft crossing the frontier, and, further, it might also concern itself with finance and propaganda. We confine ourselves to volunteers. We are not concerned apparently as the financial aid sent to either of these two Governments; we are not concerned with what propaganda is used throughout the world on behalf of one Government against another, and apparently there has been no special attention paid to the very vulnerable point of aircraft. Despite all these imperfections, however, people might be disposed to say that this, because it was at any rate a first step towards keeping out of the conflict, was a valuable step to take. I think, however, that people who would say that—certainly people with the viewpoint of the majority in this country—would add to it an expression of regret that there was no indication from those who are in control here as to whether they think that it is an agreement likely to be honoured or an agreement likely to be broken; whether they think that control will be effective, and whether they think, the control of volunteers and arms being effective, there will be a further attempt to control financial aid and the aid—and a very definite aid it is— of propaganda on one side or the other.

Now, in this connection it is impossible, no matter how much the Government may desire to have it so, to disregard the fact that we are closely connected with a country which has very definite international engagements and which has, very definitely, valuable international possessions in an area which is adjacent to the area of the conflict. This country is very closely related to Great Britain, and if President de Valera were going to say here that, as well as having in the back of his mind this humanitarian idea of stopping the conflict in Spain, he also recognised that British influence in that part of the world was of importance and that British influence in that part of the world might be diminished if this conflict took a certain course, and if he were strong enough to come forward and tell us that, in the interests of the Irish people and in the interests of humanity in general, it was well worth while having British interests in that area upheld, we could listen to his arguments and weigh them up. But we are following—it may be without advertence, it may not be laid down as a line to be followed—but as a matter of fact we are following a British proposal, and that in itself is not to be criticised; and the reasons why Britain wants a certain line taken in this matter are easy to understand. It is quite easy to excuse, however much the humanitarian may deplore it, that a British viewpoint might be in favour of a particular issue to this conflict in Spain, even though that might be an issue that was dangerous from the outlook of the spread of certain doctrines. Britain has a viewpoint with regard to Gibraltar, and she has a viewpoint with regard to the coast opposite Gibraltar, and also she has a viewpoint with regard to the control of the Mediterranean—one that she must have—and to the emergence into greater power and influence of Germany and Italy in that sphere; and a viewpoint that Britain might hold, in favour of having a Red Government in Spain beaten, might be weakened by the thought that the beating of that Red Government in Spain could only be accomplished by the strengthening of two outside powers who have intervened in Spain and who are trying to put themselves in a more powerful position in the Mediterranean. One can understand their viewpoint just as one can understand the French viewpoint; but, remember, the proposals we are backing are of British and French origin, and we have accepted a certain relationship with Great Britain, and there is a suspicion that the newly-converted are trying to show they are of stronger faith than other people. That is a point that cannot be lost sight of. This country will be definitely paraded before the world, and naturally so paraded, as having a veering towards British policy in regard to this area, not entirely and completely founded upon Irish interests or Irish considerations, and that will loom all the larger in people's minds if there is no explanation of British policy when we stand to accept the policy in this Bill.

The amendment before the House asks that, coincident with this passing, there should be a definite cutting off of diplomatic relations with what is described as the Government at Valencia. That is being refused Deputy Belton has another amendment to the effect that the two sides in the conflict should be put, at any rate, on a basis of equality to the extent at least that we should have some relation or some attachment towards the Government at Burgos. The President, as usual, stands uncertainly and unsteadily between the two. We have a representative still accredited to Madrid—geographically at St. Jean de Luz, and also at a point geographically nearer to Burgos than to Valencia. That representative, presumably, is going to give aid to any of our unfortunate citizens who happen to find themselves in Spain. The only aid that any representative of ours could render to any nationals of ours who found themselves in Spain during the summer was to get the aid, and the powerful aid, of the British Diplomatic Office and of British gunboats, and whatever influence our representative might have been able to exert in securing the passage of our nationals out from Spain is going to be considerably lessened by the fact that he is now ensconced across the frontier in France and that he is not clearly accredited to one Government or the other—that he is in this halfway house, nearer to Burgos but further from Valencia, but accredited, as far as one can learn from what we have heard in this House, to the Red Government.

For the future, people need not bother themselves about what towns or what villages or what territory General Franco or his opponents occupy. All we have to do is to keep our eye on Mr. Kerney's movements, because, we presume, he will be moved nearer to the Pyrenees according as General Franco goes towards Madrid, shifting, like the Roman legions, backwards and forwards as the legions progress; and if the President's mind continues to move in the particular grove in which it is moving at the moment, we have only to watch Mr. Kerney's progress in order to see how the conflict goes in Spain. The nearer to Burgos the further from Valencia. There is no manly attitude in that. It may be, of course, that the majority in this country are entirely misled about the issues in Spain. It may be that the clergy, the poor man, the rich man, the educated man, the Hierarchy, are wrong. It may be, as I say, that we are all wrong, generally speaking, in this country in our attitude towards the present conflict in Spain. It may be that we are all the victims of the propaganda used with such effect by General Franco. If that is so, if we are all mistaken, cannot we be disabused of our errors? Is there nobody on the Government side to tell us what is the real issue in Spain? We want no fending off on this question. There is a responsibility on people who put themselves forward for responsible positions, and who secure them, to declare, in their representative capacity, what they know. They have despatches and communications and documents that none of the rest of us have, and surely, in an important matter of this kind, they are bound to put before the representative House of the nation what are the facts in regard to Spain. Instead of that, or of any attempt to do that, what do we find?

Deputy MacDermot intervened in this debate to-day, and, however much I may regret the silence of the Fianna Fáil Party, their silence does them credit in comparison to the uncouthness of Deputy MacDermot in his intervention in this debate. However, we cannot just entirely separate Deputy MacDermot from the Government. I think it is without precedent that a Minister for External Affairs, speaking in this House, should indicate that the correct attitude under international law had been accurately and precisely stated by a Deputy on a question on the preceding day. That is the position the President adopted in regard to Deputy MacDermot. There is a phrase common in America which expresses a man as being the "fall guy" from time to time. Deputy MacDermot, apparently, has become the "fall guy" for the Government. He can be held up as the man who correctly expresses something which they do not want directly to express themselves. They can adopt him as the sort of person who would paraphrase best all the intricacies of the international law on a particular subject.

The Deputy tells us that this Party in this matter is trying to cash in, electorally, on Christianity. In any event, this Party, over the years when Deputy MacDermot was exhausting his crusading efforts in other directions, were trying to lodge something to their credit in regard to Christianity and they believe that they have something upon which they can now draw in that matter. Deputy MacDermot may feel that any attempt on his part to cash in on that matter may result in the ordinary "return to drawer". The Deputy knows very little about cashing in on anything in this country. The Deputy has made an attempt to get credit from a variety of sources politically and has failed generally. He has one useful occupation at the moment. He has become, what I can only describe as the sandwich-board man of the Government, a man who can be sent round with their placards, a man who bears round their propaganda and again he gets rather more kicks than halfpence from the Irish Press for it. He thinks fit to intervene in this debate and to characterise this Party —and when he is characterising this Party in this way, remember he is characterising the majority of the people in this matter and characterising the attitude of the Hierarchy in this matter—as trying to cash in on Christianity. We are in good company to start with and we are in even better company since we have been deprived of Deputy MacDermot's services.

The Deputy is accepted by the Government as the man who indicates properly what is the international law on this matter. Can we consider very briefly now what is the reaction of international law at all in this matter? There is no precise point laid down at which a Government may be recognised. The ordinary viewpoint which is held is this, that when, in the mind of an outside Government, the persons purporting to become the Government have achieved de facto jurisdiction, then they are entitled to be recognised. Can anybody judging the conflict in Spain either by extent of territory held, by numbers, by anything that has to do with the enlargment of sway over the country, say that the odds are not definitely in favour of one side and that not the side to which we are accredited at the moment. Are we to take the test of elections? Are we to look upon one side as folk who have risen in rebellion against the elected Government? That might have been an issue three or four months ago but can anybody say that the people who now hold sway under Caballero have any link or any tie whatever with an election or that could in any way claim to have been set up as a Government as the result of the election machine working? Are not the people who are now in power in Valencia, folk who took over, and took over by strength, from another Government who had succeeded themselves on the weakening of the lot who paraded themselves as the folk emerging from the throes of an election? If the question of an election has to be brought into this, neither party has a title but General Franco has as good a title as the other people have.

We are told, according to the President, that, whatever we may think about this conflict in Spain those who are in Spain recognise it or that, at least, most of them recognise it as a fight of one "ism" as against another. Where does the President get his evidence of that? Can the President quote any person of repute, or any number of persons of repute, who will say that in recent months that is the situation in Spain? Apart from that, we are not passing this Bill on what, the President tells us in a vague way, most of the people engaged in combat in Spain regard the conflict as being for. We are asked to prohibit Irishmen from taking part in a certain fight. Is there any appreciation on the President's part that, though the Irish people may be wrong, the Irish people do not regard the struggle in Spain as, what he thinks lightly, is one ideology against another, one "ism" against another? If this phrase was an evasion, the usual evasion, one could understand it. If by saying that it was one "ism" against another "ism" he meant that the conflict is recognised as one between religion and irreligion, between God and the absence of God, between atheism and something that appertains to the recognition of God—if that is what he meant by "ism" against "ism," then it is true, but that is not the way in which the remark was made. It was not to convey that meaning to the people that the phrase was used. It was to convey that this is a squabble between the Russians on one side aided, to some extent, by the French, and the Italians and the Germans on the other side.

The President has tried to suggest that political philosophy was the source of the trouble in Spain, not the viewpoint of Christianity against the negation of Christianity. The President tries to make it out as a struggle of one political philosophy against another political philosophy. Has he ever heard that General Franco has, again and again, expressed himself as vehemently against Fascism as against Communism? I think he is recognised as the leader of one group at the moment and that his personal viewpoint may be of considerable value if his forces emerge victorious. That personal viewpoint has been expressed as being hostile to Fascism equally with Communism. He has not expressed himself in any ambiguous way in regard to any other matters in conflict in Spain. He has definitely said that it is a struggle for religion against irreligion, that it is against atheism, that it is against that side of Communism which expresses itself in the negation of Christianity. There is no doubt whatever about that. Deputy Belton read at much length yesterday extracts from sources at which we cannot sneer or laugh away. These extracts show, beyond any possibility of doubt, that as far as certain of the religious in Spain are concerned, so far as the majority of the religious in Spain are concerned, they do not regard this as a conflict between political philosophies. There is a far deeper thing at issue, a thing that cuts deeper into the life of the people. These extracts show a very definite appreciation of the fact that one side is fighting for a thing that everybody, who has any belief in any type of religion must value. On the other side there are people who would like to see atheism, the negation of religion, something that is anti-Christian not merely in Spain, but would also like to see that country made a breeding ground, as Russia itself is a breeding ground, from which these doctrines might spread out right through the world.

Now, that is the Spanish viewpoint put up in the casual phrase used by the President here, without one piece of documentation to support it—as far as the people in Spain are concerned, it is one "ism" against another. The extracts that Deputy Belton used in his speech are a definite refutation, until the President brings forward something of a documentary type, not his view, as to what the people in Spain think. The President must answer what Deputy Belton read here at such length, read with such cogency. That document itself, if there was nothing else to be brought into this debate, indicated that in Spain, amongst the combatants, there is not held the view the President here said there was.

Apart from that, have we no viewpoint ourselves? I could give thousands of quotations as to what is thought in this country of the struggle in Spain. Let me go to the highest authority that can be got in this country. His Holiness the Pope addressed a group of Spanish refugees in mid-October of last year. One may say that the language used with regard to this conflict has been exaggerated. One may say that imagination often runs riot and that people even bear testimony to things they have not seen, things that are only the product of their imaginations; but there is no doubt that in these matters the Vatican is very experienced—the Vatican is very experienced in wars and stories of wars. These matters reported to the Vatican are examined and sifted with scrupulous care before a person in the position of His Holiness would think fit to address a group of people in the way in which he did.

The cynic here and abroad may deride these stories and allude to all the fantastic nonsense that was talked in the Great War—the tales of bestiality that the ordinary newspaper was filled with and most of which were afterwards disproved. But from people who visited the Vatican, fresh from the conflict, the Pope derived certain information and these are the words of a responsible person. He spoke in this way:

"The highest members of the sacred clergy, bishops and priests, consecrated virgins, the laity of every class and condition, venerable grey hairs and fair flowers of youth, sacred and solemn tombs have been assaulted, violated, destroyed in the most ruthless and barbarous ways in an unbridled, unparalleled, confusion of forces so savage and so cruel as to have been thought utterly impossible for human dignity let alone for human nature even the most debased."

These words we cannot sneer at; we cannot say that is propaganda; we cannot say these words would be casually uttered and that a person in that position would address these refugees, and through them the world, without having weighed every word, every epithet, and there are many in that scarifying address with regard to that situation. If we read that, and read it with understanding and some belief, we must be put on the alert against people who say "Ah, as regards the war in Spain, it is one `ism' against another."

It is not necessary to tire the House with a multitude of these things. The Cardinal in this country, speaking in September, talked about the vital issues that were at stake in the war in Spain. One of the phrases was "The people's fight for Christianity," and he criticised, as he was bound to criticise, the attitude of this State in regard to that conflict. In connection with the recent pastorals read in churches here, I think it was correctly phrased in this House last night that the keynote of them all was that Communism was a menace, not merely abroad, but in this country. The Cardinal, I think it was, who wound up an appeal on that matter to the people by asking them to see that this thing would not be tolerated in our midst.

But, contrary to the views of the hierarchy, all of them, contrary to what the Cardinal says in regard to this country, Deputy MacDermot is of opinion that there is no Communism here and the man responsible for putting it out is the President. If one is inclined, one can go back to a debate here on the introduction of the amending Bill connected with Article 2A of the Constitution, in October, 1931. The President's views, expressed from this side of the House then, was that Communism at that time was a negligible force in the country. The President himself put that on record and adduced as evidence, not evidence that I would regard as very solid, but adduced as evidence the small number of votes polled by people who paraded themselves openly and clearly as Communists. He did not confine himself entirely to that. He delivered in this House in October, 1931, his view that Communism was almost non-existent. Deputy MacDermot thinks it has been completely exorcised from the State since by the beneficent attitude of the President.

The clergy do not think so. They use words that might be pondered a little more closely by Deputy MacDermot. They have said that the worst feature of Communism is its insidiousness; certain people imbibe it without knowing what it is. Their view is surely more acceptable than that of a man who can pass through this country on his infrequent sojourns here and not really understand what is going on, who will not even lend an ear to people who, for their sins, have got to spend their time in the country and who may be affected by whatever vices and virtues spring up here. One could go through a list of statements from people in important positions, but if one can confine one's attention only to the statements made by the clergy, by the bishops, one cannot say that the menace of Communism is completely absent from this country and one cannot say, if the hierarchy in this country represent the people, that the Spanish conflict is regarded as a matter of one political philosophy against another.

It may be that we are all wrong in that: it may be that we as a body are trying to cash in electorally on Christianity and that the bishops, for some other reason, are trying to befuddle their flocks with exaggerated statements about the menace of Communism in this country, and the menace the Spanish conflict is to Christianity and the world. If there is any information in the President's possession which could put us right, why could not we get it on this Bill?

The only point in a speech of great lucidity and quiet force by the President was that his view, without the slightest bit of documentation, was that whatever we may think about it, the majority of people in Spain regard this as a conflict of one "ism" against another. If that is the viewpoint, not merely is this non-intervention Bill one that we should pass, but it is one that should have been passed when the first proposal was mooted in regard to it. We should have jumped to this; we should have said it was foolish to allow Irishmen who might think they were indulging in a religious crusade to be fooled and we were not going to permit them to become the tools of Moscow or Rome; neither Fascism nor Communism would use these young people.

If the Bill had been introduced earlier, with some documentation by the President to show that men were being deluded, or that they were deluded even by the clergy, that it was more than one political philosophy against another, we should have done what France did and passed this in anticipation and said it will be brought into force when the rest of the European nations give effect to it. We have delayed until we are now rushing at it. We are rushing at it without any viewpoint being expressed by the President other than the one, that as far as the people of Spain are concerned it is one political philosophy against another. Remember, if that was alone the position, one might not pay so much attention to it, but people have harked back to what the Parliamentary Secretary (Deputy Flinn) said at Galway. He had his mind clear in these days. It was Fascism against democracy. I think there can be no doubt as to which side is Fascist after his declaration of Fascist in this controversy. So that democracy means Caballero. That was Deputy Flinn's placing of the positions in the summer-time.

The organ controlled by the Government set out on one occasion to explain the true position in Spain to its readers. Here are the words used: "That country is now divided into two camps in which the most unrestrained passions and the most intense hatreds prevail." There we have what prevails in that Party. The Government organ can speak of two camps, one blackened equally with the other, and of the prevalence of unrestrained passions and of the most intense hatreds. Deputy Flinn classes Caballero as the democrat opposed by the Fascist Franco. The President tells us that as far as the combatants generally are concerned it is "ism" against "ism." In these circumstances why should we withdraw the ambassador? There is no reason. But that is not the viewpoint of the Irish people. Deputy Belton, I think, has proved that it is not the viewpoint of the Spanish people. The net point in this is, should we at this moment ask the Irish people, on the evidence we have before us, to accept the viewpoint that it is just a bit of a dog-fight, both in the wrong, something that should be brought to an issue as speedily as possible?

When there was trouble in this country there was an amount of propaganda used to try to get people to understand that the situation developing here was some sort of a dog-fight. Efforts were used here to try to get nations outside to take a clear view of the situation. We would have been horrified and dismayed if in the height of these circumstances the representative of a nation that we had thought to be in favour of freedom of opinion, freedom of political view and freedom of religious view said: "As far as the conflict between England and Ireland is concerned, it is one party against another."

Comment on this

That is a bit farfetched.

Comment on this

It is not farfetched. Did we think it was one party against another? We did not. Do the Spaniards think it is one political philosophy against another? Are the Irish people not to have a viewpoint as to whether the Spanish people think that? Is it to be the viewpoint put by the President in this phrase? If the Irish people do not accept that as a true statement of the position, is there not some action required when we are intervening in this way? We are going to make it a criminal offence for Irishmen to join either party. We have moved the pawn nearer to Burgos than Valencia. He is still accredited to the Red Government. Anywhere this action of ours is read of, there can be only one construction put on the situation as we leave it, and that is that the President convinced the House, as far as Spain was concerned, that there was no question of religion at stake, there was no question of Catholicity. There was no question of Christianity against all-comers of a non-Christian type; the President convinced his followers that in Spain they were merely fighting out a cruel warfare about an academic distinction as between political philosophies and, in these circumstances, he found it easy to convince the House that there was no necessity to take any action of the type that Deputy Belton wants, the recognition of both Governments, nor a necessity to take any action of the type we want—the denial before the world of any implication there might appear to be from the fact that we still recognise one Government only in Spain. Neither on the ground of international law, accurately phrased by Deputy MacDermot, nor on the ground of basing ourselves on the people, could we be criticised in any country for dropping our representation with the Madrid Government at present. The greatest purist with regard to international law could not find cause for complaint with that. Against all that there is undoubtedly this immense wave of opinion in this country, which may be wrong, but which prevails at present, that in Spain there is a definite, fundamental conflict going on and there is one Government placed there as being against Christianity and there is one Government placed as for it. We are going to prevent our people fighting there, but we keep our representative with the Government that is not Christian.

Comment on this

I regret the lines upon which this debate was originally launched, particularly by Deputy Belton. We were treated last night to a discourse of over an hour which was continued to-day and lasted in all something like 2½ hours. I regret to say that it was more or less a bitter harangue directed in a kind of composite way to a personal attack on the President and, not only that, but there was very regrettable use made of documents that should not have been made. Deputy MacDermot pointed out to the House to-day that because my colleague, Deputy Mrs. Concannon and myself—I think it was we who were meant—happened to enjoy some of the efforts of Deputy Belton to get round some Spanish pronunciations, we were immediately daubed with the red brush and called pure firebrand Communists. I do not accept that for a moment from Deputy Belton, and I do not think anybody in this House accepts it. Any little thing helps in the case that Deputy Belton was trying to build up. I am perfectly convinced that there is not to-day, that there never was, and that while Ireland is Ireland, populated by the types of individuals in it at the present moment, there need be no fear or dread of the ills of Communism here. After all, we have struck more or less on evil days. Here is a little country which has suffered for and maintained its faith, if one wants to put it like that, against many and greater difficulties than are likely to ensue in future. To our pride we have had all through the ages guardians who advised us in these matters, men who were ordained for that purpose, the Hierarchy and the clergy. To-day, according to Deputy Belton who has placed himself at the head of a movement called the Christian Front——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not deal with that movement on this motion.

Comment on this

At any rate something had to be done, and the Deputy made his effort here. No cause and no movement ever gained the slightest advantage by misrepresentation or by false interpretation of any documents. I regret that very much, as I think it occurred here once before, when a church document was read on a famous debate. I regret the introduction of such documents in Parliamentary debates, because I believe that a bishop's pastoral to his flock is a sacred document, addressed to his people; it is a document, above all other things the sanctity of which raises it above the ordinary hurly-burly of politics and political friction. For that reason I regret that it should have been used as it was used here last night, and put into the phraseology that appears in the newspapers, that President de Valera had practically told the Irish people, by the introduction of this Bill, that the pastoral letter of the Cardinal Primate of Spain was a lie. I regret that language of that kind should be used in an Assembly like this. I regret that a document like a bishop's pastoral should be used in such a way or brought up in debate in the manner it was brought up last night. As to any Deputy on this side of the House having the slightest sympathy with some of the things that have occurred in Spain, they have not. No one knows that better than those who spoke from the opposite benches. Instead of Deputy Belton's descriptions being made a laughing stock of, we regret that the clergy had to flee from Madrid. We regret that very much, and we condemn it. If all the information and all the reports from Spain are true, nobody condemns the butcheries and church burnings more than the members of this Party. At the same time, while German volunteers, Italian volunteers, French aid and other countries are taking different sides in Spain; while aeroplanes and tanks are being used, and bombs being dropped on cities like Madrid and Barcelona; while women and children are being slaughtered, this Bill, in my opinion, is fundamental and is intended to prevent the young men of this country going out there to be made cock-shots of for whatever "ites" or "isms" are involved, because there must be issues in addition to those which were mentioned by Deputy McGilligan and other speakers.

After all, there should be some sense of proportion when an amendment such as Deputy Belton's is moved. He wants recognition of General Franco's Government. I can understand Deputy O'Sullivan's amendment much better, that our ambassador should be withdrawn from Spain or brought home. To some extent that is understandable. The other proposal is less understandable, that this Government should immediately recognise General Franco's Government. It is not definitely established, and for that reason I say there ought to be some sense of proportion and some example from people who introduce subjects of this kind. I have respect certainly for established government. I have respect for a Government elected by the majority of the people, but if I introduced an amendment such as Deputy Belton's, I should not like to leave it in the power of other Deputies to taunt me with this fact, that in my own country, when ordered government was established, I had a record against me of being fined £25 before the Military Tribunal following an attempt to sabotage my own Government by anarchy, chaos, and attacks on State property. There should be a sense of proportion in all these things, and when we hear talk of recognition of General Franco's Government in Spain we should relate that to the sense of respect, the sense of esteem and of obedience that we have for the native Government under which we live in the country that we call our own.

I do not want to discuss in detail the rights and wrongs of matters that were raised during the debate. One thing in this Bill fundamentally concerns us and that is to see that this country of ours should not, so far as is humanly possible, take any part, or identify itself with the civil war at present being waged in Spain. I see nothing wrong in that. I subscribe to the views that were expressed by another Deputy, who spoke of how the big nations in Europe are arming. Germany is spending every cent she can get her fingers on on guns, armaments and munitions, while a Bill to provide £1,500,000,000 for armaments was introduced recently in the British Parliament. It is the same story in France and everywhere in Europe. What is all the rearmament for? I hope that another war is far off but I am afraid that some day there will be an outburst on the Continent of Europe and if that catastrophe should take place it would end civilisation as we know it. I believe in peace, and it is in the interest of peace I am supporting this Bill. I would not want any other reason for doing so, because we know enough of what happened in the last big war, and how countless numbers of young men who left this and other countries perished. For what? We see the position that has been reached in European politics. If this small contribution of ours will only go one inch towards securing peace in Europe, or contributing to an atmosphere of peace, notwithstanding all the speeches, notwithstanding all the little kudos that may be adopted by those opposing this Bill, I say that the President has done his duty, and that later, when this situation has passed, the President will be able to point to the action he took as one that was in the interests of humanity and, as Deputy McGilligan said, in the interests of establishing peace everywhere. After all the life of man is a short one. I could quite understand anybody reading several of the letters of the bishops that have been published feeling rather acutely on this question. I read many of the bishops' Lenten pastorals. Why should not the state of affairs in Spain be the keynote of these pastorals? Is there one member of the Irish Hierarchy who would desire that acts should take place that would lead to blood being spilled or that there should be another conflagration like the last war? There is not one.

After all, we must approach this matter as it has been approached by the bishops of every country. The head of a flock approaches not a particular sect or class or individual in that flock. The bishop over a diocese approaches the entire diocese. He approaches them all, and I was always taught and led to believe that the farther away an individual was from the right path the greater the effort which would be made by the guardian of that flock to try to bring him back to the right path again. No matter how great a criminal might be there was always in those pastoral letters— if they were properly interpreted; if they were not interpreted from a political angle, and not interpreted having at the back of our minds the fact that there is a general election coming on —a genuine note of appeal to those who may not be on lines that are right, on lines that are religious, to try and reform and do some good before the time had passed when it was possible to do that good.

I want to refer to an article which appeared in the Sunday Express. I am not going to quote it in this House. Unfortunately I did not think that the debate would have developed on those lines, but if anybody looks up the files of the Sunday Express he will find an article on General Franco, written a short time after the war broke out. I was amazed to read this article, and I carefully followed that paper—there are some interesting articles in the Sunday edition of that paper—to see if there would be any repetition of this. One of the things boasted about the monarchy in Spain was that the King—King Alphonso, who abdicated —deserved better of that country, because he had succeeded in keeping Spain out of the big war. As a result of that, there were people who amassed fortunes, and there was one particular man about whom this article was written who became a multi-millionaire. Early in the conflict he retired to France or some other place. This multi-millionaire, as far as I could make out from the article, gave a certain amount of the finance which enables General Franco to carry on the present operations. I do not think that this gentleman, who is so described in that article I am referring to, can be pointed out as a pillar of Christianity in Europe or anywhere else. I am only mentioning this by way of putting, as it were, some view of the case that has not yet been put. I do not believe they are all saints in Spain, nor do I believe that they are all sinners in Spain. We are not all saints and we are not all sinners here in Ireland. While human nature is human nature there will be that blend of good and bad in every country in the world, and there will be things done by people who are more or less irresponsible. There is a tendency in the human mind, more highly developed in some people than in others, towards crime. It does take an effort at all times and it does take a strong hand at all times to deal with those people who have those criminal tendencies. Churches were burned in Spain? Of course they were. Bishops were murdered in Spain. Of course they were; everybody knows that now. Nobody regrets that more than we do here, and it has practically been suggested by the mover of the second amendment that we look on and smile and sneer at those things——

Comment on this

Which you do.

Comment on this

——and that our whole sympathies go to the people who are guilty of those crimes.

Comment on this

Yes, precisely.

Comment on this

The Deputy himself does not believe that for a moment.

Comment on this

I do. I will prove it to you.

Comment on this

The Deputy himself does not believe that for a moment.

Comment on this

I do—on your own declarations.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

The two of us cannot address the House together. At any rate, I am sorry if that is the view of the Deputy. If there was any proof I could give which would convince him, I would be only too glad to do so, but if a person has already made up his mind that you are a criminal it would take a very strong perfume and odour of sanctity to make you appear a saint in the eyes of that person. However, much of those matters may be dispensed with. I do want to refer to the document which I referred to in the early part of my remarks—that is, the Cardinal Primate's pastoral. I regret that that was introduced in the way it was introduced last night, and I regret that the words in the Independent of to-day——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Better leave the newspapers out of it. The newspapers should be allowed to conduct their controversies outside this House.

Comment on this

But every other Deputy who quoted a newspaper here to-day gave the name and the date. This is the report of last night's meeting.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may refer to the report of last night's debate.

Comment on this

Do not forget the Daily Express. Quote your friendly English paper.

Comment on this

At any rate I do regret that that pastoral was used and I am glad the Deputy is here now. I regret that he put the interpretation on it which he did put on it. To make a speech in this House and to attack the President is one thing. That is justifiable enough in ordinary politics, but when in the daily press the following day, and all the papers have the same report of the speech, the President is made to appear as trying to make the statement in the letter issued by the Cardinal Primate of Spain a lie, it is going a bit too far.

Comment on this

You make it true, will you?

Comment on this

When we come to that stage, and when we can put no other interpretation on documents of that kind, it is pretty well nearly time to stop talking about them altogether. These are not ordinary documents at all. They are meant for everybody and not for any particular sect or class or type, and, as I said before, there always is that note of appeal in these documents to the members of the flock to which they are addressed; and there is no member of any hierarchy, no eminent ecclesiastic, who writes a pastoral letter who has not in his mind when penning such a document the fact that it is intended to do good and that it applies to the community as a whole. They will condemn wrong where wrong is done, and try to put right the doing of wrong if they possibly can. That is my interpretation of pastorals; that is my interpretation of letters such as have been quoted in this House. I would certainly take advantage of and use quotations in support of a case in so far as they would help me, but I would refuse, in this House or outside it, to use a letter in the way Deputy Belton used this letter last night.

Comment on this

Is a pastoral not as good evidence as the Daily Express.

Comment on this

I am not saying anything else, but I do object to special personal interpretations put upon these pastoral letters and the analogy made between these letters and the action of the President in bringing in this Bill and characterising his conduct as such that it is giving the lie direct to the Cardinal Primate of Spain.

Comment on this

Is the Cardinal Primate of Spain not a good witness of what is going on in Spain. Can he not be quoted?

Comment on this

He can, but what about the analogy?

Comment on this

Let us not be disturbed by what papers outside say.

Comment on this

What about the personal interpretation? That is what I object to.

Comment on this

I put no interpretation upon it—I merely read it.

Comment on this

And it gives evidence.

Comment on this

The interpretation was given when the Deputy, after reading extracts from the documents, was attempting to sum up. He said that we had arrived at the stage when the President of the Executive Council, the first citizen of the State, was giving the lie direct to the Cardinal Primate of Spain by the introduction of this Bill.

Comment on this

Is he not in direct conflict with the Cardinal Primate?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

I am sorry; I thought you liked interruptions.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair does not.

Comment on this

I certainly do at times, but I hope the Deputy who made this speech understands and appreciates the point I am making.

Comment on this

But you cannot make a point. That is your whole trouble.

Comment on this

I have made this point, and I want to make it perfectly clear, that if there was any danger to the Church in this State, if there was any danger to the Faith, if it came to an issue between Christ and anti-Christ, or to a religious issue, where the Faith would be at stake, there is none of the men on these benches who would not be as quick to respond to the call for protection for the Church as Deputy Belton or any other Deputy on that side, and well the Deputy knows it. I know he did fly to the flag on one occasion. I made a slight error here once, and I apologise here for it now. I gave the Deputy credit on one occasion, and he accepted it under false pretences, for fighting for this country in the G.P.O. He was never in it in his life except to post a letter. I apologise for ever having said it, but, forgetting about all that, these are my views in supporting this Bill. It is introduced in the interests of peace.

Comment on this

What about the amendment?

Comment on this

This country is better out of the Spanish war than in it——

Comment on this

We are all agreed on that. What about the amendment?

Comment on this

If Deputy McGilligan were Minister for External Affairs, there is no one would take quicker or keener action to adopt the same attitude as the President adopts in this matter.

Comment on this

Plus the withdrawal of the ambassador.

Comment on this

If Deputy Donnelly is as well informed on every matter——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney.

Comment on this

But, Sir, he should not have been allowed to go away entirely from his subject to fling an insult across the floor.

Comment on this

I wish to congratulate Deputy Donnelly, though I am afraid I must pay him in a way a rather back-hand compliment. He, of all those timid little gentlemen in the Front Bench, who sit dumb and mute during a discussion—the Minister for Justice sitting there as long as he has to-day, with the Minister for Education and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs coming in, and with even the short incursion we had from the Minister for Finance—is the only one who has the courage to address the House on behalf of this Bill. I congratulate Deputy Donnelly. It seems to me that Deputy Donnelly has at least the manliness that the other members of the Fianna Fáil Party, and especially its Front Bench and its Leader, distinctly lack. While I pay that compliment to him, and while I admire his courage in addressing the House in favour of this Bill, I am afraid I cannot be entirely complimentary to him in the remarks I have to make to the House. I wish that when Deputy Donnelly had the courage to address this House, he would have had the courage also to express his own views clearly and definitely, and that, instead of the non-committal speech he made, we would have had a clear statement from him as to where his sympathies lie in respect of this war in Spain.

Comment on this

I know where they lie.

Comment on this

I should have liked to hear from him something which is relevant to the two amendments and I should have liked to hear whether he thinks it right and proper that the Government, showing partiality to one side in this Spanish war, should keep its representative accredited to the Red Government in Spain and have no representative with the anti-Red Government at Burgos. That was a matter upon which Deputy Donnelly was unfortunately very silent, as the Deputy is silent upon most things that count. He did indeed make an attack upon Deputy Belton's speech, and upon him personally, because he had referred to the Pastoral of the Cardinal Archbishop of Burgos, the Primate of Spain, because, he says, these Pastorals are meant entirely for the flock to which they are addressed and that the rest of the world should pass them over with what he would rather regard, I think, as silent contempt, and certainly not use them as sources of information. Where can we get a better source of information? How can we go to any more impartial source, or any source on which we can place greater reliance, than a statement by the Cardinal Primate of Spain?

It is not a mere Pastoral and he is not merely the Primate of Spain, nor is he merely the Archbishop of Burgos. He is more than that. He is a Prince of the Catholic Church because he is a Cardinal, and, more than that, he is the accredited representative of the Vatican with the Burgos Government. He is speaking much more than as a Cardinal or a bishop speaking to his flock. He is the head of the Church in Spain, speaking, not merely to his flock, but telling the whole world the things that are being done in Spain to the Catholics of Spain, and especially to the priests and nuns and religious communities in Spain. It is in that capacity that the Cardinal Archbishop of Burgos speaks, not merely to his flock, but to the world, and because he is speaking to his flock and to the world, he is taken by Deputy Belton as being the very best authority that we in this country can get. Is Deputy Belton to be told by Deputy Donnelly that it is improper and wrong to cite him? Where are we going to get better authority?

This is a grave matter. This Bill is no trifling Bill and we must consider that it will be looked at from a double angle. It will be looked upon as to how it affects our people abroad, and it will be looked upon and considered by our people at home. The people abroad want to know how the Government stand in this matter. The people at home want to know how the Government stand in this matter. Personally, although it is rather a matter of deduction, I have very little doubt where President de Valera stands, and where the Fianna Fáil Party stands, and I personally have very little doubt as to where the sympathies of President de Valera and the Fianna Fáil Party lie. But I have no respect for the Party, and especially for the Party leader—and even Deputy Donnelly loses a little of the respect I had for him—who will not openly and boldly tell the country where their sympathies lie. I hope Deputy Donnelly is at variance with the bulk of his Party in this matter. I take the statement of the President yesterday and his remarks as to the Spanish people being only interested in "isms." and as to their regarding the battle between Catholicism and Communism as a mere battle of "isms." I think I draw a fair conclusion from that when I see repeatedly the attitude taken up by the Irish Press upon this matter. When Deputy Belton, in his, to my mind—and I differ from Deputy Donnelly in this—extremely well documented speech, can produce a photograph of a member of the Executive Council taken with an emissary of the Red Government of Spain sent to this country, and when I see the speech of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance which has been quoted here already, I find very little difficulty in coming to the conclusion that the sympathies of the Fianna Fáil Party are entirely with the Red Government in Spain.

Comment on this

Sticking out.

Comment on this

If they are not, if their sympathies are with General Franco, let me be put right at once, but it seems to me that there is no reason on God's earth, if their sympathies are against the Red Government and with General Franco and his troops, why the President should dodge and hesitate and shift in the way he has been doing here when questioned on this matter on two consecutive days. I do not see why there cannot be a very plain, simple statement on that fact from the Government Benches. Why should not there have been such a statement? I do not see why Deputy Flinn—the only member of the Government who has spoken clearly and definitely upon this matter, who though he may hold a subordinate office in the Administration is still a member of it—has never been disowned by a member of the Executive Council. Why not? Why not, unless he spoke the voice of the members of the Executive Council? It seems to me, as I have said, abundantly clear that the sympathies of the Fianna Fáil Party and the sympathies of the Executive Council are with the Red Government in Spain, but that they do not let their sympathies be known because they think it impolitic. It is "like the cat in the adage letting I dare not wait upon I will." The Government know perfectly well that it would be a most impolitic thing for them to announce that their sympathies are with the Reds in Spain. Therefore, they dodge and they prevaricate.

This debate will have done some tremendous good, even though the amendment moved be not carried. It will have done tremendous good by the arguments we have introduced and the strength of the feeling that each and every Party knows this question has aroused in the country. The Fianna Fáil Party are now forced and compelled to turn their coats and forced and compelled without any real sympathy but a sense of policy to express their lip sympathy with the Government of General Franco. Let them express that sympathy in a practical way, as is suggested in Deputy O'Sullivan's amendment. Remember this is not a small matter. I myself and I suppose every member of this House, is receiving propagandist documents from the Red Government of Spain. I suppose we are all receiving such documents. At any rate, I get them and they are things to me of a most offensive nature. Why is it worth the while of these gentlemen to do this propagandist work? I am sure Deputy Donnelly receives these propagandist notes also. Does he ask himself why is it worth their while to do this propagandist work? It is because they want to attach world opinion to their side. They want to convert the people of this country to their side. They think that world opinion is valuable to them. We all know it is valuable to them. It is on this terrible crash in Spain that the future of Christendom is being fought and it is of the greatest value to the combatants that there should be a clear expression of world opinion behind them. The side with the largest volume of world opinion is more likely to succeed. Though we may be a small country our opinion counts in this matter. I feel inclined to laugh at Deputy Donnelly's argument—though to laugh at it would be wrong—that if this Bill was not passed the peace of Europe would be endangered.

Comment on this

Oh, come now, I never said that.

Comment on this

Well, that is the way I understood the argument. He talked about peace and the stopping of the spilling of blood, and that the passage of this Bill by the Government was going to have that effect.

Comment on this

I said we were doing our little humble part and giving our very small contribution to the cause of peace. That is what I said.

Comment on this

A very small contribution! Personally, I do not see how it is any at all, big or small. But here you have got the fact that in this State there have been certain steps taken, certain sums of money have been collected in the churches and sent out to one side in Spain. Certain sums of money have been collected outside the churches by the Christian Front, and these moneys have been sent to Spain. A certain number of men have gone out from this country; and more are endeavouring to go out from this country. These men, with very insignificant exceptions, have all gone out to fight for General Franco and the Catholics. All the money that has been collected has been sent out. This Bill stops that.

This Bill is a Bill which may do an injury to General Franco and his cause. It is a Bill which cannot do the slightest harm to the opposing junta. See how the world looks at this matter. How must the people of our own country look at it? You have got an accredited representative with this Red Government. You have got a Bill before this House the object of which, in fact, is to stop recruitment to the patriotic forces of General Franco. That is all that is aimed at. That is all that could be aimed at. How is the world going to look at that? With the indefinite speeches of the members of the Government, and their acts which are not so indefinite, how is the world to look at it except by coming to the conclusion that the present Administration is in favour of what the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, Mr. Hugo Flinn, calls the cause of democracy as against the cause which is represented by General Franco and his people. That is an important thing.

We want the Government definitely to make the statement that the sympathies of this State, expressed by official action, are on the side of those who are fighting for the cause of Christianity against anti-Christianity in Spain. There has been a certain amount of suggestion falling from Deputy Donnelly and from the President that this is a civil war in Spain that only concerns the Spaniards engaged in it. Nothing could be more false. The issue in Spain is, of course, of vital importance to Spain. From the world point of view, that importance is small in comparison with its importance to other countries. There was an election in France immediately after the Spanish election. The result was a Socialist Government in France. Nobody who is aware of the course of European history and who watches what is happening now can have the slightest doubt that if this Communistic or Soviet Parliament—call it by whatever name you choose—is victorious in this war and a Soviet republic is set up successfully in Spain or over any large portion of it, you will have precisely the same thing happening in France within a year. There is no use in living in a fool's paradise. There is no use in shutting your eyes to what is happening. There are people who believe in the Communist doctrine, who support it and who endeavour to spread it. They are a real and serious danger and menace to Christendom and to western civilisation.

Precisely the same issue is being fought out in Spain now to save Christendom as was fought out in the times of the Crusades. What does this Bill do? It is designed to prevent persons from this country going out to fight on behalf of Christendom and on behalf of the continuation of a society based upon Christian principles in Spain and, incidentally, in the world. I said a moment ago that this conflict was as important as any crusade. If I were to take a historical parallel to the present position in Spain, and if I were to compare any character in history with General Franco, I would say that General Franco, fighting round Madrid and elsewhere in Spain, as he is to-day, is fighting to save Christendom just as surely and as certainly as Don John of Austria fought to save Christendom at Lepanto. There the Turks were threatening to overrun Europe. There the great powers were standing by, jealous of one another and afraid to stir. Getting his rather nondescript forces together, Don John defeated the Turks and flung back the menace which their invasion and power were to the existence of Christendom in Western Europe. There is precisely the same danger now. Christendom and civilisation were not in greater danger from the attacks of the Turks than they are at the present moment from the spread of Bolshevist ideas. In one case, the enemy was outside. In this case, the enemy is inside. The Turks were endeavouring, by force from outside, to crush out Christianity. Communism is endeavouring to destroy Christianity by subtle propaganda from within. The danger is equally great, and it is as necessary that it should be defeated in one case as in the other.

If you read this Bill, and if you could fling back history for a few hundred years, what would be the position? Let me take the time of the First Crusade or the Second Crusade. Suppose the eloquence of Peter the Hermit and St. Bernard de Clairvaux were to ring around this country, stirring up men to go against their own interests or, in spite of their own interests, to fight in a foreign country for the interests of Christianity, what would the answer be? What would the answer be if Peter the Hermit or St. Bernard de Clairvaux visited the Irish Free State and preached the doctrine he preached for the preservation of Christianity? The answer would be a £500 fine or a term of imprisonment not exceeding two years. If another Crusader, St. Louis of France, who was not quite so successful, were to come to this country urging a crusade, because he was not so successful he might be more leniently dealt with and brought under the ban of the Minister for Justice rather than under the ban of the Attorney-General. He might possibly escape with a fine of £50 on summary conviction. There is no difference between the young Irishmen who at present go to fight for Christianity in Spain and the Crusaders who went from all over Europe to fight for Christianity in the Holy Land. There is no getting away from that. These are the plain, simple facts, and I wish the House would bear these facts in mind.

This is a very strange Bill. I do not understand, and never will understand, the passion which this Government has for retrospective legislation—the punishing of things as crimes which were not crimes at the time they were committed. Here you have wantonly drawn into this Bill a complete bit of retrospective legislation. At the present moment, nobody who goes from this country to fight in Spain is breaking the law. Let this Bill pass and nobody who goes from this country to fight in Spain will break the law of this country because this Bill does not become law until there is a proclamation or an order made by the Executive Council bringing it into force. It may never come into force. This great measure on which the peace of the world depends may never come into force. Whether the Bill will come into operation or not will depend on an order of the Executive Council. But between the period at which this Bill passes the House and the period at which it is brought into force by the Executive Council it will be perfectly lawful, for anybody who likes to do so, to leave this State and go to Spain for the purpose of assisting General Franco's troops. The President, who introduced this Bill, visualised a delay of 12 months at least. Paragraph (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 5 says "that it shall not be lawful:

"for any person who is a citizen of Saorstát Eireann and is not, at the passing of this Act, a member of the military forces of a belligerent to accept or to obtain or attempt to obtain any commission or engagement in or otherwise to join or become a member of or attempt to join or become a member of the military forces of a belligerent."

The House will notice nothing there about when the Act comes into force, when it shall become operative as a statute. There is the reference to the passing of the Act by this House. Therefore, a person may do something that is perfectly lawful and not become liable to the penalties laid down. He may go out to Spain and it will be perfectly lawful for him to do so, but when he has been there for six or nine months he may suddenly discover that the Act has been put into operation. It is then that this retrospective clause comes into force. I hope, if anybody on the Government side imitates the reckless courage of Deputy Donnelly and dares to get on his feet and address the House on this Bill on behalf of Fianna Fáil, that he will explain to us the reason for this retrospective clause. What is the reason for their love of this retrospective legislation? Everyone denounces retrospective legislation. Every jurist denounces it. In criminal matters, it is obviously unjust and yet here in the most wanton manner, as it seems to me, the Government introduce this piece of retrospective legislation in this Bill.

I submit to the judgment of the House that if this Bill becomes law, without the acceptance of Deputy O'Sullivan's amendment, the position of this country will be entirely misunderstood. It will be clear to the world that the sympathies of this State are with the Red Government and not with the Government that our sympathies ought to be, and, in fact, are. The Government are not impartial. They are not even standing fairly between the two Governments in Spain. They have a representative with one Government and not with the other. The Government here have definitely and clearly selected for their sympathy and moral support the Government in Spain which is fighting against the forces of Christianity. If this amendment is accepted the Government will have little trouble with their Bill. I do not like the Bill, but I can see that something can be said in its favour if this amendment is accepted. By passing it without the amendment the Government are doing a wrong to the people of this country. They are misrepresenting them to the world at large.

Comment on this
Thomas Derrig Minister for Education (Mr. Derrig) Fianna Fáil

Listening to Deputy McGilligan, a former Minister for External Affairs, I was rather surprised to see that he had no reasons to give the House in support of this amendment which the chief Opposition Party have placed on the Order Paper. One would expect that in matters of foreign policy, where it is considered that the Government are in error, an ex-Minister of Deputy McGilligan's experience and capabilities would at least tell this House and the Irish people the reasons which prompt him to suggest to us that we should break off relations with the present Government at the same time as we propose bringing this Bill into law. I think that as an ex-Minister for External Affairs the Deputy has not been quite frank with the House, nor has he given the country the advice to which it is entitled in an important matter of this kind.

The Deputy knows that in international affairs there are well-recognised lines of procedure to be followed. The mere fact that the Irish Free State should itself set up a special standard for its representatives, or for its Government, in international affairs does not mean, even if we should make the effort, that we are going to succeed. For example, when it was bruited abroad that the President of the Executive Council should have taken advantage of his presence at the League of Nations Assembly in Geneva to refer specifically to Irish domestic matters he pointed out, I think, with reason—I cannot see how anybody who has any real familiarity with these matters or is sincerely interested in them can contest his statement—that it would have been impossible in the circumstances then existing to raise that question. The League of Nations had assembled for a particular purpose. The big nations of Europe were interested in a very special matter, and to suggest that the President of the Executive Council of the Irish Free State could suddenly jump up and attempt to divert the attention of that Assembly from the great international problems that faced it to call attention to the specific problems of his own State, or to the adjoining part of this country, was simply absurd.

Comment on this

What has this got to do with Spain?

Comment on this

It has got to do with the statement of Deputy McGilligan that our representative at the Non-Intervention Committee should have got up there in front of the representatives of Great Britain, France, Russia, Germany, England and the 20 other nations represented and asked questions, demanded that certain things be done and, presumably, be satisfied in the name of the Irish Free State Government before he gave his consent to the proposals submitted. The Deputy was not present when Deputy McGilligan was speaking.

Comment on this

I beg the Minister's pardon, I was present during the whole of his speech.

Comment on this

Then the Deputy must have not heard Deputy McGilligan's point which was adumbrated at great length that we did not know enough about this Non-Intervention Committee. True, it is an unsatisfactory body from more points of view than one, but, if we are to believe some people who are criticising the present Government, the League of Nations with all that it means to the future of the world and the peace of the world, is not worth considering, for if a European State should suddenly determine to break its obligations to the Covenant and declare war on another party to it, the Irish Free State should stand aside. Again, if it seemed to be good from the political point of view at the moment to do so, I question very much whether in that matter, or in the non-intervention matter, it would be good policy for us in the long run, having regard to our interests as a small State, somewhat isolated in the West of Europe, to take up an entirely independent attitude in these matters.

We must have regard to the policies of other countries. We must have regard to the possibilities that the future holds in store, and we have to guide our steps carefully. The world may be, for all we know, on the eve of tremendous events, and is it suggested that the Irish Free State should rush in and proclaim itself as a crusading nation for this, that, or the other purpose? At the time of the Abyssinian question we were told that we should have stood out and adopted an independent attitude when 58 nations took up, deliberately and in the most solemn manner, a particular policy, and carried it out. It was suggested that we should not have toed the line in that way, that we should have run away, that we should not have had the moral courage to stand up and say that this policy was the better policy for this nation in the long run. We believe in this policy of non-intervention, and the Opposition, in their rather contradictory speeches, have at least that in common with us, that they recognise it as a good policy, and in fact, the only policy. I presume that they have in their minds that at some time in the future this country may be confronted with having to make some such choice as they would have us make now, and that we should suddenly precipitate ourselves into making that choice as for one "ism" against another. We decline to be put in the position of committing our people unnecessarily. We decline to be put in the position of committing this nation to foreign engagements except where it is absolutely in the interests of our people. Our general aim is to keep as far apart as we can from these disputes, and I think that the policy of the Irish people and their inner feeling in the matter, however they may regard disputes from a particular point of view, will be that that is the right policy and that, as a country, we have everything to gain and nothing to lose by standing apart in these matters.

Accordingly, I think it must be with a feeling of disappointment that those who considered the Opposition were going to put some policy before the country, will read Deputy McGilligan's speech, because, although he asks us to take an independent line of action, to act differently from the other 28 nations on the Non-Intervention Committee, and to stand apart even when the two groups of divided nations—the group represented, let us say, by Great Britain and France, and the group represented by Italy and Germany—have come together in this matter, and that they apparently consider that, in their respective interests and for the peace of Europe, it is better that they should all act together in this matter, apparently, we in the Irish Free State, should bravely go forth shouting "Excelsior."

I would remind Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, when he talks about the Crusades, that no doubt very many fine and splendid knights went to the Crusades, but that a great many of them began to fight for other things before they came back again, and a great many of them forgot the reasons for which they went there in the first instance. The Deputy has to go back a very long way in history. Surely there must be some period nearer than the Crusades to which he can point as an example of what would be the right thing for a small nation like ours to do in the present emergency. When the Opposition Party take on themselves the cloak of Christianity, and when Deputy McGilligan tells us that he speaks for the Irish Hierarchy, I am tempted to remind him that, during the Great War, one of the great nations which have now declared war on Communism, and which apparently is exercising its powers to the fullest possible extent to destroy Communism, not only within its own frontiers but wherever it may exist, permitted Lenin and Trotsky, the two apostles of Communism, to enter Russia, and they subsequently created that State. The illustration may be of use in recalling to the House the fact that when great nations go to war, though they may hold the banner of Christianity very high, as they did in 1914, when some of the Irish newspapers that are telling us now what our duty is, on the ground of Christianity, were telling Irishmen and were largely responsible for Irishmen going out in thousands to fight for Christianity, for Catholic Belgium and the rest of it—am I not right, Sir, in recalling to the House and to the country that these great nations who talk a great deal, or who allow others to talk for them, when they are at war, about how they are out for Christianity, are a great deal apart from Christianity and that very little Christianity is in their ideas? They are out simply and solely for their own political interests, for the expansion of their territories, for the increase of their influence, and, generally speaking, getting their place in the sun.

I think that there is a danger, if this conflict in Spain were to continue as it has been continuing, that the two camps in Europe would very soon come into grips and that war would be absolutely inevitable. In these circumstances, were we to assume that this country of ours was bound to either one side or the other in these two opposing camps? We as a Government, having regard to our responsibilities to the Irish people, are not prepared to make a choice as between Communism and Fascism. In the matter of international affairs, generally speaking, I think I will be correct in stating that both under the last Government and under the present Government our position with regard to international affairs—co-operation in the League of Nations, for example— has been that we took our stand with the free democracies of Europe, the Scandinavian democracies in particular. That was our general feeling, and when newspapers tell us that we are standing in with Russia or with France, or with Imperial Britain, in this matter, I say that they know a great deal more about Imperial Britain and a great deal more about recruiting for Imperial Britain, and about getting 50,000 Irishmen to leave their bones in Flanders, than we do.

We have always stood for the interests of Irishmen. We have stood for Irishmen fighting for their own interests in this country, and against their going outside this country for anybody else, if we can possibly avoid it. That is our position, and I should like to know, since when have these newspapers the right to question us when we speak for the Irish people? I say that it is not because of Russia or France or England or anybody else, but because we believe it is in our own true interest, and because we believe it is in the permanent interests of this country to take the action we are now taking, that we recommend it. In any case, besides these great nations, of which, according to our critics, we are only the rag-tag and bobtail—a mere tail—is no regard to be taken of the other nations like Poland and Belgium? Poland early decided, as we read in the newspapers, that she was not going to have volunteers going to Spain. She put a ban on volunteers going to Spain and laid down certain penalties, such as, I think, loss of citizenship. We also know the attitude of Belgium in this matter. Then there is a large number of other States—Holland, Sweden, Norway, all peace-loving countries whose great interest and desire is to preserve the peace of Europe and have friendly relations between all peoples. We, however, for no stated reason, are to suddenly strike out on a path of our own. I think that in a matter of this kind, where there is no loss of national liberty or no injury to national interests, we should fall in, wherever we can, with the concert of Europe, that we should co-operate with European nations, particularly when we know that the aim and object is to bring about better relations between them all and to try to lay the foundations of peace in Europe.

This action, it has been admitted even by the critics of the Bill, is not going, even from the narrowest point of view, to deprive General Franco of any support that he can get in Spain. It is not going even to hinder him in certain other directions. It is going to mean that those nations in Europe that seemed to be divided, and which were gradually being forced into a war position, can come together on a basis of co-operation. That is a tremendously important factor in connection with non-intervention. It may also lead to an end of the conflict in Spain if these nations can, between themselves, work out an arrangement by which, without any further bloodshed or destruction, some machinery can be created by which the Spanish people themselves will select a Government according to their own ideas. They might be able, possibly, to speed that Government on its way and again bring about peaceful conditions in Spain. At any rate, even from the point of view of the Spanish people themselves, was it to their advantage that these two groups of nations were helping one side or the other? We were told that volunteers were going into Spain in large numbers. At any rate, this non-intervention machinery will do a great deal to stop that. I question very much whether if, by a policy of intervention, either party succeeded in setting up a Government by force of foreign arms, that party could always maintain its position. In the long run a Government has to get its strength from the people. It is a matter for the Spanish people themselves in the long run, and the sooner the position can be reached when the Spanish people themselves will freely and peacefully be able to decide on, and to legitimatise a Government by their votes in the usual way, the sooner will the dangers of war in Europe and the dangers of the international situation be removed.

No basis whatever, in my opinion, has been put forward by Deputy McGilligan for the suggestion that we should have adopted an independent attitude in this matter. He could scarcely have done so, in view of the fact that most of the prominent speakers on the Opposition Benches have expressed their sympathy with the principle of this Bill. We decline to recognise the right of Deputy McGilligan, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney or anybody else, to extract from us a confession of faith as to our beliefs in regard to this matter. We refused that before. The President stated in this House, and I repeat what he then said as far as I can remember it, that it would be a very bad day indeed if political Parties in this country could put themselves into the position in which they could say that they were the guardians or the protectors, one political Party above another, of religious interests in this country. Political Parties have to take cognisance of religious interests. The Government of this country take cognisance of these interests, and it would be a very sorry day for this State if we had one Party claiming that they were the only Party standing as the defenders of Christianity, and trying to force a position so that the Irish people might be induced to believe—because that is what is sought to be done here—that the Party in office are in some way lacking and wanting in their duties as a Christian Government.

I have questioned the basis on which the alternative action recommended is suggested. We are told that there is something extraordinary about our having sent a diplomatic representative to the Government of Spain. It is even pretended that the representative, who is now on the borders of Spain, is accredited specifically to the Caballero Government. The experts in international procedure and international law, naturally, would not like that the country should be made to realise that our ambassador was sent in the first instance to the Government at Madrid in 1935. Is it the position that, every time there is a change of Government, the ambassador has to be withdrawn? The only possible position is the position to which the President has already agreed, the position mentioned by Deputy MacDermot, that when an insurgent party are undisputably in control of the greater part of the territory of the country, have the support of the inhabitants, and are endeavouring to function as a Government in the usual manner, then the question of their recognition comes up. The precise moment may be a matter of opinion but, at any rate, international procedure, the procedure of diplomacy, is well recognised in this matter. That has always been the principle. None of the 27 nations represented on the Non-Intervention Committee have withdrawn their diplomatic representatives.

Comment on this

Question.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy mention any State that has?

Comment on this

Germany and Italy have withdrawn their representatives from the Valencia Government.

Comment on this

Germany and Italy may have withdrawn their representatives.

Comment on this

You insisted that none of the 27 had.

Comment on this

We are not going to adopt a particular line of policy because Germany and Italy had done so.

Comment on this

I was only questioning your statement of fact.

Comment on this

In any case, even if Germany and Italy have recognised General Franco's Government, there must be, if the figures are correct, 25 other States which have not.

Comment on this

What about Portugal?

Comment on this

The mere fact that Germany and Italy have recognised that Government is no reason why we should recognise it. The question of whether we should recognise that Government is entirely a matter for ourselves.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

It is not determined by any consideration except what is best in the interests of the Irish people. The fact that particular Governments recognise or do not recognise General Franco does not affect us. That is not in itself a reason why we should take similar action, but if a large body of nations, acting together, feel that certain action is necessary and advisable in the interests of peace in Europe, I question myself whether we should stand out and take an independent attitude, as if we were a big power capable of carrying into effect in some way the policy which our independent attitude indicates. It is very well known that we cannot very often take up an independent attitude in these matters, no matter how much we might desire it. We would find ourselves incapable very often of carrying our wishes into effect.

In these matters of diplomacy there are well-recognised practices. There is caution and care and observation of all the circumstances of the situation, and we are certainly not going to take any action until we are fully satisfied that it is necessary and proper to take in our own interest.

Deputy MacDermot pointed out that representation at a foreign government does not mean any agreement whatever with the policy of that government; it gives no certificate of approval of that government's actions. The representative is accredited to the country rather than to the particular government which may be in office at the moment. Besides, the representative is there for a specific purpose, to look after the interests of his country, and of the nationals of his country who may be there. Our representative at the present time is, as far as he can under the circumstances, looking after the interests of any of our nationals who may be there, and observing the position generally as it may affect our interests. He may also be of some use, I hope he may be and will be, in helping to bring the conflict to an end. If at any time any joint action is taken, if the different countries interested would take such action through their diplomatic representatives, it would be only natural and proper that, so far as he can do so, our representative should play as big a part as possible in such negotiations.

Deputy McGilligan quoted an important statement from His Holiness the Pope with reference to the situation in Spain. The Deputy went to great length to try and prove that in a matter in which our Irish Catholic people have strong views and in which their sympathies, as has been explained and as has been agreed in the House, are in a particular direction, it is only natural for us to listen with the greatest care and the closest attention to what the Holy Father has to say. But it is very significant that Deputy McGilligan, while reading the Holy Father's pronouncement, took care not to mention that amongst the States which have not withdrawn recognition from the Government in Valencia is the Vatican State. According to some of the critics, we should not wait for the Vatican; we should be more Catholic than the Pope and more Irish than I do not know whom——

Comment on this

Mary McSwiney?

Comment on this

I do not know what standard it is proposed to set up in that connection. It is presumed that a great number of people in this country have a great deal of knowledge of the situation in Spain. I am no expert in regard to that situation. I simply consider that there is a good deal of truth in a statement which I read recently, that a civil war of this barbarous nature is far worse for a nation than any type of international warfare in which it might be engaged. It is bound to have terrible effects, effects which will not be healed for many a long day. When to the civil war are added acute and fundamental religious differences, it must be obvious that the conflict is of a nature. a bitterness and a depth that ordinary wars cannot have. And it is because we realise that that war is so painful, so agonising and so terrible in its effects on the great Spanish people, that we would like to see its early termination.

It seems to be questioned in this House whether we are justified in expressing a wish that that conflict should be brought to a sudden end. If by taking the action that the Opposition suggest, the Government could help to bring this conflict to an end, I am sure they would consider the matter very carefully indeed. But they know that the Opposition are faced with a general election; they have not any policy worth speaking of to put before the people; they see before them the framework of a movement which might be of use to them in trying to build up their shattered political fortunes; and what could be more natural than that they should take advantage of the opportunity which now offers to hold themselves out as the great crusaders of Christianity in this country, and the Government in office, of course, as a Government failing to do their plain, simple and honest duty in defence of Christianity.

I hope that before the debate closes the Opposition will be able to show us how the mere recognition or non-recognition by the Irish Free State of a particular Government, or the mere withdrawal or otherwise of our representative in Spain, is going to affect the situation. We know there are tremendous factors and forces at work and we should not make the mistake of assuming that as regards those who are interested, who are making themselves interested in this war in Spain and who have taken great trouble with men and machines and material to force their point of view, it is the ideals of Christianity, as we understand them in this country, that are prompting them, in the first instance. Very far from it, I suggest. I hope that we shall not reach the position in this country when the sincerity of Deputies, their belief in their religion, their adherence to its principles, are going to be measured by fulsome statements in the Dáil or outside it as to how strongly they feel in matters of this kind, and what they are or are not prepared to do in the interests of Christianity in other countries.

We are in an entirely different position to the critics in the daily newspapers, who have no purpose in view except to get a whack at the Government wherever they can, to try to sell their newspapers, to have some doctrine or other prominently headed and leaded that will work up a certain amount of feeling and will associate their particular organ with the point of view which they hope is a very popular point of view and the view of the great majority at the time. Nor are we in the position of our friends in the Opposition, whose sole duty in this debate is to criticise the Government as best they can—with quite contradictory and inconsistent arguments at times.

We have our responsibility to the people and we are prepared to stand over our action in this matter. We are prepared, when the time comes, to explain fully to the people, as we have tried to explain to the Dáil, that it is not always advisable, nor is it feasible as a general rule, for this little State of ours to take up independent attitudes, manly attitudes, as Deputy McGilligan would have us do. To the best of our ability, when the opportunity offers, when we feel it is a vital matter and that we shall not have to retreat in any way from the position that we have taken up and, when we are satisfied it is in the best interests of our country to do it, we shall not be in any way slow in taking up a manly and independent attitude.

Comment on this

Before the Minister spoke, I had a certain idea which I was rather hesitant to put forward because, although I was quite certain it was sound, I felt it was not quite provable. It is clear to me since the present Government came into power that their policy in external affairs has been, roughly, to be dragged at the tail of what I would call the pink liberalism of Europe. The Minister who has just spoken has said how absurd it is for us to expect the Government to take up an independent attitude, to ask questions, to raise points even on the Non-Intervention Committee. What actually happened with regard to the Non-Intervention Committee was that on February 15th the sub-committee met and on it we were not represented. The sub-committee at that meeting came to an agreement as to the ban on volunteers and as to the scheme for providing the naval cordon around Spain. We had no representative on that sub-committee, but the Press liaison officer of the sub-committee was able to tell the Press that the whole committee would agree to it. "The full committee will consider the recommendations to-day," says Reuter. "Their acceptance is a foregone conclusion."

We are sitting in this Dáil to-day, not because our Government, acting as our Government, decided that we should; not because our Government, represented on the Non-Intervention Committee, agreed to a certain thing. We are sitting here because the sub-committee, upon which we were not represented, came to certain decisions and decided for us, possibly having been given a blank cheque by our Government's abdicating its own rights in the matter. The committee, on which this country was not even represented, decided that this Dáil should sit to-day and pass this Bill. That committee, through its spokesman, announced beforehand that, as far as the Irish Free State was concerned as a member of the main body, of the exterior body, of this Non-Intervention Committee, we would agree, either because it was decided we should, or because they had been given a blank cheque beforehand. The Minister for Education indicated a doctrine which to me is appalling and nationally disgraceful. Towards the end he said that we are speaking on this matter, and taking the line we are taking on it, because a general election is coming on; that we have no policy and want to appear as the champions of Christianity.

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this

That is a dastardly and blackguardly statement and I will say nothing more about it. When we were the Government for ten years, never at any time in any statement to the world did we suggest that we as a Government represented Christianity, solely represented it, and that the opposition to us was opposition to Christianity or to Catholicism. That was never done. When this Government came into power, one of its first acts was that President de Valera got on the end of a wireless to announce to the whole world that now in this country we had a Christian Government set out to create a Christian order, meaning that the Government which had gone out of office had not been such a Government, but that his was. That, of course, was a despicable thing to do. It was a subordination to ends, in that it was clearly, maliciously, without any charity, and with dishonesty, purporting to tell the world that it was encumbent upon a Catholic to support his Party, his venal Party, and that failure to give it support was itself something contrary to Catholicism.

This is a matter on which I personally feel very strongly—I do not care tuppence what my Party think on it— but although it was one of the supreme issues in the world, and in the Irish nation, we did not raise it at all. We left it to the Government to take appropriate action and only raised it when the Government was proposing the adjournment of the Dáil over a number of months. We left it to the last moment to do that. A movement has been started called the Christian Front. I will speak perfectly frankly. I think that what should have been done, but the attitude of the Government made it difficult, was that President de Valera and Deputy Cosgrave, representing the two big Parties in this country, should have been invited to participate in that. Because that was not done, I personally have had nothing to do with the Christian Front because I felt that, as the official Government organ has declared war on that organisation——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have precluded two Deputies from discussing the policy of the Christian Front, and the Deputy may not pursue that line.

Comment on this

I was not aware you had done so. What I am trying to do is to point out the absolute injustice of the remark made by the Minister who has just spoken. I merely wanted to point out that against one's own inclinations, rather than that there should be any suggestion that we were trying to subordinate the religious to the political motive, we have kept aloof. We only brought up the matter when this Dáil was being adjourned for a number of months, and we have not brought up the matter now. This is brought in by the Government to-day because a sub-committee of the Non-Intervention Committee decided on a certain policy and announced that those who were not on the sub-committee were to or must take certain action, and we are now taking action as decided by that committee on which we were not represented.

The doctrine of the Minister for Education is that we are like a sort of poor relation at a feast; that at the League of Nations or at any international committee our business is to go there and to keep our mouths shut; to be very thankful that we are given that very artificial honour of being there, to have no feelings in the matter, and to say "Yes" when the socialistic, pinkish, liberalistic statesmen of Europe decide what suits their interest. I remember that some time ago President de Valera made a speech which was applauded by all the Communistic, liberal, pinkish papers in Europe. If I remember rightly, he actually implied criticism of the Nazi Government in Germany and their treatment of Jews. In so far as the action of the Nazi Government in Germany towards Jews is unjust, I disclaim it and approve of what President de Valera said. But just notice. When it was a matter on that occasion of the pink liberals and Communists in Europe wanting an opportunity of hitting at Germany, they all applauded President de Valera and President de Valera was very quick to give what was required. In the case of Abyssinia there was the same position. A terrible Fascist enemy had to be denounced, and President de Valera was not merely a tacit assenter to the doctrine of sanctions, but he was an active advocate of it. It was not a question of tacit assent. Now, in this case I have not heard—do not think I am in any way trying to justify or to draw the veil over any injustices that may have happened in Germany or making any plea for them—but I have not heard of the murder of any rabbi or the burning of any synagogue. I am not saying that the absence of these things means that justice was not outraged. On that occasion President de Valera felt it his duty—his soul could not keep quiet—to denounce what was happening in Germany. As far as Spain is concerned we have no such action.

The Minister asked how our proposal that a Minister be no longer accredited to the anarcho-Communist Government in a certain portion of Spain affects the situation. I shall give two instances. A short time ago Mr. Vogt, speaking on the B.B.C., was rather combating the suggestion that the B.B.C. showed a Red bias in the Spanish matter. He said the B.B.C. was criticised for referring to the Catholic side in Spain as rebels and to the anarcho-Communist side as the Government. He said:—

"Our Government has accredited a representative to one side and, consequently, I am bound to call those who are at war against them rebels, and bound to call those to whom we have sent an accredited representative as the Government."

He also said:—

"If our Government withdraws its accredited representative from the Valencia Government, and accredits an ambassador to Burgos, then I will speak of General Franco's Government as such and of Caballero's as the rebels."

Some years ago, at a time when in China there were at least seven Governments of different Parties purporting to exercise authority there, the Chinese representative of the League of Nations made speeches which were rather annoying to the big Powers. One of the representatives of the big Powers, in order to shut him up, said to him:—

"You talk about representing the Chinese Government; what Government do you represent?"

He came back very quickly and said:—

"I represent the Chinese Government to which your Government accredits a representative."

The man who tried to shut him up was very quickly shut up himself.

When we accredit a representative to a Government the Minister for Education says that that in no way implies that we approve of the policy of that Government. That is quite true. However, it implies one thing —it means that we recognise the Government as the moral person of that State; that we recognise that that Government exercises authority received from God which is binding on the conscience of the people of that country. That is what we are doing by sending an accredited representative to the Caballero gang in Spain. What do we ask? We ask that we should cease to have an accredited representative there. As for the talk about his function being to assist our nationals there, he has not been in Spain, and does not propose going there, since it was dangerous to be there. I think he had left on holidays beforehand, but there was some member of the staff there who got out as quickly as possible. I cannot say if it was with the assistance of the British Government or not. Since that time the British representation that remained there, and that was not in such a hurry out of the place, has acted for our nationals.

Consequently, I feel about the situation in Spain that it is an absolute scandal that we should have continued to have a representative with the so-called Government there. I cannot see any grounds why he should be there. That Government does not control the major part of Spain; it controls the smaller part, and it is not an elected Government—not that I put the enormous value on "elected" that the Government Party does. That Government does not exist for the promotion of the common good of the people in Spain. All intelligent judgment indicates clearly that if that side should win in Spain, instead of promoting good human life for the people it would institute an order or disorder which is absolutely contrary to what good human life requires. Therefore, on no ground whatever should we maintain a representative with that Government, or recognise it as an authority with binding force over the consciences of the Spanish people.

This Bill proposes to extend the operation of the criminal code. It is a serious matter. To do that it requires to be justified. There has been no attempt to justify it. I am not misrepresenting the President, but he purports to know the secrets and the hearts of those gallant young men in Spain who are fighting for order, for a noble and an ancient Spanish tradition, who have risen up in arms in defence of that tradition; these splendid young men who wish to maintain the historic and the true religion of Spain, knowing that defeat means its overthrow. The President says that with most of those fighting in Spain it is only a matter of one "ism" against another "ism." We have said that that is not true. If you like, it is the fight of Catholicism or Christianism against Atheism. The word "ism" means a sort of creed which is contrary to right reason. When the President said that most of those fighting in Spain are fighting for one ideology that is contrary to right reason against another ideology that is contrary to right, he is perpetrating a diabolical libel on splendid young men who have risen to fight for things they hold dear. That is a thing I resent. Some of my own friends, distinguished Spaniards, have been killed or brutally murdered for standing for all that is admirable in the history of Spain. The President purports to know that they are only fighting for some "ism."

The President says that the all-important thing is that this war in Spain should end quickly. That is not the all-important thing to me. The all-important thing to me is that the right side should win in Spain. I admit that in considering this we have to take into account contingent circumstances, and the argument that intervention brings the danger of the fight in Spain extending to Europe. One might argue as to whether it would be better to have the right side beaten in Spain rather than have the war spread to Europe. Personally, as one who recognises war in itself as an essential evil, knowing also that in certain circumstances there comes greater good from the right to resort to war, and knowing that on no account should we assist in the overthrow of religion, or the overthrow of truly human order, to be supplanted by order that is contrary to humanity, it seems to me that an argument could be put up that, even if it meant the war extending beyond the realm of Spain, we might take certain action to bring about victory on the right side there. That is an argument to put up. What are the facts of the matter? The facts are that there was a movement to make Spain Communistic or Anarchist, and that that brought about the present situation. Immediately that took place, as one has seen from letters published in the Italian newspapers from one of the representatives of Spain to one of the French Government's who interviewed four Ministers—and the account of the interview was not refuted—and certain British statesmen indicated, that amongst the volunteers fighting on the various sides in Spain possibly the largest number are French—there was an organised and steady flow of French recruits and French arms to Spain to support the Red side. We know that the only producer and the only trader and exporter in the Union of the Soviet Republics is the Russian Government. For everything produced and sold there is only one dealer and one manufacturer, and that is the Russian Government. We know that in Spain there are Russian tanks, Russian arms and equipment of all kinds. Consequently, we know that these things have not come from private traders or from private exporters but from the Russian Government.

As far as I can follow it these people were trying to ensure the overthrow of order in Spain and to establish a nonhuman order, and it was as a counter act against that and not for some advantage that assistance was lent to what I call the right side in Spain. When it appeared that their assistance was going to be more effective than the surreptitious assistance of the other countries, then there was a proposal of non-intervention. They raised then the point that there was danger of a European war. And why? Because there are certain interests involved.

The present British Minister for Foreign Affairs just a short time ago made, to my mind, the worst speech of any British Foreign Minister since the War. Since the War Great Britain has been in the remarkably favourable position that its very circumstances made it always on the side of the angels. It was satisfied with things as they were. It was not seeking for any particular gain in any place. It wanted peace. It stood for disarmament and for everything we applaud. But a short time ago the British Foreign Minister warned the world that any probability or any act which put a great Power in force in the Iberian peninsula was a matter of immediate interest to the British Government, and not to be tolerated by them. There was a fear that, if Italy or Germany were assisting the one side in Spain, they were doing that for their own interests and that as a result Italy or Germany would receive territory or power in the Iberian peninsula which would be dangerous to France or dangerous to Great Britain. On the other hand, one can well understand that Italy and Germany might feel that they also could not tolerate a Red Government in Spain, in very close alliance or subordination to the Government of Russia or of France. It was in that that the danger of war lay. If the Italians sent over 500,000 men, and if those lies put out by the Soviet Government forced from Spain the Balearic Islands or other parts, there would be danger to France, which France would not tolerate, and danger of a European war.

But the truth is that there is no fear that any number of men that comes from Ireland are likely to lead to the handing over of any part of Spain as additional territory to the Irish Free State. No country in Europe has any fear whatever of that. No country in Europe has any fear that by our getting into the very closest alliance with Spain our power there will be such as to endanger British shipping or endanger communications between France and Morocco. We could send 50,000 men over to Spain, and there would not be any possibility of war from that; that is to say, it would not increase the fear that the great countries in Europe have—and particularly those interested in the Mediterranean —that some rival Power will get into position and possibly control or prevent their action. The only danger of war arising out of our volunteers going out to fight in Spain is this, that by going and supporting the Franco side they might make it victorious, and that Russia or another Communist State might feel so determined to establish Communism in Spain that they would ensure this actively rather than let Caballero and his gang be beaten. That is the only significance of our action there. That is the only danger of war that our action there brings about. If that is so, if Russia is determined at any cost —even at the cost of endangering European peace—that Franco shall be beaten, then I feel it is more than ever our duty to let our recruits, if they want to, go out there and fight on the Franco side.

It is a regrettable thing that in this country there has been, for years past, a general tendency to wander away after what I call the socialistic, liberal pink propaganda of Europe. When Adolph Dolfuss, as the legitimate authority in Austria, doing his duty by his people, took action against the machine-gun emplacements in Vienna, and manned by the Socialists, I remember words in this House, from the Labour Party, I think, indicating strong disapproval of the crime of Dolfuss in governing and in putting down organised crime in his own country. A couple of years ago when the miners in the Asturias—because Catholics became members of the Spanish Government—rose up and dynamited and burned churches, the whole liberal Press of Europe made an outcry against the crime of the Spanish Government in taking action against those gentle dynamiters and murderers. But now, when those Asturians and their allies have done acts in Spain that really one can hardly bear to contemplate, when they have murdered, destroyed and outraged all over the country, we find there is not a word to be said against it. Every excuse that can be brought forward is made for them. Yet our own Government and our own President indicated strong disapproval of what was happening in Germany. As I say, I am not for one moment going to defend injustice in Germany or anywhere else. It was quite all right at that time to indicate disapproval, but now the best interests of our diplomacy require that he should pretend to be unaware of what is happening in Spain.

We have the Minister for Education saying that when we are in the League of Nations or in international committees our business is to keep our mouths shut and let the big fellows have just what they want. I am not saying that in the Non-intervention Committee or in the League of Nations we, in isolation, could achieve anything. I am not saying we could, but I do say that this country does stand for something. It has stood up and denounced the action of Italy in Abyssinia. I remember a couple of years ago at a meeting in Trinity College, there was Lord Cecil, President de Valera, and I. Lord Cecil and President de Valera indicated strong disapproval of the League of Nations because it had allowed Japan to operate in Manchukuo. The only way the League of Nations could have pre vented that would have been by sending an army out there. I must say I had to laugh when I heard President de Valera getting up and saying how he was disgusted and disheartened by the League of Nations having allowed the Japanese to enter into Manchukuo when I knew perfectly well if they had said, "We are not going to let Japan into Manchukuo. Everybody must come forward now, and shouder the burden of putting them out and keeping them out. Mr. de Valera, how many men are you going to send out, and how many millions of money are you prepared to contribute?" he would have said, "There is nothing doing."

He loves to get up and make high-sounding speeches when they will win applause from the officials of the League of Nations Secretariat, from every socialistic pink Liberal in Geneva. He can always make a speech to win their applause, but at the present moment when the Irish people, by their sort of splendid intuition, realise that one of the greatest struggles in history is being fought out in Spain—it is not a matter of their sympathy; it is not a matter of mere "feeling with" as the word "sympathy" means; it is much more than that; the Irish people know in their hearts that all they regard as holy and noble is in travail in Spain at the moment and struggling against its most diabolical enemy—we are told that that is a fight between one "ism" and another in Spain. I object strongly to this Bill. I am quite satisfied that we are right in desiring, and desiring very strongly, and being prepared to go some distance to make a sacrifice in order to win the victory of the one side in Spain. I am quite satisfied also that if we refused to pass this Bill, it would not have any effect whatever towards bringing the danger of war nearer. It would have no effect whatever on that matter, because nobody is afraid that the Irish Free State, in doing so, is trying to establish a footing in Spain to exercise a position there detrimental to the interests of the great Powers. The British Foreign Minister indicated that the Spanish Peninsula must be occupied only by a weak Power, and even if the Irish Free State took it over altogether, I do not think he would feel he had much to worry about.

This Bill is brought in, as I say, because a Committee on which we were not represented came to a certain agreement and decided that we and twenty odd others would automatically, by reason of their decision, bring in such legislation. I object to the continuance of the accredited representative to the so-called Valentia Government for the reasons I have indicated. If it means anything, it means that we recognise these bloodstained men as the moral persons of Spain, able to make laws binding upon the consciences of the people of Spain, that we recognise that they are the legitimate Government of Spain and able to speak as the international person, Spain. I deny that. By maintaining that representation there, to go back to the Chinese analogy, we recognise that they are the only legitimate government, and, as Mr. Vogt pointed out, as long as we maintain that representation, we must denounce Franco as a rebel and hail Caballero as leader of the legitimate Government, and I deny both.

Also, I think the very person we are sending, by reason of his activities, to which I have referred before, is the wrong man to send. I have pointed out here before, and President de Valera took his usual shelter of drawing on his unlimited resources of virtuous indignation to dodge meeting the point, that there is every reason to believe that the man we are sending there has himself acted as a go-between in order to get assistance from the Russian Government through Russian agents in Italy. That is the man we are choosing, most appropriately, as one might say, to represent us to the so-called Government in Valentia.

I think it is a perfect scandal that this thing should be brought in, and I think it is indicative of this, if I might repeat myself, that ever since President de Valera came in I know myself—and I saw it in the officials, and I knew it in myself—that when you go into these international assemblies where these Liberal-Socialist-Communist pinks and reds are always ready to applaud splendid Christian sentiment—hatred of war, love of disarmament, objection to aggression and all the rest of it—a man who is guided solely by personal vanity will always try to win the applause of that crowd. For myself, I have nothing but contempt for it. I quite agree that what I stand for and what the Irish people stand for is something which is discordant with the general view of European statesmen, with the general point of view of the European Press, and, if you like, with the general point of view of the modern mind, but if this country has anything to distinguish it from other countries, it is only that it has inherited a tradition which has something of the eternal in it, that it does stand for things that transcend the mere superficial matters that occupy the minds of modern statesmen, that we have an order of values and that we recognise certain values as transcending infinitely other considerations.

In this matter whether or not there is going to be in Spain an order which is a human order, which facilitates man in securing the destiny for which he was created, or an order which is designed solely to destroy everything that is noble and everything that is moral in him, I feel that all our national traditions, all that we hold as holy and all we know to be true leaves us no option but to declare that we are on one side and whole-heartedly and unmistakably on one side. What our Government does then is blatantly to misrepresent us in the eyes of the world, to give us a certain sense of shame in the action of our own country, and it does that without any excuse. I know that people like my friend Deputy Thrift have an honest concern about the danger threatening Europe of a European war. This Bill brought in here, the Bill in France, the Bill in Italy and the Bill in England have some significance in the matter, but as far as this country is concerned, it has no relationship whatever and it has no reaction whatever on the danger or immunity to European war. It is brought in here in the most contemptible way, and we have the little dishonest methods of President de Valera, who had not the guts to say: "Yes, we are sending our representative to Valencia and there is none at Burgos." He said: "He is going to St. Jean de Luz, and you know the geographical position of St. Jean de Luz. It is nearer Burgos than Valencia." One can have some respect for the man who will get up and tell a decent honest lie, but the man who will quibble and twist is beneath contempt.

That is the position as I see it. I feel that it was a scandal to bring in this Bill, and that every attempt to defend it has been based on misrepresentation and dishonesty. It is brought in, not as a Government Act, and not as a result of a formal commitment that our Government entered into in conference. It is brought in by the decision of a sub-committee of the Non-Intervention Committee on which we had no representation, but President de Valera, who wants Ireland to have some sort of freedom that belongs to no human institution whatever, is ready to accept his orders from anybody except the Irish people or anybody who might legitimately give orders to him.

Comment on this

Deputy Donnelly in the course of his speech said he personally and members of his Party condemned the butcheries, the burnings and the atrocities committed by the Caballero Government or junta in Spain. If that is Deputy Donnelly's attitude, I suggest to him that the only effective way of answering that Government and the only effective form of condemnation of their actions is to support the amendment proposed by Deputy O'Sullivan. I must confess that, from Deputy Donnelly's traditions, I did expect that he was one member of the Fianna Fáil Party who would stand out by himself on this particular issue, and I certainly was under the impression that he would, to put it mildly, find it very difficult to oppose the amendment proposed by Deputy O'Sullivan. Deputy Donnelly, however, has ranged himself beside his leader, and I assume that his leader's attitude will be taken as typical of the attitude of all the other members of the Party on this subject.

The Minister for Education said that, so far as possible, the policy of the present Government was to keep as far away from international disputes as they conveniently could. I certainly think that is a very wise policy because I do not think the Free State Government have cut a very dignified figure in their association with the big international disputes up to the present, and I do not think their attitude in connection with certain international disputes has added either to their reputation or to the reputation of this State. I do think that the proceedings here, for part of yesterday and the whole of this day, to a certain extent lack a sense of dignity. After all, here we are discussing a Bill introduced at the behest of Great Britain, or, at least, at the behest of the great Powers. Obviously the members of the Government themselves do not clearly understand the Bill. It is certain that they do not understand its implications. It is a Bill the implications of which no Deputy in this House understands. We were told that this is a Bill to give effect to certain agreements reached by the Non-Intervention Committee in London. How do we know how the arrangements or agreements reached in London are going to be made effective? We do not understand the first thing about the non-intervention machinery. We do not know what form or type that machinery will be. Even yet the members of those Governments cannot agree amongst themselves on the particular form and type of machinery which is to be set up for giving effect to the non-intervention proposals, and if we are to judge by this day's Press, not all of these Governments are in agreement on that particular question. Yet we have spent all this day and part of yesterday discussing a Bill which apparently the President and the members of the Government do not understand. At all events, it is a Bill about which, if they do understand it, they are strangely silent. It is certain that no Deputy in the House understands it. The whole trend of the discussion on the part of the Deputies who have spoken to-day centred on seeking information about the Bill, about how it is to work and what its effect in this country is to be. The question arose about its urgency or why we should bother our heads about it at all—what interest is it of ours. The Minister for Education told us that he doubted very much if the men fighting in Spain were inspired by Christian motives, handling, as they are, the frightful instruments of war utilised by both sides in this dispute.

The Minister for Education obviously in that respect has made a peculiar statement. Is he not prepared to accept the evidence tendered to him by high Christian authorities? Is he prepared to dispute the evidence submitted by the Holy Father, by the representative of the Holy See, the Cardinal Primate of Spain? His attitude is typical of the attitude of his leader, who said yesterday that this is a war of "isms," presumably meaning that it is a war between Communism on the one side and Fascism on the other side. Surely we have had sufficient evidence at our disposal to arrive at a decision as to the real nature of the civil war in Spain? Surely anybody who has read the evidence over a long period of years relative to the activities of the Russian Communists in Spain must come to the conclusion that their one and only object was to get a grip on the Government in Spain. Anybody who understands the doctrines of Communism cannot but realise that its central idea is to destroy religion and all belief in God. Having spent so much time and devoted so much money to propaganda in Spain, is it not natural to assume, from what has happened since the outbreak of the civil war, that they are inspired with this idea of anti-God and anti-Christ? It is well to bear in mind that many atrocities and butcherings took place before the outbreak of the civil war at all. These atrocities have since taken place on a huge scale. Does anybody who studies or observes the position, and looks at it impartially, conclude that these things could have happened through any other motive except that of destroying all traces of religion in Spain?

It is an extraordinary thing that the Minister for Education should have made the statement he made here to-day. I cannot understand the attitude of the members of the Government on this whole question. Deputy Anthony to-day said that it should be the first duty of the Government on a question of this character to make it absolutely clear to the peoples of the world that we in this country are a Christian people and that our sympathies are entirely with the side in Spain who are fighting for Christian principles. I think the Minister for Education made no effort whatsoever to reply to the speech of Deputy Anthony. When introducing the Bill yesterday the President made no effort to justify or explain the attitude of the Government in regard to this Bill, and neither did Deputy Donnelly. Neither they nor anyone on the Government side made any effort to explain their attitude to the Government in Spain led by General Franco.

The President stated that one of the objects of the Bill was to bring the present conflict in Spain to a speedy conclusion. I would be interested to know what sort of a speedy conclusion he had in mind. The overwhelming majority of the people of this country, at all events, want the war to conclude in one way. I wonder if the President has any regard for the wishes of the overwhelming majority in this country in that respect. It seems to me that if this war does not conclude in one particular way, there is no future for Spain and no future for Europe. Because, if the Reds win, Spain will be made the jumping-off ground for the purpose of enabling Communism to make an onslaught on the other European countries.

There is one extraordinary section of the Bill which requires a great deal of explanation. That is the last section—Section 11—of the Bill. That section imposes a penalty of £500 or, at the discretion of the court, imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years, or both such fine and imprisonment. For any infringement of the Bill these penalties can be imposed for five years even after the Bill itself has expired. To me, at all events, that is an amazing section. I have never read or heard of such a penalty being imposed in the past by any legislation introduced in this or any other country. It would be very interesting to know if Bills similar to this are being introduced and passed by the other countries concerned in the Non-Intervention Convention in London. Are similar drastic arrangements to be imposed by other Governments on their own nationals who come within the scope of such legislation?

There is no question about it that the sending of an ambassador to the Caballero Government simultaneously with the introduction of this Bill has given the impression down the country that the present Free State Government have ranged themselves on the side of the Caballero junta in Spain. That may have been an unfortunate coincidence, but, certainly, one can quite understand how the impression is being created that our Government are anxious to uphold the Caballero junta in Spain. Evidence of that is to be found in the fact that a few days ago this Government sent their representative to the nearest point convenient to the city or town in which the Caballero Government is functioning at the moment. The Minister for Education said that one of the ambassador's functions there is to protect our nationals. That is a very desirable and necessary function. But does that mean that he only protects our nationals on the one side? What about our nationals on the other side —our nationals who were fighting on the side of Franco? Irish citizens who are fighting on the side of the Red Government in Spain are presumably to receive special treatment from the Free State ambassador. Are the interests of Irish nationals who are fighting on the side of Franco to be completely ignored?

Personally I cannot see that there was any necessity whatsoever to send any representatives to the so-called Government of Caballero in Spain. After all, whatever his functions may be, they must, of necessity, be very, very small. Certainly his presence there cannot be justified. The mere fact that we are sending some few hundredweights of eggs to Spain and selling them at a price less than the price of Chinese eggs in the British market is no argument for sending an ambassador to the Red junta in Spain. The Government are being placed, to a certain extent, in a very undignified position by the fact that a Bill of this character has been introduced and that an effort has been made to rush it through without giving the House an opportunity of discussing it properly or the country an opportunity of becoming acquainted with its contents. After all, we understood that the President was out for the complete and absolute independence of the country. Yet, in a matter of this kind, he has allowed himself to be dragged at the tail of one of the big nations. Surely that is not a very dignified position or a position which reflects credit on either the Executive Council or the State.

Comment on this

Great will be the disappointment in the Saorstát when the people realise that the London talks with the Dominions Secretary have brought forth nothing but this Bill. The hopes of the Irish people were raised when the President met the Dominions Secretary in London. They thought that there was going to be a settlement of the economic dispute.

Comment on this

I was wondering if that would not come in.

Comment on this

Even at that time, I heard prophecies that this would be the result. I did not think it was so, but it shows that there were some sane people in the country at the time. I am sure the people will be thoroughly disgusted to find that the only thing that happened at the London talks was that the President was convinced that he ought to put a stop to volunteers going out to help General Franco in Spain. When Deputy Donnelly was speaking, he reminded me forcibly of an incident which happened to myself at one time. It is rather a good story. I was coming from the opening of a Catholic mission at which there was a good sermon preached. I chanced to say to another person: "That was a very good sermon." His reply was: "It certainly was for anybody who wanted it." Deputy Donnelly told us that the Bishops' Pastorals made marvellous reading and that it could not be denied that they were great stuff. They were written deliberately and for a purpose but, apparently, they were not applicable to Deputy Donnelly or, as a matter of fact, to members of this House. We are exempt; we are above that. Deputy Donnelly I regard as a very honest man. I lay emphasis on "very." I am really sorry that he finds himself in the position in which he is, and I am likewise sorry for many of the other Fianna Fáil Deputies. I know they do not like the position in which they are —and no wonder. Deputy Donnelly tells us that the pastoral of the Cardinal which was quoted by Deputy Belton was a very admirable document, but was not applicable to the members of this House and should not be brought up here. Is the Deputy not very inconsistent in taking up that line? Take the people in the lanes and roads of the country. They read the Bishops' pastorals. Deputy Donnelly believes and feels they should be influenced by them. How much more ought the legislators be influenced by them, if they apply to them? I am sorry for Deputy Donnelly and I do not wonder at the mixed feelings there are in the Fianna Fáil Party about the Spanish war when we find that a well-informed Deputy, like Deputy Donnelly, has nothing to rely upon but an article from the Sunday Express. To me, that seems extraordinary in the case of Deputy Donnelly. If there is anybody in the House who ought not to take the British Press as the basis of truth so far as Catholicity is concerned, it ought to be Deputy Donnelly.

Comment on this

It is very anti-Red, as you know.

Comment on this

What I propose to quote now is not a pastoral letter, but it is a communication from a high Church dignitary of whom Deputy Donnelly has a very good opinion— Most Rev. Dr. Mannix. According to the Irish Independent of the 18/11/36 this is what Doctor Mannix said about the British Press and the situation in Spain:—

"I have always found that the sympathy of the British Press is on the side against the Catholic Church."

Further, he said:—

"I have never known any instance in which the British Press has taken our side and, in the troubles in Spain, the sympathies of the British Press are on the same side. The Press has been very consistent in its sympathies. It might be thought that the Press would be ashamed of what is happening in Spain but nothing will change it."

That is the opinion of Doctor Mannix on the Press from which Deputy Donnelly quoted to-day—the British Press. I advise Deputy Donnelly that, when he wants information regarding the Church or Catholicity or anything of that sort, he ought not to go to the British Press for it. We in this country have better traditions than the British Press has. The statement by the Minister for Education—it may have been a slip on his part—that this country had a perfect right, if it desired to do so, to take individual action was worth making. We had a perfect right to take individual action. The President, Deputy Thrift and Deputy MacDermot appeared to think that if this country did not take material action in this way, it would possibly lead to an outbreak of war. Does anybody seriously think that any material action we can take would have any effect, good, bad or indifferent, on the European situation? It will have no effect whatever and nobody believes that it will. Will any action of ours have a moral effect on the civil war in Spain? I say "yes." I say that action of ours on the moral side may have a very important effect in assisting the right side to win in Spain. We are afraid to take such action. That is the whole story. What appears to me to be really wrong in this matter is that the Government is not able to make up its mind. This country has been a great Christian country. So far as world affairs are concerned, outside Christianity we have never counted for anything and let nobody think we have. At the moment, we do not count for anything. So far as Christianity is concerned, we have counted for more than any other country. If you take any part of the world to-day and enumerate the people there on behalf of Christianity, you will find the Irish nation first. Are we ashamed of that?

We have been a great Catholic nation, and we are not ashamed of our traditions. Unfortunately, we have in this country at the moment two Parliament functioning. One Parliament has said that it is a Protestant Parliament for a Protestant people. I would not say that we here are a Catholic Parliament for a Catholic people. If you like, we are a Catholic Parliament for everybody, and to all we have shown fair play and equality. But we are not ashamed or afraid to say that the majority in this country are Catholics, and always have been Catholics. The unfortunate thing about Fianna Fáil is that they cannot make up their minds as to what is the right thing for the Government of this country to do. First of all, they ought to decide what effective action, if any, we can take, and what the effect of non-action would be as far as the Spanish war is concerned. The Minister for Education this evening repeated the President's statement last night. That statement was to the effect that the Government appeared to think that the war in Spain is a war between political-isms. If Deputy Donnelly and the people who sit with him have the respect for the Bishops' pastorals that the Deputy gave us to understand that he has, I think they should be convinced that it is not a matter of political-isms so far as Spain is concerned.

As Catholics, we must and do regard the Catholic Church as the greatest organisation in the world. When it speaks from the top it speaks with authority and with knowledge, and it does not speak without both. If the Cardinal Primate of Spain and the bishops of this country tell us that there is a certain position in Spain we know, at least, that they have knowledge of what they are talking about, and, speaking for myself, I do not want to go beyond that authority for conviction. In the first place, I have not the means of finding out the truth on these matters such as they have. If the Government here are able to convince themselves, or if they can be convinced by anybody, that the war in Spain is what the Pope, the Cardinal Primate of Spain and the bishops of this country have represented it to be, namely, a war against Christ by anti-Christ, what should their actions be, if they are convinced of that? As Deputy McGilligan pointed out, if they are not convinced of that, if they have some evidence which convinces them otherwise, then this House is entitled to get that evidence, and it is not fair to allow the people of this country to go astray while the Government have some evidence to offer which would put them on the right path. Deputy Jordan laughs, but I do not think it is a laughing matter.

Comment on this

It is, as far as the Deputy is concerned.

Comment on this

Deputy Jordan has his own Press at his disposal. I am sure it would be only too delighted to take his signature to a letter of any extent that he might wish to send to it, informing the bishops of this country where they are wrong, a letter which would convince us if it was able to convince the bishops. The Government must make up their minds as to whether or not this war is what it is represented to be. Apparently, they have not been able to do that. The Minister for Education said that the Government declines to commit the people of this country unnecessarily. If there is a war of anti-God against God, would the Irish people be unnecessarily committed on the side of God? Does anyone in this country, no matter what his religion, maintain that they would? Has it not always been a tradition with us in this country that we have always fought on the side of God, and that our ancestors have been martyred on that side? There is no country in the world that has suffered more for the Christian faith than this. With all that evidence, I wonder why it is that Fianna Fáil cannot make up their minds on this matter. I am perplexed and puzzled to know why they cannot.

The Minister for Education said that it was not desirable for the Irish representatives in the Non-Intervention Committee to take independent action. I wonder why. He said there was nothing to prevent them doing it. Suppose that the Irish representatives gave expression to the traditions of this Christian country and said they would withdraw our representative from Spain, a thing which they were quite entitled to do, what effect, I wonder, would that have on the other 26 nations represented there to which the Minister referred. The worst feature in all this was the statement of the President when moving the Second Reading of this Bill. He said that the people with whom he was connected on this Non-Intervention Committee previously were—he as much as told us this—people of bad faith who had already refused to carry out their obligations. We have no evidence that they are going to carry them out now either.

As far as geographical boundaries are concerned, we all know what the relations are between Spain and her neighbours. We know, too, what the relationship is between the Spanish Government and some of its neighbouring Governments, that is as far as the Spanish Government's inclinations are concerned. If we are going to prevent volunteers going from this country to fight for Spain, we ought to have some guarantee, beyond the word of people who have already let us down, that there will be an enforcement of obligations entered into on their part. There are times when people feel that the pride of race and ancestry and all that is simply hollow, and that the things we learned to be characteristic of those who went before us seem far away. This is one of the times when the Irish nation that had been so long struggling for its freedom, that thought it had found its feet, and that had found its feet, and that on the word of the President and the word of the Minister for Education had a perfect right to act individually, take its own action, and do anything it liked in this matter— this is the time when it had not the courage to do that and to do it in the cause for which our ancestors were martyred.

Now, I am convinced that the difference between the people on the far side of the House and the people on this side of the House is that we are convinced that the war in Spain is all that the Catholic authorities say it is. That is the difference. Believing that, we feel that the action that this House is taking to-day, in bringing in this Bill to prevent volunteers going to Spain while, at the same time, we have an accredited representative to the Red Government in Spain, is bringing disgrace on a great tradition that was in this country. When the Minister for Education said that no case had been made for the amendments, I do not think he really meant that, because every speaker who spoke on our side drew attention to the fact—and it wants no pushing beyond the mere mention of the fact— that we are convinced, and the majority of the people of this country are convinced, that the war in Spain is a war between the forces of God and the anti-God forces, and that we ought not to have a representative on the anti-God side. Now, if the President would simply think over what we might do in this country and what effect our actions on behalf of Christianity and the Christian forces fighting in Spain might have—what moral effect our actions might have on the world—because, mind you, we have had and still have considerable influence on the Christian world, though from a material point of view we are very small indeed—if he and his Party would consider what effect a decision of ours might have morally, and, perhaps, by reaction and repercussions, on the material end of the war in Spain, he would probably take a different line of action altogether.

The Minister for Education, of course, told us that Deputy MacDermot had certain views on this particular matter. Deputy MacDermot appears to be a godsend to the Fianna Fáil Party when they are in a hole. It does seem rather peculiar, however, that Deputy MacDermot should endeavour to set himself up in this House to tell the people of this country that there is no Communism in this country and that the tide of Communism is on the wane. I am sure Deputy Donnelly and myself are at one to this extent at least, that when we do want spiritual teaching we will not go to Deputy MacDermot. After all, I should much prefer taking into the House—which Deputy Donnelly objects to—even the Bishops' pastorals, and leaning on them for spiritual guidance rather than on Deputy MacDermot. Of course, Deputy MacDermot has a different opinion on Communism from what I have. His opinion is that Communism is entitled to be put forward freely on platforms all over the country. I do not agree with him at all on that. I never did agree with it. He, however, evidently thinks that that is right, and he evidently also thinks that Communism is on the wane, but the Catholic authorities do not think so, and I think that the greatest danger this country is in at the moment is to think that. We have not any guarantee whatever that in the future we will be free from the inroads of Communism, and particularly would we want to be afraid of that when we see how successful the propaganda has been even on the Government of the Irish Free State, because it has been. Either the Government of the Irish Free State, —the Fianna Fáil Party, if you like— believe that the war in Spain is what it is represented to be—that is, a religious war—or they do not believe it. If they do not believe that, they believe the Red propaganda. When it comes to the stage that people like the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, and the President, and Deputy Donnelly and all those other people are being got at by Red propaganda in that way, it looks very dangerous.

Comment on this

Bad-looking, all right.

Comment on this

There are times, however, when one would feel proud to be the successor of those that went before us, and there are times when one does not, and I am afraid that when the history of this country comes to be written in future years, the present period and the present incidents will not shine out on the records of Irish history and will not be creditable to Deputy Donnelly and the people who are taking up that attitude.

Comment on this

It seems to me, Sir, that there is one consideration which, in this legislative assembly or in any other legislative assembly in Europe, when one is called upon to consider anything relating to foreign politics to-day, should outweigh every other consideration, however important such might be in ordinary conditions, and that is the consideration of the preservation of peace in Europe. It is from that point of view that I should like to come to the consideration of the Bill and the amendments before the House, and I ask myself is the Bill likely to put any weight, however small, on the scale in favour of peace, or is it likely to put some weight on the scale, which endangers peace? I would ask the same questions as regards the two amendments. I notice that the members of the Opposition who have criticised the Bill, and supported one or other amendment, have not, as far as I could see, argued anything at all against the policy of the Government in regard to non-intervention. I take it, therefore, that their policy in that respect, in favour of non-intervention, is the same as it was two months ago when a somewhat similar issue was debated here. On that occasion, the Leader of the Opposition made this important statement (column 1197, Vol. 64):—

"I am not suggesting that we abandon the policy of non-intervention.... Of that policy we on this side of the House fully approve."

Although there were some observations made from the Front Opposition Bench to-day and yesterday which might seem to very a little from that statement, I do not think any definite change of policy has been announced in that regard, and so we may take it that the policy of the Opposition and the policy of the Government in regard to non-intervention are identical. The main question that concerns the House is whether that non-intervention should be made more effective or left in the admittedly rather ineffective way in which it has been left for months past.

Comment on this

The amendment. Come to the amendment.

Comment on this

I will come to that. I am not losing sight of it at all. The Government has proposed a Bill which, in agreement with the great majority of the Governments of Europe—I think, almost unanimously in agreement with the Governments of Europe—is believed to make the policy of non-intervention somewhat more effective. Admitting possible evasion, and admitting evasions that may have occurred in the past, the Opposition and Deputy Belton have put forward amendments which would tend to make that greater effectiveness, if it is to be greater effectiveness, conditional on certain actions which they press the Government to undertake. Taking the question, first, as to whether the Bill will make non-intervention more effective, one can only hope in that respect, and accept, as far as one may, the fact that a number of very competent people, with certain information not at the disposal of ordinary Deputies, like myself, have formed the deliberate opinion, after months of consideration, that such action as they propose would be more effective. It has been said that it does not make any difference whether this country joins in that action or not, that we are of no importance. On the other hand, it has been maintained that our moral example would be of great importance to the world.

I suggest that any falling away from unanimity amongst the nations in regard to non-intervention would weaken that policy and that, though our own action in the matter of the number of volunteers that would go from this country is not likely to make any great difference in the fortunes of war in Spain, the fact that there is any falling away, any schism in this unanimous opinion amongst the States of Europe, would weaken that policy and would provide a precedent for other countries which might be hesitating or thinking of falling away also. Instead of having a united policy which has hopes of being effective to some extent, we would have a policy of dissension and opposition amongst the nations of Europe in the next week or two. Small as our influence may be, the fact that we were dissidents might be a precedent for other nations to become dissidents also.

The curious suggestion has been put forward that we are so unimportant that we might do anything that no other nation dare not do, that our reputation for honesty and our dislike of buccaneering were such that we could send an expedition to Spain without in any way involving us in a suspicion of a desire to seize other people's territory. That has been put forward by Deputy Fitzgerald quite seriously a short time ago. The important consideration is not that the expedition we might send might do no great harm, but the fact that we were able to send an expedition might induce other countries, with far greater resources in men and arms, to follow our example. Our power is small and our influence may be small, but that does not take away from the responsibility of the judgment we have to form on behalf of the State here to-day.

I have been puzzled a good deal during the debate these last two days by various things, by a great deal of the discussion which seemed to me to be irrelevant to the issues raised either by the Bill or the amendment, but what has puzzled me more than anything else is the attitude, which at first was amazing to me, that the official Opposition has taken up in regard to this question of the Spanish war. I was puzzled first on the debate here on the adjournment a few months ago, and I have been more puzzled now to account for the determined policy they have adopted. They have adopted the theory that the present contest in Spain is a contest between Fascism and Communism. It seems to me that it is possible that there is no democracy on either side, but according to his own declared policy, General Franco is the declared enemy of democracy. The main line of his whole policy is to suppress democracy, a declaration that when he is in power over Spain there will be no democracy in that country for the next five years. There will be an absolute military dictatorship. It has puzzled me that members of the Opposition Front Bench should throw their weight on the side of a political leader in any country who adopts that line of policy. This country owes much to members of the Opposition, some who are with us and some who are gone, for establishing this country on a democratic basis at a time when the principles of democracy were being challenged by those who now rightly base their claim to exercise authority on the principles of democracy, but I cannot understand why members of the Opposition should have taken the line they have adopted on this particular question.

I agree with what has been said, and said forcibly by Deputy MacDermot this morning—that the question of the rights and wrongs of the dispute in Spain is not one on which this House is called to make up its mind. It is not one on which the Government has to make up its mind, or the President has to make up his mind. Every member of the House, every member of the community, is at liberty to form what opinion he thinks right as to the rights and wrongs of the dispute; but it is quite a different thing to suggest that it is the duty of the Government to represent the sum of the private opinions of the various members of the community in a matter which does not concern this community as a community or this State as a State. It seems to me that nothing can be more mischievous to the cause of peace at the present moment than that different States should follow the invitation given to this State to-day to ally itself on one side or another in the present dispute. If that invitation were accepted by this Government and by the Governments of other States, so that we should know what countries were backing each side in Spain, the peace of Europe would be seriously endangered.

I am not concerned, Sir, to express an opinion in favour of either of the contesting parties in Spain, or to express my sympathy with aims or objects of either party. If I confess freely that I do not know enough about the facts, I recognise that a number of perfectly honest and sincere statements have been made by people who have viewed the struggle from different sides and have formed definite opinions about it. Statements have been made which may be perfectly accurate. I am not in a position to question them. We have such statements made both by those who represent the Government in Spain and by those who represent the forces and the opinions marshalled behind General Franco. I do think it worth while, however, to draw attention to a number of assumptions, misrepresentations, and misunderstandings which appear in much of the arguments to-day. A great deal of these assumptions and misrepresentations have been linked with the use of nicknames, such as "Reds" and "Communists." General Franco was held up to us to-day by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney as a follower of Don John of Austria. We know that Don John fought the infidel, but General Franco has gone further and has brought in the infidel as an ally. I am not suggesting that General Franco is wrong; I am arguing against the suggestion that we should take any sides in this dispute. I am not prepared to take any sides and I do not, either in theory or practice. I am concerned that the House should not be misled by the use of nicknames which have no basis behind them. It seemed to me that misunderstanding, gross misunderstanding, has underlain a great deal of the argument to-day. We have been told that the war in Spain is a fight between Christianity and Communism. We have been told that it is a fight against the Reds, against Communism, and of theism against atheism. Deputy Dillon mentioned theism apparently to include the Moors, because he thought that all General Franco's followers could not be included under the Christian banner. Surely it must be patent to anybody that if this is a conflict between Christianity and Communism, between theism and atheism, it is not going to be settled by sword and bomb, it is a conflict that must be settled by human thought and human reason, and that so far from advancing any of these causes by taking up swords and bombs one is preventing any real solution of any of the problems involved.

We listened with great interest to most of the quotations read to us by Deputy Belton last night. In these documents, and in documents that we have been reading in the daily Press during the last few weeks, we are given the right advice as to how Communism should be combated, where it has to be combated—by taking away the abuses which were responsible for the growth of Communism and by meeting Communism fairly, reasonably, honestly and charitably in that way. The assumption that is underlying much of the arguments we have heard to-day, that taking up the sword or dropping the bomb is advancing the cause of Christianity or Communism, or for that matter any other cause such as theism or atheism, is absurd. These things have to be fought out with human reason and not by methods of murder and massacre.

There are only a couple of points in regard to this conflict in Spain that I would like to add to what I have already said. There are certain facts which stand out, which make it difficult for one to accept the ready labels which have been attached in the various discussions that have taken place. It is a fact that, somewhere about a year ago, a Government was constitutionally elected on democratic principles in Spain. It is a fact that in the Parliament so elected there were only 15 Communists out of a Parliament of 475. It is stated, and I think with truth, that that Government was not very effective in controlling abuses, that atrocities took place which it was not able to control. The fact is that there was a Government there appointed to carry out its duties, and I think it is for the people of Spain, and not for the people of this country, or any other country, to decide whether that Government carried out its duties or not.

The second fact is that that Government was attacked by an aristocratic junta. They may have been right. I do not question the right of people to go into rebellion if abuses are connived at by the existing Government. But the composition of the forces that constitute the insurgents, the composition of the forces that are behind General Franco, certainly raises one question. The occasion of his action raises another question. It has been said that the rebellion in Spain was undertaken because of the grave abuses that existed under what is nicknamed "the Red Government," a Government that contained no Communists. The fact, of course, is that the revolt began when that popular Government proceeded to make certain land reforms, proceeded to bring in an Act to distribute uncultivated land in order that it might be cultivated by the peasants. That aroused the anger of the landed proprietors, as it has aroused the anger of landed proprietors in other countries with which we are, perhaps, more familiar. That was the cause; it was not the burning of churches, the assaults on religious—not abuses of that sort, but interference with the property of the aristocrats. That is what started the trouble.

I would like to read a few extracts from a statement made by a very independent observer of high standing, one who probably is as familiar with the affairs of Europe as any man in Europe, Viscount Cecil of Chelwood, a man who certainly could not be suspected by anyone of sympathy with Communism or Bolshevism or even with the pink variety that Deputy Fitzgerald talks about. He is, moreover, a man who certainly could not be regarded as sympathetic with a deliberate attack on any recognised Church. Speaking in the House of Lords on the 26th November, the day before a debate on the same topic here, he used these words—they are taken from the Official Report of the Debates in the House of Lords—referring to the composition of the insurgent forces:—

"...there is at any rate the remarkable fact that the forces which seem to be fighting are not Spanish forces except in a very small degree. There is a very small section of Fascists fighting on behalf of General Franco, and the old Carlists are fighting. Those, as far as I can learn, are the only Spanish forces that he has at his command; the rest are the Foreign Legion and the Moors. That is what I am assured, and that if there are any other troops they are, at any rate, of such limited enthusiasm that they have not been put in the front line."

That is the army of civilisation led by General Franco.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Did he say anything about the Russians on the other side?

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

No, I thought he did not.

Comment on this

If Deputy Rice is suggesting that Lord Cecil is likely to be in sympathy with the Russians, he is suggesting something that will come as a surprise to Lord Cecil, if he reads it. I chose the words of Lord Cecil because I thought no more independent or well-founded observer could be chosen.

It seems to me that this House is not in a position to form any opinion as between the rights of the contesting parties in Spain. It seems to me, further, that even if it were in such a position, it would be a highly improper thing for it to do. I suggest we have no right to interfere in the domestic politics of any other country; that, however small our influence may be, we are endangering peace by any such meddling. Holding those views, I have no hesitation in supporting the Bill and voting against the two amendments. I thought it right to give my opinion and not to content myself with a silent vote on a matter on which every member of the House should form an independent opinion and should not allow himself to be led away by false nicknames, misrepresentation and misunderstanding.

Comment on this

I have very great admiration for Deputy Rowlette's sincerity and for his ability, but surely he cannot be serious when he suggests that this learned English lord is an authority upon events in Spain, or the composition of the forces and that he is unbiassed and unprejudiced when he sets out to give a description of the forces engaged on both sides and he merely gives a description of one? With all due respect to the Deputy, we have had authorities quoted here to-day which I am prepared to accept before the learned lord. I would much rather accept the view of the Cardinal Primate of Spain as being impartial than any other person who has yet been quoted—and I am accepting that view. I do not wish to say much on this Bill, but it surprises me in many ways. Some years ago the present Government, when in Opposition, were shocked at the rushing through of a Bill that they said was going to infringe the rights of certain people in this country. But that Bill had to pass through two Houses. We are now going to put one through which gives just as much if not more far-reaching powers than even that Bill gave because it is not only retrospective, but even after it has ceased to be in force people can still be punished for something that took place either before or while it was in operation.

The President, in introducing the Bill, was hardly fair to himself or to the Irish people. He said that the main object of the Bill was to end the war quickly—that the Irish people had no regard to how it ends. That is not so. We are deeply interested as to how it is going to end. I believe that the President also is interested in how it is going to end. I do not charge him with being anxious that the Red Government in Spain should succeed. Deputy Rowlette told us that Deputies on these benches had done much for democracy and that democracy is a very high ideal—that it is the highest ideal. That is untrue. It is not the highest ideal. It is true that it is a very high ideal, but there is one higher, and considerably higher. I repudiate the right of any Government to deny me the right of freedom of conscience, whether that Government be the most democratic that can be elected or not. As far as I am concerned, as an ordinary plain Irishman, not much of a Catholic perhaps, but the best I can be, I will resist by every means at my disposal any attempt to interfere with my right to exercise freedom of conscience and to exercise the creed in which I believe.

The people of this country have shown in no uncertain way where their sympathies lie. Deputies may sneer at Deputy Belton and at the Christian Front movement as they like, but this is true, that the people of the country flocked to it and are flocking to it simply because it has as its object the helping of the wounded in Spain on one particular side and the maintenance or strengthening of Christianity in this country and, as far as it could, all over the world.

Under this Bill, the simple virtue of charity cannot be exercised by sending ambulances with certain first-aid units to Spain except under licence from the Minister for Justice. It is in keeping with the whole Fianna Fáil policy of interference with everything that they should not interfere in. To come down to ordinary mundane matters, you cannot get a half-stone of Indian meal without a licence. That is their whole mentality, their whole policy. Why should Red Cross units not be excluded from this Bill? Why has the Minister for Justice to be brought in to allow people to perform an act of charity? There is no question, as I have said, that the overwhelming majority of the Irish people, whether Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Labour, regard General Franco as the defender of Christianity and Catholicism in Spain, even though he has Moors to assist him. When Queen Elizabeth's hordes were cutting off the heads of our people here, if Moors or anybody else could have been got to assist this country at that time they would have been welcomed. During the civil war period, when we were in a certain position we were told we must be wrong because we had ex-British soldiers, ex-Unionists, or some people like that, to help us. The very fact that we had them to help us meant that we were wrong! That is nonsense. If men are prepared to give their lives for any cause we should give them the benefit of the doubt—give them the credit of doing what they think is right at any rate.

I do not think I should let this opportunity pass without saying something in reply to Deputy MacDermot's references to General O'Duffy. I hold no brief for General O'Duffy but I will say this: that when this country needed the services of General O'Duffy he did a man's part. If people like Deputy MacDermot sneer at what he did then or now I think that it ill-becomes Deputies to let it pass, no matter on which side of the House they sit.

Whether we approve of General O'Duffy's actions or not, we must recognise that he has organised and succeeded in getting to Spain a certain number of Irishmen. Personally, I thought he would not be able to do it. We must pay tribute to the fact that he has done it and that he has organised it well. The least we can say of his brigade is: "May it uphold the glories and honours of this country while it is in Spain." Deputy MacDermot says that if General O'Duffy's military abilities are only equal to his statesmanship as a politician, he does not hope for much results. I think I can leave that alone. It hardly requires any comment. But I think it was insolent and cheeky on the part of Deputy MacDermot to make a statement like that about General O'Duffy and men of his type in the Parliament of the Irish nation that they helped to establish.

We are told that the amendment does not make any difference, that the appointment of an ambassador or a Minister to a Government does not give recognition to that Government or show that we support it. I should like to ask members of the Fianna Fáil Party, and particularly those in the Government, when the first Minister was appointed to the Irish Free State, what resolution was passed by them? What telegrams did they send to the American Minister when he arrived here? What were their views as to the recognition of the Cosgrave administration, as they called it, then? Why have they changed so rapidly in their opinion about what sending a Minister to a Government means? At that particular time they were very clear and definite about it. Now it does not mean anything. It does not mean recognition of that Government; it only means recognition of that people. Did they not see that then, or has there been a conversion?

If we have committed ourselves to the policy of non-intervention, while I do not say that we should go back on our word, I submit that the sending of a representative or a Minister back to Spain recently, even though he is a distance away from it, is giving a wrong impression not only of the people but, in my opinion, of the Government. The Government is not fair to itself when it does that, and in accepting the amendment they will be doing something which will make the matter clear beyond all doubt. I am sure that the President does not wish Communism to succeed. I am sure he admits that General Franco should not be denied support because he happens to have Moors and others amongst his forces. The best way to show his own, and the Irish people's place in this struggle, is for the President to accept the amendment. I do not want to make any political capital out of this matter, and I am perfectly satisfied that no member of my Party wants to do so.

That brings me again to protest— although I hardly think a protest is necessary—against Deputy MacDermot's phrase, "cashing in on Christianity." I know thoroughly well that Fianna Fáil would prefer if Deputy MacDermot were on this side of the House when he talks in that way, because I see the pleasure Fianna Fáil would have if the Deputy used such phrases from these benches. That would be certainly something they would "cash in" on. I would not blame them if they did. In my opinion, this is a situation in which there should be no political "cashing in"; it is one in which we should do what we think is the right thing. I believe firmly in my heart that if we pass this Bill without the amendment, it will show to the world that we are more in favour of the Caballero Junta than the other side: that we accept the point of view put forward here this evening by Deputy MacDermot, Deputy Rowlette and people who think like them, as against the information conveyed to this country by the Cardinal Primate of Spain. I will not do that. I am going to accept the statement of the Cardinal as against anybody else, and I ask the Dáil to agree with me.

Comment on this

We heard from Deputy Rowlette, who represents Dublin University, a very extraordinary speech. I may say that extraordinary as that speech was, there is this much to be said about Deputy Rowlette that, at least, he had the decency and the manhood to get up in this House and tell it what way he was going to vote on this measure, and on the amendments. This debate began at 8.30 p.m. last night, was resumed at 10.30 this morning and has been in progress all day, yet, apart from the cursory opening by the President, one short speech from a back-bencher, and a contribution later in the day from the Minister for Education, we have had no assistance, good, bad or indifferent, as to what view the Government really takes of Deputy O'Sullivan's amendment as a condition for giving the Bill a Second Reading. Deputy Rowlette had the decency to tell us what his views were. He said that he had not fully gone into the facts of the case, and that he had not studied them sufficiently to be able to come to a conclusion as to which side in the conflict in Spain was right or wrong.

I do not believe that the Deputy meant that, because it was clear as he proceeded that he had extraordinarily definite views on the question as to who was right in the Spanish conflict. There was absolutely no doubt that the Deputy had made up his mind that he was anti-Franco, whatever else he was. That emerged clearly from his speech. I should like to ask the President if it is his intention to reply at all on this debate, or to make any further contribution to it.

Comment on this

If I am given time, I certainly shall.

Comment on this

Then I will not be responsible for the President not having time to reply. When he is replying I should like him to tell the House where Fianna Fáil really stands on this question, and what opinion they hold about the conflict raging in Spain. In his opening statement the President said that he had no doubt at all about where the sympathies of the Irish people lay, but not many weeks ago we had it from the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, that there was a fight going on in Spain between the forces of democracy and Fascism, and that Fianna Fáil had no use for Fascism. Is that the President's view or is it the view of the Fianna Fáil Party?

Comment on this

I would like to see that quotation.

Comment on this

I have not got the quotation here, but the President knows that it was used in the course of the debate.

Comment on this

The Irish Press of August 3rd, 1936.

Comment on this

I suppose the views of the Fianna Fáil Party have changed since the 3rd of August. Is that the President's point?

Comment on this

The Deputy will not make any points, no matter how long he speaks, except empty ones.

Comment on this

I will give the Deputy a full opportunity of making his points in a few moments. He will have the opportunity of making them in an orderly way, and of behaving himself. I would like to find out from the President, who is the proper person to inform the House on a matter of this kind, what the views of the Fianna Fáil Party are about this Spanish conflict.

Is he of opinion that the majority of the Irish people believe—as I think they do believe—that the Franco forces are the forces of Christianity, and that the forces opposed to them are the forces of Communism and irreligionism? Does the President take the view that the forces of Franco are forces which should be supported by the majority of the people of this country? Is he of the view that they are, in fact, supported by the majority of the people of this country? If he is, why is he hiding behind a smoke-screen which he himself has created for the purpose of evading an answer to that question? Where does the Fianna Fáil Party stand in this matter? We have had no reference, good, bad or indifferent, either from Deputy Donnelly or from the Minister for Education, as to why they will not accept the amendment proposed by Deputy Professor O'Sullivan. We are discussing here three things at the moment. We are, first of all, discussing the Non-Intervention Bill. Of course, that has the support, I take it, of the whole House, except, perhaps, that of Deputy Belton. I take it that we are all agreed that there should be non-intervention in the Spanish civil war. Deputy Professor O'Sullivan put forward an amendment that before giving this Bill a Second Reading we should break off relations with the Madrid Government. Now, what does that mean? It means simply this, that the majority of the people of this country have made up their minds that the Madrid Government represents the forces of Communism, of Bolshevism and of anti-Godism, and that this country as a Catholic and Christian country—do not call it a Catholic country if you do not like; call it a pro-God country—will not any longer have any relations with that Government of Spain constituted as it is at present. That is the simple issue raised by the amendment put forward by Deputy Professor O'Sullivan.

What is the President's view on that? He is apparently of opinion, in view of his intended rejection of this amendment, that we should go on recognising this Government; that, notwithstanding the fact that the majority of the people of this country have made up their minds long ago as to the merits of the dispute that is going on in Spain, we should continue to give recognition to this anti-God Government. That is the only meaning that I can see which can possibly be given to the Government's attitude on this amendment of Deputy Professor O'Sullivan. Will the President tell us, when he is replying, whether in fact it is his view that the conflict which is at present going on in Spain is simply a conflict, as he himself said, between "isms."

Comment on this

How often more will I have to draw attention to the fact that I did not say that in the way in which it has been misrepresented?

Comment on this

I was in the House when the President said it. The President said that this was merely a war between two different "isms."

Comment on this

And I deny that I said that.

Comment on this

Well, I will say this: I may be wrong perhaps in putting in a comma or a semi-colon, but that in substance was the phrase which the President did use.

Comment on this

And I read out last night from the Official Reports—if the Deputy was interested he could find it—what I did say.

Comment on this

That it was a dispute between "isms."

Comment on this

I am reminded by the President's interruption of a point which the Vice-President made here a short time ago. I think you, Sir, will allow me to make this point by way of analogy. We on this side of the House were referring to the fact that the Government had promised full de-rating to the farmers of this country. That point had been made several times on this side of the House and the Vice-President had shaken his head. When he stood up to reply he made this point; he said, "When we went to the country we told them that £2,000,000 would be available for de-rating. We only said it would be available; we did not say it would be availed of." That was the point which the Vice-President wanted to make, and about which he was shaking his head. I think the President's point now about his "isms" and the way in which he put it, is precisely on all fours with that point. The President made it perfectly clear here last night that his view was that this was merely a war between Fascism and democracy.

Comment on this

And once more I deny that I either said it or that it is my view.

Comment on this

I repeat that the President, in substance, made the point here last night——

Comment on this

And again I deny that the President said it in substance.

Comment on this

Let me finish my sentence.

Comment on this

The truth is very hard.

Comment on this

Lies are very hard.

Comment on this

I depend on my own hearing for having got the substance of it at least. I may not be right in the actual words I used, but the President made the point that the conflict at present going on in Spain was a conflict between one "ism" and the other.

Comment on this