Committee on Finance—Vote On Account.
Contributions 1–177 of 578. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I move:
Go ndeontar i gcuntas suim nách mó ná £10,490,000 chun no mar chabhair chun íoctha na Muirear a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá de Mhárta, 1938, i gcóir seirbhísí áirithe puiblí, eadhon:—
£
2 | An tOireachtas | 28,400
3 | Roinn Uachtarán na hArd-Chomhairle | 4,400
4 | An tArd-Scrúdóir | 6,000
5 | Oifig an Aire Airgid | 22,900
6 | Oifig na gCoimisinéirí Ioncuim | 269,500
7 | Pinsin tSean-Aoise | 1,150,000
8 | Deolchairí Cúitimh | 3,400
9 | Coimisiúin agus Fiosrúcháin Speisialta | 3,600
10 | Oifig na nOibreacha Puiblí | 39,100
11 | Oibreacha agus Foirgintí Puiblí | 325,800
12 | Saotharlann Stáit | 2,570
13 | Coimisiún na Stát-Sheirbhíse | 8,000
14 | Cúiteamh i gCailliúna Maoine | 16,000
15 | Cúiteamh i nDíobhála Pearsanta | 300
16 | Aois-Liúntaisí agus Liúntaisí Fágála | 148,000
17 | Rátaí ar Mhaoin an Rialtais | 32,300
18 | An tSeirbhis Sheicréideach | 6,700
19 | Coimisiún na nDleacht | 1,800
20 | Costaisí fén Acht Timpeal Toghachán, agus fé Acht na nGiúirithe | Nil
21 | Costaisí Ilghnéitheacha | 2,500
22 | Páipéarachas agus Clódóireacht | 53,000
23 | Measadóireacht agus Suirbhéireacht Teorann | 10,440
24 | Suirbhéi reacht an Ordonáis | 10,630
25 | Deontaisí Breise Talmhaíochta | 450,000
26 | Dlí-Mhuirearacha | 22,500
27 | Longlann Inis Sionnach | 3,200
28 | Príomh-Scoileanna agus Coláistí | 79,650
29 | Forbairt Chadhnraide Leictreachais | 16,000
30 | Oifig an tSaor-Chíosa | 1,250
31 | Bainistí Stoc Rialtais | 15,320
32 | Oifig an Aire Dlí agus Cirt | 12,500
33 | Gárda Síochána | 664,000
34 | Príosúin | 25,000
35 | Cúirt Dúithche | 12,900
36 | Cúirt Uachtarach agus Ard-Chúirt an Bhreithiúnais | 16,500
37 | Oifig Chlárathachta na Talmhan agus Oifig Chlárathachta na nDintiúirí | 16,000
38 | An Chúirt Chuarda | 17,000
39 | Oifig na nAnnálacha Puiblí | 1,630
40 | Tabhartaisí agus Tiomanta Déirciúla | 850
41 | Rialtas Aitiúil agus Sláinte Puiblí | 415,300
42 | Oifig an Ard-Chlárathóra | 4,200
43 | Gealtlann Dúndroma | 5,000
44 | Arachas Sláinte Náisiúnta | 98,000
45 | Oifig an Aire Oideachais | 59,400
46 | Bun-Oideachas | 1,350,000
47 | Meadhon-Oideachas | 144,390
48 | Ceárd-Oideachas | 87,950
49 | Eolaíocht agus Eladha | 17,250
50 | Scoileanna Ceartúcháin agus Saothair | 55,000
51 | An Gailerí Náisiúnta | 3,000
52 | Talmhaíocht | 212,450
53 | Iascach | 13,920
54 | Tailte | 702,600
55 | Foraoiseacht | 51,000
56 | Seirbhísí na Gaeltachta | 37,000
57 | Tionnscal agus Tráchtáil | 155,700
58 | Seirbhísí Iompair agus Meteoraíochta | 24,780
59 | An Bínse Bóthair larainn | 950
60 | Muir-Sheirbhís | 3,207
61 | Arachas Díomhaointis agus Congnamh Díomhaointis | 400,000
62 | Oifig Chlárathachta Mhaoine Tionnscail agus Tráchtála | 4,970
63 | Puist agus Telegrafa | 770,000
64 | Fóirleatha Nea-shrangach | 20,500
65 | An tArm | 531,900
66 | Arm-Phinsin | 200,860
67 | Ghóthaí Coigríche | 30,500
68 | Cumann na Náisiún | 4,300
69 | Scéimeanna Fostaíochta | 750,000
70 | Deolchairí agus Conganta Airgid um Easportáil | 750,000
71 | Iasachtaí Coigríche Dháil Eireann d'Aisíoc | 2,900
72 | Pinsin do Bhaintreacha agus do Dhílleachtaithe | 83,333
An tIomlán | 10,490,000
That a sum not exceeding £10,490,000 be granted on account for or towards defraying the Charges that will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1938, for certain public services, namely:—
£
2 | Oireachtas | 28,400
3 | Department of the President of the Executive Council | 4,400
4 | Comptroller and Auditor General | 6,000
5 | Office of the Minister for Finance | 22,900
6 | Office of the Revenue Commissioners | 269,500
7 | Old Age Pensions | 1,150,000
8 | Compensation Bounties | 3,400
9 | Commissions and Special Inquiries | 3,600
10 | Office of Public Works | 39,100
11 | Public Works and Buildings | 325,800
12 | State Laboratory | 2,570
13 | Civil Service Commission | 8,000
14 | Property Losses Compensation | 16,000
15 | Personal Injuries Compensation | 300
16 | Superannuation and Retired Allowances | 148,000
17 | Rates on Government Property | 32,300
18 | Secret Service | 6,700
19 | Tariff Commission | 1,800
20 | Expenses under the Electoral Act, and the Juries Act | Nil
21 | Miscellaneous Expenses | 2,500
22 | Stationery and Printing | 53,000
23 | Valuation and Boundary Survey | 10,440
24 | Ordnance Survey | 10,630
25 | Supplementary Agricultural Grants | 450,000
26 | Law Charges | 22,500
27 | Haulbowline Dockyard | 3,200
28 | Universities and Colleges | 79,650
29 | Electrical Battery Development | 16,000
30 | Quit Rent Office | 1,250
31 | Management of Government Stocks | 15,320
32 | Office of the Minister for Justice | 12,500
33 | Gárda Síochána | 664,000
34 | Prisons | 25,000
35 | District Court | 12,900
36 | Supreme Court and High Court of Justice | 16,500
37 | Land Registry and Registry of Deeds | 16,000
38 | Circuit Court | 17,000
39 | Public Record Office | 1,630
40 | Charitable Donations and Bequests | 850
41 | Local Government and Public Health | 415,300
42 | General Register Office | 4,200
43 | Dundrum Asylum | 5,000
44 | National Health Insurance | 98,000
45 | Office of the Minister for Education | 59,400
46 | Primary Education | 1,350,000
47 | Secondary Education | 144,390
48 | Technical Instruction | 87,950
49 | Science and Art | 17,250
50 | Reformatory and Industrial Schools | 55,000
51 | National Gallery | 3,000
52 | Agriculture | 212,450
53 | Fisheries | 13,920
54 | Lands | 702,600
55 | Forestry | 51,000
56 | Gaeltacht Services | 37,000
57 | Industry and Commerce | 155,700
58 | Transport and Meteorological Services | 24,780
59 | Railway Tribunal | 950
60 | Marine Service | 3,207
61 | Unemployment Insurance and Unemployment Assistance | 400,000
62 | Industrial and Commercial Property Registration Office | 4,970
63 | Posts and Telegraphs | 770,000
64 | Wireless Broadcasting | 20,500
65 | Army | 531,900
66 | Army Pensions | 200,860
67 | External Affairs | 30,500
68 | League of Nations | 4,300
69 | Employment Schemes | 750,000
70 | Export Bounties and Subsidies | 750,000
71 | Repayment of Dáil Eireann External Loans | 2,900
72 | Widows' and Orphans' Pensions | 83,333
Total | 10,490,000
The purpose of the Vote on Account, as the Dáil is aware, is to enable sums to be made available for the carrying on of what are termed the Supply Services during the interval in every financial year which must elapse before the Dáil has had an opportunity of discussing each Supply Service Estimate in detail and passing it. Normally, the greater part of the first four months of the financial year has elapsed before all such Estimates have been considered by the Dáil, and before the annual Appropriation Act has become law, and it is therefore customary to provide in the Vote on Account sufficient moneys to cover the working of the various Departments and services for a period of four months. The amount necessary, accordingly, is, in most cases, one-third of the Estimate, but in certain cases where special circumstances exist a departure from that fraction is necessary and the necessary modifications in the fraction have been made, accordingly, in those Estimates in which such a departure is unavoidable.
The total net provision to be made for the Supply Service Estimates for the coming financial year is £29,262,269, and, as may be seen from the general abstract of the Estimates which is included in the volume circulated to Deputies this figure shows a net increase of £49,251 over that of last year.
I think I ought to direct the attention of the House for a moment or two to this figure of £49,251. I have seen it stated that it has been "calculated by an erroneous and fallacious comparison" that, actually, "as compared with the corresponding figures of a year ago, the present Supply Estimates represent an increase of no less than £1,740,486." The first of these statements raises a grave issue for, in so many words, it charges the Executive with issuing in an official publication figures in regard to this important matter of public expenditure which are false, misleading and deceitful. What is the basis for the charge? It is that the table entitled "General Abstract of the Estimates for Public Services for 1937-38," compared with 1936-37, which forms one of the documents prefixed to the details of the Estimate is "erroneous and fallacious." In that General Abstract there is set out in regard to each of the services the estimate, which we have been able to frame, of its cost in the coming year and its estimated cost in the present year. In some cases there are increases; in other cases there are decreases. But the net effect is to show an increase in the estimated cost for 1937-38 of £49,251. How could such an abstract be made upon a basis which would be "erroneous and fallacious" and a knowledge of that fact escape this House? The House knows what has already been provided for each service covered by the Supply Estimate in this year. The House has discussed these Estimates in detail and has voted the sums which are set down here as being the sums which the House is prepared to supply for these public services. If the Estimate is "erroneous or fallacious" it could only be either because it understates or overstates the amount which is required and which has been voted in the present year or because the Estimates, which are submitted for the coming year, are framed upon such a basis that past experience shows them to be deliberately "erroneous and fallacious." When we say that a statement is an erroneous one we imply that it contains errors of fact which vitiate it. I should like that the organ responsible for that grave charge against not merely the Government but the officers of the public service as a whole would tell the country which of the Estimates contains errors or is vitiated by errors? If it should happen to be that we have misstated the figures for the Supply Services in the current year, no doubt the Opposition will call our attention to the fact and, no doubt, the authority which has made itself responsible for this grave statement is prepared to point out in which of the 72 services covered by these Estimates that erroneous statement is made. If, on the other hand, the allegation is that the cost of these services for the coming year will be, according to past experience, much greater than we have set down in the volume as our estimate of the cost, then I suppose the authority which has made itself responsible for levelling this charge against the Executive will not delay in coming forward and giving the specific item or items on which it bases its allegation. Is the charge levelled against the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, whose net Estimate for the coming year is £32,066 higher than it has been for the present year? Or is it against the Minister for Agriculture, whose net Estimate for 1937-38 is £637,350 as compared with a net Estimate of £665,610 for the year 1936-37? Or is it against the Minister for Lands, whose net Estimate for 1937-38 is £1,743,146 as compared with £1,610,821 in the current year? If the charge is levelled against none of these Ministers or, indeed, any other Minister, shall we be told by this august authority that, in fact, no error can be discovered in the abstract of Estimates and that, therefore, this grave allegation against the honour and probity of the Executive is withdrawn?
The second assertion which is being made in regard to Supply Estimates which we are discussing is that they actually show, in comparison with this year's Estimate, an increase of £1,747,000. I wish to say that this statement can be shown by an examination of the printed facts, each of which ought to be within the knowledge of anyone professing to be an authority, to be, in the words of whosoever is responsible for this charge, "erroneous and fallacious." This year, the volume of Supply Estimates in its final form, was available to the House and to the Deputies on the 25th February. Last year, however, on the 3rd March, only a limited number of uncorrected proof copies of the volume were available, and the volume in its final form was not distributed until the 14th March. The Vote on Account, however was taken on this day last year. In moving the Vote on Account on that occasion I said, as reported in volume 60, column 1563:—
"From the White Paper which has been circulated it will be noted that the total amount required in the coming year for the Supply Services for which there is existing statutory authority amounts to £27,514,783, representing a decrease by comparison with the amount ultimately voted for the corresponding services in the current year of £823,806. I have to point out, however, that there are two important facts to be brought into consideration when we are discussing that figure. The first is in connection with the Supplementary Agricultural Grant in respect of which the White Paper shows a decrease of £370,000. When the printed volume of Estimates in its final form is circulated within a week or so it will indicate that, as soon as the Oireachtas has passed the necessary legislation, a Supplementary Estimate for a further amount of £370,000 in respect of Vote 25 will be presented, bringing the total of the grant for the relief of rates on agricultural land for the present year up to £1,870,000, that is the same figure as last year."
It is to be noted that this statement was made before the volume of Estimates was published, and that the footnote mentioned in it was duly appended to Vote 25—Supplementary Agricultural Grants—in the volume as published. It is clear, therefore, that the Dáil, the Press and the public, in so far as the public was kept accurately informed by the organs which profess to serve it, had full knowledge that though the nominal amount for Supply Services was given as £27,514,000 odd, in actual fact it was going to be greater by at least £370,000, as soon as the necessary legislation, which at that time and for several years before had been enacted annually, was passed by the Oireachtas. Everyone interested, therefore, was warned by my statement in the House and by the footnote, and everyone therefore knew, at this date last year, that the expenditure to be provided for was £27,884,000. I presume that a fact so generally known would not be unknown to the author of the statement that "the present Estimates show an increase of no less than £1,747,000 as compared with last year's figures." Yet, the difference between £29,262,000 and £27,864,000 is considerably less than £1,747,000. How, therefore, are we to explain this latter "erroneous and fallacious figure"? I do not propose to ascribe it to ignorance of the facts, but the alternative explanation cannot be any more satisfactory to those who have to make it.
From the same source as this "erroneous and fallacious figure" has come, there have emanated a number of other reflections on the present Estimates which warrant some examination. We are told, for instance —I cite this not because I desire to discuss it at length but to show how, in anxiety to misrepresent the true position in regard to the finances of this State and the public expenditure thereof as in other matters of fundamental importance, the same wanton disregard of published official reports and documents is manifested—that five years ago, taxation was £7,000,000 less than now. The House, of course, knows that reference to the respective White Papers for 1931-32 and 1936-37 and a simple sum in subtraction would show that comparison to be "erroneous and fallacious" by millions of pounds.
What again is to be made of the statement that
"in connection with the Estimates, it is to be observed that the various pensions paid by the State under different headings now reach the colossal total of £4,763,000"?
I do not challenge the accuracy of the figures but I do say that the statement, in the form in which it is made, is a deliberate suggestio falsi. It is “erroneous and fallacious” in the sense that it is intended to be deceptive and deceitful. It is intended to convey to the public mind the implication that almost £5,000,000 is paid out by the State as pensions to former public functionaries, members of the Civil Service, the Army and the Guards. The plain truth is that this aggregate figure includes £3,466,000, odd, for old age pensions, £443,000 for superannuation and retired allowances, £602,000 for Army pensions and £250,000 for widows' and orphans' pensions, so that, of this sum of £4,700,000, no less than £3,700,000 is ascribable not to pensions in the generally accepted sense of the term of pay deferred and earned by years of previous service but to two social services the benefits under which might, with equal accuracy and reason, be described not as “pensions” but as “allowances.”
The implication contained in the statement that
"the various pensions paid under the different headings have now reached the colossal total of £4,763,000"
is that these services ought to be cut and that, of course, the pruning should take place among the more colossal. That, I presume, is the policy of the Opposition because that is the policy of the organ which supports them in the country and that is the policy to which, when they were originally put in office by the people of this country, they gave effect, when the first of their official acts was to reduce some part of this "colossal figure" of, at that time, £3,200,000, which was being paid out for old age pensions and allowances to blind and infirm people.
This year, we may presume, the Opposition will have an opportunity of putting its policy before the country. This year, as in other years, the Party organ which has made this statement—that no less than £4,700,000 is being paid by way of pensions by the State—is going to ask the people to vote for the Opposition, when the plain implication of the statement made in regard to these Estimates and in relation to this particular branch of the social services is that the "colossal figure" ought to be pruned and that, if pruning is to be done, it has got to be done on the larger services. Yesterday, when a measure to amend and extend the original Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Act, which was introduced by this Government, came before the Dáil —a measure which ought to have been passed by the Opposition years ago if what they say about the happy condition of the country when they were in office is true—the Opposition got up and welcomed the measure and the very same organ of the Press which refers to this "colossal expenditure" upon pensions writes a leading article this morning praising the Government and commending it for that Act. Next year, however, that Act is going to cost us an additional £200,000. That additional provision will have to be made in the coming Budget. When the Estimates for 1938-39 come to be published, notwithstanding the enthusiasm which was manifested yesterday in the House and which is manifested this morning in the newspaper to which I have been referring, I have no doubt that we shall be reading in the selfsame editorial columns the statement that "it is to be observed that the various pensions paid by the State under the different headings now reach the colossal total of £4,963,000." Is it not time that we had done with such hypocrisy? The public is sick of the attitude of the Opposition in this House and down the country. To every clamour and every demand made upon the public purse they lend their voice and their assistance but when it comes to a suggestion of paying for it, then we hear a great deal about "the crushing burden of taxation."
Comment on this
We did, but we had the honesty to say this that there were certain services which we proposed to increase and certain other payments which we did not propose to make——
Comment on this
—— elsewhere, and these would enable us to increase the social services for the people of this country. We have been better than our word. We have increased the social services, and at the same time we have fought to keep here in this country the money which was formerly paid out to increase for other people their social services.
Comment on this
I shall continue to tell you the things that you do not like to hear. The authority which has made itself responsible for this and other "erroneous and fallacious" statements about the amount which is being paid by way of pensions has also said in regard to this year's Estimates
"that the largest increase is under the title of public works and buildings, a service which will cost the taxpayer £145,136 more than it now costs."
It omitted to mention, however, that this figure is represented mainly by the following items: £150,000 which is being provided for the Shannon airport as against £20,000 in the current year; £70,000 for the Dublin airport as against £10, and £40,000 for the erection and equipment of the new preparatory college at Ballyvourney as against £20,000. It would be very interesting if the critics of the Vote for the Office of Public Works would tell the country which of these items they would propose to delete from the Vote on Account.
As I have said, there is no use criticising expenditure and proclaiming that it is "wanton extravagance" unless those who criticise it have sufficient conviction to vote against it when it is proposed in this House. I do not think that a division has been challenged by the Opposition upon a single proposal relating to the development of aerial navigation and aerial transport in this country. Either the Opposition agree with the policy of the Government in regard to these matters and are prepared to acquiesce in the Government raising the necessary funds and therefore imposing the necessary taxation, or they are opposed to it. If they are in favour of the Government's policy, and, therefore, do not divide the House and oppose it, then they and their supporters in the country at least ought to have the common honesty to state that fact openly, and to say that whenever we make the necessary provision for these developments, and, as I have indicated, imposed the necessary taxation to meet the cost of them, we are justified in doing so. We should hear no more about the size of the Estimates for the public services, and certainly we ought not to be told, as we have been told elsewhere, that, with the exception of a certain other gentleman,
"there is no Government which has so unique a record in fooling the public with promises that were dishonest."
These are new developments. They were not foreseen at the time. These are new social services which our predecessors might have realised the necessity for but which they were not prepared to give effect to. They appeal to the public. The people demand them, and the proof that the people do demand them and do want them is the fact that not once, in regard to the measure for unemployment assistance, in regard to the Bill for extending old age pensions, in regard to the Bills for providing widows' and orphans' pensions—the first Bill and the amending Bill—in regard to the Bill for the development of aerial transport: not once have the Opposition had the courage to demand a division or to oppose any of these measures in this House.
Comment on this
The Minister should tell the Minister for Industry and Commerce that, because he does not know that about some of them.
Comment on this
Now it is true that the Estimates for 1937-38 show a considerable increase on those for 1931-32, but this increase is represented mainly by the following figures:—In 1931-32 the provision made for employment schemes was £140,000. In this year it is £1,500,000, an increase of £1,360,000. The provision made in 1931-32 for unemployment assistance and insurance was £160,000, and this year the figure is £1,052,000, an increase of £892,000. In 1931-32 the provision for the Land Commission was £578,000. In 1935-36 it was £1,743,000. In 1931-32 the provision for old age pensions was £2,756,000, and in 1935-36, £3,466,000. For local government and public health the provision in 1931-32 was £517,000; this year it is £1,259,000. The Supplementary Agricultural Grant for 1931-32 was £599,000, and this year is £1,270,000. Agriculture, in 1931-32, got £434,000, and this year £637,000. The provision for widows' and orphans' pensions in 1931-32 was nothing. In 1935-36 it was £250,000, and in the coming year is going to get an additional £200,000, making a total of £450,000. On public works and buildings the amount allocated in 1931-32 was £678,000, and this year the amount is £977,000.
Comment on this
It is being provided for in quite a different way, and, as the Deputy ought to be aware, while it was nominally included in the volume of Supply Estimates, it was never treated as a Supply service, because the total amount of local loans was regarded by my predecessor and was described by him as abnormal expenditure. It was borrowed for and never provided for out of taxation, but the services which I am dealing with are all being provided for mainly out of taxation. To those who are prepared to talk on another occasion about the fact that there has been an increase in taxation in this country as compared with 1931-32, I say it is their duty, and I challenge them now, in the course of this debate, to point out which of those they propose to dispense with. The House, in this Vote, is called upon to indicate that it is prepared to find money so that every one of the 72 services set out on the face of the Order Paper may be carried on, and if the House now passes the Vote on Account the plain implication is that there is not one service of the whole of these 72 services which are set out here which it would be prepared to dispense with. On the other hand, if the Opposition feel that taxation is too heavy——
Comment on this
——it is their duty to tell the country plainly and straightforwardly and honestly which of the services they are prepared to forego, which of the services they are going to ask the people to forego. Are they going to stop housing? Are they going to abandon aerial development? Are they going to reduce the Supplementary Agricultural Grant? Are they going to revise the scale of old age pensions and bring the old age pensions down to the level of what they were in 1931-32? Are they going to refuse to provide the £1,500,000 which is being used for employment schemes—or what might be more properly called development schemes—in this country? Are they going to reduce the provision which is being made for local government and public health? It suits them, on occasions, to deplore the housing conditions which exist in this country. These housing conditions did not come into being with the advent of the Fianna Fáil Government to office in 1932. They are the fruit of generations of neglect. The slum problem was here, and in a much more acute form in 1931-32 than it is to-day. At any rate, however, we are facing up to the fact and to the reality that the problem is there and that something must be done to cure it.
If we are going to be told that Ministers are misstating the facts in regard to the economic condition of the country—and I presume that one of the arguments which would be used to substantiate that statement would be that taxation has gone up— I would ask the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, if he speaks in this debate, to tell us this: He knows the extent of the housing problem in Dublin and elsewhere in the country. He was in office when the provision for this Department amounted to £517,000, and to-day it has gone up to £1,259,000. Will the Minister for Local Government and Public Health tell the House, if he speaks in this debate, whether he is going to save on that particular Vote or not, and will he tell us where he is going to economise? Is he going to abolish the grants for milk, or is he going to repeal the Housing Act of 1932 and subsequent Acts and go back——
Comment on this
——to the emasculated measure of 1931? The Deputy speaks of a simple cure. The trouble about simple cures is that one never knows whether they are going to be fatal or not——
Comment on this
——but the country that escaped demise under Deputy Mulcahy is, I think, unlikely to revert to his simple remedies.
Comment on this
At any rate, it has almost worked you out, and when the next general election comes along I am afraid——
Comment on this
I am asking you to be honest with them now. We meet on common ground there, Deputy O'Leary. I am asking you to be honest with the people now and to tell them, in regard to this Vote on Account, and in anticipation of the coming Budget—because it is essential that we should know—which of these services the Opposition is prepared to dispense with, because after all they are going to have to be paid for. This is when you are calling the tune. In a few weeks you will be paying the piper. Which of these services do you think you could do without?
Comment on this
Which of these services do you think you could do without? Take old age pensions. Deputy Mulcahy, by his simple remedy, might be able to save £750,000 by his scheme if he could go back to the old age pensions scheme which he administered. Surely he can tell the House whether, if he comes into office again and happens to become Minister for Local Government and Public Health again, he will bring in a Bill to repeal the Old Age Pensions Act of 1932 and go back to the pre-existing code.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy think that that will reduce the expenditure on public services? That is what we are considering now. We are not dealing with questions of taxation, and the Deputy knows as well as I do that it would be out of order on this debate. I am dealing with the question of public expenditure. Does the Deputy think that by repealing an alleged tax on old age pensions—although I cannot see how it could possibly be taxed in that way, but the Deputy seems to have some idea in his mind or some simulacrum of information on which he has based that allegation—but will he tell us how that is going to reduce the public expenditure, and, if he comes into office, will he tell us more particularly whether he will save at least £700,000 by reverting to the pre-1931 code in regard to old age pensions?
Comment on this
I am asking the Deputy now, with his two eyes open and his vocal organs active, to tell the House whether, if he comes into office, he will save £700,000 on old age pensions, and £741,000 on the other services administered by the Department of Local Government and Public Health? The same is true, of course, of the widows' and orphans' pensions and of the Vote for Agriculture, and the Votes for Industry and Commerce and for Land.
I see Deputy Roddy, who used to be in charge of the Land Commission. During his period of office in that Department, the amount of the Land Commission Vote was £579,000. This year it is £1,743,000. In other words, it is up by £1,164,000. Will Deputy Roddy, if he comes again into office, go back to the 1931-32 conditions, and will he save no less a sum than £1,164,000? It is a considerable saving. It represents a tax of about 10d. on the tea——
Comment on this
—— and at least 1¼d. on sugar. Will Deputy Roddy make that saving? Of course, if he says he will, he ought to tell the country that it means that land division is going to be slowed down; that, instead of the Land Commission work being completed in five years, as is now anticipated, it would probably take another generation to do the job; that, not merely that, but all the annuities, under the 1923 Act and later Acts, will be restored to their former level; and that, instead of enjoying the 50 per cent. reduction, as tenant purchasers do now, under the 1933 Act they will have to pay annuities upon the same level as they were paying them prior to the Act of 1933. I think that I am putting fair questions to the Opposition. I think that, in the course of this debate, these are questions to which the Opposition must seriously direct its attention, for these are plain and straight questions to which the public are expecting a plain and straight answer in this debate and during this present year.
Comment on this
Sir, I think the House will agree that that was a pretty tedious performance. It began with an attack upon the Irish Independent.
Comment on this
The Chair heard a paper mentioned at least 35 times. We heard the Minister speak for about an hour and refer to a newspaper on several occasions. If the Minister were referring to his own kept newspaper he would have referred to the Irish Press.
Comment on this
May I intervene to point out that I could not have been speaking for an hour? I did not commence to speak until twenty minutes past three.
Comment on this
The Minister will allow me to continue. I now propose to name it and to say that the allegation made in that paper did not charge any Government Department or any Government official with publishing misleading figures but what it did, and very rightly did, and what I now desire to repeat most emphatically is, it charged the Government with publishing figures in a way calculated to mislead. That the Government has most unquestionably done. In the Minister's own statement to-day there was a flagrant attempt made to mislead the public. He proceeded to go down through the series of payments for 1931 and compare with them the payments for 1936-37 and the largest payment he deliberately omitted with the deliberate intention of misleading the country. What are the facts? The Book of Estimates is presented to this House every year and during the Fianna Fáil administration it is common knowledge that the moment the Book of Estimates has been presented, a shower of Supplementary Estimates begins. Let me direct the attention of the House to this fact, that the shower of Supplementary Estimates for 1936-37 has not yet stopped. We got one to-day and a new shower for 1937-38 has already commenced. If we did not get one to-day we got it a few days ago.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy tell us the total amount of Supplementary Estimates introduced for this year?
Comment on this
I listened with patient respect to a very tedious speech from the Minister and I would ask him to listen to me. He will have an opportunity to reply at length at the end of the debate. The figure on the cover of the Book of Estimates was supplemented by a hail of Supplementary Estimates. That deluge has not yet stopped for 1936-37. It is still falling and even before it stops, we are warned that it is going to begin again in 1937-38. The figure on the cover of the Book of Estimates for 1936-37 was £27,514,000. The figure on the cover of the Book of Estimates for 1937-38 is £29,262,000, representing an increase of approximately £1,700,000 and even these figures must be qualified at the end of the respective financial years to which they apply by additional Supplementary Estimates which the Government may see fit to bring in. Our experience during the five years that the Fianna Fáil administration has been in office is that these Supplementary Estimates represent a very large sum, as a general rule. There is no doubt whatever that the burden of taxation in this country is steadily and recklessly rising and that recklessness comprises two considerations (1) increases in certain expenditure and (2) the absolute indifference of the Government to the income out of which that expenditure has to be met.
Let us remember that when the present Minister for Finance took office, he had the Estimates prepared for him by his predecessor. These Estimates, which he presented bore on their cover the sum of £21,921,000. In the last Budget of this Parliament, our Estimates are £29,262,000. That represents an increase of £8,300,000, and even from these, the Estimates for locan loans, which amounted to over £1,000,000, have been taken out. I admit that these figures are complicated and susceptible of misrepresentation. They are useful for bemusing the public mind and confusing it. An unscrupulous Minister for Finance can do that but it is not a good policy either for the Party to which he belongs or for the Minister for Finance himself. It is very much better to tell the people openly and plainly what their commitments are and let them pass judgment. That the Minister has tried to avoid and in so far as the Irish Independent or any other paper directs attention to the chicanery of the Minister in that regard, it is doing a public service.
The Minister says that if the Opposition do not vote against the Vote on Account, they automatically endorse what the present Government stand for. The Minister knows that that is claptrap. The Vote on Account has not been voted against in this House for the last ten years. He was the last person who led such an irresponsible movement into the Lobby. The Vote on Account is the instrument whereby the public services are carried on until such time as an opportunity has been given to study the Estimates with the leisure and the attention which they deserve. I can quite well imagine that the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce may have gone into the Lobby to vote against such a Vote, but since then they have learned a good deal of sense, and I am happy to say that we have acted no small part in teaching it to them. I believe in doing that that we have done a public service because we have made something that was unbelievably bad into something that is only just third rate.
The last cogent observation of the Minister for Finance in the course of his speech was to the effect that he wondered if Deputy Mulcahy would be in favour of reducing old age pensions by 1/- as Mr. Blythe, the last Minister for Finance, did in the course of his administration. Certainly the Opposition Party to-day are not in favour of that. But I think it relevant in that connection to mention this point, and I take occasion to direct the Minister's special attention to it. I took the trouble to inquire into the domestic budgets of two old age pensioners in County Donegal who are in receipt of the maximum pension. Under the cut made by Mr. Blythe they lost, I think quite unfairly, 2/- between them. They got that back under the Old Age Pensions Act of 1933. This year I got from them the list of goods that the old woman had bought as a weekly food supply, and the shopkeeper from whom she bought them was good enough to open his books to me and we compared the prices that the old couple paid for the foodstuffs they required for a week with the prices that they would have paid for these foodstuffs in 1931.
Comment on this
That was the last year in which the Cumann na nGaedheal Government was in office. The Minister can speak after me and rebut my arguments if he can. I am going to show that the present Government— and he will not put me off this point— is stripping the poor of this country. When I make that point, he can try to rebut it, but he will not be able to get away with his rebuttal. I then compared the purchases made by this old couple this year with the purchases made by them in 1931, and I found that the goods, which consisted exclusively of foodstuffs essential for their existence, cost them 4/3 more in 1936 than it cost them in 1931.
Comment on this
When I say foodstuffs that they required for their subsistence, I include in them 4d. worth of snuff for the old woman. I suppose she could have done without that. According to the Minister for Finance, tea, tobacco and snuff are luxuries that the poor ought not to have, but I regard snuff for an old countrywoman in the West Donegal area as something that it would be a very material hardship to deprive her of. Of course, I live closer to those people than does the Minister for Finance. Anyway, they were 4/3 worse off on these essential commodities. That represents 2/1½ each. Do I do the present Government an injustice if I say that, if we look back with regret on the reduction some years ago of 1/- a week in the old age pension we must contemplate with horror and dismay the reduction of 2/1½ in the old age pension of to-day? Remember that that reduction is being made by the gentlemen who are storming this country telling the people about the awful crime committed in 1924-25, when the 1/- was taken off the old age pensions.
There is no use putting cap or cloak on the fact that I think most of us on these benches regret that reduction of 1/- in the old age pension. But the man who made it, made it with the full knowledge that he could not do a more unpopular thing politically. He did it, having been warned by his supporters that it was tantamount to cutting his throat, politically speaking. He eventually prevailed on his colleagues, and, without counting the political cost, he did it and he paid for it bitterly in political kudos.
The present Government are swaggering round as the Government of the people, the plain people, the Christian Government that loves the poor. Admittedly they restored the 1/- to the old age pension, but then they came like a sneaking thief in the night and they snatch out of the larder the few mouthfuls of food that will bring back to the Exchequer 2/1½ in place of the 1/- that they gave back. Compare the political folly, if I may so term it, of Mr. Blythe, with the political chicanery, the slippery chicanery, of his successor in office, and ask yourselves from the social, the economic, or from any point of view which was the better course for this country.
I referred to the failure on the part of the Minister for Finance, when dwelling on our national expenditure, to address his mind to the question of national income. The two things are indissolubly associated. We have sounded a note of warning more than once that it was criminally wrong to raise the standards of our social services until you had made prudent provision for maintaining them. I want to be perfectly clear on this. It may shock some orthodox economists. My ideal in any State with the public life of which I was associated— and I believe I speak for most of my colleagues in this—would be that everyone in the State would have enough before anybody would be allowed to enjoy a surplus.
So far as I am personally concerned, I offer this challenge to the Minister or the Labour Party or any other Party in the House. Produce a scheme that will effect that ideal and that will work, and I am prepared to campaign the country. I have read a good deal on economics, and I have listened to those learned in the science and who are sympathetically inclined towards the view I now express, but I have yet to hear of anybody who can evolve a scheme which can produce that highly desirable state of affairs. Until such a scheme is available, if we continue to believe in the capitalist system and the system founded on individual liberty and individual enterprise, as all of us most emphatically do, we have to address ourselves to the task of alleviating the evils inherent in that system, and the common generic term for the means taken in democratic countries to alleviate these evils is social services. The more of them we have, the better it will be for the country. The more of the evils arising from a disparity of income amongst our people that are abolished, the better it will be for the country.
But Deputies have to bear in mind that you cannot get things by wishing for them; you cannot have two and two make five by passing an Act of Parliament. There are many Deputies who think you can give 9d. for 4d. if you pass a law to that effect. You may do it for a short time, but if you do, the catastrophe at the end of that kind of policy is going to be infinitely greater than if you never embarked on the policy at all. But you can, by prudently exploiting your natural resources, by snatching every advantage that offers for the people, raise the standard of living for the people steadily and continually, and that should be the object of any Government. And it is because I allege that the present Government have no proper regard for this consideration, that I believe them to be reckless and foolish in much of what they do.
Our external assets are one extremely useful barometer of how the nation goes economically, and the gross external assets of the joint stock banks of this country amounted, in December, 1932, to £142,248,000. In December, 1936, they amounted to £131,624,000. That represents a decrease of £11,000,000 in their value, but those are gross figures. I believe if you take the net figures that the decrease will approximate more closely to £14,000,000 than to £11,000,000. That figure is alarming, but not unduly so. It is capable of explanation. But it does show a trend and it would be well for Deputies to remember that, in considering that figure, they must not only look at its capital element but they must realise that so much of our invisible exports as the interest on that decrease represents are gone. We are not getting the income from our external assets that we used to get, because from £11,000,000 to £14,000,000 of these external assets are gone.
The national capital of this country really consists, not only of our external holdings in stocks and shares, but also of our industrial enterprises in this country, of our land and of the foundation stock of our agricultural industry. Statistics in relation to those four categories are hard to come by, particularly in regard to land and the foundation stock. I want to submit this to the House and I ask their particular attention for it. I say that you have an infinitely greater depreciation of that national asset which is represented by the agricultural land of this country than you have even in the external assets held by the joint stock banks. The greater part of the property of the small farmers of this country is included in the third and fourth categories I have mentioned. I think it is true to say that 80 per cent. of the people in this country are living on the land. Of these people, almost all have their entire assets sunk in their land, their houses and outhouses, and their stock.
I say that the arable land of this country is steadily depreciating and has immensely depreciated in the last four years. I say that fences, drainage, and outbuildings on the farms have depreciated immensely in the last four years and that but for the grants made available under the Gaeltacht Housing Acts that depreciation would be greater even than it is. Remember that the grants from the Gaeltacht Housing Acts may be ignored for the purpose of this argument only. They do not represent profits made by the farmers out of their enterprise and reinvested in the farms. But the improvements financed by profits made out of land have practically ceased and the land is deteriorating from one end of the country to the other. That is evident to anybody who drives through it and who sees rushes where he never saw rushes before, who sees gorse growing on land where gorse was never allowed to take root before, who sees gates and fences broken down and drains filled up, and who sees outhouses falling into disrepair. Unless he is accustomed to living in the country, he will pass these things by, not noting them, because on each individual holding they represent a comparatively insignificant change. But when you realise that that change is taking place on every holding all over the country at the same time you begin to realise that there is capital depreciation going on in this country on an appalling scale which escapes the attention of the majority of the people responsible for the national welfare.
In this same period of five years to which I refer I say that the stock of this country has depreciated in value immensely. In that connection you must note that we are referring to foundation stock and foundation stock consists of the cow population. The cow population in terms of cows has increased; there are more cows in the country now than some years ago. The cow population at present is approximately 1,348,625, that is an increase of 100,000 cows on 1932. But this is a fact that escapes the attention of a great many people. In 1934, at the nadir of the economic war, people were quite unable to sell a rough beast at all. Unless they had something choice to offer, it was not a question of taking a bad price— they could get no price at all. They had to get money to pay the things that were falling due. During that disastrous year the best cattle in this country were brought out and sold for half their value. Out of this country at that time went a flow of good heifers and good cows that it would take a generation to get back, and we now have in this country a larger population of inferior cows.
Deputies, of course, who are living on large farms, Deputies who have been making money out of remunerative contracts, or whose neighbours have been doing so, cannot be expected to see these things. But those of us who are living in the congested areas see them. The small man, whose margin was narrow, had to take out his best stock at that time and sell it for half nothing, and that stock is gone. The foundation stock left has immensely depreciated and, in so far as it has depreciated, it has brought about an immense reduction in the national wealth of this country. At the same time, the cost of living to the small farmer is steadily going up. Assuming that the index number of agricultural prices was 100 for the last two months of 1936—there are not yet available any statistics; but assuming it was two points higher than in October, the average index number for 1936 of agricultural prices is 90.7; it was 110 in 1931. That means that the prices of foodstuffs fell by 19 points in so far as the farmer who produced them is concerned.
Comment on this
No. If the Minister will have patience he will understand the force of my argument. The cost-of-living index figure in 1931 was 160; it remains at that figure to-day.
Comment on this
I thought the Deputy said it went up by 25 per cent. What about the old age pensioners in Donegal?
Comment on this
Will the Minister wait? I suggest that the goods which the farmer has to sell are 19 points below what they were, but that the goods he has to buy are as dear as ever they were.
Comment on this
It was largely produced in your flour mills, your sugar factories, and subject to your taxation. The farmer is getting less for his stuff, but the gentlemen whom you have saddled on the farmer's back are knocking out of the farmer the difference between what he gets for the stuff and what he has to pay. The bacon factories operating at the present moment are making profits while the farmers starve; the flour mills the Minister is unable to control, that he got up in the House and said he knew were charging too much, but he had not yet succeeded in making them charge a fair price; the sugar factories that are paying the farmer 37/6 per ton for beet and charging the public 3½d. per lb. for sugar—that is where the money is going. Is it any consolation to the farmer, who is slaving in a field to get £17 10s. for an acre of beet, to know that the Government are paying £24 per acre of a subsidy on that, and yet when he goes to buy a pound of sugar he has to pay a penny more than his neighbour across the water? Does it console him, is it a help to him to be told, or does it rebut the argument, that while the cost of everything the farmer has to sell is at a scandalously uneconomic price, the cost of everything he has to buy is rising, rising, rising every day?
Comment on this
The cost-of-living index figure, as compiled, is the same. But does not the Minister himself know from his own figures and admissions in this House that the cost of foodstuffs that the unfortunate farmer has to buy are going up? And that is not all. In this year are included the cost of clothes and the cost of coal, both of which the Minister has been responsible for advancing very considerably by his own intervention. There is something missing from these figures, and there is something no statistician can put his finger upon. These figures are compiled on the basis of price, but there is no reference in them to quality. I spoke here of a labouring man from Gloucester Street, or from Mary-borough, who was able to afford the luxury of a cotton singlet and spent up to 2/- on it. He can still be spending 2/- on it to-day, but he is getting to-day for 2/- a singlet he could have bought for 1/- four years ago. That is not in the cost-of-living figure. According to the cost-of-living figure, the price of that cotton vest has not risen at all. But, in fact, the cotton vest he bought four years ago for 2/- would last him for 12 months; the cotton vest he will now buy for 2/- will last him for six months, while the price has gone up by 100 per cent. There is no reference to that in the cost-of-living figure— there never has been—because it is quite impossible to assess variations in quality. The Minister knows that as well as I do. That is repeated time and again in parts of the cost-of-living index statistics, which are heavily weighted for the purpose of getting the final figure. The cost of food in this country has been inflated. Flour is selling at the inflated price of 12/- per sack more than it is selling for in Great Britain. I ask the House to remember this, that the mills in this country are all licensed. There is one mill in Limerick, controlled by a great Liverpool firm, which can to-day buy a cargo of wheat on the Atlantic, and can instruct that boat to call to Limerick to deposit half of the cargo there, and then put to sea again and go around to Liverpool and leave the other half there. These two halves of the same cargo of wheat are then milled into flour, and for every sack of flour milled in Limerick that miller gets 12/- more than he gets for the sack of flour milled from the same wheat in Liverpool. The Minister knows that. He is the Minister who denounced Deputy McGilligan as being the corrupt servant of that particular miller, the fact being that, owing to Deputy McGilligan going out of office, that miller is making 12/- more on the sack of flour than Deputy McGilligan ever allowed him to get. The Irish people are paying it, and this is the Minister, the champion of the Irish people, and the hammer of the miller and of his predecessor in office, who was the paid slave of the miller, and the hammer of the Irish people. When we get to that stage, we have got to the stage when "yes" means "no," and "no" means "yes." These are the kind of things that are happening at the present time. To-day the Government choses to close its eyes to that, and its supporters refuse to see, and no man is so blind as the man who will not see what is under his nose.
The cost of the raw material in the agricultural industry is going up. Maize meal is costing 9/- per cwt. here compared to 6/9 in Derry. Deputies may say that the advantage has gone to the growers of barley and oats. Here are the figures of barley and oats since the maize meal mixture was put into force. The only effect of the maize meal mixture scheme, according to the official statistics of the Department, is that it beat down the price of oats to a lower figure than it ever reached in the history of this country compared with Great Britain. In 1929 oats was about 7/7 per cwt.; in 1930, 6/10; in 1931, 7/3; in 1932, 7/9; in 1933, 5/4; in 1934, 6/8; in 1935, 5/10. I am talking in terms of cwts. in each case, not barrels.
Comment on this
The price of oats in England was from 4d. to 6d. per cwt. under the price of oats in Ireland in 1929, 1930, 1931, but in 1933 it went up. In 1934 it went back again. In 1935 we were down to the English price, 5/10, and in 1936 we were about equal at 7/2 per cwt. I cannot vouch for the last figures, because I do not think the official figures are out, but I vouch for the others emphatically and categorically. In regard to barley, the English figures relate to all classes of barley, but the Irish figures relate to Irish Free State malting barley only. These are the only figures I could get. In 1929 the price of malting Irish barley was 7/10 per cwt. of 112 lbs. In 1930 to 1935 it stood about 7/- or 1d. or 2d. above or below 7/-, and practically remained at that figure.
Comment on this
These are the figures given by the Minister. He has them in front of him. Deputies should go to the Minister, and if they are wrong show him where they are wrong. His Department prepares them, and it is from him I got them. The maize meal mixture has conferred no appreciable advantage whatever on the growers of barley, if you compare prices ruling now with prices five years ago, and compare the burden that has been placed upon pig producers, representing an increase of 2/6 per cwt. at least in maize meal. The Minister says that nobody uses plain maize meal only; that they add bran, pollard and other offals. They do if they can get them. They cannot be got. A person has to go with his hat in his hand to the millers to beg for them. The Minister is the most innocent creature that God ever put the breath of life into. He compares the price of bran and pollard here and in Great Britain. Millers cannot sell red pollard here, but they mix it with white pollard, and they get for the mixture the same price as if it were white pollard, while the British are selling the red bran and pollard about 2/- per cwt. less than the white offals. The farmers here are paying for maize meal mixture 2/6 more than the farmer in England pays for Indian meal. The Minister says that it takes 6 cwt. of meal to fatten a pig. That means that the farmer here is losing 6/- on every pig he produces compared with his competitors in Northern Ireland and Great Britain. Deputy Corry asked if the farmers had not been helped in other ways. Let us face the issue. Beet at 37/6 a ton is Congo slavery for the farmers of this country. A yield of 10 tons per statute acre is a fair yield of sugar beet. The statistics give 10½ tons as the yield per acre, but I believe these statistics are wrong, because a great many who made contracts grew a little more beet than they were entitled to grow, particularly in the Carlow area. A yield of 10 tons to the acre gives £17 10s. 0d. per acre. It has to be borne in mind that for the beet he delivers the farmer gets back so much sugar pulp free. But he has to pay freight on the beet which he delivers, so I set off the sugar pulp against the freight, and that leaves him about £17 10s. Give him 10/- more—£18 an acre for sugar beet. It is an extremely difficult crop to cultivate, to keep free from weed and properly thinned and looked after. It is a crop which the farmer has to go out and pull and top and wash whenever the factory tells him to do so, no matter what the weather or no matter what other calls there are upon his time. It is a laborious crop, difficult, chancy.
Comment on this
Yes, but fortunately we have discovered that by the application of borax to the land we can avert one of the greatest dangers to the crop. Anyone who knows anything about the cultivation of beet knows that until that discovery was made some frightful devastation took place. Deputy Moore knows as much about beet cultivation as I know about the Koran.
Comment on this
You get £18 an acre from sugar beet. Potatoes are not so laborious a crop, and a fair return from a statute acre of potatoes to-day is seven tons. There are people who will not get more than five tons; others may get ten tons, but seven tons is the average. At the present time, the farmers with good quality potatoes can get £5 a ton for them. I saw potatoes sold for 7/- a cwt. in rural Ireland only last Friday, but that is an exceptional case. Certain varieties are not worth more than £3 a ton, but taking the good with the middling they would fetch £5 per ton; that is £35 per acre. I do not think that 18 tons of Swedes per acre is an excessive yield off well-farmed land. If a farmer can get 1/- a cwt. that crop it worth £18 an acre. In regard to mangolds, if the farmer sows good seed and attends to the crop he can get 20 tons to the acre. Are they worth 1/- a cwt.? If they are, that acre of mangolds is worth £20 to the farmer.
A lot of people will say, "Oh, but that sugar beet gives us sugar, and national security, and the farmer only gets £2 10s. more out of mangolds or turnips. Is it not a good thing to have him sowing beet?" But those people forget that the farmer gets £20 out of mangolds without getting a penny from the Exchequer at all. The farmer who is getting £17 10s. out of beet is getting from the Government a subsidy of £24 an acre. When the farmer delivers his beet to the factory he gets £17 10s., but when the factory comes to unload it they find sitting on the top of every acre of beet delivered to the factory six-and-a-half notes put there by the Government. They get the beet for nothing and £6 10s. into the bargain for being kind enough to open the door and take it in. Compare that crop with other crops as a substitute for the things of which the farmers have been robbed. Deputy Corry will say, "If you are going to knock the bottom out of beet, what about wheat?" Deputy Allen, the expert from Wexford, said that wheat grown in this country is superior to Manitoba No. 1. When he has said that, there is no necessity to listen to him any more.
Now we come to the men who are a little nearer to earth, the sons of the soil; we come to Deputy Corry. Will Deputy Corry deny that last year some of the men who sowed winter wheat and farmed it well got a yield as low as five barrels to the acre? Will Deputy Corry deny that if the wheat last year was bushelled in accordance with the regulations laid down under the Wheat Act, half the farmers of this country would not have got paid for it at all? Will Deputy Corry deny that he knows of men who tilled their land well, sowed it and cultivated it well, got a crop of wheat off it, and lost money last year? I do not think he will. Will Deputy Corry deny that where a man was able to get out, having sown oats or barley, a man similarly circumstanced who sowed wheat was absolutely ruined—that the weather was so adverse last year that it crippled many a good farmer who put his land under wheat? Will Deputy Corry deny that this year, if we had achieved his ambition of having 800,000 acres of wheat in this country we would have to face one of the greatest agricultural catastrophes that ever overtook this country? Imagine, if we had 800,000 acres prepared for winter wheat now there would not be 200,000 acres sown. People in many parts of this country were not able to get the wheat into the land, and any quantity of winter wheat sown now will never ripen. You can sow certain varieties of spring wheat up to the middle of April, but if there were 800,000 acres under wheat to-day there would be hundreds of thousands of acres ploughed and harrowed, and no man would be able to sow wheat on them. They may not be even harrowed because the horses would not be able to get in to do the necessary work of preparing the seed bed. It is for those reasons I say that wheat is so precarious a crop, so dangerous a crop. It is slavish to put our people on it and waste all our good land on its cultivation. I know a man, a friend of a Deputy in this House, who spent more on seeds, manure and cultivation than he got out of the wheat crop last year. He lost money, even at the increased price made available for him by the Government in the heel of the hunt.
How does all that come about? It comes about very simply. Let us look at the story that is told of our trade with Great Britain as compared with the other States members of the British Commonwealth of Nations in 1932. During the years 1925, 1926 and up to 1930, the trade of all the States members of the Commonwealth of Nations with Great Britain was falling. Then we come to the Imperial Conference at Ottawa. From that moment the trade of Canada began to rise; the trade of New Zealand went up; the trade of Australia shot up, but the trade of the Irish Free State went steadily down. It is dramatic, if you look at the graph, to see how the line representing the trade of all those other countries turns sharply upwards, but the line representing that of the Irish Free State goes steadily downwards. Those figures that I am about to quote are approximate. Our exports to Great Britain in 1931 would be about £37,000,000. They had dropped in 1933 to £17,500,000, and they went up in 1936 to approximately £21,000,000. That is the picture for the Irish Free State—a heavy drop, and then a very slow, flattened out increase. What is the picture for Canada? In 1931 Canada exported to Great Britain approximately £32,000,000 worth of goods. In 1936 Canada exported to Great Britain £75,000,000 worth of goods. The picture for Canada is a deep decline in 1932 and then an uninterrupted rise. What is the picture for Australia? In 1931 they exported to Great Britain about £46,000,000 worth of goods——
Comment on this
——and in 1936 they exported to Great Britain about £62,000,000 worth of goods. Here again there is a steady rise. Take the case of New Zealand. In 1931 they exported to Great Britain about £36,000,000 worth—very much what we ourselves were doing. New Zealand and ourselves stood almost together in 1931 in our exports to Great Britain. In 1936 New Zealand sent to Great Britain £44,000,000 worth of goods, and we sent £21,000,000 worth. We stood together in 1931 and, since then, New Zealand is sending £2 worth of goods for every £1 worth we send.
Comment on this
New Zealand seems to like it. I can guarantee the Minister one thing: New Zealand is making more profit on her exports to Great Britain than we are making on our exports to Valencia or to Belgium. The Minister can go into those figures and satisfy his mind about them. He can invite the German buyer who patronises our cattle market to say what he is paying for the best Irish cattle near Grangegorman every week, and he can ask him, the next time he bids for cattle there, if he thinks he is in the lunatic asylum or in the city market, because that buyer must think he has found his way into the lunatic asylum when he finds himself in our market and our farmers selling cattle to him at the prices they will take for cattle at present.
We missed our chance at Ottawa, and I want to ask the Minister for Finance this question, if he knows anything about the general policy of the Government to which he belongs: Are we going to the Imperial Conference in London this year, or are we not? Can the Minister tell us that, because it is vital that this country should know? The Minister will spring to his feet and start reading returns about the imports of pianos and clock and china ornaments, and say that, when he goes to the pictures in the evening, he sees every evidence of wealth and prosperity about him and that the country looks to him to be blooming. That is the phenomenon which was exactly reproduced in Australia just before Australia went bankrupt and had to renege on all her external loans and reduce her currency. Anybody living there will tell you that the cities of Adelaide, Melbourne and Sydney were booming. Why? Because the country had become so impoverished that the people left the land and came into the cities. They could not get a living on the land and they came to the cities, and you had the extraordinary phenomenon of the cities being on an expanding scale while the country itself was perishing at the same time.
Comment on this
The Minister has a gift for absolutely ignoring the statistics available to his own Department as no other Minister in the Administration has. He will have plenty of time to answer me and I urge him to do so. Let me remind him, however, that at the present time the people are notoriously flying from the land. They are coming to the cities and flying to Great Britain. I admit that a person living in Dublin would never realise what was the condition of affairs in rural Ireland. Dublin is comparatively prosperous, but I now assert and I challenge any Deputy representing any rural constituency to deny, that the standard of people living on the land is steadily going down. There are parts of Ireland at present in which a lower standard of living obtains for the ten to 50 acre farmer than has obtained here since 1879.
The Coal-Cattle Pact has just been published and, admittedly, it has brought a considerable amount of relief to the horse breeders, but so far as coal and cattle are concerned what benefit has it produced for our people? It has produced one concrete result and that is that the British Government said: "Look here, if we are going to take the tariff off horses, you will have to send us so many more cattle so that we will get back on the cattle what we lose on the horses" and, accordingly, the Minister for Agriculture has arranged and measured the extra number of cattle he has to send in order to ensure every penny which the British Government claims being paid in tariffs on them. In order to enjoy the privilege of transferring a sufficient number of cattle to Great Britain to pay the annuities, he has undertaken to induce our people to buy more coal than ever before. If you can get the tariff off horses by negotiation, if you can negotiate the tariff off horses, why can you not negotiate the tariff off cattle and pigs? If it is no breach of principle, if it is no selling of your lofty principles, to get the tariff off horses, how can it betray lofty principles to get the tariff off cattle and pigs? You have said to the British Government: "We would sooner pay the annuities through pigs and cattle rather than partially through horses" and the British Government said: "Certainly. We do not care how you pay so long as you pay," whereupon you said: "Oh, we do not owe them and we will never admit that we owe them, but, by-the-by, we would sooner pay them through cattle than through horses." That is in order that the President can get up here, and, looking like a male Caitlin Ní Houlihan, say: "We will never surrender."
I suggest that if you are going to stand on that ground, the sensible thing to say to the British Government is: "We will never pay—not a penny; but seeing that we are going to pay, although we will never pay, we would sooner pay it by cheque than through cattle and pigs." You can lodge a strong protest. You can send over 12 cheques, one every month, and say every month: "We protest most emphatically and we deny your right to accept this payment; we assert that we will take every step we can to prevent your getting it but we would sooner not pay it through cattle and pigs"—that is only if the President is going to maintain the position of a male Caithlin Ní Houlihan. If, on the other hand, he is going to show an altogether unexpected vein of common sense, I suggest he should go to the British Government and say: "Look here, we have been fighting for the last five years over this. It has hurt you and it has hurt us and it is better for all parties that we should make an end of it. Seeing that you will not admit that you are a fraud, a rogue and a thief; seeing that you will not agree with us that the first President of the Executive Council of Saorstát Eireann is a dirty rogue, a fraud and a thief who robbed his own people, who betrayed his trust, sacrificed his honour and prostituted his word before the whole word—we should like you to agree and we have tried to persuade you that that was so for the last five years—if you will not agree in putting out that kind of information for world consumption about the first President of the Executive Council of Saorstát Eireann, we will not insist on it, but we do suggest, seeing that you cannot see our view and we cannot see yours that we should make a compromise. Let neither side insist on getting all they claim to be their due, but let us get the trouble out of the way." If they do that, is there any rational man in this House who does not believe that a compromise can be arrived at?
There is no question now of giving anything away. You are giving away every penny that is claimed and a great deal more. The British Government are actually collecting more money than they at present claim themselves. Suppose they stood for the last penny, they will take less than you are already giving them, but it is certain that, as they have frequently said, they are prepared to make a deal along the lines of compromise. Why can that not be done? Why is it so important to the Government to maintain the thesis that the men who laid the foundations of this State and carried it on for ten years were traitors to their trust, betrayed the people, dishonoured their word and sold this country for no consideration? Why must their desire to perpetuate that slander stand in the way of settling this business for the benefit of the Irish people?
I tell you that the standard of living of our people is going down. The Minister says that the consumption of manufactured goods is going up. Will he repeat that statement now in regard to boots and shoes?
Comment on this
I say now that the standard of living of the people is going down. We have warned the people who are interested in industry in this country repeatedly that if agriculture is allowed to perish, sooner or later industry will feel the repercussions of that. I say that the boot and shoe trade, owing to the decreased consumptive capacity for boots and shoes of our agricultural population, is going to feel the backwash at no far distant date. The symptoms of that backwash may alarm and disturb those who are most concerned with the industrial revival in this country, but I warn the House now that if that decline in agriculture is allowed to continue, those symptoms will manifest themselves, not only in the boot and shoe trade, but in every other trade which caters for the consumption of the Irish community. The plain facts are that the prosperity of this country, its industries and social services depend not on Arigna coal which does not exist, nor on Wicklow gold which has not yet been found, but——
Comment on this
The prosperity of this country rests ultimately on the 12,000,000 acres of arable land and the profitable exploitation thereof. Deputy Corry rejoices that the home market has been preserved for the farmers who live on that land. Now we have to remember that 5,000,000 acres of our land will provide all the foodstuffs— beet, wheat, potatoes and everything else—that we require, or all the foodstuffs that the Irish people can consume. You have got to sell the produce of the remaining 7,000,000 acres profitably or this State is going to perish; the social services for which this House is going to be responsible are going to collapse unless we can sell profitably the produce of the remaining 7,000,000 acres. Unless we can do that, every industry founded in this State before the advent of the present Government, and every industry founded in this State since the advent of the present Government, is going to collapse. The only way in which you can exploit that 7,000,000 acres profitably is by getting the British market. You can get the British market at the present time by going to the British and pointing out to them that they have got to get foodstuffs in time of war. You can point out to them that if their expenditure of £1,500,000,000 on guns and munitions is to be of any good they will need to have a guarantee of sufficient foodstuffs. You can point out to them that unless they are prepared to take our agricultural produce in time of peace, that agricultural produce is not going to be maintained in time of war. You are going to get at present a better bargain from the British than ever before if you go and point out these facts to them. By acting in that way a standard of living can be procured for our people higher than can be secured for any nation in the world. If this is not done now, the chance is going to pass, because Great Britain is going to make provision for her food supplies in the immediate future. The provision she is going to make now must fit in with her general defence plans. If England is going to be able to purchase or secure food supplies in the time of war she must make her arrangements now in peace time. If we do not take advantage of the present opportunity the time may come when England will not take our goods at any price.
The Government will very soon be going to the country, and it has this opportunity of mending its hand in regard to this economic dispute with Great Britain. The Government has a chance of mending its hand, and the country, too, has a chance of mending its hand at the next election. I put it to the Government that, unless we do that, the social services adumbrated in this Budget are going to become impossible of being maintained. The creation of social services without prudent provision as to the means of maintaining them in the times to come, is one of the greatest crimes anyone can commit against the people of this country. Social services are at present being built up, while the means of maintaining them are being neglected. I warn the Government that they are undermining the whole social fabric of this State. They have a chance of mending their hand, and the country, too, is going to get a chance of mending its hand, but it may be too late. I urge the Government to consider well the liability that rests on them in this matter of providing a market for the 7,000,000 remaining acres of arable land. Let them stop posing as Caitlin Ní Houlihans or super-patriots who know not the meaning of the words conciliation or conference.
Comment on this
While two Ministers most interested in the matter about which I want to speak are present, might I ask if either of them can explain the reason for the increase in the Estimate for Electrical Battery Development from £8,000 in the current year to £46,000 in this Estimate? Might I ask if the Government own all the property and assets of the Drumm Battery Company? Might I ask how much of this sum of £46,000 is intended for the Drumm battery itself, and how much for the purpose of railway electrification? Might I ask what security have we for the moneys advanced? Might I ask if Dr. Drumm or any of his staff are at present engaged in research work with a view to the future electrification or development of our railways? As one who read in the papers some time ago of the great things we were to get from this invention, I would expect something more to be done or some information to be forthcoming. If the Minister is aware of the agreement existing between the Drumm Battery Company and the State, could he tell us if the Government of the country is protected under that agreement, and to what extent? Could he tell us if further research is taking place, and whether any of the money now in this Vote is for the purpose of further research, or is it merely for paying overhead charges and allowing things remain as they are? I think the public is entitled to know something more about the development of the Drumm battery, and whether other countries are interested in what the Irish Free State is doing in connection with this invention. I know both Ministers are somewhat interested, but I will not delay the House further, beyond saying that I would be glad if we could have some information on these points.
Comment on this
I think the Minister is a little naïve when he works up passions and indignation about the alleged misrepresentation in connection with his Budget. The Minister must know that for years past it was extremely difficult for a member of the public—and I presume the public are interested in this matter—to know where we stood both as regards total expenditure and total taxation. More than once before I called attention to the growing tendency on the part of the Government in this matter of Supplementary Estimates. I admit that a certain amount of Supplementary Estimates are inevitable, but everyone must have noticed that there is a growing tendency on the part of the Government to create a gap between the annual statement on the Budget and the various additions during the year, one might call them collations to the principal meal. These collations are asked for by the Government during the year.
Let us take the volume as it stands. The policy of the Government is before us and surely the country is at least justified in drawing attention to this particular lesson that this country has to face year by year of an increasing Budget and an increasing demand for expenditure. That is obvious even from this particular volume now before us. Remember that what I might legitimately call all the services are not by any means represented in these Estimates. I am not referring now to matters like the Judiciary and other such items that do not appear here. I am referring to the policy of giving help to the various industries and these items no longer appear in the way in which they used to appear in the Budget or in the Estimates. Consequently, the public are no longer in a position to know what services they are required to meet nor are they in a position to know what taxes they are likely to pay. There was a time when the various industries were financed out of the Central Fund. In those days at least the public were able to take some idea as to what the total services of this State cost. They are no longer in that position. Many a man is at present contributing to services that do not appear in this book of Estimates. He is paying taxes that will not appear in the Budget. This is really a very successful effort—I congratulate the Minister upon it— to conceal from the public the real burden which is being placed upon them. This volume of Estimates does not represent the full burden to be placed upon the people. Nor will the Budget represent the full burden of taxation, either. Taking good care that the country would swallow the camel, we saw the Minister, for almost three-quarters of an hour, straining at the gnat. The country is not in a position to judge the bill which it has to foot. A couple of years ago, the Government showed a tendency in this direction. As the years go on, they are perfecting that system. They have learned one thing, at least, remarkably well, as Deputy Dillon has indicated in regard to old age pensions. That is, that if you take a shilling from a man directly, he will almost revolt but if, by way of indirect taxation, you deprive him of 2/6, he is almost thankful to you. The Government has learned that particular piece of jugglery well. There is hardly any limit to the burdens you can impose upon everybody in this country by way of indirect and concealed taxation. These burdens can be placed not alone upon the rich, but upon the poor. The rich are, in fact, more alive to these burdens than are the poor. The Government has taught the country that this sort of thing can be done and that the Government that does it can get away with it. This volume of Estimates indicates the ever-upward trend of taxation in this country. A great deal of the burden does not appear in this volume but, if you look through the various Estimates, you will find that the cost of administration has, almost in every case, gone up. With the notable exception of the Ministry of Agriculture, there has been, I think, an increase in the personnel of virtually every service. The Fianna Fáil Party promised that the cost of administration would go down. There is hardly a Department of Government in which we do not see an increase year by year. The Minister for Industry and Commerce is always keen on pointing out the number of men who have been put into employment. He is prepared to judge the prosperity of an industry by that canon. Applying that test to one Department of Government, we find that is it a great success. I refer to the tax collecting Department. Year after year, there have been considerable additions to the staff of the Revenue Commissioners. They were noteworthy additions—not additions of ten or 20. This year, we see a further addition to their staff. In fact, the most successful industry in the country at the present time is the collection of taxes.
The economies with which the great promises are redeemed are found in an early portion of this volume—the salary of the Governor-General and the cost of the Seanad. I presume the latter item is only temporary. These are the items they have to show in fulfilment of the rosy promises they made before election to office. The millions of additional taxation, direct and indirect, which they have imposed are all debited by the Government to social services. If you complain that the burden of taxation is now much higher than it was in 1931, answer "social services." Again, when we come to deal with the question of the land annuities, as the Minister did, and when we ask where the money saved by the retention of the land annuities is going, the answer is "social services." The cost of the social services bears no comparison to the burden which the Government have imposed on the people. That is shown by an examination of the figures here. We are reaching a position of stabilisation of ever-high expenditure and, at the same time, we are reaching a position of stabilisation of the conditions under the Coal-Cattle Pact. I gathered from the reply given by the President to-day that that was his intention and that he was not aware of the suggestions contained in Deputy MacDermot's question—that the British tariff on cattle is causing continued distress amongst small farmers and under-nourishment of their children. If the President is not aware of that, and if Ministers are not aware of that, it may be because they are completely out of touch with the country and because members of their Party who ought to be in touch with the country do not make it their business to tell them what is happening. How could the position be otherwise in country districts when we have before us the figures, which are now almost classic, given by the Minister for Agriculture. There we had a confession by him of the catastrophic fall in the return from agriculture, the catastrophic fall in the average income of the farmer and the farm labourer. With figures of that kind put forward, and even paraded, by the Government, how could the position be anything else than appalling for the people living in the country districts? These of the Minister are average figures. They include the big farms as well as the small farms and, therefore, the return to the small farmer must be much less than the £1 per week to which the policy of the Minister has reduced the average farmer. How can it be said that the country is not feeling the pinch and that agriculture is in a healthy position in these circumstances? It is a pity that when the Minister for Finance said that the country was sick, he did not stop at that. Agriculturally and economically, the country is sick. It has been brought to that condition by the policy of the Minister and his colleagues.
We have huge expenditure. There is no indication that the upward trend of that expenditure is going to be stopped. The indications are that staffs will go on increasing—particularly in connection with the collection of taxes— and that expenditure will go on mounting. At the back of it all, what is there? What has the Government given the country in return for that increased expenditure? The destruction of our principal industry and a muddled economic policy.
Speaking of the plan, that plan has been brought before the House on many occasions. Now my objection to the Government, so far as that is concerned is, that beyond parading that plan for electoral purposes the plan has had no other existence. The plan was never a reality. They had no plan so far as this country was concerned. They had a belief at one time in the efficiency of tariffs to save the whole situation. They had an unbounded belief in the value of promises from an electoral point of view, but beyond that there was no plan whatsoever that the Government ever had. We have seen them year after year and month after month trying to remedy previous mistakes and committing new ones in the attempt to do so. That is what the Government call having a plan, and as a result of a policy of that kind, pursued over a number of years, we see the country brought to the position in which it is at the present moment—a country with emigration again rife. It does not require even the figures supplied by the Government themselves, or at least it ought not to, to convince the Ministry and this House as to what the facts are there. They need only go down to any portion of the West of Ireland. I speak of one county in the South-West of Ireland, and what I said 12 months ago is equally true to-day: that the emigration out of that county, and especially to Great Britain—some may come to Dublin and some may go to other big cities—but the emigration from that county at the present moment to Great Britain recalls to the minds of the people in that county the emigration to America of 35 years ago.
Comment on this
The Minister knows nothing about Kerry. I am speaking, if the Minister would listen, of the scenes that take place at the railway stations at the present moment in that county: the scenes of emigrants going to Great Britain recall to the people of Kerry the scenes that used to take place of the emigrants going to America 35 years ago.
Comment on this
The fact remains that during the period of our Administration, the period of ten years ago mentioned by the Minister, there was a steady decline in the loss of population in this country, and that continued up to the time that we left office.
Comment on this
During that period there was a steady decline in emigration, but the moment the Minister and his Party started the economic war, and made it impossible for the people of this country to get a decent wage, the people began to leave the country again for England. They drove the people from this country, where they could not get a living, to England, where they could get a living. Everyone in my native county, it does not matter what Party he belongs to, is aware of that. Everyone there is aware that the people are leaving in large numbers for employment in England, and some of them to join the British Army.
Comment on this
They are leaving in larger numbers now than ever. I will give one quotation from one of the most respected men in Kerry, the Dean of the diocese, when he was interviewed in connection with the decline in the school averages. He points out what the facts are on the one hand, and the explanation of them on the other. The Right Reverend Monsignor David O'Leary, P.P., V.G., P.A., Tralee, referring to the decline, told me that "for many years the number of marriages had been decreasing, owing largely, "he believed, "to the depressed conditions of the farmers, who," he remarked, "do not seem to have the means of settling their children in married life. The tendency on the part of the young people to go to England in search of work must also have an effect in bringing about a smaller number of marriages at home. There is not," said Monsignor O'Leary, "sufficient work at home for the young men and women, but, apparently, there is plenty of work across the Channel; and I am glad to know from an authoritative source that the young people are carefully looked after there by the clergy and religious societies."
Of course, everybody knows the scenes that took place at Killorglin station last year when the emigrants from the surrounding districts were leaving. I mentioned it because it was outstanding. Large numbers are also leaving the Glencar district. Every Friday the trains are packed, and recently extra carriages had to be put on to take emigrants out of the country. When this question of emigration to England was first mentioned in the Dáil, Ministers refused to listen. They suggested that we were drawing on our imaginations. In answer to that, all that I can say is that all the people of Kerry must be drawing on their imaginations, because they know perfectly well what is occurring. The people cannot find work at home, and they are deserting the land at the present moment. They did so last year, and they are doing so this year. I wonder does the Minister deny that they are leaving in huge numbers: that they are going, some of them, to find work in England, and some of them to join the military services in England. It is no wonder, due to the policy of the Minister and his Government, that they are setting up again in England two dissolved battalions in Irish regiments.
Comment on this
All that I do know is that the figures for men of Irish birth in England will go back very much farther than the date of the setting up of this State. What the Minister expects to get out of that figure in reference to either of the two Governments, I do not know. Is he making the suggestion that all the people in Great Britain in 1931 who had been born in Ireland, emigrated there during our period of office? The Minister nods. That is the kind of statement that the Minister is capable of making. It certainly requires a man with the neck of the Minister to put forward a statement which is so obviously absurd.
Comment on this
I am not referring to the statistics, but rather to the way in which the Minister used them and to the nod he gave when I put a plain question to him. Did he argue, I asked him, that the number of Irish-born people to be found in England in 1931 had emigrated there during our period of office?
Comment on this
The Minister is now mending his hand. Will he give the grounds on which he bases that statement, not merely the numbers, but the grounds on which the interpretation was based.
Comment on this
But the policy of this Government increased it and gave it, so to speak, an extra acceleration. The Government by its policy has driven the people out of the country during the last two years. The Minister may deny that. He can repeat here what he and his colleagues have repeated again and again with the cynicism that no Irish Minister ought to be responsible for, that the farmers were prosperous, that the farmers were better off than they ever were. Nothing of the kind. Everybody who knows the country knows perfectly well the truth of the statement made by my colleague, Deputy Dillon, when he spoke of the way the land of the country was deteriorating. You need only go through the country, you need only speak to the farmers to learn the truth of that. You need only speak to the shopkeepers in the country towns to know what the purchasing capacity of the farmers of the country is at the present moment. Of course that is the last thing that the Minister for Industry and Commerce would think of doing, or his colleague, the Minister for Finance. When it is pointed out that the cost of the things that the poor people actually need, of the commodities that they have to buy and consume, has been increased by at least 2/6 to the poor old age pensioner as compared with the period when we were in office, the answer we get from the Government is: "Look at the figures." But the poor old age pensioner cannot live on figures. The money that they are getting now buys less for them than it did then.
One of the great difficulties we always have with the Minister is the impossibility of knowing from him what value you are getting for an article. He always holds that the article you get here for the same price is equal to the same article you can get for the same price in England, and he also always holds that if you pay more for the article here, then it is a better article. Now, Sir, there is at least one standard article. It is not an article that I have anything to do with myself, unfortunately, but at least it is a standard article to a large extent. It will not be pretended that the article made here, to which I refer, is better than the article you buy across the Border, and yet, surely, the Minister knows how much more it costs to buy a motor car here than it costs to buy exactly the same motor car across the Border. He knows that there is a difference of £50 or £60 or more in the case of the cheaper makes of motor cars—that it costs £50 or £60 more to buy the same car here. Does the Minister pretend that the car one buys here is better that than the same article across the Border?
Comment on this
Does the Minister say that the motor car bought here is better than the same car that could be bought across the Border?
Comment on this
Well, take the bulk of them. The Minister says "some of them." Is that honesty? I say that that is wriggling out. No wonder the House is deceived. When the Minister is asked what the general position is, he takes one or two cases and says "some of them." Obviously, that is the kind of thing with which he has been trying to fool this House for year after year. I was speaking a moment ago on the question of the flight of the people from the land and from this country to England, because the people, if they cannot get work in this country, and if they cannot get the advantages of the British market in this country to which they are entitled, are pursuing that market across the Channel and finding work there, and are finding it in large numbers. I say that anybody who has the welfare of this country at heart must know perfectly well what is happening. No wonder people down the country are gravely uneasy from many points of view by reason of this extraordinary emigration that has sprung up in the last few years under the patronage of the present Government.
Comment on this
No, but when we had arrested it your policy took care to set it going again, and you are proud of it. As long as you have the farming industry in the position to which the Ministers have reduced it: as long as you have this emigration continuing in the way in which it is continuing and developing and increasing in the way in which the last year has shown it to increase: as long as you have that, I say it is necessary to help industries in the towns, but a large portion of the public money that is being spent in aiding these industries is, owing to the other policy of the Ministers, wasted. Not nearly as good a return can be got, from the point of view of manufacturers and from the point of view of industries in the towns, out of the public money that goes into the support of these industries, because of the policy of the Government which has brought about a decline in the population of this country and which has, in addition to that, gravely destroyed the purchasing power of the main bulk of the population of this country. That, Sir, affects not merely the farming community—the farmers and the farm labourers. It affects not merely the shopkeeper in the country town—and he knows perfectly well what the condition of the farmer is because very often, owing to the system of business that prevails in the country where a large amount of credit has to be given out and is given out by most shopkeepers, he knows remarkably well the condition of the farmer and the farm labourer. It affects not merely these, but in addition, owing to the particular policy by which the main source of the wealth of the country is frittered away, and where you have that emigration going on and stimulated by Government policy, the very industries for the upkeep of which we are paying such a large amount of money, for the upkeep of which the taxpayer, directly or indirectly, in a concealed or in an open fashion, is paying so much—these very industries themselves, and their future and their value to the country, are put in jeopardy by the general policy of the Government. I am convinced that a great deal of the money that, at the moment, this country is paying to build up industries is practically being thrown away uselessly because of the other side of the Government policy which has hit agriculture so heavily and the results of which you can now see all over the country. I am sure that many manufacturers themselves must be gradually beginning to awake to that particular danger. If not, I am afraid that, notwithstanding the State's support, they are to a large extent living in a fool's paradise. No amount of State support, necessary though it may be to set these industries on their feet, can compensale for the loss of the purchasing power of the community that has been caused by the policy of the present Government.
In the beginning of 1932, Sir, when the late Mr. Hogan and Deputy McGilligan went over to London, they did get a concession in the way of a certain preference for goods going from this country to England. That was only to be a foretaste of what could be got at the Ottawa Conference. The Fianna Fáil Party at the time were highly contemptuous of the preference that was given then. Well, in a short time, they certainly did away with that preference and turned it into a debit against us. Not a help, not a preference, but a penalty was what we got as a result of their policy, and we see the effect of the Ottawa Conference, and of the concessions that were there given to other Dominions, reflected in the trade of the other Dominions with Great Britain. Deputy Dillon made that quite clear and I do not intend to go into it now, but it is quite obvious, from the answer of the President the other day, that, apparently, even with that example before him, the present Government is content with the small increase in our trade with Great Britain that has followed from the conclusion of the Cattle Pacts. Apparently, the Government is content with that and has not yet made up its mind whether it is going to the Imperial Conference or not. Such things as the doubling of the trade of Canada during these few years, and the complete reversal of our position in comparison with New Zealand, matter nothing to the Government. The economic welfare of the country matters nothing. They do not know whether they are going to the Imperial Conference or not! They have not made up their minds! They might be able to get something out of it for the country if they went.
What actually is their position? We had to-day the extraordinary answer of the President that, apparently, he thinks that, when two States get into a dispute, then it is question of unconditional surrender for either one or the other. He was asked by Deputy MacDermot would he consent to consider any compromise: "No, because to think of any compromise on our part would mean unconditional surrender." Therefore, if this dispute is ever to be settled there must be unconditional surrender on the part of Great Britain. These are the only terms we learned to-day, on which a settlement is possible, I must say for the first time so clearly stated. No doubt we shall be accused of misunderstanding him, but for the first time it was clearly stated to-day that any compromise whatsoever would be regarded by the President as "an unconditional surrender." Why, he has surrendered already, completely surrendered already, unconditionally surrendered almost.
What is the use of the President or the Minister for Finance getting up this afternoon and speaking as if we were not paying the annuities? The very Coal-Cattle Pact, as has been repeatedly pointed out, is the method by which we agree to pay these annuities to Great Britain. The Coal-Cattle Pact has been of benefit to this country. It was, so to speak, the oxygen that kept the patient alive. In the year 1934-35, the Government had brought this country to the verge of collapse. So near to the verge of collapse had they brought the country that even they, themselves, recognised it and they made this Coal-Cattle Pact. It was a relief. They are now taking credit for the increase of trade, a couple of millions, as a result of that whereas the other Dominions which took part in the Ottawa Conference have increased their trade with Great Britain by tens of millions.
Our Government boasts around the country that things are not as bad as they were in 1934 or 1935. They are not, because the Government surrendering, actually giving in, to the British Government made this Coal-Cattle-Pact by which the British were able to collect not merely the land annuities but the other sums in dispute, and that with the connivance of our Government. They were quite willing to make that settlement. They were quite willing to make that surrender. So long as it was not a full agreement, they were ready to sacrifice the country. When they go boasting about the country now as to what they have achieved in the way of better prices for cattle, what does that mean? It means that they are in the position of people who, having deliberately set the house on fire, boast because at the eleventh hour they have called out the fire brigade. That is practically the policy of the Government. They have inflicted so much damage on the Irish people that any relief will be greeted by the unfortunate victims as something to be thankful for. Therefore, instead of greeting it with indignation, the people listened calmly to the slight relief that was given to them. When we see the revival of trade that is taking place in what is our principal market outside this country, what is practically the only market of any consequence outside this country, when we see also the improved value of that trade, we can only be indignant that the Government let slip month after month every opportunity of giving our people the benefit of the improvement in that market. They appeal to the economic blizzard to explain what this country has suffered in the last couple of years though undoubtedly, during the period that they have been in office, our trade diminished much more rapidly than that of any of the other countries affected by the economic blizzard. Our trade went down absolutely like a rocket while in other countries the depression was gradually stayed. That can only be attributed to the policy of the Government. Now that improvement has come in that market, we are not in a position to make the best of it. The people are being deprived of the advantage of that particular market and of the improved conditions obtaining in it.
One thing at all events the Government has demonstrated. It has demonstrated, quite clearly, by its policy from 1932 up to 1936, the futility of one of the main planks in its economic programme—self-sufficiency. It is not a long time since certain people were thanking God that the British market was gone, a thing that was no use, and that, so far as it was there at all, was harmful to this country. That has now passed. We have one of our Ministers, a protagonist of that policy of self-sufficiency, getting up here in this House and blowing that particular contention sky-high. "We could," he says, speaking in this House on, I think, the Agricultural Wages Bill, on the 12th November, as reported in column 371-2 of the Official Debates, "as Deputy Corry says, get a better price for all these things if we were to get rid of the export market entirely." However, that brilliant suggestion of his colleague he rejects and rejects on the following grounds. It used to be the policy of the Party that that was the ideal to aim at. He need not blame Deputy Corry because Deputy Corry happened to be some 12 or 18 months behind the agile-minded members on the Front Bench. The Minister turns down the suggestion on these grounds: "But," he says, "that would mean putting about 31.8 per cent. of the agricultural land out of production because 31.8 of our agricultural produce is exported." Self-sufficiency, therefore, from the Fianna Fáil point of view, would have the extraordinary result of putting one-third of our land out of cultivation.
As I say, by their abject surrender on the Coal-Cattle Pact, by statements of that kind coming from the Minister for Agriculture, that Party has proved to this country to its cost, and to Great Britain too, the complete futility of that policy of complete self-sufficiency for which they stood and which they made their ideal. We occasionally hear about economic dictation from the other side. What Party has ever suffered and has ever tolerated economic dictation from the other side to the extent to which the Minister's Party has suffered it? They have allowed that economic policy to be dictated from the other side in a way their predecessors would not have thought of. What have they to offer to the country for that betrayal? What have they to offer to the country for the huge expenditure that mounts year after year, a muddled economy so far as the towns are concerned, and a depleted and ruined agriculture so far as the countryside is concerned?
I thought the attitude of the President, in that portion of his reply to Deputy MacDermot's question which I heard, was an extraordinary revelation. It was a revelation, on the one hand, of the carelessness, the callousness, of the Government so far as the sufferings of the ordinary people in the country are concerned, and a determination to sacrifice them, no matter how great the sacrifice, so long as he can claim, like the Bourbons, that he has been consistent.
I understand that the Government organ splashed across its pages the other day that one of the main trenches in the economic war had been captured, the major trench, as a result of the recent Coal-Cattle Pact. But we learned some years ago from the man who introduced the Vote on Account to-day that the war had been won! I must say he has adopted high military tactics. We have often noticed in communiques coming from the battle-front of places that have been recaptured that were never lost, of how trenches had been retaken that had never passed into the hands of the enemy. Now, a couple of years after the winning of the economic war, one of the principal trenches has been taken. The other trenches, the main ones unfortunately, are still intact.
I wonder do the Government know whether they are at peace or war? If there was any truth in the boast of the Minister for Finance a couple of years ago that the war was won and was over, I wonder what the people have been suffering for in the years that intervened between that statement and now? Certainly if we won the war, the Government have taken very good care to see that we have lost the peace because the peace has been as disastrous to us as the war has been.
We gather from this book of Estimates that expenditure is stabilised and we gathered from the President to-day that our economic relations with England also are stabilised, and the most that this country can hope for is a renewal year after year of the agreement by which we pay in the most objectionable form, as the President acknowledged, the land annuities to England. That is the most this country can hope for. That is the only thing one can read out of the President's answer to the first question this afternoon.
The people are to rejoice because an important industry, but by no means the most important industry in the country, has been saved from deteriorating still more by this belated effort on the part of the Government. I have no desire to diminish the satisfaction of the people in the horse-breeding industry in the advantage they have got. It is an important industry, but unfortunately it does not affect very much my native county, the county I have the honour to represent. It would have been much more beneficial, strange as it may seem to people here, to the people of that particular county if they had got the tax taken off, say, greyhounds, in which, before this particular fight for freedom— which we have won but in which we have really surrendered all along the line and in which we are still capturing the first trenches—they had a very remunerative trade. That remunerative trade in greyhounds was severely interfered with by the economic war.
Having brought the country to the verge of collapse, by the first Coal-Cattle Pact the Government stepped in and saved the country, kept it alive. But that is practically all they did. They had not restored this country to economic health. I cannot believe that members of the Fianna Fáil Party—however ignorant the Ministers may be of the fact—can be ignorant of the fact that the country is economically, at the present moment, in a very unhealthy condition and all the Government can do is to stabilise it at that, not to return it to health or anything like it.
No effort has been made to follow the examples of the other Dominions and make the most out of the British market. Where their trade has increased by tens of millions, our Government are satisfied if, in comparison not with 1931 or 1932, but in comparison with last year or the year before, they can show an increase of a couple of millions. That certainly is an extraordinary outlook for any Government to have.
I spoke of the effect that the Government policy was having on the population of the country. They are driving the people out. I am speaking now for my native county and I am saying what every responsible person in that county will tell the Minister about the increased emigration that has taken place in the last couple of years and the menace it is becoming to the countryside there. I drew attention to the statements of responsible people who gave their explanations in regard to the fall in population. Have the Ministers ever asked themselves what effect their taxation on the necessities of life must have, say, in the case of a poor, large family? Have they considered the effect in the case of a family of, say, the husband and wife and eight or ten children? Has the Minister calculated how the increased cost of flour must affect a large family of that kind?
A family consisting of a husband, wife and a couple of children are hard hit, but how hard hit must be the family that consists of a husband, wife and eight or nine children? Everything they eat is taxed up to the hilt. Flour, tea, sugar and so on are all highly taxed. Has the Minister ever considered the effect that will have on the future population of this country? Apparently not. We have heard the complaint, I have heard it repeated in several parishes in my native county, of the growing decrease in the marriage rate, the fewer marriages that take place. Apparently, from the Minister's point of view, the clergymen do not know what they are talking about.
Comment on this
Apparently the clergy do not know what they are talking about. Even so far as the births in the county are concerned, I think the Minister will find a decline.
Comment on this
Just as the bishops know nothing about Communism, so the clergymen who perform the marriages do not know anything about the marriages in their parishes. I have here a statement published on the 10th December, 1936, from a clergyman——
Comment on this
You may have contempt for him, but I have not. You may have contempt for him, such as your leader has for the bishops, but I have not. I have no contempt for this man who merely gives the facts. If it comes to a question of whether I should take the view of clergymen as to the marriages that took place or the Minister's view, I will say at once that I am prepared to take theirs instead. I take it for granted that these people, when they are speaking about the affairs of their parishioners, about the existence, say, of Communism in their particular dioceses, know what they are talking about and are not doing it without a certain sense of responsibility. It was not one case that was referred to. You find it in various other parishes as well. If teachers complain that there is a declining average at present, I very much doubt, in fact I am absolutely certain from returns I have seen, that their position will be very much worse in the year 1941 than it is at the present time.
As I say, the policy of the Government is really what we do condemn in connection with this Vote. It is a huge Vote, and a Vote to be put at the service of a policy that is doing damage, not benefit, to the country. The President may get up, as he did to-day in reply to the first question on the Order Paper, and unfurl the banner of no surrender. He can afford to do it. The surrender has taken place already. As every Deputy knows, the annuities are being paid, and paid to the full. That surrender has taken place already. He might as well get the value of that particular surrender which he has made. He has made the surrender, but the country has not got the value for it that it ought to get. It has got nothing like the value that the other Dominions have got in the way of increase of trade with Great Britain. I wonder whether the Minister will have figures to show that their trade has had the decrease our trade has had for five years, and the scanty increase it has had for the last year or two?
Comment on this
I did not intend to intervene in this debate so soon, but Deputy O'Sullivan's speech prompts me to do so. It was a moving speech. I notice that he moved most of his colleagues, including his leader, to vacate the House. I hope their going is some indication that they have still some glimmering sense of their duties and responsibilities as members of this House. It is, of course, the normal function of an Opposition Party to criticise the policy of the Government in office, and to dispute its claims as to the beneficial effects of that policy on the economic conditions and the political conditions of the country. But the Party opposite cannot be regarded as normal in that regard. Their position is not normal. They have got themselves into a situation in which their only hope of electoral victory is a national disaster of some kind, whether it is an economic disaster or a financial disaster, or a political disaster. If I were to come here this afternoon and announce that a large number of additional people had been put into employment, or that there had been a substantial improvement in agricultural conditions, or that some change in economic circumstances beneficial to our people was going to take place, there would be gloom and depression amongst the members of the Fine Gael Party. But, if I had to admit that unemployment was getting worse, or that emigration was growing, or that agricultural prices were falling, they would whoop with joy. I am sure there must be amongst them some member who is occasionally appalled by the position in which they now find themselves. It is not merely the case, however, that they are continuously hoping and praying for a disimprovement in the conditions of this country, but that they are on occasion deliberately striving to produce that disimprovement.
The speeches which we had this afternoon were a case in point. The speech of Deputy Dillon could only have been calculated to do as much damage as possible to the economic interests of this State. He told the farmers that they were going to lose money by growing wheat, that they were going to lose money by growing beet, although the national interests undoubtedly demand, in present circumstances, an increased production of both these crops. He told us that the appearance of prosperity which is to be found in certain directions, is only indicative of coming bankruptcy, and that circumstances generally were such that anybody would be a fool who invested his money in Irish industrial enterprise, or in the production of agricultural crops, or who would in any way endeavour to utilise his energies for the benefit of this country. Deputy Dillon was not merely speaking in that strain in the belief that he might convince people that he was telling the truth. He spoke in that strain with the intention of producing here economic conditions which he believes will be beneficial for his Party, and these are economic conditions detrimental to the interests of the Irish people. That Party opposite have no chance, and they know they have no chance, unless economic conditions can be made worse. That is why, on the one hand, they are continually asserting that they are getting worse and, on the other hand, endeavouring to make their words true. Of course, they have failed. They cannot do it. They cannot possibly talk away the accumulation of facts which show that there is a steady and rapidly improving expansion in production in industrial, agricultural and commercial activities of all kinds.
It is very difficult to know precisely where one should start in order to get Deputies opposite to possess a clear picture of our economic position. Let me at the start say that the circumstances now existing in this country could not be described as prosperity. I have never said it. deputy O'Sullivan alleged I had described the circumstances of the farmers as prosperous. I never said anything of the kind; nobody could say it. But I do say that this country is in every way better this year than last year; that it was better last year than the year before, and better in any of these years than it was in 1931. Occasionally we get credit from certain parties on the ground that we undertook more vigorously the same type of development which our predecessors had been attempting in a more leisurely manner. We are told that we accelerated the rate of industrial development and speeded up the change-over in economic activity here which was, in any event, going to take place. Those who speak in that way have an entire misconception of the way cumstances that this Government had to deal with in 1931.
It is essential that Deputies should remember that in 1931 this country was in a very serious decline. Not merely was that decline noticeable in agriculture, but it was noticeable in every form of economic activity. In industry the gross value of production was decreasing, the number of persons employed was decreasing, and the amount paid in wages was decreasing. In agriculture the number of persons employed was decreasing, and the gross value and volume of agricultural production were also diminishing. In every sphere of employment there was a diminution in the number of persons engaged. I will give later facts and figures to substantiate every one of these statements I am making, so that Deputies will realise that when this Government tackled the task in 1932, it had not merely to improve on the work of its predecessors, but to arrest the rot that their policy had caused. It took a very considerable part of the energy of every member of the Government, and of every Department of State, to secure that the decline, which had started some years before, would be arrested, before we could hope to produce an improvement—an improvement which has been secured to a very substantial degree.
There are people leaving this country for Great Britain. Deputy O'Sullivan was correct in that one statement, but, undoubtedly, he endeavoured to convey the impression that this emigration began last year, or the year before, and was in some way associated with the policy of this Government. The first fact that Deputies must grasp is that over the inter-censal period, 1926 and 1936, emigration from this country was less than in any similar period since the Famine, and such emigration as did take place during that inter-censal period took place mainly in the first half. When Deputy O'Sullivan talked about emigration to Great Britain he could, of course, speak with greater freedom. No one knows precisely what the emigration to Great Britain is. It is not possible to measure accurately the number leaving this country for Great Britain, whereas the numbers leaving for the United States or anywhere overseas can be known exactly. We can only estimate from the returns of population, and the returns in respect of births and deaths, what the gross emigration is, by deducting from the gross figure of the known numbers going to other countries to arrive at an estimated figure of those going to Great Britain. Deputy O'Sullivan spoke of the large number of emigrants who were going to Great Britain, but he baulked at the question I put to him: "How many Saorstát-born citizens were in Great Britain in 1931?" That was the last year for which his Government was responsible. According to the British statistics, Saorstát-born citizens in Great Britain in 1931 numbered 356,000, and that figure should have suggested to the Deputy that there was substantial emigration to that country long before this Government came into office, before the economic war started, and before the conditions to which he attributes that emigration would be admitted by him to have existed. During the eight years 1924 to 1931 the total number of emigrants who left this country by sea was 164,000. The actual number of emigrants who went over the land frontier was substantial. The average number that left was 20,500 per year, including the last year that the Cumann na nGaedheal Government was in office, when they alleged emigration had been arrested. Taking the total number of emigrants in the four years 1932, 1933, 1934, 1935, 20,000, was less than the average year when Cumann na nGaedheal was in office.
In any one year on the average there were more emigrants by sea from this country while Cumann na nGaedheal was in office than in all the years together up to 1935 with which Fianna Fáil is concerned. I will admit at once that these figures relate only to emigrants who left by sea, and that members left for Great Britain by the land frontier, but, according to an estimate that the Minister for Local Government prepared from the information available, the total emigration by land and sea to Great Britain, and to everywhere else from the middle of 1935 to the middle of 1936, was 23,700, quite a substantial figure, but it has to be compared with the figures for the period during which those who are attributing that emigration to the effects of Fianna Fáil policy, were in office. There was no Fianna Fáil policy and no economic war from 1923 to 1927, yet the estimated emigration by land and sea was in 1923-4, 26,000; in 1924-5, 39,000; in 1926-7, 36,000; in 1927-8, 28,000.
So far as this country is concerned emigration otherwise than to Great Britain no longer exists. There are emigrants coming and going but the net movement of population, otherwise than to Great Britain, has been inward in 1932, 1933, 1934 and 1935. I will admit that the existence of emigration is evidence of economic difficulties here, and the fact that some 20,000 people went out over a period of 12 months—they were mostly females—is an indication that there is yet a lot of work to be done here, before we can be satisfied of the soundness of our economic position. I contend that the fact that emigration is much less now than ever since 1851, is some indication of the progress we have made in improving economic conditions. In any event that is true of the total emigration during the whole of the inter-censal period when the figure was 5.7, the lowest recorded since the earliest period at which statistics are available. There is, of course, in consequence of that emigration last year a resumption of the decline in our population. The population of this country declined continuously over a long period until 1930. From 1931 to 1935 the total population increased. In 1936 there was a slight set back because the total number of emigrants exceeded the natural increase, which is the excess of births over deaths. It has been suggested that the decline in population, which since 1936 was shown to have occurred during the ten years from 1926 to 1936, occurred entirely towards the end of that period, whereas the reverse was the case. There was from 1926 to 1930 a sharp fall in population. From 1930 there was a rise in population up to 1935 when the fall declined again. There has been, however, a continuous increase in the male population, and Deputies who have been relating the population figures and our employment position have carefully ignored that fact. For the first time since 1841 the Census of 1936 recorded an increase in our male population of 11,918.
We had Deputy O'Sullivan, however, speaking here to-day not merely about emigration and its effect on population, and economic conditions and their reaction upon the number of marriages, but also about what he called the drift to the towns, and that is a subject upon which Deputy McGilligan occasionally lets himself loose. Before I go on to that, however, I want to put Deputy O'Sullivan right upon the position as to the number of marriages. He told us that there were fewer marriages than ever before recorded in this country, and he quoted some clergyman who had written a letter to the paper as proof of that contention. I contend, and I have the statistics here before me, that the rate of marriages recorded in 1935 was the highest recorded since 1925. There were 4.83 per 1,000 of the population. In no year since 1925, the earliest year for which figures are given here, was there a higher marriage rate recorded. That increase in the number of marriages which occurred in 1935 occurred not merely in the towns, but also in a number of countries. There were certain counties where the marriage rate was lower—Mayo was one—but in the province of Munster the marriage rate in the year 1935 was 4.46. The annual average for 1925 to 1927 was 4.41, so that the tendency in Munster would appear to be upwards, as it is upwards over the country as a whole. The census of population also revealed that while there had been a decline in the number of people in rural areas —even though that was the smallest decline ever recorded at a census taken here—there had been a substantial increase in the population of towns and cities. Deputy McGilligan, in his haste to furnish some explanation of that figure which would tend to the discredit of the Government, said that the increase was entirely due to the fact that the population was being driven, by the Government's economic policy, off the land and into the towns. The greater part of the increase in the town population was a natural increase; it was not due to any drift of population from the country areas into the towns. The total increase in the town population in the Saorstát in the inter-censal period was 91,000, of which 47,000 was a natural increase; a net migration inwards accounted for 34,364.
Comment on this
I hope the Dublin Corporation will take note of some of the facts that were published in the preliminary volume of the census, because they have, apparently, based a policy for the city upon a considerable exaggeration of the facts. In Dublin City and County the increased population was, as I said, 81,346, of which only 34,364 were migrants. Of those migrants, 12,450 were males. The average annual migration of males from the country into Dublin was 1,250, which is a much smaller figure than certain persons associated with the Dublin Corporation had apparently thought.
Comment on this
The only figure I have ever heard was from the city Manager, who said 28,000—that is even less than what the Minister is speaking of.
Comment on this
The Minister has made a statement about people having exaggerated ideas. The only statement I heard was at a housing inquiry, where the City Manager said 28,000.
Comment on this
The contention was made that a number of male workers were coming into the city and getting employment on the relief works initiated in Dublin for the benefit of the Dublin unemployed.
Comment on this
The only figure quoted was in regard to the population to be provided for by way of housing, and the figure given by the City Manager was 28,000 beyond the natural increase.
Comment on this
I want to deal with the contention that the migration which has taken place to some extent from rural areas into the city is due to the policy of the Government, to the disimproved position of the agricultural industry, and occurred entirely during the past four years. That, I think, is the argument of Deputy McGilligan, and it was certainly the argument of Deputy O'Sullivan to-day. First of all, I want to draw attention to the obvious fact that the drift of population from the rural areas into the towns did not start with the Free State, and certainly did not start with the Fianna Fáil Government. It has been going on since the beginning of the century. Figures are now available in the published volume. Since the beginning of the century there has been recorded a substantial increase in the town population and a decrease in the rural population. I will admit that in the last intercensal period the increase in the town population was greater, but on the other hand the decrease in the rural population was the lowest recorded. However, it is very hard to come to any positive conclusion as to the years over the whole of the inter-censal period during which that migration took place, but I have certain figures which will suggest to Deputies—if in fact they do not convince them—that in the main whatever migration did take place must have taken place to a far greater extent in the first five years of the intercensal period rather than in the second; those are the figures of the number of persons engaged in agriculture. Deputy Mulcahy, I know, has got himself tied up in those figures to such an extent that he is almost incapable of thinking of anything else at the moment. I am going to try to elucidate them for him. I do not claim that the figures are 100 per cent. reliable, but they are the only figures we have.
Comment on this
And in the discussion we will abide by the ordinary rules of arithmetic? Is that agreed?
Comment on this
Quite. The figures are under three main headings: first, the number of persons engaged in agriculture as members of families; secondly, the number of persons engaged in agriculture as permanent agricultural workers; and thirdly, the number of persons engaged in agriculture as temporary agricultural workers. The number of persons engaged in agriculture as members of families declined between 1927 and 1931 by 29,377. If there was any drift to the towns, any substantial migration of population from the rural areas into the cities, its effect would be most clearly seen in the number of persons engaged in agriculture as members of families. It is in that class that there exists those engaged in agriculture who are unemployed or only partially employed. There may be too many members of a family for a particular farm to support, or more members than the work of the farm would require, and if there was any employment in the towns sufficient to attract people to leave the rural areas, the effect would be immediately noticeable upon the number of persons engaged in agriculture as members of families rather than in the number of agricultural labourers employed for hire. In the period 1927 to 1931 the number of persons engaged in agriculture as members of families decreased by 29,377. Since then it has increased.
Comment on this
Would the Minister explain whether there was a change in the type of enumeration between 1928 and 1929 in respect of that?
Comment on this
I am not ignoring it. The figures for each year were revised so as to be comparable one with the other. Between 1931 and 1936 there was an increase—a small increase, but nevertheless an increase.
Comment on this
According to Deputy McGilligan the reason is the drift of population from the rural areas into the towns. If that is the explanation, then the whole of that drift occurred before 1931, and cannot be attributed to the policy of the Fianna Fáil Government, or the economic war, or to anything else except the blighting effect of our predecessors. Between 1931 and 1936, the number of agricultural labourers, permanent and temporary, employed for wages, increased from 141,248 to 145,306. Deputy Mulcahy made a most solemn pronouncement here yesterday. The announcement was that between 1935 and 1936 there was a decrease in the number of agricultural labourers employed. He was quite right. He was just as right as a millionaire would be who, on 1st January, 1936, owned £1,000,000, and on 1st January, 1937, owned £999,999 and who announced that he had lost money during the year. The number decreased from 145,898 to 145,306. There are of course, these fluctuations in the figures from one year to another.
Comment on this
Both permanent and temporary, added together. In any event the system of enumeration is not a very exact one, and certain allowances must be made for that.
Comment on this
Yes. As between 1931 and 1936, there was an undoubted increase—an increase in the number of persons working in agriculture as members of families, an increase in the number of persons working in agriculture as permanent agricultural labourers, and an increase in the number of persons working in agriculture as temporary agricultural labourers. There has been an increase under all three headings.
Comment on this
Between 1931 and 1936? The Minister's figures show that there was a reduction of 2,202.
Comment on this
No. In 1931 the number of members of families engaged in agriculture on 1st June, and over 18 years of age, was 374,704, and that number went up to 375,492 by 1st June, 1936.
Comment on this
You have already published things in printed documents and revised them. I will give the Minister two figures for unemployment insurance which he has revised.
Comment on this
We merely try to correct the Deputy, but that is an impossible task. I draw attention merely to the fact that the figures recorded show that that increase took place in the number of persons employed in agriculture. If, during the period 1926 to 1931, there was a decrease in the number of persons employed in agriculture, as there was, and if, during the period 1931 to 1936, there was an increase, I submit that it is a reasonable assumption that if over the whole period there is evidence to show that there was a drift of people from the rural areas into the towns, that drift must have taken place, in the main, during the first five years and not during the second five years.
Comment on this
There would be another conclusion, too, would there not, that farming was much more profitable in the last five years than in the previous five years as an attraction for men to work at?