Central Fund Bill, 1937—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–163 of 315. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 1937 ›
The Second Reading of the Central Fund Bill as usual has been availed of for the purpose of undertaking a national stocktaking in respect of the general policy of the Government. In particular, the Government's policy in respect of industrial and agricultural development has been reviewed in the course of the discussion on the Second Stage of the Bill. I just want to travel some distance over that ground in order to mark here and there appreciation of what has been done by the Government, and at the same time to indicate that in my opinion sufficient advantage is not being taken by the Government of the opportunities which present themselves to-day for developing our industrial potentialities, and for conserving for our people the opportunities of manufacturing the commodities which our people require. So far as the Government's policy has manifested itself in the form of an active development of native industries, I think that policy has everything to commend it. After all, in a world which is now bent irrecoverably on developing a policy of national self-sufficiency, it would be the height of absurdity to imagine that a small State such as this could continue to exist by keeping its market open for the produce of every other land but its own.
I welcome, therefore, every effort that has been made by the Government to develop our industries, because I see in the development of our industries not merely the production of goods which our own people require, and not merely the provision of employment for our own people, but the provision also of a market for such raw materials as can be produced in the country. When the Government's policy in respect of the development of industries is under consideration, I think those who are concerned with the provision of work for our people, those who are concerned with the provision of a market for our raw material, those who are anxious to maintain here a volume of work which was formerly given to other countries in providing the commodities which our people required, must feel satisfied that the development of our industries marks a very substantial step in the direction of building up an economically and industrially healthy nation here. After all, the abandonment of an industrial development here must inevitably mean for our people that large scale emigration which we experienced from 1922 to 1932. Emigration is deplored to-day and rightly deplored, but during the years from 1922 to 1932 this country exported 250,000 of the flower of its manhood, the cream of its womanhood, to make for the greatness of other lands. When we think of that appalling drift of our people, when we think of that appalling exodus of the most virile of our people, we must welcome an effort to display here a balanced system of economy which is providing at home opportunities which our people were then forced to seek in other lands. If the drift of emigration on the large scale which we knew it in former years is to be stopped, then the development of industries must be welcomed in order to provide work for our people and to avoid the loss of our manhood and womanhood in the form of emigration to other countries, to seek there a livelihood which they were not able to obtain at home.
What intrigues me in discussions on industrial development here is to ascertain what exactly is the policy of the Fine Gael Party. That Party has voted against protection of our industries on almost every possible occasion, and if the speeches of Opposition leaders are to be taken as an index of their policy—they must not always be taken as an index—then one can only come to the conclusion that the policy of the Opposition is one of giving this country a mild and insipid form of protection, if in fact their policy is not one which embodies a very substantial measure of free trade. Deputy Dillon has already described the schemes for growing beet and wheat as gigantic frauds. Presumably, the Fine Gael Party, if they ever come to office again, will take steps to abolish beet growing and to abolish wheat growing, since Deputy Dillon is convinced that the production of beet and wheat is part of a gigantic fraud.
The agricultural community, therefore, must, if Deputy Dillon's words are to be taken as indicating the policy of Fine Gael, prepare themselves for the possibility that, under a Fine Gael administration, wheat-growing and beet-growing would be abolished. On the industrial side, Deputy McGilligan echoes that view, and his viewpoint on the development of industries as at present proceeding, is somewhat comparable with Deputy Dillon's view of wheat-growing and beet-growing. If we take the two viewpoints, I think the only conclusion one can come to is that Deputy Dillon stands for a policy of free trade in agriculture and Deputy McGilligan for a policy of free trade in respect of industrial commodities, or, at most, perhaps, the Party might be induced to give adherence to a policy of insipid protection. We are living, however, in the year 1937; we are living now in a period when every country in the world has found it necessary in its own interest to adopt a policy of national self-sufficiency. I agree at once that a policy of national self-sufficiency has considerable limitations in any country, and I agree it has very definite limitations in a small country; but, in a world where mass-scale production is the order of the day, where markets are virtually closed to all exporting countries, and where the surplus products of mass-scale industry in one country are exported and sold at slaughter prices in the open markets of another country, it becomes utterly impossible for us to maintain here an open market for the produce of other countries. Whether we like it or not, therefore, we are driven, as a matter of self-defence, to protecting our own industries, and that can only be done in existing circumstances by the imposition of substantial tariffs on commodities produced elsewhere and which are capable of being produced here.
Deputy Dillon's viewpoint, as expressed in this House within the past fortnight, was substantially that we ought to let in here quite a variety of commodities simply because they cannot be produced here as cheaply as they can be produced elsewhere. The logical end of that policy is to allow in practically every commodity that could be produced here, because you can find, amongst all the countries of the world, certain countries which will produce goods much more cheaply than we can produce them here.
Comment on this
Examples of that have been found in various directions, and further examples could be found if they were searched for. The trade unions in the clothing trade in Dublin have been compelled to draw the attention of the Minister to the fact that readymade suits were being imported here from Poland at a price which would not pay for 50 per cent. of the labour on the making of that suit in Dublin, apart from the raw material and the completed commodity which was included in the suit, so that a suit of clothes could be imported here from Poland and sold here at a price which would not pay 50 per cent of the labour cost if that suit were manufactured in Dublin.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy know what is the cheapest suit of clothes being made in this city at present?
Comment on this
The Deputy knows the accuracy of the statement he has now made, and the Deputy presented statistics to the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the matter and they could not be challenged by the Minister.
Comment on this
Let the Deputy inquire of the clothing trade unions what the cheapest suit being made in Dublin at present is. The Deputy may get a great surprise.
Comment on this
The Deputy will get no surprise in that respect. A short time ago, chairs were being imported here from Finland. The workers in the furniture industry, having examined the chairs and ascertained the cost of producing a similar chair here, found that the completely manufactured and finished chair being imported here was being sold at less than the amount which would pay for the labour on that chair if it were made in the City of Dublin. We have the further example of sugar imports. Czecho-Slovakian sugar is being imported here at an extremely low price, although the Czecho-Slovakian citizen must pay almost three times the price for that sugar in his own country. In those instances, the export of commodities to this country at low rates is part of a policy by exporting countries of sending to this market the surplus products of their own market and selling them here at prices with which it is not possible for the native manufacturer to compete.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy know that the British are shipping sugar into this country at a penny a lb.?
Comment on this
That is where the sugar was refined. Where was the sugar made and what is it made from?
Comment on this
Two years ago I listened to a delegate from Trinidad telling a conference of the conditions under which the sugar workers were employed in Trinidad, and a more appalling description of industrial slavery I never listened to before.
Comment on this
Has the Deputy investigated conditions in Vermont in the United States of America where maple sugar is produced.
Comment on this
The Deputy gave a number of places. I am telling him of a statement I actually listened to by a sugar worker who was working on sugar plantations in Trinidad. He described conditions there in such a manner as to revolt the feelings of those who listened to him. That is the kind of sugar we import here at low prices. Why produce anything at all here? Why not let the world manufacture for us at these low prices, and let us arrange national parades and wait until such time as these commodities are imported; but let Deputy Dillon tell us where the money is to be found for the purchase of those commodities, even at the low price at which they are being imported.
Comment on this
The Deputy thinks it right, then, to charge people here 3½d. a lb. for sugar at present?
Comment on this
The Deputy thinks it right to produce in this country every single commodity we can produce at something like an economic price.
Comment on this
Quite, because, of course, the price of Trinidad sugar is fixed on an economic basis. The price is fixed by exploiting the sugar workers of Trinidad. We can never hope to produce sugar as cheaply as it is produced in Trinidad; we can never hope to produce clothes as cheaply as they are produced in Poland; we can never hope to produce furniture as cheaply as it is produced in Finland. We could do it if we were to allow our workers to be exploited here in the same unscrupulous manner as they are exploited in those other countries.
I think that a fair summary of the viewpoint of the Opposition in the matter of industrial and agricultural production is that they want to get back to the agricultural position and to the industrial position that existed here during the ten years from 1922 to 1932. I think that is a fair summary of the remarks made over a long period by Deputy Dillon. In short, that means getting back to reliance on grass as the chief source of our wealth, to a reliance on raising bullocks as the chief source of our wealth and in endeavouring to secure from Britain a market for those products. We can, of course, under a policy of that kind, maintain the ranching system that existed here. We can concentrate, in the main, on the production of bullocks. We can neglect the development of our secondary industries and we can get back to a policy of exporting annually 25,000 to 30,000 of our people from this country.
Comment on this
It is just as easy for the Deputy to say two and a half millions as a quarter of a million.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Cosgrave deny that a quarter of a million people emigrated from the Free State in those ten years?
Comment on this
Then the Deputy does not believe the figures issued by his own Government. Deputy Mulcahy is the statistician of the Fine Gael Party and he knows——
Comment on this
I hope I will take a better and a sounder interest in them than Deputy Mulcahy because the Deputy is suffering from indigestion from swallowing too many figures.
Comment on this
I suppose the explanation of that is that having eaten New Zealand butter for ten years, and having been without it for five years, the Deputy has now got indigestion from eating it again.
Comment on this
It is evident that Deputy Mulcahy's digestion is not now inured to New Zealand butter.
Comment on this
You can, of course, get back to that industrial and agricultural economy which we had from 1922 to 1932. But let there be no mistake about it that we will pay an appalling price for that industrial and agricultural policy. We can maintain that policy by maintaining large ranches, by the export of large numbers of our population annually, and by the maintenance of an appallingly low standard of living for our people. Deputy Dillon, of course, will tell us, as an ex-Deputy of the Fine Gael Party told us recently, that the ten years from 1922 to 1932 were the most prosperous years in the history of this country.
Comment on this
Yes, certainly, were it not for the destruction carried out in that time by the people now sitting on the Government benches.
Comment on this
I am sure it would be only for the destruction carried out during that time by the people now sitting on the Government benches.
Comment on this
We were told that those ten years were the most prosperous period in the history of this country. If there was a shadow of justification for that contention, surely the country could have carried a much greater volume of social services than obtained at that period. Yet, when we examine the policy of the Fine Gael Government from 1922 to 1932, the most marked feature of their policy was the most profound reluctance of the Government of the day to spend, on social services, even a fraction of the money that is being spent on them to-day. So that in the midst of all the so-called prosperity to which the Fine Gael speakers refer, we find that the prosperity was never sufficiently great to carry on the social services which have been carried on for the five years from 1932 to 1937.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton will agree that over that period the damage done the country by the people who carried on the civil war was liquidated.
Comment on this
Who caused the damage and who caused the civil war? Who refused the offer of a commission to inquire into it?
Comment on this
The Deputy refused the offer of a commission of inquiry into the cause of the civil war.
Comment on this
Excuse me, I am prepared to stand over every act done by the Government from 1922 to 1932. I am not a hypocrite.
Comment on this
The Deputy was very silent on this matter during the by-elections in Galway and Wexford.
Comment on this
We can get back to the economy of the years 1922 to 1932, and concentrate on the production of grass as the main source of our wealth and neglect the development of our secondary industries, but an appalling price will be paid by the nation in existing circumstances for a reversion to that kind of policy which can only be maintained by keeping the ranches intact; by allowing the people to remain in a condition of permanent idleness; by allowing an appallingly low standard of living, and by the resumption of the massed scale emigration that we knew from 1922 to 1932. Emigration to-day threatens, I am afraid, to assume some of its former proportions, and it is here that I complain of the ineffective steps which are being taken by the Government to curb the tendency in respect of emigration which has manifested itself during the past two years. Great Britain has now embarked upon a gigantic rearmament policy, a policy which will involve an expenditure of £1,500,000,000 on rearmament alone, during the coming five years. Britain will spend a sum of money which is about 50 times our normal revenue, and in addition to embarking on that policy, in each of these years Britain will carry an enormous Budget of between £800,000,000 and £1,000,000,000.
That policy of spending £1,500,000,000 on armaments is inevitably going to create a condition of inflation in Great Britain. The only possible safeguard is that the British, having to borrow the money, will be interested in keeping these rates of interest as low as possible. But it appears to be almost inevitable with the expenditure of such a large sum of money on armaments, with the throwing into the money market such large sums for such purposes, it will be impossible to avoid the inflatory effects of that expenditure. As a matter of fact, already there is evidence of the effect of that rearmament policy on the British cost-of-living index figure. With such a large scale expenditure on rearmament, Britain will inevitably attract to it persons in other countries who are seeking employment; and ours being a small country close to highly industrialised Great Britain, where there are large schemes of work in operation and where the Irish worker has such a natural aptitude for employment on these schemes, I fear that Great Britain is going to become such a considerable attraction for the unemployed Irish worker that it will be extremely difficult to stem the tide of emigration from the Free State to that country. The Government ought to take cognisance of that fact. If there were no industries here, or if we had a neglected industrial position such as we had from 1922 to 1932, I fear the exodus to Britain would be very much greater than it is. We must remember that Britain has to-day very definite attractions for unemployed Irish workers. It ought to be the task of our Government to consider in what way our people can be provided with a livelihood at home instead of being forced to emigrate to Great Britain.
Comment on this
I know Irish workers who went over within the last three weeks and who could not find employment. They had to come back.
Comment on this
A considerable number of Irish workers are unemployed in Great Britain and a considerable number of Scottish and English workers are also unemployed there, but I think the proportion of Irish workers unemployed in Great Britain is far less than that of English and Scottish workers. In any event, if they are unemployed in Great Britain they can get, under the Unemployment Assistance Act, rates of benefit more than twice as high as they can get when fully employed in agriculture in this country.
Comment on this
Surely that is an irresponsible statement. The Deputy is not going to let it go out from him as leader of the Labour Party that if a country boy goes to England he can become eligible there for unemployment pay greater than the agricultural wages in this country?
Comment on this
That is a dangerous statement to make. If it gets about in the country that Deputy Norton said that, dozens of young fellows would go to England thinking they would get unemployment pay. But they cannot get that until they have been there for a very protracted period and have had some connection with the Unemployment Insurance Fund.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy is not correct in the statement he makes. Does he know that the Unemployment Assistance Act in Great Britain is administered in such a way as to provide benefit for persons who were never connected with unemployment insurance?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy suggest that a person who crosses to Liverpool can, on arrival there, draw unemployment assistance?
Comment on this
It is not the fact and you know it is not the fact. I defy you to produce any evidence of it.
Comment on this
The Minister knows perfectly well that no Irish citizen who went to Great Britain has ever been deported by a local authority or by the Government.
Comment on this
But it can be done. They have power to do it. The Deputy should not try to mislead the House and the country.
Comment on this
Why is it that there was not a general exodus from this country before there was any unemployment assistance here at all?
Comment on this
The unemployment assistance scales in Great Britain and the rates of benefit provided by public assistance committees there are very much better than the rates of unemployment assistance benefit provided here. In many cases, the rates are twice as good as the amounts paid here to workers fully employed in the agricultural industry. I make that statement and it cannot be controverted.
Comment on this
Prior to 1933, they were infinitely better because there was nothing with which to compare them here.
Comment on this
The point is that, if the Deputy's statement be correct, there ought to have been a general exodus prior to 1933 but there was not.
Comment on this
My statement is correct and the Minister ought to get the Department of Industry and Commerce to supply him with reliable information on a matter of which he clearly knows nothing.
Comment on this
The Minister appears to doubt that there is emigration to Great Britain. Nobody need have any doubt about that. If the Minister cares to buy a copy of the Leinster Leader for this week, he will find an announcement of a meeting of a football club from Newbridge which is to be held in London. The exodus from Newbridge has been such that they have been able to establish a football team in London. If the Minister cares to buy the paper each week, he will find periodic reports of meetings of groups of Kildare people in certain places in London. If he cares to go to Newbridge and make inquiries, he will find that, during the past few years, there has been a very considerable exodus to London.
Comment on this
May I take it that Deputy Norton is not implying that there has been a reduction in the opportunities for employment in Newbridge in recent times?
Comment on this
The Deputy will surely give me credit for knowing what is happening in my own constituency.
Comment on this
There are very few opportunities for employment in Newbridge or anywhere else for adults between 30 and 45 years of age.
Comment on this
If the Minister cares to make an investigation, instead of making interruptions, he will find that quite a considerable number of the people who have been forced to emigrate did so because they were able to get work on building jobs for which, as the Minister may know, Irish workers are in considerable demand in Great Britain.
Comment on this
Between any ages so long as they are able to do the work. I tell the Minister very definitely that the industrial development that is taking place here is providing very little outlet for the energies of men of 35, 40 or 45 years of age. I should like the Minister to get a census taken by the Department of Industry and Commerce of the number of workers over 30 years of age employed in the industries established here. He will find that a very small percentage of the workers over 30 years are finding employment in these industries. There are industries where they find employment—peculiarly male industries. Let the Minister examine any of the industries in Kildare, or elsewhere, and find how many workers over 30 years of age are employed in them.
Comment on this
Let the Deputy check up on his information and then come back. I have no hesitation in saying that there is a very definite drift towards Great Britain because of the opportunities for employment there. My complaint is that the Government appear to be oblivious of that drift and do not appear to be taking the necessary steps to counteract it.
Comment on this
That is an amazing question from a member of a Party which had a plan which involved bringing back exiles from America.
Comment on this
I want to hear Deputy Norton's view. We are on the eve of an election and this is a good morning for hearing those things.
Comment on this
Let Deputy Norton tell us what he would do to employ these men of between 30 years and 45 years.
Comment on this
There is no enthusiasm about it this morning. I was making the point that, while there is a very definite drift of Irish workers to Great Britain, the Government seem to be oblivious of that fact and unconcerned about the consequences, and that nothing is being done here by the Government to counteract the pronounced emigration tendency which has been manifest for the past couple of years and is particularly manifest to-day. Fianna Fáil Deputies may say what they like about there being no emigration. We may be told that it is only female workers who are going to Great Britain, but those who are in possession of the facts of the case know that more than female workers are going to Great Britain— that adult workers are going there, and they are going because they can get the employment there which is not available for them at home. I had a letter yesterday morning from a woman in the County Kildare who asked when was the Agricultural Wages Bill going to be introduced, and did I think there was a prospect of the wages in the agricultural industry being substantially increased. The woman added, by way of explanation for this inquiry, that a chap, who is a native of the district in which she lives, is home on holiday from England; that he is endeavouring to induce her son to go back to England with him and promised him regular employment; that he had told her son there is employment there at very much better rates of wages than this boy could get at the present time working in the agricultural industry in the County Kildare. That is happening. Last year I paid a visit to South Galway and, in the course of my stay there, I asked where were two farm lads whom I had met there the previous year. The farmer who employed them told me that they were now in Surrey. When I asked what they were doing there he said they were employed on some big construction job in Surrey. I asked him if many had gone, and he said "Yes." Some, he said, went in the first instance. After some time they wrote and told the unemployed lads at home of the conditions there. A number of the other unemployed lads then drifted away, and he said that now there was quite a considerable number of local lads working on those jobs in Surrey. What I want to ascertain from the Government is, what is being done to stop that drift. Is there any feature of the Government's policy calculated to offer employment to our own people here, instead of compelling them to emigrate to Great Britain where work is going to be much more plentiful in the future than it has been in the past?
We had a statement from the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance a few days ago to the effect that 45,000 persons were employed on rotational schemes of work. In reply to a supplementary question, the Parliamentary Secretary admitted that many of those workers were employed for three days and four days per week, and that the average employment available to them was for three and a half days per week. Now, let us examine the position. Employment on three days per week on a rotational scheme of work in the County Kildare will give a man 15/- per week, less National Health Insurance contributions, and, if the work is in any way industrial work, less also unemployment insurance contributions. So that three days' work per week in the County Kildare is going to give the man in receipt of that work the magnificent sum of about 13/6 per week. If the man were unemployed and had a wife and five children to maintain he would be entitled to 12/6 per week under the Unemployment Assistance Act, but under the rotational scheme of employment, if he is employed for three days per week, he gets a net sum of approximately 13/6 per week. That, therefore, is the kind of employment which we are offering to Irish workers in order to induce them to stay at home and to enable them to provide for themselves, their wives and dependents at home. Is it any wonder that employment of that kind fails to stop emigration to Great Britain? If that is the only dam that the Government can erect against the tide of emigration to Great Britain, then I am afraid it is a particularly weak dam.
These rotational schemes of employment have been devised, in the main, for depriving persons of unemployment assistance benefit. A man getting three days' work per week on a rotational scheme of employment gets, as I have said, a net sum of approximately 13/6. If he were entirely unemployed he would get 12/6 per week at the employment exchange, so that a scheme requiring him to work for three days per week has, in my view, been devised merely to deprive him of unemployment assistance benefit and, at the same time, to prevent his earning a decent week's wages. A good deal of the work done under these schemes will last for a prolonged period. Why not, therefore, give the workers employed on them at least a complete week's work instead of breaking up the week into two periods.
Comment on this
On the Central Fund Bill the Deputy should not anticipate discussion on the Estimates. I submit that the matter which the Deputy is now discussing will come up on the appropriate Estimate. It should not be further discussed now.
Comment on this
I did not intend at all to argue the merits of this particular rotational scheme. What I am endeavouring to do is to show that, if it is intended to be one of the fortifications against emigration, it is an extremely poor one, and not calculated to keep our people here. I want to know whether this is the only effort which the Government is making to endeavour to retain Irish workers in employment here. Is this the best effort that can be made? Is this the plan in existence? Is this all the Government can do to keep Irish workers at home instead of their being compelled to emigrate and seek elsewhere the employment that they cannot get here, or what is the Government's precise policy in regard to this emigration menace? Large numbers of adult workers are unemployed. In the agricultural industry they are being compelled to work for scandalously low rates of wages, and every member of the House knows that under the rotational schemes of employment they are getting work for three or four days at such miserable rates as to be incapable of sustaining them, and I want to know whether that is all the Government can think of doing in respect of providing work for our people.
I know that many good things have been done and that many useful things have been done. Industries have been established, and, to the extent that they have provided work, that is quite beneficial and everybody, I think, will welcome it; but my complaint is that not sufficient is being done and that the Government are losing opportunities for providing additional sources of employment for our people by their hesitant and half-hearted policy. I see nothing whatever in the Government's programme or policy calculated to absorb into employment the 90,000 persons who are registered for employment at the employment exchanges, or the additional 50,000 workers who will be registered there as soon as the present rotational schemes of employment end, and while any kind of large schemes of public works have much to commend them in so far as they employ labour, my complaint is that there is no properly thought-out plan for providing regular employment for the tens of thousands of workers in the towns, in the cities and in the rural areas, who are craving for an opportunity to work.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking in the House on Wednesday night, was frank enough to acknowledge that there was a serious unemployment problem to be met. He was frank enough to acknowledge that there were flaws in the economic system and that the Government had not provided work for all those for whom work must be provided if the problem of unemployment was to be dealt with effectively. In my opinion, however, the outward evidences of unemployment and distress indicate that there are not merely flaws in the economic system but that there are very serious cracks, and these cracks all indicate that the problem of unemployment, the deep vein of misery and poverty which exists for many of our people, will continue unless the Government bestir themselves and do something to deal with the problem of unemployment in a much more effective way than is being done to-day. My complaint is that there is no planning behind the Government's industrial or agricultural policy. When in opposition, the President used to give lip service to the idea of establishing an economic General Headquarters, which would be the eyes, the ears and the brains of the nation, from the standpoint of economic planning. The Government have been in office for five years. The economic General Headquarters. which the President talked so much of when in opposition, has ceased to make any appearance under the auspices of the Government now that they are in office, and I say that a good deal of the development which has gone on during the past five years has been a thoughtless kind of development, that it has not been a co-ordinated and regulated kind of development, and that it has not been carried on as part of a systematic and well thought-out plan, and of course we are getting evidence of that fact already. Boot and shoe factories have been established here.
They have now reached saturation point, and the position is that there are large numbers of boot and shoe operatives now on half-time, and when some of the workers employed in those industries acquire a greater measure of skill, you are going to have here a regular quota of unemployed boot and shoe workers—proving conclusively that saturation point has been reached already even in that relatively new industry. In the ready-made clothing industry, I think, the same situation is arising, and in the furniture industry the same situation is arising in respect of many articles of furniture— all indicative of the fact that there is no proper planning behind the Government's policy in respect of its industrial programme.
I believed the President was right when he advocated the establishment of an economic council which, in other countries, has given such useful service in assisting in economic and industrial development.
Comment on this
I think the Minister has enough advisers to tell him. He should not have to pick everybody's brains. As I was saying, I believed the President was right when he advocated the establishment of an economic council, and I believe he is wrong now in failing to establish it so as to plan industrial development on proper lines and to prevent the kind of haphazard development which is taking place here. However, we ought to have from the Government some definite indication as to when the large number of persons registered at the employment exchanges will be provided with an opportunity of work. We ought to have from them, too, some justification of the rotational scheme of employment under which persons are limited to obtaining three and four days' employment per week when there is work available for them for complete weeks and for a number of consecutive complete weeks. We ought to know from the Government what is the explanation of the refusal to give persons continuous employment on the schemes of public works. We ought to have the admission from them, frankly and definitely, that this is merely a device for depriving those persons of unemployment assistance benefit.
I think that there is no feature of the Government's present programme that offers a solution for the problem of unemployment. What we are doing here is being done by conservative Governments in other countries, and we are not even doing as much as some of the conservative Governments in other countries are doing in the matter of relieving unemployment. I shall be told, I suppose, that there are more people in employment here to-day than there were last year or in 1932. There are more people in employment in every country in the world to-day than there were in 1932. The International Labour Office at Geneva issues statistics from time to time, compiled from Government sources in the different countries, and those statistics indicate that since 1932 there has been an increase in the volume of employment in every country in the world. The increase has varied from country to country, but an examination of those statistics will show that there is no particular reason why we should be terrifically proud of our achievement here, having regard to what has happened in other countries.
I want to conclude by asking the Government what is its programme in respect of the provision of employment: what it is going to do to provide for the thousands registered at the employment exchanges, and what is going to happen the 45,000 workers employed on public relief schemes when those schemes are finished, and whether the Government regard it as an adequate remedy for the unemployment problem to provide such workers with part-time employment each week and then at such miserable rates of pay as are unable to sustain them.
Comment on this
Sir, before coming to the general discussion that has ranged around the Central Fund Bill, I should like to deal with a few points made by Deputy Norton.
I want to say that, while I quite believe that Deputy Norton is anxious to get a greater push on with the work started by this Government since it came into office, he has been unfair in his speech to-day. He has been unfair in making comparisons in the abstract and he has not given these comparisons to the House in detail. The main burden of his speech to-day could be brought down to three or four points. On the one hand he dealt with emigration, chiefly to England. He stated that emigration from this country to England was due, firstly, to the hopeless position of employment here, the low rates of wages paid to people who get employment as compared with those paid in England, and as compared even with the handsome unemployment assistance they would get in England if unemployed there. Deputy Norton knows that, when he is making these comparisons, he is making a comparison between an attempt by this Government to order employment, and to provide unemployment assistance when there is no employment in normal circumstances, with an abnormal situation in England. Deputy Norton knows that for the past few years there has been an abnormal situation there, due to the race in armaments, and that technical men, who cannot be found over-night or made into technical men overnight, get very high rates of wages in such war conditions. Consequently it is not fair to compare work of that kind with ordinary normal development which takes place in a country which is trying to order its affairs altogether apart from a war atmosphere.
The Deputy did not analyse the classes of people who emigrated. Deputy Norton knows better than most persons in this House the classes who emigrate to England. He did not tell us how many of the persons emigrating were domestic servants who are being brought over there in very large numbers because of the shortage of domestics due to the situation there. If he read last week's newspapers he would find that very high wages are being offered to domestic servants over there, and that there is an outcry against the number of Austrian girls who are being brought into England. He has compared that abnormal situation in England with an attempt here to deal with development on a normal basis. Another thing which Deputy Norton seems to ignore is that this Government is doing its best to bring about the development of industry suitable to the country's needs in normal circumstances.
Comment on this
I say the Deputy was unfair in the comparisons he gave us. I accept that the Deputy had the best intentions in the statements he made, but I say that he was unfair in his speech in not giving the details that he should have given. Deputy Norton forgets that we are out to develop industries in this country, not for the building of warships or the provision of arms and ammunition to be exploded at a moment's notice and, then, when it is all over, to look around to see what we are going to do next. He forgets that we inherited from our predecessors in office a large number of men, and to a certain extent women, who had become what I might call the chronic-unemployed, who had done no work in many cases for almost a lifetime and for whom it was impossible to provide an industry which would give them any future. In connection with that I have in mind the person to whom Deputy Norton referred, the person from 35 to 40 years of age. We inherited a great number of such people who had been chronically unemployed, who had been unemployed for the best part of their lives.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy think that the Government should have treated them like the old cows?
Comment on this
If we had the mentality of the Deputy, a lot of them would not have become old cows. They would have been executed long since.
Comment on this
I was saying, before Deputy Mulcahy interrupted me, that we had inherited from our predecessors a large number of persons who had been unemployed for the major part of their lifetime, who had, as I have described, become the chronic-unemployed, who could not be absorbed into new industries because they were not persons who could be trained for the purpose of building up a future for themselves or for the industries. For these people, either relief work or maintenance had to be found, and Deputy Norton did not give us the credit that he should have given, by pointing out that when we were faced with a serious situation in which we had to provide for these people, and also for the younger people who were growing into adults, we took the responsibility for the maintenance of them as best we could in the circumstances, in accordance with what the country could afford. We had it from the Opposition over there that maintenance for the unemployed, extra social services, in fact the giving of free milk to the children of the destitute poor, was, in the opinion of Deputy Mulcahy, at any rate, Communism, and it was so described by him in this House.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey showed you how to give unemployment assistance. He made you introduce it.
Comment on this
I do not know what Deputy Morrissey did. I am only referring to matters within my own recollection—that what this Party considered to be the practical application of religion, the religion of the majority of the people of this country, they put into effect; and gentlemen over there, who to-day try to parade their Church on the cuffs of their sleeves, described that practical application of religion as Communism. It is about time people should realise what has been suggested on the other side and what has been attempted over here in a practical way. We have heard Deputy Dillon and other speakers on the Central Fund Bill. I was amused when I listened——
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon certainly made several interruptions and his interruptions were on occasions sufficiently long, with the permission of the person then speaking, to be interjections of the speech type. We heard a number of Deputies on the other side. We have heard them every year since we took office on the Central Fund Bill. I should like to remind these gentlemen of some of the things they used to say and let them face the question themselves as to whether they are discussing the Central Fund Bill on its merits as it is before them, or whether it is a case of trying to get away from previous political attacks on this Party by the substitution of new ones. At one time Deputy Mulcahy took great trouble to make inquiries about the industries which this Government was attempting to set up. These industries were described by gentlemen over there, if I remember rightly, as being back-room shops, back-room factories, belowstairs kitchen factories and we were asked: "Where are they?" Deputy Mulcahy put in this House, week after week, a series of questions to know where were these factories. He could not see them.
Comment on this
At one time the Deputy told the House that he had gone round looking for the factories and could not find them, and he asked the Minister to give a list of the factories, to indicate where they were and how many people were employed in them. He has dropped all that now.
Comment on this
I expect the reason is because everybody in the Twenty-Six Counties knows of the existence of those factories. They see them in the immediate vicinities and the only trouble now is that the Ministers have deputation after deputation from various towns and districts that have not factories asking when the Government are going to establish factories in their localities similar to the ones established elsewhere.
Comment on this
The Deputy is wrong again. At the beginning he took the line that our policy was producing merely backyard factories.