We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Spanish Civil War (Non-Intervention) Bill, 1937. - Spanish Civil War (Non-Intervention) Bill, 1937—Committee Stage.

Contributions 137–264 of 264. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Spanish Civil War (Non-Intervention) Bill, 1937
Enacted

No. 4 of 1937 ›

Deputy MacDermot asks who said there was. He has been almost saying his prayers to this policy of non-intervention for the last few days. There is, I submit, every reason for this need for distrust. The policy of non-intervention is founded on pure expediency. The nations who are gathered together in the Non-Intervention Committee in London, or represented there, are, each and every one of them, playing for their own hands and we have got to watch out to see that we are not led or misled by any other nations along a road that we ought not to travel. Therefore, there is every need for this distrust. I have the greatest admiration for British diplomacy, but I have no delusions about it.

Comment on this

You were not always so.

Comment on this

We know who are getting the delusions now.

Comment on this

When I find France and Germany agreeing upon a course of action with regard to Spain I look upon that agreement and the policy which they adopt with extreme suspicion. Therefore the people of this country ought not to be and will not be deluded into the belief, as some Deputies who spoke here would have them believe, that there is something sacrosanct in this policy of non-intervention. When we find France and Britain, Germany, Italy and the Soviet Republics joining together for one alleged common object, then we ought to begin to take notice and examine our own political and international consciences to know if we are not in some extraordinarily strange company. We are in a terrible hurry under this Bill to honour our international obligations. I think that the country is entitled to know, by means of the information that would be given if Deputy Belton's amendment were carried, what effective provision is to be made to secure that other countries, equally with this country, will honourably carry out their international obligations. That is the object of the amendment, as I understand, and that is why it has met with my approval. Deputy Mulcahy spoke about the impression the Minister's speech made upon his mind. It made precisely the same impression on my mind. I had, as a matter of fact, taken a note to refer to it. The only emphasis the Minister placed on any portion of his speech was on the sentence: "We are going to see immediately that there will be no recruiting from this country."

Comment on this

What is wrong with that?

Comment on this

I shall tell you if you wait a moment. It was almost impossible to hear the other portion of the Minister's speech but he came as near to heat as he is capable of attaining when making that statement. While the Minister was speaking in this fashion I had a mental vision of what was operating in his mind. He was thinking of General O'Duffy and his Fascist army, as described by the Minister for Finance. This is not a Bill to honour our international obligations at all. It is a Bill to prevent General O'Duffy bringing recruits to Spain.

Comment on this

What about the other brigade?

Comment on this

Where is there any other brigade?

Comment on this

Some people left this country who had sympathy with neither Communism nor Fascism, who were strong supporters of this Party and who went for honourable reasons. They left good jobs for Spain in what they believed to be in the interests of their religion and not in the interest of Fascism. I believe that this Bill is brought in because it was General O'Duffy started the Irish Brigade. That is the real reason. An unanswerable case has been made for Deputy Belton's amendment. We are going to honour our international obligations. When we find ourselves in such strange company as that of Socialist France, Protestant England, irreligious Russia and Germany, and Fascist Italy, I want to know to what we are going to commit ourselves. What steps are we to be committed to by those other people who regard one another with extreme disgust and who will be playing their own hands for their own diplomatic ends?

Comment on this

It is rather a tribute to the virtues of parliamentary government that Deputy Davin should have found himself so swayed by one argument that he is now a definite adherent to a proposal of which he knew very little before he came into the House. Perhaps he will become even more enthusiastic for it. The amendment ought to be properly considered. It is in relation to a section which is headed "Commencement and duration of the measure." Deputy Belton has a very clear aim. It is that this measure, which establishes an addition to the criminal code of the country and under which certain people may be made criminals, should not come into operation until we see whether the mess of pottage for which, in a certain sense, the national soul is being sold, is worth having. How can we see that? In the first place, should we have any say in the matter at all? The Minister for Education angrily objected when it was put to him that, in the course of his speech here on Friday, he created the impression that it was not for a small nation like Ireland to intervene in these questions.

Comment on this

To intervene when intervention on our part would demand, or seem to demand, action that we would not be capable of pursuing.

Comment on this

Let me give a quotation from the Minister's speech which is not in accord with that interpretation. The Minister was adverting to the fact that I had asked whether, when certain discussions were taking place at the Non-Intervention Committee, our representative had even asked a question, not to speak of proposing a resolution or bringing forward a scheme. Here is what the Minister said in relation to what a certain argument had got to do with Spain:

"It has got to do with the statement of Deputy McGilligan that our representative at the Non-Intervention Committee should have got up there in front of the representatives of Great Britain, France, Russia, Germany, England, and the 20 other nations represented, and asked questions, demanded that certain things be done and, presumably, be satisfied in the name of the Irish Free State Government before he gave his consent to the proposals submitted."

Surely, it was a natural thing to ask if our representative on this committee had been informed and to ask that the House be told whether he agreed that the information given him was sufficient to win his adherence to whatever proposals were put forward. The Minister thought it was amazing to expect our representative to stand up in front of these big people and ask certain questions. Later in his speech he said:

"I question myself whether we should stand out and take an independent attitude as if we were a big power capable of carrying into effect in some way the policy which our independent attitude indicates. It is very well known that we cannot very often take up an independent attitude in these matters, no matter how much we might desire it."

We have the confession from the Minister for Education that it is not possible for this country to take up an independent attitude on these matters and that the proposals that have come from the Non-Intervention Committee may not have met with the acceptance of our delegate. He may somehow have been browbeaten or overawed into some sort of tacit adherence to what was proposed. This Bill is intended to carry out our international obligations and is not confined to the sending of volunteers. The question of non-intervention, in so far as proposals were put forward at that Committee, may be divided into three parts. The first part is concerned with the export of arms and ammunition. The President told us, in introducing this Bill, that all these same nations had pledged themselves to prevent the export of arms and ammunition to Spain and had failed to carry out their promise. We are asked to stand behind proposals which our representative on the Committee did not question and behind proposals put forward by a group of nations which previously put forward proposals to prevent the export of arms and ammunition to Spain and failed to carry out their guarantees. There are two proposals now before the Committee. The first proposal, with regard to the sending of volunteers, was effective as from Saturday night last. The next proposal is with regard to the patrolling of the coasts. The scheme has not yet been arranged and it is not proposed to make it effective before the 6th March. In addition to that, General Franco, by letter, raised two points and another representative raised another point as to what was going to happen in the case of aircraft, propaganda and the influx of finance to back up one or other of the two sides. We are proposing to block intervention. Intervention may be by means of arms and ammunition going into Spain, by men going into Spain, by aircraft going in there, by propaganda or by gold having its effect. Deputy Belton says that we should not commit ourselves to degrading certain of our citizens and treating them as criminals until we know what the scheme is and whether it is likely to be effective.

We are asked to turn that down as an unreasonable proposition. Deputy MacDermot, who wants another pat of commendation from some Government Deputy, distorts the argument and says that we should wait until we see the scheme working. Deputy Belton is not even asking that, although it might be reasonable to do so in face of the fact that the big nations which gave other guarantees on the matter of arms and ammunition broke down on their performance. Delay on the part of this country until we see the scheme working is not asked for. What is asked for are details of the scheme to see whether it is likely to prove effective or not, and whether it covers all the points that have been mentioned. We have been told that the big nations will be watching each other like hawks. Of course, they will, although on the question of arms and ammunition they did not find it possible to find a scheme which they could keep to. We have a representative on the Non-Intervention Committee. Surely we might, at least, expect that if he is powerless in the matter of action, he would be alert in reporting as to what takes place. In that way we might expect that some information would filter through to this House as to what the proposals are, and the likelihood of their being carried into effect. Apparently, he has not even reported correctly to the Minister. In any event, the Minister is not possessed of the information which Deputies in this House could get, and that some have shown they have got, through reading the newspapers.

Comment on this

That is the newspapers, but that is not a decision of the Non-Intervention Committee.

Comment on this

I am not saying that, but the matter has moved from the point that we had under discussion here on Thursday and Friday and on that the Minister, apparently, has no information. The Minister, parading himself to-day in not knowing whether the Russian fleet was to take part in the patrolling of the coast, was certainly in a lamentable position.

Comment on this

That has not been agreed to.

Comment on this

The Minister was discussing the whole thing from the angle of the proposal, and in the context of the proposal he indicated the view-point that Russia was not in it. In the matter of the proposal Russia was.

Comment on this

There has been no decision.

Comment on this

The Minister was speaking of the proposal. There is no necessity to quibble about it.

Comment on this

I am not trying to quibble.

Comment on this

No definite conclusion has been come to on the matter at all. The Minister was, therefore, talking of the proposals. It was stated here with accuracy on Thursday night that there were at least two proposals with regard to patrolling the coast. There were to be four sectors, each to be patrolled by one of the four fleets. The Russian counter-proposal was that there should be one fleet of mixed units. Recently there was a move forward from this, and there was a suggestion that Russia should be assigned to some area around the Bay of Biscay. The Minister, apparently, has no information as to the Russian view-point on that. The matter has not yet been decided. When we are asked to take a definite step on this, Deputy Belton's attitude is "Pass your measure if you like, but stay your hand in bringing it into operation until such time as the details of the scheme are revealed to this House and approved of by it." It appears to be an easy answer to that to say: "If non-intervention proves to be a farce, we can denounce it and get out of it." But can we? Can we repair all the harm that has been done in the meantime?

I ask Deputies to look at Section 5, which must be read in conjunction with Section 2. It is provided that the Act will come into operation after a certain date. That may be a month hence. If it does come into operation a month hence, any person who, under Section 5, has attempted to obtain a commission in the belligerent forces as from the date of the passing of the Act is declared to be a criminal. Suppose that in a few months' time we have a number of men in jail, and suddenly discover that this grand scheme of non-intervention is a futile thing and decide to get out of it, what happens the poor men in jail? They have been jailed because they decided to make an attempt to get in amongst the belligerents in Spain, and here it is proposed to make them criminals in the interests of non-intervention which we may hereafter discover to be an impossible thing. But the harm will have been done.

I suggest that, in the light of the answers given to me to-day, to say that we are only doing what is our bounden duty under an international obligation is a gross exaggeration of the facts. I asked two questions to-day. First of all, I wanted to know whether we were stepping in in a hurried way into the breach, and I endeavoured to find out what all the other members of the non-intervention countries had done. I wanted to know which of the countries represented on the Non-Intervention Committee had legislative authority, or had introduced legislation, to prohibit their own nationals going as volunteers to Spain. One is Great Britain, but Great Britain is operating through the old Foreign Enlistment Act. If Great Britain is going to operate on the lines of preventing nationals of other countries going to Spain, she can only operate on nationals going from this country as British subjects and as nothing else, because that is the only legislation Great Britain has at her disposal. Belgium is also said to have legislation. These are the only two countries that had power in regard to their own nationals prior to the 16th February. Since then legislation for the same purpose was brought into operation—I will have to query this later on—by nine other countries. Those nine are said to be taking measures.

In my second question I sought to find out how many countries had covered the same territory that we proposed to cover in relation to prohibiting not merely their own nationals but in taking power to prohibit the nationals of other countries moving about their own country with a view to going to Spain. I find that the Department are unable to say that any legislation contains these powers. The only thing is that there is a pious hope, an expression, that the Governments' representatives are taking the necessary steps towards this end. I note in the typescript of the reply to my first question that the person who drafted the answer anticipated that the Governments represented on the Non-Intervention Committee "will take" the necessary steps towards this end, but the words "will take" are transformed into "are taking." So that without any information we are jumping in ahead of anybody else to do what none of the others are doing. We are doing that at the behest of the President who, speaking last week of the same Non-Intervention Group, said of them that while they came to a conclusion that arms and ammunition should be stopped going into Spain and gave guarantees to that effect, they failed to carry out their guarantee. We are represented on this Non-Intervention Committee by a man who apparently does not want to take any action on the committee, and our Minister for Education feels that he should not even ask a question on it. Deputy Belton takes a much more democratic view, which is that this House should not be committed to an enlargement of the criminal code until this House has had put before it, and is satisfied, that there is a good scheme likely to be effective for the purpose of achieving the end of this Bill.

Comment on this

It is true that Deputy Belton's amendment only asks for details of the scheme of enforcement. Every argument that can be used in favour of the amendment can be used more strongly in favour of waiting to see how the thing is actually working. I put it to the House and to Deputy McGilligan in particular, is it a practical suggestion that we who will have little to do with the enforcement of non-intervention outside our own country, should sit back and refuse to act until we hear all the details and how the various fleets are going to be distributed around Spain, how many observers there are going to be on the French frontier and on the Portuguese frontier?

Comment on this

That is not even asked for.

Comment on this

If we are going to wait for full details of the scheme of enforcement, that is asked for.

Comment on this

No, it is not.

Comment on this

Why not?

Comment on this

If there is sufficient of a scheme to put forward to warrant the approval of this Dáil for it, that is sufficient.

Comment on this

Yes, but what is the scheme to consist of? Is it to be something that is truly comprehensive, and, if it is not to be something truly comprehensive, is it going to satisfy Deputy Belton or those who will vote this evening?

Comment on this

It is the House that will vote on it.

Comment on this

Yes, but how is the House to make up its mind on that matter? Will we not hear the same kind of speeches as we have heard already this evening? Deputy Costello said that we were being faced with a kind of trap, and that we were being asked to walk into the trap. The fact that certain nations, such as Germany, France, Great Britain, Russia, and other countries, are working together, seems to fill him with suspicion. Why is that? One would imagine that the coming together of such great nations as these would hardly be for a purpose, as the Deputy practically suggested, of conspiracy between them to the disadvantage of a nation like ours. I suggest that, while it is true that the whole policy of non-intervention is founded on a policy of expediency, the need for that expediency is overwhelming and that the motive that could have brought such countries as Germany, France, Russia, and the other countries involved, together, is the motive of preventing a European war. I think that that motive stands out to be seen plainly by anybody who does not wilfully refuse to see it, and I say, and protest, that the line or argument that has been hitherto used in support of this amendment is purely obstructive.

Comment on this
Thomas Derrig Minister for Education (Mr. Derrig) Fianna Fáil

I should like to say, Sir, that the House has already been informed that the scheme for supervision will not come into force much before the 6th of March——

Comment on this

Another change in the date.

Comment on this

——and that certain details have to be arranged before that scheme can come into operation. It is not claimed, I think, by anybody who has an understanding of the situation, that the work of the Non-Intervention Committee is likely to be perfect. Apart from being satisfied as to the details, we would have to be satisfied that these great nations, which have entered into this agreement, have done so bona fide, and that they are sincere in their intentions of carrying out these proposals honourably. In what way could this Dáil, at any time, in a discussion, except by action of the Government in bringing the matter forward, satisfy itself that the Governments in question were not carrying out their intentions honourably, except through the machinery of having an observer on the Non-Intervention Committee? We are quite satisfied that, in the circumstances, the proposals which have been made at that committee are fairly satisfactory and that, if they are loyally carried out, they are likely to achieve the end in view, so far as is possible. No doubt, it will be possible for individuals to get into Spain and for small quantities of arms to be brought through unless every square yard of the Spanish coast and of the Spanish frontier is guarded, which is an absolute impossibility; but because that state of affairs exists, are we to withdraw from the Non-Intervention Committee? Should we not be satisfied, when these great nations have come together, that there is a genuine and honest desire to carry a non-intervention policy honestly into effect? I submit that we can never be definitely assured that these nations will do so, and that we can only wait and see how the situation develops in order to satisfy ourselves that these nations are in earnest.

As the Minister for Justice has suggested, if at any time the Government should be satisfied that the non-intervention proposals are plainly not being carried out, then the Government can report the matter to the House with a view to seeing what further action, if any, may be taken. I stated on the last day, and I still adhere to my belief, that it is not the business of the delegate from the Irish Free State to take a foremost part, as we are not concerned in the actual supervising arrangements—we may not even be in the position of being represented among the supervisors to be appointed. What I do say is that our representative should be there in order to see what is going on, but that he should not attempt to take upon himself the task of questioning these Powers, if he were unable to do so. If the Government, and the Department of External Affairs in particular, felt that it was the duty of their representative to question any of these arrangements, or that it would be his duty in the future to do so, I have no doubt whatever but that the Government would issue the necessary instructions to him. We know, of course, that up to the present the committee is not being carried on in a perfectly unanimous manner. We know, as Deputy MacDermot said, that some of the nations there represented are violent opponents of one another in some cases and that there is a certain amount of dissension. I think, however, that the Irish Free State should not take any part in that dissension unless we have solid grounds for suspicion. If we see any move being made which might give reasonable grounds for suspicion, then we should intervene, and that has been our policy, not alone now but for months past. If the Government feel that they are wrongly informed or that these proposals are not being carried out in the way in which they think they should, then they will review the whole matter and come before the Dáil again. If we are satisfied that, having regard to all the difficulties of the situation, the proposals are satisfactory and as good as can be, then we shall endeavour to co-operate to the fullest possible extent.

Comment on this

I must confess, Sir, that I have been astonished by the tone of the speech which we have just heard from the Minister for Education and at the, to my mind, extraordinary doctrine he has laid down. What is it? There is to be international discussion between great Powers and small Powers and, because we are a small Power, it is our duty to have a representative there who shall be nothing better or nothing other than a mere dummy: a person who is never to open his month to favour or put forward any suggestion; a person who is never to do anything except to see what has happened. That is supposed to be the attitude which our representative is to take up, according to the Minister for Education. I protest, Sir, against such a doctrine being put forward. It is quite true that we are a small nation. It is quite true that, as far as military power goes, we are negligible in the world when we are dealing with great Powers such as Great Britain or France or Russia. It is quite true that, as a naval power, we do not exist; but I do protest against the doctrine preached here by the Minister for Education to the effect that, as a moral power we do not exist, and that, when great questions concerning international morality or concerning the eternal principles of right and wrong are being discussed, because they are being discussed by strong men or by the representatives of great Powers, never should the voice of our representative be raised in the cause of right.

Comment on this

May I suggest, Sir, to the Deputy, that I made it quite clear that, when we consider it appropriate and proper to do so, we are quite ready to raise our voice. I should also like to say, however, that we are not prepared to raise our voice, as the Deputy is raising his, merely for the sake of raising it.

Comment on this

According to what you said, you are not prepared to raise your voice at all.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I take it that the Deputy is addressing the Chair.

Comment on this

Well, Sir, the Minister addressed me in the same fashion, and so, I am afraid we are both at fault. However, Sir, as I was saying, no matter how small a nation may be, it does not follow that that nation, in putting forward a suggestion, may not carry great Powers with it; but, if we are to believe what we have heard from the Minister, we are too small to have courage; we are too small to have brains; we are too small to have intelligence; we are too small to put forward sensible views, and we are too small to preach, in international assemblies, the principle of right against wrong. "But," the Minister says, "our representative can tell the Government, and if the Government think that there is anything wrong, they may afterwards give him instructions." In other words, after the horse has been stolen, and stolen for a very long time, our representative may get instructions to shut the stable door. That is the principle which is put forward by the Minister for Education in the, to my mind, extraordinary speech which he delivered to the House in the last few minutes. My idea is quite the opposite. My idea is, no matter how small we may be, by our force of argument and our moral courage, by putting before the world what is right, no matter how small we or any other nation may be, our representative and the representatives of these nations will have a moral influence in the discussions carried on between even the greatest Powers, and our representative, in my humble judgment, should exercise that influence.

To come back to what is really more germane—I wandered after the Minister for Education on an issue which is hardly germane to this present amendment; it seems to me that the Minister hardly knows what this amendment before the House is—here we are giving completely untramelled power to the Executive Council. I am very glad, incidentally, to note that the force of my criticism has compelled the Minister for Education to withdraw from the House. The Executive Council ask in this sub-section for time. It does not tell us that it will ever put this Bill into force. When the time arrives at which it wishes to put this Bill into force, why should it not put its reasons before the House and the country? There is no doubt that it can carry the Bill. We know perfectly well that the Executive Council, with the potent aid of Deputy MacDermot, can certainly carry any motion here. What we do ask, and what Deputy Belton's amendment seeks, is that the whole of the country should know, through discussion here in this House, what are the reasons which are animating the Government in taking the course they are taking and what methods are being adopted to put these non-intervention proposals into force.

The real difficulty in enforcing non intervention will be found along the French frontier. If the Minister for Justice takes up last week's Spectator, he will find a long article there from a correspondent who travelled from France into Spain with a whole train full of men, every single one of whom was going to Catalonia to fight for the Red Government in Catalonia. I think it will be extremely difficult to prevent French Communists from joining the Spanish Communists. We would like to know before we pass this Bill through all its stages, what steps it is proposed to take to prevent such a thing happening. That is all we ask. We ask that before the Government puts this Bill into operation it will come before the House and tell the House exactly what is happening, the reasons which are actuating it, that it will assure the House that it will not act in the dark or behind closed doors, and that it will let the country know, through this House, what is happening. If it is not afraid of criticism I do not see why it should not accept this amendment.

Comment on this

On Friday night last Deputy McGilligan was 100 per cent. non-interventionist provided, he said, that policy was accompanied by the withdrawal of the Ambassador who was over there in Spain.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present.

Comment on this

I congratulate Deputy Davis on his speech. It is the first he has made for three years—to ask for a count.

Comment on this

It was very effective.

Comment on this

He rang the bell, anyhow.

Comment on this

I was saying that Deputy McGilligan was 100 per cent. non-interventionist on Friday night. He is the same to-night, subject to certain qualifications. The Deputy wants brought into this House, in support of Deputy Belton's amendment, the detailed scheme, I presume, as to how non-intervention can be put into practical effect. Somehow or other I would have expected rather a different viewpoint from Deputy McGilligan because nobody knows better than Deputy McGilligan the trouble that is entailed in putting all these schemes into effect. When Deputy Belton was introducing his amendment, I followed his arguments as closely as I could, and one of the main reasons why Deputy Belton suggested the holding up of this Bill was the difficulty of guarding the French frontier. There are other frontiers as well as those of France, and there is also the sea end. All these things have got to be carefully considered, and I do submit to Deputy McGilligan that it would be a practical impossibility to do what he suggests. I think it would be foolish to hold up this legislation until a definite scheme has been formulated. Deputy McGilligan's viewpoint must be reconciled with that of Deputy Costello. I was rather surprised to note Deputy Costello's outlook on this amendment. He said the Bill was originally introduced because General O'Duffy had recruited the Irish Brigade to take part in the war in Spain.

Comment on this

He did not say that.

Comment on this

He said something like it.

Comment on this

What he said was that in making a certain statement the Minister had a mental picture of General O'Duffy's activities.

Comment on this

That is what I gathered from Deputy Costello's remarks. This Bill would have been introduced by any sensible Irish Government if General O'Duffy had never been born. It applies to all volunteers; it applies to anybody taking up a similar attitude. What is wrong with the Bill? The quicker it is put into operation, in my opinion, the better. We may go down the country and talk about these subtle little remarks and objections put forward by Deputy Belton, but if you go to Mullingar or to any other town in Ireland you will find the people do not understand them. What the ordinary citizen does understand—and no one knows it better than Deputy Belton—is that we do not want young Irishmen going out to Spain. The quicker that is stopped, the better. We do not want to have them taking part in a war where, as the President has already pointed out, the big Powers are trying out their machinery of war and are merely making a cockpit of that unfortunate country. With the very least delay, this Bill should be put into operation.

There is something to be said for the viewpoint expressed by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. It does not follow that, because we are a small nation, we should not do something to make ourselves felt. There was a very proud boast at one time made by prominent members of the present Opposition about this country being able to take its place amongst the great Powers of the world at Geneva. It is also taking its place amongst the big Powers at the Non-Intervention Committee. Surely there is nothing wrong in this Twenty-Six County unit emulating the example of the big Powers and contributing their quota, in so far as they possibly can, in the interests of the Spanish people?

I have no doubt Deputy Belton's mind rankles slightly because of the defeat of the bigger amendment last Friday night. The suggestion in that amendment was that this Government should recognise Franco's Government in Spain. We all know that he has not a Government there yet, and we also know that the Caballero Government do not speak for the whole of the people in Spain.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Suppose the Deputy speaks to the amendment?

Comment on this

In that terrible state of affairs, is there not all the more reason why there should be expedition so far as this legislation is concerned? Where there is such an unsatisfactory state of affairs, is it not more advisable that we should keep our own people at home? There is, therefore, every need for the immediate passing of the legislation we have before us.

Comment on this

There is one person we will not keep at home.

Comment on this

Who does the Deputy suggest he is?

Comment on this

Our Minister.

Comment on this

Let me put this to Deputy McGilligan. Suppose the Government said "Yes, we will keep that Minister at home," would the Deputy take up the same attitude as he is taking now?

Comment on this

I would still argue for the amendment.

Comment on this

If the Government accepted Deputy Belton's amendment, I expect there would be something different suggested by the Deputy.

Comment on this

I think it is a reasonable amendment in regard to intervention.

Comment on this

The only thing I see wrong with the Government's attitude is that they are not putting this through with the same speed as I would like to see it going through. There is not a man or woman in Ireland, not one voter, who does not approve of this legislation. Everybody in the House heard the President declare that he had received numbers of letters about young people being sent abroad and being fired into that conflict. Do we want a continuance of that?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy relate what he is saying to the amendment, which has reference to whether the Dáil should have particulars of the scheme for non-intervention before this legislation comes into effect?

Comment on this

"Particulars" is not in the amendment. The amendment deals with the scheme for enforcing non intervention.

Comment on this

Surely the scheme would also include the particulars? That is not the real reason why these things are being introduced. They are being introduced in an attempt to stop this legislation going through. Nobody knows better than Deputy Belton that this amendment will not be accepted, and Deputy McGilligan knows it, too.

Comment on this

Then the whole thing is dishonest.

Comment on this

It is not dishonest. The dishonesty, if such a thing takes place in the House, is on the side of the Deputies who are introducing these things, because they know perfectly well they have not the ghost of a chance of passing. They are introduced for the deliberate purpose of trying to delay this Bill.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy explain why has this not a chance?

Comment on this

The Minister has not given us any information in regard to this matter. I think he really does not know anything at all about it.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows all about it.

Comment on this

The Minister could not give us an outline of the scheme.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know all about the scheme?

Comment on this

No; if he did, he would not be asking you.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not the same sources of information as the Minister.

Comment on this

The Government are in the position that they can give us no information. The amendment has served at least this purpose; it has exposed the whole sham. Crocodile tears have been shed here about the stopping of bloodshed. Anyone who knows anything about the conditions in Spain is aware that no Non-Intervention Committee or pact will stop bloodshed there. There have been too many massacred there and it has to be fought out. It is a strange thing to observe efforts at non-intervention just now. It was stated by Deputy McGilligan, or perhaps it was Deputy Costello, that there was no talk of this sort for months when Great Britain and France considered that intervention would favour Caballero. When there was a hold-up at Madrid there was no talk of non-intervention, but now that Franco has got on the move, we are to have non-intervention and we are being used as the tools.

What is the secret about this whole matter? If the Minister knows anything he should tell us the truth, he should tell us what is at the bottom of this. In my opinion there are two Spains, the Red and the White Spain, at the bottom of it. That is what Great Britain, France and Russia are angling for and we are to be used as the tools to help that. The Minister for Justice, because of his spite against General O'Duffy, takes up a certain attitude. When he mentioned the Irish Brigade here he almost ground his teeth.

Comment on this

I never mentioned the Irish Brigade. I am not a bit surprised if the Deputy continues his misrepresentations here. I never mentioned the Irish Brigade.

Comment on this

Did you not say you would see no volunteer would leave from here for Spain?

Comment on this

When the Bill becomes law.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is supposed to be dealing with the amendment, which says nothing about the Irish Brigade.

Comment on this

He was merely dealing with the Minister's argument.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy's speech was not relevant.

Comment on this

In the amendment I ask the Government to produce the scheme which would implement non-intervention and when you drew my attention to it I was just quoting the Minister, the way he replied and dealt with my request. Has the Minister any information as to how this job is to be done? Is there any engineer, any business man, any man of 21 years and upwards or any boy of 10 years and upwards who would give his promise to do a thing until he knew first how it was proposed that thing should be done? That is the type of thing we are being committed to.

There were a couple of Ministers here a while ago. A few days ago they were able to talk for hours, but now they are not able to tell us how this job will be done. I want to remind them of what is operating. I heard it discussed in high quarters in Spain that what Great Britain and France wanted was to divide Spain. Are we going to be parties to that? Deputy Davin talked about electing the Government that the Spanish people want and so stop this bloodshed. I have been over all the fighting fronts in Spain, with the exception of the southern, and all this talk about electing the Government that the people want, or to know what sort of Government they want, is really laughable. I am surprised at Deputy Davin, in the teeth of the civil war going on in Spain, talking about electing a Government.

If there is going to be genuine intervention, how is it going to be carried out by the people who have failed in the much easier job of keeping out war munitions? Is there any responsible person in the Government here able to tell us? I do not mind Deputy Donnelly's little bit of a speech. I want the Minister to tell us how they propose to succeed in the matter of non-intervention when they did not succeed in keeping out munitions. The same parties are contracting now to do the larger thing when they failed to do the smaller thing before.

Comment on this

I want to make my position clear on one matter that Deputy Donnelly referred to. I support this amendment as moved by Deputy Belton to-night. If the Government had agreed to withdraw the Irish Minister, now resorting in St. Jean de Luz, from being an accredited agent of ours to Spain, I would still, in the interest of an effective non-intervention policy, ask that this amendment should be accepted. I only did that because I thought we still preserved this as a remnant of the old-time system of government in the country—that we are supposed to operate on each other's minds by argument, and that people would be asked to vote for what they considered feasible and proper in certain circumstances.

It is easy to distort argument. Deputy Donnelly and Deputy MacDermot made play with "You would want all the details and so on." All you want to know is the scheme. The word "particulars" is not used in the amendment. It may be said that the scheme includes particulars. All that is required is that such a scheme should be put forward to the House and should commend itself to the House when discussed. The method by which it would commend itself to the House might also fall for criticism. If it were done under the closure of guillotine, obviously there would be something suspicious about it. Deputy Donnelly, as a person who, having been a democrat once, pretends still to adhere to the democratic view-point, ought to be in favour of matters coming before the House for discussion and for the victory of argument. He is against that. He thinks that we ought to accept what? That we ought to accept something put up at a Non-Intervention Committee at which our representative has now twice been declared by a Minister here not to be able to do anything. Apart from not being able to do anything, he is not required to do anything.

Comment on this

Is the only objection of the Deputy that the scheme has not accompanied the legislation?

Comment on this

My objection is that we should not seek to make any people of ours liable for criminal penalties until such time as we are sure that the matter which we are aiming at is likely to be effected—nothing more than that. But the whole idea at the back of the scheme is that of the old nursery rhyme: "Open your mouth and shut your eyes and let down what the anti-Gods will give you." There you have the case not merely on the Non-Intervention Committee but in this House. Deputy Donnelly advances the amazing argument in a democratic assembly that it is dishonest to put up this when Deputy Belton knows it will not be carried. The new scheme of legislation is to consult the Whip of the majority Party, and if he says it will not go through, it is dishonest to bring it forward.

Comment on this

Practically.

Comment on this

It may be dishonest to beat up the majority vote if the merits are not with it. Surely democracy demands that one should be entitled to put forward reasons, even though you are beaten, and continually beaten. Deputy Donnelly is against that. I have never thought fit in this House to describe Deputy Donnelly as a coward, but he is the worst type of coward because he is afraid of reason.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The word "coward" may not be used.

Comment on this

I am only using it metaphorically.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does the Deputy withdraw it?

Comment on this

Yes. I used it in inverted commas, and I think Deputy Donnelly will accept it in that sense. He knows well what I mean.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 46
·
Níl 71
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 2:—

To delete sub-section (4).

I think the inquisition has gone far enough, and that, as a man can be got at the present time, the sword should not be held over his head for years. In the light of the discussion that took place on the previous amendment, this measure may have to be withdrawn very soon, yet there is power of retrospective legislation. The case against retrospective legislation is all the stronger in circumstances in case a Minister might be seen grinding his teeth to see who he was to get after.

Comment on this

If it were not for the fact that this sub-section is as inelegantly drafted as it could possibly be, the amendment should be accepted. The sub-section provides that a person may be convicted for an offence alleged to have been committed. It is quite obvious that the last phrase in the sentence should have been put up near the top of the sub-section. Apart from that point, it shows how rushed this Bill has been, that it could not be even properly drafted. There is a fundamental principle underlying the amendment. If the Government refuses to accept it, and insists in retaining the sub-section, they are presenting themselves in advance with —and the Minister for Justice is accepting in advance-a certificate of incompetence. The object of the section is to enable people who have committed an offence or, who are alleged to have committed an offence, under this measure during its currency to be prosecuted after the Act has lapsed. The whole purpose of this Bill, if it has any purpose, is to prevent people from going to Spain. If anybody in the teeth of all the powers that the Government is allocating to itself succeeds in eluding the vigilance of the Minister, the Guards, the British Navy, the Soviet Navy, the French Navy, the Italian Navy, and the German Navy, surely to goodness that person ought to be immune from prosecution when he comes back to his native land, having in spite of all these Powers got to Spain and survived the civil war.

Comment on this

And having also eluded the "Muirchu."

Comment on this

There is a principle involved. Nobody should be prosecuted except during the currency of the Act. If the Minister is not able to capture people and to prevent them going to Spain, when the Bill becomes an Act, then it fails in its purpose. There is no purpose in this sub-section at all. It is inelegantly drafted, enshrines a bad principle, and is as I have said a certificate of incompetence given to and accepted in advance by the Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

I do not think that this sub-section should be considered without regard to sub-section (1) (a) of Section 5. This Bill does not come into force as soon as it passes this House. It may not come into force for a very long time. It is visualised in sub-section (3) of Section 2 that for a whole year there may be no promulgation of this Bill, no putting it into force by the Executive Council. Accordingly, let us say two or three months may elapse between the passing of this Bill and its coming into operation. During that time it is perfectly lawful for any person to go to Spain. Until the Bill comes into operation nobody is breaking the law if he goes to Spain. But very carefully the words are chosen in Section 5 (1) (a) "at the passing of this Act." The words "after the coming into operation of this Act" are used in one section, clearly and definitely, but the words in Section 5 (1) (a) are not "after the coming into operation of this Act" but "at the passing of this Act." Therefore, a person will commit no offence by going out to Spain between the passing of the Act and the coming into operation of the Act; he may be given a long time to do so, and he may do so. But if he goes out to Spain during the period between the passing of this Act and the coming into operation of this Act he has committed a criminal offence, because the Act is made retrospective as far as he is concerned.

I pointed that out on the Second Reading. If this was not the intention of the Government they could have brought in an amendment inserting the words "coming into operation" and not "passing of this Act" in Section 5. They have allowed the words "passing of this Act" to stand; therefore, they must really mean it. Applying that to the present sub-section, a person may go out to Spain perfectly unconscious that he is breaking the law. As a matter of fact he is not breaking the law; until the Act comes into operation he is not breaking the law. But the Act does come into operation at some future date; then a man, although in Spain, although fighting in an army in Spain, under Section 5 (1) (a) has committed a criminal offence retrospectively. He then comes back after the Act has ceased to be in operation, and he discovers that under this sub-section (4) of Section 2 he can be prosecuted and convicted. Although he went to Spain quite legally—the Act came into operation after his going—when he comes back, after the Act has expired, he is to be caught and prosecuted. I think Section 5 (1) (a) is a monstrous piece of retrospective legislation, but it makes this sub-section (4) possibly the worst monstrosity which has appeared in any Act or any Bill which has come before this House for consideration, because after the expiration of the Act a person who has committed no criminal offence at all, except being caught by a retrospective piece of legislation, can be arrested and tried, and if convicted punished under this Act. It seems to me that this is certainly a sub-section which should not be allowed to pass this House, and I sincerely hope that the Minister for Justice, who is now in charge of the measure, will express his intention of accepting Deputy Belton's amendment.

Comment on this

This sub-section (4) appears to me to be a monstrous proposal. In order to understand the implications of the sub-section, one has to turn to Sections 6 and 11, so as to see in Section 6 what the offences are, and in Section 11 what the penalties are. We find in Section 6 that a person may be accused of endeavouring to go to Spain by going from one place in Saorstát Eireann to another place in Saorstát Eireann; according to Section 11, the Guards may, without a warrant, apparently years afterwards, arrest him on suspicion that that particular journey was for the purpose of going to Spain even though he did not get to Spain, and he may be convicted of that. What appears to me to be the monstrous thing about it is this: of course the Government will have a right to repeal the Act at any time, but they apparently have not the right to repeal the consequences. The consequences of the Act will still continue. Although the Act expires and goes out of commission, still the Guards, and apparently the Courts, will continue to operate. I should like to know from the Minister for Justice how he is going to end that situation, because apparently as far as this sub-section and any other part of the Act is concerned, there does not appear to be any end to it; its consequences are going to continue indefinitely. According to Section 11, fines to the extent of £500 or two years' imprisonment may result for years after the Act itself has expired. That appears to me to be a monstrous proposal. I think that, as Deputy Belton pointed out, the thing has gone far enough without having those far-reaching effects. Once the Spanish war is over, as it will be over some time, surely we ought then to forget what people have done with regard to intervention.

Comment on this

I should like to urge the Minister to accept Deputy Belton's amendment for the following reason: It is a rather peculiar thing that the Irish Government undertakes to do what the British Government failed to do against the Papal Zouaves in 1870. Although the Foreign Enlistment Act was in force when the Papal Zouaves came back, there was no attempt to prosecute them, and yet we have the Irish Government here to-day attempting to do what the British Government failed to do at that particular time. Suppose the remains of somebody from Ireland who was killed in that war in Spain are brought back here next week, by some of his comrades, before this Act comes into operation. If they go back to Spain, they then commit an offence, and when they return—if they ever do— when that war is over, you are going to make criminals of them for coming back and performing the ordinary virtue of charity. I have stressed that before, and in fair-play to everybody I think the Minister should accept this amendment.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to accept this amendment. This section was put in for the purpose of being a deterrent. Such a case as was mentioned by Deputy Belton, where this thing might come to an end quickly, is one of the influences that might have something to do with people going out to Spain and ignoring the other sections of the Act.

Comment on this

It will not deter a single man.

Comment on this

It may not. The Government can only do its best to make the Act effective. This is not retrospective legislation, or at least, it will not operate as such. It has not been contemplated that this Bill should become an Act to-night and that it should be brought into operation in a week's time. I hope that if the Bill passes to-night, it will come into operation to-night, or in a very short time. There is no such thing as contemplated by Deputies opposite as having an Act hanging for some time without being in operation. That is not contemplated at all and, in fact, I think that was quite clear from the attitude we adopted here in trying to come into line with other countries who are parties to this Non-Intervention Pact. We wanted to fall into line with them as quickly as possible, and that was pointed out as one of the aspects of its urgency when it was before the House last week. None of the difficulties and none of the hardships which Deputies have in mind are likely to arise. As soon as this Bill becomes an Act, there will be practically no delay in bringing it into effective operation.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say why, if that was the object of the Government, they put in sub-section (1) of Section 2 providing power for the Executive Council to bring this Act into operation by Order in Council.

Comment on this

It all depends on the circumstances.

Comment on this

The Minister said that their whole object from the start was to have the Bill operate instanter, once it was passed, and here we find this provision in the first sub-section of Section 2 to enable the Executive Council to defer bringing the Bill into operation until they make an Order in Council. It again shows that this Bill has not been thought out. The Minister says this section is not intended to be retrospective. It may not be intended to be retrospective, but, in its effect, it will be retrospective. Deputy MacEoin has put one case.

May I put two different instances of the way this will work if it becomes law as it stands—and the Government have introduced no amendments to this Bill so satisfied are they with the Bill as being perfect drafting. There is no power in this Bill to enable an Irish Catholic clergyman to go out as chaplain to the Spanish forces. He cannot do it under Section 4 if it passes. No Catholic priest can go out to Spain and I understand from the newspapers that there is a Catholic priest at the moment in Spain. He cannot come home to see his religious superiors, nor can he come home for a holiday. Once he comes, he is caught in the net of this Act and he cannot leave again. If he does, he becomes a criminal under the Act and in 20 years' time can be prosecuted. In reference to that particular state of affairs, it must be remembered that those who have already joined General Franco's forces in Spain have committed no offence and it is specifically made clear in this Bill that it is not intended that they should be guilty of any criminal offence. There you have a provision in the Bill that those who have already got commissions, or have become engaged in General Franco's army in Spain, are doing something which they had a legal right to do and which they have a legal right to continue to do, so far as this Bill and the law of Saorstát Eireann is concerned. But dare they come home to see their relatives who are dying for a few days, they are at once caught under the Bill. No chaplain can go out and no chaplain who is out there at the moment can come home without being a criminal. Is that what is intended by the non-intervention policy of the Government and the provisions of this Bill?

Comment on this

With regard to that question about the chaplain, I am advised that it does not apply to a chaplain.

Comment on this

I make most specifically the assertion here that the Bill if passed will not allow a chaplain to go out. He is not a unit of three or four people. He is one individual.

Comment on this

I am advised that it does not apply to chaplains.

Comment on this

I assert here most categorically that, in my opinion, for what it is worth, you will not under this section allow a chaplain to leave Saorstát Eireann for the forces in Spain.

Comment on this

The Bill is certainly intended to apply to people who are doing something illegal. It does not apply to people who are already participating in the war out there.

Comment on this

Suppose they come home.

Comment on this

It certainly is clearly intended, and it is the intention behind the Bill, that it must apply to them and that they are going to be dealt with like anybody else who attempts to go out and join up in the war again. There is no doubt of that, and there is no vagueness about it. That is clearly intended in this Bill.

Comment on this

Even if the effect of that intention would prevent Irishmen killed in Spain from being returned by the Spanish military authorities to their own country for burial.

Comment on this

If they want to go out after coming home with the remains, they certainly come under the Bill.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell me if whoever advised him that this Bill did not apply to a Catholic chaplain going to Spain, can say how a chaplain can be held to be a unit of two or three persons? "Whenever the Minister is satisfied in respect of a body of persons (in this section referred to as a unit)..." How can an individual chaplain be a body of persons constituting a unit under Section 4? I should like to know the legal opinion the Minister got which says that that allows him to send one chaplain out of the country.

Comment on this

It does not apply, in any case. We are satisfied on that.

Comment on this

Will the Minister let us have a look at the legal opinion? It would certainly be amusing, to say the least of it.

Comment on this

Is it reasonable to think that for ten years after this war is over—and it may collapse in six months —somebody who had gone out with the best possible intentions in the world should be looked on as a criminal and should be liable to be charged with a criminal offence, and that that should subsist for all time, because there is no point of time in the Bill when it ceases to be a criminal act. I think it is very unreasonable, and I have never heard of such a thing before. It is without precedent as far as I know, and the Minister ought really to consider it very seriously. It remains for all time, because there is no point set down at which it ceases to be a criminal offence.

Comment on this

The Statute of Limitations does not apply in the way the Deputy thinks it applies to civil liabilities. These people who commit what will be an offence under this Act know that they are committing an offence.

Comment on this

Not necessarily.

Comment on this

Ignorance of the law is no excuse, I suppose. They should know that this Bill has been passed, and is in operation, and that it prohibits recruiting, going out to Spain and the various other things it provides for. If they do any of these things, they are committing an offence just as any other person commits an offence.

Comment on this

Do I understand from the Minister—it comes as somewhat of a surprise—that if a Catholic chaplain lawfully serving in Spain and who left this country as a citizen of Saorstát Eireann returns to his country, he becomes a criminal under this Bill? Is that the intention of the Bill?

Comment on this

No, that is not the intention. What I stated was that a chaplain under the definitions in this Bill is not a member of the military forces.

Comment on this

What definition?

Comment on this

Section 3.

Comment on this

Does he not render ancillary services to the combatant forces?

Comment on this

I do not think his services would be regarded as such in the circumstances.

Comment on this

That is a very poor case.

Comment on this

It will not apply to any case.

Comment on this

The guillotine is now to be dropped on this discussion and the Minister apparently will not accept any of the amendments in my name. Is that so?

Comment on this

We have only got to the second yet.

Comment on this

We cannot get any further now owing to your handiwork. Are they all going to be opposed by the Minister? Will the man who is fighting in Spain for his God be run in here by the Minister, if he comes back to see his dying parents? If that is the attitude, I say that we got 100,000 people to declare for Franco in College Green, and we will get 200,000 to tear up this Bill in College Green if it becomes an Act, and put the Minister and his colleagues about their business.

Comment on this

We will see whether you will.

Comment on this

Wait now and see.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That Sections 2 to 11 inclusive stand part and that the Title as set up be the Title to the Bill"— put.

Tá 74
·
Níl 47
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?