We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance—Vote On Account.

Contributions 178–376 of 578. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

If there is any other conclusion than that, I should like to hear it stated.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Sullivan said —I must relate my speech to what Deputy O'Sullivan said for the purpose of relating it to something—that we had done so much damage to this country by our policy that it was almost incapable now of recovering. Deputy Dillon went further, and said that it does not matter when the election is held, that even if Fine Gael got in to-morrow, it could not repair the damage, and that no matter how emphatically the people may desire change of Government, even a change of Government can do them no good now. That was Deputy Dillon's argument. It is, however, noticeable that he and Deputy O'Sullivan kept as far away as possible from any tendency to come down to hard facts, and on the one or two occasions on which I interjected remarks asking for definite information, they shied off at once to a new subject. I do not know on what basis we are to determine the extent of the damage alleged to have been done by the Fianna Fáil Government here. The number of unemployed, the output of industry, the number of persons engaged in agriculture, or some other fact, must be capable of being produced if there is any truth in the assertions made by Deputies opposite. Both Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Dillon, however, spoke about the difficulty of taking advantage of the existing prosperity in Great Britain, and they urged a change of policy, so that our farmers and other people here could get full advantage of the prosperity they alleged existed in Great Britain. If we study the British conditions, then, we will get some information as to what conditions Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Dillon will admit constitute prosperity, because they talked of the prosperity of Great Britain.

Let us consider the prosperity of Great Britain in relation to unemployment. I have given these figures before, and I am going to give them again, and I hope to have the opportunity, between now and the date of the election, of stating these figures on many occasions. In relation to population, there are fewer people unemployed in this country than in Great Britain—substantially fewer. The most recent figure for the number of registered unemployed in Great Britain is 1,689,223. The population of that country, at the census of 1936, was 45,805,000, and the unemployed, expressed as a percentage of the population of that country, was 3.69. 3.69 per cent. of the population of Great Britain were registered as unemployed at the employment exchanges. In Northern Ireland, the number of registered unemployed was 77,139, and the population in 1936 was 1,293,000. The unemployed expressed as a percentage of the population was 5.97.

Comment on this

This is not too good for Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

In the Free State, the number of registered unemployed on the 15th February was 91,918. The population in 1936 was 2,966,000, and the unemployed, expressed as a percentage of our population, was 3.09, just slightly more than half what it is in Northern Ireland, and substantially less than what it is in Great Britain. If conditions in Great Britain, according to Deputy Dillon and Deputy O'Sullivan, constitute prosperity, then conditions here cannot be much worse for the unemployed. There is at least as good a prospect of the unemployed man in this country getting work here as there is of the unemployed man in Great Britain getting work there.

Comment on this

How is it they are going to Great Britain if that is so?

Comment on this

The Deputy was out during the earlier part of my speech dealing with emigration, but if I thought it would do him any good, I would go over it all again.

Comment on this

I am in in time for this remark and there is no answer from the Minister.

Comment on this

I drew attention to the fact that emigration is evidence of some inadequacy in our economic organisation. I admitted the fact that some 20,000 people emigrated last year was evidence that our work is not yet done and that we have a lot further to go and a lot more to do before we can be satisfied with economic conditions here; but I also drew attention to the fact that emigration in last year was less than in any year during which the Deputies opposite were in office and that over the four years, 1932 to 1935, added together, there were fewer emigrants than in the average year during which they were in office.

Comment on this

And nobody growled as much as Deputy Belton.

Comment on this

If the existence of emigration in 1936 was evidence of economic difficulties, then these economic difficulties must have existed in much greater degree before this Government came into office and the economic war started and we began to do this damage to the country which it is now too late to repair.

Comment on this

The Deputy will notice that he has not got an answer to his question as to why unemployed people leave this country to go to a bigger unemployed area, England.

Comment on this

I stated that the unemployed person in this country had a better prospect of getting work here than the unemployed person in Great Britain has of getting work in Great Britain.

Comment on this

But they, nevertheless, go.

Comment on this

There are a number of other factors which explain the reasons and Deputies know why a large proportion of these people who leave this country to go to Great Britain are able to get employment there almost at once. By far the greater proportion of them are, of course, girls going to domestic service.

Comment on this

No, indeed.

Comment on this

They are.

Comment on this

Ordinary manual labourers.

Comment on this

On the contrary, I give the figures here.

Comment on this

That does not settle it at all.

Comment on this

I leave the unemployment position at this: that though it is bad, it is at least better than the unemployment position in Great Britain, and it is not half as bad as the unemployment position in Northern Ireland. Let us consider the damage we are alleged to have done to the country in relation to the number of persons in employment. This is Deputy McGilligan's personal question and for once I am in a position to meet him personally and not by proxy. I stated that when this Government got into office conditions in this country were getting steadily worse. Not only was there no progress, but there was a definite decline, a decline to be found recorded in all relevant statistics—industrial output and industrial employment, agricultural output and agricultural employment. The average number of weekly contributions to the Unemployment Fund in the year 1929-30 was 182,213. These figures are authentic, and Deputy McGilligan should know that.

Comment on this

I have got the stamp figures. That is all I want.

Comment on this

That number had decreased in the following year to 176,842. I merely mention these facts to emphasise my statement that in the years immediately preceding the change of Government the conditions here were getting decidedly worse. There was this decline in the average number of persons engaged in industrial employment as indicated by the figures I have read out. Take the year 1931 and compare it with the year 1936. One finds that the increase in the average weekly number of employed went up by 54,000. I gave the figure of 45,000 or 46,000 during the debate on the Control of Imports Act. But my calculation at that time was based upon the figures for 1936 up to the end of September. Now, having got the figures for the full year, a further increase is shown, as I anticipated on that occasion.

Comment on this

That is an increase of 12,000 for the last three months of the year.

Comment on this

One cannot be as precise as that. Firms who employ a large number of workers purchase stamps in bulk and keep them until they are wanted. I do not want to labour these figures unduly. Certain factors may inflate or deflate the figures for one period as against another, but, when one does see a steady increase from the year 1931 to the year 1936, one is confident that a substantial increase has taken place.

Comment on this

Has the Minister the stamp figures for the year 1936, and the value of the unemployment insurance stamps sold?

Comment on this

If I have, I will give them to the Deputy.

Comment on this

Has he the figures for 1934?

Comment on this

No; I have these figures which I am reading now. They are all set out in that document entitled "The Trend of Unemployment and Employment."

Comment on this

When were they published?

Comment on this

They were published in 1935. The figures for 1936 are being printed.

Comment on this

That return does not include the 1934 figures. Some time ago the Minister gave Deputy Norton a figure of 800,000, and, in an answer to me at about the same time, or close to it, he gave the figure of 744,000. That is 60,000 of a difference.

Comment on this

The first figure we got was an unrevised figure and subject to check by the auditor.

Comment on this

This figure was asked for, and the Minister gave Deputy Norton the figure of £800,000, and he gave me £744,000. Both statements are in the same volume of the debates; there is not a fortnight between them. Was that the calendar year 1934?

Comment on this

No, the financial year. The financial year is the proper year to give. Any figure for the calendar year must be an estimated figure, because the accounts are made up for the financial year.

Comment on this

You get them in month by month, and the calculation could be made month by month. I know it can.

Comment on this

The figure of the receipts is the figure over which we stand. That is up to the 31st March. The necessary adjustments are made to previous overlapping. In 1934-35, the approximate net income was £820,000, representing 215,000 average weekly contributors, which had increased to 242,000 in 1936. The actual increase in employment is not represented by that figure, but the figure which would convey a true reflex of the actual increase in employment must be less than that, because that figure is based upon the assumption that all persons who got employment got a full year's employment, whereas it is known that in many occupations the employment is seasonal, and in any case the people come into employment during the year, and though their employment is permanent, they might begin it at some period after the beginning of the year. From 1931 to 1935, over 97,000 persons may have got books and may be regarded as coming within that number, even though they were not in full-time employment, and though they got only seasonal employment during portion of the year. Therefore, the figure that would represent an increase in employment is something less than 97,000. It was a figure between 97,000 and 54,000. That would represent an increase in employment in occupations under the Act.

In addition there was an increase in employment under the National Health Acts which would be represented by a figure of somewhat over 4,000. In the actual weekly numbers so employed 4,000 is the increase. Not all these people were employed in industry. The increase in employment in industry was less than that figure. Some number of them were employed upon housing, others upon public works of one kind or another, and a proportion of them were employed in commerce, transport, etc. The increase in employment in industry between 1929 and 1935 is, according to the figures I gave here a couple of weeks ago, 25,262. We have not got the figures for 1936 yet, but, as everybody knows, there was an equally substantial increase recorded in that year. Let us take the position of industry. We are told that our policy has done so much damage to the country that it is too late to repair it. That damage did not decrease the number of persons who got a livelihood from agriculture. It increased them. It did not decrease the number of persons engaged in industrial pursuits. That number was substantially increased, and it constitutes a record for the Twenty-six Counties for the whole period for which statistics are available. The damage was done at an earlier period to our industrial organisations. Again, in order to convey that picture to the minds of Deputies, I want to give them certain facts—facts which they cannot dispute, though they may dispute the conclusions I draw from them. The facts themselves cannot, however, be controverted. We take periodically a limited census of industry. Not all industries and not even all the most important industries are included in this census. It covers 23 industries, and although most of the important industries are in it, certain occupations in which large numbers of people are employed, such as house-building, are excluded. Taking these 23 industries as typical of the whole, reference to statistics will show that between 1929 and 1931 the gross output of these industries fell in value by £5,520,000, whereas between 1932 and 1935 the gross value of the output increased by £13,617,000.

Comment on this

How much of that is represented by bounties?

Comment on this

I do not know to what the Deputy is referring.

Comment on this

The Minister has quoted a figure, and I should like to know what portion of that figure is represented by bounties.

Comment on this

Are these figures based on Free State prices or on world prices?

Comment on this

On Free State prices.

Comment on this

Before 1932 the figures would represent world prices, whereas since then they would be based on Free State prices.

Comment on this

We shall get some other way of reckoning the matter.

Comment on this

It is easy to jump up figures if a thing sold at 5/- on the world market is sold at 150/- on the Free State market.

Comment on this

What basis will the Deputy accept?

Comment on this

World prices.

Comment on this

Or the number of people employed or the amount paid in wages?

Comment on this

The Minister is dealing with prices and the value of the output.

Comment on this

The gross value of the output.

Comment on this

How much is included in that figure of increased gross production for bounties?

Comment on this

Bounties to whom?

Comment on this

To exporters, for instance.

Comment on this

Nothing.

Comment on this

Pass on to the net production until we see.

Comment on this

The gross value of the output from 1932 to 1935 showed an increase of £13,617,000.

Comment on this

What is in that?

Comment on this

Raw materials——

Comment on this

And tariffs on raw materials.

Comment on this

Raw materials are the big thing.

Comment on this

I asked Deputy McGilligan if he was serious in the argument he put forward on the last occasion, and he told me he was. I want to proceed to deal with that argument. In all industries, from 1929 to 1931, apart from the 23 covered by the limited census of production, there was a similar decrease in the gross value of the output. The net output represents the gross output less the amount paid for materials, fuel, power and certain other charges—the value added by industrial work to the materials purchased. Between 1929 and 1931, the net value of the output decreased by £59,000, but between 1932 and 1935 it increased by £3,344,000. That is the net output. If that particular index does not satisfy Deputies, let us take the number of wage-earners. Between 1929 and 1931, the number of wage-earners engaged in these 23 industries decreased by 1,602, but, between 1932 and 1935, it increased by 23,285. If that does not satisfy Deputies, we shall take the wages paid by industry. Between 1929 and 1931, the wages paid to workers in these 23 industries decreased by £553,000, but, between 1932 and 1935, they increased by £1,604,000. These figures lead to only one possible conclusion.

Comment on this

Did that increase in wages account for an increased production of £13,000,000?

Comment on this

That is not Deputy McGilligan's argument, and I want to deal with Deputy McGilligan's argument. Let me get the Deputy's argument right. Bearing in mind that this argument was advanced by a man who was for eight or nine years Minister for Industry and Commerce, and responsible for the direction of industrial activities in this country, is it any wonder that there was that decline in output and in wages paid during the period I mentioned? Deputy McGilligan drew attention to the fact that, though there had been this increase in the gross value of the output, the increase in the net output was only £2,500,000. He said:

"The net production, even including subsidies, which are not properly related to the matter, is about £2,500,000 on £12,500,000 gross."

Comment on this

The subsidies are in both.

Comment on this

Nonsense. The Deputy went on:

"Therefore, our tariffing of industries in this country in five years has meant that in certain groups the consumers are paying something additional to an increased cost of £12,500,000, and, in the end, we have a net production of £2,500,000. That is interesting when one looks at it from the point of view of the relation between the employee and the manufacturer."

At that point I interrupted and asked if the Deputy meant that argument seriously. He assured me that he did. Does he really contend that these figures show that the consumers are paying £12,500,000 for a net increased production of £2,500,000?

Comment on this

How do you get the £12,500,000?

Comment on this

The selling price.

Comment on this

Somebody is paying. Who is it? Is it the wholesaler?

Comment on this

That is the selling price of the goods at the factories.

Comment on this

Therefore the consumer has to have the retail price added on. That proves my point.

Comment on this

If I have proved the Deputy's point, I have done it inadvertently, because I do not know what the point is. Is the Deputy's point that goods that could have been purchased for £2,500,000 cost £12,500,000?

Comment on this

Is the point that if our tariff policy had not operated, the goods which these industries produced and sold for £12,500,000 could have been bought at a lesser sum?

Comment on this

I did not advance that argument, but I shall consider it.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy's point that the sole benefit this country got from that increase in industrial production should be valued at £2,500,000 and not at £12,500,000?

Comment on this

I have here a list of 23 industries. Let us take bacon curing. The gross output was £5,163,000, and the net output was £732,000. The difference was £4,430,000. Does Deputy McGilligan contend that the people of this country got no part of that? Where did the raw materials of the bacon industry come from? Where did they get their power?

Comment on this

If they did get a part of it, it is in the net production figure.

Comment on this

It is in the net production figure of the agricultural industry, but it is not in the net production figure of £2,500,000. So far as the bacon-curing industry is concerned, the whole of the raw materials are got in this country.

Comment on this

Again you were wrong.

Comment on this

Of the whole of the raw materials, I will exclude salt and perhaps one or two other chemicals which they may use, but of the £4,433,000 which the industry pays for raw material, at least £4,000,000 is spent in this country.

Comment on this

I say yes. The next is the grain-milling industry, where again we have the same situation. There was a gross output of £7,800,000. The net output was £1,400,000, leaving a difference of £6,400,000. In the grain-milling industry some part of the raw materials is still being imported, but in 1931 all the raw materials were being imported, all the wheat which was being ground in Irish mills. Since then one-third of the raw materials used in the industry has been produced by Irish farmers, and one-third of the amount paid for these raw materials——

Comment on this

Who pays it?

Comment on this

The people who pay the £12,500,000.

Comment on this

The man who eats dearer bread.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This dialogue may be very interesting, but it is not debate.

Comment on this

The next industry is the malting industry. All the raw materials for it are being procured in this country. With regard to the sugar industry——

Comment on this

The Minister will have to make a step there.

Comment on this

The whole of the difference between the value of the gross output and the value of the net output is represented by the money paid out to Irish people——

Comment on this

Who pays it?

Comment on this

——for the production of the raw materials. The Deputy is trying to get away from his original contention, but I do not propose to allow him to do so. His contention was that the only benefit which our people got from this increased production of £12,500,000 was the value of the net output.

Comment on this

On the industrial side.

Comment on this

I say the difference is of much greater benefit to the people of this country, because it represents, in the main, the money paid out through industry to the producers of primary products for the raw materials used in those industries. I could go down through the list—brewing, distilling, tobacco. With regard to tobacco, a large part of the raw materials used in the tobacco industry has to be imported, but an effort is now being made, and a beginning attempted to replace at least a proportion of imports by our own products. Then there is wood furniture, engineering, linen, woollens, boots and shoes, and so on. Not all of these, of course, are working on native raw materials, but far the greater number of them are. Those of them that are using native raw materials are of direct benefit to this country, not because of the employment they give, but because of the market which they afford here for native raw materials which otherwise would be imported from abroad in the form of finished products. Therefore, it can be said that the increase in the gross value of industrial production of £13,500,000, which took place since 1932, and offset a decrease of £5,000,000 in the previous two years, is of £12,500,000 benefit to this country, or almost that. I admit that coal is being imported to an increasing extent, because the great majority of our industries are now consuming electrical power, as well as certain other raw materials, but, in the main, the position in the industries covered by this limited census indicates that there is no more substance in the Deputy's argument in this particular matter than there is in his arguments generally.

Comment on this

That is very crushing.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon spoke about figures being presented here in a manner calculated to mislead, and he gave an amazingly efficient exhibition of how it could be done. First of all, he spoke of some old age pensioner in Donegal who, although he got an extra couple of shillings in the week from this Government under the 1932 Act, had to pay that out in an increased cost of foodstuffs. He, of course, set out to compare the cost of foodstuffs in 1932 with what was the cost in 1931. I asked him why 1931, because he was trying to justify the reduction in the old age pensions which took place in 1924, at a time when the cost-of-living index for food items alone was 194 as compared with the figure at the present time of 147. In any case, the figure for 1936— 147—is not higher than the figure for 1931, and if there has been the substantial rise in the cost of food purchased by a working-class family which Deputy Dillon alleges, then the people who are compiling those statistics—who are getting information from every important centre in the country, and who are experts at their jobs—must be misled in some way. However, I am prepared to take their conclusions and to base my policy on their conclusions and not upon Deputy Dillon's fallacies.

I do not know that there is much more that I need deal with. The Party opposite gave notice of their intention to discuss here to-day the consistent misrepresentation of vital facts by Ministers. If they had profited by their recent experience and decided to abandon their consistent misrepresentation of Ministers, and made a serious effort to get their facts right, they could render much more useful service to this country as an Opposition than they are doing at present. Their function at present, and for many years to come, will be to act as an Opposition. Let them try at least to be efficient as an Opposition. I know they failed as a Government. Nobody is prepared to contemplate the possibility of their ever becoming a Government again, but if they are condemned to act for the future as an Opposition, they should at least make an effort to be a serious Opposition. They should try to get away from the position in which they find themselves, of being under the necessity of applauding every adverse report that is published from any source, of going hunting round for footnotes in every official publication for some item of information which would seem to convey the idea that conditions in the country were getting bad and of producing if here in all cheerfulness as something which was going to add to their own electoral stock. They are in a position which some of them must feel very anxious to get out of. If, however, they are prepared to deal with facts and if they have a constructive policy, they can be of some service to the country; but unless they are prepared to do that they can be of no service either to the country of to themselves.

Comment on this

Is there better prosperity here than ever before?

Comment on this

I did not say there was any prosperity.

Comment on this

Is there better production here?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Mulcahy.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance challenged us this afternoon as to the items which we would remove from the Estimates. The first series of items which I would remove from the Estimates would be those for Ministers' salaries. That would be the way to start clearing up the present situation. For instance, we are asked to vote a salary for the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I would protest against the passing of that item. The attitude with regard to the Coronation, as explained by the President, is one of detachment and protest. Nevertheless, on Friday last a lady and a gentleman, apparently representing an English factory situated about 40 miles from London, attended at the women's department of the Labour Exchange, Beresford Place, looking for 300 girls to work in this factory making paper hats for the Coronation. They gave a demonstration of the type of work to be done, indicating the type of skill necessary. They made an offer of 26/- a week, 2/- to be deducted until such time as the travelling expenses of the girls to London had been refunded. They wanted, it appears, 300 girls. One girl was offered this and she declined it, and the lady at the hatch asked her was she declining to take on this work, and she said she was; and the normal payment that girl expected to get that week, having got it in previous weeks, was withheld from her.

Comment on this

If it was withheld from her, it was withheld illegally.

Comment on this

Well, it was done, anyway.

Comment on this

The Deputy took good care not to send the facts to me before bringing up the matter.

Comment on this

I say that it was withheld.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The discussion on the Vote on Account may not be itemised. Matters of that kind should be reserved for the Estimate. It would obviously be impossible for Ministers to deal with specific items of that character without notice.

Comment on this

Might I suggest, Sir, that the question of emigration has been dealt with at great length by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and here is a question of forced emigration from the labour exchanges through the cutting-off of the girls' unemployment money. Surely, Sir, that could be raised as a spectacular item to show that these people are being forced out of the country.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows quite well that, if that happened, it was due to some administrative mistake—to some mistake possibly by a clerk—and not to any Government policy.

Comment on this

I do not agree with that whatever. I have other evidence—not so direct as that, perhaps —but bearing out that that is what is happening. The principle was that people must be willing and offering for employment, but it is now being considered as offering for employment anywhere.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

It is true, and I respectfully submit to the Chair that it is relevant to the question of enforced emigration.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair holds that it relates to one particular item—possibly an important item— and discussion on these items should be reserved for the Estimates.

Comment on this

I want to deal with Ministers' misrepresentation of a general position here in this country and, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce is here, and before he goes away, I want to put this in the front of my picture. The refusal of the money is only one point, but during the last week-end 37 girls were sent to London at this rate of pay through the instrumentality of the labour exchanges here. Detachment and protest!

Comment on this

And they want 300.

Comment on this

The rate is 26/ a week and 2/- to be deducted, and, particularly after the investigation carried out in Great Britain as to the conditions under which girls are working there, and the type of social contacts they are in danger of making there, I say that on that alone I hope the Minister will extend his policy of detachment and protest to the Coronation, to the work of sending girls to work at that particular type of wages in connection with anything over there, whether connected with the Coronation or not. Now, the Minister takes up the attitude that Deputies on this side of the House are endeavouring to paint catastrophic conditions in this country and are doing it for purposes of party political advantage. The Minister, no doubt, is entitled to express that opinion, but he cannot hold it if he observes the conditions that have grown up in this country. If he observes the trend of things in this country, he cannot hold that opinion and he must hold that, if there is any party or any section of people in this country careful or interested in the present-day or the future interests of the people, economically or culturally, they ought to be outspoken as to the things that are happening, the trends that are taking place, and the causes of these trends.

The minister dealt with the question of population. Only comparatively recently, a very systematic attempt was made on the part of the Government to hide the fact that the natural rise in population that began in 1930 and started to go steadily upwards then, has been arrested and turned downwards by the impact of the conditions brought about in this country by the economic war.

Comment on this

Was the fall in population before 1931 due to the economic war?

Comment on this

The conditions with regard to the population before 1931 are perfectly clear, but I am dealing with the conditions since 1931, the ministerial attitude to those conditions, and the necessity of people being outspoken on the one hand, so far as their public representatives are concerned, and of people throughout the country not being misled. It was only the other day—on the 24th February—that I raised a question with the Minister for Local Government and Public Health as to the accuracy or otherwise of the figures given us by him in regard to the population in this country since 1931. It arose out of a speech made by the Minister for Finance that, in my opinion, was misrepresenting the situation here. In the course of the questioning in the House here, I said:

"In view of the fact that the figures given by the Minister for Local Government to the Dáil show that what has happened is that, during the last five years, the tendency of the population of this country to rise has been arrested and has, in fact, been turned into a downward tendency..."

And then the Minister for Industry and Commerce "butts" in and says: "Nonsense."

Comment on this

The Deputy talked about the conditions created by his Government, and not about the last five years.

Comment on this

The records of this House——

Comment on this

I do not care what is in the records. That is what the Deputy said.

Comment on this

The records I have here are substantially correct. What is not correct is the record in the House of my remarks following the Minister's saying "Nonsense," because his Party roared me down so that my words could not be heard. However, the position is that after the turn in 1930 the whole political propaganda of the Ministry was that the population was rising and the figures provided by the Registrar-General indicated substantial and increasing annual increases. Then, when the census of April, 1936, was produced and the figures were revised, we find that, in the yearly increases from 1930 to 1931 and onwards, instead of there being an increase of 11,000 followed by an increase of 17,000 followed by an increase of 19,000, and followed by two increases of 20,000 up to June, 1935, the actual increases were 6,000 at the end of 1931 and 16,000 at the end of 1932, and that then, instead of that going on and increasing, it started to fall. For 1933 the increase was 13,000, and for 1934 the increase was 9,000. It ran flat to June, 1935, and it fell by 5,000 to April, 1936, and by another 1,000 to June, 1936. Now the Minister tells us here to-day that a decline began in 1936. A decline began between June, 1934, and June, 1935, and with all the boasting that there has been of the increase in population and the provision that was being made for these people throughout the country, the figures now show that the rise in the population, that began vigorously in the two years 1931 and 1932, reaching an increase of 16,000 in the year ended June, 1932, was hit by the economic circumstances produced by the economic war and was actually turned into a downward trend until we still have——

Comment on this

There is a declining female population, I admit, but the male population is increasing.

Comment on this

If the Minister thinks that a declining female population in a declining population improves the situation, then he is thinking very superficially about the matter.

Comment on this

I want to direct the Deputy's attention to the fact that the decline is entirely among the female population, and that the male population is increasing.

Comment on this

And I say that that is one of the most disastrous features of the situation.

Comment on this

I am not denying it, but what are the economic causes of it?

Comment on this

The cause is that this country was injured economically by the circumstances brought about by the Ministry.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy be good enough to explain to us the causes of that sudden increase from 1930 to 1931?

Comment on this

The benefits of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government.

Comment on this

The cause of the increase was that emigration was falling and even though the Minister does not believe it, again it controverts one of the statements made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that emigration in the year 1936 was less than it was in any of the previous years during the term of office of the previous Administration.

Comment on this

Now that the Deputy has given us that explanation of the increase in population between 1930 and 1931, would he give us also an explanation of the heavy decrease in population that took place in 1927, 1928, 1929 and 1930?

Comment on this

Sir, I am not going to be prevented discussing events in this country from 1931 and the reasons for them. I simply say that in so far as emigration from this country is concerned, the net migration outwards in the year ended June, 1931, was reduced to 9,201, and that in June, 1932, there was a net migration inwards of 3,000. That was the end of the migration situation in respect to the years 1931 and 1932. I am dealing with misrepresentations on the part of the Ministry about which I want to be clear and concise. The figures that have been given by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health as regards the trend of population since 1931 deserve to be recorded. They are given in respect of the year 1931 to 1935 in the report of the Dáil Debates of the 4th November, 1936. Subsequently, he informed us, on the 11th of November, 1936, that the population of the Saorstát in the middle of 1936 was 2,965,000. It was already reported that the census of April, 1936, indicated that the population then was 2,965,854. Therefore, instead of its being nonsense, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce suggests, to say that the rise of population that began in 1932 was arrested or driven downwards, it is entirely a fact and it is a fact that is expressed in the figures quoted by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health in the statistics he has already given. That is a very serious thing for the country. It is a serious thing for a country in which so much capital is being invested at the present moment and in which a large number of new industries are being set up, new industries that have to depend for their market on the number of people in the country and on their purchasing power.

The attempt of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to challenge and minimise the importance of the statement that the population is falling by suggesting that the decrease was mainly among women shows the extent to which Ministers are prepared to go in order to gloss over or obscure serious economic facts affecting this country. Not only is that the position, but as already explained in the discussions that have taken place, there is an exodus from the rural parts of the country. Whether that exodus arose out of circumstances existing ten years ago or out of circumstances existing five years ago, is not a matter with which we are concerned when we are discussing the remedies that have to be applied to the situation so that agriculture should get a chance and so that the farmers and the agricultural community in general should get a chance to develop the real source of capital and of wealth production in this country. When we take into consideration the falling population at the present time brought about by the economic war, and the drift to the towns, we have to consider also the position that is shown in connection with the schools in the country. The figures already published by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health show that there are 11 counties in which, for every 100 children that are going to school now, there will be only 95 attending in the year 1941. There are 17 counties in which, for every 100 children going to school at the present time, there will be only 94 attending in 1941. We have to consider also that the schools in the rural parts are going to suffer infinitely more than schools in the urban districts.

So far as the population is concerned, it is obvious that the people at the present time are vanishing out of the rural districts and are crowding into the towns. Then we come to the question of the forces that are driving the rural population out of the country. Here, again, is a sphere in which everything possible is done, particularly by the Minister for Agriculture and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, to minimise and obscure what is happening to the agricultural industry in this country. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance had the audacity to address the business community of the City of Cork in January last.

Comment on this

There was nothing very audacious about that, considering that he is a representative of the city.

Comment on this

It was very audacious on the part of any person to stand before representatives of commerce and of industry in Cork City and to tell them: "I have been amazed to find how little difference that complete revolutionary change in the whole of our economic life has made." It was particularly audacious to tell them that if he graphed all the exports and imports of commodities as far as this country is concerned, he could not point out the spot on the graph which indicated when the economic war began in this country. An attempt has been made to pretend to the people of this country that what happened agriculture since 1931 is a continuance of the conditions that began to operate in the world in 1929. There was a time when Ministers could not see that there was a world economic depression from 1929 to 1931. Now Ministers do see it. Not only are they able to see it now, but they endeavour to persuade the country that we are still in the throes of a world economic depression and that that is what is impoverishing farmers at the present time.

I want to point out that when a Special Committee of the League of Nations examined the matter and reported in May, 1931, they indicated there were two countries in the whole world that had fairly escaped the worst part of the economic depression. They explained that Ireland was one of these and Denmark was the other and that the reason why these two countries had escaped the worst of the economic depression in these years was that they were agricultural countries, that their agricultural economy was based on the production of live stock and live-stock products, and while the prices of these things fell, the prices of feeding had fallen at the same time. When the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance starts to graph his figures and conveniently cannot see where the economic war began here, he ought to make some kind of attempt to compare the figures we have and the statistics that are shown for this country and the rest of the world. We find that in Great Britain they began to get over the effect of the economic depression of 1929 and 1931 at the end of the year 1931. We find that in Denmark, and in the case of the other members of the British Commonwealth of Nations, they began to get over the effect of the world economic depression in 1931 and 1932.

The position as regards ourselves and the world generally may, perhaps, be best illustrated by considering what happened immediately before the end of 1931 in Great Britain and Northern Ireland and what happened here. As regards the exports of Great Britain in 1930-31, if we compare them with the exports for the year 1929 and see what was the cumulative fall for these two years below the 1929 figure, we find that it was £497,322,000. If we take their exports for the years 1932 to 1936 and see how they were related to the year 1931, we find there was a net increase in their exports cumulatively, over the 1931 standard, of £41,879,000. That shows that whereas Great Britain lost in exports in the two years ended 1931, £497,322,000 below the 1929 standard, by the end of 1936 she had begun to go up again and had increased her exports cumulatively by £41,879,000.

Our position was very different. By the end of the year 1931 the cumulative fall in our exports for the two years 1930-31 below the 1929 level was £13,135,000. Did we improve our export position in the following five years over the 1931 position? Unfortunately, we did not. In the years 1932-1936, instead of improving our position we fell below the 1931 figure by a total of £74,937,000. While the world, as indicated by the export trade of Great Britain, began to improve, we were still sinking and we sank infinitely lower after the world had begun to improve than we had before that. Our cumulative losses for the two years before 1931 were £13,135,000. Our cumulative losses for the next five years were £74,937,000.

Let us turn to Australia. The exports began to improve there immediately after December, 1931. In Canada the fall was practically slacked off in 1932 and the position began to improve in 1933. In New Zealand the fall ceased at the end of 1931 and they began to go up after 1933. In South Africa, if we exclude gold, they began to go up immediately after 1932. In the Irish Free State we were still going down in the year 1933 and we are hardly above that level yet. In Denmark, the country with which we were compared, instead of going down after 1932, the export trade rose quickly.

While other countries were beginning to recover their position, we were going steadily and definitely down. Why were we going down? Because of the policy pursued by the Ministry. The pretence is still being kept up that the increased cereal growing in this country is going to make good the losses of the farmers by the destruction of the live stock and live-stock product industry.

We have paintings in Ministerial statements and in the Ministerial Press that things are better in this country than in any other country, that the position of the farmer is steadily improving and that there is a very great increase in industrial employment in the towns. What is the position of the farmer? If we take the fall in cereal imports and say that for every pound fall in cereals imported the farmers had increased cereal production in this country to that amount, nevertheless we find that the farmer has lost enormous amounts of money every year since the policy of the Fianna Fáil Government interfered with the farming industry.

Let us take the year 1932. If the farmer had an income from increased cereal production to the full value of the fall of the imports of cereals in that year, nevertheless, on the net export trade he would have lost £7,362,000. That would be the position in the year ended December, 1932. The position was worse in 1933, because he would have lost £8,859,000. His position would even be worse in 1934, because he would have lost £10,007,000. In 1935, he would have lost £7,023,000, and in the year 1936 he would have lost £5,354,000. Assuming that the fall in cereals imported had been made up in production here that brought in cash, the farmers interested in that particular transaction in these five years would have lost £38,590,000.

The pretence is that the farmers were never securer than to-day. The Minister for Industry and Commerce went further when he made the statement that there was more agricultural employment in this country to-day than there was in the year 1931. That is not a fact. The Minister circulated figures which show that in the year 1931 the total number of males employed in agriculture was 562,573. He answered a question only the other day in which he said that the total number of males employed in agriculture in June, 1936, was 560,371. I asked if he agreed to deal with these matters by the ordinary rules of arithmetic and he said he did. If he agrees to that, then there was a fall of 2,202 males employed in agriculture in 1936 as against 1931, in spite of the great cereal-growing policy which is being pursued and which cost an enormous amount of money to the purchasers of flour, bread, vegetables and sugar, and an additional cost in paying enormous bounties for the export of agricultural produce.

The Minister for Finance used quite a regular string of phrases about national honour and integrity and all that kind of thing. What can we say of the attitude of a Ministry which will make statements contrary to the facts published by themselves? We have, first, the statement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in an interjection, that there was more employment in agriculture to-day than ever before. Then we had his definite intervention in the debate in which he quoted certain figures, but they were not the figures which he gave previously in reply to questions here. The net position in the country as a whole, as given by him in reply to questions already, is that there are 2,202 less males employed in agriculture. As against that, we have an increase of 223,673 acres of wheat; an increase of 14,363 acres of barley; and an increase of 56,479 acres of beet. We have a fall in oats of 63,890, in potatoes of 11,879, and in turnips of 32,000. Nevertheless, we have a very much advertised and a very much subsidised so-called tillage policy going on, and the total result is that there are less males employed in agriculture to-day.

The Minister claims that there is an enormous increase in the male population of the country. They have been driven away, apparently, from agriculture to such an extent that even the cultural side of our life is going to be injured. There was a certain amount of indignation a year or so ago when statements were made that emigration from this country was bringing about the depopulation of some rural areas. I think some people interested in the G.A.A. at that time were rather indignant that such a statement should be made and contradicted it. However, we had the president of the Connaught Council of the G.A.A. complaining at a convention held at Galway on 28th February last that the athletic movement in the county cannot be kept up in certain places because of the young men leaving. The Minister explained that there was an increase of 23,000 persons in the last five years in the industries covered by his census of production. Half that was an increase of women and the position that the towns find themselves in is that men are pressing in from rural districts into the towns and are taking from the natural town worker the employment that should be his. A very grave situation has been created in places like Dublin and other cities and towns by reason of the fact that persons are being driven off the land and are coming to the cities and towns looking for work.

The industrial side of our life here is also being injured by the money that is taken away from agriculture. I have indicated that the farmers would have lost, on the balancing of the increased cereal production against their loss on the export of live stock products, a sum of £38,000,000. That is not only taken away from our people as capital but could be laid at the foundations of Irish industry. It is also taken out of daily circulation and the result is that our industries are being hit at present by the fall in the purchasing power of our people. For the last three years we have been bringing to the notice of the Government and the Dáil that in certain articles, such as boots and shoes, clothing, soap, candles, sugar, confectionery, furniture and hosiery, there has been a substantial fall in purchasing by the people. The Minister for Industry and Commerce vigorously denies these things annually. Even to-day, in response to an interruption, he reiterated the statement that there were more boots being purchased now than in 1931. I want to bring him back to the 16th May, 1935, when, as reported in column 1110 of the Official Reports, the question was first brought before him on the general resolution in connection with the Budget. At that time I claimed that there had been a fall in the value of boots and shoes purchased between the years 1931 and 1933 of £256,000. The Minister declared: "There are more boots and shoes being bought at the present time than four years ago by at least 500,000 pairs." He said a lot more than that on the subject, but that was his statement. On the 28th April, 1936, a year afterwards, on his own estimate, the subject was returned to with additional information bearing on the 1934 position. I said: "The Minister has never realised that a Government cannot undermine the main earning industry in this country and not undermine the capacity of the people to buy clothing, boots and shoes and hosiery" and the Minister for Industry and Commerce said: "They are buying more than ever they bought."

He reiterated again to-day that people are buying more shoes than they ever bought, but he issued the Trade and Shipping Statistics for the year 1935 at the end of last year, which reached us some time in December or January, and that volume brings out the value of the consumption of boots and shoes made up from imports and native production from the year 1931 to the year 1935, and brings out also the number of thousand dozen pairs of boots and shoes consumed in the country during these years. Here we have a Minister who in May, 1935, stated that more boots and shoes were being bought at that time than were bought four years before, by at least 500,000 pairs, which would be about 41,000 dozen, and who says a year afterwards that people were buying more than they ever bought. His Department produces information which shows that in 1932 we consumed 47,000 dozen less pairs of boots and shoes than in 1931. In 1933 our consumption was below the 1931 figure by 16,000 pairs, in 1934 by 19,000 pairs, and in 1935 by 14,000 pairs, notwithstanding the fact that in one of these years 120,000 dozen pairs of shoes were brought to this country, the value being 17/4 per dozen pair. In spite of the fact that 120,000 dozen pairs of that type of boot or shoe were consumed every year, we have been shown to be using less boots and shoes. When I argued this matter before, I argued on the amount of money spent, and the Minister for Finance was very excited that it should be argued on the number of boots and shoes. The Minister has now lost his excitement.

Comment on this

The Deputy's speech is not very exciting.

Comment on this

No, not very exciting, but these are the vital and terrible things that this country is faced with to-day, and as a result of the Minister's policy and that of his colleagues has brought our people to this position, that they are not able to provide themselves with the necessaries of life to the same extent that they were before they began to apply their policy. In each of the years 1932, 1933 and 1934 we spent £368,000, £328,000 and £385,000 less on boots and shoes because we were not able to buy as much; yet the Minister carried on for two years arguing that the people were never better shod. The Minister suggested to-day, in spite of the figures he gave us, and he boasted somewhere recently in the country, that in 1936, at any rate, we were supposed to have used more boots and shoes than ever before. Next year when the figures are produced we will find that his statement was just as mendacious this year as the other statement on boots that I have read out.

We turn next to clothing. In 1932 our people spent on hosiery £223,000 less than they spent the year before; in 1933 they spent £238,000 less; in 1934 £146,000 less, and in 1935 £26,000 less. On other kinds of clothing other than hosiery as compared with 1931 we spent in 1932 £923,000 less; in 1933, £1,154,000 less; in 1934,£887,000 less, and in 1935, £594,000 less. We get this indication, that whereas in 1935 there was a falling off in the fall in consumption, it was because the price of boots and shoes had gone up again. There was a natural fall in the price of boots and shoes throughout the world for some years but the average price in 1935 was higher than it was in 1934, 1933 or 1932. What we complain of is that the roots of the economic well-being of this country are being destroyed; that the people are living to-day under conditions of very grave hardship, and that there is not a single aspect of our economic life or of our people's life that is not being merrily misrepresented by statements that are reiterated, month after month and year after year, by Ministers who have information before them that would show that what they are saying is absolutely and utterly untrue, and absolutely regardless of the position in which they are leaving the people. We had the President speaking here to-day saying that he could come to no agreement with Great Britain on any of the things in dispute; that compromise on his part meant surrender. The position we are left in is that as long as there is a small majority of a dictatorial and tyrannical kind in the Fianna Fáil Party, and as long as the back-benchers are cowed behind it, this country, until it next gets an opportunity of speaking, is going to go through the losses, the miseries and the hopelessness that large sections of our people are experiencing at the present time. It is nearly time that some of the back-benchers in Fianna Fáil, seeing the conditions to which the farming community has been reduced, seeing the fall in agricultural employment, seeing the condition to which education is going to be reduced as a result of the fall in attendance at rural schools, seeing the crippling taxation that is falling upon the people, even upon the old age pensioners who have to pay a new and surreptitiously imposed income tax of 4/10 in the £; seeing our people reduced to the position that they are not able to buy the necessaries of life to the same extent as in the past; it is nearly time that some of them would wake up and say that whatever their sins of political commission or omission were in the past, they were not going to destroy this country entirely or leave it in a most hopeless condition.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy in his closing sentences talked about a narrow and a small majority. The Deputy should be the last man in this House to open his lips about majorities because he did queer things to a minority when he had a majority. As for Fianna Fáil back-benchers, to which he referred, there have been many changes on the benches occupied by Deputy Mulcahy during the last three or four years, as individuals who were absorbed into his mixed-up Party disappeared as soon as they could gather their skirts together and left in disgust when they found the kind of team they were with. We need only look at the benches opposite to see that the Centre Party which was swallowed up as well as its leader——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not fall for discussion on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy wished to see the same thing happen in Fianna Fáil as happened with Deputy Belton, with Deputy MacDermot and General O'Duffy——

Comment on this

I am only asking Deputies to speak their minds.

Comment on this

You saw what happened.

Comment on this

I taught your side a lesson.

Comment on this

After the next general election we will be looking over at the opposite side, but there will be no one there.

Now to get down to business. Deputy Dillon, although we repeatedly advised him to leave farming to farmers, stuck his head into it again to-night. He told us all about the price of oats and barley. But there was something which Deputy Dillon did not tell us, and that was that during the last two or three years of the Cumann na nGaedheal régime, from 1928 onwards, it was absolutely impossible for farmers to sell their oats or barley in this country.

Comment on this

They are growing less oats now.

Comment on this

The condition of the farmers in the grain growing areas of my constituency was such that the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy for that constituency, Deputy Carey, came forward at a meeting of the local urban council with a resolution appealing to the Minister for Lands not to collect any more annuities because the people could not pay them. That was in 1929, and that was the condition of affairs into which that bench over there brought the farmers of my constituency. When we hear talk over there about prices, we wonder whether they ever cast their minds back. When I hear Deputy Dillon talking about the price of pigs and pig products, I wonder whether he ever casts his mind back to these little figures. They are rather interesting. In the year 1930 we were paid £5,717,000 for our exports to Great Britain in bacon, hams, fresh pork and other pig meat, and live pigs. In the following year, 1931—there was no tariff; there was no economic war; there was no trouble at all; the two hands of friendship were out—we got £2,432,000 for pigs and pig products exported to Britain. That is a difference of £3,000,000 in one year.

Comment on this

And then you went to Ottawa.

Comment on this

Whilst you got £2,432,000 from Great Britain in the year 1931 for pigs and pig products exported to her, you paid the Chinese £1,600,000 for becon to feed the Irish people. What is the position to-day? In 1936, for bacon, hams, etc., exported you got £2,513,000 and in addition to that you have a market here at home that was worth £1,670,000 in 1932; you have that market here at home which was supplied by Chinese bacon imported to feed the Irish people. We feed them with Irish people. We feed position of the pig market that we are told has been ruined, has been robbed, has been plundered by the present Government. The Irish farmer got very close on £2,000,000 more for his pigs last year than he got during the last year in which Cumann na nGaedheal misrepresented this country.

Comment on this

What is the difference in the cost of production?

Comment on this

You look it up.

Comment on this

I have looked it up.

Comment on this

I took the care and trouble to get this much.

Comment on this

Answer that question.

Comment on this

You will tell us all about it in a minute. We will be delighted to hear it. Deputy Dillon actually stands up here to-night and starts off about the admixture scheme ruining the country, the admixture scheme that got for the farmers in my constituency and for every other grain-growing constituency in the Twenty-six Counties a market for the grain which they could not sell whilst Deputies over there were members of the Executive Council. I remember down in Midleton in the harvest of 1931 the local brewery, as a great compliment, took 50,000 barrels of barley out of 380,000, and told the people they could feed the rest to whatever they liked. That was the position in 1931. Then Deputy Dillon gets up over there and starts telling us how we have ruined the Irish farmer by making Irish pigs eat Irish barley. Then we have ruined the Irish farmer by the Pigs Marketing Board, and then we have ruined him by some other means. I remember recently in this House, after Deputy Dillon had made outlandish statements of that description, I produced three witnesses here to prove Deputy Dillon's statement to be false. I wonder if I were to produce them again would I be able to satisfy Deputies opposite?

The first witness I would produce would be Mr. E.J. Cussen, of the Farmers' Union, Cork. His statement made at the Cork County Committee of Agriculture six months ago was that the Pigs Marketing Board has increased the price of pigs for the Irish farmer by anything between 10/- and £1 per cwt. The next witness I would bring in is Mr. Buckworth, Cork, a man who fattens about 1,000 pigs at a time. At a meeting held in the University College, Cork, at which the Minister for Agriculture, Dr. Ryan, was present, he made the statement that despite the admixture scheme and everything else he had made money on fattening pigs until the Pigs Marketing Board came in and ruined the market. Those are the two high priests side by side. Let us then take the third, to whom I give every credit; he was a man who had the courage of his convictions and believed what he was stating. The third man is Mr. Dring, of Glanmire. Mr. Dring started off by attacking the admixture scheme, right, left and centre. He said it was ruining the pig trade of the country. Then, low and behold, the tariffs come on top of that. Mr. Dring became desperate, and in the finish he said: "Well, I do not see any use in carrying on further with the job. I will go over to England; I will fatten my pigs there on pure maize; I need not pay tariffs on them and I will have the market there beside me without paying any freight." He went and spent 12 months in England fattening pigs on pure maize and selling them under the English Marketing Board. When the 12 months were up he came back into Glanmire again to fatten pigs on Irish barley and sell them under the Irish Pigs Marketing Board. These statements can appear in the Press to-morrow morning and I defy any one of those gentlemen to contradict them.

Comment on this

What does he say about fattening pigs under present conditions?

Comment on this

Experience teaches even an idiot like Mr. Dring——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Statements of that kind should not be made with reference to anybody.

Comment on this

I am sorry. I withdraw it.

Comment on this

The two practical men knew what they were saying.

Comment on this

The two practical men? One practical man said that the Pigs Marketing Board had increased the price of pigs by anything from 10/- to £1 per cwt. The other practical joker said he was ruined by the Pigs Marketing Board. I made those statements here six months ago, and the Deputy can read them in the Official Report. The third joker went across the water for 12 months and tried fattening pigs on pure maize, selling them in England without any tariff, with the market at his door. When he had had 12 months of that he came back here to fatten his pigs on Irish barley, and sell them under the Irish Pigs Marketing Board.

Comment on this

Is not Mr. Cussen a curer?

Comment on this

Mr. Cussen was one of the highest feathers in your cap when he had a blue shirt on him in Marsh's yard.

Comment on this

He is a curer—not a producer.

Comment on this

He was then the representative of the downtrodden farmers of Cork. Deputy Belton can make his own speech when I have finished. I will state facts, one after another, which will convince even Deputy Belton.

Comment on this

They would want to be something better than those facts.

Comment on this

There they are. I am quoting the cases of three gentlemen who cannot contradict my statements. I will give you the public statement in each case. Surely Mr. Buckworth, who fattens 1,000 pigs at a time, knew what he was saying?

Comment on this

Certainly. What did he say?

Comment on this

Mr. Dring, who fattens and rears and breeds a couple of thousand at a time——

Comment on this

I know both of them well.

Comment on this

——went over to England, tried the game there, and came back here to do it. Why?

Comment on this

Yes, why?

Comment on this

Because it paid him better to do it here.

Comment on this

What interests had he here?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us have no cross-examination. Deputy Corry is making his speech.

Comment on this

That was a bad one for the Deputy.

Comment on this

What interests had he here? What interest had he in going over to spend 12 months in England fattening pigs and in coming back and trying the game here again? Facts are stubborn things. We had Deputy Dillon on sugar beet. It is a very nice subject for him. I do not want to go into figures in regard to the sugar beet industry, but I ask any Deputy who is interested to get the British figures and to study them. I think he will find there a complete answer. Let him study the figure at which they are producing beet in England, the figure which they are paying labour for producing beet, what they are paid for the beet and what is their average tonnage per acre.

Of course, the Deputy had to have a crack at wheat. It would not do at all if Deputy Dillon did not have a crack at wheat. I think I have Deputy Belton with me in this. Again, facts are stubborn things, and the fact in regard to wheat is that the farmers have increased their acreage each year, and when the returns are published this year it will be found that they have further increased it, despite the bad season.

Comment on this

How many of them have increased their manured acreage?

Comment on this

Look it up.

Comment on this

You look it up.

Comment on this

Whatever time you can spare from the other job, turn it to that. Deputy Dillon told us about the rotten crop wheat was last year, what an unsafe crop it was for any Irish farmer to grow, and the foolishness of the Irish farmers to grow it. I wonder did Deputy Dillon ever see a dead bullock? One would think there was no loss whatever in other crops and that every crop was dead safe except wheat. And Deputy Dillon speaks with the authority of the Fine Gael Party on these matters. I advise the Deputy to study the subject closely and not to speak about farming until he learns about it in some other way than from a flower pot in a window here in Dublin.

We had Deputy Mulcahy telling us about expenditure and the rest of it. When Deputy Mulcahy was on these benches, at least from 1927 to 1932, appeal after appeal was made to him on behalf of the rural population, on behalf of the unfortunate agricultural labourer who was living in a tumbledown shack and who came home at night to find the rain pouring down on his bed, and on behalf of the small farmer under £25 valuation who could not get the price of building a new house. Appeals that that small farmer should get something for the reconstruction of his old house were made to Deputy Mulcahy, and Deputy Mulcahy was deaf to all these appeals. The farthest he could see in respect of housing the people of this country was the borough boundary of the City of Dublin. He never saw beyond that. Cottage acres for which labourers had applied in 1913 and which were bought and paid for by the local authorities in 1913 and 1914 were lying there from 1914 until 1933.

Comment on this

All over the country.

Comment on this

Why do you not elect a better board of health then?

Comment on this

The board of health at the present day consists of eight Blue-shirts and myself.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Even the Cork Board of Health does not fall for discussion on this Vote.

Comment on this

You are more concerned with Spain and the Christian Front than you are with the cottages.

Comment on this

That is the bother. There is nobody a Christian here except Deputy Billy Sunday. As I have said, housing was absolutely ignored by Deputy Mulcahy during all those years and the acres of ground purchased in 1913 lay there until 1933 before they were built on. Luckily, the present Government came in and by reason of the Housing Acts passed by the Minister for Local Government, which are responsible for a lot of this present expenditure, we found ourselves in the position last year of voting £500,000 for agricultural labourers' cottages in Cork alone. In the South Cork Board of Health area alone there are now close on 2,000 houses to be built under the scheme for non-municipal towns and these proposals would be absolutely impossible to carry out were it not for the fact that the present Minister for Local Government takes a very different viewpoint from the viewpoint of Deputy Mulcahy. Then you had the position of the small farmer. He never had a hope of building a new house. He had not enough money for it and he could not afford it. Now at least he will get a free grant of £40 towards repairing his present house, and, if he wants to build a new house, he will get a decent grant. The conditions of the people are absolutely changed and one need only cast one's mind back to the condition of affairs when we took over and compare it with the condition of affairs at present, even with the economic war since 1933.

There is the difference in prices, for instance, as between 1929 and 1931. This country sold more agricultural produce to England in 1931 than it did in 1929, but it got £13,000,000 less for that produce. Any Deputy who wishes to study those figures will find them in the Library. Remember that £13,000,000 is two and a half times the land annuities and the other payments which Britain is claiming. It is more than was paid in tariffs and everything else in the three years of the economic war.

I admit that about three months before the general election in 1932 the ex-President of the Executive Council woke up to the position; he went over and made an appeal there to the British people. He said that the Irish people could not pay and he asked for a moratorium on £250,000 or £500,000. He was refused and told to go back and pay up the annuities. What is the use of the Deputies opposite talking about the condition of the country, about the poverty of the country and about the position of the small farmers of the country? One would think they had a very fair opportunity and a very decent chance of knowing the minds of the small farmers of the country. I met Deputy McMenamin in County Galway during the by-election. He spoke about the position of the small farmers there and, though he is a very fluent Deputy here, he did not impress the small farmers of Galway very much. They did not seem to think they were ruined. Deputy Dillon was in Galway, too. All I can say is that in the coming general election I hope he will be spared from whatever district he is standing for and get an opportunity of rambling down to Cork. His presence in the constituency would be worth 5,000 votes to the Fianna Fáil Party. All I needed during the Galway election to clear up any question at any meeting in any parish in the county was to produce the official report of Deputy Dillon's speeches in the Dáil. I took the reports down with me. How did his speeches in these official debates react on the farmers there? Well, the farmers of Galway were not anxious to see their beet factories closed down, or to see wheat-growing knocked on the head by Deputy Dillon. Galway was not the only place where the effect of Deputy Dillon's speeches was tested on the electors. It might be said that the Galway farmers are only smallholders. He went to the County Wexford afterwards, and Deputies know what happened there.

Comment on this

That was worse than Galway.

Comment on this

Deputies opposite had it proved to them what the effect on the farming community of the speeches of Deputy Dillon was. The result showed what the farming community in this country think of the situation. Deputies opposite will not challenge a division on a Vote of this kind. Why? Because they have made such a disgraceful showing in the Division Lobby for the past six months that no notice is taken of what they do now. We are supposed to have a very bare majority here, a very small majority. Still, when you read the division here, the majority is anything from 25 to 50.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What has that to do with the Estimates?

Comment on this

I am anxious to show that Deputies opposite are now so convinced of the foolishness of their arguments that they will not ask us to have a division on these Estimates. I think, too, that I have absolutely convinced Deputies of the foolishness of the statements made here, particularly the statements made by Deputy Dillon who, indeed, is never tired of making foolish statements. The Deputy seems to think that he knows everything about all classes under the sun. The Deputy by his action here proves the old saying that a little knowledge is a dangerous thing. He comes in here as a kind of jack-of-all-trades and master-of-none. But he will finish up the same as the rest. I only hope that he will spare a little time to go down to my constituency during the general election. I wonder if Deputy O'Neill could coax him down. I hope what I have said will so convince Deputies opposite that they will not waste any more time on this debate.

Comment on this

This Vote on Account gives us an opportunity for a general survey of the national policy and its working over the year. This Vote is asking for a sum of £10,000,000 odd or roughly one-third of the total Estimate for the coming year. I think a general survey of the whole position would be more profitable at this stage than the detailed puny arguments to which we have been listening. There is one outstanding point that in the last two or three years has entered pretty largely into the debate on the Vote on Account. It is not so much with the material side of this point that I am concerned as with the policy that is behind it. I now refer to the Coal-Cattle Pact which is becoming a hardy annual. It was extraordinary that the Minister for Finance or the Minister for Industry and Commerce or any other Minister or Deputy on the Government Benches did not deal with this matter.

Comment on this

It is not extraordinary, because there is a Bill before the House, down for Second Reading to-day, Item No. 5, Imposition of Duties (Confirmation of Orders) Bill, under which the Coal-Cattle Pact can be adequately discussed.

Comment on this

Well, as a question of policy rather than the material side of the pact I cannot understand how the Minister for Finance coming here asking for a Vote on Account of £10,000,000 did not think it worth his while to deal with the matter, especially as it was only this afternoon that, in reply to a question, the President said that any settlement—substantially those were his words—would be a surrender of the position taken up on the land annuities. I wonder is the Coal-Cattle Pact not a surrender of that position? Leaving aside for a moment the monopoly that it has given to Britain the cattle trade has been carried on. For my purpose I am only concerned with the principle of refusing to recognise Britain as having any right or title in the land annuities and those other payments. I am not concerned with the coal side of this pact—only just because of the national stand that has been taken on that question of the annuities and other payments. The Minister for Finance, I am sure, is aware that the cattle trade with Great Britain has been carried on in the last 12 months through the medium of export licences. According to the Coal-Cattle Pact of last year and this year, on each beast, according to the category to which it belongs, we have to pay an import duty into Great Britain. On a beast two-years-old and over there has to be paid an import duty to England of £4 5s. 0d.

That is still being paid under this pact. What is that £4 5s. 0d.? It is the amount levied on each beast sent over, and it is levied in order to liquidate the claim by Great Britain on us for £5,000,000 for land annuities and other payments. Strange to say, the President this very afternoon told us that the doing of any such thing as paying that money would be a national surrender. Agreeing to pay it under the Coal-Cattle Pact is, to my mind, in no way different to agreeing to pay it under any other pact. We, or rather our Department of Agriculture, gets the export licences from the British Board of Agriculture. Our Department cannot issue one licence to export one beast. It is the British Department of Agriculture that issues them.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is not this rather a matter for the Department of Agriculture and not a matter of general policy? It is rather a matter of administration. The Deputy will have plenty of opportunity to discuss this fully on the appropriate Estimate, the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture. The discussion on this Vote on Account should be confined to the general financial policy of the Government.

Comment on this

I am not concerned with the administration of the Department of Agriculture. There is a time for criticising and discussing the policy of that Department. I am concerned with national policy only and I want to show that we are paying these annuities to Britain. The whole economic structure of the country has been undermined by this policy of saying: "We will not pay the annuities" and then devoting a great deal of time to misleading the people into the belief that we are not paying them. We are paying them and we are paying them by agreement. That is a question of national policy and not a question pertaining to the administration of the Department of Agriculture.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy was proceeding to deal with the issue of licences.

Comment on this

I was dealing with the point that we get licences from Britain and that on those licences, and no other instruments, can we export cattle. There is a feeling amongst people who have no direct interest in agriculture that some department of our Government issues those licences. In passing, I wanted to correct that impression. We, in this country, have no power to export a beast.

Comment on this

The Deputy is a long time in passing.

Comment on this