Spanish Civil War (Non-Intervention) Bill, 1937—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 289–441 of 441. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 4 of 1937 ›
Will the President tell us, Sir, when he is replying, what he considers the conflict in Spain to be?
Comment on this
He will not repeat himself, of course. He will not tell us, when he is replying, what he considers the conflict that is going on in Spain really is.
Comment on this
The Deputy need not be a prophet. He is as likely to be mistaken in his prophecies as he is in his recollections.
Comment on this
I am not going to make any prophecies about the President. I should be a very rash man to do that. If I were to prophecy that he would adhere to the proposition that two and two make four I would be an extremely rash man, having on several occasions witnessed his efforts to make it five.
Comment on this
The President is always speaking of the aspirations of the Irish people. We are always being told by the President—that is, of course, since 1926—that what the majority of the people want is something which they must get. He told us here in the Dáil last night that there is no doubt whatever as to where the sympathy of the majority of the Irish people is at present. Now, I would ask the President to clarify this point at least? Of course, if I make a statement now that when he said that he meant that the sympathy of the majority of the Irish people is with General Franco, I may be met with an immediate rebuttal; so I will not say that. I will simply ask the President to tell us where he thinks the sympathy of the majority of the Irish people is. But merely assuming, for the purpose of argument, that when he said that he meant that their sympathy was with General Franco in the conflict which is at present going on, why does he not do what the majority of the Irish people must want as a corollary to that, namely, the breaking off of relations with the Government which is opposed to General Franco?
I will tell you now, as a last word, what I think is the true reason for all this obstinacy in this matter. It is something, of course, over which the President will develop a broad grin when I say it, but it is really at the root of this matter. Our paths have undoubtedly parted at some point. There are people on that side of the House at the moment who take the view that relations with Spain should not be broken off. I have seen them laugh several times during the course of the day when it was suggested that their sympathies were anywhere except with General Franco. For instance, when Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney suggested that their sympathies were with the Reds there was loud laughter. I take it that that was laughter of derision. Perhaps I am wrong in that again, but I assume that for the moment to save myself from further interruption. I was saying that our paths have undoubtedly parted. We take the view that relations should be broken off. We have always adhered to that view. The Fianna Fáil Party, apparently, takes the view that relations should not be broken off. If you go back along the line from the points at which we now find ourselves, and try to find where the pathways did part, it is extremely difficult to find it, because you have got to go back almost to the outbreak of the Spanish civil war. I will tell you where you will find it. You will find it is the attitude of the Irish Independent towards this civil war. They took the view that Franco was right, and immediately the Irish Press, true to form, took the opposite view. That is the only real explanation of the antagonism of the Government to the forces of Franco at the moment.
Comment on this
I agree with the observations made by Deputy MacEoin as to Deputy Rowlette's speeches in this House. I have listened to him on a number of occasions, and I have listened to him with great pleasure. I was amazed, as Deputy MacEoin was, in listening to his speech this evening. I have heard him make speeches before, and express views with which I disagreed, but that did not prevent me from admiring the speeches he made, but, as I say, I was amazed at the speech he made this evening. He told us that we should not make up our minds as between one side and the other in this Spanish struggle, and if there was one thing apparent in Deputy Rowlette's speech, it was that not only had he made up his mind, but that he had made up his mind with a blind prejudice in favour of one side against the other. He asked us if this Bill, or these amendments, were likely to bring any weight into the scale in favour of peace, and he said he did not think they were. I do not think they are either, but there is a spiritual value in things which this nation has always had regard to, and the spiritual value in this case is, whether we are able to help or whether we are not, that we, the Irish people, should be on the side of religion, Christianity and justice, as against Communism and the policy of the Reds in Spain and in Europe.
Deputy Rowlette quoted that very eminent gentleman, Lord Cecil, and if I were not speaking in the Parliament of the Irish people I might express in plain English my opinion of that eminent member of the House of Lords. I am not going to do so. He quoted him as saying that it was very difficult to test the composition of the Franco forces—that there was a very small section of Fascists and Carlists among them, and that the others were foreign legionaries and Moors. In answer to a question from me, he informed me that the statement as to the composition of the Franco forces made by Lord Cecil was not accompanied by any statement as to the composition of the forces on the other side. He told the House that General Franco has brought in the infidel as his ally. He is referring, of course, to the Moors.
I should like to know if Deputy Rowlette was given the choice of associating with a Moor, who believes in God and worships God, or associating with the Russian Reds, what would be his choice. I should like the Deputy to tell us what his choice would be. Would he associate with the Russian Bolshevists, who not only have no religion themselves, but refuse to allow their fellow-citizens to have any religion, and who refuse to allow the children in their country to worship God? Would the Deputy prefer association with these gentlemen to association with the Moors, who say there is no God but God, and Mohammed is his prophet? They worship the same God as we do and they believe that the great prophet of God was Mohammed. The Irish people believe in Christ, but the Moors worship the same God as we do. The Russian Bolshevist, whom Deputy Rowlette passes over with charitable silence this evening, worships no God at all.
Deputy Rowlette has told us that we should not make up our minds between the two sides. I think there is a great deal of force in that argument, and, personally, I must say that for a very considerable time after this struggle in Spain began, I refrained, on reading the propaganda of both sides, from making up my mind until something definite happened that enabled me to make up my mind. I am aware, and we are all here aware, that it is a tradition of the leaders of our Church to be extremely conservative in expressing opinions on events that happen. They do not take sides unless they feel they are compelled to express opinions, and they certainly do not issue statements without having verified them to the fullest extent. I was able, then, to make up my mind when the Cardinal Primate of Spain and other Church authorities expressed views on this subject, because I was satisfied that these eminent dignitaries would not express an opinion without having completely satisfied themselves as to the facts on which their information was based. I see on the other side a statement quoted by reputable authorities, news agencies, as to the views of President Caballero, and President Caballero certainly has a very nice dislike for clerics of every description and has certainly shown a firm determination that he is going to have nothing to do with them, and that Spain is going to have nothing further to do with them, if he wins in this struggle.
I would have thought, too, that Deputy Rowlette, before he formed his views on this subject, and before he took sides in such a definite and partisan way with the Reds, might have been influenced by the opinion, for instance, of people around him. I have the honour of knowing as personal friends a very large number of our people who are co-religionists of Deputy Rowlette. I have not found a single one of them to express the views I have heard him express here to-night on this subject.
I would have thought too, that Deputy Rowlette might have been influenced in forming an opinion as to the rights and wrongs of this struggle in Spain by considering the kind of people who went out there from our own community to fight for the Reds. Who were they who did go there to fight for the Reds? A number of people who are known in this country as notorious Communists went out to fight and are fighting on the side of the Reds in Spain. Was it hatred of the Moors that brought them there? Was it love for democracy that brought them there? They are there anyway, and Deputy Rowlette might have taken that fact into account before he made up his mind. The Deputy told us that the struggle in Spain is caused by the division or the proposal to divide uncultivated land. Now that is a very nice expression, and I must say that Deputy Rowlette is very innocent when he uses such an expression. I am not doubting his sincerity. But when he quotes for us a statement that the civil war in Spain was caused because the Government that contained only ten Communists proposed to divide the uncultivated land, I suggest to him that any person who swallows that story is indeed a very innocent person.
Comment on this
I did not say that was the cause of the civil war. I said it was the occasion of the outbreak of the civil war. That is an historical fact.
Comment on this
I am not good at logic, but I must confess that I see small distinction and little difference between the two statements. Whether you call it the cause of the outbreak or the occasion of the outbreak of the civil war in Spain does not make very much difference. I think the ordinary man in the street will not quibble very much as to whether you call it the cause or the occasion of the civil war. I think the ordinary man in the street, on hearing what the Deputy has said, would say that Deputy Rowlette had said that the war was started by the proposal to divide uncultivated land. I agree with the view that I think Deputy Rowlette was putting forward when he said that the passing of this Bill or adopting this amendment, is not going to weigh down the scales on either side in Spain very greatly in either direction. But I do think that that is not the consideration that ought to weigh with us in determining what our attitude on this question should be.
I doubt very much if the members of the Government Party would maintain that the great majority of the people of this country are not in favour of the view that we on this side of the House are taking. Non-intervention, of course, is highly desirable. Non-intervention means neutrality. Are we showing complete neutrality and impartiality, as between the two parties who are contending in Spain, when we recognise the Bolshevic Government which is carrying on the anti-Christian war in Spain? We recognise that Government by having our representative there. There is no use in drawing distinctions that it is the Spanish people we are recognising. We are not recognising the Spanish people, because three-fourths of the territory of Spain at the present time is under the occupation of General Franco's forces and supporters.
I do not want to fall into the error that Deputy Rowlette has fallen into of accepting everything I read from the news agencies, but there is some reason for the belief, at all events, that if it were not for the highly efficient, up-to-date equipment furnished to the Bolshevic Government in Spain by Russia, that struggle in Spain would have been over long ago. But we, by our recognition of the Red Government, take sides against General Franco and the people of Spain who are behind him. Dr. Rowlette has told us that General Franco is going to do away with democracy in Spain for a period of five years. He is going to do away with democracy in Spain, not only for five years, but for ever, so long as you define "democracy" as the Red Government and their present supporters in Spain. There is no use in attaching labels to people and calling them democrats and calling other people something else. The Red Government in Spain and their Party and supporters describe themselves as democrats. Therefore, when General Franco says he is going to get rid of these fellows, Deputy Rowlette tells us that he is going to get rid of democracy.
Comment on this
That is what he said himself, not I. I quoted General Franco.
Comment on this
I know the Deputy did. General Franco is going to get rid of the kind of democracy they have at the present moment in that part of Spain that he is not occupying. As General MacEoin said here this evening, this is a matter out of which no political capital should be made. I think the Government and the Opposition ought to rise to something better than that. I think we ought to remember the traditions of this people as a Christian nation—I refuse to accept the more limited word Catholic. We ought to remember our traditions, and if we do remember our traditions there is only one thing we can do and that is to dissociate ourselves from the rabble who are ruling the eastern part of Spain under the name of a Government.
Comment on this
I, for one, approach this matter with very considerable diffidence. There has been a number of things said here to which it is imperative we should give our personal reprobation. To these some things said here to-day I wish to give a flat and absolute denial. They are things that have nothing at all to do with the Bill before the House. I sat here—and to my amazement I heard Deputy MacDermot charge the Party to which I belong—and this is one of the reasons why I intervene in this debate—with cashing in on Christianity. For myself, at all events, since the very first day of this unfortunate conflict in Spain I have never had such a thought in my mind and I treat the statement of the Deputy with the most absolute contempt. I believe that there is nothing more tragic than civil war in any country. I think outside people should scrupulously avoid any interference. I again characterise the charge made by Deputy MacDermot, against myself, for example, of cashing in on Christianity, as a gross lie. I resent that charge and I resent it so much that I cannot find language adequate to give expression to that resentment.
I was astonished at the amazing statement made by Deputy Rowlette that this is a fight between democracy on the one hand and Fascism on the other hand, implying thereby that the Party to which I belong has ceased to be democratic. I wish to tell Deputy Rowlette and anybody who thinks with him that, so far as I am concerned, this Party is entirely democratic. But I would a thousand times prefer to see the Party to which I belong entirely abolished and driven out of public life than to think for one moment I would be associated with or give countenance in any way to a Party that was attempting to cash in on Christianity. Deputy Rowlette has, I am sure, gone much more deeply into this question than his speech would lead one to believe. If this were a question merely of democracy versus Fascism, I should not trouble about it. That would be a domestic matter for the people of Spain. But the issue in Spain is not democracy versus Fascism. Whether the camarilla in authority is called Fascist or democratic, I am not concerned to inquire. I do not mind what political labels parties or individuals attach to one another in Spain. A few days ago I opposed in this House action by this Government by which we would be bound by an international agreement which the other parties could ignore when it suited them. Is this Bill going to be enforced? It is farcical to suggest that, when this Bill becomes law, we can enforce it. It is just as farcical as was the position in regard to the Bill I opposed last week. Whatever Government is concerned it will not be able to enforce this Bill. There is nothing more scandalous, in my opinion, in the record of international politics than the behaviour of the parties to the international agreement which was arrived at by the Non-Intervention Committee.
This Government honestly and bona fide entered into that pact and observed it. Having regard to the behaviour of the other parties to that pact, the Government should tell them that they can take what action they like but that they will not fool them any more. That non-intervention pact was religiously observed by us but it would be a waste of time to comment on the manner in which it was treated by the other signatories.
My action on this Bill is not influenced by the alleged issue of Fascism versus democracy; it is dictated by quite another consideration. There is only one issue involved in Spain and that is Christianity or Atheism, by which I describe Communism. It is known that our representative in Spain was recalled. I understand that he has been here for some months. Knowing what has happened, one would expect that when he was here he would have been kept here. When he was in Spain, I admit it was rather difficult to recall him but if I were head of a Government I would recall him. If he were here, and if I had his reports before me, I certainly would have kept him here. But he has been sent back. Where and to whom? It would take a long time to trace the philosophy which brought about the present position of affairs in Spain. Deputy Rowlette tells the House that the raison d'être of the conflict in Spain is the division of land. How innocent. It reminds me of the attitude of the British Government. They say: “feed both sides of the conflict with food, arms, money and ammunition and let them fight there but do not let them come near England.” I feel rather cynical about the speech of Deputy Rowlette. Deputy MacDermot held up Lord Robert Cecil as a model to this House. The Cecil family are amongst the chief families who have kept the peoples of the world at one another's throats for England's purposes. The Cecils are the mainspring of British foreign policy. They are the chief influence in British foreign policy, the Church of England and the Government of England. Down through the ages, Lord Robert Cecil's ancestors have gathered and turned hordes of savages upon the Christian peoples of the world. I was surprised to hear a learned gentleman like Deputy MacDermot quoting Lord Robert Cecil as a model for this House. Deputy Rowlette is shocked at the idea of the Moors fighting anywhere. I wonder would he be shocked if the Moors were fighting on the side of Caballero. Did he inquire as to the antecedents of the persons against whom the Moors are fighting? There would be easy proof as regards the antecedents of this band of gentlemen which calls itself a government and at whose court our representative is to appear. Have the Government made any inquiry as to the composition of this camarilla? One gentleman and 14 of his supporters have been Cabinet Ministers in Spain since the inauguration of the civil war. It is solely due to the revolutionary power that he exercises that 14 of his nominees have been Cabinet Ministers. This gentleman operated as a croupier in a gambling house. I do not know much about gambling houses but I think that the croupier is the type of gentleman who puts the pea under the thimbles. He lost that position. But, apparently, he lost that position and had to become knocker-out of this gambling house.
Comment on this
When I state that, Deputies will appreciate how bad his reputation had become. In Spain he fought, I think, seven duels, but so bad did his reputation become in Spain that the Spanish people, or a considerable portion of them, turned against this gentleman and he had to get away to South America. After some considerable time there he returned and settled in Catalonia. He got a broad-rimmed hat for himself with some ribbons indicating what the national colours in Spain are. He got a huge wide pair of pants which he had striped with the national colours. I want to give Deputies a full description of this gentleman. He also grew a very pronounced moustache.
Comment on this
I am. This may appear trivial, but I want to give the House some idea of the character of the people involved in this, and a picture of this gentleman.
Comment on this
He then burst forth as a leader, as a Spanish patriot in Catalonia. He had all the elements to play on that go to the making of a demagogue. Apparently he was an astute enough psychologist to know that he was stepping into the midst of a spirit that was abroad, plus the activities and propaganda and the vast sums of money spread by Russia. He had the ground well prepared for him. The waves were, so to speak, coming in behind him, until in the end he became a hero. This was the gentleman who was a croupier in a gambling house. Having lost that position he became the knocker-out in it, and afterwards became notorious fighting duels. So bad was his reputation that he had to flee from Spain to South America, from which he returned after some considerable time. I have given the House his history. On his return to Spain he became a member of the Cabinet, and so great was his power, apparently, in the country that fourteen of his nominees became Cabinet Ministers.
If the war in Spain was a domestic matter it would not annoy me very much, but I submit to the House that it is not. It was this gentleman and about half a dozen others who brought about the present condition of affairs in Spain. I say emphatically that the real cause of the civil war in Spain, despite all that Deputy Rowlette has said, did not arise in Spain. The civil war in Spain is mainly and directly due to Russia. We had Lord Robert Cecil quoted to us by Deputy McDermot. I do not know of anything more debasing than the conduct and history of the Cecils in foreign affairs. It is almost impossible to conceive anything more contemptible than their conduct in that sphere. I think that any Irishman who has any respect either for himself or the past history of his country should not mention the name of Cecil in this House.
The Cecils belong to a nation which, 20 years ago, gathered up all the blacks and yellows and greens in the shape of human beings that they could find all over the world and brought them to France to fight in the name of small nationalities. The Cecils and the nation they belong to did their best to throttle this country when striving for the achievement of her national aspirations. In spite of all that we had Deputy MacDermot quoting the Cecils as models for us. He wants us to approve of the Cecils, while making an attack on General O'Duffy. I think that all the members of this House, irrespective of what side they sit on, are well aware of the national record of General O'Duffy. He was a man that I did not know until he joined this Party. I did not know him in the way that I have known Deputy Donnelly. I know him for the last 20 or 25 years, but I did not get to know General O'Duffy until long after he had joined this Party. But this has been a principle with me in my private and public life: that if I know a man, irrespective of the country or Party he belongs to, and particularly if he is a brother Irishman, I will not allow anybody to traduce him or defame him. If, for instance, Deputy MacDermot were to make an attack on an opposing Deputy I would not allow him to do it if I could prevent him. We have the Cecils paraded before us for our admiration. It can be said of General O'Duffy that with men sitting on both sides of this House he did his part in winning national freedom for the country, and he and they did that in spite of the Cecils.
Deputy MacDermot says that we are cashing in on Christianity and asks us why we do not take our philosophy from the Cecils. There is one thing that I do want to tell the President, and it is this: that the country expects the Government to cut adrift from the Spanish junta. I am speaking in this debate lest my silence might be misunderstood in my constituency. There is no thinking man in the country, lay or clerical, who has any doubt as to the issue involved in this war in Spain. I want to pay this compliment to the Caballero junta that what is going on in Spain to-day is not really due to them but to Moscow. Moscow got its propaganda across, and when this war broke out everyone was shocked and horror-stricken and sympathised with Spain, that great old nation which was being rent and ravaged by a civil war, but everybody could see what was involved then. On the world side, if you like, it was an anarchist junta that got hold of the Government and overthrew the constitutional Government there, and the present Government there is no more a representative or elected Government of Spain than I am the Government of Spain.
The world saw that it was a revolutionary junta there that got control, and world opinion, in the main, was against that junta; but then the junta in Spain, assisted by the Russian Ambassador there, plus the assistance they got from Russia, with the active assistance of their propaganda, enabled them successfully to put it across the world that the issue now is the issue that Deputy Rowlette and Deputy MacDermot would ask this House to believe, and that is that it is Fascism on the one side and democracy on the other. Let me repeat to this House that that is not the issue in Spain. I want to see General Franco win.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would allow me to correct him, I want to remove altogether from his mind the idea that I suggested that the issue in Spain was between Fascism and democracy, or even between Fascism and Communism.
Comment on this
Well, I was certainly sitting very calmly here, and I certainly understood that that was Deputy MacDermot's thesis. If that was not so, I very gladly and very willingly withdraw.
Comment on this
Is it not clear what issue is being fought out in Spain? Is it not easy to see why the outbreak occurred in Spain and why it occurred at the particular time it did? Had the outbreak succeeded in Spain, what would be the position in Western Europe to-day? The magazine was quite ready to be fired in France. It would be absolutely impossible to pre vent it spreading to Portugal, and the whole of Western Europe would now be caught in the meshes of a civil war. So far as this conflict has been confined to the borders of Spain, I am very glad, and if our participation in this pact has rendered any assistance in the confining of the conflict to the borders of Spain, I am very glad, but I say that we add nothing material to it. I say that the way in which these Powers, having got the head of this Government to join them in a pact, have behaved since, is a scandal. They openly, barefacedly, and unabashedly, threw all their forces from one side to the other. How does the President mean to suggest to this House that, so far as he is concerned or in so far as the citizens of this State are concerned, that pact will be enforced or the agree ment will be enforced? Does anybody think that France and Russia, on the one hand, will not continue to put, down through Portugal or otherwise, all the resources at their command to assist the Red Government, or, on the other hand, does anybody deceive themselves to the extent of believing that Hitler and Mussolini will not throw all the resources at their command on to the side of General Franco?
This Bill is rather vague, so far as the definition clauses in it are concerned, and so far as doing anything outside this country is concerned. It is quite possible that I would not have intervened in this debate at all had it not been for a sectional clause here. Whether it was meant or not, or whether it was put in by an oversight—and I expect that the President, as Minister for External Affairs, is better informed on this matter than the House is, and certainly better informed on the matter than I am—it is clearly admitted or implied in this definition section that there are two Governments in Spain. The clause I refer to says that the word "belligerent" means one of the Governments, or organisations in the nature of Governments, between whom the war is being waged. The clear implications of that are that there are two Governments in Spain. As I say, I do not know whether that was meant or not, or whether it is the intention to permit it to remain in the Bill, but I certainly think that if the President is going to allow our representative to remain there as representative of anybody, and certainly accredited to some Government, the singular should be used there and not the plural, because I think that, if there are two Governments there, we should send representatives to both or to neither of them. I do not think we can logically justify ourselves there, while the Government at the same time claims it is non-partisan in this matter.
The whole philosophy of Communism is being fought in Spain. The question of the land, the division of land, the ownership of property, has passed completely out of the matter. I felt rather stung by the insinuation or the implication in Dr. Rowlette's statement when he referred to the division of land and the question of the ownership of property. He did not go far enough to explain it, although I felt I could draw the implication that he intended; but for the reason that he did not go far enough, I shall let it pass. There is, however, an implication in his statement arising out of the propaganda that is being used against Catholic organisations in Spain. That is the propaganda that is being used and sent forth by the Communists and all these Communistic elements that back them up. However, as I say, since Dr. Rowlette did not proceed with that, I shall just let the matter remain at that. If I felt that it was necessary for me to deal with it, I would do so.
As I was saying, the whole issue in Spain is not that they are against Catholics—they could not be, of course, because there are Catholics on both sides—but the real issue and the one enemy in Spain is clerics and clergymen and all these Catholic organisations. It is not land or property or wealth or the distribution of wealth. It is a war, on the one side, to do away with anything that represents religion—clergymen, churches, crucifixes, or anything else connected with religion. That is the issue. The pretext at the beginning was the priests and the nuns. They glorified in the fact that they were eliminating them from Spain. At whose behest was that? I am not going to go so far as to charge that against Caballero and his colleagues. I submit that that came directly from Russia. I have studied the lives of these men who were in charge, so far as they are Spanish, and in regard to one of these gentlemen I must say that at one time I could not make him out, from what he was saying, as anything but a pure anarchist. With regard to the others, so far as their past lives are concerned, I could not go so far as to say that, but I do say that the philosophy of the Kremlin has got an absolute grip on Spain. So far as the Kremlin is concerned, the idea is that nothing will remain in Spain in the shape of clergymen, nuns, crucifixes, or anything else religious. That is the issue.
This Bill says that there are two Governments in Spain. One of those Governments represents the Cross. You have the emancipation and the salvation of the human race on the one side; on the other side is annihilation and destruction. No matter what may be said in this House, let that be said, because that is the issue. After all this heat has passed away, after all this flow of language and oratory have passed away, when the historian comes to deal with the facts coldly in the future he will write down that alone as the issue in Spain, no matter how this House votes. Let it be clear that these are the issues involved.
I am rather diffident even to cast a vote on any side in this matter in so far as it is a Party issue, or so far as Franco and Caballero represent Parties. I am not going to cast my vote on that aspect of the matter. I am not voting for the amendment or for General Franco as a Fascist. If I were asked to do that, I would vote against it. The fact that he may be a Fascist is accidental. Circumstances have thrown him into a position which indicates that that is the political form of Government he now represents, but remember that crises of this kind do not wait for labels or do not mind about labels. Things so direct themselves, so rush forward, that men are created and rise, as it were, automatically, to step in to fill certain breaches. That is why Franco is here. He is not here as a Fascist. It might have been somebody else faced with the same circumstances. It might have been any one of us, but it so happens that it is General Franco.
Will anybody tell me that anybody could say before the rise of Napoleon that that particular individual, Bonaparte, would rise to control France? Not at all, but a great Irishman had prophesied the rise of this man and he was jeered at when he did it. He said: "Out of this ruin, the circumstances existing will of themselves send up an individual to take charge of events, to sweep away all this chaos, this anarchy, disorder and bloodshed." Edmund Burke thundered that to the English nation, the Irish nation and the world. If somebody 12 months ago had foreshadowed the rise of General Franco of course he would have been jeered at. It is circumstances, not Fascism, that created General Franco. So long as these circumstances existed, some man would have to come capable of dealing with them. The thing was as certain as that night follows day.
Nature revolts against disorder. In crises such as that you will always find some individual to take charge of the helm and put it down. We will follow such a man no matter who he is. Come the individual will and the nation will follow him. Human nature abhors a revolt against order. Order is the first law of heaven and earth cannot long remain or exist without it. Caballero created this anarchy and overthrew not only social order, not only the existing institutions of State, but the images that were erected in honour of the God they represent. Caballero had enunciated that doctrine in Catalonia before, his intention to overthrow everything that stood for constituted order and religious beliefs. Let us not come here bandying about the name of General Franco as a Fascist. That has nothing to do with the issue. You can call him a Fascist if you will, but it is a mere waste of time. History will justify him and put his rise on an exact parallel with the rise of Napoleon. You had anarchy, chaos, bloodshed and ruin after the French Revolution. Human nature revolted against that, a man arose to put an end to it and the nation followed him. Caballero and his colleagues brought about the same state of affairs in Spain. That existed for a while but human nature revolted and, on that melting mass of anarchy, arose General Franco. In that sense he is a political entity. Call him Fascist if you like, but he is there representing the forces of law and civilisation. He is representing, over and above that, Christianity and he is fighting for it. So far as he represents that, I am prepared to vote against our Consul being accredited to the Red Government in Spain. I want to put on record that neither by thought, word or deed will I have any hand, act or part in giving approval or recognition to that coterie which has been mobilised in Spain, with the assistance of forces from Russia, to overthrow everything that the Irish people have sacrificed everything, and are prepared to sacrifice everything, to uphold.
I think it is unfortunate that the Government before introducing this Bill did not consider it more seriously and tell the other Governments that were a party to this non-intervention agreement that they had behaved in such a manner that they could not enter into any further engagements with them. That was an excellent opportunity for them. We could have dropped quietly out of this whole thing. Apparently the Consul was here in Ireland. He could have been kept quite easily at home and the President, as Minister for External Affairs, could have told the heads of the other nations: "Very well, I signed a Pact with you. I have honoured that Pact in the letter and the spirit, but you have disregarded it in every way." Of course they have never done anything in history but that, they have broken everything, the little treaties and agreements into which they entered with this country down through history. I do not want to say this in any sort of offensive or cruel way, but I think it is a sad mistake that we are taking any part in this arrangement at all. I think it is a highly unfortunate thing.
Another matter we dealt with before the adjournment was more unfortunate than that. However, it was done. The Government did it, as representing the nation. Let us hope it was for the best, but I think there was a serious mistake made from the nationalist point of view. However, it is done. Having made that mistake from a nationalist point of view, I think they should have probed their minds well and long. They might consider the excellent position in which they were. In some quarters it might be said of the Government, "You are a disgraceful, dishonourable, treaty-breaking crowd, and we will have nothing further to do with you." It is all very unfortunate, and all we can do is to hope for the best.
I am not afraid to prophesy. Let there be no mistake about it, Franco is going to win in Spain. I will go so far as to say he has won in Spain. The cause he represents cannot perish, and it will not perish. Let there be trimming here about Fascism or anything else you like, Franco represents a cause that has withstood all attacks down through the ages. The institutions that Franco represents have withstood all the shocks of history. Even a biassed Protestant historian like Lord Macaulay in his day was obliged to pay a tribute to the Catholic Church, which, he said, was great and powerful. He tells us of the New Zealander standing on London Bridge, viewing the ruins of St. Paul's. At that time he believed that Rome would be as triumphant as ever. That is the philosophy that animates the party fighting behind Franco. That unquenchable spirit will ultimately defeat Caballero and his crowd.
Comment on this
Would I be allowed to clear up definitely a misunderstanding, that I apparently created in the mind of Deputy McMenamin, by reading one sentence from the report of my speech this afternoon?
Comment on this
I am prepared to accept Deputy MacDermot's word and, if I misrepresented him, I withdraw.
Comment on this
The sentence is:—"I have felt all along that there could be no doubt that those who stood, not merely for Christianity, but for order, decency, civilisation and ancient culture as against barbarism and cruelty, could have no choice but to range themselves in sympathy with the Franco Government."
Comment on this
I desire strongly to support the amendment moved by Deputy O'Sullivan. It is a very reasonable amendment, one that would be supported, I believe, by the majority of the Irish people. We have been kept here all day when we could have been at home in the ordinary course, all for the purpose of carrying on this debate simply because the President refuses to accept this amendment and to give expression to the will of the Irish people. There is no question about it being the wish of the Irish people to break the connection with the Gaballero Government, the Government of the Reds in Spain, the Government that is out for the destruction of everything we hold dear in this world.
I am prepared to give the President credit for having no sympathy with the Caballero Government, but then, why should he give the impression to the world that the Irish people are sympathetic with that Government? He is the spokesman of the Irish people; he is our President, and what opinion can the world have of the attitude of the Irish people towards this question only to come to the conclusion that this country sympathises with the Red Government because we send to Spain an accredited representative? The object of this Bill is to prevent any support going to either side. The fact that we have a representative in Spain rather conveys to the world that the Irish people are sympathetic with the representatives of anti-Christ.
This amendment is put forward so as to enable the Government to save the Irish people from the misrepresentation they are liable to incur under this Bill. There is one remarkable feature appearing out of this debate. Some Deputies have spoken as if the object of the Opposition were to defeat this Bill. Anyone who reads the amendment proposed by Deputy O'Sullivan can see that there is nothing of the sort. We are not opposing this Bill. Why, then, is the whole burden of the speeches made by those who favour the Government attitude directed to the argument that the Opposition are opposing the Bill? Non-intervention is an agreed matter on all sides, but before this measure is passed it should be made clear to the world what is the attitude of the Irish people with regard to the Spanish conflict.
Even President de Valera has said that there is no doubt where the sympathies of the Irish people are. There is certainly no doubt in the country as to where the sympathies of the people are; but there is doubt about where the sympathies of the Government are, and the speeches of members of the Government are responsible for that. There is also a doubt in other countries about the sympathies of the Irish people and that doubt should be promptly removed by the Government.
I hope the President will make it clear why he is not prepared to accept this amendment, and why he will not break contact with the Reds in Spain. Perhaps he will explain to us why he is keeping a representative there? Is he a trade representative? The Minister for Education told us that our representative was there to safeguard the interests of citizens in that small section of Spain controlled by the Caballero Government. I doubt if that is the only purpose for which that Minister is there. It is only a short time ago since I read of shiploads of cattle and other things being sent to that Government. Under Section 10 of this Bill, power is taken to prevent the sending of any war material or anything else to the belligerents in Spain. What is food only one of the sinews of war? Why should we keep an agent there for the purpose of carrying on trade between this country and the Red section there and, at the same time, send no representative to the other Government? Why should we not trade with both alike. By accepting the amendment, withdrawing our representative and refusing to recognise the Caballero Government any further, we should be treating both Governments alike. That certainly is a very reasonable thing to ask.
Deputy O'Sullivan's amendment did not go so far as to ask the President to recognise the other Government, although the majority of the Irish people would favour that, I believe. He kept to what he believed the President could and should accept. That does not conflict with the international views which the President seems to be so anxious to uphold in order to perform his share in the international agreement. It does not conflict with that at all. Therefore, this House and the country are entitled to know why the President does not accept this amendment, which is in accordance with the wishes of the Irish people. It is only a short time ago since a Bill was brought into this House to remove doubts about so-and-so. If the President accepts this amendment he will remove grave doubts about his sympathies and the sympathies of the Irish people on this question. It is quite a reasonable proposal and I cannot understand why the House has been kept debating this all day when the matter could have been disposed of in an hour or two this morning, if the President accepted the amendment. There are doubts. Indeed, speeches made from those benches and through the country give reason for doubt. The speech of Deputy Hugo Flinn, which I heard quoted here yesterday, and which has not been contradicted, does give serious reason for doubt. Even the speech of the President himself, when he said that it was held by people, either in Spain or elsewhere, that it was a fight between two "isms" does give reason for a certain amount of doubt. Deputy Hugo Flinn made it much clearer when, speaking on this very question of the war in Spain, he represented that it was a question between Fascism and democracy. He did not say they had no use for Communism. Therefore, the only meaning that can be taken out of Deputy Flinn's speech is that his sympathy at least was with the Caballero Government. Does the President's sympathy differ from that of Deputy Hugo Flinn? Would it not be well for the President to make that clear! I hope he will. I do not believe he has any sympathy with that Government. Then, why should he hold up the Irish people to the world as sympathising with that Government?
Speaking for myself, I agree with Deputy Flinn and everybody else who says we have no use for Fascism. I have no use for Fascism. But, if we are in earnest in desiring to keep Fascism down, the remedy is to prevent Communism, because Fascism never precedes Communism. It follows Communism. It is the antidote to Communism. The first antidote to Communism is a Christian philosophy. If that fails, the only antidote is Fascism. That has been proved whereever Communism has got a foothold. Communism has got a foothold in Spain, and there is a life and death battle there between Communism and Christianity. There is no need to stress the point because it has been stressed sufficiently for the last few days by people who went to great pains in quoting the various authorities that are worthy of credit upon this point. So that there can be no doubt at all upon it that the issue is between Communism and Christianity. As I said, if we want to obviate the necessity for Fascism, let us deal with Communism and the only way to deal with Communism at home is to show to the world that we do not sympathise with it in Spain. No matter what country may sympathise with it in Spain, let the Irish people not sympathise with it. I am favourable to the Non-Intervention Bill, but this amendment does not interfere with the President in carrying out his policy.
Deputy Donnelly dealt with a number of points. I do not propose to go over all of them, but I should like to deal with one or two. He advised Deputies on this side of the House to leave Communism to the Church—that the Church is the proper body to deal with that. I quite agree. But the Church has spoken. All the Catholic Bishops of Ireland and the Archbishops and Bishops of Spain have spoken. What is the use of their speaking if we, the Catholic section of this country, are not prepared to accept their teaching. If we question their word, and if we take the word of Deputies, who have spoken in this House in contradiction to the teaching of the Cardinal, in preference to the Cardinal's, then the Cardinal and the Bishops may stop. I agree with Deputy Donnelly that we should respect their word and listen to it, but there is no use listening to it if we do not act upon it. He also told us that they regretted the murders in Spain. I do not question that. I am sure that everybody in this House regrets them as much as we do. But then why not condemn the murderers? Why continue to feed the murderers? Why continue to recognise them and to hold this country up to the world as supporting those murderers? That is the effective way to do it, and I hope it will be done. He also told us that the Caballero Government was elected by the majority of the Spanish people. I deny that. That Government represents the minority of the Spanish people. I can refer the Deputy to proof of that statement, which was made not so much in support of General Franco but by a man who is against him. I have not got the statement here, but if it is questioned I guarantee to produce it to anyone who wants to see it. There is no question but that the Caballero Government was elected by a minority.
Comment on this
On a point of correction, I did not refer to any election, good bad or indifferent, held in Spain.
Comment on this
Have a look at the Official Report. You referred to majority government. I took a note of it at the time.
Comment on this
Deputy Donnelly also stated that the Opposition were opposing this Bill. I deny that. We are not opposing it. All the talk about opposition to the Bill is to draw the mind of the public away from the real issue dealt with in the amendment, so that the Irish Press can come out with columns of stuff saying that the Opposition were opposing the Bill. The amendment speaks for itself, and simply seeks to cut the connection with the Caballero Government before the Bill is passed. If the President had consented to that this morning, the Bill could have been passed and it would not be at 10.30 to-night it would be going through.
Deputy Donnelly also stated that whatever the Cardinal Primate of Spain said was a matter for the people of Spain. To a certain extent that is so, but when his Eminence gives certain information, and as Deputy Belton stated, autographed a special copy of his pastoral and sent it to Ireland, his intention was that it should apply to the Irish people. Whether he is a Cardinal in Spain, in Rome or in Ireland, his words deserve respect, and when he sent a special copy of his pastoral and autographed it, he knew that the Irish people would respect what he says. At this stage I hope that the President will accept the amendment, or if he cannot do that now, that he will at least give the House an assurance, before the Bill is passed into law, that he will give effect to what it proposes.
Comment on this
Questions were addressed to me, and, as it will be necessary to make arrangements for the completion of the Committee Stage on Wednesday, I am taking this occasion to begin perhaps earlier than I would otherwise do. If there is anything more than another that is disappointing in this House it is that when a serious matter arises, on which there could be legitimate differences of opinion, instead of dealing with it on the merits, and dealing with it honestly, we find an effort made all the time to misrepresent. We had several examples of that. In fact, I might say that the majority of the speeches made in this debate have been made on the basis of deliberate and persistent misrepresentation; so much so that the attention of speakers was called to the fact that they were misrepresenting in the statements they were making.
Before I get into this matter, perhaps I should deal with a few things connected with the introduction of the measure. We made it known very early that we regarded the policy of non-intervention as being the best policy, in our opinion, for Spain, in the interests of the people of Spain; and the best policy for Europe, as well as being the best policy for our own people. There could be no doubt in the mind of anyone in the country about that being our policy, and more than that, the Opposition formally approved of that policy as a policy. Back in November, Deputy Cosgrave, in very explicit terms, made it clear that he agreed with that policy. Anybody who wants to get the exact words will find them in column 1197 of the Dáil Debates of November 27th, 1936. Our whole efforts, as a member of the Non-Intervention Committee, have been to try to get that policy of non-intervention accepted by all the States. Everything that our representative was instructed to do was with that aim, and, accordingly, we were very glad when, despite all our fears, agreement was reached, in the first place, not to import war materials into Spain on either side, and later when it was agreed that there were to be no volunteers sent from any other country into Spain.
With the words of the Leader of the Opposition in my mind, I thought that we could get this measure in time to make it effective by midnight on Saturday. It was very important, from the general point of view of Europe, that that agreement should be made effective at once. The moment we got word that agreement was reached on Tuesday night we took measures to have a Bill drafted. It is true that the First Reading was not on the Order Paper, but we tried to have the Bill drafted as quickly as possible, and on Wednesday when I indicated to the House that I wished to have the First Reading of the measure, I was met at the time—as I expected, indeed, from the attitude which the Opposition had taken up— with the statement that they were prepared to facilitate me in that regard in taking the Second Reading. I did that, believing that I represented not merely the Government point of view, in giving the undertaking that it would be made effective, but that I represented practically every member of this House. But, apparently new policies were introduced into the Opposition. They thought they could do something better, the whole attitude changed over-night, and we have presented to us two amendments which have no relation on earth to the Bill— no relation good, bad or indifferent to the policy which is in this Bill, which we were led to understand was the policy accepted, not merely by the Government but by other members of the House, because there was not a single dissentient voice to that policy. It is a policy I believe that is accepted by the vast majority of the Irish people. I have no doubt whatever that the Irish people are as convinced as the Government is convinced that the best thing that could be done in the interests of the Spanish, and in the interest of the thing we hold dear, would be to let the Spanish people settle this matter for themselves. I, for one, have no doubt in what way they will settle it for themselves—none whatever. If I were a Spaniard speaking in Spain I would wish to see every single foreigner out of my country, because foreigners, when they come into a country as representatives of big Powers, have, as we know to our cost in this country, a knack of trying to stay there. I believe, therefore, that the best thing that could be done in the interests of Spain is to keep the foreigners out. When you read what the Cardinal Primate of Spain said about the origin of that war, and the immediate causes of it, you find that he talks of the foreign tyranny, because he is a Spaniard and he does not want the foreign tyranny there. I have no doubt whatever that if the Spanish people are left to themselves they will settle this question in the right way. It is for that reason that I am strongly in favour of the non-intervention policy, as I am also in favour of it from the point of view of what is the proper attitude for our country, considering that what we do other nations will do, and that the amount of assistance we can give is relatively small while the harm that could be done by the other countries is relatively great. Consequently, I think that our going into this matter would be bad for ourselves, bad for Europe and bad for Spain.
Again, as I have said, I thought that everybody in this House agreed with that policy and with what is in this Bill to give effect to that policy. The States of Europe, undoubtedly, are on both sides. You have Russia in it; you have France in it; you have Italy in it; you have Germany in it, and we ought to be grateful for our own sakes, grateful for the sakes of the people in Spain, and grateful for the sake of Europe, that an agreement of this sort has been reached. We want to give it effect, and what do we find? We find that the Opposition, because they cannot oppose this particular Bill in view of their previous statements, come along and bring up an issue which is not germane to it. They could raise at any time the question of the recognition or the continued recognition of any of the Governments in Spain. That is an issue which could be raised in this House at any time, and it was brought up in this way in order to cause delay and prevent us from meeting engagements which were entered into in the full belief that this Parliament would support us in getting the Bill through in proper time.
There has been an attempt to get rid of this and to make an excuse for causing this delay by pretending that we had not put it on the Order Paper. The decision was reached on Tuesday night. We had to have a Bill ready. On the next day I brought this matter before the House and pointed out that it was necessary to put it through so as to enable it to be effective before Saturday. Then we get the excuse that they had to delay us because we did not put it on the Order Paper; because I did not give the House sufficient notice. I gave them notice practically as soon as I got it myself. We are told also that there must be time for amending in detail. If there was a desire on the part of the Opposition to facilitate us in keeping this international engagement, it would be very easy to arrange for detailed consideration of the various parts to-day, and we could get it through on Saturday, but obviously it was not that which the Opposition wanted. They wanted to make a parade of this matter, and to try and misrepresent the Government. They wanted, without a single fact on which they could rely, to try to make it appear that this Government had sympathies with the Communist Government in Spain. They cannot point to a single thing which would indicate that there is any truth in that suggestion.
Comment on this
They would like to have headings like this in the evening papers: "The Government Accused of Sympathising with the Reds." They pretend to be anxious about the honour of our country, and the effect that our attitude will have on other peoples; and yet they have constantly, for two days now, tried to herald it to the world that this Government are Communist or in sympathy with Communists. They tried it before internally in this country; the Irish people saw through them, and the Irish people will see through them to-day as they saw through them then.
Comment on this
I am asked what are my views. Where have I at any time, in any place, in public or in private, expressed any sympathy whatever with Communism? I have said in public that I detest Communism because I believe that it means the breaking up of the social order as we understand it. I have always said that I believe Communism did not accord with the nature of man—with man's ideals. I expressed those views years ago. I did not have to wait to express them now. I expressed those views then and now, and I believe in them. I also believe that Fascism, even if not equally bad, is bad. It is, perhaps, not equally bad, but it is a desperate alternative, and I hope that this country will be saved from having those alternatives as a choice. Everything we have done as a Government has been directed to seeing that this country would not have such a choice. Thank God that, so far, anyhow, we have been successful, and I believe that if the policy we stand for is continued there will be no stage at which this country will be faced with the alternatives that they have in Spain at the present moment.
We have been honest in this matter. There has been nothing that the Government has done that it could not stand over everywhere. As members of the Non-Intervention Committee, anxious to get non-intervention adopted by all the States, we naturally had to do our utmost to take up a position which would enable us to be genuine advocates of non-intervention. If we start intervening, obviously there is no use in our asking other people not to intervene. When the volunteers were going out from here I, for one, felt that it did to a certain extent damage our influence in getting the policy of non-intervention adopted. But other nations were doing it, and the agreement at that stage had not reached to volunteers. The agreement had only reached to war material. It is said, and I admit, that the agreement with regard to war material was not fully kept. To the extent to which it was not, we regret it. Any effort of ours was directed to press that it would be kept, and, in regard to this agreement in so far as volunteers are concerned, everything that we can do to see that it is kept we will do. One of the things that we must do, if we are going to press on other people to keep it, is to keep it ourselves, and that has been our attitude in regard to the position in the past. This matter has not been argued on its merits. If we were about to argue it on its merits the first thing the House would have done would have been to give us this Bill, on the understanding that we would give a day for the discussion of the question of the recognition or non-recognition of one of the Spanish Governments, or organisations—as is in the Bill—that claim to be Governments. That would have been a reasonable line. We could have understood it if any member of the Opposition had stood up and said. "We agree with your policy of non-intervention. We indicated our agreement months ago. We agree that it is in the general interests that this should be entered into at once. We will give you this Bill, but we do not agree with your policy in some other respects and we would like that time would be arranged so that we can discuss this whole question." I would have given it, of course, gladly. It would be the right of the House to have it. I do not say it would have been wise or anything like that, but I should have felt in duty bound to grant the time for this discussion; but to bring it in as an amendment to this Bill, to try to get an excuse for voting against a policy which they accepted seems to me to be unworthy of any official Opposition.
I will take a few of the misrepresentations. The first was by Deputy Belton—that we had orders from the Committee. He is the Deputy who took upon himself the responsibility of moving a reasoned amendment to the motion for the Second Reading, and he did not even inform himself as to what was the nature of this Committee, who were the representatives on it, or anything else. He came in here, and when he spoke he showed quite clearly that he did not understand that we ourselves were members of that Committee. It is cheap and easy to say, "Taking your orders from somebody." We did not take orders except that we agreed with others in accordance with the policy which was announced—and we were very glad to get the others to agree because we believed it was the best policy—that this should be done, and surely there is no question of taking orders when you set out to get a certain result and your aims have been realised to the extent of getting the policy adopted.
Then, again, we see the sincerity in debate, the sincerity of conviction, when a jocose remark is made by one of our Deputies at Deputy Belton's apparent difficulty with the pronunciation of the Spanish Primate's name. It was not a question that anybody need sneer at. It was merely that he had obvious difficulty, and the jocose remark was made. How was that turned? That it was a sneer at relition, at the Spanish Primate. If it was a sneer, and I do not believe it was, it could only be interpreted as a sneer at the Deputy's inability to pronounce the Spanish name. It was not a sneer at all—it was a good-humoured remark, and nothing more. But, in order to give a false complexion to this whole question, it was necessary for Deputy Belton to pretend that that jocose remark was intended as a sneer on religion. As we are talking about religion, perhaps we might be a little bit frank about it. So far as religion is concerned, there is very little, if anything, to choose between them, and if you were going to select either the sheep or the goats in this House, and if they were coming in that door, you would find it very difficult to know whether to turn to the right or to the left to find the sheep quickly, if you wanted sheep, or to find the goats quickly, if you wanted goats. The fact is, and the Irish people know it full well, that any differences between these two Parties are not differences based on religious beliefs or religious conviction. It is vain for gentlemen on the opposite benches to try to suggest otherwise, because the Irish people will not believe them.
That was the first matter of misrepresentation. The next is a statement of my own, and what was going to be done with it was clear the moment I had made it. Deputy Belton's remark make it quite clear what he was up to, just as it was clear what he was up to when he tried to have Deputy Donnelly's jocose remark interpreted as a sneer at religion. I was speaking of the non-intervention policy, and I said:—
"All the nations of Europe are represented on this Non-Intervention Committee. I am anxious that we should play our part in trying to shorten this conflict in Spain by preventing the export of arms to the combatants, and also by preventing recruitment to the various sides who are fighting out in Spain, a fight which, for most of them, at any rate, is not the sort of fight that we think it is, but is a fight for one `ism' against another."
Is there any Deputy so dull as to equate that statement to the statement which has been repeated here despite the fact that last night, the first moment it was uttered by a responsible Deputy on those benches opposite, Deputy O'Sullivan, when he tried to misrepresent this, I immediately said that what he said was not what I said. The first thing I did was to ask for the report. Here it is as it came in, and last night I read out that statement as I have read it out now. Yet, because it was good in order to misrepresent the attitude of the Government, it was used continually through to-day's debate. It was first used to show that it was my view that the fight in Spain was a fight for one "ism" against another, and that was all there was to it. Later, it was used by Deputy Fitzgerald—I was not in the House, but I was told it was used by him—to suggest that I thought the people who were fighting in Spain were fighting for one "ism" against another. The plain meaning of that is opposed to either of these two views. It is clear to be seen that what I was referring to was the people whose recruitment from outside Spain was taking place—the people who come from Italy, the people who come from Germany, the people who come from Russia, and the people who come from France. Is there anybody in this House who denies that I was right when I said that if these people go into Spain, it is for "isms" they go in, and there are very few of them who are going in, in my opinion, simply because it is a question of Christianity. I believe, and I do not care who contradicts me, that the majority of the recruits who went into Spain, whether they went from Italy, from Germany, from Russia, or from France, went in there to fight out a fight between Communism and Fascism.
Comment on this
I spoke of those who went there, and I said they were making a cockpit of Spain to fight this battle out, and, because I said that, which is true beyond contradiction, we have people here who want to misrepresent that clear and explicit statement into a suggestion that this Government at the present day, seeing the position as it is in Spain, took the view that it was tweedledum and tweedledee, a fight between one "ism" and another. Now, I call that dishonesty. And I say that any Party that hopes to build up a programme or a reputation on that sort of thing is doomed to be disappointed, because the Irish people, in the long run, are not fools.
Comment on this
The fooling is being tried to be done by other people, but they are not able to fool them now.
Comment on this
There are as good men on these benches as you are and they are not going to be fooled.
Comment on this
When we went to the Irish people the last time, after being 12 months in office, the Irish people put us back again and, please God, they will do the same again as long as they are true to their own interests.
Comment on this
I want to warn Deputy Coburn that further interruptions will lead to action by the Chair.
Comment on this
At the start I challenged anybody to show any action on our part which suggested that our sympathies were with the Communist Government in Spain at the present time.
Comment on this
Undoubtedly they are. Deep down in your heart your sympathies are with the Red Government and the same is true of everyone of your Party.
Comment on this
Deputy Coburn can see into other people's minds. Whatever that Deputy wants to think is right, of course.
Comment on this
Deep down in our hearts we are interested in seeing that right principles will prevail here as in Spain, and we are as interested in that as anybody in this House. The difference is that we have responsibilities; and in regard to these things we have to do what is right and proper as representing this nation. The ugliest thing about this whole debate, the feeling I have anyway, is that if those Deputies who are attacking us for doing this, happened to be seated on these benches they would pursue exactly the same policy that we are pursuing because, in fact, any other policy would be extremely difficult, improper and dangerous. We, first of all, entered into diplomatic relations—it was our general policy, as I understand it was the general policy of our predecessors, to enter into diplomatic relations with the principal European powers and with the principal countries of the world. We had diplomatic relations with the United States, Germany, France, the Vatican City, that is with the Holy Father, and other States.
Back in 1935, long before the general election in Spain and the subsequent happenings which brought about the present civil war, it was proposed to us to enter into diplomatic relations, and we entered into diplomatic relations with the Spanish people, with the Spanish State, with the Spanish Republic. At that time the President, I think, was President Zamora. Everybody who has paid any attention to these matters and certainly anybody who has been Minister at any time knows, full well, that when diplomatic relations are entered into between two States, these diplomatic relations continue with changes of Government —sometimes even with changes of régime. These relations continue with no new accreditation whatever.
What is the fundamental nature of these diplomatic relations between States? What do they mean? Does it not mean this—that in order to get closer and better opportunities for promoting the interests between one country and another, safeguarding the interests of one country and another, such as the interests of the nationals of one country that might be situated in the other country, certain organs are set up. Their purpose is, as I have said, to further the interests of both countries, and it is merely accidental that the question of Government comes in, or whether the people were in sympathy with another Government or not. It is seldom these matters enter into the question. If they did I am afraid there would be very few of the diplomatic relations that exist left, because successive Governments are not always equally favoured by outside countries. Are we going to assume that the existence of diplomatic relations between ourselves and other countries implies that we sympathise with that Government of an outside country—that we sympathise with its policy? Nothing of the kind. Everybody knows that that is not true. Everybody knows that it does not imply any such commendation or approval on the part of one Government of the policy of another Government. All you do is this—if a State has a Government that is able and willing to perform services for you that are implied in these relations, you avail of that Government, and if another Government comes along that is in a position to do it, you deal with that other Government.
What is the position of the States of Europe to-day with regard to Spain? The fact is that they continue as we are continuing our diplomatic relations with the Spanish State, with the Spanish people. That means when a State is in a state of flux, and you are not sure where you are, you deal with the Party in power who can deal with your citizens. Practically all the States of Europe, with the exception of Germany and Italy, have followed that rule. At least that was the case up to lately. There have been a few changes but, until recently, that was the position that was continued by all the States of Europe except Germany and Italy.
Comment on this
Is anybody going to tell me that Germany or Italy changed except directly because of the fact that they wanted to have in Spain a régime that corresponded with their own? If we are going to do our best to get the policy of non-intervention accepted it is quite clear that we ought not to put ourselves out of court, so to speak, in advocating that course by taking a step of that kind. That is my answer in connection with our steps about the Non-Intervention Agreement.
What have other States done? There are some exceptions. There are States who have representatives at the seat of government in Valencia, but the majority of the States in Europe have their diplomatic representatives at Hendaye in France, a place on French soil and in close proximity to the Spanish Border. They have their representatives there because of the fact that they wanted to be able to be in touch with the two Parties in Spain in order to safeguard whatever interests they had in that country—to safeguard any interests of their own nationals or any other interests they might have. Now what is the position of our representative? Our representative was in Spain and got ill there some time about, I think, the 7th July. The revolution did not break out until about the 18th July. Our representative got seriously ill, and it is very mean for an ex-Minister for External Affairs to suggest that a man who is in that responsible position left that position in Madrid through cowardice. I was not here when that statement was indicated and I make full apologies to the ex-Minister for External Affairs if I am wrong, but it was suggested, I am told, that this representative of ours left his position in Madrid through cowardice. He had been ill and he left Madrid, because of illness, actually before the revolution broke out.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan certainly did not make it and the President referred to an ex-Minister for External Affairs.
Comment on this
I had not time to look the matter up. If I am wrong, I shall withdraw, but I want, as Minister for External Affairs, responsible for the Department, to say that no member of our Department was guilty of any such misconduct. As a matter of fact, our representative was extremely ill. He had to stay for a considerable time in Spain before he could be removed. He came to convalesce in this country and he was here from August. The office in Madrid was kept open to serve our nationals long after the time which we here thought was safe. It was kept open so long as it was at all possible to help our nationals. A short time ago, having convalesced— I think it was on the 29th January —our Minister left here. For what purpose? Because, in the Department of External Affairs, we got letters from heartbroken parents telling us that their children, who were under age, had left without their knowledge or consent to fight in Spain—some on one side and some on the other. They asked us if we could do anything to bring these people back. We sent our Minister to join the other representatives—in this case at St. Jean de Luz, as I told the House —to see whether he could not establish contact with both sides and ascertain what could be done to bring those people, who were under age, back and get them released from any obligations they had entered into there.
That is the "recognition" and that is the act that has been misrepresented without a single question as to why it was done. An inquiry could have been made. A simple question could have been put to me as Minister for External Affairs any day as to why the Minister for Spain had gone back or if there was any reason why he should be going back at this time. He left this country on the 29th January —long before this agreement to prohibit recruiting was arrived at. When he was well and able to perform this work for our people, he was sent there to establish contact with the two sides.
Deputies on the opposite bench know as well as I do what the usual procedure is and what the meaning is of representation and accreditation. Yet, they come along and deliberately misrepresent this action as a step by us, at this particular time, to indicate to the world and to the Communist Government of Spain that we, the Irish Government, support them. If they have any cause at heart, it is very hard for that cause to be aided by such tactics. Everybody knows that there is no such thing as direct accrediting to the present Caballero Government. It is a choice, when you come to a certain stage, of what instrument or what organ of a particular country you can use in order to safeguard the interests which you may have in that particular country. That is why, as a rule, it is de facto Governments that are recognised. It is only de facto Governments that can do the work. It is only to de facto Governments you can appeal to do things. Governments that are not de facto Governments are unable to do these things and, if recognised, it is always a gesture—a gesture of partisanship. Whatever might be our views on the matter, I considered that if we were to be effective in that Non-Intervention Committee, it was our duty, so far as we could, not to take up a position of partisanship. Does that mean that we do not understand what way the Irish people feel about this matter? I have indicated long ago that we do. I have no doubt about it. I am perfectly certain that, once it became clear, as I think it is now, that the triumph of one side meant the furtherance of Communism in Europe, it was impossible for the Irish people to have views except in one direction.
Comment on this
If the Deputy had been here or if he had card to listen, he would know why. The amendment has nothing to do, good, bad or indifferent, with this Bill.
Comment on this
That is the position with regard to our representative in Spain. He is in touch, so far as he can be, with both sides in order to serve the interests of our people who are there on both sides. The statement of Hugo Flinn has been brought in here——
Comment on this
The statement of the Parliamentary Secretary has been brought in to try to make it appear that, from an early date, our sympathies were altogether with one side in Spain. I asked one of the speakers to-day if he would give me the date of that statement. I was anxious about the date because I was aware that most people here—whatever side they were on—were, at the very beginning, as confused about the happenings in Spain and what was really the issue there as I was. I confess I was confused about the situation because, so far as I knew up to that time, there had been a Government elected in Spain and there was a revolt. That is as it seemed to me, and that is as it appeared, I think, to most people. What was behind the revolt, what were the causes that led to the revolt, I did not know. I tried to find out as soon as I could. It was not unreasonable that anybody, in the early stages of the trouble, should have thought that, in Spain, it was a fighting-out of the fight which was fought elsewhere—a fight between Fascism and Communism. Therefore, I asked when this statement was made. I was told it was made in August and that the report was taken from the Irish Press. I thought that it might be worth while to read the report to see exactly what the context was and what the Deputy was talking about when he made this speech. This is, I think, the paragraph that is referred to:
"Systems of government in parts of Europe were in a state of flux. They had dictatorships in Russia, Italy and Germany, and, at the present time, in Spain. The struggle was concerned with an attempt to change the system of government. There was a struggle going on between Fascism and democracy."
Where? Was not the Deputy clearly talking about the position in Europe as a whole?
Comment on this
I think I can interpret just as well as most other people. I am not out to try to misrepresent. I say that in the context that is what the Deputy wanted to say. That was on August 3rd, and the revolution broke out some time about the middle of July. "Fianna Fáil had no use for Fascism." Fianna Fáil has no use for Fascism, and it is perfectly true to say that Fianna Fáil has neither any use for Communism, and Deputy Flinn did not say so because he would know perfectly well that if he did say so he would be telling something which was not true.
Comment on this
It is much easier for the Deputies opposite to take phrases and use them than to use proper argument, and that is what the Deputies on the opposite benches have been trying to live on. Because, having nothing but phrases like that to live on, they are where they are, and they are likely to remain where they are.
Now, the Irish people at the beginning of the trouble were confused, as many other people were confused, as to what the issues were. Deputy Belton read for us a considerable amount from the translation of the Cardinal Primate's pastoral. The people in Ireland, whether they were here on these benches or throughout the country, found it very difficult, in view of the statements that were made and the publicity given to them, to know exactly what was happening in Spain, and why. Deputy Belton has read a large portion of this pastoral, but there is a section of it which I think it would be very well for our people to read, because of its lessons, and I hope they will read it all.
Comment on this
I very sincerely hope that they will. There is a part of it which I would like to read, because it conveys to us very important lessons, and it is well for us and for every other country to take stock and to heed the warnings that are contained in this pastoral. The section that I propose to read is headed "Causes of the Present Disaster." The greater part of this has to deal with the principal cause, namely, that of Communistic propaganda, and the foreign tyranny which the Cardinal pointed out Spain was at that time suffering from. In this part the Cardinal says:
"We must now be brief. When we denounced the principal factor, which—to our knowledge—has been instrumental in producing the present Spanish conflagration, we did not intend to point out those national defects which by a gradual process have made our land an easy prey to Communism. No one becomes suddenly good or wicked. Constitutional weakness or a slow disease will sooner or later lead to ruin and death. To point out such weaknesses in our race and customs is not our object here. Our only desire is to judge the immediate causes of the present disaster. We can enumerate the following: forgetfulness of our tradition and history, the insatiable desire during the last two centuries to copy slavishly the things of other lands in literature, laws and customs; the lack of comprehension of the problems of the moment, our inconsistency in political affairs, the undignified character of our democracy, the dishonesty of our Parliamentary and electoral systems, the lack of formation of a national conscience, and the confusion of our international relationships; selfishness and want of scruples in political matters, the curse of extreme regionalism, and of its opposite, the too rigid state that takes no account of regional peculiarities and aspirations. Each one of these causes could provide matter for the chapters of a book tracing our national decadence.
"To these we can add our present rigid economic system, which has refused to yield to the just demands of a working class, whose standard of living is far below the level of that of the rest of Europe, thus making the workers an easy prey to false propaganda. Other defects are to be found in the slowness of the clergy to adapt themselves to changed conditions, and in their failure to apply new methods in their priestly apostolate; in the appalling corruption of morals and, what is worse, in the corruption of minds owing to the excessive liberty of expression to be found in the university, on the platform and in the Press."
Now, I have read that because it is only fair that when you are quoting from a document of this kind you should give the whole picture and not a part of it. I would say that if we ponder on some of these paragraphs we will ask ourselves many a question, and if we answer them rightly I believe that we can save this country from ever having to face the torments which Spain is at present facing. It was precisely because I believed fundamentally in these ideals, in the fact that at the time there was no realisation on the part of those who were well-off of the conditions of the working people, that I for one did not want to see Communism getting in this country allies which it need never have. The whole policy, to which I objected when on the opposite benches in 1931, was to force into the ranks as allies, even if they did not accept the general principle, to force into the ranks supporting Communism with which they had no interest, but supporting it because they were open to the same attack as the Communists were open to, those who had only one idea, that is, national aspirations. An attempt was being made to drive them in as allies of the Communists. The same thing was done by those who were not ready to listen and to give full weight to the legitimate demands of the working people who were looking for proper conditions.
I opposed the attitude which at that time was being pursued by the previous Government. I said "you are going to do a damnable thing when you do that, to drive in as allies to them and for something for which they have no immediate concern, those who have objectives of a national character, or those who have objectives of a legitimate social character. If I had read out at that time, without saying where I got it, some of the passages either from Rerum Novarum or Quadragesimo Anno, it would have been said that I was sympathetic with Communism. What we were trying to do was to get those people to realise that human beings have a right to get the opportunities to live a decent life.
Comment on this
No, they have not got it yet. Rome was not built in a day. It is not for want of trying on our part, at any rate.
Comment on this
I believe, if the Previous Government had been in power for the last five years that, instead of having the position we have, thank God, to-day—and I have been following it closely—I have been getting the police reports upon it and I know the position——
Comment on this
I know the position of Communism, properly called. I know well the position, and whatever we are trying to do, at any rate, we are trying to remedy these evils and not to turn a blind eye to them, or to try by force to make the pretence that those who are looking for their legitimate rights and legitimate liberties are necessarily Atheistic and Communistic. Now, A Chinn Comhairle, we stand here with this policy before this Parliament—a policy that has been approved—the policy of non-intervention. The object of this Bill is to give effect to it as far as we are concerned. No matter how much you may try to bring in this other question of recognition or not, the question is: Are you going to support the policy of non-intervention or not? There is going to be a vote on that issue.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not want to believe, and we had better leave him in his wilful unbelief.
Comment on this
I knew all about law and order before the President did. I knew about law and order when the President was out to upset law and order in this country.
Comment on this
I have tried to prevent the misrepresentation of our people and the misrepresentation of our Government in this matter. I have been given here a paper— the Irish Catholic—and its policy, apparently, is to suggest that the 204,000 affiliated members of the Irish Trades Union Congress are tacit supporters of Communism. Is there anyone here, or anybody in the country, who is going to believe that? Yet it is that that is being taken abroad and reprinted in the Osservatore Romano for its readers to judge from it as to what is the position of the Irish people in regard to Communism —that the workers in the Irish Trade Union Congress, if you please, are Communistic. Is there anybody here who believes that? In 1931 the Deputies on the opposite benches, when they were here, went out on a programme to try to get re-elected on the basis of the necessity of combating Communism, and there were reports taken around in private; but when we got into office and got hold of those reports and brought them in here, I exposed these reports in order to show that they themselves bore evidence that there was no serious threat of Communism in the country at the time. Of course, however, if you are going, for Party reasons or for other reasons, to try to drive in and class as Communists the 204,000 members of the Irish Trades Union Congress, and if you are going to class as Communists those who do not agree with your particular views about the national position, then, of course, you can very rapidly increase the number of Communists—and I would suggest that it is a very dangerous thing to do.
Comment on this
No; but you have been trying to misrepresent the representatives of the majority of the Irish people as Communists.
Comment on this
I think, Sir, that I might be allowed to claim at least a little bit of liberty as well as the President; nobody from this side ever suggested that the members of the Trades Union Congress were Communists——
Comment on this
If the Deputies make it quite clear that they withdraw that suggestion, I shall be certainly glad.
Comment on this
——all the main arguments advanced here for the last two days have been to try to make it appear that we sympathise with Communists and that we were in fact——
Comment on this
I pointed out the heading in the paper this evening, and I say that that is the whole purpose of the manoeuvring in this connection as far as the speakers on the opposite side are concerned.
Comment on this
I say that you suggested that we were, and we represent the majority of the Irish people.
Comment on this
I shall not deal with it now, but I shall deal with the Bill before you, which you should vote for if you are going to be consistent on the question of non-intervention. The amendment will not be accepted now. The real question at issue is the question of non-intervention, and the question of when exactly we shall withdraw from one side completely will be determined by us from the knowledge of the facts and when we think it will be in the best interests both of Spain and of Europe to do so, and, so far as we are concerned, it will not be done one minute before.
Comment on this
As far as my view of religion, in this House, is concerned, I say that we are pretty well on a par on both sides of the House, and that, in all probability, if you were to take a census of differences of opinion on this side of the House as well as on the other side, it would be found that, if there are differences of opinion, or if there should be differences of opinion on this side of the House, you will find them balanced by differences of opinion on the other side.
Comment on this
It is quite clear, for instance, from the attitude of Deputy Dillon and Deputy Cosgrave, when they spoke before, and from their attitude here for the last two days, that there is a difference of opinion over there. Otherwise, could you refuse to give me that Bill to-night, and to-morrow if necessary, in order that we might fulfil our obligations? But no, you wanted to force me into the position of appearing to rush this Bill through by guillotine methods, although you knew that if we were to keep strictly to our international obligations we would put this Bill through all its stages before this time to-morrow night. That is actually what our duty is, but I do not want this matter to be misrepresented. I want the Irish people to have full opportunity to understand what we are doing in their name, and I have no doubt whatever that the Irish people approve of this policy, and with regard to the question of its being in the best interests of Spain to allow the Spaniards to settle this matter by themselves, I could prove to anybody with an ounce of sense that it was the right and the best thing to do.
I have already suggested that when foreigners, representatives of the big Powers particularly, come into any country, you will find that they generally come there with some ulterior motive, and that it is much easier to get them in than to get them out. They are trying their new machines; they are trying their latest methods, and I, for one, wishing well to the Spanish people, and desiring to see Spanish independence continued, would like to see every one of them outside the territory of Spain. If somebody says to me: "It is not the end of the conflict we want to see, but to have it settled in the right way," I say it will be settled as the Spanish people want it settled or it will not be settled at all, because if you put in a Government by foreign aid, although it may be established for a time in Spain, do you think that if it does not correspond with the feelings of the Spanish people it is going to last? Do you not know perfectly well that it is the will of the Spanish people that is ultimately going to determine what form the Government is going to take? It may, of course, take some time. Foreign forces may enable a certain group or clique to hold sway in Spain for a while, but is there anybody here who thinks that such a Government is going to last? Having confidence, as I have, in the national spirit of the Spanish people, in the ideals—and the religious ideals at that —inspiring the Spanish people, I have no doubt, for one, how this contest is going to be ultimately finished by the Spanish people. As I say, it will be the Spanish people, if they are going to remain independent, unless they are going to be completely subjected by an outside Power, who will settle this trouble themselves. If I were a Spaniard, I would hate even to get my freedom with foreign aid, because I would hate to have it in the mouths of that part of my nation which I wished to have loyal to me afterwards, "Oh, you are the creation of some foreign people."
Somebody has said that, at any rate, they should be glad to get help. We are all glad to get help. Unfortunately, we accept help very often too willingly from outsiders. When we get bitterly into a fight, we are very willing to accept aid from outside. We jump into the pit and we do not always think of how we are going to get out of it. There is no doubt in my mind —whatever might be said about getting equipment and arms from outside—that the Spanish people will be better served if they can be liberated and are allowed to establish a stable Government by their own arms and their own votes.
In so far as we can do it, our aim in dealing with other nations will be to allow these nations to settle their problems for themselves, even though we may have an interest in them. Let me say that I am not uninterested or that I am not indifferent to the conflict in Spain. So far from being indifferent, I am very interested. My views may not be the same as other people's views. I hold these views, however, and I do believe, holding these views and wishing that one side definitely should triumph, and wishing to see a stable Government established in Spain, that the best contribution we can make is to get outsiders to take their hands off the Spanish conflict. That is the policy I stand for. I have no doubt whatever the Irish people will agree with me notwithstanding all that may be said to misrepresent the position of our representative in Spain at the present time. The Irish people are content to allow this Government in accordance with the general policy of non-intervention, to choose the time when intervention on our part will be legitimate and effective.
Comment on this
The President, above all other men, speaking as an Irish traditionalist should surely be the last person to forget that there was a time when we sang:
"There is wine from the royal Pope, Upon the ocean green,
And Spanish Ale shall give you hope, My dark Rosaleen."
However, we have to forget some of the aspects of Irish traditionalism that we should like to discuss here, as we have to forget some of the President's cures for Communism in this country upon which he touched. What we are concerned about here is that the President brings a Bill before the House to prevent intervention in a military sense in Spain. This is done at a time when a Minister accredited from this country to Spain, having left it at the time of the outbreak—whether he left it before the actual military rising or not we do not know—practically simultaneously with the adoption of the non-intervention policy as regards enlistment, has gone back to Spain accredited only to the Caballero Government. The President speaks, and speaks at a rather late stage in this discussion, of the fathers and mothers who have appealed to him to try to get the Government to intervene to rescue some of their children from the position in which, without their parents' consent, they find themselves in Spain. It is a pity the President was not concerned about that somewhat earlier. What he offers to these parents now is to leave their children—because most of their children have gone to fight for Franco and the cause which, in their eyes, Franco represents— fighting under an interdict, as it were, of this Government against their action. The putting up of a proposition of this kind is a criticism and a condemnation of their action in the past and that at a time when this State is accredited only to the so-called Government against which they are fighting.
What we are discussing now is not the merits or demerits of non-intervention but why, when the policy of non-intervention is being laid down subject to drastic penalties the President does not reconsider the position in which this nation stands before the world—a Catholic nation with all the Christian ideals about which the President has so often spoken, which is now ready to swallow all these professions and still permits itself to be accredited to the Government that is responsible for the position brought about in Spain. We asked the President to withdraw the representative of this State from the Caballero Government at a time when he joins with other nations to prevent intervention of a military kind in Spain. He talks about a policy of allowing Spaniards to settle their own differences and he has been joined by some of the queerest forces in this country in an effort to misrepresent the position of the Franco Government. He has had the Irish Times to his help and now, in a most unexpected way, he has Deputy Rowlette getting up and complimenting the people on the Opposition Benches who, he said, made a contribution to democratic government in this country, a very definite contribution to democratic government. He expressed amazement that it is possible for them to take up the position they are taking up with regard to the rival “isms” in Spain. He likes to picture the Franco Government as being a group of people who rose in rebellion against a democratically elected government because that government started land division.
Does the President stand for that type of misrepresentation of the position? Does the President take up the attitude that the men who have gone to Spain, stirred by an instinct that is very strong in the hearts and minds of our people, and the strength of which has been manifested by the movement that took these hundreds of men to Spain—does he think that this House can accept it that they have gone to fight a democratically elected government because that government started to divide land, started to do the things which the President and his Party would allege that they were practically the first people in this country to do?
Comment on this
The President has a different opinion on that. I want to put before the President some of the facts that, within his knowledge, he has withheld from the people of this country when dealing with this matter, and I challenge the President to say that the Government in Spain, to which his Minister is accredited, is a Government that is elected by the majority votes of the people.
Comment on this
So that we here have a representative to a Government in Spain that the President does not say is elected by the majority votes of the people?
Comment on this
I have said that I did not say that the present Government in Spain was a Government that was democratically elected. It has gone beyond that stage long ago. Secondly, I repeat that we are in diplomatic relations with Spain, that it was with Spain our diplomatic relations were originally established. There is no Spanish representative here and our representative is not at the seat of government. We have not broken off relations.
Comment on this
We send a representative from this country, for whatever reason, to a popularly elected Government in Spain. The representative we sent as a Minister was sent as the representative of the popularly elected Government of this country to the popularly elected Government in Spain.
Comment on this
I have been asked a question, and, if I am asked a question, I take it I am expected to answer.
Comment on this
We entered into diplomatic relations with the Spanish Republic. It was the de facto, the only Government, in Spain at the time. Whether it was democratically elected or otherwise, it was the de facto Government and it was as such that our representative was sent there. That is the position.
Comment on this
The House could very well be informed, officially and formally, by the President as to what the position in Spain is. I want to give a certain amount of information. First and foremost, there was an election in Spain in the early part of this year. Votes to the number of 4,356,000 were cast in favour of the Left, votes to the number of 4,570,000 were cast in favour of the Right, and there were 340,000 votes cast for the Centre Party. The Parliament consisted of 256 Deputies of the Left and 197 of the Right. The first thing that was done a state of alarm was proclaimed. Then the Monarchist leader had to complain of a large number of disturbances that were taking place since the new Government had come into office, he warned the Cabinet of the progress of Red propaganda amongst the armed forces, and ended by declaring that the answer to a dictatorship of the proletariat might be a counter-attack to set up a totalitarian State.
The President, Senor Alcala Zamora, began to find his position difficult. The leader of an important Party in the State, Gil Robles, provided him with a difficult problem; he had either to dissolve Parliament or admit this clerical Party to power; but he was warned by the Left that the admission of a disloyal Party would be regarded as treason. Then there was almost immediately a growth in power of the Left Wing and this was demonstrated, not only by many acts of violence, but well organised activities calculated to gain further power for the Left. And then land division took place. What was the type of land division that took place? In the Province of Badajoz, where 60,000 agricultural workers, under the leadership of Communist Deputies, to all intents and purposes took possession of the whole Province, they confiscated the big estates and proceeded to partition the land amongst themselves. Their leaders demanded of the Government that the settlers be provided with the wherewithal to cultivate the land.
The person who found himself the real leader of the extreme Left was the man who is now the head of the Communistic Government in Spain, Senor Largo Caballero. Immediately, in some parts of the country there were rumours of attempts to form a Soviet system of government, and the Confederation of Labour decided that the moment had come when an attempt should be made to establish Soviets.
Comment on this
The documents put together by a Committee representing the Parliaments of Canada, South Africa, Australia, New Zealand and Great Britain to provide information on international affairs for the use of people who cannot otherwise get it. It is called the "Report on Foreign Affairs." Next, the situation arose that the leader of the Opposition, Gil Robles, warned the Government that their Left supporters were merely awaiting a suitable opportunity for attack, which would overthrow both the Government and the Republic. Signs became apparent that the Right Wing Parties were not going to remain inactive in face of the growth and coordination of the Left Wing Parties.
The position was that the Parties of the Right found it difficult to come to an agreement on a general line of policy. The Parties of the Left did not, because the Parties of the Left, before the election in February, had come together and placed a moderate policy before the electorate and, through the moderateness of the policy they put before the electorate, they were able to get the support that they did although, as the figures I have quoted show, they were nearly 600,000 below the Parties that could be considered the Parties of the Right—that is, the Centre together with the Right. Then, the situation further changed. In Andalusia, Extremadura, Castile and elsewhere the peasants peaceably took possession of the lands and were then working the lands with every hope of having sufficient food for the coming winter. The townspeople, realising they were dependent on the food from the land for their existence, adopted a kind of rough-and-ready economic philosophy of siding with the people who took possession of the land, because they expected to get their food from them.
The Left Parties consisted of the General Labour Union with about 2,000,000 members, the National Federation, 1,000,000 members, the various Marxists, 25,000, and the Communists, 55,000. The second largest one of these, the National Federation, who were the Anarcho-Syndicalists, at a congress in May at Saragossa proposed an alliance with the General Labour Union, the largest body with 2,000,000 members, and the proposal was adopted. One of the proposals that these large Parties of the Left adopted was for the "destruction of the present social and political régime." The General Labour Union did not accept that proposal at once, but it was heartily welcomed by Largo Caballero, who subsequently became the head of the present Spanish Government. He stated that when the alliance of the whole Labour movement became an actual fact (and he was working for it) there would be no organised force, not even the State and its fighting machinery, capable of opposing "the rising tide of the masses."
It was believed by all the Parties of the Left that some form of revolutionary struggle must take place soon in order to make a complete clearance of the present "reformist" régime. Again we get a picture of the situation developing thus. On the 16th June, the leader of the Opposition reported in the Cortes that up to that time 160 churches had been destroyed, 251 churches damaged, 269 people killed, 1,287 wounded, 381 buildings attacked or damaged, 113 strikes, 228 partial strikes, 43 newspaper offices attacked and destroyed, 146 bombs thrown. These figures were challenged, but the representatives who put together this information from the various countries I speak of, and whose political interests, as far as Great Britain is concerned, as was suggested by Deputy McGilligan to-day, lie rather in the direction of the success of the Communist Government in Spain, declared that, while these figures were challenged, "it is believed that they cannot be very inaccurate."
Then there developed a movement on the part of the State teachers demanding the immediate closing of church schools. The large Parties to the Left still regarded the Government as a mere stop-gap. Gangster warfare showed itself on all sides in the beginning of July. On the night of the 12th July a lieutenant of the shock police, named José Catillo, was murdered. On the following day a group of men in the uniform of the shock police entered the house of Sénor Calva Sotelo, the outstanding leader of the Right, and murdered him in a singularly brutal manner. This act proved to be a culminating point in the Right-Left feud. The result was that throughout the country communications were cut off and a military revolt originating in the army in Morocco started.
Comment on this
I am very sorry to have to interrupt the Deputy, but I want to get this Bill and the necessary resolutions passed before 10.30 p.m.
Comment on this
As the Deputy knows, there is the possibility of opposition to a motion that we should take all the remaining stages of this Bill next week——
Comment on this
It is a peculiar kind of return for the courtesy with which the President was met to-night, when he was allowed to intervene in the debate earlier than he should have.
Comment on this
Nobody regrets more than I do—I do not know whether the Deputy will believe me or not—that I have to intervene and interrupt the Deputy. But it is necessary as the Deputy knows——
Comment on this
You were accorded the courtesy of speaking earlier to-night than you were entitled to do.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the question be now put."
Do you agree with this result?
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
Question put: "That the Bill be now read a Second Time."
Do you agree with this result?
I propose that we take the Committee Stage on Wednesday, and I want to give notice that we will have a motion on the paper to get all the Stages through that day.