Committee on Finance—Vote On Account.
Contributions 377–578 of 578. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I want to impress that fact on the Minister who, perhaps, is not aware of it. If he is made aware of it, he may, in his public utterances, have greater regard for the truth. Before I finish, I shall bring the Minister over some chapters of speeches which, perhaps, he would like to forget. We have now an opportunity of dealing with national policy and bringing before the Minister his trade of scurrility in Cavan a couple of Sundays ago. The Government's lack of policy in regard to the question of partition will also be brought under the Minister's notice and it will be shown that he, a victim of partition from Belfast, has lent himself to aiding the same British Government that partitioned this country to partition Spain.
Comment on this
I submit that, according to the White Paper, we are spending money on external affairs.
Comment on this
There is a Minister responsible to the House for the policy and administration of the Department of External Affairs. Whatever details the Deputy desires to raise, within the rules of order, can be raised on the Estimate for that Department and should not be raised on this Vote.
Comment on this
Every Vote shown here is a Vote appropriate to some Department. If I am to be precluded from discussing any item which comes under a particular Estimate, then I shall be precluded from speaking at all.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not precluded from speaking. It is permissible for him to speak on general Government policy but he cannot be allowed to discuss the administration of any particular Department. The administration of each Department will arise on the Vote for that Department and can then be discussed within the rules of order and relevancy.
Comment on this
I quite appreciate that it would not be permissible to discuss the detailed administration of any Department on this Vote but I do not propose to go into any details. I wish to discuss general policy.
Comment on this
I do not propose to discuss in the air this matter of order so far as the Deputy is concerned. I have listened to what the Deputy has to say and when I think he is contravening the rules of order I will intervene.
Comment on this
On the older cattle which we export we pay £4 5s. 0d. per head. We might as well pay £4 5s. 0d. for each licence we get. In fact, it would be better for us to do so because it would not dislocate trade and we would be selling our cattle at the world price. Without going into the full losses sustained by agriculture by this arrangement, it is true to say that the entire amount of Britain's claim is being paid to Britain under this Coal-Cattle Pact. It has been agreed between our Government and the British Government to pay that sum of £5,000,000 in a particular way. Certain Deputies have praised, both here and throughout the country, the remission of the tariff on exported horses. That remission may be good for the horse trade, which is a very small branch of agriculture. The amount of duty which was imposed on horses going into Britain is not, however, remitted. The horse trade is relieved of it, but the amount that Britain used to collect off the horses will be collected off something else. A previous speaker made that point. Two or three speakers from the Government side, including a Minister, have spoken since and none of them attempted to deny that contention.
Comment on this
I heard the opening of Deputy Dillon's speech and I thought he made that point. If he did not make it, then I make it now. The fact that the Minister for Finance said that he did not think Deputy Dillon made the point shows that he was expecting it would be made. At all events, his attention is sufficiently drawn to it now and his reply will be interesting.
The House is asked to vote over £1,000,000 for the Land Commission. I would like to refer to the general policy pursued by the Land Commission. I would ask the Minister for Finance to see that the Land Commission be required to get better work done for the money advanced to it.
Comment on this
I suggest that I am dealing with policy. When the Land Commission divide large ranches into small farms they do not make roads.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy understands the difference between policy and administration? The matter that the Deputy has referred to has reference to the administration of a Department, and is one that can be fully and adequately discussed on the Vote for the Minister in charge of that Department.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I would like to have some guidance from the Chair for Deputies who may desire to speak on this Vote on Account. I do not propose to speak on it myself. Some of the previous speakers picked out one or two items concerning agriculture and dealt with them in a general way. Deputy Corry occupied the time of the House for over half an hour speaking on wheat, beet and pig feeding. Deputy Belton is called to order when he discusses matters that seem to me to be relevant on this Vote. What I am anxious to get is a ruling from the Chair for the guidance of other speakers. I had always understood the practice to be that one could speak on the various items in the Vote on Account, but that detailed references were not permitted. During the afternoon, and again this evening when the Ceann Comhairle was in the chair, Deputies were allowed to discuss items in the Vote on Account and in doing so were not ruled out of order. With all respect, I submit that Deputy Belton was in order when addressing himself to the Coal-Cattle Pact.
Comment on this
I have too much respect for the intelligence of Deputies to try to indicate to them the difference between policy and administration. I may say that I did not rule Deputy Belton out of order when he made a reference to the Coal-Cattle Pact. I could if I desired have indicated to him that his reference to horses as coming into the present Coal-Cattle Pact might be left over until item 5 or 6 on the Order Paper is reached, when that particular matter could be more fully discussed. I do want to indicate to the Deputy that if the administration of every Department were to be discussed on the Vote on Account that would mean a discussion on all the Estimates. It is only the general policy of the Government that can be discussed on this Vote. Every member of the House knows that, in connection with agriculture, there is what is described as an intensive cultivation policy, and on that a Deputy would surely be entitled to make some reference to wheat and beet-growing, such as Deputy Corry did. Deputies, I am sure, will agree that the proper distribution of estates is a matter of administration.
Comment on this
I did not touch on the question of distribution, but seeing that we are asked to vote £1,000,000 for the Land Commission, I want to draw the Minister's attention to the fact that the Land Commission is not making proper roads when breaking up estates. They are not making roads up to the standard required from local authorities.
Comment on this
You are puzzling me. A Leas-Chinn Comhairle, so far as seeing the line between administration and general policy is concerned. I do submit that I am not getting as good a crack of the whip as those who spoke before me.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not going to get away with that. The Chair in this House has a tradition for impartiality, and whoever the occupant of the Chair may be at a particular time he has always endeavoured to uphold that tradition. The Deputy must withdraw that remark.
Comment on this
I withdraw the remark. If I am to be precluded from dealing with the question of new roads made, or rather, not made, by the Land Commission—in passing I should say this is something which overlaps the work done by the Local Government Department, and in its effects not only derides the standards set up by local authorities but causes them expense by reason of having to make those roads and bring them up to a certain standard—I want to point out that I am not dealing with the administration of that particular Department. I am simply dealing with the work of that Department as it affects the national work of the Government. We had a Deputy this evening speaking on wheat and beet and the mixture of grain. I certainly am a bit at sea to know where I stand. The Minister for Industry and Commerce dealt in a very detailed way with the administration of his Department.
Comment on this
He quoted quite a lot of statistics and went into details so much that he gave figures as to the number of stamps sold.
Comment on this
The Deputy is continuing to make his point against the ruling of the Chair and is not dealing with the Vote before the House. I listened to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who dealt with the policy of the Government towards the unemployment problem, and in so far as they affected that problem he made a reference to stamps.
Comment on this
Is Deputy Belton to be allowed to deal with policy under the heading of agriculture? I admit it is a very fine point.
Comment on this
I take it that I am entitled to deal with the general policy of the Government, and that it embraces concerns in this country that have been brought into existence by Government money. In that connection, I want to draw attention to the general policy of the Electricity Supply Board, which has cost this country about £10,000,000.
Comment on this
I understand that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is. After all, £10,000,000 of public money has been dumped into the Shannon scheme.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot discuss that on this Vote. He must keep to general Government policy. Every other member of the House who has spoken on the Vote seemed to be able to get on quite well in discussing general policy without introducing extraneous matters such as the administration of the Electricity Supply Board. I have already ruled that the Deputy cannot discuss administration on this Vote.
Comment on this
Well, I want a direction, Sir. In the matter of local administration, on local authorities devolves the duty of public lighting, and I want to draw the Minister's attention to an important town in County Dublin that has been refused public lighting.
Comment on this
If the subject of that matter is not extended all over the State, surely it is not a matter of policy. It is a matter of particular detail which can be raised when the Minister in charge of that particular Department introduces his Estimate to the Dáil.
Comment on this
But the trouble is, Sir, that though this operates all over the State, there is a peculiarity here: that it is not permitted to operate in this particular place, and I suggest that we should have national Government and not party Government. We should have no vindictive Government.
Comment on this
From what I can gather the Deputy is referring to, I suggest, Sir, that since the Minister for Industry and Commerce is not here, the Deputy ought not to go into the details of the Electricity Supply Board.
Comment on this
If it is wanted to raise a matter which is not general Government policy, it cannot be raised on this Vote. As I have pointed out to the Deputy, matters of detail can be raised on the particular Estimate concerned. Most Deputies understand what general Government policies mean, and I think that the Deputies who addressed themselves so far to this Vote on Account understood it and spoke to it. I have sufficient faith to believe that the Deputies who will address themselves to it from this on will do the same. If the Deputy wants to raise some matter of detail, it is a matter of question and answer and adjournment, and matters of detail should be dealt with on the Estimate concerned.
Comment on this
A matter was mentioned here by Deputy Corry to indicate that the general policy of the Government had improved agricultural conditions, and he instanced the pig feeding, the admixture of corn, and the price that was obtainable for it. The market for agricultural produce in this country is the live stock, and what the Deputy kept away from was the very important fact that a year ago cattle licences were worth about 30/-, whereas to-day cattle export licences are worth nothing. Why are they worth nothing to-day? They are worth nothing for the simple reason that farmers have got out of stall-feeding, that they have been driven out of it by the Government policy. I am sorry Deputy Allen is not here. I was speaking, two days ago, to a large cattle dealer who went around practically all the farms in Wexford looking for stallfeds last week and the beginning of this week, and he could not get them. A further proof that we have not cattle to export now can be gleaned from the fact that committees of agriculture, which distribute these licences, have told the Minister to have the licences abolished as they are not worth the 1/6 apiece that the committees of agriculture have to give for them—that they can be bought for 2d. and 3d. each. That shows that in the domain of agriculture the Government policy has not succeeded as it anticipated or as it boasts it has succeeded.
Then we were told about the profit of wheat-growing. Well, I have said here on many occasions that the profits made by wheat-growing are profits made by robbing the land of its fertility, and I have not heard any member from the Government side take up that point and argue it in this House. I challenge any of them to take it up now and argue it. Most wheat-growing in this country at the present time is wheat crop after wheat crop after wheat crop, with a diminishing return every time, and robbing the land of its latent fertility that has been built up in the soil through years, and perhaps generations, of good husbandry. That fertility is now being robbed as truly and deliberately as if an armed man went into a bank and robbed the bank of its money. The Minister probably knows—the Minister for Lands would know—of one of his colleagues on that bench, or very near it, who grew wheat for four or five years on the same farm and then handed it over to the Land Commission when it had been robbed in that fashion; and now it is divided and given to poor unfortunates to pay the annuity on it— and if they do not pay the annuity, the local authority will have to pay. Will the Minister contradict that? He is a colleague who is a very likely candidate, a selected candidate, of his Party for the next election in a southern constituency.
We heard a lot of talk from the Minister for Industry and Commerce about the development of industries here. I am one of those who always believed in protection for industry, who always believed in protecting our young industries here; but I know enough of economics to know that in an agricultural country like this, in order to start industry and start it on a sound basis, you can only do so out of the sound profits of agriculture. Here we have a Government that started five years ago, simultaneously, an economic war with England, robbing agriculture of about £5,000,000 a year and impoverishing it to that extent, depressing the price of agricultural produce in the home market by a similar amount, and at the same time starting a vigorous drive in the direction of industrialisation in this country and asking agriculture to pay, during that period of depression together with the world depression, the price for the industrialisation of this country. I was opposed to that then, not because I was opposed to protection, but because I was a supporter of protection and wanted to give protection a fair chance, which it has not got. We hear the boasting coming from the Government Benches—we heard it to-day—of the progress of industrialisation. It is time that we in this country came down to tin-tacks and got some little moral courage. It is time for us to pull the wool off our eyes and tell this House and tell the country what industrialisation in this country really means. It means that we are handing this country over to a gang of international Jews.
Comment on this
It is these international Jews who are reaping the harvest out of the sweat of the Irish people. It is to guarantee their dividends that the game is being kept up.
Comment on this
Do not be bothering us, wasting the people's time with that sort of "lingo."
Comment on this
Ask any of the old industrialists of this country. Ask any of them who in their youth started the industrial revival and who subsequently supported and participated in the industrial revival. I could get many of them, supporters of the Government because of their industrial development policy, but not supporters of the Government policy which allows the industrial development of this country to be a shelter for undesirable aliens coming into this country, many of them the outcasts of the countries in which they previously resided—coming in here and getting full citizenship rights.
Comment on this
Yes, but they worked for their living wherever they went. Does the Minister compare the Irishman who, no matter what country he goes into, is prepared to take off his coat and work, with the Jew who comes to live on the people of this country——
Comment on this
I think the village of Nazareth has at least as much claims on humanity as Deputy Belton's birthplace.
Comment on this
We shall leave the Minister to his village of Nazareth. That is our industrial development. That is the policy which allowed these people to dig themselves in in industry, and as a result of which they have gone into commerce, with the consequence that in some of the principal streets in Dublin to-day you have not got a single Irishman owning one of the houses.
Comment on this
How many Irish firms are doing business in Grafton Street to-day? It is not a matter for laughter because this development has a social and a religious side.
Comment on this
I allowed the Deputy to make reference to internationalists, shall we call them, who, he alleges, have been allowed to come in and start in industry here. That would have reference to the Government's policy of industrial development, but when he goes on to refer to internationalists who are in business, I do not know how that has reference to general Government policy.
Comment on this
The Government have not responsibility for their advent into ordinary shop-keeping, shall we say.
Comment on this
But the Government have responsibility for the policy that they permit in industry which develops a commercial end to that industry.
Comment on this
They are responsible so far as industry is concerned but I do not think they can go any further.
Comment on this
We have, or we ought to have, an Irish foreign policy. We are keeping up an institution to promote it but we have not got it. There is no foreign policy that is distinctly Irish being pursued by our Government. There are no Irish ideas apparent in the policy of the Government as far as it has been made public and it is doubtful whether we would not be as well served if we had no Department of External Affairs at all for its utility as an Irish institution has not yet, as far as I can see, revealed itself. It is only giving an opportunity to the Minister for External Affairs to entangle this country in international obligations which we might be able to repudiate if we had not direct representation there. It entangled us last year in sanctions and it entangled us this year in what has been euphemistically styled non-intervention in Spain but which, in reality, means taking sides.
Comment on this
An Act went through this House in reference to that matter. It was discussed in full and the Government has only acted within the terms of that Act. The matter of non-intervention or intervention in Spain is not open for discussion again.
Comment on this
The Deputy referred to two specific instances, neither of which can be discussed now because they have been already decided. One was the matter of enforcing sanctions against Italy on the issue of the Italian-Abyssinian war. The second instance had reference to non-intervention in Spain. The House has definitely expressed its opinion already in regard to these two issues and they cannot be reopened on this Vote on Account.
Comment on this
Is it not open to me in a general way to criticise the policy of the Department of External Affairs on this Vote?
Comment on this
I am ruling on what the Deputy definitely stated, or proceeded to state, when he said that we were involved by the President, as Minister in charge of the Department of External Affairs, in the policy of non-intervention in Spain or in the unfortunate incidents now taking place there. The House has already passed an Act dealing with that matter and, as I have pointed out distinctly, it is not now open for discussion.
Comment on this
A Deputy getting up in this House to criticise anything before the House gives his views as he sees the matter under discussion. I see the general policy of external affairs in a certain light. As a member of this House I should like your ruling on this question: Have I not a right on the Vote on Account to criticise the policy of the Department of External Affairs or any other Department, as I see it?
Comment on this
The Deputy has not the right to reopen a discussion on what the House has already decided; the House has enshrined its decision in an Act.
Comment on this
I only referred to that particular title of the Act as a proof of my general criticism. I was not going on to criticise the Act itself; neither am I now.
Comment on this
The Department of External Affairs in relation to external affairs. It may be Spain, France, or anywhere else. The Act that was passed here, I do not propose to criticise; but the policy of the Department of External Affairs as I see it, I was going to criticise in general terms. We in this country have suffered and I take it that our greatest suffering at the present time, the greatest blot on our nation, is the partition of this country. Nothing has been done by the Department of External Affairs in relation to that and the question is whether the Department considers that to be a matter of external affairs or a matter of internal affairs.
We are represented in the League of Nations at Geneva. We are told that we are co-equal with the British representatives there. I wonder if our Minister for External Affairs considers this economic war between ourselves and England a matter that concerns us internally or externally? If it concerns us internally, then I wonder where the Republic has gone? If it concerns us externally, why have we never heard of this matter being raised at the League of Nations? Is it not only a waste of our money, money that we can ill afford, to keep up membership of the League of Nations?
Comment on this
Will Deputy Belton say why he did not take that up with Deputy McGilligan when he was sitting beside him a few months ago?
Comment on this
——because the matter at issue now was not at issue when Deputy McGilligan had any authority or voice in external affairs.
Comment on this
The implication being that Deputy McGilligan had not any voice or authority in external affairs?
Comment on this
If it is fit to be an issue now, it was fit to be an issue when the Minister stood on the platform on Burgh Quay and said that he would jump into the Liffey rather than follow Belton into the Dáil. That is a queer one for the Minister.
Comment on this
Over the same ground I will meet the Minister and beat him just as I beat him before when we fought on the same ground. And when I had the prestige of a Party with me along with the Minister, I got three times more No. 1 votes than he did in the same constituency.
Comment on this
The irrelevancy came from the Minister. Nobody ever accuses him of being relevant. Our Department of External Affairs never raised the question of partition, never raised the question of the economic war, in the League of Nations. What service has it given this country there except to undertake obligations that might lead this country anywhere, perhaps into war, perhaps into war on the side that the people of this country would not want? One of the greatest crimes that has been committed against this country is partition, and our Minister for External Affairs has declared from platforms in this country, he has preached it all over the United States of America, that our old inveterate enemy, England, has partitioned this country and divided the Irish people. From the same England, the same Minister, the same President de Valera, has taken his orders to hook this country with England in order to partition another country that has always been the friend of this country.
Comment on this
It must be assumed that the Chair has some intelligence; that assumption must be accepted. The Deputy stated a few moments ago that the President was trying to implicate this country with the issues in another country—with Spain. Now he comes along and says the same thing without mentioning the country.
Comment on this
On grounds of general policy, forgetting about the country, when our Department of External Affairs commits us to aid England to partition Japan, France, Russia or Germany, is it not time that we, seizing the first opportunity we have here, should criticise that Department?
Comment on this
A Bill was introduced here which asked the House to decide as to intervention or non-intervention in Spain, and whether we would act in connection with other Powers in that respect. The Dáil decided on that matter and a Bill was passed. Now, I will not allow any statement regarding that; it is not open for discussion, and if the Deputy endeavours to introduce it by referring to some State which is not specifically mentioned, I will rule it out in so far as his statement is concerned, for I will understand that he is referring to that country in so far as the facts lead me to understand he is referring to that country.
Comment on this
I am quite well aware that an Act has been passed here— the Spanish Non-Intervention Act— but I submit that in that Act, from beginning to end, there is not one word about our giving support or refusing to give support to Great Britain to partition Spain or any other country. I am dealing with the general policy of the Department of External Affairs, quite removed from that Act.
Comment on this
I thought so. Therefore it is ruled out because an Act has been passed dealing with that.
Comment on this
There has been no Act dealing with the partition or nonpartition of Spain passed by this House.
Comment on this
He will not. He will leave the House. I will leave the House when I am officially asked to leave it.
Comment on this
The Deputy may do so though it should really go to a vote of the House, once he has been named.
Comment on this
I do not want to put the House to that trouble. While I am a member of the House I want to get fair play.
Comment on this
The Deputy must make no remarks. If he wishes to avail of the opportunity to withdraw, he will do so at once.
Comment on this
The Minister to-day, when introducing this Vote on Account, asked me if I were prepared to say that an expenditure of £1,743,146 for the Land Commission was too high. According to the Land Commission returns and according to all the information which the Land Commission have made available as to their activities during the last two or three years, it would appear that the Land Commission are distributing on an average less than 100,000 acres of land per year and, that being so, I do say in reply to the Minister that an expenditure of £1,743,146 is, in my opinion, too high. The largest single item in that Estimate is an item for improvement of estates amounting to £780,750. Assuming for the moment that the Land Commission are distributing on an average 100,000 acres of land per year, that means that for every single acre of land purchased and distributed by the Land Commission they are spending £7 for the purpose of improvement. Going back over the whole history of the Land Commission for a period of 20 years, the Minister will find, if he cares to look up the figures, or if he gets the officials of the Land Commission to look up the figures, that the average expenditure in respect of improvements per acre on land never exceeded £2. I asked exSenator Connolly when Minister for Lands, and I have asked the present Minister for Lands if they were satisfied that this huge expenditure on improvement alone was justified, but neither of them answered or attempted to answer my question. It does appear to me that that expenditure is extravagant and, until I get a satisfactory answer from the Minister for Lands, I am prepared to hold to my opinion that the expenditure is extravagant.
The Minister went on to deal with the general question of land distribution, and he finished up by making this most extraordinary statement—that the land question in this country would be settled in the course of the next five years. The Minister for Finance may understand a good deal about high spending or extravagant spending if you like, and judging by the Vote on Account we are considering to-day, there is no question but that he does understand a great deal about the extravagant expenditure of money, but he does not understand the first thing about the land problem or he would not make such an absurd and ridiculous statement.
There is no one in this country who believes for one moment that the land question is going to be settled in five years. So far as it is possible to obtain information from available returns, there are still over 1,000,000 acres of land to be dealt with and, even at the present rate of distribution, it would take five years to distribute all that land. Even apart from this question of land distribution altogether, there is the other question of the vesting and disposing of land already distributed and dealt with under all the Land Acts and, even at the bare minimum, it would take 25 or 30 years to dispose of the land problem. I do not imagine there is a Deputy in the House, no matter how young, who will ever live to see the end of the land problem, because by virtue of the very policy pursued by the present Government they are creating a new land problem, and that new land problem will be much more apparent in the course of the next few years than it is to-day. So much for the Minister's challenge.
To-day we are asked to give the Minister £10,000,000, portion of £29,262,269, which he requires for the Public Services of the State during the coming financial year. To the £29,000,000 must be added the Supplementary Estimates which will be introduced during the course of the coming year, so that it is quite safe to assume that the expenditure on Supply Services by the end of the next financial year will amount approximately to £30,000,000, and to that may be added £4,000,000 for the Central Fund, making the total expenditure between £34,000,000 and £35,000,000. The highest annual expenditure we have had hitherto in this State was for the financial year 1923-4, when expenditure amounted to £38,000,000, but that £38,000,000 included the cost of the civil war. Now under a Fianna Fáil Government that promised to reduce taxation by at least £2,000,000—and on that subject no one was more eloquent than the Minister for Finance—we are drifting towards, and probably in the course of the next few years will have succeeded in reaching, an expenditure that was not reached during the civil war period. At this stage it is interesting to go back over the annual expenditure since the Free State was established. I am sure that members of the Fianna Fáil Party, and of the Government, will not relish the comparison. Nevertheless, it is exceedingly interesting, and it shows how far the Minister and the members of the Government have departed from the fulfilment of the promises they made to the taxpayers. In 1922-23 the total expenditure was £29,000,000; in 1923-24, £38,000,000; in 1924-25, £27,000,000; in 1925-26, £26,000,000; in 1926-27, £27,000,000; in 1927-28, £26,000,000; in 1928-29, and in 1930-31, £25,000,000; in 1931-32, £26,000,000; in 1932-33, £28,000,000; in 1933-34, £31,000,000; in 1934-35, £31,000,000; in 1935-36, £31,000,000 and in 1936-37, according to my estimate, the expenditure will be about £33,000,000. I suppose the Minister recalls the days when he was sitting here on the Opposition Benches, and how eloquently he pleaded for a reduction of taxation; how at that time he pointed out that the country could not possibly endure taxation higher than £20,000,000. In fact, if my recollection serves me right, on one occasion he stated that he was satisfied that the whole 32 Counties could be easily and satisfactorily run on £20,000,000. I am speaking entirely from recollection.
Comment on this
At any rate, the Minister made a statement of that kind in the Dáil. To-day what do we find? The Government that was to reduce taxation by £2,000,000 has consistently increased it since it assumed the responsibility of Government, with the result that in the coming financial year we are faced with a total expenditure amounting to the enormous sum of £35,000,000, or almost war-time expenditure. What do we find on looking over the Votes? While the majority of the Estimates have been increased, one item in almost every case is increased very substantially, that under the heading of "wages, salaries and allowances." The biggest increases are probably taking place in the Department of Industry and Commerce, where there is a total net increase in expenditure of £12,000, and a net increase in salaries and wages of over £15,000. In the Department of Lands the total increase is £132,325 and the increase in wages and salaries represents £32,475. In the Revenue Commissioners' Department there is a total increase of £52,042 in wages, salaries and allowances. We can all remember members of the Fianna Fáil Party telling the electors that after an exhaustive examination of all the Votes included in the Estimates for the year 1931-32, they had deliberately come to the conclusion that it was quite possible to reduce expenditure on the administration of every single Department. What do we find now? Starting at pages 4 and 5 of the Book of Estimates, and continuing to the last page, in every one of the Votes standing out prominently above all the other items is that of "wages, salaries and allowances," showing an increase in practically every case, meaning inevitably increased staffs. I agree that so long as the so-called economic war lasts it is necessary for the Government to bolster up their policy with all sorts of artificial aids, with tariffs in some form, subsidies and bounties, but every one of these artificial expedients means increased staffs, so that in the course of another few years it is quite possible that the number of civil servants in the country may very well represent 35 per cent. of the population, assuming that emigration to Great Britain continues at the same rate.
The Minister boasts that the Government had fulfilled every one of its election promises. I think the Minister for Lands when recently in Kilkenny was more specific than the Minister for Finance, as he said that they had fulfilled 100 per cent. of their election promises. That was certainly interesting. Apparently the Minister for Finance, and also the Minister for Lands when speaking in Kilkenny, forgot the £2,000,000 reduction of taxation that was promised to the electors. He also forgot that we have an unemployment problem; that unemployment instead of diminishing seemed to be increasing, and that we have not yet stopped emigration. We had to-day an extraordinary transformation, when the Minister for Finance justified an increase of £10,000,000 in expenditure on the Public Services in this State, while the Minister for Industry and Commerce defended emigration from this State, notwithstanding the election promises of 1931-32. I was going to remind the Minister of a statement he made on one occasion, when he said that not only would emigration stop, but that in order to carry out the big industrial policy they proposed to embark upon they would have to bring back all the exiles to work in our factories. We were also promised that the annuities would be withheld. I sometimes wonder if they have been withheld. The President stated that the annuities were being taken from us in a form which inflicts more hardship on our people than if they were paid directly. I mention another promise that was made, and that was a reduction in the staffs of the various departments of the Civil Service, yet, to-day these staffs are increasing at an alarming rate, and before the economic policy, especially the industrial policy of the Fianna Fáil Government is fully implemented, God knows what the figures for the staffs of these departments will reach. Reference was made to the Coal-Cattle Pact, which now appears to be changed to the sugar-horse pact. I thought that the Minister for Finance, when he was introducing this Vote on Account, would have made some reference to it. There is no question whatever about it that the latest pact has caused a tremendous amount of disappointment in the country. Undoubtedly, the people of this country were given the impression, rightly or wrongly—and especially prior to the interview between President de Valera and Mr. Malcolm MacDonald—that the pact on this occasion would be much more satisfactory, and would certainly mean a very substantial decrease in the duties imposed by the British Government. However, apparently it is quite evident now that the British have definitely made up their minds to get the withheld moneys from this country and that unless some abnormal situation arises there is not likely to be a satisfactory settlement of what has hitherto been called the Coal-Cattle Pact. Surely the Minister realises that this so-called economic war cannot go on indefinitely, and that a stage must come, and come very soon, when a settlement will have to be made. Probably, when that stage does arise, the circumstances may not be quite so favourable towards a satisfactory settlement of that problem as they are at the moment. If the members of the Government were really alive to the condition of affairs in the country —and the picture painted to-day by Deputy Dillon, Deputy Professor O'Sullivan and Deputy Mulcahy has not been in the slightest degree exaggerated—they would certainly make a determined effort to put a speedy end to this conflict which is not reflecting any credit on them.
Comment on this
I notice that Deputies on the opposite benches very often, in fact nearly always, suggest by their speeches that somehow or another we got into power by waving a magic wand or by deceiving the people. They go a little bit further and say that we did it on two occasions, and will do it on the third occasion. I myself believe that the people had very good reasons for making a change. One of the main reasons why the agricultural population were so determined to make a change was that about the year 1931, before the first election that we won here, the farmers of this country discovered that their produce had dropped to the tune of about £13,000,000. That, of course, began to make them think very seriously. They went back then to the 1923 Land Act, which was ushered in with great sounding of trumpets. It was necessary, and it was a good Act. The Act was right enough, but the operations were carried out in an extremely bad way. Of course that might be one of the reasons why it is costing a bit more to improve land to-day than in Deputy Roddy's time.
Comment on this
The real fact of the situation was that Great Britain discovered she had not a whole and complete grip of it, and there was what some people called a secret agreement. There was an agreement of some description, and from the existence of an agreement I take it that there was something taken from us. England got the land annuities anyway.
Comment on this
As soon as England got the land annuities she had the circle complete. We paid our rent to her; we produced the stock and sold it to her, and anything we bought was bought from her. England was in a very happy position, and the people discovered that fact. As soon as they discovered that fact they decided to change the system, and to put in a Government not that deceived them, but that satisfied them. The proposals we made to them were accepted by them, and notwithstanding what was said here from time to time, we did not in any detail deceive them. We have carried out our proposals. Any reasonable individual who wants proof of that —and remember, nothing that may be said here will prove it—can go through the country and see the improvements that were made there for people who were badly in need of those improvements. Houses were built for those who needed them. Lands were divided and houses put on them.
Whatever may be said about the operations of the Land Commission since we came in—they may not be perfect—they are certainly a great deal better than the operations carried out during the time of the previous Government. Many Deputies have mentioned the question of the tariff on cattle. No doubt it is very objectionable, but they never mentioned that we are in a position to impose tariffs. If I may offer them a little advice in their difficulties it is that they may as well tell the whole truth, because the people are perfectly well aware of it. They know perfectly well that the British Government manoeuvred herself into a position where she would sell us all we wanted, collect the rents of our land, and buy our stock. It is rather awkward for her—and she does not deny that it is awkward—that they have to pay tariffs on their produce coming in here.
Comment on this
What good is that to the poor unfortunate Irish farmer? You are talking through your hat.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Deputy who pays the tariffs on the goods coming into this country from England?
Comment on this
It is such things as that which have left that Party opposite nearly a skeleton Party.
Comment on this
Members flitted out of it because of those foolish statements which the people could not swallow.
Comment on this
We are only obliged to you for saying that we were on two occasions able to fool the people! We are certainly very brilliant. I do not claim for one moment that we are able to fool the people, but I do claim that the people are intelligent and they are now satisfied that the road they started on is the right and proper road. Any sensible individual who goes through this country to-day, when we are supposed to be impoverished— every Deputy on the opposite side did his best to prove that this country is impoverished—can see the difference between the position to-day and the position that existed when the Party opposite were in power.
Comment on this
It is quite true, as Deputy Corry said, that there were many plots of land taken in 1930 for labourers' cottages. I know many of them. There were no cottages built on those lands until 1933.
Comment on this
Before they could build houses they had to build the bridges which you tumbled down. They wanted to put the people in a position to get into the houses.
Comment on this
Later on—I will not delay you too long—you can explain your point. That is their whole weakness. They tell a little of it but the public know it all, and they might as well tell the two sides and be quite candid about these things. The position that arose after this famous secret agreement was made was the cause of all the tariffs.
Comment on this
Whatever you like to call it. I am not a lawyer and all I know is the simple part of it that there must have been something to get when there was an agreement.
Comment on this
Somebody must have made a bloomer somewhere. If there was an agreement made and we handed over the land annuities——
Comment on this
I am afraid I have touched a sore spot somewhere. I am very sorry if it is a sore spot, but these things cannot be helped, anyway. I heard Deputy O'Sullivan holding forth on the woes of Kerry. He said that the people were emigrating there in train loads and that nearly every week they had to get extra carriages to take them away and that Kerry was one of the districts in which there was extreme hardship. He did not, however, mention any other districts. I am not going to deny for one moment that there is hardship. I know that there is hardship in many of the mountainy districts and I know that very well.
Comment on this
I know that there is extreme hardship in many of these mountain districts and I know perfectly well that we get 80 per cent. of the votes in those districts, notwithstanding that hardship.
Comment on this
We did it twice before and I am sure we will do it the third time, which shows that the people there are intelligent. The Deputy's own county is not a distressed county. Wexford is an extremely good county and they are well off there.
Comment on this
The worse they are under us, the more they vote for us. That may be the policy. At the same time, I can tell Deputy O'Sullivan that nobody will deny that there are districts in great hardship in the country which has this market they talk about so much and which has all the wealth which that country has, and that while they may talk about that El Dorado, there are many distressed areas there and a great deal more hardship in those areas than there is here.
We have statements about the price of cattle. Great Britain had to give a subsidy to her cattle trade and Deputy Keating will not deny that the price of beef now is about 35/-plus the subsidy.
Comment on this
But for the policy of this Government, would not cattle over two years old be worth £4 5s. 0d. a head more?
Comment on this
We are a very powerful people. Not alone can we win elections here but we can reduce the price of beef in England. Notwithstanding the fact that there is a subsidy attached to it, the price of beef in England to-day is 35/- a cwt.
Comment on this
There is always a very fair margin between the two. The price of beef in England is round about 35/- and it has a subsidy attached to it. Without that subsidy, what would the price be? The subsidy is 5/- or whatever it is. They want 10/- and they say they cannot carry on. There, again, we do not hear it mentioned that the British farmer needs a subsidy and is in distrees. We are the only people in difficulty and suffering hardship.
Comment on this
These are facts that ought to be revealed, and if Deputies on the opposite benches would reveal these facts they would get on twice as well, because the people are very intelligent and know what the position is.
Comment on this
With the greatest of pleasure, Sir. I am tired listening to nonsense.
Mr. Keating withdrew.
Comment on this
The position is that a great part of the statements made on the opposite benches will be recognised by the public as mere political propaganda without any foundation whatever, and if they take my advice they will state all the facts when they make these statements. I do not deny that there is very great hardship among farmers in the country. I know it well and I know that the hardship amongst the larger types of farmers is very extreme. I know also that that hardship was coming on them since 1921, and that from 1927 on their hardships became extreme. The fall in the price of cattle in 1921 and the continuous drop from that on left many of these farmers in a hopeless plight, and that is another reason why in a county like Meath the majority of those farmers voted for us instead of for the other side. They saw some hope of things at least being put in order. The other side never held out the slightest hope of that, but quite a number of those farmers to-day have hopes that their position will be put in order. The other side gave no thought to that at all.
I am not going to delay the House much longer. All I want to say in conclusion is that no matter what may be said from the opposite benches, the people in general in this country are satisfied that we adopted the right policy and the proof of that is evident to anybody who goes the roads or passes through the cities or towns. A degree of reconstruction has taken place in this country which affords positive proof that we, as a Government, are honest in our endeavours to rebuild and reorganise our country.
Comment on this
I should like to say a very few words about the condition of the agricultural community in a purely objective spirit. I have no motive for trying to strain the case against the Government. I think it is on the whole desirable in the public interest that the Government should remain in office for another term. They have learned a good deal since they have been in office, but it would be an exaggeration to maintain that their political education is complete, and, as for the Fianna Fáil Party outside this House, its political education, judging from the proceedings at Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis, has hardly begun. If a further reason is necessary, I would say that a settlement, political and economic, with Great Britain that will establish friendly relations on a permanent basis between the two countries is something which we must all intensely desire, and I believe that such a settlement, to be lasting, had better be made by the Fianna Fáil Party. Consequently, I not only believe but I hope that they will be returned to power again after the next general election; and the few words that I am saying this evening are not said with any desire to make an artificial case against them. I am speaking as objectively as I know how to speak. The main attention in this debate has been devoted to the subject of whether the country has improved or deteriorated under the rule of Fianna Fáil. That is a very interesting and important question, but it is not the question with which I propose to deal. There seems to me to be a simpler and less controversial question that we can ask ourselves, and it is, perhaps, even more worth while asking. That question is: Is the condition in the agricultural community satisfactory, and, if it is not satisfactory, can we see an easy and obvious way to make a great improvement in it? The first part of that question has just been answered by Deputy O'Reilly, himself a member of the Fianna Fáil Party. He admits that the condition of the agricultural community is not satisfactory. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has admitted that they are not prosperous. To say these things is to indulge in under-statements. In my opinion, the condition of the agricultural community was most unsatisfactory before the present Government came into office, and, whether it is worse now or not—and I think it is worse—it still remains most unsatisfactory. In these days, when trade unions in industry are getting stronger, when measures are being passed about the conditions of employment for the benefit of working men in industry, the trend is towards establishing a sharp distinction between those engaged in agriculture and those engaged in other pursuits. As I see it, unless there is some change in the general direction of our policy, those engaged in agriculture are going to sink, and sink while watching helplessly the improved conditions of those who are engaged in other branches of industry.
As I have said, the unsatisfactory condition of the farming community has been admitted by Fianna Fáil spokesmen themselves. Deputy O'Reilly tells us that we ought to be consoled, or rather more than consoled, for the tariffs that are put upon our farm produce by Great Britain when we consider the tariffs that we have put on British industrial products. Now I say, quite frankly, that if I had a choice between having no tariffs at all on either side, and having all the existing tariffs maintained by both sides, I would choose the former. Of the two I think that that policy would be the least damaging to the country. But, in point of fact, we are not called upon to make any choice. The suggestion implied in Deputy O'Reilly's speech was that the British Government were adopting a threatening attitude towards this country, and that to him and to his colleagues it was apparent that at any time when we put into force an industrial policy containing tariffs on British goods, we were likely to be faced with a crushing British tariff on our agricultural produce.
There is absolutely no evidence to support that view. Every British Dominion has put tariffs on British industrial products. Nevertheless, we have heard figures quoted to-day to show how the Dominions have succeeded in doubling their exports to Great Britain during the period when our exports to Great Britain have been halved. It would have been perfectly possible to have proceeded with the industrial policy of the Minister for Industry and Commerce without taking the action which, in fact, caused the imposition of British tariffs upon our agricultural produce. Nay, more, the hope of the success of the policy of the Minister for Industry and Commerce would have been immensely increased if the buying power of the community had not been damaged by the policy of the Government which caused those tariffs to be put upon our agricultural goods.
What is the evidence of the distress amongst the agricultural community? In the first place, the evidence of one's own sight. When I go to my own constituency, and especially every time I go to the poorer parts of my constituency, I feel that their condition is not only unsatisfactory, but a disgrace to civilisation. I am not pretending that that poverty is a new thing. I believe that it is deeper than it was five years ago. That may be a matter for controversy, but that the poverty is there is admitted on all sides. When the Government tell us that the injury done to the agricultural community by the imposition of the British tariffs has been compensated for by the benefits they have given in the reduction of annuities, for example, and by increased social services, I reply that that is not enough. These things were needed by the agricultural community in any event, if there had never been any tariffs on our exports to Great Britain. Irish agriculture is, and has been, the Cinderella of this community, and it is no answer, on the part of the Government, to say that they have not made matters worse. It is their duty to make matters better. That duty they have not accomplished.
What about this matter of emigration? The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that from the 1st of April, 1935, to the 31st of March, 1936, the emigration from this country to Great Britain, including emigration via Northern Ireland, was 23,000. There were figures published in this morning's papers showing that for the calendar year 1936 the total net emigration from this country to Great Britain by sea, and not including the emigration via Northern Ireland, was 29,000. To this must be added the very considerable emigration by way of Northern Ireland into Great Britain. The Minister for Industry and Commerce suggests that these emigrants are nearly all girls going into domestic service in Great Britain. I invite him to go down to the North Wall or to Dun Laoghaire, use his own eyesight, and look at the number of young people leaving by the boats any Friday evening. He will see a stream of vigorous young men going abroad, coming entirely from the agricultural community, and, particularly, from the agricultural community in the West of Ireland. If the Minister does so, it will be impossible for him to suggest that there is not a formidable stream of emigration from this country to Great Britain.
What are the tests one is to apply? What about wages? We passed a Bill here a few months ago providing for wages boards to be set up in order to improve the wages of agricultural labourers. How far has that measure got? What activities have taken place under that Act? What are the hopes under present conditions of appreciably raising the wages of agricultural labourers? These wages are an absolute disgrace, and every Deputy here knows they are an absolute disgrace. No matter what the figures may be as to the revenue flowing into the Exchequer, no matter what the figures as to the consumption of necessaries, and luxuries in the cities may be, it is impossible to take a rosy view of the general economic conditions of the country so long as we find the agricultural community in the state in which it is. So long as you find the people as poor as they are in the country districts, and the agricultural labourers as miserably paid as they are, you cannot but feel that the prosperity of other industries or of other parts of the country is resting upon an insecure foundation.
The Fianna Fáil Party answers that there cannot be very much wrong with the country districts because the people in those districts continue to vote for that Party. They say that they would not do that if they were really suffering as much as I suggest they are suffering. I do not find that argument convincing. The truth of the matter is that the more distressed people get in the country districts, the less independent they feel; the more they are forced to hold out their hands for Government relief in some form and the more they feel obliged to join Fianna Fáil clubs. Since Fianna Fáil came into power there has been a stream of people joining Fianna Fáil clubs for no other reason than that they believed that that was the best method for securing such pecuniary advantages from the State as were to be obtained. I am prepared frankly to confess that there is a second reason—that is, that the personal popularity and prestige of President de Valera are very great and that a large number of people vote for him out of a sort of romantic affection, a sort of feeling that he is a great man who will lead them to security and prosperity some time or another in the future. The Party on this side were ten years in office, and if there was nothing else to make them unpopular—I am not saying that there was nothing else to make them unpopular—that, in itself, was enough to create considerable unpopularity for them. I shall not pretend that, up to the present, the Front Bench of the Government Party is not more personally popular than the Front Bench of the Opposition Party, but I think the Government would be very unwise to reckon on that state of things continuing for ever. The time will come when the people will get sick of their personalities, too, and the time will come when the people will feel that membership of the Fianna Fáil clubs has not, after all, brought them that security and happiness which every human being has a right to expect. When that time does come, there may be a landslide that will sweep the Government out of office. Even on the lowest grounds, the Government would be well advised to take into consideration the state of the agricultural community.
I am not going to pretend that the Government are not amenable to higher motives than those. I am sure they are sincere in the onslaught they have been conducting on poverty since they came into power. I am sure that every individual in this House is eager to see that attack on poverty maintained. There are two ways of doing it. One way is to redistribute wealth, to some extent, by taxation and to improve the social services—to devote money on an increasing scale to social services, as the Minister for Finance has boasted to us to-day that he is doing. Along with that, you have got also—and it is even more important— to husband and increase the general wealth of the community. If one has to choose between the two things, I think the second is more important, even to the very poor, than the first. In connection with the first part of that policy, the Minister for Finance would be well advised to pay serious attention to what Deputy Dillon and others have been saying about the cost of the things that the poor people in the country have to buy. I hope very much—I suppose the observation is not strictly relevant to this Vote but it is relevant to what has been said in this debate—that, when the Budget comes, we shall, in existing circumstances, see a substantial reduction in indirect taxation even if it involves an increase of the income tax to 5/-. I personally believe that every citizen of the State should be conscious of taxation, that every citizen should realise that money cannot be spent without being raised from somewhere. I should like every citizen to be conscious of taxation, but I do feel that, in existing circumstances, the agricultural community is being called upon to contribute far more than it is fair it should be called upon to contribute.
We had to-day what seemed to me to be a deplorable reply from the President of the Executive Council to a question of mine—that any sort of compromise with a view to the removal of the tariff on cattle would be, in his view, an unconditional surrender. That is a new and extraordinary definition of the word "compromise." A compromise when entered into by President de Valera becomes an "unconditional surrender." Presumably, a compromise which would have to be simultaneously entered into by the British Government would be, for them, an overwhelming victory. Why it should be an overwhelming victory as applied to the British Government and an unconditional surrender as applied to our Government, neither I nor anybody else can explain. What right have the Government to be so stiff-necked and so vain in a matter where the sufferings of the poor are concerned? Heaven knows they have been prepared to compromise their principles in many other matters.
We had one such matter within the last few days when we were told that they were taking steps to raise the salaries of Government Ministers. I agree that the present salaries of Government Ministers are not sufficient, but there was a time when it was a matter of the highest principle with the Fianna Fáil Party that the salaries of Government Ministers should not exceed £1,000 a year. They have not thought it beneath their dignity to compromise on a matter affecting their own pockets. Why should it be beneath their dignity to compromise on a matter concerning, much more importantly, the pockets of the poor? Even if I am the only person in this House to do it, I shall vote against any increase of salaries for the Ministers of the Government so long as they continue in the attitude that they are prepared to make no concession——
Comment on this
It may be rather invidious for me to intervene but I would point out that the Deputy may be prejudicing the investigations of the commission which is to be set up to inquire into this matter. I put that view-point to him for his consideration.
Comment on this
In any case, my point is sufficiently plain. If concessions of principle can be made by Ministers, they should be made in matters in which enormous benefit can be achieved for the agricultural community. It is, as I said, indisputable—it is even admitted—that the condition of the agricultural community is unsatisfactory. Can it be denied that no single measure can be thought of that would do more for the agricultural community than the removal of the tariff on cattle? Everybody knows that that would be a measure of enormous value. After all the theorising of the Fianna Fáil Party, after all their attempts since they came into office to change the face of Irish agriculture, the cattle trade to-day plays as big a part in our agricultural economy as ever it did. In our exports to Great Britain, the proportion of cattle to other agricultural exports is actually higher than it was before the present Government came into office. Everybody knows that the crying need of the agricultural community at present is to have the British tariff on cattle taken off. I suggest that that operation is perfectly practicable without anything that could be reasonably described as an "unconditional surrender."
There has been no attempt at compromise. I put a question some months ago and I put another question to-day in order to elicit whether there had been even an attempt to compromise and there has not. That is plain. I say that, as long as that is so, Ministers are false to their duty to the country.
Comment on this
After listening to Deputy MacDermot speak, if I could get the same vein of Olympian detachment to everything in this country that he professes to have, no matter how much from time to time I may be annoyed and disappointed with the arguments coming from the benches opposite, I have this feeling that if they have helped to create the mess they are floundering in, at any rate they cannot go to the boatside at Dun Laoghaire and leave this country when the going gets too bad as Deputy MacDermot can. Deputy MacDermot wants to see the political education of President de Valera and of the Fianna Fáil Government continued. The Deputy in this House in the year 1933 committed himself to this observation: "I know of no man since Cromwell who has done more harm to this country than Mr. de Valera," and that is the man that he wants educated. Well, our forefathers would not have liked to see the Lord Protector Cromwell living here for years in order to have him educated. They would have something with boiling oil in it for him. Will Deputy MacDermot put himself in the position of one of our farmers whose income, according to the Minister for Agriculture, has dropped from £93 in 1926 to £51 in 1934, and think whether he would like to live on that reduced income of £51 just to have President de Valera educated. If Deputy MacDermot had his roots fixed in this country and was really concerned about emigration, would he like to think of the old tendency there was in regard to emigration being reversed as it had been, with thousands of our people being forced out of this country even, as was explained to day, through the medium of the labour exchanges to get President de Valera educated?
Deputy MacDermot was very eloquent this evening on the woes of the agricultural community. Nobody could be too eloquent on that subject. I propose to quote again—I quoted it here before—from the pamphlet sent around by the St. Vincent de Paul Society to most people in this city, in the month of November of last year, dealing with the situation in this city. They say in it that
"The provision of new houses in the suburbs for large families who are living on unemployment assistance or home assistance provides a problem which might have been foreseen."
They point out that these poor people formerly lived in a single room
"... with just a few pieces of furniture, at rents of from 3/6 to 7/6 a week according to the accommodation provided. Now they find themselves outside the city, with comfortable houses but practically no furniture, and an increased rent to pay out of the same income they received in the slum dwelling. To this additional rent has to be added train or 'bus fares for the families when the children go to school or the parents have to go to the city."
And finally they wind up by saying that there is a
"... reduction in the amount of food purchased so that the increased rent may be paid."
Must we have those people condemned to live in such circumstances so that the President and his Ministers can get educated? Deputy MacDermot will approve, in a mood of detachment, of all that is going on in the country to have that education carried on for another five years.
Comment on this
The quotation that the Deputy has given will be dealt with on the Estimate when it comes before the House, and the statements made therein will be refuted.
Comment on this
Here is another sentence from it:
"There are numerous families which in the past were enabled to maintain themselves in frugal comfort on small incomes, but which under present economic conditions find it impossible to live except on a level which amounts practically to starvation."
Should we continue to have those people who previously had a meagre livelihood brought to, and kept at, the border-line that means practically starvation for them so that the President and his Ministers can get a proper education, and so that Deputy MacDermot, detached and aloof, can see whether they are getting educated or not. Finally, the St. Vincent de Paul Society say: "In years gone by it was comparatively easy to collect quantities of unwanted clothes for the poor; nowadays it is almost impossible to get anything approaching the amount required."
That is the situation that should be allowed to continue until certain people here get educated!
Comment on this
The remarks made there relating to the new houses which the Corporation are providing will be questioned when the Estimates come forward.
Comment on this
What is said is this, that if the people in the new houses have to pay an increased rent and have the same old income, therefore they have less available to pay for food. Does the Deputy think that sort of situation ought to be allowed to continue so that five years more will roll on to see what the effects of the educative process will be on those people? Deputy O'Reilly talked about the Party's promises. I remember when it was only necessary to produce the old plan and it was a case of every back bencher in the Government Party becoming petrified. I do not know that they are so eloquent about the plan now. There is talk of 100 per cent fulfilment of promises in face of that. There has been a lot of education at the expense of the unfortunate natives of this country whom Deputy MacDermot has no right to speak for. The Deputy is very anxious to have a new Budget situation this year in which indirect taxation will be lowered and income tax raised. I think that if anything is to be done in the way of increasing taxation, it certainly ought not to be in indirect taxation. The necessities of the poor ought not again to be touched. The price of the education already given to the people opposite in the last five years has been worked through hardships on the people in the way of taxes on their bread, butter, sugar, tea and coal. There are people to whom that means nothing. It may mean nothing to Deputy MacDermot, but there are people to whom it means something.