We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Spanish Civil War (Non-Intervention) Bill, 1937. - Spanish Civil War (Non-Intervention) Bill, 1937—Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–136 of 264. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Spanish Civil War (Non-Intervention) Bill, 1937
Enacted

No. 4 of 1937 ›

I move amendment No. 1:—

In sub-section (1), line 20, after the word "purpose" and before the word "and" to insert the words "and after Dáil Eireann has been supplied with and approved of the scheme for enforcing non-intervention."

We have been discussing non-intervention for two or three days. I was glad to hear Deputy Dillon to-day saying that his view of non-intervention is that we in this country want General Franco's side to win and, if non-intervention is conducive to that end, he is for it; if it is not, he is against it. That is precisely my attitude. Seeing that the signs do not indicate that non-intervention will be conducive to the success of General Franco, now that this Bill is forced upon us by the majority machine in this House without giving the matter much thought, I put down this amendment to ensure that, as far as possible, if we are going to have non-intervention, we should know the mechanism of that non-intervention and whether it is likely to be effective.

I have said that the indications are that non-intervention will not be good for General Franco. My reason for saying that is the message appearing in the papers this morning from General O'Duffy. An officer of the Spanish Army could not get out such a message through the censor if General Franco wanted non-intervention. That in itself should have made us go cautiously. But the guillotine had been moved after the House heard the eloquence of my friend on the left. He told us that the only use for Christianity is to cash in on it—that was the diatribe used in this House, and, as Deputy Dillon said at the time, no honourable man would use it. The Deputy who used it cheered for General Franco that day; he cheered for him to-day, but he is voting to crucify him.

If we are going to have non-intervention, what sort will it be? Have we any evidence as to how effective it will be? Nobody from the Government side has told us what steps will be taken to protect, above all, the French frontier. Had those holding that frontier not allowed so many of the Reds to cross over it, the war would probably have been over long ago. Who is going to watch that frontier now? If that frontier is not going to be patrolled and guarded so that the proverbial crow will not pass through, then we are only being hoodwinked in this country and we are doing something that is a crime. I am perfectly convinced that we have committed a crime.

The Minister for Justice and other Ministers said we are doing nothing beyond what other nations are doing. Why were Irishmen let out and then betrayed? My phrase on that was referred to by the Minister—"that though I did not approve of the wisdom of Irishmen going out to fight in Spain." Those were my exact words, delivered in College Green six months ago.

Comment on this

What about the wild geese?

Comment on this

What about them? You did not see them outside the Irish Press, and it is only one of the many wild geese and untrue statements made by that organ, so far as I am concerned. In order to know exactly what we are doing, I submit that these few words proposed by me as an amendment should be inserted in this section. This country should not be committed to anything unless it knows what it is being committed to. We are committed now to non-intervention. Let us at least have effective non-intervention. I would like to know from the Minister in charge of this Bill what steps the Government contemplate taking.

President de Valera kept us for an hour the other night to tell us he was misrepresented, when he was quoted exactly. He was misrepresented! Because he saw the difficulty of facing the public with the obvious meaning of the words he had spoken, he cried: "I was misrepresented." He was misrepresented over "isms." He said nobody was helping the Franco Government except Italy and Germany, who were seeking there a Government after their own heart. That was his speech. Therefore, when he recognises the Caballero Government, he must be seeking a Government after his own heart.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Deputy not travelling a bit?

Comment on this

We may as well wipe the cobwebs off our eyes; we may as well look facts in the face. We were told by responsible Ministers and by the President that they never supported Communism. No, nor did they ever condemn Communism.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

The President in his speech on Friday night last.

Comment on this

Read the Official Report.

Comment on this

Where did he do it, on a public platform?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

How does condemnation or condonation of Communism arise on this amendment?

Comment on this

In this way. Before this country is committed to non-intervention we must see that it is not one-sided non-intervention. In order to know exactly what we are doing we should have the scheme proposed to be adopted to implement this Non-Intervention Pact before us here. Let us examine it and see is it going to be effective or is wool being pulled over our eyes.

Comment on this

I am in favour of the policy enshrined in this Bill and I am in favour also of the most complete and effective form of non-intervention. That is why I should like a little bit more information from the Minister for Justice as to what is likely to happen when the Bill becomes law. I would support the Bill whole-heartedly if it had been brought in and passed six months ago, because if it had been passed six months ago and had come into operation at that time it would have saved the politicians and people of this country the trouble of trying to explain to the outside world how Catholic Ireland should think fit to send two sections of its citizens to fight in a civil war in Spain. I think every politician in this country with any responsibility during the civil war we had here found it hard enough to explain, if it could ever be explained, how it was necessary for us to have a civil war in 1922 and 1923. I think it would be impossible for anybody on any side of this House to explain why two sections of our Catholic citizens should go out to fight in a civil war in another country and force us to read in the newspapers that some of these men have been killed while engaged in a civil war in a foreign country. If this Bill had been passed six months ago it would, at any rate, have saved us that trouble and that trial. The Germans, the Russians and the Italians who are on one side or the other in this war, are united and have their full forces thrown on either one side or the other but, unfortunately that is not the position of the brigades who left this country to take part in this conflict in a foreign land.

Comment on this

It is not the fact in regard to Italy either.

Comment on this

There may be individuals——

Comment on this

There are.

Comment on this

There may, of course, be individual citizens of Germany, Italy or Russia on either one side or the other, but the full force of the Russian Government and troops, and the governmental machinery—and the same applies to Italy and Germany—is thrown on either one side or the other. I am in favour of a complete and effective system of non-intervention, and by that I mean, at any rate, the refusal on the part of this Government to recognise the so-called Government of either Caballero or Franco. Deputy Belton told us here the other night that 99 per cent. of the Irish people were in favour of the recognition of the so-called Franco Government. From where did he get that information?

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is this relevant?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not at all relevant. The Deputy should not continue to travel on that line.

Comment on this

I presume that if we are to have an effective form of non-intervention, it should lead to a decision on the part of this Government to refuse to recognise either one side or the other until the civil war is over and the Spanish people, by a free vote, can decide for themselves what form of government they will have.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There is nothing about that in the amendment.

Comment on this

You should have been here on Thursday or Friday last.

Comment on this

I am sorry to say that circumstances prevented me from being here.

Comment on this

I am extremely sorry to hear it, because you would have been a welcome aid.

Comment on this

I am saying what I truly believe.

Comment on this

The only thing is that you should have said it on Thursday or Friday.

Comment on this

It is never too late to mend. I wonder what Deputy McGilligan, as Minister for External Affairs at a particular period, would think if the Spanish Government in 1922 and 1923 sent a diplomatic representative here to recognise the de Valera republican Government at that time?

Comment on this

We would have hurled him out.

Comment on this

Is not that the kind of suggestion Deputy Belton and you are making when you say that this Government should recognise the Franco Government or refuse to recognise the Caballero Government?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is travelling over what I have already indicated is not relevant to the amendment. I ask him to confine himself to the amendment, which is

"...and after Dáil Eireann has been supplied with and approved the scheme for enforcing non-intervention."

That has nothing to do with the recognition of either of the presumed Governments.

Comment on this

Is not the Deputy now making the speech which he intended to make on Thursday or Friday?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not concerned with that.

Comment on this

What Deputy McGilligan is trying to do is to anticipate what I was going to say and, in that very cute Parliamentary style of his, prevent me from saying what I have a perfect right to say.

Comment on this

What you were going to say.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I think you are in order.

Comment on this

I am in order, I submit, in asking the Government, when submitting this scheme which is called for, to provide in the scheme for refusal, under existing circumstances, to recognise either the so-called Government of Caballero or the so-called Government of Franco. That is a fair point to make in support of the amendment.

Comment on this

It is the amendment.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton did not make that plain.

Comment on this

I submit that the relations with these various Governments in the matter of diplomatic representation have nothing to do with the enforcement of a measure of non-intervention.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is the point I am endeavouring to make, that the question whether the scheme for non-intervention should recognise, or otherwise, either of the two presumed Governments in Spain does not arise on the amendment.

Comment on this

I am beginning to think that Deputy MacDermot is deciding points of order.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

No. The Deputy must not say that to the Chair. The Chair rules on its own and is not coerced or induced by any Deputy.

Comment on this

I withdraw that remark if it has any application to yourself, but Deputy MacDermot is determined to see that I will not be allowed to say anything if he can help it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

He is entitled to raise a point of order, just as any other Deputy is, and he has exercised that right.

Comment on this

He is obviously prejudiced against you.

Comment on this

I took the trouble, and it meant a good deal of trouble, to read the two-and-a-quarter hour speech made by Deputy Belton on Friday last and the other speeches made during the 12 hours' sitting.

Comment on this

You do not seem to have learned anything.

Comment on this

I learned this, that apparently there was a very deliberate attempt, successful to an extent, on the part of the Opposition in this House, including Deputy Belton, to misrepresent the position of the Party with which I am associated.

Comment on this

I never mentioned the Party with which you are associated.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton says he did not make any attempt to misrepresent the Party with which I am associated As a matter of fact, a paid official——

Comment on this

Is this relevant to the amendment?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I will hear what the Deputy is going to say first.

Comment on this

Surely he has a right to represent his Party?

Comment on this

This is the first opportunity that has been afforded to any member of this Party to speak, as far as I know. We have a Party, and Deputy MacDermot only represents himself and perhaps half a dozen people in Roscommon. I think it is unfair that he should endeavour to hold me up when I am attempting to put my views on a matter like this before the House.

Comment on this

On what matter?

Comment on this

The Deputy is not the person in a position to say whether I should or should not say anything. There has been a deliberate attempt on the part of members of the Opposition to misrepresent the views of members of the Labour Party. The members of the Labour Party publicly declared the anti-Communistic attitude of that Party at the annual conference in 1934.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The attitude of the Labour Party towards Communism does not arise on the amendment, nor does the attitude of any other Party.

Comment on this

I was making the point that in order to give effect to the amendment moved by Deputy Belton, it was presumed that the Government should recognise either of the two Spanish Governments. Am I entitled to make a case on these lines, seeing that Deputy Belton did so?

Comment on this

I will permit you.

Comment on this

Will the Chair give me an assurance that I will not be again interrupted by Deputy MacDermot if I attempt to proceed? I want to see a democratic system of government re-established in Spain but, before that can be done, or before the people of Spain get an opportunity of voicing their views regarding the future form of government they want, the civil war must come to a conclusion.

Comment on this

On a point of order, this has nothing whatever to do with the amendment. We have a limited time for discussion and we are now getting back to Second Reading speeches.

Comment on this

In view of the policy of non-intervention let the Deputy proceed.

Comment on this

I will gladly sit down if Deputy Minch will speak. He speaks so seldom, and with little sense, when he does speak, that I will give way now.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin tells us that he wants to see democratic government re-established in Spain. Part of the struggle we are carrying on here for the past couple of days is to see democratic government re-established in this country. We want to deal with an important question like this in a way in which a Parliament erected on democratic principles, and carrying on with respect for these principles, would deal with it. I sympathise very much with this amendment, as I think it bears on the general lines of the attitude the House would have towards this Bill. We have emphasised repeatedly that we stand for non-intervention. But we would expect, when putting such a measure before the House, after non-intervention in the matter of arms had been tried and failed, that in a measure dealing with non-intervention in the matter of men as well as arms, the Government would put before it a plan indicating how that plan was expected to work. We are interested to see what countries are going to be responsible for enforcing the Non-Intervention Pact, and what machinery they are going to adopt. We should like to have that information as an indication of what the end of non-intervention is likely to be in Spain. Part of the difficulty that has arisen from the closure of the Second Reading discussion, and from the closure of the Committee and Final Stages, is that the Government have given no information good, bad or indifferent. The country is asked to accept a non-intervention Bill as a measure that is going to ensure success of the Franco Government and, therefore, the rehabilitation of a Government in Spain that will give fair play, to say nothing more, to the religion of the vast majority of the people there. From the information we are able to get in odd ways, here and there, we know that certain countries have intervened on one side and have sent men to Spain. Certain opinions have been expressed as to what non-intervention is going to mean, but I should like to put before the House one or two quotations from volumes of reports on foreign affairs that I was putting before the House on Friday night when I was stopped, as indicating the problems raised and the necessity of getting information on the amendment. In the Non-Intervention Committee in September last the representatives of Great Britain and France held that non-intervention was in favour of the Madrid Government. It is fair to say that the Madrid Government did not accept that opinion. Subsequently it is stated on page 663:—

"No convincing estimates of the numbers of these foreigners were available by the end of December, but it was reliably asserted that by that date not less than 15,000 Germans, 5,000 Italians and others had joined General Franco's Army and, on the Government side, not less than 10,000 experienced soldiers from other countries had joined Largo Caballero."

Another extract from the report states:—

"General Franco's military position was becoming critical through shortage of good fighting man-power."

Comment on this

What has this to do with the amendment?

Comment on this

Certain facts existed in Spain, and these facts were influenced because soldiers from other countries had gone to Spain and were fighting on both sides. The machinery that is going to be set up to enforce non-intervention is, I take it, going to be provided by these countries, and supervised either by their representatives or by a combination of them. If the position is that from Russia and other countries 10,000 experienced soldiers have gone to join Largo Caballero, we want to know what position that Government is going to have in the control of the non-intervention machinery; and if 15,000 Germans and 5,000 Italians have gone to Spain, we are interested to know what is the position of the German and the Italian Governments in relation to the non-intervention machinery; whether we can have confidence that the machinery being set up is not going to assist the nationals of one or other European Governments to continue the kind of interference in the Spanish war that has been going on up to the present.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that the German and Italian Governments have recognised the Franco Government, and are not parties to non-intervention?

Comment on this

They are parties to it.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin had difficulties when Deputies were putting questions to him. I think I am in order in saying that if the Deputy is in any way interested in this matter, particularly when he thinks there is something in Deputy Belton's amendment, if he listens he will get some facts that he did not get from the Government, and that it is questionable if Deputies in their ordinary daily reading could get. However, these Governments to that extent have intervened. It was the opinion in September of the French and British representatives on the Non-Intervention Committee that non-intervention favoured the Madrid Government, and the military position in Spain, as indicated in the Foreign Affairs Report at the end of December was that:

"The struggle itself became more acute, because of these outside factors. General Franco's military position was becoming critical through shortage of good fighting man-power. His foreign legion and Moors had grown thoroughly exhausted from having borne the brunt of nearly all the heavy fighting, and he could not rely upon the garrisons of regular army units to take their place in the front line. Hence, foreign aid was essential to replace the weary Moors and legionaries, if he should win. On the Government side there was no shortage of man-power."

Comment on this

What is the Deputy quoting from?

Comment on this

From the Empire parliamentary Association Report on Foreign Affairs for the months of November and December, 1936, page 663. After all the talk that we have heard from the Government Benches, and from other benches in this House, as to how they stand, we ought to have some statement of the facts as regards the present situation in Spain, and some statement of the facts as to what is proposed under this Bill. If we are a democratic Government, taking decisions that are going to be helpful in Europe, and are going to be helpful on the side that we want to see win in Spain——

Comment on this

What side is that?

Comment on this

The side that is fighting against the Communist Government in Spain.

Comment on this

It should be the side of the Spanish people.

Comment on this

That is the side of the Spanish people.

Comment on this

From time to time we hear talk about popular fronts, and I am sure if there were talk about a popular front here we would be criticised very much for suggesting it was not on the side of the people. We are concerned about the victory in Spain of the people who in July last were burning churches, murdering bishops, murdering priests and destroying schools, the people whose Minister for Education sent a message to the anti-God meeting in Moscow the other day about wiping religion out of the country.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is travelling a good deal.

Comment on this

If you could keep Deputy Davin in order I would not travel half that distance.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should now try to confine himself to Deputy Belton's amendment.

Comment on this

I have covered practically all the ground I want. If we are passing a non-intervention law in this country, or standing for it, we ought at least to get a chance of opening our eyes as to what the facts are; we should be helped by the Government, who alone has the information, to open our eyes to them. Is the non-intervention machinery going to be operated in a way that is going to allow Russian troops in to assist the Caballero Government, which is declared here at the end of December to be in no want of man power? That is the matter that this House is concerned with and, therefore, I think the amendment put down by Deputy Belton is a reasonable one, as an amendment endeavouring to extract some information from the Government on this matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Joseph Ruttledge Minister for Justice (Mr. Ruttledge) Fianna Fáil

We are only asking this House to do what Legislatures in other countries have already done, and what others are in the course of doing.

Comment on this

What about the recruiting of non-nationals? I do not understand that that is done anywhere else—the prevention of recruiting of non-nationals. I asked a question to-day, and was told that there is no information that any of the other countries is doing this.

Comment on this

The Deputy is referring to Question No. 3, to which the reply was as follows:—

"I am not in a position to say whether the legislative measures referred to in the preceding answer prohibit the recruiting, transit and dispatch of persons other than their own nationals as volunteers for Spain. It is anticipated, however, that the Governments represented on the Non-Intervention Committee are taking the necessary steps towards that end in accordance with the agreement of the Non-Intervention Committee of the 16th February."

Comment on this

Then why say we are only doing what other nations are doing?

Comment on this

We are doing what was proposed by the Non-Intervention Committee.

Comment on this

But we have no information that any other nation is doing what we propose here.

Comment on this

We are following the Non-Intervention Committee's agreement. Our object is to ensure, in regard to that agreement entered into between those 27 countries, that so far as we are concerned we are going to make it effective: that we are going to carry out that agreement. If it is found subsequently that other countries have not carried out that agreement, that is a matter which will arise before the Non-Intervention Committee. If it is found that other countries are ignoring agreements already arrived at, I think the position could be and would be reviewed here. With regard to the measures to be taken, the position is that it is proposed to have supervision with regard to the land frontiers between Spain and the countries adjacent to it, and also to have the navies of Great Britain, Italy, Germany and France——

Comment on this

And Russia?

Comment on this

And Portugal.

Comment on this

So far as the report I have seen is concerned, I have not seen that Russia was included, but I accept the Deputy's correction.

Comment on this

Do you think they should not be included?

Comment on this

I do not.

Comment on this

Do you think they should?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

And they are not being included?

Comment on this

According to what I have seen up to the present, they were not included in the zones that were to be divided up for the purpose of preventing recruits or other people from going in.

Comment on this

If the Minister will allow me to intervene, I think the situation as reported in the newspapers is that——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I have asked for information not from the newspapers, but from the Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

I want information from the Minister and not from the newspapers; I can read that for myself.

Comment on this

As the Minister has been kind enough to allow me to intervene, I do so merely for the purpose of pointing out that the situation appears to be that the co-operation of the Russian Navy has been accepted in principle, but there is still some doubt as to what portion of the coast is going to be under the charge of it.

Comment on this

Is that an official statement on behalf of the Ministry?

Comment on this

He has made other official statements.

Comment on this

In the report I saw of official decisions arrived at, Russia was not included at the time.

Comment on this

What was the date? How far back is your information?

Comment on this

In any case I do not see what point there is in it. I am sure the Russian Government, just the same as the Italian and German Governments, should be considered in those matters. I do not see that even a debating point arises there. In any event, a number of details have to be provided and agreed upon by the Non-Intervention Committee before I would be able to give Deputy Belton all the information he wants.

Comment on this

That is what I want.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that this agreement will not, in certain respects, be effective until 7th March, and that in the meantime a number of details have to be worked out as to the officials that will man the frontiers, the type of officials and so on. So far as we are concerned, we are going to ensure, at any rate, that as soon as the necessary Order is made there will be no recruitment in this country, and there will be no more expeditions of volunteers from this country to Spain.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister has really answered the point of Deputy Belton's amendment. My own point of view, and I think it is representative of the ordinary point of view in this country, is that, irrespective of what may be the feeling in the other 26 countries, the people of this country quite rightly think that involved in this fight now going on in Spain are certain transcendent values. We do not regard it as a matter of indifference to us what the outcome is. With regard to non-intervention, we are prepared to participate in non-intervention under certain conditions. We are not prepared to do so if that agreement is used to the advantage of the wrong side and to the disadvantage of the right. Usually, bringing in a law, the Government is exercising its own powers. It is taking certain powers which it can use effectively. In this, the actual creation of a condition of non-intervention in Spain is not possible for our Government. They can only participate in that with others. The Minister says here that so far as this country is concerned, at any rate, they intend to make non-intervention effective. That will be acceptable, provided we are satisfied that the same applies to every other country. If he says that all that matters is that so far as we are concerned, non-intervention shall be made applicable, I entirely disagree.

What we want, and want earnestly, is that the Franco side in Spain should win and anything we can do to assist them we are prepared to do. We are quite prepared, judging the circumstances there, to participate in a real non-intervention. Now, what do we find? First, as I pointed out the other day, a sub-committee of the Non-Intervention Committee came to certain decisions, announced that they had come to these decisions and that people who were not on that Committee were necessarily going to agree to them, and we duly agreed. The Minister for Education said—I do not want to misrepresent him but the effect of his statement was—that it was too much to expect that our Government, when participating in any international gathering, should dare even to ask a question.

Comment on this

The Deputy should quote.

Comment on this

I cannot quote, but I do not want to misrepresent the Minister. He rather ridiculed the idea that when there were big countries present, with big interests involved, we should go out on a line of our own, or even ask a question. That, I think, was implicit in the Minister's words. Our Government, a member of the outside body, allowed the special select body, the inside body, to decide with regard to this. What has happened? When the fighting began, everybody knows that thousands of recruits passed over the French frontier. The one specific case of definite Government participation in intervention that one can point to is that of Russia. In Russia, there is no producer, no owner, no trader and no exporter, except the Russian Government, and in as much as everybody knows that in Spain at this moment fighting for the Communist-Anarchist side are Russian tanks, Russian arms and Russians, we know that those tanks were produced by the producer in Russia, the Russian Government, that they were Russian Government owned tanks and were shipped on Russian Government owned boats, manned by Russian Government employees, to Spain. Therefore, the only Government we can definitely accuse of participation is the Russian Government.

The Minister does not apparently take sufficient interest in this matter to bother reading the newspapers, but the newspapers indicate that the Russian fleet were allotted a certain part of the North Coast of Spain for their area of patrol, and that they have protested, and that they want a part on the East Coast of Spain, which, incidentally, would be a very nice part for anyone to control who wanted to allow free ingress of arms and men to assist Communism in Spain. I myself happen to know very well the northern frontier of Spain. I have travelled the Pyrenees from Cerbere to Hendaye, and only once since passports came into operation have I ever got into a country without a passport. Walking from Catalonia across Andorra, with a passport in my pocket ready to show to the first French official, I got right into Hospitalet and afterwards into Aix-le-Thermes and never met anybody to ask me for my passport. Everybody who knows that frontier, where the mountain range is very wide and where smuggling has been an occupation, and a very satisfactory occupation for those who pursued it, knows perfectly well that it is practically impossible for the French Government, if it wanted to, and for the local governing authorities in the south of France to effectively prevent recruitment across that frontier.

Now, we are asked here not to question what any other people is going to do, although, admittedly, their Governments have participated in and have connived at the breaking of the non-intervention arrangements to which they had already been parties. Not only is our Government to say that, so far as we are concerned and so far as this country is concerned, we will see that nobody and no assistance goes from this country to assist the cause that we think is of transcendent importance, but it is unthinkable that we should even try to find out if anything approaching that same condition is being produced in other countries. We know perfectly well that the Russian Government has not bothered about keeping its word already in this matter, and we know that at this moment they have already been allotted a portion of the Spanish coast to patrol, and that they are asking for a portion of the Spanish coast which would enable them most effectively to thwart the object of non-intervention by allowing recruits and arms in to support the Reds in Spain. This amendment, as I understand it, merely asks that before this is made effective, information will be given to the Dáil to allow us to judge whether the agreement that is entered into is going to be as effectively implemented by other countries, who are anxious to assist the Reds in Spain, as it obviously is going to be implemented in this country, where we are all anxious to assist the anti-Reds in Spain.

I think that when the Minister got up what he might have said was whether or not he was accepting Deputy Belton's amendment, and, if he was not accepting it, to give a sound reason for not accepting it. Instead of that, he merely showed that the President is not sufficiently interested as Minister for External Affairs to come in and deal with this Bill. He was more anxious the other night to try to prove that the words he said meant what they could not possibly mean, and to suggest that they did not possess the only meaning they could possibly have. He has wasted the time of this House by talking for a long time also with a view to explaining that Deputy Hugo Flinn's words meant what they could not possibly mean.

Comment on this

May I inquire whether we are continuing the discussion on the Second Reading of the Bill?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

No, we are not.

Comment on this

I can quite understand that the Minister does not want that matter raised.

Comment on this

I have no objection, but might I call your attention to the fact that the debate was understood to be restricted? I have no objection to raising all the issues that were raised on the Second Reading debate. I am quite prepared to do so, but I was under the impression that the Chair had ruled that we were not to go back.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair has very decided objection to the Second Reading debate being resumed on this amendment. Deputy Fitzgerald is certainly travelling outside relevancy when he is dealing with what the President said and what defence he made of certain remarks on the Second Reading debate.

Comment on this

I have possibly been somewhat irrelevant, but it came in as a sideline. The President, who is in charge of this Bill, is not bothering to be present, and he only comes in to say that his words did not mean what they did mean. He has left in charge a Minister who obviously does not know as much about this situation as any ordinary man or woman walking up and down the street. What we want to see is somebody who will say whether or not the Government is accepting this amend ment, and, if it is not accepting it, somebody who will give a reasoned and reasonable ground for not accepting it.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister one question——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy MacDermot.

Comment on this

Commonsense tells us that the powers interested in this matter of non-intervention will watch each other like hawks. It is very unlikely, indeed, that Italy and Germany, to name no others, would allow Russia to get away with breaches of the Non-Intervention Pact; and very unlikely that Russia and, perhaps France, would allow Italy and Germany to get away with breaches of the pact on their side. I suggest that if every nation that is concerned in this matter is going to wait until it has proof positive that non-intervention has worked, then non-intervention will never begin to work, because every nation will be watching every other nation. Surely the commonsense view to take is that the arrangements will work satisfactorily. We are assured that there are to be foreign observers on the French frontier and foreign observers on the Portuguese frontier——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I suggest Deputy MacDermot is out of order. The amendment asks that this be postponed until "after Dáil Eireann has been supplied with and approved of the scheme for enforcing non-intervention." The Deputy is obviously speaking about an amendment which is not down—an amendment asking that this shall be held up until such time as we have watched the operation of the non-intervention methods—satisfied ourselves as to their workings. That is not the case.

Comment on this

What I suggest is perfectly relevant to the amendment as it stands.

Comment on this

But it is not the amendment about which the Deputy is speaking.

Comment on this

There is no need for this extreme distrust which is causing us to hang back and not go on because other people may not go on with their undertakings. I take it that, if non-intervention measures do prove to be a farce, there is nothing in the world to stop us from announcing that we have come to that conclusion and going out of the Non-Intervention Pact. The main task we have to perform here is similar to what is being done in every other country concerned, and that is to get on with our own job. If there are unsatisfactory developments later we can deal with these unsatisfactory developments when they arise.

Comment on this

It seems the only interpretation we can put on the remarks of the Minister is that this Bill is not the Bill that they suggested to the House it was—that this is a Bill to prevent anybody going to the Spanish war from this country.

Comment on this

That is a misrepresentation of what I stated.

Comment on this

The only impression the Minister leaves on me is that this Bill is not the Bill that was portrayed by Ministerial statements; that it is a Bill to prevent people going from this country to the Spanish war; that it is a Bill to get us to take our attention as a Parliament, and to take the attention of our Government here, as a Government, completely off the present Spanish position, completely off any consideration of what the Spanish position is to be in a month, two months, three months or six months' time, to take our attention off anything that is going to happen as a result of non-intervention being ineffective in other countries.

Comment on this

If other countries do not make it effective, it is a matter that can be reviewed.

Comment on this

What will you do then?

Comment on this

The President, on the Second Reading, indicated his desire for unity of action and co-operation. He invited the co-operation of all Parties in favour of an effective scheme of non-intervention. I think a very reasonable and sound case has been made in support of this amendment. I think so because the case put forward by Deputy Fitzgerald has not been answered. I understand from the President's Second Reading speech that this country is free, without consultation with any other nation in the Commonwealth, to take its own line in connection with the policy of non-intervention. That makes it more desirable, to my mind, because of the peculiar situation in this country, that there should be united action on the part of the Dáil. My view is that a very reasonable case has been made in favour of the amendment. Another argument is that we are now under a Single Chamber system of government here, and I think, rather than allow our Government to go ahead on lines which they might afterwards find would be wrong, it would be better, in the interests of the country as a whole, to accept this amendment, especially after seeing that our country is likely to take a different line or view-point from the other nations of the Commonwealth. That is one of the reasons why I think this amendment should be accepted. In that way the Government could secure the co-operation of all Parties in this House.

Comment on this

The long title of this Bill is "An Act to carry into execution the international obligations of Saorstát Eireann in relation to the civil war now being waged in Spain ...." As I understand Deputy Belton's amendment, it is aimed to secure that as we are by this Bill undertaking international obligations, the Dáil, and, through the Dáil, the people of Saorstát Eireann who have undertaken these obligations, ought be assured that the other parties to this agreement who have undertaken similar obligations, internationally, will carry out these obligations in the same full measure as we intend to carry them out, and that the Dáil should have information as to the method by which that end will be secured.

Deputy MacDermot said there is no need for the extreme distrust that is being displayed in reference to the other international parties to this non-intervention measure. I suggest that there is every need for this distrust. It has been made abundantly clear from these benches what our attitude is on the question of the policy of non-intervention. We are in favour of non-intervention on the lines and for the reasons suggested by Deputies O'Sullivan, Dillon and Mulcahy. I want to say for myself that, while I fall in with that policy of non-intervention, I see nothing sacrosanct embodied in that policy. That policy has been put forward by some Deputies as if it were some sacred principle of international relations that we almost adore and as if there was something fundamental in this policy of non-intervention. The real truth is that it is a pure question of expediency and that there is nothing at all sacred in it.

Comment on this

Who said there was?

Comment on this